Efficacy of a Multicomponent Intervention with Animal-Assisted Therapy for Socially Withdrawn Youth in Hong Kong

Article (PDF Available)inSociety and Animals · June 2017with 461 Reads
DOI: 10.1163/15685306-12341462
   () -
©   , , | ./-
Ecacy of a Multicomponent Intervention with
Animal-Assisted Therapy for Socially Withdrawn
Youths in Hong Kong
Paul W.C. Wong
Department of Social Work and Social Administration, Faculty of Social
Sciences, The University of Hong Kong, Pokfulam
Rose W.M. Yu
Department of Social Work and Social Administration, The University of
Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China
Tim M.H. Li
Department of Social Work and Social Administration, The University of
Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China
Steven L.H. Lai
Chinese Evangelical Zion Church Social Service Division, Hong Kong, China
Henry Y.H. Ng
Chinese Evangelical Zion Church Social Service Division, Hong Kong, China
William T.W. Fan
Hong Kong Animal Therapy Foundation Limited, Hong Kong, China
This is an evaluation study of a pilot multicomponent program with animal-assisted
therapy () for socially withdrawn youth with or without mental health problems
in Hong Kong. There were fty-six participants. Decreased level of social anxiety, and
increased levels of perceived employability and self-esteem across two withdrawn
groups were observed. When comparing those who did and did not receive the 
component(s), however,  did not seem to have additional impacts on outcomes.
The qualitative data collected through interviews with ten participants reected that
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 1 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 ./-|  .
   () -
the  component was attractive because the nonhuman animals made them feel
respected and loved. This pilot study showed that a multicomponent program with a
case management model correlated with increased levels of self-esteem and perceived
employability, and a decreased level of social interaction anxiety. In addition, using
nonhuman animals in a social service setting appears to be a good strategy to engage
dicult-to-engage young people.
hikikomori – socially withdrawn youth – animal-assisted therapy – multicomponent
program – Hong Kong
Young people who seclude themselves at home, do not attend school or work,
and have minimal social contact appear to be an increasingly common in
urbanized and technologically advanced societies (Kato, Shinfuku, Sartorius,
& Kanba, 2011; Kato et al., 2012; Li & Wong, 2015b). In Japan, people with so-
cial withdrawal behaviors are referred to as hikikomori (Kato et al., 2011), and
they are referred to as “socially withdrawn youth” in Korea (Lee, Lee, Choi, &
Choi, 2013), Hong Kong (Wong et al., 2014; Yong, 2010), and other countries (De
Michele, Caredda, Delle Chiaie, Salviati, & Biondi, 2013; Garcia-Campayo, Alda,
Sobradiel, & Abos, 2007; Ovejero, Caro-Canizares, de Leon-Martinez, & Baca-
Garcia, 2014; Newman, 2008; Furuhashi et al., 2013). Two observational studies
that reported data on the epidemiology of social withdrawal estimated that
the prevalence rate of social withdrawal among youth is about 1 to 2% in Japan
(n = 232,000; Koyama, & Kawakami, 2010) and Hong Kong (n = 16,900-41,000;
Wong et al., 2014).
Recently, with the increase in research on hikikomori in Japan, some
researchers proposed that hikikomori can be further divided into primary
hikikomori and secondary hikikomori (Kato et al., 2012; Suwa, Suzuki, Hara,
Watanabe, & Takahashi, 2003). Primary hikikomori refers to social withdraw-
al in youth that is not associated with psychiatric disorders, while secondary
hikikomori refers to social withdrawal in youth that seems to be caused by one
of the currently recognized psychiatric disorders: afective, anxiety, person-
ality, autism-spectrum, social anxiety, psychotic, and developmental disor-
ders (Kondo et al., 2007; Kondo et al., 2013). However, because of the limited
understanding on this issue, the diferentiation between primary and second-
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 2 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 | ./-
   () -
ary hikikomori, in terms of their intervention and prognosis, is largely unknown
and unexplored (Li & Wong, 2015a).
There is a lack of evidence-based practices for socially withdrawn youth.
According to a narrative review by Chan and Lo (2014), there are many forms
of help and support available for socially withdrawn youth in Japan that range
from job training, online counseling, psychotherapy, and residential care, to
horse therapy; however, many of their ecacies remain untested. As far as
we know, there is only one empirically tested intervention on helping socially
withdrawn youth reported in the English literature (Li & Wong, 2015b).
In Lee et al.’s (2013) study, youth with social withdrawal behaviors in Korea
were visited at home and case-managed by well-trained caseworkers and
assistants. A team visited the home of each withdrawn youth and delivered
ve manual-based, person-centered psychotherapy intervention sessions.
After the home visits, most of the young people utilized treatment centers,
such as attending community mental health centers, visiting psychiatric clin-
ics, participating in camps for socially withdrawn youth, and receiving on-
line counseling. Lee et al. (2013) found that after the intervention, the Global
Assessment Functioning scores and participation in social activities had im-
proved somewhat in 68.3% of the participants. However, their study did not
examine or discuss the diferent impacts of such a program on withdrawn par-
ticipants with or without psychiatric disorders.
