ArticlePublisher preview available
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Technological and design process complexities may pose challenges to engineering design and related outcomes through invention. Understanding the trends related to the complexity of inventions and invention processes is crucial for informing engineering design research and education for invention, but has not been formally developed in the design literature. Herein, we utilize a set of patent-based metrics, drawn from complex systems research and engineering design research, to detect various aspects of the complexity in invention processes. By an analysis of U.S. patents from 1975 to 2011, our results suggest that technology inventions have been increasingly (1) requiring larger teams and more distant collaboration, (2) integrating a growing base of prior technologies, and (3) delivering more systemic and integrative new technologies. These trends may positively reinforce each other so as to contribute to a continual growth of the complexity in invention processes. Individual productivity for invention is also in decline, as we measured from the patent data. These findings suggest the increasing importance of research, education and application of complex system analysis methods and tools to control and manage the complexity in invention processes.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
ORIGINAL PAPER
The growing complexity in invention process
Jianxi Luo
1
Kristin L. Wood
1
Received: 30 May 2014 / Revised: 9 August 2017 / Accepted: 12 August 2017 / Published online: 22 August 2017
Springer-Verlag London Ltd. 2017
Abstract Technological and design process complexities
may pose challenges to engineering design and related
outcomes through invention. Understanding the trends
related to the complexity of inventions and invention pro-
cesses is crucial for informing engineering design research
and education for invention, but has not been formally
developed in the design literature. Herein, we utilize a set
of patent-based metrics, drawn from complex systems
research and engineering design research, to detect various
aspects of the complexity in invention processes. By an
analysis of U.S. patents from 1975 to 2011, our results
suggest that technology inventions have been increasingly
(1) requiring larger teams and more distant collaboration,
(2) integrating a growing base of prior technologies, and
(3) delivering more systemic and integrative new tech-
nologies. These trends may positively reinforce each other
so as to contribute to a continual growth of the complexity
in invention processes. Individual productivity for inven-
tion is also in decline, as we measured from the patent data.
These findings suggest the increasing importance of
research, education and application of complex system
analysis methods and tools to control and manage the
complexity in invention processes.
Keywords Invention Design Innovation
Collaboration System Complexity
1 Introduction
The evolution of design processes may shape our ability to
invent next-generation technologies, systems and services.
How do the design and invention process in general change
over time? Is there any general pattern of change in both
technologies and invention processes? Answers to these
questions can guide the direction of future engineering
design research and education for more inventive out-
comes. However, such understanding is still rather limited.
Current engineering design research and education are not
informed to respond to the evolution of technologies and
invention processes.
Indeed, the engineering design literature and engineer-
ing thought leaders have suggested that contemporary
technologies have become increasingly linked and inte-
grated into larger and more complex systems (Simon 1996;
Vest 2009; de Weck et al. 2011; Summers and Shah 2010;
Allaire et al. 2012; Sinha et al. 2013). Thus, a single
individual or organization will be less likely to possess all
of the resources and expertise necessary for designing a
desired invention (Hagedoorn 2002;Luo2015a). More
than ever, scientists and engineers with different expertise
and from disparate geographical regions are benefitting
from collaboration (Wuchty et al. 2007; Jones et al. 2008).
The increasing interlinking of technologies also heightens
the need for invention at a system or system-of-systems
scale (Ackoff 1971), and the need to draw upon a broader
and more diverse knowledge base.
According to the recent report of the joint Committee on
Science, Engineering, and Public Policy (COSEPUP) of the
&Jianxi Luo
luo@sutd.edu.sg
Kristin L. Wood
kristinwood@sutd.edu.sg
1
Engineering Product Development Pillar, Singapore
University of Technology and Design, 8 Somapah Road,
Singapore 487372, Singapore
123
Res Eng Design (2017) 28:421–435
DOI 10.1007/s00163-017-0266-3
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... However, the accumulation of technological concepts created through innovation over time may increase the knowledge demands or burdens on future innovators (Jones 2009). To derive originality beyond an expanding space of prior art, later-coming innovators need to navigate, learn, master, synthesize and benchmark against a wider space of prior art than before, engage more multidisciplinary teams, and cope with increasing complexity and uncertainty in the invention process (Luo & Wood 2017). As a result, achieving originality in design might become more difficult. ...
