ArticlePDF Available

Preventative Dentistry Delivery to Children in Rural Communities in the United States

Authors:

Abstract

New models in the delivery of healthcare such as mobile clinics, retail clinics, and telehealth have helped to bring care to patients who might not otherwise receive care due to geographic limitations. Such alternatives may help to address the need for dental care in rural communities in the United States. In addition to these solutions, dental therapists can increase the available provider base to deliver preventative dental services to children. © 2016 Dental Hypotheses | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow.
Preventative Dentistry Delivery to Children in Rural
Communities in the United States
Lauren K. Dulieu
School of Dental Medicine, University of Connecticut, Farmington, Connecticut, USA
Abstract
New models in the delivery of healthcare such as mobile clinics, retail clinics, and telehealth have helped to bring care to patients who might
not otherwise receive care due to geographic limitations. Such alternatives may help to address the need for dental care in rural communities in
the United States. In addition to these solutions, dental therapists can increase the available provider base to deliver preventative dental
services to children.
Key words: Dental therapists, mobile clinic, preventative dentistry, retail clinic, teledentistry
INTRODUCTION
There are only approximately 5000 practicing pediatric dentists
in the United States.
[1]
The limited number of pediatric dentists
and their high concentration in populated areas often implies
that children living outside these areas, i.e., rural areas,
encounter barriers in access to even rudimentary and
preventative dental care. The most significant of these
barriers are the very miles of travel necessary to reach a
dental office.
[2]
Solving the problem of access for these
children should be a priority for organized dentistry because
it has been shown that early preventative dental services are
highly effective in controlling and preventing tooth decay. In
light of the provider shortage and the vast geographic areas that
need to be covered, it is crucialto consider innovative options to
care for these children. This article will review some novel
alternatives to bring preventative dental care closer to children
living in rural areas.
MOBILE DENTAL CLINICS
A mobile dental clinic (MDC) is a vehicle, usually a van,
outfitted with a complete dental operatory including a dental
chair, lights, sterilization equipment, and other equipment to
perform dental procedures. The primary goal of an MDC is to
provide care to rural communities where dental care may not be
readily accessible. Ultimately, the premise isthat, if the patient
cannot travel to the dental office, the dental office can travel to
the patient. Care providers staffing an MDC often include
dentists, hygienists, and dental students who deliver services
ranging from restorative to preventative care.
[3]
One of the most
prominent applications of MDCs is to provide care to school
children in rural locations. Vans often supply children with
dental supplies and informational brochures with oral hygiene
instructions. In addtion, children may receive oral exams,
cleanings, radiographs, fluoride varnish applications, and
sealants as preventative services. By bringing care to school
children, mobile dental clinics serve as an innovative method
for servicing rural populations in providing both preventative
and restorative care.
RETAIL CLINICS
Retail clinics allow patients to walk inat any time for care
because they are conveniently located and associated with the
pharmacies of major retail stores in the United States. Retail
clinics serve to bring healthcare to patients who may not have
access to a dentist due to geographic barriers. Each medical retail
clinic is staffed by physician assistants and nurse practitioners
who provide a variety of healthcare services. The scope of
practice for these providers includes the diagnosis, treatment,
Address for correspondence: Ms. Lauren Kathryn Dulieu, University of
Connecticut School of Dental Medicine, Connecticut, USA.
E-mail: dulieu@uchc.edu
This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 License, which allows others to remix,
tweak, and build upon the work noncommercially, as long as the author is
credited and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.
For reprints contact: reprints@medknow.com
How to cite this article: Dulieu LK. Preventative dentistry delivery to
children in rural communities in the United States. Dent Hypotheses
2016;7:160-1.