Social withdrawal behavior in youth began to attract public attention as
an emerging youth problem in Hong Kong in the 2000s. However, only a few
local studies have been conducted to explore this issue (Ngai & Ngai, 2007;
Wong et al., 2014; Wong, 2009). Wong et al. (2014) telephone-interviewed 1,010
young individuals to examine the prevalence and correlates of socially with-
drawal behaviors in Hong Kong measured by a proposed research diagnos-
tic criteria for hikikomori (Teo & Gaw, 2010). They found that the prevalence
rates of social withdrawal among young people aged 12 to 29 years in Hong
Kong were 1.9%, 2.5%, and 2.6%, respectively, for those who had the prob-
lem for more than six months, less than six months, and those who met the
diagnostic criteria but self-perceived as non-problematic. Youth who with-
drew for more than three months faced a number of risks—for example, bul-
lying and self-injurious behavior, as well as low rates of help-seeking behavior
(Wong et al., 2014).
This paper reports the development and evaluation of a pilot multicompo-
nent intervention for withdrawn youth in Hong Kong. This program adopted
a case management model aimed at addressing a wide range of concerns of
socially withdrawn youth, including self-esteem, social needs, and employ-
ment, in addition to their social withdrawal behaviors through a variety set of
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 3 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 ./-|  .
   () -
components. Animal-assisted therapy () with dogs and job training were
introduced as core components of the program.
 was introduced for three main reasons: (1) the intrinsic attributes of the
nonhuman animals, in particular dogs, that could create a calming efect that
might help to ease the anxieties of withdrawn youth in individual or group
situations (Katcher & Wilkins, 1993; Kruger & Serpell, 2010); (2) the therapeutic
function of the nonhuman animals that can facilitate cognitive and behavioral
changes that supplement the working relationship between the youth and the
professionals, which can help enhance self-ecacy and facilitate the mastery
of new skills (Adams, 2009; Fine, 2006; Kruger & Serpell, 2010); and (3) pre-
vious research has shown that inpatient settings have a positive impact on
individuals with social withdrawal behaviors due to mental health problems
(Matuszek, 2010). Employment training was included because many of the
withdrawn individuals were unemployed, and it was hypothesized that this
component would assist the participants in their job search.
The present study evaluated the feasibility, ecacy, and also the potential
harm of the “Regain Momentum” () program: a pilot multicomponent pro-
gram that involves dogs. We aimed to answer three major research questions
(): (1) What is the ecacy of the  program in enhancing self-esteem
and perceived employability, as well as reducing social interaction anxiety of
youth who have been withdrawn with and without mental health problems?;
(2) What are the diferences in outcomes of the youths who did and did
not receive the animal-assisted therapeutic component of the program?; and
(3) What are the roles of the nonhuman animals in this innovative program,
the rst multicomponent program with an  component to undergo empiri-
cal testing in Hong Kong?
Materials and Methods
A pre-post evaluation design was adopted to investigate the efectiveness of
the  program. A less rigorous approach was adopted because this was a pilot
study, and inclusion of a comparison group, therefore, was beyond the scope
of this preliminary investigation. Individual and small focus group interviews
were conducted to investigate the perspectives on using non-human animals
in the multicomponent program.
Participant Recruitment
In this program, withdrawn youth were dened as young people who, by self-
report, had been socially withdrawn with or without mental health problems.
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 4 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 | ./-
   () -
Youth in these two groups who did not exhibit other mental health problems
were considered to be primary hikikomori. Youth who had withdrawal behavior
and exhibited other mental health problems were considered to be secondary
hikikomori, regardless of the duration of their withdrawal state.
Participants were recruited through referrals mainly from non-governmen-
tal organizations, schools, and the hotline inquiry service. Initially, partici-
pants were limited to youth between the ages of 15 and 24 who were suspected
of having been withdrawn for three months or more. However, the program
accepted referrals beyond the age range for ethical reasons due to the limited
services available for socially withdrawn people in Hong Kong.
A total of 115 youths participated in the  program. Among them, 56 con-
sented to take part in the research study and completed both the pre- and post-
questionnaires. The percentages of male and female study participants were
66.1% and 33.9%, respectively. Around 16% (n = 9) of the participants were
older than 25 years and 7% (n = 4) were younger than 14 years old. Fifty-two
(92.9%) were eligible to participate in the labor force, but 79% were unem-
ployed at intake. About 70% (n = 39) were considered to be primary hikiko-
mori; 22 of these subjects participated in the , and 17 did not. About 30%
(n = 17) were withdrawn individuals with mental health problems, and they
were considered to be secondary hikikomori; 15 of these subjects participated
in the , and 2 did not. Depressive or anxiety disorders (41%, n = 7) and psy-
chosis (23%, n = 4) were the most common disorders among those with mental
health problems.
The  Program adopted a multicomponent intervention approach with a
case management model. Components of the intervention included four non-
 components and four  components. The Pet Partners’ (previously
Delta Society) denition of  was used to guide the design of the  com-
ponents, which denes “animal-assisted therapy as a goal oriented, planned,
structured and documented therapeutic intervention directed by health and
human service providers as part of their profession” (Pet Partners, n.d.). The
non- components included (1) a hotline for referrers, parents, and socially
withdrawn youths; (2) referral to further clinical assessment; (3) 3 to 5 face-
to-face, individual counseling sessions with social workers; (4) support groups
led by professionals. The  components included (5)  in the form of indi-
vidual counseling and small group activities with the therapy dog as a support
to the trained social worker; (6)  in the form of social gatherings with dogs
and volunteers from several dog visitation agencies; (7) a pre-employment
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 5 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 ./-|  .
   () -
training program focused on companion animal grooming; and (8) a pre-em-
ployment training program focused on taking care of the therapy dog in the
youth center.
