Content uploaded by Jack Gelfand
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Jack Gelfand on Sep 18, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
An#Amateur#Instrument#for#the#Detection#of#the#Cosmic#
Microwave#Background#
!
"#$%!"!&'()#*+!,-.!
/#(+01*231(('4!56!!789!
":'()#*+;*'<!
#
ABSTRACT#
92<=>*>?'=2! +'<'$<! <-'! @>2?1$! A1$=>0#3'! /#$%:=>B*+! C@A/D! #2! #*! 'E<=#! *>12'!
'FB13#('*<!<>!#!G(#$%!G>+H!=#+1#<1*:!#<!#!<'?I'=#<B='!>)!J;KL!M;!N-'H!+>!<-12!01<-!#*!
1*2<=B?'*<!$#(('+!#!?1$=>0#3'!=#+1>?'<'=;!9!=#+1>?'<'=!12!#!=#+1>!<'('2$>I'!0->2'!
='2I>*2'! 12! $#(1G=#<'+! 01<-! %*>0*! <'?I'=#<B='! 2>B=$'2;! 9! I=>)'221>*#(! #II#=#<B2!
B<1(1O'2!<-'!<'?I'=#<B='!>)!(1FB1+!-'(1B?!<>!$#(1G=#<'!<-'!<'?I'=#<B='!2$#('!#*+!#(2>!
<>! $>>(! <-'! '('$<=>*1$2!)>=! FB1'<! >I'=#<1>*;!P! -#3'! )>B*+! <-#<! >*'! $#*! >G<#1*! #!
='#2>*#G('!('3'(!>)!I'=)>=?#*$'!01<-!1*'EI'*213'!'('$<=>*1$2!>I'=#<1*:!#<!QR!&SO!#<!
#?G1'*<!<'?I'=#<B='!#*+!#!$#(1G=#<1>*!$>*)1:B=#<1>*!B21*:!(1FB1+!*1<=>:'*!#<!KKM;!!
!
I.#Introduction#
92! <-'! B*13'=2'! $>>('+! #)<'=! <-'! /1:! /#*:4! 1<! '*<'='+! #! 2<#:'! 1*! 0-1$-! 1<! 0#2!#!
B*1)>=?4! 1>*1O'+! I(#2?#;! 92! <-'! I(#2?#! $>>('+! )B=<-'=4! <-'! '('$<=>*2! #*+! I=><>*2!
='$>?G1*'+!<>!)>=?!#!*'B<=#(4!<=#*2I#='*<!:#2;!T-'*!0'!(>>%!1*<>!<-'!2%H!<>+#H!0'!
2''! G#$%! 1*! <1?'! <>! <-'! (1:-<! (')<! >3'=! )=>?! <-#<! <=#*21<1>*;! /'$#B2'! >)! <-'! $>2?1$!
='+2-1)<4! 0'! *>0!2''! <-#<! (1:-<! 2-1)<'+! <>! ?1$=>0#3'! )='FB'*$1'2;! N-12! =#+1#<1>*4!
$#(('+! <-'! @>2?1$! A1$=>0#3'! /#$%:=>B*+4! 12! <-'! ?>2<! BG1FB1<>B2!'('$<=>?#:*'<1$!
=#+1#<1>*!1*!2I#$'4!#*+!)1((2!<-'!'*<1='!2%H!1*!#((!+1='$<1>*2;!
!
N-'!>=1:1*#(!->?>:'*'>B24!+'*2'!I(#2?#!#G2>=G'+!#((!(1:-<;!9!I=>I'=<H!>)!#!?#<'=1#(!
<-#<! $>?I('<'(H! #G2>=G2! =#+1#<1>*! 12! <>! <-'=?#((H! =#+1#<'! 1*! #! ?#<-'?#<1$#((H!
2I'$1)1'+! 0#H! $#(('+! #! G(#$%! G>+H! =#+1#<>=;! N-'! @A/! 12! +'<'$<'+! #2! <-'=?#(! *>12'!
'FB13#('*<!<>!#! G(#$%!G>+H!=#+1#<1*:! #<!J;KL! M;!9! ?1$=>0#3'!=#+1>?'<'=! 12!B2'+! <>!
?'#2B='!<-12!=#+1#<1>*!C.1$%'!QUVWD;!9! =#+1>?'<'=! 12! $#(1G=#<'+!01<-!<-'=?#(! G(#$%!
G>+H!=#+1#<1>*!)=>?!#!I'=)'$<!#G2>=G'=!?#<'=1#(!#<!<0>!%*>0*!<'?I'=#<B='2;!!
!
9!I=>)'221>*#(!#II#=#<B2!B<1(1O'2!#!3'=H!FB1'<!?1$=>0#3'!#?I(1)1'=!<>!+'<'$<!<-'!<1*H!
21:*#(;! N-'! '('$<=>*1$2! ?B2<! G'! $>>('+!1*! (1FB1+! -'(1B?! <>! >G<#1*! <-12! ('3'(! >)!
I'=)>=?#*$';! XB=<-'=?>='! <-'! (1FB1+! -'(1B?! 12! B2'+! <>! $#(1G=#<'! <-'! <'?I'=#<B='!
2$#('!>)! <-'!#II#=#<B2;! N-12!2'<BI! 12!FB1<'! 'EI'*213'!#*+! $>?I('E4!#*+! >B<21+'!<-'!
='#$-!>)!#?#<'B=!#2<=>*>?'=2;! T1<-!2>?'!21?I(1)1$#<1>*24!<->B:-4! 1<! 12!I>221G('!)>=!
#*!#?#<'B=!<>!$>*2<=B$<!#!21?1(#=!#II#=#<B2!<>!+'<'$<!<-'!@A/;!P!-#3'!)>B*+!<-#<!>*'!
$#*! #$-1'3'!#! ='#2>*#G('! ('3'(! >)! I'=)>=?#*$'! 01<-! 1*'EI'*213'! '('$<=>*1$2!
