ArticlePublisher preview available

Corrosion Detection in Pipelines Using Infrared Thermography: Experiments and Data Processing Methods

Authors:
  • Eniprogetti SpA (Entreprise of ENI group), Venice, Italy. Formerly Full Profesor at the National University of Rosario and Researcher of the National Scientific and Technical Research Council (Argentina)
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

This article summarizes the main results of an investigation about the corrosion detection in pipelines by infrared thermography, a non-destructive testing and evaluation technique that allows a reliable and fast analysis of large surfaces. The experimental work has been carried out in laboratory on a specimen that has been manufactured using a piece of a real pipeline system for oil transportation. Defects of different kinds have been artificially introduced in such a system to be tested by thermography. The objective is the detection and analysis of the presence of water in the pipeline jacketing system, that is the cause of the corrosion under insulation. Standards indicate thermography as a technique for the detection of this last phenomena, even though a precise procedure is not defined up today. This work aims at contributing in the specification of such a procedure.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
J Nondestruct Eval (2016) 35:49
DOI 10.1007/s10921-016-0365-5
Corrosion Detection in Pipelines Using Infrared Thermography:
Experiments and Data Processing Methods
G. Cadelano1·A. Bortolin1·G. Ferrarini3·B. Molinas2·
D. Giantin2·P. Zonta2·P. Bi son 1
Received: 29 April 2016 / Accepted: 9 August 2016 / Published online: 17 August 2016
© Springer Science+Business Media New York 2016
Abstract This article summarizes the main results of an
investigation about the corrosion detection in pipelines by
infrared thermography, a non-destructive testing and eval-
uation technique that allows a reliable and fast analysis of
large surfaces. The experimental work has been carried out
in laboratory on a specimen that has been manufactured
using a piece of a real pipeline system for oil transportation.
Defects of different kinds have been artificially introduced
in such a system to be tested by thermography. The objec-
tive is the detection and analysis of the presence of water
in the pipeline jacketing system, that is the cause of the
corrosion under insulation. Standards indicate thermogra-
phy as a technique for the detection of this last phenomena,
even though a precise procedure is not defined up today.
This work aims at contributing in the specification of such a
procedure.
Keywords Corrosion under insulation (CUI) ·Infrared
thermography (IRT) ·Higher-order statistics (HOS) ·
Pulse phase thermography (PPT) ·Principal component
thermography (PCT)
1 Introduction
Corrosion detection is one of the main fields covered by
the Non-Destructive Testing and Evaluation (NDT&E) tech-
niques in the last years and the principal problem for
BP. Bison
paolo.bison@itc.cnr.it
1CNR-ITC, Corso Stati Uniti, 4, 35127 Padua, Italy
2Tecnomare S.p.A., Via delle Industrie, 39-30175
Porto Marghera, Venice, Italy
3DII-UNIPD, via Venezia 1, 35131 Padua, Italy
industries such as the naval oil and energy among others
[13]. Significant savings could be achieved on maintenance
and repair cost if the prevention and early detection of hidden
corrosion is performed. Moreover, a greater safety could be
ensured if a possible failure is detected in advance, avoiding
disasters such as the piper Alpha in 1988 or the BP offshore
platform in 2010 [4,5].
There are different forms of corrosion in metals (uniform
attack, crevice corrosion, pitting galvanic corrosion, inter-
granular corrosion, selective leaching, erosion corrosion and
stress corrosion) that could cause an unexpected or prema-
ture failure of a structure or component. One form could be
more or less probable instead of the other depending on the
specific material and its environment.
In this study the objective is the detection of corrosion in
pipelines in which a hot fluid (90/130 C) flows through, as
commonly found e.g. in piping network for oil transportation
or chemical production plants. Particularly, extended corro-
sion on the bottom of the pipe has the appearance of cavities
and is considered very dangerous because even a small per-
centage of material loss can cause the failure of the system
with the consequent leakage of the fluid. There are many
NDT techniques that could be applied to inspect the presence
of corrosion (eddy currents, ultrasounds, radiography, etc.)
