ArticlePublisher preview available

The role of patience as a decision-making heuristic in leadership

Emerald Publishing
Qualitative Research in Organizations and Management
Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to address the gap in the literature by providing a precise conceptualization of the concept of patience in the context of leadership. Design/methodology/approach The current study was conducted using a qualitative approach as it aimed to explore leaders’ perceptions and experiences with patience and eventually build a theoretical model in relation to the role of patience in leadership. Because the aim of the study was to obtain insight into the experiences of the participants in their own words, this study adopted a grounded theory research design. Findings The grounded theory study resulted in an emergent theoretical model for understanding the decision-making process of leaders who exhibit patience as a character strength and how those leaders promote organizational success. Through an inductive approach, this grounded theory study identified the behaviors that participating leaders viewed as patient, as well as the outcomes and the contextual conditions for the effectiveness of such behaviors. Research limitations/implications A major contribution of this study is that leaders epitomized by patience are guided by a decision-making framework that can contribute to more favorable decision making outcomes. Practical implications The proposed model for patience leadership has implications for developing the leadership capacity. Originality/value Patience, as a leadership quality, has been overlooked virtue in the social and psychological sciences. In order to explore the potential nexus between patience and leadership, the study has offered an emergent theoretical model and indicated the specific ways in which leaders may effectively practice patience.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
The role of patience as a
decision-making heuristic
in leadership
M.D. Haque
ADR Global Management, Los Angeles, California, USA
Lu Liu
Department of Organizational Leadership,
University of La Verne, La Verne, California, USA, and
Angela TitiAmayah
Department of Business Management and Economics,
State University of New York Empire State College, Rochester, New York, USA
Abstract
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to address the gap in the literature by providing a precise
conceptualization of the concept of patience in the context of leadership.
Design/methodology/approach The current study was conducted using a qualitative approach as it
aimed to explore leadersperceptions and experiences with patience and eventually build a theoretical model
in relation to the role of patience in leadership. Because the aim of the study was to obtain insight into the
experiences of the participants in their own words, this study adopted a grounded theory research design.
Findings The grounded theory study resulted in an emergent theoretical model for understanding the
decision-making process of leaders who exhibit patience as a character strength and how those leaders
promote organizational success. Through an inductive approach, this grounded theory study identified the
behaviors that participating leaders viewed as patient, as well as the outcomes and the contextual conditions
for the effectiveness of such behaviors.
Research limitations/implications A major contribution of this study is that leaders epitomized
by patience are guided by a decision-making framework that can contribute to more favorable decision
making outcomes.
Practical implications The proposed model for patience leadership has implications for developing the
leadership capacity.
Originality/value Patience, as a leadership quality, has been overlooked virtue in the social and
psychological sciences. In order to explore the potential nexus between patience and leadership, the study has
offered an emergent theoretical model and indicated the specific ways in which leaders may effectively
practice patience.
Keywords Leadership, Leadership and patience, Leadership decision making,
Management decision making, Patience, Patience and decision making
Paper type Research paper
Introduction
Many scholars have claimed that leadersweakness in capacity and character (Grahek
et al., 2010) as wellas poor and risky decision making (Segon and Booth, 2015) were significant
contributors to the recent global financial crisis. This prompted consideration of the
leadership development practices and in particular, the leader virtues (De Braine and Verrier,
2007; Grahek et al., 2010; Rego et al., 2010). Several scholars recognize patience as an important
leader virtue, especially in the context of decision making (Fry and Slocum, 2008; Khuntia and
Suar, 2004; Sankar, 2003). Leaderspatience in followers is part of transformational leadership
(Shamir et al., 1998), leader-member exchange theory (Graen and Uhl-Bien, 1995) servant
leadership (Covey, 2006) as well as of spiritual leadership (Fry, 2003). Peterson and Seligmans
(2004) review resulted in 24 leadership characteristics, and patience is one among them.
In the context of decision making, patience is primarily associated with correct timing
Qualitative Research in
Organizations and Management:
An International Journal
Vol. 12 No. 2, 2017
pp. 111-129
© Emerald Publishing Limited
1746-5648
DOI 10.1108/QROM-01-2015-1263
Received 1 January 2015
Revised 1 April 2016
17 September 2016
3 January 2017
Accepted 28 February 2017
The current issue and full text archive of this journal is available on Emerald Insight at:
www.emeraldinsight.com/1746-5648.htm
111
Role of
patience
... The role of patience as a decision-making heuristic in leadership has already been empirically proven [6,18,26]. Further, forgiveness has been identified as an inevitable factor in servant leadership and leader-member exchange relationships [12,19,49]. Studies on positive leadership, employee inclusion, and workplace well-being have proved the negative impact of discrimination on organizational members [1,20]. ...
