ArticlePDF Available

Debating education for nation building in Malaysia: National school persistence or vernacular school resistance?

Authors:

Abstract

School and education system may be a critical and strategic platform for nation-building. At the same time, the politicization of the education system as well as the interdependent nature of schools and external forces may contribute to the destabilization of the role of school in nation building. In Malaysia, the issue of mono-lingualism as a medium of instruction in schools has been a contested one with efforts of accommodating bilingualism and multilingualism continue to be attempted with no solutions in sight. The persistence of vernacular schools has generated both intense debates and resistance. This article examines the reasons for the resistance to, and persistence of vernacular schools. The data were drawn from three main sources, namely interviews with heads and/or representatives of 12 schools (mostly national schools and Chinese schools) from four states namely Selangor, Kelantan, Sarawak and Sabah as part of a wider project on social cohesion study as well as newspapers and web sources. The resistance to vernacular schools was premised on the affirmation that national schools rest on the idea of inculcating and sustaining national identity as well as facilitating cross-cultural experience and communication while eliminating the more segregating and divisive forces in vernacular schools. By contrast, the persistence of vernacular schools pertains to the idea of sustaining minority cultural identity, countering the lack of national schools' sense of accommodation and questionable quality of education, and refuting the perception of vernacular schools as structural cause of disunity. Besides these negotiation difficulties of cultural identities in the school system, wider power politics and market politics interplay in influencing the resistance and persistence of vernacular schools.
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 14
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
Debating education for nation building in Malaysia: National school
persistence or vernacular school resistance?
Sivapalan Selvadurai¹, Ong Puay Liu2, Marsitah Mohd Radzi3, Ong Puay Hoon4, Ong Puay Tee5,
Badariah Saibeh2
1Faculty of Social Sciences and Humanities, Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia, 2Institute of Ethnic Studies
(KITA), Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, Bangi, Selangor, Malaysia, 3Faculty of Humanities, Arts and Heritage, Universiti Malaysia
Sabah, Kota Kinabalu, Sabah, Malaysia, 4Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Universiti Malaysia Sarawak, Kuching,
Malaysia, 5Faculty of Business, Multimedia University, Melaka, Malaysia
Correspondence: Sivapalan Selvadurai (email: sivap02@gmail.com)
Abstract
School and education system may be a critical and strategic platform for nation-building. At the same time, the
politicization of the education system as well as the interdependent nature of schools and external forces may
contribute to the destabilization of the role of school in nation building. In Malaysia, the issue of mono-lingualism
as a medium of instruction in schools has been a contested one with efforts of accommodating bilingualism and
multilingualism continue to be attempted with no solutions in sight. The persistence of vernacular schools has
generated both intense debates and resistance. This article examines the reasons for the resistance to, and
persistence of vernacular schools. The data were drawn from three main sources, namely interviews with heads
and/or representatives of 12 schools (mostly national schools and Chinese schools) from four states namely
Selangor, Kelantan, Sarawak and Sabah as part of a wider project on social cohesion study as well as newspapers
and web sources. The resistance to vernacular schools was premised on the affirmation that national schools rest on
the idea of inculcating and sustaining national identity as well as facilitating cross-cultural experience and
communication while eliminating the more segregating and divisive forces in vernacular schools. By contrast, the
persistence of vernacular schools pertains to the idea of sustaining minority cultural identity, countering the lack of
national schools sense of accommodation and questionable quality of education, and refuting the perception of
vernacular schools as structural cause of disunity. Besides these negotiation difficulties of cultural identities in the
school system, wider power politics and market politics interplay in influencing the resistance and persistence of
vernacular schools.
Keywords: Chinese school, education, lingualism, National school, social identity, vernacular school
Introduction
Ideally Malaysians would like to believe they have a collective culture that captures the imagination of its
people as one nation. However the social reality in the socio-political landscape is otherwise because the
idea of modern state, the understanding of the people and the execution of the institutional process differ.
Prior to colonization, the country was led by Malay sultanate and feudal structures with distant
contacts in this part of the world between the eastern Chinese frontier and western Indian and Islamic
frontier. After Western colonization, the people were exposed and socialized to different sets of
institutional structures. The influxes of economic migrants from China and India through the colonial
economic agenda created a complex socio-political landscape with the formation of a plural society. This
has led to an amalgam of structures and institutions that underpin the country’s education and school
system.
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 15
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
The current education system in Malaysia has its origins in the pre-Independence era (Ong et al.,
2013). The British introduced secular education with English as the medium of instruction and later other
vernacular schools, classified according to the language of instruction, were the Malay, Chinese, and
Tamil schools. The British colonial ‘indirect’ rule in 1874 through the residents’ system was an
interventionist move that enable the introduction of formal English education into the Malayan school
system, which later became ‘national schools’. The curriculum of these schools had much in common
with the British schools. Emphasis was given to the acquisition of the three R’s (Reading, wRiting,
aRithmetic) during primary school. Most of the time spent on teaching was specifically for aiding
children whose mother tongue was mainly Malay, Tamil, Cantonese and Hokkien.
What was witnessed was the existence of multi-lingual school system with vernacular schools having
separate medium of instruction. Besides vernacular language for the Malays, the British felt obligated to
provide a basic form of education designed to teach the children of the local people to do subsistence
farming and fisher. The Chinese and Indian communities established their vernacular schools with school
curricula and teachers from China and India respectively. In 1913, the first Chinese school was set up in
Malaya (then in Singapore). Chinese schools saw the introduction of English and Malay language in 1945
where later the accommodation of language and culture issues was settled through the Fenn-Wu Report
(1951). Also the syllabus in all Chinese schools was reviewed to reflect the local context.
The characteristics of the Chinese school differ as there are two types of Chinese schools, namely
vernacular Chinese school (at the primary level) and independent Chinese school (at the secondary level).
In this article, reference is made to the vernacular Chinese school which follows the national curriculum.
Many students in these vernacular Chinese schools, after completion of their primary education, move to
national secondary schools where the medium of instruction is in Malay. This system would make the
students from Chinese-medium schools trilingual and all other pupils at least bilingual (those from Tamil
schools and Arabic/religious schools are also trilingual). Chinese schools would thus be integrated into
the national system and yet not be abolished.
Meanwhile the scenario in national schools after independence in Peninsular Malaysia saw a shift to
Malay language as the medium of instruction in the 1970s with the eventual completion of the task in
1978 (David & Govindasamy, 2005). In Malaysia, the setting up of vision schools involves placing a
national school and other vernacular schools (i.e. Chinese and Tamil schools) together at the same site to
share common facilities such as the school canteen and sports ground. It is hoped various races will
encourage greater interaction between them and foster national unity (Mohd Izham & Jamallullail, 2010).
With the exception of the English national schools and Christian missionary schools, the vernacular
schools comprised mainly of pupils from a single ethnic group. However, while this is true for Tamil
schools, statistics for Chinese schools show that 15% of students studying at the nearly 1,300 Chinese
primary schools in the country are non-Chinese (Wong, 2014).
The identification of vernacular schools by linguistic affiliation and ethnic groups consolidated the
cultural divide especially at the primary school level. This divide was further solidified by geographical
location as the majority of the Malays tend to reside in rural villages, with the Chinese in urban areas, and
the Indians in rural plantation areas. These diverse schools had diverse management and financial
resources which comprised of government-maintained schools, missionary schools, non-profit schools,
and privately funded schools (Ong et al., 2013) which further enhanced the social divide.
