No full-text available
To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.
Risk of Treatment Failure in Patients with Drug-susceptible Pulmonary Tuberculosis in China
Abstract
The objective of this prospective study of the risks of treatment failure in patients with drug-susceptible pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) was to provide reference data to help develop a disease control strategy. Participants were recruited in eight provinces of China from October 2008 to December 2010. A total of 1447 patients with drug-susceptible PTB and older than 15 years of age were enrolled. Demographic characteristics, bacteriological test results, and patient outcome, i.e., cure or treatment failure were recorded and compared using the chi-square or Fisher's exact tests. Multivariate logistic regression was used to identify factors associated with risk of treatment failure. Of the 1447 patients who were enrolled, 1349 patients (93.2%) were successfully treated and 98 (6.8%) failed treatment. Failure was significantly associated with age 365 years [odds ratio (OR)=2.522, 95% confidence interval (CI): (1.097-5.801)], retreatment [OR=2.365, 95% CI: (1.276-4.381)], missed medicine [OR=1.836, 95% CI: (1.020-3.306)], treatment not observed [OR=1.879 95% CI: (1.105-3.195)], and positive culture result after the first [OR=1.971, 95% CI: (1.080-3.597)] and second month [OR=4.659, 95% CI: (2.590-8.382)]. The risk factors associated with treatment failure were age 365 years, retreatment, missed medication, treatment not observed, and positive culture at the end of month 1 or month 2. These risk factors should be monitored during treatment and interventions carried out to reduce or prevent treatment failure and optimize treatment success.
... Since TB treatment outcomes are a key programmatic output of any TB control program [11] and are very important for both public health and clinical perspectives [12], the determinants of treatment outcomes have been investigated worldwide [13,14]. Individual characteristics such as old age, cavitation on chest radiography, and TB treatment history have frequently been found to be related to poor treatment outcomes [15,16]. However, spatial information, such as patients' residence location, public transportation, and the treatment hospital, which are related to the accessibility and quality of services [17], is often ignored. ...
... According to the guideline for implementing TB control programs in China [22], patients who had successful treatment outcomes were defined as those who were cured or had completed treatment. Patients who had poor treatment outcomes were defined as those who failed TB treatment, died, were lost to followup, or discontinued treatment because of side effects [16,22,23]. ...
Objectives:
Tuberculosis (TB) treatment outcome is a key indicator in the assessment of a TB control program. We aimed to identify spatial factors associated with TB treatment outcome, and to provide additional insights into TB control from a geographical perspective.
Methods:
We collected data from the electronic TB surveillance system in Shanghai, China and included pulmonary TB patients registered for the period from January 1, 2009 to December 31, 2016. We examined the association of physical accessibility to hospitals, autoregression term and random hospital effects with treatment outcomes in logistic regression models after adjusting for demographic, clinical and treatment factors.
Results:
Of the 53475 pulmonary TB patients, 49002 (91.6%) had a successful treatment outcome. The success rate increased from 89.3% in 2009 to 94.4% in 2016. The successful treatment outcome rate varied among hospitals from 78.6% to 97.8%, and there were 12 spatial clusters of poor treatment outcome during the 8-year study period. The best fit model incorporated the spatial factors. Both the random hospital effects and autoregression terms had significant impacts on TB treatment outcome, ranking sixth and tenth, respectively, in terms of statistical importance among 14 factors. However, number of bus stations around home is the least important variable in the model.
Conclusion:
Spatial autocorrelation and hospital effects are associated with TB treatment outcome in Shanghai. In highly-integrated cities like Shanghai, physical accessibility is not related to treatment outcome. Governments need to pay more attention to the mobility of patients and different success rate of treatment among hospitals.
... Individuals who developed drug-susceptible TB or drugresistant TB received treatment for the disease incurred additional costs due to this treatment and had an additional risk of death [21,22]. For individuals with drug-susceptible TB, 94.00% of them was assumed to be successfully treated, and the probability of treatment success for drug-resistant TB was assumed to be 41.00% [23,24]. The probability of relapse from successfully treated drug-susceptible TB and drug-resistant TB was 2.49% and 6.58%, respectively [25,26]. ...
Purpose
Several model studies suggested the implementation of latent tuberculosis infection (LTBI) testing and treatment could greatly reduce the incidence of tuberculosis (TB) and achieve the 2035 target of the “End TB” Strategy in China. The present study aimed to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of LTBI testing and TB preventive treatment among key population (≥ 50 years old) susceptible to TB at community level in China.
Methods
A Markov model was developed to investigate the cost-effectiveness of LTBI testing using interferon gamma release assay (IGRA) and subsequent treatment with 6-month daily isoniazid regimen (6H) (as a standard regimen for comparison) or 6-week twice-weekly rifapentine and isoniazid regimen (6-week H2P2) in a cohort of 10,000 adults with an average initial age of 50 years.
Results
In the base-case analysis, LTBI testing and treatment with 6H was dominated (i.e., more expensive with a lower quality-adjusted life year (QALY)) by LTBI testing and treatment with 6-week H2P2. LTBI testing and treatment with 6-week H2P2 was more effective than no intervention at a cost of 24,211.84 per QALY gained in China. The one-way sensitivity analysis showed the change of LTBI prevalence was the parameter that most influenced the results of the incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs).
Conclusion
As estimated by a Markov model, LTBI testing and treatment with 6-week H2P2 was cost-saving compared with LTBI testing and treatment with 6H, and it was considered to be a cost-effective option for TB control in rural China.
... Although preventive measures have made great progress, the prevention and treatment of tuberculosis still involves enormous challenges, such as increased drug resistance [19,20], dual infection of tuberculosis and AIDS [21], and increased migrant population [22]. Furthermore, urban air quality is an important potential factor in the contribution of tuberculosis infection. ...
The autoregressive integrated moving average with exogenous regressors (ARIMAX) modeling studies of pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) are still rare. This study aims to explore whether incorporating air pollution and meteorological factors can improve the performance of a time series model in predicting PTB. We collected the monthly incidence of PTB, records of six air pollutants and six meteorological factors in Ningbo of China from January 2015 to December 2019. Then, we constructed the ARIMA, univariate ARIMAX, and multivariate ARIMAX models. The ARIMAX model incorporated ambient factors, while the ARIMA model did not. After prewhitening, the cross-correlation analysis showed that PTB incidence was related to air pollution and meteorological factors with a lag effect. Air pollution and meteorological factors also had a correlation. We found that the multivariate ARIMAX model incorporating both the ozone with 0-month lag and the atmospheric pressure with 11-month lag had the best performance for predicting the incidence of PTB in 2019, with the lowest fitted mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) of 2.9097% and test MAPE of 9.2643%. However, ARIMAX has limited improvement in prediction accuracy compared with the ARIMA model. Our study also suggests the role of protecting the environment and reducing pollutants in controlling PTB and other infectious diseases.
... In a previous study, male gender was not identified as a risk factor for treatment failure, which may be due to insufficient sample size [21] . The present study showed that the risk of treatment failure significantly increased with increasing patients' age, which is consistent with the findings of other studies [13,[16][17]22] , indicating that younger patients had a higher rate of treatment success. This could be attributed to the weakened immune system in the elderly, the cumulative effects of tobacco consumption, or air pollution, which were not addressed in this study. ...
... Although current guidelines do not recommend prolonging treatment based on extensive disease, 13 our study supports those from China and the Netherlands showing clinicians individualise treatment duration based on knowledge of risk factors for failure and the response to treatment. [14][15][16][17] Whether extending treatment in those with risk factors for failure or relapse improves outcomes is uncertain: certainly, in our setting where individualised treatment duration is the norm, treatment failure or relapse is rare; 2 however, the high prevalence of treatment extension across disparate geographical and health systems highlights the importance of trials to definitively answer this question. ...
BACKGROUND Treatment of TB is often extended beyond the recommended duration. The aim of this study was to assess prevalence of extended treatment and to identify associated risk factors. We also aimed to determine the frequency and type of adverse drug reactions (ADR) experienced by this study population. METHODS We performed a retrospective cohort study of all patients treated for active TB at Christchurch Hospital, Christchurch, New Zealand, between 1 March 2012 and 31 December 2018. Data for 192 patients were collected on patient demographics, disease characteristics and treatment characteristics, including planned and actual duration of treatment and ADRs. RESULTS Of 192 patients, 35 (18.2%) had treatment extended, and 85 (46.5%) of 183 with fully drug-susceptible TB received ≥9 months treatment. The most common reasons for extension were persistent or extensive disease and ADR. Extended treatment duration was not associated with any patient or disease characteristics. We found 35 (18.2%) patients experienced at least one ADR. The most common ADRs were hepatitis, rash and peripheral neuropathy. CONCLUSION TB treatment extension beyond WHO guidelines is common. Further research is needed to guide management of those with slow response to treatment. Methods for early detection of ADR, systems to improve adherence and therapeutic drug monitoring are potentially useful strategies.