>I'=#<1*:! #<! =>>?! <'?I'=#<B='! #*+! #! <'?I'=#<B='! $#(1G=#<1>*! B21*:! #! G(#$%! G>+H!
=#+1#<>=! 1*! (1FB1+! *1<=>:'*!#<! KKM;! N-'! +'21:*! >)! ?H! 1*2<=B?'*<4! 2->0*! 1*! <-'!
I-><>:=#I-!G'(>04!12!#+#I<'+!)=>?!'#=<-YG#2'+!1*2<=B?'*<2!B2'+!GH!&'>=:'!8?>><!
#*+!-12! :=>BI! <>!?#%'! ?'#2B='?'*<2!1*! <-'!(>0'=!?1$=>0#3'! =':1>*!CM>:B<!'<! #(;!
QUZZ4!QUURD;!8>?'!$>?I>*'*<2! #='!21?I(1)1'+!0-1('!='<#1*1*:! <-'! $=1<1$#(!'('?'*<2!
>)! <-'! +'21:*;! 9++1<1>*#((H4! <-'='! -#3'! G''*! ><-'=! #?#<'B=! >=1'*<'+! 2H2<'?2! >)!
2>?'0-#<!21?1(#=!+'21:*!CM>II'*4!JRQ[\!,1#<4!JRQK\!8<'1*!]!X>2<'=4!JRRZD;!
!
II.#Design!
N-'! I=1*$1I#(! )'#<B='! >)! <-'!+'21:*! 12! <-'! B2'! >)! #! ?1$=>0#3'! ->=*! #*<'**#! )>=!
='$'I<1>*;!S>=*!#*<'**#2!-#3'!<-'!-1:-!+':=''!>)!2I#<1#(!2'('$<131<H!*''+'+!<>!+'<'$<!
<-'! 0'#%! @A/! 1*! <-'! 2%H! 1*! <-'! I='2'*$'!>)! #?G1'*<! <-'=?#(! *>12'! 1*! <-'! (>$#(!
'*31=>*?'*<;! 9! +12-! #*<'**#! -#2! I>>='=! 2I#<1#(! 2'('$<131<H!G'$#B2'! >)! 2$#<<'=1*:!
)=>?! <-'! 2<=B$<B='! #*+! ('#%#:'! #=>B*+! <-'! '+:'! >)! <-'! +12-;! 9*><-'=! I=1*$1I#(!
)'#<B='! >)! <-'! +'21:*! 12! <-'! B2'! >)! #! .'0#=! )(#2%! $>*)1:B='+! #2! #! ?1$=>0#3'!
0#3':B1+'!?#<$-'+!<>!<-'!+1#?'<'=!>)!<-'!->=*!#*<'**#;!N-'!.'0#=!-#2!?1$=>0#3'!
#G2>=G'=! ?#<'=1#(! I(#$'+! #<! <-'! G><<>?;! N-'! #G2>=G'=! ?#<'=1#(! 12! $>3'='+! 01<-!
(1FB1+!*1<=>:'*!<>!2'=3'!#2!#!$>(+!<-'=?#(!=#+1#<1>*!2>B=$'!
!
!
!
X1:B='!Q;!N-'!?1$=>0#3'!=#+1>?'<'=!2H2<'?!+'2$=1G'+!1*!<-12!I#I'=!
!
N-'!)='FB'*$H! =#*:'!>)! <-'!@A/!G(#$%! G>+H!=#+1#<1>*!'E<'*+2! )=>?!#II=>E1?#<'(H!
R;[! &SO! <>! LRR! &SO! 1*! <-'! =#+1>! )='FB'*$H! 2I'$<=B?4! 01<-! #! I'#%!#<!QWV! &SO;!
^EH:'*! #*+! 0#<'=! 3#I>=! 1*! <-'! #<?>2I-'='! #G2>=G! ?1$=>0#3'2! >3'=! ?>2<! >)! <-12!
)='FB'*$H!=#*:';!!N-#<!12!0-H!?>2<!?'#2B='?'*<2!>)!<-'!@A/!#='!I'=)>=?'+!B21*:!
2#<'((1<'24!-1:-!#(<1<B+'! G#((>>*2!>=!<'('2$>I'2!#<!<-'!8>B<-!,>(';!N-'!#<?>2I-'='!124!
->0'3'=4!2BG2<#*<1#((H!<=#*2I#='*<!)=>?!Q!&SO!<>!QR!&SO!#<!<-'!(>0!'*+!>)!<-'!@A/!
)='FB'*$H!2I'$<=B?;!N-12!01*+>0!12!2->0*!1*!X1:B='!J!G'(>0;!!
!
5989!
!
X1:B='!J;!.1#:=#?!>)! <-'!<-'=?#(!'?1221>*!>)! #<?>2I-'=1$!:#22'2!3'=2B2!)='FB'*$H!
1*! &SO;! 5><'! <-#<! #++1<1>*#(! *>12'! I='2'*<! 1*! >B=! >0*! :#(#EH! )=>?! ='(#<1312<1$!
'('$<=>*2!$='#<'2!2BG2<#*<1#(!G#$%:=>B*+!*>12'!G'(>0!Q!&SO;!
!
5B?'=>B2! <HI'2! >)! #?#<'B=! #*+! $>??'=$1#(! ?1$=>0#3'! ='$'131*:! 'FB1I?'*<! #='!
#3#1(#G('!)>=!B2'!1*!<-'!Q!_!QR!&SO!=#*:';!!P!-#3'!$->2'*!<>!B2'!$>?I>*'*<2!)=>?!#*!
`YG#*+!+12-!2#<'((1<'!#*<'**#!#2!+'2$=1G'+!G'(>0;!!
!
II.a.#Antenna#Size#
N-'! ?>2<! 1?I>=<#*<! )#$<>=! <>! $>*21+'=! 1*! +'21:*1*:! #! ?1$=>0#3'! =#+1>?'<'=! <>!
