ArticlePDF Available

Shelf-life monitoring of food using time-temperature indicators (TTI) for application in intelligent packaging

Authors:
  • Poznań University of Economics and Business

Abstract and Figures

Shelf-life of products, their safety and quality is strictly dependent on storage time and temperature especially when fresh and minimally-processed food is concerned. The paper presents issues concerning food products deterioration due to temperature abuse in the distribution chain and possibilities of monitoring them using time-temperature indicators (TTIs). Biegańska focuses mainly on fresh or minimally-processed chilled and frozen food products and different TTIs for monitoring their shelf-life. The paper also shows the studies on the 3M Monitor MarkTM responses/colour changes under different temperature conditions and on different packaging materials (cardboard, polystyrene trays).
Content may be subject to copyright.
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
75
Marta BIEGAŃSKA
Poznań University of Economics and Business
Faculty of Commodity Science
Department of Commodity Science and Ecology of Industrial
Products
Shelf-life monitoring
of food using
time-temperature
indicators (TTI)
for application in
intelligent packaging
Key words: food safety, shelf-life, TTI, distribution chain,
food quality monitoring
Słowa kluczowe: bezpieczeństwo żywności, okres trwałości produk-
tu, wskaźniki TTI, łańcuch dostaw, monitorowa-
nie jakości żywności.
1. Introduction
Globalization and growing international food trade
present a major quality and safety problem. These
globalized food chains are a challenge for food
monitoring and control. Within them temperature
control plays one of key factors in maintenance of food
quality and safety. The concept of supply chain
management especially in the field of perishable
products (e.g. food, beverage and pharmaceuticals) is
challenging, because of their short shelf life and a
number of strict requirements. Improper storage
conditions in the distribution chain regarding
temperature not only lead to shelf life reduction, but
also significant economic losses [1]. Temperature abuse
can occur at any point in the distribution chain, such as
loading and unloading of products, temperature
conditions in walk-in-coolers or
even during transport to
consumer's home [2]. The reason
for this is that the distribution
chain rarely has the facilities to
store each commodity under its
optimal conditions. Fresh or
ready-to eat (RTE) vegetables,
cheeses etc. that require different
storing temperatures are stored in
walk-in-coolers, cooled food
displays or mixed produce freight
containers that are adjusted to a
specific temperature (too low or
to high for some of the stored
products) sometimes greater or
equal to 9oC [3-5].
The use of intelligent
packaging e.g. time-temperature
indicators (TTIs) could lead to
introduction of an effective system
for monitoring the temperature
conditions of individual products
along the distribution chain and to
showing their remaining shelf life
not only 'use by date'. Such system
would go in line with already
existing Hazard Analysis Critical
Control Point method (HACCP)
and Good Manufacturing and
Hygiene Practices as monitoring
of critical control points may be
achieved by using TTI labels/tags.
The TTI tag should then be
selected or pre-adjusted so that the
activation energy required to
produce a colour change is similar
to that required to initiate
significant deterioration in the
food being monitored.
The use of TTI tags would
enable indication of problem
areas in the distribution system
and allow their resolving. It
would also help in facilitating the
scheduling of products distribution
so that the products approaching
the end of their shelf life are
moved first at the warehouse and
in the retail system. This approach
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
76
would not often go in line with currently practiced policy first-in first-out (FIFO), that makes
the products that came to the warehouse first move out of the warehouse first as well, not
taking into account the real condition, quality and remaining shelf-life of stored products
[1, 2, 6].
2. Time-temperature (TTI) technologies
Time-temperature indicators or integrators (both names can be found in the literature) are
devices or tags that can show an accumulated time-temperature distribution function. The
TTIs are based mainly on three systems: mechanical, chemical or enzymatic that change
irreversibly starting from the time of their activation. Their response is visible through
a mechanical deformation, colour movement or colour change [1, 2, 5-14]. The rate of that
visible/measurable change is temperature dependent and it increases at higher temperatures. In
order for a TTI to be reliable it's necessary that the temperature dependence of its response is
similar to that of the food quality loss. Moreover, the TTIs end point should coincide with the
end of product's shelf life [5, 15].
In the last decades there have been many studies on developing new and efficient TTIs.
However, only several of them got to be patented and commercialized and some reached
a prototype stage. An example of probably the one remaining on the market for the longest
time is a 3M Monitor Mark TM (St. Paul, MN, USA). It has achieved one of the first significant
applications of TTIs since it was used by the World Health Organization (WHO) for
monitoring of refrigerated vaccine shipments. Monitor MarkTM is based on diffusion of
patented polymer materials [1, 5, 6]. With increasing temperature above the threshold of the
specific TTI a blue dyed fatty acid ester diffuses through a porous wick (made from a high
quality blotting paper), thus giving a measurable response similar to reading a thermometer.
This indicator also requires activation, in this case by adhesion of the two materials. Before
use Monitor MarkTM can be stored for a long period at ambient temperature [2, 5, 6, 9, 12].
However, before activation it should be conditioned for at least two hours at the same
temperature as the product is stored at.
a) b)
Fig. 1. Example of the CheckPoint® label where a) has a green dot signalling the product is OK to use and
b) where the dot is red meaning do not use
Rys. 1. Przykład etykiety CheckPoint® a) zielone wnętrze koła (tzw. kropka) sygnalizuje, że produkt jest zdatny do
spożycia, b) kropka jest czerwona, co oznacza, że produkt nie nadaje się do spożycia
Source/Źródło: a) http://vitsab.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/Why-TTI_2.jpg
b) http://vitsab.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/12/Endpoint.jpg.
