Content uploaded by Daniel Lambach
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Daniel Lambach on Mar 14, 2019
Content may be subject to copyright.
The Territorialization of Cyberspace*
!
"#$! %
&&
&"#
& !
"#
' ( ) * +
, - . / 01!02
. 0345 - ,-
.6 07!08.0349 --
,,. 6 9:0347 )%
+; 41 : 0347 <
= /%= )>=% /? +?@ :? *?
/A?A B? C/ A/D 6: ,D E
+& F .G .
4
Introduction
//%"F
)H#I/0342J/ >%%;
F() "
#I% + ?@0349 2J
%!%
"#
= H K ;
"# &%I
?0341 ,0345J!
! I
( + 034L M J "
+# B-="*
%NN
#I=4889J=IB-
4889J ">
#I+0345 049J* ">#IF0343 )
0339J=!#
4 ( #
+ "O # .
" #
I ,+/% P034LJ0+
! ; "
#-
>&
I
4%>I6033L
&0335 ,F0339 (%,0338J
0":#;
!FF"#&"#I%0343
/0349J=I0340 0345J!%
FK;
(>I0342J
0
6 0332J )
!"#. &
>
I0342 +0342J Q!
%
)
R
L&CK>
AK +
>
I+0332 *
0331 : 0335J % .
& > .%
6 !
> %
%
F M
M"#/
-.:I - . :%J%B =BI0337J
C
&&
> I!J
K >
S
MM
L " #
IE4889 +4881J
I-4887J !/>I4884 60334 /0331J
L
Reviewing Current IR Approaches to Cyberspace
+ Q
I&%0343 51JK
> %
"#
> I= 4878J
I033LJ
# A > M
-%M%FF
F) .T.I..J
> "# I/0345 021J
IF4873J!I=&;
+0349 /0347J)> ::
UI:0345 4L4!
10J M
%
M & I)0340
J.A
IJ;
S /#
"
%
# I/0343 4 +0340 4888J
& "
# %I+0340 22!8J=
&
%5
MK"%# %%
:%&&!&
5 SM "# " # F
A
&%
5
I(0332 443J.%
"
# I/ 0343 9J & %
F&% >
% R
%
!:%I(0332 (0347J.
"R# " %>
#I(0347J
. &
% %
" ;
% # I/0343 2J ":%# I/ .
?034L ?0338J
%
A&
Exercising Control on the Internet
% Q !%
A"#B,":
" I (!A 488LJ
%/
I(/
034LJ S!
%I 0340 94!0 +0341 492 +!
:0340J RK
I&%0343 51J
..I/0345 073 :0345 40J
# Q ; I
B % ?0349 99 0340 99J /I0342J
%
1
/#
6;
>
I0340 90J.
;
M
>!&&I
0341J
I"#J
Q
R> A
!
% V
V> S+%
IJIJ+>
C +
,I4871J.AI4887J
% "# C .
! >
)# I4884J "- K
# I> 4888 098J &% I0343J
> ;!
%
C!!!% %
+S>
" # ;
AI=0342J
FI0349J
> K
+
KIJ"#
9
C K+"&#
! + &
+ >
>
I+ / 0338 : 0345 41L!20J
M
) "
WXV>
#I)0339 L94J
&I )% ,J
K
% C")F#%%
>M;
M)
($#,-I,-J
($I($J
Approaches to Territory in the Cyberspace Literature
CK
Q
%IF<0349J16
) ,
"A&
#I,0345 914J">#
"WX#
I60332 92 +!:0340J
>
&M
/I?0341
/C% 0343 + 0332 + 034L . 4888J * I0331J
1 ) 6 ?&
,&I0349J (/I034LJ
2
" # I "
%#"#JK+
C
" # I* 0331 40 /C%0343 L78J "#
%&!U
/
> "# V
K&
I>0340 / . ?034L /0342J)
=# R >
) +
"WXU
# I+
0332 043J) > "IJ;
% %
#I+0332 04LJ.%
>. 6
"#!
