Content uploaded by Billy Haworth
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Billy Haworth on Dec 20, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
Implicaons of volunteered geographic informaon for disaster
management and GIScience: A more complex world of volunteered
geography
Abstract
!"# $%&!"
!!!"
!"'!!"( $%""!)
)"!!!*"+!
(!"!!""'"
"!!"!!
$%(,-!) $%
!"!!""'
!(-"!!" $%)
!"!)."
"(%"
"."
$%)-#-&"(
/)"!)")'
!!!!""
)!!$%(%!"
0
!! $%"'!!
)"
(1/"+!! $%
!" $%23)!
!"(
Keywords4volunteered geographic informaon (VGI); disaster risk reducon; GIScience;
disaster management; digital divide
5
Introducon
Volunteered geographic informaon (VGI)
!!+
#$6&")5(7
#$5705&()5(7#,385779&)+"
)"
#$577:&)-!
.)5(7!!)"
#)(570;&(%577:$!$6
!"# $%&( $%!
)!"'"!"
#$577:)&(8<#570=&$3-"
.!" $%
!!""#(($5705>
(570=&(
$%))!!")
)5(7$)?"#$?&
!'"))"#$577:)&
)"!@!#8,
577A&( $%')!"#570B&
)"!#C(5707&!)
!"#$%&)!!D
,!E!#,E&#)577F&""23"
B
!#$577:)&("
)-!"!"(
<D"")"!))!
$%D)6,!"#5705&(!
).!!!").!!
$%(23 $%".!
.!!,E#6,!"5705&(
! $%.!!!)
"'!"#(570:&(
$%!!G"
!""(<!
/ $%!"!!"/"
!!#$5705&(-
!!"$%!!"
)!!#$577F>
?577F>577F&(H!!"
)+)!"!!!2+
!!3+.!"!!#I''570=&(
.!!!)
!!J $%)."
!!")
"!!)
"!!"!))
=
.!#$5705&("
G!!!!"
'"!!#I''570=&(H!)
"/"!)I''#570=&
!"neo!!(.!
!!+!!
"#$577F&(!)"
!"!".!!
!!"D"")!"
"!".!!"
#$577A>I'570=&(6"!.!)
+.!-!>
!!!.))($!
)+".!"!!$%
"!+!"
.!!"")! $%#$
5705&(6IK#5705&)-
!"!"')""
"!"/
!"!"!"( $%!
!""!
!"-!!"(,-!) $%
#5709&"(
9
VGI and disaster risk reducon
". $%.
!""#<88&(<!"
! $%")(
)!!"
-)!))) $%
)-"-"'
.(EL $%!))
!"!"(E!+
"!)"
!""!) $%
"!+!"(
)
!+!+#?577B>?I577:&(?
"!
'#0AAA&(<!!
!)""#(
577B>E(5700&(G
!'!""!)
!)!"!"#?577B&(?#577B&!
!'!)!"!")")
!!)'""(
"1"5779+5709*!
;
!)0;F!'+)
D"#H%<85779&1
<88"5709+57B7!"!"
!!#H%<85709&(<
)!!+)"
))""!"+
'"+!"#)577;&(
%G!!!)!
) -86#et al.5707>EI
5705&(!!!!)#)
!!))
&(!
!"#<88&(
"(!
!2)3!"
).!""
!)#6570=&(8)!
)!!!"M!'+
D)'G
!-!N#C(5707!(5F&(H"
<8#H<8>6,$5700&-)
M""'"N
"!"+
:
!#!(9&(6
?"?!8!8
#??88&#??5700&(?"!!
!">!!
"!!!"!
)!))'!
">!"G
!'!!D!
!!>!!!"+D
")+)#)5770&(
8!' $%!#
5709>K(570;&(!)
!!!""!!""
!))!!#K(
570;&(.!4)!!D
!5707"/#E5705&>
+!!!"
"!!!!OPI<5707Q00
#E<5700>(5705&> $%""
""-)577:+577A
#$$5707&570B#%(5709&(
)!!"!) $%
!"(!"".
F
!"#(5705&"+
""!"
)))#+R8570B&"
!!"!)#E<
5700&)!"!!
"#LEI5709&/
!!"!) $%(.!!
)/#,!"5700>$I5705&
"!#(570B&!
!)#570B&!"
!"!"# <*
570B>$570B&(
)! $%)!
)-"!!"(<
2++3M!.!+
"S"")!)N#?I577:!(:5:&( $%
-!""!+
"!"!(
<-"!!"
!" $%.!!!"
)-#wildreforest re"&"
")!" $%&
")&!!$%(
A
!!D
!!"!