As a case management model was adopted, the mobilization and coordi-
nation of various service components were tailor-made to the participants’
needs. In general, participants in the  program received all the non-
components (1 to 4). They were then invited to receive the  components
(5 to 8) on a voluntary basis. However, not all the participants in the  pro-
gram received the  components due to reasons such as cultural beliefs,
previous negative experiences with nonhuman animals, or potential allergies
to nonhuman animals. The combination of the service components was tailor-
made and formulated in conjunction with the participant to meet their per-
sonal goals.  was carried out by qualied social workers under the close
supervision of a psychiatrist specialist through a monthly case conference to
discuss and review the progress of the cases and to identify psychosocial fac-
tors underlying the social withdrawal behavior.
Nonhuman Animals in the  Component
Dogs were the nonhuman animals used in the program. They served as an ad-
junct to the social workers either in individual or group sessions. The therapy
dog supported the social workers in fullling two major therapeutic tasks:
(1) facilitating personal expression and social interaction; and (2) creating a
safe environment where the human-nonhuman animal relationship could be
reected on as mirroring the interpersonal issues of the participants.
For the individual counseling sessions, an on-site therapy dog was recruited.
The dog was adopted from a dog shelter after being assessed by a qualied dog
trainer who was familiar with  as suitable for the tasks. To ensure that the
on-site therapy dog could adapt to the new environment smoothly, support
from all the team members in the center was secured before the study recruit-
ment began. In addition, a member of staf at the center, who was a social
worker and the team leader of the  program, was designated to take care of
and provide continuous training for the on-site dog to fulll the role as a thera-
py dog. Measures were also taken to protect the health and well-being of both
the therapy dog and individuals who had contact with the dog; for example,
provisions were made for frequent medical check-ups, veterinarian back-up
for the dog during weekends or holidays, and training for all center staf on the
care and management of the dog. Each session involving the on-site therapy
dog lasted no longer than one hour.
Therapy dogs for the group sessions were provided by two local organi-
zations in Hong Kong specialized in registering/training therapy dogs for
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 6 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 | ./-
   () -
services. Before the commencement of the program, volunteers of the two
organizations were briefed on the special characteristics of the target partici-
pants to ensure that therapy dogs with suitable temperaments were selected.
Around 3 to 5 therapy dogs, accompanied by their guardians, participated in
each group session, which did not last for more than 45 minutes.
Quantitative Measurements
Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale ()
The  is a widely-used instrument to measure an individual’s sense of self-
worth. It consists of 10 items regarding both positive and negative feelings
about the self. All items are answered using a four-point Likert scale that rang-
es from Strongly Agree to Strongly Disagree with the corresponding statement.
Scores range from 0 to 30, and a higher score indicates higher self-esteem with
the cut-of for high self-esteem being 15; for instance, individuals scoring less
than 15 are considered to have low self-esteem (Rosenberg, 1962).
Interaction Anxiousness Scale ()
The  is a 15-item self-report measure that assesses the dispositional social
anxiety of an individual. The items relate to subjective feelings of anxiety and
are answered on a ve-point Likert scale. The scores ranges from 15 to 75, and
a higher score indicates a higher level of social anxiety. In a sample of over
1,000 students in three U.S. universities, the mean value was 38.9 (Robinson,
Shaver, & Wrightsman, 1991).
Perceived Employability Self-Ecacy Scale ()
The  is a 14-item self-report test designed to measure participants’ be-
liefs about their ability to successfully deal with situations and act in ways that
facilitate their career development (Daniels, D’Andrea, & Gaughen, 1998). A
ve-point Likert scale was used to indicate their perceived capability in ac-
complishing job-related tasks. Scores range from 15 to 75 and a higher score
indicates a participant’s stronger belief in his/her ability to accomplish those
tasks (Daniels et al., 1998).
Qualitative Measurements
The les of ten cases were reviewed, and unstructured individual and small
group interviews were conducted within three months of completing the
 program with participants who had received the  component(s) that
examined the potential harm of using nonhuman animals in the program and
participants’ experiences and perceptions of the assisted nonhuman animal
component of the program.
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 7 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 ./-|  .
   () -
Statistical Analysis
Cronbach’s alpha coecients were calculated for the three measurements. A
repeated measures analysis of variance () was conducted to compare
the efects of the two intervention groups (no  vs. with ) on , ,
and  in the three withdrawal groups (withdrawn vs. withdrawn and with
mental health problems; between-subjects factor). Following any signicant
interaction efects and main efects, pre- and post-test correlated t-tests were
conducted for each group, and the efect sizes (Cohen’s d) were reported. The
sample was weighted by the sample sizes to address the unbalanced design for
the  analyses and the t-tests. Estimated marginal means in the 
analyses (rather than the actual means) were reported, given the disparity in
sample sizes. All data analyses were conducted using  software.
Reliability of the Measurements
In the pre-test, Cronbach’s alpha coecients were 0.769, 0.859, and 0.929 for
, , and , respectively. In the post-test, Cronbach’s alpha coe-
cients were 0.876, 0.845, and 0.925 for , , and , respectively.
Three-Way  Analyses
The time × withdrawn groups interaction was marginally signicant, Wilk’s
Lambda = .96, [F (1, 71) = 3.36, p = .071], with a small efect size (eta-squared =
.04). Mean  was signicantly greater at post-test (M = 16.4) than at pre-test
(M = 14.5) in the withdrawn group (d = 0.43, p = .005). The change from pre- to
post-test fell short of signicance in the group with mental health problems.