... In addition, while not the primary focus of this study, the increased percentage in elderly and bacteriologically confirmed TB was found to be significantly related to unfavourable treatment outcomes. Similar results for elderly people with TB were found in other studies [26,27], suggesting that elderly people need more interventions to improve the treatment outcomes. A study from India found that patients with initial sputum of 3 + grade was significantly associated with poor treatment outcome compared with those having sputum of scanty to 2 + grade [28], but the association between treatment outcome and bacteriologically confirmed TB needs to be confirmed by further studies. ...
Background
In China, an indigenously developed electronic medication monitor (EMM) was designed and used in 138 counties from three provinces. Previous studies showed positive results on accuracy, effectiveness, acceptability, and feasibility, but also found some ineffective implementations. In this paper, we assessed the effect of implementation of EMMs on treatment outcomes.
Methods
The longitudinal ecological method was used at the county level with aggregate secondary programmatic data. All the notified TB cases in 138 counties were involved in this study from April 2017 to June 2019, and rifampicin-resistant cases were excluded. We fitted a multilevel model to assess the relative change in the quarterly treatment success rate with increasing quarterly EMM coverage rate, in which a mixed effects maximum likelihood regression using random intercept model was applied, by adjusting for seasonal trends, population size, sociodemographic and clinical characteristics, and clustering within counties.
Results
Among all 69 678 notified TB cases, the treatment success rate was slightly increased from 93.5% [95% confidence interval ( CI ): 93.0–94.0] in second quarter of 2018 to 94.9% (95% CI : 94.4–95.4) in second quarter of 2019 after implementing EMMs. There was a statistically significant effect between quarterly EMM coverage and treatment success rate after adjusting for potential confounders ( P = 0.0036), increasing 10% of EMM coverage rate will lead to 0.2% treatment success rate augment. Besides, an increase of 10% of elderly or bacteriologically confirmed TB will lead to a decrease of 0.4% and 0.9% of the treatment success rate.
Conclusions
Under programmatic settings, we found a statistically significant effect between increasing coverage of EMM and treatment success rate at the county level. More prospective studies are needed to confirm the effect of using EMM on TB treatment outcomes. We suggest performing operational research on EMMs that provides real-time data under programmatic conditions in the future.
... En dépit de différentes définitions opérationnelles de l'éloignement, la place de l'accès géographique au CSDT sur l'issue du traitement antituberculeux est indéniable.La présente étude a montré que la persistance de la positivité du frottis après deux mois de traitement est associée à l'échec du traitement. Cette observation est similaire à celles faites par Ni Wang en Chine (20), Dovonou et al. au Bénin(21), et Amoran au Nigérian(22). Ces constats sont en phase avec l'affirmation d'Alobu(23) selon laquelle la négativation des frottis peut être considérée comme un indicateur approprié pour évaluer la réponse au traitement. ...
... female sex (OR 1.2; 95% CI 1.1-1.3) and a new case type favor the success of TB treatment, as reported in previous studies [8,9,17,48,68,69,86,138]. Not drinking alcohol was also a predictor of favorable treatment results (OR 2.0; 95% CI 1.6-2.4). ...
Objective
To produce pooled estimates of the global results of tuberculosis (TB) treatment and analyze the predictive factors of successful TB treatment.
Methods
Studies published between 2014 and 2019 that reported the results of the treatment of pulmonary TB and the factors that influenced these results. The quality of the studies was evaluated according to the Newcastle-Ottawa quality assessment scale. A random effects model was used to calculate the pooled odds ratio (OR) and 95% confidence interval (CI). This review was registered in the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) in February 2019 under number CRD42019121512.
Results
A total of 151 studies met the criteria for inclusion in this review. The success rate for the treatment of drug-sensitive TB in adults was 80.1% (95% CI: 78.4–81.7). America had the lowest treatment success rate, 75.9% (95% CI: 73.8–77.9), and Oceania had the highest, 83.9% (95% CI: 75.2–91.0). In children, the success rate was 84.8% (95% CI: 77.7–90.7); in patients coinfected with HIV, it was 71.0% (95% CI: 63.7–77.8), in patients with multidrug-resistant TB, it was 58.4% (95% CI: 51.4–64.6), in patients with and extensively drug-resistant TB it was 27.1% (12.7–44.5). Patients with negative sputum smears two months after treatment were almost three times more likely to be successfully treated (OR 2.7; 1.5–4.8), whereas patients younger than 65 years (OR 2.0; 1.7–2.4), nondrinkers (OR 2.0; 1.6–2.4) and HIV-negative patients (OR 1.9; 1.6–2.5 3) were two times more likely to be successfully treated.
Conclusion
The success of TB treatment at the global level was good, but was still below the defined threshold of 85%. Factors such as age, sex, alcohol consumption, smoking, lack of sputum conversion at two months of treatment and HIV affected the success of TB treatment.
... Studies have indicated that 42% of TB patients in China have not completed their first course of treatment before hospital discharge [8]. Another study analyzed 1447 Chinese patients with TB and found that treatment failure occurred in 98 of these patients [9]. It is estimated that 20.5% of non-treated TB patients can develop MDR-TB, which is more prevailing than that in newly diagnosed patients (3.5%) [6]. ...
Lack of laboratory standards for cured tuberculosis (TB) can lead to early discharge of untreated TB patients from the hospital, resulting in increased risk of TB spread and of developing drug resistant Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb). We used ultra-high performance liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry (LC-MS) to detect heparin anticoagulant in plasma of untreated TB patients, two-month treated TB patients, cured TB subjects, and healthy controls. Screening of differentially expressed metabolites resulted in identification of four differentially expressed metabolites such as, l-Histidine, Arachidonic acid (AA), Biliverdin, and l-Cysteine-glutathione disulfide after 6 months of TB treatment. Among them, l-Cysteine-glutathione disulfide and AA could be identified after 2 months of TB treatment. We established a cured TB model with an area under the curve (AUC) of 0.909 (95% CI, 0.802-0.970), 86.2% sensitivity, and 85.2% specificity. The diagnostic model fitted from the four differential metabolites in combination (l-Histidine, AA, Biliverdin, and l-Cysteine-glutathione disulfide) can be used as potential biomarkers for cured TB. Our study provided laboratory standards for hospital discharge of TB patients, as well as experimental basis for evaluating the efficacy of anti-TB drugs.
... The risk factors associated with the drug-susceptible TB treatment failure are age, retreatment, nonadherence to medications, failure to monitor treatment, and positive culture at the end of treatment months 1 or 2. [23] Older age, unemployment, HIV infection, and alcohol use have also been identified as independent risk factors of unsuccessful treatment (e.g., death, lost to follow-up, failure, transfer out, and other). [24] Diabetes mellitus seems to be a contributing factor to culture-positive rates at the end of the second month, treatment failure, and death. ...
Kazakhstan has a high burden of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (TB). The patient-centered National Program for the treatment and prevention of TB has been implemented in Kazakhstan. The program is aimed at meeting the needs of patients and expansion of the outpatient treatment of TB in the country.
The aim of the study was to compare the efficacy of the outpatient and inpatient treatment of drug-susceptible TB.
This study was a retrospective cohort study.
A total of 36.926 TB cases were included. The majority of patients were treated as inpatients. The socioeconomic factors, sex, age, HIV status, and other diagnostic factors (e.g., sputum smear results, extrapulmonary disease) may serve as risk factors to estimate the likely TB treatment outcome. The outpatient treatment of drug-susceptible TB seems to be a comparable option to the inpatient treatment in terms of efficacy.
The socioeconomic factors are the main modifiable risk factors for treatment failure. The outpatient treatment of drug-susceptible TB is safe and effective.
... La estratificación por edad de los datos mostró un mayor porcentaje de fumadores actuales con edad superior a los 50 años en el grupo de casos. Este resultado es similar al encontrado en la investigación de Wang et al. (22) que señala que con el envejecimiento, el riego de fracaso en el tratamiento también aumenta. Sin embargo, este hecho puede estar relacionado con la distribución de la tuberculosis en Brasil, que también es mayor en ese rango de edad. ...
Objective:
To determine the association between smoking and pulmonary tuberculosis treatment failure.
Methods:
This was a case-control study conducted at the Brazilian Institute for Tuberculosis Research in the city of Salvador, Brazil, between 2007 and 2015. We evaluated 284 patients treated for pulmonary tuberculosis, comparing 50 cases of treatment failure with 234 control cases in which the final outcome was cure.
Results:
Treatment failure was attributed to smoking and age rather than to gender, income, level of education, alcohol consumption, or marital status. Therefore, even after adjustment for age, the risk of treatment failure was 2.1 times (95% CI: 1.1-4.1) higher among the patients with a history of smoking. In addition, being over 50 years of age was found to increase the likelihood of treatment failure by 2.8 times (95% CI: 1.4-6.0).
Conclusions:
Smoking and aging are both associated with pulmonary tuberculosis treatment failure. Therefore, as part of a tuberculosis control program, health personnel should be prepared to offer strategies to promote smoking cessation and should be more careful with older patients.
