Content uploaded by Henry Dicks
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Henry Dicks on Dec 01, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Henry Dicks
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Henry Dicks on Dec 01, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
This is a pre-publicaon version of an arcle
! !!" !#!$%! "%
&$$"%$'
(( () *
+ , -
+ -( *)
+ .) + ) (
( , /(0 &&"1, %,2 * 03! !,3! 1,)
( (
(04)3! ,.*3! 5,/*63! $1,
)+
+( ,,
+,,,((*
(+(,),
)),,(7-)(*8
9 : ; 2
) ,
,),
; )), ,, ,, ( (
)*;,%,(
(<+<)+<<2*
+*2,
)6** =,., ', ) techné
+ 8%)(,
,%4(,(
, ) (
+))(0/( &&"1>,
, ( ?# (
)* ;, , , )
, ) ((
% 0, , , %
189+:,(-(/(
- 9+ : 0 ) , 9+
:1
( 7 )
+@8,)
3
?
A
5
$
"
#
&
!
3
?
A
5
$
"
#
&
3!
3
33
3?
3A
35
3$
3"
3#
3&
?!
?
?3
??
?A
?5
?$
?"
?#
?&
A!
A
3
)))-)
% - (()+ 97: ,(,
;,,,
7, 9+ : ) +
9: , (, ) ) (
)()()
)( ( *)
, ) ( )
-))*(,,;,-,
)()(7
< , *
() ,(,,,
(, %(, (
, , * * )
) , ,
,7
B,8 ) 9+ :
)* /(, %, 2*,
) ( 7
0,C &##, &&!<D3! 1,(
);(0* && 18,,(
9+ : ( )
, ( , , (
( , , *7 ,
(,70D43! 51
! "
,/((+,/)(
+ + (, ) (
E/( +)9 FG()
H*
, , ( : 0/( &&", 1
/( * , ( )
0, 1 +0, ,,
(, (1 + , /(
) 9/( 7 IH
J?#(,2)*2
2:0/( &&",1B,
;,,
*)(((@,(
?# (+ 9) :
,*+,+(,
( 9 : 7 9:
)
3
A3
A?
AA
A5
A$
A"
A#
A&
5!
5
53
5?
5A
55
5$
5"
5#
5&
$!
$
$3
$?
$A
$5
$$
$"
$#
$&
"!
"
"3
"?
"A
"5
"$
""
"#
"&
#!
#
#3
#?
#A
#5
#$
?
A
) ( )( is 09( is )K:1,
+* ( uses 09(
uses K:1 ) ) )
( is uses 9:
/),,*+E/()
) 9 ),,: 0 &&", "1,)
+
+
+((
+
+((
+)
+*(
+
+)
+)0/( &&","1
8 9:+
)9:6*, kanon,9(:
,(,9: 9 :, ,
( ), 9 7: 4, 7
; - , , , ,
(,-7abstracted+, transferred -,,translated -
08DL3! 51,9),,:)
, ) +, *)
< , /(H (*
+,(-((*+
- (
,
9: 9: , ) + does ) ) should do 8
, + M(+
,)(
, ) should
) should ,
) ( /( , +H laws principles - ,
,strategies -,
+N)shouldN;
/(HL),(
((( *, (,,
8)((
(,,*;-((
;)+()
)
?
#"
##
#&
&!
&
&3
&?
&A
&5
&$
&"
&#
&&
!!
!
!3
!?
!A
!5
!$
!"
!#
!&
!
3
?
A
5
$
"
#
&
3!
3
33
3?
3A
35
3$
3"
5
$
"
#
&
!
