Conference PaperPDF Available

The IKEA Catalogue: Design Fiction in Academic and Industrial Collaborations

Authors:
  • Independent Researcher

Abstract and Figures

This paper is an introduction to the "Future IKEA Catalogue", enclosed here as an example of a design fiction produced from a long standing industrial-academic collaboration. We introduce the catalogue here by discussing some of our experiences using design fiction` with companies and public sector bodies, giving some background to the catalogue and the collaboration which produced it. We have found design fiction to be a useful tool to support collaboration with industrial partners in research projects - it provides a way of thinking and talking about present day concepts, and present day constraints, without being overly concerned with contemporary challenges, or the requirements of academic validation. In particular, there are two main aspects of this we will discuss here, aspects that are visible in the enclosed catalogue itself. The first is the potential of design fiction as a sort of 'boundary object' in industry and academic collaboration, and second the role of critique. After this introduction to the paper we enclose the output of our collaboration in the form of the catalogue itself.
Content may be subject to copyright.
The IKEA Catalogue:
Design fiction in academic and industrial collaborations
Barry Brown, Julian Bleecker, Marco D’Adamo, Pedro Ferreira, Joakim Formo, Mareike
Glöss, Maria Holm, Kristina Höök, Eva-Carin Banka Johnson, Emil Kaburuan, Anna Karlsson,
Elsa Kosmack-Vaara, Jarmo Laaksolahti, Airi Lampinen, Lucian
Leahu, Vincent Lewandowski, Donald McMillan, Anders Mellbratt, Johanna Mercurio, Cristian
Norlin, Nicolas Nova, Stefania Pizza, Asreen Rostami, Mårten Sundquist, Konrad
Tollmar, Vasiliki Tsaknaki, Jinyi Wang, Charles Windlin, Mikael Ydholm
Mobile Life Centre
Kista, Stockholm
barry@mobilelifecentre.org
1. INTRODUCTION
This paper is an introduction to the “Future IKEA Catalogue”,
enclosed here as an example of a design fiction produced from a
long standing industrial-academic collaboration. We introduce the
catalogue here by discussing some of our experiences using
design fiction` with companies and public sector bodies, giving
some background to the catalogue and the collaboration which
produced it. We have found design fiction to be a useful tool to
support collaboration with industrial partners in research projects
it provides a way of thinking and talking about present day
concepts, and present day constraints, without being overly
concerned with contemporary challenges, or the requirements of
academic validation. In particular, there are two main aspects of
this we will discuss here, aspects that are visible in the enclosed
catalogue itself. The first is the potential of design fiction as a
sort of ‘boundary object’ in industry and academic collaboration,
and second the role of critique. After this introduction to the paper
we enclose the output of our collaboration in the form of the
catalogue itself.
2. Boundary objects and critique
The research centre where we work brings together ten or so
companies (including IKEA), along with three host academic
institutions, working together on different technology and
interaction related research projects. Research collaborations with
industry are something that can face many challenges for both
industrial and academic partners. First, there is the question of
different expectations over timelines and the sorts of problems
research should address. While it is not always the case, broadly
academic partners have a much longer focus, whereas industrial
partners need focus on much shorter timespans. The lifetime of a
company in the fortune 500 is less than fifteen years one
perhaps should think how universities would behave if they only
survived for on average fifteen years. In turn, success for
industrial partners in a project is often seen through impact on
their own company. Careers within companies are made (and not)
on internal company impact. For academics while impact is
important, it is mainly through publications and teaching.
Research collaborations can hit problems when the ‘output’ is
narrowly defined in terms of an academic paper, or what will fit
with an academic paper, in contrast to what will have an ‘impact’
within an organisation.
It is here that we have found design fiction surprisingly useful
[6]. Design fiction offers the possibility for a different genera of
communication, a possibility for collaboration that escapes the
limitations of a lengthy academic paper or specific technical
prototypes. The fiction acts as a sort of “boundary object”
between academics and practitioners, meaning different things to
different groups. As Star and Greisemer put it, boundary objects
are: “objects which are both plastic enough to adapt to local needs
and constraints of the several parties employing them, yet robust
enough to maintain a common identity across sites.” [7].
