ArticlePDF Available

Do You See What i See? Using Ethograms to Observe Animal Behavior

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

The process of exploration and the methods that scientists use to conduct research are fundamental to science education. In this activity, authentic scientific practices are used to develop hypotheses to explain the natural world. Students observe grass shrimp in aquaria and construct an ethogram, which is a compilation of the observable behaviors an animal exhibits. They then conduct an experiment, just as real scientists would, to determine how changes in the environment alter shrimp behavior. This activity is designed for a fourth-grade science class and allows students to experience the excitement of observing a live organism while learning about scientific inquiry, and also reinforces quantification and graphing skills. "Do You See What I See" covers Next Generation Science Standards and addresses the science and engineering practices of engaging in argument from evidence. © 2016 National Association of Biology Teachers. All rights reserved.
Content may be subject to copyright.
ABSTRACT
The process of exploration and the methods that scientists use to conduct
research are fundamental to science education. In this activity, authentic
scientific practices are used to develop hypotheses to explain the natural
world. Students observe grass shrimp in aquaria and construct an ethogram,
which is a compilation of the observable behaviors an animal exhibits. They
then conduct an experiment, just as real scientists would, to determine how
changes in the environment alter shrimp behavior. This activity is designed
for a fourth-grade science class and allows students to experience the
excitement of observing a live organism while learning about scientific
inquiry, and also reinforces quantification and graphing skills. Do You See
What I Seecovers Next Generation Science Standards and addresses the
science and engineering practices of engaging in argument from evidence.
Key Words: Animal behavior; ethograms; graphing; inquiry; science education;
NGSS.
Introduction
Teachers and education leaders are becoming
more aware that the process of exploration
and the methods that scientists use to conduct
research are fundamental to science educa-
tion, as indicated by the Next Generation
Science Standards (NGSS Lead States, 2013).
These new standards focus less on following
a set scientific process and more on using
the knowledge and skills that scientists use
to investigate and explain scientific phenom-
ena. Scientists employ many of the same tools
in their research that teachers utilize in the
classroom: models, charts, and graphs. One
particular tool that can easily be implemented in life science units
is an ethogram, which is a compilation of the observable behaviors
an animal exhibits. The frequency of these behaviors can be
recorded and displayed in graphs.
Ethograms have been used by scientists to study a wide variety
of organisms: mammals, fishes, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and
even protists (see Torr & Shine, 1994; Ricci et al., 1999; Scheer
et al., 2004; Gokula, 2011; Cavraro et al., 2013; Cikanek et al.,
2014). The resulting information can be used for conservation,
because ethograms can provide scientists with information on
how animals normally behave and how changes in the environment
can affect their behavior. Ethograms can fit easily into any observa-
tional investigation that students perform in the classroom and are
a connection to real-world scientific practices. Several examples of
educational ethograms can be found on EthoSearch (http://www.
ethosearch.org). In the present activity, students construct their
own ethogram, conduct systematic observations of grass shrimp,
and perform an experiment to determine how changes in the envi-
ronment alter shrimp behavior. Then, they model shrimp behavior
by creating bar graphs that depict how frequently each behavior
was exhibited. This activity is designed for a fourth-grade science
class and addresses Next Generation Science Standards (Figure 1).
Background: Grass Shrimp
Grass shrimp are decapod crustaceans that are
abundant in estuaries along the East Coast of
the United States and in the Gulf of Mexico
(Morgan, 1980). They can be collected from
marshes using dip nets or can be found at
some major chain pet stores or bait shops.
Grass shrimp are easy to collect, handle, and
maintain (Kunz et al., 2006) and have been
used in many scientific studies (Welsh, 1975;
Pung et al., 2002; Chaplin-Ebanks & Curran,
2007; Williamson et al., 2009; Partridge, 2010;
Sherman & Curran, 2013, 2015; Garcia et al., 2014; Brinton &
Curran, 2015a). For example, Kunz et al. (2006) examined how
the behavior of the daggerblade grass shrimp (Palaemonetes pugio)
was affected by the presence of a fish predator. In other studies, grass
Scientists employ
many of the same
tools in their research
that teachers utilize
in the classroom:
models, charts, and
graphs.
The American Biology Teacher, Vol. 78, No 3, pages. 226232, ISSN 0002-7685, electronic ISSN 1938-4211. ©2016 National Association of Biology Teachers. All rights
reserved. Please direct all requests for permission to photocopy or reproduce article content through the University of California Presss Reprints and Permissions web page,
www.ucpress.edu/journals.php?p=reprints. DOI: 10.1525/abt.2016.78.3.226.
THE AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER VOLUME. 78, NO. 3, MARCH 2016
226
INQUIRY &
INVESTIGATION
Do You See What I See? Using
Ethograms to Observe Animal
Behavior
MARY CARLA CURRAN, AMBER SILER,
MICHELE B. SHERMAN
shrimp were observed to determine whether the behavior of the
animal was altered by a parasite (Chaplin-Ebanks & Curran, 2005;
Brinton, 2014; Brinton & Curran, 2015b), potentially increasing its
susceptibility to predators (Brinton, 2014; Brinton & Curran,
2015b). Grass shrimp have also been used in K12 activities to teach
students about marine organisms and scientific research, because they
are ideal organisms for young students to observe (Aultman &
Curran, 2008; Aultman et al., 2010; Siler & Curran, 2011;
Gunzburger & Curran, 2013; Gerido & Curran, 2014).
