Conference PaperPDF Available

CONFORMANCE TO SCIENCE: A NEW APPROACH TO PEER REVIEW

July 2016

DOI:10.15444/GMC2016.02.01.01

Conference: Bridging Asia and the World: Global Platform for Interface between Marketing and Management

Authors:

Kesten Green

University of South Australia

J. Scott Armstrong

University of Pennsylvania

No caption available

…

Figures - uploaded by Kesten Green

Content may be subject to copyright.

Content uploaded by Kesten Green

Content may be subject to copyright.

Panel session on

Disseminating & gaining acceptance

of Guidelines for Science

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

Panelists)

#$%&"'(()*+),"-.&/+$0"

1%(2"#$3*4$(56"

7,*4,5"8$,,5"

9(6,$":/$*&/;;!

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!"

<=>?"8;(@/;":/$A,B56".(5C,$,5%,"/4"D(56"7(56"

"#$%&!'!""$(#)*!+,!-.,,.//0!12234!52,678!-2,9!:2,9!

%%!;<=0!%#">!

EF4;+5,"(C""

8F+),;+5,*"C($"1%+,5%,"

G/5,;"1,**+(5"

>H I54$()F%B(5!?2!?@.!/.//+2,!7,8!?@.!A7,.=+/?/!!

!!!!!!!!!B5@7+6!'!&!3+,<?./C!

<H G/J,$!2,!D1.E+.F+,9!1./.76G@!H26I/!?2!)//.//!!

523A=+7,G.!?2!JG+.,G.K! ! !BL6..,!M!)63/?62,9!'!%#!3+,<?./C!

KH G/5,;+*4*!A6./.,?!+8.7/!N26!8+//.3+,7O,9!7,8!97+,+,9!

7GG.A?7,G.!N26!L<+8.=+,./!N26!JG+.,G.!

!!!!!!!!!B*76/@7==4!H228/+8.!'!%%!3+,<?./C!

LH 1F66,*B(5*!N623!?@.!P226 !B5@7+6!M!7<8+.,G.!'!%Q!3+,<?./C!

MH 1F33+56NFJ !!!!!B5@7+6!'!&!3+,<?./C!

H228/+8.!R!%!"#$#Q!S*!

E@O,%BP,"(C"session)

)//<3+,9!?@7?!,2!.E+8.,G.!+/!N26?@G23+,9!?@7?!

G@7==.,9./!?@.!!"#$%&#'%()*+,)-.#%'/(0(!7,8!!"#$%&#'%()*+,)

-.#%'.%!G@.GI=+/?/T!

!!!!!!!!!-2F!G7,!F.!97+,!?@.!7GG.A?7,G.!2N!/G+.,O/?/!7,8!

?@.!2?@.6!/?7I.@2=8.6/!?2!</.!?@.!G@.GI=+/?/!?2!78E7,G.!

/G+.,OUG!I,2F=.89.V!

S6.=+3+,760!/?.A/!?@7?!@7E.!26!F+==!/22,!W.!?7I.,$!

• !X+//.3+,7?.!?@.!A7A.6!

• !56.7?.!7!F.W/+?.!

• !X.E.=2A!7AA/!

H228/+8.!R!Q!"#$#Q!S*!

GF$J(*,"(C"4&,"panel)

X+/G<//!A2//+W+=+O./!N26!</+,9!.E+8.,G.RW7/.8!

9<+8.=+,./!?2!W.Y.6!78E7,G.!/G+.,OUG!

I,2F=.89.Z![,!A76OG<=76!W0!.,G2<679+,9T!

"Z 1./.76G@.6/!?2!G.6ON0!?@7?!?@.+6!A7A.6/!76.!

/G+.,OUG!B.Z9Z4!W0!</+,9!?@.!!"#$%&#'%()*+,)

-.#%'/(0(!G@.GI=+/?C!

%Z J?7I.@2=8.6/!?2!6.E+.F!6./.76G@!F26I/!7,8!

A62A2/7=/!?2!8.?.63+,.!F@.?@.6!26!,2?!?@.0!76.!

/G+.,OUG!B.Z9Z4!W0!</+,9!?@.!!"#$%&#'%()*+,)-.#%'.%!

G@.GI=+/?C!

H228/+8.!R!(!"#$#Q!S*!



Paper

Reviewing research works to assess

Compliance to science 

7,*4,5".H"8$,,5!

1'#2%,(#03)+*)-+"04)5"(0,6&#6)7"(#'%(()-.4++&8!

QH"1%(2"#$3*4$(56!

1'#2%,(#03)+*)9%''(3&26'#68!!