From an academic viewpoint design fictions that can be seen as a
way of experimenting with ideas and issues. Fictions are perhaps
not as heavyweight as an academic publication, without the
requirements of citation, verification and the like. This allows for
more speculative and potentially innovative thinking. Design
fictions can thus be used to illustrate and provoke ideas that are in
development, particularly where design is part of the ideas in
development. For industrial participants, design fiction is in turn a
venue where ideas can be experimented with and implications
discussed, without being seen necessarily as a comment on current
products or practices. Their ambiguity means that participants can
speculate without worrying about negative implications being
drawn for the present. Figure one is a demonstration of this from
the catalogue. On one side it talks to the way in which IKEA has
always moved ‘labour’ (such as construction and transpiration) to
the purchaser, allowing it to sell products for much cheaper. Yet,
on the other side, it also talks to an interest in ‘labour’, maker
culture and DIY. How would IKEA interact with those who want
to ‘hack’ and build variations on the NYFIKEN bookshelf? What
Figure 1: Bookshelf “levels of service”something
between industrial and academic concerns
if personal fabrication is more widespread, would IKEA simply
sell plans and 3D cad models?
A second interesting issue about working together on design
fictions is how a design fiction can act as a piece of critique. The
relationship between design fiction and the (perhaps better known
in HCI) critical design illustrates this issue. It is not that design
fiction is without critique, and critical design is all about critique
nor is it that organizations (commercial and public) are unable to
deal with critique as part of projects they work on. Rather what
matters is the form that critique takes, and how it can contribute to
a collaboration, rather than seeming as an “academic privileging”
that steps outside a specific situation [4].
While it is a broad and perhaps even contested term, critical
design has at its heart the subversion of status quo through the
deployment of irony and satire. In the work by Dunne & Raby [3]
that coined the term, there is an attempt to subvert design’s focus
on “the product” the ways in which design usually takes for
granted its relationship with commerce, (over)-production,
consumption and the like. As Pierce et al put it, critical design is
an attempt to “question[s] the role of design in shaping our
everyday reality.” [5] Yet, as Pierce et al also point out, there is
increasing diversity in what is described as or subverts “critical
design” (Dunne & Raby themselves have moved more on to use
the term ‘speculative design’). Critique is still central to the
enterprise - in Bardzell & Bardzell's [1] use of the term, there is an
even more explicit connection with humanistic critical theory, and
cultural studies.
In contrast, design fiction is less clearly a critical enterprise. It has
a lineage is perhaps less in design (or even critical theory), but
rather in science fiction. As Bruce Sterling describes it, design
fiction is “when science fiction thinking opens itself to design
thinking” [8]. If good science fiction tells us not about the future
but about the present, then design fiction itself also reveals our
fears and problems in current time. Bleecker’s design fiction work
includes ‘catalogues’ of concepts that are simultaneously
uncomfortable, but at times also reassuring concepts that paint a
story of a particular future, playing on our hopes and fears of the
present [2]. Critique is sublimated within other engagements,
humour; spectacle; aspiration; technological desire. This is not to
say that design fiction is without critique as with science fiction
much of the work is clearly critical in intent. Yet it can go further
- design fictions can be possible but interesting, unusual but also
upsetting. Design fiction without critique is neutered falling into
corporate publicity. Yet design fiction perhaps has more diverse
goals than critical design.
When working on design fiction with large, privately funded
companies and large, publically funded government organisations,
one question that we encountered is how critical do you want to
be? Or more specifically, what is the useful role of critique in
such collaborations: of technology, of futures, of contradictions in
the present, or indeed of the role of the company that is
participating in the project? In rethinking technology, it is hard to
avoid being critical to some extent. Thinking about different
futures involve looking for contradictions in current systems or
practices, or trends that may be benign or merely frustrating (such
as incompatibilities), but with benign potential. Yet being critical
might cause all sorts of problems in collaborations and even in
interaction. The first can come in working with those who might
be uncomfortable, or hostile, to this sort of critical thinking. An
inescapable part of corporate culture in nearly every organisation
is to avoid direct explicit public critique of that organisation itself.
This can conflict with a more critical intent.
Perhaps, more insidiously, there is also the question of how we
might end up (in advance) censoring our work so as to avoid a
perceived conflict. As we respond to ideas, and concepts the work
might simply never be guided in a critical direction, simply
replicating the worldviews of participants. Or there are times
when a direct critique might simply fail to gain purchase. One of
the very points of working with large non-academic organisations
is that they have power and influence. That power can come
through explicit legislation and policy (when working through
public sector bodies) or through an influence on what is made and
sold, or even just on the transmission of ideas that takes place in
forums outside academia. Collaborations offer the possibility of a
positive influence but at some level this is reliant on
communication and personal relationships. Critique if it takes
the wrong form, if it is clumsy or too brazen can seem indulgent
or simply irrelevant. We might say that a specific comment or
investigation about an issue might lead to engagement and
reflection, whereas a broader critique could be summarily
rejected. Perhaps academic work should have little concern for
these issues. But research in conjunction with industry has the
potential to have a positive influence through and with different
organizations and public bodies. An important purpose of
industrial collaboration is to rejuvenate academic work by
patching it together with industrial concerns, and to rejuvenate
industrial work with new ideas and arguments.
