ArticlePDF Available

Phytoremediation potential of Canna indica L. in water contaminated with lead

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Today there are many technologies for wastewater treatment and rhizofiltration is one of phytoremediation techniques that is very promising for cleanup of large quantities of water with medium or low concentrations of heavy metals. The aim of this study was to investigate phytoremediation potential of ornamental plant C. indica in water contaminated with lead. The present research demonstrated that dry weight of aboveground and below-ground biomass was significantly increased at the highest treatment containing 41 mgPb/L. Lead accumulation in below-ground biomass was up to 90-fold higher than in above-ground biomass. The highest Pb concentration was recorded in root (2480.07 mg/kg) on the 21st sampling day in treatment with the most Pb added. The highest bioconcentration factor (81.16) was recorded in the nutrient solution with the least Pb added. Translocation factor was not significantly affected by lead concentration in nutrient solution or exposure time and it was low (0.01). Symptoms of lead phytotoxicity were not observed on any plant in treatments and control. The results of this research further support the idea that terrestrial plants are more suitable for rhizofiltration than aquatic plants and that C. indica can be used in rhizofiltration systems or floating islands for treatment of water polluted with lead.
Content may be subject to copyright.
© by PSP Volume 25 No. 9/2016, pages 3728-3733 Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
3728
PHYTOREMEDIATION POTENTIAL OF CANNA INDICA L.
IN WATER CONTAMINATED WITH LEAD
Nevena Cule1*, Dragica Vilotic2, Marija Nesic2, Milorad Veselinovic1, Dragana Drazic1, Suzana Mitrovic1
1 Institute of Forestry, Kneza Višeslava 3, 11030 Belgrade, Serbia
2Faculty of Forestry, University of Belgrade, Kneza Višeslava 1, 11030 Belgrade, Serbia
ABSTRACT
Today there are many technologies for
wastewater treatment and rhizofiltration is one of
phytoremediation techniques that is very promising
for cleanup of large quantities of water with
medium or low concentrations of heavy metals. The
aim of this study was to investigate
phytoremediation potential of ornamental plant C.
indica in water contaminated with lead. The present
research demonstrated that dry weight of above-
ground and below-ground biomass was
significantly increased at the highest treatment
containing 41 mgPb/L. Lead accumulation in
below-ground biomass was up to 90- fold higher
than in above-ground biomass. The highest Pb
concentration was recorded in root (2480.07 mg/kg)
on the 21st sampling day in treatment with the most
Pb added. The highest bioconcentration factor
(81.16) was recorded in the nutrient solution with
the least Pb added. Translocation factor was not
significantly affected by lead concentration in
nutrient solution or exposure time and it was low
(0.01). Symptoms of lead phytotoxicity were not
observed on any plant in treatments and control.
The results of this research further support the idea
that terrestrial plants are more suitable for
rhizofiltration than aquatic plants and that C. indica
can be used in rhizofiltration systems or floating
islands for treatment of water polluted with lead.
KEYWORDS:
rhizofiltration, lead, Canna indica L., biomass,
bioconcentration factor, translocation factor
INTRODUCTION
Plants require a considerable number of metals
in very small quantities for their growth and
development. However, some of biogenic elements,
such as Cu, Se and Zn, are toxic in high
concentrations and may be found in some types of
wastewater. Other metals such as Cd, Hg, Pb, As,
Tl and U can also be detected in industrial and other
wastewater, but they have no biological value to
living organisms, and are extremely toxic in
relatively low concentrations [1,2]. These metals
have an adverse effect to the environment and
humans because they can easily travel through the
food chain and accumulate for many years in its
highest links [3].
Rhizofiltration is one of phytoremediation
techniques that uses plant roots for the absorption,
concentration and precipitation of metals from
water [4]. Terrestrial plants are considered more
suitable for rhizofiltration because they have longer,
stronger and usually fibrous roots with a large
surface area for metal sorption [5]. Canna indica L.
(Cannaceae) may be a good candidate for heavy
metal removal from polluted water because it has
several important features of plants suitable for
phytoremediation.
The aim of this study was to investigate
phytoremediation potential of C. indica. To achieve
this aim main objectives were to grow plants in
nutrient solution with three different concentrations
of lead, to determine dry biomass of vegetative
parts, to analyse plants for lead concentration, to
compare lead concentration in above-ground and
below-ground biomass, to quantify the potential of
plant to concentrate desired metal from the medium,
and to determine the ability of the plant to
translocate heavy metal from roots to above-ground
biomass.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
The plant material was established from
rhizomes (with the approximately same number of
buds and weight) of the species C. indica which
were planted in peat at the beginning of April.
Planted material was stored in the laboratory with a
glass roof till the beginning of the experiment (the
end of May). Light regime was consistent with
normal alternation of day and night.
Well-cultivated seedlings with an average
height of 50 cm were transferred to containers filled
with 3L of modified half strength Hoagland
solution. Nutrient solution contained (mM): 2
Ca(NO3)2 x 4H2O, 3 KNO3, 3 NH4NO3, 1 MgSO4 x
7H2O, 1 KH2PO4 and 0,2 FeEDTA, and (µM) 4,5
MnSO4, 23 H3BO3, 0,1 (NH4)6Mo7O24, 0,4 ZnSO4
and 0,2 CuSO4 [6]. Solutions were changed and
© by PSP Volume 25 No. 9/2016, pages 3728-3733 Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
3729
supplemented with new ones after a week. Lead
was supplied as Pb(CH3COO)2 x 3H2O to the
medium at three different concentrations: 50 µM ,
100 µM and 200 µM containing 10 (treatment I),
21(treatment II) and 41 (treatment III) mgPb/L
solution, respectively. Plants grown in nutrient
solution without lead presented control.
Plant samples were collected on 9th and 21st
day of the experiment. Plants were removed from
nutrient solution and divided into roots, rhizomes,
stems and leaves. All vegetative parts were rinsed
three times in distilled water to remove surface
adsorbed lead. Plants were then transferred to paper
bags and dried at 80oC for 24 hours [7]. Plant
samples were milled to powder to pass 20-mesh
sieve. Representative samples were placed in plastic
containers and stored for chemical analysis.
