ArticlePDF Available

Employment patterns of families with children

Authors:
Insights on Canadian Society
Catalogue no. 75-006-X
ISSN 2291-0840
Employment patterns
of families with children
by Sharanjit Uppal
Release date: June 24, 2015
Correction date: September 21, 2015
Standard table symbols
The following symbols are used in Statistics Canada
publications:
. not available for any reference period
.. not available for a specic reference period
... not applicable
0 true zero or a value rounded to zero
0s value rounded to 0 (zero) where there is a meaningful
distinction between true zero and the value that was rounded
p preliminary
r revised
x suppressed to meet the condentiality requirements
of the Statistics Act
E use with caution
F too unreliable to be published
* signicantly different from reference category (p < 0.05)
How to obtain more information
For information about this product or the wide range of services and data available from Statistics Canada, visit our website,
www.statcan.gc.ca.
You can also contact us by
email at infostats@statcan.gc.ca
telephone, from Monday to Friday, 8:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., at the following toll-free numbers:
Statistical Information Service 1-800-263-1136
National telecommunications device for the hearing impaired 1-800-363-7629
Fax line 1-877-287-4369
Depository Services Program
Inquiries line 1-800-635-7943
Fax line 1-800-565-7757
Published by authority of the Minister responsible for Statistics Canada
© Minister of Industry, 2015
All rights reserved. Use of this publication is governed by the Statistics Canada Open Licence Agreement.
An HTML version is also available.
Cette publication est aussi disponible en français.
Note of appreciation
Canada owes the success of its statistical system to a
long-standing partnership between Statistics Canada, the
citizens of Canada, its businesses, governments and other
institutions. Accurate and timely statistical information could not
be produced without their continued co-operation and goodwill.
Standards of service to the public
Statistics Canada is committed to serving its clients in a prompt,
reliable and courteous manner. To this end, Statistics Canada has
developed standards of service that its employees observe. To
obtain a copy of these service standards, please contact Statistics
Canada toll-free at 1-800-263-1136. The service standards
are also published on www.statcan.gc.ca under “About us” >
“The agency” > “Providing services to Canadians.”
Correction has been made to this product
A minor correction was made to Table 1 and the associated text. This correction did not affect the rest of the paper, and did
not impact the ndings reported in the article.
Statistics Canada — June 2015 Insights on Canadian Society / 1
Overview of the study
This paper examines the employment patterns of families with children (under the age of 16) over the period
from 1976 to 2014, with a particular focus on couple families with children. This article also highlights regional
differences in the working patterns of parents and provides additional information on the employment patterns
of lone parents.
In 2014, 69% of couple families with at least one child under 16 were dual-earner families, up from
36% in 1976. Among dual-earner families, almost three-quarters had two parents working full time in
2014.
In 2014, single-earner families made up 27% of all couple families with children, down from 59% in
1976. Families with two non-working parents accounted for 4% of couple families with children in
2014 (compared with about 6% in 1976).
Among the 27% of single-earner families, 16% had a stay-at-home mother and 2% had a stay-at-home
father. Others (9%) had a parent that was either unemployed, attending school or permanently unable
to work.
Regionally, Alberta had the lowest proportion of dual-earner families in 2014 (65% of couple families
with children), while Saskatchewan (74%) and Quebec (73%) had the highest. Alberta also had the
highest proportion of families with a stay-at-home parent (26% of couple families with children).
Stay-at-home mothers had lower levels of education, had more children under 16 and were younger
than working mothers. Stay-at-home fathers had lower levels of education, had fewer children, and
were older than their working counterparts.
Employment patterns of families
with children
by Sharanjit Uppal
Introduction
Over the past few decades, women’s labour force
participation has been increasing and so has men’s
involvement in child care. The increase in labour market
participation of women has been mainly driven by
changes in cultural attitudes, improved female education
levels and general labour market conditions.1 However,
other factors such as flexibility of work arrangements
(for example, part-time work) and family support (child
care subsidies, child benefits and paid parental leave)
have also contributed to changes in the labour force
participation of women.2
The increased labour force participation of women has
led to changes in the employment structure of families,
particularly during the 1980s and 1990s. For example,
in Canada, the percentage of dual-earner families (with
children under 16) rose significantly between 1976 and
1997.3 Over the same period, the percentage of lone-
parent families doubled, and the proportion of families in
which the wife was the sole earner grew. These changes
have contributed to a steep decline in the percentage
of families in which the husband was the sole earner.4
These changes in the structure of family employment,
especially the increase in dual-earner couples and lone
parents, have had a number of consequences. For
example, parents face greater challenges balancing
work and family responsibilities, and, in order to meet
these challenges, some decide to pay for child care
and other household services while others alter their
2 / Insights on Canadian Society June 2015 — Statistics Canada
Employment patterns of families with children
work arrangements—sometimes
by having one parent working and
another staying at home.5
The main objective of this article is to
provide an update of the employment
patterns of families with children
based on Labour Force Survey (LFS)
data over the period from 1976 to
2014 (see Data sources, methods and
definitions). This paper also highlights
provincial differences, and provides
information on the working patterns
of lone parents with children. In
this paper, families with children
are defined as economic families
with at least one child under the
age of 16 living with one parent or
both parents. In 2014, these families
represented 23% of all family units
in Canada, including 18% couples
and 5% lone parents (Table 1). In
1976, the proportion of family units
with children aged less than 16
amounted to 39% (35% couples and
4% lone parents).
The first part of this article examines
changes in the employment structure
of families with children between
1976 and 2014. The full-time /
part-time working patterns of dual-
earner couples are also examined
for the period. In addition, this paper
examines differences in the profiles
of stay-at-home parents, single-
earner and dual-earner couples,
and lone parents. Readers should
note, however, that this study does
not attempt to explain factors
contributing to changes in household
labour supply over time or those
associated with the distribution of
paid work among couples or the
effects of young children on female
labour supply.6 Rather, it provides
an overview of some historical and
recent trends on the employment
structure of Canadian families, and
provides additional information
on the characteristics of working
families. Work refers to paid work
throughout this paper.
Increase in the share of
families with two working
parents between 1976 and
2014
How are families with children
distributed across employment
categories? This section provides
overall information about the
distribution of families with children
under the age of 16, including lone
parents. Other categories include
couple families with a single earner,
with two earners, and without
earners. Percentages in this section
are expressed as a proportion of
all families with at least one child
under 16.
In 1976, the majority of families with
at least one child under 16 were
single-earner families (53%), most
often with a working father and a
non-working mother (Chart 1.1).
Dual-earner couples accounted for
one-third of families with children,
and lone-parent families (working
or not)—headed by a mother in the
vast majority of cases—accounted
for about one-tenth.
During subsequent decades—
particularly in the 1980s and
the 1990s—the labour force
participation of women increased
significantly. The employment rate
among females rose from 42% in
1976 to 58% in 2014. For those
aged 15 to 64, the changes were
even more pronounced as the rates
increased from 47% in 1976 to
69% in 2014. The employment rate
among males declined slightly over
the period, from 73% in 1976 to
65% in 2014. For those aged 15 to
64, the employment rate remained
relatively stable (79% in 1976,
compared with 75% in 2014).7
The increase in female employment
rates led to notable changes in
the working patterns of Canadian
families with children (Chart 1.2).
