ArticlePDF Available

RECONFIGURING THE “MIXED TOWN”: URBAN TRANSFORMATIONS OF ETHNONATIONAL RELATIONS IN PALESTINE AND ISRAEL

Authors:

Abstract

Identifying ethnonational mixed towns as an analytical and comparative category, we show how in Palestine and Israel such towns underwent six major historical transformations and how their history under Ottoman, British, and Israeli rule displays an emergent and bifurcated sociospatial configuration. On one level, they personify the political conflict over space and identity as it evolved from millet -based confessional communities to modernist nation-based collectives shaped by milestones of the Palestinian–Israeli conflict. On another level, they form political and cultural arenas that defy the binary logic of ethnonationalism and urban colonialism. Avoiding the restrictive Manichaean conceptualizations of the colonial, the divided, and the dual city, we show how such towns embody segregation and exclusion while actively resisting them. Scrutinizing demographic diversification, cultural expansion, intercommunal relations, and the secularizing, modernizing effect urbanity has had in the region, our analysis, which emphasizes relationality, reconfigures the sociospatial history of Jewish–Arab mixed towns.
Int. J. Middle East Stud. 40 (2008), 226a. Printed in the United States of America
DOI: 10.1017/S0020743808080811
Dan Rabinowitz and Daniel Monterescu
RECONFIGURING THE MIXED TOWN”: URBAN
TRANSFORMATIONS OF ETHNONATIONAL
RELATIONS IN PALESTINE AND ISRAEL
Identifying ethnonational mixed towns as an analytical and comparative category, we show how
in Palestine and Israel such towns underwent six major historical transformations and how their
history under Ottoman, British, and Israeli rule displays an emergent and bifurcated sociospa-
tial configuration. On one level, they personify the political conflict over space and identity
as it evolved from millet-based confessional communities to modernist nation-based collectives
shaped by milestones of the Palestinian–Israeli conflict. On another level, they form political and
cultural arenas that defy the binary logic of ethnonationalism and urban colonialism. Avoiding the
restrictive Manichaean conceptualizations of the colonial, the divided, and the dual city, we show
how such towns embody segregation and exclusion while actively resisting them. Scrutinizing
demographic diversification, cultural expansion, intercommunal relations, and the secularizing,
modernizing effect urbanity has had in the region, our analysis, which emphasizes relationality,
reconfigures the sociospatial history of Jewish–Arab mixed towns.
© 2008 Cambridge University Press 0020-7438/08 $15.00
https:/www.cambridge.org/core/terms. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0020743808080811
Downloaded from https:/www.cambridge.org/core. IP address: 45.45.147.51, on 20 Feb 2017 at 08:19:39, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use, available at
... According to Monterescu (2011), the very fact that neither side defines the mixed city as ethnically/religiously homogeneous is what defines its political and cultural existence. In the formulation of Rabinowitz and Monterescu (2008), 'Palestinian and Jewish-Israeli public discourses constitute mixed towns as a marked cultural and political category, deeply intertwined with the future of Israel and its Palestinian minority ' (p. 200). ...
... Focusing on this specific issue in future studies emerges as a promising direction. This 'hybrid urbanism,' in the terms of Rabinowitz and Monterescu (2008), results in a complex reality that raises unique dilemmas and leads to unique decisions. These decisions may be understood as yet another attempt to gain some of the power missing from their day-to-day 'trapped minority' experience. ...
Article
The state of Israel has an indigenous minority of Arabs, distinguished from the Jewish majority by national, religious, cultural, and linguistic characteristics. Most Jews use Hebrew as their L1, while Arabs use Arabic, both official languages in Israel. Most Arabs tend to live in separate geographical areas and about 10% of Israel’s Arabs live in ‘mixed cities.’ Since neither side defines them as homogeneous, these cities may afford rich insights about Israeli reality. Recently, there has been a growing tendency among Arab parents in mixed cities to send their children to Hebrew-speaking educational settings, especially in preschool years. This study aimed at understanding this phenomenon from both sociolinguistic and psychological perspectives, viewing language as closely related to power and identity as well as to emotions and close relationships. Qualitative information was gathered from interviews with parents, focusing on parents’ motives to send their children to these educational settings and on the impact of this decision on the family’s language policy and emotional interactions. Overall, findings reveal how the external urban setting interacts with the internal family system. The mixed city context appears to invade the family dynamics in mixed ways, and sociopolitical dimensions interact closely with emotional ones.
... Acre's designation as a peripheral town referred to more than its geographical location, becoming a cultural and social marker as well. This was much like the rest of Israel's mixed cities, which had to adapt their economic and political rhythms to the needs and objectives of the new political order after 1948 (Monterescu and Rabinowitz 2008;Weiss 2012;Piroyanski 2014). 4 Similar to the case in other peripheral cities, Acre's synagogues were initially established by ethnic communities seeking to commemorate their places of origin and shape an urban space of their own within everyday city life. ...
Article
Full-text available
In recent years, Lefebvre's concept of rhythm analysis has been implied in various ways to critically examine how rhythms are formed, disrupted, and reformed through different urban venues. One theme that this body of knowledge has yet to comprehensively examine, however, is how changes in the urban sphere impact the spatial rhythms of religious institutions in cities, which can be pivotal for understanding how religious institutions are formed as urban public spaces. This article addresses this issue with a rhythm analysis of a particular religious urban locus: a synagogue in the mixed Palestinian and Jewish city of Acre in northern Israel. Based on ethnographic fieldwork and an urban survey, the article discusses how different forms of rhythm‐making undergo a process of contested synchronization with linear and cyclical rhythms of the city. More specifically, how the ability to forge a space hinges on the ability to maintain a rhythmic cycle of attendance, which, in turn, is not only dependent on the ability to achieve synchronization amongst the needs of the different participants but is also intertwined with the larger linear cycle of urban life as a rhythmic equation that fuses the personal with the political, the linear with the cyclical, and the religious with the urban.
