Content uploaded by Elsamma Chacko
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Elsamma Chacko on Oct 17, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
Abstract
How blood glucose responds to exercise depends on the timing of the physical activity with
respect to the proximate meal. Although study after study has confirmed this, many researchers
still report results without specifying exercise timing. This laxity could be the source of some of
the uncertainties and inconsistencies found in the field. In place of the current practice of using
the binary categorization of the feeding cycle into pre-meal and post-meal periods, we look at it
as consisting of four time intervals: the pre-meal period plus the early, mid- and late postprandial
periods. Two of these intervals stand out. Pre-meal exercise uses endogenous glucose and
muscle glycogen as the main fuels offering varying effects on glycemia. Exercise during the
mid-postprandial period uses exogenous glucose as the main fuel. Exogenous glucose is
abundant in the blood during the 30 to 90 min post-meal period, rendering this interval a unique
opportunity to use up the excess glucose as fuel for moderate aerobic exercise, thereby blunting
the glucose surge. Hypoglycemia risk is minimal within the bounds of this exercise window.
The continuing arrival of glucose from the gut in copious amounts minimizes the risk for
hypoglycemia. The role of different modes of exercise and combinations during the mid-
postprandial period on metabolic markers remains to be explored.
What is new?
The pre-meal/post-meal binary categorization of the feeding cycle can be profitably
modified using the quartet: pre-meal, early, mid- and late postprandial periods. The pre-
meal (counterregulation, steady glucose) and mid-postprandial (insulin action, surging
glucose) intervals stand out. The mid-postprandial period offers a window of opportunity
to diabetes patients to exercise and blunt the glucose surge without fear of hypoglycemia.
The early and late postprandial periods are “grey” segments, constantly vulnerable to
intrusion by hepatic glucose.
A time for exercise: the exercise window
Introduction
In 1982, a team of Canadian scientists reported in the American Journal of Physiology how
exercise affected blood glucose levels (20). The exercise was a moderately paced treadmill walk
that started 30 min post-meal and lasted for 45 min. Although the focus of the study lay
elsewhere, the graphical results presented in the paper pointed to an intriguing possibility: could
physical activity be used to drain off – in real time -- the exogenous glucose entering the
bloodstream from the food being digested along the alimentary canal? The authors noted that
“with exercise, glycemia returned rapidly to fasting levels . . .” in healthy people and in those
with type 1 diabetes. Since then, a large number of studies have come out featuring exercise
timings that vary widely: pre-meal, 15 min post-meal, 30 min post-meal, 45 min post-meal and
one hour to several hours post-meal (2, 7). Many others, however, have been inexplicably silent
on the timing of the exercise in relation to meal. These studies have also used various exercise
intensities, durations, frequencies and combinations thereof. Now, 34 years later, it is still not
clear what exercise conditions would best improve the key metabolic parameters, HbA1c and
lipids. Translational efforts are exceedingly slow in this critical area. This report suggests a
somewhat more refined framework than the binary pre-meal – post-meal categorization of the
feeding cycle to help account for how meals and exercise influence blood glucose levels and
other metabolic measures. Although high-intensity/resistance exercise (25, 8) offers many health
benefits this paper will be focussing on moderate aerobic exercise. The remainder of this paper
reviews existing studies that point to the utility and rationale of this approach.
Research over several decades now has shown that blood glucose levels are sensitive to various
exercise conditions: timing, intensity, duration, frequency and sequencing of exercise (2, 7).
Light to moderate exercise pre-meal raised postprandial glucose, but a similar walk post-meal
lowered glucose levels (4, 5). Remarkably, an hour-long, energy-intensive interval exercise gave
the opposite results: it was the pre-meal exercise that improved glycemia (25).
Exercising in the late postprandial period could lead to hypoglycemia (7). In people with type 1
diabetes, delayed nocturnal hypoglycemia, which usually follows high-intensity or resistance
exercise, is a problem as well (17, 30). For many with type 1 diabetes, fear of hypoglycemia has
been a potent deterrent against partaking in exercise activities. This and extra carbohydrate
intake, meant to prop up falling blood glucose levels, lead to weight gain. Insulin pumps and
continuous glucose monitoring have made the task of regulating the insulin dose much simpler
(although these gadgets and associated procedures remain beyond the reach of the vast majority
of diabetes patients worldwide.)
