Conference PaperPDF Available

Impact of Social Networking on Academic Engagement and Performance: A Literature Review

Authors:

Abstract

There is no question that social networking sites (SNS) has gained wider acceptance and usability and becoming probably one of the important interacting tool among students specially at the higher level of educational pursuit. SNS can be defined as: web based services that allow individuals to construct a public or semi-public profile within a bounded system, articulate a list of other users with whom they share a connection, and view and traverse their list of connections and those made by others within the system (Boyd & Ellison, 2007). According to the eBizMBA rank (May 2014), the five most popular SNSs starting from the highest are Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Pinterest and Google Plus. The quick rise in popularity of SNSs began in the second half of the last decade partly because of their extensive usage by school and university students (Kirschner & Karpinski, 2010). Therefore it is essential to discover the impact of the SNSs usage on student academic performance and the engagement. Hence social networking is a tool, with both its advantages and problems for usage and in teaching and learning (Hoffman, 2009). This sentiment was echoed by Hamid, Waycott, Kurnia, and Chang (2010) who studied the use of online social networking for higher education and conclude that, despite the potential benefits they have identified, harnessing social technologies offer both opportunities and challenges. The impact can be segregated in to two main aspects such as positive impact and the negative impact arise in terms of the academic performance and engagement due to extensive use of SNS by the students, especially undergraduates. The aim of this literature review is to bring such consequences into surface from the previous studies to examine the contradiction between positive and negative impact thus to build a conceptual model to inspect which aspect significantly influence most and to propose solutions to mitigate available negative consequence. Keywords: Social Networking Sites (SNS), Students, Positive Impact, Negative Impact
216
Impact of Social Networking on Academic
Engagement and Performance: A Literature
Review
H.A.H. Hettiarachchi
1
Abstract
There is no question that social networking sites (SNS) has gained
wider acceptance and usability and becoming probably one of the
important interacting tool among students specially at the higher level
of educational pursuit. SNS can be defined as: web based services that
allow individuals to construct a public or semi-public profile within a
bounded system, articulate a list of other users with whom they share
a connection, and view and traverse their list of connections and those
made by others within the system (Boyd & Ellison, 2007). According to
the eBizMBA rank (May 2014), the five most popular SNSs starting
from the highest are Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Pinterest and Google
Plus.
The quick rise in popularity of SNSs began in the second half of the last
decade partly because of their extensive usage by school and
university students (Kirschner & Karpinski, 2010). Therefore it is
essential to discover the impact of the SNSs usage on student
academic performance and the engagement. Hence social networking
is a tool, with both its advantages and problems for usage and in
teaching and learning (Hoffman, 2009). This sentiment was echoed by
Hamid, Waycott, Kurnia, and Chang (2010) who studied the use of
online social networking for higher education and conclude that,
despite the potential benefits they have identified, harnessing social
technologies offer both opportunities and challenges. The impact can
be segregated in to two main aspects such as positive impact and the
1
Department of Commerce and Financial Management, Faculty of Commerce and
Management Studies, University of Kelaniya. (email: harshaka@kln.ac.lk)
217
negative impact arise in terms of the academic performance and
engagement due to extensive use of SNS by the students, especially
undergraduates. The aim of this literature review is to bring such
consequences into surface from the previous studies to examine the
contradiction between positive and negative impact thus to build a
conceptual model to inspect which aspect significantly influence most
and to propose solutions to mitigate available negative consequence.
Keywords: Social Networking Sites (SNS), Students, Positive Impact,
Negative Impact
Positive Impact
There are enormous previous literature available which emphasis the
positive consequences and benefits of using SNSs by the students.
Hence such literature can be identified in different contexts as
mentioned below.
SNSs were originally built with the purpose of enhancing social
interactivity. In fact communication is vital for such interactivity.
Hence SNSs are apparently become a medium of communication,
especially among college students and undergraduates. Liccardi, et al.,
(2007) reviewed that the students are socially connected with each
other for sharing their daily learning experiences and do conversation
on several topics. So it is a fact that SNSs would enhance the
connectedness among students in terms of their academic activities.