One way we have sought to deal with this is by the use of
equivocality in our designs. Equivocality in design fiction
involves ideas that incorporate concepts that make the reader
uncomfortable. There is the aim of visualizing ideas that have
multiple meanings, that are presented in a straightforward way but
that leave room for different readings. Working with equivocality
lets us explore subversions that rather than acting as leaden
criticism, are more playful and open to different engagements.
This is a little like the use of homophonic puns in mandarin as a
way of subverting Internet censorship.
3. The catalogue
Moving onto our specific output - the catalogue enclosed here was
produced as a group effort bringing together collaborators from
public sector bodies, academic institutes, and major organisations
- including Stockholm City, IKEA and Ericsson. We worked
together over different concepts trying to establish possible
futures that highlighted the sorts of tensions that we though were
interesting to investigate, as well as productive in terms of
design.
Throughout the catalogue we attempted to mix the sort of
wholesome scenes that one encountered in a contemporary
catalogue, with possible subversions. So, on the first page we see
a typical gendered family scene - father away, while mother plays
with child. Yet the scene entails two subversions: the sofa is
Figure 2: How do we feel about IKEA selling living
organisms? What about a pricing model work where we need
to pay 9.99 per month for a lifetime subscription only?
watching what unfolds, collecting memories, and the father is
wearing a VR headset. This makes the scene perhaps a little bit
more shocking, the father is not merely attending to a different
activity, but they are in a different space their vision glanced by
a memory recording sofa. Similarly, on pages 5 and 6, we see one
ongoing concern of IKEA play out in an unusual way. Here, we
have a storage cabinet, but one that mixes digital
recommendations, delivered by drones. What we see is a play
between a concern for storage in a digital world, with the rather
intrusive “analysis [of daily activities] for an accurate subscription
offer”.
At first glance, the catalogue then offers a rather cozy futuristic
vision, but if one looks at the copy instead one can read a more
equivocal vision: IKEA as not only the provider of the home, but
as a data collection entity. How would we feel about IKEA
replacing Google as the repository of our memories?
4. Conclusion
We only are at the beginning of experimenting with design fiction
and the role it can play in these collaborations. The enclosed
catalogue helped us start to explore new ways of collaborating
with industry, but has also been adopted for use in teaching by our
colleagues, as well as encouraging our industrial partners to pick
up the ideas and run their own design fiction events. Clearly, it
conveys research in different ways and lets us reach out. In the
enclosed catalogue you can see examples of the equivocality,
critique, and boundary objects in particular designs. Yet more
broadly, the opportunity here comes from the possibilities of
working with a new form for academic research not just as a
new way of communicating research outcomes, but as a new
forum for communication and collaboration with a variety of
partners.
5. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors are collaborators in the Mobile Life Centre, as such
we also thank the host collaborating companies and organisations.
6. REFERENCES
1. Jeffrey Bardzell and Shaowen Bardzell. 2015. Humanistic Hci.
Synthesis Lectures on Human-Centered Informatics 8, 4: 1
185.
2. Julian Bleecker. 2009. Design Fiction: A short essay on
design, science, fact and fiction. Near Future Laboratory 29.
3. Anthony Dunne. 2008. Hertzian tales: Electronic products,
aesthetic experience, and critical design. MIT Press.
Retrieved February 10, 2016 from
http://www.citeulike.org/group/7111/article/3508492
4. Michael Lynch. 2000. Against Reflexivity as an Academic
Virtue and Source of Privileged Knowledge. Theory, Culture
& Society 17, 3: 2654.
http://doi.org/10.1177/02632760022051202
5. James Pierce, Phoebe Sengers, Tad Hirsch, Tom Jenkins,
William Gaver, and Carl DiSalvo. 2015. Expanding and
refining design and criticality in HCI. Proceedings of the 33rd
Annual ACM Conference on Human Factors in Computing
Systems, ACM, 20832092. Retrieved February 10, 2016 from
http://dl.acm.org/citation.cfm?id=2702438
6. Ian Sommerville, Tom Rodden, Pete Sawyer, and Richard
Bentley. 1992. Sociologists can be suprisingly useful in
interactive systems design. In Proceedings of the HCI’92
Conference on People and Computers VII. pp 341353.