The share of single-earner families
with the father as the sole earner
declined the most, from 51% in
1976 to 17% in 2014. Over the same
period, the share of dual-earner
couples rose, increasing from 33%
in 1976 to 55% in 2014. The share
of female lone parent families also
doubled over the period (from 8%
in 1976 to 16% in 2014).
More than one-half of
couples with children were
working full time in 2014
In this section, more information is
provided about the working patterns
of couple families with children
aged less than 16, i.e., dual-earner
families, single-earner families and
non-earner families (see Lone-parent
families for additional information
about the working patterns of
Table 1
Distribution of family units by family type, 1976 and 2014
1976 2014
percentage
Unattached individuals 26.7 34.8
Couple families with at least one child less than 16 35.0 18.2
Lone parent families with at least one child less than 16 3.6 4.6
All other family types 34.8 42.5
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, 1976 and 2014.
Statistics Canada — June 2015 Insights on Canadian Society / 3
Employment patterns of families with children
Chart 1.2
Distribution of families with at least one child under 16, by employment status, 2014
Dual-earner couples Couples, single-earner father Couples, single-earner mother
Couples, no earner Male lone parents Female lone parents
Source:
Statis tics Canada, Labour Force Survey, 2014.
55%
17%
5%
3%
4%
16%
lone parents). Couple families with
children aged less than 16 numbered
2.8 million in 2014, about the same
number as in 1976.
Over the past four decades, the
number of dual-earner families has
been on the rise, almost doubling
from 1.0 million families in 1976 to
1.9 million families in 2014 (Chart 2).
The entire period can be broken
down into three distinct sub-periods.
First, there was a period of relatively
strong growth, when the number
of dual-earner couples increased
by 60% between 1976 and 1989.
This was followed by a period of
slower growth, when the number of
families in such a situation increased
by 15% between 1989 and 2005.
Finally, the number of dual-earner
families increased only marginally
(1%) in recent years (between 2005
and 2014).
Although the number of dual-
earner families increased in nearly
each year during the period, some
years witnessed a decline, mostly
as a result of economic stagnation.
For example, the unemployment
rate increased from 7.6% in 1981 to
11.0% in 1982. During this two-year
period, the number of dual-earner
couples declined by 4%. Similar
trends were also seen for 1990-92
and 2008-09.
Among couples with children aged
less than 16, the proportion of dual-
earners increased from 36% in
1976 to 69% in 2014 (Table 2).
Most dual-earner couples had two
spouses working full time, and this
proportion rose over the period.
In 1976, 24% of couples with
children had two full-time working
parents (representing two-thirds of
dual-earner couples). By 2014, this
proportion had risen to more than
33%
51%
2%
5%
1%
8%
Chart 1.1
Distribution of families with at least one child under 16, by employment status, 1976
Dual-earner couples Couples, single-earner father Couples, single-earner mother
Couples, no earner Male lone parents Female lone parents
Source: Statistics C anada, Labour Force Survey, 1976.
4 / Insights on Canadian Society June 2015 — Statistics Canada
Employment patterns of families with children
Table 2
Employment status of couple families with at least one child under 16
1976 2014 1976 2014
thousands percentage
Total couples 2,825 2,753 100.0 100.0
Dual earners1 1,014 1,901 35.9 69.1
Both working full time 673 1,402 23.8 50.9
Husband full time, Wife part time 329 422 11.7 15.3
Wife full time, Husband part time 7 55 0.2 2.0
Both part time 5 23 0.2 0.8
Single earners (SE) 1,657 736 58.6 26.7
SE working father 1,593 585 56.4 21.2
Mother unemployed 95 86 3.3 3.1
Mother not in the labour force 1,498 499 53.0 18.1
Permanently unable to work 3 12 0.1 0.4
Attending school 30 41 1.1 1.5
Staying home2 1,466 446 51.9 16.2
SE working mother 64 151 2.3 5.5
Father unemployed 33 70 1.2 2.5
Father not in the labour force 31 81 1.1 2.9
Permanently unable to work 6 11 0.2 0.4
Attending school 4 16 0.1 0.6
Staying home2 21 54 0.7 2.0
Non-earners 154 116 5.4 4.2
1. Excludes couples in the Armed Forces.
2. Defined as two-parent families with at least one child under 16 at home, with one non-working parent who is not in the
labour force, excluding non-working parents who are unemployed, attending school or unable to work due to a disability.
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, 1976 and 2014.
50% (or three-quarters of all dual-
earner couples). This suggests that
women did not only increase their
labour market participation, but
also their work intensity. The share
of couples with a full-time working
husband and a part-time working
wife also rose as a proportion of all
couples, albeit more slowly (from
12% to 15%).
Among single-earner couples, the
non-earner can either be actively
seeking work (unemployed) or not
(out of the labour force). Among
those who are not in the labour
force, some may be permanently
unable to work or going to school;
these parents are not considered as
stay-at-home parents in this paper.
The remaining parents who are not
in the labour force are defined as
stay-at-home fathers or mothers.
Single-earner families represented
27% of all couple families with
children in 2014, down from 59%
in 1976. In most cases, the father
was far more likely to be the sole
working parent, even in 2014 (21%
of all couple families with children,
representing about 8 in 10 single-
earner families with children).
However, there has been a significant
increase in the number of single-
earner families with the mother
as the sole earner. In 2014, the
151,000 single-earner families with a
working mother accounted for 21%
of single-earner families (compared
with just 4% in 1976), and for just
under 6% of all couple families with
children.
Among single-earner families, the
situation of the non-working parent
varied depending on whether the
family had a mother or father as the
sole earner. Among father-earner
families, most mothers were out of
the labour force as a stay-at-home
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
2,000
1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014
thousands
Chart 2
Number of dual-earner couples with at least one child under 16, 1976 to 2014
Source:
Stati stics Canada, L abour Force Sur vey, 1976 to 2014.
Statistics Canada — June 2015 Insights on Canadian Society / 5
Employment patterns of families with children
parent. The number of stay-at-
home mothers as a proportion of
non-working mothers, however,
declined over time. In 1976, for
example, 9 in 10 non-working
mothers in a single-earner family
were stay-at-home parents. The rest
were either unemployed, students,
or permanently unable to work.
In 2014, three-quarters of non-
working mothers were stay-at-
home moms, while one-quarter
were either unemployed, students
or unable to work.
In contrast, non-working fathers
were less likely than mothers to
be stay-at-home parents. Among
single-earner families with a working
mother, approximately one-half of
the fathers were unemployed in
both years (52% in 1976 and 46%
in 2014), and about one-third were
stay-at-home fathers (32% in 1976
and 36% in 2014).
In terms of numbers, single-earner
families with a stay-at-home parent
dropped from 1.5 million in 1976
to 500,000 in 2014. Families with
stay-at-home mothers declined by
1 million, whereas those with stay-
at-home fathers increased by 33,000
(Chart 3). The number of stay-at-
home mothers declined in almost
every year between 1976 and 2014.
The majority of the decline occurred
between 1976 and 1991 (851,000,
compared with 169,000 between
1991 and 2014).
