ArticlePDF Available

Use of the HIVAMAT 200 with manual lymphatic drainage in the management of lower-limb lymphedema and lipoedema

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Background: Manual lymphatic drainage (MLD) is a well-recognised and traditional treatment modality for oedema. HIVAMAT(®) 200 is a novel device that uses an intermittent electrostatic field to stimulate blood and lymphatic flow, thereby reducing oedema. This study aims to compare the effects of MLD alone to HIVAMAT(®) 200 plus MLD. Method: Three females with lipoedema and two males with lymphoedema were recruited. The larger leg was treated with HIVAMAT(®) 200 plus MLD and the contralateral limb with MLD only over the course of 3 weeks. Efficacy of treatment was determined with measurements of leg volumes and high-definition ultrasound to analyse oedema. Results: The mean reduction in volume for the HIVAMAT(®) 200 plus MLD-treated legs was 902 ml (SD 793 ml) and the mean reduction in MLD-only legs was 707 ml (SD 630 ml). While there was greater improvement in the HIVAMAT(®) 200-treated limb, this was not statistically significant (p=0.06). Using high-definition ultrasound to analyse oedema, the limbs treated with HIVAMAT(®) 200 plus MLD showed significantly greater reduction in levels of oedema than the limbs treated with MLD alone (p=0.017). Conclusion: HIVAMAT(®) 200 reduces lower-limb oedema and is at least as efficacious as MLD in achieving volume reduction. Prospective studies with larger numbers of participants are required to further evaluate this.
Content may be subject to copyright.
Review
Isabel Teo, Anna Coulborn, DA Munnoch
Use of the HIVAMAT® 200 with manual
lymphatic drainage in the management of
lower-limb lymphoedema and lipoedema
Lower limb oedema is aributed to
increased uid in the extracellular
space, which may be due to local
or systemic causes. Local causes include
lymphoedema, lipoedema, deep vein
thrombosis and venous disease. Systemic
causes include cardiac failure, renal failure,
hypoalbuminaemia and medications such
as calcium-channel blockers, steroids and
anti-inammatory drugs (Gorman et al,
2000). e principles of oedema treatment
are to rst manage the precipitating cause
if possible. If there is persistent uid in
the limbs, however, methods to encourage
uid to move back into the venous or
lymphatic circulation are advocated
(Gorman et al, 2000).
Lymphatic drainage
Manual lymphatic drainage (MLD)
facilitates the drainage of accumulated
extracellular uids via the collecting
lymphatic pathways. MLD is a standard
lymphoedema treatment modality (Ezzo
et al, 2015). Performed by an appropriately
HIVAMAT® 200
HIVAMAT® 200 (which stands
for HIstological VAriable MAnual
Technique), which is made by Physiomed
Elektromedizen AG, is also known as Deep
Oscillation® therapy. A special design makes
it possible, using electrostatic araction and
friction, to produce mechanical vibrations
in the body, not only at the skin surface but
also in deeper tissues (Brenke and Siems,
1996; Boisnic and Branchet, 2013). e
frequency can be varied within the 5–250 Hz
range. e therapist applies an electrode to
his or her own arm while the patient holds
a small titanium bar, which connects both
individuals to the equipment (voltage
source). ere is a vinyl lm between the
applicator and/or vinyl gloves are used.
e patient functions as a dielectric. is
results in a weakly conducting capacitive
layer between the contact surfaces. In
action, pulsed electrostatic aractions draw
and pull the tissue towards the applicator/
gloved hand and release it at the rhythm of
the chosen frequency. e therapist sets the
Abstract
Background: Manual lymphatic drainage (MLD) is a well-recognised and traditional treatment
modality for oedema. HIVAMAT® 200 is a novel device that uses an intermient electrostatic eld
to stimulate blood and lymphatic ow, thereby reducing oedema. is study aims to compare the
eects of MLD alone to HIVAMAT® 200 plus MLD. Method: ree females with lipoedema and
two males with lymphoedema were recruited. e larger leg was treated with HIVAMAT® 200 plus
MLD and the contralateral limb with MLD only over the course of 3 weeks. Ecacy of treatment
was determined with measurements of leg volumes and high-denition ultrasound to analyse
oedema. Results: e mean reduction in volume for the HIVAMAT® 200 plus MLD-treated
legs was 902 ml (SD 793 ml) and the mean reduction in MLD-only legs was 707 ml (SD 630 ml).
While there was greater improvement in the HIVAMAT® 200-treated limb, this was not statistically
signicant (p=0.06). Using high-denition ultrasound to analyse oedema, the limbs treated with
HIVAMAT ® 200 plus MLD showed signicantly greater reduction in levels of oedema than the
limbs treated with MLD alone (p=0.017). Conclusion: HIVAMAT® 200 reduces lower-limb
oedema and is at least as ecacious as MLD in achieving volume reduction. Prospective studies
with larger numbers of participants are required to further evaluate this.