Chapter
Since the non-western perspectives of ethics have not been well explored in the literature, this paper addresses this concern by explaining ethics from an ancient Indian concept of dharma. Though we consider various normative aspects of dharma from multiple conversations available in the Indian scriptures, we consider a precise narrative of dharma from Nāradaparivrājaka Upaniṣad as the fundamental reference to define dharma as a multidimensional construct. Further, we adopt a dharmic approach to highlight the significance of ethics in leadership which may significantly contribute to assuring sustainable business practices. The paper would bring in certain theoretical implications as follows. First, elucidating certain dimensions of dharma would help broaden the normative domain of ethics literature. Second, given the sustainability-engrained nature of Vedic philosophy, such a dharmic approach toward ethical leadership would further widen the construct with a novel theoretical viewpoint. Third, the acknowledgment of a specific leadership act to be ethical or unethical becomes more objective in this context with the provision of a definitional framework of dharma, narrated in this paper.
... When one focuses on the strategic role of patience in nations, it is often accompanied by civil disobedience (Lyons, 1998). The scant literature focuses on persons working in organizations, and mostly on psychological benefits to the individual not on patience as strategy (e.g., Comer & Sekerka, 2014;Haque et al., 2017). ...
Article
Full-text available
Recent years have seen a step-change in the severity and nature of threats to United States democracy, including extensive efforts by elected officials to undercut democratic governance. When elected officials undermine democracy, this constitutes "deformation of democracy." As implementors and agents of policy, public administrators can sometimes play essential roles as bulwarks against democratic deformation. However, among public administrators there is historically a strong ethos emphasizing neutral competence and subordination to political authority, in some cases reinforced by law. How should public administrators respond when confronted by deformation and, at the same time, constrained by tradition and law? We selectively review strands of public administration theory, focusing on theory especially relevant to the United States governmental system, to construct and assess a catalog of responses that public administrators can take under democratic deformation. We conclude by offering a set of recommendations focused on institutionalized collective action by public administrators.
... It is an important skill in professional nursing practice and a key competence for the nurse's quality care delivery and clinical success. Decision-making in nursing is critical for the development of effective health policies, accurate decisionmaking related to health-care services and implementation of these decisions (Akhondzadeh et al., 2007;Dorgham and Al-Mahmoud, 2013;Haque et al., 2017). The Association of American Nursing Colleges of Nursing (2008) states that decision-making is an important leadership skill in nursing education As such, it is considered that there is a relationship between leadership characteristics and decision-making abilities (Al-Dossary et al., 2014;Fulop and Mark, 2013). ...
Article
Purpose: The purpose of this study was to determine the relationship between the leadership orientations of nurses and their clinical decision-making skills. Design/methodology/approach: This descriptive study was conducted between June and December 2018 on nurses working at three hospitals in Turkey. This study was completed with 1,100 nurses. The Personal Information Form, Leadership Orientation Scale and Clinical Decision-Making Scale in Nursing were used for data collection. Findings: A significant correlation was found between the leadership orientations of nurses and age, sex, institution where they were employed, time spent in the profession, being in a management position and satisfaction with the current unit of employment (p < 0.05), and a significant correlation was found between clinical decision-making skills of nurses and age, sex and occupational status (p < 0.05). Furthermore, a significant correlation was found between the mean scores of the Leadership Orientation Scale and Clinical Decision-Making in Nursing Scale (p < 0.05). Originality/value: The development of leadership orientations of nurses positively affects their clinical decision-making skills. In this respect, it is important to instill effective leadership orientations in nurses and to incorporate novel training methods in nursing education to develop accurate and timely clinical decision-making skills.
Article
How do managers time the launch of new technologies? Without actionable frameworks to ensure consumers and other stakeholders are ready, innovation releases remain a risky endeavor. Previous work on legitimacy has focused on stages following a product launch. However, launch timing concerns shared expectations of when actions should occur prior to launch. This conceptual article evaluates the alignment between firm and stakeholder expectations regarding launch timing. It proposes that the market timing of new technology launches is structured by two dimensions: firm-led coordination and stakeholders’ willingness to change. Combining these dimensions, the authors map four types of market timing situations managers can encounter: antagonistic, synergistic, flexible, and inflexible timing. Temporal legitimacy is achieved when a firm and its key stakeholders share timing norms about the ideal moments when activities should occur in a market process. The authors conceptualize proto-markets as prefacing the well-known market legitimacy stages. This article concludes with a detailed managerial decision tree on how to create the optimal technology product launch moment and avenues of future research on market timing beyond technology launches.