There were no other signicant interaction efects and main efects.
There was a statistically signicant main efect for time, Wilk’s Lambda = .81,
[F (1, 71) = 16.25, p < .001]. Post-test  was signicantly lower (M = 44.3) than
pretest  (M = 47.6, p = .003, d = 1.16). The time × intervention groups inter-
action was statistically signicant, Wilk’s Lambda = .94, [F (1, 71) = 4.48, p =
.038], with a small efect size (eta-squared = .04). Mean  was signicantly
lower at post-test (M = 45.3) than at pre-test (M = 49.1) in the non- group,
d = 1.17, p = .019. The change from pre- to post-test fell short of signicance in
the .
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 8 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
 | ./-
   () -
The time × withdrawn groups interaction was marginally signicant, Wilk’s
Lambda = .95, [F (1, 71) = 3.73, p = .057], with a small efect size (eta-squared =
.04). Mean  was signicantly lower at post-test (M = 44.5) than at pretest
(M = 47.4) in the withdrawn group (d = 1.14, p = .032) and signicantly lower at
posttest (M = 43.7) than at pretest (M = 48.4) in the group with mental health
problems (d = 1.21, p = .017).
The time × intervention groups × withdrawal groups interaction was statisti-
cally signicant, Wilk’s Lambda = .92, [F (1, 71) = 5.96, p = .017], with a moderate
efect size (eta-squared = .06). The signicant triple interaction was probed
by conducting simple main efects tests of the efect of time within each of
the four groups. The change from pre- to post-test was signicant only for the
withdrawn with mental health problems without . For the ones with men-
tal health problems with no , the means of  reduced from pre-test (M =
48.5) to post-test (M = 33.5, d = 1.48, p = .014).
There was a statistically signicant main efect for time, Wilk’s Lambda = .94,
[F (1, 71) = 4.56, p = .038]. Post-test  was signicantly greater (M = 48.6)
than pretest  (M = 44.8, p < .001, d = 0.96). There were no other signicant
interaction efects and main efects.
Self-Reported Qualitative Process Outcomes
Ten respondents who had participated in the  components were inter-
viewed either individually or in small groups of 2 to 3. Examples of the in-
terview questions included “Why did you decide to stay at home in the rst
place?”, “What did the social workers in the organization do to make you in-
terested in the program?”, and “How did you feel about having a therapy dog
in the program?” The interviews were transcribed and a thematic analysis was
In general, participants gave positive feedback about the intervention. No
potential harm was recorded in the case les or reported in the interviews.
We identied two major themes: (1) The  component(s) served as a cata-
lyst for program participation. Some participants were attracted by the inclu-
sion of dogs in the program, which aroused their interest to learn more about
it. Among the ten participants interviewed, three participants stated that if
it were not for the inclusion of nonhuman animals, they probably would not
have joined the  program at all. This result was echoed by ndings of the
intake assessment. Respondents were asked in the intake assessment if there
were no  component, would they would join the  program. Around
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 9 5/18/2017 8:26:44 PM
  ./-|  .
   () -
one fourth (23.2%) of the respondents stated that they would denitely not or
probably not do so. Further, engagement through the therapy dog was found to
have minimized the negative stigma attached to being “in counseling.
(2) The presence of the therapy dog(s) enhanced the therapeutic environ-
ment. A majority of the interviewees expressed that the most helpful element
in the  project was feeling that the therapy dog(s) accepted them as they
were. One participant who had previously experienced being bullied said he
felt more at ease when interacting with the on-site therapy dog, whom he per-
ceived to be “very straightforward and simple.” Some participants originally
felt that seeing a social worker was threatening and anxiety provoking; but the
presence of the on-site therapy dog was enough to calm them down and pro-
vided a distraction from their anxiety. One participant expressed that she felt
less depressed and that her mood improved with the therapy dog during her
counseling session. The participants also spoke of having a sense of achieve-
ment after the dog grooming training session. Taking care of the on-site ther-
apy dog provided the participants with a high level of satisfaction and a sense
of worth. As one participant described, “If you helped them [the nonhuman
animals], they would show their happiness directly, as if they wanted to say
‘Thank you.’”
In this study, we sought to provide empirical data to evaluate the ecacy of a
multicomponent program with  and job training in enhancing self-esteem
and perceived employability, and reducing social anxiety of young people who
were socially withdrawn with and without mental health problems, using an
uncontrolled research methodology. Although this was an uncontrolled study
with a small number of participants, irrespective of whether the participant
had received  as an intervention component, the  program appeared to
have achieved its goals of enhancing self-esteem and perceived employability,
as well as reducing social anxiety for socially withdrawn youth without (pri-
mary hikikomori) and with mental health problems (secondary hikikomori).
The  component did not seem to provide statistically signicant additional
impacts on the outcomes of the program.
Based on the analysis of qualitative ndings from the ten in-depth inter-
views, it seems that the involvement of nonhuman animals (therapy dog,
visiting dogs, dog grooming training) was an important factor in attracting
withdrawn youth to join and remain in the program, helping the partici-
pants to feel comfortable with the intervention setting, and giving them extra
opportunities and responsibilities to look after the on-site therapy dog. Most
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 10 5/18/2017 8:26:45 PM
 | ./-
   () -
importantly, adverse harmful efects were not observed in the participants
who completed the program, although we acknowledge that most likely, those
who felt uncomfortable with nonhuman animals had already refused to par-
ticipate in the  component at the very beginning. Also, post-intervention
data showed that the percentage of those unemployed at intake dropped from
85% to 33%, indicating that the job training component was helpful and that
the participants were able to step out from their withdrawn status and re-enter
the society.