The fresh and dry weights of vegetative parts
were measured on electronic balance in order to
determine above-ground and below-ground
biomass.
The heavy metals were extracted using a
microwave digestion method described by Senila et
al. [8]. Microwave digestion unit (CEM MDS 2000,
Berghof, Germany, Mod. Speedwave MWS3+) was
used for sample preparation. Samples of a dry well
homogenised plant material (250-300 mg) were
weighted in Teflon vessels and 5 ml of 69% HNO3
and 2 ml of 30% H2O2 were added. Closed vessels
were placed in a microwave digester. Cooled
samples were decanted in 25mL volumetric flack
and were made up to the graduated line with
distilled water [9]. Samples were then filtrated with
filter paper and stored in closed sterile containers in
refrigerator for heavy metal analysis.
Heavy metal content in plant tissue was
analysed using ICP-OES (Varian Vista-PRO, CCD
Simultaneous ICP-OES). All tissue heavy metal
concentrations are reported on a dry weight basis.
Bioconcentration factor (BCF) was used to
quantify the potential of C. indica to concentrate
desired metal from the medium. It represents the
index that indicates the possibility of the plant to
accumulate the metal of interest in relation to its
concentration in the nutrient solution [10].
Bioconcentration factor (BCF) was calculated as:
BCF
= Pb concentration in dry plant tissue (mg/kg) at harvest
initial Pb concentration in nutrient solution (mg/L)
In rhizofiltration BCF of below-ground
biomass is more relevant measurement of plants
phytoremediation potential then BCF of whole
plant or BCF of above-ground biomass [11]. For
that reason BCF was separately calculated for both
above-ground and below-ground biomass. The
higher the value of bioconcentration factor is the
plant is more suitable for phytoremediation of
targeted heavy metal [12].
Translocation factor (TF) was calculated to
determine the potential of C. indica for
phytoremediation. It represents the index that
indicates the ability of the plant to translocate heavy
metals from roots to above-ground biomass [13].
Translocation factor (TF) was calculated as:
TF
= Pb concentration in dry above ground biomass (mg/kg)
Pb concentration in dry below ground biomass (mg/kg)
Values of translocation factor less than 1
indicates that the heavy metal accumulates largely
in below-ground biomass and its translocation to
the above-ground biomass is poor [14].
Influences of various treatments on biomass
dry weight, lead concentration in biomass,
bioconcentration factor and translocation factor
were tested using one-way analysis of variance
(ANOVA) followed by Fisher's LSD test (P <
0.05). All statistical analyses were carried out using
Statgraphics Centurion XVI (Statpoint
Technologies, Inc., Warrenton, VA, USA).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The results obtained from the analysis of
effects of treatments and sampling day on the dry
weight biomass of C. indica are presented in Fig.1.
The present study demonstrated that dry weight of
above-ground and below-ground biomass were not
significantly affected by lead concentration in
control and treatments I and II on both sampling
days. Significant increase of dry weight biomass
was determined only at the highest treatment
containing 41 mgPb/L.
FIGURE 1
Effects of treatments on above-ground and
below-ground biomass.
ab bba
bbb
a
bb
b
a
bbb
a
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0 I II III
Biomass (g)
Treatmen Pb conc. (mg /L)
AGB 9
AGB 21
BGB 9
BGB 21
© by PSP Volume 25 No. 9/2016, pages 3728-3733 Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
3730
Within each graph different letters indicate
significant differences between treatments on the
same sampling day. Error bars represent ± SE of the
mean of 6 replicates. (AGB9 and AGB21 - above-
ground biomass on 9th and 21st sampling day,
respectively; BGB9 and BGB21 - below-ground
biomass on 9th and 21st sampling day, respectively)
The reason for this is not clear but biomass
weight could be affected by changes in enzyme
activity, mineral nutrition, hormonal status or
membrane permeability [15]. Although, our results
differ from some published studies [16,17,18,19],
they are consistent with those of De Jesus and
Yllano [10] who showed significant increases in the
root and shoot biomass of Zea mays L. in the
highest Pb treatment where Pb was supplied as
Pb(NO3)2.
Canna indica L. regulated lead uptake so that
concentration in plant tissue reflected levels of lead
in growth media (Tab. 1 and Tab. 2). The content of
lead in plants also increased with exposure time.
This was in agreement with data obtained by Bose
et al. [20] and De Jesus and Yllano [10].
The highest Pb accumulation in above-ground
biomass was 26.39 mg/kg at highest Pb supply on
the 21st sampling day (Tab. 1). The leaf and steam
contribute to this value was almost equal with 12.16
mg/kg and 14.23 mg/kg, respectively (Tab. 2).
These results are consistent with those of
Subhashini and Swamy [21] for lead accumulation
in C. indica and Qian et al. [22] for several wetland
plants such as Cyperus alternifolius L., Marsilea
drummondii A.Braun, Myriophyllum
brasiliense Camb. The accumulation of lead in
above-ground biomass was much lower compared
to Z. mays and Brassica juncea but close to lead
accumulated by B. juncea cv. 184290 [23].
Lead accumulation in below-ground biomass
was up to 90- fold higher than in above-ground
biomass. The same trend of accumulation was
observed in Z. mays [10] and B. juncea [23]. The
highest Pb bioaccumulation in below-ground
biomass was 2807.85 mg/kg at the highest Pb
supply on the 21st sampling day (Tab. 1). The root
accumulated much more Pb then rhizome with
2480.07 mg/kg and 327.77 mg/kg, respectively
(Tab. 2). These results are in line with those
obtained for Z. mays [10]. However, C. indica in
this study accumulated more Pb compared to other
findings for C. indica [21], Z. mays [23] and
wetland plants such as Polygonum hydropiperoides
Michx., C. alternifolius, M. drummondii and M.
brasiliense [22]. Dushenkov et al. [5] reported that
B. juncea was among the best accumulators in their
study with 136000 mgPb/kg thus C. indica in this
study was far behind stated results for B. juncea.
