ArticlePDF Available

Characterization and Weathering of the Building Materials of Sanctuaries in the Archaeological Site of Dion, Greece Citation

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The sanctuaries of Demeter and Asklepios are part of the Dion archaeological site that sits among the eastern foothills of Mount Olympus. The main building materials are limestones and conglomerates. Sandstones, marbles, and ceramic plinths were also used. The materials consist mainly of calcite and/or dolomite, whereas the deteriorated surfaces contain also secondary and recrystallized calcite and dolomite, gypsum, various inorganic compounds, fluoroapatite, microorganisms and other organic compounds. Cracks and holes were observed in various parts of the stones. The influence of specific weathering agents and factors to the behavior of the materials was examined. The particular environmental conditions in Dion combine increased moisture and rain fall, insolation and great temperature differences, abundance of intensive surface and underground water bodies in the surrounding area, an area full of plants and trees, therefore, they can cause extensive chemical, biological and mechanical decay of the monuments. The following physical characteristics of the building materials have been studied: bulk density, open porosity, pore size distribution, water absorption and desorption, capillary absorption and desorption. The chemical composition of bulk precipitation, surface and underground water was investigated. The salts presence and crystallization was examined. The influence of the water presence to the behavior of the materials was examined by in situ IR thermometer measurements. Temperature values increased from the lower to the upper parts of the building stones and they significantly depend on the orientation of the walls. The results indicate the existence of water in the bulk of the materials due to capillary penetration. The existence of water in the bulk of the materials due to capillary penetration, the cycles of wet-dry conditions, correlated with the intensive surface and underground water presence in the whole surrounding area, lead to partial dissolution-recrystallization of the carbonate material and loss of the structural cohesion and the surface stability.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Trends Journal of Sciences Research (2015) 2(3):95-103 http://www.tjsr.org
Characterization and Weathering of the Building Materials of
Sanctuaries in the Archaeological Site of Dion, Greece
Spathis P.1, Papanikolaou E.2, Melfos V.2, Samara C.1, Christaras B.2, Katsiotis N.3
1School of Chemistry, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece,
2School of Geology, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, 54124 Thessaloniki, Greece,
3School of Chemical Engineering, National Technical University of Athens, 15780 Athens, Greece
Correspondence: Spathis P. (spathis@chem.auth.gr)
Abstract The sanctuaries of Demeter and Asklepios are part of the Dion archaeological site that sits among the
eastern foothills of Mount Olympus. The main building materials are limestones and conglomerates. Sandstones,
marbles, and ceramic plinths were also used. The materials consist mainly of calcite and/or dolomite, whereas the
deteriorated surfaces contain also secondary and recrystallized calcite and dolomite, gypsum, various inorganic
compounds, fluoroapatite, microorganisms and other organic compounds. Cracks and holes were observed in
various parts of the stones. The influence of specific weathering agents and factors to the behavior of the materials
was examined. The particular environmental conditions in Dion combine increased moisture and rain fall, insolation
and great temperature differences, abundance of intensive surface and underground water bodies in the surrounding
area, an area full of plants and trees, therefore, they can cause extensive chemical, biological and mechanical decay
of the monuments. The following physical characteristics of the building materials have been studied: bulk density,
open porosity, pore size distribution, water absorption and desorption, capillary absorption and desorption. The
chemical composition of bulk precipitation, surface and underground water was investigated. The salts presence and
crystallization was examined. The influence of the water presence to the behavior of the materials was examined by
in situ IR thermometer measurements. Temperature values increased from the lower to the upper parts of the
building stones and they significantly depend on the orientation of the walls. The results indicate the existence of
water in the bulk of the materials due to capillary penetration. The existence of water in the bulk of the materials
due to capillary penetration, the cycles of wet-dry conditions, correlated with the intensive surface and underground
water presence in the whole surrounding area, lead to partial dissolution-recrystallization of the carbonate material
and loss of the structural cohesion and the surface stability.
Keywords: : stone, deterioration, physical characteristics, capillary rise, IR thermometry.
Citation: Spathis P., Papanikolaou E., Melfos V., Samara C., Christaras B., Katsiotis N. Characterization
and Weathering of the Building Materials of Sanctuaries in the Archaeological Site of Dion,
Greece. Trends Journal of Sciences Research. Vol. 2, No. 3, 2015, pp. 95-103.
Introduction
Deterioration of historical monuments is the result
of chemical reactions of polluted air, soil and water with
the stone building materials. The crystallization and
hydration of weathering products result in their expansion
causing the degradation of dolomite, limestone, marble,
sandstone and other building materials. In most cases the
stone surfaces are gradually covered by salts and black
crusts containing calcium, magnesium, sodium, potassium
sulphates, nitrates and other constituents. Also the water
can easily penetrate and remain into the building stone
materials, resulting in a destructive influence due to the
absorption and evaporation of the moisture that affects
their volume and causes cracks leading to the deterioration
of the structure[1]. Under these conditions, the stone
surfaces disintegrate into powder and the building
materials gradually lose their mechanical strength and
their artistic form[2-6]. In the case of marbles the main
mechanism of deterioration is the sulphation of their
surfaces, leading to the formation of gypsum layers on the
stone surface, due to the solid state diffusion of Ca2+ [7-13].
Various destructive or non-destructive methods are used
for the study of the weathering of the building stone
materials of the monuments, being part of their
conservation[14-16].