Access this article online
Quick Response Code:
Website:
www.dentalhypotheses.com
DOI:
10.4103/2155-8213.195979
Student Forum
160 ©2016 Dental Hypotheses | Published by Wolters Kluwer - Medknow
[Downloaded free from http://www.dentalhypotheses.com on Thursday, January 05, 2017, IP: 192.30.84.249]
and prescription for common illnesses; vaccinations, treatment
of skin, and musculoskeletal conditions; routine lab tests; and
wellness services including counseling and school physical
exams. Retail clinics do not currently include dental care, but
opening these clinics to involve dental providers could increase
access and overall oral healthcare for children living in rural
areas. Since retail clinics have gained popularity in medicine and
minor health needs are met, primary care physicians will be able
to treat more medically complicated conditions.
[4]
TELEDENTISTRY
Like telephones allow people to communicate from two different
locations, teledentistry allows dentists and patients to connect
over long distances. Telehealth helps to reduce healthcare
disparities for rural populations by eliminating distance as a
barrier to care. There are currently three different categories
of teledentistry, namely, store and forward,”“real-time
consultation,and remote monitoring.
[5]
Store and forward
allows for exchange of clinical information between providers to
aid in treatment planning and consults. This method would be
useful to ensure that patients in rural communities maintain a
virtual record of their care from providers through mobile dental
vans or clinics. Real-time consultationinvolves video
conferencing between providers such that a provider working
in a clinic could directly consult an overseeing dentist at the
time of treatment. Remote monitoringallows dentists to
monitor patients in hospitals or homes situated in remote
locations. Remote conferencing would allow patients to
consult with distant practicing dentists from their own home.
With advances in technology, the development of camera
attachments for mobile phones, tablets, and other com-
munication devices could allow consulting dentists to better
assess patient needs and create treatment plans. Teledentistry
has demonstrated the value of intraoral cameras and teledentistry
in pediatrics and preventative dentistry as a means of screening
high risk children for caries.
[6]
Unfortunately, telehealth still raises
concerns from a legal perspective and licensure for both
physicians and dentists consulting with patients across state
lines. The benefit of telehealth for patients is also great for
these concerns to not be addressed in the future.
DENTAL THERAPISTS
Dental therapists provide a level of intermediate care that may
include preventative and restorative services that can benefit
patients and dentists. Unlike much of the western world, the
practice of dentistry by dental therapists in the United States
remains controversial. The American Dental Association
(ADA) opposes dental therapists performing surgical or
irreversible procedures which include drilling or extracting
teeth.
[7]
Controversy aside, it is estimated that, in the United
States, there are roughly 75 million children which equates to
approximately 15000 children for every 1 pediatric dentist.
[8]
The supply providers is inadequate to meet the demand and
dental therapists can fill this unmet need. Even though services
of dental therapists may be limited to preventative services that
include prophylaxes, fluoride varnish applications, screenings,
radiographs, sealants, and diet counseling. By taking
preventative action in early childhood, the overall dental
health and hygiene of these individuals would be signifi
cantly improved later in life. Therapists could help to triage
more complicated cases and consult with either a local dentist
overseeingthe practice or a distant dentistusing teledentistry. In
addition, dental therapists could help children become more
comfortable with a dental care provider that has the potential to
improve cooperation in the dental setting. This would lessenthe
stress on dentists and may increase care by general dentists
when pediatric dentists are not available.
DISCUSSION
A combination of mobile dental clinics, teledentistry, retail
clinics, and dental therapists could serve as one of the most
promising solutions in addressing the lack of pediatric dental
care in rural areas of the United States. Mobile dental clinics
and retail clinics through retail pharmacies (such as CVS or
Walmart) could provide the opportunity for dental care in
rural areas that may not readily have access to dental offices.
Dental therapists could then staff either mobile dental clinics
or retail clinics. Preventative services could include
preventative services such as prophylaxes, fluoride varnish,
sealants, diet counseling, and radiographs, which have all
been shown to improve the oral health of children. Finally,
teledentistry could connect dentists, dental therapists, and
patients in offices, retail clinics, or MDCs.
Financial support and sponsorship
Nil.
Conflicts of interest
There are no conflicts of interest.
REFERENCES
1. Kerins C, Casamassimo PS, Ciesla D, Lee Y, Seale NS. A preliminary
analysis of the US dental health care systems capacity to treat children
with special health care needs. Pediatr Dent 2011;33:107-12.