The first enzymatic indicator I-Point Time Temperature Monitor, was later succeeded by
the VITSAB CheckPoint® Time Temperature Indicator (Limhamn, Sweden) shown in Figure
1. It was based on a colour change occurring from controlled enzymatic hydrolysis of a lipid
substrate (pH decrease). It comes in a variety of response lives and temperature dependencies
which are the effect of using different combinations of enzyme-substrate concentrations. It
requires activation that occurs through mechanical breaking of a separating barrier inside the
TTI which causes mixing of the enzyme and substrate. Hydrolysis of the substrate causes acid
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
77
release, and the pH drop induces a colour change of a pH indicator from deep green to bright
yellow to orange red [1, 2, 6, 12]. In order to maintain long shelf life of these TTIs, they need
to be kept chilled before activation [5].
Moreover, the Lifelines Freshness Monitor® and Fresh-Check® TTI (Morris Plains, NJ,
USA) are examples of chemical systems, as they are based on a solid state polymerization
reaction that results in a highly coloured polymer; the response of this TTI is a colour change
measured as a decrease in reflectance. The Fresh-Check® is based on the property of
disubstituted diacetylene crystals to polymerize through a lattice-controlled solid-state reaction
resulting in a highly coloured polymer. The colour of the active centre of the TTI label has to
be compared with the reference colour of a surrounding ring. These indicators are active from
the time of their production and in order to significantly slow down their response prior
application, they need to be stored at deep frozen temperatures [1, 2, 5, 6, 12].
Another commercially available TTI is the Ciba OnVuTM (SW) shown in Figure 2. It's also
based on a solid-state reaction, but in this case in a crystal phase. Photosensitive compounds
(e.g. benzylpyridines) are excited and coloured by exposure to low wavelength light. The
coloured state (dark blue) is reversible and goes back to its initial colourless state at a
temperature-dependent rate. The temperature sensitivity and response lives can be set by
controlling the type of photochromic compound and the time of light exposure during
activation. The OnVuTM TTI can take the form of a photosensitive ink and thus gives a wide
range of applications [1, 5, 6, 12]. It is one of the leading TTIs as it can be easily activated at
the point of application by exposure to UV light from a special activator supplied by the
manufacturer. It can be printed directly onto packaging in a cost-effective manner [15].
Fig. 2. Example of an OnVuTM TTI label
Rys. 2. Przykład etykiety OnVuTM na której ciemny punkt w środku okręgu wskazuje, że produkt jest świeży,
a zgodnie z jaśniejącymi polami u dołu rysunku, gry zmieni barwę na jasnoszarą jest już nieświeży
Source/ Źródło: http://freshpoint-tti.com.keam.co.il/_userfiles/labels/OnVu1.gif.
Worth mentioning is also the (eO)® TTI (Gentilly, France) which is based on a pH change
that is expressed as colour change from green to red using suitable pH indicators. The colour
change is continuous an can be perceived through visual recognition or measured
instrumentally. The latter allows its application in shelf life management schemes. This pH
change is obtained through a controlled microbial growth in a gel. The response lives and
threshold temperatures are adjusted for select microorganisms by appropriate variations in the
gel composition. The manufacturer of the (eO)® claims that it mimics microbial spoilage of
the monitored products, because its response is based on the growth characteristics of similar
microorganisms (select patented strains of Carbonbacterium piscicola, Lactobacillus
fuchuenis, Leuconostoc mesenteroides) [6, 12]. Before use the (eO)® needs to be stored frozen
to prevent the bacterial growth and activation is simply by defrosting them at room
temperature for a few minutes [5].
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
78
The TT SensorTM (USA) is another example of a diffusion-reaction concept. In this TTI
diffusion of a polar compound between two polymer layers occurs and the change of its
concentration results in a colour change of a fluorescent indicator from yellow to bright pink
[6]. The TTI can be stored in an inactive form. It comes as two separate components: an
indicator label and a transparent activator overlay. To activate the sensor the two layers are
brought together automatically by a dual-spindle applicator. Unlike some TTIs this one doesn't
require refrigeration before application, comes at different sensitivities and offers a six-month
shelf life [15].
A recently available full-history TTI is Keep-it® (Oslo, Norway). It is shown in Figure 3
and is primarily based on a chemical reaction between an immobilized reactant (e.g. Fe3+) and
a mobile reactant (i.e. ferrocyanide) that initially are in separate compartments separated by
a sealing. Once the sealing is removed (activation) the reaction begins mobile reactant in
a time-temperature dependent way is brought into contact with the immobilized one resulting
in a visual reaction signal [5].
Fig. 3. Example of the Keep-it® shelf life indicator in which the dark blue rod moves to the left-hand side with
time and temperature showing the remaining days of products shelf life
Rys. 3. Przykład wskaźnika Keep-it®, w którym granatowe zabarwienie pręcika z upływem czasu oraz dodatkowo
przy zmianach temperatury przesuwa się w lewo wskazując ilość pozostałych dni do spożycia produktu
Source/Źródło: keep-it.com.
2.1. Commercial applications of TTIs
In order to give a better view of where TTIs can and are used here are some market
examples. Fresh-Check® is being used on vaccines supplied to the UNICEF Children's
Vaccine Campaigns worldwide (e.g. measles). Moreover, it is used on food products by
Monoprix retail chain (France) on several of their own label perishable products, Carrefour
retail chain uses this TTI on packed fruit and salads sold via e-shopping. They are also present
on Milco® dairy and juice products.
The (eO)® TTI has its application also by Monoprix, but on packed fresh pork. It is also
used by LECLERC in Bretagne on ”Marque Repère” and fresh packed sandwiches by
Auchan, Coran and Elior.