บทนำ: จากข้อมูลการรายงานผู้ป่วยวัณโรคของโรงพยาบาลรัตภูมิ ปีงบประมาณ 2559 - 2564 พบจำนวนผู้ป่วยที่ติดเชื้อวัณโรค ตั้งแต่ปีงบประมาณ 2559 - 2564 มีจำนวน 36, 23, 34, 46, 42 และ 27 ราย ตามลำดับ ซึ่งมากกว่าร้อยละ 50 เป็นผู้ป่วยที่เคยรักษาวัณโรคมาก่อนแล้วกลับมาเป็นซ้ำ โดยมีวัตถุประสงค์ เพื่อศึกษาอัตราผลการรักษา และปัจจัยที่มีความสัมพันธ์ต่อความไม่สำเร็จของการรักษา อำเภอรัตภูมิ จังหวัดสงขลา วิธีการศึกษา: การศึกษาครั้งนี้เป็นการศึกษาแบบย้อนหลัง (Retrospective study) เก็บรวบรวมข้อมูลจากเวชระเบียนผู้ป่วยวัณโรค ระยะเวลา 5 ปี ตั้งแต่ปี พ.ศ.2559-2564 กลุ่มตัวอย่าง จำนวน 208 คน และวิเคราะห์ข้อมูลโดยใช้สถิติเชิงพรรณนา ได้แก่ ร้อยละ ค่าเฉลี่ย ค่ามัธยฐาน ค่าส่วนเบี่ยงเบนมาตรฐาน และสถิติเชิงอนุมาน ได้แก่ สถิติ Chi-square test หรือ Fisher exact test และLogistic regression ผลการศึกษา: อัตราผลการรักษาที่ไม่ประสบผลสำเร็จ ร้อยละ 18.7 และปัจจัยที่มีความสัมพันธ์ต่อผลการรักษาไม่สำเร็จของผู้ป่วยวัณโรค อำเภอรัตภูมิ จังหวัดสงขลา อย่างมีนัยสำคัญทางสถิติที่ระดับ 0.05 ได้แก่ โรคเอดส์ (HIV) ผู้ป่วยที่มีประวัติเคยรักษาวัณโรคมาก่อน การไม่มีผู้กำกับการกินยา ผลการ X-ray ครั้งที่ 1 และครั้งที่ 2 ผลการตรวจเสมหะด้วยกล้องจุลทรรศน์เดือนที่ 2 5 และ 6 และการทดสอบความไวต่อยารักษาวัณโรค Streptomycin, Isoniazid, Rifampicin, Ethambutol สรุปผล: อัตราผลการรักษาไม่สำเร็จ ร้อยละ 18.7 และปัจจัยที่มีความสัมพันธ์ต่อผลการรักษาไม่สำเร็จของผู้ป่วยวัณโรค ได้แก่ โรคเอดส์ (HIV) ผู้ป่วยที่มีประวัติเคยรักษาวัณโรคมาก่อน การไม่มีผู้กำกับการกินยา การ X-ray การตรวจเสมหะด้วยกล้องจุลทรรศน์ และการทดสอบความไวต่อยารักษาวัณโรค
Purpose:
This study evaluated the possible association between climate and environment and the incidence of tuberculosis and determined the characteristics of tuberculosis in different climatic and air pollution conditions.
Methods:
Data on tuberculosis incidence, climate (i.e., precipitation, atmospheric pressure, relative humidity, temperature, and wind speed), and air quality (inhalable particulate matter, sulfur dioxide, and nitrogen dioxide concentrations) in Beijing from 2004 to 2016 were collected and systematically analyzed based on a structural equation model.
Results:
The tuberculosis incidence was negatively correlated with the concentration of inhalable particulate matter, sulfur dioxide, or nitrogen dioxide. Precipitation, atmospheric pressure, and relative humidity had negative effects on tuberculosis incidence by indirectly lowering the concentrations of inhalable particulate matter and sulfur dioxide. By contrast, wind speed had a significant positive correlation with the incidence of tuberculosis. Temperature and wind speed had positive effects on tuberculosis incidence by improving the concentrations of inhalable particulate matter and sulfur dioxide.
Conclusions:
Climate and air quality are potential regulators of the incidence of tuberculosis. The improved air quality contributes to the decline of incidence of tuberculosis in Beijing. The impact of climatic indicators on the incidence of tuberculosis was mainly regulated by the environment. Further studies are needed to formulate preventive and regulatory strategies for tuberculosis based on different climatic and air quality conditions.
Drug-resistant tuberculosis (TB) is an important public health problem in Latvia.
To document trends, characteristics and treatment outcomes of registered patients with multi-drug-resistant (MDR-) and extensively drug-resistant (XDR-) TB in Latvia from 2000 to 2010.
A retrospective national cohort study.
Of 1779 patients, 1646 (92%) had MDR- and 133 (8%) XDR-TB. Over 11 years, the proportion of XDR-TB among MDR-TB patients increased from 2% to 18%. Compared to MDR-TB patients, those with XDR-TB were significantly more likely to have failed MDR-TB treatment (OR 8.4, 95%CI 4.3-16.2), have human immunodeficiency virus infection (OR 3.2, 95%CI 1.8-5.7), be illegal drug users (OR 5.7, 95%CI 2.6-11.6) or have had contact with MDR-TB patients (OR 1.9, 95%CI 1.3-2.8). Cure rates for XDR-TB were 50%. Compared with MDR-TB patients, those with XDR-TB had a higher risk of treatment failure (29% vs. 8%, respectively, P < 0.001). Unfavourable treatment outcomes were significantly associated with being male; having smear-positive disease; pulmonary cavities; failure, default or relapse after previous MDR-TB treatment; and a history of incarceration.
More MDR-TB in Latvia is now also XDR-TB. This study identified several risk factors for XDR-TB and, for unfavourable treatment outcomes, highlighting the importance of early diagnosis and appropriate management of MDR-/XDR-TB.
In Burkina Faso, the tuberculosis (TB) treatment failure rate increased from 2.5% in 2000 to 8.3% in 2006. The risk factors for TB treatment failure in the country are not well known. The study aims to determine the risk factors for treatment failure among pulmonary tuberculosis patients in four health region of Burkina Faso and to recommend appropriate interventions.
A case control study was conducted among pulmonary TB patients who began TB treatment in 2009. A case was any patient who remained smear-positive at fifth month of TB treatment and a control was a patient who tested smear-negative at fifth month of treatment. A structured questionnaire was administered to one hundred cases and one hundred controls to collect information on exposure factors. Odds ratio were calculated using bivariate and multivariate analysis to determine the association between exposures and outcome.
Multivariate analysis showed that independent risk factors for TB treatment failure were fail to take TB drugs for more than 14 consecutive days (OR = 18.53; 95% CI:4.56 - 75.22), sputum smear-positive at two months of treatment (OR = 11.52; 95%CI:5.18-25.60), existence of comorbidity (OR = 5.74; 95%CI:1.69-19.44), and use of traditional medicines or herbs (OR = 2.97; 95%CI:1.12-7.85).
Early identification of patients with the above risk factors for intense case management will improve TB treatment outcome. Patient with smear positive at 2nd(nd) month of treatment require more intense follow-up, and involving traditional healers who provide traditional medicines or herbs in the educational programme on TB are required. The national referral laboratory capacity needs to be strengthened to do drug susceptibility testing and routine drug monitoring on cases of non conversion at 2(nd) month of treatment.
Noncompliance to the DOTS regimen leads to treatment failure, relapse, MDR tuberculosis, XDR tuberculosis etc. requiring more prolonged & expensive therapy.
To assess the adherence rate among pulmonary tuberculosis patients in west Tripura district and to study the factors affecting adherence to DOTS regimen among pulmonary tuberculosis patients.
This community based cross-sectional study was conducted among 220 pulmonary tuberculosis patients registered for treatment with DOTS therapy; under six randomly selected DMC of West Tripura District.
The study revealed that the adherence rate among the pulmonary TB patients was 84.50 percent. Male tuberculosis patients had 87.10 percent less chance of being adherent to the DOTS regimen in reference to females, and Cat I patients were 8.96 times (C.I. 2.689-29.857) more adherent to the therapy compared to the retreatment cases. Again, patients whose continuation phase was supervised as per the guidelines of DOTS were 12.07 times more adherent to the therapy. PTB patients who had the knowledge of supervised therapy in DOTS and curability of the disease, were 4.70 times (C.I. 1.39-15.79) and 9.39 times (C.I. 1.03-85.99) more adherent to the therapy, respectively.
The study showed good adherence to the regimen among pulmonary tuberculosis patients in spite of being a difficult area. It may also help in planning and implementation of tuberculosis control measures by addressing and overcoming the barriers regarding treatment completion.
Copyright © 2015 Tuberculosis Association of India. Published by Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Unsuccessful TB treatment outcome is a serious public health concern. It is compelling to identify, and deal with factors determining unsuccessful treatment outcome. Therefore, study was aimed to determine pattern of unsuccessful TB treatment outcome and associated factors in eastern Ethiopia.