Results (Tab. 3) showed that different
treatments had an effect on BCF of above- ground
and below-ground biomass on the 9th sampling day
(p<0.05). However, with the duration of the
experiment differences in BCF among treatments
were reduced both for the above-ground and for the
below-ground biomass (p>0.05).
TABLE 1
Mean Pb concentration in above-ground and below-ground biomass (mg/kg)
Treatment
Pb concentration (mg/kg)
Above-ground biomass
Below-ground biomass
9 day
9 day
21 day
I
4.32±0.560b
278.61±32.876b
840.89±73.535b
II
13.79±2.454a
1178.41±167.637a
1536.10±213.770b
III
15.87±2.348a
1216.05±60.073a
2807.85±408.962a
Values with a different letters within column and on the same sampling day are significantly different at <0.05.
Values are means ± SE of six replicates. TABLE 2
Mean Pb concentration in different vegetative parts (mg/kg)
Sampling
day
Vegetative
part
Treatments
I
II
III
9
Leaf
2.68±0.441b
7.75±1.131b
11.41±2.462c
Steam
1.63±0.293b
6.04±1.499b
4.46±0.897c
Rhizome
39.58±6.626b
96.04±21.369b
144.92±21.770b
Root
239.03±28.365a
1082.37±149.926a
1071.12±57.566a
21
Leaf
3.97±0.230b
6.40±1.281b
12.16±0.926b
Steam
4.39±1.234b
14.43±3.773b
14.23±3.125b
Rhizome
75.55±3.979b
129.72±32.350b
327.77±99.875b
Root
765.34±72.447a
1406.38±188.990a
2480.07±374.995a
Values with a different letters within column and on the same sampling day are significantly different at <0.05.
Values are means ± SE of six replicates.
© by PSP Volume 25 No. 9/2016, pages 3728-3733 Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
3731
TABLE 3
Effects of treatments on BCF of above-and below-ground biomass and TF
Treatment
BCF of above-ground biomass
BCF of below-ground biomass
TF
9 day
21 day
9 day
21 day
9 day
21 day
I
0.41±0.053b
0.80±0.134a
26.89±3.174b
81.16±7.099a
0.02±0.001a
0.01±0.001a
II
0.67±0.120a
1.02±0.239a
57.70±8.209a
75.22±10.468a
0.01±0.001a
0.01±0.001a
III
0.38±0.056b
0.63±0.087a
29.34±1.449b
67.75±9.868a
0.01±0.001a
0.01±0.002a
Values with a different letters within column and on the same sampling day are significantly different at <0.05.
Values are means ± SE of six replicates
Contrary to the highest value of Pb
accumulation in the treatment with the highest Pb
supply, the highest BCF of below-ground biomass
(81.16) was recorded in the nutrient solution with
the least Pb added. In this study C. indica had
greater BCF compared to same plant in the
experiment carried by Subhashini and Swamy [21]
where BCF of whole plant did not reach more than
3.64. However, this maximum BCF value was
much lower than root BCF of Z. mays, B. juncea
and B. juncea cv. 184290 [23].
The above-ground biomass BCF was much
lower compared to below-ground biomass. This
further support finding of this study that much more
lead was accumulated from nutrient solution and
stored in roots than translocated to rhizome, steam
and leaves. The highest above-ground biomass BCF
was 1.02 in treatment II with medium Pb supply. As
with below-ground biomass BCF this value was
being far less than shoot BCF of the Z. mays, B.
juncea and B. juncea cv. [23].
The current study found that TF was not
significantly affected by lead concentration in
nutrient solution or exposure time (Tab. 3).
Translocation of lead was restricted from roots to
above-ground biomass thus TF was very low with a
value of 0.01 in all treatments and sampling days
except in treatment with the lowest Pb supply on
the 9th sampling day where it reached value of 0.02.
Several reports have also shown low TF for C.
indica [20], Brassica napus L. [13] and Z. mays, B.
juncea and B. juncea cv. 184290 [23]. It seems
possible that limited transport of lead from root to
other vegetative parts is due to the root endodermis
which acts as a barrier permitting lead entrance into
the central cylinder [15]. Seregin et al. [24] point
out that at the lethal concentrations of Pb the
plasmalemma is damaged, its barrier function is
broken and thus the greater amount of heavy metals
moves in to the symplast. It appears that Pb was
not supplied in lethal doses in present experiment so
low concentrations of Pb were found in above-
ground biomass compared to below-ground
biomass and thus TF was very low.
Based on the results of this study it could be
argued that C. indica may be classified as an
indicator plant in accordance to its ability to absorb,
accumulate and tolerate lead in its tissue. The plant
had a lower heavy metal accumulation as compared
to hyperaccumulators but it can produce at least ten
times greater biomass and thus the amount of the
accumulated heavy metals from contaminated
media is much higher. Furthermore, as a terrestrial
plant C. indica is also more suitable for
rhizofiltration than aquatic plants. The limited
rhizofiltration potential of aquatic macrophytes is
attributed to their relatively small root and its slow
growth rate in addition to the high water content in
their tissue which complicates their drying [5].
Results of our previous studies [25] showed that C.
indica can produced a significant amount of
biomass both of the above-ground and below-
ground biomass after a month and a half of growing
in water without the addition of any nutrients.
Furthermore, the plants were able to develop very
dense, strong fibrous roots with a large area for the
sorption of heavy metals. These findings further
suggest that C. indica may be tolerant to poor
environmental conditions.
The visual non-specific symptoms of lead
phytotoxicity [26] were not observed on any plant
in treatments and control. This finding was
unexpected and it may be the first step in
suggesting the strong possibility that C. indica may
also be tolerant to high levels of lead. The results of
this study corroborate the findings of Zurayk et al.