Article
Full-text available
Bu araştırma özel eğitim öğretmenlerinin sabır ve iş doyumu düzeyleri arasındaki ilişkiyi tespit etmek amacıyla gerçekleştirilmiştir. Nicel araştırma yöntemlerinden ilişkisel tarama modeline göre yapılandırılan araştırmanın çalışma grubu Malatya ilinin Yeşilyurt ilçesinde basit seçkisiz yöntemle belirlenen özel eğitim okullarında görev yapan toplam 135 özel eğitim öğretmeninden oluşmaktadır. Araştırmada veri toplama aracı olarak “Öğretmen Sabır Ölçeği” ve “İş Doyumu Ölçeği” kullanılmıştır. Araştırmanın sonucunda özel eğitim öğretmenlerinin genel sabır ve öğretim boyutundaki sabır düzeylerinin “çok yüksek”, etkileşim boyutundaki sabır düzeylerinin ise “yüksek” olduğu; genel iş doyumu ve dışsal doyum boyutundaki iş doyumlarının “orta” düzeyde, içsel doyum boyutundaki iş doyumlarının ise “yüksek” düzeyde olduğu tespit edilmiştir. Araştırmada ayrıca öğretmenlerin sabır ve iş doyumu düzeyleri arasında orta düzeyde pozitif yönlü bir ilişki olduğu ve öğretmenlerin sabır düzeyleri arttıkça iş doyumlarının da arttığı sonucuna ulaşılmıştır. Araştırmadan elde edilen sonuçlar doğrultusunda öğretmenlerin sabır ve iş doyumlarını artırmaya yönelik önerilerde bulunulmuştur.
Article
Full-text available
A process perspective in research has been largely neglected, including in studies of leadership. This neglect is partly because of the dominant quantitative variance approaches to research that have been adopted in many disciplines. However, it is also because of the difficulties that researchers encounter in conceptualising and investigating their research from a process perspective. This process of conceptualisation is particularly challenging for post-graduate students. Threshold concepts are critical to student learning, providing gateways to understanding particular fields or disciplines. This paper adopts this idea of threshold concepts and relevant teaching practices to illustrate its use in post-graduate students' teaching and learning activities to develop a conceptual framework that can investigate a process. Several key topics are addressed: How conceptual frameworks are introduced and taught; Differentiating quantitative variance conceptual frameworks from qualitative process conceptual frameworks; and Explaining and illustrating how to conduct process theory in qualitative research using the case study method, grounded theory method, and critical incident technique.
Chapter
In this study, I examined the seven principles developed in Gregory’s (Leading across cultural boundaries: An analysis of 1 Corinthians 9:19-27. In Henson, J. (editor) Biblical organizational spirituality: New testament foundations for leaders and organizations (pp. 199–214). Palgrave Macmillan, 2022) and Hunt and Dobric-Veiss’ (Leadership, maturity, and unity: An analysis of Ephesians 4:1-16. In Henson, J. (editor). Biblical organizational spirituality: New testament foundations for leaders and organizations (pp. 215–234). Palgrave Macmillan, 2022) studies using the contemporary organizational leadership literature, followed by a bounded case study where the seven principles were examined using the following three research questions: How is each principle evident in the participant’s organization? What is the benefit/outcome of each principle? Why is the benefit/outcome of each principle useful for the employees’ well-being and the overall health of the organization? Four participants were either managers who practiced some or all of the six principles or employees who reported to managers who practiced some or all of the six principles. Both managers and employees could speak about the culture and climate of an organization that practiced some or all of the six principles. Each participant was asked 21 questions (7 principles times 3 research questions each). The analysis of the 84 responses (7 principles times 3 research questions each times 4 participants) yielded a total of 507 codes, which were grouped into 43 themes. Fourteen scale-development items emerged from the analysis of the responses to research question 1. The study’s findings are useful for scholarly researchers to understand the New Testament-based organizational spirituality concept. The next research step will be the development of an operationalized definition and scale development to measure the New Testament-based organizational spirituality concept. The findings should help practitioners and consultants understand what the selected seven principles contribute to the organizational culture and perceived organizational climate.