In 2003, the Ministry of Education mandated the use of English for teaching all Mathematics and
Science subjects in order to prepare its student population for competition in an increasingly globalized
market. However this bilingual policy was reversed in 2012 with both subjects now being taught in Malay
language.
School and education are critical components of State agenda as they concern public interest and have
become a critical and strategic platform in nation-building, of which national school is viewed as a
strategic educational tool (Azly Rahman, 2013). However historical and political attempts to consolidate
all schools under a single stream national school have failed even in the postcolonial era. Even prior to
independence the intent in establishing national schools has encountered resistance from the Chinese
fraternity. On the opposing front, the resistance to vernacular schools has also gained momentum. The
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 16
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
issue of mono-lingualism as a medium of instruction in national schools has been a contested one.
Attempts to accommodate bilingualism and multilingualism are ongoing in Malaysia with no solutions in
sight. However, two key personalities - one an educationist (UiTM pro-chancellor Abdul Rahman
Arshad) in 2012 and another a politician (Cheras Umno chief Syed Ali Alhabshee) in 2014 have urged the
government to look into setting up a single-stream school system to overcome the barrier towards racial
unity posed by the multi-stream. The most recent call for the abolition of vernacular schools was the
Hapuskan SJKC’ [Get rid of SJKC] banners displayed during the Malaysia Day 16 September 2015 rally
by the ‘Red Shirts’, dubbed ‘the#Merah169’ (Malay Mail Online, 2015).
Why is there resistance to vernacular schools when it is perceived to be performing well? Why hasn’t
the national school been popular among the minorities? Why did the vernacular school persist? Why the
resistance to national school implementation?
The objective of this article is to examine the reasons for the resistance to and persistence of
vernacular school. The data were drawn from three main sources, namely interviews with 12 schools
(mostly national schools and Chinese schools), heads and/or representatives from four states namely
Selangor, Kelantan, Sarawak and Sabah as part of a wider project on social cohesion study (see
acknowledgement) as well as newspapers and web sources.
Literature review
There are two sources for the literature review namely theoretical and empirical sources related to the
question of language and identity in schools, with particular reference to the issue of persistence and
resistance to vernacular school.
Theories on language and identity-politics
There are two strands of theory with regard to the debate on language as medium of instruction in national
schools and vernacular schools. These theories explain the relationship between language and identity
through social identity theory and postcolonial theory.
The social identity theory is premised on the socio-psychological approach which assumes a direct
relationship between language and ethnic identity where language contact is seen as an outcome through
group membership. Tajfel’s famous social identity theory contends that groups are formed on the bases of
self-definition, attraction, and cultural participation (Bagby & Rector, 1992). Giles and Byrne (1982)
proposed a theory of ethnolinguistic identity where ethnolinguistic vitality provides a subjective feeling of
belonging to a particular group (in Pavlenko & Blackledge, 2004). This theory suggests language as a
salient marker of ethnic identity and group membership (in Pavlenko & Blackledge, 2004). There are two
ways of viewing this relationship between language and group membership and identity. If the mother
tongue language and ethnic identity of the minority group are strong, it suggests a strong in-group
identification, in-group vitality high, in-group boundaries are closed and identification with other groups
weak and low likelihood to assimilate and learn the second language. Opposing characteristics are
observed if the in-group identification is weak.
Meanwhile the post-structural and related postcolonial critical approaches view identity as
multidimensional, contingent and subject to negotiation across context (Doran, 2004). Here language is
used as a key for strategic enactment of subject positions projecting particular aspects of their social
identities and downplaying others in particular settings. Language ideologies, ethnic and national
identities are linked to relations of power and political arrangement in communities and societies
(Pavlenko & Blackledge, 2004). Language choices in multilingual contexts are assumed to be embedded
in larger social, political, economic and cultural systems. Bourdieu (1991) views linguistic practices as a
form of symbolic capital convertible into economic and social capital and distributed unequally within
any speech community especially in terms of linguistic stratification (in Pavlenko & Blackledge, 2004).
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 17
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
Postcolonial theory extends this post-structural view by contesting and rejecting meta-narratives of
universal ideas of modern education, nation state, homogenous identity, and universalizing tendencies.
These tendencies are often carried over by postcolonial states that are perceived as neocolonial states
because of the hegemonic nature of their actions. Their actions, instead of being inclusive, rely primarily
or continue on a platform set by their past experiences with colonials. As such the postcolonial states are
seen to become neocolonial masters often with hegemonic discourse, showing limitation of outlook by its
inability to empathize across boundaries of culture and ethnic differences. The representation of others
(e.g. minorities) as ‘them’ (other cultures) from the powerful majority shows a way of achieving this
limited end.
Postcolonial theory shows how a particular system (e.g. school system) is silent on matters related to
politics of education. Postcolonial theory tries to foreground question of cultural difference and diversity
and examine their treatment in school, for example spaces for multilingualism. Postcolonial theory
celebrates hybridity and cultural polyvalency. For example Homi Babha’s (1994) idea of third space for
understanding the dynamics of identity negotiation in minority communities entails creating an in-
between space of culture where hybrid identities transgress fixed identities of traditional order.
Postcolonial approach sees states of marginality, plurality and perceived ‘otherness’ as sources of energy
and potential for change.
Past empirical studies
The issue of resistance to vernacular school and its persistence can be framed by examining the counter
context whether monolingualism or bilingualism or multilingualism should be promoted in national
school system. The notion of lingualism means the modes of language instruction used in the school
system as means for teaching and learning process. The prevalent discourse is between the need for
bilingualism and multilingualism. Monolingualism suggests a single-stream medium of language
instruction in a school and promotes the idea of single cultural foundation for nation-building process.
Bilingualism rests on arguments to accommodate globalization, internationalization, industrialization, and
solidarity, and while multilingualism premised on linguistic and cultural diversity in schools has the
potential to enlighten and expand our understanding of others, access to ease of learning at early stage,
and thinking in mother tongue to sustain cultural identity.
Lai and Byram (2003) explore the politics of bilingualism in Hong Kong with the shift from English
to Chinese (e.g. Mandarin) as medium of instruction in schools. The language shift policy was
problematic for Hong Kong as it has to go through the decolonization process since 1997 and
internationalization of English under globalized developments witnessed in ICT. Some of the problems
are associated with hegemonic struggle of social groups in the society such as the indigenous elite class
and national ruling elites at both the local and national level.
Tupas and Lorente (2011) examined the Philippines experience where there were three phases of
language use in schools from monolingualism to bilingualism to multilingualism. Since 1901 the
public education system in Philippines established by the Americans saw English as the sole medium of
instruction. However, since 1974 the Bilingual Education Program of the Philippines (BEP) was
introduced with English as the medium of instruction in science and mathematics and Filipino, the
national language, in all other subjects. The bilingual approach saw Filipino as the national language can
smoothen the learning among Filipinos and express their identity as a nation (Smolicz & Nical, 1997)
while English played the role as a global language. Since 2009, the BEP was replaced by the
implementation of Mother Tongue-Based Multilingual Education (MTBMLE) at primary school level to
encourage mother tongue acquisition. This action was seen as progressive in accommodating the needs of
the varying indigenous communities in gaining access to primary education, who were displaced by the
bilingual stream.