7. Susan Leigh Star and James R. Griesemer. 1989. Institutional
Ecology, `Translations’ and Boundary Objects: Amateurs and
Professionals in Berkeley’s Museum of Vertebrate Zoology,
1907-39. Social Studies of Science 19, 3: 387420.
http://doi.org/10.1177/030631289019003001
8. Bruce Sterling. 2005. Shaping Things (Mediaworks
Pamphlets). Retrieved February 10, 2016 from
http://www.citeulike.org/group/7111/article/548260
The smart
everyday for
the many
people
NEWS
Experience the new IKEA
catalogue — now with
Holograms!
NOTE:
For research
purpose
only
(c) InterIKEA Systems B.V. 2015
Enjoy the comfort
of your home..
NEW SÖMNRIK
smart bed
Let your sleeping preference
follow you on your trips!
See p. 8
Curated by: Designed by:
JULIAN BLEECKER
NEAR FUTURE LABORATORY
SAN FRANCISCO
BARRY BROWN
MOBILE LIFE
STOCKHOLM
BORIS DESIGN STUDIO
HONG KONG / STOCKHOLM
249:-
/year/household
(c) InterIKEA Systems B.V. 2015
NOTE:
For research
purpose
only
... However, with the games industry now valued at over US$249.60bn worldwide as of 2023 6 ; it is clear that education surrounding games is profitable, and those studying it will be highly employable. Not only is an education that focuses on the broad range of game topics a well-regarded research discipline of its own, but also an asset to the industry; helping to train individuals to enter the game industry post-graduation. ...
... Previously, speculative design has been applied to a broad range of design tasks. For instance, Brown et al. [6] explored the future of IKEA catalogues with IKEA, and in that way it opens up for thinking and talking about present day concepts and constraints. The task reflected in this section is based on Fiesler's work on ethical speculation [15], where she discusses her approach to creative speculation for ethical and legal courses to address uncertainty and consequences with emerging technologies through the use of black mirror as a teaching exercise. ...
... Many times, we see these technologies as positive and beneficial without thinking about their challenges or limitations. Similar to what Brown et al. [6] highlight in their IKEA catalogue work, imagining these possible futures enables a way for us to see the current situation of the present day through a more critical lens. For instance, students working on a system to assist security guards at nightclubs questioned the limitations and challenges of security guards, and why these challenges exist in the present day in first place. ...
... Encouraging people to envision future possibilities and stimulating their imaginations are key challenges in human-computer interaction (HCI). Design fiction has been commonly used to craft speculative scenarios from counterfactual artifacts (Auger 2013;Brown et al. 2016;Dunne and Raby 2013) or experiences Dunagan 2016, 2017;Candy and Kornet 2019;Candy, Dator, and Dunagan 2006;Kozubaev 2018) in the HCI and interaction design communities. Candy and Dunagan (2016) presented how they designed and staged experiential interventions for their participants. ...
... Through such interventions, design researchers not only craft design fiction but also construct experiences for their participants. Most design fiction research addresses the suspension of disbelief through visual (Brown et al. 2016;Dunne and Raby 2013;Sturdee 2016;Stockburger 2003;Voegelin 2014;Wong, Van Wyk, and Pierce 2017) or textual (Baumer et al. 2014;Blythe 2014) interventions. How auditory experiences engage people in experiencing imagined worlds has yet to be thoroughly explored. ...
Article
Experiential intervention in design fiction has been an effective approach to stimulating imagination through visual or textual materials. However, the potential of design fiction to create auditory experiences that encourage listeners to immerse themselves in imagined worlds remains largely unexplored. This paper introduces Soundscape Fiction, a four-layer audio composition for stimulating experiential imagination. We explored its temporal form through audio mixing, framed a design space for each layer using a tangible Soundscape Mixer, and developed research artifacts called Quartet Tubes to enable users to incorporate Soundscape Fiction into their daily lives. We present participants’ experiences of using Quartet Tubes in everyday settings, demonstrating how situated listening, as a form of speculative engagement, can shape personal realities. The research contributes to the experience-centered approach of practical design fiction by illustrating a research-through-design process for creating imaginative auditory experiences. It concludes with design considerations for future exploration of experiential intervention in auditory imagination.