The aim of the present work is the study of the effect of
the environmental factors and the deterioration problems
of stone monuments of Demeter and Asklepios sanctuaries
in Dion archaeological site (Figure 1), one of the most
important religious centers of ancient Greeks in central
Macedonia. In earlier works[17-20] it was found that the
main building materials of the monuments are limestones
and conglomerates. Sandstones, marbles and ceramic
plinths were also used. The materials consist mainly of
calcite and/or dolomite. The surfaces of the building
materials are partially covered by the weathering products
of the primary minerals such as secondary carbonate
(calcite-dolomite) precipitated from water solutions,
recrystallized calcite and dolomite and in some cases
gypsum. The presence of crusts of various
96 Spathis P., Papanikolaou E., Melfos V. et al: Characterization and Weathering of the Building
Materials of Sanctuaries in the Archaeological Site of Dion, Greece
inorganic/organic compounds, such as illite, kaolinite,
sericite, rutile, Fe-oxides, Mn-oxides, fluoroapatite,
fragments of fossils, is related to various sediments that
covered the primary materials. No significant amounts of
salts were found on the surface or inside the pore of the
materials. The purpose of this investigation is the analysis
of the environmental conditions in the area of the
archaeological site, the examination of their contribution
to the deterioration of the building materials and the study
of the influence of the water presence to the behavior of
the materials by in situ IR thermometer measurements and
laboratory measurements of their physical characteristics.
Materials And Methods
A series of samples of the various building materials
were collected from different locations of both
monuments, Asklepios and Demeter. The accurate
sampling sites were previously mentioned and
presented[17]. The in situ measurements were focused in
two monuments, Asklepios Temple, Altar in Demeter
sanctuary (Figure 1).
Figure 1 General view of the sanctuaries of a) Asklepios, b) Demeter.
The mineralogical study of thin sections of the samples
was carried out by optical microscopy using a Leitz
Laborlux 11 POL S microscope. Scanning electron
microscopy (SEM) was used to study the surface of
samples. The SEM experiments were carried out with a
JEOL, JSM-840 A scanning microscope, connected with
an Energy Dispenser Spectrometer - EDS - (LINK, AN
10/55S). The physical properties of the materials were
studied according standard methods[21].
Twelve samples of bulk precipitation were collected on
a monthly basis (December 2010 to November 2011)
using a bulk precipitation collector located in the
archaeological area for a period of one year. Three
samples of surface waters were also collected from
Vaphyras river and two rillets, all passing from the
archaeological area. Upon receipt in the Laboratory,
precipitation and surface water samples were filtered
through 0.45 μm pore diameter cellulose membranes to
remove particles. Chemical analysis for the determination
of the chloride, nitrate and sulphate ions was carried out
by Ion Chromatography.
Two series of IR thermometer in situ measurements, in
conditions of sunny or wet weather, were carried out by a
portable infrared laser thermometer (Center 358, Infrared
thermometer, Range:-18o C~ 315o C). The question was to
determine the high of the capillary water at the base of
building stones, at the contact with the soil, given that the
aquifer is very high, quite near to the foundation level of
the monument. The idea was to use an infrared
thermometer, because the inside temperature of the wet
part of a stone is different than the next dry part, of the
same stone, for the same time and weather conditions. The
environment temperature during the measurements was ~
28ο C (sunny conditions) or ~ 9ο C (wet conditions). In
this study, infrared thermometer measurements were used
in the assessment of moisture in porous stones. Due to the
difference between the thermal diffusivities of moist and
the dry stones, IR thermometer measurements are capable
of showing qualitative variations in respiration behaviour
(i.e. moisture impact), appearing as surface temperature
fluctuations[22-23].
Results and Discussion
The results of the mineralogical analysis of the
deteriorated surfaces and inside the pores in the bulk of
the materials are shown in Table 1 and Figures 2-3.
From these results it is evident that the surfaces of the
building materials are partially covered by the weathering
products of the primary minerals such as secondary
carbonate (calcite-dolomite) precipitated from water
solutions, recrystallized calcite and dolomite and in some
cases gypsum. An intense presence of lichens and
bryophyte is observed. The presence of crusts of various
inorganic/organic compounds, such as illite, kaolinite,
sericite, rutile, chromite, Fe-oxides, Mn-oxides,
fluoroapatite, fragments of fossils, is related to various
sediments that covered the primary materials.
Trends Journal of Sciences Research 2015, 2(3): 95-103 97
Table 1. Mineralogical composition of the deteriorated surfaces of the building materials of Asklepios and
Demeter sanctuaries.
Primary minerals
Secondary minerals
(sediments products)
Secondary minerals
(deterioration products)
Calcite: CaCO3
Aragonite: CaCO3
Dolomite: CaMg(CO3)2
Quartz: SiO2
White mica and sericite:
KAl2(Si3Al)O10(OH,F)2
Albite: NaAlSi3O8
Amphibole:
Ca2(Mg,Fe)5Si8O22(OH)2
Epidote: Ca2(FeAl)3(SiO4)3(OH)
K-feldspar: KAlSi3O8
Kaolinite: Al2Si2O5(OH)4
Illite: (K,H3O)(Al,Mg,Fe)2(Si,Al)4O10[(OH)2,(H2O)]
Mn-oxides
Rutile: TiO2
Hematite: Fe2O3
Fluoroapatite: Ca5(PO4)3F
Chromite: FeCr2O4
Organic matter
Gypsum: CaSO4•2(H2O)
Secondary carbonate (calcite-
dolomite)
precipitated from water
solutions
Recrystallized calcite-
dolomite crystals
Figure 2 Photomicrographs of calcite limestone (a-d) and dolomitic limestone (e-f), secondary mineralogical composition of the deteriorated surface, a)
Secondary carbonate (calcite-dolomite) precipitated from water solutions, SEM, b) secondary calcite-dolomite crystals, SEM, c) recrystallized calcite-
dolomite crystals, SEM, d) gypsum crystal, SEM, e) secondary dolomite-calcite, SEM, f) carbonate (dolomite-calcite) precipitated from water solutions,
SEM.
Figure 3 Recrystallization inside the pores of calcite limestone (a, b,), calcite sandstone (c, d)
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.7
3.5
3.1
3.2
3.3
3.4
3.5
3.6
3.7
98 Spathis P., Papanikolaou E., Melfos V. et al: Characterization and Weathering of the Building
Materials of Sanctuaries in the Archaeological Site of Dion, Greece
The results of the study of the physical properties and
characteristic pores of the materials are shown in Tables 2
and 3 and Figure 4.