Safety
Teachers should determine whether any students have seafood allergies
prior to using grass shrimp or any other aquatic organism for this activ-
ity. Students will only be observing animals during this activity and will
not need to handle them. However, appropriate caution should be
taken if the teacher permits the students to hold the organisms.
Conducting the Activity
Approximate Teaching Time
The activity will require three class sessions, each lasting ~45 minutes.
Materials
Plastic aquaria (12 gallon; one per group of three or four
students)
Freshwater obtained from sources such as lakes, rivers, and
ponds or
Saltwater collected from sources such as a marsh, ocean, or
marine lab. Saltwater can also be made in the classroom by
using synthetic sea salt, which is designed for animal husbandry
and can be purchased from national chain pet stores and aquar-
ium specialty stores. The teacher should acquire water that has
approximately the same salinity as the water from which the
organism will be collected.
Refractometer or hydrometer
Grass shrimp (other aquatic organisms such as ghost shrimp
[Palaemonetes sp.] can be used if grass shrimp cannot be
obtained; ghost shrimp can be acclimated to either saltwater or
freshwater and can be obtained from most national chain pet
stores)
Pencils (one per student)
Figure 1. Standards addressed in this activity.
THE AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER ETHNOGRAMS
227
Science journals (one per student)
Timer (one per group)
Observation chart (Figure 2) (one per student)
Crayons, markers, or colored pencils (per student)
•“What Can I Conclude?worksheet (one per student) (Figure 3)
Activity Preparation
Fill small plastic aquaria three-quarters full with either freshwater
or saltwater. If making saltwater with synthetic sea salt, use a refrac-
tometer or hydrometer to determine the salinity or density, respec-
tively, of the water. Place one shrimp in each aquarium.
Procedure
Day 1
1. Discuss animal behavior with the class and how that behav-
ior can be observed. Begin with animals that students are
familiar with their pets. How can you tell when your pet
is hungry? If it wants to play? Draw a T-H-C chart on the
board (see Appendix Table 1). Ask students to think about
why animals would move or behave in certain ways and
how someone can best observe an animal to determine its
movements and behavior. Ask the students to brainstorm
about these questions in small groups for five minutes, and
then discuss the possible answers as a class and record the
studentsresponses on the chart.
2. Prior to completing this step, teachers should determine
whether any students have seafood allergies (see Safety).
Arrange students into groups of three or four. Provide each
group with a timer and an aquarium with one shrimp.
Instruct each group to observe the shrimp for four minutes
and write down in their science journals any shrimp behav-
ior that they see, even if the shrimp is resting. Before begin-
ning the observation and the timer, discuss with the students
the importance of remaining quiet, keeping a reasonable dis-
tance from the aquarium, and not disturbing the aquarium
during the observation period, since tapping on it or making
loud noises could change the behavior of the shrimp.
3. After the observation period, ask students to share their qual-
itative findings and decide on universal descriptions for the
shrimp behaviors. Compile a T-H-C chart on the board, with
the names of the shrimp behaviors listed on the left side and
the description of each behavior written on the right (see
Appendix Table 1). Discuss each behavior until there is a
consensus among students, just as there would be among
scientists, as to what defines a specific behavior. The final list
of behaviors will form the ethogram. Make copies of the
ethogram so that each student can place it into his or her sci-
ence journal on Day 2. See Appendix Table 2 for a list of
behaviors that other students observed during this activity.
Day 2
1. Distribute the compiled ethogram and an observation chart
(Figure 2) to each student. Instruct the students to write
the names of the shrimp behaviors listed on the ethogram
in boxes AF on the observation chart.
2. Arrange students into groups of three or four and provide
them with a timer and an aquarium with one shrimp; groups
can be different than they were on Day 1 if the teacher prefers.
Explain to students that they will not be using words for their
observations but will only be making tally marks on the obser-
vation charts. Instruct students in each group to begin the
timer and then immediately observe the shrimp briefly for
Figure 2. Observation chart. Students mark which behavior
the grass shrimp is exhibiting at each time interval. Names
of the shrimp behaviors listed on the class-created
ethogram should be written in boxes AF.
Figure 3. What Can I Conclude?worksheet.
THE AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER VOLUME. 78, NO. 3, MARCH 2016
228
one or two seconds (Figure 4) and tally each behavior that the
animal exhibits during that brief period on their individual
observation charts next to the time 0.00(Figure 2). Have
the students continue to briefly observe the shrimp (for one
or two seconds) once every 20 seconds for three consecutive
minutes and tally each behavior exhibited on their observa-
tion charts. Results should be recorded instantaneously,
meaning that the behavior exhibited right at the 20-second
mark should be recorded, as opposed to all behaviors exhib-
ited over the span of 20 seconds.
3. At the end of the observation period, ask each student to add
his or her quantitative findings to a class tally chart compiled
on the white board. This could also be compiled on a Smart
Board, if one is available, or on a piece of chart paper.
4. Later in the day, instruct students to record shrimp behavior
again for another three minutes on a new observation chart.
Students should observe the same shrimp that they observed
earlier in the day. Depending on the class schedule, it is best
to allow students to make a total of two to four observations
throughout the day, because animals may behave differently
depending on the time of day. At the end of each observation
period, instruct students to add their quantitative findings to
a class tally chart compiled on a white board, Smart Board,
or piece of chart paper.