... Fiction around the future of work has also taken the shape of design fiction probes and fictional artifacts. Following the tradition of the Ikea catalog of the future by Brown et al. [9], these "material objects help tell stories about the future" [36]. The Office Jungle [18] is a critical and speculative vision of a future office environment that encourages physical activity by embracing wildness. ...
... As we unveiled points of tension and opportunities, we took note of our main insights and questions in a research diary, which constitutes a basis of the points we discuss in Section 7. The choices we made while editing the narrative reflect our positionality as design researchers [48] (Section 6). We used the AI Art Generator Midjourney as a support to visualize the Trinity world and compile the company brochure, inspired by the iconic Future Ikea catalog [9]. Refining the prompts progressively to reach a suitable vision for the agents involved reflection in action and triggered additional insights. ...
... By responding to what-if questions regarding pre-identified future challenges [44], SD props are provocative and shall trigger questions about how the future of social and societal living environments may look like [43,104]. They can take different formats, for example a fictional product catalog [19,85] or newspaper [119], speculative product and service websites [62], imaginative forum questions or posts [165], or scenes and software prototypes [54]. Besides objects, narratives are another mode of materialization of speculations [72]. ...
Article
Currently, the development of the metaverse lies in the hands of industry. Citizens have little influence on this process. Instead, to do justice to the pluralism of (digital) societies, we should strive for an open discourse including many different perspectives on the metaverse and its core technologies such as AI. We utilize a participatory speculative design (PSD) approach to explore Japanese citizens' perspectives on future metaverse societies, as well as social and ethical implications. Our contributions are twofold. Firstly, we demonstrate the effectiveness of PSD in engaging citizens in critical discourse on emerging technologies like the metaverse by presenting our workshop framework and participants' processes. Secondly, we identify key themes from participants' perspectives, providing insights for culturally sensitive design and development of virtual environments. Our analysis shows that participants imagine the metaverse to have the potential to solve a variety of societal issues; for example, breaking down barriers of physical environments for communication, social interaction, crisis preparation, and political participation, or tackling identity-related issues. Regarding future metaverse societies, participants' imaginations raise critical questions about human-AI relations, technical solutionism, politics and technology, globalization and local cultures, and immersive technologies. We discuss implications and contribute to expanding conversations on metaverse developments.
... Speculative design relies on imaginative and creative concepts that help people to think critically about the present moment and to imagine alternative futures. There is a rich history in the field of speculative design of creating "future catalogs" as a way of imagining what future products and inventions might look like [8]. This is a common assignment in speculative design classes, and this kind of assignment asks that students create images and write descriptions that represent an imagined future world. ...
Article
This paper focuses on interaction across and between the physical/digital divide. We use blending theory to design for these situations, otherwise known as conceptual integration. Initially, this paper offers a discussion of the literature around blends. From this literature, we applied Benyon’s (Benyon, 2014) proposition of conceptual integration in mixed reality spaces (Blended Spaces) to consider interactions with the digital that complement the physical. We investigated blended spaces in partnership with undergraduate students during a live theatre festival. Our collaborators designed applications that applied blending principles, employing techniques drawn from speculative design. Outputs consist of speculative, narrative storyboards that use data gathered directly from stakeholder interviews and over 380 festival visitors. Our work led us to propose reworking Blended Spaces into a model that novice designers could easily conceive and apply. The work we conducted highlighted the need to consider user transitions from physical to digital and back again and highlighted the experiential nature of this type of interaction.
Article
As new forms of data capture emerge to power new AI applications, questions abound about the ethical implications of these data collection practices. In this paper, we present clinicians' perspectives on the prospective benefits and harms of voice data collection during health consultations. Such data collection is being proposed as a means to power models to assist clinicians with medical data entry, administrative tasks, and consultation analysis. Yet, clinicians' attitudes and concerns are largely absent from the AI narratives surrounding these use cases, and the academic literature investigating them. Our qualitative interview study used the concept of an informed consent process as a type of design fiction, to support elicitation of clinicians' perspectives on voice data collection and use associated with a fictional, near-term AI assistant. Through reflexive thematic analysis of in-depth sessions with physicians, we distilled eight classes of potential risks that clinicians are concerned about, including workflow disruptions, self-censorship, and errors that could impact patient eligibility for services. We conclude with an in-depth discussion of these prospective risks, reflect on the use of the speculative processes that illuminated them, and reconsider evaluation criteria for AI-assisted clinical documentation technologies in light of our findings.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The term 'critical design' is on the upswing in HCI. We analyze how discourses around 'critical design' are diverging in Design and HCI. We argue that this divergence undermines HCI's ability to learn from and appropriate the design approaches signaled by this term. Instead, we articulate two ways to broaden and deepen connections between Design and HCI: (1) develop a broader collective understanding of what these design approaches can be, without forcing them to be about 'criticality' or 'critical design,' narrowly construed; and (2) shape a variation of design criticism to better meet Design practices, terms, and ways of knowing.
