Content uploaded by Billy Haworth
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Billy Haworth on Dec 20, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
Assessing the application and value of participatory mapping for
community bushfire preparation
!"#$%&'
$
'() !"#$%&'$
Highlights
*+,)%&-&&
.&%+%%/,)-!%%&//+
+,)+-%!
0/+%%/%%%+++-!%%&
Abstract
+%//%+&+-
&++&+/+*1
,//%+&2,)3//%+&-%
&#-//+-4-+%%//
%%+&1'%
///%&%%1.%//&+%
%%-%/++&%%&+1
%%&,)-!&/%&%+%%/
%%1)*+,)%&+%-/
*%-&/,)%&&&++
-/1.&%+%%/%-!4
++&+1%&&%%4+%%/*-4-
/+%%/1+56%&%%%
+%%/-&/+&-!%%&++++-
-/-!//+
&17/*/--+%%
+///%!+&1.&%%-&+%
8&&//++-!+&%/
+%%/1++&/+&%-%&%
/%&%91:
*%!/++%-%%&1
6
6
;
5
<
=
>
?
@
A
6B
66
6;
65
6<
6=
6>
6?
6@
6A
;B
;6
;;
;5
;<
;=
;>
;?
;@
;A
5B
56
5;
55
5<
5=
5>
CD-!,)%&%+%%/++//+&
%%&
1. Introduction and background
1.1 Bushfire preparation and community engagement
$++%%&++%-!1.%&
%%%1'&/
E/%%&4+/2.;B6B3+%F+%%G2
H.;B653+9%%2.+et al1;B65 0%et al1;B6<3
%%&2.+et al1;B6>3/2et al1;B6>3%%
%!-!2(7et al1;B65 et al1;B65310%++&/
+%%&%%&+2.;BB5 +et al.
;BB? /et al.;B6=31//&+/+/++&
%I++%%&+///%&%
%%1EJ+/++-++
%&%&/+%%&20''3
-/21/1")0';B6=31)K%%%-
++%&%&+-"&/0'2$LK;B6631
)K++%&%&!+/+/+4-%&1
,$:KGF$++:/G%/+-
6AA5///%/---!%%&2$:K;B6>31
++%+%%%-+:2:3F!4
'"/-G2'"3%/+++&--!
%++-!&&&
1%/++%+&-%%%-!
%--%%-!2:;B6<31+%/+*$
2F:+4:G3K2F:$++&G3+//&/
/-%/+%-!2!3-
2(;B66 (0/et al1;B6<31
$++//+%&%&+/+%&+/-
I/1)/++%&&&/+//&&
/%&%%%2..''3%/21/1
et al1;B6< et al1;B6=31'*+%F,K+G
+J+;B6B4669$"M%
%9&2,+et al1;B6;3/%
0/+C+/;B6="%9-
%&4-2';B6=31C/&&
J-I/-
//%%&//1/-
%&&+&++&/-//
;
5?
5@
5A
<B
<6
<;
<5
<<
<=
<>
<?
<@
<A
=B
=6
=;
=5
=<
==
=>
=?
=@
=A
>B
>6
>;
>5
><
>=
>>
>?
>@
>A
?B
?6
?;
?5
?<
?=
++/++///%+&
2,)3%&//+%&#-%-+/
+/+/%&%+/+2H;B6=31
1.2 The emergence and promise of VGI
,)4/%&+%&
/&+&//%+&2et al.;B6; ;BB?
;BB@31/)-;1B/-%&/+/
--++&+%&/+%
-%&/&///%+&-
%BB? .H7;BB?31/+%+&+
%-&-&%&/%&+%
&%%&-+&/
-/////%+&+2)3%
2et al.;B6631
'%%+,)%%%&
/!%%&1:*+%%&
'2;B6B3%%%&,)+%&#%/-
+/+%-&//+&-
+1$++%&%&+/-/#+
+%/+%&-&,)/!2H
';B6B31et al.2;B6;3-%%&)//%%-
/-,)1///2;B6<3%
%%,)&//2C3/+
+%1C&+&+/%&-
-//++%
++///-/&2//et al.;B6<31
K/%+,)+%-+%&1$/&
&+-,)&%+%+
&#//-*%4%+&
&&%&2;B6>31
1.3 VGI in disaster management
+%//%+&+-
&++&/
+/+*2H;B6B H;B6=31+-4-
+%%/%N+/%%+&
2L+H%&;B66 7H.;B6B31-:-
*+/2et al.;B6; et al.;B6;3++%*&&
+/+%%/2(;B6;31et al.2;B6>3-&+%&%&
+%%///+%/+%-+/
+%%+-+4%%&%&%+++&
5
?>
??
?@
?A
@B
@6
@;
@5
@<
@=
@>
@?
@@
@A
AB
A6
A;
A5
A<
A=
A>
A?
A@
AA
6BB
6B6
6B;
6B5
6B<
6B=
6B>
6B?