These results show that exist great differences in the
values of open porosity, water and capillary absorption
between the various building materials. Despite this, it is
observed that in all cases of materials the values of
capillary absorption are close to the corresponding values
of total water absorption indicating that capillary
absorption is enough for the materials to reach moisture
saturation conditions. It is also shown that a significant
amount of the capillary absorbed water remains in the
material after desorption in environmental conditions. In
the specific conditions of the archaeological area a
permanent intensive presence of surface and underground
waters for all periods of the year and high temperature
values in the dry periods of summer are observed, leading
in repeated cycles of wet-dry conditions of the materials.
From these results and observations, in correlation with
the observed main weathering products, secondary and
recrystallized calcite and dolomite, follow that the main
deterioration problem of the materials is the moisture
presence due to capillary action. The cycles of wet-dry
conditions lead to partial dissolution-recrystallization of
the carbonate material and loss of the structural cohesion
and the surface stability.
Table 2 Physical properties of the building materials of Asklepios and Demeter sanctuaries
Material
Property
Conglo
merate
Lime
stone -
calcite
Lime
stone -
dolomite
Sand
stone -
calcite
Sandstone -
dolomite
Ceramic
Plinth
Marble -
calcite
Marble -
dolomite
Bulk density, γ,
(gr/cm3)
2.56
2.42
2.81
4.04
1.84
1.82
1.99
1.61
Dry bulk
density, γ(d)
(gr/cm3)
2.72
2.59
2.84
5.41
1.93
2.78
2.01
1.62
Porosity
Open, Pop, %
5.69
6.45
0.99
25.46
4.61
33.67
1.15
0.86
Water
absorption,
Wab, %
2.24
3.69
0.47
9.31
3.42
18.41
0.98
0.65
Water
desorption
Wde, %
2.21
3.65
0.44
9.13
3.36
17.05
0.92
0.62
Capillary
absorption
Cab, %
1.80
3.40
0.43
7.72
2.90
17.00
0.86
0.61
Capillary
desorption
Cab, %
1.78
3.37
0.41
7.57
2.83
15.69
0.81
0.59
Remained % of
capillary
absorbed-
environmental
conditions
1.02
0.89
5.03
1.85
2.61
7.73
5.53
3.21
Remained % of
capillary
absorbed
0.31
0.37
0.79
1.12
1.85
0.29
2.35
1.14
Table 3 Pore size Distribution %
Material
Pore
size(μm)
Conglo
merate
Lime
stone,
calcite
Lime
stone,
dolom
Sand
stone,
calcite
Sand
stone,
dolom
Ceramic
Plinth
Marble,
calcite
Marble,
dolom
100-200
23.87
30.49
73.17
23.34
49.63
22.28
46.18
71.82
200-300
76.13
20.71
-
53.15
34.70
45.68
18.21
15.48
300-500
-
21.96
21.26
12.11
11.85
12.29
0.76
0.89
500-700
-
11.76
5.05
8.64
3.54
13.68
19.31
8.54
>700
-
15.00
0.52
2.76
0.28
6.07
15.55
3.27
Trends Journal of Sciences Research 2015, 2(3): 95-103 99
Figure 4 Photomicrographs of characteristic pores of calcite limestone (a, b,), calcite sandstone (c, d), ceramic plinth (e-f).
The results of the chemical analysis of bulk
precipitation and surface water for major anions are shown
in Figure 5.
In all surface water samples, ionic concentrations
followed the order nitrates>sulphates>chlorides while the
highest values were found in Vaphyras river. In all
samples, ionic concentrations were within the range of
values found in the river systems of Macedonia, northern
Greece[24-25].
All bulk precipitation samples exhibited alkaline pH
(6.5-7.5) suggesting neutralization of rainwater with
alkaline reagents, such as gaseous ammonia and
calcareous dust particles. Expectedly, bulk precipitation
samplers, which are continuously open, also sample gases
and particles deposited on the collection surface. With the
exception of May and June samples, that exhibited
extremely high sulphate content, concentrations ranged
between 4.1 and 16 mgL-1 in agreement with the range of
values found in wet-only precipitation samples in
Thessaloniki (2.5-30 mgL-1)[26-27]. Nitrate concentrations
were highest in April and May (13 and 17 mgL-1,
respectively), but in most months they were below 4.4
mgL-1, similarly to previous data. Finally, chlorides
exhibited somewhat elevated concentrations (2.4-39 mgL-
1) with highest values in May and June suggesting
possible transport of marine aerosol.
From these results it is evident that there are not
significant amounts of various ions such as chlorides,
nitrates or sulphates (except a period of two months of
rain water samples). This observation is in accordance
with the mentioned absence of crystallized salts on the
surface or inside the pores of the materials (only limited
gypsum was observed).
Figure 5 Concentrations (mgL-1) of sulphates, nitrates and chlorides in surface waters (A: Rillet A, B: Rillet B, C: Vaphyras river) and rainwaters (1:
Dec 2010, 2-12: Jan-Nov 2011)
100 Spathis P., Papanikolaou E., Melfos V. et al: Characterization and Weathering of the Building
Materials of Sanctuaries in the Archaeological Site of Dion, Greece
The results of the IR thermometer in situ measurements
are shown in Figures 6, 7 (sunny conditions) and Figures
8, 9 (wet conditions).