Article
Full-text available
ion is a key part of this process - the computer science researcher is always examining the problem at hand to discover abstractions and to produce general rather than specific solutions. Confirmation of 10 Ian Sommerville, Tom Rodden, Pete Sawyer and Richard Bentley theoretical predictions or, indeed, the discovery of theories by analysis of experimental results is not currently a significant research methodology. The sociology research methods of relevance to our work are based on observation. The sociologist looks at a society to determine its practices, and behaviours. The sociologist may try to fit these observations into an existing theoretical framework or may derive a new theory from them. For ethnographers, all detail is potentially significant and they are reluctant to make abstractions in case this hides potentially important system details. However, different sociologists are concerned with looking for different things. Some sociologists are concerned with observing socia...
Article
Although it has influenced the field of Human-Computer Interaction (HCI) since its origins, humanistic HCI has come into its own since the early 2000s. In that time, it has made substantial contributions to HCI theory and methodologies and also had major influence in user experience (UX) design, aesthetic interaction, and emancipatory/social change-oriented approaches to HCI. This book reintroduces the humanities to a general HCI readership; characterizes its major epistemological and methodological commitments as well as forms of rigor; compares the scientific report vs. the humanistic essay as research products, while offering some practical advice for peer review; and focuses on two major topics where humanistic HCI has had particular influence in the field—user experience and aesthetics and emancipatory approaches to computing. This book argues for a more inclusive and broad reach for humanistic thought within the interdisciplinary field of HCI, and its lively and engaging style will invite readers into that project. Table of Contents: Preface / Acknowledgments / Introduction / Part I: Theorizing Humanistic HCI / What is Humanistic HCI / Humanistic HCE and Methods / Enacting the Struggle for Truth in Full View: Writing and Reviewing Humanistic Research / Part II: Major Topics in Humanistic HCI / User Experience and Aesthetics / Social Change and Emancipation / Conclusion / Bibliography / About the Authors
Article
Scientific work is heterogeneous, requiring many different actors and viewpoints. It also requires cooperation. The two create tension between divergent viewpoints and the need for generalizable findings. We present a model of how one group of actors managed this tension. It draws on the work of amateurs, professionals, administrators and others connected to the Museum of Vertebrate Zoology at the University of California, Berkeley, during its early years. Extending the Latour-Callon model of interessement, two major activities are central for translating between viewpoints: standardization of methods, and the development of `boundary objects'. Boundary objects are both adaptable to different viewpoints and robust enough to maintain identity across them. We distinguish four types of boundary objects: repositories, ideal types, coincident boundaries and standardized forms.
Article
Reflexivity is a well-established theoretical and methodological concept in the human sciences, and yet it is used in a confusing variety of ways. The meaning of `reflexivity' and the virtues ascribed to the concept are relative to particular theoretical and methodological commitments. This article examines several versions of the concept, and critically focuses on treatments of reflexivity as a mark of distinction or source of methodological advantage. Although reflexivity often is associated with radical epistemologies, social scientists with more conventional leanings often speak of reflexivity as a methodological tool, substantive property of social systems, or source of individual enlightenment. Radical and conventional social scientists alike tend to stress the importance of being reflexive, as opposed to being unreflexive, but they do not share a coherent conception of what `being reflexive' means or entails. As an alternative to reflexive self-privileging, I recommend an ethnomethodological conception of reflexivity as an ordinary, unremarkable and unavoidable feature of action. The ethnomethodological conception does not support a particular theoretical or methodological standpoint by contrasting it to an `unreflexive' counterpart. It has little value as a critical weapon or source of epistemological advantage, which, in the present context, can have advantages of its own for promoting peace and epistemic democracy.
Hertzian tales: Electronic products, aesthetic experience, and critical design
  • Anthony Dunne
Anthony Dunne. 2008. Hertzian tales: Electronic products, aesthetic experience, and critical design. MIT Press. Retrieved February 10, 2016 from http://www.citeulike.org/group/7111/article/3508492
Design Fiction: A short essay on design, science, fact and fiction
  • Julian Bleecker
Julian Bleecker. 2009. Design Fiction: A short essay on design, science, fact and fiction. Near Future Laboratory 29.