,,<
%(+(,@(
( )
8, , , 9+ (
(:,9)((:,(
, ( ( * !!O ( 0
1,((
J,* !!O()
((>*),,
9+ *(: 9+ :,
)((,
( ) (
B,(+
biodiversity,))(0,
1
(,,
+3B,),
P) *(/(H( ,
)*, ()*+ ,
(, abstracon ) + ; translaon
)(
)+-)
) (/( - ( )
7 ,
( 8 )(, 7 ) 9
(:,%,)
9:,(,()
+
2) (, /(
9+ : 8, (@
,(*)*2*,(,9+
:0*3! 1(/(all)*<
( *)* (
* >8Q0/( &&", 3 -?$1+,
/(H*))
)**,)(@
*(,(9+:,)
.*03! 519:(,*,
3 L =H 9%: 6 4H
9 (:, )
(0.*3! 5</*63! $1,),(
),
)@,)
)
%( +
A
3#
3&
?!
?
?3
??
?A
?5
?$
?"
?#
?&
A!
A
A3
A?
AA
A5
A$
A"
A#
A&
5!
5
53
5?
5A
55
5$
5"
5#
5&
$!
$
$3
$?
$A
$5
3
?
A
5
$
"
#
&
; *H)* 9H ):03! , A&1 9
( : 0*3! , #518 ) ,)
(,(/(, ()7
R,technological ,,%,
) + < , ethically
epistemologically )* *, ) ())
(,,%++
2,)(
*H)*+
) *H * )
> 8 8 ) ) *H New Roots for
Agriculture 0 3, 2/() 2 .* Q
&"A )( )* *, Toward an Ecological Ethic,
)()M>8, &"$,
* )* ( *, )
,) (, * )
/(,),* * )
(,>
88*(
)(*H;L%
(, 9+ :, ) ( (
9(2*:0*3! 1,((
)*), *(
*H9:
-(9+:-
( ( ) ) *
9@: ),)
( %%;
0*3! ,$?%$A1*H(
2) %) , +-
( - 9:9: ) -
-78*H,
) ,*) * ) (
-9:-)*)
8,),
M(,)D(,
*H,((
) ( , ( (
R0'S3! 51>(,)
( )9:
H(7,/(H
*H (
+*9 F)G*
)) .) (,
) (, ) *): 0* 3! , "#1 +, ) ,
5
$$
$"
$#
$&
"!
"
"3
"?
"A
"5
"$
""
"#
"&
#!
#
#3
#?
#A
#5
#$
#"
##
#&
&!
&
&3
&?
&A
&5
&$
&"
&#
&&
3!!
3!
3!3
3!?
3!A
3!5
3!$
3!"
3!#
3!&
3 !
3!
3
,
only;)+
- ( 94:-
J,*H))*>8,+
(<,
, ( 7 ( (
(
*H(*+
(.)(2/((
+,*()9%
(:(0*3! ,$#-" 1,)*,
T,4,',)*(,7
=)0 &5$1-J-,)*
9:9:
8),)(+,
@(*, 9 :, )
+-(-( source
,())
? L(*H )*,),(
9%(: + )* 2
(,(
J,*+))*)
()*>8,(%
( )* >*), ( (
( ( ( ; ,
( (+
*H)*2,))
+())(
#! $%
2 E )
()
?6**9:,;()(8
9:+H
)abstracted translated)
)( ) ; (
;+
9 : + )
)* ( ( 8, ) (
)+, ,, ;(
())*(,,,
0 .* 3! 51 (
9:(,
)+(0C(3!!$1
$
3
3 3
3 ?
3 A
3 5
3 $
3 "
3 #
3 &
33!
33
333
33?
33A
335
33$
33"
33#
33&
3?!
3?
3?3
3??
3?A
3?5
3?$
3?"
3?#
3?&
3A!
3A
3A3
3A?
3AA
33
3?
3A
35
3$
3"
3#
3&
?!
?
?3
??
?A
?5
))+A),
( )
)+*(8)(
( ; ) ( *
);)L
,8)(
+ / ,),R(
)
')(,)(,(
) + object ( +
7(L(,(
%-J(0U &#?<U &&A1+
0Q@ &&"1-97:(+7,,
% mere 7, (
0 71 ) ) +071
( M)(, ( , ,
,,*(,+,())
(do something for Nature,(
8 ) ) +
0)( 1, ;)
)+ direct ,(,+,(
indirect ,(,(()E.