The CheckPoint® is applied to vacuum- or modified atmosphere (MA) packed fresh
seafood imported to the U.S. by several importing companies. The import of these products is
covered by FDA's Import Alert #16-125. Such products are placed on detention unless
importers are on the Green List. To qualify to the list, manufacturers, shippers, or importers
have to provide the information to FDA to establish that controls are in place to prevent C.
botulinum toxin formation or provide a visual indication of a potential problem. The L5-8
CheckPoint® TTI response conforms to these requirements.
CheckPoint® Flight label 1 based on B7-24 label, on the other hand, is a flight label used
on board British Airways flights for monitoring temperature for proper handling of served
meals.
The OnVuTM is used on all packages of Kneuss fresh chicken produced and distributed by
Ernst Kneuss Geflügel A.G. (Switzerland) [6].
The Keep-it® is used by a Norwegian retail chain Rema 1000, an e-shop Kolonial.no, but
also by Oslo Universitetssykehus (hospital), Gilde, Nortura and Stange (meat and meat
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
79
products manufacturers), Godehav and Salmar (fish and fish products manufacturers)
[keep-it.com].
3. Legal aspects of TTIs as intelligent packaging
Examples of intelligent packaging, ones having the ability to communicate information
about the requirements known to ensure product quality like time-temperature history are
TTIs. Such packaging technology is already implemented in the United States, Japan and
Australia. However, legislative restrictions in the EU have delayed its development and
implementation. The reason for this is among other things the differences in approach in
regulations for food contact materials. In Europe it's based on the theory that all materials
should be explicitly cleared and publicized in regulations and that all clearances must be based
on toxicological evaluations of the listed substances. On the other hand in the U.S. substances
in the TTI should not cause any toxicological concern due to minimal dietary exposure, based
on analytical chemistry data and extrapolations. The U.S. regulations for those food contact
materials that are considered to be ”food additives” are under the Federal Food, Drug, and
Cosmetics Act. As long as any substance in the intelligent packaging system isn't intended to
be added to the food or to have a technical effect in the food, there are no special regulations
in place for food contact materials. Whereas in the EU the regulations are more detailed. For
example, Regulation 1935/2004/EC states that materials or articles should be manufactured
according to good manufacturing practice (GMP). They also shouldn't transfer their
constituents to food in quantities sufficient to cause a danger to human health, and shouldn't
cause unacceptable change in food composition or cause deterioration of the organoleptic
characteristics.
Another EU regulation gives additional specific requirements in this area. Regulation
450/2009/EC states that only substances that are legally included in an EU list should be used
in active and intelligent components. The substances can be put in a separate container or be
directly incorporated into the packaging material. If they are not positioned on the outer
surface of the package or if there isn't a barrier made from food contact material preventing
the migration of substances into the food, then they are subject to requiring legal permission
[9, 10].
4. Experimental
4.1. Materials
The 3M Monitor MarkTM indicators (9860B: threshold 5oC and 9860C: threshold 10oC,
both with response time of 48h) were used to evaluate the TTIs' responses at dynamic
temperature conditions (simulating temperature abuse). The second part of the experiment
involved the packaging material effect on the TTIs' responses. This was designed to show
whether their response was or wasn't dependent on the type of packaging material to which
they were attached to.
4.2. Methods
Both MonitorMarkTM TTIs were preconditioned at room temperature (25oC) and placed on
a polystyrene (PS) tray used for food packaging or on a cardboard (CB) box used as
a secondary packaging as shown in Figure 4. Three TTIs of each threshold (9860B: threshold
5oC B5 and 9860C: threshold 10oC C10) were used at each packaging material (PS, CB).
They were first stored at room temperature for 2.5 h, then placed in a laboratory coldbox
set to 4oC ± 1 for 21.5h and finally after 24h from activation placed again at room temperature
for the next 40h to reach their end points.
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
80
The responses of the investigated TTIs were measured using a slide caliper. Each time the
distance from the starting point of the TTI's window to the front of the blue colour visible on
the indicator were measured. Measurements were taken at different time intervals. The blue
dyes movement in each TTI attached to the PS or the CB surface was measured three times.
5. Results
Figure 4 shows the visual response of the investigated MonitorMarkTM TTIs. As one can
see the movement of the blue dyed fatty acid was clearly visible and the length of the blue
colour could be measured easily. This movement also confirms that above threshold
temperatures for both B5 (bottom three labels) and C10 (top three labels) TTIs the diffusion
occurred giving the sensors response. Although, stored at the same temperature the distances
of the blue dye colour movement in B5 and C10 were slightly different. These responses
varied even within the same type of TTI.
As shown in Figure 5 and 6 the packaging material to which the TTIs were attached didn't
have any effect on the investigated Monitor MarkTM indicators responses. The measured
lengths of the blue colour were almost the same independently from the packaging material,
on which they were placed, in the B5 and C10 indicators respectively. This leads to the
conclusion that the effect of the packaging material used in the experiment has little or no
effect on the TTIs performance and can be neglected.
a) b)
Fig. 4. The visual response of the MonitorMarkTM TTIs B5 and C10 showing movement of the blue dyed fatty
acid ester when subjected to room temperature (25oC) much above the thresholds of the indicators. In
a) sensors placed on cardboard box (CB) and b) placed on a PS tray.
