Presentation

Defining and identifying the vulnerability of suspects: towards a conceptual framework

Authors:
To read the file of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

No file available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the file of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
This study examined clinical, legal and social variables, and their relationship to forensic evaluators’ opinions of competency to stand trial on each of the three Dusky prongs (factual understanding of court proceedings, rational understanding of court proceedings and ability to assist one's counsel). Information was extracted from 257 competency to proceed to trial evaluations conducted between 2010 and 2013. Psychotic symptoms, intellectual disabilities and impairment in mental status (e.g., lack of orientation to person, place, time and/or situation) predicted opinions of not competent to stand trial across the Dusky competency prongs. However, the prongs were differentially related to mental health issues. Impaired mental status was associated with impairment on all three competency prongs. Delusions were associated with impaired rational understanding and impaired ability to assist one's counsel. Finally, thought derailment and a diagnosis of mental retardation were associated with impaired factual understanding of court proceedings.
Article
Full-text available
In their study, Kassin and Kiechel (1996) falsely accused students of causing a computer crash and found that 69% of them were willing to sign a false confession, 28% internalized guilt, and 9% confabulated details to support their false beliefs. The authors interpreted these results to mean that false confessions can be easily elicited. However, in their study, false confessions were explicitly not associated with negative consequences. The current study examined whether false incriminating evidence may elicit false confessions in undergraduate students when such confessions are explicitly associated with financial loss. We also explored whether individual differences in compliance, suggestibility, fantasy-proneness, dissociation, and cognitive failures are related to false confessions. The large majority of participants (82%) were willing to sign a false confession. In about half of the participants, false confessions were accompanied by internalization and confabulation. There was no evidence that individual differences modulate participants' susceptibility to false confessions. Taken together, our study replicates previous findings of Kassin and Kiechel.
Article
Full-text available
The present study is a meta-analysis of competency to stand trial research. One meta-analysis was previously conducted in this area, but the large number of empirical studies that have been conducted since and the introduction of new instruments and revision of old instruments warranted updating and expanding upon the previously conducted study via contemporary meta-analytic methods. We meta-analyzed 68 studies published between 1967 and 2008 that compared competent and incompetent defendants on a number of demographic, psychiatric, and criminological variables. Categorical and continuous variables commonly investigated in competency research were coded and aggregated to generate cumulative effect sizes in the form of odds ratios and Cohen's d statistics, and moderation was tested via meta-F and meta-regression analyses. The most robust findings were that defendants diagnosed with a Psychotic Disorder were approximately eight times more likely to be found incompetent than defendants without a Psychotic Disorder diagnosis and the likelihood of being found incompetent was approximately double for unemployed defendants as compared to employed defendants. The likelihood of being found incompetent was also double for defendants with a previous psychiatric hospitalization compared to those without a hospitalization history. Comparative data on 12 competency assessment instruments and three traditional instruments were also explored and the effect sizes associated with the competency measures were substantially larger (i.e., approximately one Cohen's d-point) than those for the traditional measures. Limitations of the primary research and the previous and present meta-analyses are presented and future directions in this area are outlined. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2012 APA, all rights reserved)
Article
This paper describes the development of a new compliance questionnaire which is intended to complement the present author's previous work into interrogative suggestibility. The questionnaire consists of 20 true-false statements which have particular application to interrogative situations involving retracted confession statements. The questionnaire has satisfactory internal consistency and test-retest reliability. Data are presented which support the concurrent and construct validity of the questionnaire.
Article
There have been major changes in English Law with regard to confession evidence, which followed the implementation of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE) in January 1986. This paper reviews the main legal changes that are relevant to the admissibility and reliability of confessions and their psychological importance within the context of both research and expert testimony.
Article
This study has several aims. First, to validate the Gudjonsson Suggestibility Scale (GSS) among delinquent and adolescent boys placed in an assessment and short-term treatment centre. Second, to test the hypothesis that adolescent boys are particularly susceptible to suggestions when they are ‘pressured’ by negative feedback and instructions. Finally, to investigate the hypothesis that suggestibility is related to memory recall and self-esteem. The GSS was administered to 31 boys (ages 11 to 16 yr) who had been independently rated by two teachers on measures of suggestibility and self-esteem. Suggestibility as measured by the GSS was found to correlate significantly with the teachers' ratings of suggestibility, supporting empirically the criterion-related validity of the GSS. Compared with young ‘normal’ adults the boys were no more likely to give in to suggestive questions than the adults, unless their performance was subjected to criticism and negative feedback. The results suggest that deliquent adolescents may be particularly responsive to interpersonal pressure during interrogation. The findings have important implications for police interrogation procedures.