Conference PaperPDF Available

Mind the Gap: Probing Exertion Experience with Experiential Design Landscapes

Authors:
Xipei Ren at Beijing Institute of Technology
Xipei Ren
Yuan Lu at Eindhoven University of Technology
Yuan Lu
Aarnout Brombacher at Eindhoven University of Technology
Aarnout Brombacher
Sander Bogers at Eindhoven University of Technology
Sander Bogers
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract and Figures

In this paper, we report our study on applying Experiential Design Landscapes as the basis of design process to support the design of exertion games. We approach this question by setting up an 8-day interaction design module with 7 groups of students. The methods of our module were developed based on the process model of Experiential Design Landscapes. According to the provided framework, the students were engaged in designing embodied interaction for office workers in their daily routine to support active lifestyles. We collected data including their design process and design results to discuss on how Experiential Design Landscapes lead students to explore the exertion experience. The students also wrote self-reflections after the course to reflect on their experience of the methods used during the module. We finally discuss the strengths, limitations, and opportunities of our approach in this context to enlighten future research and practice initiatives.
No caption available
… 
Figures - uploaded by Xipei Ren
Author content
All figure content in this area was uploaded by Xipei Ren
Content may be subject to copyright.
Content uploaded by Xipei Ren
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Xipei Ren on Nov 23, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
67'8!*.4)!9$/:&0%$!*&+%,-!./-/,&0&-'!;#-1&2&-$&!
4-13&$'%#-!<#%-')!*&+%,-!=&+&/2$8!.&&'+!*&+%,-!<2/$'%$&!
>#+'#-?!@"9?!66A6B!CD3(!67EF! !
;#G(2%,8'!H!67EFI!;#G(2%,8'!%-!&/$8!G/G&2!#-!'8%+!$#-1&2&-$&!G2#$&&:%-,+!%+!'8&!G2#G&2'(!#1!
'8&!/D'8#2J+KI!<&20%++%#-!%+!,2/-'&:!'#!2&G2#:D$&!$#G%&+!#1!'8&+&!L#2M+!1#2!GD2G#+&+!2&3&5/-'!
'#!'8&!/N#5&!$#-1&2&-$&?!G2#5%:&:!'8/'!'8&!/D'8#2J+K?!+#D2$&!/-:!$#G(2%,8'!-#'%$&!/2&!%-$3D:&:!
#-!&/$8!$#G(I!O#2!#'8&2!D+&+?!%-$3D:%-,!&P'&-:&:!QD#'/'%#-?!G3&/+&!$#-'/$'!'8&!/D'8#2J+KI
:)1?!*45!V,<E!6(2W)19!./5(*)21!./<5()51+5!
A)*4!./<5()51*),-!758)91!S,1?8+,<58!
q%G&%!=Ufp?!dD/-!W@?!9/2-#D'!>=b.>9;TU=!/-:!"/-:&2!>b`U="!
U%-:8#5&-!@-%5&2+%'(!#1![&$8-#3#,(!
!"#',0*#7)7%$+#3%#$%71$'#1.$#*'.8(#1"#)776(0":#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#
L)"8*&)7%*#)*#',%#2)*0*#1-#8%*0:"#7$1&%**#'1#*.771$'#',%#8%*0:"#1-#%a%$'01"#
:)5%*C#`%#)77$1)&,#',0*#/.%*'01"#2(#*%''0":#.7#)"#kb8)(#0"'%$)&'01"#8%*0:"#
518.6%#30',#l#:$1.7*#1-#*'.8%"'*C#U,%#5%',18*#1-#1.$#518.6%#3%$%#
8%9%617%8#2)*%8#1"#',%#7$1&%**#518%6#1-#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*C#
Z&&1$80":#'1#',%#7$1908%8#-$)5%31$4+#',%#*'.8%"'*#3%$%#%":):%8#0"#
8%*0:"0":#%52180%8#0"'%$)&'01"#-1$#1--0&%#31$4%$*#0"#',%0$#8)06(#$1.'0"%#'1#
*.771$'#)&'09%#60-%*'(6%*C#`%#&166%&'%8#8)')#0"&6.80":#',%0$#8%*0:"#7$1&%**#)"8#
8%*0:"#$%*.6'*#'1#80*&.**#1"#,13#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*#6%)8#*'.8%"'*#
'1#%a761$%#',%#%a%$'01"#%a7%$0%"&%C#U,%#*'.8%"'*#)6*1#3$1'%#*%6-b$%-6%&'01"*#
)-'%$#',%#&1.$*%#'1#$%-6%&'#1"#',%0$#%a7%$0%"&%#1-#',%#5%',18*#.*%8#8.$0":#',%#
518.6%C#`%#-0")66(#80*&.**#',%#*'$%":',*+#6050')'01"*+#)"8#1771$'."0'0%*#1-#1.$#
)77$1)&,#0"#',0*#&1"'%a'#'1#%"60:,'%"#-.'.$%#$%*%)$&,#)"8#7$)&'0&%#0"0'0)'09%*C#
!"#$%&'(Y#%a%$'01"#:)5%*+#%a7%$0%"'0)6#8%*0:"#6)"8*&)7%*+#%a7%$0%"'0)6#
7$12%*+#%a%$'01"#%a7%$0%"&%C#
!
!
!
!
!
!
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
p!! ;#22&+G#-:%-,!/D'8#2)!q)<5)!#51!r!&A0/%3)!/G(51i*=5G1-!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E777!
>1*(2?=+*)21!
UP&2'%#-!,/0&+?!'8&!:%,%'/3!,/0&+!'8/'!2&QD%2&!G8(+%$/3!G&21#20/-$&?!
8/5&!N&&-!+&&-!+D$$&++1D33(!+#0&'%0&+!%-!G2#5%:%-,!%-:%5%:D/3+!L%'8!
+D11%$%&-'!G8(+%$/3!/$'%5%'%&+!'#!/%:!8&/3'8A2&3/'&:!%++D&+?!+D$8!/+!L&%,8'!3#++!
J*D--%-,?!677cK?!2&8/N%3%'/'%#-+!J;/0&%2á#?!>/:%/?!b33&2?!]!n&2+$8D2&?!67E7K?!
1/33!G2&5&-'%#-+!JO&--&(!]!W&&?!67E7K?!&P&2$%+&!G2#0#'%#-+JOI!iO3#(:j!
.D&33&2?!n&'&2&?!`%NN+?!9,/0/-#3%+?!]!"8&2%:/-?!67E7^!OI!.D&33&2?!`%NN+?!]!
n&'&2&?!67E7K?!/-:!/-'%A+&:&-'/2(!N&8/5%#D2!J`/#!]!./-:2(M?!67EE^!
./-:2(M?!`&23%-,?!]!"'/-3&(?!67EYK?!&'$I!!
<2&5%#D+!'8&#2&'%$/3!+'D:%&+!8/5&!+DGG#2'&:!'8&!:&+%,-!#1!&P&2'%#-!
,/0&+!12#0!0/-(!G&2+G&$'%5&+I!"%-$3/%2!&'!/3I!J677XK!G2#G#+&:!/!:D/3!13#L!
0#:&3!'#!N/3/-$&!'L#!%0G#2'/-'!1/$'#2+!%-!'&20+!#1!/''2/$'%5&-&++!/-:!
&11&$'%5&-&++!L8&-!:&+%,-%-,!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+I!`&23%-,!&'!/3I!J67E7K!G/%2&:!
'8&!$2%'&2%/!#1!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!L%'8!/,&A2&3/'&:!G+($8#AG8(+%#3#,%$/3!
2&QD%2&0&-'+!'#!%:&-'%1(!'8&!:&+%,-!,D%:&3%-&+!+G&$%1%$!'/2,&'%-,!1#2!&3:&23(!
G&#G3&I!`/#!/-:!./-:2(M!J67EEK!/:#G'&:!'8&!'8&#2(!#1!$/+D/3!,/0&!'#!
:&5&3#G!$/+D/3!&P&2'%#-+!'8/'!%-$2&/+&!'8&!/$$&++%N%3%'(!'#!G2#5%:&!3#LA
%-'&-+%'(!&P&2$%+&!%-!/!+8#2'!G&2%#:I!"%0%3/23(?!./-:2(M!&'!/3I!J67EYK!
&+'/N3%+8&:!/!+&2%&+!#1!:&+%,-!,D%:&3%-&+!'/M%-,!'8&!0#'%5/'%#-/3!
G&2+G&$'%5&+!%-'#!/$$#D-'!'#!&-$#D2/,&!G&#G3&!'#!:#!3%,8'!&P&2$%+&!
2&G&/'&:3(!%-!'8&!:/%3(!3%1&!'#!$#0N/'!+&:&-'/2(!N&8/5%#D2I!>/+&:!#-!'8&!
/GG2&$%/'%#-!#1!'8&!1D-:/0&-'/3!2#3&!'8/'!N#:(!%-!%-'&2/$'%#-?!.D33&2!&'!/3I!
J67EEK!8/5&!%:&-'%1%&:!'8&!UP&2'%#-!O2/0&L#2M?!L8%$8!G2#5%:&+!1#D2!3&-+&+!
#1!N#:(A2&3/'&:!+$8&0/!'8/'!:&+%,-&2+!$/-!D+&!L8&-!:&+%,-%-,!&P&2'%#-!
,/0&+I!*D&!'#!'8&%2!/N+'2/$'!-/'D2&?!8#L&5&2?!%'!%+!+'%33!5&2(!8/2:!'#!,&-&2/'&!
&PG3%$%'!+'2/'&,%&+!'#!+DGG#2'!:&+%,-&2+h!$2&/'%5&!G2#$&++!L8&-!:&+%,-%-,!
&P&2'%#-+!1#2!'8&!+G&$%1%$!$#-'&P'!JOI!OI!.D&33&2?!`%NN+?!n&'&2&?!]!U:,&?!
67EYKI!!
4-!1/$'?!'8&2&!8/+!N&&-!3#-,!2D-!'#!$3#+&!'8&!,/G!N&'L&&-!'8&#2&'%$/3!
12/0&L#2M+!/-:!G2/$'%$/3!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!%-!'8&!T;4!/-:!:&+%,-!$#00D-%'%&+I!
\8%3&!&P%+'%-,!&P/0G3&+!'2%&:!'#!N2%:,&!+D$8!$#--&$'%#-+!N(!:&5&3#G%-,!$/2:!
+&'+!1#2!%:&/'%#-!D+&!JOI!OI!.D&33&2!&'!/3I?!67EYK?!N(!%-5#35%-,!&-:AD+&2+!%-!'8&!
:&+%,-!G2#$&++J\/33:%D+?!67EZK?!/-:!N(!/:#G'%-,!O3#L!UPG&2%&-$&!J.%25%+?!
EBBEK!%-'#!'8&!:&+%,-!1#2!+&2%#D+!&P&2'%#-+!J92-/N?!<&2''D3/?!]!"D#0%-&-?!
67EYK?!L&!/GG2#/$8!'8%+!$#-'&P'!N/+&:!#-!UPG&2%&-'%/3!*&+%,-!W/-:+$/G&+!
JU*W+K?!L8%$8!L/+!1%2+'!%-'2#:D$&:!N(!`&-'!&'!/3I!J67EEK!/-:!/%0&:!/'!
#11&2%-,!:&+%,-&2+!/!0&/-+!'#!%-'2#:D$&?!'/%3#2?!/-:!/:/G'!'8&%2!-#5&3!:&+%,-?!
UPG&2%&-'%/3!<2#N&+!JU<+K!J<&&'&2+?!.&,&-+?!TD00&3+?!]!>2#0N/$8&2?!