Rys. 4. Wizualna odpowiedź wskaźników MonitorMarkTM B5 i C10 przedstawiająca dyfuzję estru kwasu tłuszczo-
wego zabarwionego na niebiesko, przechowywanych w temperaturze pokojowej (25oC) znacznie powyżej
temperatur progowych wskaźników. Na a) widoczne są wskaźniki umieszczone na pudle tekturowym, a na b)
umieszczone na polistyrenowej tacce
Source/Źródło: Own picture.
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
81
Moreover, these two Figures (5 and 6) show that after designed 48h of response time both
B5 and C10 didn't reach their end points. Furthermore, when stored at 4oC (below threshold of
B5 and C10) the rate of the diffusion dropped in the case of C10, whereas the blue colour
movement was still visible in the B5 indicators.
Fig. 5. The length of the blue dye movement in B5 TTIs at different temperature conditions in time and at two
packaging materials (CB and PS)
Rys. 5. Długość niebieskiego zabarwienia wskaźników B5 w różnych temperaturach i po określonym czasie,
umieszczonych na dwóch materiałach opakowaniowych (CB i PS)
Source/Źródło: Own work.
Fig, 6. The length of the blue dye movement in C10 TTIs at different temperature conditions in time and at
two packaging materials (CB and PS)
Rys. 6. Długość niebieskiego zabarwienia wskaźników C10 w różnych temperaturach i po określonym czasie,
umieszczonych na dwóch materiałach opakowaniowych (CB i PS)
Source/Źródło: Own work.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65
B5/ CB
B5/ PS
The lenght of the colour movement
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65
Time [h]
C10/ CB
C10/ PS
The lenght of the colour movement
in the TTI in cm
Time [h]
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
82
Fig. 7. The length of the blue dye movement in B5 and C10 TTIs at different temperature conditions in time
placed on CB
Rys. 7. Długość niebieskiego zabarwienia wskaźników B5 i C10 w różnych temperaturach i po określonym czasie,
umieszczonych na CB
Source/Źródło: Own work.
Fig. 8. The length of the blue dye movement in B5 and C10 TTIs at different temperature conditions in time
placed on PS
Rys. 8. Długość niebieskiego zabarwienia wskaźników B5 i C10 w różnych temperaturach i po określonym czasie,
umieszczonych na PS
Source/Źródło: Own work.
The graph for B5 indicators was linear and for C10 showed a lag phase when stored below
threshold temperature. This is rather alarming, especially when we take into account that B5
indicator can be used for perishable food products monitoring, that need to be stored at
temperatures below 5oC. This shows that even below or even to threshold temperature B5
indicators gave visual response (diffusion occurred). This however, needs further research in
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65
Time [h]
B5/ CB
C10/ CB
The lenght of the colour movement
in the TTI in cm
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65
Time [h]
B5/ PS
C10/ PS
The lenght of the colour movement
in the TTI in cm
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
83
order to confirm this kind of sensors' behaviour close to threshold temperature leading to false
indications of the time-temperature history.
Figures 7 and 8 show the investigated TTIs' visual responses at cardboard box and PS tray,
respectively. It is noticeable that in the case of both packaging materials the rate of blue dyed
fatty acid was greater in case of C10 indicator. The responses of B5 and C10 were similar
within first 30 hours of the experiment both on CB and PS. After which C10 sensor showed
faster blue dye movement compared to B5. This is surprising, as from the 24th hour of the
experiment they were both store at room temperature. It was expected that the rate of
coloration in B5 should be greater than in C10, due to different temperature thresholds.
According to the performance of the investigated TTIs the rate of the diffusion is greater
with increasing temperature above threshold, because the reaction is temperature dependent.
In this case the higher the storing temperature the faster dye diffusion. As the temperature
difference between the storage and the threshold temperature was greater for B5 than for C10,
the blue dye movement in B5 should be faster. Obtained result however, showed that it was
faster for C10.
6. Conclusions
In this work two MonitorMarkTM TTIs were evaluated under dynamic temperature
conditions (simulating temperature abuse) and the effect of packaging material, to which
indicators were attached to, on their responses was investigated. The type of packaging
material had little or no effect on the TTIs responses. This suggests that both TTIs, cardboard
box, and PS tray had close or even same temperatures throughout the experiment and no
cooling or heating of the TTI by the packaging materials took place.
More interesting were the results showing movement of the blue dye in B5 indicator and a
lag phase in C10 when stored below threshold temperature. Besides, both TTIs reached their
end points long after designed 48h. Also the diffusion rate of the dye in B5 was higher than in
C10 when stored above threshold (room temperature) after 30h of the experiment (around 6h
after removing from coldbox). This could lead to misleading or even false readings of the B5
TTI (9860B: threshold 5oC, response time 48h) in real applications, however due to limited
number of samples and only two storing temperatures, this requires further research.
The problem of food waste due to its quality deterioration is not only the problem within
the distribution chain but also, and perhaps most importantly, because of inappropriate storing
conditions at the consumer level. Europeans and North Americans produce around 95-115 kg
of food waste annually per capita. This accounts to more than one-third of the food production
in these countries. The problem lies in the lack of basic knowledge of where in the refrigerator
should different food be placed, which products can be frozen or even what temperature
should the refrigerator be set to [5, 16]. Application of TTIs would not only facilitate the cold
chain management, but would also provide consumers with information on food products'
remaining shelf life leading to food waste reduction.
7. References
[1] Eden M., Raab V., Kreyenschmidt, Hafliðason T., Olafsdóttir G., Bogason S.G. (2011)
Continuous temperature monitoring along the chilled food supply chain. In: Food Chain
Integrity. A Holistic Approach to Food Traceability, Safety, Quality and Authenticity,
115-129. Woodhead Publishing Ltd.