Since a moist porous material presents emittance
variations, moisture detection in porous stones by means
of IR thermometer measurements is feasible. IR
thermometry monitors the water movement in porous
materials and detects its impact by recording temperature
variations on the stones' surfaces. The presence of
moisture (lower temperatures) that arises as a result of the
capillary movement of water causes deterioration of the
building material. In such cases, the optical properties are
altered, the density, specific heat capacity and thermal
conductivity are also affected and so any temperature
changes are much slower in a moist area, as the energy
required to raise the temperature of a moist area would be
much greater than an area that is unaffected by water. In
all cases of IR thermometer in situ measurements, the
recorded temperatures on the side surfaces of the walls
increase with the distance from the ground. The
temperature differences depend mainly on the
environmental conditions (sunny or wet), also on the kind
of the material and the orientation of the wall, being
greater in sunny and smaller in wet conditions. The IR
thermometer measurements correlated with the water and
capillary absorption and desorption results (Table 2) and
also the permanent intensive presence of surface and
underground waters indicate that the main deteriorating
factor of the materials is the moisture penetration due to
capillary action. In sunny conditions, moisture penetrates
into the materials only by capillary absorption (greater
temperature differences, Figures 6, 7), while in wet
conditions rain water and environmental humidity
contribute also to the total moisture absorption (smaller
temperature differences, Figures 8, 9).
Figure 6 IR thermometer measurements, sunny conditions, Asklepios temple, a) north side, b) east side, c) south side, d) west side
Trends Journal of Sciences Research 2015, 2(3): 95-103 101
Figure 7 IR thermometer measurements, sunny conditions, Demeter sanctuary, Altar, a) north side, b) east side, c) south side, d) west side.
Figure 8 IR thermometer measurements, wet conditions, Asklepios temple, a) north side, b) east side, c) south side, d) west side
102 Spathis P., Papanikolaou E., Melfos V. et al: Characterization and Weathering of the Building
Materials of Sanctuaries in the Archaeological Site of Dion, Greece
Figure 9 IR thermometer measurements, wet conditions, Demeter sanctuary, Altar, a) north side, b) east side, c) south side, d) west side.
Conclusions
From the combination of laboratory experiments and in
situ IR thermometer measurements follow safe results
about the deterioration problems of the materials.
The surface of the building materials are partially
covered by the weathering products of the primary
minerals such as secondary calcite and dolomite
precipitated from water solutions, and recrystallized
calcite and dolomite.
Limited presence of crystallized salts on the surface or
inside the pores of the materials is observed.
Absence of significant amounts of various ions such as
chlorides, nitrates or sulphates is observed in the rain and
surface waters.
The main weathering factor of the materials is the
moisture penetration due to capillary action.
In sunny conditions, moisture penetrates into the
materials only by capillary absorption, while in wet
conditions rain water and environmental humidity
contribute also to the total moisture absorption.
The existence of water in the bulk of the materials due to
capillary penetration correlated with an intensive surface
and underground water presence in the whole surrounding
area lead to loss of the structural cohesion and the surface
instability of the building materials.
References
[1] Young, D., (2008) “Salt attack and rising damp, Technical Guide”
Melbourne, Australia
[2] Price, C.A., (1996) “Stone conservation: an overview of current
research” Getty Conservation Institute, Santa Monica, CA, xiii, 73 pp.
[3] Winkler, EM., (1997) “Stone in architecture: properties, durability”
Springer-Verlag, Berlin; New York, xvi, 313 pp.
[4] Lan, T.T.N., Nishimura, R., Tsujino, Y., Satoh, Y., Thoa, N.T.P.,
Yokoi, M., Maeda, Y., (2005) “The effects of air pollution and climatic
factors on atmospheric corrosion of marble under field exposure”
Corrosion Science, 47, 10231038.
[5] Skoulikidis, T., (2000) “Corrosion and conservation of the building
materials of the monuments” University Editions of Creta
[6] Moreno, F., Vilela, S.A.G, Antunes, A.S.G., Alves, C.A.S., (2006)
“Capillary-rising salt pollution and granitic stone erosive decay in the
parish church of Torre de Moncorvo (NE Portugal)-implications for
conservation strategy” Journal of Cultural Heritage, 7, 5666.
[7] Camuffo, D., Del Monte, M., Sabbioni, C., Vittori, O., (1982)
“Wetting deterioration and visual features of stone surfaces in an urban
area” Atmospheric Environment 16-9, 2253-2259.
[8] Camuffo, D., Del Monte, M., Sabbioni, C., (1983) “Origin and
growth mechanisms of the sulfated crusts on urban limestone” Water,
Air and Soil Pollution 19, 351-359.
[9] Del Monte, M., Sabbioni, C., Ventura, A., Zappia, G., (1984)
“Crystal growth from carbonaceous particulates” The Science of the
Total Environment 36, 247-254.
[10] Rodriguez-Navarro, C., Sebastian, E., (1996) “Role of particulate
matter from vehicle exhaust on porous stones (limestone) sulfation” The
Science of the Total Environment 187, 79-91.
[11] Keatings, K., Tassie, G.J., Flower, R.J., Hassan, F.A., Hamdan,
M.A.R., Hughes, M., Arrowsmith, C., (2007) “An Examination of
Groundwater Within the Hawara Pyramid, Egypt” Geoarchaeology: An
International Journal, 22, 5, 533554.
[12] Simao, J., Ruiz-Agudob, E., Rodriguez-Navarro, C., (2006) “Effects
of particulate matter from gasoline and diesel vehicle exhaust emissions
on silicate stones sulfation” Atmospheric Environment, 40, 6905–6917.
Trends Journal of Sciences Research 2015, 2(3): 95-103 103
[13] Sharma, P.K., Khandelwal, M., Singh, T.N., (2007) “Variation on
physico-mechanical properties of Kota stone under different watery
environments” Building and Environment, 42, 41174123.
[14] Moropoulou, A., Avdelidis, N.P., Koui, M., Kanellopoulos, N.K.,
(2000) Dual band infrared thermography as a NDT tool for the
characterization of the building materials and conservation performance
in historic structures. In: T. MATIKAS, N. MEYENDORF, G.
BAAKLINI, R. GILMORE ed. Nondestructive Methods for Materials
Characterization, Publ. Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, 591,
169-174.