[69] each one with advantages and drawbacks. There is not
an ultimate means of corrosion detection for all the corrosion
forms. The most suitable technique must be selected con-
sidering each particular case. InfraRed Thermography (IRT)
could be one of these techniques and the purpose of this work
is to verify its potentiality. IRT as an NDT&E technique pro-
vides a reliable, fast and straightforward means to retrieve
vital information (surface and subsurface) when a clear
relationship exists between surface temperature and defect.
Moreover, large areas can be scanned with a relatively high
throughput. The ultimate goal is to test the detection capabil-
123
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... In 2012, Burleigh and Sanders [18], based on the research results of the crude oil pipeline with foam insulation and galvanized metal jacket in Alaska, described in detail the specific operation process, analysis method, precautions, and applicable conditions of using IRT to detect whether water is contained in the foam insulation in engineering. In 2016, G. Cadelano et al. [19] established an experimental setup to simulate the sublayer corrosion of carbon steel thermal pipes with an aluminum protective jacket and glass wool insulation. as shown in Fig. 5. ...
... Sub-layer water corrosion inspection in pipelines based on IRT[19] ...
Article
Among all the feasible solutions for current energy transportation and the resulting cost, environmental, and safety issues, pipeline transportation is undoubtedly one of the most widely used and promising energy transportation solutions. However, pipelines are inevitably exposed to various damage risks during operation. Therefore, regular health monitoring and evaluation are essential for safe pipeline operation. Transmission pipelines are protected by cladding, and conventional inspection methods for such pipelines face complex problems that affect their technical performance and feasibility. To overcome these problems, the innovative application of traditional detection techniques, the refinement of implementation methods, and the development of new detection techniques are imperative. However, few review articles are available in this area. This article provides an overview of the studies on NDT techniques and implementation methods for pipelines with cladding, including recent research results, current application status, challenges, and future research potential. First, the detection techniques used for pipelines with cladding are categorized, their detection principles are presented, and their advantages and disadvantages are summarized. In addition, the experimental results of pipeline detection methods with cladding are analyzed to demonstrate their application capabilities. Then, the latest proposed pipeline detection techniques and their implementation methods are presented, and their ideas are summarized. Finally, an outlook on the challenges facing pipeline inspection techniques without cladding removal is given, including recommendations, developments, and implementation methods.
... Cadelano et al. [20] proposed a system detecting corrosion in pipelines using ITT. The authors applied infrared thermography to a sectioforn of the pipeline under laboratory conditions while the liquid was heated to approximately 90 degrees through the pipeline to analyse the thermal effect of the pipeline due to the presence of water. ...
Article
Full-text available
Liquids such as water, chemicals, oil, and gas are mostly transported via pipelines worldwide. It is considered one of the fastest, cheapest, and most reliable methods of transporting oil and gas. One of the major threats to this form of transportation of liquids is leakage due to vandalism or deterioration causing economic loss, environmental damages, and loss of lives and properties. To mitigate these threats, several techniques have been proposed. This systematic review analysed the various principles and approaches of pipeline leakage detection and monitoring. Furthermore, relevant standard, taxonomy of different methods of monitoring, and leakage detection of oil and gas in pipelines were discussed; their merits, performance and limitations were also discussed. Kitchenham literature search strategy was adopted to search relevant academic databases using various principles of inclusion and exclusion criteria to filter unaligned articles. It was found that integrating two or more techniques enhances the efficiency, effectiveness and accuracy of detecting and monitoring leakages in pipeline. Finally, this review concludes by outlining potential ways for future researchers based on the limitations and findings of the reviewed articles.
... Infrared thermography (IRT) is an extensively used imaging method in non-destructive testing (NDT), which efficiently identifies flaws by visualizing heat patterns on material, providing reliable and rapid nondestructive testing and evaluation (NDT&E) to extract critical information about both surface and subsurface conditions, mainly when there is a correlation between surface temperature and defects [14]. Thermographic studies are done to obtain results that help us infer the effect of acid corrosion on crevices. ...
