DataPDF Available

Minimi SAT Formic Submission 201612001202445287

Authors:
  • Independent consultant


  

   
 1 0
 0 N/A
 0 N/A
 
 0 1
!"#$%&   0'$%&  0
(  0 0
)"*+$%&  0'$%&  0
, 0 3
-"#.#
3 1
 !
"+++#/  0 0
"//0  0 0
1"//2  0 0
"//2  0 0
!"//0  0 0
 0 0
)"//2*  0 0
,"//2  0 0
-"0//#+  0 0
3"//*  0 0
"//  0 0
"//#+ 4# 440$51'6  0
1"02/  0 0
"//0*  0 0
!"//0  0 0
("//0  0 0
)"0//  0 0
"
1#
0 0
1$.#
/# 0/# 2
#$ 
"/0  0 0
7/8/+++ 48$ 4 0
17/+  0 0
"/  0 0
!"/  0 0
("/0#+  0 0
)"/.00  0 0
,"/.00  0 0
-"/+++  0 0
 %&& &
++##9 '+ 0: 2


0

0
18#;
 0 4
#++//#  / 4/ 4
!++ 
0
/*+
4
(5<; =
2
4
1
)"+*+=>"$5

0 3
,"+#6 =>"$5 N/A N/A
 !
#8++# N/A N/A
"+/0  0 0
1"+/2  0 0
"+/2  0 0
!"+/0  0 0
("+///*#*  0 0
)"+/2*  0 0
,"+/2  0 0
-"+/#+0  0 0
3"+/*  0 0
"+/  0 0
"+/#+0 4# 4470  0
1"+/2  0 0
"+/0*  0 0
!"+/0  0 0
("+/0  0 0
)"+
 07$ 4
" % %' 
1$#  0 4
1#  0 0
11#  0 0
1#  0 0

0

0
1(+#9  0/: 2
!?/ 2!-?-3?/0 0
1,@##  3?/+# 31?3?/ 4
1-@ 3?/+# 3-3?3?/ 4
13@+ -3?/0 033?3?/+# 3
1@/+  4 0
1+
 0 0
11+ N/A 8 N/A
1*  4 4
1!# / 0/# 4
(
(
(
(
/#

A4
0$51'6
/

148
&
#$5165$6/
8

/
0
/8

$6#/
8
B/!3?

/#

$6
$67 /#

("////*
#*
%:+

C!?


%:+

C!?
A
#

=#

)*
+*,!-.$.$/
$51'6* 
5$66$51
;

+
0#
0
"*+$
1!#+#/# 
+
1)@+" +##

D/

#$  !
"+0
 0"E0 1
7+88+8+
48$ 4470 48$ 4
17++
 0> 4
"+  0 0
!"+  0 0
("+0#+  0 0
)"+.00  0 0
,"+.00  0 0
-"+++  0 0
"  ! &
4
$67#
2
1 /*+=>"$5   0 0
11 /#6 =>"$5  0 0
1"
4 2
1!"#/# : 0,,+$D 4
1(" N/A N/A
1)$;#  4 0
"  ' &
1"/0  0 0
1"/2 FG 4$6 FG 4
11"/2  0 0
1"/0  0 0
1!"///*#* &G 4$6 &G 4
1("/2* F%* 37  0
1)"/2  0 0
1,"/#+0  0 0
1-"/*  0 0
13"/  0 0
1"/#+0  0 0
1"0/2  0 0
11"/0*  0 0
1"/0  0 0
1!"/0  0 0
1("0/  0 0
"" & 
11@#  41-!8;8  0
11# 4 1
"#$  "&! "
1" 0 "E01 2$6E01H7E01 "E0 1
17 88++  0 0
117 +  0 0
1"   0 0
1!"   0 0
1(" 0#+ =" 4$6  0
1)" .00 44> 47 44>1 2
1," .00 4=> 4$6  0
1-" +++  0 0
 %'
/&DE 0/&DE 0
0 1
1#8+  0 0
##  4 4
!"*+=>"$5  0 0
("#6 =>"$5  0 0
 !
"2  0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
F%* 47F$5166$5 F%* 4
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
"
1.##  0'.  0
1+  0 0
#$ & &
8+/#9# 0 "E0 17F"0 "E0 1
48$ 4F 48$ 4
> 17F > 1
"0()
+"1.$$$2-,'32(44.5/
1+## 
'6E>#8/
"