This study was one of the very rst programs developed for socially with-
drawn youth being evaluated in places with such youth issues, and the inclu-
sion of nonhuman animals in social services was novel in Hong Kong. At this
stage, it is premature to conclude that such multicomponent programs with
 are efective in helping socially withdrawn youth in terms of their with-
drawn status. Participation in the  component(s) was self-selected, and on
a voluntary basis, probably driven by previous positive experience in keeping
companion animals and a more positive attitude toward dogs. This might limit
the generalizability of the results to those who are less comfortable with non-
human animals. Future evaluation studies should focus on the content and
designs of the programs to determine the correlational or causal efects of the
improvements of outcomes with specic program components.
In sum, the  program has provided an alternative model for providing social
services for withdrawn youth who are usually dicult to identify, engage, and
retain for services. There were correlations between the program as a whole
with post-intervention improvement in self-esteem, reduction in social anxi-
ety level, and increased perceived employability of the participants. The 
program is distinctive from other service approaches for withdrawn youth who
tend to be “invisible” in society (Li & Wong, 2015a) and shy away from tradi-
tional service models. We believe that the results drawn from this study are
an important reminder of the real diculties we face in dealing with emerg-
ing problems among youth and that innovation is needed to tackle this new
The “Regain Momentum” Animal-Assisted Therapy () Mentorship Pro-
gram ( Program) was a 2-year pioneer project launched by the Chinese
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 11 5/18/2017 8:26:45 PM
  ./-|  .
   () -
Evangelical Zion Church in 2010 with funding from the Bank of China Car-
ing - Heart Warming Campaign. We thank all the volunteer nonhuman
animals and guardians of the animals who participated in the program. And
most importantly, we thank all the colleagues from the Chinese Evangelical
Zion Church who made this research possible. In delivering these services, the
 Program also worked in partnership with several agencies: the Richmond
Fellowship of Hong Kong who provided clinical psychology services, the Hong
Kong Animal Therapy Foundation and Fat Fat the therapy dog who provided
 supervision, and the Animal Asia and Mongrel Club who provided nonhu-
man animal visitations.
Adams, N. (2009). Animal assisted interventions for adolescents with emotional and
behavioural problems: A review of selected literature. Unpublished postgraduate
diploma dissertation. Monash University: Melbourne.
Census and Statistics Department. . (2006). Thematic household survey report
no.26: Keeping of pets by household. Retrieved Oct 17, 2016, from http://www
Daniels, J., D’Andrea, M., & Gaughen, K. J. S. (1998). Testing the validity and reliability
of the Perceived Employability Scale () among a culturally diverse population.
Journal of Employment Counseling, 35(3), 114-123.
De Michele, F., Caredda, M., Delle Chiaie, R., Salviati, M., & Biondi, M. (2012).
[Hikikomori (ひきこもり): A culture-bound syndrome in the web 2.0 era]. Rivista
di Psichiatria, 48(4), 354-358.
Furuhashi, T., Tsuda, H., Ogawa, T., Suzuki, K., Shimizu, M., Teruyama, J., … Pionnié-
Dax, N. (2013). État des lieux, points communs et diférences entre des jeunes adultes
retirants sociaux en France et au Japon (Hikikomori). L’Evolution Psychiatrique,
78(2), 249-266.
Garcia-Campayo, J., Alda, M., Sobradiel, N., & Abos, B. S. (2007). A case report of hikiko-
mori in Spain. Medicina Clinica, 129, 318-319.
Fine, A. H. (2006). Incorporating animal-assisted therapy into psychotherapy: Guide-
lines and suggestions for therapists. In A. H. Fine (Ed.), Handbook on animal-assisted
therapy: Theoretical foundations and guidelines for practice (pp. 167-206). San Diego:
Academic Press.
Katcher, A., & Wilkins, G. (1993). Dialogue with animals: Its nature and culture. In
S. R. Kellert & E. O. Wilson (Eds.), The biophilia hypothesis (pp. 173-200). Washington,
..: Island Press.
Kato, T. A., Shinfuku, N., Sartorius, N., & Kanba, S. (2011). Are Japan’s hikikomori and
depression in young people spreading abroad?. The Lancet, 378(9796), 1070.
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 12 5/18/2017 8:26:46 PM
 | ./-
   () -
Kato, T. A., Tateno, M., Shinfuku, N., Fujisawa, D., Teo, A. R., Sartorius, N., & Kanba, S.
(2012). Does the ‘hikikomori’ syndrome of social withdrawal exist outside Japan? A
preliminary international investigation. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemi-
olgy, 47, 1061-1075.
Kondo, N., Iwazaki, H., Kobayashi, M., & Miyazawa, H. (2007). [Psychiatric background
of social withdrawal in adolescence]. Seishin Shinkeigaku Zasshi, 109, 834-843.
Kondo, N., Sakai, M., Kuroda, Y., Kiyota, Y., Kitabata, Y., & Kurosawa, M. (2013). General
condition of hikikomori (prolonged social withdrawal) in Japan: Psychiatric diag-
nosis and outcome in mental health welfare centres. International Journal of Social
Psychiatry, 59(1), 79-86.