Published accounts where no information on exercise timing is forthcoming show inconsistent
results for the effects of exercise on HbA1c (9, 10, 15). The reviews and meta-analyses reporting
on HbA1c have generally yielded only small improvements except in a few cases where the
improvements have been quite impressive (9, 10, 15). What is common to virtually all of these
studies is the absence of information on the timing of the exercise bout with respect to meals.
The physiology
The complex exercise – glycemia connection can be best understood by considering exercise
timing, the sources of glucose and the hormones involved. The post-meal period is far from
monolithic and, in fact, consists of three segments defined by the rise and fall of the glucose flux:
early (0-30 min), mid- (30-90 min) and late (> 90 min) postprandial periods. Categorization of
the feeding cycle in this manner is reasonable and warranted because, unlike the relatively
tranquil pre-meal period, the post-meal period is quite eventful, especially in people with
diabetes, what with the ebb and flow of the blood-glucose concentration (3). The dome of the
glucose peak, where exogenous glucose is abundant in the blood, is pegged as the 30-90 min
post-meal interval.
In this formulation two intervals stand out: pre-breakfast (where counterregulation is active) and
mid-postprandial (where insulin action prevails). The other two intervals are in grey areas where
the potential for intrusion by hepatic glucose is constantly present. It is, however, in the late
postprandial period that hypoglycemia mostly lurks. Fortuitously, the new framework comes
with a built-in antidote for the fear of hypoglycemia harbored by many diabetes patients. Start
and finish the daily exercise session within the bounds of the mid-postprandial period, and
patients are assured of plentiful supplies of blood glucose.
The dominant source of endogenous glucose, the liver plays a crucial role in glucose dynamics.
The hormones controlling blood glucose levels during exercise are insulin, glucagon and
catecholamines. The pre-breakfast period is characterized by low insulin-to-glucagon ratios.
Levels of catecholamines go up with high-intensity exercise (18). Moderate exercise during
insulin action lowers glucose levels while moderate exercise during counterregulation stabilizes
it (2, 22). As for high intensity pre-meal exercise, markedly elevated hepatic glucose production
leads to substantial post-exercise hyperglycemia (2, 7, 12, 13) before any glucose lowering effect
sets in (2, 6, 12, 21). In this scenario, the extent of hepatic glucose production holds the key to
glycemia. In the mid-postprandial period, hepatic glucose production is suppressed, free fatty
acids remain low and meal-derived glucose is pouring in, making the 30-90 min interval the right
time to drain off any excess glucose using moderate physical activity (1, 20, 24). What is
apparent here is the improvement of insulin sensitivity through insulin-mediated and contraction-
mediated glucose transport, nipping the post-meal surge in the bud – in real time at that. The
goal of timely exercise is to deny meal-derived glucose the chance to build up in the blood. This
denial not only avoids the serious long term consequences of repeated microvascular damage but
may reduce abnormal fat distribution.
Exercise timing
A 2013 review on exercise timing concluded that post-meal exercise of moderate intensity is
superior to pre-meal exercise for dealing with hyperglycemia (7). Moderate exercise during the
mid-postprandial period improved glucose consistently (1, 2, 4, 5, 11, 14 20, 22, 24, 26, 29).
Glucose lowering has been less efficient during the early (23) and late (5) postprandial periods
presumably because of the involvement of hepatic glucose. In the mid-postprandial period,
exercise starting at 30 min after the first bite into the meal showed the most effective blunting of
the glucose surge (1, 20, 24) (Table 1). As Nelson and colleagues demonstrated decades ago, by
intervening at the right time with an exercise bout of the right intensity, it is possible to keep the
post-meal glucose peak from forming altogether (1, 20, 24). This tactic also minimizes the
hypoglycemia risk because the continued arrival of glucose from the gut serves as a protective
measure.