!!!!-("
"!!
" $%!
-$%("D!
!)-4 $%#
5709&).!!
)+."
>)"#
E5709>570;>L570;&
)!!(%
.!"O""
/!!"!!" $%
(
"(.")O)
.-(G
%""
)L")!!!" $%(
I%!"D"
(
07
A tale of three studies
.
$%<88)-
)!#-8
H)T()-)(((U&!
V).!!!"' $%(
$%'!)
!"O/)-!
"!! $%!!"
!"!"-!/
.)" $%(
-"!
#W5700&()-
!!!")+)
!"!!.#E6
?L577A&D!!")
.)"#15705&(E*)-
"#.!(5709>
%(5709>8(570;>L570;&(
%")-
!!)(
!!(?!
""!!!(
00
)!!"!!
-)!!!"
"D""""
!!"#?577B&(1"
!)!"!"!!
<88)#H%<85709&(P"D"
!!!" $%!"<88
)(
Study 1: Assessing the potenal use of VGI in DRR through community surveys
-.!" $%
)-")!
"(05+"
)+!09=!#
-E5709&(!!
)!!" $%
!!"!"!@
1)(P"
$%+!!L!"
)-!!")) $%
!!!!(6""-!"
$%!"!"
!""(E $%"
X!"!"!")
05
!""")!
(
Study 2: The perspecves of emergency management professionals
)0
!!"!!!"
$%+
0B!"!!
'"#-570;&(%!
$%!"""
!D"(?"-
"."'!+
!"-!!" $%(<!
)//
!)(
!!!!D" $%"'"
""'"
/"
!"!
!" $%!!"(
Study 3: Tesng VGI in pracce through parcipatory mapping
!!!
)-!!"!"))
3)-
0B
<88(!!"!
!!!"!)!"!
/"#-L
570;&(?"!L!"
)"!!+)!!"")-
!!"(!'#YB0&!
""'")!!")/"
!!!")")!"!
!"!!"!"
!!!!"(!"!!!!!
" $%!!!
!)")- $%$%(
!)"/"!!"!
!! $%)-)!"
!))"!"!"(*-
.!"!)-
!!! $%!!)
!"!!!(6!! $%
/!!"!"
!&)&)-&!!
)!!.!+!!
!(
0=
General discussion
-)
(!"-
."%)"
!!"(
1! $%(!!
)+.!)(?
!'))
)."!!!) $%(% $%
)D"
!!"(%!"!!!!"
)))!+!"!
!!!")-
(1<88!
!23#!!)& $%)
.!)(KI#5709&!!
)"!
")"!!!
!)(!
!"))/!!
/
)!-/"
.#KI5709&(K#570;&!'
09
!))
")("!"
!'!"!/"
)"/"
!#K570;&(
$%)")
!)"(<X)!)
."#KI5709&
"-.!)!#
5&()"! $%
)D"( $%!*)
X(I)!! $%
))"!
")+!
"-! $%(
$%!"!"%"
23 $%!"
!@())
"!+)"
/")&!'"23
-+!"
#E(570;&>)&"
23(!!)
0;
!@)
"!!!)!
")(32
3D!
!!"!")!"J
!"'""'
)!") $%)
.23 $%!"
)23(
?"O)-!"(
%"-
"!!" $%(6).!
)L))X
""#0&(
!!"'+!"
" $%X#5&(!!"!-
!!)
#B&(
$%/))!"(
)X $%!"! $%!"
!(")
!" $%)( $%!
#E6E"' !5709&)/
0:
.!+)!6-
)
-"G(E6E"' !#5709&
"!!+(1!
23!!.!" $%)"!!
!"!"23)"
$%!!(
% $%
!")-
!!(!
)) $%)"!!" $%
!!!).
!"!(!(
1!) $%"(
)!"! $%
!"" $%)-!!"
( $%!!"
!"!"!"!
!"!!!""() $%!
2)3)!" $%"
!"(
!!)GD $%!.!
!)!"!!!")-"
0F
""(!! $%!"!"-
"!"!-"
)(
")" $%!.G
.)."+)
+)(.
""
D)!!
)!(!"
-.($!!" $%!)
!"!"
!!!)-!"
!!!!"!(
Implicaons
Implicaons for authoritave disaster management
$%)!*
!!!"(
,!" $%!"
!!""'+
!"!"(%!" $%!!
.
!!"(!-G $%
0A
(? $%!!
"++
!-""!!
""L
!!" $%!!
(
$%D!
!!"
!!"(%"" $%
!"!!!1))
-(+)!)4
))!""