[11] who suggested that ability to tolerate high
levels of targeted heavy metal may be associated
with an increase of phytoaccumulation, with the
increase of heavy metal supply and restricted
translocation of heavy metal from root to shoot.
CONCLUSION
The findings of this study strongly suggest that
it is possible that C. indica is a very good candidate
for rhizofiltration of water contaminated with Pb.
The plant was tolerant to high Pb concentration in
nutrient solution thus the plant growth was not
impaired. Based on this fact and previous research
[25] it can be concluded that C. indica can grow
fast, rapidly produce large biomass and a dense root
system in unpolluted as well as in contaminated
water. Although, accumulation of Pb was not high
compared to B. juncea, C. indica performance was
generally better than commonly used plant species
for phytoremediation of Pb [1,10,14,16,22,23]. C.
© by PSP Volume 25 No. 9/2016, pages 3728-3733 Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
3732
indica was able to limit root to shoot translocation
of Pb thus prevent the entry of lead into the food
chain, hinder its bio-magnification in the
environment and reduce the amount of secondary
waste at the end of rhizofiltration process. C. indica
is widespread ornamental species that is well
adapted to various climatic conditions. And finally,
the establishment and cultivation of the C. indica
seedlings were very simple. The results of this
research further support the idea that terrestrial
plants are more suitable for rhizofiltration than
aquatic plants and that C. indica can be used in
rhizofiltration systems or floating islands for
treatment of water polluted with lead.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
This paper was realized as a part of the
doctoral dissertation by Nevena Cule
Phytoremediation of polluted water by plant
Canna indica L. and selected decorative
macrophytes” at University of Belgrade.
REFERENCES
[1] Kamal, M., Ghalya, A.E., Mahmouda, N.,
Cote, R. (2004) Phytoaccumulation of heavy
metals by aquatic plants. Environment
international, 29 (8), 1029-1039.
[2] Sekulić, P., Kastori, R., Hadžić, V. (2003)
Zaštita zemljišta od degradacije. Novi Sad,
Naučni institut za ratarstvo i povrtarstvo. (in
Serbian)
[3] Gutiérrez-Ginés, M.J., Pastor, J. and Hernández
A.J. (2010) Effect of heavy metals from mine
soils on Avena sativa l. and education
strategies. Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
19, 9b, 2083-2086.
[4] Zhu, Y.L., Zayed, A.M., Quian, J.H., De
Souza, M. and Terry, N. (1999)
Phytoaccumulation of trace elements by
wetland plants: II. Water hyacinth. Journal of
Environmental Quality, 28 (1), 339-344.
[5] Dushenkov, S., Kumar, P.B.A. N., Motto and
H., Raskin, I. (1995) Rhizofiltration: the Use of
Plants to Remove Heavy Metals From Aqueous
Streams. Environmental Science Technology
29(5), 1239-1245.
[6] Zayed, A., Lytle, C.M., Qian, J.-H., Terry, N.
(1998) Chromium accumulation, translocation
and chemical speciation in vegetable crops.
Planta, 206(2), 293-299.
[7] Campbell, C.R. and Plank, C.O. (1998)
Preparation of plant tissue for laboratory
analysis. In: Kalra, Y.P. (ed.) Handbook of
reference methods for plant analysis. Boca
Raton: CRC Press, Taylor & Francis Group,
37-49.
[8] Senila, M., Senila, L., Roman, C. (2011)
Evaluation of performance parameters for trace
elements analysis in perennial plants using
ICP-OES technique. Journal of Plant
Development, 18, 87-93.
[9] Aksoy, A. and Sahin, U. (1999) Elaeagnus
angustifolia L. as a Biomonitor of Heavy Metal
Pollution. Tr. J. of Botany 23(2), 83-87.
[10] De Jesus, B.R. and Yllano, O.B. (2005)
Bioaccumulation and Bioconcentration of Pb in
the Tissues of Zea mays L. Philippine Journal
of Science 134 (1), 21-29.
[11] Zurayk, R., Sukkariyah, B., Baalbaki, R.,
Ghanem, D.A. (2002) Ni Phytoaccumulation
in Mentha aquatica L. and Mentha sylvestris L.
Water, Air & Soil Pollution, 139(1),355-364.
[12] Blaylock, M.J., Salt, D.E., Dushenkov, S.,
Zakharova, O., Gussman, C., Kapulnik, Y.,
Ensley, B.D. and Raskin. I. (1997) Enhanced
accumulation of Pb in Indian mustard by soil-
applied chelating agents. Environmental
Science and Technology, 31 (3), 860- 865.
[13] Marchiol, L., Assolari, S., Sacco, P., Zerbi, G.
(2004) Phytoextraction of heavy metals by
canola (Brassica napus) and radish (Raphanus
sativus) grown on multicontaminated soil.
Environmental Pollution 132(1), 21-27.
[14] Mellem, J.J., Baijnath, H., Bharti Odhav, B.
(2009) Translocation and accumulation of Cr,
Hg, As, Pb, Cu and Ni by Amaranthus dubius
(Amaranthaceae) from contaminated sites.
Journal of environmental science and health.
Part A, Toxic/hazardous substances &
environmental engineering, 44 (6), 568575.
[15] Sharma, P. and Dubey, R,S. (2005) Lead
toxicity in plants. Brazilian Journal of Plant
Physiology, 17(1), 35-52.
[16] Wang, Q., Cui, Y., Dong, Y. (2002)
Phytoremediation of Polluted Waters Potentials
and Prospects of Wetland Plants. Acta
Biotechnologica, 22 (1-2), 199-208.
[17] Mishra, A. and Choudhuri, M,A. (1998)
Amelioration of lead and mercury effects on
germination and rice seedling growth by
antioxidants. Biologia Plantarum, 41(3), 469-
473.
[18] Breckle, C.W. (1991) Growth under heavy
metals. In: Waisel, Y., Eshel, A., Kafkafi, U.