Table 1 summarizes representative studies (4, 14, 20, 21, 23, 27, 28) done during the four
segments of the feeding cycle. A few cautionary observations are in order here. The glucose
responses shown use different measures: the quoted area-under-the-curve (AUC) values may
refer to the “total,” “incremental” or unspecified variety. Also, hyperglycemia reduction can be
just for the meal or for the whole day. But the overall trend is apparent: intervention starting
closer to the 30 min mark in the mid-postprandial period with exercise of moderate intensity
yields better glycemic control. Tellingly, these studies were not done for the purpose for which
they are being cited here and as such whatever support they offer to the considerations laid out in
this paper may be deemed independently proffered.
Same timing, different intensities
In two studies healthy people exercised at 30 min post-meal for 60 min at different intensities,
50% VO2max and 71% VO2max (24, 19). The lower intensity exercise normalized the glucose
level in 15 min and kept it at that level throughout the exercise, thereby blunting the peak well
(24). At the higher intensity, after the initial drop, glucose started going up 20-min into the
exercise bout and hyperglycemia persisted until the exercise ended (19). When Manders and
colleagues compared two intensities, 35% VO2max for 60 min and 70% VO2max for 30 min, at 60
min post-meal in people with type 2 diabetes, the lower intensity exercise offered the better
glycemic outcome (16). At higher intensitiesthe high end of the moderate intensity range, shorter
duration of exercise may be needed to keep hepatic glucose at bay.
Coordinating meals and exercise
A practical approach to moderating the 24-h glucose profile is to have one big meal, preferably
breakfast, as the designated “exercise meal” and two smaller meals plus two or three snacks.
This meal plan, along with mid-postprandial exercise would lower hyperglycemia after breakfast,
lunch and dinner (29). This lifestyle also minimizes the risk for hypoglycemia. The alternative,
of course, is to exercise three times a day. Light exercise for 15 min after every meal showed
some blunting of the peaks, but the energy expenditure was not enough to produce a significant
effect (5, 29). Taken together, the studies shown in Table 1 hold the promise of an even better
glycemic response to moderate activity starting 30 min post-meal (1, 2, 20, 24). Moderate post-
meal exercise can be done every day, the effects on glycemia are additive (28).
There's work to do
Although there is good evidence that the right time to start the moderate exercise session for
maximum benefit is some 30 min after the start of the meal (20, 24), data on HbA1c and lipids are
scarce. Immediate (real time), short term (48-72hours) and long term (3 months) effects of
moderate aerobic exercise on metabolic measures (HbA1c, levels of lipids, liver fat, and markers
of oxidative stress) in the mid-postprandial period remain to be explored.
Focusing research efforts on the mid-post-meal period is critical for accelerated translation:
physical activity is the one means available to vast populations living with diabetes in the
impoverished corners of the world. Moreover, if diabetes patients follow the current guidelines
and exercise moderately before breakfast or work out intensely any time other than in the mid-
postprandial period, chances are that glucose levels go up right after the physical activity (4, 5,
12, 13).
Conclusion
Although many studies extant inexplicably do not specify the timing of the exercise in relation to
the meal, enough data exist to suggest the rationale and utility of looking at the feeding cycle as
consisting of four segments: the pre-meal, early postprandial, mid-postprandial and late
postprandial periods. The mid-postprandial period (30 – 90 min post-meal) offers a unique
opportunity to diabetes patients to manage hyperglycemia, with minimal risk of hypoglycemia,
using a moderate aerobic activity. When exercise timing and intensity are taken into account
blood glucose levels respond to the physical activity in a predictable and consistent manner.
Funding: This work received no specific funding.
Duality of interest: The author declares that there is no duality of interest associated with this
manuscript.
Author's contribution: The author is the sole contributor to this paper.
Table 1. Glucose response to moderate aerobic exercise at different timing
Exercise
Mode
Population Timing Intensity & duration Favorable Glycemic
Response
Pre-meal (21) T2D “before breakfast” 60-75% HRmax for 60
min
Hyperglycemia/day
reduced by 12-15%
(delayed effect)
Early
postprandial
(23)
T1D 15 min post-meal 65% VO2max for 30 min Hyper glycemia for the
meal reduced by one
third
Mid-
postprandial
(20)
T1D and
Healthy
30 min post-meal 55% VO2max for 45 min “. . . glycemia returned
rapidly to fasting
levels.”