In contrast, pessimism prevails in South Africa to bring on board the mother tongue education as an
additive bilingualism policy. Banda (2000) sees this policy as facing obstacles when the utility of
vernacular languages is perceived as lesser to English by key actors such as role models, learners and
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 18
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
parents. In a somewhat similar fashion, Gupta (1997) has argued against vernacular schools namely
problems encountered by children in multilingual settings, and the potential for mother tongue education
to be socially and ethnically divisive as well as marginal groups diminish access to power structures.
De Klerk (2002) posits the discourse on multilingualism or linguistic diversity rests on the concerns
for human rights as well as cultural and linguistic sustenance of minority groups. This approach positions
the role of mother-tongue education as a key political and linguistic tool in the empowerment of marginal
communities such as minorities. Mother tongue of minorities is viewed as a basic human right and its
growth is viewed as progressive in countering hegemony of majority languages in terms of injustices and
inequalities (De Klerk, 2002).
Stroud (2003) viewed multilingualism education through vernacular and local languages have both the
negative and positive effect of globalization. Multilingualism can reinforce the negative effect of
globalization by marginalizing these languages as witnessed in case of Malay language sidelined in the
predominantly English preferred market place. Multilingualism can also counteract the negative effects of
globalization by promoting the mother tongue and other local languages.
Debate
We will frame this debate along two lines, firstly, arguing for the resistance to vernacular school, which
inevitably comprises the affirmation and support for the national school, and secondly, arguing for the
persistence of vernacular school, which will inevitably comprise resistance to its counterpart national
school.
Arguments for the resistance to vernacular schools
Arguments for the resistance to vernacular schools mainly premised on the claim and affirmation for the
support of the national schools. It rests on the idea of inculcating and sustaining national identity as well
as facilitating cross-cultural experience and communication through national school, and eliminating
segregative and divisive forces in vernacular school.
1) National identity through national schools and not vernacular schools
The cause of national schools for nation building purposes is without doubt an avenue for the State to
shape the society with positive values and perspectives celebrating the nation’s diverse community make
up. As such, the national school can be a microcosm reflective of the Malaysian society. This ideal if
properly cultivated will provide a collective view of a sense of belonging, trust and shared destiny. In the
Malaysian case, the common and popular ideal is the promotion of the idea of single language stream
(monolingualism) with Bahasa Melayu (Malay language) as the medium of instruction in the national
school but there were also options for bilingualism as in the case of teaching of Maths and Sciences in
English in 2003. The assumption of the mono-lingual strand is that as a Malaysian, one should be in a
Malay-medium national school as their national language is Malay. The second bilingual strand is
somewhat accommodative of English as a market and global language of which the nation’s position
matters.
Thus the main resistance to vernacular schools was based on this ideal of nation building and
formation of national identity. As a consequence, the State’s intent and interest has always been to ensure
that the diverse minority population favouring vernacular schools embrace a national school curriculum
with the national language as a platform for national culture with the slogan bahasa membentuk jiwa
bangsa” which literally means “language forms the soul of the nation. From this angle vernacular school
with its mother tongue or minority language as medium of instruction contradicts the national aspiration.
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 19
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
2) Cross-cultural experience and communication in national cultural foundations
Nations cultural foundations and values are reinforced in national schools and this serves as a platform to
grapple with the idea of a racially and culturally diverse Malaysian society. Thus by creating a Malaysian
fabric in the national school, it will facilitate cross-cultural experience that will influence beliefs and
behaviour of students and eventually develop skills to engage in communication. Thus, the opportunity to
interact with wider sections of the community with different languages and different ethnic groups were
enlarged through the national school platform. Here the vernacular schools were perceived to be limited
in view of the lack of a common national language to play a facilitating role, besides lack of opportunity
for cross-cultural experience with a wider mix of ethnic groups. It was envisaged that if there are greater
number of vernacular schools present, then there is also less possibility for greater mix of ethnic groups in
national schools.
3) Vernacular school as segregative and divisive obstacle to unity
From the idea of schools as a reinforcing agent of values and perspective, vernacular school with its
parochial mother tongue language as medium of instruction and ethnically preference groups were
perceived to be segregative in nature as partial values of a minority group is projected and not the national
aspiration. Besides that, the lack of opportunities for students to interact with the wider mix of people acts
as an obstacle to unity. This is more so a problem if the students come from a segregated living
environment and end up in a segregated vernacular school which could be counterproductive to the unity
aspiration if these students were to continue until the secondary level.
Arguments for the persistence of vernacular schools
Several arguments for the persistence of vernacular schools have been put forward by the Chinese
stakeholders namely sustaining cultural identity, lack of accommodation in national schools and
questionable quality of education in national school. Besides the perennial social identity concerns
associated with Chinese schools, the interdependence between the factors was seen where the persistence
of Chinese schools is partly due to the governance and politics of education and lack of faith in the
national schools which are viewed as less inclusive and lacking in quality of education.
1) Sustaining minority language to sustain minority culture and identity
One of the key arguments for the persistence of vernacular schools is in sustaining minorities’ culture,
especially in the Malaysian case, the sustenance of Chinese and Indian culture. The identity of minorities
in terms of their mother tongue is very much dependent or rooted in the medium of instruction of the
vernacular school. Also certain subjects that create cultural awareness such as literature, history and ethics
are all embedded in this vernacular stream. This argument can be traced back to the formation of the
education act prior to Malaya’s independence where the Fenn-Wu report (1951) found that the Chinese
leaders were concerned about the abolition of Chinese schools and its possible consequences on the
erosion and eventual eradication of their culture after the policy formulation. Besides the cultural roots
and needs thesis, mother tongue education is also perceived as both an individual and social rights
concerns. In short the survival of the minority culture and identity has been squarely placed on the role of
vernacular schools to impart cultural education and identity. However the presence of non-Chinese
students in Chinese schools can be viewed from a favourable view of embracing different language skills
for the market as well as for future prospects in global business. The non-Chinese seeking purposeful
education in Chinese vernacular schools will not witness erosion of their cultural identity and would not
become more ‘Chinese’, as the wider landscape is multicultural in nature.
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 20
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
2) Lack of accommodation of minorities mother tongue education in the national school
Critics argue that if the national schools have been more forthcoming in accommodating the main
minority languages, it would have been easier to form a more inclusive education under one roof (i.e.
national school) instead of a separate roof (i.e. vernacular school). Suspicion and lack of faith in the
State’s effort in incorporating multilingual and multicultural education in the national school system has
been a key factor for the persistence of vernacular schools.
This lack of faith was reflected by a headmaster from a primary school in Sarawak who opined that the
“Chinese society is against the idea of integration school like the sekolah wawasan [vision school]. Why?
Because they are scared that they’ll lose the identity of Chinese schools. When under sekolah wawasan
[vision school], the Chinese school will become merged with other schools.”
The Chinese are against Vision school (as means of cultivating integration aka inclusive national
school) because of several reasons:
a. Suspicious of the perceived ‘Islamic consciousness agenda’ underway in national schools. This
agenda was reflected in national schools where non-Islamic students were forced to wear baju
kurung (Malay costume perceived to be Islamic) and often enticed to chant or listened to Islamic
prayers at assembly and during recess.
b. Chinese community will lose their identity of Chinese school. Losing their language is like “losing
their cultural backbone”
c. Under vision school (aka national school), Chinese schools might become a mere source of offering
only Chinese subject e.g. Mandarin language without offering other cultural component.
d. Chinese schools currently offer jobs to various segments of the Chinese educated class. This
economic opportunity will close the door for language and cultural enthusiasts.
