ArticlePDF Available

A Review of The Turbine Cooling Fraction for Very High Turbine Entry Temperature Helium Gas Turbine Cycles For Generation IV Reactor Power Plants

Authors:
Arnold Gad-Briggs at EGB Engineering UK
Arnold Gad-Briggs
  • EGB Engineering UK
P Pilidis
P Pilidis
P Pilidis
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Theoklis Nikolaidis at Cranfield University
Theoklis Nikolaidis
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

The potential for high Turbine Entry Temperatures (TET) turbines for Nuclear Power Plants (NPPs) require improved materials and sophisticated cooling. Cooling is critical to maintaining mechanical integrity of the turbine for temperatures >1000°C. Increasing TET is one of the solutions for improving efficiency after cycle optimum pressure ratios have been achieved but cooling as a percentage of mass flow will have to increase, resulting in cycle efficiency penalties. To limit this effect, it is necessary to know the maximum allowable blade metal temperature to ensure the minimum cooling fraction is used. The main objective of this study is to analyse the thermal efficiencies of four cycles in the 300 – 700 MW class for Generation IV NPPs, using two different turbines with optimum cooling for TETs between 950°C - 1200°C. The cycles analysed are Simple Cycle (SC), Simple Cycle Recuperated (SCR), Intercooled Cycle (IC) and Intercooled Cycle Recuperated (ICR). Although results showed that deterioration of cycle performance is lower when using improved turbine material, the justification to use optimum cooling improves the cycle significantly when a recuperator is used. Furthermore, optimised cooling flow and the introduction of an intercooler improves cycle efficiency by >3%, which is >1% more than previous studies. Finally, the study highlights the potential of cycle performance beyond 1200°C for IC. This is based on the IC showing the least performance deterioration. The analyses intend to aid development of cycles for deployment in Gas Cooled Fast Reactors (GFRs) and Very High Temperature Reactors (VHTRs).
Content uploaded by Arnold Gad-Briggs
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Arnold Gad-Briggs on Oct 10, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
A review of the turbine cooling fraction for
very high turbine entry temperature helium
gas turbine cycles for Generation IV reactor
power plants
!
Click!or!copy!and!paste!the!below!link!into!your!browser:!
!
https://dspace.lib.cranfield.ac.uk/handle/1826/11190!
... The temperature at which the coolant enters the system is identified as a significant factor that affects both the dissipation of heat and the efficiency of the cycle. It is worth noting that different configurations of the pre-cooler, such as co-current and counter-current setups, lead to distinctive outlet temperatures for the heat sink and affect its compactness [44,45]. The selection of the operational fluid in this cycle carries substantial importance in determining the pressures, temperatures, and overall efficiency of the power plant. ...
'Greening' an Oil Exporting Country: A Hydrogen and Helium Closed-cycle Gas Turbines Case Study
Article
Full-text available
  • Feb 2024
Holistic decarbonisation requires collaborative efforts and substantial investments across diverse economic sectors. This study introduces an innovative national approach, blending technological insights and philosophical considerations to shape decarbonization policies and practices. Libya is the case study. The proposed framework involves submersible power stations with continuous-duty helium closed-cycle gas turbines to supply electricity demand and hydrogen. Extensive national data is analysed, incorporating factors such as sectoral consumption, sea temperature, and port locations. An analytical model is developed, providing a valuable foundation for realistic decarbonization scenarios. The model aims to maintain the benefits of current energy consumption, assuming a 2% growth rate, while assessing changes in a fully green economy. The results offer qualitative and quantitative insights on hydrogen use and an expected rise in electricity demand. Two scenarios are examined: self-sufficiency and replacing oil exports with hydrogen exports. This study provides a quantitative perspective on decarbonization, focusing on a submersible helium closed cycle gas turbine concept resistant to natural disasters and proliferation. Findings underscore the substantial changes and investments needed for this transition, identifying primary needs of 27 GW or 129 GW for self-sufficiency and exports, respectively. This foundational analysis marks the start of research, investment, and political agendas toward decarbonization.
View
... During service, turbine blades are usually subjected to severe and complex operating conditions. To enhance the thrust-to-weight ratio of an aero-engine, the gas temperature at the turbine inlet is constantly increasing and then, brings about higher requirements for the materials of the blades (Cumpsty, 1997;Singh, 2014;Gad-Briggs et al., 2017). Nowadays, nickel-based single-crystal or directionally solidified superalloys are the most widely used turbine blade materials, which are remarkable for their excellent high-temperature mechanical properties and corrosion resistance. ...