Conversely, even though the number
of single-earner families with a stay-
at-home father experienced an
upward trend, some periods were
characterized by a decline. Most
of these periods of decline were
periods of expanding employment
following an economic slowdown
(for example, 1984, 1994 to 1997,
2003 to 2005, and 2010).
As a result of these trends, stay-at-
home fathers accounted for 11% of
all Canadian families with a stay-at-
home parent in 2014. This compared
with less than 2% in 1976.
Alberta had the highest
proportion of stay-at-home
parent families in 2014
As a proportion of couple families
with children, families with a stay-
at-home parent accounted for 53%
of families in 1976 and 18% in 2014.
In 1976, Quebec had the highest
proportion of couple families with a
stay-at-home parent (59%). At the
other end of the spectrum, Ontario
had the lowest proportion (49%).
Over the period, the proportion
of stay-at-home parent families
declined in all provinces. However,
the magnitude of the change was not
the same across provinces. In 2014,
Alberta had the highest proportion
of couple families with a stay-at-
home parent (26%), while Quebec
had the lowest proportion of stay-
at-home parent families (13%). This
suggests that the proportion of stay-
at-home parent families declined
faster in Quebec than in any other
region of the country.
The number of stay-at-home fathers
also increased in all provinces,
albeit at different rates. One way
to examine the changing profile of
stay-at-home parent families is to
examine the proportion of stay-at-
home families with the father at
home. In 1976, for instance, the
Atlantic provinces had the highest
proportion of stay-at-home fathers
(3% of families with a stay-at-home
parent) while other provinces had
proportions below 2% (Chart 4).
Between 1976 and 2014, the
proportion of stay-at-home fathers
increased faster in Quebec (a
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014
Stay-at-home fathers
(thousands)
Stay-at-home mothers
(thousands)
Chart 3
Number of stay-at-home mothers and fathers with at least one child under 16,
1976 to 2014
Stay-at-home mothers Stay-at-home fathers
Source: Statis tics Canada, L abour Force Sur vey, 1976 to 2014.
6 / Insights on Canadian Society June 2015 — Statistics Canada
Employment patterns of families with children
14 percentage-point increase)
and in the Atlantic provinces (a
13 percentage-point increase). The
increase, however, was smaller in
Alberta (less than 4 percentage
points). This led to a widening gap
of the provincial difference in the
proportion of stay-at-home fathers.
In 2014, the Atlantic provinces
still had the highest proportion of
families with a stay-at-home father
(16% of families with a stay-at-home
parent), followed closely by Quebec
(15%). At the opposite end of the
spectrum, Alberta had the lowest
proportion (4%).8
Interprovincial differences in the
proportion of dual-earner families
were also important (Chart 5).
In 1976, Alberta had the highest
proportion of dual-earner couples
(43% of couple families with
children) followed by Ontario (42%).
The Atlantic provinces and Quebec
had the lowest proportions (27%
and 29%, respectively). Between
1976 and 2014, the proportion of
dual-earner couples increased in all
provinces, but not equally across
provinces. The proportion of dual-
earner couples increased the least
in Alberta, while it rose faster in
Quebec and in the Atlantic provinces.
As a result, Alberta had the lowest
proportion of dual-earner couples
(65%) in 2014, while Saskatchewan
(74%) and Quebec (73%) had the
highest proportions.
Stay-at-home mothers are
younger and have younger
children than working
mothers
Stay-at-home mothers, single-earner
mothers and mothers who are part
of dual-earner couples may not have
the same characteristics, even if they
are all in couple families with at least
one child under the age of 16.
0
2
4
6
8
1
0
1
2
1
4
1
6
1
8
Atlantic Que. B.C. Ont. Canada Sask. Man. Alta.
percentage
Region or province
Chart 4
Stay-at-home fathers¹ as a proportion of families with a stay-at-home parent,
by region or province, 1976 and 2014
1976 2 014
1. Earning mother.
Note:
Atlantic provinces have been grouped together because of sample size issues.
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, 1976 and 2014.
0
1
0
2
0
3
0
4
0
5
0
6
0
7
0
8
0
Sask. Que. Man. Atlantic Canada Ont. B.C. Alta.
percentage
Region or province
Chart 5
Dual-earning couples as a proportion of couple families with at least one child
under 16, by region or province, 1976 and 2014
1976 2 014
Note:
Atlantic provinces have been grouped together because of sample size issues.
Source:
Statis tics Canada, Lab our Force S urvey, 1976 and 2014.
Statistics Canada — June 2015 Insights on Canadian Society / 7
Employment patterns of families with children
For example, stay-at-home mothers
were slightly younger on average
than both single-earner mothers and
mothers who were part of a dual-
earner couple (Table 3). The average
age of stay-at-home mothers was 37
years, compared with 39 years for
single-earner mothers and 38 years
for mothers who were in a dual-
earning couple.
Correspondingly, stay-at-home
mothers were also more likely to
have younger children. In 2014, 58%
of them had at least one child under
the age of 5 at home. In comparison,
this was the case for 36% of single-
earner mothers and 43% of dual-
earner mothers. Furthermore,
stay-at-home mothers were twice
as likely as single-earner and dual-
earner mothers to have more than
two children under 16.
Stay-at-home mothers were also
more likely to have lower levels of
education. In 2014, 41% of them
had a high school diploma or less.
In comparison, this was the case for
28% of single-earner mothers and
20% of dual-earner mothers.
Information on the previous
occupations of stay-at-home
parents was available for those who
worked during the year preceding
the survey. About 17% of stay-at-
home mothers in 2014 worked in
2013. The comparable proportion
for stay-at-home fathers was 36%.
More than one-third of stay-at-
home mothers who had worked in
2013 were employed in sales and
service occupations. This compared
with about one-quarter of single-
earner mothers and one-fifth of
dual-earning mothers who were
part of this occupational group.
Conversely, single-earner and
dual-earner mothers were more
likely than stay-at-home mothers
to be working in health-related
occupations and occupations in social
science, education, government and
religion.
Unlike stay-at-home mothers,
who were younger than mothers
in single-earner and dual-earner
families, stay-at-home fathers were
older (average age of 43 years) than
fathers in single-earner (40 years)
and dual-earner families (41 years).
However, as was the case for stay-
at-home mothers, stay-at-home
fathers were more likely to have
lower levels of education. In 2014,
44% of them had a high school
diploma or less. In comparison, 33%
of single-earner fathers and 27% of
dual-earner fathers had similar levels
of education.
Table 3
Characteristics of mothers and fathers in couple families with at least one child
under 16, by family employment status, 2014
Mother Father
Stay-at-
home
Single-
earner
Dual-
earner
Stay-at-
home
Single-
earner
Dual-
earner
average
Average age 36.6 39.4 38.3 43.2 39.6 40.7
Average number of children under 16 2.0 1.7 1.7 1.7 2.0 1.7
percentage
More than two children under 16 25.4 13.3 13.3 13.3 25.4 13.3
At least one child under 5 at home 57.7 36.1 42.6 36.1 57.7 42.5
All children aged 5 to 15 42.4 63.9 57.4 63.9 42.4 57.5
Education
Less than high school 11.9 6.0 3.3 13.7 11.4 6.1
High school diploma 29.1 21.5 16.6 30.8 21.5 20.8
College/trades diploma or certificate 29.3 34.3 38.3 28.6 33.3 39.8
University degree 29.7 38.2 41.9 27.0 33.8 33.4
Worked last year 17.1 .. .. 35.8 .. ..