3) Perceived higher quality and market advantage in vernacular school education
Some argue that the persistence of vernacular schools seen from the increasing demand for vernacular
schools as not for the reason of language alone but quality issue. The Chinese school system imparts extra
quality issue through discipline, values and performance which are sought after by parents. The demand
for these schools is getting higher because it is seen as an alternative to the national schools. Abolishing
vernacular schools will not solve the problem as it will only force a higher demand for alternative private
schools. Thus the issue of quality becomes the concern of parents and stakeholders at large.
4) Perceived lower quality of national schools is the politics of the persistence of vernacular schools
A common perception amongst the Chinese educators as well as comments from newspaper readers and
internet sites is that the national school has compromised on the quality of education. Three signs that
indicate the quality of national schools has declined were, firstly, when the government by its own
admission enacted and introduced the policy of teaching maths and science in English in 2003; secondly,
when Malays (considered to be nationalists) begin to send their children to Chinese schools; and thirdly, it
can be attributed to the lowering of the passing mark to enable students to secure grades in multiple A’s
which has been a phenomena of late. A related point to this third sign is that when these same students sit
for higher level exams such as foreign GCE A’ levels, they struggle to pass with ease.
5) Counterpoints to the role of vernacular schools in not promoting racial or national integration
Beyond school environment or other external factors, responses from the Chinese school stakeholders
argue that ethnic integration issue is externalized and not due to vernacular schools per se. One school
board member cites as follows:
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 21
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
“If we want racial harmony/integration, it is not because we are in Chinese/Tamil schools and we
become extremists. But it is a matter of how our government provides opportunities for higher
education and employment. These are the things that make the people racialist. Not because of the
schools. If government is fair in higher education and employment opportunities, then they will
achieve more national unity”.
Besides school environment and government policy, some argue that educators, community and media
play a role in inculcating national integration. Others point out that segregative school environments exist
in other social spaces such as independent and private schools, religious schools, mono-ethnic residential
schools, mono-ethnic MARA junior colleges and even universities (such as UiTM). They question why
there were no calls to abolish these institutions. They also question whether there are more to national
integration than social environment alone.
Also some argue that vernacular schools such as Chinese schools were already multi-racial school.
This point was put forward in view of the common sight to see non-Chinese namely Malay and other
natives (in Sabah and Sarawak) parents sending their children to Mandarin medium schools. Besides that
a mainstream ruling component party member went on to say the following: “Non-Chinese students
studying at Chinese primary schools throughout the country now comprise 12% of the total number of
students. This means that SJK(C) schools are now more diverse than national schools” (Malaysian
Insider, 2014). Lack of access to classified data makes it difficult to validate this statement. In fact in one
rural school in Kelantan, the Chinese school is sustaining mainly because of the presence of majority of
Malay students, as the outmigration of Chinese community to urban areas have reduced their children’s
presence. In some rural communities, the proximity of a Chinese school makes it a practical choice for
Malay students. However the scale of multi-racial composition in Chinese school on average is low. In
fact a columnist even question whether a non-Chinese “because they speak Chinese [by virtue of
attending Chinese vernacular school], they are segregated from their ethnic cousins and other Malaysians
who learn in Malay” in national schools (Wong Chin Huat, 2014).
There were several reasons for non-Chinese to send their children to Chinese schools; the discipline
and quality of education, learning Mandarin as a third language for market needs, non-Muslim natives
(i.e. in East Malaysia) fearing the Islamization in national schools and convenient location of vernacular
school.
Discussion and conclusion
The idea of national school education based on English language during the colonial and early part of the
post-independence period, followed by the shift to Malay language in 1978 and vernacular schools using
the mother tongue for their respective communities have shaped the educational landscape in Malaysia.
Traces of colonial agenda in education revolve around two areas namely regulating or constructing order
in socio-cultural sphere and facilitating wider interests in economic resource exploitation. By implication,
the continuity of representation and practices of education in post-colonial period can be traced to
colonial modes of rationality.
As can be seen in this debate on the resistance to vernacular schools, the emphasis on the affirmative
position of those who support the national schools and simultaneously resist the vernacular schools was
that they appear to emphasize the goals desired i.e. inclined towards the resolution of the outcome. Their
position is that national schools cohere with the goals of national identity and there is no compromise in
their standpoint. There might be problems in the mechanism, for example lower quality of education or
hindrance to socialization, but these process elements are viewed as negotiable and solvable over time.
From a theoretical standpoint, the social identity theory partially explains the persistence of vernacular
schools. Since the mother tongue language and ethnic identity of the minority group are strong, it
suggests strong in-group identification and less likelihood to assimilate and learn the second language.
This was further reinforced by problems of quality of education and lack of inclusivity of other cultures
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 22
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
and languages in national school. An interesting point is that the national school project to use Malay
language as mode of instruction was prompted by the same social identity logic that is to inculcate
national identity where a new in-group identification and socialization is facilitated.
However social identity theory’s relevance stops there and was unable to capture the dynamics of the
social reality, especially negotiation of cultural identities in the school system, where wider power politics
and market politics interplay in influencing the resistance and persistence of vernacular schools. There are
three possible scenarios in the Malaysian context where the language policy in the education system has
evolved: emulate the colonial mould to suit the power interest (neo-colonial continuity), resist the colonial
mould and come up with a local mould and formulate a hybrid mould. Using the postcolonial lenses one
can see that the ideological forces that had pushed the colonized Malaysia to internalize the colonizers
values and norms especially among the elites. This was reinforced by the nation state formation,
schooling and planning system as well as the duplication of the administrative structures and the market
modernization and industrial process that comes with it. At the same time the postcolonial regimes were
also resisting the colonial ideologies by formulating their own structures most of which they were
emulating the colonial masters as most of them were educated in the Anglo-Saxon English education
system or models. Reasons for the justification and legitimation of Islamic education and subsequently
incorporation of the religious fervor in the national school can be traced to the colonial missionary
education where religious education was promoted. While this process was taking place in the national
school, the persistence of the vernacular school was consolidated with improved performance in the
quality of education. This process somewhat reinforced the multilingual and ethno linguistic affiliation,
though some pragmatic cross-cultural practices were in place for market reasons. The value of a particular
language variety in a symbolic market place such as national school is derived from the legitimization by
dominant group and dominant institutions.
In the Malaysian case, bilingualism and multilingualism should not be a problem if one were to
consider the diverse ethnic composition of its population. However there is a fragmented approach to the
acquisition of second and third languages with the presence of vernacular schools (i.e. medium of
language instruction are in Mandarin and Tamil) and religious schools (i.e. Arabic) which are
predominantly aligned along ethnic groups, and form an important part of the Malaysian historical roots.
Though these schools provide rich language resource but they are not accessible to the wider population.
Acknowledgement
This article is part of a research project titled ‘Social cohesion through developing the 1R concept in
Malaysian education’ (1R+3r). This research project is funded by the Ministry of Education under the
Long Term Research Grant Scheme (LRGS) [code: LRGS/BU/2011/UKM/CMN).
References
Alderson JC (2009) Setting the scene. In: Alderson JC (ed) The Politics of language education:
Individuals and institutions. Multingual Matters, Bristol.