... Jones (2009) observed an increase in inventors' age at their first invention, which suggests that more education and exploration time are required before actualizing originality in their ideas. Luo & Wood (2017) found a decrease in the number of patents per average inventor, indicating a decline in inventive productivity. Bloom et al. (2020) reported declining research productivity based on firm-and industry-level census data in the semiconductor, crops and health industries. ...
... Similar or related trends have been documented in several prior studies, albeit with more coarse-grained empirical evidence at the level of discrete breakthrough inventions (Huebner 2005), patented inventions (Luo & Wood 2017), or regarding the behaviors and productivity of individuals (Jones 2009), firms and industries (Bloom et al. 2020). Our analysis examines the elemental concepts that constitute inventions and their relations that form the total technology space, thereby providing both finer-grained and more macro-empirical evidence on the possible trends of innovation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Innovation, typically spurred by reusing, recombining and synthesizing existing concepts, is expected to result in an exponential growth of the concept space over time. However, our statistical analysis of TechNet, which is a comprehensive technology semantic network encompassing over 4 million concepts derived from patent texts, reveals a linear rather than exponential expansion of the overall technological concept space. Moreover, there is a notable decline in the originality of newly created concepts. These trends can be attributed to the constraints of human cognitive abilities to innovate beyond an ever-growing space of prior art, among other factors. Integrating creative artificial intelligence into the innovation process holds the potential to overcome these limitations and alter the observed trends in the future.
... However, the accumulation of technological concepts created through innovation over time may increase the knowledge demands or burdens on future innovators (Jones 2009). To derive originality beyond an expanding space of prior art, later-coming innovators need to navigate, learn, master, synthesize, and benchmark against a wider space of prior art than before, engage more multidisciplinary teams, and cope with increasing complexity and uncertainty in the invention process (Luo & Wood 2017). As a result, achieving originality in design might become more difficult. ...
... Jones (2009) observes an increase in inventors' age at their first invention, which suggests that more education and exploration time are required before actualizing originality in their ideas. Luo and Wood (2017) find a decrease in the number of patents per average inventor, indicating a decline in inventive productivity. Bloom et al. (2020) report declining research productivity based on firm-and industry-level census data in the semiconductor, crops, and health industries. ...
... Additionally, the increasing complexities in new technologies, design processes, and organizations, as evidenced and analyzed in many prior studies (de Weck et al. 2011;Luo & Wood 2017), may also introduce further challenges to future innovation. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Innovation, typically spurred by reusing, recombining, and synthesizing existing concepts, is expected to result in an exponential growth of the concept space over time. However, our statistical analysis of TechNet, which is a comprehensive technology semantic network encompassing over four million concepts derived from patent texts, reveals a linear rather than exponential expansion of the overall technological concept space. Moreover, there is a notable decline in the originality of newly created concepts. These trends can be attributed to the constraints of human cognitive abilities to innovate beyond an ever-growing space of prior art, among other factors. Integrating creative artificial intelligence (CAI) into the innovation process holds the potential to overcome these limitations and alter the observed trends in the future.
... However, the accumulation of concepts created through innovation over time may increase the knowledge demands or burdens on future innovators (Jones, 2009). To derive originality beyond an expanding space of prior art, later-coming innovators need to navigate, learn, master, synthesize, and benchmark against a wider space of prior art than before, engage more multidisciplinary teams, and cope with increasing complexity and uncertainty in the invention process (Luo & Wood, 2017). As a result, obtaining originality from design might become more difficult. ...
... Jones (2009) found an increase in inventors' age at their first invention, suggesting increased education and exploration time required before actualizing originality in their ideas. Luo and Wood (2017) found a decrease in the number of patents per average inventor, indicating a decline in inventive productivity. Bloom et al. (2020) reported declining research productivity based on firm-and industry-level census data in the semiconductor, crops, and health industries. ...