Further it will bridge the gap of academic connectedness among
students and instructors. Madge, et al., (2009) and Salaway, et al.,
(2008) argue that often students use social networking web sites to
discuss their academics issues formally and informally and also to
interact with their instructor, teachers and professors. Further as a
result, SNSs are encourage to use as a collaborative learning tool.
Griffith and Liyanage (2008) suggests that the positive aspect of SNSs
and their use is starting to be seen, as students are using SNSs in their
academic studies for group and team based work. Similarly social
218
networking sites are also seen to be in use in various academic
activities, including communicating with faculty, and lecturers, and
discussing academic issues with class mates (Helou & Ab.Rahim, 2011).
Later SNSs became a tool that permits the distance learning, to be
more precise as an e-learning platform where students can do things
far beyond communication. Bradly et al. (2010) reported that, for a
majority of students, social networking sites provide significant e-
learning benefits in their courses. Ellison et al (2007) analyzed that
there is a strong link between social networking web sites and
students as social networking web sites helps to maintain relation with
people when they move from one offline community to another. Such
connections could help students in term of home assignments and
projects in terms of job, internship and other opportunity.
As the evolving benefits of SNSs, students are no longer stick in to the
traditional teacher centric learning environment thus they would
encourage to learn by themself and up-to-date their knowledge as SNS
are mostly providing latest findings, news, etc. Tinto (1997) reviews
that new information on social networking web sites encourages
growth and provide students with an ever growing learning
community which in turns substitute both academic and social
success. Despite of the interactivity, SNSs are capable of enhancing the
students’ educational skills. Yu, Tian, Vogel, and Kwok (2010)
determined that online social networking can improve students’
psychological well-being and skill development; desired learning
outcomes. Ubaidullah (2010) indicated that social networking sites can
enhance language, particularly second language, learning since the
social integration, authenticity, feedback, and learner autonomy
found in a SNS are also the key characteristics of successful language
learning, and teachers should consider SNSs as an engaging option.
Negative Impact
Despite there were vast previous literature found with relating to the
positive impacts in terms of the student SNS usage and their academic
219
engagement and performance, yet there were previous studies
pertaining to emphasis the negative consequences. Such literature can
be recognized from different contexts as mentioned below.
Internet is a very important element of life which cannot be ignored.
Internet is used for educational purpose by a large community but
unfortunately we have a large community including majority of youth
and teenagers who use internet only for social networking sites (Boyd,
2006). Though SNSs were considered to be interactive and learning
medium, it was proved that SNSs are distracting the learning process
significantly for a certain extent. This is mainly due to multitasking,
procrastination and lack of concentration etc. Mainly, as a result of
that students are unable to balance a strike between SNSs usage and
their respective academic engagement, leading to lower academic
performance. Among various unique distractions of every single
generation, Facebook remains a major distraction of current
generation (Karpinski & Duberstein, 2009). According to the
Kuppuswamy and Narayan (2010) social network websites grab
attention of students and then diverts it toward non-educational and
inappropriate actions including useless chatting. Kirschner and
Karpinski (2010) claims that students tend to participate in such web
site activities while doing their homework so that it may have negative
effect on their academic achievements by interrupting them from the
learning process. Therefore it is apparent that there is a direct
correlation between SNS usage and undergraduate academic
performance. Negative impact can be seen from numerous reasons
such as multitasking, procrastinating, etc. Even though several
attempts have been made to prove the fact that teenagers seem to
possess skills, most empirical studies suggests that they either lack
multitasking skills or act in the way that has negative influence on their
concentration.
It was evident that most of the students have lack of awareness on
using SNSs for educational purposes while they rely only on social
interactions and entertainment. Despite the fact that relatively large
number of SNSs including Facebook was initially created for learning
220
purposes, there is some evidence that most SNS users show almost no
attitudes towards finding academic information (de Villiers, 2010).