[15] Moropoulou, A., Delegou, E.T., Avdelidis, N.P., (2002) “NDT
planning methodology of conservation interventions on historic
buildings”, In: R.V. GRIEKEN, K. JANSSENS, L. VAN`T DACK, G.
MEERSMAN, ed. 7th International Conference on Non-destructive
Testing and Microanalysis for the Diagnostics and Conservation of the
Cultural and Environmental Heritage, Book of Proceedings.
[16] Christaras, B., (1998) “Natural building stones. Technical
characteristics Non destructive methods of study. Notes for the post-
graduate courses of “Monument protection”, NTUA – Dept. of Chemical
Engineering.
[17] Papanikolaou, E., Spathis, P., Christaras, B., Melfos, V.,
Pingiatoglou, S., (2010) “Preliminary Observations on the Buinding
Materials and the Deterioration Problems of the Monuments of Demeter
and Asklepios Sanctuaries in the Arghaeological Site of Dion” 8th
International Symposium on the Conservation of Monuments in the
Mediterranean Basin, 31 May-2 June 2010 Patras, Greece.
[18] Papanikolaou, E., Spathis, P., Melfos, V., Christaras, B., Pavlidou,
E., (2011) “Characterization and Properties of the Building Materials for
the Determination of Weathering of Sanctuaries in the Archaeological
Site of Dion, Greece” Salt Weathering on Buildings and Stone
Sculptures, SWBSS 2011, Limassol, Cyprus, 19-22 October 2011.
[19] Papanikolaou E., Spathis P., Christaras B., Melfos V, Katsiotis
N.(2012): “Application of Infrared Thermometry and Ultrasonic Velocity
for the Investigation of the Building Materials of Historic Monuments of
Dion, Greece”, SPIE Smart Structures/NDE Symposium, San Diego,
California, USA, 11-15 March, 2012, "Smart Sensor Phenomena,
Technology, Networks, and Systems Integration V" Conference
(SSN08), "Cultural Heritage and Non Destructive Testing" Session.
[20] Papanikolaou E., Spathis P., Samara C., Melfos V., Christaras B.,
Sawidis T.. (2012): Effect of environmental factors to the deterioration of
stones monuments in the Archaeological Site of Dion. “Protection and
Restoration of the Environment XI” conference. Thessaloniki, Greece, 3-
6 July 2012.
[21] ICCROM ARC, Borrelli, E., Urland, A., (1999) “Laboratory
Handbook” Rome, Italy.
[22] Avdelidis, N.P., Moropoulou, A., Theoulakis, P., (2003) “Detection
of water deposits and movement in porous materials by infrared
imaging”, Infrared Physics & Technology, 44, 183-190.
[23] Avdelidis, N.P., Moropoulou, A., (2004) “Applications of infrared
thermography for the investigation of historic structures”, Journal of
Cultural Heritage, 5, 119127.
[24] Kouimtzis, Th., Samara, C., Voutsa, D., Zachariadis, G., (1994)
“Evaluation of Chemical Parameters in Aliakmon River/Northern
Greece. Part I: Quality Characteristics and Nutrients” J. Environ. Sci.
Health, A29(10), 2115-2126.
[25] Voutsa, D., Manoli, E., Samara, C., Sofoniou, M., and Stratis, I.,
(2001) “A study of surface water quality in Macedonia, Greece:
Speciation of nitrogen and phosphorus” Water, Air and Soil Pollution,
129: 13-32.
[26] Samara, C., Tsitouridou, R., Balafoutis, Ch., (1992) “Chemical
composition of rain in Thessaloniki, Greece in relation to meteorological
conditions” Atmospheric Environment 26B (3), 359-367.
[27] Samara, C. and Tsitouridou, R., (2000) “Fine and coarse ionic
aerosol components in relation to wet and dry deposition” Water, Air and
Soil Pollution, 120, 71-88.
... The characterization of materials in the artefacts and monuments of cultural heritage is very important because it offers valuable information to archaeology and to conservation science and practice. The most common building material found in the archaeological sites in Greece are limestone, conglomerate, sandstone, travertine and marble [1]. Marly limestone is the main construction material in the archaeological site of Pella, the capital of ancient Macedonia and the birthplace of Alexander the Great [2,3]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The goal of the study was to characterize the limestone that was used extensively in the ancient city of Pella (Macedonia, Greece), the birthplace of Alexander the Great. An on-site examination of the building material was carried out to record the types of damage and to select sampling areas. A variation in the nature of the stone and the degree of deterioration, even between the stones that comprise a specific monument structure, was observed, with water absorption and biological colonization being the main factors resulting in the deterioration of the stone. A comprehensive microanalysis and testing scheme was conducted to fully characterize the mineralogical, chemical, mechanical and thermal properties of the stones collected from various areas of the archaeological site. Optical microscopy, XRD and SEM–EDX were used to investigate the chemical composition and the structure of the stone samples. Finally, other properties, such as porosity, specific gravity and water absorption, were measured. Surface alterations, material degradation and biological deterioration were observed in most samples. The results obtained using XRD showed that the dominant mineral phase of the limestone is calcite, with quartz and clay minerals also detected in traces. The microscopic examination of the samples showed that the main natural stone at the archaeological site is a marly limestone. Thermographical measurements showed that the decay of the stones due to ambient temperature variation and corresponding contraction/expansion phenomena may be relatively limited, as the stone exhibited a low thermal diffusivity. Moreover, high porosity values (12.06–21.09%) and low compressive strength (11.3–27.7 MPa) were recorded, indicating the vulnerability of the stone and the need to take conservation measures.
... Pollution in the atmosphere is an important factor in causing decay. The presence of moisture increases weathering rate as water holds in solution and transports weathering agents on the material surface [1][2][3][4][5]. Typical such agents are sulphate, chloride, nitrite and nitrate ions that reacting with the hydrogen ions of water act as acids, attack the carbonate material and lead to the formation of sulphate, chloride and nitrate salts [6]. ...
