Content uploaded by Ron Eglash
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Ron Eglash on May 30, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Ron Eglash
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Ron Eglash on Nov 04, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
, Revista Teknokultura Vol. 13 !"##
$%
&'(%
&()'%
""
"*"
+""
,&&-
.&%//'/0&.&/123/&4/-/&"5*#+
An Introduction to Generative Justice
Una introducción a la justicia generativa
Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute
eglash@rpi.edu
ABSTRACT
!"#
$ % &
' (& $%
)'
*(+,'-'
$'%)
(
$#%$#%
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## !
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
KEYWORDS
*(+))-)')
RESUMEN
-,.
/#-01
/
/1
2,/#
3 4!"5
#, #1 /
6'
&(2
#) 0
,7.0
-
4)
/ #
-708#8-
# # 89 :8;9:< -
.#
PALABRAS CLAVE
*(+))')0)0-
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
+ 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
CONTENTS
= :
> 7?#
! :9@&
A B
C
CONTENIDOS
= 1/
> 7?#
! 9:/
A B/
C
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## +
Acknowledgement
@''D3E
*:"FAGFH"'
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
($#
I ' % 6
,
? $ #%
!" #
$%J'
?
' $ % ?
7 # ? '
$'%
7 $'% I
' ' I
!*$*(+%,
'-),
?
))@
'#?
#
: # # )
K'
' ( '
# ?
#
7
, $ %
$% $#%
':#
@
#) ,
)
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## +
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
1. Generating unalienated value
($%'
''
@ '
E ' ?
3'K$%)'
L(*7&,,@7@B
L7*'*7 (
'-M3'
(
$%7
$%
) )$
%@
7
'
@ '
$ %
@$%$%(
=FAA'3N
?$(
O-O)
%; G"< P ,
$%;$%<@
?$%)
$% )$%
6)
(
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
+# 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
I
I 3 +
=
$
7
'%
;=FGQ Q!GQ!H< 3N
:91#'
$%
$%'$%
'$%1
@ R :
, )
$
%(3N=@'
$%K?
'7
' I
3'LI6
'
E = R (-
;< ( -
= (*: ! " ;>""=<
P ' ;
$%<
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## +5
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
E(:S=?:D7@(T9S3@(B(D(JUSJ(3E7(D:
3?
;$%<
;3=F"C<@
;$''K
%< ;6 =FF!< B
,
#;3=FF><(=
R
,@'')$
%-@
?)
')-II
'
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
+ 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
;$#$%&'(( (!#()< ;&'=F="<
>
E(:S>$(D*(7DBJDJE@P7(B73%
3?'
( ?
B
, O , 9
(- @
> 'JE9-*+
$%(-
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## ++
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
$%C)
R
@9K #E';:V9=FF=<
E
$%'7
' 1;=FF!<
?$
%;A><@
T $ %
$%I3;>"==<>CKI
, '
;B V >"="< -@
7E>
D7
@=""""
,,I
! , I
K I ,
; E >"=C< B
1 , '
I ) ,) '
I;R
<-;
< ; >""><
,$%
;P>""H<?
( : M ( M
! @
'
;W =FFQ)
7'VJ>""G)>"=!<
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
+* 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
(M'
'M@-
D6 S
A
E(:S!?71(D7@*T71S(DE7L@B7&(@71(3
3?
?;=F">=FG<
$%
A @E-#
$%;1>"=Q<
3
- D6
) ;7
- >"=C <) & ,
E -
7 K D
7;>"=!)>"=!<
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## +!
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
(-
? #I I
#
,(
#;>"=Q<()(
,
(!RE=
RI'
' ' I
'E!
6
$% $% ' ?
$ % ')
I@
?
MB
;A<
E(:SA?73PJ3PJD 7**&S3) P7(*7B*7 JX)B7E(B7DBJDJ6P7(3@+1
3?)*, 7
7D+
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
* 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
@'
I C?$
) ' %B
'
? ' 8 8 8
'8;@=FGG<
E(:SC?E1J6JET71S(D3@7@&17DD*BJSD(3
3?