[2] Fu B., Labuza T.P. (1992) Considerations for the application of time-temperature
integrators in food distribution. Journal of Food Distribution Research, 23 (1), 9-17.
[3] Kou L., Luo Y., Park E., Turner E.R., Barczak A., Jurick II W.M. (2014) Temperature
abuse timing affects the rate of quality deterioration of commercially packaged ready-to-
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
84
eat baby spinach. Part I: Sensory analysis and selected quality attributes". Postharvest
Biology and Technology, 91, 96-103.
[4] Badia-Melis R., Mc Carthy U., Uysal I. (2016) Data estimation methods for predicting
temperatures of fruit in refrigerated containers. Biosystems Engineering, 151, 261-272.
[5] Koutsoumanis K.P., Gougouli M. (2015) Use of Time temperature integrators in food
safety management. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 43, 236-244.
[6] Taoukis P.S. (2010) Commercialization of time-temperature integrators for foods, [in:]
Case studies in novel food processing technologies. Innovations in Processing,
Packaging, and Predictive Modelling, 351-366. Woodhead Publishing Ltd.
[7] Pereira Jr. V.A., Queiroz de Arruda I.Z., Stefani R. (2015) Active chitosan/PVA films
with anthocyanins from Brassica oleraceae (Red Cabbage) as Time-Temperature Indica-
tors for application in intelligent food packaging. Food Hydrocolloids, 43, 180-188.
[8] Kim K., Kim E., Lee S.J. (2012) New enzymatic time-temperature integrator (TTI) that
uses laccase. Journal of Food Engineering, 113, 118123.
[9] Lee S.J., Rahman A.T.M.M. (2014) Intelligent packaging for food products. [in:]
Innovations in Food Packaging, 171-209. Elsevier Ltd.
[10] Ghaani M., Cozzolino C.A., Castelli G., Farris S. (2016) An overview of the intelligent
packaging technologies in the food sector. Trends in Food Science & Technology, 51,
1-11.
[11] Park H.R., Kim K., Lee S.J. (2013) Adjustment of Arrhenius activation energy of
laccase-based time-temperature integrator (TTI) using sodium azide. Food Control, 32
(2), 615620.
[12] Ellouze M., Augustin J-C. (2010) Applicability of biological time temperature integrators
as quality and safety indicators for meat products. International Journal of Food
Microbiology, 138, 119129.
[13] Brizio A.P.D.R., Prentice C. (2015) Development of an intelligent enzyme indicator for
dynamic monitoring of the shelf-life of food products. Innovative Food Science and
Emerging Technologies, 30, 208-217.
[14] Yam K.L. (2012) Intelligent packaging to enhance food safety and quality, [in:] Emer-
ging Food Packaging Technologies. Principles and Practice, pp. 137-152. Woodhead
Publishing Ltd.
[15] Sharrock K.R. (2012) Advances in freshness and safety indicators in food and beverage
packaging. [in:] Emerging Food Packaging Technologies. Principles and Practice,
pp. 175-197. Woodhead Publishing Ltd.
[16] Masson M. Delarue J., Blumenthal D. (2017) An observational study of refrigerator food
storage by consumers in controlled conditions. Food Quality and Preference, 56,
294-300.
Summary
Shelf-life of products, their safety and quality is strictly dependent on storage time
and temperature especially when fresh and minimally-processed food is concerned. The paper
presents issues concerning food products deterioration due to temperature abuse in the
distribution chain and possibilities of monitoring them using time-temperature indicators
(TTIs). It focuses mainly on fresh or minimally-processed chilled and frozen food products
and different TTIs for monitoring their shelf-life. It also gives commercial examples of TTIs
applications and mentions legal regulation regarding active packaging. The paper also shows
the studies on the 3M Monitor MarkTM responses/colour changes under different temperature
conditions and on different packaging materials (cardboard, polystyrene trays).
TOWAROZNAWCZE PROBLEMY JAKOŚCI 2(51)/2017
85
Marta BIEGAŃSKA
Uniwersytet Ekonomiczny w Poznaniu, Wydział Towaroznawstwa,
Katedra Towaroznawstwa i Ekologii Produktów Przemysłowych
MONITOROWANIE OKRESU TRWAŁOŚCI ŻYWNOŚCI Z WYKORZYSTANIEM
WSKAŹNIKÓW CZASU I TEMPERATURY (TTI) DO ZASTOSOWANIA
W OPAKOWANIACH INTELIGENTNYCH
Streszczenie
Okresy trwałości produktów, ich bezpieczeństwo oraz jakość w dużej mierze uzależnione
są od czasu i temperatury przechowywania, zwłaszcza w przypadku świeżej i minimalnie
przetworzonej żywności. Artykuł porusza kwestie związane z pogorszeniem jakości żywności
wynikającej z nieprawidłowości w reżimie temperaturowym w łańcuchu dostaw, a także moż-
liwego ich monitorowania przy wykorzystaniu wskaźników czasu i temperatury (TTI). Praca
skupia się głównie na wskaźnikach TTI zastosowanych do monitorowania okresu trwałości
świeżych i minimalnie przetworzonych produktów przechowywanych w warunkach chłodni-
czych oraz mroźniczych.