!">"">
'!!"!!>
)")-+!! $%)-
!!($!"
!"!!!
!!"!!!!
)B(%!")
"'!!
!"!)L+!
!" $%(
57
, $%( $%
"!""
""(-"!)
2!!3!)
2.!3( $%!"!"
""(1 $%
'!"'!"
(%. $%
!"/
!!"!!"
"+!"!"!!"
!("!G
!)"'3
)")X!!" $%
)D"'()!
! $%!@)X
.!"'+
"'(8"!)!
"'!-
!)(
%!" $%
!!")-)-!!(8%
!" $%!."
50
/!'")+!'
"(!-
!#5&"
)X3!"!" $%!"(
$%!is!!!!
!)(!"!"!
!.)-!
"!!
with")+
)!!G $%!@(
"")
()!(%
$%)-%
!"/'"(
!"!"
!""'"+
!""G!
'!+""!)"
!!""'(1!
!D"($
!.!" $%!")
"/(!
55
"'" $%")
!!" $%"
""D" $%
(+!"!!!!!"'
$%!!!(
% $%!!
"GX
(1*)
'"("
!!G!-"
.).!!)
!! $%
!"(!".!
.)D $%"
( $%)!!)"
(!"D"! $%
"))+"'".!
!))-
".)-!!"(!!
"'"!""" $%
(
5B
Implicaons for geography and GIScience
6)""!"(1
!'" $%!!!"
! $%!!)$#577:)&)!' $%
!)!.!"(% $%!
) $%) $%(L
)3"""D!"!
#$577:)>570B&""#((6et al.577A&
) $%#((1E'
577F&3 $%!"(
$%!!!
"+.!)" $%)
!-"<88(%!
)" $%)"
))-!!"
!-"!!( $%)!
!!"!)!!"
!))))(
6!' $%!"!
"'"!"!"
"!")!/"(
""$%
"-" $%")-
5=
!"!!"#?$%&!)!"!"$%#??$%&
#E6E"' !5709>570:&(E6E"'
!#5709Ⱥ:& $%!"!
"!
"!(#!"B&
!-!!"(
%! $%"')!"!#570B>
E6E"' !5709&??$%
)"!""'!""
$%( $%!"!
".!!"!!!
!!BD!!
(!!)-) $%??$%)
!""!@"
)")!!"!"!
!"!
( $%)!2)3#5709&
$%!23
)"(!!
!!))
! $%!"!!!))
)!)!!$%(
59
)0!!" $%
!-"!!
$%<88
)(
Table 1. A summary of the key implicaons of VGI
[INSERT TABLE 1 HERE]
Consideraons and future work
!)""
)"<88.")-!$%
+!"-("
"!"!"".
!!!"(
!"#0&!"!!!
!#B&)!"!(!
+!"!!!
+!"!!'
+)(%)!!"!!!
!"!.))
!"!+!
!"#KLZ570=>570:&(1/
)L++! $%!"!!!
!*(
5;
I(1!!"!!!
!"/"
.!"!""!"!"!"
)
!)(8")-!!"!
$%!"/"!"!3
perceived(1+!!"!)
!V"))!-"
$%!!.)-
!!".!"L)-!(
1"!!
$%""!@(" $%
!#5&
)!"!!!!#B&(
)!!"(!(
1 $%!@!"!"
!(!)"!)
!!
!!"!!)
(I)"'#6!570;&
!*D""'"'
(
5:
!) $%!"
!!))-
!"!"( $%
/L"(1'"
/!)L+"'
)!) $%""'+!
).")(
/")! $%!"
)()!
!(,
G)-.!"
)"! $%(!
)/"! $%)L>
!>23
)2323>!!
23>2)3
!"!!!J/")!
!"(
I.!- $%)-!!"
(-!!))/")
. $%.(%"-""(
1))-.!"!
.!!"
5F
!!DD
!"D+
!"(
!!" $%)
!??88(8
". $%!
)"!!")!!" $%
!"!"Q).(,
)/" $%<88
.)
")G(
$%!"!!!"
!)"!
!(!"""(
/")-)
'O!"
(+!!
!O)(8
"" $%)"D
)!")
!)*-(
5A
Conclusion
$%<88!"
)L+!!"!"""
"""!+-)
-(%!" $%)!")
"'$%"
')2.!3"'"!"!!"
!+!!$%(E)
!)!!"!) $%(
"!.M!N#$
577:)!(500&"!""'$%"
!!""( $%
!!!"!"!
."!"
!G+')) $%(.
$%)!)
)+!'""'+!!(%'"
)!""!"
"')) $%!!")