6B@
6BA
66B
666
66;
665
66<
66=
%1/%*///%+&-&&#
%%+&/++//+%%&
%&,)-..''%+/+2H;B6=31
,)%-%%&/+/+2H;B6=
;B6>31,)48&%++&-
&84++&-%-&/+
+&+%%481/&
/-%!+//,)-%%
&+//+-+
+%%/+%/;B6B&92(;B6;31//&#
++&+-/++%-
+%%%-++/++
%&-4%%%1/-+//
+/%&/-%%&1.%+//%/
+//+%/
2.;B6>31:+%++
&+&-&/,)2'et al.;B6=31
K%/,)92et al.;B6>31K,)+
+&4%+9&9
-/+/1'%
%%&/--+/+&21/1et al.;B6; /
et al.;B6> %HC+/;B6;31)%+%
+&--21/1et al. ;B6531'
-%&,)%/-/%+
O&2;B65 et al.;B6531*//-
,)1,)---
%%+/&2et al.;B6=31
)+%/%N++++/+
/+//+/,)+&/
%&27H;B66 Ket al.;B6=31:
,)E+/+/+G%4%%+&+&
2;B6> .H7;BB?31:+/,)-/2";BB63
&++%-&F+%/G/
-+/+/#2et al.;B65 $H:;B6=31
7!%///%&
%%2H;B6=318/%%&
,)%%&%&-!1,)-4
/4%,)%%&2HL+;B6>31
/*+&,)%&+&/-&-
+%%%&P+/&/
<
66>
66?
66@
66A
6;B
6;6
6;;
6;5
6;<
6;=
6;>
6;?
6;@
6;A
65B
656
65;
655
65<
65=
65>
65?
65@
65A
6<B
6<6
6<;
6<5
6<<
6<=
6<>
6<?
6<@
6<A
6=B
6=6
6=;
6=5
6=<
6==
+/+1),)-*%-&/
,)%&%&%+%%/++1,)
%&/%&%%,)%
/%&&%%-,)/
*+,)%&2et al.;B6;31
1.4 Participatory mapping
)/++&%9-0''2H(;BBA31
(2;BBA3++4-0''%&%&-/++&
&!&2/#-&%&31K/
I+&&%&%&%+%44
+&2/et al.;B6531
L%%/++&0''/%&%)2.)3%-
%&%&)2..)31.)..)--!-&/+-/
%%&%&2H:/+;B6=31K///%//&+
/%&/.)+/%&9&
+%&+%&)20;BB?31)%/*%&
++++-+%+%%&/
2$-;BB53%&%4+/%++
+%+++&2;BB? ($et al1;B6=31
+%&%/..)%%%&/4
++%-&&
&++%/2($et al1;B6=31)
&%%%8-%%2%
HCQ;B6<3-%:/+G2;B6=3!&
F%&%+%%/G-%&#&/+%
,)1
K/%&-..),)2;BB@3%+,)
&)2($et al1;B6= -H;B6=31,)
%&%&+%+&%
+&%%%+%++-+
2($et al1;B6=31/+GF%/+G-2;B6=3
..)cultural informaon++,)%+
%technological informaon1&*%&&%
-..),)%%/2$+H+;B65
;BB@31..)-&%&/
%&///+&//,)-9
*-F%/+G+--2;B6=3
%&&4/1
.&%%%-8++&I48&+
+/--&2Ket al.;B6B3/-+&+
=
6=>
6=?
6=@
6=A
6>B
6>6
6>;
6>5
6><
6>=
6>>
6>?
6>@
6>A
6?B
6?6
6?;
6?5
6?<
6?=
6?>
6??
6?@
6?A
6@B
6@6
6@;
6@5
6@<
6@=
6@>
6@?
6@@
6@A
6AB
6A6
6A;
6A5
6A<
6A=
+-)/&/%&)
%%+2;BB>31$et al.2;B6<3/
&&-!+%/&#G&
/+&&%&//!///
8&%&%&,)&&E+/%%!1
)+%%//-+%0''!+/+%%&
+/!#+2$H$/6A@A3+%+/
+/!-2Cet al.;B6B31.&%+%%/
-++&%-%#%
&+2H(;BBA31/et al.2;B653-
++4-+%+&+&/&
--++4+1)%!!
%-%&%&++8&!+/+-/
/%+!++&%/%%&
%++++-2:H$%;B6<31:$%2;B6<3
9%&%+%%/-//%
//+%1+9-
/&/&+%//%&%
*%+&&1)+%$-2;BB53/%&%+%%/%
--/++%&+++++-//4
4+/-%/-+%/
++&1
$&9..)&+%&%)+%+/#
++&/+%*//-
/++%&%&2$-HC;BB=31,)++
-&%+&/%&%%&-
%1
)%%&%+%%/%%/,)-!&
/++%1)-%&%+%%//+
%++%%&%+
/-/%%%%/%%/9
%%2et al.;B6<31%+9&2(*;BB>
et al.;B6<3//%&%-&1%
&-&-%&%/+%%&%&
+%%/%%&+-+
1%&%%%-//-
-+%+%&%G///
207H;B6<319&+%/%%%%
%%9&&/&-&&
/&%%-%%&2$&et al.;BBB31+%
8+%/%&/%4-+1%&%
>
6A>
6A?
6A@
6AA
;BB
;B6
;B;
;B5
;B<
;B=
;B>
;B?
;B@
;BA
;6B
;66
;6;
;65
;6<
;6=
;6>
;6?
;6@
;6A
;;B
;;6
;;;
;;5
;;<
;;=
;;>
;;?
;;@
;;A
;5B
;56
;5;
;55
;5<
;5=
;5>
%+-+-+%%/%
%&%/++%/2et al.;B6<3/!&
&/,)%&-1
1.5 Study aims
+%+%%/-&//
+&-!%%&++++-G
/-!//+
&1(%!/9&D
630%&-&//,)//+-!