-)
-,)+ ,
) +, + (
,))+((
) 0 1 B, , C 0 &&51
,)+,
)%,
M;)))M(
70,,(,1RE>(,
@) + object -) ,@,
, )* - ,
, ),
,,),
(,+
2 ( )
+source,(,)
AL7((,),
,,
, BH 9(:8 , ),
(,) 9:,9: 9: 0B &&!,& - #1,
) ) ) ( ( +, )
(ethical0,,1)
"
3A5
3A$
3A"
3A#
3A&
35!
35
353
35?
35A
355
35$
35"
35#
35&
3$!
3$
3$3
3$?
3$A
3$5
3$$
3$"
3$#
3$&
3"!
3"
3"3
3"?
3"A
3"5
3"$
3""
3"#
3"&
3#!
3#
3#3
?$
?"
?#
?&
A!
A
A3
A?
AA
(+ ()
(M+2+
object , source , +,
+,*(+,,
+,)+,+8,)
)+,(0V
+1,+,)),),
)+
-+-
( M ; 0)(
1 + ) ( *
,(5-Q,
, E 8 , ) ;
) ( ) +
,; )(
,)+4,7C
+,
+
J,+,)(*9:E8
, ; )
+,)))
RE2))),;
,,(,(,(P(,
(E>(,@(M
0)( 1, ,
(,,
8) )
, ( *+
*+7,
9:+(, ,
anything like +,
)+(
8,))(;*9%(:
(+,*)
%(,%((),(1
7@<1
;()@))
8 )* ( *
( % ( 6 , (
*(( %(,(()M
), 8 , ( *9C
) ) +E: ( = U 0 &"&1 D /(
CH9(:)(,9+*):0C &" ,A %
58 (9(:9(:,(
#
3#?
3#A
3#5
3#$
3#"
3##
3#&
3&!
3&
3&3
3&?
3&A
3&5
3&$
3&"
3&#
3&&
?!!
?!
?!3
?!?
?!A
?!5
?!$
?!"
?!#
?!&
? !
?
? 3
? ?
? A
? 5
? $
? "
? #
? &
?3!
?3
?33
?3?
?3A
?35
A5
A$
A"
A#
A51,UM)(
9)+: 9: , ) ( ) ( )
+,)*)+<3 9:,
)))+,
+H(<?9: ,)))(()
+< A 9:, )) +H
<59:,))( +H
)(%,()U7<$9:
,))()+ )()
<"9:,J *),))
(9:+
8)),)),)UH
0)(1,
)( ) (
UH*
9) +:, ) J )
()9+:,
)9):,7)8,U*
)( @ ( ( (
), ,;( 9:;
+04)3! , .* 3! 51, , , ;(
).*9:,9:,9:(0.*3! 51,
, + , , , ), )
M)(,(following +0(,,
*))1
UH(M)+8
) +
< ) , )
necessarily always cannot ever)+,)
;L,)(
,)( (
*()9):,,,)
(,+)
) inter-human , U
-“* :9/( (*):9 (
):9):K 0U &"&,3$1-(
- ( )
(-)+,
) +, %((,
),)U
)
) ) (
) WX ( (W =
&
?3$
?3"
?3#
?3&
??!
??
??3
???
??A
??5
??$
??"
??#
??&
?A!
?A
?A3
?A?
?AA
?A5
?A$
?A"
?A#
?A&
?5!
?5
?53
?5?
?5A
?55
?5$
?5"
?5#
?5&
?$!
?$
?$3
?$?
?$A
?$5
?$$
?$"
?$#
?$&
A&
5!
