Content uploaded by Dawit Abate
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Dawit Abate on May 31, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
International Journal of Soil and Crop Sciences: Vol. 2(7): pp 073-076, October, 2014.
Copyright © 2014 Spring Journals
Full Length Research Paper
Determination of optimum seed and fertilizer rate for
fodder oat in Bale Highland Southeastern Ethiopia
Dawit Abate and Teklu Wegi
Sinana Agricultural Research Center P.O.Box 208, Bale-Robe, Ethiopia
*Corresponding Author’s: E-mail: dawit_40@yahoo.com
Accepted 11th October, 2014
The experiment was conducted from 2011 to 2012 for two years at Sinana on-station and on farms
(Selka and Agarfa) with the objective to determine optimum seed rate and fertilizer level for herbage
and grain production. The trial was carried out in factorial RCBD with three replications. Seed rates of
60, 70, 80 and 90 kg/ha were used as main plot treatments where as fertilizer rates of 0, 25kg UREA
and 50 kg DAP, 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP and 75kg UREA and 150 kg DAP were used as sub plot
treatments. DM yield, seed yield, plant height and standing percentage and leaf to stem ration were
significantly (P<0.05) varied among different seed rate and fertilizer rate combination. The DM yield of
fodder oat increased with increasing level of fertilizer. The highest value (15.0 t/ha) was obtained at
seed rate of 80kg/ha and at the higher fertilizer level. This could be due to the more competitiveness
of oats with weeds at the higher seeding rate. Moreover, these fertilizers promote vigorous plant
growth and a larger leaf area that contribute to the dry matter yield of the fodder oat. At the higher
levels of fertilizer application, the DM contents did not increase significantly. It indicated that there is
no significant difference in DM yield of fertilizer application of 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP and the
highest level which is 75kg UREA and 150 kg DAP. However, seeding rate and application of fertilizers
above optimum level often produce no additional yield increase. Moreover, higher fertilizer rates
could result in higher lodging of oats. Hence, there is no need to go for higher seed rate and fertilizer
level. The highest seed yield (44.8Q/ha) was obtained at seed rate of 70kg/ha and fertilizer rate of
50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP, while the lowest seed yield 36.8Q/ha was obtained at seed rate of
80kg/ha without fertilizer. A modest increase in seed yield occurred with an increased seeding rate up
to 70kg/ha with fertilizer level of 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP. The increasing seeding rates above
70kg/ha are more likely to reduce size and quality of seed. The highest plant height (134.2cm) was
recorded at the higher fertilizer level with seed rate of 80 and 90 kg/ha respectively. The lowest plant
height (124.3 cm) was recorded at seed rate (80kg/ha) without fertilizer application. This study also
indicated that application of fertilizer showed significantly (P<0.05) higher plant height than group
having no fertilizer. Generally, the study indicated that seeding rates and fertilizer application at
different level have an impact on yield and agronomic parameters of fodder oat. So it is found to be
very important to have the optimum seed rate and fertilizer level for producing reasonable DM and
seed yield of fodder oats. Hence, the optimum seed rate and fertilizer level to get reasonable DM yield
will be at seed rate of 80 kg/ha and at fertilizer level of 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP. While if the target
is for forage seed production, seed rate of 70kg/ha with fertilizer rate of 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP is
very optimum to farmers in order to obtain reasonable yield.
Keywords: Fodder oats, Avena sativa, Bale highland
INTRODUCTION
The use of cultivated forage crops has received
considerable attention for complementing the
conventional feed resources especially in areas where
high producing crossbred dairy cows are owned in the
Ethiopian highlands (Daniel, 1990). The very nature of
the integrated crop-livestock production systems in the
Ethiopian highlands requires multipurpose forage
species suitable for feed and food or feed and natural
resource conservation thereby to address the multi-
faceted problems of the farming community. Due to its
Int. J. Soil. Crop Sci.
short life cycle, suitability in crop rotations and better
performance on marginal lands, oats is the most
important species for integration into the existing farming
system. Oats appears to be the main forage crop grown
at very high altitudes (up to 3000 m) or on heavy soils
(vertisols) where temperate grasses such as ryegrass,
cocksfoot or tall fescue are difficult to establish
(Lulseged, 1981). The species owes its reputation to its
versatility as it can be grown for grain, hay, silage or
direct grazing and is being used as feed for dairy cattle,
young stock, sheep and hogs (Kipps, 1970; Boonman,
1993). Moreover, it has superior recovery after grazing
and is highly useful for overcoming critical periods of
feed shortage or for finishing animals for market when
permanent pastures are of poor quality (Lovett and
Scott, 1997).