A case control study was used. Cases were records of TB patients registered as defaulter, dead and/or treatment failure where as controls were those cured or treatment complete. Multivariate logistic regression models were used to derive adjusted odds ratios (OR) at 95% CI to examine the relationship between the unsuccessful TB treatment outcome and patients' characteristics.
A total of 990 sample size (330 cases and 660 controls) were included. Among cases (n = 330), majority 212(64.2%) were because of death, 100(30.3%) defaulters and 18(5.5%) were treatment failure. Lack of contact person(OR = 1.37; 95% CI 1.14-2.9, P, .024), sputum smear negative treatment category at initiation of treatment (OR = 1.8; 95% CI 1.3-5.5,P, .028), smear positive sputum test result at 2(nd) month after initiation treatment (OR = 14; 95% CI 5.5-36, P,0.001) and HIV positive status (OR = 2.5; 95% CI 1.34-5.7, P, 0.01) were independently associated with increased risk of unsuccessful TB treatment outcome.
Death was the major cause of unsuccessful TB treatment outcome. TB patients do not have contact person, sputum smear negative treatment category at initiation of treatment, smear positive on 2(nd) month after treatment initiation and HIV positive were factors significantly associated unsuccessful treatment outcome. TB patients with sputum smear negative treatment category, HIV positive and smear positive on 2(nd) nd month of treatment initiation need strict follow up throughout DOTs period.
In limited resource settings, sputum smear conversion at the end of the intensive phase of tuberculosis treatment is an indicator not only of patients’ response to treatment, but also of anti-tuberculosis program performance. The objective of this study was to identify factors associated to sputum smear non-conversion at the end of the intensive phase of treatment, and the effect of smear non-conversion on the outcome of smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis patients.
This retrospective cohort study was carried out on data of patients treated in the Diagnostic and Treatment Centre of Baleng, West-Cameroon from 2006 to 2012. Logistic regression models were used to evaluate the association of socio-demographic and clinical factors with delay in sputum smear conversion, and the association of this delay with treatment outcomes.
Out of 1425 smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis patients treated during the study period, 1286 (90.2%) were included in the analysis. Ninety four (7.3% CI: 6.0- 8.9) patients were identified as non-converted at the end of the intensive phase of treatment. Pre-treatment smears graded 2+ and 3+ were independently associated to delay in smear conversion (p < 0.01). Years of treatment ranging from 2009 to 2012 were also associated to delay in smear conversion (p < 0.02). Delay in smear conversion was significantly associated to failure [Adjusted Odd Ratio (AOR):12.4 (Confidence Interval: CI 4.0- 39.0)] and death, AOR: 3.6 (CI 1.5- 9.0).
Heavy initial bacillary load and treatment years ranging from 2009 to2012 were associated to sputum smear non-conversion at the end of the intensive phase of TB treatment. Also, delay in smear conversion was associated to unfavorable treatment outcomes. Patients with heavy initial bacillary load should thus be closely monitored and studies done to identify reasons for the high proportion of non-conversion among patients treated between 2009 and 2012.
SETTING: The National Tuberculosis (TB) Control Programme in Yemen.OBJECTIVE: To identify risk factors associated with TB relapse.METHODS: In a prospective nested case-control study, relapse cases were recruited from a cohort of pulmonary TB patients registered between July
2007 and June 2008. Four controls per case were randomly selected from the list of non-relapse patients. Three forms were used for data collection, which included interviews with the participants and review of their medical cards and TB registers. Multivariate logistic regression analysis
was performed to identify independent risk factors for relapse.RESULTS: A relapse rate of 5.7% was found. Multivariate logistic regression analysis showed that unemployment, smoking, presence of cavitations, weight gain, weight loss, non-adherence during the continuation phase and diabetes
were significantly associated with relapse (P < 0.05).CONCLUSION: Relapse rates can be reduced by ensuring that patients take their treatment regularly and are counselled effectively to stop smoking. Reinforcing the implementation of the DOTS strategy and strengthening the anti-smoking
campaigns are important actions. Action to help unemployed patients, including free services and the creation of new job opportunities, should be adopted. Using rifampicin-based regimens in the treatment of cavitary TB and bi-directional screening in TB and diabetes patients are recommended.
Objectives
From the perspective of public health, tuberculosis (TB) remains an important issue that threatens health. Korea is an intermediate burden country with a TB incidence of 97/100,000 individuals. Among many TB control measures, a relapse rate of TB is one indicator that can be used to indirectly assess the level of TB control in countries and in communities. Relapse TB has an approximately 12% yearly incidence in Korea. This study aims to estimate the relapse rate of TB and to investigate the associated factors by using nationwide TB notification data in Korea.
Methods
The nationwide TB notification data in 2005 was used with the exclusion criteria of duplicated reporting, foreign-born patients, outcome–died, and outcome–diagnosis changed. The data were double-checked as to whether they were reported again during 2006–2010 and the estimated relapse rate of TB. Associated factors were analyzed by multivariate logistic regression with the variables of age, sex, registration type, results of sputum smear test, medication, and outcome of treatment.
Results
Among 45,434 TB patients in 2005, 4,371 patients were again reported as TB patients from 2006 to 2010. Five hundred and sixty-four patients were reported more than twice and the cumulative number of relapses was 5,072 cases. The 5-year relapse rate was estimated as 9.62%. The relapse rate decreased yearly: 4.8% in 2006, 2.4% in 2007, 1.6% in 2008, 1.4% in 2009, and 1.0% in 2010. Age, sex, registration type, tuberculosis type, and medication were independently associated with a relapse of TB. In the multivariate logistic regression analysis, the following factors were related: male sex, 40–49 years old; registration type, relapse, treatment after failure, treatment after default, transfer in, and other, the sputum smear-positive pulmonary TB, and medications (including individuals taking 2–5 drugs).
Conclusion
This study has estimated a 5-year relapse rate of TB in Korea that is slightly lower than the rate of relapse TB in the annual reports. This study could be conducted and cross-checked with data from the National Health Insurance in the future.
Tuberculosis remains an important health concern in many countries. The aim of this study was to identify predictors of unfavorable outcomes at the end of treatment (EOT) and at the end of study (EOS; 40 months after EOT) in South Korea.
New or previously treated tuberculosis patients were recruited into a prospective observational cohort study at two hospitals in South Korea. To identify predictors of unfavorable outcomes at EOT and EOS, logistic regression analysis was performed.
The proportion of multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) was 8.2% in new cases and 57.9% in previously treated cases. Of new cases, 68.6% were cured, as were 40.7% of previously treated cases. At EOT, diabetes, ≥3 previous TB episodes, ≥1 significant regimen change, and MDR-TB were significantly associated with treatment failure or death. At EOS, age ≥35, body-mass index (BMI) <18.5, diabetes, and MDR-TB were significantly associated with treatment failure, death, or relapse. Among cases that were cured at EOT, age ≥50 and a BMI <18.5 were associated with subsequent death or relapse during follow-up to EOS. Treatment interruption was associated with service sector employees or laborers, bilateral lesions on chest X-ray, and previous treatment failure or treatment interruption history.
Risk factors for poor treatment outcomes at EOT and EOS include both patient factors (diabetes status, age, BMI) and disease factors (history of multiple previous treatment episodes, MDR-TB). In this longitudinal, observational cohort study, diabetes mellitus and MDR-TB were risk factors for poor treatment outcomes and relapse. Measures to help ensure that the first tuberculosis treatment episode is also the last one may improve treatment outcomes.
Trial registration
ClinicalTrials.gov ID: NCT00341601
Objectives. The aim of this study was to assess treatment outcome and associated risk factors among TB patients registered for anti-TB treatment at Enfraz health center, northwest Ethiopia. Methods. A five-year retrospective data (2007–2011) of tuberculosis patients (
n
=
417
) registered for anti-TB treatment at Enfraz health center, northwest Ethiopia, were reviewed. Tuberculosis outcomes were following the WHO guidelines. Data were entered and analyzed using SPSS version 20. Results. Among 417 study participants, 95 (22.8%), 141 (33.8%), and 181 (43.4%) were smear-positive, smear-negative, and extrapulmonary tuberculosis patients, respectively. Of the 417 study participants, 206 (49.4%) were tested for HIV. The TB-HIV coinfection was 24/206 (11.7%). Seventeen study participants (4.2%) were transferred to other health facilities. Among the 400 study participants, 379 (94.8%) had successful treatment outcome (302 treatment completed and 77 cured). The overall death, default, and failure rates were 3.4%, 0.5%, and 1.2%, respectively. There was no significant association between sex, age, residence, type of TB, HIV status, and successful TB treatment outcome. Conclusion. Treatment outcome of patients who attended their anti-TB treatment at Enfraz health center was successful. Therefore, this treatment success rate should be maintained and strengthened to achieve the millennium development goal.
Background and Objectives
In pulmonary tuberculosis, bacteriological status at two months affects subsequent treatment and prognosis. The effect on treatment outcome and risk factors for sputum conversion at two months treatment in previously untreated pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients was studied in the following report.
Methods
A 1:1 case-control study was performed from June 2006 to February 2008 on patients in the Revised National Tuberculosis Control Program in a tertiary level institute in Delhi, India. Patients with previously untreated PTB with sputum smear positive at 2 months of treatment (cases) were compared with those who achieved conversion (controls).