Day 3
1. Arrange students into the same groups as on Day 2 and pro-
vide each with a new observation chart. Instruct each group
to repeat the observation series, this time creating a distur-
bance in the aquarium during the observation period
(e.g., inserting nets, plastic pipets, spoons, or food into the
water). Again, it is best to allow students to make a total of
two to four observations throughout the day.
2. At the end of the observation period, ask each student to add
his or her quantitative findings to a class tally chart compiled
on a white board, Smart Board, or chart paper.
3. Ask each student to make a bar graph using the information
from the compiled class tally chart from Day 2. Behaviors
should be listed on the x-axis and the number of times each
behavior was observed on the y-axis (see Appendix Figure 5).
Students can use crayons, markers, or colored pencils to color
the bars of the graph.
4. Instruct students to generate a second graph using the obser-
vation data from Day 3 to illustrate how disturbing the
aquarium may or may not have affected shrimp behavior
(see Appendix Figure 5).
5. Finally, lead a discussion about the observations and main
findings. Discuss how this information could be used by sci-
entists who study grass shrimp. For example, scientists could
use the information to evaluate how shrimp behavior would
change if the environment was altered by adding more
shrimp or a predator (see Modificationsfor more informa-
tion on how to do this in the classroom).
Animal Care after the Activity
Shrimp that were purchased from a store should not be released
into the environment; they should instead be retained in a class-
room aquarium or given to someone who has an aquarium and
can care for the animals. If shrimp were collected from the environ-
ment, they can be released or cared for as described previously.
Shrimp can also be preserved in jars in isopropyl alcohol, which
can be purchased at most grocery or drug stores.
Assessment
The ethogram, observation charts, bar graphs, and What Can I
Conclude?worksheet (Figure 3) can be used as formal assessments
of student participation, understanding, and mastery of using sci-
entific tools and practices.
Discussion
Engaging students in hands-on activities is a great way to teach
them about scientific inquiry. Students who participated in this
activity enjoyed observing a live animal and were very excited to
learn that they were conducting an experiment similar to those per-
formed by real scientists. An audio podcast that describes the expe-
rience of bringing shrimp into the classroom can be accessed by
searching for the word shrimpunder Episode Searchat http://
coseenow.net/podcast/. In this activity, one behavior that was often
observed was resting, and students thought that something was
wrong with how they were conducting observations. Prior to con-
ducting this activity, teachers should take the time to inform stu-
dents that there are no incorrect behaviors for the shrimp to
perform, and that resting or remaining motionless is a behavior
commonly exhibited by shrimp. Some teachers and students opted
to extend the activity by observing shrimp for several weeks.
Figure 4. A student observes grass shrimp (upper right of
aquarium) and records the behavior on her observation
chart (Figure 2).
THE AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER ETHNOGRAMS
229
Individual students were assigned observation roles at varying
times throughout the day or week and then any observed changes
in behavior were discussed as a class. The majority of students
noted that the shrimp rested more frequently as time progressed,
likely because of the static nature of their environment, but that
their behavior often changed when the water in the aquarium was
changed.
In Do You See What I See,students create and use an ethogram
to determine how shrimp behavior changes when the environment of
the animal is altered. This activity allows students to experience the
excitement that comes along with observing a live organism while
learning about scientific inquiry, and also reinforces quantification
and graphing skills. The NGSS places emphasis on using authentic
scientific practices to teach science concepts (NGSS Lead States,
2013), and ethograms are an easy way to integrate these standards
into classrooms while providing a rich, rewarding, and realistic scien-
tific experience.
Modifications
If space or monetary restrictions limit purchase to only one aquar-
ium, the groups could rotate use of the aquarium. If grass shrimp
are unavailable, others animals such as ants, mice, hamsters, frogs,
and turtles could be used for observation. Consider selecting ani-
mals that are safe, easy to keep in a classroom, and display a range
of observable behaviors. Students could also observe animals out-
side the classroom by using web camera clips or taking trips to a
local zoo. A marine scientist could be invited to class to do a pre-
sentation about an organism. If the guest speaker is not available
to physically visit the class, a video conferencing session could be
planned.
The time frame used in this activity could be adjusted to best suit
each classroom. The activity could be completed in one day. Addi-
tionally, long-term monitoring could easily be incorporated into
the daily or weekly classroom schedule because observations take
only three minutes. The students could be asked if they observed
any new behaviors over time through this effort.
Other experimental designs could be employed in conjunction
with the use of the ethogram. Several shrimp could be placed in
one aquarium, and their behavior could be compared to that of a sin-
gle shrimp. A larger organism such as a fish or turtle could be added
to the aquarium to determine how the behavior of the shrimp
changes in the presence of a potential predator.
For lower grade levels, teachers could create pictographs and ask
students to determine how many times an organism exhibited a par-
ticular behavior. See Kunz et al. (2006) for illustrations of common
grass shrimp behaviors. For higher grade levels, students could create
an anatomically correct drawing of a grass shrimp. They could use
labels to describe how the different sets of legs aid in the shrimps
movement and which body parts are used most or least when different
behaviors are exhibited. A labeled grass shrimp diagram can be found
in Aultman et al. (2010). Students could also convert their data into
percentages and use a circle graph to present the data, as described
by Hoover and Curran (2010). In addition, students could observe
more than one species throughout the year, ideally from different taxa,
such as comparing shrimp (a crustacean) to other invertebrates like
snails (a mollusk) or worms (an annelid). A testable hypothesis
regarding differences in behavior along with a laboratory report could
be developed, as described by Aultman et al. (2010).