W pracy znalazły się także przykłady komercyjnych zastosowań wskaźników TTI oraz
wspomniano o regulacjach prawnych dotyczących opakowań inteligentnych. Artykuł prezen-
tuje ponadto wyniki badań wizualnych zmian odpowiedzi/zabarwienia wskaźników Monitor
MarkTM (3M) w różnych warunkach temperaturowych oraz na różnych materiałach opakowa-
niowych (tektura, tacki polistyrenowe).
dr inż. Marta BIEGAŃSKA
Poznań University of Economics and Business
Faculty of Commodity Science
Department of Commodity Science and Ecology of
Industrial Products
al. Niepodległości 10, 61-875 Poznań, Poland
e-mail: marta.bieganska@ue.poznan.pl
... The Keep-it TTI is used by a Norwegian retail chain Rema 1000, an e-shop Kolonial.no, but also by Oslo Universitetssykehus (hospital), Gilde, Nortura, and Stange (meat and meat products manufacturers) (Biegańska, 2017). Moreover, TTIs can also be used for evaluating the sterilization and pasteurization process (Ahmed et al., 2018). ...
... The Green list includes manufacturers, shippers, and importers. The L5-8 CheckPoint TTI response conforms to these requirements (Taoukis, 2010;Biegańska, 2017). Another Vitsab TTI (Fresh Check) was applied to turbot quality monitoring; in the study, five kinds of bacteria were investigated (ones that are related to turbot freshness), and among them, Pseudomonas spp. was confirmed to show the fastest growth. ...
... Whereas, the reliability of a photochromic TTI OnVu by Freshpoint (Switzerland) was evaluated to ensure the marketing of Cobia (Rachycentron canadum) (Gao et al., 2020). Godehav and Salmar (Norwegian fish and fish products manufacturers) use Keep-it TTI for monitoring the remaining shelf life of their products (Biegańska, 2017). Lidl Finland uses Tempix TTIs for securing the cold chain of their fresh fish brand ISOKARI (Lidl Finland, 2020). ...
Chapter
Consumer demand for dairy products has changed significantly in recent years. Globalization, urbanization, and changing lifestyles with increasing number of consumers with higher incomes in developing countries keep pushing demand for innovative dairy products. The current trend observed on the dairy market regarding healthy products forces producers to increase the variety of premium and specialty products. Consumers are more aware nowadays of health benefits of dairy products and require controlled quality, convenience (e.g., on-the-go dairy), extended shelf life, and eco-friendly products. To meet these growing requirements, manufacturers are introducing product innovations to the market, as well as modern packaging. Beside the typical packaging functions like protection, containment, communication, marketing, and ergonomics novel packaging should also have an active role. As dairy products are highly perishable, they require proper packaging in order to protect and prolong shelf life of the product inside. Among different types of packaging, active and intelligent packaging is a powerful tool, alongside with novel packaging materials (e.g., paper-based, bioplastics). Moreover, novel packaging can be a tool for detecting food fraud, but also facilitates traceability. This review will cover potential use of smart packaging with indicators (e.g., gas/integrity, freshness, time-temperature), antimicrobial coatings, data carriers, sensors in dairy packaging.KeywordsDairy productsShelf lifeSmart packagingActive packagingIntelligent packagingData carriersSensors
... The Keep-it TTI is used by a Norwegian retail chain Rema 1000, an e-shop Kolonial.no, but also by Oslo Universitetssykehus (hospital), Gilde, Nortura, and Stange (meat and meat products manufacturers) (Biegańska, 2017). Moreover, TTIs can also be used for evaluating the sterilization and pasteurization process . ...
... The Green list includes manufacturers, shippers, and importers. The L5-8 CheckPoint TTI response conforms to these requirements (Taoukis, 2010;Biegańska, 2017). Another Vitsab TTI (Fresh Check) was applied to turbot quality monitoring; in the study, five kinds of bacteria were investigated (ones that are related to turbot freshness), and among them, Pseudomonas spp. was confirmed to show the fastest growth. ...
... Whereas, the reliability of a photochromic TTI OnVu by Freshpoint (Switzerland) was evaluated to ensure the marketing of Cobia (Rachycentron canadum) (Gao et al., 2020). Godehav and Salmar (Norwegian fish and fish products manufacturers) use Keep-it TTI for monitoring the remaining shelf life of their products (Biegańska, 2017). Lidl Finland uses Tempix TTIs for securing the cold chain of their fresh fish brand ISOKARI (Lidl Finland, 2020). ...
Chapter
Cold plasma is an emerging technology that has attracted the attention of scientists in recent years as a potential alternative to chemical and thermal disinfection of food and other temperature-sensitive products. It is a chemical-free, water-free, and environmentally friendly technique, which works at room temperature and short processing times, thus minimizing the undesirable thermal effects on food. This chapter presents the fundamentals, process parameters, equipment, the microbial inactivation mechanisms, and the intrinsic factors related to microorganisms and foods subjected to the treatment. An overview of recent research on the effects of cold plasma on food quality from a microbiological, physicochemical, sensory, and toxicological perspective is also addressed, as well as the advantages, disadvantages, the regulatory context, and the scale-up challenges.
... To reduce this unintentional product waste, so-called intelligent packaging concepts could be utilized. But this is not the only advantage these technologies provoke ( Year Development References 1500 BC Ancient Egyptians developed glass water pots for stored food/water [5] 1800 Paperboard was first used to manufacture folding cartons [6] 1962 First commercially available Time-Temperature Indicators (TTI) by Honeywell Corporation [7] 2012 Wheat Flour Milling Traceability System (WFMTS) incorporating 2D barcode and radio frequency identification technology [8] ...
Article
Full-text available
Today's consumer wants healthy and nutritious food products which could be preserved, convenient, easy to serve and free from microbial contamination. Packaging is an indispensable vehicle to deliver product to the consumer. In today's era of convenience based food products, a need for an overall packaging system is highly felt. Intelligent packaging is beneficial to communicate the content and status of packaged food to the consumer. This has the potential to be one of the greatest achievements in the field of food science and technology as this system can work efficiently to reduce the waste and shortage of the food supply. This study presents the importance of intelligent packaging, various tools which help to make convenient and communicate the products to the consumer and application of IP technology.