Chapter
Full-text available
Moisture presence, salt precipitation and crystallization, temperature and ultraviolet radiation are main environmental factors of deterioration of the building materials of historic monuments. The presence of moisture in a material is due to rising and falling damp. Many commercial stone consolidation and water-repellent products contain tetraethoxysilane (TEOS). Synthesis of composite and nanocomposite coatings is an important method to improve the protective properties of these products. In this work composite coatings by adding silica nanoparticles to TEOS-based commercial products were synthesized. TEOS-based commercial products were RC-70 and RC-90. The type of silica nanoparticles used was Aerosil 200. As substrate dolomite marble specimens were used. The protective properties of the coatings were examined by water capillary absorption tests, salt spray tests and ultraviolet radiation tests. Coating characterization, the study of the morphologies of the surfaces and the investigation of the coatings behaviour in weathering conditions, was carried out by SEM, AFM, gravimetric measurements, optical observation and measurements of colour variation, contact angle and porosity. The protective properties of the coatings depended on the type of the polymeric material and the addition of silica nanoparticles. All coatings used protected marble against salt weathering and ultraviolet radiation. Polymeric coatings decreased porosity, surface roughness, water absorption, salt crystallization and the height of the capillary rise and increased contact angle values. Exposure in ultraviolet radiation conditions decreased in all cases contact angle values. Better protective properties were observed in the case of RC-90 in comparison to RC-70. This can be attributed to the increased elasticity of the structure of RC-90, due to the presence of the methylphenyl component. The addition of silica nanoparticles decreased porosity and improved the protective behaviour of the coatings against salt weathering and ultraviolet radiation.
Thesis
Full-text available
Karadağ, also known as Binbirkilise, which is located within the borders of the province of Karaman, had continued to exist as an important religious and cultural center, from the Hittites to the last periods of the Eastern Roman Empire. There are many monuments in the region that are dated to these periods. Among the region monuments; two tomb monuments are noteworthy for their period, construction systems and original forms. These tomb monuments were completely unearthed during the archaeological excavations carried out by the Karaman Museum in 2015. After archaeological excavations, deterioration problems started to appear in these tomb monuments. The deterioration problems observed in the monuments; It is determined that they have atmospheric, biological and anthropogenic origin. In order for these monuments to be sustainably protected and transferred to future generations, the deterioration in buildings and building stones and the mechanisms causing these deterioration must be accurately and precisely identified. After these diagnoses, it will be possible to develop a model proposal that will stop the deterioration mechanisms and create solutions against the deterioration. For these purposes; visual and architectural documentation of the monuments were made, the deterioration detected by observations in the monuments were mapped, lithological analysis of the building stones in the monuments were performed, NDT applications were made on the building stones of the monuments, and the ancient quarry where the building stones of the monuments were obtained was found and block samples were collected from there for laboratory experiments. From the collected samples, the characteristics of the rock used in the monuments were determined by laboratory studies. By comparing the geomechanical properties of the rock determined in the laboratory and data from NDT applications on building stones in the field, the deterioration of the building stones was determined. In the monuments, the deterioration detected and mapped by observation and the deterioration detected by NDT applications comparing, the factors causing the deterioration in the building stones were tried to be revealed. In addition, with seasonal NDT measurements, temperature and moisture behaviors that causing deterioration in the building stones were determined. As a result of the study, it has been determined that in the monuments, the sections showing the most deterioration are in the building stones that were uncontrollably uncovered from the soil by archaeological excavations and have the white crust on their surfaces, and are in the top cover of the monuments. In addition; building properties, building destructions, aspects and microclimatic conditions were also found to be effective on deterioration processes. In the light of these inferences, regarding the deterioration and deterioration mechanisms observed in the monuments; environmental improvement, stone correction, completion, integration, filling, injection, drainage and cleaning interventions have been proposed. / Keywords: Andesite building stone, Binbirkilise, deterioration, Karadağ, Karaman, non-destructive testing techniques (NDT), stone deterioration. ///// Karaman il sınırları içerisinde bulunan Karadağ, diğer adıyla Binbirkilise, Hititler’den Doğu Roma İmparatorluğu’nun son dönemlerine kadar, önemli bir dini ve kültürel merkez olarak varlığını sürdürmüştür. Bölgede, bu dönemlere tarihlenen, birçok anıt bulunmaktadır. Bölge anıtları içerisinde; ait oldukları dönem, inşa sistemleri ve özgün formları ile iki mezar anıtı dikkat çekmektedir. Bu mezar anıtları, 2015 yılında Karaman Müzesi tarafından gerçekleştirilen arkeolojik kazılar ile tamamıyla ortaya çıkartılmışlardır. Arkeolojik kazılar sonrasında, bu mezar anıtlarında, bozunma problemleri görülmeye başlanmıştır. Anıtlarda gözlenen bozunma problemlerinin; atmosferik, biyolojik ve antropojenik kökenli oldukları belirlenmiştir. Bu anıtların, sürdürülebilir bir biçimde korunması ve gelecek nesillere aktarılması için, yapılarda ve yapı taşlarındaki bozunmalar ile bu bozunmalara neden olan mekanizmaların, doğru ve hassas bir biçimde teşhis edilmesi gerekmektedir. Bu teşhislerden sonra, bozunma mekanizmalarını durdurabilecek ve bozunmalara karşı çözüm oluşturabilecek, bir model önerisi geliştirmek mümkün olabilecektir. Bu amaçlarla; anıtların görsel ve mimari belgelemeleri yapılmış, anıtlarda gözlem