67EeK?!'#!G&#G3&!/-:!%-!2&'D2-!'#!+DGG#2'!'8&%2!:&+%,-!G2#$&++I!!!!!!!!!!!!
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E77E!
[8%+!G/G&2!&PG3#2&+!8#L!'#!/:/G'!U*W+!%-!:&+%,-%-,!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!'#!
+DGG#2'!:&+%,-&2+!'#!#G&-!DG!'8&!:&+%,-!+G/$&!L%'8!/-:!1#2!G&#G3&!%-!
+G&$%1%$!$#-'&P'+I!O#2!'8%+!GD2G#+&?!L&!#2,/-%S&:!/-!cA:/(!G2#,2&++%5&!
:&+%,-!0#:D3&!N/+&:!#-!'8&!0#:&3!#1!U*W+!L%'8!X!,2#DG+!#1!+'D:&-'+I![8&!
+'D:&-'+!L&2&!&-,/,&:!%-!'8&!'/+M!#1!:&+%,-%-,!&0N#:%&:!%-'&2/$'%#-!%-!'8&!
L#2M%-,!&-5%2#-0&-'!'#!+'%0D3/'&!/$'%5&!3%1&+'(3&+!#1!#11%$&!L#2M&2+I!>(!
/-/3(+%-,!'8&!:/'/!%-!'&20+!#1!'8&%2!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!/-:!:&+%,-!2&+D3'+!L%'8!
UP&2'%#-!O2/0&L#2M!JOI!OI!.D&33&2!&'!/3I?!67EEK?!L&!&P/0%-&:!8#L!#D2!
0&'8#:+!+DGG#2'&:!'8&!:&5&3#G0&-'!#1!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&I!W/+'3(!L&!
/+M&:!1#2!+&31A2&13&$'%#-+!12#0!/33!'8&!+'D:&-'+!#-!'8&%2!&PG&2%&-$&!#1!D+%-,!
'8&!0&'8#:+!:D2%-,!'8&!0#:D3&I!\%'8!'8%+!/GG2#/$8?!L&!/%0!'#!%:&-'%1(!'8&!
#GG#2'D-%'%&+!#1!U*W+!%-!2&3&5/-'!2&+&/2$8&+!/-:!G2/$'%$&+I!
./<5()51*),-!758)91!S,1?8+,<58!!
[8&!'&20!#1!U*W+!L/+!:&1%-&:!N(!`&-'!&'!/3I!J67EEK!/+!/!:&+%,-!'##3!'#!
%-1#20!0/2M&'!2&+&/2$8!#1!:%+2DG'%5&!%-'&33%,&-'!+(+'&0+I!U*W+!0&'8#:!%+!/!
:&+%,-!2&+&/2$8!0&'8#:!/%0&:!/'!:&+%,-%-,!1#2!/-:!L%'8!G&#G3&!%-!'8&%2!
-/'D2/3!&-5%2#-0&-'+!'#!1%-:!L/(+!'#!+'2D$'D2/33(!$8/-,&!G&#G3&h+!N&8/5%#D2!
J<&&'&2+!]!.&,&-+?!67EYKI!9+!%+!+8#L-!%-!O%,D2&!E?!U*W+!0&'8#:!%+!N/+&:!#-!
Y!G2#,2&++%5&!+'&G+?!2&5#35%-,)!
•!.1C)8)21)19E!*&+%,-&2+!JL%'8!#'8&2+K!&-5%+%#-!/-:!&PG3#2&!/-!
D-1/0%3%/2!$#-'&P'!/-:!$#0&!DG!L%'8!-&L!5%+%#-+!#1!:&+%,-I!!
•!758)91)19!)1*5(C51*)218E!*&+%,-&2+!+'/2'!'#!1%-:!:&+%-,&23(!L/(+!'#!
$2&/'&!'8&%2!G2#G#+%'%#-+!'8/'!$#D3:!+DGG#2'!'#!+'%0D3/'&!-&L!
N&8/5%#D2!$8/-,&!%-!'8&!+G&$%1%$!$#-'&P'I![8&!G2#G#+%'%#-+!L%33!
'8&2&1#2&!/$'!/+!G2#N&+?!0#2&!G2&$%+&3(!U<+?!1#2!'8&!:&+%,-!2&+&/2$8!
'&/0!'#!+'D:(!'8&!#D'$#0&+!#1!'8&%2!:&+%,-!%-'&25&-'%#-+I!
•!$+\=)()19!?,*,E!*&+%,-&2+!$#33&$'!:/'/!%-!U*W+!N(!:&G3#(%-,!U<+!'#!
2&$#2:!N&8/5%#D2!/-:!$#-'&P'I![8&!/$QD%2&:!:/'/!&-/N3&+!:&+%,-&2+!
'#!:%,!%-!G&#G3&h+!$#-+$%#D+!#2!D-$#-+$%#D+!:&$%+%#-?!N&8/5%#D2+!/-:!
0#'%5/'%#-+I!!!
•!$1,-D8)19!^!C,-)?,*)19E!*&+%,-&2+!D+&!'8&!'&$8-%QD&+!#1!:/'/!
/-/3(+%+?!+D$8!/+!:/'/!0%-%-,!/-:!G2#$&++!0%-%-,?!'#!:%+$#5&2!:/'/!
G/''&2-+!/-:!&P'2/$'!0&/-%-,!12#0!'8&0I!!!!!!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E776!
#
D0:.$%#@# U,%#<IL*#5%',18C#U,%#&%"'$)6#6117#0*#',%#0"'%$)&'01"#2%'3%%"#7%176%#)"8#
<V*M#',%#1.'%$#0*#',%#8%*0:"#7$1&%**#6117#1-#%"90*01"0":+#8%*0:"#0"'%$9%"'01"+#)&/.0$0":#
8)')+#)"8#)")6(*0":#K9)608)'0":C#Z8)7'%8#-$15#
,''7Yrr333C%a7%$0%"'0)68%*0:"6)"8*&)7%*C&15#
4-!'8&!:&+%,-!G2#$&++?!'8&!:&+%,-!2&+&/2$8&2+!+&/2$8!/-:!&PG3#2&!
#GG#2'D-%'%&+!'#,&'8&2!L%'8!'8&!G&#G3&!D+%-,!'8&!U<+!%-!/!+8#2'!3##G!#1!
/-/3(+%+!/-:!:&+%,-!+(-'8&+%+I!U<+!/$'!/+!+0/2'!+&-+#2!/,&-'+!/-:!$/-!N&!
+&&-!/+!G2#N&+!/+!'8&(!D+&!%-!'8&%2!%-'&33%,&-$&!'#!,/'8&2!:/'/!#1!'8&%2!D+&!
/-:!#-!'8&!N&8/5%#D2!#1!G&#G3&!%-!'8&!U*W+!J<&&'&2+!&'!/3I?!67EeKI![8%+!L/(!
#1!G2#N%-,!/33#L+!'8&!:&+%,-!2&+&/2$8&2+!'#!,/%-!1%2+'!G&2+#-!G&2+G&$'%5&!/-:!
D-:&2+'/-:%-,!#1!'8&!G&#G3&!%-!'8&!U*W+!J.&,&-+?!<&&'&2+?!TD00&3+?!]!
>2#0N/$8&2?!67EeKI!>(!%-$#2G#2/'%#-!L%'8!#N+&25%-,?!%-'&25%&L%-,?!/-:!
QD&+'%#-%-,?!:&+%,-&2+!$/-!/$QD%2&!2%$8!%-1#20/'%#-!'#!1%-:!0#2&!'#!2&/+#-!
'8&!N&8/5%#D2!G/''&2-!/-:!%-!2&'D2-!0#:%1(!'8&%2!:&+%,-!G2#G#+%'%#-+!%-!-&P'!
%'&2/'%#-I!
\8%3&!G2&5%#D+3(!U*W+!8/5&!N&&-!%-5#35&:!%-!:&+%,-!2&+&/2$8&+!/+!'##3+!
'#!%-1#20!0/2M&'!%--#5/'%#-!J`&-'?!.&,&-+?!<&&'&2+?!TD00&3+?!]!WD?!
67EENK?!/+!/!L/(!'#!+DGG#2'!+#$%/3!'2/-+1#20/'%#-!%-!'8&!8&/3'8A2&3/'&:!
'#G%$+!J.&,&-+!&'!/3I?!67EeK?!/+!/!0&'8#:!'#!G2#N&!&0&2,&-'!N&8/5%#D2!
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E77e!
J<&&'&2+!&'!/3I?!67EeK?!L&!/$$&++!U*W+!/+!/!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!'#!+DGG#2'!'8&!
:&5&3#G0&-'!#1!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!1#2!G/2'%$D3/2!$#-'&P'+I!O#2!'8%+!GD2G#+&?!
'82&&!%0G#2'/-'!1&/'D2&+!#1!U*W+!$/-!N&!#N+&25&:)!O%2+'?!%'!G2#5%:&+!/!2&/3!
3%1&!&-5%2#-0&-'!1#2!D-:&2+'/-:%-,!G&#G3&h+!N&8/5%#D2?!%-!'D2-!:&+%,-&2+!
$/-!2&13&$'!#-!'8&!%-1#20/'%#-!'#!$2&/'&?!0#:%1(!#2!&P'&-:!'8&%2!:&+%,-!
$#-$&G'I!"&$#-:?!%'!2&QD%2&+!ND%3:%-,!%-'&2/$'%5&!G2#'#'(G&!:D2%-,!'8&!&/23(!
G8/+&!#1!:&+%,-!G2#$&++?!'8D+!:&+%,-&2+!$/-!QD%$M3(!'2/-+1#20!'8&%2!
M-#L3&:,&!'#!'8&!%0G3&0&-'/'%#-+I![8%2:?!2/'8&2!'8/-!/!1%-%+8&:!+#3D'%#-?!
U<+!/2&!:&+%,-&:!/+!/!2&+&/2$8!'##3!'#!+'%0D3/'&!:&+%,-&2+!'#!$2&/'&!1D'D2&!
%-%'%/'%5&+?!'8D+!:&+%,-&2+!$/-!D'%3%S&!'8&!%-+%,8'+!'8&(!,/%-&:!12#0!U*W+!'#!
:&5&3#G!-&L!+(+'&0+I!4-!'8&!2&0/%-%-,?!L&!%-5&+'%,/'&!8#L!'8&+&!1&/'D2&+!
#1!U*W+!L#2M!L8&-!:&+%,-%-,!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+I!
:5*42?8!
[#!&P/0%-&!1D2'8&2!#-!8#L!U*W+!L#2M!%-!:&5&3#G%-,!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+?!L&!
:&$%:&:!'#!+&'DG!/-!%-'&2/$'%#-!:&+%,-!0#:D3&!L%'8!#D2!+'D:&-'+I![8&!
GD2G#+&!#1!'8%+!+'D:(!L/+!'#!&5/3D/'&!'8&!D'%3%'(!/-:!'#!%:&-'%1(!'8&!5/3D&!#1!
U*W+!%-!:&+%,-&2+h!G2/$'%$&I!\&!G2&+&-'!#D2!0&'8#:+!%-!:&'/%3+!%-!'8&!
2&0/%-%-,!G/2'+!#1!'8%+!+&$'%#-I!!
U,%#518.6%#
\&!$#-:D$'&:!/-!cA:/(!0#:D3&!L%'8!X!,2#DG+!#1!+'D:&-'+!/-:!&/$8!