Key words
HIVAMAT ®200, manual lymphatic drainage;
lipoedema; lymphoedema; oedema
Isabel Teo is specialist registrar in plastic surgery,
Ninewells Hospital, Dundee, Scotland; Anna Coulborn
is tissue viability nurse and lymphoedema nurse specialist,
Eastbourne Wound Healing Centre, Eastbourne, UK;
DA Munnoch is consultant plastic surgeon, Ninewells
Hospital, Dundee, Scotland
Declaration of interest: None.
qualied practitioner, the aected area is
manually massaged in a distal to proximal
direction to encourage excess uid to
return to the circulation system (Ezzo et
al, 2015). e frequency and duration of
treatment is tailored to individual patients.
Compression, in the form of bandages or
garments, is applied in between sessions and
thereaer to minimise the re-accumulation
of uid.
MLD is hypothesised to stimulate
lymphatic contractile function by tissue
manipulation, and hence promote
the clearance of lymph uid from the
aected areas. Tan et al (2011) injected
indocyanine green intradermally into
subjects and compared the pre-MLD
lymphatic contractile function against
post-MLD lymphatic function in healthy
and lymphoedematous limbs. ey
found that the average lymph velocity
increased in both lymphoedematous and
asymptomatic limbs, which supports the
hypothesis that MLD stimulates lymphatic
contractile function.
Journal of Lymphoedema, 2016, Vol 11, No 1 49
Review
pressure gradient, speed and direction of
the movements. e patient can treat him-
or herself with applicators if appropriate.
e treatment procedure is characterised
by minimal external mechanical eect,
which allows it to be used in cases of
acute pain, so tissue trauma and in the
treatment of wounds. Numerous pilot
studies have demonstrated pain reduction,
minimisation of oedema, antibrotic
and anti-inammatory eects, as well as
improved wound healing (Gasbarro et
al, 2006; Fisteo et al, 2011; Hernández
Tápanes, 2012; Boisnic and Branchet,
2013). HIVAMAT is commonly used
for the treatment of lymphoedema (Jahr
et al, 2008). Deep Oscillation® has been
shown by echographic image recording to
penetrate to a depth of 8 cm (Hernández
Tápanes et al, 2010).
Aim
e aim of this study was to evaluate
whether HIVAMAT® 200, combined with
MLD, is useful as an adjunctive treatment
modality in lower limb swelling compared
to the ecacy of MLD alone.
Methods
Patients who were referred for therapist-
led treatment of lower limb swelling were
considered for this study. e inclusion
criteria included:
Age >18 years
Lower-limb swelling (unilateral or
bilateral)
• e request for the treatment of excess
uid volume
• Informed consent to participate for the
full 3 weeks of the study.
Exclusion criteria included previous
treatment of any form on the participants’
limbs. is study was approved by the local
ethics commiee.
e rst ve consecutive patients fullling
the criteria were three females (lipoedema)
and two males (lymphoedema). In each
case, one leg was treated with HIVAMAT®
200 plus MLD, and the other with MLD over
the course of 3 weeks. Ecacy of treatment
was determined by measurements of leg
volumes and high-denition ultrasound
(HDU) scanning to analyse oedema.
Limb volume measurements and HDU
scans to measure oedema were taken
before, during and at the end of treatment
(designated time 0, end of week 1 and end
of week 3, respectively). Objective leg
volumes were determined by measuring
the circumference of each limb at 4 cm
intervals, beginning from the malleolus
and advancing proximally to the groin.
Truncated-cone measurements were
utilised and the volume of the leg between
two adjacent measurements (a segment)
was calculated using the following formula
to give a volume in millilitres:
V= 4/12 π (C11+ C11 + C22)
where V is the volume of a segment, and
C1 and C2 are the measured adjacent
circumferences.
e entire limb volume is calculated by
adding up the volumes of all the segments.
is is a validated method of limb volume
measurement commonly used in clinical
practice (Ridner et al, 2007; Schaverien et
al, 2012; Teo and Munnoch, 2015).
e HDU scanner (Episcan Longport
Inc; with a frequency of 20 MHz, which
gives an axial resolution at 65 μm) is an
assessment tool that provides quantitative
information on the uid content of the
epidermis, dermis and subcutis. Each
HDU scan is analysed using a form of
pixel distribution analysis whereby pixels
below certain intensities are classed as
low echogenic pixels (LEPs). e ratio
of LEPs to total pixel (TP) count reects
the dermal water content. is provides
a quantitative assessment of the level of
oedema in the tissue (Gniadecka, 1996;
Gniadecka and Quistor 1996). e scan
is taken consistently at the mid thigh and
mid calf, for values of the proximal and
distal legs, and the distal and proximal
readings averaged to represent the average
LEP:TP ratio for the entire limb.
e larger leg in all patients was assigned
Study leg
volume (cc)
Control leg
volume (cc)
Subject Age Gender Diagnosis Time 0 Final Time 0 Final
1
57 M
Right leg lymphoedema secondary to
complications following right inguinal
hernia and orchidectomy 12,402 12,190 12,351 10,911
2 56 F Lipoedema 15,339 14,831 13,581 13,568
3 52 M Primary lymphoedema of the right leg 16,940 15,217 13,068 12,241
4 47 F Lipoedema 14,477 13,557 12,851 12,746
5 43 F Lipoedema 16,354 14,781 15,593 14,443
Table 1. Effect of HIVAMAT® 200 plus manual lymphatic drainage on the study leg
versus manual lymphatic drainage alone in the control leg in the 5 study subjects.