Occupation1
Management 4.9 7.1 7.1 F 12.0 12.6
Business, finance and administration 22.6 20.2 25.6 F 9.8 10.3
Natural and applied sciences 2.6 3.3 4.4 F 13.6 14.0
Health 5.6 14.5 14.6 F 2.4 3.3
Social science, education,
government and religion 15.2 18.4 19.7 F 4.2 6.2
Art, culture, recreation and sport 4.3 4.9 3.8 F 1.7 2.2
Sales and service 36.3 25.6 19.7 17.0 12.9 14.9
Trades, transport and equipment operators 2.9 F 1.7 37.9 29.5 26.0
Primary industry 2.4 F 1.1 12.6 6.9 4.0
Processing, manufacturing and utilities 3.4 3.4 2.4 F 6.4 6.6
Sector1
Public 21.0 29.9 32.6 11.2 11.0 17.5
Private 70.0 58.1 53.6 79.3 67.9 62.6
Self-employed 9.0 11.6 13.9 9.9 20.7 19.9
average
Average usual weekly hours .. 35.7 34.4 .. 41.6 40.5
Average hourly earnings ($) .. 25.22 26.10 .. 30.36 30.76
Average weekly earnings ($) .. 908.34 897.95 .. 1,249.68 1,225.58
.. not available for a specific reference period
F too unreliable to be published
1. For stay-at-home parents, occupation and sector refer to their occupation and sector in 2013, and apply to those who
worked in 2013.
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, 2014.
8 / Insights on Canadian Society June 2015 — Statistics Canada
Employment patterns of families with children
a decline in the number of stay-
at-home mothers. Of all stay-at-
home families, the father stayed
home in 11% of cases in 2014. This
compared to less than 2% in 1976.
The profile of stay-at-home parents
was largely different from that
of other parents. Stay-at-home
mothers were generally younger
and more likely to have children
under the age of 5 than single-
earner and dual-earner mothers.
Conversely, dual-earner parents
were more likely to be university-
educated than stay-at-home parents.
Finally, stay-at-home parents who
worked during the previous year (in
2013) also tended to be in different
occupations than dual-earner or
single-earner parents.
Sharanjit Uppal is a senior analyst with
the Labour Statistics Division at Statistics
Canada.
More than one-half of stay-at-
home fathers who had worked in
2013 were in trades, transport and
equipment operator and related
occupations, or in primary industry.
Conversely, more than one-third of
single-earner and dual-earner fathers
were employed in management
occupations, or in natural and applied
sciences or in business, finance and
administrative occupations. This is
expected, as single-earner and dual-
earner fathers had higher levels of
educational attainment than stay-at-
home fathers. Dual-earner fathers
were also more likely than other
fathers to be working in the public
sector (18% versus 11%).9
Conclusion
Over the past few decades, the
labour force participation of women
has increased as a result of a change
in cultural attitudes, improved
education of females, and generally
improved labour market conditions.
This has led to a change in the
employment patterns of Canadian
families. This paper used LFS data
from 1976 to 2014 to examine
some of these changes among
families with children under the age
of 16. Between 1976 and 2014, for
example, the share of couple families
with the father as the sole earner
declined from 56% to 21%. During
the same time period, the share of
dual-earner couples almost doubled
among couple families with children,
from 36% to 69%. Families with
two full-time working parents now
represent at least one-half of all
couple families with children in
Canada.
Overall, the number of families with
a stay-at-home parent declined
from 1.5 million in 1976 to 500,000
in 2014. This was largely due to
Data sources, methods and definitions
Data sources
This study uses annual data (1976 to 2014) from the Labour
Force Survey (LFS). The LFS is a monthly survey that collects
labour market information for all household members aged
15 and over as well as demographic and family relationship
information for all household members, making it possible to
derive family types. Excluded from the survey’s coverage are
persons living on reserves and other Aboriginal settlements,
full-time members of the Canadian Armed Forces, and the
institutionalized population. These groups together represent
an exclusion of less than 2% of the Canadian population
aged 15 and over.
The LFS began collecting earnings information from all
employees for their main job in 1997. Respondents are asked to
report their hourly rate of pay or their regular salary (weekly,
bi-weekly, etc.) before taxes and other deductions, including
tips, commissions and bonuses. Hourly and weekly earnings are
calculated in conjunction with usual paid work hours per week.
In this study, families are classified based on the type of
economic family. Couple families include married couples
and common-law couples. Same-sex couples cannot, however,
be identified with LFS data.
Definitions
Single-earner family: a couple family, with at least one
child under 16 at home, who reported that only one parent
was employed in the survey reference week, either part time
or full time, while the other was unemployed or not in the
labour force; similarly, in a dual-earner family both parents
are employed.
Stay-at-home parent: a person in a couple family with at
least one child under 16 at home, who did not have a job
or business, was not looking for work, was not attending
school, and was not permanently unable to work during the
survey reference week; parents on maternity/parental leave
are not considered to be stay-at-home if they have a job to
which to they are returning—they are considered employed
and absent from work.
Employment rate: the number of persons employed in a
group (e.g. age, sex, marital status, family type) expressed as
a percentage of the population for that group.
Full-time work: refers to those who work at least 30 hours
per week in their main job; part-time work refers to those
who work less than 30 hours per week.
Statistics Canada — June 2015 Insights on Canadian Society / 9
Employment patterns of families with children
Lone-parent families
There has been a notable increase in the number of lone-parent families with children—from 289,000 in 1976 to 698,000 in
2014. Lone-parent families accounted for 20% of families with children aged less than 16, up from 9% in 1976. Of note, lone
mothers accounted for 81% of lone-parent families in 2014 (compared with 86% in 1976).1
The number of both lone-father and lone-mother families increased during the period. However, most of the growth in the number
of lone-mother families occurred in the first half of the period, i.e., from 1976 to 1994 (Chart A.1). In contrast, the number of
lone-father families was relatively stable during the first half of the period, but increased during the second half (after 1990).
Employed lone mothers were older, had higher levels of education and were less likely to have younger children than stay-at-home
lone mothers. Among stay-at-home lone mothers, 8% had a university degree, while this was the case of 25% of employed lone
mothers (Table A.1). These proportions, however, were lower than for mothers in couples, not only among those who were
employed (about 4 in 10 women in this category had a university degree), but also among those who were staying home (3 in 10).
Both lone mothers and lone fathers were less likely to be employed than those who were in a couple. In 2014, 69% of lone
mothers and 82% of lone fathers were working. The comparable rates for their couple counterparts were 75% and 90%.
However, as was the case for females in couple families, lone mothers registered significant gains in employment over the period
as their employment rate moved up from 48% in 1976 to 69% in 2014 (while remaining stable among lone fathers). Previous
research indicated that recent gains in employment and earnings of Canadian lone mothers aged 40 and over were a result of
demographic effects whereby the better-educated baby boom generation replaced earlier cohorts.2
Lone mothers were more likely to work in sales and service occupations than females in couple families. Similarly, lone fathers
were more likely to be working in occupations that require relatively lower levels of education.