Results
In 74 cases and 74 controls, independent risk factors for sputum smear positive at two months were: illness for >2 months, presence of cavity or extensive disease on chest X-ray, and interruption in intensive phase of treatment. Patients with smear positive at 2 or 3 months of treatment were more likely to fail or default from treatment. Aforesaid factors were also associated with sputum culture positive status at 2 months in univariate analysis. Patients who interrupted treatment ⩾3 times in the first two months were more likely to be culture positive at two months and had a higher rate of default and failure.
Conclusions
Illness for more than 2 months, presence of cavity or extensive disease on chest X-ray, and interruption in intensive phase of treatment are independent risk factors for sputum smear positivity at two months, which in turn is associated with poor treatment outcomes. Patients with these factors merit special attention under the national program.
With changing demographic patterns in the context of a high tuberculosis (TB) burden country, like India, there is very little information on the clinical and demographic factors associated with poor treatment outcome in the sub-group of older TB patients. The study aimed to assess the proportion of older TB patients (60 years of age and more), to compare the type of TB and treatment outcomes between older TB patients and other TB patients (less than 60 years of age) and to describe the demographic and clinical characteristics of older TB patients and assess any associations with TB treatment outcomes.
A retrospective cohort study involving a review of records from April to June 2011 in the 12 selected districts of Tamilnadu, India. Demographic, clinical and WHO defined disease classifications and treatment outcomes of all TB patients aged 60 years and above were extracted from TB registers maintained routinely by Revised National TB Control Program (RNTCP).
Older TB patients accounted for 14% of all TB patients, of whom 47% were new sputum positive. They had 38% higher risk of unfavourable treatment outcomes as compared to all other TB patients (Relative risk (RR)-1.4, 95% CI 1.2-1.6). Among older TB patients, the risk for unfavourable treatment outcomes was higher for those aged 70 years and more (RR 1.5, 95% CI 1.2-1.9), males (RR 1.5, 95% CI 1.0-2.1), re-treatment patients (RR 2.5, 95% CI 1.9-3.2) and those who received community-based Direct Observed Treatment (RR 1.4, 95% CI 1.1-1.9).
Treatment outcomes were poor in older TB patients warranting special attention to this group - including routine assessment and recording of co-morbidities, a dedicated recording, reporting and monitoring of outcomes for this age-group and collaboration with National programme of non-communicable diseases for comprehensive management of co-morbidities.
Monitoring the outcome of tuberculosis treatment and understanding the specific reasons for unsuccessful treatment outcome are important in evaluating the effectiveness of tuberculosis control program. This study investigated tuberculosis treatment outcomes and predictors for unsuccessful treatment outcome in the Tigray region of Ethiopia.
Medical records of smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients registered from September 2009 to June 2011 in 15 districts of Tigray region, Northern Ethiopia, were reviewed. Additional data were collected using a structured questionnaire administered through house-to-house visits by trained nurses. Tuberculosis treatment outcomes were assessed according to WHO guidelines. The association of unsuccessful treatment outcome with socio-demographic and clinical factors was analyzed using logistic regression model.
Out of the 407 PTB patients (221 males and 186 females) aged 15 years and above, 89.2% had successful and 10.8% had unsuccessful treatment outcome. In the final multivariate logistic model, the odds of unsuccessful treatment outcome was higher among patients older than 40 years of age (adj. OR=2.50, 95% CI: 1.12-5.59), family size greater than 5 persons (adj. OR=3.26, 95% CI: 1.43-7.44), unemployed (adj. OR=3.10, 95% CI: 1.33-7.24) and among retreatment cases (adj. OR=2.00, 95% CI: 1.37-2.92) as compared to their respective comparison groups.
Treatment outcome among smear-positive PTB patients was satisfactory in the Tigray region of Ethiopia. Nonetheless, those patients at high risk of an unfavorable treatment outcome should be identified early and given additional follow-up and social support.
The Objective of this analysis was to identify predictors of death, failure, and default among MDR-TB patients treated with second-line drugs in DOTS-plus projects in Estonia, Latvia, Philippines, Russia, and Peru, 2000-2004. Risk ratios (RR) with 95% confidence intervals (CI) were calculated using multivariable regression. Of 1768 patients, treatment outcomes were: cure/completed - 1156 (65%), died - 200 (11%), default - 241 (14%), failure - 118 (7%). Independent predictors of death included: age>45 years (RR = 1.90 (95%CI 1.29-2.80), HIV infection (RR = 4.22 (2.65-6.72)), extrapulmonary disease (RR = 1.54 (1.04-2.26)), BMI<18.5 (RR = 2.71 (1.91-3.85)), previous use of fluoroquinolones (RR = 1.91 (1.31-2.78)), resistance to any thioamide (RR = 1.59 (1.14-2.22)), baseline positive smear (RR = 2.22 (1.60-3.10)), no culture conversion by 3rd month of treatment (RR = 1.69 (1.19-2.41)); failure: cavitary disease (RR = 1.73 (1.07-2.80)), resistance to any fluoroquinolone (RR = 2.73 (1.71-4.37)) and any thioamide (RR = 1.62 (1.12-2.34)), and no culture conversion by 3rd month (RR = 5.84 (3.02-11.27)); default: unemployment (RR = 1.50 (1.12-2.01)), homelessness (RR = 1.52 (1.00-2.31)), imprisonment (RR = 1.86 (1.42-2.45)), alcohol abuse (RR = 1.60 (1.18-2.16)), and baseline positive smear (RR = 1.35 (1.07-1.71)). Patients with biomedical risk factors for treatment failure or death should receive heightened medical attention. To prevent treatment default, management of patients who are unemployed, homeless, alcoholic, or have a prison history requires extra measures to insure treatment completion.
The available information on the epidemic of drug-resistant tuberculosis in China is based on local or regional surveys. In 2007, we carried out a national survey of drug-resistant tuberculosis in China.
We estimated the proportion of tuberculosis cases in China that were resistant to drugs by means of cluster-randomized sampling of tuberculosis cases in the public health system and testing for resistance to the first-line antituberculosis drugs isoniazid, rifampin, ethambutol, and streptomycin and the second-line drugs ofloxacin and kanamycin. We used the results from this survey and published estimates of the incidence of tuberculosis to estimate the incidence of drug-resistant tuberculosis. Information from patient interviews was used to identify factors linked to drug resistance.
Among 3037 patients with new cases of tuberculosis and 892 with previously treated cases, 5.7% (95% confidence interval [CI], 4.5 to 7.0) and 25.6% (95% CI, 21.5 to 29.8), respectively, had multidrug-resistant (MDR) tuberculosis (defined as disease that was resistant to at least isoniazid and rifampin). Among all patients with tuberculosis, approximately 1 of 4 had disease that was resistant to isoniazid, rifampin, or both, and 1 of 10 had MDR tuberculosis. Approximately 8% of the patients with MDR tuberculosis had extensively drug-resistant (XDR) tuberculosis (defined as disease that was resistant to at least isoniazid, rifampin, ofloxacin, and kanamycin). In 2007, there were 110,000 incident cases (95% CI, 97,000 to 130,000) of MDR tuberculosis and 8200 incident cases (95% CI, 7200 to 9700) of XDR tuberculosis. Most cases of MDR and XDR tuberculosis resulted from primary transmission. Patients with multiple previous treatments who had received their last treatment in a tuberculosis hospital had the highest risk of MDR tuberculosis (adjusted odds ratio, 13.3; 95% CI, 3.9 to 46.0). Among 226 previously treated patients with MDR tuberculosis, 43.8% had not completed their last treatment; most had been treated in the hospital system. Among those who had completed treatment, tuberculosis developed again in most of the patients after their treatment in the public health system.
China has a serious epidemic of drug-resistant tuberculosis. MDR tuberculosis is linked to inadequate treatment in both the public health system and the hospital system, especially tuberculosis hospitals; however, primary transmission accounts for most cases. (Funded by the Chinese Ministry of Health.).
In India, under the Revised National Tuberculosis Control Program (RNTCP), the percentage of smear-positive re-treatment cases is high. The causes of re-treatment include relapse of the disease after successful completion of treatment, treatment failure, and default in treatment. RNTCP does not follow up the patients for any period of time after successful completion of treatment to determine whether they relapse. Given the high cost of treatment for each patient under RNTCP and the potential for spread of disease from these patients, it is crucial for the success of the program and control of the disease in the country to find out more about the reasons behind this. T0 o conduct a systematic review of literature and determine evidence regarding recurrence of TB after its successful treatment with standard short course chemotherapy under DOTS guidelines. T0 en databases were searched including Medline, Cochrane database, Embase and others and reference lists of articles. 255 papers resulted from these searches. Seven studies were finally included in the review after applying the inclusion, exclusion and quality assessment criteria. R0 elapse rate is high (almost 10%) in India which is higher than international studies. Majority of relapse cases present soon after completion of treatment (first six months). Risk factors for relapse included drug irregularity, initial drug resistance, smoking and alcoholism Sex and weight were not risk factors in India. The outcome of relapse cases put on treatment is positive but less effective than new cases. There are sound arguments and sketchy evidence that DOTS Category 2 treatment may not be adequate for retreatment patients.
