Conference PaperPDF Available

Geometry-based Computational Methodology to Reduce Markers Deviation

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Nowadays, determination of the ankle angular displacement and angular velocity are very common in sports biomechanics. The determined human biomechanics can be used to evaluate the surgical outcome of patients after surgery and the effects of ankle supportive braces (Figures 1). Human biomechanics are usually determined by the marker-based motion capture system. In order to compute the biomechnaics of ankle joint, markers are usually attached to the the fifth metatarsal head, heel, lateral malleolus and medial malleolus (Figure 2). Nevertheless, it is known that computation of human biomechanics is significantly affected by the deviation of markers positions [2, 3]. Particularly, the markers at the lateral malleolus and medial malleolus will have large deviation with the original position when the subjects are wearing ankle supportive braces (Figure 1b). In order to reduce the computational errors due to the deviation of markers positions, a simple and fast geometry-based computational methodology is proposed. The methodology makes use of the simple human anatomical geometry and the thickness of the brace compartments to estimate the original position of the markers (Figure 3). Then, the estimated position of the markers are used to determine the biomechanics of the ankle. In order to validate our methodology, experimental results of a subject with and without applying the proposed methodology were compared with the biomechancis of a subject without wearing ankle supportive brace. Experimental results showed that the proposed methodology can reduce the error of ankle biomechanics due to the deviations of the markers effectively. (a) (b) (c) Figure 1: (a) An ankle supportive brace; several markers were attached the subject ankle positions to determine the ankle biomechanics when a subject: (b) with; (c) without wearing supportive brace
Content may be subject to copyright.
2nd International Symposium on Computational Mechanics (ISCM II)
12th International Conference on Enhancement and Promotion of Computational Methods in Engineering and Science (EPMESC XII)
November 30 – December 3, 2009
Hong Kong – Macau
Geometry-based Computational Methodology to Reduce Markers Deviation
Y. M. Tang,
The Hong Kong Polytechnic University,
Department of Industrial and Systems Engineering, Hong Kong SAR, China;
mfymtang@inet.polyu.edu.hk
Keywords: ankle, braces, biomechanics, markers, motion capture system.
ABSTRACT
Nowadays, determination of the ankle angular displacement and angular velocity are very
common in sports biomechanics. The determined human biomechanics can be used to evaluate
the surgical outcome of patients after surgery and the effects of ankle supportive braces (Figures
1). Human biomechanics are usually determined by the marker-based motion capture system. In
order to compute the biomechnaics of ankle joint, markers are usually attached to the the fifth
metatarsal head, heel, lateral malleolus and medial malleolus (Figure 2). Nevertheless, it is
known that computation of human biomechanics is significantly affected by the deviation of
markers positions [2, 3]. Particularly, the markers at the lateral malleolus and medial malleolus
will have large deviation with the original position when the subjects are wearing ankle
supportive braces (Figure 1b). In order to reduce the computational errors due to the deviation of
markers positions, a simple and fast geometry-based computational methodology is proposed.
The methodology makes use of the simple human anatomical geometry and the thickness of the
brace compartments to estimate the original position of the markers (Figure 3). Then, the
estimated position of the markers are used to determine the biomechanics of the ankle. In order
to validate our methodology, experimental results of a subject with and without applying the
proposed methodology were compared with the biomechancis of a subject without wearing ankle
supportive brace. Experimental results showed that the proposed methodology can reduce the
error of ankle biomechanics due to the deviations of the markers effectively.
(a) (b) (c)
Figure 1: (a) An ankle supportive brace; several markers were attached the subject ankle
positions to determine the ankle biomechanics when a subject: (b) with; (c) without wearing
supportive brace
Figure 2: The markers positios. 1: the fifth metatarsal head; 2: heel; 3: lateral malleolus; 4:
medial malleolus. [1]
Figure 3: Location of the skin markers position and the estimated maker position.
REFERENCES
[1] C.L. Vaughan, B.L. Davis and J.C. O'Conner, Dynamics of Human Gait, Champaign, 1992.
[2] A. Cappozzo, “Three-dimensional analysis of human walking: experimental methods and
associated artifacts”, Hum Movement Sci, Vol. 10, Issue 5, pp. 589-602, (1991).
[3] A. Leardini, L. Chiari, U.D. Croce and A. Cappozzo, “Human movement analysis using
stereophotogrammetry Part 3. Soft tissue artifact assessment and compensation”, Gait
Posture, Vol. 21, Issue 2, pp. 212-25, (2005).
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
In the context of clinical gait analysis, experimental and analytical problems associated with the assessment of joint kinematics and kinetics are dealt with. Reference is made to the 3-D analysis of the lower limb during walking carried out using a stereometric optoelectronic system and forceplate. Experiments are described aiming at the determination of both instrumental inaccuracies and artifacts due to the movement of skin markers with respect to the underlying bone.
Article
When using optoelectronic stereophotogrammetry, skin deformation and displacement causes marker movement with respect to the underlying bone. This movement represents an artifact, which affects the estimation of the skeletal system kinematics, and is regarded as the most critical source of error in human movement analysis. A comprehensive review of the state-of-the-art for assessment, minimization and compensation of the soft tissue artifact (STA) is provided. It has been shown that STA is greater than the instrumental error associated with stereophotogrammetry, has a frequency content similar to the actual bone movement, is task dependent and not reproducible among subjects and, of lower limb segments, is greatest at the thigh. It has been shown that in in vivo experiments only motion about the flexion/extension axis of the hip, knees and ankles can be determined reliably. Motion about other axes at those joints should be regarded with much more caution as this artifact produces spurious effects with magnitudes comparable to the amount of motion actually occurring in those joints. Techniques designed to minimize the contribution of and compensate for the effects of this artifact can be divided up into those which model the skin surface and those which include joint motion constraints. Despite the numerous solutions proposed, the objective of reliable estimation of 3D skeletal system kinematics using skin markers has not yet been satisfactorily achieved and greatly limits the contribution of human movement analysis to clinical practice and biomechanical research. For STA to be compensated for effectively, it is here suggested that either its subject-specific pattern is assessed by ad hoc exercises or it is characterized from a large series of measurements on different subject populations. Alternatively, inclusion of joint constraints into a more general STA minimization approach may provide an acceptable solution.
  • C L Vaughan
  • B L Davis
  • J C O'conner
C.L. Vaughan, B.L. Davis and J.C. O'Conner, Dynamics of Human Gait, Champaign, 1992.