\7,8!:4,%';%,<=76(()>'(/0"0%?)1'#2%,(#03)+*)-+"04)5"(0,6&#6)

<=>?"8;(@/;":/$A,B56".(5C,$,5%,"/4"D(56"7(56"

"#$%&!'!""$(#)*!+,!-.,,.//0!12234!52,678!-2,9!:2,9!

%%!;<=0!%#">!

523A=+7,G.!?2!/G+.,G.RE"%R:5L!

#"1(;FB(5""

I),5BCR"%(3J;+/54"$,*,/$%&"

"Z ![8.,ON0!G23A=+7,G.!?2!/G+.,G.4!/2!7/!?2T!

§ !]^G=<8.!E+2=7O,9!F26I/!N623!/G+.,G.!_2<6,7=/!

§ )9";&#(4).+@A&#6'0)B+,C()

%Z!`@+/!G2<=8!W.!82,.!W0!7,0!7,8!7==!/?7I.@2=8.6/!

!✓_2<6,7=!.8+?26/ !✓6./.76G@.6/!!!✓6.G6<+?.6/!

! !✓N<,8.6/ !!!✓A2=+G0!37I.6/ ! !✓G2<6?/!

!✓_2<6,7=+/?/ ! !✓S@X!8+6.G?26/!

QZ!H.!76.!G2,G.6,.8!A6+376+=0!F+?@!D+",'6&(!+,!?@+/!/.//+2,!

>!"#$#Q!S*!

D+*4($R"(C"Q(F$5/;"G,,$"$,P+,S"

• ;2<6,7=!A..6!6.E+.F!W.97,!+,!3+88=.!2N!?@.!

%#?@!5.,?<60!!

• `@.!.a.G?/!2N!?@.!G@7,9.!2,!/G+.,G.!

7AA.76!?2!@7E.!W..,!8.?6+3.,?7=!!

• b26!7!@+/?2604!/..!c<6,@734!;Z5Z!B"dd#CZ!!

e!"#$#Q!S*!

G$(@;,3*"S+4&"O(F$5/;"J,,$"$,P+,S"

E",,%'0!_2<6,7=!A..6!6.E+.F!A67GOG./!76.!G23A=+G+?!+,!?@.!

A<W=+G7O2,!2N!</.=.//!6./.76G@Z!!

`@.!6.E+.F!A62G.//!+/T!

"Z 5<6/260!B7E.679.!7W2<?!(!@2<6/!A.6!6.E+.F.6C!

%Z c+7/.8!797+,/?!,.F!8+/G2E.6+./!

QZ c+7/.8!797+,/?!/+3A=.!3.?@28/!

(Z f,6.=+7W=.!

&Z J=2F!?2!A62G.//!/<W3+//+2,/!

>Z J=2F!?2!8.G+8.!7,8!?2!G233+?!?2!A<W=+/@!

eZ f,+,?.6./?.8!+,!G23A=+7,G.!?2!/G+.,G.!

g!"#$#Q!S*!

T$/)+B(5/;"O(F$5/;*"-TQ*0"3F*4"/)/J4U"

"($"6(",VB5%4"

§ `;/!B%,%!,..8.8!?2!8+//.3+,7?.!6./.76G@!U,8+,9/!

§ `@.![,?.6,.?!,2F!82./!?@7?!W.Y.6!

§ 9FG-)GH:)W.G73.!?@.!=769./?!_2<6,7=!+,!?@.!F26=8!+,!

2,=0!&!0.76/!W.G7</.!+?T!

§ 8+//.3+,7?./!E+7!?@.!+,?.6,.?!

§ 7886.//./!7==!2N!?@.!A62W=.3/!F+?@!`;/I)

§ %J.%A0!7//.//+,9!G23A=+7,G.!?2!/G+.,G.)

§ >'(0%6$)7//.//./!D/2<,8,.//K!!

BF@+G@!+/!'+0!6.=7?.8!?2!G23A=+7,G.!F+?@!9<+8.=+,./!N26!

A<W=+/@+,9!</.N<=!/G+.,G.ZC!

d!"#$#Q!S*!

I3J;,3,5B56"4&,"*(;FB(5W"

->0".,$BCR"%(3J;+/5%,"S+4&"*%+,5BX%"J$+5%+J;,*"

"Z ]E7=<7?.!6./.76G@!F26I!?2!.,/<6.!+?!3..?/!

/?7,8768/4!7/!+,!37,0!2?@.6!U.=8/Z!!

%Z JA.G+UG7==04!.E7=<7?.!6./.76G@!?2!8.?.63+,.!

F@.?@.6!+?!+/!(.#%'/K.)

QZ h7=+8!7,8!6.=+7W=.!G.6OUG7O2,!6.i<+6./!!

– ]E+8.,G.RW7/.8!A6+,G+A=./!BDL<+8.=+,./!N26!/G+.,G.K!A7A.6C!