Thus it is possible that students are spending their time on visiting SNS
instead of doing their academic subject requirements. Furthermore,
these studies imply that the main issue contributing to academic
procrastination is the fact that students consider SNS mostly as an
entertainment or social system (Lampe, 2011). In other words,
students tend to pay more concern towards social options of SNS
rather than academic.
Internet addicted people and SNS users particularly, may experience
several problems with their motivation that can possibly lead to the
low academic performance (Ishfag & Tehmina, 2011). Thus, it could
conceivably be hypothesized that achievements of these students that
were obtained in the real life become less important for them than
those in the SNS thus leading to low academic performance. Students
that were involved in the extensive usage of SNS did not pay attention
to their academic conditions in most cases (D’Agostino, 2010). Due to
the lack of concentration and multi-tasking, it was found the student
SNSs users are unable to manage their time available to their studies.
Facebook users devoted lesser time to their studies in comparison to
non-users did and subsequently has lower GPAs (Karpinski, 2009).
Similar findings were reported by Paul, Baker and Cochran (2012), the
relationship between time spent on online social networking sites and
academic performance, stating that time spent on SNSs is shown to
negatively impact academic performance.
Neutral Impact
While many researchers weigh in on the positive and negative
influence of SNSs on academic engagement and performance, certain
literature reported as being significantly neural. The relationship
between students who are actively involved in social networking and
their academic performance is inconclusive (Flad, 2010).
221
Nevertheless, in this study neural impact is not considered since it isn’t
significant comparing to the positive and negative impact arises due
SNSs usage of students. Thus this study attempts to explore the most
influential aspect; whether positive impacts are higher than negative
or vice versa.
References
Boyd, D. (2006). Friends, fraudsters, and My Space Top 8: Writing
community into being on social network sites. First Monday,
11(12).
Boyd, D., & Ellison, N. (2007). Social network sites: Definition, history, and
scholarship. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 13 (1),
210-225. Retrieved May 13, 2014, from
http://jcmc.indiana.edu/vol13/issue1/boyd.ellison.html
Brady, K., Holcomb, L., & Smith , B. (2010). The use of alternative social
networking sites in higher educational settings: a case study of the
e-learning benefits of Ning in education. Journal of Interactive
Online Learning, 9(2), 151-170. Retrieved from
http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=eric&AN=
EJ938842&site=ehost-
live&scope=site;http://www.ncolr.org/jiol/issues/pdf/9.2.4.pdf
D’Agostino, S. (2010). Facebook and Texting vs. Textbooks and Faces. Math
Horizons, 18(1), 34. Retrieved May 15, 2014
de Villiers, R. (2010). Academic use of a group on facebook - initial findings
and perceptions. Informing Science and IT Education Conference (p.
175). Gauteng: University of South Africa.
eBizMBA Guide. (2014, May). http://www.ebizmba.com/articles/social-
networking-websites. Retrieved from http://www.ebizmba.com:
http://www.ebizmba.com/articles/social-networking-websites
Flad, K. (2010). The influnce of social networking participation on student
academic performance across gender lines. Counselor Education
Master's Thesis, Paper 31. Retrieved from
http://digitalcommons.brockport.edu/edu_theses/31
222
Griffith, S., & Liyanage, L. (2008). An introduction to the potential of social
networking sites in education. Proceedings of the Emerging
Technologies Conference (pp. 18-21). University of Wollongong.
Helou, A., & Ab.Rahim, N. (2011). The influence of social networking sites on
students' academic performance in Malaysia. International
Conference on Internet Studies. Kuala Lampur, Malaysia. Retrieved
from
http://utech.academia.edu/shanaleebrown/Papers/1119387/THE_I
NFLUENCE_OF_SOCIAL_NETWORKING_SITES_ON_STUDENTSACAD
EMIC_PERFORMANCE_IN_MALAYSIA
Hoffman, E. (2009). Evaluating social networking tools for distance learning.
TCC Proceedings 2009, (p. 98). Retrieved from
http://etec.hawaii.edu/proceedings/2009/hoffman.pdf
Ishfag, A., & Tehmina, F. (2011). A look out for academic impacts of Social
networkingsites (SNSs): A student based perspective. African
Journal of Business Management, 5(12), 5022-5031.