(eds.) Plant roots: the hidden half. New York,
NY: Marcel Dekker, 351-373.
[19] Obroucheva, N.V., Bystrova, E.I., Ivanov,
V.B., Antipova, O.V., Seregin, I.V. (1998)
Root growth responses to lead in young maize
seedlings. Plant and Soil, 200(1), 55-61.
[20] Bose, S., Jain, А., Rai, V., Ramanathan, A.L.
(2008) Chemical fractionation and
translocation of heavy metals in Canna indica
L. grown on industrial waste amended soil.
Journal of Hazardous Materials 160(1), 187-
193.
© by PSP Volume 25 No. 9/2016, pages 3728-3733 Fresenius Environmental Bulletin
3733
[21] Subhashini, V. and Swamy, A.V.V.S. (2014)
Phytoremediation of Metal (Pb, Ni, Zn, Cd
And Cr) Contaminated Soils Using Canna
Indica. Current World Environment, 9(3), 780-
784.
[22] Qian, J.H., Zayed, A., Zhu, Y.L., Yu, M.
and Terry, N. (1999) Phytoaccumulation of
Trace Elements by Wetland Plants: III. Uptake
and Accumulation of Ten Trace Elements by
Twelve Plant Species. Journal of
Environmental Quality, 28(5), 1448-1455.
[23] Huang, J.W. and Cunningham, S.D. (1996)
Lead phytoextraction: Species variation in lead
uptake and translocation. New Phytologist,
134(1), 75-84.
[24] Seregin, I.V., Shpigun, L.K., Ivanov,
V.B. (2004) Distribution and Toxic Effects of
Cadmium and Lead on Maize Roots. The
Russian Journal of Plant Physiology, 51(4),
525-533.
[25] Cule, N., Jovanovic, Lj., Drazic, D.,
Veselinovic, M., Mitrovic, S., Nesic, M. (2011)
Indian Shoot (Canna indica L.) In
Phytoremediation Of Water Contaminated
With Heavy Metals. Sustainable forestry, 63-
64, 51-64.
[26] Burton, K.W., Morgan, E., Roig, A. (1984) The
influence of heavy metals upon the growth of
sitka-spruce in South Wales forests II.
Greenhouse experiments. Plant and Soil, 78(3),
271-282.
Received: 01.04.2016
Accepted: 11.07.2016
CORRESPONDING AUTHOR
Nevena Cule
Institute of Forestry, Kneza Viseslava 3
11030 Belgrade, Serbia
e-mail: nevena.cule@yahoo.com
... Therefore, wet plants, emerging fauna, aquatic leaf fauna, and submerged plant species are often used to sequester pollutants in wastewater. Other plant species frequently used for phytoremediation include sweet flag [42], cattail and sweet grass [43], canna species [44], Amaranthus caudatus L. and Tagetes patula L. [45], water hyacinth [46], Typha latifolia and Thelypteris palustris [47], Duckweed [48] and Cyperus alternifolius [49]. In addition, the economic importance, potency and the cost of the plant species are considered in selection of a suitable plant for the process. ...
Article
There are numerous benefits to treating wastewater using bacteriological and phytochemical methods. Microorganisms are employed in bioremediation to break down or reduce the concentration of harmful substances in polluted environments. In phytoremediation, green plants absorb harmful pollutants and restore abiotic conditions. These methods are often more cost-effective and environmentally friendly compared to conventional approaches. The synergy between plants and microorganisms is effectively utilized in processes like constructed wetlands or wastewater treatment wetlands, which offer several advantages, including low energy requirements, aesthetic appeal, and habitat creation for various wildlife species. However, the combined application of microorganisms and plants in wastewater treatment has not been thoroughly investigated or fully understood. Therefore, this analysis aims to evaluate the roles of microorganisms and plants in wastewater treatment, their interactions, and the conditions that facilitate these processes.
... ICP-AES was used to test for heavy metal concentrations in the root and shoot (leave and stem) of the C. indica after digestion. The bioconcentration factor (BCF) was determined as follows: [11,12] Where; b= metal concentration in plant (mg/kg); a= metal concentration in industrial wastewater (mg/L) The BCF of below-ground biomass is a more accurate indicator of a plant's phytoremediation potential than the BCF of the plant body or the BCF of aboveground biomass [13] G. Translocation Factor (TF) The TF is a measure that indicates a plant's ability to transport heavy metals from the roots to aboveground biomass. By dividing the metal content in aboveground tissues by the metal content in root tissues, the TF was derived. ...
Experiment Findings
Full-text available
Delhi is a key center for industry, trade, and production as the country's capital. Due to heavy metals pollution's longevity, scientists are becoming interested in phytoremediation; a low-cost, ecologically friendly plant-based remediation approach. This study aims to see how effective plant species canna lilly (C. indica) grown in a hydroponic system using different concentrations for removing heavy metal s (Cr, Cu, Fe, Pb, and Zn) from integrated industrial wastewater (IIWW). The test plants were placed in five different troughs containing 100%, 80%, 60%, 40% of IIWW, and a control trough (tap water) and conducted study for 25 days. The results suggest that C. indica has the maximum heavy metal reduction efficiency at 80% from IIWW. Besides this, the Bioconcentration factor (BAF) and translocation factor results were also recorded at 80% of IIWW concentrations. The plant attributes in terms of root and shoot plant length and fresh weight and dry weight (root and shoots) of C. indica were significantly (P<0.001) recorded after the phytoremediation experiment. This study may be encouraging to employ CW-based treatment as a decentralized water treatment in periurban and rural areas, to relieve stress on natural water bodies.
... Each of cells I-IV had three floating islands with 25 (in the first three cells) or 30 (in cell IV) seedlings, using stone wool as a substrate. Non-invasive and plants suitable for rhizofiltration (Blaylock and Huang, 2000;Cule et al., 2016;Dushenkov et al., 1995;Kumar et al., 1995;Salt et al., 1995) were selected and obtained from local nurseries. Species Phragmites australis (Cav.) ...