7R,;C< '
K;!<@
,
Q(S33BB
C (:
;>"==<3YA
QE:;>""!<
S33?,'.;8@6'68<
' ;< '
;
''K<
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## *
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
T, '
?
6;1
=FF!) >"=>< '
? )
D:# '
7'
#?
!/0
& 0
2. Arduino: a case study in generative justice
P # (-;=<
R#Q
7
@ 7
-$'%
$*(+%(
' G( 7 (
'('
H7
B $ %
$%; '>"=!<@
G 7 '*';<F"Z
>"=C$ % @
?K
H 7 BB7 37'
' 7 ;
$%<
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
* 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
R ' E (
$%
#, 'R'
;7>"="<
E(:SQ?:D7@(T9S3@(B(D@PT71SE1J6EJ7*S(DJ?
3? S 7 B : &)
S1&7 S3 3'E)
11& '3
('$%?
+@
) W ;>""H< $
%(
'
'$[%
'
'
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## *
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
(' B *;>""Q<
@
$%I
I $ %)
,R,(
'?(
' ' , ;>" =!<
K
(
B;>""><;>""G<$
OO OO ',
%;'VD>"=A<
PE
S'
:
@ ;B< @ B 3 ;D 9< , '
6 7
-'
7>"=C;' <
$:%B$7%(S37(I
I
( ) '
;* >"=!<&3;=FHA<
($R'%
;' < '
P7S33'E'
6
;Q<3'E
F
(&;(&<R
F &B:&(>"=A3'EB
??\\'\\
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
*# 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
& ( ' K 3
; <
;<(
-',
&(&
((&,="3'E
'
E?
(3'E3>""G
-
'7R'
((
('6(
(''C
((3'E]
-'
(#(==
;3'E>""F=<
@RQ?
#? :
?&B
) '
=" 3 3'E BJ D 3 = >"=! ;
?\\#\^\\==!\"H"=>"=!\"H"==!Z>"@Z>"Z>"3<
-?B
,
== ?\\'\\CF=G! 3 ?\\'\\=QCA )
' 3'E -
3#$%
#3'E K
,
' @ ' ' 7
$(L%P BS7'
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## *5
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
!"I:DS
I'#
@,7$%=FQ"
? >"=A => ;J>"=A<)
$%; >"=!< J
#
67
? ;7
>"=><) , ;:, V * 9 >"=><)
;1 >"=><)
;' >"=A<92:/,.-, (@
$'D%
; $*(L% 7 *(+
<3'
? 7 $: %
*(+ : K
K 9
E';>"=!<
(
7 $%? B B $
% B W ;
R<( $%7
-P
R#6'
'#
-K)DL
@ ;>"=C< $ ]
%;!><3
;
>"=A) V&>"=C<P
?*(+!$
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
* 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
% ' 7
@
$%
'7I
7 I @*
L &,
@ W J
$%
(
''-
;<#
:#'7
?K-
B '
-
@ 3 3 & B ;
3 < ' D +' 3
E?''
@]@
7)'
6
=> -
B]
' 3,
;:>"=C<
P3 K
' ?>"=C7
7
$7% 3
=> 1 ;>"=C< >""F >"== B
' (
1 K6'
'
#
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## *+
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
, 7&3
$:%
7@ '
R
?1E7;
7 <
$
% ;
B7R)B>"=!<
1
9K=!9K
# =A @ #
9K I '
(
) (
'E7
;$&%< $% # '
' )'
1
1&?'
PII
7; VP>"="<
=! @?9K
=A 9K =H=!?$@
_
''
% P
-';6
=FFF<
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
** 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
(''I'
I'
?(
' Q
' @'
$%
M
@R 7'
$% E
-
B
'';>"=C<;$%<
K'
6')@;>"=Q<@;>"=!<
' @ $'%
7
$% -E
;>"=C< $' % (
'
'*(+?'
)P'$%)
$% 1J1 J'
$ -
'\'%;1J1J'<
: 7
?'D :/,
.-, 1 E
@ * @
:/,.-,
'$%;6>"=!<(
K #
K 7
K $ % '
##
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## *!
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
#-
3. Generative Justice as a Transformative Process
@ ' , &;>""=<
=G('
$%?