Karpinski, A. (2009). A description of Facebook use and academic
performance among undergraduates and graduate students. San
Diego, Calif: Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research
Association.
Karpinski, A., & Duberstein. (2009). A description of Facebook use and
academic performance among undergraduate and graduate
students. San Diego, California: American Educational Research
Association.
Kirschner, P., & Karpinski, A. (2010). Facebook and academic performance.
Computers in Human Behavior, 26, 1237-1245.
Kuppuswamy, S., & Narayan, P. (2010). The Impact of Social Networking
Websites on the Education of Youth. International Journal of Virtual
Communities and Social Networking (IJVCSN), 2(1), 67-79.
Lampe, C. (2011). Student use of Facebook for organizing collaborative
classroom activities. Computer-Supported Collaborative Learning, 6,
329-347.
223
Liccardi, I., Ounnas, A., Pau, R., Massey, E., Kinnunen, P., Lewthwaite, S., . . .
Sakar, C. (2007). The role of social networks in students’ learning
experiences. ACM SIGCSE Bull, 39(4), 224-237.
Mahadi, N., & Ubaidullah, N. (2010). Social networking sites: opportunities
for language teachers. The International Journal of Learning, 06,
313-323. Retrieved from http://www.learning-journal.com, ISSN
1447-9494
Paul, J., Baker, H., & Cochran, J. (2012). Effect of online social networking on
student academic performance. Computers in Human Behavior,
28(6), 2117-2127. Retrieved from
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.chb.2012.06.016
Tinto , V. (1997). Classrooms as communities: Exploring the educational
character of student persistence. Journal of Higher Education,
68(6), 599-623.
Yu, A., Tian, S., Vogel, D., & Kwok, R. (2010). Can learning be virtually
boosted? An investigation of online social networking impacts.
Computers and Education, 55, 1494-1503.
... For instance, the use of social networks such as Facebook, resulted in an impact on the psychological well-being (autonomy, purpose in life) of individuals (Verduyn et al., 2015). The discovery of negative effects of social networks in learning environment can be categorize in terms of the distraction of the learner (Hettiarachchi, 2014) or the display of cyber loafing behaviors (Hassan et al., 2015). This is due to a decrease of academic success as a result that learners using online learning environments cannot devote enough time to learning in such situations. ...
... This is due to a decrease of academic success as a result that learners using online learning environments cannot devote enough time to learning in such situations. Therefore, learners may postpone the academic work and spend more time on social networks for various purposes such as entertainment and communication (Hettiarachchi, 2014). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study used a mixed method approach design which included quantitative and qualitative study to explore use pattern of social by undergraduate students SUA. The target population of this study was 3000 undergraduate students in their first, secondhand third year at SUA stationed at Solomon Mahlangu Campus (SMC) available during the year 2021. Stratified random sampling was used to get three strata: first, second and third year undergraduates. From each stratum, 30 students were selected systematically by picking their names from the student registers of classes available from admissions office. Thus, a total of 90 students were given a questionnaire to fill in. The results have indicated that, undergraduate students are using social networks in their everyday life and it is having a positive impact on them by providing them with reliable information on the day-to-day activities. The common social networks have been found to be Whats App, Facebook, Google docs. None of the respondents were found to be using LinkedIn; asocial network very important especially for the students since it helps them in creating good connections and an easier job seeking option once the schooling days are done. The students have reported their preference of social networks over the traditional library, something that results in declining trend in the use of traditional library in the institutions. It can therefore be concluded that social media have become inevitable technologies that help students in accessing information, let alone other services like entertainment and so on. The students have an understanding on social networks but there is a need for libraries to utilize these networks to promote information access. Social Network Entrepreneurship skills should also be taught to students so as to put into good use the social networks students are already using beneficially. When students are encouraged to use social media available or linked to library websites, the use of traditional library will continue as it used to be in the past.