Article
Full-text available
Magnesium alloys have garnered significant attention in the aerospace and marine industries due to their exceptional mechanical properties, including low density and a high strength-to-weight ratio. Despite these advantages, their widespread adoption is hindered by susceptibility to corrosion, particularly under harsh environmental conditions. While considerable research has focused on uniform surface corrosion of magnesium alloys, studies addressing hidden corrosion remain limited. Hidden corrosion is a critical defect that can severely compromise the structural integrity of aging aircraft. In this study, the hidden corrosion behavior of the AZ91 magnesium alloy was explored using infrared thermographic non-destructive testing. Seven blind holes were drilled into the surface of the alloy, which was then exposed to simulated acid rain for ten days to examine the effects of corrosion. The rate of corrosion in the drilled samples was observed to be slightly higher compared to bare samples, likely due to the accumulation of acid in the crevices. Changes in the initial and final hole dimensions and volume were used to determine the corrosion rate, providing valuable insights into the mechanisms governing hidden corrosion in magnesium alloys. This work offers a deeper understanding of hidden corrosion, with potential implications for improving the longevity and safety of critical aerospace and marine components.
... It's sensitive to the objects with varying materials and shapes at the same temperature, enabling the detection of anomalies such as water accumulation, circumferential welds, and foreign objects. Cadelano et al. [6] summarized the main research outcomes of the pipeline corrosion detection in which a hot fluid (90/130 ℃) flows through with IRT. Zhou et al. [7] explored the thermal response mechanisms of defects at different locations were detected using IRT in order to detect and evaluate corrosion defects of different types and depths in pipelines. ...
Article
The inspection of oil and gas pipeline retains important. These newly constructed pipelines may have defects near the circumferential welds and potential issues with water accumulation. Improper management of these issues can lead to severe consequences. Thus, the inner pipe structure detection prior to their operation is critically essential. Visual camera provides a direct view of the pipeline environment such as circumferential weld seams and water accumulation. In contrast, infrared thermal camera capture infrared radiation distribution from varied shapes and materials, offering an indirect insight into the pipeline environment. This paper designs an integrated infrared and visual NDT system for pipeline detection, capable of capturing time-synchronized infrared and visible image pairs along with corresponding odometer and gyroscope data for further processing. Moreover, an infrared and visual fusion detection algorithm is proposed, comprising coarse registration, base detectors, and probability-based late fusion strategy. The late fusion strategy enhances detection accuracy by leveraging the complementary information from both infrared and visual modalities. Furthermore, as the focus is primarily on the defects near the circumferential welds, the size of the circumferential welds in forward images can be used to predict their position in the circumferential visual detection system, achieving a 96.7% reduction in computational complexity compared to processing all images. The proposed system and algorithm were actually tested in a 26.8 km 1219 pipeline. The results verified the reliability of the system and the robustness and accuracy of the algorithm. The demo code is available at: [https://github.com/ljcuestc/Probability-based-late-fusion.git].
... It provides a reliable, fast, direct evaluation method with a broad response range. It uses infrared imaging systems (such as infrared cameras) to record electromagnetic waves emitted by objects and establish a clear relationship between temperature and material corrosion defects [53]. The advantages of IRT are as follows: as a non-invasive technique, IRT does not affect the target [51,54] and can safely monitor very high temperatures or dangerous objects [54]; IRT provides two-dimensional images for comparison of different regions of the target [54]; IRT is an online (real-time) monitoring technique that can achieve large-scale real-time monitoring (with the help of advanced image processing techniques) [32,54,55]. ...