2. ADA News CDC: Childrens preventative dental care effective, use
low. Available from: http://www.ada.org/en/publications/ada-news/2014-
archive/september/cdc-childrens-preventive-dental-care-effective-use-low
[Last accessed on 2016 Aug 8].
3. Ganavadiya R, Chandrashekar B, Goel P, Hongal S, Jain M. Mobile and
portable dental services catering to the basic oral health needs of the
underserved population in developing countries: A proposed model. Ann
Med Health Sci Res 2014;4:293-304.
4. Laws M, Scott MK. The emergence of retail-based clinics in the United
States: Early observations. Health Affairs 2008;27:1293-8.
5. Jampani ND, Nutalapati R, Dontula BS, Boyapati R. Applications of
Teledentistry: A literature review and update. J Int Soc Prev Community
Dent 2011;1:37-44.
6. Kopycka-Kedzierawski DT, Billings RJ. Teledentistry in inner-city
child care centres. J Telemed Telecare 2006;12:176-81.
7. American Dental Association Statement on Accrediting Dental
Therapy Education Programs. Available from: http://www.ada.org/
en/press-room/news-releases/ 2015 archive/august/american-dental-
association-statement-on-accrediting-dental-therapy-education-programs
[Last accessed on 2016 Aug 8].
8. Mertz E, Mouradian W. Addressing childrens oral health in the new
millennium: Trends in the dental workforce. Acad Pediatr 2009;9:433.
Dulieu: Preventative dentistry in rural communities in the U.S
Dental Hypotheses ¦ Oct-Dec 2016 ¦ Volume 7 ¦ Issue 4 161
[Downloaded free from http://www.dentalhypotheses.com on Thursday, January 05, 2017, IP: 192.30.84.249]
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
Article
Full-text available
India is the second most populous country in the world with an extensive rural population (68.8%). Children less than 18 years constitute about 40% of the population. Approximately, 23.5% of the urban population resides in urban slums. The extensive rural population, school children and the urban slum dwellers are denied of even the basic dental services though there is continuous advancement in the field of dentistry. The dentist to population ratio has dramatically improved in the last one to two decades with no significant improvement in the oral health status of the general population. The various studies have revealed an increasing trend in oral diseases in the recent times especially among this underserved population. Alternate strategies have to be thought about rather than the traditional oral health-care delivery through private dentists on fee for service basis. Mobile and portable dental services are a viable option to take the sophisticated oral health services to the doorsteps of the underserved population. The databases were searched for publications from 1900 to the present (2013) using terms such as Mobile dental services, Portable dental services and Mobile and portable dental services with key articles obtained primarily from MEDLINE. This paper reviews the published and unpublished literature from different sources on the various mobile dental service programs successfully implemented in some developed and developing countries. Though the mobile and portable systems have some practical difficulties like financial considerations, they still seem to be the only way to reach every section of the community in the absence of national oral health policy and organized school dental health programs in India. The material for the present review was obtained mainly by searching the biomedical databases for primary research material using the search engine with key words such as mobile and/or portable dental services in developed and developing countries (adding each of these terms in a sequential order). Based on the review of the programs successfully implemented in developed countries, we propose a model to cater to the basic oral health needs of an extensive underserved population in India that may be pilot tested. The increasing dental manpower can best be utilized for the promotion of oral health through mobile and portable dental services. The professional dental organizations should have a strong motive to translate this into reality.
Article
Full-text available
Teledentistry is a combination of telecommunications and dentistry involving the exchange of clinical information and images over remote distances for dental consultation and treatment planning. Teledentistry has the ability to improve access to oral healthcare, improve the delivery of oral healthcare, and lower its costs. It also has the potential to eliminate the disparities in oral health care between rural and urban communities. This article reviews the origin, rationale, scope, basis, and requirements for teledentistry, along with the current evidence that exists in the literature. This article also reviews the ethical and legal issues related to the practice of teledentistry and the future of this alternative and innovative method of delivering dental care.
