ArticlePDF Available

Short note on a new anurognathid pterosaur with evidence of perching behaviour from Jianchang of Liaoning Province, China

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

A new anurognathid pterosaur, Vesperopterylus lamadongensis gen. et sp. nov., is erected based on a complete skeleton with a skull preserved. It is characterized by two short distinct ridges present on the ventral surface of the cervical vertebrae; coracoids slightly longer than scapula; humerus, wing phalanx 3 and tibia nearly the same in length; grooves clearly present on the posterior surface of the wing phalanges 1-3; and the first toe reversed. It is the first anurognathid pterosaur from China with a definitively short tail, and the first pterosaur with a reversed first toe. The reversed first toe of Vesperopterylus indicates that it had arboreal habitats. The discovery of Vesperopterylus lamadongensis from the Jiufotang Formation strongly expands the geological age range for anurognathid pterosaurs.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Short note on a new anurognathid pterosaur with evidence
of perching behaviour from Jianchang of
Liaoning Province, China
JUNCHANG LU
¨1,2*, QINGJIN MENG3, BAOPENG WANG3*, DI LIU3,
CAIZHI SHEN1,2 & YUGUANG ZHANG3
1
Institute of Geology, Chinese Academy of Geological Sciences,
Beijing 100037, China
2
Key Laboratory of Stratigraphy and Palaeontology, Ministry of Land and Resources
of China, Beijing 100037, China
3
Beijing Museum of Natural History, Beijing 100050, China
*Correspondence: wbppku@163.com; Lujc2008@126.com
Abstract: A new anurognathid pterosaur, Versperopterylus lamadongensis gen. et sp. nov., is
erected based on a complete skeleton with a skull preserved. It is characterized by twoshort distinct
ridges present on the ventral surface of the cervical vertebrae; coracoids slightly longer than scap-
ula; humerus, wing phalanx 3 and tibia nearly the same in length; grooves clearly present on the
posterior surface of the wing phalanges 13; and the first toe reversed. It is the first anurognathid
pterosaur from China with a definitively short tail, and the first pterosaur with a reversed first toe.
The reversed first toe of Versperopterylus indicates that it had arboreal habitats. The discovery of
Versperopterylus lamadongensis from the Jiufotang Formation strongly expands the geological
age range for anurognathid pterosaurs.
Supplementary material: The character list and data matrix for phylogenetic analysis are avail-
able at http://doi.org/10.6084/m9.figshare.c.3873394
The anurognathid pterosaurs were a group of small
pterosaurs known mainly in Europe and Asia dur-
ing the Jurassic period. At present, four genera are
reported: Anurognathus, from the Late Jurassic of
Germany (Do
¨derlein 1923; Bennett 2007); Batra-
chognathus, from the Late Jurassic of Kazakhstan
(Ryabinin 1948; Unwin & Bakhurina 2000; Costa
et al. 2013) and also a specimen from Mongolia
(Bakhurina & Unwin 1995); Dendrorhynchoides,
from the Middle Jurassic of China (Ji & Ji 1998;
Ji et al. 1999; Lu
¨& Hone 2012; Jiang et al.
2015); and Jeholopterus (Ji & Yuan 2002; Wang
et al. 2002; Sullivan et al. 2014) from the Middle
to Late Jurassic of China. Here, we report a new
anurognathid pterosaur: Versperopterylus lama-
dongensis gen. et sp. nov. from the Early Creta-
ceous Jiufotang Formation of Lamamdong, in
Jianchang of Liaoning Province (Fig. 1). It repre-
sents the youngest anurognathid pterosaur in geo-
logical age and this substantially expands the
temporal range of anurognathid pterosaurs. The
reversed first toe of Versperopterylus lamadongen-
sis provides direct evidence of its perching
behaviour.
Systematic palaeontology
Pterosauria Kaup, 1834
Anurognathidae Kuhn 1937
Versperopterylus lamadongensis gen. et sp. nov.
Etymology.Versper-, Latin word for ‘dusk’
implying that the new pterosaur may seek food at
dusk; -pteryl, Latin word for ‘wing’. The specific
name is referred to the fossil locality, lamadong of
Jianchang County, Liaoning Province.
Type specimen. An almost complete skeleton
with skull and jaws (BMNHC-PH-001311). The
specimen is now stored in the Beijing Museum of
Natural History.
Locality and horizon. Lamadong goumen, Jian-
chang County, Liaoning Province; Jiufotang
Formation.
Diagnosis. A anurognathid pterosaur with the
following combination of characters: the skull is rel-
atively smaller than other anurognathids; the ratio of
length to width is approximately 79.1%; the poste-
rior region of the skull is rounded (shared with Anu-
roganthus and Bactrachognathus); the anterior end
From:Hone, D. W. E., Witton,M.P.&Martill, D. M. (eds) New Perspectives on Pterosaur Palaeobiology.
Geological Society, London, Special Publications, 455, https://doi.org/10.1144/SP455.16
#2017 The Author(s). Published by The Geological Society of London. All rights reserved.
For permissions: http://www.geolsoc.org.uk/permissions. Publishing disclaimer: www.geolsoc.org.uk/pub_ethics
of the lower jaw is horizontally expanded; the cau-
dal end of the mandible is without a distinct dorsal
‘coronoid’ eminence; postexapophyses are present
on the cervical vertebrae; the number of caudal ver-
tebrae is 15 or fewer (shared with Anuroganthus);
metacarpals I III are the same length (shared with
Batrachognahus and Dendrorhynchoids); a promi-
nent anteriorly directed tubercle on the dorsal apex
of the external trochanter of the femur; the length
of metatarsal IV is shorter than metatarsals IIIII
(shared with Jeholopterus); coracoids are slightly
longer than the scapula; the humerus, wing phalange
3 and tibia are nearly the same length; the wing
metacarpal is approximately 36% of the length of
the humerus; grooves are clearly present on the pos-
terior surface of the wing phalange 1 to the wing
phalange 3; and the first toe is reversed.