Article
Full-text available
A series of advanced equipment exposed to sub-/supercritical water environments at high temperatures, high pressures, and extreme water chemistry with high salt and dissolved oxygen content faces serious corrosion problems. Obtaining on-site corrosion data for typical materials in harsh environments is crucial for operating and maintaining related equipment and optimizing various corrosion prediction models. First, this article introduces the advantages and disadvantages, usage scenarios, and future development potential of several in situ monitoring technologies, including ultrasonic thickness measurement, the infrared thermography method, microwave imaging, eddy current detection, and acoustic emission. Considering the importance of electrochemical corrosion data in revealing microscale and nanoscale corrosion mechanisms, in situ testing techniques such as electrical resistance probes, electrochemical corrosion potential, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, and electrochemical noise that can be applied to sub-/supercritical water systems were systematically discussed. The testing platform and typical data obtained were discussed with thick and heavy colors to establish a mechanical prediction model for corrosion behavior. It is of great significance to promote the development of corrosion monitoring techniques, such as breaking through testing temperature limitations and broadening the industrial application scenarios and maturity.
... Until now, various NDT methods have been reported in the literature to address the challenge of CUI inspection without removing the insulation, including infrared thermography [3], long-range guided wave ultrasonic testing [4], radiography [5], neutron backscatter [6], optical fiber-based water sensing [7], capacitive imaging [8], and pulsed eddy-current testing (PECT) [2,[9][10][11][12]. Among them, PECT has seen steady development and increased applications in recent years. ...
Article
Full-text available
Corrosion under insulation (CUI) is a major threat to the structural integrity of insulated pipes and vessels. Pulsed eddy-current testing (PECT) is well known in the industry for detecting CUI, but its readings can be easily influenced by nearby conductive objects, including the insulation supporting metal mesh. As a sequel to our previous study, this paper focuses on the surface distribution of eddy currents at the time of the turning off of the driving voltage instead of examining the overall process of eddy current diffusion. Based on the fact that CUI takes place on the outside of the insulated specimen, the probe footprint was calculated only on the specimen surface. The corrosion depth was regarded as an increment to the probe lift-off, whose information was carried in the early PECT signal. Finite element simulations were performed to facilitate the calculation of the probe footprint and predict the signal behavior. The peak value, which appeared in the early phase of the differential PECT signal, was found to be well correlated with the corrosion depth. Further studies revealed that the mild steel mesh could result in the enlargement of the probe footprint and a decrease in the change rate of the peak value in relation to the corrosion depth. Finally, experiments were conducted to verify the simulation results. The presented findings are consistent with the previously reported results and provide a potential alternative to evaluate CUI in specific scenarios where the insulation has a fixed and uniform thickness.
Article
The transportation of oil and gas through pipelines is crucial for sustaining energy supply in industrial and civil sectors. However, the issue of pitting corrosion during pipeline operation poses an important threat to the structural integrity and safety of pipelines. This problem not only affects the longevity of pipelines but also has the potential to cause secondary disasters, such as oil and gas leaks, leading to environmental pollution and endangering public safety. Therefore, the development of a highly stable, accurate, and reliable model for predicting pipeline pitting corrosion is of paramount importance. In this study, a novel prediction model for pipeline pitting corrosion depth that integrates the sparrow search algorithm (SSA), regularized extreme learning machine (RELM), principal component analysis (PCA), and residual correction is proposed. Initially, RELM is utilized to forecast pipeline pitting corrosion depth, and SSA is employed for optimizing RELM’s hyperparameters to enhance the model’s predictive capabilities. Subsequently, the residuals of the SSA-RELM model are obtained by subtracting the prediction results of the model from actual measurements. Moreover, PCA is applied to reduce the dimensionality of the original 10 features, yielding 7 new features with enhanced information content. Finally, residuals are predicted by using the seven features obtained by PCA, and the prediction result is combined with the output of the SSA-RELM model to derive the predicted pipeline pitting corrosion depth by incorporating multiple feature selection and residual correction. Case study demonstrates that the proposed model reduces mean squared error, mean absolute percentage error, and mean absolute error by 66.80%, 42.71%, and 42.64%, respectively, compared with the SSA-RELM model. Research findings underscore the exceptional performance of the proposed integrated approach in predicting the depth of pipeline pitting corrosion.