As other any food crop, seed rate has to be
determined and recommended for forage crops including
oat varieties. Seeding rate had been previously
recommended for oat varieties in Ethiopian highlands
(Astatke Haile, 1979). Seeding rate can be influenced by
the type and fertility of the soil, climate, establishment
methods (condition of seed bed and seeding method)
and the like. Using higher and lower seed rate could
have a negative impact on herbage and seed yield of
forage crops.
On the other hand fertilizer use is one of the important
factors, which contribute to the yield of any crop. Most
soils very in nutrients require by the plants such as
nitrogen and phosphorous fertilizers. These conditions
vary greatly across the agro-ecological areas. The
response of fertilizer is very high in soil with very poor
soil and as the level of available soil nutrient increased
the need for fertilizer decreases. On the other hand as
stored soil moisture increases or growing season
precipitation increases, the need for additional fertilizer
increases. Fertilizer is not only contributes towards yield
and growth of forage but also quality. Higher fodder yield
with fertilizer application is due to their favorable effects
on plant water relations, light absorption, crop density,
plant height, leaf area and nutrient utilizations. The
applications of fertilizer improve the dry matter, seed
yield and quality of forage. However, the optimum rate of
fertilizer application is required to improve yields of the
crops. Hence, there is a need to determine an
appropriate level of fertilizer application especially in
soils deficient in the major macronutrients, nitrogen and
phosphorus. Therefore, this study was aimed to
determine optimum seed and fertilizer rate for fodder oat
varieties in Bale highlands.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Experimental sites
The experiment was carried out from 20011 to 2012 at
three locations via, Sinana Agricultural Research Center
(SARC), Sinana on-farm (Selka) and Agarfa of Bale
highlands. Sinana Agricultural Research Center is found
at an altitude of 2400 m.a.s.l. The mean annual rainfall is
563-1018 mm with minimum and maximum temperature
of 7.9 and 24.3°C, respectively. The other experimental
sites Selka and Agarfa were with an altitude of 2400 –
2600 m.a.s.l, respectively. The farming systems of the
area are classified as a mixed cereal-livestock
production system. The soil types of the study area are
mainly clay in texture (dark brown Vertisols) with slightly
acidic reaction (SARC, 2008). There are two distinct
seasons ‘Ganna’ (extending from March to July) and
‘Bona’ (extending from July to December) which are
allows double cropping. Bimodal rainfall condition is a
common phenomenon, especially in the study sites.
Experimental arrangement
Oat variety (Bonsa) which was recently released from
Sinana Agricultura Research Center was used for the
trial. The trial was carried in factorial RCBD with three
replications with seed rates of 60, 70, 80 and 90 kg/ha
as main plot treatments and fertilizer rates of 0, 23, 46
and 69 kg/ha of N and P2O5 as sub plot treatments.
Sowing was made by drilling the seeds in rows on 1.8 m
x 2 m plots spaced 0.5 m apart. All the plots were hand
weeded once a month after sowing and thereafter as
required based on occurrence of weeds.
Data collection
The variety was closely examined beginning from the
early vegetative growth and a reliable record such as
disease occurrence, stand percentage, plant height,
forage biomass yield, leaf to stem ratio and seed yield
was taken.
Statistical analysis
Analysis of variance was performed using the statistical
analysis system (SAS) software (SAS, 2001) in order to
determine the agronomic difference between different
level of seed and fertilizer rate and mean separation was
carried out using Least Significant different (LSD) test.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The combined statistical analysis showed that
differences in seed and fertilizer level had significant
(P<0.05) effect on considered agronomic and yield
parameters. DM yield, seed yield, plant height and
standing percentage and leave to stem ration were
significantly (P<0.05) varied among different seed rate
and fertilizer rate combination.