... Many of these approaches are based on patent databases. Patents contain rich design or technological information and have been widely used as proxies for technological innovations in empirical studies (Luo & Wood, 2017). Patent data have been extensively employed as digital design repositories to develop engineering design theories and data-driven design support methods and tools , although patent data sources are subject to a complex institutional system and many non-technical factors, such as examination processes, policy changes, and industry differences. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
The creation of new technological concepts through design reuses, recombination, and synthesis of prior concepts to create new ones may lead to exponential growth of the concept space over time. However, our statistical analysis of a large-scale technology semantic network consisting of over four million concepts from patent texts found evidence of a persistent deceleration in the pace of concept creation and a decline in the originality of newly created concepts. These trends may be attributed to the limitations of human intelligence in innovating beyond an expanding space of prior art. To sustain innovation, we recommend the development and implementation of creative artificial intelligence that can augment various aspects of the innovation process, including learning, creation, and evaluation.
... Design methods are recognized as crucial support for design in industrial practice [1,2], e.g., to provide transparency and traceability [3,4] and to reduce complexity and uncertainty early on in the design process [5]. Today, many companies are expanding their value capture by moving towards integrated offerings of products and services [6]. ...
Article
Full-text available
While many design methods are developed, tested and reported in the literature, their utilization in industry practice remains low. Design methods are receiving substantial scholarly focus and are considered central to efficiently achieving reliable outcomes in the engineering design process. They are particularly vital as industrial companies increasingly transition to integrated offerings of products and services with a lifecycle perspective, leading to additional uncertainty and complexity. Thus, the presented research aims to support method selection and development, focusing on resource-efficient offerings. This is achieved through an in-depth, practice-centric, empirical study of users’ requirements of design methods and the corresponding characteristics of design methods aimed at meeting these requirements in resource-efficient offerings. Highly relevant insight supporting a broad set of stakeholders is reported. Firstly, the user requirements and method characteristics reported support practitioners seeking to identify a design method fitting their needs. Secondly, academics and practitioners aiming to enhance the usefulness and impact of a design method may benefit from considering these requirements and characteristics during method development. Lastly, the systematic approach taken in this research can be applied by both method developers and potential users to identify additional requirements and corresponding characteristics specific to their conditions. Two use cases for the results attained are reported, focusing on applying the research results for method selection and deriving overall guidelines for developing design methods directed toward resource-efficient offerings.
... Function expresses the intention of the designer. The concept of function bridges the gap between human intention and physical reality [231] and represents the goal the designer has for the [ 108,109,110,111,112,113,114,115,116] Risk, Reliability, and Resiliency in System Design [117,118,119,120,121,122,123,124] [ 125,126,127,128,129,130,79,131] [ 132,133,134,135,136,137,138,139] [ 140,141,142,143,144,145,146] [ 147,148,149,150,151,152] system [232]. Erden et al. provide a broad survey of functional modeling approaches [233]. ...
Article
Full-text available
In the context of model-based product and system design, the capability to assess the impact of potential component faults, undesired interactions, and fault propagation is important for design decision-making. Addressing these potential negative outcomes should occur as early in the design process as possible to enable designers to make impactful changes to the design. To this end, a set of tools and methods have been developed over the last 20 years that leverage a function-based approach assessing the potential faults and fault propagation and develop system health management strategies. These tools and methods must overcome challenges of high abstraction and satisfaction of safety or risk requirements with limited design specification. This paper provides a detailed survey of a particular function-based analysis tool as a lens to understanding the challenges for other tools in this domain. Specifically, development and evolution of the Function Failure Identification and Propagation Framework (FFIP) is used as a lens to survey the challenges of this field. The objective of this paper is to explore the specific challenges and advancements of the FFIP framework and related tools that address similar modeling and analysis challenges. We provide an overall categorization and summary of the research efforts to date and identify specific known limitations and unaddressed challenges in the area of design-stage system risk and safety analysis.
... He and Luo [98] statistically found the most valuable inventions tend to embed extremely novel combinations of prior knowledge. Luo and Wood [99] also revealed a trend that patented inventions have been combining the knowledge of broader domains over the past three decades. Thus, by teaching GPTs to connect remote knowledge and generate solutions diverse from existing ones, creative reasoning for novel concept generation can be supported. ...