Description
The specimen is almost complete, except for miss-
ing one humerus and some cervical vertebrae (Figs
24; Table 1). The wing span is about 1 m. The
fused scapulocoracoid, the smooth long bone sur-
faces and the fusion of extensor process to the
wing phalanx 1 indicate that it is at least a sub-adult
animal. The skull is remarkably small on this ani-
mal. The ratio of skull width to humeral length is
0.57, which is smaller than that Dendrorhynchoides
mutoudengensis (this ratio is 0.74: Lu
¨& Hone
2012). It is unlike other anurognathids and its ven-
tral surface is exposed. The skull is slightly wider
than long. The ratio of length to width of the skull
is approximately 79.1%, which is similar to that of
Dendrorhynchoides mutoudengensis (this ratio is
80%: Lu
¨& Hone 2012). It is semi-circular in ventral
view (Fig. 3a). The premaxilla and maxilla are slen-
der, rod-like. The upper jaw teeth are relatively stout
with blunt tips (Fig. 3b), unlike some longer teeth
with curved tips found in Dendrorhynchoides
mutoudengensis (Lu
¨& Hone 2012). There are
eight teeth preserved. Although the exact number
of teeth is not sure due to the poor preservation,
there are, perhaps, 12 teeth in the upper jaw accord-
ing to the distance between two teeth and the
dentition length.
There are four cervical vertebrae preserved. The
anterior two are rectangular in ventral view. There
are two short, distinct longitudinal ridges on the cen-
tral portion of the centrum, which form a groove
between them. The cervical vertebrae bear a distinct
postexapophysis. The neural spine is high and
blade-like. There are no cervical ribs associated
with the cervical vertebrae.
The anterior dorsal vertebrae bear a distinct neu-
ral spine. There are 14 dorsal vertebrae preserved
with their ventral surfaces exposed. Both the ante-
rior and posterior articular ends are flat. The ventral
surfaces are smooth. The shaft of the third dorsal rib
is the widest of the dorsal ribs. The seventh dorsal
rib is the longest and the first one is the shortest.
At least 13 caudal vertebrae can be observed.
The anterior part of the tail is covered by the
ischium, but it is inferred that no more than two cau-
dal vertebrae were covered. This means that there
are no more than 15 caudal vertebrae (Fig. 4d).
Fig. 1. A map of Chinese anurognathid pterosaur sites: Dendrorhynchoides;Jeholopterus;
Dendrorhynchoides mutoudengensis;ÐVersperopterylus (BMNHC-PH-001311).
J. LU
¨ET AL.
The anterior caudal vertebrae are rectangular in lat-
eral view. The last one bears a pointed distal end.
The left scapula and coracoid are fused into
the scapulocoracoid. The shaft of the scapula is
slightly concave and it is slightly shorter than the
coracoid. The coracoid is stouter than the scapula
and it bears a distinct brachial flange. The shaft of
the coracoid is straight. The shaft of the humerus
Fig. 2. Photograph (a) and line drawings (b)ofVersperopterylus (BMNHC-PH-001311). Abbreviations: cav, caudal
vertebrae; csk, crushed skull; co, coracoids; dv, dorsal vertebrae; dr, dorsal ribs; f, femur; fot, fourth toe; fi, fibula;
ft, first toe; h,, humerus; lj, lower jaw; mc, maniual claw; mcI-IV, metacarpals I –IV; mttI-IV, metatarsals I IV;
mttv, metatarsal V; pt, pteroid; rd, radius; sc, scapula; ti, tibia; ul, ulna.
ANUROGNATHID PTEROSAUR FROM CHINA
Fig. 3. (a). Photograph of the skull of Versperopterylus; and (b) Close-up of the dentition, showing the teeth
(arrows point). Scale bar is 0.5 cm in (b).
J. LU
¨ET AL.
Fig. 4. Photographs of the holotype Versperopterylus (BMNHC-PH-001311): (a) whole specimen; (b) close-up of
the pes; (c) close-up of wing phalanges 1 and 2; and (d) close-up of the tail. Abbreviations: cav, caudal vertebrae;
fot, the fourth toe; gr, groove; mtt I– IV, metatarsal I–IV; rft, the reversed first toe; wph1, 2, wing phalanges 1 and
2; st, second toe; tt, third toe. Scale bars are 1 cm in (b) and (d).
ANUROGNATHID PTEROSAUR FROM CHINA
is straight. There is no pneumatic opening near its
proximal end. The deltopectoral crest of the
humerus is relatively small, and is longer than
wide. It is located proximally. There is a distinct
ridge near the distal end of the humerus. The lateral
margin of the deltopectoral crest is straight.
The ulna and radius are parallel to each other.
The ulna is longer than the radius. The width ratio
of ulna to radius is 1.17. The ulna bears a distinct
olecranon process at its proximal end. The shaft of
the radius is straight with slightly expanded distal
and proximal ends.
The proximal carpal is irregular in shape with a
concave surface in ventral view. It is larger than
any other carpals. It articulates with the distal end
of the ulna. There are two unfused distal carpals.
The proximal portion of the pteroid is slightly
curved. The distal end of the pteroid is expanded,
and knob-like. The length ratio of pteroid to
humerus is 0.19. Metacarpals I IV are the same
length. Metacarpal IV is stout. The first phalanx of
the first manual digit is long and slender, slightly
thinner than metacarpals I III. The ungual is deep
at its proximal end and curved with a sharp tip.
The rest of the digits of the left hand are missing.
The wing phalanges decrease in length from the
first to the third. The ventral surfaces of all the right
wing phalanges are exposed. Although the phalan-
ges were heavily depressed during preservation, a
distinct groove appears posterior to the middle
shaft of wing phalanx 1 (Fig. 4c). This groove is
on the posterior surface of the wing phalanx 1.