+'<'$<!<-'!@A/!12!->0!(#=:'!<-'!#*<'**#!?B2<!G';!^*'!0>B(+!<-1*%!<-#<!+'<'$<1*:!#!
21:*#(! )=>?! <-'! G':1**1*:! >)! <1?'! 0>B(+! ='FB1='! #! -B:'! +12-! #*<'**#;! N-12! 12! *><!
<=B';!X>=!#!+1))B2'!2>B=$'4!#*<'**#!21O'!+>'2!*><!+'<'=?1*'!21:*#(!2<='*:<-!CS#**H!'<!
#(;!JRQJD;! N-12! $#*! G'! 'EI(#1*'+! #2! )>((>02;! T'! %*>0! <-#<! )>=! #! (#=:'=! #*<'**#!
+1#?'<'=4! 0'! 0>B(+! <HI1$#((H! 'EI'$<! <>! 1*<'=$'I<! ?>='! ?1$=>0#3'! )(BE!G'$#B2'! >)!
<-'!(#=:'=!$>(('$<1>*!#='#;!S>0'3'=4!)=>?!+1))=#$<1>*!<-'>=H!0'!%*>0!<-#<!<-12!(#=:'=!
#*<'**#! ='$'13'2!21:*#(2! )=>?! #! 2?#(('=! #='#! >)! <-'! 2%H;! N-'! 1*$='#2'! >)! <-'!
$>(('$<1*:! #='#! 12! 'E#$<(H! >))2'<! GH! <-'! #*<'**#! ='$'131*:! )=>?! #! 2?#(('=! 2%H! #='#;!
N-12!?B2<!G'!2>4!>=!1<!0>B(+!31>(#<'!<-'!8'$>*+!a#0!>)!N-'=?>+H*#?1$2;!/'$#B2'!>)!
<-12!)#$<4!#*<'**#!21O'!+>'2!*><!+'<'=?1*'!='$'13'+!21:*#(!2<='*:<-;!X>=<B*#<'(H!<-'*4!
#*! #?#<'B=! $#*! $->>2'! #! ='$'131*:! #*<'**#4! 0-1$-!2#<12)1'2! ><-'=! +'21:*! $=1<'=1#;!
M''I!1*!?1*+4!<->B:-4!<-#<!<-'!21O'!>)!<-'!#*<'**#!+'<'=?1*'2!<-'!G'#?01+<-4!0-1$-!
?#H!G'!1?I>=<#*<!)>=!><-'=!$>*21+'=#<1>*2;!!
!
N-12!#*<'**#!21O'!+'21:*!$=1<'=1>*!12!B*(1%'!<-#<!>)!#*!>I<1$#(!<'('2$>I'!1*!0-1$-!0'!
)>$B2!>*! 21*:('!I>1*<!2>B=$'2!2B$-!#2!#!2<#=!>=!2?#((!:#(#EH;!P<!12!#(2>!+1))'='*<!)=>?!
<-#<! >)! #! ='$'131*:! #*<'**#! 1*! #! $>??B*1$#<1>*! 2H2<'?4! 0-1$-! 2''%2! <>! +'<'$<! #!
21:*#(!)=>?!#!21*:('!<=#*2?1<<1*:!2>B=$';!P*!<->2'!$#2'2!#!(#=:'=!?1==>=!>=!#*<'**#!12!
3'=H!G'*')1$1#(!<>!I'=)>=?#*$';!
!
II.b.#Microwave#Radiometer#
N-'! ?'#2B='?'*<! $>*)1:B=#<1>*! 1*! >B=! 'EI'=1?'*<! 12! <-#<! >)! #! <><#(! I>0'=!
=#+1>?'<'=;! T'! #='! >I'=#<1*:! 1*! <-'! =':1>*! >)!<-'! b#('1:-Y"'#*2! #II=>E1?#<1>*! <>!
<-'!(>0!)='FB'*$H!'*+!>)!<-'!/(#$%!/>+H!$B=3';!P*!<-'!b#('1:-Y"'#*2!=':1>*!<-'!<><#(!
*>12'! I>0'=! 21:*#(4! ,4! 1*<'=$'I<'+! #<! <-'! #*<'**#! 12! +1='$<(H! I=>I>=<1>*#(! <>! <-'!
<'?I'=#<B='!>)!<-'!#*<'**#!CM>:B<4!QUURD4!!
!
!!!!!,!c!%!NC#*<D!/!!!!!CQD!
!
T-'='! %! 12! <-'! />(<O?#**! $>*2<#*<4! NC#*<D! 12! <-'! <'?I'=#<B='! >G2'=3'+! #<! <-'!
#*<'**#4!#*+! /!12! <-'!)='FB'*$H! G#*+01+<-;!P*! <-12!=':1?'4! <'?I'=#<B='!?'#2B='+!
GH! ?1$=>0#3'! *>12'! I>0'=! #<! <-'! #*<'**#! $>=='2I>*+2! <>! <-'! #$<B#(!
C<-'=?>+H*#?1$D! <'?I'=#<B='! >)! <-'! =#+1#<1*:! 2>B=$'2;! @>*<=1GB<1>*2! <>! <-'! <><#(!
4*>12'! <'?I'=#<B='! #='! #++1<13';! X>=! 'E#?I('4! B*+'=! <-'! $>*+1<1>*2! 1*! <-'!
>G2'=3#<1>*2!+'2$=1G'+!-'='4!
!
N!C#*<'**#D!c!N!C@A/D!d!N!C#<?>2I-'='D!d!N!C#?I(1)1'=!*>12'D! ! CJD!
!
N-12!)#$<!#((>02!B2! <>!$#(1G=#<'!<-'!='2I>*2'!>)!<-'!=#+1>?'<'=!01<-!<0>!$#(1G=#<1>*!