– [3A=.3.,?.8!7/!7!G@.GI=+/?!!

– f,W+7/.8!7,8!N<==0!8+/G=2/.8!67O,9!A62G.8<6./!

"#!"#$#Q!S*!

Y,$+P+56"/"%&,%A;+*4"(C"*4/5)/$)*"C($"*%+,5%,"

§ H.!8.6+E.8!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!JG+.,G.K!N623!?@.!

%>!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!JG+.,O/?/K!!

§ b26!7!6.E+.F.6!?2!W.!7W=.!?2!.jG+.,?=0!

8.?.63+,.!F@.?@.6!7!F26I!i<7=+U./!7/!

/G+.,OUG4!N2==2F+,9!?@.!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!-.#%'.%K!

3</?!W.T!

§ k.G.//760!

§ J<jG+.,?!

§ lW/.6E7W=.\!

\1.E+.F.6!G7,!2W/.6E.!F@.?@.6!26!,2?!7!9<+8.=+,.!F7/!N2==2F.8!W0!

6.78+,9!?@.!A7A.6!BA6.N.67W=0!N623!?@.!7W/?67G?!7=2,.C!?@7?!

8./G6+W./!?@.!6./.76G@Z!

""!"#$#Q!S*!

EF$"%&,%A;+*4"(C"*4/5)/$)*"C($"*%+,5%,"

§ e!,.G.//7604!/<jG+.,?4!7,8!2W/.6E7W=.!

DL<+8.=+,./!N26!-.#%'.%K!

§ X.6+E.8!N623!%"!6.=.E7,?!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!

-.#%'/(0(K!!

§ [,!?@.+6!+@#((#+'4!?@.0!76.!?@.T!!

Seven deadly sins of science

"%!"#$#Q!S*!

"Q!

Guidelines for Science Checklist

(Corresponding “Guidelines for Scientists”** in parentheses)

Paper title:

Reviewer:

Date:

/ /

Check the box if the paper describes for the widest audience for whom the findings might be useful† that the research…

problem is important (2,3,5,20)

builds on comprehensive prior knowledge on the problem (2,3,4,7,8,9,14,15,19)

uses experimental evidence to tests all reasonable alternative hypotheses without bias (1,6,8,9)

data are valid and reliable (10,11)

methods are simple and validated (12,13)

hypotheses, data, and procedures are fully disclosed (17)

conclusions about findings are consistent with the evidence and follow logic (16,18)

(†Guideline for Scientists #21.)

GuidelinesForScience.com

** See GuidelinesForScientists.com

"#$#Q!S*!

1(ZS/$,"%&,%A;+*4"

H.!76.!8.E.=2A+,9!/2mF76.!?2!37I.!?@.!

DL<+8.=+,./!N26!-.#%'.%K!G@.GI=+/?!.7/+.6!N26!

/?7I.@2=8.6/!?2!</.Z!!

`@.!/2mF76.!F+==!

§ 1.G268!?@.!A7A.6!,73.!7,8!6.E+.F.6!

§ X./G6+W.!?@.!9<+8.=+,./!7,8!.E+8.,G.!

§ 1.G268!?@.!6.E+.F.6n/!67O,9/!2N!?@.!F26In/!

G2,N2637,G.!?2!/G+.,G.!

§ 523W+,.!?@.!67O,9/!2N!7/!37,0!7/!&!67?.6/!

X]*l!Jlb`H)1]!

"(!"#$#Q!S*!

I3J;,3,5B56"4&,"*(;FB(5W"

-<0"9,*,/$%&,$*"F*,"%&,%A;+*4"4(",5*F$,"%(3J;+/5%,"

§ 1./.76G@.6/!G7,!.,G2<679.!?@.!962F?@!2N!

/G+.,OUG!I,2F=.89.!F+?@2<?!7/I+,9!

A.63+//+2,4!W0!</+,9!?@.!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!

-.#%'/(0(K!G@.GI=+/?!?2!8./+9,!7,8!+3A=.3.,?!

?@.+6!2F,!6./.76G@Z!

"&!"#$#Q!S*!

I3J;,3,5B56"4&,"*(;FB(5W"

-K0"14/A,&(;),$*"F*,"%&,%A;+*4"4("J$(3(4,"*%+,5%,"

S@X!A629673!8+6.G?26/4!8.7,/4!7,8!6./.76G@!

N<,8.6/!G7,!.,G2<679.!?@.!962F?@!2N!/G+.,OUG!

I,2F=.89.!W0!</+,9!?@.!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!-.#%'.%K!

G@.GI=+/?!?2T!

• J.=.G?!/?<8.,?/!7,8!6./.76G@.6/!

• J.=.G?!6./.76G@!A62A2/7=/!