,2#DG!8/+!Z!+'D:&-'+!2&+G&$'%5&3(I!9+!G/2'!#1!'8&!a#%-'!+D00&2!+$8##3!
N&'L&&-!U%-:8#5&-!@-%5&2+%'(!#1![&$8-#3#,(!J[@g&K!/-:!_8&a%/-,!@-%5&2+%'(!
J_C@K?!'8%+!$#D2+&!L/+!$/22%&:!#D'!%-!'8&!4-'&2-/'%#-/3!*&+%,-!4-+'%'D'&!#1!_C@!
%-!;8%-/I!b-!'8&!1%2+'!:/(?!L&!N&,/-!N(!%-'2#:D$%-,!'8&!'&20!#1!U*W+?!U<+?!
/-:!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!L%'8!+#0&!5%:&#!&P/0G3&+I!\&!'8&-!+8#L&:!'8&!
12/0&L#2M!L&!G2#G#+&:!/-:!&PG3/%-&:!8#L!%'!$#D3:!L#2M!#D'!%-!'8&!:&+%,-!
G2#$&++I!W/+'3(?!L&!/++%,-&:!'8&0!'8&!:&+%,-!$8/33&-,&!%-!'8%+!$#D2+&I![8&!
,#/3!#1!'8%+!0#:D3&!L/+!1#2!&/$8!,2#DG!'#!,#!'82#D,8!/'!3&/+'!'L#!%'&2/'%#-+!
N/+&:!#-!U*W+!/-:!'#!$#0&!DG!L%'8!/!L#2M/N3&!G2#'#'(G&!'#!:&0#-+'2/'&!
'8&%2!:&+%,-!#1!'8&!&P&2'%#-!,/0&I!4-!'8&!$#D2+&?!L&!/++%,-&:!'8&0!/!
$#33&$'%5&!:&+%,-!'/+M!1#2!&5&2(!,2#DG!'#!/+M!'8&0!'#!:&+%,-!&0N#:%&:!
%-'&2/$'%#-!1#2!#11%$&!L#2M&2+!%-!'8&%2!:/%3(!2#D'%-&!'#!+DGG#2'!/$'%5&!
3%1&+'(3&+I!\&!8&3:!G2#,2&++!0&&'%-,!#-!'8&!+&$#-:!:/(?!'8%2:!:/(?!1#D2'8!
:/(?!+%P'8!:/(?!/-:!&%,8'8!:/(!/-:!/+M&:!'8&0!'#!,%5&!D+!G%'$8!#-!'8&!1%2+'!
$#-$&G'+?!'8&!1%2+'!U<+!/-:!2&+D3'+?!-&L!:&+%,-!G2#G#+%'%#-+?!-&L!1%-:%-,+?!
/-:!1%-/3!:&+%,-!2&+G&$'%5&3(I!!!!!!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E77Y!
V)$'0&07)"'*#
X!+'D:&-'+!12#0!'8&!*&G/2'0&-'!#1!4-:D+'2%/3!*&+%,-!/'![@g&!/-:!6c!
+'D:&-'+!12#0!_C@!L&2&!a#%-&:!%-!'8%+!0#:D3&I![8&!G/2'%$%G/-'+!12#0![@g&!
L&2&!%-:D+'2%/3!:&+%,-!N/$8&3#2!+'D:&-'+!%-!'8&%2!+&$#-:!(&/2!Je!(&/2!%-!
'#'/3K?!L8%3&!G/2'%$%G/-'+!12#0!_C@!L&2&!N/$8&3#2!+'D:&-'+!%-!'8&%2!'8%2:!(&/2!
JY!(&/2!%-!'#'/3KI![#!N&!-#'&:?!/33!'8&!+'D:&-'+!12#0!_C@!L&2&!%-:D+'2%/3!
:&+%,-!0%-#2!+'D:&-'+!/-:!2&$&%5&:!:&+%,-!&:D$/'%#-!1#2!'L#!(&/2+!/-:!/!
8/31I![8&(!L&2&!#2%,%-/33(!12#0!:%11&2&-'!N/$8&3#2!+$8##3+!2/-,&:!12#0!
&3&$'2%$/3!&-,%-&&2%-,?!$#0GD'&2!+$%&-$&?!0&$8/-%$/3!&-,%-&&2%-,?!
/2$8%'&$'D2&!/:5&2'%+&0&-'?!/2'!:&+%,-?!ND+%-&++!0/-/,&0&-'?!/-:!U-,3%+8!
+'D:(I![#!0#:&2/'&!'8&!N%/+!#1!%0N/3/-$&!N&'L&&-!,2#DG+?!L&!'&/0&:!DG!E!
+'D:&-'!12#0![@g&!L%'8!Y!+'D:&-'+!12#0!_C@!/+!#-&!,2#DGI!U/$8!,2#DG!/3+#!
8/:!+'D:&-'+!12#0!:%11&2&-'!:%+$%G3%-&+!'#!&-+D2&!'8&!N/3/-$&:!
$#0G&'&-$%&+I!
U,%#'116#
[#!1/$%3%'/'&!'8&%2!&PG3#2/'%#-+?!L&!G2&G/2&:!#G&-A+#D2$&!&3&$'2#-%$+!
+D$8!/+!92:D%-#!/-:!=/+GN&22(!<%?!&P&2'%#-!,/0&!G3/'1#20+!+D$8!/+!V%-&$'!
/-:!f%-'&-:#!\%%?!-&$&++/2(!+&-+#2+!+D$8!/+!O#2$&!"&-+%-,!=&+%+'#2!/-:!<%P(!
$/0&2/?!#'8&2!:/'/A$#33&$'%#-!:&5%$&+!+D$8!/+!`#<2#!/-:!0#N%3&!G8#-&?!/-:!
2&+G#-:%-,!G8(+%$/3!0/'&2%/3+!J$/2:N#/2:?!G/G&2?!1#/0?!/3D0%-%D0!1#%3?!&'$IKI!
\&!/3+#!,/5&!%-:%5%:D/3!'D'#2%/3!1#2!&5&2(!,2#DG!&5&2(!:/(!2&,/2:%-,!
G2#'#'(G%-,!/-:!w]9!#1!D+%-,!#D2!12/0&L#2M!%-!'8&%2!:&+%,-!G2#$&++I!
I)')#&166%&'01"#
9+!+8#L-!%-![/N3&!E?!L&!$/G'D2&:!5%:&#!/-:!$#33&$'&:!'8&%2!+3%:&+!1#2!
&5&2(!$#/$8!0&&'%-,!'#!2&$#2:!'8&%2!G2#,2&++I!OD2'8&20#2&?!'8&(!:&3%5&2&:!
'8&!1%3&!#1!'8&%2!1%-/3!G2&+&-'/'%#-+?!'8&%2!1%-/3!:&0#-+'2/'#2?!/-:!'8&%2!
:&0#+!#1!&5&2(!+'&G!'#!D+I!\&!L&2&!/3+#!%-'&2&+'&:!%-!8#L!'8&(!&PG&2%&-$&:!
'8&!0&'8#:+!L&!%-'2#:D$&:!:D2%-,!'8&!0#:D3&I![8&2&1#2&?!L&!/+M&:!&5&2(!
+'D:&-'!'#!L2%'&!/!EAG/,&!2&G#2'!'#!2&13&$'!#-!#L-!&PG&2%&-$&!#-!a#%-%-,!'8%+!
$3/++I!
U)26%@##U,%#*1.$&%#)"8#'(7%*#1-#8)')#',)'#3%#&166%&'%8#-$15#',%#&1.$*%C##
7,*,!82=(+5!
*&+%,-!<2#$&++!
*&+%,-!=&+D3'+!
=&13&$'%#-+!
7,*,!*D<5!
n%:&#?!+3%:&+?!
-#'&+I!
*&0#?!+3%:&+?!
G8#'#+I!
"&31A2&13&$'%#-!
2&G#2'+!
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E77Z!
I)')#Z")6(*0*#
\&!/-/3(+&:!/-:!:%+$D++&:!'8&!:/'/!,D%:&:!N(!UP&2'%#-!O2/0&L#2M!JUOK!
JOI!OI!.D&33&2!&'!/3I?!67EEK?!'8&!1D-:/0&-'/3!'8&#2(!%-!'8%+!1%&3:!'#!&-$#D2/,&!
/!8#3%+'%$!5%&L!#-!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&I![8&2&!8/5&!1#D2!N#:(A2&3/'&:!3&-+&+!
/$$#00#:/'&:!%-!UO!'#!:&0#-+'2/'&!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&?!%-$3D:%-,)!
•!#58<21?)19!W2?D!8%,83%,8'+!8#L!N#:(h+!%-'&2-/3!+'/'&!$8/-,&!#5&2!
'%0&+!N&$/D+&!#1!&P&2'%#-+I!O#2!&P/0G3&?!/!$&2'/%-!'%0&!#1!'8&!$/2:%#!
'2/%-%-,!$#D3:!$/D+&!/!2%+&!%-!8&/2'!2/'&!/-:!#$$D22&-$&!#1!+L&/'I!
•!:2C)19!W2?D!8%,83%,8'+!8#L!'#!'2%,,&2!G&#G3&h+!M%-/&+'8&'%$!+&-+&!%-!
#2:&2!'#!/33#L!'8&!N#:(h+!0#5&0&-'!%-'D%'%5&3(I![8&!&P/0G3&!$#D3:!
N&!'8&!&PG&2%&-$&:!G&#G3&!%-!'/N3&!'&--%+!L#D3:!8%'!&5&2(!N/33!L%'8!
+G&$%1%$!0#5&0&-'!12#0!'8&%2!%-'D%'%#-I!!!!
•!;518)19!W2?D!8%,83%,8'+!8#L!'#!G2#5%:&!/!$#-'&P'!1#2!'8&!%-'&2/$'%#-!
N&'L&&-!N#:(!/-:!'8&!L#23:I![/M%-,!'8&!+#$$&2!,/0&!/+!/-!
&P/0G3&?!G&#G3&!L8#!&-,/,&!%-!'8&!,/0&!+8#D3:!/3L/(+!M&&G!%-!
0%-:!'#!%-'&2/$'!L%'8!'8&!N/33I!!
•!#5-,*)19!W2?D!8%,83%,8'+!8#L!'#!2&3/'&!G&#G3&!#-&!'#!/-#'8&2!'#!
1/$%3%'/'&!'8&!+#$%/3!%-'&2/$'%#-!%-!'8&!&P&2$%+&I!"'%33!%-!'8&!$/+&!#1!
+#$$&2?!L8&-&5&2!G3/(&2+!/2&!:#%-,!/!0/'$8!#2!'2/%-%-,?!'8&!
$%2$D0+'/-$&!1#2!+#$%/3!%-'&2/$'%#-!'8&-!8/5&!N&&-!$2&/'&:I!!!
UO!G2#5%:&+!/!2&3%/N3&!+'2D$'D2&!1#2!&P&2'%#-!:&+%,-&2+!'#!)?5,*5!#-!'8&!
$#-$&G'?!'#!5-,W2(,*5!'8&!'&$8-#3#,(!:&+%,-?!/-:!'#!5/*51?!'8&%2!L#2M+!1#2!
1D2'8&2!:&+%,-!JOI!OI!.D&33&2!&'!/3I?!67EEKI![8&2&1#2&?!L&!/-/3(+&:!'8&!
G2#$&++!/-:!2&+D3'+!#1!+'D:&-'+h!:&+%,-!%-'#!'8&!/1#2&0&-'%#-&:!'82&&!G/2'+?!
D+%-,!'8&!12/0&L#2M!#1!UO!'#!&P/0%-&!8#L!U*W+!0&'8#:!L&!D+&:!%-!#D2!
