ArticlePDF Available

Supervisors and subordinates relationship impact on job satisfaction and efficiency: The case of obstetric clinics in Greece

Authors:

Abstract

The purpose of this research is to investigate supervisors and subordinates relationship factors and their impact on job satisfaction and employee performance. The research examines private and public obstetric clinics through a sample of 100 subordinates and 30 supervisors, using a structured questionnaire based on a five-point Likert scale. The research results show that the main factor that affects job satisfaction and employee performance is the relationship developed between supervisors and subordinates. Furthermore, the research results show that recognition of the work and open communication with the supervisor affect positively subordinates' psychology. It is also proved that team spirit and equal treatment between the subordinates ultimately lead in the development of subordinates and the success of the supervisors. Finally, the importance of the factors of honesty and trust between supervisors and subordinates is confirmed
International Journal of Strategic Innovative Marketing
Vol. (2016) DOI: 10.15556/IJSIM.03.03.001
1
Supervisors and subordinates
relationship impact on job satisfaction
and efficiency: The case of obstetric
clinics in Greece
Tsitmideli G.1, Skordoulis M.1, Chalikias M.1a, Sidiropoulos G.1,
Papagrigoriou A.1
1Piraeus University of Applied Sciences, School of Business and Economics, Business
Administration Department, Egaleo, Greece
a) Corresponding author: mchalikias@hotmail.com
Abstract: The purpose of this research is to investigate supervisors and subordinates
relationship factors and their impact on job satisfaction and employee performance. The
research examines private and public obstetric clinics through a sample of 100
subordinates and 30 supervisors, using a structured questionnaire based on a five-point
Likert scale. The research results show that the main factor that affects job satisfaction and
employee performance is the relationship developed between supervisors and subordinates.
Furthermore, the research results show that recognition of the work and open
communication with the supervisor affect positively subordinatespsychology. It is also
proved that team spirit and equal treatment between the subordinates ultimately lead in the
development of subordinates and the success of the supervisors. Finally, the importance of
the factors of honesty and trust between supervisors and subordinates is confirmed
Keywords: Subordinate, supervisor, job satisfaction, employee performance, obstetric
clinic.
1. Introduction
Contemporary business environment is becoming more and more competitive, which
makes it difficult for any king of business to survive. Human resources are of great
importance for the survival and the development of any modern business. Many
business executives declare that the main factors connected to low employee
efficiency deal with the reduction of their personal motivation and the decrease of
their mood to work. Due to the fact that human capital is one of the most important
resources for the success of a business (Chalikias et al., 2014; Skordoulis et al.,
2015), employees’ satisfaction should be taken into account.
According to Spector (1997), motivation concern the total actions undertaken
from both the administration and the supervisors to maintain high employees’
SUPERVISORS AND SUBORDINATES RELATIONSHIP IMPACT ON JOB SATISFACTION AND
EFFICIENCY: THE CASE OF OBSTETRIC CLINICS IN GREECE
2
satisfaction in order that they behave in a certain way. As it is mentioned, employees
with high levels of motivation may achieve higher levels of productivity and
satisfaction from their job.
Lots of researchers consider that job satisfaction is necessary for the prosperity
of a business, while others believe that employee satisfaction is an unnecessary
luxury (Valvi & et. al., 2009). According to Spector (2000), job satisfaction has a
major influence on the prosperity of a businesses and is presented through the
increase of the employee performance.
A factor that determines the correlation between job satisfaction and employee
performance is whether the first is examined as an independent variable or not.
According to Vroom (1964), the effect of job satisfaction in persons behavior is the
job performance.
According to Jewell & Siegall (1990), there is a positive correlation between job
satisfaction and employee performance; more specifically, satisfied employees seem
to be more productive. On the other hand, work displeasure means job stress and
professional exhaustion (DeMato, 2004).
Employee satisfaction is a multidimensional term which represents the overall
attitude of a person and the feelings for specific aspects of his job (Kreither &
Kinicki, 2010; Skordoulis et al., 2014). Herzberg et al. (1959), found that employee
satisfaction is in high levels in the first years of an employee’s job, then declines
with a culmination about 20 years of work, while is increased again when it is close
to 30 years until the end of the employee’s service.
In health care sector, cooperation and balanced relationship between employees
imposes them to work together and provide high quality nursing services. One of the
main health care sectors is this of obstetric which consists of clinics that provide
obstetric and gynecological services. Nowadays, competition and economic crisis
have a big impact on the survival of nursing and obstetric institutions. For this
reason, staff must be satisfied from their job in order to be more efficient. The
relationship between employees and supervisors is particularly important in this
sector because high employee performance levels in an obstetric clinic is associated
with the best of services. This high employee performance is of vital importance as
the quality of offered services can turn into a competitive advantage for an
organization (Drosos et al., 2015).
Health care sector in Greece includes diagnostic centers and clinics which are
divided into large multipurpose clinics or smaller one. There are both public and
private clinics (Pothos et al., 2014). A special category includes obstetric and
gynecological clinics operating in the private or public sector. According to ICAP
GROUP (2010) 13.7% of private health services are private gynecological clinics; the
market leader among obstetric clinics is IASO clinic holding a 37.7% of the market
share.
The purpose of this research is to examine the relationship between supervisors
and subordinates of the obstetric clinics sector and its impact on job satisfaction
and efficiency.
2. Research methodology
Due to the nature of this research, two separate questionnaires were designed. On
the one hand, 100 questionnaires were given to subordinates and 30 questionnaires
were given their supervisors.