Article
The purpose of this study was to use existing data to determine capacity of the US dental care system to treat children with special health care needs (CSHCN). A deductive analysis using recent existing data was used to determine the: possible available appointments for CSHCN in hospitals and educational programs/institutions; and the ratio of CSHCN to potential available and able providers in the United States sorted by 6 American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry (AAPD) districts. Using existing data sets, this analysis found 57 dental schools, 61 advanced education in general dentistry programs, 174 general practice residencies, and 87 children's hospital dental clinics in the United States. Nationally, the number of CSHCN was determined to be 10,221,436. The distribution, on average, of CSHCN per care source/provider ranged from 1,327 to 2,357 in the 6 AAPD districts. Children's hospital dental clinics had fewer than 1 clinic appointment or 1 operating room appointment available per CSHCN. The mean number of CSHCN patients per provider, if distributed equally, was 1,792. The current US dental care system has extremely limited capacity to care for children with special health care needs.
Article
Oral Health in America: A Report of the Surgeon General (SGROH) and National Call to Action to Promote Oral Health outlined the need to increase the diversity, capacity, and flexibility of the dental workforce to reduce oral health disparities. This paper provides an update on dental workforce trends since the SGROH in the context of children's oral health needs. Major challenges remain to ensure a workforce that is adequate to address the needs of all children. The dentist-to-population ratio is declining while shortages of dentists continue in rural and underserved communities. The diversity of the dental workforce has only improved slightly, and the the diversity of the pediatric population has increased substantially. More pediatric dentists have been trained, and dental educational programs are preparing students for practice in underserved areas, but the impact of these efforts on underserved children is uncertain. Other workforce developments with the potential to improve children's oral health include enhanced training in children's oral health for general dentists, expanded scope of practice for allied dental health professionals, new dental practitioners including the dental health aid therapist, and increased engagement of pediatricians and other medical practitioners in children's oral health. The evidence for increasing caries experience in young children points to the need for continued efforts to bolster the oral health workforce. However, workforce strategies alone will not be sufficient to change this situation. Requisite policy changes, educational efforts, and strong partnerships with communities will be needed to effect substantive changes in children's oral health.
Article
Retail-based clinics have proliferated rapidly in the past two years, with approximately 1,000 sites in thirty-seven states representing almost three million cumulative visits. Clinic operators have evolved from a dispersed group of privately financed concerns to a concentrated, largely corporate-owned group. A major development has been the move to large-scale acceptance of insurance, deviating from the initial cash-pay model. Consumers' acceptance and the fact that the clinics appear to increase access for both the uninsured and the insured has encouraged providers and policymakers to consider this approach to basic, acute care while seeking a better understanding of these clinics.
Article
In Rochester, NY, telehealth centres were established in six inner-city elementary schools and seven child-care centres. The teledentistry project complemented the existing telehealth model. Using an intraoral camera, telehealth assistants record digital images of children's teeth (768 x 494 pixels) and send the images to a computer at the expert dental site (the Eastman Department of Dentistry at the University of Rochester). The paediatric dentist at the expert site reviews the images, and provides referral and treatment recommendations. Subsequently, the telehealth assistant contacts the child's parents or guardians and assists them to obtain appropriate dental care for their child. In the pilot study, we screened 50 children. In the first nine months of 2005, we screened 123 children. The results of our initial teledental screenings of children aged 12-48 months attending inner-city child-care centres revealed that almost 40% had active dental caries, mainly early childhood caries (ECC). For the first time, many children attending inner-city child-care centres have had their teeth examined at an early age and been given prompt feedback on the need for dental care.
Preventative dentistry in rural communities in the U.S Dental Hypotheses
  • Dulieu
Dulieu: Preventative dentistry in rural communities in the U.S Dental Hypotheses ¦ Oct-Dec 2016 ¦ Volume 7 ¦ Issue 4
Children's preventative dental care effective, use low
  • Ada News
ADA News CDC: Children's preventative dental care effective, use low. Available from: http://www.ada.org/en/publications/ada-news/2014-archive/september/cdc-childrens-preventive-dental-care-effective-use-low [Last accessed on 2016 Aug 8].