The extensor tendon process is fused with the first
wing phalanx. The proximal end of the first wing
phalanx is expanded. The first wing phalange is
the longest. The proximal end of the second wing
phalanx is expanded, larger than its distal end.
The distal end of the wing phalanx 2 is slightly
expanded. The proximal end of the third wing pha-
lange is much more expanded than its distal end,
which becomes thinner but is slightly expanded.
There is also a distinct groove on the posterior sur-
faces of wing phalanges 2 and 3. The fourth wing
phalanx is rod-like, quite small and straight with
pointed distal end. This is different to the curvature
seen in the distal phalanges of other anurognathids
(see Hone et al. 2015), but this is also very small
and coupled with the apparent tapering of phalanx
3; thus, it might explain the apparent absence of
the fourth phanalx in the juvenile Anurogahtus.
Table 1. Measurements (in mm) of holotype of Versperopterylus lamadongensis gen. et sp. nov
Length Width
Skull 32.1 40.6 (between quadrate)
Single cervical 9.4 6.8
Dorsals +sacrals 112.9
Tail 31.0
Scapula 37.2
Coracoid 38.3 3.4
Humerus 71.0 6.4
Deltopectoral crest 12.5 5.2
Ulna 96.4 5.6
Radius 92.9 4.8
Metacarpals 25.8
Pteroid 13.7 1.7
Manus digit I: 1; 2 15.8; 13.6 (claw) 1.1; 5.4 (proximal end)
Width of phalange 1 121.3 (with extensor process);
117.8 (without extensor process)
4.6
Width of phalange 2 95.4 2.9
Width of phalange 3 71.0 1.9
Width of phalange 4 14.3 1.0
Acetabulum 7.8 4.7 (height)
Pre-acetabulum process 32.0
Femur 52.6 5.7
Tibia 71.9 6.6
Fibula 47.9
Metatarsals I– IV (whole) 34.5 8.0
Metatarsals I– V 30.9; 34.0; 34.0; 33.0; 13.9 3.5; ; ; ;
Pedal digit I: 1; 2 12.2; 8.1 2.1; 4.3
Pedal digit II: 1; 2; 3 6.3; 11.7; 11.2 2.5; 1.6; 4.4
Pedal digit III: 1; 2: 3; 4 5.4; 4.9; 9.8; 10.6 2.7; 2.9; 1.9; 5.1
Pedal digit IV: 1; 2; 3; 4; 5 4.6; 3.9; 2.1; 7.5; 9.2 2.6; 2.6; 2.5; 1.9; 4.1
Pedal digit V: 1; 2 19.8; 1.8
J. LU
¨ET AL.
The pelvic girdle is not well preserved. It seems
that the pubis, ischium and ilium are fused together.
The preacetabular process of the ilium is slender and
long, covering at least four posterior dorsal verte-
brae. The acetabulum bears a distinct dorsal margin
and anterior margin. The shapes of ischium and
pubis are unclear because of being covered by the
proximal portion of the femur. The femoral head
has a distinct neck, which forms an angle of 1208
with the shaft of the femur. There is a distinct
ridge on the anterolateral surface near the proximal
end. The femoral head bears a sharp margin. The
shaft of the femur is straight. The tibia is straight
with an oblique proximal end. The proximal end
of the fibula is fused with the proximal end of the
tibia. The proximal portion of the fibula is rod-like
but below it, by about 0.7 cm, it becomes sharply
expanded, which may be a pathology. The distal
end of the tibia bears two distinct condyles. Metatar-
sals I IV are in close contact with each other. Their
proximal ends are fused. Metatarsal II and metatar-
sal III are the same length and size. Metatarsal I is
shorter than metatarsal IV, which is, in turn, shorter
than metatarsals II and III. Metatarsal V is sepa-
rated from other metatarsals. It is stout and shorter
than other metatarsals. The first phalange of digit 5
is straight but its length cannot be determined due
to a missing distal portion. The first toe of the
right pes is clearly reversed (Fig. 4b), although
the left toe is slightly destroyed. The tips of the
pedal unguals of digits II, III and IV are pointed
in the same direction, whilst the tip of the first toe
is pointed in the opposite direction in both pedes;
thus, it is inferred that the first toe is reversed.
The naturally articulated dorsal to caudal series
and all other elements that are not missing indicate
that they are not transported far and are quickly
buried after death. Therefore, they are regarded as
genuine, not caused by preservation. The digital
formula is 2–3–4–5–2. The pedal unguals are
curved with sharp tips. They bear a large extension
process. The pedal unguals are slightly smaller than
the manual unguals.
Comparison and discussion
Versperopterylus differs from Dendrorhynchoides
(Ji & Ji 1998; Lu
¨& Hone 2012; Jiang et al. 2015)
in that the length ratio of wing phalange 2 to
Fig. 5. The living scene of Versperopterylus (drawn by Zhao Chuang).
ANUROGNATHID PTEROSAUR FROM CHINA
Fig. 6. Strict consensus of 630 most parsimonious trees (MPTs) obtained by TNT, based on analysis of 68 taxa and
124 characters, showing the phylogenetic position of Versperopterylus. gen. et sp. nov. (tree length, 503). The
numbers adjacent to each node are Bremer support values.
J. LU
¨ET AL.
phalange 1 (i.e. 0.79) is smaller than that of Dendro-
rhynchoides (i.e. 0.88). The length ratio of wing
metacarpal to humerus is also smaller than that of
Dendrorhynchoides (it is 36% in Versperopterylus:
however, it is 40.6% in Dendrorhynchoides mutou-
dengensis:Lu
¨& Hone 2012). Versperopterylus has
a tail that is shorter than Dendrorhynchoides.Den-
drorhynchoides was first reported to bear a long
tail because it was not clearly preserved, and was
once thought to have had the tail added onto the
specimen (Unwin et al. 2000). However, the discov-
ery of more material further confirms that there is a
greater likelihood that it had a long tail, as more spec-
imens indicate (Lu
¨& Hone 2012; Jiang et al. 2015).
