ArticlePDF Available
Commentary: Better communities require better-educated planners | www.mystatesman.com
http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/opinion/commentary-better-communities-require-better-educa/nsxcY/[10/27/2016 10:09:08 AM]
Americans often contemplate how they want government to contend with our crumbling infrastructure,
minority residents’ concerning encounters with police and increasingly complex systems of inequality.
City planners play an important role in all this. They are government agents charged with shaping the
social and built environments of cities, suburbs and rural areas in ways that directly impact our ability
to address those issues.
But today’s planners are not prepared to contend with the increasingly complex, interconnected nature
of these challenges. That needs to change, and it starts with education.
Presently, our educational process and professional practice do little to counteract often paternalistic,
reactive planning processes that divide rather than integrate grass-roots interests, resources and
ideas. For example, cities are not listening to the voices of residents within the communities hardest hit
by the historical arc of racism, exclusion and inequality — all of which are exacerbated by economic
restructuring and natural disasters.
Unfortunately, planners, although trained to open planning and development processes to resident
LOG IN
Commentary: Better communities require better-educated
planners
OPINION By Anna Brand and Andrea Roberts - Special to the American-Statesman
Posted: 7:00 a.m. Wednesday, Oct. 26, 2016
69° SUBSCRIBE
as low as 99¢
0
Commentary: Better communities require better-educated planners | www.mystatesman.com
http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/opinion/commentary-better-communities-require-better-educa/nsxcY/[10/27/2016 10:09:08 AM]
The city has landed an affordable housing deal with
a developer in Southeast Austin. The deal would
require Brookfield Residential to ... Read More
participation, instead often dilute community contributions and affirm predetermined investments in
public infrastructure and economic development. Adding to the challenge is that planners are trained to
be nonpolitical but are increasingly put in incredibly political environments. Often powerless to contest
the business and political interests that drive growth in cities, planners are charged with mitigating the
effects of disinvestment and gentrification.
Planners also are failing to make connections across different sectors such as housing, economic
development, transportation and resiliency planning. Socially and racially just development innovations
including community land trusts, cooperative enterprises and inclusive, affordable housing appear on a
piecemeal basis, but cities aren’t leading the way. Grass-roots leaders are the ones doing the heavy
lifting.
That’s why we need a broader, more inclusive
understanding of the way planning shapes people’s lives
and more expansive understandings of the everyday
processes that constitute the making of a community or
city. There are ways we can better educate tomorrow’s
planners. We can start by teaching students to center
vulnerable voices during planning processes and to
devise sophisticated critiques of and responses to
systemic inequalities.
In school, future planning curriculum should feature
critique as a core competency. By teaching students to
operate from a multidimensional or critical perspective
that reframes complex problems and engages in “historical mindedness,” education can better equip
planners to work more closely with communities to define problems and strategize more impactful
planning interventions. Planning by definition resides at the nexus of systems that disproportionately
affect women, people of color and the differently abled negatively. Future planners must be trained to
concurrently contemplate access to transportation and living-wage jobs along with the location of care
services, public schools, child care, affordable housing and community space.
Planners must reconsider their assumptions about what constitutes a community and rethink how to
serve hidden, scattered constituencies. Such a curriculum would include training students not only to
point out instances of manipulation by privatized development interests that perpetuate exclusion and
deepen inequality, but also to devise strategies to prevent the exploitation of planning processes.
We must teach future planners to maximize residents’ opportunities to contest developers’
determination of what is the highest and best use of land. Planners must be educated to contend with
the politics and power dynamics of development in order to avoid being a rubber stamp for pro-growth.
This also requires that future planners learn to ask the right questions at the right times to ensure
development outcomes that directly benefit the most vulnerable members of our communities.
+
RICARDO B. BRAZZIELL
Commentary: Better communities require better-educated planners | www.mystatesman.com
http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/opinion/commentary-better-communities-require-better-educa/nsxcY/[10/27/2016 10:09:08 AM]
Diversifying planning education and practice means reframing our curriculums to include
underrepresented theories and community building strategies. Missing from planning education are the
community development strategies that occur inside churches, at kitchen tables and in break rooms.
All of these processes and perspectives shape communities’ built environments and access to
opportunity. But more importantly, planners must look like the communities they will serve, which
requires that our planning programs enroll more students representing various ethnicities, abilities and
genders. The future health and vitality of America’s cities is on the line.
Brand is a lecturer in the School of Architecture and Roberts is a lecturer in the School of Architecture
at the University of Texas.
Boil water notice issued in western Travis, Hays
counties
by Katie Hall, American-Statesman Staff
The West Travis County Public Utility Agency advised some of its
customers at 4:30 p.m. Wednesday to boil their water before drinking
it or cooking...
How a teal pumpkin can save a child's life
by Kelly Sundstrom, For the AJC
When you have a child with allergies, the fun and excitement of
Reader Comments
Next Up in News
SIGN UP FOR
NEWSLETTERS
Want more news? Sign up for free
newsletters to get more of the
Statesman delivered to your inbox.
0
Commentary: Better communities require better-educated planners | www.mystatesman.com
http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/opinion/commentary-better-communities-require-better-educa/nsxcY/[10/27/2016 10:09:08 AM]
Halloween can become overshadowed by the haunting worry about
hidden ingredients and...
'It was always our plan': 1 year after husband's death,
wife welcomes 3rd child
by Theresa Seiger, Cox Media Group National Content Desk
More than a year after Sam Tripson lost his battle with lymphatic
cancer, his wife, Kristen, welcomed the couple's third child thanks to
in vitro...
Live coverage: Sex abuse trial of former state
psychiatrist Charles Fischer, Day 3
by Staff Writer, All Ablog Austin
7/12/2012 – Jay Janner/American-Statesman – Charles Fischer, left,
and his attorney Chris Gunter leave after appearing in court at the...
Many Republicans worry Trump has hurt the party's
relationship with female voters for years to come
by Jenna Johnson and Karen Tumulty, The Washington Post
A growing number of prominent Republican women are worried that
as members of their male-dominated party step up to defend Donald
Trump against...
More Stories
NEWS CUSTOMER SERVICE MARKETPLACE SOCIAL MEDIA TOP
© 2016 Cox Media Group. By using this website, you accept the terms of our Visitor Agreement and Privacy Policy,
and understand your options regarding Ad Choices . Learn about careers at Cox Media Group
Commentary: Better communities require better-educated planners | www.mystatesman.com
http://www.mystatesman.com/news/news/opinion/commentary-better-communities-require-better-educa/nsxcY/[10/27/2016 10:09:08 AM]
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.