ArticlePDF Available

Abstract

This classic work chronicles how New York, London, and Tokyo became command centers for the global economy and in the process underwent a series of massive and parallel changes. What distinguishes Sassen's theoretical framework is the emphasis on the formation of cross-border dynamics through which these cities and the growing number of other global cities begin to form strategic transnational networks. All the core data in this new edition have been updated, while the preface and epilogue discuss the relevant trends in globalization since the book originally came out in 1991.
Review
Reviewed Work(s): The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo. by Saskia Sassen
Review by: Frank J. Macchiarola
Source:
Political Science Quarterly,
Vol. 107, No. 2 (Summer, 1992), pp. 370-371
Published by: The Academy of Political Science
Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/2152688
Accessed: 27-02-2020 15:49 UTC
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide
range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and
facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at
https://about.jstor.org/terms
The Academy of Political Science
is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and
extend access to
Political Science Quarterly
This content downloaded from 24.103.74.58 on Thu, 27 Feb 2020 15:49:57 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
370 | POLITICAL SCIENCE QUARTERLY
lina, but Iowa and Pennsylvania and almost anywhere he stumped. He had a
growing radio audience, "becoming almost a regular on NBC" (p. 308). Raymond
Moley of Roosevelt's Brains Trust said, "I have never known a mind that moved
with more clarity, decisiveness, and force" (p. 309).
Long's relentless, comprehensive distortion of democratic processes and obses-
sion with personal power converted Louisiana into "a full-fledged dictatorship"
(p. 277). Nonetheless, there was "much he had done for Louisiana" as governor
(p. 227). Construction of roads and bridges (and the labor employed in doing so)
were joined by improvements in public education (mostly for whites), in night
literacy classes (mostly benefiting blacks), in Louisiana State University (where
his interest went even beyond the football team), and in hospitals (again benefiting
mostly whites). But mixed motives -or, more accurately, undiluted ambition-
and dubious results characterized most that he undertook as both governor and
U.S. senator. In the end, the questions hang. Could the promises and the conse-
quences possibly have been worth the violations of popular democracy? Would
the probable results have been worth the probable costs had Long lived longer?
Hair's well written, valuable, comprehensive biography will surely lead most, if
not all, to say no.
ALEXANDER HEARD
Vanderbilt University
The Global City: New York, London, Tokyo by Saskia Sassen. Princeton, NJ,
Princeton University Press, 1991. 397 pp. $39.50.
The thesis of The Global City is that New York City, London, and Tokyo,
long-time centers of business and finance, have become very different kinds
of cities in terms of their basic characteristics and the roles they now play in
international economic affairs. In earlier periods these cities served as sites for
corporate headquarters, major commercial banking, and manufacturing. These
activities have either relocated or diminished in importance and notwithstanding
the changes-corporate headquarters move-outs, the decline of the power of
commercial banks, and massive reductions in the size of the industrial sector in
urban areas - Saskia Sassen sees New York, London, and Tokyo as being in an
ascendant position with respect to world economics. She sees these cities as
significantly well situated in terms of the trends and transformations that are
occurring; in fact, she sees these cities as becoming important well beyond the
economics of their respective nation-states.
These cities have emerged despite the fact that economic activities continue
to be globally dispersed with regional centers seeing job growth and increased
economic significance. Sassen contends that a number of forces have enhanced
central functions at a time of enormous dispersal of production. These three cities
retain their advantage as commercial centers with more control needed at central
This content downloaded from 24.103.74.58 on Thu, 27 Feb 2020 15:49:57 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
BOOK REVIEWS | 371
sites even as important activities are further dispersed. While this process means
fewer employees on central assignment - with back office activities moving out -
it also means considerable support for the fewer who work at these places. There
is the need for increased control of the global assembly line, with small firms
staffed by technically competent experts. The global city becomes the place where
specialty skills are increasingly found. These firms have various niches that sup-
port the corporate governance function. Once seen as the traditional law, ac-
counting, and advertising firms, they are newer companies whose employees cut
across academic disciplines and help give state-of-the-art advantages to highly
competitive business. The growth of these enterprises has been most striking in
places like New York, London, and Tokyo. These enterprises are true production
centers providing the kind of services that are part of the new needs for successful
business. Their contribution is observed, analyzed, and reported skillfully by
Sassen. This is the knowledge business and it forms the core of strength for the
global cities.