75. Dawit and Wegi
Table 1: Mean agronomic and yield performance of fodder oat under different seed and fertilizer rate combined over locations from 2011 to
2012
PH=Plant Height, SP= Stand Percentage, DM= Dry Matter, SY= Seed Yield, CV= Coefficient of Variation, LSD=Least Significance
Difference. Figures with the same letters in columns are not significantly different (P>0.05).
The DM yield of fodder oat increased with increasing
level of fertilizer. The highest value (15.0 t/ha) was
obtained at seed rate of 80kg/ha and at the higher
fertilizer level. This could be due to the more
competitiveness of oats with weeds at the higher
seeding rate. Moreover, these fertilizers promote
vigorous plant growth and a larger leaf area that
contribute to the dry matter yield of the fodder oat.
Similarly, the increasing trend of green forage yield in
response to increasing level of N fertilization was also
observed by many other workers (Sultana et al., 2005;
Khan et al., 1996). However, the DM yield is not
significantly differ at seed rate of 80 and 90 kg/ha. At the
higher levels of fertilizer application, the DM contents did
not increase significantly. It indicated that there is no
significant difference in DM yield of fertilizer application
of 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP and the highest level
which is 75kg UREA and 150 kg DAP. However, seeding
rate and application of fertilizer above optimum level
often produce no additional yield. Moreover, higher
fertilizer rates result in higher lodging. Hence, there is no
need to go for higher seed rate and fertilizer level.
The highest seed yield (44.8Q/ha) was obtained at
seed rate of 70kg/ha and fertilizer rate of 50kg UREA
and 100 kg DAP, while the lowest seed yield 36.8Q/ha
was obtained at seed rate of 80kg/ha without fertilizer. A
modest increase in seed yield occurred with an
increased seeding rate up to 70kg/ha with fertilizer level
of 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP. The increasing seeding
rates above 70kg/ha are more likely to reduce size and
quality of seed. The highest plant height (134.2cm) was
recorded at the higher fertilizer level with seed rate of 80
and 90 kg/ha respectively. The lowest plant height
(124.3 cm) was recorded at seed rate (80kg/ha) without
fertilizer application. Similar studies also indicated that
plant height increased with increasing seeding rate
indicating competition for light (Reddy and Reddi, 1992).
The better plant height might have contributed for better
forage yield of fodder oats. A crop provided enough of
plant nutrients to meet out its requirements is expected
to perform better than crop provided less than its
requirements. This study also indicated that application
of fertilizer showed significantly (P<0.05) higher plant
height than group having no fertilizer. Similarly, there
were significant differences with regards to standing
percentages and leaf to stem ratio among evaluated
Treatments
PH (cm)
SP (%)
leaf to stem
ratio
DM (t/ha)
SY (Q/ha)
Seed rate (kg/ha)
Fertilizer rate (kg/ha)