Azly Rahman (2013) The Allah controversy and other essays on Malaysian hypermodernity. Strategic
Information and Research Development Centre, Petaling Jaya.
Homi Babha’s (1994) The Location of Culture. Routledge, London.
Bagby RM, Rector NA (1992) Prejudice in a simulated legal context: A further application of social
identity theory. European Journal of Social Psychology 22 (4), 397406.
Banda F (2000) The Dilemma of the mother tongue: Prospects for bilingual education in South Africa.
language. Culture and Curriculum 13(1), 51-66.
Blasé J (ed) (1991) The politics of life in schools: power, conflict and cooperation. Sage Publications,
Newbury Park.
GEOGRAFIA OnlineTM Malaysian Journal of Society and Space 11 issue 13 (14 - 23) 23
© 2015, ISSN 2180-2491
David MK, Govindasamy S (2005) Negotiating a language policy for Malaysia: Local demand for
affirmative action versus challenges from globalization. In: Canagarajah AS (ed) Reclaiming the local
in Language policy and practice. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates Inc., New Jersey.
De Klerk G (2002) Mother tongue education in South Africa: The weight o history. International Journal
of the Sociology of Language 154, 2946. [Cited 15 Oct. 2014]. DOI: 10.1515/ijsl.2002.011.
Doran M (2004) Negotiating between Bourge and Racaille: Verlan as youth identity practice in suburban
Paris. In: Pavlenko A, Blackledge A (eds) Negotiation of identities in multilingual contexts.
Multilingual Matters Ltd., Clevedon, UK.
Giles H, Byrne J (1982) An intergroup approach to second language acquisition. Journal of Multilingual
and Multicutural Development 3 (1), 17-41.
Gupta AF (1997) When mother-tongue education is not preferred. Journal of Multilingual and
Multicultural Development 18(6), 496-506.
Malay Mail Online (2015) MCA wants sedition probe on anti-Chinese school banners at #Merah169
rally, Malay Mail Online, 17 September 2015. [Cited 2 October 2015]. Available from:
http://www.themalaymailonline.com/malaysia/article/mca-wants-sedition-probe-on-anti-chinese-
school-banners-at-merah169-rally.
Mohd Izham Mohd Hamzah, Jamalulail Abd Wahab (2010) Pelaksanaan Sekolah Wawasan: Memenuhi
keperluan kepelbagaian pelajar dan perpaduan kaum. Available from: http://www.iab.edu.my.
Ong Puay Liu, Sivapalan Selvadurai, Badariah Saibeh, Marsitah Mohd Radzi, Shazlin Amir Hamzah,
Ong Puay Hoon (2013) Tracking the pathways of education in Malaysia: Roots and routes. Asian
Social Science 9 (10), 93-104.
Lai PS, Byram M (2003) The politics of bilingualism: A reproduction analysis of the policy of mother
tongue education in Hong Kong after 1997. Compare: A Journal of Comparative International
Education 3 (3), 315-334.
Malaysian Insider (2014) Don’t challenge Chinese, Indians’ rights to study in vernacular schools, says
MCA Youth, Malaysian Insider, 11 October 2014 . [Cited 15 Nov. 2014]. Available from:
http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/malaysia/article/dont-challenge-chinese-indians-rights-to-study-
in-vernacular-schools-says-m#sthash.cOshXB5i.dpuf.
Pavlenko A, Blackledge A (2004) Negotiation of identities in multilingual contexts. Multilingual Matters
Ltd., Clevedon, UK.
Smolicz JJ, Nical I (1997) Languages of the Phillipines - A study of English, Filipino and the vernaculars
in the three language communities. In: Wolck W, De Houwer A (eds) Recent studies in contact
linguistics. Dummlers, Bonn.
TupasTRF, Lorente BP (2011) A new politics of language in the Philippines: Bilingual education and the
new challenge of the mother tongues. National University of Singapore, Singapore. [Cited 13 Nov.
2014]. Available from: https://www.academia.edu/1456781/
A_new_politics_of_language_in_the_Philippines_bilingual_education_and_the_new_challenge_of_th
e_mother_tongues.
Stroud C (2003) Postmodernist perspectives on local languages: African mother-tongue education in
times of globalization. International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism 6(1), 17-36.
[Cited 11 Nov. 2014]. DOI:10.1080/13670050308667770.
Wong Chin Huat (2014) Malay kids in Chinese schools. Malaysian Insider, 27 August 2014 [Cited 15
Nov. 2014]. Available from: http://www.themalaysianinsider.com/opinion/wong-chin-
huat/article/malay-kids-in-chinese-schools.
Wong Chun Wai (2014) Language advantage. The Star Online, 12 October 2014. [Cited 15 Nov. 2014].
Available from: http://www.thestar.com.my/Opinion/Columnists/On-The-
Beat/Profile/Articles/2014/10/12/Language-advantage-It-is-bewildering-that-vernacular-schools-
should-be-made-the-scapegoat-for-race-r/.
... Dapatan kajian sebegini memberi gambaran terhadap situasi di sekolah dan penerimaan dalam masyarakat. Menurut Selvadurai et al. (2015), penentangan terhadap sekolah vernakular adalah berdasarkan penegasan bahawa fungsi sekolah kebangsaan adalah untuk menyemai dan mengekalkan identiti kebangsaan serta memudahkan pengalaman dan komunikasi silang budaya sambil menghapuskan kuasakuasa yang lebih berasingan dan memecah-belahkan di sekolah vernakular. Sebaliknya, pengoperasian sekolah vernakular adalah bersandarkan kepada semangat untuk mengekalkan identiti budaya minoriti, mengatasi kekurangan rasa kepunyaan sekolah kebangsaan dan kualiti pendidikan yang dipersoalkan, dan menyangkal persepsi sekolah vernakular sebagai punca perpecahan kaum. ...
... Bahagian A mencatatkan 5 item latar belakang responden. Bahagian B mengandungi 8 item untuk mengukur aspirasi masyarakat terhadap SJK yang diadaptasi daripada Lee et al. (2017), manakala Bahagian C mengandungi 23 item untuk mengukur aspirasi masyarakat terhadap Sekolah Agama yang diadaptasi daripada Selvadurai et al. (2015). Pekali Alpha Cronbach digunakan untuk menentukan kebolehpercayaan borang soal selidik seperti disarankan oleh Wadkar et al. (2016) kerana ia dikatakan sesuai untuk bidang sains sosial. ...