' ;3V 3=FHC) P=FFG< &
'')
&
$%B
)
7I' #I
-'
;B>"=Q<
@ I
$ %I =C '
'
J '
;>"=!<$
'
%;>=!<
@;B>""F<7*P
;>"=A<?
(II
,
=C D$%;
V '>"=A<
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
! 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
']'
%
;*P>"=AHQ<
@
$% ; >"">) >""G) ( >"=C< J
$ %; ' >""Q) PV '>"==)
9'>"=!<'
' ( =F
&
3 ;>"=C<
$
`
%;=CA< #
# @ I
K
#J'
Q)
'
@-
I
I
Non-humans in the circulation of unalienated value
67'
: 9 $ %)
$ %$ %' 6
$%
$%)
#,
\
$%
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## !
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
$%;&'=FFC<
'
'
@
;P=FHA<
$% ;3>"=><
$%
3'$%;$%<
$% ;JD
>""F<J7;>"=C<
$ - %J
,#
& 1
=Q E P ;=FFG<
$ % ' -
;'
<) : ;>"=A< -
@
'
#
&;>"=><,'9@37*P
$, 88
88
% ; G< 6 #
$
=Q ($%'
B
7(*3 ? ,
;=FFQ< @ $
%J
#
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
! 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
%? ,,
77;>"="<'$
%;=!F<7?
I
'
); >""G<
6]
;<?
;B =FHQ &' =FFC) >"=") >"=><
$% $%
;P>"=C< 6' ;>"=C< '
(
:
J
R #I
I
,, (
$ % ; V : >"=A< @ ,
-?
'E'
'
@ K # -
$%;&'<
@J;>"="<
B &;B&< ( D
, K
6
;>""><B&'?$
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## !
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
%I'I
P
B&I
$%',I
#7J?
7 ;>""A <
7 '
$%$%
$%
II
7
)
]
@#B
$%D
K)
(B@;DVB>"=A<
4. Conclusion
(?7#
?
B
B
I I
E
R@
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
!# 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
; <
@ - :
,$%$%'
$%$%
; <M :
#,
';6
>""H< '
M6
);S3'
a=> <MP#
' , $ %
;L>"="<)$%;6>"=!<)$%;B
>"=A<)$%;: V3>"=C<) $%
;P>"=C<)M
@,?
- '
;B>"=!<- 6';>"=C<
#
, I $
%I $%
,
$ % , $# %
$%;>""G)'VD>"=A<M7DB'
- ' ;E >"=><
]
1 #
\ (
?
@ '
-? '
# MP
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## !5
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
;* B >""F) ' V
' >"=C) @ >"=!<
,M3I'
7I
$% K
;M<@
-
#
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
! 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
5. References
77JD3JD37;>"="<PB& @&?B
11123!3
43(7K@:6S
b?\\\c\\\\7^((&6&>"="==d
7(LDP7*:3VJ:767;>""G<(L3
4425;!<C!FeQ>"
717(J3 ;>"="< 6!7+41 21 84 ?
(S&
7117 +:L(3@11:S@7L67L(@BPD93(@PJVB17L7;>"=C<
7(7&P?&
&eB'&92:;=C"eCG
71@(( 7 ;>""A< 7 ?
- 21
2<43!2243=3H>H
7D:1(D3;>"=C< :?U 7 9 3
1>?;><!A=!CA
7DL3;>""Q<B6'4!A";!<ACCeG>
77*L;>"=><DOU&1*.=>>CC!
DL1+;>"=!<&7?&'&E3
34!>;><>=!>C=
DD@@9 3@7D: D V *7*J 7 ;>"=C< ( 6'M
B E & 3 SL* 7(9 VD3
;< 8 + & @ @M ; =!F=CH<
1?
DD@@9 ;>"="< "8+ 32! *DB1?
*'S&
J1 V &P(11(&3 9 ;>"=C< @ J
@95A1>!FeG=
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## !+
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
SBP1+1V P(11 ;>"="< 1& 6?PP 1 @
3 D * B ( 3
4!;*(3<;=FF>"G<7*'
B7117P7D ;>"=Q<7*(( 3*B
(E & 7 3*B ="=! >"=Q @'S
3@'9
B711JD;=FHQ<33@?*3
E 3 (19;< 3&1 6+7&
4!B&;=FQe>!!<1?VL&
B7JD9:( 3JDLVP(117;>"=A<BPB?