Versperopterylus differs from Jeholopterus
(Wang et al. 2002; Sullivan et al. 2014) in that Jeho-
lopterus does not bear a tail (according to the holo-
type (IVPP V12705) and the referred specimen
(CAGS-IG-02-81), which came from the same
place, both do not have a visible tails; therefore,
we inferred that Jeholopterus does not bear a tail,
although we cannot exclude the possibility that the
tail is not preserved even if they do have a tail,
the tail should be very short); the length ratio of
wing phalange 2 to phalange 1, and the ratio of
ulna to humerus and femur to tibia, are smaller
than those of Jeholopterus (IVPP V12705) (they
are 0.79, 1.36 and 0.73 in Versperopterylus, whilst
they are 0.88, 1.44 and 0.80 in Jeholopterus,
respectively).
Versperopterylus differs from Anurognathus
(Do
¨derlein 1923; Dalla Vecchia 2002; Bennett
2007) in that the length ratio of the wing metacarpal
to the metatarsals is greater than that of Anurogna-
thus (this ratio is 0.61 in Anurognathus (BSP
1922.I.42), whilst it is 0.76 in Vesperopterylus).
Versperopterylus differs from Batrachognathus
(Ryabinin 1948; Unwin & Bakhurina 2000) in that
its length ratio of ulna to humerus is greater than
that of Batrachognathus (the ratio is 1.0 in Batra-
chognathus, whilst it is 1.36 in Vesperopterylus).
At present, there are three kinds of anurognathid
pterosaurs from western Liaoning and its surround-
ing areas, in terms of their body bauplans: a tail-less
one, such as Jeholopterus; one with a short tail, such
as Versperopterylus; and one with a longer tail, such
as Dendrorhynchoides. The reversed first toe of Ver-
speropterylus indicates that it had arboreal habitats,
which seems like more of a gripping adaptation: ver-
tical clinging, branch climbing and/or branch cling-
ing (above or below the branch) (Fig. 5).
Phylogenetic analysis
A phylogenetic analysis was carried out which in-
cluded 88 ingroup taxa and 124 characters (based
on the modified data matrix of Lu
¨et al. 2016). We
subjected the dataset to a maximum parsimony anal-
ysis in TNT v1.1 (Goloboff et al. 2008). We first
conducted a ‘new technology’ search (with default
parameters for sectorial search, ratchet, tree drift
and tree fusion) that recovered a minimum length
tree in 10 replicates. This procedure aims to broadly
sample tree space and identify individual tree
islands. We then subjected the recovered most par-
simonious trees (MPTs) to a traditional search with
TBR branch swapping, which more fully explores
the tree islands found in the ‘new technology’
search. This process returned a total of 3 043 358
MPTs in 503 steps. Bremer values were used to
assess clade support. The strict consensus of the
630 MPTs (Fig. 6) recovers a monophyletic group
of anurognathid pterosaurs, with Versperopterylus
basal to other anurognathid pterosaurs. The clade
Anurognathidae is supported by the following syn-
apomorphies: skull broad with very short preorbital
region; palatal elements reduced to thin bars of
bone; teeth are small, peg-like and widely spaced;
cervical ribs are highly reduced or absent; the com-
bined length of the caudal vertebrae is shorter than
the dorsal series; the ulna is 133150% of the
humerus length; the manus digit IV (wing-finger)
phalanx 1 is 1.5 2.0 times longer compared to the
length of the tibiotarsus; the contribution of the
wing-phalanx 1 to the wing-finger length is 30
40%; and preacetabular process of the ilium is lon-
ger than the postacetabular process.
Conclusion
Versperopterylus is the first anurognathid pterosaur
from China preserved with a clearly reduced tail,
and it is also the youngest anurognathid pterosaur
in geological age. The reversed first toe of Versper-
opterylus may indicate that it, perhaps, has a grip-
ping adaptation.
We thank Dr Dale Winkler (Southern Methodist Univer-
sity, Dallas, TX, USA) for providing thorough comments
on the earlier version of this paper. This study was sup-
ported by the National Natural Science Foundation of
China (grant Nos 41688103 and 41672019), the Funda-
mental Research Funds for the Chinese Academy of
Geological Sciences (grant No. JB1504) and the project
from the China Geological Survey (DD 20160126) to
Junchang Lu
¨.
References
Bakhurina, N.N. & Unwin, D.M. 1995. A survey of
pterosaurs from the Jurassic and Cretaceous of the for-
mer Soviet Union and Mongolia. Historical Biology,
10, 197245.
Bennett, S.C. 2007. A second specimen of the pterosaur
Anurognathus ammoni.Pala
¨ontologische Zeitschrift,
81, 376398.
ANUROGNATHID PTEROSAUR FROM CHINA
Costa, F.R., Alifanov, V., Dalla Vecchia, F.M. &
Kellner, A.W.A. 2013. On the presence of an
elongated tail in an undescribed specimen of Batra-
chognathus volans (Pterosauria: Anurognathidae:
Batrachognathinae). In:Saya
´o, J.M., Costa, F.R.,
Bantim, R.A.M. & Kellner, A.W.A. (eds) Short
Communications, Rio Ptero 2013 – International Sym-
posium on Pterosaurs. Universidade Federal do Rio de
Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, 54 56.
Dalla Vecchia, F.M. 2002. Observations on the non-
pterodactyloid pterosaur Jeholopterus ningchengensis
from the Early Cretaceous of northeastern China.
Natura Nascosta,24, 8– 27.
Do
¨derlein, L. 1923. Anurognathus Ammoni, ein neuer
Flugsaurier. Sitzungsberichte der Mathematisch-
Naturwissenschaftlichen Abteilung der Bayerischen
Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Mu
¨nchen.
Goloboff, P.A., Farris, J.S. & Nixon, K.C. 2008. TNT.
A free program for phylogenetic analysis. Cladistics,
24, 774– 786.
Hone, D.W.E., Van Rooijen, M.K. & Habib, M.B.