Mid-
postprandial
(14)
T2D 45 min post-meal 53% VO2max for 45 min 4 h glucose-AUC for
the meal reduced by
50%
Mid-
postprandial
(4)
People with
metabolic
syndrome
60 min post-meal 60% VO2max for 45
min
3 h glucoseAUC for
breakfast reduced by
22%
Mid-
postprandial
(27)
T2D 90 min post-meal 50% Wmax for 30 min Hyperglycemia/day
reduced by 24%
Late
postprandial
(28)
T2D with and
w/o insulin
150 min post-meal 50% Wmax for 45 min Hyperglycemia/day
reduced by 33%
T2D- type 2 diabetes; T1D- type 1 diabetes; AUC-area under the curve
References
1. Caron D, Poussier P, Marliss EB, Zinman, B. The effect of poastprandial
execise on meal-related glucose intolerance in insulin-dependent diabetic
individuals. Diabetes Care 5:364-369, 1982.
2. Chacko E. Exercising tactically for taming postmeal glucose surges. Scientifica
doi.org/10.1155/2016/4045717, 2016.
3. Daenen S, Sola-Gazagnes A, M'Bemba J, et al Peak-time determination of post-
meal glucose excursions in insulin- treated diabetic patients. Diabetes Metab
36(2): 165-169, 2010.
4. Derave W, Mertens A, Muls E, Pardaens K, Hespel P. Effects of post-
absorptive and postprandial exercise on glucoregulation in metabolic syndrome.
Obesity 15: 704- 711, 2007.
5. DiPietro L, Gribok A, Stevens MS, Hamm L, Rumpler W. Three 15-min bouts
of moderate post-meal walking significantly improves 24-h glycemic control in
older people at risk for impaired glucose tolerance. Diabetes Care. 36:3262-3268,
2013.
6. Francois ME, Baldi JC, Manning PJ et al. 'Exercise snacks' before meals: a
novel strategy to improve glycaemic control in individuals with insulin resistance.
Diabetologia 57:1437-1445, 2014.
7. Haxhi J, di Palumbo A and Sacchetti M. Exercising for metabolic control: is
timing important?Ann Nutr Metab 62: 14-25, 2013.
8. Heden TD, Winn NC, Mari A, Booth FW, Rector RS, Thyfault JP and
Kanaley JA. Post-dinner resistance exercise improves postprandial risk factors
more effectively than pre-dinner resistance exercise in patients with type 2
diabetes. J Appl Phsiol doi:10.1152/japplphysiol.00917, 2014.
9. Jelleyman C, Yates T, O'Donovan G et al. The effects of high-intensity interval
training on glucose regulation and insulin resistance: a meta-analysis. Obesity
Reviews 16: 942-961, 2015.
10. Kessler HS, Sisson SB and Short KR. The potential for high-intensity interval
training to reduce cardiometabolic disease risk. Sports Med 242(6): 489-509,
2012.
11. Kirwan JP, O'Gorman DJ, Cyr-Cambell D, Cambell WW, Yarasheski KE
Evans WJ. Effects of a moderate glycemic meal on exercise duration and
substrate utilization. Med Sci Sports Exer 33(9):1517-1523, 2001.
12. Kjaer M, Hollenbeck CB, Frey-Hewitt B, et al. Glucoregulation and hormonal
responses to maximal exercise in non-insulin-dependent diabetes. J Appl Physiol
68:2067-2074, 1990.
13. Kreisman SH, Manzon A, Nessim S, et al. Glucoregulatory responses to intense
exercise performed in the postprandial state. Am J Physiol Endocrinol Metab
278:E786-E793, 2000.
14. Larsen JJS, Dela F, Kjaer M, Galbo H The effect of moderate exercise on
postprandial glucose homeostasis in NIDDM patients. Diabetologia 40: 447-453,
1997.