Microstructure degradation of service-exposed turbine blades made of directionally solidified DZ125 superalloy
Article
Full-text available
  • Sep 2022
The investigation about the degradation behavior of turbine blades exposed to complex and extreme environments for long-term service is of great importance to assess the remaining life of the blades. In our work, the microstructure at different positions of the service-exposed turbine blade was characterized from the micron scale to the nanoscale. The results showed that there are noticeable differences in the microstructure at different positions of the blade and the blade has a complex service history. These conclusions suggest that the most severely damaged part of the blade should be responsible for assessing the remaining life of the blade, moreover, the mechanical properties of materials should not be limited to life at constant temperature and stress, rather non-isothermal and variable stress tests are more instructive in assessing the performance or life of aircraft engine blade materials.
View
View
View
View
A high-entropy alloy nitride protective coating for fuel cladding in high temperature lead-bismuth eutectic alloy
Article
  • Jun 2022
  • J NUCL MATER
High temperature coatings possess great potential for improving operation temperature of 4th generation nuclear reactor. In this paper, a high-entropy alloy nitride coatings (CrAlTiNbV)Nx were investigated for the application in corrosive lead-bismuth alloy (LBE). The coatings were synthesized by unbalanced magnetron sputtering on ferritic/martensitic (F/M) steel. Properties of (CrAlTiNbV)Nx are systematically investigated from perspective of the electron structure, crystalline, and mechanical properties under different bias voltage applied on samples. Significant improvement of hardness (30 GPa) is obtained at bias voltage of -156 V. Furthermore, the corrosion behavior in 550 °C lead bismuth eutectic (LBE) was conducted for 1200 h with saturated oxygen content, which demonstrates the dense structure of coatings with no obvious crack, spallation that characterized by the SEM, EDS, and TEM. Upon the application of high bias voltage, more prone formation of high-density grain boundary with fine grains extends the diffusion path of Pb and Bi are achieved for excellent LBE corrosion resistance. Our work not only provide an insight to the electron structure of high entropy alloy nitrides, but also shows a potential application for (CrAlTiNbV)Nx protecting fuel cladding in the next generation lead based reactor.
View
Comparison of sCO2 and He Brayton cycles integration in a Calcium-Looping for Concentrated Solar Power
Article
  • May 2022
  • ENERGY
Concentrated Solar Power is expected to play a crucial role to reach a sustainable power generation. Efficiency increase and development of long-term storages are the main aspects that could be further addressed to enhance the Concentrated Solar Power diffusion. In this context, the Calcium-Looping process is a promising opportunity for the ThermoChemical Energy Storage. Previous studies showed that, between the indirect integrations, Brayton cycles operating with supercritical CO2 or Helium are an interesting alternative. However, since their discussion has been developed in separate works, a detailed comparison of these integrations is lacking. The purpose of the present study is to find the differences, similarities and important aspects that characterize the two systems, performing a comparison in energy, economic and technical terms. Results show that choosing the He power block allows to reach the highest performances, while the cheapest alternative is the sCO2 cycle. Compression, regeneration, and high-temperature heating are the most important aspects for the He integration, differently from the case with sCO2, where only the regeneration process determines changes of the plant benchmarks. The comparison does not highlight univocally a better option, but according to the criteria required is possible to evaluate the most suitable alternative.
View
Benefits, Drawbacks and Future Trends of Brayton Helium Gas Turbine Cycles for GFR and VHTR Generation IV Nuclear Power Plants
Article
  • Jul 2020
Numerous studies are on-going on to understand the performance of Generation IV (Gen IV) Nuclear Power Plants (NPPs). The objective is to determine optimum operating conditions for efficiency and economic reasons in line with the goals of Gen IV. For Gen IV concepts such as the Gas-cooled Fast Reactors (GFRs) and Very-High Temperature Reactors (VHTRs), the choice of cycle configuration is influenced by component choices, the component configuration and the choice of coolant. The purpose of this paper to present and review current cycles being considered - the Simple Cycle Recuperated (SCR) and the Intercooled Cycle Recuperated (ICR). For both cycles, helium is considered as the coolant in a closed Brayton gas turbine configuration. Comparisons are made for Design Point (DP) and Off-Design Point (ODP) analyses to emphasise the pros and cons of each cycle. This paper also discusses potential future trends, include higher reactor Core Outlet Temperatures (COT) in excess of 1000 degrees Celsius, simplified cycle configurations and reduced stages on the helium compressor.