Acknowledgments
Funding was provided by the NOAA Living Marine Resources Cooper-
ative Science Center (award no. NA06OAR4810163), Department of
Education (Title VII, award no. P382G090003), and National Science
Foundation (GK12, award no. DGE-0841372). We thank the counse-
lors and students at the 2011 Coast Camp summer program held at
Savannah State University for participating in this activity, and the
anonymous reviewers who helped improve the manuscript. This pub-
lication is also listed as Contribution No. 1758 of the Belle W. Baruch
Institute for Marine and Coastal Science.
References
Aultman, T. & Curran, M.C. (2008). Grass shrimp: small size but big role in
food web. Current: Journal of Marine Education, 24, 2933.
Aultman, T., Curran, M.C. & Partridge, M. (2010). Bringing scientific inquiry
alive using real grass shrimp research. NSTA Science Scope, 33(7), 5460.
Brinton, B.A. (2014). The effect of the bopyrid isopod Probopyrus
pandalicola on the predation preferences of the mummichog Fundulus
heteroclitus, and the effect of temperature on the synchronization
between parasite reproduction and molting of its grass shrimp host.
M.S. thesis, Savannah State University, Savannah, GA.
Brinton, B.A. & Curran, M.C. (2015a). The effect of temperature on
synchronization of brood development of the bopyrid isopod parasite
Probopyrus pandalicola with molting of its host, the daggerblade grass
shrimp Palaemonetes pugio.Journal of Parasitology, 101, 398404.
Brinton, B.A. & Curran, M.C. (2015b). The effects of the parasite Probopyrus
pandalicola (Packard, 1879) (Isopoda, Bopyridae) on the behavior,
transparent camouflage, and predators of Palaemonetes pugio Holthuis,
1949 (Decapoda, Palaemonidae). Crustaceana, 88, 12651281.
Cavraro, F., Torricelli, P. & Malavasi, S. (2013). Quantitative ethogram of
male reproductive behavior in the South European toothcarp Aphanius
fasciatus.Biological Bulletin, 225, 7178.
Chaplin-Ebanks, S.A. & Curran, M.C. (2005). The effect of the parasitic
isopod, Probopyrus pandalicola (Packard, 1879), on tidal activity
patterns of the grass shrimp, Palaemonetes pugio Holthuis, 1949.
Crustaceana, 78, 10531061.
Chaplin-Ebanks, S.A. & Curran, M.C. (2007). Prevalence of the bopyrid
isopod Probopyrus pandalicola in the grass shrimp Palaemonetes
pugio in four tidal creeks on the South Carolina-Georgia coast.
Journal of Parasitology, 93, 7377.
Cikanek, S.J., Nockold, S., Brown, J.L., Carpenter, J.W., Estrada, A., Guerrel,
J. et al. (2014). Evaluating group housing strategies for the ex-situ
conservation of harlequin frogs (Atelopus spp.) using behavioral and
physiological indicators. PLoS ONE, 9, e90218.
Crowther, D.T. & Cannon, J. (2004). Strategy makeover: from K-W-L to T-H-C,
a popular reading strategy gets a science makeover. Science and
Children, 42(1), 4244.
Garcia, R.N., Chung, K.W., DeLorenzo, M.E. & Curran, M.C. (2014). Individual
and mixture effects of caffeine and sulfamethoxazole on the
daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio following maternal
exposure. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 33, 21202125.
Gerido, L. & Curran, M.C. (2014). Enhancing science instruction through
student-created PowerPoint presentations. American Biology Teacher,
76, 627631.
Gokula, V. (2011). An ethogram of spot-billed pelican (Pelecanus
philippensis). Chinese Birds, 2, 183192.
Gunzburger, L. & Curran, M.C. (2013). Counting parasites: using shrimp
to teach students about estimation. Natural Sciences Education, 42, 913.
THE AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER VOLUME. 78, NO. 3, MARCH 2016
230
Hoover, K.M. & Curran, M.C. (2010). Trash pie: is your school serving?
Science and Children, 47, 5457.
Kunz, A.K., Ford, M. & Pung, O.J. (2006). Behavior of grass shrimp
Palaemonetes pugio and its response to the presence of the predatory
fish Fundulus heteroclitus.American Midland Naturalist, 155, 286294.
Morgan, M.D. (1980). Grazing and predation of the grass shrimp
Palaemonetes pugio.Limnology and Oceanography, 25, 896902.
National Marine Educators Association (2013). Ocean literacy: the essential
principles and fundamental concepts of ocean sciences for learners of
all ages. Version 2. Available at http://oceanservice.noaa.gov/
education/literacy/ocean_literacy.pdf.
National Research Council (1996). National Science Education Standards.
Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
NGSS Lead States (2013). Next Generation Science Standards: For States, By
States. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.
Partridge, M. (2010). Behavioral effects of the parasite Probopyrus
pandalicola on the swimming endurance and toxicity of fipronil to the
daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio, and integrating shrimp
density data into a K12 activity. M.S. thesis, Savannah State University,
Savannah, GA.
Pung, O.J., Khan, R.N., Vives, S.P. & Walker, C.B. (2002). Prevalence,
geographic distribution, and fitness effects of Microphallus turgidus
(Trematoda: Microphallidae) in grass shrimp (Palaemonetes spp.) from
coastal Georgia. Journal of Parasitology, 88, 8992.