Article
This paper addresses the problem of internal pitting corrosion in metals. The approach to solving this problem is carried out by means of long-pulse thermography (step heating) and digital image processing, using the median filter in the pre-processing and the Fourier transform in the processing. The long pulse thermography technique is an excellent way of detecting corrosion in metals. According to the state of the art, most of the works reviewed detect only the presence of external corrosion. In the experiments plates of different thickness were evaluated, one of 2 mm and another of 8 mm; this is another point in favor since most of the reviewed articles only focus on a single sample. In the development of this project, the following lines of research have been identified: implementation of new digital image processing methods, improvement of the thermography technique using other energy sources to heat the plates in a shorter time, exploring other functions of image processing in programming languages, carrying out tests with plates of different thickness and size, measuring the percentage of corrosion.
Article
Full-text available
In this paper a novel approach is proposed which combines simultaneously advantages both of pulse (PT) and modulated (MT) infrared thermography. In a nondestructive evaluation perspective, the specimen is pulse-heated as in PT and the mix of frequencies of the thermal waves launched into the specimen are unscrambled by performing the Fourier transform of the temperature evolution over the field of view. Of interest is the maximum phase image with many attractive features: deeper probing, less influence of surface infrared and optical characteristics, rapid image recording (pulse heating, surface -wide inspection), possibility to inspect high thermal conductivity specimens. Several results are presented and the theory is discussed as well. - 2 - 1. Introduction Infrared thermography (IT) is a nondestructive evaluation (NDE) method with an increasing span of applications 1,2,3 . To summarize briefly the principle of operation, in the active scheme, an external thermal stimulation is...
Article
Full-text available
Since the piper Alpha disaster in 1988, many changes have been implemented across world offshore regions. The emanating points for these sweeping changes have been the Cullen Report and the UK North Sea industry. However, there are many secondary, finer points that constitute important lessons learnt, many of which still need to be addressed, if pragmatic life cycle safety and performance are to be recognized. This review looks at such major changes instigated by step changes in safety criticality regarding offshore assets. It is argued that the second tier modes of failure, such as internal corrosion, environmental cracking, erosion, etc., have been somewhat overlooked. These mechanisms are equally major threats to the integrity of any infrastructure, especially within high-risk deepwater and arctic applications. It is noted that such root causes of failure as witnessed in practice or as predicted in theory have yet to be appraised fully, and as a result such frontier areas may be sitting on the proverbial time bomb if due attention is not fully paid. The authors use wide experiences post Piper Alpha to highlight worries and concerns, offering rational pragmatic solutions through related case histories. Conclusions and recommendations are based on cross-asset interpretations and verified, with solutions offered. The clear industry disconnects between knowledge transfer and management under this tutelage are identified, and refocused. Powerful advances in mechanical, materials, and corrosion engineering are emphasized and the use of key performance indicators (KPIs) is reasoned for best life-cycle integrity management. This is important where surprise failures, environmental and political snafus are not an option. It is argued that more purposeful design investment at CAPEX is more amenable than at OPEX, and the gray zone between the two cost centers must be bridged to industry advantage. Introduction On the 6th of July 1988, the world's worst offshore oil industry disaster occurred on the Piper Alpha platform in the UK sector of the North Sea. The loss of life was staggering: 167 dead, with 62 survivors, and dozens badly injured. Wood Group itself lost 39 employees in that tragedy. Much has been written and debated on the incident. This paper examines a new angle on the subject matter, and that is the closer review of so called secondary items of interest. These are corrosion-related items that have been accepted as pertinent over the years, but generally and often erroneously perceived with less priority. This is largely because the subject matter is considered too specialistic, or complex and often requiring costly subject matter expertise. As a result, corrosion integrity is sometimes erroneously and dangerously taken off the agenda by non-subject-appreciative project or even industry leaders. This paper delves into this sometimes contentious area, examines the role of corrosion mechanisms in the root cause analyses of most significant failures and virtually all loss of performance issues. The interpretations are made with the support of solid observations and new understandings in the direct context of integrity and corrosion management. The authors come from a mixed blend of offshore disciplines, with over 80 years of combined experience, predominantly from the North Sea and Gulf of Mexico. The objectives are aimed to be educational and not controversial, but the opinions are strong and considered very worthy of continued debate and development.