Content uploaded by Paula Saavalainen
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Paula Saavalainen on Aug 01, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
1 0
0 N/A
0 N/A
0 1
!"#$%& 0'$%& 0
( 0 0
)"*+$%& 0'$%& 0
, 0 3
-"#.#
3 1
!
"+++#/ 0 0
"//0 0 0
1"//2 0 0
"//2 0 0
!"//0 0 0
0 0
)"//2* 0 0
,"//2 0 0
-"0//#+ 0 0
3"//* 0 0
"// 0 0
"//#+ 4# 440$51'6 0
1"02/ 0 0
"//0* 0 0
!"//0 0 0
("//0 0 0
)"0// 0 0
"
1#
0 0
1$.#
/# 0/# 2
#$
"/0 0 0
7/8/+++ 48$ 4 0
17/+ 0 0
"/ 0 0
!"/ 0 0
("/0#+ 0 0
)"/.00 0 0
,"/.00 0 0
-"/+++ 0 0
%&& &
++##9 '+ 0: 2
0
0
18#;
0 4
#++//# / 4/ 4
!++
0
/*+
4
(5<; =
2
4
1
)"+*+=>"$5
0 3
,"+#6 =>"$5 N/A N/A
!
#8++# N/A N/A
"+/0 0 0
1"+/2 0 0
"+/2 0 0
!"+/0 0 0
("+///*#* 0 0
)"+/2* 0 0
,"+/2 0 0
-"+/#+0 0 0
3"+/* 0 0
"+/ 0 0
"+/#+0 4# 4470 0
1"+/2 0 0
"+/0* 0 0
!"+/0 0 0
("+/0 0 0
)"+
07$ 4
" % %'
1$# 0 4
1# 0 0
11# 0 0
1# 0 0
0
0
1(+#9 0/: 2
!?/ 2!-?-3?/0 0
1,@## 3?/+# 31?3?/ 4
1-@ 3?/+# 3-3?3?/ 4
13@+ -3?/0 033?3?/+# 3
1@/+ 4 0
1+
0 0
11+ N/A 8 N/A
1* 4 4
1!# / 0/# 4
(
(
(
(
/#
A4
0$51'6
/
148
&
#$5165$6/
8
/
0
/8
$6#/
8
B/!3?
/#
$6
$67 /#
("////*
#*
%:+
C!?
%:+
C!?
A
#
=#
)*
+*,!-.$.$/
$51'6*
5$66$51
;
+
0#
0
"*+$
1!#+#/#
+
1)@+" +##
D/
#$ !
"+0
0"E0 1
7+88+8+
48$ 4470 48$ 4
17++
0> 4
"+ 0 0
!"+ 0 0
("+0#+ 0 0
)"+.00 0 0
,"+.00 0 0
-"+++ 0 0
" ! &
4
$67#
2
1 /*+=>"$5 0 0
11 /#6 =>"$5 0 0
1"
4 2
1!"#/# : 0,,+$D 4
1(" N/A N/A
1)$;# 4 0
" ' &
1"/0 0 0
1"/2 FG 4$6 FG 4
11"/2 0 0
1"/0 0 0
1!"///*#* &G 4$6 &G 4
1("/2* F%* 37 0
1)"/2 0 0
1,"/#+0 0 0
1-"/* 0 0
13"/ 0 0
1"/#+0 0 0
1"0/2 0 0
11"/0* 0 0
1"/0 0 0
1!"/0 0 0
1("0/ 0 0
"" &
11@# 41-!8;8 0
11# 4 1
"#$ "&! "
1" 0 "E01 2$6E01H7E01 "E0 1
17 88++ 0 0
117 + 0 0
1" 0 0
1!" 0 0
1(" 0#+ =" 4$6 0
1)" .00 44> 47 44>1 2
1," .00 4=> 4$6 0
1-" +++ 0 0
%'
/&DE 0/&DE 0
0 1
1#8+ 0 0
## 4 4
!"*+=>"$5 0 0
("#6 =>"$5 0 0
!
"2 0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
F%* 47F$5166$5 F%* 4
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
"
1.## 0'. 0
1+ 0 0
#$ & &
8+/#9# 0 "E0 17F"0 "E0 1
48$ 4F 48$ 4
> 17F > 1
"0()
+"1.$$$2-,'32(44.5/
1+##
'6E>#8/
"
+#
%!3?#
+#
6
#8
7!3?#
#8
4+
7#
E8.#
=9I
-.4.