60
0
125.55cd
81.94bc
0.43b
11.4b
38.8ab
25kg UREA and 50 kg DAP
125.94bc
81.50bc
0.5ab
12.5 ab
39.9ab
50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP
128.78ab
80.22cd
0.53ab
12.7 ab
41.3ab
75kg UREA and 150 kg DAP
134.05a
83.39ab
0.56ab
12.7 ab
44.2a
70
0
129.50ab
82.5bcd
0.50ab
12.3 ab
38.0ab
25kg UREA and 50 kg DAP
128.67ab
81.94bc
0.53ab
12.7 ab
39.9ab
50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP
129.55ab
83.55ab
0.61ab
13.9 ab
44.8a
75kg UREA and 150 kg DAP
130.22ab
84.39ab
0.65a
13.5 ab
44.3a
80
0
124.33d
79.33d
0.60ab
12.7 ab
36.8b
25kg UREA and 50 kg DAP
131.05ab
83.72ab
0.53ab
12.9 ab
40.1ab
50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP
134.00a
84.67ab
0.6ab
14.8a
43.7ab
75kg UREA and 150 kg DAP
132.78ab
87.50a
0.63a
15.0a
44.1a
90
0
126.17bc
83.28ab
0.5ab
12.3 ab
38.5ab
25kg UREA and 50 kg DAP
128.44ab
84.55ab
0.53ab
13.7 ab
43.5ab
50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP
131.72ab
85.72ab
0.5ab
13.7 ab
43.5ab
75kg UREA and 150 kg DAP
134.22a
86.22a
0.66a
14.8a
43.9a
Mean
129.62
83.34
0.55
13.1
41.7
CV
8.25
8.53
18.2
21.17
25.6
Lsd
7.03
4.68
0.16
1.82
6.66
76. Int. J. Soil. Crop Sci.
seed and fertilizer rates. The maximum number of leaf to
stem ratio (0.65) was recorded for seed rate of 70 kg/ha
and the maximum fertilizer rate application. Even though
there are no very large differences among the different
treatments, leaf to stem ratio was increased for
treatments received fertilizer as compared to treatments
without fertilizer. This indicate that fertilizer contribute for
the increment of leaf area of fodder oats. On the other
hands, there is no significant differences in leaf to stem
ratio among the different seeding rate treatment that
received fertilizer. While, the least leaf to stem ratio was
recorded for the treatment with lower seed rate and
without fertilizer application (Table 1).
CONCLUSION
It is recognized that the level of fertilizer required
depends on the status of soil fertility, mineralization up
potential of the soil, stored soil moisture, previous
cropping and manuring history of soil. Hence, the need
for fertilizing soil is very high in a continuous cereal
cropping like Bale highlands. As observed from the
result seeding rates and addition of fertilizer at different
levels have great impact on the yield and agronomic
parameters of fodder oats. However, seeding rate and
application of fertilizer above optimum level often
produce no additional yield. Therefore, it is important to
have the optimum seed rate and fertilizer level for
producing reasonable DM and seed yield of fodder oats.
Hence, the optimum seed rate and fertilizer level to get
reasonable DM yield will be at seed rate of 80 kg/ha and
at fertilizer level of 50kg UREA and 100 kg DAP. While if
the target is for forage seed production, seed rate of
70kg/ha with fertilizer rate of 50kg UREA and 100 kg
DAP is very optimum to farmers in order to obtain
maximum forage production.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors would like to thanks the technical staff of
Animal Feeds and Nutrition Research Case Team of
Sinana Agricultural Research Center for their
involvement in data collection and compilation. The
financial support provided by Oromia Agricultural
Research Institute (OARI) is also dully acknowledged.
REFERENCES
Astatke Haile (1979). Forage Crops and Pasture Management
in the Highlands of Ethiopia. Forage and Range Bulletin No.
2: IAR (Institute of Agricultural Research), Addis Ababa,
Ethiopia.
Boonman JG (1993). East Africa’s Grasses and Fodders: Their
Ecology and Husbandry. Kluwer Academic Publisher, the
Netherlands.
Daniel Keftasa (1990). Effect of management practices on
Rhodes grass and lucerne pastures with special references
to developmental stages at cutting and associated changes
in nutritional quality. Proceedings of the first workshop on
utilization of research results on forage and agricultural by-
product materials as animal feed resources in Africa, held in
Lilongwe, Malawi, 5-9 December 1988.
Khan MJ, Shajalal M, Sarkar AR (1996). Yield, chemical
composition and nutritive value of oat (Avena sativa) fodder
at different levels of nitrogen fertilizer. Bangladesh J. Anim.
Sci., 25(1-2):109-115
Lulseged G Hiwot (1981). Summary of fodder oats research
undertaken by IAR. Pasture and fodder forage bulletin no. 2,
IAR, Addis Ababa.
Lovett JV, Scott JM (1997). Pasture production and
management. Inkata Press, Melbourne, Australia.
Kipps MS (1970). Production of field crops. Tata Mc Graw-Hill
Publishing Company Ltd., New York.
Sultana MN, Khan MJ, Khandaker ZH, Uddin MM (2005).
Effects of Rhizobium inoculum and nitrogen fertilizer on
biomass production of cowpea (Vigna unguiculata) forage at
different stages of maturity. Bangladesh J. Agri. Univ.,
3(2):249-255.