<'?I'=#<B='24! KKM! #*+! #?G1'*<! >B<+>>=! <'?I'=#<B='4! eJUWM4! #*+! B2'! #! (1*'#=!
'E<=#I>(#<1>*!<>!+'<'=?1*'!N!C8%HD;!
!
!
!
X1:B='!L;!@B<#0#H!31'0!>)!<-'!(1FB1+!*1<=>:'*!$>(+!$#(1G=#<1>*!2>B=$'!
!
!
Glass%Shell
Metallic
Coating
Liquid
Nitrogen
Microwave
Absorber
Vacuum
9*! 1?I>=<#*<! $>?I>*'*<! >)! <-'! =#+1>?'<'=! 2H2<'?! 12! <-'! $>(+! <'?I'=#<B='!
$#(1G=#<>=4! >=! $>(+Y(>#+;!P*! <-'! $>(+Y(>#+4! <-'=?#(! '?1221>*! >)! <-'! (1FB1+! *1<=>:'*!
$>>('+!?1$=>0#3'!#G2>=G1*:!?#<'=1#(!12!$>BI('+!<>!<-'!='$'131*:!#*<'**#;!N-12!?B2<!
G'!+>*'!1*!2B$-!#!0#H!#2!<>!#3>1+!'?1221>*!)=>?!0#<'=!1$'! >=!)>:!1*!<-'!?1$=>0#3'!
$#31<H;! N-'! ?1$=>0#3'! $#31<H! $#(1G=#<>=! <-#<! P! B2'! 12! #+#I<'+! )=>?! <-'! +'21:*! >)!
/'*2#+>B*!CQUUJD;!9!$B<#0#H!31'0!12!2->0*!1*!X1:B='!L;!9!.'0#=!)(#2%!12!B2'+!#2!#!
?1$=>0#3'! 0#3':B1+'! 01<-! #! 2'$<1>*! >)! ?1$=>0#3'! #G2>=G'=! #<! <-'! G><<>?;! N-'!
#G2>=G'=!12!$>3'='+!01<-!(1FB1+!*1<=>:'*;!N-'!(1FB1+!*1<=>:'*!2(>0(H!G>1(2!#<!KKM! <>!
?#1*<#1*! <-'! <'?I'=#<B=';! N-'! #G2>=G'=! ?#<'=1#(2! #='! <HI1$#((H! ?#+'! GH! ?1E1*:!
I>0+'='+! $#=G>*! 01<-! 3#=1>B2! I>(H?'=! ?#<'=1#(2;! P! B2'! a#1=+! N'$-*>(>:1'2! R;[f!
)>#?! GB1(<! 1*<>! 2?#((! IH=#?1+#(! 2-#I'2! >*! <-'! 2B=)#$'! <>! ?#<$-! <-'! 2-#I'! >)! <-'!
.'0#=;!
!
N-'!0#((2!>)!<-'!.'0#=! #='! $>#<'+!01<-!#!<-1*!?'<#(!)1(?! 0-'*!?#*B)#$<B='+;!N-12!
2'=3'2!<>!%''I!>B<!1*)=#='+!=#+1#<1>*;!P*!<-12!+'21:*!<-'!?'<#(!)1(?!#(2>!2'=3'2!#2!<-'!
0#((2!>)!#!?1$=>0#3'!0#3':B1+'!<>!$>*)1*'!<-'!G(#$%!G>+H!=#+1#<1>*!)=>?!<-'!(1FB1+!
*1<=>:'*! $>>('+! ?1$=>0#3'! #G2>=G'=;! 9++1<1>*#((H4! <-'! I=>)'221>*#(! +'21:*! -#2!
*B?'=>B2! <-1*! )1(?! 01*+>02! <>! %''I! ?>12<! #1=! )=>?! '*<'=1*:! <-'! $#31<H;! N-'!
01*+>02!#='!*'$'22#=H!G'$#B2'!1*!I=>)'221>*#(!>G2'=3#<1>*2!>*'!?#H!?#1*<#1*!<-12!
$>*)1:B=#<1>*!)>=!JV!->B=2!>=!?>='!0-1('!)1(('+!01<-!(1FB1+!-'(1B?;!P!-#3'!)>B*+!<-#<!
2(>0!'3#I>=#<1>*!>)!+=H!*1<=>:'*!)=>?!<-'!G#<-!12!2B))1$1'*<!<>!I=>31+'!0#<'=!3#I>=!
)=''!>I'=#<1>*!01<->B<!01*+>02!)>=!#*!->B=4!(>*:!'*>B:-!)>=!?H!+#<#!=B*2;!!
!!
II.c.#Microwave#Receiver#
N-'! ?1$=>0#3'! ='$'13'=! B2'2! <-'! ->=*! #*<'**#! )''+! )=>?! #! Ng! +12-! *'<0>=%!
='$'13'=;! P! +>! *><! B2'!<-'! I#=#G>(1$! +12-! GB<! B2'! <-'! 2?#((! ->=*! #*<'**#! )''+! #*+!
#22>$1#<'+!'('$<=>*1$2;!92!?'*<1>*'+!'#=(1'=4!<-'!+12-!#*<'**#!$>*)1:B=#<1>*!12!?>='!
2B2$'I<1G('! <>! 2<=#H! *>12'! <-#*! #! ->=*! #*<'**#! #(>*';! N-'! #*<'**#! )''+! ?>+B('!
='$'13'2! 1*! <-'! =#*:'! >)! QR;K! YQQ;K! &SO;! N-'! ?>+B('! 12! $#(('+! #! a>0! 5>12'! /(>$%!
Ca5/D!#*+!$#*!G'!IB=$-#2'+!>*!'/#H!)>=!#2!(1<<('!#2!h!L!'#$-;!A>2<!`Y/#*+!a5/2!#='!
>)! 2BG2<#*<1#((H! <-'! 2#?'! +'21:*;! N-'H! $>?I=12'! #! Jf! +1#?'<'=! ?1$=>0#3'! ->=*!