+1.$-, #(.$-.6-/
.&D+E0&DE $&DE&D"0J=>"$5
F/$6/7/
@/#
###5 $-/ ";
+*8
F
EI//
'#
#
'#
#
"8+/#9# /
0
1"8+/#9# /
2
"8+/#9# /
2
!"8+/#9# /
0
("8+/#9# /
//*#*
)"8+/#9# /
2*4/#
,"8+/#9# /
2
-"8+/#9# /
#+0
3"8+/#9# /
*
"8+/#9# /
"8+/#9# /
#+0
1"8+/#9# /
2
"8+/#9# /
0*
!"8+/#9# /
0
("8+/#9# /
0
)"8+/#9# /
78+/#9# 88
+8+
178+/#9#
+
8+/#9# 0 0
!8+/#9# 0 0
(8+/#9# 0#+ 0 0
44>1 27F4E6E4>1 44>1 2
0 0
0 0
%
2
4#
4
0 0
0 0
!"++
4
0
!!"8+ N/A '" N/A
!(+#+*++#
0 N/A
'
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0F%* 3
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 4
" "" '
!1#0+*8/+ F 3$6" 7 4
!1"# ( 2 )3 3
!11$# 0++ 0
!1++#+
0 1
#$ '!
!"0/+0 "E0 14# "E01 2
!70/+88+8+ 34# 3
> 14# > 1
!"0/+ 0 0
!!"0/+ 0$ 2
!("0/+0#+ 0 0
!)"0/+.00 44>1 24# 44> 4
!,"0/+.00 0 0
!-"0/+++ 0 0
%.*$
% !%"
(++# 4 2
(*+#
2 2
(1#++
1 4
(*+#
2 3
%" """ %
(1E+#$
0
E+
1
(1 4 4
(114# F 0 1
' '"
)++#+# N/A 8 N/A
)"*+=>"$5#+
0 3
)1"#6 =>"$5#+
0 0
)"+#+++/+++
4
0
)!@#+8+#
3
$6
2
' &
4
(
0
)#*#8+ 4 4
)1##;
4
4
'" """ &
)1++ # %
2
5
4
)1++ # %
2
5
4
N/A ' N/A
'#$
)8+/#9# .0
0
,8+/#9# .0
0
-8+/#9# +
+
$.$,&7.$ -2
!"-$88.
!"-$88.*+ =>"$5"*+"
//1"*+$//1/
!1"-$88.# 6 =>"$5
7#
"
+
'
!"-$88./0
!"-$88./2
!1"-$88./2
!"-$88./0
!!"-$88.8/ /*#
*
!("-$88./2*
!)"-$88./2
!,"-$88./#+0
!-"-$88.8*
!3"-$88./
!"-$88./#+0
!"-$88./2
!1"-$88.80*
!"-$88.80
!!"-$88.80
!("-$88.
!)*#-.8.8#+
E+
*#
+
6#*
+#
+
48 48
!170/++
*
)31)8@/!(8@;8
5$665
*
7+!3!3
#
#+
+#
E
7+!3!3
#
#+
+#
$/
+++
E+
/#+++
*
7+#
3!3
#++#
4.+#
!333
#++#
,)8@
!)8;5$665
E
H #
8;8
%#
'09:;1#<01);=);7
2-8>-,#($ -428
"*+$
B/$6#
8/+
#
4#+
*#
;
++
"+#+
*##
;+
+
)6/5###*+
*+
$60
/#
*
8
#
9#;
+K#E
/L333!
=+K#E
L3333
+K#&
L3331
=+K'9&
L3
)11.++
)6/5# 1 4
)'#';"*+ ';" 3
3> ';" 3
31 31
!% ? @-( !?
' .
% 4
! >-
-
'#
*+
"!
'$%&
'$%&
%"
F.+
>=
!
'
+
33?
3!!?
1()?
1?
333333-!
8
$6/
8/*+
+/G5G
4
E
$6
+#
5$68/
H#H
#
>=/
&*
@
$7
9
+
'+/
+
=
#$%&
=
#$%&
#
'
D/
&%
$65
,,+"
5
$6H5
13,8;8
&"
$6
$6
&
#5
!
'.