Article
Full-text available
This paper aims to analyse the dynamic responses within FTW constructed on the riverbank, focusing on pH, dissolved oxygen (DO), and the dynamics of calcium and magnesium concentrations. While some research has been carried out on Ca and Mg behavior in constructed wetlands no papers specifically addressed the removal mechanisms of these ions in FTWs have been found. Results showed that both polluted and treated water exhibited characteristics consistent with a mildly alkaline environment. Extremely low DO levels in cells with floating islands were increased after water passing through cell with algae. Ca removal efficiency in cells with floating island cells ranged from 2% to 6%, while the cell with algae achieved 23% to 49% efficiency. Modest Mg removal (1-6%) could indicate potential challenges in Mg removal processes within the FTWs. The analysis of plant responses to polluted water exposure reveals species-specific variations in Ca and Mg concentrations in shoots and roots. Ca concentration in algae tissue increased over time contrasting the marked decrease of Mg content. The study also revealed a gradual decrease of Ca and Mg concentration in stone wool corresponding to exposure duration. This research contributes to a better understanding of the complex dynamics of water treatment in FTWs, emphasizing the need for continued investigation into ion removal mechanisms, plant responses to increased Ca and Mg concentrations, and the role of algae in these biological systems.
... The plant species which possess high tolerance towards metal toxicity and have a high surface area for absorption of metal are preferred (e.g., Salix spp., Populus spp., Brassica spp.). Terrestrial plants have been reported as a suitable candidate for rhizofilteration as they possess a more developed and fibrous root structure, thus provide a higher surface area for absorption of contaminants (Cule et al. 2016). This strategy can be applied for the remediation of contaminated sites loaded with heavy metals and radionuclides. ...
... AMF colonization in the three different inoculation treatments C. indica is a pioneer EFB plant species that commonly occurs in the remediation of various contaminated water bodies, such as rivers (Liu et al., 2020), lakes (Wu et al., 2016), coastal wetlands (Lyu et al., 2020) and reservoirs (Xin, 2012). It is widely used to purify HM-contaminated wastewater (Cule et al., 2016;Dong et al., 2019;Olawale et al., 2021). It has strong vitality and can resist various abiotic stresses due to its developed aerenchyma and adventitious roots. ...
Article
Arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi (AMF) have been demonstrated to be ubiquitous in aquatic ecosystems. However, their distributions and ecological functions are rarely studied. To date, a few studies have combined sewage treatment facilities with AMF to improve removal efficiency, but appropriate and highly tolerant AMF strains have not been explored, and the purification mechanisms remain unclear. In this study, three ecological floating-bed (EFB) installations inoculated with different AMF inocula (mine AMF inoculum, commercial AMF inoculum and non-AMF inoculated) were constructed to investigate their removal efficiency for Pb-contaminated wastewater. The AMF community structure shifts in the roots of Canna indica inhabiting EFBs during the three phases (pot culture phase, hydroponic phase and hydroponic phase with Pb stress) were tracked utilizing quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction and Illumina sequencing techniques. Furthermore, transmission electron microscopy (TEM) and energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) were used to detect the Pb location in mycorrhizal structures. The results showed that AMF could promote host plant growth and enhance the Pb removal efficiency of the EFBs. The higher the AMF abundance, the better the effect of the AMF on Pb purification by EFBs. Both flooding and Pb stress decreased the AMF diversity but did not significantly inhibit the abundance. The three inoculation treatments showed different community compositions with different dominant AMF taxa in different phases, and an uncultured Paraglomus species (Paraglomus sp. LC516188.1) was found to be the most dominant (99.65 %) AMF in the hydroponic phase with Pb stress. The TEM and EDS analysis results showed that the Paraglomus sp. could accumulate Pb in plant roots through their fungal structures (intercellular mycelium, intracellular mycelium, etc.), which alleviated the toxic effect of Pb on plant cells and limited Pb translocation. The new findings provide a theoretical basis for the application of AMF in plant-based bioremediation of wastewater and polluted waterbodies.
... In recent years, especially in countries with a warmer climate, canna has been increasingly used as a plant element of a sewage treatment plant useful in phytoremediation. Phosphorus and nitrogen from contaminated water from households can be effectively treated by canna [3][4][5], as well as lead in rhizofiltration systems [6] or oil refinery wastewater [7]. In addition, canna positively affects the preservation of biodiversity in ecosystems through flowers that attract birds and insects [8,9]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Recently, the ecological awareness of society and the need to take care of our surroundings and the natural environment has significantly increased. There is also an urgent problem of searching for new, environmentally friendly techniques for its purification (soil, ground and surface waters, sewage sludge and air) with the use of living organisms, especially higher plants. One plant species investigated for phytoremediation is canna. Ten varieties of canna, grown on degraded and garden soil, were tested in this respect. The disease index and species composition of fungi inhabiting its organs, growth dynamics, parameters of photosynthesis and gas exchange were determined. The conducted research showed that cannas are able to satisfactorily grow even in seemingly unfavorable soil conditions with its strong degradation. Among a total of 24 species of fungi obtained from its organs, genus Fusarium, considered as pathogenic for canna, Alternaria alternata, and, less frequently, Thanatephorus cucumeris and Botrytis cinerea, dominated. The cultivars ‘Picasso’, ‘Cherry Red’, ‘President’ and ‘La Boheme’ had lower rates of photosynthesis and gas exchange than the least affected ‘Botanica’, ‘Wyoming’, ‘Robert Kemp’ and ‘Lucifer’ cultivars. Those turned out to be the most beneficial and they can be recommended for cultivation on strongly degenerated soils.