) ) ,
()))0U &"&, A1
)+(U,;*)(0U
&"&, 51< )+9 : )
) ( , ), )( )
(M,
,as a balance+)2
*(()(+-*,
,>H9(:9:0.*3! A1-
))also))
)(U7)+9(
((W,)
+,,)+(
) +; object < 7 , )(
,)+,(+
7 @
(<for ourselves)@
+ for Nature ) +
9:9:@byfor,)))
+9F)G),()
: 0U &"&, $1 )) ,), 9)
+:-)+-(
(
@,)UH,
) ) @
) ( )*
;( ontological ; +, poec
+ , ethical + , epistemological
+ 0.*3! 51,) @ (
) ) +
),UH(
(),*0)
((+
1,
(9)+:,,
)+-)+
-, , )
( )+ %
8 UH M @
,7;(
)@))8,9C)
) +E:
!
?"!
?"
?"3
?"?
?"A
?"5
?"$
?""
?"#
?"&
?#!
?#
?#3
?#?
?#A
?#5
?#$
?#"
?##
?#&
?&!
?&
?&3
?&?
?&A
?&5
?&$
?&"
?&#
?&&
A!!
A!
A!3
A!?
A!A
A!5
A!$
A!"
A!#
A!&
A !
A
A 3
A ?
A A
5
53
7,Environmental Ethics,7
( J (8,) ( )
M % - , ,
,, , , , ,
6 , - % ( )
9)+:0 12, *
9C))+E:)UH*,Environmental Ethics: Dues
to and Values in the Natural World 0U &##,?3-AA18
9) +:, UH
()()U)
-+
- ) ( ) ,
, , (, ) ( ) ( )
,)+
,UR()+,((
, (,)+ 7)) $>*),)
(,
( ) + ) , )
( * ), 9)
+:),(
)* ( < U (
)+)
,8),
))()
( 9 ): 0 UH *1, (
+ source ( @,
nametrue place"))
&! '
)7@
*2(,J,)+E2(
) * +, ; ) (
E) ;)(*+
for ourselves, ) , for Nature 0 1, )
)(,),)
applicaon 2 value,))
(measure B,*+
(7meansend,*+(
, ( , ,
( U 98 E: 0U &"51,
$U(),)
(
"/(9:,87
A 5
A $
A "
A #
A &
A3!
A3
A33
A3?
A3A
A35
A3$
A3"
A3#
A3&
A?!
A?
A?3
A??
A?A
A?5
A?$
A?"
A?#
A?&
AA!
AA
AA3
AA?
AAA
AA5
AA$
AA"
AA#
AA&
A5!
A5
A53
A5?
A5A
5?
5A
55
5$
5"
5#
9(:,)(
)+0U &"&1B)+,U
, ( 9:, ( 9 :
9:,)9:
7 8 ) B, ),
;(
genuine 0 CH 1 U
0 &"&1,)(,*)+,
meanshumanendU(*(.)
9)(:,9FG*
/( CH I ) (H:
0*( &&3,?"1,,,9)
I(HIJH(,,,
, (, , (,
((:0*( &&3,?#1 , ( ,
)((),
+-()+- *()
)
FKGV
),))
)( * , ,
) > )
%7
0*( &&3,3&1
B,))*
) 9 : )
*+0,,(,(,,1,
()(()
(
)*++
+
= Y+,
,=
,(,
K
+ '+
2,
)K
"%! ',*-
, ), )(
(logical )*
+ L (, ( *, * +
3
A55
A5$
A5"
A5#
A5&
A$!
A$
A$3
A$?
A$A
A$5
A$$
A$"
A$#
A$&
A"!
A"
A"3
A"?
A"A
A"5
A"$
A""
A"#
A"&
A#!
A#
A#3
A#?
A#A
A#5
A#$
A#"
A##
A#&
A&!