The majority of the questions included in the questionnaires were closed
questions and used five-point Likert Scale.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STRATEGIC INNOVATIVE MARKETING
3
The sampling method which was used to achieve the research objectives is the
stratified sampling. Each strata was one of the five bigger obstetric clinics in Attica
(MITERA clinic, LITO clinic, ELENA clinic, ALEXANDRA clinic and REA clinic). The
sample percentage which was extracted was representative of the size of each clinic.
3. Research results
3.1. Demographics of the sample
From the sample of 100 employees who are subordinates and took part in the
survey, 22 were employed in MITERA clinic, the 17 employees in LITO clinic, the 19
employees in IASO clinic, 13 worked in ELENA clinic, 18 were employees in
ALEXANDRA clinic and 11 were working for REA clinic. The above data are
presented in Table 1.
Table 1. Demographics of 100 the subordinates
Demographics
Percentage
Obstetric Clinic
REA clinic
MITERA clinic
LITO clinic
IASO clinic
ELENA clinic
ALEXANDRA clinic
11%
22%
17%
19%
13%
18%
Gender
Male
Female
35%
65%
Age
26-30 years old
31-45 years old
46-60 years old
>61 years old
7%
36%
44%
13%
Current department
Nursing
Administrative
52%
48%
Years of working experience
<1 year
1-5 years
6-10 years
>10 years
13%
53%
21%
13%
Years of collaboration with current
supervisor
<1 year
1-5 years
6-10 years
>10 years
23%
54%
16%
7%
Based on the above table’s data, as far as the subordinates are concerned, we
can concluded that:
Women responded with almost twice number compared to men.
Age has a range of 26 to 45 years old.
The period time of working in the clinic, for the majority of respondents ranges
from 1 to 5 years.
The percentages of employees in the administrative and the nursing
departments are almost the same).
The majority of the respondents collaborate with their supervisor from 1 to 5
years.
SUPERVISORS AND SUBORDINATES RELATIONSHIP IMPACT ON JOB SATISFACTION AND
EFFICIENCY: THE CASE OF OBSTETRIC CLINICS IN GREECE
4
For the present research, a sample of 30 managers who worked in public and
private maternity hospitals in Attica was used. Specifically, 8 (26.7%) of them
worked for MITERA clinic, 6 (20%) for LITO clinic, 6 for REA clinic, 4 (13.3%) for
IASO clinic, 3 (10%) for ALEXANDRA clinic and finally 3 for ELENA clinic.
Table 2. Demographics of the 30 supervisors
Demographics
Percentage
Obstetric Clinic
REA clinic
MITERA clinic
LITO clinic
IASO clinic
ELENA clinic
ALEXANDRA clinic
20%
26,7%
20%
13,3%
10%
10%
Gender
Male
Female
47%
53%
Age
26-30 years old
31-45 years old
46-60 years old
>61 years old
10%
66,7%
20%
3,3%
Current department
Nursing
Administrative
Scientific
16,7%
46,7%
36,7%
Years of working experience
<1 year
1-5 years
6-10 years
>10 years
13%
53%
21%
13%
Years of working experience as a supervisor
<1 year
1-5 years
6-10 years
>10 years
16,7%
36,7%
23,3%
23,3%
3.2. Factors which influence job satisfaction and employee performance
According to the responses on the question about the extent to which the
relationship between supervisors and subordinates affects job satisfaction and
performance, it was found that this effect is the highest among all the other factors.
Business policies seem to have the least influence on job satisfaction and
employee performance. These results are compatible with the factors that cause
motivation for performance according to Herzberg’s motivation theory (1959).
The factor concerning the relationship with the supervisor (i.e the interpersonal
relationships that are developed between a supervisor and a subordinate) is a
promoter factor. In contrast, the factor which describes enterprise policies, namely
the way which a company is organized and managed, is a displeasure factor. On the
one hand they create resentment and they reduce job satisfaction when there aren’t
at work; on the other hand they don’t provide motivation for high performance.
Job description factors concerns the content of a job and the duties of an
employee; 32% of the respondents seem to be affected at a great extent while 6% of
them, very little.
The factors concerning job certainty and chances for development are the next
factors affecting performance according to the respondents.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STRATEGIC INNOVATIVE MARKETING
5
Furthermore, factors such as the feeling of a fair reward and the stress level
seem to be connected with employees’ motivation.
As job satisfaction and employee performance at the clinic are concerned, it was
revealed that the main factor affecting them is the relationship developed between
senior managers and employees. The factor which affects less these constructs is
this of business policies along with the culture of the clinic. The following table
shows the factors affecting job satisfaction and employee performance the most. The
results confirm Herzberg's motivation theory in the obstetric sector.
Table 3. Job satisfaction and performance
Mean
Std. Deviation
Business Policies
3,52
1,01
Stress Level and Daily Pressure
3,67
1,01
The feeling that you rewarded fairly
3,7
1,11
Chances for development
3,8
0,92
Job Certainty
3,83
1,02
Job Description
3,98
0,89
Relationship with the supervisor
4,04
0,98
3.3. he impact of subordinates and supervisors relationship elements on job
satisfaction and performance
In this section we will try to find the elements of the relationship between
subordinates and their supervisors impact on job satisfaction and performance.
According to the research results, the factors that affect the most job satisfaction
and performance concern the recognition of employees by their supervisors, the
open communication with them as well as the collaboration with them. The following
table shows the impact of subordinates and supervisors relationship elements on job
satisfaction and performance.