#*<'**#! )''+1*:! #! $1=$B1<! G>#=+! 1*! #! $#2<! #(B?1*B?! ->B21*:;! N-'! $1=$B1<! G>#=+!
$>*<#1*2!#!(>0!*>12'!I='#?I(1)1'=!#*+!bX!?1E'=!$1=$B1<!<>!2-1)<!<-'!)='FB'*$H!>)!<-'!
='$'13'=!<>!<-'!Q!Y!J!&SO!!"#$%&$'!(#$)*%$+,$"-.)/012)=#*:'!0-'='!1<!12!<=#*2?1<<'+!
<-=>B:-!#!$#G('!<>!<-'!Ng!='$'13'=!1*!<-'!->B2';!P*!<-12!2H2<'?!the#receiver#is# tuned#
to"10.75"GHz"by"the"choice"of" a!1" GHz" IF!filter'with'a'50' MHz' bandwidth.!The!total%
noise& power& in& the& 50& MHz# bandpass# is# read% on% a% Hewlett% Packard% HPY432A!RF!
power&meter.!
!
There% are% numerous' other' configurations,!which!could& be& used,& such& as& a&
commercial)10!GHz$ communications* receiver.'Also,' the'IF'section'could'be'replaced'
by# a# software# defined# receiver# with!a" noise!power& measurement!algorithm.!The$
most% important% performance% criterion% for% the% detector$ system$ is$ linearity.& As&
discussed'earlier'in'this' paper,"the" radiometer"works"on"the" linear" extrapolation"of"
the$ temperature$ calibration$ response.$ $ Keep$ in$ mind$ that$ most$ commercial& and&
amateur'equipment'use!an!Automatic%Gain%Control%(AGC)%circuit%to%keep#the#output#
constant'in!spite&of&signal&strength(changes.)This) circuit)must)be)disabled)for)use)in)
this%application.!
!
II.d.#Horn#Antenna!
N-'! Jf! ->=*! #*<'**#! I=>31+'+! 01<-! <-'! a5/! 12! +'21:*'+! #2! #! )''+! ->=*! )>=! <-'!
I#=#G>(1$!+12-;!X>=!<-12!#II(1$#<1>*4!1<!-#2!#!3'=H!G=>#+!G'#?!01+<-!>)!K[!+':=''2;!P!
-#3'!#++'+!#*!'E<'*21>*!->=*!<>!<-'!>=1:1*#(!Jf!+1#?'<'=!->=*!<>!*#==>0!<-'!G'#?!
01+<-!<>!#!QR!+':=''!)1'(+!>)!31'0;!N-12!?#%'2!1<!I>221G('!<>!I>1*<!#<!<-'!2%H!01<->B<!
1*<'=)'='*$'! )=>?! 2B==>B*+1*:! <=''2! #*+! GB1(+1*:2;! 9! *#==>0! G'#?01+<-! 12! #(2>!
='FB1='+!GH!<-'!I=>$'+B='!<>!+'<'=?1*'!#<?>2I-'=1$!'?1221>*!GH!?'#2B=1*:!NC8%HD!
#<!+1))'='*<!'('3#<1>*2;!!
!
!
!
X1:B='!V!N-'!$>*)1:B=#<1>*!>)!<-'!'E<'*21>*!->=*!#*<'**#!#2!1<!#<<#$-'2!<>!<-'!'*+!>)!
<-'!2?#((!->=*!>*!<-'!a5/!
!
N-'! 'E<'*21>*! ->=*! 12! 2->0*! 1*! X1:B='! V;! P<! 12! )#G=1$#<'+! )=>?!;RQRi! 2-''<! G=#22!
)>=?'+! 1*<>! #! $>*'!01<-! #! J;Rf! +1#?'<'=! >I'*1*:! #<! <-'! 2?#(('=! '*+! #*+! #! W;Rf!
>I'*1*:!#<! <-'! (#=:'=! '*+;! N-'! $>*'! 12! U;Rf! (>*:;! N-12! 12! #*! >I<1?B?! ->=*!
$>*)1:B=#<1>*! )>=! #! QR! +':=''! G'#?01+<-! C9G>2'=0#(! #*+! /#(#*12! JRQLD;! N-'!
2<#=<1*:!I#<<'=*!12!$B<!)=>?!2-''<!G=#224!2''!000;$?=I;$>?j$>*'Y$#($B(#<>=;!
!
II.e.#Atmospheric#Emission#
T-'*!I>1*<1*:!#<!<-'! @A/! <-=>B:-!<-'!#<?>2I-'='4! 0'! #(2>!='$'13'!<-'!:(>0! )=>?!
#<?>2I-'=1$!:#22'2!#++'+!<>!<-'!2%H!<'?I'=#<B=';!N-'!'?1221>*!12!I=1*$1I#((H!)=>?!
>EH:'*! #*+! 0#<'=! 3#I>=;! N-12! I-'*>?'*>*! -#2! G''*! 2<B+1'+! GH! #2<=>*>?'=2!!
C/'=2#*'((1!'<!#(;!QUU[D4!#*+!#(2>!'E<'*213'(H!GH!<-'!#<?>2I-'=1$!2$1'*$'!$>??B*1<H!
C"#*22'*4! QUULD4! 0-'='! <-12! '?1221>*! 12! B2'+! <>! ='?><'(H! 2'*2'! $>*+1<1>*2! 1*! <-'!
#<?>2I-'=';! N-'! :(>0! $>=='2I>*+2! <>! #! G=1:-<*'22! <'?I'=#<B='! #<! QR! &SO! #<! 2'#!
('3'(! >)! #II=>E1?#<'(H! [! M! <>! Q[! M4! +'I'*+1*:! >*! <-'! ('3'(! >)! ?>12<B='! #*+! $(>B+!