15. Liubaoerjijin Y, Terada T, Fletcher K, Boule NG. Effect of aerobic exercise
intensity on glycemic control in type 2 diabetes: a meta-analysis of head-to-head
randomized trials. DOI 10.1007/s00592-016-0870-0, 2016.
16. Manders RJ, Van Dijk JW, van Loon, LJ. Low-intensity exercise reduces the
prevalence of hyperglycemia in type 2 diabetes. Med Sci Sports Exerc 42: 219-
225, 2010.
17. Maran A, Pavan P, Bonsembiante B. Continuous glucose monitoring reveals
delayed nocturnal hypoglycemia after intermittent high-intensity exercise in non-
trained patients with type 1 diabetes. Diabetes Technol Ther 12[10]: 763-768,
2010.
18. Marliss EB and Vranic M. Intense exercise has unique effects on both insulin
release and its roles in glucoregulation. Diabetes 51 [Suppl. 1]: S271-S283, 2002.
19. Marmy-Conus N, Fabris S, Proietto J, Hargreaves M (1996) Preexercise
glucose ingestion and glucose kinetics during exercise. J Appl Physiol 81(2): 853-
857, 1996.
20. Nelson JD, Poussier P, Marliss EB, Albisser AM and Zinman B Metabolic
response of normalman and insulin-infused diabetics to postprandial exercise. Am
J Physiol 242: E309-E316, 1982.
21. Oberlin DJ, Mikus CR, Kearney ML, Hinton PS, Manrique C, Leidy HJ et
al. One bout of exercise alters free-living postprandial glycemia in type 2 diabetes.
Med Sci Sports Exerc 46[2]: 232-238, 2014.
22. Poirier P, Mawhinney S, Grondin L et al. Prior meal enhances the plasma
glucose lowering effect of exercise in type 2 diabetes. Med Sci. Sports Exerc
33:1259-1264, 2001.
23. Rasmussen OW, Lauszus FF, Hermansen K. Effects of postprandial exercise
on glycemic response in IDDM subjects. Diabetes Care 17: 1203-1205, 1994.
24. Shin Y-H, Jung H-L, Ryu J-W, Kim P-S, Ha T-Y, An J-Y, Kang H-Y. Effects
of pre-exercise meal on plasma growth hormone response and fat oxidation during
walking. Prev Nutr Food Sci 18[3]: 175-180, 2013.
25. Terada T, Wilson BJ, Myette-Cote, Kuzik Nicholas, Bell GJ, McCargar LJ,
Boule NG. Targeting specific interstitial parameters with high-intensity interval
exercise and fasted-state exercise in type 2 diabetes Metabolism 16: 599-608,
2016.
26. Tobin LWL, Kiens B and Galbo H. The effect of exercise on postprandial
lipemia in type 2 diabetic patients. Eur J Appl Physiol 102: 361-370, 2008.
27. van Dijk J-W, Manders RJF, Tummers K,Bonomi AG, Stehouwer CDA,
Hartgens F, van LOON LJC. Both resistance- and endurance- type exercise
reduce the prevalence of hyperglycemia in individuals with impaired glucose
tolerance and in insulin treated and non-insulin treated type 2 diabetic patients.
Diabetologia 55(5): 1273-1282, 2012.
28. van Dijk J-W, Tummers K, Stehouwer CDA, Hartgens F, van LOON LJC.
Exercise therapy in type 2 diabetes Is daily exercise required to optimize glycemic
control. Diabetes Care 35: 945-954, 2012.
29. van Dijk J-W, Venema M, van Mechelen W, Stehouwer CDA, Hartgens F, van
Loon LJC. Effect of moderate-intensity exercise versus activities of daily living
on 24-hourblood glucose homeostasis in Male patients with type 2 diabetes
Diabetes Care 36(11): 3448-3453, 2013.
30. Yardley J, Mollard R, Macintosh A, MacMillan F, Wicklow B, Berard L,
Hurd C, Marks S and McGavock J. Vigorous intensity exercise for glycemic
control in patients with type 1 diabetes. Can J Diabetes 7: 427-432, 2013.