Sassen's analysis is quite powerful as she demonstrates how New York, Lon-
don, and Tokyo have managed to grow and prosper. The real issue for these
cities, however, rests in the implications that this growth has for the social and
economic conditions within the cities themselves. Economically, the results are
basically positive for the emerging global city. The diversification of business and
the intensity of competition make the city an important place in which to do
business. The well educated, technically proficient employee and entrepreneur
stimulate the local economy and attract new activity to the global city. The
business district grows; old neighborhoods are transformed into exciting places
for new city leaders. Particularly true for New York, Tokyo, and London, Sassen
also shows the phenomenon has been at work in regional cities like Osaka and
Los Angeles. She gives the global city description quite sparingly.
It is in the area of the social order that is developing within the global city
that Sassen's data is the most disturbing. She does not analyze the political
consequences of the changes that she has tracked. The data, however, strongly
suggest that there ought to be some political difficulties. Sassen asks a basic
question: has all this progress resulted in a better situation for marginal city
residents? She answers the question for New York, London, and Tokyo in the
same way: no! She sees an increasing disparity between the condition of the rich
and the poor in these cities, with about two in five of new jobs being for the rich
and almost three in five of new jobs for the poor. Clearly the implications for
the middle class are profound.
Sassen's work in explaining change while in its midst is quite fine. These are
insights that build around a keen understanding of the significant swirl that
describes our economy today. These insights are well researched and well pre-
sented.
FRANK J. MACCHIAROLA
Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law
Yeshiva University
This content downloaded from 24.103.74.58 on Thu, 27 Feb 2020 15:49:57 UTC
All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms
Article
Full-text available
The rapid development of the new generation of information technology makes digital enterprises and the digital economy important forces in promoting the sustainable growth of the world economy. Under the influence of the digital economy, the original urban network may undergo drastic changes. There have been studies that have arrived at conflicting conclusions. This paper primarily illustrates whether or not the digital economy has changed the urban network structure. China's digital economy is developing rapidly, becoming a new engine for the high-quality development of the Chinese economy. Therefore, this paper demonstrates the impact of China's digital economy on the urban network structure by using data from China's Top 500 New Economy Enterprises in 2020 and the headquarter–subsidiary ownership method. The results show that 1) China's urban network has changed significantly. Compared with APS enterprises and listed companies, the urban network of the digital economy has become more polarized, and Beijing has become the absolute control center. 2) Chinese cities have been reshuffled in the era of the digital economy. Beijing, Hangzhou, and Chengdu, with their industrial foundations in the digital economy, have performed better within the network. Simultaneously, some heavily industrialized cities, such as Wuhan, Shenyang, and Chongqing, have been declining due to the difficulties associated with transformation. 3) Although the digital economy has reshaped China's urban network structure to a certain extent, the original urban pattern still plays a dominant role in the new system. The network spatial pattern of dense east and sparse west still exists, and provincial capitals and subprovincial cities still play a more significant role in the network than ordinary cities. 4) Network diffusion is typically a hierarchical diffusion between core nodes. Geographical proximity has a low constraint on network diffusion, and subsidiaries expand outward through hierarchical diffusion.
Article
Full-text available
The transnationalization of corporate activities has contributed to a rise in the number of transnational professionals and transnational corporate elite members. These transnational actors establish ties within and across national borders and contribute to the formation of a more connected global corporate network. And yet little is known about the geographical locations through which these transnational corporate elites operate, both nationally and internationally. This article aims to fill this gap by applying the network backbone detection algorithm to detect the global cities that are connected through the operations of the transnational corporate board members. The article detects the backbone of around 300 global cities, centered around London, New York and Hong Kong. The findings show that the backbone is currently structuring over a set of border-crossing communities and expanding to the locations beyond the Anglophone corporate world. The study interprets the presence of these new communities as the first signs toward the convergence of practices, norms and possibly identities of national elite members.