Article
Generating novel and useful concepts is essential during the early design stage to explore a large variety of design opportunities, which usually requires advanced design thinking ability and a wide range of knowledge from designers. Growing works on computer-aided tools have explored the retrieval of knowledge and heuristics from design data. However, they only provide stimuli to inspire designers from limited aspects. This study explores the recent advance of the natural language generation (NLG) technique in the artificial intelligence (AI) field to automate the early-stage design concept generation. Specifically, a novel approach utilizing the generative pre-trained transformer (GPT) is proposed to leverage the knowledge and reasoning from textual data and transform them into new concepts in understandable language. Three concept generation tasks are defined to leverage different knowledge and reasoning: domain knowledge synthesis, problem-driven synthesis, and analogy-driven synthesis. The experiments with both human and data-driven evaluation show good performance in generating novel and useful concepts.
... He & Luo [98] statistically found the most valuable inventions tend to embed extremely novel combinations of prior knowledge. Luo & Wood [99] also revealed a trend that patented inventions have been combining the knowledge of broader domains over the past three decades. Thus, by teaching GPTs to connect remote knowledge and generate solutions diverse from existing ones, creative reasoning for novel concept generation can be supported. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Generating novel and useful concepts is essential during the early design stage to explore a large variety of design opportunities, which usually requires advanced design thinking ability and a wide range of knowledge from designers. Growing works on computer-aided tools have explored the retrieval of knowledge and heuristics from design data. However, they only provide stimuli to inspire designers from limited aspects. This study explores the recent advance of the natural language generation (NLG) technique in the artificial intelligence (AI) field to automate the early-stage design concept generation. Specifically, a novel approach utilizing the generative pre-trained transformer (GPT) is proposed to leverage the knowledge and reasoning from textual data and transform them into new concepts in understandable language. Three concept generation tasks are defined to leverage different knowledge and reasoning: domain knowledge synthesis, problem-driven synthesis, and analogy-driven synthesis. The experiments with both human and data-driven evaluation show good performance in generating novel and useful concepts.
Chapter
Metro rails are the most desired infrastructure for metropolitan cities. These projects are inter- organizational due to its involvement of numerous stakeholders, complex project objectives, and cultural diversity etc., As a result of these specific features, most metro rail projects are facing complexities, which have increased overall project complexity. The analysis of project complexity is a critical step in the project's execution. In this study, a novel assessment technique was developed with the specific goal of understanding complexity factors and their interdependency in metro rail projects. Semi-structured interviews and a questionnaire survey were conducted to identify the complexity and its factors. Decision making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL) a structured method is used to identify the interdependence among its factors. The analysis revealed that there are dynamic relationships between the complexity factors, with changes in one affecting the other. The complexity map and causal diagram are used in the study to represent the most significant complexity factors in terms of their overall relationship with the other factors. This research has practical implications so that practitioners can focus on complexity factors that have a significant interrelationship for effective management of complexities in metro rail projects. As a result, project owners, contractors, and consultants can use specific findings to create management plans and allocate resources.KeywordsMetro RailComplexityDecision making trial and evaluation laboratory (DEMATEL)
Article
System engineering education is challenged to address the need posed by rapidly changing technology epitomized by Industry 4.0 and the digital transformation. In particular, there are relatively slow and inaccurate feedback mechanisms between the needs of employers, students and universities at the level of educational program content development. To address this issue, the Systems Engineering Education Ecosystem (SEEE) was established to create and assess the feedback mechanisms by which educators, students and employers can communicate their specific educational capabilities, desires and needs, in order to provide the dynamic feedback necessary to accelerate the evolution of graduate Systems Engineering (SE) educational programs, clearly communicate the characteristics of existing programs, provide access to relevant educational materials, and create a dynamic self-evolving educational system. This paper describes the vision, objectives, design and development process, current status and future developments, with the intention to support a global systems engineering education ecosystem.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Engineering designers often investigate patents as design precedents to learn about relevant prior arts, seek design inspiration, or assess the novelty of their own new inventions. However, patent retrieval relevant to the design of a specific product or technology is often unstructured and unguided, and resultant patents do not accurately capture the prior knowledge base. This paper proposes an iterative and heuristic methodology to comprehensively search for patents as precedents for the design of a specific technology or product. The methodology integratively mines patent text, citation and inventor information to identify relevant patents; in particular, the search keyword set, citation network, and inventor set are expanded through heuristic learning from the patents identified in prior iterations. The method relaxes the requirement for search keywords while improving patent retrieval accuracy. We apply the method to the identification of self-propelled spherical rolling robot patents. Engineers can use this repeatable method to retrieve patent sets representing the design precedents of their specialized interests.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
This research investigates the effects of using stimuli, such as patents, on ideation outcomes, through the research questions: (a) What is the effect of stimuli on ideation outcomes? and (b) What is the effect of stimuli distance on ideation outcomes? An experiment to address these questions entails an ideation exercise involving 105 participants generating 226 concepts without or with patents and other resources. Significant findings are: (a) more concepts are generated with patents than without patents, (b) more concepts are generated with patents identified by participants on their own than using pre-chosen patents, (c) more concepts are generated using both patents and other resources than other degrees of stimulation, (d) concepts developed using both patents and other resources have higher novelty and quality than concepts generated without any stimuli, and (e) no significant correlations are observed between the proximity of stimuli to problem domains with novelty and quality of concepts. These results have practical implications on using stimuli to improve ideation outcomes for designers, design teams, and organisations, and motivate investigation into the stimuli used.