+#

%!3?#
+#

6
#8
7!3?#
#8
4+

7#

E8.#

=9I

-.4.
+1.$-, #(.$-.6-/
.&D+E0&DE $&DE&D"0J=>"$5
F/$6/7/
@/#
###5 $-/ ";
+*8

F


EI//



'#
#
'#
#
"8+/#9#  /
0
1"8+/#9#  /
2
"8+/#9#  /
2
!"8+/#9#  /
0
("8+/#9#  /
//*#*
)"8+/#9#  /
2*4/#
,"8+/#9#  /
2
-"8+/#9#  /
#+0
3"8+/#9#  /
*
"8+/#9#  /

"8+/#9#  /
#+0
1"8+/#9#  /
2
"8+/#9#  /
0*
!"8+/#9#  /
0
("8+/#9#  /
0
)"8+/#9#  /

78+/#9# 88
+8+
178+/#9# 
+
8+/#9#   0 0
!8+/#9#   0 0
(8+/#9# 0#+  0 0
44>1 27F4E6E4>1 44>1 2
 0 0
 0 0
 %

2
4# 
4
 0 0
 0 0
!"++ 
4

0
!!"8+ N/A '" N/A
!(+#+*++#
 0 N/A
 '
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0F%* 3
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 0
 0 4
" "" '
!1#0+*8/+ F 3$6" 7 4
!1"# ( 2 )3 3
!11$#  0++  0
!1++#+
0 1
#$ '! 
!"0/+0 "E0 14# "E01 2
!70/+88+8+ 34# 3
> 14# > 1
!"0/+  0 0
!!"0/+  0$ 2
!("0/+0#+  0 0
!)"0/+.00 44>1 24# 44> 4
!,"0/+.00  0 0
!-"0/+++  0 0
%.*$
% !%" 
(++# 4 2
(*+#
2 2
(1#++
1 4
(*+#
2 3
%" """ %
(1E+#$ 
0
E+
1
(1  4 4
(114# F 0 1
' '"
)++#+# N/A 8 N/A
)"*+=>"$5#+

0 3
)1"#6 =>"$5#+
 0 0
)"+#+++/+++  
4

0
)!@#+8+#
3
$6
2
'    &

4
( 
0
)#*#8+  4 4
)1##;

4

4
'" """ &
)1++ # %
2
5
4
)1++ # %
2
5
4
N/A ' N/A
'#$ 
)8+/#9# .0
0
,8+/#9# .0
0
-8+/#9# + 
+
$.$,&7.$ -2
!"-$88. 
!"-$88.*+ =>"$5"*+"
//1"*+$//1/ 
!1"-$88.# 6 =>"$5
7#
" 
+
'


!"-$88./0
!"-$88./2
!1"-$88./2
!"-$88./0
!!"-$88.8/ /*#
*
!("-$88./2*
!)"-$88./2
!,"-$88./#+0
!-"-$88.8*
!3"-$88./
!"-$88./#+0
!"-$88./2
!1"-$88.80*
!"-$88.80
!!"-$88.80
!("-$88.
!)*#-.8.8#+
E+
*#
+

6#*
+#
+
48 48
!170/++
*

)31)8@/!(8@;8
5$665
*

7+!3!3
 #
#+
+#
E


7+!3!3
 #
#+
+#
$/
+++
E+

/#+++
*
7+#
3!3 
#++#



4.+#
!333 
#++#
,)8@
!)8;5$665

E
H #

8;8
%#

'09:;1#<01);=);7
2-8>-,#($ -428
"*+$
B/$6#
8/+
#

4#+
*#
;
++

"+#+
*##
;+
+

)6/5###*+
*+
$60
/#
*
8
#
9#;

+K#E
/L333!
=+K#E
L3333
+K#&
L3331
=+K'9&
L3
)11.++
)6/5#  1  4
)'#';"*+ ';" 3
3> ';" 3
31 31
!% ? @-( !?
' .
% 4
 ! >-
-
'#
*+

"!
'$%&
'$%&

%"
F.+
>=
!
'
+
33?
3!!?
1()?
1?
333333-!
8
$6/
8/*+
+/G5G
4

E
$6


+#
5$68/
H#H
#


>=/
&*

@
$7 
9
+
'+/
+
=
#$%&

=
#$%&

#
'
D/


&%
$65
,,+"

5
$6H5

13,8;8
&"
$6
$6
 &
#5

!
'.