2015. The wingtips of the pterosaurs: anatomy, aero-
nautical function and ecological implications.
Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology,
440, 431– 439.
Ji,S.A.&Ji, Q. 1998. A new fossilpterosaur (Rhamphorhyn-
choidea) from Liaoning, Dendrorhynchus curvidenta-
tus, gen. et sp. nov. Jiangsu Geology,22, 199–206.
Ji, S.A., Ji,Q.&Padian, K. 1999. Biostratigraphy of new
pterosaurs from China. Nature,398, 573– 574.
Ji,Q.&Yu a n , C.X. 2002. Discovery of two kinds of proto-
feathered pterosaurs in the Mesozoic Daohugou Biota in
the Ningcheng region and itsstrati graphic and biologic
significances. Geological Review,48, 221– 224.
Jiang, S.X., Wang,X.L., Cheng, X., Costa, F.R., Huang,
J.D. & Kellner, A.W.A. 2015. Short note on an
anurognathid pterosaur with a long tail from the
Upper Jurassic of China. Historical Biology,27,
718722.
Lu
¨, J.C. & Hone, D.W.E. 2012. A new Chinese anurogna-
thid pterosaur and the evolution of pterosaurian tail
lengths. Acta Geologica Sinica,86, 1317– 1325.
Lu
¨, J.C., Kundra
´t,M.&Shen, C.Z. 2016. New material
of the pterosaur Gladocephaloideus Lu
¨
et al
., 2012
from the Early Cretaceous of Liaoning Province,
China, with comments on its systematic position.
PLoS ONE,11, e0154888. https://doi.org/10.1371/
journal.pone.0154888
Ryabinin, A.N. 1948. Remarks on a flying reptile from the
Jurassic of the Kara-Tau, Akademia Nauk, Paleonto-
logical Institute, Trudy,15, 86– 93.
Sullivan, C., Wang, Y., Hone, D.W., Wang, Y.Q.,
Xu,X.&Zhang, F.C. 2014. The vertebrates of
the Jurassic Daohugou biota of northeastern China.
Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology,34, 1– 37.
Unwin, D.M. & Bakhurina, N.N. 2000. Pterosaurs
from Russia, Middle Asia and Mongolia. In:Benton,
M.J., Shishkin, M.A., Unwin, D.M. & Kurochkin,
E.N. (eds) The Age of Dinosaurs in Russia and
Mongolia. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
420433.
Unwin, D.M., Bkhurina, N.N. & Lu
¨, J.C. 2000. On the
systematic and stratigraphic significance of pterosaurs
from the Lower Cretaceous Yixian Formation (Jehol
Group) of Liaoning, China. Mitteilungen aus dem
Museum fu
¨r Naturkunde in Berlin, Geowissenschafli-
chen Reihe,3, 181– 206.
Wang, X.L., Zhou, Z.H., Zhang, F.C. & Xu, X. 2002.
A nearly completely articulated rhamphorhynchoid
pterosaur with exceptionally well-preserved wing
membranes and ‘hairs’ from Inner Mongolia, northeast
China. Chinese Science Bulletin,47, 226– 232.
J. LU
¨ET AL.
... They shared a distinctive suite of morphological characters consistent with being specialized aerial insectivores active in low light conditions. These include (1) a wide mouth with a large gape and a sharp isodont dentition adapted for catching and holding insects (Bennett, 2007a;Ősi, 2011;Hone, 2020), (2) small size, a deep wing with curved wingtip and a short pliable tail, which together facilitated slow and highly maneuverable flight in dense forests (Bennett, 2007a;Ősi, 2011;Hone et al., 2015;Hone, 2020) and (3) large, anterolaterally directed eyes that were likely adapted for nocturnal and/or crepuscular predation (Bennett, 2007a;Lü et al., 2018). The gross morphology of anurognathids changed little during their 40-Ma existence, which suggested they had a rather conservative bauplan Bennett, 2007a;Hone, 2020). ...
... Nine specimens (including specimens of Anurognathus, Dendrorhynchoides, Luopterus, Sinomacrops, and Batrachognathus, and specimens NJU-57003 and CAGS-Z070 [Dalla Vechia, 2002;Yang et al., 2019;Hone, 2020;Wei et al., 2021]) show characteristics of immaturity, e.g., unfused articular bones, scapula-coracoid, pelvis and cranial elements. In contrast, the holotypes of Jeholopterus and Vesperopterylus show osteological maturity and are thus (sub)adults (Wang et al., 2002;Lü et al., 2018). Two specimens lack detailed descriptions, and their ontogenetic state is unknown (Gao et al., 2009;Jiang et al., 2015). ...
... Inadequate recognition of ontogenetic status in previous studies of anurognathids has raised concerns about confounding ontogenetic variation with systematics (Hone, 2020). In particular, many length ratios used as diagnostic (e.g., Wang et al., 2002;Lü and Hone, 2012;Wei et al., 2021) or in analyzing characters (e.g., Kellner, 2003;Lü et al., 2018) may change greatly during growth (Delfino and Sánchez-Villagra, 2010). Previous statistical studies on ontogenetic changes in other pterosaurs have suggested or prompted taxonomic revisions for some taxa (e.g., Bennett, 1995Bennett, , 1996Bennett, , 2006Bennett, , 2007bBennett, , 2013Jouve, 2004;Vidovic and Martill, 2014). ...
... Apart from the family Anurognathidae, all Cretaceous pterosaurs are pterodactyloid monofenestratans, and none possess the elongate, stiffened tail of more basal pterosaurs (Unwin 2006;Lü et al. 2010;Witton 2013). However, only a single species of anurognathid, Vesperopterylus lamadongensis, has been reported from the Cretaceous, occurring in the Aptian Jiufotang Formation of China (Lü et al. 2017). ...