%%&R
;30&-&+%%/++R
53)///++%%/%++&R
<3)+%%8&++&//++-!
+&R
2. Methods
2.1 Study sites and rationale
.&%+%%/%-!++&+K
2:/631(+--%&!#1!+
+#+%++&/4
&/2:;B6;31-!6A>?+G%-
>;5BBB-/2(K;B66310-!+%
+;B65/;B5&-/!
S6BB+2&+&+/%
%&9&%-%320.K$;B6531;B6=46>
+-!*--4+&+
2"$'$;B6=31K&/%O;=BT
+/F,/:0/G/%/-;B@64;6BB/+
%%&2:*4/et al1;B6=31+
/-!1
%&2:/63&-61%
++-!-%&!&
-,)%%&++&8///%*&/
++//+++%!!1
?
;5?
;5@
;5A
;<B
;<6
;<;
;<5
;<<
;<=
;<>
;<?
;<@
;<A
;=B
;=6
;=;
;=5
;=<
;==
;=>
;=?
;=@
;=A
;>B
;>6
;>;
;>5
;><
;>=
;>>
;>?
;>@
;>A
:/61%&+1
-61$&%
Region Bushre
risk1
Signicant
re event2
Populaon3Geography Engaged
bushre
groups4
Part of BRN
program5
Ke&ering *+ 6A>? A@< ' U +
St Marys "
*+ ;BB> @BB ' U U
St Helens "
*+ ;B6< 6<A@ .4- " +
Tolmans
Hill
- *+ ;B6< <AB - " "
6+'+%%-.2.3;B6B1KAP;P;B6>
V%DPP111P%P*B5P'WK+W(%%/X1;/!D+++!&1
+//+-P++%+21/1
-O31,+&P15;B66$K&&2K31<0++
%4*&/-%&/++4!+/+4/%R1/1/-/%+&/-
%1=!4'"/-D"%'" +//+ U++1
V%DPP1-!/-11/1PX1
@
;?B
;?6
;?;
;?5
;?<
;?=
;?>
;??
;?@
;?A
2.2 Participant recruitment
.&%/D263%%/%&%%
2et al.;B6=32;3253&++
!/%-++/&/1K
+&&%+&+2Y;<B3
*%E%++%2Y=B3-*%
1)+&+++%(2Y6=B3
2Y6=B3+1%&+-
/+-21/1+:
++/&3//%+&:-2-//%/
X6@31
2.3 Workshop process
%"+-0+-;B6=<4=
%1%%&%+&%+%%/+4&&
++-*%//
++++--1%%&
%%+%%/&2%%*+AB+3-25B+3/+%%/
&2%%*+?=+3-%&%+%9&26=+31.
%&/:%&+'"
%/+1!%%+%&%
%%%-+&
--&-+:+I+/
+/+%&1
%-/+
*%%&&1!&%%+%%/-%&%
/%;4=/%+/2#K63%/%+%2#K63 ++
%&% 2I:+/F-%G+&3
2#K;3-%%%&+&&1
.&%+&+%-!
%%&++/+-&%41
**%-&+%%/%&%+%
%-1%///&
+/-%%%/%--!
++-%%%%/+++/%+4
4%&+%/&
:F%G1K+%&*%&%%+%
/%1:/;%*+%%%+%+%/*1
&2/+%%/3&/+&+/%
+--+%1/)&+ M+%%N+21#+%1+3
+%-1+%-++%
A
;@B
;@6
;@;
;@5
;@<
;@=
;@>
;@?
;@@
;@A
;AB
;A6
;A;
;A5
;A<
;A=
;A>
;A?
;A@
;AA
5BB
5B6
5B;
5B5
5B<
5B=
5B>
5B?
5B@
5BA
56B
566
56;
565
56<
56=
56>
56?
56@
56A
5;B
%//%/%%+%2/%&%
#+%3'7+%-%&%-/-
-%%+%+%-%1.&%
+%P+/-1%N+-%
8/1K%&%-
%&P-/+&%%/1
.&%-%-+&9
1:/5%*+%+%/+%1
K9&+%-%&%%-9&&9&
//%/*%+%%/+++&
+%%/+/++-!%%&++
%&%,)1Z&%
(J*/K&&2K3;B66
$1C///-&+%&%
//&+-1
:/;1K*+%%%+%%/C/%
6B
5;6
5;;
5;5
5;<
5;=
5;>
5;?
5;@
5;A
55B
556
55;
555
55<
55=
55>
55?
:/51K*+%/+%M+%%N+%/C/%
3. Results
516.&%+/%
+56%&%/2C/Y6> (
YA YB +Y>31+%
+%9&1K-&+2=5T3+2<?T3%&%1
/-&%&%5=2/5=4=BY;BT =64?BY=5T
X?BY;?T31:/<%+%-/%&+%
%++%%&1ABT
%26BT3%2>?T3265T31(%&%
++=2?>T3;<T/+;B1=?T
%&%&9!&+O+%2<?T3&2=BT31
66
55@
55A
5<B
5<6
5<;
5<5
5<<
5<=
5<>
5<?