5&
$!
for the bene't of Naturefor the bene't of humans#8*),
R(-()*
/(-)04>@
3!!&,/*3! $104)3! 1)* )(
, ) (,
) humans alone ( Nature also
(humans aloneNature also
94 : ( 8 9+
: - , (,
, , ) ( -, )
(any non-anthropocentric measure2,
(*))*H
)*,/C0 &##, &&!1,
07)71)(
( % @ (
*)(
) )
0)( 1 B ,
+P
,(+object
(,,,,(
* + source , ( ,
(,,*+)+
0 && , &&31C0 &&51 9(: (
M 2 + * (
P7(,)
converge, C*7,
.H'B,+H),)
diverges 2 *, ),
)( ) +H CH themselves
converge ; protect
+D(, (
+ a reason forprotecng Nature (
B,9(:,2)*B
0 &&51))
+,)-9:0(()
9:, ) >, monere, 9: :1 - (
+9(:
B9( ( P(< (
) ) , )*(
#/U *()() ( )
)+empiricallogical/)
;()M
,7(
?
A&
A&3
A&?
A&A
A&5
A&$
A&"
A&#
A&&
5!!
5!
5!3
5!?
5!A
5!5
5!$
5!"
5!#
5!&
5 !
5
5 3
5 ?
5 A
5 5
5 $
5 "
5 #
5 &
53!
53
533
53?
53A
535
53$
53"
53#
53&
5?!
5?
$
$3
$?
$A
$5
$$
( (: 0B &&5, 5$1 BH
+H((,),9
%):0B &&5, 5$1<,*U*(,
+01(7)(instrumentalizing
+why we should
protect Nature, ), ( +
--)(
( contrasng 0)( 1 ) ,
)()
+
. (
)*
++
0)(
1
+
object
=
values
'
+
=
+
2
,
K
+
source
=
measures
B)
+
=
+
,
(,
K
"%!# ,*-
8((,7*
+(7@
, ) 7 ,
87, ()%
4 % doing something for others,)
0Q1,01,
)))((01,
)))(,(,0J
>1 4, ) ) (
J),)(,(,)(
(,7,*
0,,(,),18
) ) + + (
((,,,,,(
(,((
8,),)*,,
,)),
) ) * - , *,
,- 8 , objects
,sources)+
))(7
+,),(+(,
( + ( 2 , )
(()))*,
),7(
A
5?3
5??
5?A
5?5
5?$
5?"
5?#
5?&
5A!
5A
5A3
5A?
5AA
5A5
5A$
5A"
5A#
5A&
55!
55
553
55?
55A
555
55$
55"
55#
55&
5$!
5$
5$3
5$?
5$A
5$5
5$$
5$"
5$#
5$&
$"
$#
(<) ,((
/()())
;(
( ) 7 + > )
+(+(,
(%(M+)(*
(++both7and
,)(
B ,>H
>,),((
9FaG )
preserve (, (, ( ( 8 ) )
):0> &A&,335,(1/)(--
( ( ( ,
;,,(,,,(
;(
*((
, ) * (
7,*+,
)(
/! $.+
8
, ; R
( ) 0)(
1/(*,
, (, , , )
(,7((
+,(
) *H ,) ( (,
,@,
,),,9*;:
0*3! !, 531((
* ( (
7)+*) (-
(B0 &&51-(+)
(+()
)(9:)),
%(, , 8 + ,
,,,)(
) ( ( ( 0
),*,,1
R ) 0)(
1,)(
5
5"!
5"
5"3
5"?
5"A
5"5
5"$
5""
5"#
5"&
5#!
5#
5#3
5#?
5#A
5#5
5#$
5#"
5##
5#&
5&!
5&
5&3
5&?
5&A
5&5
5&$
5&"
5&#
5&&
$!!
$!
$!3
$!?
$!A
$!5
$!$
$!"
$!#
$!&
$ !
$
$ 3
$ ?
$&
"!
7 ) + ( +
( )( ) + ( ( )
)( +, (
7 R (
)+(@ not to protect Nature8+H0
(, (, , , 1
(,()+
/()).*03! 519(I)*(H:
,),)(()
+((, , (
(,(
< + only ,
also7
$
)))
(4(,
( ; +,
(,),@+
source,)89:,),*
, (
( D ( ( - )
) )(-, )
+,2*,
+ , ) ( 9:
,)(>)(@9:
D, 7 ( )*
)* + ,
*))/
()(8,7(
, )
)* ),
, ),
)()(
*)*)()
%(, (,
),%(,,,
;)(9:
0
/(,0 &&"). /(8(+)X*='
/*,T/603! $18/(+)2(*
(Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics,3&031,3!?-3 "
$
$ A
$ 5
$ $
$ "
$ #
$ &
$3!