%"
# I60332 97J6
! "# " #
" >
#I60332 97J
A Territorial Ontology of Cyberspace
)
%
Q I.0345 471!8J "+ %#%
K
"+#;
I4881J!
7
& RV
I 6&4812 ;J %
& %
I-033L 443J
Territory
" #
I(034L 42J+
> !
I+4881 28J
K "
YZ; M#
I-033L 444J "AM R
#I.%4879 48J K K
) "K# I.%4879 04J C
K .
A > I=% 0339 03J
K "#
&
K
A9
;R
>
% & I ? 0338J
%M
9"#I ,4887 ?0345J
:
%
&I?0345 L95!1 F0342J
A
8
I033LJ%&!%
"# >% %
% %
!
% M
:% C>&
&
&I60332J=% %C
&
&
+A
) ; M
!
CC I=
0342J !
+ "> #
I+0341 492J I
% / 0342 43L!5J
A
; IB % ? 0349 99J
6 % ;
&&%%"!
: N%
% # I &% 0343 59J *
%"# I+034LJ "# I+!
:0340J"A#I/C%0343J
R%V
V ; I
0349 .0345J:"IJ&
&
# I: 0345 44J I+J
% %
43
+
Territories in Cyberspace
>
A6
"#"C#
!>
,>
I,034L 473!4JF%"#
! R
>%A> "#
+ "#
IJ !"#
I .0340J
,"#YZ#I0340
180J.!-
+!
I,-. !
J !I.0340JF!
; I F!) % = J %
& , & I >
<-: QJ ! ; M
= 2
,) "%#
#F
%
I0349J . !K!
K I. 0342 440J
) K
2!
*;;A
%I0340 180!2J
44
% I 0345J )Q
I"# ,P%0344J
,%.
"#I.0345 491J
I > J
"M# I0340 184
0345 83J6
%
% I!J
"O#I?0345 ,034LJ/
"#I.4888J
"# IP%,0332 592J"
#I,034L 428JC>"XXWX#I?
0345 L95J4883"#!!
6 ,I034L 473J
;K>
[ ;
& SO
"
#IP%,0332 597JSO
;"##I+0332J
Combining Network and Territorial Ontologies
>
%
;.&
/-
&"
# I/-034L 09LJ
40
-.:%IB = B0337JR
MB = B
%
%"
C"IB = B
0337 L84J ;
%M M
=B =B%
/ "IJ
>
#I/0337 549J
-.:% %
&:%&
&MIB = B0337 L8LJ
R
/%
%I,034LJ
"
# I0340 123J
% I:0345 432!L3J
!C
%
=B =B MA"
&R!
K#IB = B0337 L85J
RF&
%&%
%K&%
%
Q
4L
Practices of Deterritorialization and Reterritorialization
%!
& &7
> =R
&&M
! & &
>
&
&
;
&&K&
,A I4872J Q C
Q!+FIE%
4885 4887J&
&
& ;
& & " # I( 0331J
& ,A &
& IE % 4885 = 4888 = 0343 - 0343J
:> &
&I=4888J
& &
& &
&I:0339 =0342J
% \ %
& "
#I4887
7.&%%
6 B =B "IJ
CK ; R>A
M#IB = B0337 L80
J.%
%
45
94J&
&&
I-0343 200J
IE%4885 L70J
;
;K
;M I-0343 205J
& &
% K
)> &K
I64888J
>. C
AI!J&
Territorial Practices
F&&
! ) =I0343J &
IF<0349 048!03 0349J
%%
KM-"A
%%#I-0344 5J
- K I4J I0J
A ILJ
I5J %%
I1J %
I-0344 9!2J
. H) K
>
41
I!J==%I0339 04!2J<I0338J
>%
4 K
0 +!%
L > !%
>;
-
Q%I
J8
Deterritorialization and Reterritorialization in
Cyberspace
&&
A!&
>
S !