$#D2+&!+DGG#2'&:!'8&!:&+%,-!2&,/2:%-,!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&I!\&!/3+#!
#2,/-%S&:!+'D:&-'+h!2&13&$'%#-+!%-'#!'8&!+'2D$'D2&!#1!)?5,*)21?!5-,W2(,*)21?!
/-:!5/*518)21!'#!&5/3D/'&!#-!L8/'!2#3&!#D2!/GG2#/$8!$#D3:!/$'!'#!+DGG#2'!
'8&!:&+%,-!1#2!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&!%-!+G&$%1%$!$#-'&P'+I!
#58=-*8!,1?!)1)*),-!,1,-D8)8!
\&!1%2+'!G2&+&-'!1#D2!$/+&+!#1!#D2!+'D:&-'+h!L#2M+!%-!'8%+!0#:D3&!%-!#2:&2!
'#!+8#L!8#L!U*W+!L#2M&:!%-!G2/$'%$&I!\&!'8&-!+D00/2%S&!/!1&L!M&(!G#%-'+!
12#0!+'D:&-'+h!2&G#2'+!'#!+D,,&+'!'8&!+'2&-,'8+!/-:!3%0%'/'%#-+!#1!#D2!L#2MI!
f&P'?!L&!&3/N#2/'&!#-!#D2!1%-:%-,+!%-!:&'/%3+I!!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E77F!
I%*0:"#&)*%*#
T&2&!L&!+8#L!'8&!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!/-:!2&+D3'+!#1!Y!:&+%,-!$/+&+!12#0!Y!
2&G2&+&-'/'%5&!,2#DG+!%-!'8%+!+'D:(!'#!:&+$2%N&!8#L!U*W+!/$'D/'&:!+'D:&-'+h!
L#2M!%-!'8%+!$#D2+&I!\&!+'/2'&:!'8&!/-/3(+%+!N(!2&/:%-,!'8&!+3%:&+!/-:!
L/'$8%-,!'8&!2&$#2:&:!5%:&#I!O#2!&/$8!,2#DG?!L&!$#:&:!#D2!1%-:%-,+!%-'#!
'82&&!$/'&,#2%&+!/$$#2:%-,!'#!'8&!+'2D$'D2&!#1!>?5,*)21?!.-,W2(,*)21?!/-:!
./*518)21d#5C)8)21I!933!'8&+&!Y!,2#DG+!2&G#2'&:!'8/'!'8&(!8/5&!$/22%&:!#D'!e!
%'&2/'%#-+!/-:!&P'&-:&:g2&5%+&:!'8&%2!:&+%,-!'L%$&!%-!'8%+!$#D2+&I![8&2&1#2&?!
L&!/::!#-&!$/'&,#2(!#1!@)1,-)H,*)21!'#!:&+$2%N&!'8&%2!3/+'!&P'&-+%#-g2&5%+%#-I!
4-!'8&!:&+$2%G'%#-!#1!&/$8!$/+&?!L&!8%,83%,8'&:!'8&!'&P'!'8/'!+8#L&:!
+'D:&-'+h!$#-+%:&2/'%#-+!#-!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&I![8&!$/+&!+D00/2(!L/+!
,%5&-!%-!'8&!&-:!1#33#L&:!&/$8!$/+&!:&+$2%G'%#-I!
%,85!JE!`2?D!;B5*+4)19!
•!>?5,*)21E![8&(!1#D-:!0/-(!;8%-&+&!'2/:%'%#-/3!&P&2$%+&+!/2&!
+(0N#3%S&:!/+!'8&!+D+'/%-/N3&!/$'%5%'%&+!'#!$8/-,&!#D2!N#:%&+!%-!/!
0#:&2/'&!L/(?!+D$8!/+![/%!;8%I![8&(!N&3%&5&:!'8/'!'8&!G8%3#+#G8(!#1!
[/%!;8%!$/'&2!1#2!'8&!$#-'&P'!#1!#11%$&!+&''%-,+I![8&%2!0/%-!%:&/!L/+!
'#!=85!-2AN)1*518)*D!,+*)C)*)58!*2!9(,?=,--D!+4,195!4=0,1X8!W2?D!
8*,*=8I!!
•!.-,W2(,*)21E!O2#0!'8%+!GD2G#+&?!'8&(!+'/2'&:!'8&!&PG3#2/'%#-!#1!8#L!
'#!$#22&3/'&!'8&!L/(!#1!:#%-,![/%!;8%!L%'8!L#2M%-,!&PG&2%&-$&+!+#!
'8/'!'#!$2&/'&!/-!/$'%5&!L#2M%-,!&-5%2#-0&-'I!"45D!=*)-)H5?!&)15+*!
*2!?5C5-2<!*45!<(2*2*D<5!*2!85185!W2?D!02C5051*?!L8%$8!&-/N3&+!
G&#G3&!'#!0/-%GD3/'&!e*!0#:&33%-,!+#1'L/2&!N(!:%11&2&-'!N#:(!
,&+'D2&+I!
•!./*518)21d#5C)8)21E!O2#0!'8&!1%2+'!G2#N%-,?!'8&(!1#D-:!'8/'!'8&!
,&+'D2&!G2#'#$#3+!L&2&!'##!$#0G3%$/'&:!1#2!D+&2!'#!%-'D%'%5&3(!0#5&!
'8&%2!N#:(?!,%5&-!e*!0#:&33%-,!%+!-#'!/!+%0G3&!'/+M+I![8&2&1#2&?!'8&(!
/::&:!'8&%2!1#$D+!#-!42A!*2!<(2C)?5!8)0<-5!*,8B!32(!<52<-5!*2!
02C5!*45)(!W2?D!)1*=)*)C5-DI![8&(!%0G3&0&-'&:!1D33AN#:(!%-'&2/$'%#-!
%-'#!+M&'$8%-,?!%-!L8%$8!G&#G3&!#-3(!-&&:!'#!:#!+#0&!+%0G3&!N#:(!
0#5&0&-'+!'#!$2&/'&!,&#0&'2%$!,2/G8!J&I,I!$%2$3&?!2&$'/-,D3/2?!3%-&?!
/-:!'2%/-,D3/2!&'$IK!#-!'8&!+$2&&-!1#2!N2/%-+'#20%-,!D+&I!
•!@)1,-)H,*)21E!4-!'8&!+&$#-:!'&+'%-,?!'8&(!-#'%$&:!G&#G3&!G2&1&22&:!'#!
$#-'/$'!L%'8!'8&!+(+'&0!'#,&'8&2!%-!'8&!GDN3%$!+G/$&I![8D+!'8&(!
1%-/3%S&:!'8&%2!:&+%,-!'#!%-$3D:&!*45!+218)?5(,*)218!23!82+),-!
)1*5(,+*)21!N(!/33#L%-,!G&#G3&!'#!$2&/'&!+#0&!+G&$%/3!,&#0&'2%$!
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E77X!
,2/G8!'#,&'8&2!%-!'8&!+(+'&0!:D2%-,!'8&!0&&'%-,!'%0&I!<3&/+&!1%-:!
'8&!:&0#!1#2!1%-/3!:&+%,-!5%/)!8''G+)gg5%0&#I$#0gEFeBcZBc6!
U)26%#>##U,%#*.55)$(#1-#',%#&)*%#H18(#E4%'&,0":C##
>?5,*)21!
.-,W2(,*)21!
./*518)21!
@)1,-)H,*)21!
!
!
#58<21?)19!
`2?D)!%-+G%2&:!
N(!'8&![/%!;8%!
12#0!3#$/3!
$#-'&P'!'#!
G2#5%:&!3#LA
%-'&-+%'(!+G#2'!
'#!$8/-,&!N#:(!
+'/'D+I!
!
!
;518)19!`2?D)!
>(!%-'&,2/'%-,!
V%-&$'!%-'#!'8&!
+(+'&0?!<&#G3&!
$/-!0/-%GD3/'&!
e*!0#:&33%-,!
+#1'L/2&!N(!
'8&%2!N#:(!
,&+'D2&+I!
!
!
:2C)19!`2?DE!
G2#5%:&!+%0G3&!
'/+M+!J:2/L!
+%0G3&!
,&#0&'2%$!
,2/G8K!1#2!
G&#G3&!'#!0#5&!
'8&%2!N#:%&+!
%-'D%'%5&3(I!
!
!
#5-,*)19!`2?DE!
/33#L!G&#G3&!'#!
$2&/'&!+#0&!
+G&$%/3!
,&#0&'2%$!
,2/G8!'#,&'8&2!
%-!'8&!+(+'&0!
:D2%-,!'8&%2!
0&&'%-,!'%0&I!
!
%,85!'E!.15(9D!#5-5,8)19!`2**-5!!
•!>?5,*)21E!"%0%3/2!'#!,2#DG!E?!'8&(!/3+#!G#+%'%#-&:!'8&%2!$#-$&G'!12#0!
'8&!G/2'%$D3/2!1&/'D2&+!%-!'8&!$#-'&P'I![8&(!-#'%$&:!/!8&/3'8(!
N&8/5%#D2!'8/'!;8%-&+&!G&#G3&!3%M&!'#!$/22(!/!L/'&2!N#''3&!'#!&-+D2&!
+D11%$%&-'!L/'&2!%-'/M&!%-!'8&%2!:/%3(!3%1&I![8&(!N&3%&5&:!'8/'!*45!
W2**-5!+2=-?!W5!,1!)?5,-!+,(()5(!*2!85185!?,*,!3(20!W2?D!)1!*45!
+21*5/*!'#!#11&2!/!0#2&!$#0G2&8&-+%5&!8&/3'8!&PG&2%&-$&!1#2!#11%$&!
G&#G3&I!!
•!.-,W2(,*)21E!O2#0!'8%+!GD2G#+&?!'8&(!&0N&::&:!&3&$'2#-%$+!%-!'8&!
L/'&2!N#''3&!'#!&-$#D2/,&!G8(+%$/3!0#5&0&-'!L%'8!'8&!N#''3&I![8&%2!
$#-+%:&2/'%#-+!1&33!%-!42A!*2!)1*5(,+*!A)*4!W2?D!02C5051*8!
+218)8*51*-D)!9'!1%2+'?!'8&!WU*!#-!'8&!N#''3&!$#D3:!2&0%-:!G&#G3&!'#!
:#!&P&2$%+&!N(!1/:%-,!'8&!3%,8'!/L/(I!\8%3&!&P&2$%+%-,?!'8&!$#3#D2!#1!
3%,8'!L#D3:!M&&G!#-!$8/-,%-,!/$$#2:%-,!'#!'8&!%-'&-+%'(!/-:!
:D2/'%#-!#1!D+&2h+!0#5&0&-'I!!
•!./*518)21d#5C)8)21E!O2#0!'8&%2!1%2+'!G2#N%-,?!'8&(!1#D-:!'8%+!
+'2/'&,(!$#D3:!%-$2&/+&!G&#G3&h+!/L/2&-&++!#-!8#L!0D$8!&11#2'!'8&(!
%-5&+'&:!/-:!%-!'D2-!0#'%5/'&!'8&0!'#!:#!0#2&I!O2#0!&/23%&2!+'D:(!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E77c!
JG3&/+&!1%-:!'8&!D+&2!'&+'!:&0#!5%/)!8''G+)gg5%0&#I$#0gEFeBcFFEeK?!
'8&(!/3+#!-#'%$&:!'8&!+#3%'/2(!G3/(!$#D3:!N&!&0N/22/++%-,!1#2!D+&2+!%-!