Figure 1. Mean volume of limbs treated with HIVAMAT® 200 plus manual lymphatic
drainage versus manual lymphatic drainage only (control) before (Time 0), during and at
the end of the assessment period.
50 Journal of Lymphoedema, 2016, Vol 11, No 1
Review
200 plus MLD limbs (Figure 1), this
did not reach statistical significance
(p=0.06).
e HDU scans showed that the mean
LEP:TP ratios improved for the proximal
and distal legs, indicating a reduction
in oedema in the HIVAMAT® 200 plus
MLD legs. Interestingly there was an
increase in LEP:TP for the legs treated
with MLD only (Figure 2) in the proximal
leg. Figure 3 shows the LEP:TP ratios
for the distal (HIVAMAT® 200-treated)
leg, demonstrating greater reduction in
oedema in the treatment this leg compared
MLD only.
e overall LEP:TP ratio for each limb
(taking the mean of the distal and proximal
reading) and change from time 0 to week
3 was compared in the HIVAMAT® 200
plus MLD group versus the MLD-only
group using t-test analysis. is showed a
statistically signicant improvement in the
reduction of oedema in the HIVAMAT®
200 group (p=0.017).
Discussion
Lymphoedema and lipoedema
Lower-limb swelling can occur for a
multitude of reasons, and can generally be
aributed to increased deposition of uid
and/or fat. Lymphoedema is a common
cause of lower limb swelling, in which an
abnormality of lymphatic ow results in
pooling of protein-rich lymph uid in the
interstitial tissues (Gorman et al, 2000). A
study across a west London community in
2003, for example, reported a lymphoedema
prevalence rate of 1.33/1,000 across
all age groups (Moa et al, 2003).
Lymphoedema may occur following trauma
or infection or be secondary to malignancy
or oncological treatment, such as nodal
surgery or radiotherapy. Lymphoedema
may also occur without any identiable
precipitating causes, when it is known as
primary lymphoedema.
e standard treatment for
lymphoedema is complete decongestive
therapy (Huang et al, 2013), also known
as decongestive lymphatic therapy,
which should be provided by a qualied
specialist practitioner (International
Society of Lymphology, 2013).
Decongestive lymphatic therapy consists
of an initial reductive phase and subsequent
maintenance phase. e initial phase
consists of MLD, multilayer compression
bandaging, therapeutic exercises, skin care
lipoedema, one male had primary
lymphoedema and one had secondary
lymphoedema following complications
after a right hernia repair and right
orchidectomy. The volumes of each study
leg versus the control (MLD-only) leg
over the 3 weeks of treatment are given
in Table 1.
The mean reduction in volume for
the HIVAMAT® 200 plus MLD legs was
902ml (standard deviation 793 ml) and
MLD-only legs was 707ml (standard
deviation 630 ml). While there was
greater improvement in the HIVAMA
to receive HIVAMAT® 200 plus MLD and
the smaller contralateral leg MLD only.
Treatments were administered twice-
weekly for the 3 weeks. HIVAMAT® 200
was applied at each session for 25 minutes
at 200 Hz. igh-length compression
garments (Class 2 or 3) were given to
patients, to be worn continuously on both
legs in the interim. All data were analysed
using SPSS V20.
Results
Mean patient age was 51 years (range
43 57 years). All three females had
Figure 2. Analysis of the low echogenic pixels to total pixels (LEP:TP) ratio reecting tissue
oedema in the proximal legs. e LEP:TP ratio for HIVAMAT® 200 plus manual lymphatic
drainage (blue line) showed a reduction in oedema, while manual lymphatic drainage only
(red line) showed a slight increase in oedema.
Figure 3. Low echogenic pixels to total pixels (LEP:TP) ratios of the distal leg demonstrating
greater reduction of oedema in the distal limbs treated with HIVAMAT® 200 plus manual
lymphatic drainage (blue line) compared to manual lymphatic drainage only (red line).
Journal of Lymphoedema, 2016, Vol 11, No 1 51
Review
and education in self-management. The
maintenance phase consists of lifelong
self-delivered drainage, skin care and the
use of compression garments (Huang et
al, 2013).
Lipoedema is a bilateral and
symmetrical limb condition that
typically results in enlarged, painful
lower limbs, although the upper limbs
may be affected as well. It almost
exclusively affects women and causes
gross enlargement of the entire lower
limb, with characteristic sparing of
the ankles and feet (Langendoen et al,
2009). The aetiology is unknown but
is postulated to be related to circulating
oestrogens, as the onset is often
associated with hormonal changes,
such as puberty or pregnancy. There is
increased deposition of fatty tissue with
excess fluid (Langendoen et al, 2009).
Földi and Földi (2006) performed an
epidemiological study and estimated that
11% of the female population is affected.