"# "#
& )
M>C:
A&&
M
Private territories
-=
I==.J $ +I+J /!$
I/$J % F( >
8U
&) ..
/+I0347J
49
$
&43#
S I"&#
J
) "# )
-:( SQ
I=0338 (+ 034LJ >
.
&&
S
& ; %
/$+I*% ) B
/!0333] )% A ]
.J /$ / / * !- ,
/ !
% \
% F .
> )
C
%.. M%
MA. %M
\
/!!)%
& > $S
Q
I"# ^# "^#J =
;
>
S) > I"# 0347J =
43 %S
!
42
S%S% Q"#
S
SS
"#&
&
S
>K
-
States and state territories
.&44!
#C
&
"#I "#J
%
"# "#"#
+ K %),
I% + ?@0349 51!7 )0349 28J
%
: K !%
K
K%-%%
",)+#
!%>
:?>>
44 F%"# !! *
I CJ
47
"%#=M
>
I:0345 488!004J
%
U%V
"%# .-
I0344 =0342J
&%.
40 &
"S
# I=0341J
% C =!
; ; "
#I=!0342 L2J
:K % &
"#!!
IJ I/
= 0342J . %
% & "#
:
"#
: &
"#4L ) %
+I.0340
414J "# A%
40 !
;!.I% + ?@0349 L8!50 )
033LJ
4L % MKI
0340 .034L F0340JK
I%
0342 0349J*MC
% > M
% A A% >I/
0342 00!1J
48
+Q%
K %
" !# IF 0340 281!7J
. "#
> I 0349 L09!2J
S"A%#
"#
+
"KQ#IQ
J I/C%0343 L75!7 +0341J
>>I)0349 28
/0342 2L!2J"#"#
"#
I" # "% %#J
&RH
= & %
O
#I/0342 74!5J*:
.I:.J -
: .
> "#I% + ?@
0349 07J
=& ;
>#
>45
% M .
&A6
% $ . % ($ %
>%
45 ">#
"#
I<034LJ
03
+>CB
+
"C >
M # I0341 9L = 0330J
CC #
;!) )
-I+:J,($")A#+:
,
,# C($I%0347 045!7J
%
% I.0349J
K I)60349 .A0342
0347JF
-
%
>
%
4883 &
% R &
I+0341J>$. F
!
&%$:
I$:J$I$J
+"!%F!
W X# I = 0347 419J
I&%=%0342 F0342 F0340 280!L /0342 13!
92J
: $ :
, # ) +A 4887 I%%! 0340J 033L 0331F
. . $:! , )
0339 0344 + C% $&%
04
$: ,
$F+IF+J0340
$
$
F+K
$ .%
0345$-/
"C#
% &
%%A
I&%=%0342J=
V+"#
KI=0347 417J
$: , , (> )
+>.I$:,,(J.0335
> !
0342
A034L 0341 $:
+ I.% 0342J >M
I/0342 1J
&"#
%
FM"#
">#
"&# ! I.4888J &
>R
"#
Corporate territories
+ " # *
+. A#%4823 I(
00
+034L L9!2J/ "#I% , /Q
&J (
%
"KWX
#I-A0333 5LLJ+
/Q % ;
&
>!%!M
+K
+ > "= +#
% & ? !%
)%#IJ "#
%\%
")# PA " # IPA
0337 458JK%IJ %!
%,
6 M
IF
-J K>
+ "
#K
K)%
-"034L A < )%
#Y)%#Z) )- <#
)%# # I60347J
A0340_M!KQA;
)%
> &
#!`!*
!%&%*
0L
$ .
.<I>K
"%#)%/%P%J
.
SM R
MI?)>0342 43JF%
\%)%A
>!
6 K"#
%!!
%
"# A
"U %
M#I=0347 40J
"+#>
> >
M%
# M
" #
I.0349J " K
# I
0347 9L3J A
I=0347J41
.&
$.+*$ 0347 ( +#"!#
C !