5<@
5<A
5=B
:/<1%++&%&/%%&%%&%/
/%+%K;B66$%%&1
3.2 Workshop observations
3.2.1 Parcipant interacons
.&%%%+&--!%%&
++191)%&
%%+%%/&/%&%&1+%&%-
/-++++-++
&//+%%/&&+-%%2
%%+&/+%%31
)&%%//+%%/&1+E9/
&&-9%&%&/&1)+
%&/%++-%2-%%+%+%3/
/%++%%&+%&%--
/&+-/1KJ&&+//
&++/%&+%%/++-/
+%1
3.2.2 Group Discussions
6;
5=6
5=;
5=5
5=<
5==
5=>
5=?
5=@
5=A
5>B
5>6
5>;
5>5
5><
5>=
5>>
5>?
5>@
5>A
0+%+%8-+%%/+
,)4+%+-%%-++%
[/10%-%//-!++%
+%%+&%+
-+%%/%&1
.&%/-%/+%%/-&
-&51;161+%%/-%%4
//+&-!%%&&&+//%%
-/%!///1
-+%%-*+/!+&21/1%%&
/-3-&+/+&
-&/P%%+++%
%&/21/1 ) 31
3.2.3 The informaon contributed
%&%+%%%&!
++++&%%%&#
4-FG%+-
%-&1
/!&&%&%-
++%%++%-1)+
+-/+-//-G
++&C/%&%%%4
//-4-!+/+/%+%1.&%
+%+++/-+%/-!%%+1'/
-+++%&!&%/8%+-
-/++&1.&%/+%%+
+////+-!%%&++
-+/%1
3.3 Questionnaire responses
3.3.1 The user experience of mapping community informaon
%&%-*%+%%/+&
++%&1A?T%&&-!
%%&A?T/+%/8&%+&
??T+/--!%%&++/+%%/
*1.&%++%%&%%-
/-/++/%//++
+//+//-!1
65
5?B
5?6
5?;
5?5
5?<
5?=
5?>
5??
5?@
5?A
5@B
5@6
5@;
5@5
5@<
5@=
5@>
5@?
5@@
5@A
5AB
5A6
5A;
5A5
5A<
5A=
5A>
5A?
5A@
5AA
<BB
<B6
<B;
<B5
<B<
<B=
<B>
/&&++++-+%%&%
%&//%&*%A<T!+/%+
--!%%&&&++1+
%&%++/-!%%&-
&81:*+%D
\)--6?---]%
%/+/--
++^29&%%;B6=31
L++G%-&!
%+%%/&&1
:/=%%&%G%%&%%&%+%%/&&
%&//+<2/3+%&/*%
+++%%/-!%%&1
:/=17+%%&%+%%/*/+<
2/3+1-%+-%
F//GF0/GF"GFK/GF//G7+
%%&%%/1
%/2;>T3+%-%&%/
+&%-+++%+&-!
%+&10%
@>T%&%-+++%+
%1
3.3.2 Paper mapping versus digital mapping
6<
<B?
<B@
<BA
<6B
<66
<6;
<65
<6<
<6=
<6>
<6?
<6@
<6A
<;B
<;6
<;;
<;5
<;<
<;=
<;>
<;?
<;@
<;A
<5B
)%9&8-%%+%%//++,)
/+%%/%&%-/+2-;31:/>
%&%%%%+%%//+%%/+
%+-++1
:/>1+-%/%&%%/+%%/+KD
+D-++1
-;1/,)+%%/+&!-%%&%1
Strengths Weaknesses
Paper
Mapping
P-+/ 0I+
)& !+%
/% '&/+%+/
(E%_1/1/ ./-
"%
7+P-%/
7+P++
'
)+&-/
-1/1)
Digital
Mapping
/& /I+
K-+ 0/_
6=
<56
<5;
<55
<5<
<5=
<5>
<5?
<5@
<5A
$&/+& /
)/ )P+&
$#+P%&_
/-
)+&!&_+//+
% $/+%
/ %+)%N+
(-- 0%%P
(&%+&1/1
+/
+
/PJ
0-+-
+%-
+&+%%R
1/1%-
L-
+&1/1!%
K-
3.3.3 The informaon mapped
.&%--+%%+&1@<T+&
%?<T/++-!%%&1
A5T,)-+/+/+&1A<T-%&%,)
++++-%%%&%
%+&-++-++1L%&%
++D
\.%/`-1)11%1"
%&#^29&%%;B6=31
4. Discussion
%%%&%&%-,)++
-!%%&1'%+%%//%&+&
-!%%&++++--
/-!//+&1
!/-*+%1
4.1 Study sample
+%&+%56%&%*%&!/
-%%&%&%&%%V5=/
%&%%X=B2:/;31,-/%*%//
/%%&/%%1
)/-%%&,)F-G++-&/
+%-%&R%&%++%#
/++//+0''%&
6>
<<B
<<6
<<;
<<5
<<<
<<=
<<>
<<?
<<@
<<A
<=B
<=6
<=;
<=5
<=<
<==
<=>
<=?