$>3'=;!!,=>)'221>*#(!#2<=>*>?'=2! -#3'! <-'! #+3#*<#:'! >)!>G2'=31*:!)=>?!G#((>>*2!>=!
)=>?! 2I#$'! 0-'='! <-12! $>=='$<1>*! 12! *':(1:1G(';! P<! 12! #! 2BG2<#*<1#(! $>=='$<1>*4!
->0'3'=4!)>=!#?#<'B=2!0->!I=1*$1I#((H!>G2'=3'!#<!2'#!('3'(;!N-'!21<B#<1>*!:'<2!G'<<'=!
#<! -1:-'=! #(<1<B+'2;! 9<! QJ4RRR! )''<! <-'! #<?>2I-'=1$! *>12'! 12! #G>B<! Q! M! #<! QR! &SO!
C/'=2#*'((1!'<!#(;!QUU[D;!
!
P*!>B=!$#2'!#<?>2I-'=1$!*>12'!#++2!(1*'#=(H!<>!<-'!@A/;!
!
!!!!NC8%HD!!c!NC@A/D!d!NC9<?D! ! ! ! CLD!
!
T'!$#*!2'I#=#<'!<-'!<0>!$>?I>*'*<2!GH!?'#2B=1*:!NC8%HD!#<!<-'!O'*1<-!#*+!#<!('#2<!
>*'! #++1<1>*#(! #*:(';! N-12! $#*! G'! +>*'! G'$#B2'! >)! <-'! :'>?'<=1$! ='(#<1>*2-1I!
G'<0''*!<-'!I>0'=!+'<'$<'+!#*+!<-'!('*:<-!>)!<-'!I#<-;!!
!
#
#
!
X1:B='![!9!+1#:=#?!2->01*:!<-'!='(#<1>*2-1I!G'<0''*!#1=!?#22!#*+!>G2'=31*:!#*:('!
!
X1:B='![!2->02!<-'!I#<-!('*:<-!1*!<-'!#<?>2I-'='!#2!#!)B*$<1>*!>)!>G2'=3#<1>*!#*:(';!
T'!$#*!2''!<-#<!<-12!I#<-!('*:<-4!$#(('+!<-'!#1=!?#224!12!='(#<'+!GH!<-'!)#$<>=!8'$!θ #2!
2->0*!1*!kFB#<1>*!V!G'(>0;!
!
!!!!aCθD!c!aCRD!8'$!θ (4)!!
!
T-'='!aCRD!12!<-'!I#<-!('*:<-!<-=>B:-!<-'!#<?>2I-'='!#<!<-'!O'*1<-!#*+!aCθD!12!<-'!
I#<-!('*:<-! #<! <-'! >G2'=31*:! #*:('! θ;! P*! <-'! b#('1:-Y"'#*2! #II=>E1?#<1>*! <-'!
>G2'=3'+!<'?I'=#<B='!:=>02!(1*'#=(H!01<-!#1=?#22!#2!2->0*!1*!kFB#<1>*![;!
!
! ! ! ! NC9<?4!θ) = NC9<?4!RD!8'$!θ (5)
T-'='! NC9<?4! 0)! 12! <-'! #<?>2I-'=1$! $>?I>*'*<! >)! <-'! >G2'=3'+! <'?I'=#<B='!
?'#2B='+!)=>?!<-'!2%H!#<!<-'!O'*1<-4!#*+!NC9<?4!θ)!12!<-'!#<?>2I-'=1$!$>?I>*'*<!>)!
<-'!>G2'=3'+!<'?I'=#<B='! ?'#2B='+! )=>?!<-'!2%H! #<! #*:('!θ. X=>?!kF;! L!#*+!kF;![!
0'!$#*!+'=13'!#!='(#<1>*!'EI='221*:!<-'!$>*<=1GB<1>*!<>!NC8%HD!)=>?!NC9<?D!2->0*!
1*!kF;!W!G'(>0;!A'#2B='?'*<2!$#*!G'!?#+'!#<!#!*B?G'=!>)!#*:('2!#*+!$>?G1*'+;!
!!!!
NC9<?4!RD!c!lNC8%H4!θ) − Τ(8%H4!RDm!@>2!θ (6)!
Zenith
L(0)
L(e)
e
!
III.#Method#
N-'2'! ?'#2B='?'*<2! ?B2<! G'! I'=)>=?'+! 01<-! #! $>?I('<'(H! B*>G2<=B$<'+! 31'0! >)!
<-'!2%H;!N=''2!#*+!><-'=!>Gn'$<2!<-'=?#((H!=#+1#<'!#<!<-'!#?G1'*<!<'?I'=#<B='!>)!<-'!
'*31=>*?'*<! $#B21*:! 2BG2<#*<1#(!'==>=2;! N-'='! 12! *>! *''+! <>! I'=)>=?! <-'2'!
?'#2B='?'*<2!1*!+#=%*'22;! 6>B!+>! *''+!<>!#3>1+! I>1*<1*:!<-'!#*<'**#! <>0#=+!<-'!
2>B<-!0-'='!Ng!2#<'((1<'2!#='!<=#*2?1<<1*:!*'#=!<-'!='$'13'=!G#*+I#22;!!
!
N-'! I=>$'+B='! 12! 21?I(';! N-'! <><#(! ?1$=>0#3'! I>0'=! '?1<<'+! )=>?! <-'! KKM! $>(+!
(>#+4!#*!#?G1'*<!<'?I'=#<B='!G(#$%!G>+H!=#+1#<>=!#*+!<-'!2%H!?B2<!G'!?'#2B='+!1*!
2'FB'*$';!N-12!2'FB'*$'!12!2->0*!1*!<-'!I-><>:=#I-2!1*!X1:B='!W;!!
!
!
!
!
!
X1:B='!W;!8'FB'*$'!>)!#*<'**#!I>21<1>*2!#*+! 2>B=$'2!)>=! $#(1G=#<1*:!<-'!=#+1>?'<'=!