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
1976 1978 1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014
Lone-father families
(thousands)
Lone-mother families
(thousands)
Chart A.1
Number of lone-mother and lone-father families with at least one child under 16, 1976 to 2014
Lone-mother families Lone-father families
Source:
Statis tics Canada, Lab our Force S urvey, 1976 to 2014.
10 / Insights on Canadian Society June 2015 — Statistics Canada
Employment patterns of families with children
Lone parent families (continued)
Table A.1
Characteristics of lone mothers and lone fathers with at least one child under 16, by employment status, 2014
Lone mother Lone father
Employed
Stay-at-
home Employed
Stay-at-
home
average
Average age 38.5 34.7 41.8 42.2
Average number of children under 16 1.5 1.9 1.5 1.6
percentage
More than two children under 16 8.3 23.5 7.4 F
At least one child under 5 at home 25.1 51.9 17.5 24.3
All children aged 5 to 15 74.9 48.1 82.5 75.7
Education
Less than high school 6.5 27.3 9.3 F
High school diploma 22.1 34.5 23.8 F
College/trades diploma or certificate 46.9 30.4 40.8 F
University degree 24.5 7.8 26.1 F
Employed
Full time 78.3 ... 93.7 ...
Part time 21.7 ... 6.3 ...
Occupation1
Management 5.6 F 11.1 F
Business, finance and administration 24.4 F 8.7 F
Natural and applied sciences 3.2 F 13.3 F
Health 12.6 F F F
Social science, education, government service and religion 16.5 F 5.1 F
Art, culture, recreation and sport 3.1 F F F
Sales and service 27.6 F 17.9 F
Trades, transport and equipment operators 3.1 F 27.2 F
Primary industry 0.7 F 4.6 F
Processing, manufacturing
and utilities 3.3 F 7.0 F
Sector1
Public 28.4 F 18.2 F
Private 60.9 F 63.3 F
Self-employed 10.7 F 18.5 F
average
Average usual weekly hours134.8 ... 40.1 ...
Average hourly earnings ($)123.14 ... 29.48 ...
Average weekly earnings ($)1809.32 ... 1,169.39 ...
... not applicable
F too unreliable to be published
1. Data on occupation, sector, hours and earnings are for the employed population.
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, 2014.
1. Shannon (2009) examines the rise in Canadian lone-mother employment rates during the 1990s. He found that the increased lone-
mother employment rate was partly due to changes in income-support policies, which increased the incentive to work. Myles et al.
(2007 and 2009) found that most of the gains in employment and earnings of Canadian lone mothers aged 40 and over were a result
of demographic effects whereby the better-educated baby boom generation replaced earlier cohorts.
2. See Myles et al. (2007, 2009). In 1976, however, lone mothers were more likely to be employed than mothers in couple families
(48% versus 38%). See also Dooley (1994) for a comparison of the labour supply of married and lone mothers with children under
18 in Canada.
Statistics Canada — June 2015 Insights on Canadian Society / 11
Employment patterns of families with children
References
Apps, Patricia F. and Ray Rees. 1997. “Collective labor supply
and household production.” Journal of Political Economy.
Vol. 105, no. 1. February. p. 178-190.
Baker, Michael, Jonathan Gruber and Kevin Milligan. 2008.
“Universal childcare, maternal labor supply and family
well-being.” Journal of Political Economy. Vol. 116, no. 4.
August. p. 709-745.
Cherchye, Laurens, Bram De Rock and Frederic Vermeulen.
2012. “Married with children: A collective labor supply
model with detailed time use and intrahousehold
expenditure information.” American Economic Review.
Vol. 102, no. 7. December. p. 3377-3405.
Connelly, Rachel. 1992. “The effect of child care costs on
married women’s labor force participation.” The Review
of Economics and Statistics. Vol. 74, no. 1. February.
p. 83-90.
Dooley, Martin D. 1994. “The converging market work
patterns of married mothers and lone mothers in
Canada.” The Journal of Human Resources. Vol. 29,
no. 2. Spring. p. 600-620.
Eissa, Nada. 1995. Taxation and Labor Supply of Married
women: The Tax Reform Act of 1986 as a Natural
Experiment. NBER Working Paper No. 5023.
Cambridge, Massachusetts. The National Bureau of
Economic Research.
Fox, Liana, Wen-Jui Han, Christopher Ruhm and Jane
Waldfogel. 2013. “Time for Children: Trends in
the Employment Patterns of Parents, 1967–2009.”
Demography. Vol. 50, no. 1. February. p. 25-49.
Gershuny, Jonathan and John P. Robinson. 1988. “Historical
changes in the household division of labor.” Demography.
Vol. 25, no. 4. November. p. 537-552.
Kent, Katherine. 2009. “Households, families and work.”
Economic & Labour Market Review. Vol. 3, no. 5. May.
p. 17-22.
Jaumotte, Florence. 2004. “Labour Force Participation of
Women: Empirical Evidence on the Role of Policy
and Other Determinants in OECD Countries.” OECD
Economic Studies. No. 37, 2003/2. p. 51-108.
Marshall, Katherine. 1998. “Stay-at-home dads.” Perspectives
on Labour and Income. Vol. 10, no. 1. Spring. Statistics
Canada Catalogue no. 75-001-XPE. p. 9-15.
Marshall, Katherine. 1994. “Balancing work and family
responsibilities.” Perspectives on Labour and Income.
Vol. 6, no. 1. Spring. Statistics Canada Catalogue
no. 75-001-XPE. p. 26-30.
Milligan, Kevin. 2014. “The Road to egalitaria: Sex differences
in employment for parents of young children.” CESifo
Economic Studies. Vol. 60, no. 2. June. p. 257-279.
Notes
1. See Jaumotte (2004).
2. See Nakamura and Nakamura (1981); Connelly (1992);
Eissa (1995); Jaumotte (2004); Baker et al. (2008);
Milligan (2014).
3. See Marshall (1998). Similar studies have been
conducted by Walling (2005) and Kent (2009) for the
United Kingdom, and by Fox et al. (2013) for the United
States.
4. See Marshall (1998).
5. See Marshall (1994).
6. Some studies of interest in these areas include
Cherchye et al. (2012); Gershuny and Robinson (1988);
Apps and Rees (1997); and Nakamura and Nakamura
(1994). Nakamura and Nakamura (1992) provide a
comprehensive summary of earlier studies on the
effects of children on female labour supply.
7. See Table A.2 for additional information about the
employment rates of men and women by family type.
8. One explanation for these trends could be the seasonal
nature of work in Atlantic Canada and a strong economy
in Alberta.
9. The qualitative conclusions for age and education were
similar in 1976 and 2014. Among mothers, those who
stayed at home were younger while those who were
single earners were older. The opposite was true
for fathers. Stay-at-home mothers were more likely
to have children under the age of 5. Dual-earner
parents were more likely to have a university degree
than stay-at-home parents. Lastly, dual-earner parents
were more likely to be working in the public sector.