yoluyla tespit edilen bozunmalar haritalandırılmış, anıtlardaki yapı taşlarının litolojik analizleri gerçekleştirilmiş, anıtların yapı taşları üzerinde NDT uygulamaları yapılmış ve anıtların yapı taşlarının elde edildiği antik taş ocağı bulunarak, buradan laboratuvar deneyleri için blok numuneler derlenmiştir. Derlenen numunelerden, laboratuvar çalışmaları ile yapılarda kullanılan kayacın karakteristik özellikleri belirlenmiştir. Kayacın, laboratuvarda tespit edilen jeomekanik özellikleri ile sahada yapı taşları üzerinde gerçekleştirilen NDT uygulamalarından elde edilen veriler kıyaslanarak, yapı taşlarındaki bozunmalar belirlenmiştir. Anıtlarda, gözlem yoluyla tespit edilen ve haritalandırılan bozunmalar ve NDT uygulamaları ile tespit edilen bozunmalar karşılaştırılarak, yapı taşlarında bozunmaya neden olan faktörler ortaya konulmaya çalışılmıştır. Ayrıca, mevsimsel olarak yapılan NDT ölçümleri ile de yapı taşlarında bozunmaya neden olan sıcaklık ve nem davranışları tespit edilmiştir. Çalışma sonucunda anıtlarda, en çok bozunma gösteren kesimlerin, arkeolojik kazılar ile topraktan kontrolsüzce çıkartılan ve yüzeylerinde beyaz kabuk bulunan yapı taşları ile üst örtüde olduğu belirlenmiştir. Ayrıca; yapı özellikleri, yapı tahribatları, bakı ve mikroklimatik koşulların da, bozunma süreçleri üzerinde etkili oldukları görülmüştür. Bu çıkarımlar ışığında, anıtlarda gözlenen bozunmalara ve bozunma mekanizmalarına yönelik olarak; çevre iyileştirmesi, düzeltme, tamamlama, bütünleme, dolgu, enjeksiyon, drenaj ve temizlik müdahaleleri önerilmiştir. / Anahtar Kelimeler: Andezit yapı taşı, Binbirkilise, bozunma, Karadağ, Karaman, tahribatsız test teknikleri (NDT), taş bozunması.
Book
Full-text available
Petra, Angkor, Copan, Venice, Lascaux, Easter Island—all are examples of irreplaceable cultural heritage built in stone and now slowly disappearing. In 1996 the Getty Conservation Institute published Stone Conservation: An Overview of Current Research as a tool for conservators and conservation scientists to guide policy, practice, and research in the preservation of stone in monuments, sculpture, and archaeological sites. This second edition reflects the explosion of new research, enlarging the discussion of preventive conservation and adding new sections on rock art and other subjects. It provides a strategic overview of the intervening fifteen years in stone conservation research and an updated critique of the field's strengths and weaknesses. The accompanying bibliography summarizes material published between 1995 and 2009 and provides a framework for building a coherent base of useful knowledge for practicing conservators and scientists. Eric Doehne is a scientist at the Getty Conservation Institute. Clifford A. Price is emeritus professor of archaeological conservation at University College London.
Article
This article reviews all original research by the authors and their co-workers from 1964 to 1998, and the application of their results in monuments, especially in the Acropolis monuments. The corrosion and the replacement by titanium of the corroded steel clamps, junctions and skeleton (for the first time in monuments) are presented, as well as the observation for the first time that on the surface of gypsum films, formed on the surface of statues and sculptured ornaments, details of the reliefs are preserved. A new method is described for their consolidation by conversion of gypsum back into CaCO3. Also shown are: new non-destructive method of identifying gypsum and of measuring gypsum thickness; a new mixture of ameliorated lime for the consolidation of porous stones and monument surfaces; a new cleaning method; revealing the mechanism of sulphation of monument marbles and stones by a galvanic cell model; a new protective system using n-semiconductors; and a new method of preparation of artificial patinas.
Article
The sanctuaries of Demeter and Asklepios are part of the Dion archaeological site that sits among the eastern foothills of Mount Olympus and covers roughly 100 hectares. The excavations finds from this area are dated since the Hellenistic, Roman and Early Christian times. The main building materials are limestones and conglomerates. Sandstones, marbles, and ceramic plinths were also used. The materials consist mainly of calcite and/or dolomite, whereas the deteriorated surfaces contain also secondary and recrystallized calcite and dolomite, gypsum, various inorganic compounds, fluoroapatite, microorganisms and other organic compounds. Cracks and holes were observed in various parts of the stones. The most proper approach to select effective methods for the structural and surface consolidation, the cleaning, the protection and the overall conservation of these structures is the knowledge of the processes contributing to their deterioration. The influence of the water presence to the behavior of the materials was examined by in situ IR thermometer measurements. Temperature values increased from the lower to the upper parts of the building stones and they significantly depend on the orientation of the walls. The results indicate the existence of water in the bulk of the materials due to capillary penetration. To confirm these observations measurements of the following physical characteristics of the building materials have been studied: open porosity, pore size distribution, water absorption and desorption, capillary absorption and desorption. The existence of water in the bulk of the materials due to capillary penetration, the cycles of wet-dry conditions, correlated with the intensive surface and underground water presence in the whole surrounding area, lead to partial dissolution-recrystallization of the carbonate material and loss of the structural cohesion and the surface stability.
Article
Carbonaceous particle samples from an oil-fired power plant were collected by means of an in-stack isokinetic sampler. After a chemical and physical characterization of the carbonaceous particles collected, the successive formation of various crystalline species from the particles themselves was observed in controlled environmental conditions. The morphology, chemical composition and, when possible, the mineralogy of the single crystals found, were studied. A progressive order of formation of the crystals, nucleated from the carbonaceous particles is reported herein. However, the correlation between the nature of the carbonaceous matrix, its chemical composition and the order of formation of the crystals observed is still under investigation.