Table 4. Elements of the relationship between supervisor-subordinate
Mean
Std. Deviation
Encouragement to materialize innovative programs
3,36
1,07
The possibility for developing skills through the
participation to educational programs
3,56
1,02
The possibility for undertaking more activities
3,59
0,95
Sharing responsibilities
3,6
0,88
Opportunities for continuing vocational education
3,65
1,03
The ability of supervisor to motivate
3,68
0,99
Detailed description of tasks and obligations
3,75
0,86
Encouragement to undertake initiatives
3,76
0,79
Achieving goals with teamwork and common effort
3,83
0,95
Support in difficult issues
3,85
0,94
Employees flexibility in the department
3,87
0,76
Collaboration with supervisor
4,01
0,75
Open communication with supervisor
4,08
0,87
The recognition of work by the supervisor
4,19
0,77
SUPERVISORS AND SUBORDINATES RELATIONSHIP IMPACT ON JOB SATISFACTION AND
EFFICIENCY: THE CASE OF OBSTETRIC CLINICS IN GREECE
6
3.4. Supervisors’ “socialized power” motives impact on job performance
The respondents seem to be affected by specific factors of their supervisors’ behavior
that are originated from the so-called motives of “socialized power”.
Specifically, the highest percentage of the employees answered that equal
treatment and team spirit are the factors that influence them the most to improve
their work performance. On the contrary, factors such as the possibility of taking
initiatives and the assignment of more responsibilities seem to have a low influence
in the development of subordinates.
Table 5. The extent to which job performance is affected by “socialized power” motives
Mean
Std. Deviation
Equal treatment
4,32
0,82
Team spirit
4,31
0,84
Reward by supervisors
4,28
0,81
The possibility for development
4,12
0,84
The supervisor must understand employees’ personal
peculiarities
3,8
1,21
Possibility of undertaking initiatives
3,61
1,03
Assigning more activities
3,53
1,08
3.5. The relationship between subordinates and their supervisors
The questionnaire responded by the supervisors, was designed to collect data
concerning their opinions regarding subordinatesjob satisfaction and department’s
increasing efficiency.
The departments’ supervisors were asked if they believe that there is a
correlation between job satisfaction and employee efficiency. According to Jewell &
Siegall (1990), there is correlation between job satisfaction and employee
performance and especially, the most productive employees are more satisfied with
their work. 18 supervisors strongly agreed with the fact that there is a correlation
between job satisfaction and employee efficiency.
Furthermore, a 50% of supervisors strongly agreed with the fact that job
satisfaction is necessary for welfare in a clinic. According to Spector (2000), job
satisfaction significantly affects businesses prosperity and is presented through the
increased employee performance. It makes sense that a satisfied employee is a
productive employee.
Supervisors, who motivate subordinates are aimed to take responsibility, to
make efforts for achieving goals. From the responses of subordinates it was
confirmed that 67% of them strongly agree with the fact that a supervisors’ role
leads in job satisfaction and subordinate's increasing performance. Also, 29 out of
30 departments’ supervisors agreed with the fact that subordinates’ activation is a
concern for senior management and goals achievement depends on the cooperation
with human resources.
3.6. Elements contributing to a balanced relationship between subordinates and
their supervisors
At this point supervisors were asked to express their opinions on the factors
contributing to a balanced relationship with their subordinates.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STRATEGIC INNOVATIVE MARKETING
7
To begin with, a supervisor is necessary to be informed about the successes and
the failures of his department. With the above statement, a 73% of the respondents
strongly agreed while a 3% of them strongly disagreed. In this way a leader can
organize and utilize the knowledge and information that accrues to achieve his goal.
An important factor is trust. A 70% of supervisors strongly agreed with the need
for trust and honesty between both the subordinates and the supervisors. The
importance of trust between the members can give to employees’ greater job
satisfaction.
If every employee knows what he is capable to do, then all the work will have
successfully ended. A 33% of the supervisors strongly agreed with the fact that
that each subordinate should know his own needs and abilities.
The following table depicts the supervisors’ views on the elements contributing to
a balanced relationship between them and their subordinates.
Table 6. The extent to which job performance is affected by “socialized power” motives
Mean
Std. Deviation
The number of things a supervisor be should informed
about, depends on his mood and trust to his subordinates
3,13
1,50
A supervisor must externalize his desires and peculiarities
3,5
1,04
A subordinate depends on his supervisor
3,63
0,76
A subordinate must know the external pressures on
supervisor’s goals
3,66
1,15
A subordinate must see the positive side of work even he
accepts critical comments by his supervisor
3,76
0,97
A subordinate must control his reactions towards the
supervisor
4,1
0,76
Each subordinate must know his own needs and abilities
4,1
0,88
There should be trust and honesty between both members
4,53
0,90
A supervisor is necessary to be informed for the successes
and failures of his department
4,63
0,81
3.7. Factors of a balanced relationship between supervisors and subordinates
There is a number of constructs associated with the balanced relationship between
supervisors and their subordinates. Due to the large number of these constructs, a
factor analysis will be carried out, in order to categorize them.
According to Table 7 data, the examined variables were categorized into four
dimensions which represent mutual recognition of needs and pressures (F1), the
development of a climate of confidence (F2), conflict situations (F3) and, distinct
rights and obligations of subordinates and supervisors (F5) respectively.
Kaiser Meyer Olkin measure of sampling adequacy value equals to 0.722, and
Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity p-value equals to 0; the aforementioned values indicate
that the performed factor analysis is valid and reliable.