Article
Full-text available
The value chain concept is often used in the analysis of agricultural competitiveness. Its application seeks ways and activities that add value to products. The focus is on finding opportunities for efficient monitoring of modern trends, challenges and business risk assessment in order to sustainably produce processing and marketing of agri-food products. The production of fruits and vegetables by small producers is characterized by short chains from production to product placement, without adding value. There are numerous critical points in the analyzed chains, such as quality of input, processing, drying and storage of products, lack of training and financial resources for storage and preservation of products after harvest. The link between primary production and the processing industry should ensure stability for primary producers in terms of the market, and entities in the processing industry for continuity in the supply of raw materials of domestic origin. In order to improve product value chains, and thus the competitiveness of the national agri-food sector, it is necessary to improve productivity in primary production, horizontal and vertical integration, as well as additional investments in processing capacities. The key areas in the legislation and its implementation in order to improve the value chain of livestock products are: animal husbandry, hygiene on farms and in meat processing plants, as well as environmental protection. These are some of the priorities that should create the conditions for the possibility of exporting live animals, meat and meat products to the EU. Improving the milk value chain would contribute to better efficiency, competitiveness and sustainability of production, milk quality, especially in microbiological terms (reduction of the number of bacteria and somatic cells). Conditions should be created for the adoption of good agricultural practice, adaptation to market requirements, reaching standards in the field of animal welfare and health, improving the genetic potential of animals for milk production, hygiene and environmental protection. Quality is an important factor in competitiveness and sustainable agricultural production. As the main elements of the quality management system and adding value to products, the appropriate standards are applied: ISO 9000, HACCP, GMP, ISO 22000, ISO 14000, HALAL standard, Kosher standard, BRC standard, GOST-R standard, Demeter, GLOBAL GAP, IFS standard . In order to overcome and solve environmental problems of agricultural development, more and more importance is attached to the application of animal protection policy measures. Domestic and international standards and regulations for environmental management ISO 14001 are applied, including the EU Environmental Management and Audit Scheme (EMAS). Genetic potentials and biological diversification are important for the development and sustainability of agricultural production. The richness of flora and fauna, genetic resources and great biological diversity constitute natural comparative advantages in every respect, especially for sustainable agricultural production and environmental protection.
Chapter
Lead (Pb) is one of most widely studied heavy metals in respect to plant responses and accumulation potential in tissues, but scientific opinion on the use of plants in phytoremediation of Pb-contaminated soil and wastewater is sometimes controversial. Therefore, the aim of the present review was to analyze recent information on phytoremediation of lead, emphasizing possible problems related to use of various experimental systems. After a brief review of Pb tolerance and uptake by plants, an analysis of Pb accumulation in various experimental systems was performed. It is evident that the use of plant material from natural metal-contaminated habitats cannot give reliable results due to possible aerial contamination. Similarly, while hydroponic cultivation system has been frequently used for Pb accumulation experiments, it is that that extrapolation of results obtained in hydroponic experiments can be misleading and cannot be used for estimation of Pb accumulation capacity. Sometimes, experiments in tissue culture are employed for assessment of Pb accumulation, but the degree of generalization of the obtained results is limited by the possible interaction of Pb with medium components, as well as the dependence of the results on the type of explants. Soil-based experimental systems seems to be the most reliable for evaluation of Pb accumulation potential in plants. In contrast to chemically-assisted Pb phytoremediation systems, which have several problems of practical nature, microbially-assisted systems combined with co-cropping seem to be the most perspective for practical use.KeywordsAccumulationLeadPhytoremediation
Article
Full-text available
The aim of this paper is to present the validation of inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectrometry (ICP-OES) method used for metals determination from several perennial plant samples. The suitability of two digestion procedures using wet digestion with mineral acids mixture on hot plate and microwave digestion was investigated to determine As, Cd, Cu, Fe, Mn, Pb and Zn in plants samples. The LOD of the seven analysed elements in solid samples varied between 0.20µg g-1 for Mn and 0.55µg g-1 for Pb. The found values for metals determined by ICP-OES in a vegetable certified reference material digested using the two procedures were compared with the certified values and good agreements between these values were obtained. The proposed method indicated satisfactory recovery, detection limits and standard deviations for trace metal determination in perennial plants samples.
Article
Full-text available
Wetland plants are being used successfully for the phytoremediation of trace elements in natural and constructed wetlands. This study demonstrates the potential of water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes), an aquatic floating plant, for the phytoremediation of six trace elements. The ability of water hyacinth to take up and translocate six trace elements--As(V), Cd(II), Cr(VI), Cu(II), Ni(II), and Se(VI)--was studied under controlled conditions. Water hyacinth accumulated Cd and Cr best, Se and Cu at moderate levels, and was a poor accumulator of As and Ni. The highest levels of Cd found in shoots and roots were 371 and 6103 mg kg[sup [minus]1] dry wt., respectively, and those of Cr were 119 and 32951 mg kg[sup [minus]1] dry wt, respectively. Cadmium, Cr, Cu, Ni, and As were more highly accumulated in roots than in shoots. In contrast, Se was accumulated more in shoots than in roots at most external concentrations. Water hyacinth had high trace element bioconcentration factors when supplied with low external concentrations of all six elements, particularly Cd, Cr, and Cu. Therefore, water hyacinth will be very efficient at phytoextracting trace elements from wastewater containing low concentrations of these elements. The authors conclude that water hyacinth is a promising candidate for phytoremediation of wastewater polluted with Cd, Cr, Cu, and Se.
Article
Full-text available
Contamination of soils by heavy metals is of widespread occurrence as a result of human, agricultural and industrial activities. Among heavy metals, lead is a potential pollutant that readily accumulates in soils and sediments. Although lead is not an essential element for plants, it gets easily absorbed and accumulated in different plant parts. Uptake of Pb in plants is regulated by pH, particle size and cation exchange capacity of the soils as well as by root exudation and other physico-chemical parameters. Excess Pb causes a number of toxicity symptoms in plants e.g. stunted growth, chlorosis and blackening of root system. Pb inhibits photosynthesis, upsets mineral nutrition and water balance, changes hormonal status and affects membrane structure and permeability. This review addresses various morphological, physiological and biochemical effects of Pb toxicity and also strategies adopted by plants for Pb-detoxification and developing tolerance to Pb. Mechanisms of Pb-detoxification include sequestration of Pb in the vacuole, phytochelatin synthesis and binding to glutathione and aminoacids etc. Pb tolerance is associated with the capacity of plants to restrict Pb to the cell walls, synthesis of osmolytes and activation of antioxidant defense system. Remediation of soils contaminated with Pb using phytoremediation and rhizofiltration technologies appear to have great potential for cleaning of Pb-contaminated soils.