B E 7 &
2C;;=<==He=!>
B7& 11 3 L V S@1 T1 ;>"="< 7 &
D cGC""
2!4!CD;=<=G>F
BPJ&73V3BJ@@*;>""Q<@&J33
9 !1B&4!=;G<
B(BJ3 ;>"=!7==<7 171E 7
=2
b?\\\d
BJ17D:;>""F<B3?1@'&E
J33*!>A;!<A>"ACA
*7EJD3B73(@P *6713DB7&&11(D(3LJ:1SD*&ES7:711(V
377D(:J97 ;>"=C< @ J , 3 S
373=;=<=C
*1B73(DJT;>""F<4*!+D+?96V3
*3(:D JJ;>"=!<7f*
b?\\\\d
*SD 7P3@B ;>"=A<(M 17 @*(+(
V ;<E+848B
7?(@&
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
!* 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
:173P ;>"">< B B B D 7 L
3(P'9VE:;<@8+3
37T7?DB@
:173P;>"=!<7B7D7*
3( '67V&'&.&.!+!
>FC!=>1(@T
:173PV 7DL3*7;>"=A<*:3?*,
@*@3J, 4!!";><
:173PV:7T+B;>"=A< 7:9( #3
gh3V@'7;< !3-;GCeHH<:?3
3
:173P ;>"=Q< J '? P & : 9
CF;=<
L (7P V D7*( ;>"=A<P( ;<?@(*
1P@8!=F;Q<
b?\\\#\\\\\C!!=d
D:13E;=F">< =@!133!4B?BPL
&3@(D3;=FFQ< 4+ 411 3 B&- '?
SB&
E17D*31;>"=>7!"<@'6B'3-
b?\\\>"=>\"A\!"\''\d
EJ3@9 V7:*JEEE;=FFH<8!.&9\7=FFHTC";!<!>
EJX 3 S1:7*J V J3D * ;>"=C< P' B D *? 7
EP'4(CDT B)CQeQH7B&
:@WV*(9S3@J&;>"=><28&64
G'(
:( 3JD:7P79L;>""Q< 3 3?S
&
:7*+ D3JD9V (D*73;>"=C<EE*S3P?3
1JB92";"<?=e>=
:7 *;>"==< & !"+ @==&
'SL?&
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## !!
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
:D @ ;>"=A< : D T B, ! <
!=!;><FFe==H
:(D**7V9JP7D3D ;=FF=<2H!+72
!17?7(3BSB
:JDJ69;>""!<&+H!*
4(.J?
:SD*+@;>"=C9=!<PB&B
B@3-
I?\\'\>"=C\"G\=!\
\d
P711T;=FH"<@ E & 1& B 8
!>A;=<>"eCF
P77(939iL1(D@VSLLJDD7;>"=C<@3?6&&
B B 44.7 4! 3 D+? 3 3
D'
b?\\\j>>G=FG=d
P7767+*;=FHA<@ &?@:D+'B
=F"H=F!Q4 H==>"eQA
P7767+* ;=FF><@ & ? 7 & (\
J%(:1DBV@&7;<4-D+')
>FC!!G
P7767+*9;=FFG<@T3D6J=@.&CC;=<
>>eG>
P7767+*9;>""H<48?S&
P3JD*P71:P * V 7L 3 ;>"==< + 8
1?
P(117 ;>"=C< `E` B J :
EE7"!>;!<
b?\\\\\\7P\P7PS
>"=Ad
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
# 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
(7D(1;>"=C<P'',4 !