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The automatic detection of subsurface defects has become a desired goal in the application of non-destructive testing and evaluation techniques. In this paper, an algorithm based on the fourth order standardised statistic moment, i.e. kurtosis, is proposed for detection and/or characterization of subsurface defects having a thermal diffusivity either higher or lower than the host material. The analysis of thermographic data for the detection of defects can be reduced to the temporal statistics of the thermographic sequence. The final result provided by this algorithm is an image showing the different defects without the necessity of establishing other evaluating parameters such as the delayed time of the first image or the acquisition frequency in the analysis, which are required in other processing techniques. All the information is contained in a single image allowing to discriminate between the defect types (high o low thermal diffusivity). Synthetic data from Thermocalc and experimental works using
Article
IR (infrared) inspection is being used to inspect oil pipelines on the North Slope of Alaska. The object of this inspection is to detect water trapped in the foam insulation around the steel pipes before it can cause corrosion that could result in a pipeline leak. This is referred to as Corrosion Under Insulation (CUI). The same method can be used to inspect insulated pipelines containing LNG (liquid natural gas), steam, heated chemicals, cryogenic fluids, etc. As long as the temperature in the pipe is substantially different (+ or -) than the ambient temperature, the IR evaluation method can work. Analysis can predict whether it will work for a specific application and operating conditions. IR can scan multiple pipes quickly and is a good qualitative screening method for detecting water trapped in insulation. Anomalies found by IR are evaluated further using RT ("C-Arm" or other RT technique) or other NDT methods. RT is a relatively slow technique compared to IR, but it is capable of detecting both water and pipe wall thinning. When the water level is high enough to reach the steel pipeline, corrosion of the pipe can occur. In this case, the corrosion is from the outside of the pipe inward. Other corrosion and erosion may take place from the inside out. Corrosion and erosion can eventually result in a hole in the pipe, which results in a leak. Thermal modeling has been performed to predict the environmental conditions under which IR testing will be successful. IR test procedures have been written and a personnel certification program has been implemented.
Article
Corrosion in metals is simulated with variations in plate thickness which are laterally infinite in a 1D model and are represented by milled flat-bottom holes in a 2D model. Temperature contrast over corroded areas is chosen as an informative parameter, quite independent of absorbed thermal energy in the infra-red thermographic test. It is shown that, due to lower sensitivity to rear-side effects at the beginning of the thermal process and increasing 3D heat diffusion effects at the end of the process, there is an optimum time to detect corrosion. A robust inversion function is proposed and its stability against variations in tested material, heat pulse duration and observation time is analysed using numerical modelling. Corrosion in a steel specimen of 1.3 mm thickness is experimentally studied, having proved the validity of the inversion algorithm with an average accuracy of 17% for material loss ranging from 74 to 14%.
Article
Active thermography has reached a high status as a non-destructive evaluation method due to both ease and speed of inspection. Nevertheless, automatic processing of an infrared (IR) sequence is essential in order to reduce human intervention. Unfortunately, this target is difficult to achieve given the amount of data recorded by the IR camera during a typical inspection process and human participation is absolutely necessary. In this paper, higher-order statistics (HOS) analysis is employed to process IR sequences and to compress the most useful information into a unique image for each inspection. Pulsed infrared thermographic temporal response is well-known with a statistical behaviour. This statistical behaviour is analyzed and the results of its application to carbon fibres reinforced plastic (CFRP) samples are reported. [All rights reserved Elsevier].