/!$#33&$'%5&!&-5%2#-0&-'?!/-:!$#D3:!/3+#!N&!:%+'D2N%-,!1#2!#'8&2+I!
[8&2&1#2&?!'8&(!2&5%+&:!'8&%2!:&+%,-!A)*4!*45!+21+5(18!3(20!*45!
82+),-!<5(8<5+*)C5?!L8&2&!'8&(!G2#G#+&:!'#!/:/G'!'8&!+(+'&0!'#!
+#$%/3!0&:%/!'#!1/$%3%'/'&!+#$%/3!&P&2$%+&!/-:!'#!+'%0D3/'&!2&G&/'&:!
G3/(I!
•!@)1,-)H,*)21E![8&(!1%-/3%S&:!'8&%2!L#2M!12#0!'8&!G&2+G&$'%5&!#1!
&2,#-#0%$+I![#!3&/:!G&#G3&!'#!0#5&!'8&%2!N#:(!%-!/!0#2&!-/'D2/3!
L/(?!'8&(!2&:&+%,-&:!'8&!1#20!#1!'8&!N#''3&!'#!0/M&!%'!0#2&!:D2/N3&!
1#2!G3/(%-,I!!
U)26%#d##U,%#*.55)$(#1-#&)*%#<"%$:(#]%6%)*0":#H1''6%C##
./*518)21!
!
!
#5-,*)19!`2?DE!
D+&!+#$%/3!0&:%/!
'#!$2&/'&!+#$%/3!
0&$8/-%+0+!
N&8%-:!'8&!
N#''3&?!+D$8!/+!
$##G&2/'%#-!/-:!
$#0G&'%'%#-I!
%,85!cE!`2=1+)19!@-22(!!
•!>?5,*)21E![8&(!+'/2'&:!'8&%2!%:&/'%#-!L%'8!'8&!QD&+'%#-!#1!42A!*2!
3,+)-)*,*5!W2?DN51C)(21051*!)1*5(,+*)21I!>(!#N+&25%-,?!'8&(!1#D-:!
'8/'!'8&2&!L&2&!#GG#2'D-%'%&+!'#!D'%3%S&!'8&!#11%$&!&-5%2#-0&-'!'#!
2&0/%-!#11%$&!L#2M&2+!G8(+%$/33(!/$'%5&I!!
•!.-,W2(,*)21E![8&(!G2#G#+&:!+&5&2/3!%:&/+!#-!8#L!'#!%0G3&0&-'!
+&-+#2+!%-!'8&!#11%$&!'#!05,8=(5!W2?D!?,*,!,1?!)1!(5*=(1!*2!
8*)0=-,*5!02(5!02C5051*!%-!'8&%2!:/%3(!2#D'%-&+I![8&(!'8&-!$/0&!
DG!L%'8!'8&!$#-$&G'!#1!+0/2'!13##2!+(+'&0!'8/'!0%0%$!3#'D+!3&/1+!%-!
'8&!G#-:I![8&%2!%-%'%/3!G3/-!L/+!'#!+&'!%'!#-!'8&!-&$&++/2(!2#D'&!%-!
'8&!#11%$&!&-5%2#-0&-'?!+D$8!/+!'8&!&-'2/-$&!#1!ND%3:%-,I!!
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E77B!
•!./*518)21d#5C)8)21E!O2#0!'8&!1%2+'!%'&2/'%#-?!'8&(!1#D-:!'8/'!'8&!
$#-$&G'!L/+!'##!:%+2DG'%5&!1#2!G&#G3&!'#!+'&G!#-!'8&!13##2I!
[8&2&1#2&?!'8&(!)1+(5,85?!*45!*4(5842-?!32(!*()995()19!*45!8D8*50I!
4-!'8&%2!-&L!G2#G#+%'%#-?!'8&!%-'&2/$'%#-!$#D3:!#-3(!N&!/$'%5/'&:!
L8&-!G&#G3&!aD0G!#-!'8&!13##2I!!
•!@)1,-)H,*)21E!O2#0!'8&!/-/3(+%+!#1!:/'/?!'8&(!2&/3%S&:!G&#G3&!L&2&!
5&2(!&/+(!'#!,&'!N#2&:!%-!'8&%2!$D22&-'!+(+'&0I!4-!#'8&2!L#2:+?!%'!
$#D3:!-#'!0#'%5/'&!2&G&/'&:!G3/(!L%'8!'8&%2!:&+%,-I!T&-$&!'8&(!
2&1#20D3/'&!/!+&'!#1!,/0&!2D3&+!L%'8!%0G3&0&-'/'%#-+!#1!/!:%+G3/(!
#-!'8&!L/33!'#!51+2=(,95!5/5(+)85!W54,C)2=(!WD!<(2C)?)19!W21=8!,*!
*45!51?!23!*45!9,05I!<3&/+&!1%-:!'8&!:&0#!1#2!1%-/3!:&+%,-!5%/)!
8''G+)gg5%0&#I$#0gEFeBcX6XE!
U)26%#A##U,%#*.55)$(#1-#',%#&)*%#H1."&0":#D611$C##
>?5,*)21!
.-,W2(,*)21!
./*518)21!
@)1,-)H,*)21!
!
!
;518)19!`2?D)!
D+&!'8&!#11%$&!/+!
'8&!+&-+%-,!
$#-'&P'!'#!
G2#5%:&!N#:(!
&-5%2#-0&-'!
%-'&2/$'%#-I!!
!
!
;518)19!`2?D)!
/::!+&-+#2+!%-'#!
'8&!13##2!'#!
%-'&2/$'!L%'8!
G&#G3&!L8&-!
'8&(!+'&G!#-!%'I!
!
!
;518)19!`2?DE!
%-$2&/+&!'8&!
'82&+8#3:!1#2!
'2%,,&2%-,!'8&!
+(+'&0!'#!L8&-!
G&#G3&!aD0G!#-!
'8&!13##2I!!
!
!
>1+51*)C58!
I<5(8=,8)21KE!
G2#5%:&!'8&!
N#-D+!'#!
&-$#D2/,&!'8&!
2&G&/'&:!/-:!
G2#3#-,&:!G3/(I!
%,85!eE!$+*)C5!;*,*)21!!
•!>?5,*)21E!@-3%M&!'8&!#'8&2!,2#DG+!1#$D+%-,!#-!'8&!#11%$&!
+D22#D-:%-,+?!'8&(!3##M&:!DG!:/%3(!3%1&!2#D'%-&+I![8&(!:&5&3#G&:!
'8&%2!$#-$&G'!N/+&:!#-!'8&!$#-'&P'!#1!0&'2#!+'/'%#-I![8&(!1#D-:!
'8/'!G&#G3&!+G&-:!/!$&2'/%-!/0#D-'!#1!'%0&!%-!'8&!0&'2#!+'/'%#-!
&5&2(:/(!/-:!0#+'!#1!'8&0!L&2&!G8(+%$/33(!/-:!+#$%/33(!%-/$'%5&!
:D2%-,!'8%+!G&2%#:I![8&2&1#2&?!'8&(!G2#G#+&:!'#!?58)91!23!W2?)-D!
)1*5(,+*)21!)1!*45!8*,*)21!*2!02*)C,*5!,+*)C5!W54,C)2=(!)1!,!1,*=(,-!
A,DI!!
•!.-,W2(,*)21E!>(!'8&!5%&L!#1!8*)0=-,*)19!<52<-5!*2!02C5!W2?)58?!
'8&%2!%-%'%/3!$#-$&G'!L/+!'#!N3%-:!'8&!&-'%2&!/:5&2'%+%-,!G/-&3?!L8%$8!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E7E7!
%+!$#00#-!#Na&$'!%-!'8&!+'/'%#-I!b-3(!L8&-!'#D$8%-,!#-!'8&!G/-&3?!
%-:%5%:D/3!$#D3:!+&&!'8&!$#-'&-'!#1!$#22&+G#-:%-,!G/2'I![#!&-2%$8!'8&!
%-'&2/$'%#-?!'8&(!:&5&3#G&:!'8&!1#33#L%-,!0&$8/-%+0+)!b-$&!
%-:%5%:D/3!'#D$8&:!#-!0D3'%G3&!G/2'+!%-!/!+8#2'!'%0&?!'8&!+(+'&0!
$#D3:!2&+G#-:!8%+g8&2!&11#2'+!/-:!8&g+8&!L#D3:!+&&!'8&!&-'%2&!
G%$'D2&g5%:&#!#-!'8&!G/-&3I!!
•!./*518)21d#5C)8)21E!O2#0!'8&!1%2+'!G2#N%-,?!'8&(!,/%-&:!'8&!%-+%,8'+!
'8/'!/3'8#D,8!'8&!$#-$&G'!L/+!,2&/'?!'8&!DGG&2!N#:(!0#5&0&-'!
0%,8'!N&!'##!0D$8!8D2:3&!%-!'8&!$#-'&P'I!4'!L#D3:!N&!0#2&!
/GG&/3%-,!%1!<52<-5!21-D!155?!*2!8*5<!21!*45!3-22(!15,(WD!*2!
=1W-2+B!*45!(5-,*5?!<,(*!23!*45!<)+*=(5dC)?52!W54)1?!*45!W-)1?I!
[8&(!/:#G'&:!'8%+!5%&L!'#!1D2'8&2!:&5&3#G!'8&%2!U<+I!!
•!@)1,-)H,*)21E!4-!'8&!+&$#-:!%'&2/'%#-?!'8&(!#N+&25&:!-&L!N&8/5%#D2!
12#0!G&#G3&I!"#0&!G&#G3&!$##G&2/'&:!L%'8!&/$8!#'8&2!'#!D-N3#$M!
'8&!&-'%2&!G%$'D2&g5%:&#I!>(!3%0%'%-,!'8&!:%+G3/(!'%0&!L8&-!G&#G3&!
+'&GG%-,!#-!'8&!13##2?!<52<-5!+2=-?!W5!51+2=(,95?!*2!(5-,*5!*2!5,+4!
2*45(!'#!$#33/N#2/'&!'#,&'8&2!%-!#2:&2!'#!+&&!'8&!L8#3&!G%$'D2&!
N&8%-:!'8&!N3%-:+I!<3&/+&!1%-:!'8&!:&0#!#1!1%-/3!:&+%,-!5%/)!
8''G+)gg5%0&#I$#0gEFeBcFY6E!
U)26%#O##U,%#*.55)$(#1-#',%#&)*%#Z&'09%#E')'01"C##
>?5,*)21!
.-,W2(,*)21!
./*518)21!
@)1,-)H,*)21!
!
!
:2C)19!`2?D)!
&PG3#2&!8#L!'#!
0#'%5/'&!/-!
/$'%5&!N&8/5%#D2!
%-!'8&!+G&$%/3!
$#-'&P'!+D$8!/+!
+'/'%#-I!!
!
!
:2C)19!`2?D)!
2&1#20!'8&!
&P%+'%-,!#Na&$'+!
J/:5&2'%+%-,!
G/-&3K!%-!'8&!
$#-'&P'!'#!
+'%0D3/'&!+D$8!
N&8/5%#D2I!!
!
!
:2C)19!`2?DE!
O%-:!#D'!3#L&2!
N#:(!%-'&2/$'%#-!
$/-!#G'%0%S&!'8&!
1&/+%N%3%'(!#1!'8&!
+(+'&0!%-!'8%+!
$#-'&P'I!
!
!
#5-,*)19!`2?DE!
/::!'8&!+#$%/3!
5/3D&!#1!'8&!
+(+'&0!'#!