... The TTI reveals when refrigeration of perishable foodstuffs has been disrupted, and thus the shelf-life date rendered invalid, or serves directly as an indicator of shelf-life. The technology depended on solid-state SP photochromism [103] although an alternative system reliant on photochromic crystals of benzylpyridine derivative was also explored [104]. Immediately before use, the photochromic ink of the TTI label is activated by UV from LEDs to ring-open the dye, developing a blue color. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
... This visual change rate depends on temperature and increases at higher temperatures. For the TTI to be reliable, the temperature dependence of its response must be comparable to that of food quality loss [5]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The quality and protection of meat is now a critical concern of the food industry worldwide, as it is related to economic development and public health. The high demand for meat processing has led the meat industry to monitor the freshness and quality of the products as expected by the consumers. It is essential to reduce the spoilage of meat products caused by chemical compounds in a manner that is sustainable and healthy. Therefore, the development and implementation of analytical methods for determining the quality and protection of meat have increased over the years. The present review was carried out using inclusion benchmarks to classify the previous articles published between 2010 and 2020, specifically related to the analytical method for detecting freshness in various meat samples. In this study, the research addresses the microbial spoilage of meat products, the chemical compounds that lead to the spoilage of the meat, and the methods used to quantify the meat’s freshness. A large section covers current techniques to detect meat freshness, including electrochemical, electronic nose and gas sensors, as well as optical biosensors. The concluding section outlines the status of current challenges, identifies current issues, and discusses future views.
... The TTI reveals when refrigeration of perishable foodstuffs has been disrupted, and thus the shelf-life date rendered invalid, or serves directly as an indicator of shelf-life. The technology depended on solid-state SP photochromism [103] although an alternative system reliant on photochromic crystals of benzylpyridine derivative was also explored [104]. Immediately before use, the photochromic ink of the TTI label is activated by UV from LEDs to ring-open the dye, developing a blue color. ...
Article
This article furnishes an introduction to one of the most well-known classes of photochromic colorant. While the properties of spiropyran dyes inspired pioneering efforts to exploit photochromism for industrial applications, their lack of robustness held them back from commercialization. Nevertheless, this type of dye remains at the heart of much of the work to develop light-responsive materials upon which many potential applications in different fields of scientific and technological endeavor depend. The article describes the photochromism, synthesis, and applications of spiropyran colorants with an emphasis on the structural subtype that has attracted the greatest scrutiny. It also acts as a springboard to sources of more detail on these aspects.
... The time-temperature indicators record the temperature history, either totally or partially, and thus indicate the shelf life of perishable products (Lee and Rahman, 2014;Wang et al., 2015b;Biegańska, 2017). In this way they can indicate and alert consumers to potential microbial growth or possible protein denaturation (Wang et al., 2015b;Zabala et al., 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
Food packaging has a crucial function in the modern food industry. New food packaging technologies seek to meet consumers and industrial's demands. Changes related to food production, sale practices and consumers' lifestyles, along with environmental awareness and the advance in new areas of knowledge (such as nanotechnology or biotechnology), act as driving forces to develop smart packages that can extend food shelf-life, keeping and supervising their innocuousness and quality and also taking care of the environment. This review describes the main concepts and types of active and intelligent food packaging, focusing on recent progress and new trends using biodegradable and biobased polymers. Numerous studies show the great possibilities of these materials. Future research needs to focus on some important aspects such as possibilities to scale-up, costs, regulatory aspects, and consumers' acceptance, to make these systems commercially viable.
Article
Full-text available
در عصر حاضر به جای تمرکز بر آزمایش و تائید محصولات نهایی بیشتر به نظارت و کنترول پارامتر های مهم در سرتاسر دوران پروسس محصول غذایی توجه شده است. نوسانات درجه حرارت باعث کاهش مدت زمان نگهداری محصولات مستعد به فسادگردیده که در نتیجه، این موضوع باعث عدم مطابقت بین تاریخ انقضا نشان داده شده در لیبل و شرایط کیفی مواد غذایی می‌گردد. ارتباطی خوبی بین خصوصیات فزیکی، کیمیایی و میکروبیولوژیکی مواد غذایی و تغییرات رنگ در معرف های حرارت و زمان وجود دارد. معرف یک وسیله ساده، ارزان و قابل پسند ازلحاظ نظارت، ثبت و تفسیر معلومات در مورد کیفیت مواد غذایی برای مصرف کننده گان بوده و معرف های حرارت و زمان موعد نگهداری (Shelf-life) باقی مانده یک محصول را نیز مشخص میسازد.
Article
Improving the capability and resolution of monitoring perishable products during their transportation and storage is essential, but there is a key requirement it is not to increase costs or the number monitoring devices. Currently there lies a knowledge gap in studies on the spatial prediction and mapping of determinant parameters (e.g. temperature) for the shelf life of perishable products. Through the viewpoint of different refrigeration failure scenarios this paper investigates and compares three data estimation tools (artificial neural networks, Kriging and capacitive heat transfer) for improved food safety. Results indicate that using these techniques makes it possible to reduce the number of sensors (through estimation of temperature distribution) within an industrial scale fully loaded strawberry-shipping container, thus reducing the overall commercial cost. Using a set of eight source sensors, an average error of 0.1 °C was achieved, which represents an improvement of 97.14% in regards to the absolute error between the ambient and product temperatures. Even when using only a single container sensor as a source for prediction, with an average error of 1.49 °C there still was an improvement of 62% with regards to the same baseline. This paper demonstrates that the adoption of these technologies not only presents significant industrial value-added potential but also the data obtained can further improve cold chain strategies and reduce product losses through more accurate shelf life calculations.