SUPERVISORS AND SUBORDINATES RELATIONSHIP IMPACT ON JOB SATISFACTION AND
EFFICIENCY: THE CASE OF OBSTETRIC CLINICS IN GREECE
8
Table 7. Components matrix for the factors of a balanced relationship between supervisors and
subordinates
F1
F2
F3
F4
A supervisor must externalize his desires and peculiarities
0.760
A subordinate must know the external pressures on
supervisor’s goals
0.730
Each subordinate must know his own needs and abilities
0.689
There should be trust and honesty between both members
0.817
A supervisor is necessary to be informed for the successes
and failures of his department
0.813
A subordinate must control his reactions towards the
supervisor
0.776
A subordinate must see the positive side of work even he
accepts critical comments by his supervisor
0.692
A subordinate depends on his supervisor
0.847
The number of things a supervisor be should informed
about, depends on his mood and trust to his subordinates
0.664
3.8. Factors affecting job satisfaction and employee performance
As already mentioned, the subordinates took part in the research were asked to
express their views on the extent to which their job satisfaction and performance is
affected by various constructs. A factor analysis will be used in order to categorize
these constructs.
Table 8. Components matrix for the factors affecting job satisfaction and employee performance
F1
F2
Business policies
0.788
Chances for development
0.770
Job certainty
0.692
The feeling of being rewarded fairly
0.676
Job description
0.668
Stress level and daily pressure
0.833
Relationship with the supervisor
0.679
According to Table 8 data, the examined variables were categorized into two
dimensions which represent workplace characteristics (F1) and, emotional factors
developed in the workplace (F2) respectively.
Kaiser Meyer Olkin measure of sampling adequacy value equals to 0.764, and
Bartlett’s Test of Sphericity p-value equals to 0; the aforementioned values indicate
that the performed factor analysis is valid and reliable.
3.9. The impact of working department on the relationship between supervisors
and subordinates
In this section we will compare how the basic guidance principles for a balanced
relationship between supervisors and subordinates are affected by the working
department on the clinic.
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STRATEGIC INNOVATIVE MARKETING
9
Using factor analysis results, we will compare the factors using an analysis of
variance (ANOVA) test. In order to run the ANOVA test we first have to confirm the
normality and the homogeneity of the data. Data normality is confirmed by the
Kolmogorov-Smirnov test as the p-value is equal to 0.410; likewise, data
homogeneity is confirmed by Levene’s test as the p-value is equal to 0.390 which
means that equal variances are assumed. These results confirm that an ANOVA test
can be carried out.
According to Table 9 data no differences between employees in nursing and
administrative departments on the relationship factors with their supervisors are
recorded (p-values > 0.05).
Table 9. ANOVA table for balanced relationship factors
Sum of Squares
df
Mean Square
F
Sig.
Mutual recognition of roles and
perspectives
Between
Groups
1.753
1
1.753
1.766
0.187
Within
Groups
97.247
98
.992
Total
99.000
99
Development of a climate
confidence in the range of a
labor equity
Between
Groups
0.006
1
.006
0.006
0.938
Within
Groups
98.994
98
1.010
Total
99.000
99
Facing conflict situations by
establishing of a framework
Between
Groups
0.619
1
.619
0.617
0.434
Within
Groups
98.381
98
1.004
Total
99.000
99
Institutional framework with
distinct rights and obligations of
subordinates and supervisors
Between
Groups
0.895
1
.895
0.894
0.347
Within
Groups
98.105
98
1.001
Total
99.000
99
3.10. The impact of gender on the factors affecting job satisfaction and employee
performance
Gender is one of the most important variables associated with job satisfaction.
Certainly, there are different sources of satisfaction for both genders. For women,
these factors can be interpersonal relationships, fair supervisor or the interest for
their work. On the other hand, factors affecting job satisfaction and employee
performance of men can be the climate of confidence and self-recognition (Schultz &
Schultz, 1994; Spector, 2000). Al Zuhani & Kishk (2006) found that women appear
to be more dissatisfied with their jobs because they are experiencing intense conflict
between their personal and professional lives. According to Vaskova (2006), women
seem to be affected from emotional factors of the working environment such as
fairness, interpersonal relationships and relationships with their supervisor, unlike
men, who are more affected by job characteristics such as fair payments and
advancement opportunities.
SUPERVISORS AND SUBORDINATES RELATIONSHIP IMPACT ON JOB SATISFACTION AND
EFFICIENCY: THE CASE OF OBSTETRIC CLINICS IN GREECE
10
Using an ANOVA we will examine if there is a difference on how the factors
affecting job satisfaction and employee performance between men and women. The
statistical tests carried out show that the data are normally distributed and
homogeneous; thus an ANOVA test can be performed.
Data in Table 10 show that, compatibly with the aforementioned researchers’
results, there are statistically significant differences between men and women.
However, these differences concern only the factor of workplace characteristics (p-
value = 0.037).
Figure 1 shows that men are more positive than women which means that
women’s job satisfaction and performance are affected more than these of men by
the workplace characteristics.
Table 10. ANOVA table for the factors affecting job satisfaction and employee performance
Sum of Squares
df
Mean Square
F
Sig.
Workplace characteristics
Between
Groups
4.329
1
4.329
4.481
0.037
Within
Groups
94.671
98
.996
Total
99.000
99
Emotional factors developed in
the workplace
Between
Groups
0.692
1
0.692
0.690
0.408
Within
Groups
98.308
98
1.003
Total
99.000
99
Figure 1. Means plot for the differences on workplace characteristics factor by gender.