)!!"(!! $%
" $%!"!!
!"!"!!!"
)"!)"
( $%!")"'
B7
!"!"!"-
!""")/")
J
Acknowledgements
%K%W6)LH<
"(%E+?K
"(?
!!)6-H'
6!"861%""
1(%!"!
))"(
B0
References
)W(5770(<4"
(Emergency Medicine0B40;9+0:B(
W(W(5700(?")-4
(Fire Technology=:497:S90F(
$(570:(!D!)!"!
!!#??$%Q?$%Q $%&(Transacons in GIS504BA+9;(
$(KLZE(570=(K!"!)!"!"$%
#??$%&4)!(Applied Geography=;4055+0B;(
()I((LE(570=(<)"!L"
!)#Megaptera novaeangliae&W4!"
!"'(Applied Geography9=4FB+A9(
?(0AAA(8-).
(The Australian Journal of Emergency Management0B#=&450S5;(
8(5709(8)4!"!
"(GeoJournal F7#=&4=::+=A7(
6<(W($[(I)W(577A( !"4
""!(Internaonal Journal of Spaal Data
Infrastructures Research=4BB5+B9F(
B5
6W(?(I(KE(5705(6"'!4
"'!"(Annals of
the Associaon of American Geographers075#;&405;:+05FA(
6!6((570;(Cizen Science: How Ordinary People are changing the Face of
Discovery.H[4,?(
6$#6,$&5700(H"<84
)"3(859E570;4
TL!4QQ(((QQQ-Q"\\\(!
U(
6E(,1(!"I(5705(<!"4
"'+(Internaonal Journal of Digital Earth9#9&4
BAFS=0;(
68(570=&(8J"!+
(Geography CompassF#A&4;5:+;=7(
($E(1(<(5705(8!
"4!"!!"(Annals of the
Associaon of American Geographers075#B&49:0S9A7(
<(8(6I(6(EL8(I(<<(
5709(Capturing community experiences in the 2015 Sampson Flat re, report for the
South Australia Country Fire Service(-H'686E)(
8B0E570;4TL!4QQ()((Q!)"Q!OU(
BB
1(E'E(577F()!"(
GeoJournal:540B:S0=F(
1E(5705(Promong community bushre preparedness: Bridging the theory–
pracce divide#<"&(80H)
570=4TL!4QQ!(((Q09B7AQU(
$E(1(577:(6"'4!"
)5(7(Internaonal Journal of Spaal Data Infrastructures Research545=+
B5(
]]](577:)(Cizens as sensors: !(GeoJournal;A#=&4
500+550(
]]](577F(64 $%JGeoJournal:5#B+=&45BA+5==(
]]](577A(H!!.!"(Journal of Locaon
Based ServicesB#5&4F5+A;(
$E(1($W((5707(6!"
!4"(Internaonal Journal of Digital EarthB#B&45B0+
5=0(
$E(1(II(5705(/!
"(Spaal Stascs04007+057(
E(570B(6"' $!%"S
!!"!"(%4<(C((E(1($#(&
B=
Crowdsourcing Geographic Knowledge: Volunteered Geographic Informaon (VGI) in
Theory and Pracce(4!(!!(079+055(
E((?6(577F()!!5(74!
$)(Geography Compass5#;&45700+57BA(
E()?(577F(,!!4+!(IEEE
Pervasive Compung:#=&405+0F(
(570;(!!"!
"4,!!"(Computers, Environment and Urban
Systems9:40FA+0AF(
((5709(!"
(Geography Compass A#9&45B:+597(
((E?(5709("4
!" $%
(The Australian Journal of Emergency ManagementB7#B&4B;+=0(
(LW((570;(!!" $%
!"!!!)-!!"(Applied Geography:;4
009+05:(
%E(?<(II(LW(E"(5709(
"+!4(
Bushre and Natural Hazards CRC and AFAC Wellington Conference 2014. 8B0
E570;4TL!4QQ()((Q!)"Q))Q)+0;50U(
B9
K8(I(?(5709()(GeoJournalF74=;B+
=:9(
K6(E.(^(<)//W(?(_O(570;
!"'4"
!!!!""(Internaonal Journal
of Geo-Informaon907B(<407(BBA7Q*97:707B(
KE(+?(570;(!4
!"!(Annals of the American Associaon of
Geographers, 07;#5&45:=+5F5(
I''(570=(,!(Annals of the Associaon of American
Geographers07=#0&4;7+:A(<,%407(07F7Q777=9;7F(570B(F=;09A
E((,3$(,3K?(8W(5700(<4)
)))JLocal Environment0;#9&4=0:S=5=(
EW(6K(?(577A(077+)-!!