Article
This paper contains an overview of infrared thermography and its applications relating to the investigation of historic structures. In particular, this state of the art, non-destructive technique was used for the assessment of various traditional–historical materials and structures after they had been conserved, restored or repaired using, depending on the case, different treatments. Non-destructive testing and evaluation was performed on the materials and structures in order to assess the physicochemical behaviour of conservation treatments such as stone cleaning, stone consolidation, repair mortars, as well as to disclose any substrate features, such as tesserae on plastered mosaic surfaces. Wherever necessary, the emissivity values of the investigated materials were taken into account, after their determination in the laboratory on representative samples. The outcome of this work provides strong evidence that infrared thermography is an effective technique for the evaluation of historic buildings and sites.
Article
Since a large amount of damage in porous materials arises as a direct or indirect consequence of moisture (static and dynamic phenomena), detection and monitoring of moisture in porous materials is important, in an attempt to determine the actual damage, as well as the deterioration rate. The most common methodology to assess the moisture content in porous materials is to collect representative samples from the sites investigated and then weigh them before and after drying. In this research, infrared thermography, an indirect moisture assessment technique, was used in the investigation of various porous stones in the laboratory during capillary rise tests. Supplementary investigation of the stones in terms of their microstructure (mercury intrusion porosimetry) and isothermic behaviour (water sorption) was also performed. Finally, an in field diagnostic survey on historic structures was carried out. The results of this study indicate that infrared imaging provides significant information in the study of moisture in porous materials.
Article
The study of a full-scale granitic building (the parish church of Torre de Moncorvo, NE Portugal, 16th–17th centuries) allowed the investigation of geochemical characteristics of capillary-rising salt pollution and their relation to the development of erosive-decay features on granitic building stones. There is visible evidence of erosive decay affecting both stone and mortars in the parish church, with height-related distribution patterns that indicate the influence of capillary-rising solutions in the decay processes. Salt efflorescences detected in the parish church and in several places of the town evidence a widespread salt pollution affecting granitic stones and other building materials. Erosive decay in the parish church is more pronounced and extensive in the walls, principally in the portals (east, north and south). The sampling program included decayed granitic stones (to study the characteristic of salt pollution affecting the stones), soils between pavement slabs and lime mortar joints (considering that these media constitute passive and cumulative indicators of salt-pollution sources and conditions). Results of water-soluble extracts indicate geochemical patterns with height that support the importance of capillary-rising pollution and which indicate that erosive-decay features affecting granitic stones occur associated with a range of total salt load and with diverse ionic compositions in a single monument. Distribution of stone erosive-decay features and geochemical characteristics of water-soluble extracts of decayed building stones, lime mortar joints and soils also indicate that cycles of capillary-rising contamination and drying of stones are predominant factors in the development of erosive decay features that affect the granitic stones, favouring salt fractionation with height and surface concentration of soluble salts. These processes are especially active in the walls (particularly in the portals), which are more exposed to cycles of capillary rise of solutions (namely, by rainwater accumulation near the walls). The existence of level differences between outside pavement and inside floor (as observed in the south wall) constitutes an additional solutions reservoir that favour stone decay. Lime mortar joints in the columns of the church's nave show accentuated salt pollution, but the granitic stones in these columns do not evidence the accentuated erosive decay features found in the walls, highlighting the influence of cycles of capillary rise of solutions and drying of stones. These results are relevant to the conservation strategy of this monument. Conservation measures must include isolation from soils (moisture- and salt-contamination reservoirs) and removal of mortar joints (salt-contamination reservoirs). Since intense and extensive erosion of ornamental stone elements is observed, almost obliterating their artistic value, replacement of some stones should be pondered. Remediation of the present salt-contamination (desalination) on the remaining stones needs to be considered and applied soon after isolation from solutions sources (or even begun simultaneously), since the removal of capillary-rising moisture would favour crystallisation of soluble salts from salt solutions inside the porous media of the stones and further promote stone decay. Consolidation procedures are proposed after the contamination-sources removal and desalination procedures. Given the size of the affected volume, a phased intervention is proposed, beginning with the portals.
Article
The physico-mechanical properties of rocks play an important role in planning and designing of civil constructional works. These properties are adversely affected by acidic and alkaline environments, where they are exposed for a longer time. The natural forces and agents of weathering have degrading effect on the appearance and structural soundness of Kota stone. These agents include rain, temperature, wind and atmospheric pollutants. Weathering agents almost never work individually or in isolation, they always act in combination with one another or with other agents of deterioration.
Article
A two‐year survey on the water quality characteristics of Aliakmon river in northern Greece is described. Physicochemical parameters (temperature, acidity, alkalinity, conductivity, hardness), as well as nutrients and major ionic components (NO3 , NH4 , PO4 , SO4 , Cl) were determined and their concentration levels were related to the flow characteristics of the river and the influence from urban, agricultural and industrial activities.The quality of the water is discussed taking into account the fact that this river will be used in the near future for the water supply of the city of Thessaloniki.
Infrared thermography is a non-destructive investigation technique, which is largely used because of the outstanding advantages that it is capable to provide in a variety of applications and especially for conservation purposes of historic monuments, where destructive sectioning is prohibited. In the present work, dual band infrared thermography (3–5.4 μm and 8–12 μpm) is used, to evaluate the humidity distribution by capillary rise in reference samples of porous materials in lab, in order to validate the examination of real scale material systems in situ. The combined study of vapor/moisture transport in prototypes simulating porous materials under controlled environmental conditions (Relative Humidity 60–80% & Temperature 25–40°C), provides interpretation tools to the investigation by IR Thermography of transport phenomena occurring at the masonry. The cross-investigation of consolidated porous stones and of repair mortars, in lab and in situ on historic monuments in Greece, permits to evaluate the performance of conservation materials, regarding their compatibility to the porous building stones on historic masonries. It is deduced that Infrared Thermography by recording thermal maps of the real surfaces under study provides information on the differential behavior of the various materials on the masonry scale regarding the water impregnation and evaporation phenomena, which control the weathering effects in porous media. Hence, infrared thermography might be used as a nondestructive technique to evaluate on a micro and macro scale the performance of conservation interventions and materials, in compatibility to the original materials on the level of the structures.