CI%0347 =0347 =0347J
41
I%0341J=I0347 483 )9JM
M,N
& % /Q C#
05
+"#
!;
*
>!!
R
!K
Re-Evaluating the Internet Fragmentation Thesis
)
.I!J
I J.
Q
>"#
% C
%
.I!J%!
"#
I60332 97J=C&
S /
> !Q
%%
I,034L 473!4J %
! &
& %
K
##
&
K "%#
01
&%C
"# "#
+
K
= &"#
)
> . &
+ %
- S
;%6 "#
) &
"# . "&#
F
A&%!!
V V
%&%
% !%&:.
Conclusion
"#
M+
&
R
U
KR%
( %
KF%
FR
R
09
I)% A J
I JI5 <J+R
$.!
;($ :($
% R
V
>I:0342J>
%/%
&&K
* %
>
K>=
& >R
)> K
"#
!
%
>%
=R &M%%!M
* %V
S% >
% & *
I0331 40J " #
# *
%)> %
MFFF>
> % >
> "# ,
02
R .
M , M$ .
($ + >
%
"# K
% "#
U > % M
%!)
%M
07
Bibliography
)=0349a.,.=/:a!
"#$$4I4J48!L143438LSCS33L
( <-0344aa%LI4J4!L9
434342S.4210824843333L4b
B .+4881&$'()%
*+
/4887a*
a#LI4J1L!97434373S45913358737532932
B033L,#"**>F!=%
&% / .=%0342a:=,)
).a$'&
*-%#- $? 57!91++$
-
/B0349a/a%*.-1ILJ
434529LS0349L501
=&; /+0349a!%!a
+!"%$4I0J429!87434342S03497
= B-4889a+a/K7
)4889 4.034LASSCMScS!
)
=! 0342a>
a$/&'*"&- /A.
FA L2V19//$-
= 0342a/-.a%% 43B
0347ASSSS!!!!!
= -.0330a,&Ba0-"*-,.-414
I0JL44!151
= -.0347aB&a1,
.-24I(=J40!L0
= B0338a=+=6a%#-'%"
% =B= 7!52*>*>$-
=% /%0339*#
= B/0342a".-.U#*/a
23"%,4567'8"
%, /?CFF 4L4!516/+
-
= -4878a...-a$2I4J45!01
= +0341-#:&,.-
09*0341
= B0340aa+Ra
a+!"%.47I0J022!82
434422S4L15399443L7L882
= B03458$'&))9"$-
++$-
= :4888a=!H.
&a$07I4JL8!27
= /0343a*,.a)
8$02I4J10!20
08
= +0347a&GPM+
)!&P.V46G
?&&GP&%=A
.A&/Q+a:;"<
%$"3I9S0347J484!03L
= :%, ? /0342a-a
)*)#-1ILJ0L8!14434373S049009240342408201L
+ /0341a--,,a&=!"
%$5LI0J953!18434422S3L31708745190911
+ B!/0345a)+!:(>
/!% ,4883a
#44I0J031!0L434373S452522L40345772L72
+ :&03408%.+/-
+ B(0332a+S.a8,.-432I4J043!19
+ ,- 0342a.+a>!%,0444032!40
434342SC034212
+ - //0338a :% ,a
3*'>)*)#- /? 42L!8L
+$-
% B0341a$!a2,!401I0JL09!88
% B0347a==a1,.-24I4J428!053
> )4888a.d. , -($
:a>-05ILJ098!85
B033La=%++ . /+a
&L0ILJ134!L3434422S3L3170873L3L033L3734
B /+!:0340a,,.
++a##-'>.-"&%
947ILJLL8!94431111S4321!0759!47LLL8
B &%0343a+)+a
!"?04I5J5L!12
& , )>,A4872>*@8$
/$/
: 0345#A"%#-:6N$-
: /%0342a,-)a08
?-,.-14I0J521!82
% FB <,+ F?@0349)
*B"%%-A*,F()
& F0335a,,=.=%a
*$C448ILJ522!87430L32S03030L80
+ /034La)+!=-)
+!.a%$.-41I4J431!00
434444S4030L
+ /0341a$+%+%
C%(%@a!"$"=..4I4J492!75
( .0331a/-,& &.