4. Conclusions and agenda for future research
The research results show that in modern obstetric clinics a balanced relationship
between supervisors and subordinates is ascertained despite the working
department. Trust and honesty should prevail between them.
According to the statistical analysis carried out, the subordinates’ responses
show that their job satisfaction and performance are eventually affected by the
relationship that is developed between them and their supervisors. Furthermore, the
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF STRATEGIC INNOVATIVE MARKETING
11
supervisors responses showed that the achievement of corporate goals and the
welfare of the clinic are influenced by the relationship between them and their
subordinates as well.
The second conclusion can be drawn is that the about the behavioral features of
a supervisor may influence the effectiveness of a department. Three are the most
important behavioral features with the highest effect namely, the rewards for a great
performance, the recognition of an excellent service and the use of development
inspection method by monitoring the work of each employee. Moreover, employees
seem to be efficient when they enjoy the favors of their supervisors.
Concerning the examination of the extent to which the motivation of socialized
power leads in subordinatesdevelopment, it was revealed that equal treatment and
team spirit affect employees in obstetric clinics the most. Thus, supervisors should
take seriously into account this finding as it is important for the success of their
departments.
Furthermore, the research results show that the existence of honesty and trust
contribute to a balanced relationship between a subordinate and a supervisor. This
was confirmed by both the subordinates and the supervisors.
Moreover, it should be noted that the assignment of activities is particularly a
negative factor that constricts the increase of employee performance. The most likely
reason is the pressure and anxiety that exists in health sector which makes
employees negative in undertaking more duties.
Based on the research results there are several avenues for further research. The
investigation of the relationship between supervisors and subordinates should be
carried out not only in health care industry but also in others. A comparison
between obstetric clinics sector and other sectors of health care industry would to
useful results which could be used for example in the administration of general
clinics operating various departments. Last but not least, a comparison between
public and private clinic would be useful as well.
References
[1] Chalikias, M., Kyriakopoulos, G., Skordoulis, M. & Koniordos, M. (2014).
Knowledge management for business processes: employees’ recruitment and
human resources’ selection: a combined literature review and a case study. In:
Communications in Computer and Information Science. 466: Knowledge-Based
Software Engineering: Proceedings of 11th Joint Conference on Knowledge-Based
software Engineering - JCKBSE, Eds., Kravets et al. Volgograd, September 2014.
Switzerland: Springer International Publishing, pp. 505-520.
[2] DeMato D.S. (2004). Job satisfaction of elementary school counselors: A new look,
Professional School Counseling, 7, 236-245.
[3] Drosos, D., Tsotsolas, N., Zagga, A., Chalikias, M. & Skordoulis, M. (2015).
Multicriteria satisfaction analysis application in the health care sector. In:
Proceedings of the 7th International Conference on ICT in Agriculture, Food and
Environment (HAICTA 2015). Kavala, September 2015. Athens: HAICTA, pp. 737-
754.
[4] Herzberg, F., Mausner, B. & Snyderman, B.B. (1959). The motivation to work. NY:
John Wileyand Sons Inc.
[5] Jewell, L.N. & Siegall, M (1990). Contemporary industrial and organizational
psychology. 2nd edition. MI: West Publishing Company.
[6] Kreither R. & Kinicki A. (2010). Organizational Behavior. 9th edition. NY: McGraw
Hill.
[7] Pothos, N., Skordoulis, M. & Chalikias, M. (2014). Study of the Greek public
servants’ healthcare and insurance organisation financial resources evolution.
Management in Health. 18, 1 33-37.
SUPERVISORS AND SUBORDINATES RELATIONSHIP IMPACT ON JOB SATISFACTION AND
EFFICIENCY: THE CASE OF OBSTETRIC CLINICS IN GREECE
12
[8] Schultz, P. & Schultz, E. (1994). Psychology and work today. 6th edition. NY:
McMillan.
[9] Skordoulis, M., Chalikias, M. & Koniordos, M. (2014). Students’ satisfaction
through DREEM and LOT-R. In: Communications in Computer and Information
Science. 466: Knowledge-Based Software Engineering: Proceedings of 11th Joint
Conference on Knowledge-Based software Engineering - JCKBSE, Eds., Kravets et
al. Volgograd, September 2014. Switzerland: Springer International Publishing,
pp. 113-122.
[10] Skordoulis, M., Chalikias, M. & Koniordos, M. (2015). Staff recruitment process
and methods: the case of the mobile telephony industry in Greece. In:
Communications in Computer and Information Science. 535: Proceedings of
Creativity in Intelligent Technologies & Data Science Conference, Eds., Kravets
et al. Volgograd, September 2015. Switzerland: Springer International
Publishing, pp. 292-306.
[11] Spector, P.E. (1997). Job satisfaction: application, assessment, cause and
consequences. London: Sage Publications.
[12] Spector, P.E. (2000) Industrial & Organizational Psychology: Research and
Practice. 2nd edition. NY: John Wiley & Sons Inc.
[13] Valvi A. & Frangos K. (2009). Is employee productivity associated with job
satisfaction? Review of Job Relations. 53, 83-90. (In Greek).
[14] Vaskova, R. (2006). Gender differences in performance motivation. European
Observatory of Working Life. Available at: http://www.eurofound.europa.eu/
observatories/eurwork/articles/gender-differences-in-performance-motivation
(last accessed 12 September, 2016).
[15] Vroom, V.H. (1964). Work and Motivation. NY: John Wiley and Sons Inc.