Ricci, N., Capovani, C. & Dini, F. (1999). Behavioural modifications imposed
to the ciliate protist Euplotes crassus by caulerpenyne: the major toxic
terpenoid of the green seaweed, Caulerpa taxifolia.European Journal
of Protistology, 35, 290303.
Scheer, M., Hofmann, B. & Behr, I.P. (2004). Ethogram of selected behaviors
initiated by free-ranging short-finned pilot whales (Globicephala
macrorhynchus) and directed to human swimmers during open water
encounters. Anthrozoös, 17, 244258.
Sherman, M.B. & Curran, M.C. (2013). The effect of the bopyrid isopod
Probopyrus pandalicola (Packard, 1879) (Isopoda, Bopyridae) on the
survival time of the daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio
Holthuis, 1949 (Decapoda, Palaemonidae) during starvation at two
different temperatures. Crustaceana, 86, 13281342.
Sherman, M.B. & Curran, M.C. (2015). Sexual sterilization of the daggerblade
grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio (Decapoda, Palaemonidae) by the
bopyrid isopod Probopyrus pandalicola (Isopoda, Bopyridae). Journal
of Parasitology, 101, 15.
Siler, A. & Curran, M.C. (2011). The learning cycle: engaging children
in the scientific method. Current: Journal of Marine Education,
27, 2432.
Torr, G.A. & Shine, R. (1994). An ethogram for the small scincid lizard
Lampropholis guichenoti.Amphibia-Reptilia, 15, 2134.
Welsh, B.L. (1975). The role of grass shrimp, Palaemonetes pugio, in a tidal
marsh ecosystem. Ecology, 56, 513530.
Williamson, C.J., Pennington, P.L. & Curran, M.C. (2009). Toxicity of synthetic
pyrethroid insecticides to the grass shrimp, Palaemonetes pugio,
parasitized with the bopyrid isopod, Probopyrus pandalicola.Journal
of Environmental Science and Health B, 44, 810816.
MARY CARLA CURRAN (curranc@savannahstate.edu) obtained her Ph.D.
in Biological Oceanography from the Joint Program of the Woods Hole
Oceanographic Institution and the Massachusetts Institute of
Technology. Dr. Curran has an interest in helping teachers use scientific
data and has developed several activities that incorporate her ecology
research. She is currently a Full Professor at Savannah State University,
Savannah, GA 31404. AMBER SILER obtained her B.A. in Elementary
Education from Florida Atlantic University. She is currently a third-
grade Talented and Gifted classroom teacher in Panama City,
FL. MICHELE B. SHERMAN obtained her M.S. in Marine Sciences from
Savannah State University, where she is currently a Marine Sciences
Technician. Her areas of interest include hostparasite relationships
and marine policy.
Appendix Table 1. Sample T-H-C chart (modified by Siler & Curran, 2011) representing student
responses (T-H-C charts were originally described by Crowther & Cannon, 2004).
THINK of why certain animals
move/behave in certain ways
HOW can someone best observe
an animal to see how it moves or
behaves?
What CONCLUSIONS can be
drawn about this animals
movement/behavior?
Crabs walk sideways because their
legs bend that way.
Sharks use their tails to swim forward.
Sloths hang upside down because
they have special hooks, and it
saves energy.
Turtles pull their head and legs into
their shells for protection.
Can touch some of them (be
careful).
Smell.
See.
May use microscope or
magnifying glass.
Catch and put in tank or cage.
Take a video.
Visit a zoo.
Most often observed
___________.
Least often observed
___________.
Uses legs to swim.
Other responses based on data
collected.
THE AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER ETHNOGRAMS
231
Appendix Table 2. Grass shrimp ethogram of the behaviors that students observed shrimp
exhibiting. Other sample ethograms can be found at a free website created by the Lincoln Park
Zoo at http://www.ethosearch.org/.
Behavior Description
Swimming The shrimp is using its legs to move throughout the water column.
Floating The shrimp is in the water column, not moving its legs.
Resting The shrimp is sitting on the bottom, not moving its legs.
Walking The shrimp is using its legs to walk along the bottom.
Backward thrusting The shrimp is using its tail to shoot itself backward quickly.
Appendix Figure 5. Bar graphs depicting grass shrimp behavior. Students recorded the behavior of the
shrimp in a normal setting (Undisturbed Trial) and when disturbances were created in the aquarium using items
such as spoons and nets to stir up the water (Disturbed Trial). The name of the observed behavior is on the x-axis
and the number of times the behavior occurred is on the y-axis.
THE AMERICAN BIOLOGY TEACHER VOLUME. 78, NO. 3, MARCH 2016
232
... More often, however, engaging in science practice was defined by contrast, or emphasizing changes from previous iterations of science education reform. Engaging in practices was contrasted with teaching about science (Huff, 2016), following a set of scientific processes (Curran et al., 2016), repeating steps predetermined by the teacher (Stroupe & Kramer, 2014), memorization of facts (Joyner & Marshall, 2016), learning facts or content (Tuttle et al., 2014;Passmore 2015), and stating what students should know (Fink, 2014). Analysis of these articles also reveal the rationales directed at teachers for engaging in science practices as a focus of the NGSS. ...