Many DOTS experiences in developing countries have been reported. However, experience in a rural hospital and information on the differences between children and adults are limited. We described the epidemiology and treatment outcome of adult and childhood tuberculosis (TB) cases, and identified risk factors associated with defaulting and dying during TB treatment in a rural hospital over a 10-year period (1998 to 2007).
Retrospective data collection using TB registers and treatment cards in a rural private mission hospital. Information was collected on number of cases, type of TB and treatment outcomes using standardised definitions.
2225 patients were registered, 46.3% of whom were children. A total of 646 patients had smear-positive pulmonary TB (PTB), [132 (20.4%) children]; 816 had smear-negative PTB [556 (68.2%) children], and 763 extra-PTB (EPTB) [341 (44.8%) children]. The percentage of treatment defaulters was higher in paediatric (13.9%) than in adult patients (9.3%) (p = 0.001). The default rate declined from 16.8% to 3.5%, and was independently positively associated with TB meningitis (AOR: 2.8; 95% CI: 1.2-6.6) and negatively associated with smear-positive PTB (AOR: 0.6; 95% CI: 0.4-0.8). The mortality rate was 5.3% and the greatest mortality was associated with adult TB (AOR: 1.7; 95% CI: 1.1-2.5), TB meningitis (AOR: 3.6; 95% CI:1.2-10.9), and HIV infection (AOR: 4.3; 95% CI: 1.9-9.4). Decreased mortality was associated with TB lymphadenitis (AOR: 0.24; 95% CI: 0.11-0.57).
(1) The registration of TB cases can be useful to understand the epidemiology of TB in local health facilities. (2) The defaulter and mortality rate of childhood TB is different to that of adult TB. (3) The rate of defaulting from treatment has declined over time.
In Gondar University Teaching Hospital standardized tuberculosis prevention and control programme, incorporating Directly Observed Treatment, Short Course (DOTS) started in 2000. According to the proposal of World Health Organization (WHO), treatment outcome is an important indicator of tuberculosis control programs. This study investigated the outcome of tuberculosis treatment at Gondar University Teaching Hospital in Northwest Ethiopia.
We analyzed the records of 4000 tuberculosis patients registered at Gondar University Teaching Hospital from September 2003 to May 2008. Treatment outcome and tuberculosis type were categorized according to the national tuberculosis control program guideline. Multivariate analysis using logistic regression model was used to analyse the association between treatment outcome and potential predictor variables.
From the total of 4000 patients, tuberculosis type was categorized as extrapulmonary in 1133 (28.3%), smear negative pulmonary tuberculosis in 2196 (54.9%) and smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis in 671 (16.8%) cases. Of all patients, treatment outcome was classified as successfully treated in 1181(29.5%), defaulted in 730 (18.3%), died in 403 (10.1%), treatment failed in six (0.2%) and transferred out in 1680 (42.0%) patients. Males had the trend to be more likely to experience death or default than females, and the elderly were more likely to die than younger. The proportion of default rate was increased across the years from 97(9.2%) to 228(42.9%). Being female, age group 15-24 years, smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis and being urban resident were associated with higher treatment success rate.
The treatment success rate of tuberculosis patients was unsatisfactorily low (29.5%). A high proportion of patients died (10.1%) or defaulted (18.3%), which is a serious public health concern that needs to be addressed urgently.
Treatment outcomes for multidrug-resistant Mycobacterium Tuberculosis (MDRTB) are generally poor compared to drug sensitive disease. We sought to estimate treatment outcomes and identify risk factors associated with poor outcomes in patients with MDRTB.
We performed a systematic search (to December 2008) to identify trials describing outcomes of patients treated for MDRTB. We pooled appropriate data to estimate WHO-defined outcomes at the end of treatment and follow-up. Where appropriate, pooled covariates were analyzed to identify factors associated with worse outcomes. Among articles identified, 36 met our inclusion criteria, representing 31 treatment programmes from 21 countries. In a pooled analysis, 62% [95% CI 57-67] of patients had successful outcomes, while 13% [9]-[17] defaulted, 11% [9]-[13] died, and 2% [1]-[4] were transferred out. Factors associated with worse outcome included male gender 0.61 (OR for successful outcome) [0.46-0.82], alcohol abuse 0.49 [0.39-0.63], low BMI 0.41[0.23-0.72], smear positivity at diagnosis 0.53 [0.31-0.91], fluoroquinolone resistance 0.45 [0.22-0.91] and the presence of an XDR resistance pattern 0.57 [0.41-0.80]. Factors associated with successful outcome were surgical intervention 1.91 [1.44-2.53], no previous treatment 1.42 [1.05-1.94], and fluoroquinolone use 2.20 [1.19-4.09].
We have identified several factors associated with poor outcomes where interventions may be targeted. In addition, we have identified high rates of default, which likely contributes to the development and spread of MDRTB.
Tertiary level tuberculosis (TB) institute in Delhi, India.
To study the risk factors for new pulmonary TB (PTB) patients failing treatment.
Prospective case-control study. The profile of new PTB patients failing treatment (i.e., sputum smear-positive at 5 months of treatment) and responders under the Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme (RNTCP) were compared and risk factors associated with treatment failure were analysed.
A total of 42 treatment failure cases and 76 controls were enrolled in the study. The presence of cavity on chest X-ray (CXR), sputum acid-fast bacilli (AFB) smear positivity at 2 months of treatment and the number of interruptions in treatment were independently associated with failures. Among failure patients at 5 months, 17 (40.5%) had negative sputum culture for Mycobacterium tuberculosis, and only six (14.3%) had multidrug-resistant TB (MDR-TB). When put on retreatment, patients with smear-positive, culture-negative sputum had cure rates of 88.2% compared to 28.6% among culture-positive patients.
The presence of cavity on CXR, sputum smear positivity at 2 months of treatment and the number of interruptions of treatment are risk factors for failure. Among failures based on smear examination, the prevalence of MDR-TB is low and many patients have negative cultures for M. tuberculosis. Smear positivity at the end of treatment may not be a reliable indicator of treatment failure.
To assess whether adding a training intervention for clinic staff to the usual DOTS strategy (the internationally recommended control strategy for tuberculosis (TB)) would affect the outcomes of TB treatment in primary care clinics with treatment success rates below 70%.
A cluster randomized controlled trial was conducted from July 1996 to July 2000 in nurse-managed ambulatory primary care clinics in Cape Town, South Africa. Clinics with successful TB treatment completion rates of less than 70% and annual adult pulmonary TB loads of more than 40 patients per year were randomly assigned to either the intervention (n = 12) or control (n = 12) groups. All clinics completed follow-up. Treatment outcomes were measured in cohorts of adult, pulmonary TB patients before the intervention (n = 1200) and 9 months following the training (n = 1177). The intervention comprised an 18-hour experiential, participatory in-service training programme for clinic staff delivered by nurse facilitators and focusing on patient centredness, critical reflection on practice, and quality improvement. The main outcome measure was successful treatment, defined as patients who were cured and those who had completed tuberculosis treatment.
The estimated effect of the intervention was an increase in successful treatment rates of 4.8% (95% confidence interval (CI): -5.5% to 15.2%) and in bacteriological cure rates of 10.4% (CI: -1.2% to 22%). A treatment effect of 10% was envisaged, based on the views of policy-makers on the minimum effect size for large-scale implementation.
This is the first evidence from a randomized controlled trial on the effects of experiential, participatory training on TB outcomes in primary care facilities in a developing country. Such training did not appear to improve TB outcomes. However, the results were inconclusive and further studies are required.
DOTS as a strategy was introduced to the tuberculosis control programme in Southern region of Ethiopia in 1996. The impact of the programme on treatment outcomes and the trend in the service coverage for tuberculosis has not been assessed ever since. The aim of the study was to assess trends in the expansion of DOTS and treatment outcomes for tuberculosis in Hadiya zone in Southern Ethiopia.
19,971 tuberculosis patients registered for treatment in 41 treatment centres in Hadiya zone between 1994 and 2001 were included in the study. The data were collected from the unit tuberculosis registers. For each patient, we recorded information on demographic characteristics, treatment centre, year of treatment, disease category, treatment given, follow-up and treatment outcomes. We also checked the year when DOTS was introduced to the treatment centre.
Population coverage by DOTS reached 75% in 2001, and the proportion of patients treated with short course chemotherapy increased from 7% in 1994 to 97% in 2001. Treatment success for smear-positive tuberculosis rose from 38% to 73% in 2000, default rate declined from 38% to 18%, and treatment failure declined from 5% to 1%. Being female patient, age 15-24 years, smear positive pulmonary tuberculosis, treatment with short course chemotherapy, and treatment at peripheral centres were associated with higher treatment success and lower defaulter rates.