Thesis
The objective of this thesis is to explore the views that fed the anticipation of the urban growth in Buenos Aires, researched both in institutional proposals for the city’s development and, in a set of strategic choices whose consequences marked its expansion. To do so, it explores the opposition between explicit and implicit, it studies primary sources (official plans, administrative documents, charts, etc.), and it analyzes different representations from people and professional teams who were behind urban planning propositions and initiatives. This work is broad in scope, as it covers a continually expanding city from an array of perspectives within urban planning as a discipline. It begins in 1958, a pivotal moment for the economic structure of urban planning in Buenos Aires and its surrounding academic environment. The research presents four parts: the urban perspectives of a long half-century; the relationship between explicit and implicit planning frameworks; a thematic view from transport, housing and nodes of centrality; and, finally, an alternative way of framing the debate based on the people and the arguments behind urban planning through this period, as a background for conclusions. The research develops a set of cases to demonstrate the current situation of Buenos Aires as a consequence of planning choices.
Article
While the numerical growth of the immigrant population in France has been documented since the early 1990s, few studies have looked at changes in the spatial distribution of this population. Most research has emphasised immigrants' concentration in large cities and their suburbs. The present study aims to show how the spatial differentiated distribution of immigrants has changed at the national level over the past four decades in mainland France and Corsica, with analyses centred on non‐metropolitan areas. Drawing on census data at the national level between 1975 and 2015, we show that while the immigrant population has increased, it has also spread increasingly into non‐metropolitan areas. This deconcentration of the immigrant population has been accompanied by a diversification of geographical origins at the local level, suggesting joint or even linked migratory dynamics in non‐metropolitan areas.
Article
London and New York are the leading cities in the world of corporate globalization: their financial, professional and creative services are at the centre of the commercial connections that constitute the world city network. The relations between the two cities are more complementary than competitive, commonly indicated by the concept of NY‐LON as a trans‐oceanic service conglomerate for facilitating economic globalization. However world city network analysis shows London growing its overall servicing connectivity more than New York. This change in the inter‐city relation is investigated through focus on the service connectivity and agglomeration capacities of the two cities. It is found that they share a very similar connectivity regional profile whilst simultaneously showing stark differences in their service agglomeration sector profiles. This is shown to be the result of London gaining the rapidly growing super‐rich servicing market. Thus while New York continues its long‐term production of financial innovations, London has grown an offshore platform for global capital specifically in the form of the world’s money management centre.
Article
Full-text available
The new attempts to implement green transformations of the economy aimed at sustainability coexist with the passage from the Fordist to the post-Fordist era, contributing to create profound territorial transformations throughout the world. Although the current economic crisis is slowing the process of energy transition at the global level, the definition of the future economic structure of territories will be strictly connected to the spatial effects of energy transitions and their intensive land use processes, given the low-power nature of renewable energy sources. Urban centres are the places where these changes are reflected most quickly and clearly, being the centres of major economic activities. In this regard, urban areas experiencing progressive economic marginalisation with consequent depopulation, face sustainability issues regarding energy use and maintenance of the existing infrastructure. With the aim of clarifying the role of shrinking cities within these transformations, a theoretical contribution is presented considering different approaches to co-production of energy transition processes in them.
Article
Full-text available
I call for a globally informed sociology of comparative placemaking that integrates historical and contemporary processes and includes the ephemeral, institutional, and personal. By placemaking, I am referring to the explicit or tacit cooperation among people to create, maintain, and give meaning to places in space through bodily occupation given differential resources and constraints. I review select place, space, and community‐based literature about urban, Black, migrant, LGBTQ, and international populations to think about how we can build upon and integrate multiple theoretical, methodological, and epistemological insights to form an explicit placemaking research agenda. A US focus on neighborhoods contrasts with a comparative examination of global urban networks, social polarization, and transformation of the built environment in the interdisciplinary field of global urban studies (Ren, 2018). I argue for a placemaking research agenda that bridges insight from US Urban Sociology with Global Urban Studies to consider how various structures and actors constrain and facilitate place projects. With a globally reaching and comparatively informed sociology of placemaking, we can illuminate our multi‐structured story of place and agency in context. We can answer questions about how and why we co‐create and are simultaneously disciplined by the process of creation.
Article
These locally rooted industries have particular importance in Japan both because of the number of small and medium sized enterprises involved, and their relation to national and international markets. -J.Clayton
Article
Outlines the conceptual preliminaries needed to understand the urbanization process as it emerges out of the capitalist mode of production, exploring in considerable detail the relationship of urban phenomena to accumulation. The extent to which specific urban phenomena can be explained by reference to the accumulation process and to the general structure of capitalist society is examined. -Editors