... Analysis of these articles also reveal the rationales directed at teachers for engaging in science practices as a focus of the NGSS. The most frequent rationale dealt with the use of science and engineering practices for sensemaking, learning or developing knowledge (Curran et al., 2016;Potter et al., 2016;Quinlan, 2019;Stroupe & Kramer, 2014;Lawrence et al., 2016;West et al., 2015). Authors also stated that students should engage in science practices to develop understanding of what scientists do (West et al., 2015;Deffit et al., 2017;Harmon et al., 2019), gain an appreciation for science and engineering (Ewing, 2015), clarify relevance of science to everyday life and increase engagement (Stuart et al., 2017), and prepare for college career and citizenship (Bokor et al., 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
Teachers are a critical component to standards-based reform systems, which require that reforms conceived at the national level pass through several layers of the educational system before impacting learning in the classroom. The Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) are an example of this type of reform and pose significant challenges for alignment between levels given their three-dimensional nature alongside inclusion of ambitious and novel reform ideas. To examine translation of NGSS reforms across levels, we provide a content analysis of alignment messages conveyed to teachers through practitioner literature. Analysis indicates some coherence with national messaging around alignment to performance expectations and science and engineering practices. Additionally, alignment to broader reform ideas like engaging in science practices, integration, engineering, and focus on phenomena were represented to teachers. However, qualitative analysis of these representations indicate that reforms are often superficially portrayed, variably defined, or missing altogether. Findings indicate that teachers receive numerous messages regarding what it means to align to the NGSS and few elaborations on how to operationalize reforms. Our work suggests a need for intentional consideration of how to design representations for practitioners that consider teacher sensemaking around novel reforms. Additionally, we see a need for further development of coherence among the research community regarding alignment to the NGSS and agreement on definition of key reform ideas. Future work should consider how teachers use and understand these representations as they enact the NGSS in their local contexts.
... It also helps develop skills such as attention to detail and pattern recognition, which are essential for scientific literacy (Ambrosino and Rivera, 2022). Ethograms, in particular, are an effective ethological teaching tool that can be easily integrated into students' observational investigations (Curran et al., 2016). ...
Article
Full-text available
Behavioral biology is a field that students find fascinating. To get the most out of the various benefits of teaching it, a practical approach should be followed. One way to do this is to use video recordings of animals which are analyzed using various software. However, learners will only benefit from this approach if they choose to actually use the provided technology. Therefore, it is critical to survey learners’ acceptance towards the use of software in the field of behavioral biology. For this purpose, 171 students were questioned at an out-of-school student lab called “KILab.” By applying the Technology Acceptance Model (TAM), we investigated students’ acceptance of authentic behavior evaluation software and possible factors influencing it. In addition, potential effects of the student lab on attitudes toward artificial intelligence and technology affinity were examined. The results show a high technology acceptance toward the used software and a dependence of this on the factors technology affinity and acceptance toward artificial intelligence. Furthermore, the use of the software has a positive impact on the self-assessed technology affinity and attitude toward artificial intelligence.The study thus shows that the use of video recordings and software for behavior analysis is generally suitable for educational use and can be a possible extension of the practical implementation of behavioral science education.
Article
Full-text available
Engaging undergraduate biology majors may present challenges for educators disseminating science concepts utilizing standard lecture classroom formats. Moreover, animal behavior courses teaching ethology may often require the use of live animals, field excursions, or students having to develop projects which can be both time-consuming or require financial investment, or that may not be well-suited to the flexibility of being taught online. Therefore, developing in-class activities which allow students to use self-discovery when generating their own observational data, work in groups, and practice hands-on science may serve to ameliorate these challenges facing faculty teaching animal behavior course content. To this end, I developed a straightforward, engaging in-class activity which allowed students to scan images available on the smartphone identifier iNaturalist to generate their own ethograms (catalogs of behaviors) for local state species. Students successfully described behaviors across a variety of animal taxa, reptiles, mammals, birds, and insects when generating their own ethograms and data, and they actively discussed how this activity enabled them to further understand both ethograms and their importance to animal behavior and overall how animals behave and allocate time performing a variety of behaviors. This activity can be modified for further use in both introductory and upper-level course work in organismal biology and can incorporate data analysis, graphing, or presentation skill sets for science majors.
Article
Anthropogenic activities are increasingly linked to emerging diseases that cause mortality across many taxa. Human interference arising from ecotourism, in particular, can increase the stress levels of wild populations and promote the spread of disease. In Akumal Bay, Mexico, green sea turtles ( Chelonia mydas ) are increasingly infected with fibropapillomatosis (FP), an infectious disease associated with stress‐induced immunosuppression linked to high human density, which is particularly high in this area because of the increasing number of tourists visiting all year round. To examine whether FP might be associated with behavioural indicators of stress and varying levels of tourist pressure, the behaviour of turtles and the number of tourists were observed through 20‐minute focal sampling periods from May to August 2017. Disease presence and tourist pressure were related to several aspects of turtle behaviour, specifically feeding, resting, vertical movements (i.e. surfacing and diving), and evasive responses. Turtles that had visible FP engaged in fewer feeding periods, vertical movements, and evasive responses. Additionally, with increasing tourist pressure, all turtles spent less time engaging in vertical movements and had more evasive responses. These results suggest that the presence of FP affects green sea turtle behaviour, potentially increasing their exposure to tourists. Sick and healthy turtles appear to react differently to tourists, suggesting that FP changes behavioural responses to tourist pressure. Future management strategies should consider regulating tourist pressure on sick animals to reduce the incidence and progression of FP and other wildlife diseases by limiting access to critical habitats and enforcing code‐of‐conduct compliance from visiting tourists.