&-8/-$&!+#$%/3!
$#8&2&-$&!
+%0D3'/-&#D+3(I!
E'.8%"'#]%-6%&'01"*##
4-!'8%+!+DNA+&$'%#-?!L&!:&+$2%N&!'8&!%-+%,8'+!L&!,/%-&:!12#0!'8&!+&31A
2&13&$'%#-!2&G#2'+I!\&!/++#2'&:!'8&!:/'/!%-'#!>?5,*)21?!.-,W2(,*)21?!/-:!
./*518)21d#5C)8)21?!'#!:&0#-+'2/'&!8#L!#D2!/GG2#/$8!L/+!D+&1D3!:D2%-,!
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E7EE!
'8&!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!%-!'8%+!0#:D3&!'8/'!$#D3:!2&13&$'!'#!'8&!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!1#2!
&P&2'%#-!,/0&+I!\&!/3+#!G2&+&-'!&P'2/!1%-:%-,+!%-!/::%'%#-/3!$/'&,#2(I!!
>?5,*)21!
bD2!12/0&L#2M!#11&2&:!'8&!$#-'&P'!'#!,D%:&!:&+%,-&2+!'#!%-%'%/'&!'8&%2!
G2#a&$'I!9+!#-&!+'D:&-'!0&-'%#-&:)!!
D0$*'+# 3%# 60*'%8# *15%# 7$0"&076%*# 1.$# &1"&%7'#*,1.68# 0"&6.8%# )"8# 3%#
81.2'%8C#U,%"#3%# 8%&08%8#'1#:1# 1.'*08%#)"8#3%# 3%$%#*1#6.&4# '1# *%%#
*15%#7%176%#)$%#810":#U)0#G,0#1"#',%#*/.)$%+#3,0&,#3)*#0"*70$0":C#
[8%+!%0G3%&+!'8/'!'8&!L/(!#1!:&+%,-!%+!:%11&2&-'!12#0!3/N!2&+&/2$8I!
"D11%$%&-'!$#-'/$'!L%'8!'/2,&'!$#-'&P'!+8#D3:!N&!N&-&1%$%/3!'#!$#--&$'!'8&!
%:&/+!'#!G2/$'%$&I![8%+!%+!$#-+%+'&-'!L%'8!'8&!1&/'D2&!#1!2&/3!3%1&!&-5%2#-0&-'!
'8/'!U*W+!G2#5%:&:I!!!
.-,W2(,*)21!
bD2!12/0&L#2M!&0G#L&2&:!:&+%,-&2+!%-!/$'%#-!N(!G2#'#'(G%-,!%-!'8&!
&/23(!G8/+&I!>(!'8%-M%-,?!:%+$D++%-,?!/-:!G&21#20%-,!G#++%N3&!N#:%3(!
%-'&2/$'%#-+?!+'D:&-'+!$#D3:!L&%,8!DG!'8&%2!$#-$&G'+!'#!$2/1'!#2!0#:%1(!'8&%2!
G2#G#+%'%#-?!#2!&5&-!'#!D-1#3:!-&L!:&+%,-!#GG#2'D-%'%&+I!9+!+#0&!+'D:&-'+!
+/%:)!!
U,$1.:,# ',%# 0"'%"*09%# 7$1'1'(70":# 3%# '$0%8# '1# '$)"*-1$5# 1.$# 90*01"#
0"'1#12R%&'*C#`%#)6*1#$%-6%&'%8#-$15#1.$#7$)&'0&%#'1#5)4%#1.$#&1"&%7'#
51$%#$%)60*'0&C#
!# ,)9%# 6%)$"%8# -$15# ',0*# &1.$*%# ',)'# ',%# 7$1'1'(7%# &)"# )6*1# 2%#
8%*0:"%8# -1$# %a761$)'01"+# $)',%$# ',)"# )"# 1.'&15%C# Z"8# ',)'# 0*# ',%#
713%$-.6#$16%#',)'#',%#7$1'1'(7%#&)"#76)(C##
./*518)21d#5C)8)21!
bD2!12/0&L#2M!G2#5%:&:!:&+%,-&2+!0#2&!#GG#2'D-%'%&+!'#!&PG3#2&!
1D2'8&2!#-!'8&!D+&2!&PG&2%&-$&!#1!'8&!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+I!O2#0!'8&!2&13&$'%#-!
2&G#2'+?!L&!-#'%$&:!'8/'!0#+'!#1!'8&!,2#DG+!1%-/3%S&:!'8&%2!:&+%,-!
G2#G#+%'%#-+!L%'8!&P'2/!$#-+%:&2/'%#-+?!+D$8!/+!=&3/'%-,!>#:(I!b-&!+'D:&-'!
/3+#!%-:%$/'&:!'8%+!1/$'!%-!8%+!2&G#2')!
I.$0":#',%#6)*'#'%*'+#3%#-1."8#0'#&)"#2%#2%''%$#0-#1.$#7$18.&'#&1"')0"*#
*15%#*1&0)6#0"'%$)&'01"*C##
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E7E6!
9+!:&+$2%N&:!G2&5%#D+3(?!U*W+!&-&2,%S&!:&+%,-&2+!'#!&PG3#2&!'8&%2!%:&/!
%'&2/'%5&3(I![8%+!-/'D2&!#11&2+!$2&:%'!1#2!:&+%,-&2+!'#!:&5&3#G!'8&%2!:&+%,-!
+D+'/%-/N3(!/3#-,!L%'8!'8&!G2#$&++I!!
O2#0!#D2!0#:D3&?!+'D:&-'+!/3+#!2&/3%S&:!'8&!%0G#2'/-$&!#1!&/23(!$#-'/$'!
L%'8!D+&2+!L8&-!%0G3&0&-'%-,!'8&%2!$#-$&G'+!%-!G2/$'%$&I!"#0&!+'D:&-'+!
8%,83%,8'&:!'8%+!'8#D,8'!%-!'8&%2!2&G#2'+)!
`%#)66# '%*'# ',)'# 3,%',%$#0'# 0*# *.0')26%# )"8#0"'%$%*'0":# -1$# 1.$# ')$:%'#
:$1.7#1-#)"8#3,%',%$#0'#5%%'*#1.$#1$0:0")6#',1.:,'C##
!'#5)8%#5%# $%)60F%#',)'# ',%#&1"&%7'# 1-# .*%$b1$0%"'%8#0*#%**%"'0)6C#`%#
"%%8#'1#4"13#,13#.*%$*#-%%6#%9%"#',%#7$1'1'(7%#0*#"1'#:118C##
!# ,)9%# 6%)$"'# ,13# '1# 0576%5%"'# ',%# 4"136%8:%# 3%# 6%)$"'#0"'1# 1.$#
7$1R%&'#)"8#&166%&'%8#76%"'(#1-#.*%-.6#8)')C#
[8%+!+'/'&0&-'!/3+#!2&5&/3+!'8/'!'8&!:/'/!&5%:&-$&!12#0!0D3'%G3&!+#D2$&+!
%-!U*W+!$#D3:!+DGG#2'!:&+%,-&2+!'#!%0G2#5&!'8&%2!L#2M+!1D2'8&2?!G/2'%$D3/23(!
%-!'8&!N#:%3(!%-'&2/$'%5&!+(+'&0+!%-!L8%$8!G&#G3&h+!N&8/5%#D2!:/'/!$#D3:!N&!
$#33&$'&:I!
`0',#',%#$0&,#8)')#;%C:C#2%,)901.$#8)')#)"8#0"'%$90%3#8)')B#-$15#.*%$#
'%*'*# 3%# 808# 3%# 5)"):%8# '1# 4%%7# 1"# 057$190":# 1.$# &1"&%7'# )"8#
7$1'1'(7%C####
!
$??)*)21,-!(58=-*8!
\&!/3+#!1#D-:!'8/'!U*W+!&-$#D2/,&:!+'D:&-'+!'#!$#-'%-D&!#-!'8&%2!L#2M!
L8&-!'8&(!L&2&!12D+'2/'&:!#1!'8&%2!G2#$&++I!9+!'8&!+'D:&-'!+/%:)!!
`%#'$0%8#5)"(#'05%*#1-#.*%$#'%*'0":C#E1#3%#50:,'#2%&15%#057)'0%"'+#
61*'# 1.$# 0"'%$%*'# )"8# %"',.*0)*5# '1# ',%# 7$1R%&'+# 2%&).*%# )66# 8)(# 3%#
R.*'# 31$4%8# 1"# ',0*C# H.'# 3%# *,1.68# *'0&4# '1# 0'+# )63)(*# -0"80":#
*15%',0":#-$%*,#)"8#"%3#0"#',%#7$1R%&'#0-#3%#3)"'#'1#81#0'#3%66C#
.#2&#5&2?!+%-$&!U*W+!0&'8#:+!N(!-/'D2&!2&QD%2%-,!0D3'%G3&!'/+M+!%-!#-&!
:&+%,-!G2#$&++?!+'D:&-'+!/2&!2&+G#-+%5&!%-!'8&%2!G2#a&$'?!/+!'8&(!+/%:)!
!# %"R1(# ',%# )'51*7,%$%# ',)'# %9%$(218(# )$%# ,0:,# 0"9169%8# 30',# ',%#
7$1R%&'#)"8#',%#'%)531$4#0*#$%)66(#31"8%$-.6C##
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E7Ee!
`%#,)9%#-$%/.%"'#&155."0&)'01"#'1#%a&,)":%#08%)*#)"8#%9%$(1"%#0*#
0"9169%8#0"C#
7)8+=88)218!
4-!'8%+!+&$'%#-?!L&!:%+$D++!#D2!1%-:%-,+!%-!:&'/%3I!>(!2&3/'%-,!'8&!2&+D3'+!
N/$M!'#!'8&!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&?!L&!1#D-:!'8/'!U*W+!$#D3:!+DGG#2'!'8&!:&%,-!
G2#$&++!#1!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!%-!'82&&!L/(+I!
!O%2+'?!'8&!+'D:(!2&5&/3&:!'8/'!U*W+!#11&2&:!/!$#-'&P'!'#!,D%:&!/-:!%-+G%2&!
:&+%,-&2+!'#!$#22&3/'&!'8&!2&/3!3%1&!+$&-/2%#!'#!'8&!%:&/'%#-!1#2!&P&2'%#-!
,/0&+I!@-3%M&!'8&!'(G%$/3!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!3/N!2&+&/2$8!JOI!.D&33&2!&'!/3I?!
67E6K!'8/'!0/%-3(!1#$D+&:!#-!N#:(!+M%33+!/-:!:&+%,-!#1!'&$8-#3#,%&+!1#2!
+G#2'+!&PG&2%&-$&+?!#D2!/GG2#/$8!$#0G3%0&-'!&P&2'%#-!'8&#2(!'#!2&0%-:!
:&+%,-&2+!$#-+%:&2%-,!#-!'8&!G2/$'%$/3!$#-+'2/%-'+!/-:!#GG#2'D-%'%&+!
J;#-+#35#?!U5&2%''?!"0%'8?!]!W/-:/(?!677FK!%-!'8&!&/23(!G8/+&I!O2#0!'8&!
/1#2&0&-'%#-&:!$/+&+?!L&!8/5&!#N+&25&:!'8/'!N(!,/%-%-,!/L/2&-&++!#-!3#$/3!
$#-'&P'+?!+'D:&-'+!:%:!-#'!aD+'!$2&/'&!/-!&P&2'%#-!%-'&2/$'%#-!ND'!/-!&P&2'%#-!