... Cretaceous pterosaur eggs and embryos within eggs have been recovered from the Albian of Argentina (Chiappe et al. 2004) and Barremian-Aptian of China (Ji et al. 2004;Wang et al. 2014aWang et al. , 2015Wang et al. , 2017b. These discoveries have included both individual eggs, eggs in nesting sites (Wang et al. 2017b) and eggs associated with females, the latter from the Jurassic (Lü et al. 2017). Such discoveries have revealed much about the early life stages and reproduction of the Pterosauria, as the discoveries are across several different clades. ...
Article
Pterosaurs, the first vertebrates to evolve powered flight, dominated Mesozoic skies from the Late Triassic to the end Cretaceous, a span of around 154 million years (∼220 mya to 66 mya). They achieved their greatest diversity in the mid-Cretaceous and had become globally distributed, even occurring at high latitudes and in a wide range of habitats. The pterosaur record is dominated by occurrences in conservation Lagerstätten in just a handful of countries and a narrow range of temporal windows, most notably China, Germany and Brazil and the Middle-Upper Jurassic and mid-Cretaceous respectively. During the Cretaceous two major pterosaur clades evolved edentulism, such that by the end of the Cretaceous, no toothed pterosaurs survived, having become extinct by the mid-Cenomanian. A distinctive aspect of pterosaur evolution during the mid-Cretaceous was the achievement of gigantic wingspans, perhaps in excess of 10 metres, hyper-elongation of the neck vertebrae in Azhdarchidae, and the evolution of highly elaborate cranial crests. For many years, pterosaur diversity in the terminal stage of the Late Cretaceous was regarded as low, but discoveries in the last few decades have indicated pterosaur taxic diversity remained high until the end Maastrichtian, although morphological diversity may have been low. The demise of the Pterosauria at the K/Pg boundary was most likely due to the same causes as the coeval dinosaur extinction associated with the Chicxulub bolide impact and its environmental repercussions. Faunal replacement by avians is no longer considered a significant factor in pterosaur extinction.
... Within Pterosauria, the clade Anurognathidae, whose phylogenetic position is still contended as either early or late branching (Kellner, 2003;Wei et al., 2021), demonstrates atypical features when compared to other pterosaurs. Anurognathidae currently consists of eight monotypic genera: Anurognathus ammoni (Döderlein, 1924), Batrachognathus volans (Ryabinin, 1948), Dendrorhynchoides curvidentatus (Ji & Ji, 1998), Jeholopterus ningchengensis (Wang, 2002), Luopterus mutodengensis (Lü & Hone, 2012), Vesperopterylus lamadongensis (Lü et al., 2018), Sinomacrops bondei (Wei et al., 2021), and Cascocauda rong (Yang et al., 2022). All anurognathids exhibit mediolaterally wide skulls (≥120% skull width: length) making the depth and width of the skull subequal lengths, ultimately facilitating a mediolaterally wide gape and accompanied by peg-like teeth (Hone, 2020). ...
... Anurognathid feet are plantigrade with predominantly anteriorly directed toes. This would give limited hindlimb perching ability although Lü et al. (2018) suggested that digit I is reversed in Vesperopterylus, which if correct, would have given it a much greater capacity for grasping. More importantly, as with all non-pterodactyloid pterosaurs, anurognathids also possessed three clawed free fingers (that were not integrated with the wing membrane) that would have been employed in any form of terrestrial or arboreal locomotion (Bennett, 2007) and are better suited to gripping than the pes. ...
Article
Across the evolution of powered flight, the ecological niche of aerial insectivore has been occupied by members of the three volant vertebrate clades—Aves and Chiroptera, and the first known volant vertebrates, pterosaurs. However, morphological and quantitative evidence to support pterosaurs exhibiting this ecology remains scant. Anurognathids are an unusual group of pterosaurs in which the skull exhibits the unique morphology of being mediolaterally expanded, so much so that their skulls may be wider than rostrocaudally long. Here, we conduct quantitative comparative cranial measurements and dental morphology in anurognathids against extant avian and chiropteran taxa, respectively, with ecologies and behaviors that are similar to predicted putative behaviors of anurognathids. Comparative analyses of both skull and dental morphology suggest anurognathid specimens in similar morphospaces as insectivorous crepuscular and nocturnal extant volant taxa. Our results support that this unique group of pterosaurs likely occupied a niche of mid‐flight insectivorous capture in low‐light conditions. Utilizing neontological approaches and comparative anatomy our results support that anurognathid pterosaurs likely occupied a niche of mid‐flight insectivory in in low‐light conditions.
... In this respect, the lower leg of Sinomacrops resembles GG 510, however, anurognathids are known from the late Middle or Late Jurassic onwards (except for Dimorphodon weintraubi; see Wei et al., 2021). Additionally, the tibiofibula of other anurognathids seem to show the 'usual' pterosaur features described above (Bennett, 2007;Döderlein, 1923Döderlein, , 1929Lü et al., 2018). Furthermore, to our knowledge, the exact area in which tibia and fibula separate (or fuse) in pterosaurs is not well exposed and depicted in the literature (with the exception of the pterodactyloid Balaenognathus maeuseri; Martill et al., 2023). ...
Article
Full-text available
Pterosaurs are a well-known component of many Mesozoic fossil ecosystems worldwide. To date, marine and terrestrial faunal elements such as cephalopods, fish, marine reptiles, dinosaurs and insects have been discovered in the Lower Jurassic clay pit near Grimmen (Western Pomerania). A new fragmentary bone is thoroughly described herein and interpreted to represent the first evidence for the presence of pterosaurs in this locality.
... In comparison, wukon-gopterids have residuals of moderately elongated cervical ribs (Wang et al., 2009;Cheng et al., 2016;Zhou et al., 2021, but see Lü et al., 2010). For anurognathids, cervical ribs are stated, but not well-documented (Dalla Vecchia, 2002;Bennett, 2007; but see Lü et al., 2018), leading Hone (2020) to evaluate them as reduced or absent. In the more primitive Changchengopterus cervical ribs are apparently absent (Zhou and Schoch, 2011). ...