The diagnosis of lipoedema is made
on clinical grounds as described by Wold
et al (1951):
Almost exclusive occurrence in
females
Bilateral and symmetrical enlargement
with minimal involvement of the feet
Minimal pitting oedema
Tenderness on pressure
Easy bruising
• Persistent enlargement after elevation
of the extremities or weight loss.
Assessing volume reduction treatment
There are numerous methods to assess
response to volume reduction treatment
and these include patient-reported
outcome measures, such as reduction in
heaviness and pain scores, episodes of
cellulitis or quality of life questionnaires
(Lopez Penha et al, 2014; van de Pas
et al, 2015). More objective methods
of assessing the success of treatment
include volume measurement and
ultrasound scans (Boyages et al, 2015).
Many techniques for volume
measurement have been described.
Magnetic resonance imaging, laser
plethysmography (Stephan et al,
2000), computer-aided design and
hand scanners are some of the current
methods for limb volume measurement.
The water displacement method is based
on Archimedes’ principle and involves
immersing the entire limb in water and
calculating the volume of displaced fluid.
This is considered the gold standard
against which other volume techniques
are compared (Sander et al, 2002;
Karges et al, 2003; Ng and Munnoch,
2010) but has practical limitations with
regards to equipment and patient factors.
Girth measurement with a measuring
tape is simple, quick, cost-effective
and acceptable to patients. Karges et al
(2003) compared water displacement
and girth measurement and found both
methods to be consistent and accurate.
The authors use girth measurements in
their clinical practice, find it clinically
reliable, and hence suitable for the
intentions of this study.
HDU scanning is a method of
analysing the water content in tissues.
It is simple, pain-free and provides a
quantitative assessment of the level of
oedema. The scan typically shows red
pixels, which indicate tissue oedema
(Figure 4), and blue pixels (Figure
5), which indicate healthy tissue. As
mentioned in the methods section, each
tissue scan is automatically analysed
using a form of pixel distribution
analysis, whereby pixels below a certain
intensity are classed as LEP. The ratio of
LEP:TP ratio has been shown to reflect
dermal water content.
HIVAMAT 200’s therapeutic
Deep Oscillation® effects create cyclic
movement through the entire depth of
soft tissue from the skin, subcutaneous
fat and muscles through to blood vessels
and lymphatics (Fistetto et al 2011).
This stimulates the mechanical pumping
and redistribution of fluids. Deep
Oscillation® is designed as an adjunct
to surgical or other wound healing,
sports medicine and respiratory diseases
(Corneaux, 2011). Reinhold et al
(2014) performed a study on 40 patients
following osteosynthesis procedures
on the extremities and spinal column.
Patients were randomised to either Deep
Oscillation® therapy or control. The
found a significant pain-alleviating effect
with Deep Oscillation®. Boisnic and
Branchet (2013) conducted a clinical
study of 20 subjects with periorbital
bags or dark circles. They concluded that
Deep Oscillation therapy was effective in
reducing both dark circles and bags by an
average of 40%. This was determined by
photography and dermatological scores,
as well as ultrasound analysis. Jahr et al
(2008) randomised 21 patients who had
secondary lymphoedema of the breast
following cancer treatment to either MLD
supplemented with Deep Oscillation, or
to MLD alone. They found that Deep
Oscillation plus MLD was significantly
better for relieving pain and swelling
than MLD alone. Gasbarro et al (2006)
analysed the effects of HIVAMAT 200
on the limbs of 20 patients and achieved
a remarkably significant reduction in the
circumference of the limbs and in the
subcutis thickness. Other studies have
found HIVAMAT 200 to be useful in the
treatment of sports injuries, burns and
epicondylitis (Brenke and Siems, 1996;
Hernández Tápanes et al, 2010; Aliyev et
al, 2012).
Limitations
There are several drawbacks to this study.
The patient numbers are small and the
assignment of the larger leg to HIVA MAT
200 plus MLD and smaller leg to MLD
only incorporates a level of bias. While
Figure 4. High-denition ultrasound scan
showing a relative excess of red pixels
compared to blue pixels, indicating oedema.
Figure 5. High-denition ultrasound
scan showing reduction in red pixels and
increase in blue pixels compared to Figure
4, indicating a reduction in oedema.
52 Journal of Lymphoedema, 2016, Vol 11, No 1
Review
Karges JR, Mark BE, Stikeleather SJ, Worrell TW (2003)
Concurrent validity of upper- extremity volume
estimates: comparison of calculated volume derived
from girth measurements and water displacement
volume. Phys er 83(2): 134–45
Langendoen SI, Habbema L, Nijsten TE, Neumann HA
(2009) Lipoedema: from clinical presentation to
therapy. A review of the literature. Br J Dermatol 161(5):
980–6
Lopez Penha TR, van Bodegraven J, Winkens B et al (2014)
e quality of life in long-term breast cancer survivors
with breast cancer related lymphedema. Acta Chir Belg
114(4): 239–44
Moa CJ, Franks PJ, Doherty DC et al (2003)
Lymphoedema: an underestimated health problem.