&PG&2%&-$&!&-/N3&:!L%'8!%-'&-'%#-!1#2!2&G&/'&:!5%+%'!%-!#11%$&!L#2M&2+h!:/%3(!
2#D'%-&+I!!
"&$#-:?!L&!#N+&25&:!'8/'!U<+!$#D3:!/$'!/+!/!'&$8-#3#,(!$/22%&2!'#!
&3/N#2/'&!#-!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!%-!/$'%#-I!\%'8!8/-:+A#-!+M%33+?!:&+%,-&2+!
&PG3#2&?!0#:%1(?!/-:!/::!'8&%2!:&+%,-!%-'&-'%#-+!N(!:&5&3#G%-,!U<+I!
;#-+&QD&-'3(?!'8&(!,/%-!:&&G&2!D-:&2+'/-:%-,!'#L/2:+!'8&!$#-'&P'?!'8&!
D+&2+?!/-:!'8&!:&+%,-I!9+!L/+!:&G%$'&:!%-!/33!'8&!$/+&+!12#0!#D2!+'D:(?!/33!'8&!
+'D:&-'+!%-5#35&:!:&+%,-!G2%-$%G3&+?!'8&!'&$8-#3#,(!+M%33+?!/-:!'8&!$#-'&P'!
$#-+%:&2/'%#-+!'#!2&/3%S&!'8&%2!G2#N&+?!L8%$8!&PG3%$%'!'8&%2!%:&/+!%-'#!'8&!
/$$&++%N3&!:&0#-+'2/'%#-+I!!!!
[8%2:?!L&!1#D-:!'8/'!'8&!%'&2/'%5&!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!#1!U*W+!G2#5%:&!
:&+%,-&2+!0#2&!#GG#2'D-%'%&+!'#!%-'&2/$'!L%'8!'8&%2!%:&/+!0#2&!:(-/0%$/33(?!
/-:!%-!2&'D2-!'#!&P'&-:!'8&%2!:&+%,-!%'&2/'%5&3(I![8%+!$/-!N&!1/$%3%'/'&:!N(!
'82&&!#N+&25/'%#-+!12#0!'8%+!+'D:()!O%2+'?!:&+%,-&2+!$/-!$#-'/$'!L%'8!D+&2!%-!
'8&!:&+%,-!G2#$&++?!L8&2&!'8&(!$#D3:!,&'!$2D$%/3!1&&:N/$M+!'#!2&13&$'!#-!'8&!
%-'&-'%#-!'8&(!%-5#35&:I!"&$#-:?!:&+%,-&2+!$/-!#N+&25&!'8&!:/'/!12#0!
0D3'%G3&!+#D2$&+!/3#-,!L%'8!'8&!:&+%,-!G2#$&++?!L8%$8!G2#5%:&!#Na&$'%5&!
&5%:&-$&!'#!+DGG#2'!#2!/,/%-+'!'8&%2!$#-+%:&2/'%#-+I![8%2:?!:&+%,-&2+!$/-!
:%+$D++?!&PG3#2&?!/-/3(+&!L%'8!&/$8!#'8&2!'#!+G/2M!'8&%2!%:&/+I!!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E7EY!
L050')'01"*#K#S771$'."0'0%*#
[8%+!+'D:(!8/+!'8&!1#33#L%-,!3%0%'/'%#-+!'8/'!$#D3:!N&!%0G2#5&:!1D2'8&2I!
O%2+'?!#D2!/GG2#/$8!0%,8'!N&!'##!#G&-A&-:&:!1#2!/33!'8&!+'D:&-'+!'#!,#!
'82#D,8I!O2#0!#D2!#N+&25/'%#-?!L&!1#D-:!-#'!&5&2(!,2#DG!GD2+D&!'8&%2!
:&+%,-!G2#$&++!5&2(!L&33I!"#0&!+'D:&-'+!/3+#!&PG2&++&:!'8&%2!$#-$&2-+!#-!
#D2!L/(!#1!/GG3(%-,!U*W+!'#!:&+%,-!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+?!/+!&P&2'%#-!2&0/%-&:!
/N+'2/$'!'#!'8&0I![8&!L#2M!2&3/'&:!'#!&P&2'%#-!$/2:+!JOI!OI!.D&33&2!&'!/3I?!
67EYK!0/(!N&!/-!%-'&2&+'%-,!/::%'%#-!'#!%0G2#5&!12#0!8&2&I!
4-!/::%'%#-?!L&!8/5&!'#!/:0%'!'8/'!'8&2&!%+!3/$M!#1!+G&$%1%$!:&+%,-!'##3+!'#!
+DGG#2'!'#!/GG3(!U*W+!%-!:&5&3#G%-,!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!%-!#D2!+'D:(I![8%+!
#N+&25/'%#-!%+!&5&-!0#2&!/GG/2&-'!1#2!+'D:&-'+!L8#!8/5&!/N+&-'!
M-#L3&:,&!#-!G2#'#'(G%-,!L%'8!'&$8-#3#,(I!4'!%+!8/2:!1#2!'8&0!'#!+0##'83(!
0#5&!/2#D-:!N&'L&&-!M-#L3&:,&?!'&$8-#3#,(!%0G3&0&-'/'%#-?!/-:!:/'/!
/-:!'#!'/M&!-&$&++/2(!:&+%,-!/$'%#-+I![#!#5&2$#0&!'8%+?!:&+%,-!'##3+!+D$8!/+!
N#:(!+M&'$8%-,!J"'#3'&20/-?!67EYK!#2!N#:(!+'#20%-,!J>D$8&-/D?!O2/-$%+$#?!
]!"D2%?!6777K!0/(!$#0&!5&2(!8/-:(!'#!,/%-!0#2&!G2#1#D-:!D-:&2+'/-:%-,!
'#L/2:+!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+I!!
W/+'3(?!&5/3D/'%-,!#D2!2&+&/2$8!QD&+'%#-!%-!&:D$/'%#-/3!$/+&+!%+!-#'!'8&!
+/0&!/+!/!:&+%,-&2h+!:/(A'#A:/(!G2/$'%$&I!T#L&5&2?!G2&5%#D+!L#2M!L8%$8!
/3+#!D+&:!:&+%,-!$#D2+&+!J"'#3'&20/-?!67EYK!+D,,&+'&:!'8%+!0%,8'!N&!/!,##:!
L/(!'#!/GG2#P%0/'&!:&+%,-!G2/$'%$&I!OD2'8&20#2&?!/!'/+M!L%'8!'&/0AN/+&:!
:&+%,-!&P&2$%+&+!%+!+%0%3/2!'#!'8&!'&/0L#2M!&-5%2#-0&-'!'#!L8%$8!:&+%,-&2+!
/2&!#1'&-!&PG#+&:I!9-(8#L?!1D2'8&2!+'D:%&+!-&&:!'#!N&!:#-&!'8&2&!'#!
$#-:D$'!3#-,&2!+'D:(!%-!2&/3!:&+%,-!$/+&+!/-:!&5&-'D/33(!$#0&!DG!L%'8!0#2&!
&PG3%$%'!:&+%,-!,D%:&3%-&+!1#2!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+I!
%21+-=8)218!
4-!'8%+!G/G&2?!L&!G2&+&-'&:!/!-&L!L/(!#1!:&+%,-%-,!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!N(!
$#0N%-%-,!'8&!N/+%$!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!#1!U*W+I![8&!:/'/!$#33&$'&:!12#0!'8&!
:%+$D++&:!:&+%,-!%-'&2/$'%#-!0#:D3&+!%-:%$/'&+!'8/'!U*W+!$/-!+DGG#2'!'8&!
:&+%,-!G2#$&++!'#!:&5&3#G!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!'/2,&'%-,!1#2!+G&$%1%$!$#-'&P'+I!
[8&!2&+D3'+!+D,,&+'&:!'8/'!D'%3%S%-,!'8&!U*W+!:&+%,-!G2#$&++!L8&-!
:&5&3#G%-,!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+!1#2!'8&!+G&$%1%$!$#-'&P'+!$/-!#11&2!'8&!$#-'&P'!'#!
,D%:&!/-:!%-+G%2&!:&+%,-&2+h!%:&/'%#-^!$/-!1/$%3%'/'&!'&$8-#3#,(!&PG3#2/'%#-+!
'#!&3/N#2/'&!#-!'8&!&P&2'%#-!$#-$&G'!%-!/$'%#-^!/-:!$/-!G2#5%:&!'8&!%'&2/'%5&!
G2#$&++!'#!8&3G!:&+%,-&2+!'#!&5/3D/'&!/-:!'#!&P'&-:!'8&%2!:&+%,-!L%'8!D+&2+?!
#'8&2!:&+%,-&2+?!/-:!'8&!$#33&$'&:!:/'/I!\&!N&3%&5&!'8/'!-&$&++/2(!1D'D2&!
2&+&/2$8&+!/-:!G2/$'%$&+!/2&!-&&:&:!'#!5/3%:/'&!#D2!$D22&-'!L#2M+!1D2'8&2I!
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E7EZ!
O#2!1D'D2&!L#2M?!1%2+'3(!L&!G3/-!'#!0#:%1(!'8&!12/0&L#2M!/$$#2:%-,!'#!
'8&!%-+%,8'+!L&!,/%-&:!12#0!'8%+!+'&GI!</2'%$D3/23(?!L&!/2&!,#%-,!'#!$3/2%1(!'8&!
-&$&++/2(!'8&#2%&+!1#2!:&+%,-%-,!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&!L%'8!+DGG#2'%-,!
0/'&2%/3+!J&I,I!$/2:+?!+3%:&+?!&'$IKI!"&$#-:3(?!L&!8#G&!'#!:&5&3#G!/!2#D,8!U<!
%-!/:5/-$&!'#!-/22#L!:#L-!'8&!+$#G&!#1!'8&!:&+%,-!'#G%$I![8&2&1#2&?!
+'D:&-'+g:&+%,-&2+!$/-!+'/2'!'8&!1%&3:!2&+&/2$8!L%'8!U<!/-:!$/-!2&13&$'!#-!
'8&!:/'/!12#0!U<!%-!'8&!5&2(!N&,%--%-,?!2/'8&2!'8/-!+'2D,,3%-,!#-!'8&!
$#-$&G'!1#2!'8&!1%2+'!G2#N&I!4-!'8%+!L/(?!L&!/2&!/%0%-,!'#!8&3G!'8&0!'#!1%-:!
'8&!'2/$M!1#2!'8&%2!/$'%5%'%&+!0#2&!&11%$%&-'3(I!\%'8!'8&!DG:/'&!#1!'8&!
G2#,2/0?!L&!'8&-!G3/-!'#!$#-:D$'!+&5&2/3!2#D-:+!#1!L#2M+8#G+!L%'8!
%-:D+'2%/3!:&+%,-!+'D:&-'+!/-:!:&+%,-&2+!'#!1%-/33(!$#0&!DG!L%'8!$D+'#0%S&:!
U*W+!1#2!:&+%,-%-,!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&I!
B8+*%$6"',"4"*C(:#U,%#-0$*'#).',1$#1-#',0*#7)7%$#0*#2%0":#
*71"*1$%8#2(#G,0")#E&,16)$*,07#G1."&06#;GEGBC#`%#',)"4#)66#
*'.8%"'*#-$15#U=r%#)"8#Pe=#3,1#7)$'0&07)'%8#0"#',%#518.6%#
1-#',0*#*'.8(C######
#535(51+58!
92-/N?!"I?!<&2''D3/?!9I?!]!"D#0%-&-?!.I!J67EYKI!O3#L!&PG&2%&-$&!/+!/!QD/3%'(!