9;!9?G1'*<!<'?I'=#<B='!#G2>=G'=!?>B*<'+!#<!<-'!'*+!>)!<-'!?1$=>0#3'!->=*!
/;!S>=*!#*<'**#!#1?'+!1*<>!<-'!$>(+!(>#+!2>B=$'!#<!KKM!
@;!S>=*!#*<'**#!#1?'+!#<!<-'!O'*1<-!
!
N-'!'('$<=>*1$2!1*! I=>)'221>*#(!'FB1I?'*<!#='! <-'=?>2<#<1$#((H!$>*<=>(('+;!P! +>!*><!
2<#G1(1O'! <-'! <'?I'=#<B='! >)! ?H! 'FB1I?'*<;! P! 0#=?! BI! ?H! 'FB1I?'*<! )>=! #<! ('#2<!
>*'!->B=!#*+!<=H!<>!'E'$B<'!<-'!?'#2B='?'*<!FB1$%(H;!P!<=H!<>!#3>1+!<1?'2!0-'*!<-'!
#?G1'*<!<'?I'=#<B='!12!$-#*:1*:!=#I1+(H;!!
!
N-'! 1*IB<! <>! <-'! S'0('<<! ,#$%#=+! I>0'=! ?'<'=! 12! ='2'<! <>! O'=>! G')>='! '#$-!
?'#2B='?'*<;!N-'!2<#G1(1<H!>)!<-'!KK!M!I>0'=!='#+1*:!12!#!?'#2B='!>)!<-'!2<#G1(1<H!>)!
<-'! '*<1='! 2H2<'?!#2! <-'! G>1(1*:! I>1*<! >)! *1<=>:'*! 12! $>*2<#*<;! P! )1*+! <-#<! <-'! <><#(!
I>0'=!='#+1*:!12!2<#G('!<>!Qo!>3'=!<-'!$>B=2'!>)!#!>*'!->B=!+#<#!=B*;!
!
IV.#Results#
N-'!#*#(H212!>)!<-'! +#<#!#*+!<-'!+'<'=?1*#<1>*! >)!<-'!?'#2B='+!@A/! =#+1#<1>*!#='!
G'2<!B*+'=2<>>+! :=#I-1$#((H;! T'! $#*! $>*2<=B$<! #! :=#I-!>)! ?1$=>0#3'! *>12'! I>0'=!
3'=2B2!2>B=$'!<'?I'=#<B='!#2!2->0*!1*!X1:B='!K!G'(>0;!
!
A B C
!"#$%&'()#*"$&+,%&%-&./01&441&5#6,7*#8-2&9#%#&
:&;&<=<<<0>&?&<=<@A/&
!"!!!!#
!"!$!!#
!"%!!!#
!"%$!!#
!"&!!!#
!"&$!!#
!"!# $!"!# %!!"!# %$!"!# &!!"!# &$!"!# '!!"!# '$!"!#
BCD'E&FCGEH&IG&
JEKFEHLJMHE&&&1"6N,2$&
5L!DOHLJDCB&LB9&JEKFEHLJMHE&9EJEHKDBLJDCB&
!
!
X1:B='!K;!9!:=#I-1$#(!='I='2'*<#<1>*!>)!<-'!?'#2B='?'*<!>)!NC8%HD!>*!<-'!G#212!>)!#!
<0>Y<'?I'=#<B='!$#(1G=#<1>*!>)!#!?1$=>0#3'!=#+1>?'<'=;!
!
N-'! *>12'! I>0'=! +#<#! #<! eJUWM! C=>>?! <'?I'=#<B='D! #*+! KKM! Ca1FB1+! *1<=>:'*!
<'?I'=#<B='D! #='! ('#2<! 2FB#='2! )1<<'+! <>! #! (1*';! N-'! 3#(B'! >)! ?'#2B='+! 2%H! *>12'!
I>0'=!12!<-'*!I(><<'+!>*!<-'!$#(1G=#<1>*!(1*';!N-'!3#(B'!>)!<-'!<'?I'=#<B='!>)!<-'!2%H!
12!='#+!>))!>)!<-'!EY#E12;!6>B!$#*!$('#=(H!2''!<-'!#+3#*<#:'!>)!B21*:!(1FB1+!S'(1B?!)>=!
<-'! $>(+! <'?I'=#<B='! $#(1G=#<1>*! )=>?! <-'! :=#I-;! N-'='! 12! #! 2BG2<#*<1#(!
'E<=#I>(#<1>*!)=>?!KKM!<>!NC8%HD;!
!
^*!<-12!=B*! ?'#2B='+!2%H!<'?I'=#<B='! 0#2! $#($B(#<'+!)=>?! <-12! +#<#!#*+! )>B*+! <>!
G'!Z;U!M;!X>=! #! $('#=!2%H!<-'!$>=='$<1>*! )>=!<-'!QR!&SO! '?1221>*! >)!<-'!#<?>2I-'='!
0#2![;R!M;!N-'!?'#2B='+!NC@A/D!124!
!
!NC@A/D!c!NC8%HD!_!NC9<?D!c!Z;UM!_![;RM!c!L;UM!!!CKD!
!
N-'!#$$'I<'+!NC@A/D!c!J;KLM!12!$(>2'!<>!<-'!?'#2B='+!<'?I'=#<B='!>)!L;UM;!b'2B(<2!
3#=H!)>=!NC@A/D!)=>?!RM!_![M!
#
V.#Discussion#
P<! 12! ?H! ->I'! <-#<! #?#<'B=2! 01((! <=H! <>! +BI(1$#<'! <-'2'! ?'#2B='?'*<2;! N-'!
I=>$'+B='2!+12$B22'+!-'='! #='!*><!<-#<! +1))1$B(<;!^(+'=4! #*#(>:! 1*2<=B?'*<2!2B$-! #2!