View
Experimental study on performance of helium low pressure compressor of HTR-10GT
Article
  • Mar 2019
  • PROG NUCL ENERG
Helium Gas Turbine System (HGTS) has compact and simple configuration, and can make full use of high temperature heat source to achieve high power generation efficiency. It will be the desirable power conversion system for the Modular High Temperature Gas-cooled Reactor (Modular HTGR) in the future. But there are some technical challenges to be solved for HGTS, including helium compressor and active magnetic bearings, etc. Helium compressor is key component for HGTS. Its aerodynamic performance had direct influences on the efficiency of the HGTS. Its features are different from those of conventional air compressors or gas turbines due to the different working fluids. The experimental and theoretical studies on helium compressors were very limited. In this paper, a performance test system for HTR-10GT project was established for the full-stage and full-scale helium compressors. Performance of low-pressure compressor (LPC) of HTR-10GT was tested and investigated on this test system. The pressure ratio and efficiency of the LPC were obtained at rated conditions and at different rotating speed, different inventory level. Surge and block boundaries of LPC were also explored. The results showed that the performance of LPC satisfied the design requirements. And the experimental study in the paper verified the validity and effectiveness of the design methods of the helium compressors at the LPC conditions, and provided the key aerodynamic performance data for further studies, such as off-design conditions, inventory control and load rejection control.
View
Experimental study on performance of helium high pressure compressors of HTR-10GT
Article
  • Mar 2019
  • ANN NUCL ENERGY
In the six candidate types of the fourth-generation nuclear power system, the Helium Gas Turbine System (HGTS) will be the ideal power conversion system for both the Modular High Temperature Gas-cooled Reactor (Modular HTGR) and the Gas-cooled Fast Reactor. The main advantages of HGTS are the compact and simple configuration and the high power-generation efficiency by taking advantage of high temperature heat source. At present, one of the main research contents of HGTS in China is helium compressors in HTR-10GT project. Previous researches showed that the aerodynamic performance of the helium compressors was one of the key factors of the efficiency of HGTS and had direct influences on the efficiency of the system. With different working fluids, features of helium compressors are different from conventional compressors. There were very limited experimental and theoretical studies in the research field of helium compressors. In this paper, a performance test system for the full-stage and full-scale helium compressors was employed to test and investigate the performance of the helium compressors of HTR-10GT, including pressure ratio, efficiency and surge and block boundaries. The performance of the high-pressure compressor (HPC) was measured at rated conditions and at different rotating speeds and different inventory levels. The results showed that the pressure ratio of the HPC satisfied the requirements of the HGTS, and the efficiency of the HPC was below expectation. The experimental study represented the applicability of the helium compressor design methods and provided the key aerodynamic performance data for future studies, such as off-design conditions, studies on compressor design methods and further improvement on the performance of the helium compressors.
View
Analyses of a High Pressure Ratio Intercooled Direct Brayton Helium Gas Turbine Cycle for Generation IV Reactor Power Plants
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2016
The intercooled cycle (IC) as an alternative to the simple cycle recuperated (SCR) and intercooled cycle recuperated (ICR) is yet to be fully analyzed for the purpose of assessing its viability for utilization within Generation IV nuclear power plants (NPPs). Although the benefits are not explicitly obvious, it offers the advantage of a very high overall pressure ratio (OPR) in the absence of a recuperator. Thus, the main objective of this study is to analyze various pressure ratio configurations, the effects of varying pressure ratio including sensitivity analyses of component efficiencies, ambient temperature, component losses and pressure losses on cycle efficiency, and specific work of the IC, including comparison with the SCR and ICR. Results of comparison between the IC and the SCR and ICR derived that the cycle efficiencies are greater than the IC by ∼4% 4 (SCR) and ∼6% 6 (ICR), respectively. However, the pressure losses for IC are lower when compared with the SCR and ICR. Nonetheless, heat from the turbine exit temperature of the IC can be used in a processing plant including the possibility of higher turbine entry temperatures (TETs) to significantly increase the cycle efficiency in a bid to justify the business case. The analyses intend to bring to attention an alternative to current cycle configurations for the gas-cooled fast reactors (GFRs) and very-high-temperature reactors (VHTRs), where helium is the coolant. The findings are summarized by evaluating the chosen pressure ratio configurations against critical parameters and detailed comparison with the SCR and ICR.