">J;C<GFFH>A
9DL(D3PEJ*3V:D9;>"=!<48+"8
7&D+?D+'S&
L767DJ73@3JD@V@11113 :9;<;>"="<4!2!+6
3377?B&
b?\\\>AG>=FA\ ^^3^^^^6^&
d
LJS(@J6D ;>"=C< @7?7K @@&
@U&37+4*1
<49F:;=<>!e!A
17@JS ;=FF!< 7 6 8 @B & B
7?PS&
1( +B ;>"=> 9 G< J 1 J 3* * H
7&-
b?\\\\\>""'\CHQFA>
d
1(D*@D 3 ;>"=C< P' B B @ & '
BB 41 ! < "
>J;C<HCAHGF
1J1J7L17D*;<*
b?\\''\\d
1+13*17BPD+ EJ3@L;>"=Q<:B?:T
B3 1CF;><
7+L;>"=!<7 2
b?\\\\d
7XL;=FGQ<(D+'D+?T
B711(3@ +SD V S3P 3 ;>"=><B * B,? 7 &
*&*
b?\\\,
d
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## #
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
BB7 B;>"=!<@BS?7B
94!>=;><C=eQ=
BJ (7;>""><BB?D*&B3
B64=Q;A<C=QeC!=
*7;>"=!<7E7Ue6*B8
b?\\\>"=!\"A\-d
DL(D:7V(BL3JD(;>"=C<@P6'6'?:1
6 1 J ( 3 FF 8
@4!>"Ge="BP(=CD+'D+?7B
JD(BL7 3 3S:7D+7 B D(@P+7 P77@P( 3V 3(D*PS 7& ;>"=A<7 S-
3PB94/.2<
!!;A<
JJWJT;>"=!< 42!1+ @! 4D
+'D+?&7K
S(11J1;>"=!<D JE'?J3
DB9@@-
b?\\'\'\>"=='
#\\!\
'#d
D13JDV BJ ;>"=A< @* & 3
7(3E9KQG;><
JD(1 & ;>""F 9 >>< & ' 7
.
b?\\\\'d
J3(D(1;>"=A=><7 ,? P 6P'@ '
.
b?\\\>"=A\"C\=>\,'
d
J3@J ;>"="< ' ?
2.&="";!<QA=eQG>
&7L7B;=F="<LG8E=@37S
D+'
b?\\\\-""'d
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
# 177)8) 39'% !"##
An Introduction to Generative Justice 4).
&7+9 ;>"=>< E &W B?7 D
P94=";!<Ge>C
&(BL(D:7;=FFC< 83 1!14B?S
B&
&(J9V37 1BE;=FHA< 4D+'D+? '
7@@J:7D J1V*( @;>"=A<E+84
8B7?(@&
7@@J;>"==<B'?B3@3
1 4!>G;A<>C>e>Q"
J337;>""G<D 6'(+ B:(? @BB(
&=1<*=;=<=!e!"
3 (BB7 9 ;>"=>< U ;<? B P 3
;<DE292!!F;=<!!eC>
3BPi*(D:;=FAA<B7?BS&
37T 9 ;=FF>< 7 8-8!9- D+'D+? 7
3P&3
3(@P ;>"==<:&DBO6&O
73&33
.!4!64!QQH!QeHAH
3&7LESD;>""F9>H<M313/-
b?\\'\\CF=G!d
3@(@33P;=F"C<2 L1&?@D&
B
@7S33(:;=FGG<@:B 37&? *
1 44!!C;;><=!"e=CC
@119LJE(DL7(**1@JD97(D7BS&P+P(11V&7DJDB;>"=Q<
: J 3? & -7 6 T 39
33?\\#\\=G!!
@JS&(D3;>"=!<EP'33M3E
b?\\\\'d
.&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+ 3%5#!
177)8) 39'% !"## #
4). An Introduction to Generative Justice
67:D3;=FF!<@(-(R6O(3''VL9
* + = 7 ' D +'?
7>A"e>AG
671@3BP(* B;=FFH<S7P?@3B(
@9K(R&12+ 9& !
!F=FC
673P(BL 6(D:JTE:S3JDLV DD@@9;>"=C<&?@'
#!3 !=AQ!HF
6DL;>""H<SB?JB
D U @'( 4!2!+ 6 3
336':S3
3E=!F=CA
6(11(731*7;>"=!<@*?BJD:J
7@3* !-
=>;A<AAFAGC
6(:P@ ;>"=!< @ B S 4
.&-GH;=<=>C
W(@@7(D9;>""H< @&4-DP?+S
&
3%5#! .&%//04/5!/6123 5*#+
## 177)8) 39'% !"##