Article
Full-text available
Abstrak: Sekolah vernakular yang ditubuhkan sebelum kemerdekaan negara sehingga kini masih dijadikan kontroversi terutamanya dalam perdebatan di media sosial dan kalangan ahli politik. Selain sekolah jenis kebangsaan, kini terdapat sekolah swasta, sekolah antarabangsa dan sekolah agama yang mempunyai falsafah dan latar belakang penubuhan yang berbeza dengan sekolah kebangsaan. Keadaan ini menimbulkan keraguan terhadap matlamat pembinaan identiti nasional seperti ternyata dalam matlamat pendidikan kebangsaan. Objektif kajian ini adalah untuk menilai aspirasi masyarakat terhadap sekolah agama dan sekolah jenis kebangsaan. Pemilihan responden adalah secara bersasar melibatkan 322 ibu bapa berbangsa Melayu. Analisis data menunjukkan kalangan masyarakat Melayu menerima baik kewujudan kepelbagaian sekolah tetapi berharap sekolah agama perlu lebih kehadapan. Penerimaan tertinggi adalah terhadap peranan penting sekolah kebangsaan untuk menyediakan asas dan memperkukuh nilai budaya bangsa serta pengalaman silang budaya dalam kalangan para pelajar, manakala sekolah agama adalah untuk membantu pelajar menguasai ilmu agama. Pemilihan jenis sekolah lebih dipengaruhi oleh kehendak ibu bapa berbanding individu disekeliling dan ibu bapa bersedia memikul tanggungjawab serta mempunyai kemampuan kewangan untuk berbuat demikian. Kajian ini memberi implikasi peningkatan stratifikasi antara kaum di sekolah-sekolah. Pembuat dasar dan agensi pendidikan di peringkat negeri dan kebangsaan dituntut untuk melaksanakan program rentas batasan kaum antara sekolah-sekolah. Kajian lanjutan untuk mengkaji potensi permuafakatan melibatkan agensi-agensi awam, swasta, berkepentingan kerajaan dan bukan kerajaan dengan pihak sekolah adalah disaran agar program yang dilaksabakan dapat meningkatkan persekitaran yang lebih terbuka antara sekolah-sekolah dan masyarakat secara umumnya. Abstract: The controversial debate on vernacular school still exists especially on social media and among politicians. In addition to national type schools, there are now private schools, international schools and religious schools that have different philosophy and establishment background from national schools. This situation casts doubt on the goal towards building national identity as stated in national education policy. The objective of this study is to assess the aspirations of the community towards religious stream schools and national-type schools. The respondents consist of 322 from the Malay community. Analysis of the data shows that the Malay community accepts the diversity of schools but hopes that religious schools need to be more forthcoming. The highest acceptance is on the important role of the national school to provide the foundation and strengthen the cultural values of the nation as well as the cross-cultural experience among the students, while the religious school is to help students master religious knowledge. Parents exert greater influence over the process of school selection due to their willingness to assume responsibility and their financial means. This study has implications for increased racial stratification in schools and the role of policy makers and education agencies at the state and national levels to implement racial cross-border programs between schools. The researchers recommend that further studies be carried out to enhance cooperation between public, private and non-governmental agencies with schools to create a more open environment between schools and the broader community.
... Despite the long-established presence of vernacular schools, their legitimacy is still being contested. Encumbered by policies that privilege certain racial groups in Malaysia (Koh 2015;Chin 2022;Lee 2022a), vernacular schools have been accused of inciting racial disunity (e.g., Selvadurai et al. 2015;Yee and Jamil 2022). Over the last few years, legal suits were taken up against these schools for allegedly being unconstitutional due to their use of vernacular languages as the medium of instruction, instead of the nation's official language, Malay. ...
Article
Vernacular schools in Malaysia, while only operating at the primary school level, have had a turbulent existence. Recently, the constitutional legitimacy of these schools was questioned through legal suits brought about by private citizens as well as non-governmental organisations and associations. These suits illuminate the discourses that surround vernacular schools in Malaysia. A discursive space where language use is worth examining is the digital realm, where there is an extent of openness afforded to users to communicate their feelings or views. To this end, three online discussion forums from Low Yat were examined. Posts that had written comments regarding vernacular schools were included. Through qualitative content analysis, six themes were yielded. They revealed perspectives that supported the abolishment of vernacular schools; however, there were also those who presented a contrastive perspective, mainly due to the negative views held against national schools and the educational system. From these posts, stereotypes associated with particular ethnic groups became evident. There were also disagreements towards the purpose and quality of different types of schools. All these indicate how public discourse regarding vernacular schools is complex, as seen through history and compounded by individual social practices.
... MOHE looks after universities and colleges under the tertiary education while MOE has authority over the pre tertiary education which includes pre-school, primary, secondary and, post-secondary schools. The schools under MOE can be further categorized into government, international, vernacular, and private depending on the focus of their curriculum [1,2]. In the secondary school system, students are offered admissions into customary fields such as science, arts, vocational, and technical. ...
Article
Full-text available
Mathematical concepts that students learnt in school play a huge part in their lives later. In fact, the underlying skills learners developed in mathematics class like taking risks, thinking logically, and solving problems, will help them solve work-related and real-world problems. One such mathematics concept is the mathematical word problem solving. This is a mathematical exercise where some background information on the problem is presented in ordinary language rather than in mathematical notations. Even though such exercises are a common way to train and test learners' understanding of concepts using a narrative, the ability to interpret the word problems into mathematical concepts can be challenging especially to non-science students. Thus, the aim of this study is to identify the difficulties faced by students in solving mathematical word problems. First sample is 30 students form 1 were randomly selected to answer a short academic test. The data was analysed to identify the difficulties faced by students and to compare the students' performance between gender in solving mathematical word problems. Based on the results obtained, the majority of students had an average knowledge in solving mathematical word problems and there is no significant relationship between a short test score among gender. Second sample is 40 students from the same school were randomly selected to answer a survey questionnaire. There are three sections in the questionnaire which relates to students' anxiety, learning enjoyment and satisfaction. The Likert scale ranging from 1 (strongly disagree) to 4 (strongly agree) were used. Based on the results obtained, it can be concluded that students felt more motivated when they learned about mathematical word problems with the help of their teachers. Besides, they were happy to be able to do practice exercises for mathematical word problems if they are practiced in group discussion. Therefore, theother study could be provided to search for new methods for sport science students to overcome the challenges in solving word problems in mathematics subjects.
... Makanya dengan situasi yang terjadi, menyebabkan masyarakat minoriti tidak selesa untuk menghantar anak-anak mereka ke sekolah kebangsaan kerana dilihat tidak melambangkan masyarakat majmuk dan tidak inklusif, serta mengakibatkan golongan minoriti berterusan memperjuangkan pendidikan sekolah vernakular kerana kekhuatiran akan kehilangan identiti budaya dan agama mereka terhakis jika berada di sekolah Kebangsaan. Malahan, ditambah pula dengan pemaparan imej Melayu-Islam-sentrik dapat dilihat dalam aktiviti pemakaian baju kurung di sekolah dan juga kelemahan pada fasiliti persekolahan seperti tiada penyediaan tempat beribadah untuk pelajar bukan Islam (Selvadurai et al., 2015) dan program sekolah yang memaksa masyarakat bukan Islam memakai songkok. Imej negatif ini dilihat tidak inklusif dari sudut pandangan masyarakat minoriti yang melihat sekolah kebangsaan adalah agenda kerajaan untuk menghapuskan secara perlahan-lahan identiti masyarakat minoriti yang pada akhirnya menyumbang kepada perpecahan antara kaum dalam sistem pendidikan negara. ...