... The earliest bone fossil remains of a pterodactyloid are recorded for the Callovian-Oxfordian boundary (Middle-Upper Jurassic boundary, [122]), while tracks are referred to the Aalenian (lower Middle Jurassic, [111]). On the other hand, the youngest osteological record of non-pterodactyloid pterosaur corresponds to the anurognathids from the lower Aptian Jiufotang Formation of China (upper Lower Cretaceous, [123]). Consequently, any pterosaur tracks younger than the latter age, including the entire Upper Cretaceous, and the Campanian age of the Anacleto Formation of the present study, cannot be supported by the non-pterodactyloid pterosaur record to date. ...
Article
Full-text available
The Campanian Anacleto Formation holds an abundant and diverse ichnofossil and body-fossil vertebrate record. Despite the striking diversity of this record, pterosaur fossils had never been described from the unit. Here, we report four pterosaur manus tracks from fluvial red beds cropping out in the Área Natural Protegida Municipal Paso Córdoba (Río Negro Province, northern Patagonia, Argentina). Tracks are longer than wide, tridactyl with digit impressions of different lengths (I < II < III), anteriorly directed and laterally asymmetrical. Being on loose slabs and lacking direct examination of pes morphology, the material is classified as undetermined pterosaur tracks. The new find represents the first occurrence of pterosaurs from the lower–middle Campanian of Argentina and one of the few evidences from South America for this time interval. In addition, it is one of the few ichnological pterosaur records from Gondwana, thus shedding light on the palaeobiogeography of this clade during the latest Cretaceous. Pterosaur tracks from the Anacleto Formation allow us to integrate the body-fossil record from the unit and to add a new component, along with birds, to the flying archosaur fauna coexisting with non-avian dinosaurs, notosuchians, chelonians, squamates and mammals in the Campanian of northern Patagonia.
Article
The Gondwanan pterosaur record is scarce when compared with that of Laurasia and is reviewed here. The majority of Gondwanan pterosaur remains are derived from South America; however, the relative richness of the South American record compared with other Gondwanan continents is largely a result of the ‘Lagerstätten’ effect. Nevertheless, the South American pterosaur assemblage represents the most speciose and diverse known from Gondwana, with several lineages represented, including the Raeticodactylidae, Rhamphorhynchoidea, Darwinoptera, Ctenochasmatidae, Gnathosaurinae, Nyctosauridae, Ornithocheiridae, Tapejaridae, Thalassodromidae, Dsungaripteridae, Chaoyangopteridae and Azhdarchidae. Gondwanan pterosauromorphs are known only from South America. From Africa rhamphorhynchids, archaeopterodactyloids, pteranodontians, nyctosaurids, ornithocheirids, tapejarids, dsungaripteroids, chaoyangopterids, and azhdarchids have been reported. The Arabian Peninsula has produced nyctosaurids, an istiodactyliform, ornithocheirids and azhdarchids. Non-pterodactyloid pterosaurs have been reported from India. A possible azhdarchid has been reported from Madagascar and rhamphorhynchids are known from isolated teeth. The Antarctic pterosaur assemblage also comprises isolated remains of indeterminate pterodactyloids, and a possible indeterminate rhamphorhynchoid. The pterosaur record from East Gondwana comprises ornithocheirids, azhdarchids and a possible ctenochasmatoid from Australia, as well as azhdarchids from New Zealand. Although our understanding of Gondwanan pterosaurs has greatly improved within the last three decades, the discovery and description of more specimens, particularly from Antarctica and East Gondwana, will enhance our understanding of pterosaurian biodiversity and palaeobiogeography.
Article
Full-text available
A reassessment of the systematic relationships of pterosaurs from the Lower Cretaceous Yixian Formation of Liaoning Province, China, shows that Dendrorhynchoides should be reassigned to the Anurognathidae (“Rhamphorhynchoidea”) and that Eosipterus possibly belongs within Ctenochasmatidae (Pterodactyloidea). These pterosaurs formed an integral part of a diverse community that inhabited lowland terrestrial environments in the region of northeast China in the Early Cretaceous. A new compilation of data for the Lower Cretaceous hints at a broad differentiation between pterosaurs that lived in continental habitats (anurognathids, ctenochasmatoids, dsungaripteroids) and those that frequented marine environments (ornithocheiroids). Moreover, there is evidence of further differentiation within continental habitats, between pterosaurs living in lowland and coastal regions (anurognathids. ctenochasmatoids) and those living in more inland environments (dsungaripteroids). The temporal and geographical range extensions for high rank taxa that are implied by the Yixian pterosaurs further emphasise the incompleteness and unevenness of the pterosaur fossil record and its unreliability for biostratigraphic zonation. Eine Neubewertung der systematischen Stellung der Flugsaurier von der unterkretazischen Yixian-Formation der Provinz Liaoning, China, zeigt, dass Dendrorhynchoides den Anurognathiden (“Rhamphorhynchoidea”) zugeordnet werden kann und dass Eosipterus vermutlich zu den Ctenochasmatiden (Pterodactyloidea) gehört. Diese beiden Flugsaurier bilden einen integralen Bestandteil einer diversen Fauna, die in der Unteren Kreide ein terrestrisches Flachland-Ökosystem im Nordosten Chinas bewohnte. Fasst man die für die Untere Kreide verfügbaren Daten zusammen, so zeigt sich eine weitgehende Differenzierung zwischen Flugsauriern, die überwiegend in kontinentalen Ökosystemen lebten (Anurognathidae, Ctenochasmatoidea, Dsungaripteroidea) und jenen, die auch oft in marinen Bereichen auftreten (Ornithocheiroidea). Darüber hinaus gibt es auch Hinweise auf eine Differenzierung innerhalb der kontinentalen Habitate, zwischen Pterosauriern, die sich in den Ebenen und küstennahen Bereichen aufhielten (Anurognathidae, Ctenochasmatoidea) und den Bewohnern von mehr küstenfernen Ökosystemen (Dsungaripteroidea). Die von den Taxa der Yixian-Formation angezeigte Erweiterung der stratigraphischen und geographischen Reichweite für Taxa höheren Ranges unterstreichen die Unvollständigkeit und Unausgewogenheit des Fossilberichtes der Flugsaurier und seine Unzulänglichkeit für biostratigraphische Zonierungen. doi:10.1002/mmng.20000030109