The introduction and expansion of DOTS in Hadiya has led to a significant increase in treatment success and decrease in default and failure rates. The smaller institutions exhibited better treatment outcomes compared to the larger ones including the zonal hospital. We identified many patients with missing information in the unit registers and this issue needs to be addressed. Further studies are recommended to see the impact of the programme on the prevalence and incidence of tuberculosis.
Early diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) is important for initiating treatment to gain cure. The present investigation was undertaken to study the association of conversion and cure with initial smear grading among pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) patients registered in a directly observed treatment - short course (DOTS) programme in Tiruvallur district, south India.
All new smear positive cases registered from May, 1999 to December, 2002 were analysed for conversion and cure related to initial smear grading.
Of the 1463 patients, 1206(82.4%) were converted at the end of the intensive phase and 1109 (75.8%) were declared 'cured' after the completion of treatment. The cure rate decreased as the initial smear grading increased and the decrease in trend was statistically significant (P=0.01). Similarly, a significant decrease in conversion rate was also observed with increase in initial smear grading (P<0.001). In multivariate analysis, lower cure rate was significantly associated with patient's age (AOR=1.5, 95% CI=1.1-2.1), alcoholism (AOR=1.7, 95% CI 1.2- 2.4) and conversion at the end of intensive phase (AOR=3.5, 95% CI= 2.6-4.8).
Cure and conversion rates were linearly associated with initial smear grading. High default and death rates were responsible for low cure and conversion. The proportion of patients who required extension of treatment and those who had an unfavourable treatment outcome were significantly higher among patients with a 3+ initial smear grading. This reiterates the need to pay more attention in motivating these patients to return to regular treatment and sustained commitment in the control of tuberculosis. There is a need to extend the treatment for one more month in the intensive phase of treatment.
We investigated the patient- and treatment-system dependent factors affecting treatment outcome in a two-year cohort of all treated culture-verified pulmonary tuberculosis (TB) cases to establish a basis for improving outcomes.
Medical records of all cases in 1995 - 1996 were abstracted to assess outcome of treatment. Outcome was divided into three groups: favourable, death and other unfavourable. Predictors of unfavourable outcome were assessed in univariate and multivariate analysis.
Among 629 cases a favourable outcome was achieved in 441 (70.1%), 17.2% (108) died and other unfavourable outcome took place in 12.7% (80). Significant independent risk factors for death were male sex, high age, non-HIV -related immunosuppression and any other than a pulmonary specialty being responsible for stopping treatment. History of previous tuberculosis was inversely associated with the risk of death. For other unfavourable treatment outcomes, significant risk factors were pause(s) in treatment, treatment with INH+RIF+EMB/SM, and internal medicine specialty being responsible at the end of the treatment.
We observed a significant association with unfavourable outcome for the specialty responsible for treatment being other than pulmonary, but not for the volume of cases, which has implications for system arrangements. Poor outcomes associated with immunosuppression and advanced age, with frequent comorbidity, stress a low threshold of suspicion, availability of rapid diagnostics, and early empiric treatment as probable approaches in attempting to improve treatment outcomes in countries with very low incidence of TB.
New smear-positive pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) patients in the Revised National Tuberculosis Control Programme (RNTCP) are treated with a 6-month short-course chemotherapy (SCC) regimen irrespective of co-morbid conditions. We undertook this retrospective analysis to compare sputum conversion rates (smear, culture) at the end of intensive phase (IP) of Category-1 regimen among patients admitted to concurrent controlled clinical trials: pulmonary tuberculosis alone (PTB) or with type 2 diabetes mellitus (DM-TB) or HIV infection (HIV-TB), and to identify the risk factors influencing sputum conversion.
In this retrospective analysis sputum conversion rates at the end of intensive phase (IP) in three concurrent studies undertaken among PTB, DM-TB and HIV-TB patients, during 1998 - 2002 at the Tuberculosis Research Centre (TRC), Chennai, were compared. Sputum smears were examined by fluorescent microscopy. HIV infected patients did not receive anti-retroviral treatment (ART). Patients with DM were treated with oral hypoglycaemic drugs or insulin (sc).
The study population included 98, 92 and 88 patients in the PTB, DM-TB and HIV-TB studies. At the end of IP the smear conversion (58, 61, and 62%) and culture conversion (86, 88 and 92%) rates were similar in the three groups respectively. The variables associated with lack of sputum smear or culture conversion were age >45 yr, higher pre-treatment smear and culture grading, and extent of the radiographic involvement.
Our findings confirm that the current policy of the control programme to treat all pulmonary TB patients with or with out co-morbid conditions with Category-I regimen appears to be appropriate.
Completing treatment for multidrug-resistant (MDR) tuberculosis (TB) may be more challenging than completing first-line TB therapy, especially in resource-poor settings. The objectives of this study were to (1) identify risk factors for default from MDR TB therapy (defined as prolonged treatment interruption), (2) quantify mortality among patients who default from treatment, and (3) identify risk factors for death after default from treatment.
We performed a retrospective chart review to identify risk factors for default from MDR TB therapy and conducted home visits to assess mortality among patients who defaulted from such therapy.
Sixty-seven (10.0%) of 671 patients defaulted from MDR TB therapy. The median time to treatment default was 438 days (interquartile range, 152-710 days), and 27 (40.3%) of the 67 patients who defaulted from treatment had culture-positive sputum at the time of default. Substance use (hazard ratio, 2.96; 95% confidence interval, 1.56-5.62; P = .001), substandard housing conditions (hazard ratio, 1.83; 95% confidence interval, 1.07-3.11; P = .03), later year of enrollment (hazard ratio, 1.62, 95% confidence interval, 1.09-2.41; P = .02), and health district (P = .02) predicted default from therapy in a multivariable analysis. Severe adverse events did not predict default from therapy. Forty-seven (70.1%) of 67 patients who defaulted from therapy were successfully traced; of these, 25 (53.2%) had died. Poor bacteriologic response, <1 year of treatment at the time of default, low education level, and diagnosis with a psychiatric disorder significantly predicted death after default in a multivariable analysis.
The proportion of patients who defaulted from MDR TB treatment was relatively low. The large proportion of patients who had culture-positive sputum at the time of treatment default underscores the public health importance of minimizing treatment default. Prognosis for patients who defaulted from therapy was poor. Interventions aimed at preventing treatment default may reduce TB-related mortality.
SETTING: An antimony mine in Jiangxi Province, China.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the incidence of tuberculosis (TB) transmission and associated risk factors in a Chinese antimony mining community.
DESIGN: Retrospective cohort study
METHODS: The 15-locus mycobacterial interspersed repetitive unit-variable number of tandem repeats (MIRU-VNTR15-China) method was used to determine clustering of patients. A region of difference (RD105) deletion-targeted multiplex polymerase chain reaction was adopted to identify Beijing strains. Risk factors for clustering were assessed.
RESULTS: Of 263 TB patients, 175 were distributed into 35 clusters. Estimated recent transmission of TB was 53.2% within the community. Patients who failed treatment were more likely to be in clusters (adjusted odds ratio [aOR] 0.03, 95%CI 2.12–6.89). Patients with multiresistant isolates were more likely to have failed treatment and to be in a cluster than those carrying a susceptible strain (aOR 0.001, 95%CI 4.89–29.7).
CONCLUSIONS: Individuals who fail treatment are an important source of infection in TB transmission, and multiresistant isolates are mostly responsible for this. TB control plans need to focus on treatment failure cases in the community.
Tuberculosis is a preventable, treatable and curable disease provided the precautionary measures and drug adherence are strictly adhered to. Structured questionnaires were administered to 280 tuberculosis patients diagnosed at the Pulmonary Unit of the University of Ilorin Teaching Hospital, Ilorin, Oyo State; a tertiary healthcare centre in Nigeria. There were 166 males and 114 females giving male to female ratio of 1.4:1.0. There was a significant association between education and patients' adherence to their medications. Side effects of the anti-tuberculosis agents have negative impact on patients' drug adherence. Positive effect of counseling on the patients' adherence to their medication regimen was also recorded. Age had no significant relationship with patients' drug adherence, whereas education was significantly associated with patients' drug adherence. Drug adherence rate accounted for 94.6% of the patients seen over the period of study. The high rate of drug adherence observed was probably due to free anti-tuberculosis drugs, free medical laboratory service and the rapid improvement in the signs and symptoms of the disease. Also, directly observed treatment short course (DOTs) currently introduced in the hospital coupled with free supply of tuberculosis resistant strain drugs to patients, improved adherence and impede tuberculosis transmission within the community, and thereby stem the tide of the disease.
Epidemiological studies indicated that the proportion of TB patients who remained smear-positive after two months of treatment could be greater than 20%. The lack of smear conversion in the second month of treatment was one of the predictors of treatment failure and relapse.
To determine factors associated with the persisting positive smear after two months of treatment and its value in predicting treatment failure.