7F"0
F+
7F
=
#$%&
=
#$%&
=
#$%&
7#
$6#
"+/7F
$5166$5
7F4E6E4>1
%'
'"
"
7
"&
)33
F+
"""
7
%48
%>
%&&
%/+
8
5
%%'
%%'
&
*
$D
++
$
+.+
0+
74E6E4>
*4E6E4>1
33-(8@/-8@;8
5$665
E
3!!8@J,,L((8@
3-8;5$665
E
H #
11)8@;8
=#8/
52/
#
*
8
#9#
;
#E
L33-
#&
L33-)
'#';"*+
>
@-(
'#
*+
Summary Case A Case B
Env Env Env Env
WASTE PREVENTION 4.00 5.00 1.11 1.39
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 6.00 18.00 1.88 5.63
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 12.00 8.00 4.29 2.86
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN 33 333 () 3,
FEWER ANCILLARIES 6.00 4.00 2.50 1.67
ENERGY EFFICIENCY 9.00 11.00 5.63 6.88
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 7.00 5.00 3.50 2.50
Case A Case B
Soc Soc Soc Soc
WASTE PREVENTION 4.00 0.00 0.59 0.00
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 4.00 4.00 0.59 0.59
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 11.00 8.00 1.72 1.25
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN 4.00 4.00 0.59 0.59
FEWER ANCILLARIES 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.03
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 12.00 8.00 10.00 6.67
Case A Case B
Econ Econ Econ Econ
WASTE PREVENTION 0.00 2.00 0.00 2.50
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 16.00 25.00 2.67 4.17
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 8.00 1.00 10.00 1.25
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00
FEWER ANCILLARIES 5.00 7.00 3.13 4.38
ENERGY EFFICIENCY 4.00 6.00 3.33 5.00
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 4.00 8.00 3.33 6.67
Case A Case B
Health Health Health Health
WASTE PREVENTION 4.00 0.00 1.11 0.00
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY 4.00 9.00 1.11 2.50
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION 14.00 3.00 3.89 0.83
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN ,33 ,33
FEWER ANCILLARIES 7.00 12.00 1.94 3.33
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT 1.00 4.00 2.50 10.00
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
Weight points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
@
$ "
@
$ D
,
1, -
(
,,
-,-
( -
,
, -
)! )
33
,- (
,) !3
,),
!,1
- -4
@"4E>&=>M>'E6' 7"E>= "%4>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6' &=6A$ED>''GDB>4G'
F>@>="'$%%"=>4 >'>= GB>FF $>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G >7>'E
SUMMARY OF ALL WEIGHT POINTS
WASTE PREVENTION , 1,-
MATERIALS EFFICIENCY ( ,,
RAW MATERIALS SELECTION -,- (-
PRODUCT BENING BY DESIGN , ,-
FEWER ANCILLARIES )!) 33
ENERGY EFFICIENCY ,-( ,)!3
RISK AND HAZARD MANAGEMENT ,), !,1
Weight
points
Case A
Weight
points
Case B
@
$ "
@
$ D
,
1, -
(
,,
-,-
( -
,
, -
)! )
33
,- (
,) !3
,),
!,1
- -4
@"4E>&=>M>'E6' 7"E>= "%4>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6' &=6A$ED>''GDB>4G'
F>@>="'$%%"=>4 >'>= GB>FF $>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G >7>'E
@"4E>&=>M>'E6'
@"4E>&=>M>'E6'
7"E>="%4>FF$>'$B
7"E>="%4>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6'
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6'
&=6A$ED>'G'DB>4G'
&=6A$ED>'G'DB>4G'
F>@>="'$%%"=>4
F>@>="'$%%"=>4
>'>=GB>FF$>'$B
>'>=GB>FF$>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G>7>'E
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G>7>'E
@
$ "
@
$ D
,
1, -
(
,,
-,-
( -
,
, -
)! )
33
,- (
,) !3
,),
!,1
- -4
@"4E>&=>M>'E6' 7"E>= "%4>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%44>%>$E6' &=6A$ED>''GDB>4G'
F>@>="'$%%"=>4 >'>= GB>FF $>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=7"'"G >7>'E
$" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
3
!
3
!
3
!
13
,
1,-
(
,,
-,-
(-
, ,-
)!)
33
,-(
,,
-11
!,1
> 4 > 5
> 4 > 5 E
$" 3!- 333 ,
$D 1- 333 !3 333 1,-
$" ,, 3!- () (
$D !(1 3!- ) !3 ,,
$" - ) 333 1,- -,-
$D ,( ! ! 3,1 (-
$" () 3!- 333 ,
$D 3, 3!- 333 ,-
$" !3 333 11 - )!)
$D () 31 1, 111 33
$" !(1 111 ,-(
$D (,, !33 ,,
$" 1!3 333 111 !3 -11
$D !3 (() (() 333 !,1
$" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
3
!
3
!
3
!
13
,
1,-
(
,,
-,-
(-
, ,-
)!)
33
,-(
,,
-11
!,1
> 4 > 5
$" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D $" $D
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
@"4E>
&=>M>'E6'
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
7"E>="%4
>FF$>'$B
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
="@7"E>="%4
4>%>$E6'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
&=6A$ED>'G'
DB>4G'
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
F>@>=
"'$%%"=>4
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
>'>=GB
>FF$>'$B
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
=4N"'5"O"=
7"'"G>7>'E
3
!
3
!
3
!
13
,
1,-
(
,,
-,-
(-
, ,-
)!)
33
,-(
,,
-11
!,1
> 4 > 5