Article
Falsafah Pendidikan Kebangsaan (FPK) dirangka hasil daripada persejarahan masyarakat majmuk di Malaysia yang telah membawa kepada peristiwa rusuhan kaum, yang terbit hasil daripada pelbagai faktor dan antara salah satunya adalah perasaan tidak puas hati terhadap peluang pendidikan antara kaum. Maka, keperluan terhadap perpaduan antara kaum, kestabilan politik, kemajuan ekonomi dan sosial serta pembangunan insan sangat mendesak untuk dicapai. Justeru, pada tahun 1970 kerajaan menubuhkan Rukun Negara bagi mencapai perpaduan antara kaum, mencipta masyarakat yang adil, kemakmuran negara dinikmati bersama, menjamin cara hidup masyarakat yang liberal tradisi dan budaya serta membina masyarakat yang progresif. Sehubungan itu, kesemua matlamat Rukun Negara ini dilandaskan kepada Falsafah Pendidikan Kebangsaan iaitu untuk mengembangkan potensi individu secara menyeluruh dan bersepadu untuk mewujudkan insan yang harmonis dan seimbang dari segi jasmani, emosi, rohani dan intelek (JERI) bagi mencapai matlamat perpaduan yang diterjemahkan melalui kurikulum pendidikan (Sejarah dan Pendidikan Sivik dan Kewarganegaraan). Malahan, nilai-nilai yang terkandung dalam FPK ini telah terangkum nilai-nilai kewarganegaraan inklusif (inclusive citizenship) iaitu seperti keadilan, solidariti, perpaduan dan pengiktirafan diri. Oleh demikian, fokus kajian ini adalah untuk melihat sejauh mana nilai-nilai kewarganegaraan inklusif yang terangkum dalam FPK diterjemahkan ke dalam dunia realiti pelaksanaan dasar pendidikan dan bilik darjah bagi mencapai matlamat yang diimpikan oleh FPK. Hasil kajian ini telah mengenalpasti lima faktor yang menjadi punca kelemahan dalam mencapai FPK seperti yang dibincangkan di bawah. Justeru, dengan pengenalpastian faktor-faktor ini membolehkan aktor pembuat dasar melihat dengan lebih jelas jurang di antara idea FPK dengan realiti dunia pelaksanaan dasar dalam mencapai perpaduan bangsa yang diinginkan.
... Mandarin is used as the official medium of teaching for National Type (C) schools 14 . It is known to be a non-alphabetical language 19 . ...
Article
Background: Good visual acuity is important for children’s learning but the actual visual acuity (VA) demands of classrooms are not well defined. Methods: In total, 61 classrooms from eight primary schools were included in this study. Classrooms were divided into lower and upper primary which reflect different stages of learning. Three types of national schools were included in the study, which were National, National Types Chinese (C) and Tamil (T). Each type of school utilizes different language as the medium of teaching. The measurements conducted in each classroom were: dimensions, maximum distance a student is seated and vertical height of the distance and near target. Near working distance of 28cm was assumed. Distance and near visual acuity demands (VA) were then calculated. Results: The distance and near VA demands were 0.11 ± 0.26 logMAR and 0.24 ± 0.10 logMAR for lower primary, and 0.09 ± 0.20 logMAR and 0.24 ± 0.09 logMAR for upper primary classrooms respectively. Distance and near VA demands between both stages were not significantly different (p>0.05). The distance and near VA demands for National schools were 0.24 ± 0.17 logMAR and 0.31 ± 0.04 logMAR, National Type (C) were 0.16 ± 0.11 logMAR and 0.13 ± 0.03 logMAR, National Type (T) were 0.09 ± 0.10 logMAR and 0.12 ± 0.03 logMAR respectively. There were significant differences for both distance and near VA demands between types of schools, F(2, 58) 42.19, p = 0.00; F (2, 58) 208.35, p = 0.00 respectively. Conclusions: High levels of visual acuity for distance and near are required to meet the demands of modern classroom environments. Both National Types schools require higher VA demand compared to National schools. These findings suggest current vision screening protocols and cut off points for schools might require revision.
Article
The difficulties of using the National Language (NL) curriculum in Tamil primary schools in Malaysia are discussed in this paper. Although Tamil primary school pupils struggle with NL competence, hurting their secondary school preparation, the Malaysian educational system requires mastery of Bahasa Melayu, the National Language. The research uses 2019 UPSR data to examine the NL success levels in comprehension and writing among Tamil school children. Focusing on a sample of Tamil pupils, the approach used a quantitative study of test results from national-type schools. Data were gathered using UPSR Comprehension and Writing papers. The results showed a notable difference in NL proficiency as only 40.11% of pupils attained an acceptable level in both examinations. Important debates focused on the absence of NL exposure in everyday life and the effect of mother tongue interference as main contributing elements. According to the report, standardising the NL curriculum and enhancing it across the institutions would assist to reduce these disparities. This study highlights the necessity of strategic changes to promote Tamil primary school pupils' language competency, therefore guaranteeing better preparation for secondary education.
Article
Full-text available
This conceptual paper aims to study the digital assessment literacy of ESL instructors in Malaysia. In education, assessment is one of the most crucial components in the teaching and learning process. Assessment allows the instructors to gather information of the students to determine the students’ knowledge and to make improvements based on the data collected. With the digitalisation in education, it has propelled the relevancy of digital assessment. Despite the increasing use of digital assessments in educational settings, many educators lack the necessary digital assessment literacy skills to effectively create, administer, and interpret these assessments. Therefore, this study aims to explore the digital assessment literacy of ESL instructors. This study will use semi-constructed interview and analysis of documents. The type of sampling employed in this study is purposive sampling towards 15 ESL instructors in Malaysian Universities. The data will be analysed using thematic analysis. The expected result from this study is that ESL instructors will have knowledge of digital assessment but have areas of improvement in doing digital assessment. The researchers acknowledge that knowing how to use digital assessment tool is not sufficient, and teachers need to remain aware of how these tools are successful or unsuccessful. It is hoped that the outcome of this research will help the teachers to be knowledgeable in how they understand, conduct, and interpret digital assessments
Article
This paper focus point is common building defects that usually give result instead of the negative impacts on the teaching and learning environment school buildings in Malaysia. An overview of common defects is involved in the school building, which will facilitate a comparative school building performance. The study stated the failure to control the critical defects in the school building and then concluded that they are affecting the teaching and learning environment. Thus, this study aimed to identify the building defects that commonly happen in school buildings in Malaysia. Next, identified the critical elements of school building involved in defects. It also analyzed the effect of school building defects towards the teaching and learning environment. A literature review was conducted to analysis the common building defects involved at the school building. Beside, this paper reviewed, summarized, and discussed the common building defects that usually happen in the school buildings and the effect to the teaching and learning environment. The survey instruments used in this study were random questionnaire distribution to fifty (50) respondents and interview with ten (10) teachers. The findings had shown that major defects in the school buildings are peeling paint, dampness, and cracked wall. The finding revealed that school building defects mostly affected students’ concentration and attendance where it found from the majority of interview participants, thereby giving a direct impact on the environment of teaching and learning. This paper provides the current information, knowledge and findings that related with common types of school building defects that may affect students’ performance. Therefore, it will assist the school building management, building facilities and other professionals to clarify the specific building defects more early based on the current findings.
Article
The qualitative study described in this paper aims to explore perceptions and challenges associated with a bi-ethnic identity in a multi-ethnic country. Sample of this study was recruited by snowball sampling technique. Semi-structured, in-depth interviews were conducted with fifteen Chindian adolescents. Results yielded a number of themes related to the perceptions of being a Chindian (i.e., enjoy the best of both worlds, peer acceptance, and sense of pride) as well as challenges (i.e., phenotype ambiguity, social insensitivity, situational ethnicity, and identity crisis). More research is required to identify ways to overcome challenges associated with bi-ethnic identity and to examine how these challenges would affect identity formation.