Koyama, A., Miyake, Y., Kawakami, N., Tsuchiya, M., Tachimori, H., Takeshima, T., &
World Mental Health Japan Survey Group. (2010). Lifetime prevalence, psychiatric
comorbidity and demographic correlates of “hikikomori” in a community popula-
tion in Japan. Psychiatry Research, 176(1), 69-74.
Kruger, K. A., & Serpell, J. (2010). Animal-assisted interventions in mental health:
Denitions and theoretical foundations. In A. H. Fine (Ed.), Handbook on animal-
assisted therapy: Theoretical foundations and guidelines for practice (pp. 33-46).
Amsterdam: Elsevier.
Lee, Y. S., Lee, J. Y., Choi, T. Y., & Choi, J. T. (2013). Home visitation program for detecting,
evaluating and treating socially withdrawn youth in Korea. Psychiatry and Clinical
Neurosciences, 67(4), 193-202.
Li, T. M. H., & Wong, P. W. C. (2015a). Editorial commentary: Pathological social with-
drawal during in adolescence: A culture-specic or a global phenomenon? Journal
of Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 56(10), 1039-1041.
Li, T. M. H., & Wong, P. W. C. (2015b). Youth social withdrawal behavior (hikikomori):
A systematic review of qualitative and quantitative studies. Australian and New
Zealand Journal of Psychiatry, 49(7), 595-609.
Matuszek, S. (2010). Animal-facilitated therapy in various patient populations: System-
atic literature review. Holistic Nursing Practice, 24(4), 187-203.
Newman, K. S. (2008). Ties that bind: Cultural interpretations of delayed adulthood in
western Europe and Japan. Sociological Forum, 23(4), 645-669.
Ngai, S. S. Y., & Ngai, N. P. (2007). Empowerment or disempowerment? A review of
youth training schemes for non-engaged young people in Hong Kong. Adolescence,
42(165), 137.
Nimer, J., & Lundahl, B. (2007). Animal-assisted therapy: A meta-analysis. Anthrozoös,
20(3), 225-238.
Ovejero, S., Caro-Cañizares, I., de León-Martínez, V., & Baca-Garcia, E. (2014). Prolonged
social withdrawal disorder: A hikikomori case in Spain. International Journal of
Social Psychiatry, 60(6), 562-565.
Pet Partners. (n.d.). Terminology. Retrieved Oct 17, 2016, from https://petpartners.org/
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 13 5/18/2017 8:26:46 PM
  ./-|  .
   () -
Robinson, J. R., Shaver, P. R., & Wrightsman, L. S. (1991). Measures of personality and
social psychological attitudes. London: Academic Press Limited.
Rosenberg, M. (1979). Conceiving the self. New York: Basic Books.
Suwa, M., Suzuki, K., Hara, K., Watanabe, H., & Takahashi, T. (2003). Family fea-
tures in primary social withdrawal among young adults. Psychiatry and Clinical
Neurosciences, 57(6), 586-594.
Teo, A. R., & Gaw, A. C. (2010). Hikikomori, a Japanese culture-bound syndrome
of social withdrawal?: A proposal for -5. The Journal of Nervous and Mental
Disease, 198(6), 444-449.
Wong, P. W. C., Li, T. M. H., Chan, M., Law, Y. W., Chau, M., Cheng, C., Yip, P. S. F.
(2015). The prevalence and correlates of severe social withdrawal (hikikomori) in
Hong Kong: A cross-sectional telephone-based survey study. International Journal
of Social Psychiatry, 61(4), 330-342.
Wong, V. (2009). Youth locked in time and space? Dening features of social with-
drawal and practice implications. Journal of Social Work Practice, 23(3), 337-352.
Yong, R. (2010). Exploring hikikomori: A mixed methods qualitative approach (Unpub-
lished master’s dissertation). The University of Hong Kong.
SOAN_advance_Wong.indd 14 5/18/2017 8:26:46 PM
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Background: Socially withdrawn youth belong to an emerging subgroup of youth who are not in employment, education, or training and who have limited social interaction intention and opportunities. The use of the internet and social media is expected to be an alternative and feasible way to reach this group of young people because of their reclusive nature. Objective: The aim of this study was to explore the possibility of using various social media platforms to investigate the existence of the phenomenon of youth social withdrawal in 3 major cities in China. Methods: A cross-sectional open Web survey was conducted from October 2015 to May 2016 to identify and reach socially withdrawn youth in 3 metropolitan cities in China: Beijing, Shanghai, and Shenzhen. To advertise the survey, 3 social media platforms were used: Weibo, WeChat, and Wandianba, a social networking gaming website. Results: In total, 137 participants completed the survey, among whom 13 (9.5%) were identified as belonging to the withdrawal group, 7 (5.1%) to the asocial group, and 9 (6.6%) to the hikikomori group (both withdrawn and asocial for more than 3 months). The cost of recruitment via Weibo was US $7.27 per participant. Conclusions: Several social media platforms in China are viable and inexpensive tools to reach socially withdrawn youth, and internet platforms that specialize in a certain culture or type of entertainment appeared to be more effective in reaching socially withdrawn youth.
  • Article
    This commentary aims to expand on the well-articulated review on youth resilience by Ungar et al. (2017), with reference to promoting resilience among young people residing in Western settings. In this commentary, we highlight some Asian perspectives on the development of resilience of school-aged young people. We also suggest two new potentially useful resources that may be incorporated into the theoretical framework proposed in the review article. We believe the proposed resources could represent emerging assets that young people around the world can utilize to enhance their resilience.