Article
Full-text available
Threshold concepts are critical to student learning, providing gateways to understanding particular fields or disciplines. This paper adopts this idea of threshold concepts and relevant teaching and assessment practices to illustrate its use in postgraduate students' teaching and learning activities when developing a conceptual framework for their research. This paper addresses several key topics, namely: (1) How conceptual frameworks are introduced and explained; (2) Differentiating quantitative variance conceptual frameworks from qualitative process conceptual frameworks; (3) Explaining and illustrating how to conduct process theory in qualitative research using the case study method, grounded theory method, and critical incident technique; and (4) Illustrating the role of formative and summative assessment as a form of scaffolding in the teaching and learning process.
Article
This paper examines the relationship between the representation of marathon runners in a fund management team and its future performance. We find that funds with a larger proportion of runner managers have a higher level of risk-adjusted excess returns. We also find that these funds have a lower level of the disposition bias, deviate more from their benchmark portfolios, hold fewer stocks in their portfolios, and hold their stocks for a longer duration. Also, they tend to hold more stocks that are about to experience desirable earnings outcomes. Overall, the results suggest that personality traits that affects achievement in other dimensions of life may translate into fund management success.
Chapter
There is a gap in the existing exegetical research for organizational leadership when it comes to the Epistle of James the brother of Jesus and cynic-turned-believer. This chapter examines James 4:13–5:12 for biblical insights into contemporary organizational leadership. The historical, social, and cultural background of the epistle of James is discussed. Then an exegetical study of the selected pericope is conducted. This exegetical study yielded the following six principles: leader humility, just compensation of workers, patience, refraining from backbiting, endurance, and integrity. The ways in which each of these principles applies to contemporary organizational leadership are then discussed.
Article
Full-text available
This study tested the proposition that deficient decision making under stress is due, to a significant extent, to the individual's failure to fulfill adequately an elementary requirement of the decision-making process, that is, the systematic consideration of all relevant alternatives. One hundred one undergraduate students (59 women and 42 men), aged 20–40, served as subjects in this experiment. They were requested to solve decision problems, using an interactive computer paradigm, while being exposed to controllable stress, uncontrollable stress, or no stress at all. There was no time constraint for the performance of the task. The controllability of the stressor was found to have no effect on the participants' performance. However, those who were exposed to either controllable or uncontrollable stress showed a significantly stronger tendency to offer solutions before all available alternatives had been considered and to scan their alternatives in a nonsystematic fashion than did participants who were not exposed to stress. In addition, patterns of alternative scanning were found to be correlated with the correctness of solutions to decision problems.
Article
Full-text available
Despite research showing that mergers and acquisitions rarely provide significant shareholder value, there is no sign of any slowing in the trend toward M&A. One of the major reasons why M&A tend, to fail, argue the authors, is that the process often puts extreme stress on senior management teams. By nature, the process is an adversarial one, with management on both sides advocating for their stakeholders. When the dust clears at the end of the process, management is left, as the authors say, "to navigate the challenging segue from 'tough negotiator' to 'trusted colleague.'" The authors draw on the experience of Hewlett-Packard, Cisco, General Electric and Adobe to propose six guidelines for improving relations between the senior management teams of both sides of the M&A equation. The first three guidelines should be undertaken as soon as possible in the integration process. The authors advise that you can reduce the defection of talented personnel by reducing role ambiguity as quickly as possible. They also urge due diligence about the talent you are acquiring as early in the process as possible, and preferably before the deal is finished. Third, they recommend allowing some "habits to die hard." Employees often rely on habits and long-standing procedures to remain comfortable, and many of them are what made the company successful in the first place. As the integration process continues, there are three more important guidelines to follow. First, acquirers should not tolerate "bad behavior" that can sabotage the integration process. Second, it is important to have patience with the new management team, as many of them will be in unfamiliar roles. Finally, the authors suggest that it is important to remember to celebrate the value of the deal for all involved. By trumpeting the value of the new team, you can increase communication and trust. Ultimately, this trust may lead to increased shareholder value for all involved.
Chapter
The Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) is a problem solving framework. It is a systematic procedure for representing the elements of any problem. It organizes the basic rationality by breaking down a problem into its smaller constituent parts and then calls for only simple pairwise comparison judgments, to develop priorities in each hierarchy.