<-'!S,VLJ9!I>0'=!?'<'=!#='!2B1<#G('!)>=!<-'2'!?'#2B='?'*<24!#*+!#='!?>+'=#<'(H!
I=1$'+! >*! 'G#H;! P<! 12! #(2>! '#21(H! I>221G('! <>! #+#I<! #! 78/! +>*:('! 2>)<0#='! +')1*'+!
=#+1>!C8.bD!#2!<-'!PX!#?I(1)1'=!#*+!+'<'$<>=4!<->B:-!>*'! 2->B(+!$-'$%! <-'!(1*'#=1<H!
>)!<-'!='2I>*2';!!
!
P!)''(!<-#<!01<-!$#='!1<!12!I>221G('!<>!='I=>+B$1G(H!>G<#1*!<-'!3#(B'!>)!<-'!<'?I'=#<B='!
>)! <-'! @A/! 01<-1*! QM! GB<! 1<! 01((! ='FB1='! 2>?'! 1?I=>3'?'*<2;! P! $#*! 2''! <-#<!
<'?I'=#<B='!2<#G1(1O#<1>*!>)!<-'!'('$<=>*1$2!01((!I=>G#G(H!G'!*'$'22#=H;!9(2>4!<-'='!12!
#! I=>G('?! 1*! <-'! $>*)1:B=#<1>*! >)! <-'! $>(+! (>#+;! N-'='! 12! #! $-#*:'! >)! 1*+'E! >)!
=')=#$<1>*!#<! <-'!2B=)#$'! >)! <-'!(1FB1+! *1<=>:'*!#1=! 1*<'=)#$'4! 0-1$-!$#B2'2! 2<#*+1*:!
0#3'2!>)! ! djY! Jo! 1*!I>0'=! ('3'(! 1*! <-'! $#31<H;!P! #?! 'EI'=1?'*<1*:! 01<-! <1(<1*:!<-'!
.'0#=!<>!$#B2'!<-'!(1FB1+!*1<=>:'*!2B=)#$'!<>!G'!#<!#*!#*:('!<>!<-'!->=*!#*<'**#!#E12;!
N-12!#II'#=2!<>!#(('31#<'!<-'!I=>G('?!GB<!*''+2!2>?'!)B=<-'=!0>=%;!
#
VI.#References!
/'*2#+>B*4!'<!#(;4!9!a1FB1+YS'(1B?Y@>>('+!#G2>(B<'!=')'='*$'!$>(+!(>#+!)>=!(>*:Y
0#3'('*:<-!=#+1>?'<=1$!$#(1G=#<1>*4!b'31'0!>)!8$1'*<1)1$!P*2<=B?'*<24!WL4!VLKKY
VLZU!C^$<>G'=!QUUJD!!
!
/'=2#*'((1!'<!#(;4!k))'$<2!>)!9<?>2I-'=1$!k?1221>*!>*!&=>B*+Y/#2'+!A1$=>0#3'!
/#$%:=>B*+!A'#2B='?'*<24!92<=>I-H21$#(!">B=*#(4!VVZ4!ZYQW!C"B(H!QUU[D!
!
"#*22'*4!9<?>2I-'=1$!8'*21*:!GH!A1$=>0#3'!b#+1>?'<=H4!T1('H!CQUULD!
!
M>:B<4!'<!#(;4!A'#2B='?'*<!>)!<-'!N'?I'=#<B='!>)!<-'!@>2?1$!A1$=>0#3'!
/#$%:=>B*+!#<!#!X='FB'*$H!>)!K;[!&SO4!92<=>I-H21$#(!">B=*#(4!L[[4!QRJYQQL!CA#H!
QUURD!
!
M>:B<4!'<!#(;4!N-'!N'?I'=#<B='!>)!<-'!@>2?1$!A1$=>0#3'!/#$%:=>B*+!b#+1#<1>*!#<!#!
X='FB'*$H!>)!QR!&SO4!92<=>I-H21$#(!">B=*#(4!LJ[4!QYQ[!CX'G!QUZUD!
.1$%'4!N-'!A'#2B='?'*<!>)!N-'=?#(!b#+1#<1>*!#<!A1$=>0#3'!X='FB'*$1'24!b'31'0!>)!
8$1'*<1)1$!P*2<=B?'*<24!QK4!JWZYJK[!C"B(H!QUVWD!!
S#*#*H!'<!#(;4!@A/!N'('2$>I'2!#*+!^I<1$#(!8H2<'?24!I='I=1*<4!<>!#II'#=!1*!,(#*'<24!
8<#=2!#*+!8<'((#=!8H2<'?24!g>(B?'!Q4!N'('2$>I'2!#*+!P*2<=B?'*<#<1>*4!#=`13p!
QJRW;JVRJ3Q!,#:'!U!CJRQVD!
M>II'*4!S>0!<>!A'#2B='!<-'!@>2?1$!A1$=>0#3'!/#$%:=>B*+!01<-!Ng!8#<'((1<'!
kFB1I?'*<!CJRQ[D!8<'1*!#*+!X>=2<'=!2B??#=H!1*!k*:(12-;!!I>=<1#;#2<=>I-H21%;B*1Y
%1'(;+'je%>'II'*j@A/;I+)!
!A1$-'(!,1#<!#<!,#=12!.1+'=><!7*13'=21<H!-#2!G''*!'EI'=1?'*<1*:!01<-!#?#<'B=!2<H('!
'FB1I?'*<;!!
-<<Ipjj000;#I$;B*13YI#=12K;)=jeI1#<jA1$-'(q,1#<2q21<'ja'EI'=1'*$'q,T;-<?(!
8<'1*!#*+!X>=2<'=4!M>2?>(>:1'!?1<!M#*1*$-'*+=#-<!B*+!T#22'=!C@>2?>(>:H!01<-!
b#GG1<01='!#*+!T#<'=D4!8<'=*'!B*+!T'(<=#B?4!ZVYUR!C"B(H!JRRZD!