  • Article
    Social withdrawal is a new mental health problem increasingly common, present in different cultures, whose psychopathology and treatment is not yet established. This study aims to determine the socio-demographic and clinical features and possible clinical subtypes that predict the 12-month outcomes of cases with hikikomori syndrome, a severe form of social withdrawal. Socio-demographic and clinical data at baseline were analysed as well as data obtained for 12 months after at-home treatment in 190 cases. The inclusion criteria were: spending all time at home, avoiding social situations and relationships, significant deterioration due to social isolation, with a minimum duration of 6 months. Six major diagnostic groups were identified: affective, anxiety, psychotic, drug use, personality and other Axis I disorders. The anxiety-affective subgroup demonstrated lower clinical severity, but worse evolution. Less than half of the cases were available for medical follow-up at 12-months. Subjects undergoing intensive treatment had a higher medical follow-up rate and better social networks at 12-months. Therefore, our findings provide data to reach consensus on the specific characteristics of social isolation hikikomori syndrome. The analysis demonstrated the fragility and tendency to relapse and have disengagement, particularly relevant in the anxiety-affective subgroup, suggesting that intensive treatments are more effective.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    The term NEET (not in employment, education, or training) has been increasingly applied to young people in Europe not engaged in the three systems mentioned. Young people who seclude themselves at home and progress to social withdrawal can be considered a NEET subgroup—the “disengaged.” This phenomenon was first identified in Japan, where such reclusive individuals are referred to as hikikomori, but youth social withdrawal has also been reported in other countries, including South Korea and Hong Kong. Research on youth social withdrawal has mainly focused on describing and identifying contributing factors to this withdrawal behavior. Very few studies have examined the transitional processes from the initial self-seclusion to later help-seeking. Examining the mechanisms behind the engagement process for helping professionals is important to guide social work services for this unique group of young people. We conducted a qualitative study involving semi-structured interviews with 30 socially withdrawn young people in Hong Kong. Thematic analysis conceptualized their social withdrawal processes into three subthemes: private status, de-friending spiral, and suspension of experiences. Three reasons for changing their withdrawal behavior were also identified: rebalancing one’s ideal self with reality, reconnecting with tuned-in people, and regaining momentum in life. This study provides practical implications for social workers to develop approaches to engage withdrawn young people.
  • Chapter
    Research is needed to identify the underlying mechanisms of animal-assisted therapy (AAT) that produce therapeutic changes. The findings from the studies would be valuable to understand how the interventions work, so that the best practice procedures can be implemented. There is a limited awareness of how AAI is applied and there is a need to demystify the process. There also needs to be a more appropriate bridge between clinical practice and best practice research. Practitioners are encouraged to pay closer attention to the need for program evaluation and documentation. This chapter aims to provide the practical insight into how animals may be incorporated into a therapeutic practice. It suggests that AAT is based on the very strong emotional connection and evolving relationship between the therapist, client, and animal. The most powerful finding from this study pertained to the specific uses of the animal within the therapeutic setting. Few studies are implemented investigating the impact that animals have in altering the therapeutic effects of an environment. A skilled and well-informed clinician should be able to recognize a multitude of benefits that animals can fulfill.
  • Chapter
    The advent of scientific medicine toward the end of the nineteenth century had the effect of displacing companion animals from therapeutic settings. The goals of this chapter are to clarify the distinction between therapies and other assistive or recreational uses of animals, and then to explore some of the theories that underlie the incorporation of animals into therapeutic contexts. The field of animal-assisted interventions currently lacks a unified, widely accepted, or empirically supported theoretical framework for explaining how and why relationships between humans and animals are potentially therapeutic. A considerable variety of possible mechanisms of action are proposed or alluded to in the literature, most of which focus on the supposedly unique intrinsic attributes of animals that appear to contribute to therapy. The notion that animals possess certain inherent qualities that may facilitate therapy is widespread in the literature. According to this view, the mere presence of the animal, its spontaneous behaviors, and its availability for interaction may provide opportunities and confer benefits that would be impossible, or much harder, to obtain in its absence. Theories regarding the mechanisms responsible for therapeutic benefits tend to center either on the notion that animals possess unique attributes that can facilitate and contribute to therapy, or that developing a working relationship with an animal can lead to positive changes in cognition and behavior through the acquisition of novel skills, and the acceptance of personal agency and responsibility.