... Employee performance in the job is of great importance, especially in relation to maintaining and growing productivity for organizations (Conway, 2006). Tsitmideli et al. (2016) similarly support Conway (2006) that job performance for an employee is one of the most crucial factors for sustaining and increasing production for organizations. However, poor relationships with managers can lead to employee stress, demotivation, counter-productivity, and poor performance. ...
... Furthermore, human capital is posited to be one of the most critical resources for organizational success. Hence, employee satisfaction should be considered a key factor by managers (Tsitmideli et al., 2016). Considering this, it becomes critical and beneficial for managers to promote good employee relations while also understanding the types of employee-manager relations aligned with employee job performance. ...
... Considering this, it becomes critical and beneficial for managers to promote good employee relations while also understanding the types of employee-manager relations aligned with employee job performance. Tsitmideli et al. (2016) continue to discuss the actions assumed by both the administration and managers to sustain high employee satisfaction in order that they act/behave in a certain way. In addition, highly motivated employees can achieve higher levels of productivity and job satisfaction. ...
Article
Full-text available
Organizational performance can be seen as dependent on employee job performance and productivity. One of the factors that influence employee job performance and productivity is the working relationship between employees and their managers. This paper examines the influence of the relationship between employees and their managers on enhancing employee performance and productivity. The study was conducted in a financial organization based in Durban (South Africa). A quantitative approach was utilized with a census method targeting a total population of 40 administrative employees. A questionnaire was constructed based on the research aims and was administered to all 40 respondents. As a result, the response rate was 65%. Key findings indicated that the relationship between managers and employees did affect employee performance and productivity. A positive relationship with a manager is closely linked to increased motivation and performance, while a negative relationship is linked with poor performance. An overall negative impact and high level of dissatisfaction amongst employees were found due to the current bureaucratic management style that managers adopt in their organization. Thus, it makes employees less productive and decreases their work performance. Furthermore, it was found that employees’ perception of their relationship with managers plays a significant role in predicting job performance. Recommendations for a better working relationship to promote employee performance and productivity include manager-employee training, team building activities, skills development programs for managers, employee rewards and recognition, increased communication platforms, and more consideration for employee well-being.
... Hence, it is reasonable to claim that only when the immediate supervisor understood, provided praise for good work, showed personal interest, and listened to their employee opinions that the workers' job satisfaction level would increase. (Babin & Boles, 1996;Singh & Pestonjee, 1974;Raziq & Maulabakhsh, 2015;Tsitmideli et al., 2016). were included within the measure of employees' job satisfaction. ...
... Consequently, to improve employee's job satisfaction, supervisor should concentrate more on this aspect. This result ties well with previous studies about the job satisfaction for the worker (Babin & Boles, 1996;Raziq & Maulabakhsh, 2015;Singh & Pestonjee, 1974;Patricia Cain Smith, 1969;Spector, 1985;Tsitmideli et al., 2016;Weiss et al., 1967). However, the results of this study are not consistent with Saeed et al. (2013) suggesting that supervisors have weak impact on job satisfaction of the employees. ...
Article
Full-text available
To maintain and develop in the fast-growing world nowadays, the roles of white-collar officers is crucially significant as well as the necessity of properly understanding their job motivations – which could beneficially influence the economic growth of one's company, or nation. Thus, this study examined elements that could affect employees' motivation in working, and whether those factors would have any significant impacts on the overall job satisfaction levels of work. The convenience sampling was used to collect data from 2409 white-collar officers in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam (including 1159 males and 1250 females). In this study, descriptive statistics, reliability statistics, factor analysis, and multiple-regression are exercised as statistical tools. The results indicated that the working environment, job characteristics, promotion opportunities, salary, coworkers, and supervisors are positively associated with the white-collar officers' job satisfaction. Especially, the collected findings suggested that white-collar officers, in Ho Chi Minh City context, were mostly determined by supervisory factors in work satisfaction. Therefore, the management of corporations should focus on these factors to enhance higher job satisfaction, organizational efficiency, and employee retention. The results could be a useful suggestion for implication in developing management strategies, especially for Vietnamese corporations.
... Hence, it is reasonable to claim that only when the immediate supervisor understood, provided praise for good work, showed personal interest, and listened to their employee opinions that the workers' job satisfaction level would increase. (Babin & Boles, 1996;Singh & Pestonjee, 1974;Raziq & Maulabakhsh, 2015;Tsitmideli et al., 2016). were included within the measure of employees' job satisfaction. ...
... Consequently, to improve employee's job satisfaction, supervisor should concentrate more on this aspect. This result ties well with previous studies about the job satisfaction for the worker (Babin & Boles, 1996;Raziq & Maulabakhsh, 2015;Singh & Pestonjee, 1974;Patricia Cain Smith, 1969;Spector, 1985;Tsitmideli et al., 2016;Weiss et al., 1967). However, the results of this study are not consistent with Saeed et al. (2013) suggesting that supervisors have weak impact on job satisfaction of the employees. ...