Article
Full-text available
Technology use in science classes can enhance lessons and reinforce scientific content. The creation of multimedia projects is a great way to engage students in lessons about estuarine ecosystems. In this activity, students can learn about estuarine organisms and use their creativity to write a story, create artwork, and develop a multimedia presentation about the organisms using the Microsoft PowerPoint program. The projects can then be shared to inform others about life in an estuary. © 2014 by National Association of Biology Teachers. All rights reserved.
Article
Full-text available
The Spot-billed Pelican (Pelecanus philippensis), a near threatened bird and one of eight pelican species in the world, can be found only in South and Southeast Asia over an area between 129000 and 181000 �m 2 with strongholds in India, Sri Lan�a, southern Cambodia and coastal areas of Sumatra. In India, it is presently distributed in southern and northeastern India with concentrations in Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Karnata�a and Assam states. An ethogram of the Spot-billed Pelican was presented and as many as 25 individual behaviors grouped under nine different categories were described: resting, alert, comfort/maintenance, locomotion, foraging, antagonistic, sexual, chic� care and foraging, and vocalizations. Descriptions of behaviors of the Spot-billed Pelican in this paper would be immensely useful while preparing conservation and management plan for the species present both in the captive and wild condition.
Article
Full-text available
Pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) such as caffeine and sulfamethoxazole (SMX) are detected in the estuarine environment. The present study characterized effects of a maternal exposure of these compounds on the development of the daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio from embryo to juvenile life stage. Ovigerous females were exposed to either caffeine (20 mg/L), SMX (60 mg/L), or a mixture (20 mg/L caffeine and 60 mg/L SMX). Embryos were then removed from the females and the effects of the PPCPs on hatching, metamorphosis, juvenile growth, and overall mortality were determined. There was no significant effect on gravid female survival after 5 days of exposure to caffeine, SMX, or the mixture; however, development of the embryos on the female shrimp was delayed in the mixture. Caffeine and SMX in mixture significantly reduced embryo survival. There was a significant effect of caffeine, SMX, and the mixture on embryo hatching time. Exposure to SMX alone significantly delayed larval metamorphosis. Exposure to caffeine and SMX separately led to significantly smaller length of juvenile shrimp. Maternal exposure to caffeine and SMX, individually and in mixture, resulted in negative effects on P. pugio offspring survival and development; however, the concentrations tested in the present study were well above maximum detected field concentrations. These results may be incorporated into PPCP risk assessments to better protect sensitive estuarine ecosystems. Environ Toxicol Chem © 2014 SETAC.
Conference Paper
Full-text available
The bopyrid isopod Probopyrus pandalicola is an ectoparasite that infects palaemonid shrimp, including the daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio. The reproduction of parasitic isopods is thought to occur synchronously with host molting because the brood would be unsuccessful if molting occurred before the larvae were free swimming and could search for copepod hosts. Temperature affects the length of the molting cycle for shrimp, and therefore may also affect the timing of isopod brood development. The purpose of the present study was to determine the duration of each developmental stage of parasite young as a function of temperature, and to determine fecundity of the parasite. Parasitized shrimp were monitored at 15°C and 23°C within environmental chambers. Brood incubation and shrimp intermolt period were significantly longer at 15°C (34.6 d and 33.1 d, respectively) than at 23°C (11.1 d and 12.1 d, respectively). Epicaridium larvae remained in the parasite marsupium for 3.2 times longer at 15°C (8.7 d) than at 23°C (2.7 d). After brood release, the marsupium remained empty for 15% (3.8 d) of the intermolt period at 15°C, compared to only 5% (0.6 d) at 23°C. This indicates less synchronization between host molting and larval release at 15°C than at 23°C. Brood size ranged from 391 to 4,596 young, and was positively correlated with both parasite and host size. Brood development progressed more rapidly at a higher temperature, suggesting that a potential effect of warming climate could be the increased prevalence of Probopyrus pandalicola and perhaps other arthropod parasites.
Article
The daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio Holthuis, 1949 is prevalent in estuaries along the East and Gulf coasts of the United States, and is an integral part of the estuarine food web. Probopyrus pandalicola (Packard, 1879) is a bopyrid isopod that parasitizes P. pugio and decreases the energy available to its host by feeding on the hemolymph of the shrimp. The parasite also causes female shrimp to be castrated. The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of Probopyrus pandalicola on the survival time of P. pugio during starvation at two different temperatures. The experiment was conducted between September 2009 and June 2012 at 20.0 +/- 0.11 degrees C and 25.0 +/- 0.10 degrees C. Three trials at each temperature were performed. For each trial, parasitized, deparasitized and unparasitized shrimp were randomly placed into individual aquaria in a temperature-controlled chamber. All trials lasted until 100% shrimp mortality occurred. The bopyrid isopod did have a significant effect on shrimp survival times, but only at the higher temperature during which parasitized shrimp survived a significantly shorter amount of time (21.8 +/- 6.93 days) than unparasitized shrimp (25.2 +/- 8.25 days). In contrast, the bopyrid did not have a significant effect on shrimp survival times at the lower temperature, with shrimp surviving an average of 26.9-27.5 days. The results of this study have implications related to potential climate change, specifically higher temperatures, as we found that a small increase in temperature significantly affected the response of P. pugio to the isopod parasite. This supports prior research on other host-parasite interactions that are affected by increased temperature.