  • Article
    This introductory chapter provides readers not only with a basic foundation to appreciate and understand this unique kinship with all living creatures but also to discover the roots to the overwhelming growing interest in animal-assisted intervention (AAI). The chapter should also help solidify and clarify how the benefits witnessed within this unique bond have prompted numerous professionals to become more curious about the advantages of animal-assisted interventions. It is apparent that dogs have been bred to coexist with their human counterparts and have filled many roles including herding, guarding, hunting, fishing and being our best friend (Clutton-Brock, 1995). Dogs have also been widely used as service animals, supporting the quality of life of people in need. There have been increasing insights into science’s current understanding of dog behavior and cognition. Perhaps one of the strongest insights that she discusses pertains to dogs’ ability to understand our behaviors (Hare, 2007; Hare et al., 2002). Horowitz (2009) explains that dogs’
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Objective: Acute and/or severe social withdrawal behavior among youth was seen as a culture-bound psychiatric syndrome in Japan, but more youth social withdrawal cases in different countries have been discovered recently. However, due to the lack of a formal definition and diagnostic tool for youth social withdrawal, cross-cultural observational and intervention studies are limited. We aimed to consolidate existing knowledge in order to understand youth social withdrawal from diverse perspectives and suggest different interventions for different trajectories of youth social withdrawal.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Background: Severe social withdrawal behaviors among young people have been a subject of public and clinical concerns. Aims: This study aimed to explore the prevalence of social withdrawal behaviors among young people aged 1229 years in Hong Kong. Methods: A cross-sectional telephone-based survey was conducted with 1,010 young individuals. Social withdrawal behaviors were measured with the proposed research diagnostic criteria for hikikomori and were categorized according to the (a) international proposed duration criterion (more than 6 months), (b) local proposed criterion (less than 6 months) and (c) with withdrawal behaviors but self-perceived as non-problematic. The correlates of social withdrawal among the three groups were examined using multinomial and ordinal logistic regression analyses. Results: The prevalence rates of more than 6 months, less than 6 months and self-perceived non-problematic social withdrawal were 1.9%, 2.5% and 2.6%, respectively. In terms of the correlates, the internationally and locally defined socially withdrawn youths are similar, while the self-perceived non-problematic group is comparable to the comparison group. Conclusions: The study finds that the prevalence of severe social withdrawal in Hong Kong is comparable to that in Japan. Both groups with withdrawal behaviors for more or less than 6 months share similar characteristics and are related to other contemporary youth issues, for example, compensated dating and self-injury behavior. The self-perceived nonproblematic group appears to be a distinct group and the withdrawal behaviors of its members may be discretionary.
  • Article
    In the societies where "delayed departure" is common, the structural pressures leading in this direction are similar. Yet the cultural response varies considerably from one society to the next. Comparative analysis across a range of countries suggests that very similar demographic facts come to assume a different degree of significance and distinctive patterns of meaning. Indeed, the main commonality across the delayed departure countries emerges in the policy responses of their governments, which are uniformly worried about the declining birth rate. As for the ordinary citizen, the "failure to launch" varies from a social catastrophe (Japan), to a somewhat milder structural frustration (Spain), to a non-problem (Italy), while for their Nordic counterparts, the ability to launch early is taken in stride, but is accompanied by the nagging sensation that the generations don't need each other as much as perhaps they should.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    The Japanese term hikikomori means literally 'to be confined'. Social withdrawal can be present in severe psychiatric disorders; however, in Japan, hikikomori is a defined nosologic entity. There have been only a few reported cases in occidental culture. We present a case report of a Spanish man with prolonged social withdrawal lasting for 4 years. This is a case of prolonged social withdrawal not bound to culture, as well as the second case of hikikomori reported in Spain. We propose prolonged social withdrawal disorder as a disorder not linked to culture, in contrast to hikikomori. Further documentation of this disorder is still needed to encompass all cases reported in Japan and around the world.
  • Article
    In 1998 the Japanese psychiatrist Tamaki Sait¯o invented the term hikikomori, referring to a condition characterised by a state of social withdrawal and avoidance (education, work, friendships) combined with a persistent isolation and confinement in the own home for at least 6 months, due to various factors. Initially it undoubtedly regarded a disorder related to a specific socio-cultural context, however in the last couple of years some cases of hikikomori behaviour have also been observed in other countries far from Japan, both geographically and culturally. By way of hypothesis this diffusion can probably be attributed to the cultural revolution represented by mass communication in the internet era; in particular, it seems to be closely related to the immediateness and diffusion of web 2.0, i.e. of social networks. Therefore, we report a case of hikikomori behaviour, who was referred to our ward. M. is a 28-year-old man, who has lived the last 10 years in a state of almost complete isolation. He has maintained contacts with the outside world almost exclusively via internet. He started several therapies with psychiatrists and psychologists, without achieving significant results. The case of M. represents, to our knowledge, the first case of hikikomori described in Italy.
  • Article
    Un certain nombre de cas de retrait social majeur chez des adolescents et jeunes adultes, a été constaté ces dernières années en Europe, en particulier en France où les cliniciens et travailleurs socioéducatifs sont de plus en plus confrontés à des tableaux inédits de repli au domicile. Au Japon, le terme Hikikomori est utilisé pour désigner les situations de retrait social extrême. Ce syndrome n’est pourtant pas encore clairement défini, ni totalement compris. Nous présentons une revue du concept de Hikikomori ainsi que des réflexions préliminaires, issues de la première année de nos recherches internationales. Selon les études de cas que nous avons analysées une différence semble apparaître quant aux facteurs déclenchant le retrait et l’abandon des investissements. Une des hypothèses soulevées concerne le rapport à l’idéal : il semble qu’au Japon, le retrait anticipe et évite une chute de l’idéal, alors que ce serait plus suite à des difficultés concrètes que se fait le repli en France. L’objectif de la recherche est, à travers le rapprochement de situations de retrait en France et au Japon, qui seront analysés avec les mêmes outils méthodologiques, d’interroger la notion de Hikikomori en tant que catégorie, et de poser les bases d’une réflexion clinico-socio-anthropologique sur ces phénomènes, dans le cadre d’une recherche pluridisciplinaire. Nous allons effectuer au Japon et en France des enquêtes par questionnaires avec des critères communs pour les cas japonais et français tenant compte des circonstances sociales et culturelles de ces pays.