Article
Full-text available
Although there are nine genera of ctenochasmatoids reported from the Jehol Biota, at present each is known from a specimen that has either a skull or a relatively complete postcranial skeleton. A nearly complete juvenile specimen of Gladocephaloideus from the Lower Cretaceous Jiufotang Formation of Sihedang, Lingyuan of Liaoning Province is the most complete ctenochasmatoid preserved to date with a skull and postcranial skeleton. Based on the holotype (IG-CAGS 08–07) and the nearly complete new specimen (JPM 2014–004), the diagnosis of Gladocephaloideus is amended: approximately 50 teeth in total with sharp tips; small nasoantorbital opening, occupying approximately 13% of total skull length; ratio of prenarial rostrum length to skull length approximately 0.63; deep groove along the mid-line of the mandibular symphysis; length to width ratio of the longest cervical vertebra = 4.1; ratio of femur length to tibia length = 0.61; tibia as long as the wing-phalange 1. Phylogenetic analysis recovers Gladocephaloideus within the clade Ctenochasmatidae. Gladocephaloideus has a closer relationship to the Chinese Pterofiltrus rather than to other ctenochasmatid pterosaurs. Microstructure of limb bones implies that JPM 2014–004 represents an early juvenile of Gladocephaloideus jingangshanensis, and that the type specimen is not a fully grown specimen either. We assume that the holotype may equate to the late juvenile or sub-adult developmental stage of Gladocephaloideus.
Article
Full-text available
Pterosaurs consist of an extinct group of flying reptiles that show short- and long-tailed species. Among those are the anurognathids whose phylogenetic position has been considered quite controversial. So far, there are about 10 described specimens from the Anurognathidae, from which only a few show the preservation of caudal elements. Here, we report a new anurognathid specimen (IVPP V16728) from Mutoudeng, Qinglong, Hebei, China that shows the most complete tail of this non-pterodactyloid clade. The preserved part of the tail has at least 20 caudal vertebrae, some showing extended chevrons and zygapophyses, which is a very primitive character within pterosaurs.
Article
The leading edge and shape of the pterosaur wing is constrained by the skeleton. Although it has long been known that at least some pterosaurs had posteriorly curved distal wing phalanges, affecting the shape of the wingtip, this has been little studied despite that this may have profound effects on flight performance. Here we examine the evidence for curved wingtips in pterosaurs and evaluate the possible aerodynamic and aeronautical effects. Curved wingtips are shown to be common in both pterosaurs likely to have inhabited terrestrial environments, and those which were strongly pelagic. The recently described genus Bellubrunnus provides new anatomical novelty for pterosaurs having anteriorly directed wingtips and thus likely had a different flight profile to all previously known pterosaurs.
Article
A new anurognathid pterosaur specimen from the Middle Jurassic Tiaojishan Formation of Qinglong, northern Hebie Province is described. The new specimen is referred to Dendrorhynchoides, based on the general morphology of the skeleton, but it represents a new species, named here as Dendrorhynchoides mutoudengensis sp. nov.. It is characterized by the presence of short, robust and straight teeth, and bearing wing metacarpal approximately 40% of the length of humerus. The new specimen provides further osteological information for anurognathid pterosaurs, especially the presence of a relatively elongate tail.
Article
The Early Cretaceous Jehol Biota of northeastern China has become famous over the last two decades as a source of feathered avialan and non-avialan theropods, preserved alongside an array of other fossil vertebrates, invertebrates, and plants. Still more recently, a rich assemblage referred to in this paper as the Daohugou Biota has begun to emerge from Jurassic strata in the same region. Like their counterparts from the Jehol Biota, Daohugou Biota vertebrate specimens are typically preserved in fine-grained lacustrine beds and often retain feathers and other soft-tissue features. At present, 30 vertebrate taxa (five salamanders, one anuran, two lizards, 13 pterosaurs, five dinosaurs, and four mammals) are known from the Daohugou Biota, which was first recognized at the Daohugou locality in Inner Mongolia. The presence of the salamander Chunerpeton tianyiensis, proposed in this paper as an index fossil for the Daohugou Biota, links the Daohugou locality to five other fossil-producing areas in the provinces of Hebei and Liaoning. The strata containing the Daohugou Biota are close to the Middle–Upper Jurassic boundary and belong at least partly to the regionally widespread Tiaojishan Formation. In general, the vertebrate fauna of the Daohugou Biota is strikingly different from that of the Jehol Biota, although paravian dinosaurs, anurognathid pterosaurs, and salamanders with cryptobranchid and hynobiid affinities occur in both. Nevertheless, the Daohugou Biota and the Jehol Biota are two successive Lagerstätte assemblages that collectively offer a taphonomically consistent window into the Mesozoic life of northeast Asia over a significant span of geologic time.
Article
Pterosaurs are represented in China by five genera and some isolated bones ranging in age from the Middle Jurassic to the Late Cretaceous period. Four of these genera belong to the derived monophyletic subgroup Pterodactyloidea; only the Middle Jurassic Angustinaripterus from Dashanpu, Sichuan, is a non-pterodactyloid (traditionally `rhamphorhynchoids', a paraphyletic taxon). Two further pterosaurs (Fig. 1) from the Chaomidianzi Formation of the Beipiao area, western Liaoning Province, occur in the Liaoning beds, several metres higher than the compsognathid coelurosaur Sinosauropteryx and the basal bird Confuciusornis. Our analysis of these two fossils and other components of the fauna suggest a Late Jurassic biostratigraphic age for the Liaoning beds, which are important in the study of avian origins.