Comparable data on occupations are not available for
1976. Data on earnings are only available starting in
1997.
12 / Insights on Canadian Society June 2015 — Statistics Canada
Employment patterns of families with children
Myles, John, Feng Hou, Garnett Picot and Karen Myers.
2009. “The Demographic Foundations of Rising
Employment and Earnings among Single Mothers in
Canada and the United States, 1980–2000.” Population
Research and Policy Review. Vol. 28, no. 5. October.
p. 693-720.
Myles, John, Feng Hou, Garnett Picot and Karen Myers.
2007. “Why did employment and earnings rise among
lone mothers in Canada during the 1980s and 1990s?”
Canadian Public Policy. Vol. 33, no. 2. June. p. 147-172.
Nakamura, Alice and Masao Nakamura. 1994. “Predicting
female labor supply: Effects of children and recent work
experience.” The Journal of Human Resources. Vol. 29,
no. 2. Spring. p. 304-327.
Nakamura, Alice and Masao Nakamura. 1992. “The
econometrics of female labor supply and children.”
Econometric Reviews. Vol. 11, no. 1. p. 1-71.
Nakamura, Alice and Masao Nakamura. 1981. “A comparison
of the labor force behavior of married women in the
United States and Canada, with special attention to the
impact of income taxes.” Econometrica. Vol. 49, no. 2.
March. p. 451-489.
Shannon, Michael. 2009. “Canadian lone mother
employment rates, policy change and the US welfare
reform literature.” Applied Economics. Vol. 41, no. 19.
p. 2463-2481.
Walling, Annette. 2005. “Families and work.” Labour Market
Trends. Analysis in Brief. July. London, United Kingdom.
Office for National Statistics. p. 275-283.
Table A.2
Employment rates by family type, with and without children aged less than 16, 1976 and 2014
1976 2014
All Men Women All Men Women
percentage
All 57.1 72.7 41.9 61.4 65.4 57.6
Unattached individuals 56.9 66.6 48.3 53.8 61.1 46.2
Couples 57.9 74.3 40.7 63.8 67.2 60.5
with children aged less than 16 64.7 91.1 38.3 82.0 89.7 74.5
without children aged less than 16 52.9 62.5 42.5 56.7 58.5 54.9
Lone parents 50.9 56.2 48.0 61.9 58.7 63.7
with children aged less than 16 52.8 81.5 48.3 71.4 82.0 68.7
without children aged less than 16 49.9 52.2 47.7 56.6 52.8 59.6
Other 45.4 58.4 36.1 55.3 60.0 51.2
Source: Statistics Canada, Labour Force Survey, 1976 and 2014.
Appendix
... For instance, according (OECD, 2019), in many OECD countries both partners working full time is a common employment pattern among couples with children. (Uppal, 2015) also states that changes in orce has been increasing over the past few decades due to factors such as changes in cultural attitudes, education level and improvements in working conditions work place flexibility, family support etc. These trends resulted in changes in employment structure, giving rise to dual earner families. ...
... W al attitudes are key driving factors (Uppal, 2015). This empirical study also revealed similar finding on reason for working expressed by few working mothers. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
Over the past years, the number of families with both parents working has been increased throughout the world. While both parents working enhance wellbeing of their children, parents face several challenges and it negatively effects wellbeing of children. The present study titled understand: the reasons for both parents working, family roles, ways of managing childcare while at work, challenges faced, effects on the wellbeing of children and solutions from the perspective of parents. A sample of 14 dual working parents were selected through convenience sampling. Data was collected using semi-structured in-depth interview and thematically analysed by manually coding and organizing in a Microsoft Excel spreadsheet. This study revealed both parents work to fulfill the financial needs of the family, pursue in career attitudes towards women working gave rise to working mothers. Most of the dual working parents divided family roles depending on the availability of father or mother yet high burden on women to do household chores was identified. While at work, childcare was managed by grandparents or relatives of children or a hired nannie. Balancing work and family and negative effects on personal health were identified as challenges. Parental perception of positive effects on the wellbeing of the children include material benefits and children becoming more responsible, confident and independent. Negative effect on emotional and social wellbeing, behavioral changes and poor parent-child communication were perceived as negative effects. In light with proposed changes to policies and practices from the participants, important recommendations with regard to policies and practices are proposed.
... Consistent with Foster et al. (2021), our data confirmed that having a child with medical complexities negatively impacts the parents' participation in the workforce, especially for women. While the proportion of mothers in Canada who are not in the labour force is 18.1% (Uppal 2015), 49.3% of the mothers in the program were not working. A similar disparity was also seen with the fathers, with 19.7% not in the labour force, while nationally the rate is 2.9% (Uppal 2015). ...
... While the proportion of mothers in Canada who are not in the labour force is 18.1% (Uppal 2015), 49.3% of the mothers in the program were not working. A similar disparity was also seen with the fathers, with 19.7% not in the labour force, while nationally the rate is 2.9% (Uppal 2015). In addition, in Canadian families with two parents, 50.9% have both parents working, while only 16.9% of the program's families had two parents working. ...
Article
The future of quality is personal. Health Quality 5.0 moves people-centred, integrated health and social care systems to the forefront of our post-COVID-19 agenda - and that cannot happen without addressing our global workforce crisis. Building back a stronger, healthier workforce is the first of the five big challenges we address in our special series. Starting with the global health workforce crisis is fitting, given it is the most fundamental and formidable barrier to health and quality today. As we put the pieces of the Health Quality 5.0 puzzle together, a picture of a more resilient health system will emerge and a new leadership agenda to get there will take shape.
... Historically, mothers were the primary caregiver (Xhaho et al., 2022) and expected to stay at home to care for the child. In today's society, there is an increasing trend of dualearner families (Uppal, 2015) where both individuals contribute to the household income. In 2014, Statistics Canada reported that 69% of couple families with at least one child under the age of 16 were dual earners and 75% of this group had two parents in fulltime employment (Uppal, 2015). ...
... In today's society, there is an increasing trend of dualearner families (Uppal, 2015) where both individuals contribute to the household income. In 2014, Statistics Canada reported that 69% of couple families with at least one child under the age of 16 were dual earners and 75% of this group had two parents in fulltime employment (Uppal, 2015). This created a demand for childcare services such as preschools, childcare centers, and family daycare homes. ...
Article
Full-text available
Historically, mothers were the primary caregiver and were expected to stay at home to care for their child. In today’s society, there is an increasing trend of dual-earner families where both individuals contribute to the household income. This created a demand for childcare services such as preschools, childcare centers, and family daycare homes. Due to the high demand, a majority of parents had difficulty obtaining childcare services and it brought into question whether parents are still able to fully assess each available childcare centers’ quality and cost, or if they are forced to select any center with available space. Additionally, considering its high demand, it’s uncertain whether centers are still providing high quality care at their price points. This study investigated if the cost of childcare at licensed childcare facilities in cities and districts under the jurisdiction of Vancouver Coastal Health (VCH) align with their structural qualities of care.