<=@
<=A
<>B
<>6
<>;
<>5
8/&&'"*%-%&%&20K;B6>31
-+%//+-
++%%++81/
%%&%+%%/%&+%
*--++%&%/+2;B6>3
+%%%%1
0%*+8%/+
%-+&+-%1K*&
%%/-4++4%+&//a+
/&++/&+//
//*$4$72%++&;B6=3&
+%%&-++1
++%#%*%
%&%1.&%%+++<%&%&/%/
%//++%%/&&-&/%&%/
%%/%/
%%%&%,)+%%-!%%&//+1
9&&/9&+%/&
9&/-&&9&
+%/+%F+G*+/%+
207H;B6<31+//%+%
+%#>46;2I;B653-+%&%&
9+/+%#1-!9&+&/
*%%&%+%#26AA=31)%E
++%%%&%-
%%&%4&
!&1+/#*%%
+%+8+%1
<1;)//
)%!+*%%%&%//%&
-&/,)///-!%%&1/
8/--!8++-++
+//-*%1%,)%%&/
/+%%/%%%+///%!-/
+%%1-&0''4//+81L%
+%+..)&&%&%%+%
%O-%&%&+%21/1;BB;31
.&%--+//%-+%
/-!/%-+&
/-%/+%%&%1(%%/-//%
6?
<><
<>=
<>>
<>?
<>@
<>A
<?B
<?6
<?;
<?5
<?<
<?=
<?>
<??
<?@
<?A
<@B
<@6
<@;
<@5
<@<
<@=
<@>
<@?
<@@
<@A
<AB
<A6
<A;
<A5
<A<
<A=
<A>
<A?
<A@
<AA
=BB
=B6
=B;
=B5
++%+&-+
-*&/+%++&4
*%&*%+-!4+%%/1
(2;BBA3//4-+%%
9+%&%++//1($et al.2;B6=3
/%&%+%%/+/%/+,)%O
--/12;BB?3%/!%&/
+,)//%+-+-G&&
*%1
'//+///%+%%/-
++1+%/++%*%//+
9/1/2;B6;3+%
%%+&%K
;B66//,)&&%+%%
+++%1%--\
/&/+/%%
+++%^2et al.;B6; "et al. ;B6631$
++E++++-G
-!%%&%&+1.&%+%%/&
%&%--+//+%
++1,)%&%+%%/++&
-+&%&-&//++
1////%&%&
%++++-+%+&+&
-/[-2+et al1;BB?3/+%
2(%;BB?31
)*+/%&%A<T
%&/,)++++-%%
-&///%-/++1)-!
&-*%%-+
++/G%-&&1
)/++%%/%8&++&/
/++-!+&%/+2:/>31+%/
-%%%/&a+
*%1'-;1B/+++-2et
al.;B6= .;B6=31/=?T%&%&4-
%/+%%/+%E+%---2;B6=3
%&,)-+&+/
&1+/2;B6>39&%+,)%
+%F%%G/%&%+%%/J
+%/+1L%&%+%%/%%%&-
6@
=B<
=B=
=B>
=B?
=B@
=BA
=6B
=66
=6;
=65
=6<
=6=
=6>
=6?
=6@
=6A
=;B
=;6
=;;
=;5
=;<
=;=
=;>
=;?
=;@
=;A
=5B
=56
=5;
=55
=5<
=5=
=5>
=5?
=5@
=5A
=<B
=<6
=<;
=<5
=<<
%&%&-+%+/+
%%%/,)&&++-
%1$-C2;BB=3+&/%-+
++%+%//
+%1:++-!%%&+-&%%/+%%/+-
%%%++&-;%&%&
,)/1
.&%G-%&+&4#
-%2%HC+/;B6; et al.;B6=31&
8++/+-92L+H%&
;B66 /et al.;B6>3/9-+O
%-7G7%++&/
&/+21/1et al.;B6B319&+-
I&+++4+%%/%O8&4&1L-;1B
%N+$!/+%+-%&&/
+&-2($et al1;B6=31($et al.2;B6=3
/-&++%&%+%%//%&/
-,)1
.%&%%&-
+&-4-%N+1)+&+%%--
%%+-&%&+!-
+1K+&%%+21/1
3+&%+%+%1-
2;B6=3//&+/&%%&
/&%&/+-9&+/1,)
%&*-E++&1:*+%&!&+/
%%&%%/%&+&
-1%&,)E++&%-
+/++%1.&&
%,)+-9%&
/++-%%/&/+
+O&1
<15:&
)+%/#+++//+-
%%-&%%Gperceived%%
//-!%%&&*%/+
-/1-%%%/
-&/&//4++%%&%+%%/-!%%&
//+++1
6A
=<=
=<>
=<?
=<@
=<A
==B
==6
==;
==5
==<
===
==>
==?
==@
==A
=>B
=>6
=>;
=>5
=><
=>=
=>>
=>?
=>@
=>A
=?B
=?6
=?;
=?5
=?<
=?=
=?>
=??
=?@
=?A
=@B
=@6
=@;
=@5
+%9&/+&&4
%,)&&1'&-++&+
-9,)%%&2-H;B6=31-+/
+%%&%+%/%&/2H(
;BBA31:+%F+%G,)+-
+%+-+R%+-4-%N+
,)+%%-/%-&%-
+/+/+&2et al.;B6>3/-,)
%&1+J-%4F++G+
/E*-%%&/&&&2H(;BBA312;B6;3
//+/&G//++%&%&&
/+%/-+%!&
%-+%////%-*%F*%44
G/-17/9+%%&
-/%&%+%%/&&+-++&%%%
/&+%%1
5. Concluding remarks
C-&%&%+%%/-!+/+%+&
%-/-/+&%&%&1+
%&%+%%//,)%/%%&++
/*/G//+%-0''1
:*%!/++%-
%%&1%!/&/9&
++%&-
//&/+++%#/+%//+-
%%&///%&P4%/%1
-!/++++-+/++&/+/
/&+%%%&%-+4%%%
%/&+-1K&
/+-9+//+++&-,)4
/++&-//
++//+1)*&/++//+/+%%/-&
%&%/&/-&/++-!