Article
Europeans and North Americans produce a total of 95 to 115 kg of annual food waste per capita, which corresponds to more than one-third of the total food production in these countries. One of the different assumptions presented in the literature is the food storage practices. With regards to food safety, poor and unhygienic handling as well as inappropriate storage conditions at the consumer level are critical issues. Consumers do not consider the nature of the food in the organization of the refrigerator. To investigate this assumption, a methodology was developed to study consumer behavior while placing food in the refrigerator. To approximate a home environment, the study was conducted in a test kitchen. Twenty consumers participated in the study. The experiments were filmed with different camera systems (four cameras fixed on the ceiling and one portable camera). The consumers were tasked with storing food from delivery bags in the refrigerator and in a kitchen closet. They also completed a questionnaire about their habits concerning food purchases and storage. This study reveals a wide diversity of behaviors for storing food in the refrigerator. The recommendations from the French Agriculture and Food Department are clearly not observed or even known. The main safety issues concern meats, ready-to-eat salads, and ready-made dough because they are sensitive to contamination with pathogens.
Article
Background Intelligent packaging is the newest technology within the food packaging field. Even though this technology is still growing and not fully commercially viable, it has enormous potential to improve the safety, quality, and traceability of food products, as well as its convenience for consumers. Scope and approach This paper first describes both the technical aspects and commercial applications of the most representative intelligent technologies—indicators, data carriers, and sensors—with special focus on systems and devices that are directly integrated into the package. Secondly, to provide useful guidelines for future research in the field, the paper discusses some important aspects that still hinder the full exploitation of intelligent technology within the food packaging industry. Key findings and conclusions Future research needs to consider some important aspects in order to make intelligent systems commercially viable, such as cost, consumers' acceptance and confidence, regulatory aspects (e.g., labeling), and multifunctionality.
Chapter
Intelligent packaging is an emerging technology that uses the communication function of the package to facilitate decision making in order to achieve the benefits of enhanced food quality and safety. This chapter introduces the basic concept of intelligent packaging and describes a conceptual framework of intelligent decision support system to minimize microbial hazards of food.
Article
This chapter begins with an overview of the various principles behind commercially released freshness and safety indicators. These include time-temperature integrators and leak detectors that simply indicate risk, and sensor labels that offer direct assessment of safety and freshness (including fruit ripeness). Since this arena has been thoroughly reviewed recently, just a couple of leading examples of each category are described to set the scene for a discussion of why most of these inventions have not proved commercially successful. The bulk of the chapter focuses on recent advances with potential to lead to successful new types of freshness and safety indicators.
Article
This chapter introduces an overall overview of the intelligent packaging (IP) systems; the emerging technology that has recently received an immense interest not only from the researchers but also from the consumers as a very attractive alternative to the conventional packaging due to the many benefits such as monitoring and maintaining the safety of products throughout the supply chain from the producers to the consumers and prolonging the shelf life of food products. The IP includes indicators (time-temperature indicators; integrity or gas indicators; freshness indicators); barcodes and radiofrequency identification tags (RFID); sensors (biosensors; gas sensors; fluorescence-based oxygen sensors), etc. Current technical addresses of the IP were updated. And also legal aspects of using the IP as well as problems associated with the commercialization and some probable solutions that will lead to wider adoption of this technology in the food industry in the near future were discussed.
Chapter
Temperature is the main post-processing parameter that determines food quality of perishable food products. Monitoring temperature is essential for effective shelf-life management. A cost-efficient way to monitor and continuously communicate the temperature conditions of individual food products throughout distribution are time-temperature integrators (TTIs). TTIs are inexpensive, active 'smart labels' that can show easily measurable, time- and temperature-dependent changes that reflect the time-temperature history of the food products. Implementing a TTI-based system could lead to realistic control of the chill chain, optimization of stock rotation and reduction of waste, and efficient shelf-life management. Current TTI technology, attitudes of consumers and food industry and commercial applications of TTIs are discussed.
Article
This work describes the development of a new smart time–temperature indicator, whose operating principle is based on the reaction between starch and iodine and the subsequent acting of an amylase on this complex, causing discoloration at a rate dependent on time and temperature of the medium. Laboratory simulations, manufacturing plant tests, and points of sale evaluated various enzyme concentrations in the TTI prototypes. The results showed that the color response of the indicators was visually interpreted as adaptive to measurement using colorimeter. Due to the possibility of defining the shelf-life of TTIs by varying enzyme concentrations, the indicators can be easily adapted to control the temperature conditions in the production chain of many perishable foods in a cheap, easy and accurate form. Industrial relevance Temperature control during the distribution and storage of perishable products is often flawed, with conditions other than those recommended by the manufacturer. The difficulty in knowing the temperature history to which a food has been exposed to makes it difficult to predict its true shelf-life. An innovative alternative to dynamically ensure the validity of food can be the use of a smart time–temperature indicator (TTI). However, the success of the industrial application of TTIs depends on the simplicity, cost and reliability during operation, characteristics that have not yet been jointly observed in the indicators available in the market. In this perspective, it is part of the development of this work, which aims to develop a new TTI that presents a favorable combination of efficiency, reliability and viability. Thus, the aim is to contribute to the commercial acceptance of the concepts of smart packaging and in the establishment of regulation standards of usage, providing benefits to the conservation of a wide variety of foods.