• 1.F768!6./.76G@.6/!

">!"#$#Q!S*!

I3J;,3,5B56"4&,"*(;FB(5W"

-L0"Q(F$5/;*"F*,"%&,%A;+*4"C($"J/J,$"*,;,%B(5"

)Z ]8+?26/!2N!G2,E.,O2,7=!A7A.6!_2<6,7=/!G2<=8!

.,G2<679.!?@.!962F?@!2N!/G+.,OUG!I,2F=.89.!

W0!</+,9!?@.!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!-.#%'.%K!G@.GI=+/?!

?2!,%D%.0!<,/G+.,OUG!A7A.6/4!26!

cZ ]8+?26/!2N!G<66.,?!2,=+,.!A<W=+/@.6/!7,8!

6.A2/+?26+./!B.Z9Z!SolJ!lk]C!G2<=8!.,G2<679.!

?@.!962F?@!2N!/G+.,OUG!I,2F=.89.!W0!</+,9!?@.!

DL<+8.=+,./!N26!-.#%'.%K!G@.GI=+/?!?2!6..%A0!7==!

/G+.,OUG!A7A.6/4!26!

"e!"#$#Q!S*!

I3J;,3,5B56"4&,"*(;FB(5W"

-M0"[*4/@;+*&"/5"(5;+5,"O(F$5/;"F*+56"%&,%A;+*4"

5Z `2!.,G2<679.!?@.!962F?@!2N!/G+.,OUG!

I,2F=.89.!W0!</+,9!?@.!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!

-.#%'.%K!G@.GI=+/?!?2!6..%A0!6&&!/G+.,OUG!A7A.6/!

"g!"#$#Q!S*!

Y,3/5)"abstracts"4&/4"),3(5*4$/4,"

%(3J;+/5%,"S+4&"*%+,5%,"

"Z [,/?6<G?!7<?@26/!?2!G2,/<=?!?@.!DL<+8.=+,./!N26!-.#%'.%K!6.9768+,9!

.^A.G?7O2,/!N26!?@.!G2,?.,?!2N!?@.+6!7W/?67G?Z!

%Z S6./.,?!?@.!7W/?67G?!</+,9!?@.!N2==2F+,9!@.78+,9/!B9<+8.=+,.!pC$!

G$(@;,3!LMN$!

G$+($"A5(S;,)6,!LON$!

DRJ(4&,*,*!LPN$!

Y/4/!LQN$!

:,4&()*!LRN$!

.(5%;F*+(5*!LSN$!

Y+*%;(*F$,!LTN$!!

"d!"#$#Q!S*!

.(*4*"/5)"\,5,X4*"4("1%+,5B*4*"P,$*F*"

T$/)+B(5/;"Q(F$5/;*"-TQ*0"

.(*4*"

• *2,.?760!G2/?!@+9@.6!?@7,!N26!

37,0!`;/!

B.Z9Z4!/<W3+//+2,!N..!q"4###!7,8!

A<W=+G7O2,!N..!2N!q"###C!

\,5,X4*"

• 1.E+.F/!G23A=.?.8!+,!870/!

• 1.E+.F/!76.!2W_.GOE.4!6.=+7W=.4!

.,G2<679.!+,,2E7O2,4!7,8!

+8.,ON0!E+2=7O2,/!2N!/G+.,G.!

• )<?@26/!G7,!6.E+/.!7,8!6./<W3+?!

• S7A.6/!?@7?!3..?!?@.!G6+?.6+7!

B#&&)W.!7GG.A?.8!

• )GG.//!?2!A<W=+/@.8!A7A.6!+/!

N6..!N26!?@2/.!F+?@![,?.6,.?!

• lAA26?<,+?0!?2!A<W=+/@!2,=+,.!

6.E+.F/!2N!A<W=+/@.8!A7A.6/!

%#!"#$#Q!S*!

G(**+@;,"X$*4"*4,J*]"

],=+/?!A.2A=.!?2!?./?!?@.!G@.GI=+/?/!+,$!

• S@X!A629673/!

• 1./.76G@!A629673/!

• ;2<6,7=/!

• 1.G6<+O,9!

• [,?.6,.?!G2<6/./!N26!6./.76G@.6/!

• S6+E7?.!G.6OUG7O2,!/.6E+G./!

%"!"#$#Q!S*!

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.

ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any references for this publication.

CONFORMANCE TO SCIENCE: A NEW APPROACH TO PEER REVIEW

Figures

Recommended publications

Seasonal Entropy, Diversity and Inequality Measures of Submitted and Accepted Papers Distributions i...

Microwave absorption on a thin film

Practising science communication in the information age: Theorising professional practices

Research study designs: An appraisal for peer reviewers and science editors