QJM 96(10): 731–8
Ng M, Munnoch A (2010) Clinimetrics of volume
measurement in the upper limb. Clinical Review. Journal
of Lymphoedema 5(2): 62–7
Reinhold J, Deeva I, Korkina L, Schaper K, Krummenauer
F (2014) Randomised pilot study for quantication
of benet from the patient’s point of view of deep
oscillation treatment in primary wound healing. Z
Orthop Unfall 152(3): 260–4 [Article in German]
Ridner SH, Mongomery LD, Hepworth JT, Stewart BR ,
Armer JM (2007) Comparison of upper limb volume
measurement techniques and arm symptoms between
healthy volunteers and individuals with known
lymphedema. Lympholog y 40(1): 35–46
Sander AP, Hajer NM, Hemenway K, Miller AC (2002)
Upper-extremity volume measurements in women with
lymphedema: a comparison of measurements obtained
via water displacement with geometrically determined
volume. Phys er 82(12): 1202–12
Schaverien MV, Munro KJ, Baker PA, Munnoch DA (2012)
Liposuction for chronic lymphoedema of the upper
limb: 5 years of experience. J Plast Reconstr Aesthet Surg
65(7): 935–42
Stephan D, Tavera C, Raponsky J et al (2000) A new
method for lower limb volume measurement laser
plethysmography: comparison with two commonly
used methods. Phlebology 15(3-4):115–2
Tan IC, Maus EA, Rasmussen JC et al (2011) Assessment of
lymphatic contractile function aer manual lymphatic
drainage using near-infrared uorescence imaging. Arch
Phys Med Rehabil 92(5): 756–64
Teo I, Munnoch DA (2015) Referral paerns to a surgical
lymphedema service: 10 years of experience. J Plast
Reconstr Aesthe Surg 68(10): 1395–401
van de Pas CB, Biemans A, Boonen R, Vieho PB, Neumann
H (2015) Validation of the Lymphoedema Quality-of-
Life Questionnaire (LYMQOL) in Dutch patients
diagnosed with lymphoedema of the lower limbs.
Phlebology pii: 0268355515586312. [Epub ahead of
print]
Wold LE, Hines EA, Allen EV (1951) Lipedema of the legs;
a syndrome characterized by fat legs and edema. Ann
Intern Med 34(5): 1243–50
of arm and leg swelling. Ann Surg Oncol 22(Suppl 3):
1263–70
Brenke R, Siems W (1996) Adjuvante Therapie beim
Lymphödem. Akt Lymphol 20: 25–9. (Combination
of lymphatic drainage together with HIVAMAT®
200 significantly better results than without DEEP
OSCILLATION)
Corneaux Z (2011) Dynamic fascial release and the role
of mechanical/vibrational assist devices in manual
therapies. J Bodyw Mov Ther 15(1): 35–41
Ezzo J, Manheimer E, McNeely ML et al (2015) Manual
lymphatic drainage for lymphedema following breast
cancer treatment. Cochrane Database Syst Rev 21;5:
CD003475. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD003475.pub2
Fistetto G, Iannitti T, Capone S, Torricelli F, Palmieri B
(2011) Deep Oscillation: therapeutic-rehabilitative
experiences with a new electrostatic device. Minerva
Med 102(4): 277–88 [Article in Italian]
Földi M, Földi E (2006) Lipedema. In: Földi M, Földi E,
eds. Textbook of Lymphology. Elsevier, Munich: 417–27
Gasbarro V, Bartoletti R, Tsolaki E et al (2006) Role of
HIVAMAT® (Deep Oscillation) in the treatment of
lymphoedema of the limbs. The European Journal of
Lympholog y 16(48): 13–5
Gorman WP, Davis KR, Donnelly R (2000) Swollen lower
limb. BMJ 320(7247): 1453–6
Gniadecka M (1996) Localization of dermal edema
in lipodermatosclerosis, lymphedema, and cardiac
insufficiency. High-frequency ultrasound examination
of intradermal echogenicity. J Am Acad Dermatol 35(1):
37–41
Gniadecka M, Quistorff B (1996) Assessment of dermal
water by high-frequency ultrasound: comparative
studies with nuclear magnetic resonance. Br J Dermatol
135(2): 218–24
Hernández Tápanes S (2012) DEEP OSCILLATION®
therapy. Experiences in cervical, lumbago and
epicondylitis. San Jose: EdiReh-Latina
Hernández Tápanes S, Bravo Acosta T, Wilson Rojas
R, Fernández Prieto B, Cabrera Morales M (2010)
Valor de la Terapia con oscilaciones profundas en la
cicatrización de las quemaduras AB. Rev Cub MFR
2(1) (Value of deep oscillation therapy in the healing
of AB burns) [Article in Spanish] http://bvs.sld.cu/
revistas/mfr/vol_2_1_10/mrf02210.htm (accessed
31.03.2016)
Huang TW, Tseng SH, Lin CC (2013) Effects of MLD on
breast cancer-related lymphedema: a systematic review
and meta analysis. World J Surg Oncol 11:15
International Society of Lymphology (2013) The diagnosis
and treatment of peripheral lymphedema: 2013
Consensus Document of the International Society of
Lymphology. Lymphology 46(1):1–11
Jahr S, Schoppe B, Reisshauer A (2008) Effect of treatment
with low-intensity and extremely low-frequency
electrostatic fields (Deep Oscillation) on breast
tissue and pain in patients with secondary breast
lymphoedema. J Rehabil Med 40(8): 645–50
both lipoedema and lymphoedema cause
excess leg volume and oedema, the former
is a bilateral condition and the latter
often unilateral, making comparisons of
the treatment and control leg distinct in
these two diseases. The true efficacy of
any treatment is highly reliant on patient
compliance and the use of garments in the
long term, which cannot be evaluated in
a 3-week time period. Nonetheless, this
pilot study provides valuable information
on deep oscillation therapy.