+&1,)%%++//+-
-+%///1
Acknowledgements
%%-)&K&:$++
K/!"#$%&'$1
%&%/%-.(!4'
;B
=@<
=@=
=@>
=@?
=@@
=@A
=AB
=A6
=A;
=A5
=A<
=A=
=A>
=A?
=A@
=AA
>BB
>B6
>B;
>B5
>B<
>B=
>B>
>B?
>B@
>BA
>6B
>66
>6;
>65
>6<
>6=
>6>
>6?
>6@
>6A
>;B
>;6
>;;
"/-++:1+
&-1'$K%%"1;B65P6B>A1
References
KK17(1H012;B6B31.&%/+++%/D
1Technical report published by the Centre for Embedded Network Sensing1
KL1+%(1HK-.12;B6=31+/+/
KD/+;B6<K"M0+/
(/+$+%1The Australian Journal of Emergency
Management5B263D;;4;>1
//1(181101(1K11011$1"K1
("C1."1,L/%:1H)+U12;B6<31Environmental Livelihood Security in
South-East Asia and Oceania: a nexus-livelihoods approach for spaally assessing change.White
Paper.$+-7D)&(/+)&2)()31';=
(;B6>+
V%DPP1+1/1/P%-&P4%-&4%P+44
4444PX1
017/(1HC12;B6;31:/:-_+/
Z,E1The Australian Journal of Emergency Management,;?263;?_
551
$1(1H$12;B6>31/%/D*+/%&%
%&+%%/1 ACME: An Internaonal E-Journal for Crical
Geographies 6=263D;B?4;;A1
12;B6;31.-%&%&)2..)3/+%/DE&
+%1URISA Journal;=2;3D?46@1
12;B6>31K+%/8%-%&%+%%/
2..)P.)P,)31&)10L)D6B16666P/16;;B?1
101.01.#K1'1H47%#'12;B6<31K+%
&%..)+1Applied Geography<@D<;4=61
1H:/+"12;B6=31+%..)P.)+%%/+D
&1Ecosystem Services65D66A46551
1HCQ(12;B6<31C%&%-%&%&)2..)3DK
-+%1Applied Geography<>D6;;465>1
;6
>;5
>;<
>;=
>;>
>;?
>;@
>;A
>5B
>56
>5;
>55
>5<
>5=
>5>
>5?
>5@
>5A
><B
><6
><;
><5
><<
><=
><>
><?
><@
><A
>=B
>=6
>=;
>=5
>=<
!"#$%&'$2"$'$32;B6=31K
-!;B6=46>D"+-%1';=(;B6>+
V%DPP1-1+1P#P6;X1
$171H.12;B6<310/0$)&+$DK)
K%%1Journal of Urban Technology;62<3D??4A51
$1H$/'1126A@A31K%%&+///%+&
+!#+%%/1 Remote sensing of Environment ;A2;3D6<?46=A1
$+1H+"12;B6531$&/4&+%&
//%+&1GeoJourna?@2<3D>=?4>?<1
$-12;BB531%&%&%+%%/D%%)&:
K/0%+2):K031
$-1(1HC$1.12;BB=31K&+*++%+
%&%//%+&+2.)31 Cartographica: The Internaonal Journal for
Geographic Informaon and Geovisualizaon <B2<3DA646B;1
$K+2$LK32;B6631"&/0'D-/
&G1';=(;B6>+
V%DPP1/1/1PPP!P&b/bb1% X 1
$:K2$:K32;B6>31$++:/1';=(;B6>+
V%DPP111/1P%4%%P++4!/P X1
$C1H:(12;B6=31+D&//
+-1GeoJournal@B2<3D<A64=B;1
$&11+1H-12;BBB31K%%+%/&
9&D*+%//%1Social Science & Medicine=BD6BB64
6B6<1
0%%K&20K32;B6>31Bush5re-Ready Neighbourhoods Round 1 2014-2016 Evaluaon
Report.'%+%+:;B6>1
0701H012;B6<31$/9&49&&+)))D/+%
//%%&%%/+1Progress in Human Geography5@2;3D
;A<45B?1
0%+.+$-20.K$32;B6531;B65+!)9'%1'
;=(;B6>+
V%DPP1%11/1PP+P;B65b+b-!b9b%P
;B65b+b-!b9b%X1
;;
>==
>=>
>=?
>=@
>=A
>>B
>>6
>>;
>>5
>><
>>=
>>>
>>?
>>@
>>A
>?B
>?6
>?;
>?5
>?<
>?=
>?>
>??
>?@
>?A
>@B
>@6
>@;
>@5
>@<
>@=
>@>
>@?