Article
To maintain and develop in the fast-growing world nowadays, the roles of white-collar officers is crucially significant as well as the necessity of properly understanding their job motivations - which could beneficially influence the economic growth of one's company, or nation. Thus, this study examined elements that could affect employees' motivation in working, and whether those factors would have any significant impacts on the overall job satisfaction levels of work. The convenience sampling was used to collect data from 2409 white-collar officers in Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam (including 1159 males and 1250 females). In this study, descriptive statistics, reliability statistics, factor analysis, and multiple-regression are exercised as statistical tools. The results indicated that the working environment, job characteristics, promotion opportunities, salary, co-workers, and supervisors are positively associated with the white-collar officers' job satisfaction. Especially, the collected findings suggested that white-collar officers, in Ho Chi Minh City context, were mostly determined by supervisory factors in work satisfaction. Therefore, the management of corporations should focus on these factors to enhance higher job satisfaction, organizational efficiency, and employee retention. The results could be a useful suggestion for implication in developing management strategies, especially for Vietnamese corporations.
... Regression outcomes depict that the relationship with the superiors has a positive coefficient which affects for the rise of employee motivation to perform routine work in the organization. It was confirmed by the study that the supervisors and subordinate's relationship have an impact on job satisfaction and efficiency: the case of obstetric clinics in Greece conducted by Tsitmideli, Skordoulis, Chalikias, Sidiropoulos, & Papagrigoriou (2016). Analysis shows that there is no significant relationship between employee motivation and work environment, rewards and incentives and teamwork. ...
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The Human Resource Information System of a reputed organization of Sri Lanka revealed that the executive staff was less motivated in performing their routine operations. The situation has escalated issues in terms of efficiency and high employee turnover of the organization. Therefore, this study was designed to identify the drivers of employee motivation among executive staff members with respect to both organizational and demographic factors. Primary data obtained from a simple random sample of 67 employees via a semi-structured questionnaire were analysed using descriptive statistical techniques, a multivariate multiple regression model and a binary logistic regression model. Results revealed that age, gender, educational level, distance from workplace and additional income sources as key demographic drivers of employee motivation. In addition, organizational factors such as work environment, responsibility, rewards and incentives, promotions, teamwork, relationship with superiors, job safety and security, significantly affect the employee motivation. Furthermore, the study recognized enhancing employee responsibility as a vital intervention. Increased power sharing for accurate managerial decision making and reformations to the existing reward structure to enable an optimistic comfortable work environment are recommended to be improved in the organization. Followed by the recommended improvements on the employees, the extent of motivation can be compared in future studies.
... From the results of this study, we can interpret that somehow employees' productivity level can be increased through good and effective relationships with supervisors which is proposed in this research study. According to Tsitmideli et al. (2016), the main factor that affects the productivity of employees is the relationship developed between the supervisor and their subordinates. It was observed by another author that effective supervision in the workplace can enhance the productivity and quality of the employees and for effective supervision; there must be a good supervisorsubordinates relationship in the concerned organisation (Omisore, 2014). ...
Article
Full-text available
This study strived to examine the management of boss-subordinate relationship that has its own effects on the commitment of the workforce of the banking sector in Rivers State, Nigeria. Poor management of boss-subordinate relationships breeds a poor work climate as well as contributes to the loss of employees’ commitment to organisational goals. Adopting a cross-sectional survey design, this study covered all the permanent employees of the banking sector and 10 banks were conveniently sampled from the 22 operating banks in the state with a total population of 210 permanent employees. The Krejcie and Morgan sample determination table was used to derive 136 respondents. Data gathered from the respondents were analysed using the Pearson Product Moment Correlation Coefficient Statistical tools. The test of moderating effect of organisational culture on boss-subordinate relationship management as well as employee commitment in the banking sector. The findings from the results of tests and data analyses revealed strong positive relationships between the dimensions of boss-subordinate relationship management and the measures of employee commitment in the banking sector and therefore recommended that complementary communication, empathy, leadership support and organisational mentorship should be taken seriously as tools for managing the boss-subordinate relationship and also that good organisational culture should be created and promoted to enhance employees commitment in the banking sector in Rivers State.
... From the results of this study, we can interpret that somehow employees' productivity level can be increased through good and effective relationships with supervisors which is proposed in this research study. According to Tsitmideli et al. (2016), the main factor that affects the productivity of employees is the relationship developed between the supervisor and their subordinates. It was observed by another author that effective supervision in the workplace can enhance the productivity and quality of the employees and for effective supervision; there must be a good supervisorsubordinates relationship in the concerned organisation (Omisore, 2014). ...
... Scott (2017) suggested that the boss should listen the ISSN: 0972-3641 UGC CARE APPROVED JOURNAL performance (Munoz-Doyague & Nieto, 2011). A high-quality relationship developed between supervisor and their subordinates is a crucial way for boosting the performance of the employees (Awan & Tahir, 2015;Tsitmideli et al., 2016;Conway, 2018;Zuchowski & Brelik, 2017) and supervisor's leadership style strongly related to the subordinates' performance (Gautam & Malla, 2013;Thisera, 2013). Result of another study Kuzua & Ozilhan (2014) shows that the degree of employees' relationships with the employee-performance is 45%. ...
... From the results of this study we can interpreted that somehow employees' productivity level can be increase through good an effective relationship with supervisor which is proposed in this research study. According to Tsitmideli et al. (2016) the main factors that affect the productivity of the employees is the relationship developed between the supervisor and their subordinates. It was observed by another author that an effective supervision in the workplace can enhance the productivity and quality of the employees and for an effective supervision; there must be a good supervisor-subordinates relationship in the concerned organization (Omisore, 2014). ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper seeks to investigate the dimensions of effectiveness of 'boss-subordinate relationship', to propose a model that logically relates the boss-subordinate relationship with the employees' productivity having the appropriate place of 'work-life balance', to examine the role of demographic variables in the above said relationships, and to obtain the directions for future research. With the descriptive research design the researchers of the current study proposed a model, which has been substantiated through the output model of ISM (Interpretive Structural Modelling) mechanism. The vary milieu of the ISM mechanism is the opinions of the experts and reviews of available literature. The above facts build upon the justified relationships among the variables that are established in the output model. The said output model (diagraph) is attesting the interrelationship among the variables of the study. This study has taken a broad look at the boss-subordinate relationship. Researchers of this study are trying to justify the importance of effective boss-subordinate relationship to enhance the employees' productivity with the clarity in roles of demographic variables. The contribution/originality of this study is reflected by antecedents of boss-subordinate relationships that lead to employees' productivity by the mediating role of 'work-life balance'.