Book
A guide to using the power of design flexibility to improve the performance of complex technological projects, for designers, managers, users, and analysts. Project teams can improve results by recognizing that the future is inevitably uncertain and that by creating flexible designs they can adapt to eventualities. This approach enables them to take advantage of new opportunities and avoid harmful losses. Designers of complex, long-lasting projects—such as communication networks, power plants, or hospitals—must learn to abandon fixed specifications and narrow forecasts. They need to avoid the “flaw of averages,” the conceptual pitfall that traps so many designs in underperformance. Failure to allow for changing circumstances risks leaving significant value untapped. This book is a guide for creating and implementing value-enhancing flexibility in design. It will be an essential resource for all participants in the development and operation of technological systems: designers, managers, financial analysts, investors, regulators, and academics. The book provides a high-level overview of why flexibility in design is needed to deliver significantly increased value. It describes in detail methods to identify, select, and implement useful flexibility. The book is unique in that it explicitly recognizes that future outcomes are uncertain. It thus presents forecasting, analysis, and evaluation tools especially suited to this reality. Appendixes provide expanded explanations of concepts and analytic tools.
Book
An overview of engineering systems that describes the new challenges posed for twenty-first-century engineers by today's highly complex sociotechnical systems. Engineering, for much of the twentieth century, was mainly about artifacts and inventions. Now, it's increasingly about complex systems. As the airplane taxis to the gate, you access the Internet and check email with your PDA, linking the communication and transportation systems. At home, you recharge your plug-in hybrid vehicle, linking transportation to the electricity grid. Today's large-scale, highly complex sociotechnical systems converge, interact, and depend on each other in ways engineers of old could barely have imagined. As scale, scope, and complexity increase, engineers consider technical and social issues together in a highly integrated way as they design flexible, adaptable, robust systems that can be easily modified and reconfigured to satisfy changing requirements and new technological opportunities. Engineering Systems offers a comprehensive examination of such systems and the associated emerging field of study. Through scholarly discussion, concrete examples, and history, the authors consider the engineer's changing role, new ways to model and analyze these systems, the impacts on engineering education, and the future challenges of meeting human needs through the technologically enabled systems of today and tomorrow.
Article
In the information science literature, recent studies have used patent databases and patent classification information to construct network maps of patent technology classes. In such a patent technology map, almost all pairs of technology classes are connected, whereas most of the connections between them are extremely weak. This observation suggests the possibility of filtering the patent network map by removing weak links. However, removing links may reduce the explanatory power of the network on inventor or organization diversification. The network links may explain the patent portfolio diversification paths of inventors and inventing organizations. We measure the diversification explanatory power of the patent network map, and present a method to objectively choose an optimal tradeoff between explanatory power and removing weak links. We show that this method can remove a degree of arbitrariness compared with previous filtering methods based on arbitrary thresholds, and also identify previous filtering methods that created filters outside the optimal tradeoff. The filtered map aims to aid in network visualization analyses of the technological diversification of inventors, organizations, and other innovation agents, and potential foresight analysis. Such applications to a prolific inventor (Leonard Forbes) and company (Google) are demonstrated.