0%.101(")1(1171(0171H1$12;B6<31.%/cR
0%/+&4++++!%%
%&&1Internaonal Journal of Wildland Fire;52>3D@@?4@A>1
0$112;BB?31.&%)d%%`)RProgress in Human Geography562=3D>6>4>5?1
12;BB>31$&%&%)D0&&
&1 Transacons in GIS,6B2=3D>A54?B@1
1(1:1H012;B6;31'///%+&D%&
//%%&1Annals of the Associaon of American
Geographers6B;253D=?6_=AB1
+/(/+K2(K32;B6631(K00-+K+
K4G0%+V%DPP1+1/1P+P+1PX1)D:
(12;B6;31.+&/++-!%%D//_%&
20&+31';=(;B6>+
V%DPP%111P6=5BAP X1
$1H.12;B65310!/+%+%%++&
4%%!1Internaonal Journal of Disaster Risk Reducon, >D@?4A?1
:$11H$%"1$12;B6<31K/9//%-
%&%&++%1Internaonal Journal of Wildland Fire;5D=@=4=AB1
:*4/.1'1(1171-1(1'1'+1K1H8"1712;B6=3
Climate futures for Tasmania future 5re danger: the summary and technical report.K&
$+H+$%&'$-+1'6B(;B6>
+V%DPP1/1P%4P%P;B6=P6;P'%b$:b:4:44
'%b;B6=b-1%X1
:(12;B6;31.+&/++-!%%D//_%&
20&+31';=(;B6>+
V%DPP%111P6=5BAP X1
1$1H(1K12;BBA31.&%4++%%/&1
Parcipatory Learning and Acon,>BD6BA_6@1
/71(1$+C11-'1(1H+1012;B6=31*%
$AP664%4+&
%%1Disaster medicine and public health preparednessA2B>3D>;=4>551
1H'12;B6B31.&,)0)"P*1
Geomaca><2<3D<5A4<=B1
;5
>@@
>@A
>AB
>A6
>A;
>A5
>A<
>A=
>A>
>A?
>A@
>AA
?BB
?B6
?B;
?B5
?B<
?B=
?B>
?B?
?B@
?BA
?6B
?66
?6;
?65
?6<
?6=
?6>
?6?
?6@
?6A
?;B
?;6
?;;
?;5
?;<
?;=
(1:12;BB?31$&#D//%1GeoJournal>A2<3D
;66_;;61
(1:1H1K12;B6B31$///%+&%D
&1Internaonal Journal of Digital Earth,5253D;56_;<61
$1HL+:1L12;B6>31&DL-O&+/
,)/4++/+1Computers, Environment and Urban Systems 2
%3%DPP*11/P6B16B6>PO1+%-1;B6>1B61BB>1
I012;B6531-/9&//%+%#%%&
&1Annals of the Associaon of American Geographers6B52=3D66B?466;;1
%K1HC+/.12;B6;31$-///+%1)D
Proceedings of the 1st Workshop on Privacy and Security in Online Social Media, ACM.
(11K,1HKK12;B6B31++%
R7`//%+&1The Cartographic
Journal<?2<3D56=_5;;1
+K1K1H12;BB?31%+&/+/
%%-+1Journal of Community Psychology, 5=2@3D6B?546B@51
12;B6>31+/+/+%%&//%+&D
L%%&//1Computers, Environment and Urban Systems=?D6@A46A@1
1H12;B6=31K//%+&
+/+1Geography Compass, A2=3D;5?4;=B1
11H(.12;B6=31+///&D/
%&+,)/++//+1The Australian Journal
of Emergency Management5B253D5>4<61
/C1C(1H'O-K12;B6>31(/-
//%+&E%DK-K1Applied Geography
>@D5?4<?1
01.111H712;B6631K/
++//%+&++%. Internaonal Conference on
Computer Applicaons and Industrial Electronics (ICCAIE 2011).
/717e1H/712;B6531.-%&%+%%/++4--
+&/&1Applied Mechanics and Materials5@B45@<D<>BA4<>651
;<
?;>
?;?
?;@
?;A
?5B
?56
?5;
?55
?5<
?5=
?5>
?5?
?5@
?5A
?<B
?<6
?<;
?<5
?<<
?<=
?<>
?<?
?<@
?<A
?=B
?=6
?=;
?=5
?=<
?==
?=>
12;BB;31)++/%"%D.[/%%-
/1)$/111(10123Community Parcipaon and
Geographic Informaon Systems."UDH:D;5;4;<=1
C'1101K1C1$1-/.1:1H'C1(12;B6B31K++%%/!
#+&%%%&!+/+1 Ecological
Modelling ;;6263D;46@1
7(1H)12;B6631+/+/++/+1
Internaonal Journal of Informaon Systems for Crisis Response and Management,52<3D6_6>1
71H.712;B6B31/%D+%+%+/
//%%&1Cartography and Geographic Informaon Science,5?263D>A_AB1
(0/$1--71H$'12;B6<31$++4-%%%/++;BBA
K-!D%+%&+%%/1Disasters5@2;3D;<A4;>>1
(*712;BB>31Z&&9&%&%R+R),1
0H'1.2130/0%+'2%%166=46;A37DK.-&1
($(1C1(H,%12;B6=31J/-//%
+&++&D/+.)1ACME: An Internaonal E-Journal for
Crical Geographies6<253D?A64@;>1
(12;B6631.-//+/-!+&/&%%D
+$K1Journal of Environmental ManagementA;26B3D;=;<4
;=5;1
(711L+(1H12;B6531G4
%&+/?:-;BBA,2K3!1Fire Safety
Journal>6D6?=46@<1
(.12;B6;31$+%%/&D%J/-
//+%&+1Journal of Map and Geography Libraries,@D@A_6BB1
(%1712;BB?317&/%++4+/+/+1
Natural Hazards<6D;A?456=1
".12;BB631Digital divide?: Civic engagement, informaon poverty, and the internet worldwide1
"UD$+-/.1
":1-C1H.8-+12;B6631$++D%+
+%&&1)1(17#11$01:+(11213
Resilience and Mental Health: challenges across the lifespan1$+-/CD$+-/
.1
;=
?=?