Fa"%"D#L3I4J7!48
( .034LD"+$+-
(!A -488La):+a%&+ 9488L
( /+B B+034La-
-K)a9"(3"%$
F6A 02!52*>*>$-
L3
( =0347a.*a$"+"*)$456E
+ (:P
(% B ,,0338aF+H=*
*.a%$.-44I4J031!L3
( 0332a"#+"6
# ./ B-B?Fa"
%"D#L0I4J439!44434444SC4521!199403323305L>
) 6033La+)(!+($!$..
6a%912I0J022!L39
) 60339a). - (!+a
>.-"*$8I4JL1L!25
434459S8393735490255
) 60340a+;-a>.-"*
$41I4JL1!10434459S!!3L3743!443741
) / =60349a+:,+a
>!"%,443ILJ501!28434342S.33308L3333349785
) /%0349a+I,JFa#*2I4J28!70
434444S4217!178840L43
) /4884a,aB+F'$#-@
,= +,-/ 72!435:N%6
F
, 4871>88"(&)1@4'=$
1+--
, +/0345a,&+Ha*G*50I1J9L1!
12434444S4038L
, B% F0339A8%H%"DA
*>
, /%034La,S
Ha#!428I0J422!70
434444SC40338
, /% /AP%0344a<&,+/$!,
-%a!"047I4J441!L0434373S439L32L00344127540
, .4887a(,(>-H+&
a*(#00I0J491!71
6 0334$"8'8#((
$-
6 (4888a. ,&)a$
$-#+ . B..+
% 4L7!12
6 >0347a)%+*$ (.a# 1
0347ASSSS0347SS31S%!!
!!!!!!
6 ,M033La.a&L0ILJ118!8L
434422S3L3170873L3L033L4334
6 ,M0332a+.-.
.a*$%">'%-."$
8 /+ </.)?!6 92!8L
6& B64812a.aA*8I5J52L!8L
6 BA +?& ?,&0349a=
)a&G$48I8J4539!0L
434422S45945557499L8821
L4
B . B% /?0349a,+=+K
++a#*2I4J99!7434444S4217!178840079
B = := /B0337a&.a+-
*?'$$09ILJL78!534434397S8432
B ,-4889a=!+a
$",.-574L92!530
? /0338a:%- - ,a3*'
>)*)#- /? 4!03+$-
? = 0341*=A6.
<-A3*)%6.)?
? .0345aA"#a*(#L7
ILJL95!75434422S3L384L014L139023
? $ +)>0342a,:.a
$'&*-%#-
$? 4!0L++$-
0342a?F).&
(.a)Q*+.,
-.I<-FJ = 5!9*0342
BM. B=0347a+H:$.
a%.L0I0J458!20
434422S335244274729L339
% B0343B(>'*D"A:
N%-/
64884*"$+=%
. (6 /A B )%: B
. 03419"(3"""$*>*>
$-
0342a+,..a?
9=+A9 ,+=:+?& 01!L1+
.-
% /+0342a+Fa$$C44
I4J58!91
0349aWA-X.+W<X%
+.)a%$*-42ILJL00!50
434444S40370
/ 0347aCMIJ
a&G$03I43JL912!22
434422S4594555747212035
/ +.03499AD'"*)A)D$6I55
+=%-
/C% //(0343a),<<=A+&
(>%a%$C15I0JL74!534
434444SC4597!0527034333180>
/ 0331B$.
/ 03428&'$)(3)*++
$-
/ /0337aF(F&.Ha+-
*?'$$09ILJ545!8434397S8432
/+ 0347A*'>%
/ . -034La=.!+,+..a
#47I0J011!99
L0
/ /03433$'#*"%#-+
/-
/ /0342A%BH$-)#8
+--
/ / )&=0342a,+:: .