... For instance, the use of social networks such as Facebook, appears to have an impact on the psychological well-being (autonomy, purpose in life etc.) of individuals (Kross et al., 2013;Valkenburg et al., 2006;Verduyn et al., 2015). When the negative effects of social networks on learning environment in learning-teaching processes are examined; social networks can be effective in terms of the distraction of the learner (Hettiarachchi, 2014) or the display of cyberloafing behaviors (Hassan et al., 2015). In particular, academic success decreases due to the fact that learners using online learning environments cannot devote enough time to learning in such situations. ...
... In particular, academic success decreases due to the fact that learners using online learning environments cannot devote enough time to learning in such situations. Therefore, learners may postpone the academic work in online and spend more time in social networks for various purposes such as entertainment and communication (Hettiarachchi, 2014). ...
... Although the use of social sharing networks could improve students' communication skills (Özmen & Atici, 2014), Hettiarachchi (2014) notes that social networks can also distract students' learning. He puts this to multitasking, procrastination and a lack of concentration. ...
Article
Full-text available
In this article, we report on a phenomenological study that explored the use of mobile social media by 21 undergraduate students registered at the Federal University of Lafia, Nigeria, to support their academic-related information needs and activities. Furthermore, in the study, we attempted to acquire an understanding of why these students seem to prefer using their mobile devices and the ways in which their use of mobile devices affect their academic-related information seeking. Following an explanation of what social media entails, the discussion focused on the ways in which information-behaviour elements such as context, the user’s inner person and information needs affect users’ information-seeking, searching and collaborative activities on social media. Also, mobile social media seems to distract social media users’ attention. A semi-structured interview schedule was employed to collect data from 21 students representing different year groups. The findings revealed that the convenience of using mobile social media and the ease with which the students could access information made social media a preferred platform for information-seeking and transfer purposes. However, the participants admitted that retrieving academic information on their mobile devices was difficult.
... One could rightly conclude that students' digital literacy improvement may have been a drive to social media utilisation. With argument that use of social media cause a lot of distractions, that could lead to decrease in academic success (Hettiarachchi, 2014), it was observed that while students are using social media to carry out various functions (such as; socialise, play games, share news, share pictures and videos, etc.), they were also increasingly using social media for more academic purposes. It was this latter use of social media that prompted the researchers' interest and provided the context in which the study needs to be comprehended. ...
Article
Students who receive literacy training tied to real-life assignments show greater improvement in literacy scores. The significance of this study revolves around the prominent role accorded social media in academic community for research, teaching and learning. In spite of the benefits associated with the use of social media for academic purposes, it is observed that many students, teachers/lecturers have not been fully exploring these advantages to improve their academic performance. The study investigated the awareness, access and social media challenges encountered by postgraduate students of Information Studies, UKZN during the lockdown caused by COVID-19 pandemics. The study employed a quantitative research design in form of an online questionnaire, using Google Forms. Fifty-five post-graduate students were sampled, of which 51 participated, giving a response rate of 93%. The findings revealed (Facebook, Instagram, Zoom, Twitter and WhatsApp) as major (100%) types of social media available for post graduate students for their academic purpose. The findings further revealed smartphone as a major tool for accessing social media by the respondents (96%), and the major challenges restraining students from effectively utilising social media for academic activities. The study underscores the importance of social media in an academic environment and offers some recommendations that could lead to more informed and effective use of social media for academic purposes.
Article
Full-text available
SNSs can be utilized to result in an improvement in the quality of language learning in schools. They are a cost-effective tool to support teaching and learning of English, where language learning needs constant communication and interaction. As the world is increasingly becoming borderless with the advances in technology, teaching and learning too should strive to go beyond the four walls of a classroom. SNSs can function as a platform to extend and expand the dialogue outside the classroom or school. They also provide a space or channel to create opportunities for students and teachers to relate to each other both academically and socially outside the classroom. The popularity of SNSs among the young generations today and the growing trend of using SNSs in educational setting abroad should compel Malaysian teachers to tag along and keep abreast with this current development. Proactive teachers should take heed of the rising changes in students' communication trends and reflect upon their pedagogical approach. Teachers should be the facilitators of 21st century skills, advocates of safe online practice, as well as promoters of the constructive use of online interactivity. As the use of SNSs in educational setting is new in Malaysia, there is a vast opportunity for exploration and research for teachers.