0&/+D2&!%-!&5/3D/'%-,!G8(+%$/33(!/$'%5/'%-,!+&2%#D+!,/0&+I!4-!L%&'.$%#
_1'%*#0"#G157.'%$#E&0%"&%#;0"&6.80":#*.2*%$0%*#L%&'.$%#_1'%*#0"#Z$'0-0&0)6#
!"'%660:%"&%#)"8#L%&'.$%#_1'%*#0"#H010"-1$5)'0&*B!Jn#3I!cF7Z?!GGI!677u
6E6KI!8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IE77XgBXcAeAeEBAE6EZXAYoEF!
>D$8&-/D?!.I?!O2/-$%+$#?!4I!"I?!]!"D2%?!CI!OI!J6777KI!UPG&2%&-$&!<2#'#'(G%-,I!4-!
G1"-%$%"&%#1"#I%*0:"0":#0"'%$)&'09%#*(*'%5*Y#7$1&%**%*+#7$)&'0&%*+#
5%',18*+#)"8#'%&,"0/.%*!JGGI!Y6YuYeeKI!
8''G)gg:#%I#2,g8''G)gg:#%I/$0I#2,gE7IEEYZgeYXFY6IeYXc76!
;/0&%2á#?!.I!"I?!>/:%/?!"I!>I!4I?!b33&2?!UI!*I?!]!n&2+$8D2&?!<I!OI!.I!CI!J67E7KI!
f&D2#2&8/N%3%'/'%#-!D+%-,!'8&!5%2'D/3!2&/3%'(!N/+&:!=&8/N%3%'/'%#-!`/0%-,!
"(+'&0)!0&'8#:#3#,(?!:&+%,-?!G+($8#0&'2%$+?!D+/N%3%'(!/-:!5/3%:/'%#-I!
e1.$")6#1-#_%.$1%":0"%%$0":#)"8#]%,)2060')'01"?!l?!YcI!
8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IEEcFgEXYeA777eAXAYc!
;#-+#35#?!"I?!U5&2%''?!VI?!"0%'8?!4I?!]!W/-:/(?!CI!9I!J677FKI!*&+%,-!
=&QD%2&0&-'+!1#2![&$8-#3#,%&+!'8/'!U-$#D2/,&!<8(+%$/3!9$'%5%'(?!YZXu
YFFI!
*D--%-,?![I!J677cKI!*/-$&?!*/-$&!=&5#3D'%#-!J**=KI!Z&'090'0%*+#Z8)7')'01"#K#
Z:0":I!8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IE7c7g7EB6YXc7c76ZFe67e!
]<_+#L=+#H]SNHZG^<]#K#HSQ<]E
E7EF!
O&--&(?!9I?!]!W&&?![I!*I!J67E7KI!UPG3#2%-,!+G/2&:!$/G/$%'(!%-!G&2+#-+!L%'8!
:&0&-'%/)!\8/'!\%%z+DG{[.zg+DG{!$/-!3&/2-I!Z&'090'0%*#Z8)7')'01"#Z:0":?!
dAJYK?!e7eueEeI!8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IE7c7g7EB6YXccI67E7IZ6ZXeF!
`/#?!dI?!]!./-:2(M?!=I!WI!J67EEKI!`2/N9GG3&ç)![8&!*&+%,-!#1!/!;/+D/3!
UP&2,/0&?!eZuYFI!
`&-'?!"I!TI!n/-?!.&,&-+?!;I!CI!<I!`I?!<&&'&2+?!.I!.I!=I?!TD00&3+?!;I!;I!.I?!]!
WD?!dI!J67EE/KI!UPG&2%&-'%/3!*&+%,-!W/-:+$/G&+!/+!/!:&+%,-!'##3!1#2!0/2M&'!
2&+&/2$8!#1!:%+2DG'%5&!%-'&33%,&-'!+(+'&0+I!4-!@*'#G)52$08:%#Z&)8%50&#
I%*0:"#N)"):%5%"'#G1"-%$%"&%!JGGI!E!u!E7KI!=&'2%&5&:!12#0!
8''G)ggLLLI-/2$%+I-3gGDN3%$/'%#-g=&$#2:4*g#/%)3%N2/2(I'D&I-3)XEBEXegW/-
,D/,&g&-!
`&-'?!"I!TI!n/-?!.&,&-+?!;I!CI!<I!`I?!<&&'&2+?!.I!.I!=I?!TD00&3+?!;I!;I!.I?!]!
WD?!dI!J67EENKI!UPG&2%&-'%/3!*&+%,-!W/-:+$/G&+!/+!/!*&+%,-![##3!1#2!./2M&'!
=&+&/2$8!#1!*%+2DG'%5&!4-'&33%,&-'!"(+'&0+?!J"&G'&0N&2K?!XucI!
`&23%-,?!VI!.I?!"$8%3:?!CI?!]!./+D$8?!.I!J67E7KI!UP&2,/0&!*&+%,-!1#2!U3:&23(!
@+&2+ç)![8&!;/+&!"'D:(!#1!"%35&2>/3/-$&?!FFuFBI!
./-:2(M?!=I!WI?!`&23%-,?!VI!.I?!]!"'/-3&(?!VI!`I!J67EYKI!*&+%,-%-,!`/0&+!'#!
*%+$#D2/,&!"&:&-'/2(!>&8/5%#D2!é!;#,-%'%5&!N&-&1%'+!éI!
8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IE77XgBXcABcEAYZF7ABFA6!
.&,&-+?!;I?!<&&'&2+?!.I?!TD00&3+?!;I?!]!>2#0N/$8&2?!9I!J67EeKI!*&+%,-%-,!
1#2!N&8/5%#D2!$8/-,&!'#L/2:+!8&/3'8(!3%5%-,I!O',#!"'%$")'01")6#G1":$%**#
1-#!"'%$")'01")6#Z**1&0)'01"#1-#E1&0%'0%*#1-#I%*0:"#]%*%)$&,?!Y6cBuY6BFI!
.%25%+?!<I!TI!JEBBEKI!O3#L)![8&!<+($8#3#,(!#1!bG'%0/3!UPG&2%&-$&I!Z&)8%5(#
1-#N)"):%5%"'#]%90%3?!@fJeK?!FeFuFY7I!
8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IZYFZg9.=IEBBEIY6XBZEe!
.D&33&2?!OI!OI?!U:,&?!*I?!n&'&2&?!OI?!`%NN+?!.I!=I?!9,/0/-#3%+?!"I?!>#-,&2+?!>I?!
]!"8&2%:/-?!CI!`I!J67EEKI!*&+%,-%-,!"G#2'+ç)!9!O2/0&L#2M!1#2!UP&2'%#-!
`/0&+?!6FZEu6FF7I!
.D&33&2?!OI!OI?!`%NN+?!.I!=I?!n&'&2&?!OI?!]!U:,&?!*I!J67EYKI!"DGG#2'%-,!'8&!
;2&/'%5&!`/0&!*&+%,-!<2#$&++!L%'8!UP&2'%#-!;/2:+?!66EEu6667I!
.D&33&2?!OI!iO3#(:?j!n&'&2&?!OI?!`%NN+?!.I!=I?!9,/0/-#3%+?!"I?!]!"8&2%:/-?!CI!
J67E7KI!C#,,%-,!#5&2!/!:%+'/-$&)!'8&!%-13D&-$&!#1!:&+%,-!%-!G/2/33&3!
&P&2'%#-!,/0&+I!V$1&%%80":*#1-#',%#O',#ZGN#E!QQ]ZV^#E(571*0.5#1"#
[08%1#Q)5%*?!@J6E6K?!FeuFcI!8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IEEYZgEceFEeZIEceFEYZ!
.D&33&2?!OI?!`%NN+?!.I!=I?!]!n&'&2&?!OI!J67E7KI![#L/2:+!D-:&2+'/-:%-,!8#L!'#!
:&+%,-!1#2!+#$%/3!G3/(!%-!&P&2'%#-!,/0&+?!YEXuY6YI!
8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IE77Xg+77XXBA77BA76FcAP!
.D&33&2?!OI?!n&'&2&?!OI?!`%NN+?!.I?!U:,&?!*I?!9,/0/-#3%+?!"I?!"8&2%:/-?!CI?!]!
T&&2?!CI!J67E6KI!>/3/-$%-,!&P&2'%#-!&PG&2%&-$&+I!V$1&%%80":*#1-#',%#>?@>#
N0"8#',%#Q)7Y#V$120":#<a%$'01"#<a7%$0%"&%#30',#<a7%$0%"'0)6#I%*0:"#L)"8*&)7%*
E7EX!
ZGN#Z"".)6#G1"-%$%"&%#1"#^.5)"#D)&'1$*#0"#G157.'0":#E(*'%5*#b#G^!#
c@>?!EcZeuEcF6I!8''G)gg:#%I#2,gE7IEEYZg667XFXFI667ce66!
<&&'&2+?!.I?!]!.&,&-+?!;I!J67EYKI!UPG&2%&-'%/3!*&+%,-!W/-:+$/G&+I!T#L!'#!
:&+%,-!1#2!N&8/5%#D2!$8/-,&?!'#L/2:+!/-!/$'%5&!3%1&+'(3&I!
<&&'&2+?!.I?!.&,&-+?!;I?!TD00&3+?!;I?!]!>2#0N/$8&2?!9I!J67EeKI!UPG&2%&-'%/3!
<2#N&+ç)!G2#N%-,!1#2!&0&2,%-,!N&8/5%#2!G/''&2-+!%-!&5&2(:/(!3%1&?!6cc7u
6ccBI!
"%-$3/%2?!CI?!T%-,+'#-?!<I?!]!./+&M?!.I!J677XKI!;#-+%:&2/'%#-+!1#2!'8&!:&+%,-!
#1!&P&2,/0&+?!@J6E6K?!6cBu6BFI!
"'#3'&20/-?!UI!J67EYKI!W&++!%+!'##!3%''3&!u!0#2&!%+!-&&:&:!>#:(!A!.#'%#-!
UPG&2%&-$&!/+!/!"M%33!%-!*&+%,-!U:D$/'%#-?!Ee6XuEeYEI!
\/33:%D+?!èI!J67EZKI!*&+%,-%-,!1#2!9$'%5&!W%1&ç)!.#5%-,!/-:!>&%-,!.#5&:!
[#,&'8&2!L%'8!*&0&-'%/!</'%&-'+?!TJeK?!YXuF6I!
!
!
!
Work or Workout? Designing Interactive Technology for Workplace Fitness Promotion
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Feb 2019
The rapid penetration of labor-saving devices and task-oriented workplace norms have substantially reduced physical exercises while increasing sedentary behaviors in many office-based jobs. The prevalence of physical inactivity at work increases the risks of developing metabolic disorders, mental illnesses, and musculoskeletal injuries, threatening office workers’ physical and psychological well-being. To tackle such issue, many strategies have been proposed to facilitate workplace fitness initiatives, such as public policies, organizational wellness programs, promotional materials, and socioenvironmental changes, etc. However, it is challenging to reach the goals of these top-down strategies, once their applications fail to blend physical activity into everyday work and persuade individuals to keep up fitness levels in office settings. The emerging fitness-promoting technologies may be leveraged to support active lifestyles in the workday context. Through integrating ubiquitous sensing and human-computer interaction (HCI), interactive technologies can sense physical states of office workers and use that information to engage them in office exercises in the short-term as well as encourage their systemic behavior change in the long-term. This doctoral dissertation therefore explores this new perspective of office vitality: How to design interactive technology to facilitate workplace fitness promotion?
View
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.