Conclusion
This is the first prospective study
comparing HIVAMAT 200 plus MLD
versus MLD only in the lower limbs.
Although our results suggest greater
efficacy with Deep Oscillation therapy
for volume reduction, this did not reach
statistical significance. The data do,
however, show that HIVAMAT 200
was more effective in reducing oedema
than standard MLD alone. The results
of this pilot study are encouraging, and
HIVAMAT 200 could be a useful addition
to practitioners’ armamentarium when
treating oedematous limbs.
Acknowledgements
AC designed the initial study and undertook
treatments. IT and DAM reviewed all data,
analysed the results and wrote the paper.
The authors would like to thank Dr S Young
who undertook the ultrasound analysis.
References
Boisnic S, Branchet MC (2013) Anti-inflammatory and
draining effect of the Deep Oscillation® device tested
clinically and on a model of human skin maintained in
survival condition. Eur J Dermatol 23(1): 59–63
Boyages J, Kastanias K, Koelmeyer LA et al (2015)
Liposuction for advanced lymphedema: a
multidisciplinary approach for complete reduction
Journal of Lymphoedema, 2016, Vol 11, No 1 53
... The low-frequency alternating electrostatic field leads to pain reduction, swelling and inflammation, which was one of the reasons Deep Oscillation® therapy was implemented in the patient's multimodal rehabilitation program. A search for scientific evidence has shown reliable therapeutic benefits for sports injuries (Aliyev (2009) (2013)); reduction of primary or secondary lymphedema (Mikhalchik et al. (2005); Teo et al. (2016)); prevention in the fibrous remodeling process, reduction of fibrosis (Gao et al. (2015)); muscle relaxation, fascial mobilization, improved range of motion; (Winkelmann et al. (2018)); promotion of the wound healing process (Reinhold (2017)). ...
Article
Full-text available
Elbow joint injuries are common and can cause secondary degenerative changes in the joint. Combined traumatic injury therapy in the setting of an underlying degenerative joint change requires and especially good understanding of the injury mechanisms and the degeneration and an appropriate treatment and rehabilitation strategy development. In the absence of an appropriate treatment, these impairments can lead to permanent functional limitations and disability. The aim is to present effects of implementing a multimodal rehabilitation, of a patient with traumatic elbow joint injury, combined with secondary post-traumatic osteoarthritis, and rehabilitation program including Deep Oscillation®, ice block therapy and special therapeutic exercises applied. Materials and Methods: The multimodal rehabilitation program was performed as outpatient in a 39-year-old patient referred for physical therapy by an orthopaedist, 4 weeks post left elbow injury. The patient reported a history of joint surgically treated trauma, at the age of 12. Radiologically, arthritic posttraumatic changes were manifested. Presently complaining of limited flextion and inability to fully extend the elbow joint, pain acompaning movement in the medial epicondyle area, difficult daily living, and self-care activities. The intervention includes: "Ice Block" cryotherapy, a set of therapeutic exercises tailored to the degree of disability and Deep Oscillation® with a handheld applicator (120-180Hz 5-7min; 14-30Hz 3-5min; 85Hz 3-5min) for 8 days. To determine rehabilitation potential, the following assessment methods were used: the Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand (DASH) to assess upper limb function, centimetry to measure joint circumference, the range of joint motion, the manual muscle test (MMT). The patient's symptoms were assessed in the period before and immediately after therapy. Results: Reduction in subjective and objective symptomatology was observed: DASH score from moderate-severe 54.5 to mild impairment 29.5; left elbow joint centimetry from 44.7cm to 42.5cm; goniometry S/0°-5°-95° to S/0°-0°-125°; RLUJ/60°-0°-55° to R/75°-0°-65°; reduced muscular imbalance, improved functional activity and ADL. Conclusion: The application of Deep Oscillation® treatment in combination with cryotherapy and therapeutic exercises effectively reduces pain symptomatology, swelling and stiffness of the elbow joint and reduces functional limitations (DASH score) in the specific patient after elbow injury on the background of a secondary post-traumatic osteoarthritis. In order to better verify the effects of the applied multimodal rehabilitation program in combined pathology of post-traumatic injuries in degeneratively altered elbow joint, it is necessary to continue research with more patients with a similar pathology.