View
Effectiveness-ntu computation with a mathematical model for cross-flow heat exchangers
Article
Full-text available
  • Oct 2007
Due to the wide range of design possibilities, simple manufactured, low maintenance and low cost, cross-flow heat exchangers are extensively used in the petroleum, petrochemical, air conditioning, food storage, and others industries. In this paper a mathematical model for cross-flow heat exchangers with complex flow arrangements for determining e -NTU relations is presented. The model is based on the tube element approach, according to which the heat exchanger outlet temperatures are obtained by discretizing the coil along the tube fluid path. In each cross section of the element, tube-side fluid temperature is assumed to be constant because the heat capacity rate ratio C*=Cmin/Cmax tends toward zero in the element. Thus temperature is controlled by effectiveness of a local element corresponding to an evaporator or a condenser-type element. The model is validated through comparison with theoretical algebraic relations for single-pass cross-flow arrangements with one or more rows. Very small relative errors are obtained showing the accuracy of the present model. e -NTU curves for several complex circuit arrangements are presented. The model developed represents a useful research tool for theoretical and experimental studies on heat exchangers performance.
View
Performance Review: PBMR Closed Cycle Gas Turbine Power Plant.
Article
Full-text available
Helium is considered as one of the ideal working fluid for closed cycle using nuclear heat source due to its low neutron absorption as well as high thermodynamic properties. The commercial viability of the Helium turbo machinery depends on operational success. The past attempts failed due to poor performances manifested in the form of drop in efficiency, inability to reach maximum load, slow response to the transients etc. Radical changes in the basic design were suggested in some instances as possible solutions. A better understanding of the operational performance is necessary for the detailed design of the plant and the control systems. This paper describes the theory behind the off design and transient modelling of a closed cycle gas turbine plant. A computer simulation model has been created specifically for this cycle. The model has been tested for various turbine entry temperatures along the steady state and its replications at various locations were observed. The paper also looks at the various control methods available for a closed cycle and some of the options were simulated.
View
Update of the French R&D strategy on gas-cooled reactors
Article
Full-text available
  • Oct 2010
  • NUCL ENG DES
Gas-cooled reactors take up a strong second role in France's R&D strategy on future nuclear energy systems as priority was given in 2005 to fast neutron reactors with multiple-recycle for their potential to optimally use uranium resource and minimize the long term burden of radioactive waste. Owing to the European past experience on sodium-cooled fast reactors (SFRs), this reactor type was logically selected as reference for a new generation fast neutron reactor intended to be tested as a prototype in the 2020s and be ready for industrial deployment around 2040. At the same time, the potential merits of a gas fast reactor (GFR) with ceramic clad fuel for a safe management of cooling accident are acknowledged for the potential of this reactor type to resolve critical issues of liquid fast reactors (safety, operability and reparability). A pre-feasibility report on a first concept of GFR was issued in 2007 that summed-up results of a 5-year international R&D effort on GFR fuel technology, reactor design and operating transient analyses. This report established a global confidence in the feasibility of this concept and its potential for attractive performances. Furthermore, it suggested directions of R&D to generate by 2012 an updated concept with improved performances and taking better benefit from GFR specific technologies.
View
Analysis of a 115MW, 3-Shaft, Helium Brayton Cycle Using Nuclear Heat Source
Conference Paper
  • Jun 2001
This paper describes the steady state performance analysis of a 3-shaft closed cycle helium turbine using nuclear heat source. The analysis is carried out using a computer program, which is specifically made for this cycle. The computer model was tested for various Turbine Entry Temperatures (TET) and absolute pressures. The analysis of the change was focused on the compressors, as these are relatively more critical than the rest of the equipments. The change in TET triggered changes in shaft speed, mass flow rate, power output, absolute pressure etc. Adjustable guide vanes were used to study the operation with constant surge margin. The closed cycle was tested for various absolute pressures and it was established that the efficiency will not be affected in using the inventory control for the load variation.
View
GTHTR300—A nuclear power plant design with 50% generating efficiency
Article
  • Aug 2014
  • NUCL ENG DES
GTHTR300 is a gas turbine high temperature reactor power generation plant design. The baseline design reported by Japan Atomic Energy Agency a decade ago attained 45.6% net efficiency. Technological improvements have since been made that make further increase in efficiency practical: first, the cycle parameters are upgraded by utilizing the newly acquired design data including those from component tests. Next, the core design is optimized to raise the reactor outlet coolant temperature from the baseline of 850 °C to the level of 950 °C demonstrated on the long-term test reactor operation. Both core physics and thermal hydraulics are investigated to demonstrate the corresponding temperature rise is within the design limit so that the existing fuel design can continue to apply. Finally, an advanced type of turbine blade material that has only recently entered in commercial service in aircraft engine is found to be useable for this design to realize a turbine inlet temperature of 950 °C without requiring blade cooling. As detailed in this paper, these design improvements result in a nearly 5% gain in overall plant efficiency and enable the GTHTR300 to break the 50% efficiency barrier of nuclear plant while using only the existing technologies. This result is expected to contribute to the early market deployment of high temperature gas-cooled reactor.