A 3-year retrospective cohort study was conducted in a 1,200-bed government hospital in Thailand New smear-positive tuberculosis patients who had pretreatment drug susceptibility test, the result of 2-month sputum smear and treatment outcomes were selected. The pretreatment drug susceptibility pattern and statistically differences on variables between groups of patients were described
Three hundred fifty six patients were included in the present study. The level of pretreatment isoniazid resistance and multi-drug resistance were 13.8% and 3.1% respectively. Factors associated with the 2-month positive smear were male sex, high initial sputum acid-fast bacilli grades, and cavitary diseases. The presence of human immuno-deficiency virus infection, drug resistance and the 2-month positive smear were significantly associated with treatment failure.
Male sex, high initial sputum acid-fast bacilli grades, and cavitary diseases were factors associated with the 2-month positive smear and increasing risk of treatment failure.
A teaching hospital in the Republic of Korea, 2003-2009.
To evaluate the effect of previous tuberculosis (TB) treatment history on sputum smear and culture conversion.
Data, including sputum acid-fast bacilli (AFB) results at baseline and at weeks 2, 4, 8, 12, 16, 20 and 24, were collected from patients with AFB sputum smear-positive and culture-confirmed pulmonary TB. Patients with multidrug-resistant TB or those with poor adherence were excluded. AFB conversion was compared between patients with a previous history of anti-tuberculosis treatment and those without.
The median age of the 208 patients was 49.0 years; 58.3% were male, while 43 (20.7%) had a history of previous anti-tuberculosis treatment. Patients with a history of previous treatment had significantly lower sputum smear-negative conversion at 2 weeks of treatment compared with patients without (70.0% vs. 44.8%, P = 0.005). However, the two groups did not differ in culture conversion and in smear conversion at 4, 8, 12, 16, 20 and 24 weeks of anti-tuberculosis treatment.
Patients with a history of previous anti-tuberculosis treatment are more likely to have positive sputum AFB smear at 2 weeks of treatment. However, sputum culture conversion is not affected by previous treatment history.
Persistent smear-positivity in patients with pulmonary tuberculosis has been shown to predict an unfavourable outcome. This study was conducted to identify the factors influencing time to sputum smear conversion.
From July 2003 to June 2007, all patients with smear-positive and culture-confirmed pulmonary tuberculosis, who had attended a medical centre and a local teaching hospital, were identified. Factors that might have influenced time to smear conversion were investigated using time-to-event analysis.
Altogether 305 patients (mean age: 58.6 years) were studied. Diabetes mellitus was the most common underlying comorbidity. Eight patients (2.6%) had AIDS. After 2 months of treatment, 34 (11.1%) patients remained smear- and culture-positive. Cox proportional hazard regression analysis indicated that the presence of a cavity on CXR, smear grading and the first 2-month treatment regimen were independent factors influencing the time to sputum smear conversion. Among patients who had received isoniazid in the first 2 months of treatment, the time to sputum smear conversion in the 24 patients whose isolate showed isoniazid resistance was not different from that in the 236 patients whose isolate was isoniazid-susceptible (hazard ratio 1.061; 95% CI: 0.697-1.616).
This analysis revealed that 11.1% of tuberculosis patients remained smear-positive after 2 months of treatment. Patients with cavitation, higher smear grading and those who had not used isoniazid, rifampicin, ethambutol and pyrazinamide continuously in the initial treatment phase had a longer time to sputum smear conversion.
Multidrug-resistant (MDR) tuberculosis is a growing clinical and public-health concern. To evaluate existing evidence regarding treatment regimens for MDR tuberculosis, we used a Bayesian random-effects meta-analysis of the available therapeutic studies to assess how the reported proportion of patients treated successfully is influenced by differences in treatment regimen design, study methodology, and patient population. Successful treatment outcome was defined as cure or treatment completion. 34 clinical reports with a mean of 250 patients per report met the inclusion criteria. Our analysis shows that the proportion of patients treated successfully improved when treatment duration was at least 18 months, and if patients received directly observed therapy throughout treatment. Studies that combined both factors had significantly higher pooled success proportions (69%, 95% credible interval [CI] 64-73%) than other studies of treatment outcomes (58%, 95% CI 52-64%). Individualised treatment regimens had higher treatment success (64%, 95% CI 59-68%) than standardised regimens (54%, 95% CI 43-68%), although the difference was not significant. Treatment approaches and study methodologies were heterogeneous across studies. Many important variables, including patients' HIV status, were inconsistently reported between studies. These results underscore the importance of strong patient support and treatment follow-up systems to develop successful MDR tuberculosis treatment programmes.
Treatment program for tuberculosis in a refugee camp in Thailand.
To determine the cumulative frequency of conversion of sputum smears examined by direct microscopy by month of treatment and to identify factors predicting failure to convert.
Analysis of conversion based on three sputum smear examinations (performed monthly) in a cohort of patients with sputum smear-positive tuberculosis treated with a directly observed daily regimen containing rifampicin throughout. Nested case-control study of patients failing to convert definitively within four months compared to controls who did convert.
Sputum conversion after the 2-month intensive phase was 75.0%, with a range from 61.7% to 90.9% in patients with initially strongly- and weakly-positive smears, respectively. The strongest predictor identified for no definitive conversion within four months of treatment was a positive sputum smear result at the end of the 2-month intensive phase (adjusted relative odds 4.2, 95% confidence interval 1.5-11.4). Of those patients who did not convert, positive smears were an isolated phenomenon in 15, repeatedly in four who definitely converted with a prolongation of treatment, and persistently positive in two requiring a re-treatment regimen.
Definitive sputum smear conversion is judged to be slower if a strict program of sputum smear examination is undertaken than under routine program conditions, but positive results late in the course are commonly an isolated phenomenon and possibly of little significance. Sputum smear results at two months strongly predict bacteriologic results beyond three months of treatment, and thus identify cases who might benefit from a prolongation of the intensive phase.
To assess the importance of monitoring sputum conversion as an early treatment indicator of treatment success.
Retrospective analysis of sputum conversion in a cohort of 'cured' tuberculosis patients.
Of 65 (95%) patients whose sputum converted in the third month of treatment, 62 were cured; only 21 of 35 (60%) patients whose sputum was still positive at the end of three months of treatment were ultimately cured.
Sputum conversion during the third month of treatment is an important predictor of treatment success; failure to convert predicts treatment failure.
Health centres in The Gambia, West Africa.
To identify factors determining the outcome of treatment of adult tuberculosis cases in a Tuberculosis Control Programme using directly observed treatment.
Information on the outcome of treatment was collected on all tuberculosis cases registered with the Tuberculosis Control Programme in 1994 and 1995 and treated under supervision by tuberculosis control staff, nurses or village health workers. Treatment outcome was recorded as cured, completed treatment, failed, defaulted or died. Transferred-out patients were traced and their treatment outcome recorded at the health centre where they had last been seen.
Data were analysed for 1357 adult smear-positive tuberculosis cases. Sputum smear conversion 2 months after the start of treatment was observed in 90% of smear-positive cases and was more likely to occur if the initial bacterial load in the sputum was low. The total cure rate was 74.6%. Female tuberculosis patients were more likely to achieve cure than males. Adjusting for sex, the cure rate was higher when treatment was provided by tuberculosis control staff in the main health centres rather than by nurses or village health workers at the peripheral level (odds ratio [OR] = 1.60, 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.23-2.09). The absence of sputum smear conversion after 2 months of chemotherapy was associated with defaulting later during treatment (OR = 2.0, 95% CI 1.15-3.57). Adjusting for age and sex, the death rate during treatment was higher in human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) positive than in HIV-negative tuberculosis patients.
Directly observed treatment is an effective intervention for improving adherence of tuberculosis patients to treatment in a resource-poor country, provided that drugs are effectively delivered to the most peripheral level, and that health staff are adequately trained and regularly supervised. Patients with high bacterial load in initial sputum smears need to be closely supervised, as they are more likely to default from treatment.
Sputum smear and culture conversion are important indicators for the effectiveness of treatment and the infectivity of the patient. The aim of this study was to identify the factors influencing both sputum smear and culture conversion time among patients with new case pulmonary tuberculosis (TB). The study was conducted in a reference hospital in Turkey in which 737 patients with pulmonary TB were hospitalised between January 2000 and 2005. We evaluated 306 (193 men and 113 women) human immunodeficiency virus-negative patients diagnosed with new case pulmonary TB. Factors associated with both sputum smear and culture conversion time (days) were investigated. Patients with diabetes mellitus (DM), cavitary disease, radiologically extensive disease had longer sputum smear and culture conversion time than the other groups. In addition, old age, male sex, smoking and thrombocytosis were found to be significantly associated with sputum smear conversion time. In the logistic regression analysis, the presence of DM and extensive disease were determined as independent factors associated with persistent sputum smear and culture positivity at the end of 2 months. The presence of DM and extensive disease were found to be independent risk factors influencing both sputum smear and culture conversion time in pulmonary TB. Sputum smear and culture examinations should be considered together to assess the poor prognosis.
Characteristics of TB patients in west Cameroon
- M Noubom
- F D Nembot
- H Donfack
Noubom M, Nembot FD, Donfack H, et al. Characteristics of TB
patients in west Cameroon: 2000-2009. Pan Afr Med J, 2013;
16, 39.