... The presented results indicated an average decrease in edema by 1.5 cm compared to the control group, which is similar to the results obtained in our own study, where in circumferential measurement at various levels, the results differed between the groups by an average of 1.5 to 3 cm per benefit of the study group. According to Comeaux [11], the process of edema reduction when using deep oscillation is to be explained by the vibration-assisting effect that applies an intermittent electrostatic charge to the deep tissue to reach the collagen matrix [12]. It provides cyclical movement in deep tissues leading to mechanical pumping and redistribution of fluids. ...
Preprint
Full-text available
Introduction: ACL anterior cruciate ligament rupture is one of the most common effects of sports knee injuries. Arthroscopic treatment is the least invasive type of surgery that restores the normal function of the ligament and the kinematics of the knee joint. Early introduced physiotherapy is the last stage of this treatment, which allows you to quickly regain mobility. Aim of the study: To evaluate the influence of deep oscillation on the early results of physiotherapy and on the activity of selected indicators of vascular inflammation and embolism in patients after reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament of the knee joint. Methods: The study involved 60 patients divided into 2 groups: study (N = 30) and control (N = 30). In the study group (GB), the knee joint was additionally deeply oscillated. The mean age of the examined people was 32.7±6.5 years. Women constituted 26.6% of the respondents, and men 73.3%. Measurements of the pain level (VAS scale and algeimeter), the range of motion of the knee joint, the extent of the swelling as well as the level of inflammatory and thrombotic markers (CPR and D-dimmers) were performed.
... Each modality provides percussive vibration/massage to purportedly reduce muscle and joint pain, improve mobility, and enhance performance by increasing blood and lymphatic flow, breaking up scar tissue, reducing muscle proton and hydrogen build up, and activating the nervous system and muscles. Hivamat, which is predominantly utilized within the medical and rehabilitation field, has been identified within the current research to effectively address lymphatic fluid buildup with less data on the effectiveness in managing in edema and/or muscle damage [22][23][24][25][26]. Theragun, however, although it is more widely utilized due to its lower cost, ease of use, and few contraindications, has limited evidence of its validity. ...
... Deep oscillation therapy (DOT) is a modality that has been used clinically to treat lymphedema with enhanced pain alleviation and swelling reduction in patients [1,2]. Additional clinical applications have been in wound healing [3] and fibromyalgia syndrome [4]. ...
Book
Praxisnahe Handlungsanweisungen für Ärzte zur optimalen Betreuung ihrer Patienten. Anschauliche Darstellung moderner Therapieoptionen und deren Indikationsstellung. Wertvolle Hinweise für Physiotherapeuten für die Vorbereitung und Nachsorge bei operativer Behandlung.
Article
Full-text available
Treatment of patients with COVID-19, prevention of respiratory and other affected systems complications, prevention of multisystem damage and faster recovery possibilities and disease consequences overcoming is a particularly relevant topic today, when the number of people who have suffered from acute coronavirus infection is increasing. A tendency to shift the focus from acute manifestations to long-term morbidity and chronic involvement of various organs and systems is observed. In these subacute and chronic phases of illness, the application of physical modalities would be potentially effective. Traditionally, physical and rehabilitation medicine deals with patients with combined pathologies in order to reduce the duration of treatment and to speed up after-illness recovery. Deep Oscillation® therapy is a relatively new physical modality that is successfully applied to a number of diseases, including inflammatory pathologies of respiratory and musculoskeletal system, trauma, burns, fibrosis prevention, edema reduction, muscle relaxation etc. The purpose of this article is to make a review of the potential therapeutic effects of the Deep Oscillation® therapy application to patients suffering from COVID-19 and/or post-COVID-19 syndrome. Materials and methods: A review of the available literature was performed, including reports, articles, feedback letters regarding the application of Deep Oscillation® therapy. The search for scientific articles was conducted in the bibliographic database of Pub Med, Google Scholar, Elsevier. Results matching the following keywords were searched: Deep Oscillation® therapy, low-frequency and low-intensity electrostatic field, COVID-19, COVID-pneumonia, post-COVID-19 syndrome, long COVID, post-acute sequelae of SARS-CoV-2 infection, chronic COVID syndrome, diseases of the respiratory system, pneumonia, obstructive bronchitis, asthma, edema, lymphedema, musculoskeletal symptoms after COVID-19, chronic pain, myalgia, arthralgia, chronic back pain, fatigue. Results: The review made found evidence regarding the anti-inflammatory, anti-edematous, pain-reducing, and anti-fibrotic effects observed with the application of Deep Oscillation® in various diseases, including such of lungs. At this time, no research data were found regarding the application of Deep Oscillation® in patients with COVID-19 or after illness except for a brief communication in the form of a feedback letter regarding the therapy application in individual clinical cases of patients with COVID -19. Conclusion: The scientific studies carried out so far testify of established anti-inflammatory, -swelling and pain-reducing effects, fibrosis reduction possibilities, muscle spasm reduction, local microcirculation improvement and anti-lymphedematous effects of Deep Oscillation® application in various diseases, including lung diseases. These data suggest that a possible positive effect of the low-frequency electrostatic field can also be assumed in patients with COVID-19. Now, however, there are no clinical studies conducted about the Deep Oscillation® application effect in patients with COVID-19 and post COVID-19. Low-frequency electrostatic field therapy is probably an appropriate adjuvant therapy but cannot be recommended as a therapeutic modality in daily clinical practice in patients with COVID-19 due to the lack of reported therapeutic benefits in scientific reports. In the presence of convincing scientific evidence, this opinion is subject to correction. At the same time, it would be appropriate to determine the benefit of this therapy in post-COVID-19 recovery and persistent arthralgia and musculoskeletal symptoms.