Article
Full-text available
Distance education as a primary means of instruction is expanding significantly at the college and university level. Simultaneously, the growth of social networking sites (SNS) including Facebook, LinkedIn, and MySpace is also rising among today's college students. An increasing number of higher education instructors are beginning to combine distance education delivery with SNSs. However, there is currently little research detailing the educational benefits associated with the use of SNSs. Non-commercial, education-based SNSs, such as Ning in Education, have been recently shown to build communities of practice and facilitate social presence for students enrolled in distance education courses. In order to evaluate the largely unexplored educational benefits of SNSs, we surveyed graduate students enrolled in distance education courses using Ning in Education, an education-based SNS, based on their attitudes toward SNSs as productive online tools for teaching and learning. The results of our study suggest that education-based SNSs can be used most effectively in distance education courses as a technological tool for improved online communications among students in higher distance education courses.
Article
Full-text available
This publication contains reprint articles for which IEEE does not hold copyright. Full text is not available on IEEE Xplore for these articles.
Article
Data from a study of a learning community program in an urban community college are used to explore the educational character of student persistence. Analyses reveal that classroom activities influence student persistence by changing the way students and faculty interact within and beyond the classroom setting. Implications for current theories of persistence are discussed and a modified theory proposed.
Article
Online social networks (OSNs) have permeated all generations of Internet users, becoming a prominent communications tool, particularly in the student community. Thus, academic institutions and faculty are increasingly using social networking sites, such as Facebook and LinkedIn, to connect with current and potential students and to deliver instructional content. This has led to a rise in questions about the impact of OSN on academic performance and the possibility of using it as an effective teaching tool. To learn more about the impact on academic performance, we conducted a survey of business students at a large state university. Survey results were analyzed using structural equation modeling (SEM). The results revealed a statistically significant negative relationship between time spent by students on OSN and their academic performance. The time spent on OSN was found to be heavily influenced by the attention span of the students. Specifically, we determined that the higher the attention span, the lower is the time spent on OSN. Further, attention span was found to be highly correlated with characteristics that predict or influence student behavior, such as their perceptions about society’s view of social networking, their likes and dislikes of OSN, ease of use of OSN, etc.
Article
What is really happening on the laptops of note-taking students during class—and to what effect?
Article
Participation with technology for social purposes has become the mainstream communication method for many people in the past several years. In particular, adolescents in high school have adopted these forms of communication as the paramount way to keep in touch with family and friends. Social Networking websites, such as Facebook and MySpace are the most popular places for these students to spend their time, and are the primary focus of this study. The researcher examined the impact of social networking participation among a sample of high school students to determine how this involvement affects academic performance, future plans, and overall attitude towards school. Differences between male and female students regarding academic achievement, performance, and social networking use will also be identified and discussed. Recommendations for school counselors and further studies will be offered.
Article
This study implies the exploration of relationship between SNSs usage and educational performance of the student users. A sample of one thousand students was selected from different universities of Pakistan. In first step of Multistage Sampling Technique, simple random sampling technique was used to select 6 universities i.e. 2 from private sector and 4 from public sector. To form clusters, these universities were further divided and each cluster consisted of four faculties i.e. faculty of social sciences, faculty of engineering, faculty of business/management sciences and faculty of natural sciences. Simple random sampling was done at last stage of multistage sampling. Personally administrated questionnaires were used as data collection tool and 73% students responded back. Conclusion drawn is that student manage their time efficiently and fulfill their study requirements effectively, hence use of SNSs does not have an adverse impact on their academic performance.
Article
Debates rage about the appropriateness of using social networking in teaching, with arguments ranging from waste of time and distraction from academic goals to needed to reach net generation students. This paper explores a range of current social networking choices and argues that like any tool, it should carefully evaluated in terms of affordances and course goals. Several different tools are reviewed, and questions that might be useful for evaluation are discussed. An example of using a social networking tool, Ning, in an online class is reported.