... The chapter suggests that Israel's national and urban planning practices since its establishment provide rich and significant empirical sources for gaining a deep understanding of these territorial policies and their intentions and results. So far, scholars have only focused on the role of planning as a political tool in Judaization policies in individual cities, particularly in East Jerusalem (Jabareen 2010); Lydda (Yacobi 2003); and Jaffa (Rabinowitz and Monterescu 2008). This chapter is the first critical account of the nature and results of the Israeli planning system as implemented at the national and regional levels. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
This volume presents new perspectives on Israeli society, Palestinian society, and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Based on historical foundations, it examines how Israel institutionalizes ethnic privileging among its nationally diverse citizens. Arab, Israeli, and American contributors discusses the paradoxes of democratic claims in ethnic states, as well as dynamics of social conflict in the absence of equality. This book advances a new understanding of Israel's approach to the Palestinian citizens, covers the broadest range of areas in which Jews and Arabs are institutionally differentiated along ethnic basis, and explicates the psychopolitical foundations of ethnic privileges. It will appeal to students and scholars who seek broader views on Israeli society and its relationship with the Arab citizens, and want to learn more about the status of the Palestinian citizens in Israel and their collective experience as both citizens and settler-colonial subjects.
... In the spirit of post-colonial critique, Yiftachel and Yacobi (2003) have claimed that Israeli state policy discriminates against the Arab minority by allocating it fewer resources and services and excluding it from social life, resulting in the emergence of cities with inferior and marginalized Arab neighbourhoods. More contemporary literature offers a less dichotomized view, emphasizing that oppression and resistance are often intertwined and that urban interactions, everyday encounters and basic mutual needs sometimes enable city inhabitants to overcome political differences and national conflicts (Rabinowitz and Monterescu 2008). This critical discourse on segregation, hierarchy and boundaries contributes to an understanding of Acre as an agglomeration of enclaves defined by national-religious segregations and social hierarchies that are maintained and reinforced by boundaries. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study explores the relationship between art and urban boundaries using the case study of a fringe theatre festival in the Israeli mixed-city of Acre. While mixed cities today are understood as agglomerations of enclaves, maintained and reinforced by boundaries, urban designers and artists have used art as a culture-led regeneration strategy through which these boundaries may be breached. This study undermines the shared assumption of both fields: that art has the power to breach boundaries, by juxtaposing a city’s artistic activity with its segregation patterns and boundaries. Using super-positioning, the findings of two research methods have been integrated: urban research and ethnographic field work. The article shows that although the artistic activity in question is rooted in an avant-garde radical desire to subvert socioeconomic structures, it actually produces new versions and interpretations of the same segregations and boundaries in both space and society.
... The current population structure is the result of a process of Judaization, in which the Palestinian community remaining in the city after the establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 has become marginalized (goren 2006;Segev 1984). nonetheless, Haifa still represents a socio-demographic reality in which there are shared elements of identity, symbolic traits and cultural markers (Rabinowitz and Monterescu 2008). For many of Haifa's Israeli-Palestinian residents, the history of the city is a daily lived experience and an important aspect of their identity (Habibi 1993;Kanafani 2001). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper derives from the experience of a community-based university course that uses visualization and on-site methods to explore participatory imagination and imaging of urban spaces. Participatory urban visualization is a platform for discourse. It allows local residents to become involved in thinking the future of their locality, thereby activating their urban citizenship. The paper starts with a discussion of urban space and citizenship, and explores the potential of urban visualization and participation. The second part of the paper explains the context of Haifa, the ethno-nationally contested city in which the course is held, and presents two case studies. It identifies collaborative professional methodologies and techniques, and stresses participatory visualization as a vehicle for promoting communal sense of place and urban identity.
Chapter
Full-text available
This new go-to reference book for global melodrama assembles contributions by experts from a wide range of disciplines, including cultural studies, film and media studies, gender and queer studies, political science, and postcolonial studies. The melodramas covered in this volume range from early 20th century silent movies to contemporary films, from independent ›arthouse‹ productions to Hollywood blockbusters. The comprehensive overview of global melodramatic film in the Lexicon constitutes a valuable resource for scholars and practitioners of film, teachers, film critics, and anyone who is interested in the past and present of melodramatic film on a global scale. The Lexicon of Global Melodrama includes essays on All That Heaven Allows, Bombay, Casablanca, Die Büchse der Pandora, In the Mood for Love, Nosotros los Pobres, Terra Sonâmbula, and Tokyo Story.
Article
Full-text available
Dominant majorities often use idealized categories to validate the ‘goodness’ and deservingness of minority citizens. For Palestinian citizens of Israel, this category is the ‘good Arab’. Since its origins in early Jewish settlement of Palestine, it has become a powerful and controversial metaphor in Israeli public discourse. As an experienced condition of limited inclusion, the ‘good Arab’ exemplifies the Palestinian dilemma of accessing socioeconomic opportunities in Jewish Israeli spaces that stigmatize and fend off their ethnonational identity. Combining a historical genealogy of the ‘good Arab’ with ethnographic research among Palestinians in Tel Aviv, this article shows how a historically evolved logic of settler colonial control and indigenous erasure continues to define liberal frameworks of conditional citizenship and inclusion. Theorized through the emerging concept of conditional inclusion , these insights open up new avenues for analysis and comparison in anthropological debates surrounding indigenous struggles, settler colonialism, urban inclusion, and citizenship.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.