Chapter
Ödeme als Symptom verschiedener Erkrankungen sind hinweisend auf ein gestörtes Gleichgewicht des intravasalen und interstitiellen Raums. Durch diagnostische Schritte muss die Ursache ergründet und kausal behandelt werden. Mit der kausalen Therapie verschwindet auch das Ödem als Symptom der zugrunde liegenden Erkrankung. Begleitend können physikalische Therapiemaßnahmen wie Manuelle Lymphdrainage (MLD), Bandagierung, Mobilisation, intermittierende pneumatische Kompression (IPK/AIK), Tiefenoszillation und andere die Ödemrückbildung beschleunigen. Lymphödeme dagegen sind kein Symptom, sondern eine eigenständige progrediente Erkrankung mit typischen Gewebeveränderungen und benötigen eine spezifische Therapie, die Komplexe Physikalische Entstauungstherapie (KPE/engl CDT) um ein weiteres Fortschreiten mit zunehmender Immobilität und Invalidität zu verhindern.
Book
The development and implementation of new technology devices to help professionals, athletes, and non-athletes improve their physical fitness, performance, health, and well-being have emerged in the last few years. This book briefly overviews the current state of the art in technology applied to sports, providing examples, literature syntheses, and recent applications to sports, focused on the most important evidenced-based developments in this area. Attention is drawn to issues and unusual matters that may arise when it comes to technological innovation applied to sport. For the reader, this could be a different perspective on technological progress in physical activity.
Article
Full-text available
This research describes and evaluates a liposuction surgery and multidisciplinary rehabilitation approach for advanced lymphedema of the upper and lower extremities. A prospective clinical study was conducted at an Advanced Lymphedema Assessment Clinic (ALAC) comprised of specialists in plastic surgery, rehabilitation, imaging, oncology, and allied health, at Macquarie University, Australia. Between May 2012 and 31 May 2014, a total of 104 patients attended the ALAC. Eligibility criteria for liposuction included (i) unilateral, non-pitting, International Society of Lymphology stage II/III lymphedema; (ii) limb volume difference greater than 25 %; and (iii) previously ineffective conservative therapies. Of 55 eligible patients, 21 underwent liposuction (15 arm, 6 leg) and had at least 3 months postsurgical follow-up (85.7 % cancer-related lymphedema). Liposuction was performed under general anesthesia using a published technique, and compression garments were applied intraoperatively and advised to be worn continuously thereafter. Limb volume differences, bioimpedance spectroscopy (L-Dex), and symptom and functional measurements (using the Patient-Specific Functional Scale) were taken presurgery and 4 weeks postsurgery, and then at 3, 6, 9, and 12 months postsurgery. Mean presurgical limb volume difference was 45.1 % (arm 44.2 %; leg 47.3 %). This difference reduced to 3.8 % (arm 3.6 %; leg 4.3 %) by 6 months postsurgery, a mean percentage volume reduction of 89.6 % (arm 90.2 %; leg 88.2 %) [p < 0.001]. All patients had improved symptoms and function. Bioimpedance spectroscopy showed reduced but ongoing extracellular fluid, consistent with the underlying lymphatic pathology. Liposuction is a safe and effective option for carefully selected patients with advanced lymphedema. Assessment, treatment, and follow-up by a multidisciplinary team is essential.
Article
The objective of this study was to evaluate the anti-inflammatory, toning and draining effect of the Deep Oscillation(® )device. The Deep Oscillation(®) device uses the forces of pulsed electrostatic attraction and friction to provoke oscillations that act on the epidermis, dermis, and sub-cutaneous layers of tissue. An ex-vivo study was first completed by using a model of skin maintained in survival condition. The draining and anti-inflammatory effects of the device were determined by pro-inflammatory cytokine assay and by histological analysis of capillary dilation. The analgesic effectiveness of the Deep Oscillation(® )was then evaluated by immunohistochemical analysis of TRPV1. To corroborate this data, a clinical study was conducted by selecting 20 subjects with periorbital bags or dark circles to undergo treatment with the device. Evaluations included photography, dermatological scores as well as ultrasound analysis. Using an ex-vivo model of human skin maintained in survival condition, the Deep Oscillation(®) device was effective in reducing inflammation with a significant reduction of dilated capillaries and IL8, while lowering sensory receptor levels. Clinically, the device was successful in reducing both dark circles and bags by an average of 40%.