7F"0
F+
7F
=
#$%&

=
#$%&

=
#$%&

7#

$6#

"+/7F
$5166$5
7F4E6E4>1
%'
'"
 "
7

"&
)33
F+
"""
7
%48
%>

%&&
%/+


8
5
%%'
%%'
 
&
*
$D
++
$

+.+
0+
74E6E4>
*4E6E4>1
33-(8@/-8@;8
5$665
E





3!!8@J,,L((8@
3-8;5$665

E
H #

11)8@;8
=#8/

52/
#
*
8
#9#
;
#E
L33-
#&
L33-)

'#';"*+
>
@-(
'#
*+
Summary Case A Case B
Env Env Env Env
WASTE PREVENTION 4.00 5.00 1.11 1.39
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 6.00 18.00 1.88 5.63
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 12.00 8.00 4.29 2.86
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN 33 333 () 3,
FEWER ANCILLARIES 6.00 4.00 2.50 1.67
ENERGY EFFICIENCY 9.00 11.00 5.63 6.88
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 7.00 5.00 3.50 2.50
Case A Case B
Soc Soc Soc Soc
WASTE PREVENTION 4.00 0.00 0.59 0.00
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 4.00 4.00 0.59 0.59
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 11.00 8.00 1.72 1.25
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN 4.00 4.00 0.59 0.59
FEWER ANCILLARIES 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.03
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 12.00 8.00 10.00 6.67
Case A Case B
Econ Econ Econ Econ
WASTE PREVENTION 0.00 2.00 0.00 2.50
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 16.00 25.00 2.67 4.17
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 8.00 1.00 10.00 1.25
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
FEWER ANCILLARIES 5.00 7.00 3.13 4.38
ENERGY EFFICIENCY 4.00 6.00 3.33 5.00
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 4.00 8.00 3.33 6.67
Case A Case B
Health Health Health Health
WASTE PREVENTION 4.00 0.00 1.11 0.00
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 4.00 9.00 1.11 2.50
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 14.00 3.00 3.89 0.83
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN ,33 ,33  
FEWER ANCILLARIES 7.00 12.00 1.94 3.33
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 1.00 4.00 2.50 10.00
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
@
$ "
@
$ D
,
1, -
(
,,
-,-
( -
,
, -
)! )
33
,- (
,) !3
,),
!,1
- -4
@"4E>&=>M>'E6' 7"E>= "%4>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6' &=6A$ED>''GDB>4G'
F>@>="'$%%"=>4 >'>= GB>FF $>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G >7>'E
SUMMARY OF ALL WEIGHT POINTS
WASTE PREVENTION , 1,-
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY ( ,,
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION -,- (-
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN , ,-
FEWER ANCILLARIES )!) 33
ENERGY EFFICIENCY ,-( ,)!3
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT ,), !,1
Weight
points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
@ 
$ "
@ 
$ D
,
1, -
(
,,
-,-
( -
 ,
, -
)! )
33
,- (
,) !3
,),
!,1
-  -4 
@"4E>&=>M>'E6' 7"E>= "%4>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6' &=6A$ED>''GDB>4G'
F>@>="'$%%"=>4 >'>= GB>FF $>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G >7>'E
@"4E>&=>M>'E6'
@"4E>&=>M>'E6'
7"E>="%4>FF$>'$B
7"E>="%4>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6'
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6'
&=6A$ED>'G'DB>4G'
&=6A$ED>'G'DB>4G'
F>@>="'$%%"=>4
F>@>="'$%%"=>4
>'>=GB>FF$>'$B
>'>=GB>FF$>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G>7>'E
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G>7>'E
> 4 > 5 E
$"  3!- 333  ,
$D 1- 333 !3 333 1,-
$" ,, 3!- ()  (
$D !(1 3!- ) !3 ,,
$" - ) 333 1,- -,-
$D ,( ! ! 3,1 (-
$" () 3!- 333  ,
$D 3, 3!- 333  ,-
$" !3 333 11 - )!)
$D () 31 1, 111 33
$" !(1 111 ,-(
$D (,, !33 ,,
$" 1!3 333 111 !3 -11
$D !3 (() (() 333 !,1
$" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
3
!
3
!
3
!
13
,
1,-
(
,,
-,-
(-
, ,-
)!)
33
,-(
,,
-11
!,1
> 4 > 5
$" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
3
!
3
!
3
!
13
,
1,-
(
,,
-,-
(-
, ,-
)!)
33
,-(
,,
-11
!,1
> 4 > 5

File (1)

Content uploaded by Paula Saavalainen
Author content
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.