Article
Full-text available
Of late, it has been found that many organizations adopt merger and acquisition as a strategy for external expansion or growth. There are various rationale for adopting this strategy of expansion. Among the major factors that drive M&A, certain factors such as strategic similarities, product portfolio, organizational culture, management team, resource base as well as due diligence are very important for the success of a M&A program. From literature review, it could be found that the M&A program has been adopted by many organizations to promote the performance of the company. For achieving this objective, the employees of the post-merged entity should be motivated and their organizational commitment should be high. If they are motivated and the commitment is high, they will continue with the post-merged entity. On the other hand, if the newly formed post-merged entity fails to promote the motivation and organizational commitment, it can lead to lower employee performance, higher level of absenteeism and high rate of labor turnover. The study is an attempt to explore the impact of M&A on employee satisfaction and organizational commitment and its ultimate impact on employee retention by the post-merged entity. The study was conducted by considering the M&A of certain leading higher educational institutions in a country like United Arab Emirates
Conference Paper
Full-text available
During the last decades the interest of health scientists has been increasingly focused on patients' needs, the quality of the services offered and the satisfaction level from the available health care. The measurement and evaluation of patient satisfaction is a milestone for the improvement of the services provided – procedures, given that these results can provide a useful variety of information and data that will lead to a high level of health services. For the purpose of this project the results presented concern a measurement of the satisfaction level of patients treated by the Greek Red Cross and more specifically by a service called " Nursing at home ". For the collection of the data, questionnaires were used in order to better record the patients' views on the health care service overall as well as their satisfaction levels on particular aspects of the service. The analysis of the results has been based on the multicriteria MUSA method, which is part of the wider category of aggregation-disaggregation approach and is based on the principles of qualitative analysis regression.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The purpose of this study is to examine the staff attraction and selection methods emphasizing the mobile telephony firms in Greece. Staff attraction and selection are fundamental processes for modern organizations. Data from 421 questionnaires answered by people employed in the three major mobile telephony firms in Greece have been statistically analysed. The statistical analysis revealed that the most widely used way of applicants attraction is through newspapers. On the contrary the least used way it through the social media. Yet, the analysis showed that employees consider the interview as most the most appropriate selection method. The employees agree with both attraction and selection methods used by the examined firms. As far as the motives are concerned, the most important is the meet of the employees’ expectations, while the least important is the prestige of the position. The study of the research results shows that the mobile telephony firms operating in Greece should continue to use interviews as the major staff selection method. As for the staff attraction methods, the examined firms may have to focus a bit more on the use of social media such as LinkedIn. These results may be used by the human resources managers in the staff attraction and selection process.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Nowadays many businesses have been focused on the recruitment and selection of the appropriate employees, in order to deploy their entrepreneurial activities. Besides, on the employees’ behalf, the increased competitiveness in a worldwide level of analysis necessitates that all employees to be facilitated with advanced capabilities throughout the organizational hierarchy. In effect, these businesses adopt and develop contemporary processes for their employees’ recruitment and selection, in order to ensure increased productivity and effectiveness in a liquefied economic environment. The development of appropriate schemes of selection and recruitment, in line to the ongoing and in-field investment of education, skills and training, are determining factors to the prosperity of manufacturing industry. The ultimate goal of knowledge management in a strategic, innovative, and operational level of decision making is the achievement of greater awareness of the interactive role of science, engineering, and technology towards businesses’ success, as well as the development of flexible organizational structures that encourage entrepreneurial creativity, structural flexibility, and managerial change. In the present study, the determining parameters of employees’ recruitment and human resources’ selection are presented in a literature overview, while the inclusion of a Case Study –being based on an innovative-oriented pharmaceutical company– reveal this company’s prominent role of identifying new markets and opportunities that might emerge and then choosing to respond to these long-term visions by activating its competitive advantages in a Management-Technology-Strategy tripartite pattern, rather than being forced into action by competitors (paper range: pp. 505-520).
Article
Full-text available
The contemporary perception about the social insurance role in the health system, considers this sector of social insurance as an important sector for the economic growth. Numeric data on the costs of pharmaceutical care, medical care, and diagnostic examinations have been recorded throughout the period between 2003 and 2008 for the whole country and have been classified by region. The statistical analysis conclusions found a disproportionate growth in the medical and pharmaceutical cost has been observed compared to the number of the insured public servants. Moreover, a growth on the healthcare cost has been recorded between 2003 and 2008; this growth is a result of the medical and pharmaceutical care costs rise.
Article
The purpose of this study was to investigate the current job satisfaction level of elementary school counselors in Virginia and compare the results with counselors surveyed in 1988 and 1995. A demographic data form and the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire were completed by 301 counselors to measure their job satisfaction level. Results indicated that counselors surveyed in 2001 were satisfied with their jobs, however, overall job satisfaction decreased during the past decade.