View
View
Evaluation of alternate power conversion unit designs for the GT-MHR
Article
  • Nov 2008
  • NUCL ENG DES
General Atomics in the USA and Experimental Design Bureau of Machine Building (OKBM) in the Russian Federation have jointly developed a nuclear power plant design, the gas turbine modular helium reactor (GT-MHR). There have been considerable improvements during the last 10 years, which resulted in a more effective, efficient and safe design. The existing design is based on a 600 MW(t) reactor cooled by helium at a pressure of about 7 MPa. The power conversion unit (PCU) uses reactor outlet helium with a temperature of 850 °C in a direct Brayton cycle to achieve the cycle efficiency of about 48%. The PCU consists of a gas turbine, a recuperator, a precooler, low-pressure and high-pressure compressors, an intercooler, and a generator. The turbomachine (TM) includes the turbine, compressors and generator mounted on a single vertical shaft. TM shaft rotation speed is 4400 rpm. The shaft of generator is connected to the turbine shaft by a flexible coupling. The required grid frequency of generated electricity is achieved by a converter. All PCU components are enclosed in a single vessel. TM uses radial and axial electromagnetic bearings (EMB) for support. Catcher bearings (CB) are provided as redundant support for the TM rotor in case of EMBs failure. Several alternative PCU designs were analyzed on the basis of current progress in technologies, new world experience, and experience accumulated in the process of GT-MHR design development. Results of these analyses will be taken into account when a final PCU design is selected.
View
Raising cycle efficiency by intercooling in air-cooled gas turbines
Article
  • Nov 2006
  • APPL THERM ENG
The working temperature of a gas turbine, necessary to achieve high efficiency, makes cooling of the first turbine stages unavoidable. Air and steam can be used for cooling. A model for an air-cooled gas turbine based on the work of Young and Wilcock [J.B. Young, R.C. Wilcock, ASME J. Turbomachinery 124 (2002) 207–221] is implemented in Aspen™. Simple cycle calculations with realistic parameters of current machines are made and confirm the results of Wilcock et al. [R.C. Wilcock, J.B. Young, J.H. Horlock, ASME J. Eng. Gas Turb. Power 127 (2005) 109–120] that increasing the turbine inlet temperature no longer means an increase in gas turbine cycle efficiency. This conclusion has important consequences for gas turbines because it breaks with the general accepted trend of increasing the TIT. An intercooled gas turbine cycle is intensively investigated, taking the turbine cooling into account. Intercooling not only lowers the work of compression, but also lowers cooling air temperatures. The major influences of the intercooling on the gas turbine cycle are mapped and explained. Optimum intercooling pressure for maximum gas turbine cycle efficiency is much lower than halfway compression. A simulation of the LMS100, the most recent gas turbine on the market from GE Energy, is made to verify the simulation methodology. The claimed intercooled cycle efficiency of 46% is confirmed. Further increasing the pressure ratio and TIT can still improve the performance of the intercooled gas turbine cycle.
View
GTHTR300 design and development
Article
  • Jun 2003
  • NUCL ENG DES
In Japan Atomic Energy Research Institute (JAERI), successful development and operations of the High Temperature Engineering Test Reactor (HTTR) are coordinated by programs to study applied systems of the promising reactor technology. One such program being carried out from 2001 to 2007 is the design and development for the Gas Turbine High Temperature Reactor of 300 MWe nominal capacity (GTHTR300), aiming at demonstration of a prototype plant in 2010s in Japan. GTHTR300 features an original design of fuel cycle based on improved HTTR fuel element and of greatly simplified plant system in pursuit of economical performance with minimal development requirements. The fuel cycle characterizes on high burnup, low power peaking factor, and extended refueling interval. The plant system incorporates salient design simplification including conventional steel reactor pressure vessel, non-intercooled power conversion cycle, horizontal single-shaft turbomachine, and distributed modular maintenance of the overall plant. Planned research and development supporting detailed design efforts include performance tests of subscale components and control system. This paper describes the GTHTR300 reference design and related R&D activities in JAERI.
View