$3
$33
$3?
$3A
$35
$3$
$3"
$3#
$3&
$?!
$?
$?3
$??
$?A
$?5
$?$
$?"
$?#
$?&
$A!
$A
$A3
$A?
$AA
$A5
$A$
$A"
$A#
$A&
$5!
$5
$53
$5?
$5A
$55
"
"3
/*,T03! $1/(4((8
Environmental Philosophy, ?031, &5-3 A
C,/0 &##1(Journal of Agricultural Ethics, 0 1,?-&
C,/0 &&!14(BB+)%
%Journal of Agricultural Ethics,?0 1,?$-A#
C,/0 &&518T+4(Electronic Journal of Analyc
Philosophy,?051
C,/0 &" 1The Closing Circle: Nature, Man, and Technology+)X*Q
C(,'03!!$1Ecological Ethics: An Introducon'(
.*,=03! A1>8(/,'(,
UUEnvironmental Philosophy, 031, "5-3!&
.*,=03! 51'(/(Philosophy & Technology, ! !!" ??A"%! 5%
!3 !%3
*(,U0 &&31Environmentalism and Polical Theory: Toward an Ecocentric Approach>
YC>'
B,20 &&51Toward a Transpersonal Ecology: Developing New Foundaons for Environmentalism
U
=),0 &5$1An Agricultural Testament4L8'
8DL03! 518DL #A5#/-(,C,4(/D8
*,20 3F &#!GNew Roots for Agriculture>>Y(+*
'
*,20 && 1L(Journal
of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics,A031,3!"-3 5
*,203! !1Consulng the Genius of Place: An Ecological Approach to a New Agriculture
/*(C
*,203! 1Nature as Measure: The Selected Essays of Wes Jackson/*(C
Q@,0 &&"1Nature as Subject: Human Obligaon and Natural Community>U)
>
>,0 &A&1A Sand County AlmanacLLY'
4,D>@03!!&1Z('/Internaonal
Journal of Design & Nature and Ecodynamics, 0A1, - !
4),B03! 1)((Organizaon & Environment,3A0A1,
?$A-?#"
"
$5$
$5"
$5#
$5&
$$!
$$
$$3
$$?
$$A
$$5
$$$
$$"
$$#
$$&
$"!
$"
$"3
$"?
$"A
$"5
$"$
$""
$"#
$"&
$#!
$#
$#3
$#?
$#A
$#5
$#$
$#"
$##
$#&
$&!
"?
"A
+,/0 && 1Toward Unity among EnvironmentalistsLLY'
+,/0 &&31(TThe Monist,"5031,3!#-33$
'S,403! 51((4*(
Internaonal Journal of Sustainable Built Environment,A0 1, A5- 5"
U,0 &#?1The Case for Animal Rights>U
U,=0 &"518EEthics: An Internaonal Journal of Social, Polical, and
Legal Philosophy, #031,&?- !&
U,=0 &"&1C))EEnvironmental Ethics, 0 1,"-?!
U,=0 &##1Environmental Ethics: Dues to and Values in the Natural World'
Y('
U,=0 &&A1T++T8U[/(01,
Philosophy and the Natural Environment 0 ?-?!1CCY'
D,''40103! 51DD/(,Journal of
Agricultural and Environmental Ethics3#051
D,203! 1,+,'
8Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics,3A0?1,3#?-?!?
#
$&
$&3
$&?
$&A
$&5
$&$
$&"
$&#
$&&
"!!
"!
"!3
"!?
"!A
"!5
"!$
"!"
"!#
"!&
"5
"$
A preview of this full-text is provided by Springer Nature.
Content available from Journal of Agricultural and Environmental Ethics
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