... With the increased employment rate of mothers with children, the economic structure of Canadian families with children has also changed. Among families with children aged 15 or younger, the share of two-earner couples increased from 33% in 1976 to 55% in 2014 and the share of couple families with a single-earner father decreased from 51% to 17% (Uppal, 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
Using Labour Force Survey data, this study analyzed recent trends in the labour market participation of parents with children aged 0 to 5 and labour market characteristics of working and non-working parents with young children in 2021. This study demonstrated that the labour market participation of parents with young children continued to evolve over the last three decades and varied by various demographic characteristics. In 2021, two-earner couples accounted for 68% of all couple families with young children, and the employment rate of mothers with young children in one-parent families reached 62%. In that year, compared with other provinces, Quebec had a larger share of two-earner couples, especially both parents working full time, among couple families with young children. The province also had a higher employment rate among mothers in one-parent families with young children. The percentage of couple families with young children that had two earners varied by mothers’ immigrant status and population group. Lastly, a non-trivial share of non-working mothers were unemployed or nonstudent discouraged workers (defined as non-students who were not in the labour force but wanted a job). Findings suggest that the employment patterns of parents with different characteristics may be influenced differently by the implementation of a Canada-wide early learning and child care system.
... Indeed, the number of lone parent families increased sharply from 1990 to 1994. 88 With less state funding supporting families directly and indirectly, separated spouses were left to turn (with or without success) to their former partners for support for themselves and their children, a shift Brenda Cossman has called "reprivatization". 89 Increasing self-representation in Canadian courts, partly due to the shortage of state-funded legal aid, 90 has probably contributed to more time-consuming litigation, with more interlocutory judgments and more applications to reopen existing arrangements. ...
Article
Full-text available
Family law in many countries has changed radically since the 1960s. However, despite family law’s central importance, few detailed quantitative analyses of the relationship between legal developments (landmark judgments and statutory changes) and the amount and subject of family litigation have been made. We examine this relationship using a unique dataset of citations among Canadian family law judgments from all levels of the court hierarchy. The network analysis draws attention to significant changes in law and legal practice over time. Not only did litigation increase overall, but the number of judgments involving multiple legal issues grew dramatically in the mid-1990s, signaling the increasing complexity of litigation surrounding family breakdowns. We probe this emergent co-occurrence of legal issues using citation network analysis and find clear links to the jurisprudential changes introduced through the landmark 1992 judgment Moge v Moge and the 1997 Federal Child Support Guidelines.
... In the problem of Russian workers they are going to offer importance to increasing performance that is firm minimum expense. Sharanjit Uppal (2015) had one presumption that the workers with disabilities will be less satisfied soon inside their jobs than the workers without any disabilities. And he conducted a survey on that basis on such form of employees. ...
Article
Full-text available
: Purpose: Present study is a descriptive and analytical in nature aiming to bring out the relationship of job satisfaction and employee commitment on employee engagement of the employees working in IT companies of South India. Design/Methodology/Approach: This study adopts descriptive and analytical approach it, starts with clear variables which are derived from theory and based on these variables. The data for the study was collected through the structured questionnaire. The sample for the present study was collected from the IT companies working in South India. A total 785 questionnaires were returned by the respondents, this indicating a response rate of 59 %. The questionnaire uses five point Likert type response format is used for all the measures ranging from strongly agree to strongly disagree. SPSS 21 and Microsoft excel are the statistical packages and correlation and regression are the tools used in the present study Findings: A significant relationship was found between job satisfaction and commitment with employee engagement of the employees working in IT companies of South India. If Job Satisfaction does not exist in an employee, his level of engagement would be minimal. Employee may be working to maintain hygiene factors according to Herzberg but the management won't be able to motivate him to either enhance productivity or engage him with the organization. Commitment comes when the hygiene factors are maintained. Every employees looks forward to ensure that the employee is committed. Only then they can motivate them to be engaged. Hence, it observed that all the commitment of employees are mandatory for employee engagement Originality/value: This study provides insightful findings in understanding the role organizational competencies like job satisfaction and employee commitment play in facilitating employee engagement. This study also shows the importance of the demographic variables with employee's engagement. In spite of the limitations of the research, the study contributed to the international human resources management by exploring the South Indian IT company's context. The theoretical framework proposes the relationship between employee engagement, job satisfaction and employee commitment. The study has found that job satisfaction and employee commitment is correlated with employee engagement and serves as the important indicator for engaging employees.
... Although, qualitative ECE is expensive; its importance to a child's early formative years is acknowledged worldwide and the ratio of early childhood educator to children has to be low to be able to provide proper care and learning experiences. Uppal, (2015) and Sinha, (2014) noted that in Canada, high-quality early childhood education and care costs are so high that many families are unable to afford it but it is important for the growth, development and the health of a child. It is more than a place for parents to leave their children when they go to work. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstract Fostering creativity among Nigerian managers has been a neglected area for too long despite the proliferation of creativity tools available for this purpose. This study was designed to investigate the Relative Effectiveness of SIMPLEX and Akinboye Practical Creativity at Work (APCAW) in fostering business creativity among managers in selected Information Communication and Technology companies in Lagos. The pretest, post-test, control group factorial design was adopted for the study. A sample of 126 managers drawn from three companies was used for the study. The managers were categorised according to their levels of emotional intelligence based on their score on the Shutte emotional intelligence scale. The participants were thereafter randomly assigned to the three groups. Each group consists of 42 subjects (21 male and 21 female managers). The experimental and control groups were exposed to six weeks of Simplex (foreign) and Apcaw (indigenous) and placebo training respectively. The dependent variable was business creativity. This was measured using all the four sub-scale of Ibadan Creativity Assessment Scale (ICAS). Four hypotheses were tested and the data were analysed using Analysis of Co-variance (ANCOVA), pair wise comparison and mean plot. Findings from the study revealed that treated participants' were significantly superior to control on business creativity competence (F(2,107)=27.325;p<0.01) ; ideative flexibility, (F(2,117) = 11.06; p <0.01); ideative originality (F(2,117) = 25.15, p<0.01; ideative fluency (F(2,117) = 16.03; <0.01); creativity motivation (F(2,117) = 8.47; <0.01). Conclusively, Simplex and APCAW techniques were found to be effective in fostering business creativity competence of managers. It was therefore recommended that management should employ the use of these techniques to enhance employee creativity competence on the job. In addition, employers of labour are strongly admonished to incorporate creativity training in their personnel programme, such as, in the induction, recruitment, selection and promotion of staff to managerial cadre. Keywords: SIMPLEX, APCAW, Emotional Intelligence (EI) , Business Creativity.
... From 1990 to 2017, however, the Canadian government had no strategic plan or policy regarding childcare. As a result, the number of regulated childcare spaces has slightly expanded over the years (Friendly et al., 2018), but access to childcare has remained substantially the same as it was when the convention was introduced, despite the increased proportion of women in the paid labor market (Statistics Canada, 2019;Uppal, 2015). There is, however, a political will to invest into the creation of an affordable Canada-wide childcare system for children aged 0-5 years. ...