Article
The bopyrid isopod Probopyrus pandalicola is a hematophagous ectoparasite that sexually sterilizes some palaemonid shrimps, including female daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio. The reproduction of parasitic isopods is thought to occur synchronously with host molting because the brood would be unsuccessful if molting occurred before the larvae were free swimming. Temperature affects the length of the molting cycle of shrimp, and therefore may also affect the incubation time of isopod broods. The purpose of the present study was to determine the effect of temperature on brood development of the parasite and on synchronization with the molting of its host. Parasitized P. pugio were monitored daily at 2 experimental temperatures, 23 C and 15 C, in temperature-controlled chambers for the duration of a full parasite reproductive cycle. Developmental stage was determined by the visible coloration of the brood through the exoskeleton of the host, and was designated as egg, embryo I, embryo II, or epicaridium larvae. Temperature significantly affected median brood incubation time, which was only 11 days at 23 C, as compared to 35 days at 15 C. The final developmental stage (epicaridium larvae) was 3 times shorter at 23 C (median 3 days; n=45) than at 15 C (median 9 days; n=15). Temperature significantly affected the intermolt period of parasitized shrimp, which was shorter at 23 C (median 12 days) than at 15 C (median 37 days). A smaller percentage of the intermolt period elapsed between larval release and shrimp molting at 23 C (0.0%) than at 15 C (3.1%), indicating closer synchronization between host molting and parasite reproduction at the warmer temperature. At 15 C the isopods utilized a smaller proportion of the time that was available for brood incubation during the intermolt period of their host. Brood size ranged from 391 to 4,596 young and was positively correlated with parasite and host size. Since development progressed more rapidly at 23 C, warmer temperatures could increase the prevalence of P. pandalicola. The corresponding reduction in the abundance of ovigerous grass shrimp as a result of sexual sterilization by bopyrids could adversely impact estuarine ecosystems, as grass shrimp are a crucial link in transferring energy from detritus to secondary consumers.
Article
The grass shrimp, Palaemonetes pugio, is a dominant species uniquely adapted to a highly stressed tidal marsh embayment. Monthly sampling of length and dry weight revealed that its life cycle was a single year, with spawning in May, June, and July and most rapid growth in late summer and fall. Mark and recapture estimates conducted quarterly and quadrat net estimates calculated monthly indicated that shrimp were present throughout the year and that densities peaked in the fall (over 1.2 million in 0.01 km2 in October). Production of biomass (growth) equated loss to predation (including decomposition) over the annual cycle, averaging 0.2 kcal@?m^-^2@?day^-^1. Respiration averaged 1.1 kcal 1.1 kcal@?m^-^2@?day^-^1. Average daily production per square meter of "total consumables" (fecal pellets = 0.8 kcal, dissolved organic matter [DOM] = 0.7 kcal, biomass = 0.2 kcal) was 60% of total ingestion (2.9 kcal); production of feces and DOM thus outweighed biomass production 15:2. Microcosm studies and observations by scanning electron microscope revealed that shrimp macerated detritus into a heterogeneous assortment of uneaten particles by plucking away the cellular matrix from surfaces of large detrital fragments. This action provided cavities that became heavily invaded by pennate diatoms, and particles that became suspended in the water column and populated by bacteria. Nutrient analyses indicated the shrimp excreted large quantities of ammonia and phosphate which together with DOM release was presumably responsible for heavy growth of microflora and increased protein fraction in both feces and large and small uneaten detrital fragments. Palaemonetes pugio, while supporting its own trophic requirements, accelerated breakdown of detritus, preventing blockages or accumulations that might have occurred from pulses of emergent grass and macroalgal detritus in the embayment. This repackaging into feces, heterogeneous fragments, DOM, and shrimp biomass made detrital energy available at a variety of trophic levels, smoothing out organic pulses over time and space, and raising the efficiency of transfer to the food web. The special adaptation of P. pugio to the low-oxygen environment of the decomposer system appeared to limit predation and competition, allowing the shrimp to develop large populations necessary to carry out its role effectively.
Article
Abstract Probopyrus pandalicola is a bopyrid isopod that infects several palaemonid shrimp species, including the daggerblade grass shrimp Palaemonetes pugio. The parasite can have several negative effects on its host, including loss of hemolymph, reduced reproductive potential, and decreased molting frequency and growth. To date, there are conflicting reports on whether Probopyrus pandalicola affects the reproductive capability of both male and female daggerblade grass shrimp. The purpose of this study was to determine whether infection by Probopyrus pandalicola resulted in the sexual sterilization of Palaemonetes pugio, and if the reproductive capability of male and/or female shrimp was restored after the bopyrid was removed. We found that parasitized and deparasitized males were able to successfully fertilize the eggs of unparasitized females, as 18.9±7.1% and 42.7±5.2% of the females paired with them became ovigerous in 4 wk, respectively. Neither parasitized nor deparasitized females became ovigerous when placed with unparasitized males during the 4-wk period. However, 45.4±20.6% of deparasitized females did become ovigerous within 10 wk. Despite the fact that female shrimp are able to reproduce when no longer parasitized, the majority of females remain infected with the bopyrid for their entire lives. Therefore, the sexual sterilization of female shrimp could potentially have a significant impact on estuarine food webs, as grass shrimp are conduits of detrital energy and a food source for many recreationally and commercially important species in estuaries on the East Coast of the U.S.A. and in the Gulf of Mexico.