Article
Full-text available
Education and the schooling system in Malaysia are constant agenda in the discourse of nation-building. This is because education is regarded as an important avenue to inculcate national consciousness and social cohesion among the people. This article attempts to track the various school systems in Malaysia, with the purpose to highlight the different routes of educational choices in Malaysia. These different routes have their roots in the education policies formulated through time and the growth of a multi-ethnic population in the country. It is argued that these different routes of educational choices display ‘inclusiveness’, catering to the needs of the diverse population of Malaysia – ethnic, language, religion, regional, disability, vocation, public or private. The Malaysian education scenario represents a complexity of choices, each colouring the pathways of educational experience, expertise and engagement. The guiding question is to what extent this complexity of educational routes influence social cohesion?
Article
Full-text available
The paper examines the position of the mother tongue in the proposed additive bilingual programmes in South Africa. It is argued that since the teaching and use of African languages, particularly as media of instruction, is less than adequate, their use in additive bilingual programmes, the official South African language in education policy, is unlikely to be successful. The paper is divided into three parts. First, the sociolinguistic, cultural, and political factors are examined. Here, apartheid education and its legacy are discussed. Second, using data from De Klerk (1996) and Smit (1996), language use and attitudes of South Africans to language and education are discussed. In this section, the pressures on standard African tongues by urban varieties and English are highlighted in relation to the pedagogical and theoretical underpinnings of additive bilingualism. Third, the practical possibilities for the implementation of mother-tongue medium of instruction given the 11 official languages, as well as...
Article
Full-text available
In this paper, we shall outline a recent social psychological approach to language and ethnicity which attends to the issue: who in an ethnic group uses what language variety, when and why? More specifically, it allows us to understand the processes underlying group members’ desires to attenuate and even create their own distinctive ethnolinguistic varieties (Giles, Bourhis & Taylor, 1977; Giles & Johnson, 1981). It is suggested that this framework is likely to advance our knowledge of factors influencing successful acquisition of a second language. Two current social psychological models of second language acquisition in inter‐ethnic contexts (Gardner, 1979; Clement, 1980a; 1980b) are then compared and evaluated critically. Whilst these models exhibit significant theoretical advances in the area, it is argued that they nonetheless possess certain deficiencies. Prime amongst these concerns is their failure to take into account explicitly processes (such as ethnic identification) which are accorded significance in current intergroup theory (Tajfel, 1974, 1978a; Tajfel & Turner, 1979) and formal status in our own approach to language and ethnicity introduced at the outset of this paper. Finally, an attempt is made to integrate the latter with important aspects of Gardner's and Clement's models culminating in a set of propositions concerned with specifying the social psychological conditions which facilitate or inhibit members of a subordinate ethnic group achieving near native‐like proficiency in the language of a dominant ethnic collectivity.
Article
Full-text available
In some language situations primary education in the mother tongue may not be desirable. A number of factors may militate against education in the mother tongue: (1) difficulty in determining the mother tongue. This is especially a problem in multilingual settings where children grow up with multiple mother tongues; (2) definition of 'a language'. Mother tongues may be deemed to be the standard variety; and (3) social and ethnic divisiveness of mother tongue education. In multilingual settings the maintenance of social cohesiveness may be of more importance than the benefitof mother-tongue education.Where patterns of language use are linked to social class, mother-tongue education could further diminish access to power structures by underprivileged groups. Ideological issues can be resolved only in the context of the particular social and political situation. There is no general rule that primary education should be in the mother tongue.
Article
New theoretical approaches to the study of negotiation of identities in multilingual contexts. "The making of an American" - negotiation of identities at the turn of the 20th century, Aneta Pavlenko constructions of identity in political discourse in multilingual Britain, Adrian Blackledge negotiating between bourge and racaille - Verlan as youth identity practice in suburban Paris, Meredith Doran (Pennsylvania State University) Black Deaf or Deaf Black? being Black and Deaf in Britain, Melissa James and Bencie Woll (City University, London) mothers and mother tongue - perspectives on self-construction by mothers of Pakistani heritage, Jean Mills (University of Birmingham) the politics of identity, representation, and the discourses of self-identification, Frances Giampapa (University of Toronto) Alice doesn't live here anymore - foreign language learning and identity reconstruction, Celeste Kinginger (Pennsylvania State University) intersections of literacy and construction of social identities, Benedicta Egbo (University of Windsor) multilingual writers and the struggle for voice in academic discourse, Suresh Canagarajah (City University of New York) identity and language use - the politics of speaking ESL in schools, Jennifer Miller (University of Queensland) sending mixed messages - language minority education at a Japanese public elementary school, Yasuko Kanno (University of Washington).
Article
Globalisation carries a number of implications for developing communities. Although the extended use of African vernaculars would be one way for these communities to counteract some of the more negative effects of globalisation, educational uses of local languages are not the panacea they are thought to be. In fact, the way that local languages are managed and provided for in education tends more to reinforce the negative effects of globalisation than facilitate the promotion of local values, often directly contributing to a marginalisation of these languages and their speakers. The paper analyses some of the ways in which language-in-education policies have attempted to come to grips with this problem, employing Bourdieu's notion of legitimate language to provide a theoretical perspective. An analysis of how communities use language shows that indigenous languages coexist with metropolitan languages in complex configurations of speech practices. The paper argues that these practices should suggest a rethinking of the purpose, function and methodology of teaching languages in developing African contexts, building on the ways that local communities themselves use multilingualism to address power relationships inherent in the local–global configuration. The paper concludes with some implications that this stance holds for selected issues related to schooling.
Article
A substantial amount of research exploring the theoretical parameters of social identity theory has utilized artificially created ingroups and outgroups. This study aimed to examine the propositions of social identity theory between naturally existing groups (French and English Canadians) where the dependent measure was more consequential than typical ratings within this experimental paradigm. Subjects read a transcript of a rape trial which varied the ethnicity of the defendant and victim and were asked to rate the victim and defendant on 18 adjectives and then determine the defendant's guilt on a 7-point scale, while the results are not entirely consistent with the predictions emanating from social identity theory, we did find that French Canadian subjects rated the outgroup (English) defendant more guilty when the victim was from the ingroup (French) than when she was from the outgroup (English) as was anticipated.
Article
In understanding the history and impact of language policies in South Africa, traditional notions of framing first-language maintenance as a linguistic human-rights issue are inadequate. This paper presents an analysis of the role and interests of various political groups as well as sociolinguists in formulating language policies in South Africa. Current language legislation in the country - which protects and promotes South African languages and virtually guarantees mother-tongue instruction as well as acquisition of second and even third languages - came about through conservatives, centrists, and ultra-leftists being able to reach consensus on language issues under the framework of additive multilingualism.
Article
Indepth studies of micropolitics at the school level are presented in this book, which includes nine qualitative studies of school politics conducted by different researchers. Chapters 2 through 10 examine the formal and informal processes and structures that constitute everyday political life in the schools. The studies explore how individuals and groups use power to achieve goals and the consequences of its use for others. Different theoretical perspectives and methodologies are used to examine a range of political issues in a variety of school settings in the United States, Great Britain, and Canada. The first chapter describes some of the important empirical and theoretical work in micropolitics completed during the last 30 years and presents a working definition of micropolitics. The final chapter assesses findings from the previous chapters in terms of four analytical themes--macro- and micro-level politics, interrelationships and effects, conflictive and cohesive factors, and political strategies and purposes. Implications of these data for further research and school-based leadership are discussed. A recommendation is made to give greater attention to the cooperative rather than conflictive dynamics of micropolitics. References accompany each chapter. (LMI)