?=@
?=A
?>B
?>6
?>;
?>5
?><
?>=
?>>
?>?
?>@
?>A
??B
??6
??;
??5
??<
??=
??>
???
??@
??A
?@B
?@6
?@;
?@5
?@<
?@=
?@>
?@?
?@@
?@A
L+:1H%&712;B6631K%E+&/9
//%+&+/+1)Proceedings of the 14th AGILE
Internaonal Conference on Geographic Informaon Science6@_;;K%1
.71H7112;BB?31$&#++&D&%&/)$4%%%-
%&%&1)Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human Factors in Compung Systems1
$K%%1?;?4?5>12K$(D6;<B?5>31
.012;BB5310%%DK4/&%%&1Disaster Prevenon and
Management, 6;D;6B_;6>1
.+101$11'1$(1K1(1C171(71H
'12;B65310!/9+%%%%%&+
!1Internaonal Journal of Disaster Risk Reducon>D>?4??1
.+101$111H'1K12;B6>31+
%%%%!RInternaonal Journal of Disaster Risk Reducon,6>D@@4A@1
.K12;B6=31+/D;BB=4;B6=1PewResearchCenter, Internet, Science & Tech1
'66K%;B6>+V%DPP1%1/P;B6=P6BPB@P4/4/4
;BB=4;B6=PX1
.12;B6>31+%%/&+-+//
+1PewResearchCenter, Global A>tudes & Trends1'66K%;B6>+
V%DPP1%/-1/P;B6>PB;P;;P+%4%444/4&44
+-44+//4+PX1
.12;B6B31-!%%&D4+/+%&
++&1.01./+-1
'1+"1HC:12;B6=31)+%&+%/%%&
/&D+%-%%&1 GeoJournal802=3D>5?4>=;1
'12;B6=31.D-"%G1';=(;B6>
+V%DPP11/P*P;B6=P=P;P4%4%44X1
(126AA=31:9&+D+%#9&1Research in
Nursing and Health,6@D6?A46@51
1)1H12;B6<31.[//D/&/%%
+/%1Internaonal Journal of Mass Emergencies and Disasters,5;263D<54>51
12;B65317///%+&1The Canadian Geographer,
=?263D6_6B1
;>
?AB
?A6
?A;
?A5
?A<
?A=
?A>
?A?
?A@
?AA
@BB
@B6
@B;
@B5
@B<
@B=
@B>
@B?
@B@
@BA
@6B
@66
@6;
@65
@6<
@6=
@6>
@6?
@6@
@6A
@;B
@;6
1(-K1KK171$%$1H(12;B6>31K
//%+&9++1Internaonal Journal of Geographical
Informaon Science64;A10L)D6B16B@BP65>=@@6>1;B6>166@A==>1
71K1'1&M1H'-112;B6531&/%+D%+%
+%%/1Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing,?A26B3D@>=_@?A1
-'11H(12;B6=31%+/23//%+&D&91
Geo: Geography and Environment;2;3D6;;465>1
01(1:1H12;B6531,//%+&*E
///1)D01M11H(1:1213Crowdsourcing geographic
knowledge: volunteered geographic informaon (VGI) in theory and pracce 2%%16_6;31D
%/1
+:2:32;B6<3!'"/-1';=(;B6>+
V%DPP1-!/-11/1P X1
(111H'%12;B6;31+%/!
%%++-/1The Australian Journal of Emergency Management,
;?263D;B_;>1
012;BB?31(++%D+%+%&%+%%/1First Monday
6;2;31';=(;B6>+
V%DPP!+1/P-P/%P-POP*1%%P+P&PP6>;BX1
01712;BB@31),)%&%&R:+%/+1GeoJournal?;254<3D6>64
6?61
"&)&/0'&2")0'32;B6=31:+
0''&;B6=4;B5B1';=(;B6>+
V%DPP1%&-1P!P<5;A6b+1%X1
,+(11(101/(1##1H$12;B6;3179&
O4%$/;B6B4;B66991';=(
;B6>+V%DPP1-11#P-+PP6BBA;P?;@=P6;><66AAb,+T;B
T;B1T;B;B6;T;B4T;B"MT;B.%656b6=B<;B6;1%R9Y6X1
1$11HC12;B6>31%;BBA
-!,K1Geographical Research=<2;3D;B54;6=1
1C1+1H(712;B6531$++/;BBA
KFG-!D%%%1
Internaonal Journal of Wildland Fire,;;2>3D@<64@<A1
;?
@;;
@;5
@;<
@;=
@;>
@;?
@;@
@;A
@5B
@56
@5;
@55
@5<
@5=
@5>
@5?
@5@
@5A
@<B
@<6
@<;
@<5
@<<
@<=
@<>
@<?
@<@
@<A
@=B
@=6
@=;
@=5
@=<
1(71H+12;B6=31K+++/
D0!&%%&/1Internaonal Journal of Disaster Risk
Reducon,65D5=@45>@1
;@
@==
@=>
@=?
@=@