+ -++!a8$G
,.-475L1!84
/ / . =?034La.:%
,a%$.-41I4J79!435
434444S40305
/ )0345a- - - -,
/..a$))G(153
I0J020!79434422S349005L84511L73L
: 0339ae[a
*(#L3I0J45L!94434484S3L384L0139188>>
: 60335a6%a&G
$9I0J481!042434422S4594555735354551
E ,f48898#'*"A#$/
$/-
E , F%4885a-IJ&
&:FIJ*a>">">
#75ILJL74!87434444SC4592!7L39488534799>
* ??0331a+-/a8-'
%!".&44I4J43!7
434422S4L1571913134433430
- 4887a=Ra#L
I4J98!77434373S45913358737532937
- 033Laa>8*# B
?/,fE 438!00/=%
- ,0343a&&a+"#
=F 200!5*%.
-A +0333a: a#"L4I5J501!L9
ASSS434349S.3349!2471I33J33344!2
0340a+FF:%-a!"$$L1I4J1!L0
434373S34530L8303449378L8
=0347a=:!./.a='
8), 6 =A= 472!
039+.-
6 ) B-0344+
:4888"-'A
:N%==%
+0341a+Ba.(3
!%%, >*% 13!21
+((
.% 4879('%++$
-
. 4888a+&+[:.[a8"
%'$)8)*"? BAF /%
M 6,/$/-
. 0345a6:%(6:%6
-.a8%.')*
8 B!)%?=%/G 474!030=.
LL
.A /: 0342&4@5%,>89'
*%#"+%-">98-8
?"8"+++$-
.A B+4887$,3$'(8$%-(8
(-B:6N$-
. 0340a+H:+a8
$*LLI4J457!23434373S4L10L0930340918182
. B034La+FF%-ga!"$$L9I4J434!7
434373S34530L8303402L3571
.% /0342a$:,,()+FHa
," 5B0342ASSS!!!!!!
!
. B=0340a%,.a
!"*-%,7ILJ52L!724310L1SB-<:7L52L
. B=0345a[%
!a%a .,!%aaHa$8.%*'>
",)G$44I0J41L!23
. B=0349ah
WCXa
ASSSS0342S!!!!!!!
!!!!!!!!!CS
. B=0342a+[+[!!:MHa
$'&*-%#- $? 443!05
++$-
/0347a:).+a*G
L4ILJL0L!8434332S4LL52!347!3L07!3
-B4881a=+ a
*(#48I4J4!41
0340a$FH$%@Q,&a%?+$=:;
"<*3#;4I5J94!2
%%! (%0340)
+>.F%$:)+A 4887!03408*
*D",+-)
/%0340a)+(
,aB%*)&+,!00ILJ192!
912
/%0345aaA%*9!9I4J78!87
/%0349a,% .a#3#
18 B/ 15!9L
/%0347a&:.a*,
.-51I5J90L!75
( /B, //034LaFHa
&G$41I1J203!L9434422S4594555740590713
< )DD .D: B!,034La)
a*$59I5JL44!LL434332S44322!34L!8425!4
< 60338a-a#45I5J972!239
F = ?<0349aF+H()
+a:;"<>J=$38I0J04L!00434332S40L88!349!3112!
4
F =0342a,+a$'
&*-%#- $? 452!95+
+$-
L5
F /0340a+-!a%$02I1J274!
88434373S3097510203402371L3
F 0342a,%-+./+a
$'&*-%#- $
? 98!73++$-
F := .=&!= -6&% (,& b
0349a-
a$L1LI9L35J4414!1434409S1390
F 4873a6-Ha?438I4J404!L9
F 0343a(>Ha?? =.&%
/ 428!77F)
P B034La(/%a:aa /K02
B034L 31B034LASSS%SS%!!!
!!!!!!03L3514
PA B0337B"%=>($%:6N$
-
P% /A /%,0332a/-,
-a+-*D'*?L5ILJ599!70
434397SLL44
L1
