A preview of this full-text is provided by Springer Nature.
Content available from Trees
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Vol.:(0123456789)
1 3
Trees (2017) 31:1015–1023
DOI 10.1007/s00468-017-1526-6
ORIGINAL ARTICLE
Extensively damaged trees tested withacoustic tomography
considering tree stability inurban greenery
RadovanOstrovský1· MarekKobza1· JánGažo2
Received: 2 August 2016 / Accepted: 13 January 2017 / Published online: 7 February 2017
© Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2017
damage area determination inside tree trunk and for overall
tree stability assessment on even extensively damaged trees
in urban greenery.
Keywords Acoustic tomography· Tree stability· Visual
assessment
Introduction
The failure of trees in an urban environment can endan-
ger lives and damage infrastructure. Schubert etal. (2009)
determine the main aspects of the stability of a tree: trunk
diameter, weight- and wind-loading, strength of trunk
wood, root anchorage as well as the location and geom-
etry of fungal decay or a cavity in the interior of a stem.
Acoustic tomography is a technique that has been explored
by many researchers in the area of urban tree decay detec-
tion as well as of determination of tree stability (Divos and
Szalai 2002; Nicolotti etal. 2003; Gilbert and Smiley 2004;
Wang etal. 2005, 2009; Liang etal. 2008; Wang and Alli-
son 2008; Johnstone 2010). As reported by Li etal. (2012),
investigations into urban trees showed great success using
acoustic tomography to detect moderate to severe inter-
nal decay within a trunk. Bucur (2005) consider acoustic
tomography as convenient for the inspection and defect
detection of standing trees from parks and public gardens
as well as for poles and other wooden structural elements.
It is possible to study visually the composition of the
stem and/or branches of different types of wood. This helps
to evaluate the location of potential hazard and its relation
to existing damage in tree stems and branches (Heikura
etal. 2008). To minimize the potential damage on one hand
and to avoid felling sound trees on the other, risk assess-
ment is crucial in managing urban trees. Decomposition of
Abstract
Key message Damaged area of five tree species was
determined by acoustic tomography. Final accuracy of
83% was found as satisfactory and proven suitability for
overall tree stability assessment.
Abstract Objectives of study were to assess the accu-
racy and reliability of the acoustic tomography technique
for detecting internal structural defects compared to visual
assessment on extensively damaged trees of five species in
urban greenery. Tomography was realized by Fakopp 3D
acoustic tomograph tool. Several types of structural defects
were determined, such as heartwood and sapwood decay,
internal and lateral cracks, ring shake and hollow. Acous-
tic tomography inspection revealed correct detection of
damage in all disc samples involved in study. Accuracy of
damaged area determination reached 90%. Total accuracy
determination for both area and location of damage was
83%. Overestimation of damaged area was observed in
eight samples, contrary to seven underestimated samples.
Difference in estimated false-positive area in comparison to
false-negative area was minimal. Irregularity of cross sec-
tion shape does not affect the final accuracy of tomograph.
Accuracy is not influenced by diameter of tree trunk. We
determined strong positive correlation between real area
of damage and results of tomography (r = 0.75; p = 0.001).
Acoustic tomography provides satisfactory accuracy in
Communicated by J. Lin.
* Radovan Ostrovský
radovan.ostrovsky@savzv.sk
1 Branch forWoody Plants Biology, Institute ofForest Ecology
oftheSlovak Academy ofSciences, Nitra, Slovakia
2 Department ofGenetics andPlant Breeding, Slovak
University ofAgriculture inNitra, Nitra, Slovakia
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.