4%-JJournal of Environmental Management
A7#F&45F0A+5F55(
E6E(K(E"'W( !W(5709(G)
!""4?$%(ACME: An
Internaonal E-Journal for Crical Geographies0=#B&4:A0+F5;(
B;
E<K(5700(!"!PO(
%4Proceedings of the surveying and spaal sciences biennial conference,
H)(
EI(W(5705(8!)+)-
G(Environmental Hazards00#0&40+09(
E?(5705(6!!"4!G)
!"(Journal of Map and Geography
Libraries F4FA+077(
EE((8I(1`(570;(K!4
)23JInternaonal Planning Studies50#=&4B=F+B;0(
,a8(5779,)07()5(746!-"J4,a88(80
,)570;4
TL!4QQB('(Q((QBF995:5:Q,8\8\+
\)\5(7\6!\<-"(!J
K%YK%W9;PW8EH?b.!Y0=:95F=0B5bY=IF
c5A:K;[ddBWW[[cB<b!++!"YcB
c57-cB<)\5(7\6!\<-"(!U
,1(!"I(5700(!O"
/!"(%4
Proceedings of the 14th AGILE Internaonal Conference on Geographic Informaon
Science, 0FS55!(
B:
?<(577B(<!!4+"!!"(Disaster Prevenon
and Management054507S50;(
?I(I((577:(6"'"4"!"%6+
!!!)!"!"(%Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human
Factors in Compung Systems(W6!!(:5:+:B;(#6E405=7:B;&(
?I(577B(<!!)!"!"4
)'""(Natural hazards5F#5+B&4500+55F(
?(?6(5700(<"!(TheAustralian
Journal of Emergency Management59#B&4F+00(
8E(,(H(577A(!4
"(Sociological Methods & ResearchB:#B&4=5;S=9=(
8W((8(8?(570;(-!!
"4570BE.!(The Australian Journal of
Emergency ManagementB0#0&4F+05(
8(<(H(570=(1''4)'I" )
$!%"$'"
I(Geography Compass8#:&4=A7+97=(
(570B(I!"(The Canadian
Geographer 9:#0&40S07(
BF
(E)((I(6!6(E(570:(
!"/(Internaonal Journal
of Geographical Informaon ScienceB0#0&40BA+0;:(
I((8("C(8)((570B("!4
!!!!(Photogrammetric engineering and remote sensing
:A#07&4F;9+F:A(
)8((8)?(W(W?((6)LW(E(570;(<!)
!"!"!")(Annals of the American Associaon of Geographers
07;#9&407B7+07=;(
<(C(577F(-"$%/4,W3L
$%(Computers, Environment and Urban SystemsB5#0&40S9(
<(C($E(1((570B( !"
.O(%4<(C(($E(1(
#(&Crowdsourcing Geographic Knowledge: Volunteered Geographic Informaon
(VGI) in Theory and Pracce(4!!!(0+05(
E($($(8!(5705(
!-!!)1)
26[!3(The Australian Journal of Emergency Management
5:#0&457+5;(
(EI8(?(5707(a577A -864
-!(a# 4E)&(
BA
-RE(8<(570B(!"
!H)5705O(Natural Hazards and Earth System Sciences
Discussion045F9A+5FF0(
H"%"<8"#H%<8&5779(Building the
resilience of naons and communies to disasters: Hyogo Framework for Acon 2005–
2015(H%<8ef(8=!570;4
TL!4QQ((Q5779QQQX+QI+Q++
+"+(!U(
H"%"<8"#H%<8&5709(
1<88"5709+57B7(85:W570;4
TL!4QQ(!")(Q-Q=B5A0\(!U(
<*W(K(577B(!.!(
TheInformaon Society: An Internaonal Journal0A#=&4B09+B5;(
(I(W()$(577;(6)"!D"
(Special issue, Public Administraon Review ;;40B0+=7(
LW(EI(W(5709(
4<-"!!"(Internaonal
Journal of Disaster Risk Reducon0B4B9F+B;F(
LW(6((K(570;($!577A
)- (Geographical Research9=#5&457B+509(
=7
(?(6(<%(#(&577B(At Risk: Natural Hazards, People’s
Vulnerability and Disasters 2nd Edion(I48(
C(W(W(W(5707(8'4!
!!"(Natural Hazards9B450+=0(
CE($E(($(5707( !
"4"/(
World Medical and Health Policy 5#5&4:SBB(
Author biography:
%II[K8,8?81
;77A(+4
)(g((("!"!$%
!"!!"
"'!"!"$%!!"
(
=0