Article
Heavy metals in the soils of old mining areas, besides affecting the productivity of their ecosystems, could also affect animal and human health. To test this hypothesis, we assessed the bioavailability of heavy metals to forage crops used as human food sources or components of fodder. The sites examined were the surrounding soils of two abandoned mines in Central Spain polluted with Al, Fe, Mn, and more than one of the heavy metals Zn, Pb, Cd, Cu, Cr or Ni, and As. All elements were determined by plasma emission spectroscopy with the exception of As, which was quantified by XRF. Levels of Zn, Pb, Cd, Cu and Fe were high in roots as well as in the above-ground parts of the plants, and high As levels were also found in roots. The accumulation of heavy metals by this plant was assessed in terms of its possible use for phytoremediation but also in view of its possible detrimental impacts on humans as well as wild and domestic animals. Strategies for education in areas faced with this problem are also proposed. People living in rural areas will need to be taught ecological concepts but we will also have to alert political leaders and administrators to the problem to encourage them to invest in dealing with polluted soils. In this context, it is essential to understand both the elements and processes affecting ecosystems and the perception and opinions held by the rural population of the problem of soil pollution.
Article
Heavy metal pollution has become one of the most serious environmental problems today. Remediation of heavy metal polluted soils is one of the significant topics in environmental restoration. As a plant based technology the success of phytoremediation is inherently dependent upon proper plant selection. The present study is an attempt to test the potential of the native species to remove heavy metals from the soil. A pot experiment was conducted to study the metal accumulation capacity of Canna indica L. Canna indica was known as Indian shot belongs to the family Cannaceae. High biomass herb species was selected to restrict the passage of contaminants into the food chain by selecting non-edible, disease resistant and tolerant plants and have very pleasant flowers. Based on the BCF and TF the plant species was used in Pb, Zn and Cr phytoextraction process and Ni and Cd phytostabilization processes. Finally it was concluded that the species was good accumulator of Pb, Ni, Zn, Cd and Cr.
Article
The leaves of Elaeagnus angustifolia L. (Elaeagnaceae) were tested as a possible biomonitor of heavy metal pollution in Kayseri. Concentration of Pb, Cd and Zn were determined in unwashed and washed leaves and soils. Differences between the unwashed and washed samples varied according to the metal pollutant levels. Significant correlations were obtained between the heavy metal concentrations in surface soil and washed leaf samples. E. angustifolia was found to be a useful biomonitor of the heavy metals investigated.
Article
Experiments on sitka-spruce seedlings grown in acidic peaty gley soils under green-house conditions, where the soils where doped with increasing amounts of Cd, Cu and Pb up to maximum levels of metal added of 16 ppm, 32 ppm and 400 ppm respectively, showed that the levels of Cd and Pb in shoots and roots increased with increasing levels in the soil, whereas levels of copper appeared to be independent. The addition of these three metals to the soils did not influence the uptake of other heavy metals, or of the nutrients potassium or calcium. Increases in the shoot cadmium levels significantly reduced the yields of the plant shoots. However, the plant yields were only affected by the highest level of lead that was added to the soil (400 ppm Pb) and unaffected by all the copper treatments (0-32 ppm Cu in the soil). The lengths of the sitka-spruce roots were reduced when cadmium and lead levels in the soil exceeded certain threshold concentrations (2.5 ppm total Cd, where 0.3 ppm was extractable with 0.5 M acetic acid; and 48 ppm total Pb, where 1.7 ppm was extractable). However, root lengths were not reduced by copper. This was probably related to the fact that copper appears to be relatively unavailable in the type of soil used, as only 1.1. ppm Cu was extractable from a total of 32 ppm Cu added. Root branching was apparently reduced by increases in the soil levels of cadmium, copper and lead. The roots of some control plants had symbiotic mycorrhizal associations (4 out of 19 plants), whereas the roots of all the plants grown in the soils with added heavy metals did not develop these.
Article
Interest is increasing in using wetland plants in constructed wetlands to remove toxic elements from polluted wastewater. To identify those wetland plants that hyperaccumulate trace elements, 12 plant species were tested for their efficiency to bioconcentrate 10 potentially toxic trace elements including As, b, Cd, Cr, Cu, Pb, Mn, Hg, Ni, and Se. Individual plants were grown under carefully controlled conditions and supplied with 1 mg L⁻¹ of each trace element individually for 10 d. Except B, all elements accumulated to much higher concentrations in roots than in shoots. Highest shoot tissue concentrations (mg kg⁻¹ DW) of the various trace elements were attained by the following species: umbrella plant (Cyperus alternifolius L.) for Mn (198) and Cr (44); water zinnia (Wedelia trilobata Hitchc.) for Cd (148) and Ni (80); smartweed (Polygonum hydropiperoides Michx.) for Cu (95) and Pb (64); water lettuce (Pistia stratiotes L.) for Hg (92), As (34), and Se (39); and mare's tail (hippuris vulgaris L.) for B (1132). Whereas, the following species attained the highest root tissue concentrations (mg kg⁻¹ DW); stripped rush (Baumia rubiginosa) for Mn (1683); parrot's feather (Myriophyllum brasiliense Camb.) for Cd (1426) and Ni (1077); water lettuce for Cu (1038), Hg (1217), and As (177); smartweed for Cr (2980) and Pb (1882); mare's tail for B (1277); and monkey flower (Mimulus guttatus Fisch.) for Se (384). From a phytoremediation perspective, smartweed was probably the best plant species for trace element removal from wastewater due to its faster growth and higher plant density.