Article
Full-text available
This study examined the longitudinal contribution of four different childcare arrangements attended during the preschool years to social behaviors and academic achievement up to age 15 years. Children participating in a Canadian longitudinal survey with available information on childcare attendance between ages 3 and 5 years (N = 6,852) were measured on multiple social behaviors (hyperactivity/inattention, depression/anxiety, disruptive behaviors) and academic outcomes (mathematic skills, academic achievement) across both childhood and adolescence. We conducted a propensity score matching analysis to control the selection bias for childcare attendance and performed generalized estimating equation models for panel data among matched groups. Our results showed no clear social or academic long-term advantage for Canadian children of attending any childcare arrangement in comparison to children being exclusively cared for by their parents. In contrast, children attending daycare centers had higher levels of hyperactivity/inattention until the age of 15 years. Children also had lower mathematic skills if attending daycare centers or informal childcare at preschool age, but this effect dissipated from childhood to adolescence. Interestingly, children from low-income families had higher levels of depression/anxiety if being cared for at home by someone other than their parents or relatives. This finding supports the dual-risk hypothesis suggesting that children from already impoverished families and attending informal childcare in their own home are at greater risk for internalizing difficulties. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2021 APA, all rights reserved).
... Moreover, irrespective of fathers' actual caregiving and employment arrangements, paternalistic concerns with family well-being may cause employers to favour workers presumed to be family breadwinners. Fathers are the most likely beneficiaries, especially fathers of young children, as the latter group are most likely to have partners who are not employed or employed parttime (Uppal 2015). ...
Article
Job loss can be difficult to navigate for individuals and their families. However, we know very little about the relationship between parental status and job loss. Drawing on rich data from Statistics Canada’s Workplace and Employee Survey, we analyse differences across gender and parental status groups in both risks of job loss and its consequences: re-employment, unemployment, and quality of new jobs relative to those that were lost. We find that parenthood reduces the probability of job loss for prime-age men with young children, but only when employer discretion is involved. This advantage is not shared by otherwise similar mothers or fathers of school-aged children, suggesting that employers are particularly sympathetic to risks to men’s breadwinning role in the early years of fatherhood. Despite similar risks of job loss relative to other groups, mothers of young children are the least likely to be re-employed in the subsequent year, mainly because of their higher levels of labour market withdrawal rather than unemployment. Holding out for “family friendly” work arrangements does not seem to account for this pattern. Overall, our results show that the risks and consequences of job loss strengthen connection to employment for fathers of young children while weakening connection for mothers. Job loss dynamics thus not only reflect but also reinforce asymmetrical breadwinning and caring roles for mothers and fathers of preschool-aged children.
Article
Full-text available
This study uses data from the Census of Population and the Labour Force Survey to examine the personal and job characteristics of child care workers and how some of these characteristics have changed over time. It also studies the changes in employment among child care workers since the start of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Article
Full-text available
This study examines the empirical associations between female labor supply and child status and marital status using 1970 and 1980 U.S. census data and 1971 and 1981 Canadian census data. When the data are used in a purely cross-sectional manner, without controlling for previous labor supply, we find, as others have, that female labor supply is negatively related to the number of children a woman has had. However, this relationship changes when we condition on weeks of work in the previous year. This study makes use of longitudinal information in the Canadian and U.S. census data that has been largely ignored. The paper also explores certain econometric issues raised by the nature of the empirical results.
Article
We propose a collective labor supply model with. household production that generalizes a model of Blundell, Chiappori and Meghir (2005). Adults' preferences depend not only on own leisure and individual private consumption of market goods. They also depend on the consumption of domestic goods, which are produced by combining market goods with individuals' time. A new identification result, which uses production shifters, is developed. We apply our model to unique data on Dutch couples with children. Our application uses a novel estimation strategy that builds upon the familiar two-stage allocation representation of the collective model.
Article
In 1985, Gary Becker predicted employment and childcare sex gaps may 'disappear or be greatly attenuated in the near future.' In this article, I examine trends in the employment gap between mothers and fathers of young children over the last 40 years. I review theoretical explanations for the gap, then proceed to analyse the gap empirically in data for Canada, the USA, the UK, and Germany. Substantial closing of the gap in the 1970s and 1980s was followed by stability since then. Evidence from Canada finds childcare subsidies have a bigger impact on the gap than parental leave. (JEL codes: J13, J16, J18, J21).
Article
Using data from the 1967–2009 years of the March Current Population Surveys (CPS), we examine two important resources for children’s well-being: time and money. We document trends in parental employment, from the perspective of children, and show what underlies these trends. We find that increases in family work hours mainly reflect movements into jobs by parents—particularly mothers, who in prior decades would have remained at home. This increase in market work has raised incomes for children in the typical two-parent family but not for those in lone-parent households. Time use data from 1975 and 2003–2008 reveal that working parents spend less time engaged in primary childcare than their counterparts without jobs but more than employed peers in previous cohorts. Analysis of 2004 work schedule data suggests that non-daytime work provides an alternative method of coordinating employment schedules for some dual-earner families.
Article
In 1973, Canadian lone mothers were more likely to work in the market than were married mothers. By the late 1980s, the opposite was true. My principal objectives are to document this trend and to consider how well one can account for it by using those variables commonly included in cross-sectional studies of labor supply. I find that the standard set of conditioning variables can account for only 29 percent of the convergence in the employment rates of married and lone mothers. The remainder of the convergence is attributable to changes in unobservable factors.
Article
This paper examines the determinants of female labour force participation in OECD countries. The econometric analysis uses a panel data set covering 17 OECD countries over the period 1985-1999, and distinguishes between part-time and full-time female participation rates. It shows a positive impact on female participation of a more neutral tax treatment of second earners (relative to single individuals), childcare subsidies, and paid maternity and parental leave. On the other hand, child benefits reduce female participation due to an income effect and their lump-sum character. Female education, the general labour market conditions, and cultural attitudes remain major determinants of female participation. Simulations illustrate the potentially significant impact that some of the examined policies could exert on female participation ...
Article
The article examines the rise in Canadian lone mother employment rates during the 1990s using data from the Canadian Labour Force Survey and methods borrowed from the United States welfare reform literature. Patterns of lone mother employment rate increases in Canada are found to be similar to those in the United States. Income support policies in both countries changed in similar directions and in both cases increased the incentive to work. Despite these parallel changes it appears that, unlike the United States, policy reforms account for only a small part of the rise in Canadian lone mother employment rates.
Article
This article describes the employment patterns of households and families using the Annual Population Survey (APS) household datasets. The household datasets are designed for analysis at the family and household level, and for person level analyses involving the characteristics of the family or households in which people live. The first part of this article concentrates on the economic activity status and composition of households in the United Kingdom. The second part of the article describes employment patterns within families and highlights the employment rates among couple mothers and lone mothers. Economic & Labour Market Review (2009) 3, 17–22; doi:10.1057/elmr.2009.72
Article
This paper emphasises the importance of incorporating household production into the 'collective model' of the household, and considers how and to what extent the results of Chiappori (1992) can be extended to this case.
Article
The effect of child-care costs on the probability that married women with children will participate in the labor market is examined. Child-care costs are estimated.using a generalized Tobit specification corrected for selection. Estimates of a structural probit model of labor-force participation provide evidence to support the prediction that increased child-care costs lower the probability of participation. It is also shown that the lower rate of labor-force participation among mothers of preschoolers is entirely the result of the higher child-care costs faced by these women and endogeneity of the number of young children in the participation equation. Copyright 1992 by MIT Press.