ArticlePublisher preview available
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract and Figures

Gambling self-reports may be subject to several types of bias, including social desirability bias, which may undermine their utility for capturing gambling behaviour in both research and clinical practice. Retrospective self-reports of gambling are frequently used to assess patterns of behaviour over specific periods of time, but may not be as reliable as experience sampling (ES) methods, which involve multiple assessments of gambling over the course of several days. The purpose of the current study was to examine the impact of two aspects of social desirability, impression management (IM) and self-deceptive enhancement (SDE), on the correspondence between reports of gambling assessed via ES and retrospective recall using the Gambling Timeline Followback (G-TLFB; Weinstock et al. Psychological Assessment, 16, 72–80, 2004). Participants were 81 emerging adult gamblers who completed a 30-day ES study and a retrospective assessment of their gambling. Although the overall association between social desirability and gambling reports was minimal, the correspondence between retrospective and ES reports was lower for those with higher scores on IM (for money won-lost) and SDE (for money intended to risk). Gamblers who wish to present themselves in a favourable way – either intentionally (IM) or unintentionally (SDE) – may be less reliable in their reports of gambling when asked to reflect on an extended period of time compared to when asked to provide an in-the-moment account of their gambling behaviour. These findings have important implications for understanding the circumstances under which individuals bias their retrospective self-reports of gambling and highlight the utility of more fine-grained assessments of gambling behaviour.
This content is subject to copyright. Terms and conditions apply.
Understanding the Effects of Social Desirability
on Gambling Self-Reports
Abby L. Goldstein
1
&Natalie Vilhena-Churchill
2
&
Melanie Munroe
1
&Sherry H. Stewart
3
&
Gordon L. Flett
4
&Peter N. S. Hoaken
5
Published online: 20 June 2016
#Springer Science+Business Media New York 2016
Abstract Gambling self-reports may be subject to several types of bias, including social
desirability bias, which may undermine their utility for capturing gambling behaviour in both
research and clinical practice. Retrospective self-reports of gambling are frequently used to assess
patterns of behaviour over specific periods of time, but may not be as reliable as experience
sampling (ES) methods, which involve multiple assessments of gambling over the course of
several days. The purpose of the current study was to examine the impact of two aspects of social
desirability, impression management (IM) and self-deceptive enhancement (SDE), on the corre-
spondence between reports of gambling assessed via ES and retrospective recall using the
Gambling Timeline Followback (G-TLFB; Weinstock et al. Psychological Assessment,16,72
80, 2004). Participants were 81 emerging adult gamblers who completed a 30-day ES study and a
retrospective assessment of their gambling. Although the overall association between social
desirability and gambling reports was minimal, the correspondence between retrospective and
ES reports was lower for those with higher scores on IM (for money won-lost) and SDE (for
money intended to risk). Gamblers who wish to present themselves in a favourable way either
intentionally (IM) or unintentionally (SDE) may be less reliable in their reports of gambling
when asked to reflect on an extended period of time compared to when asked to provide an in-the-
moment account of their gambling behaviour. These findings have important implications for
Int J Ment Health Addiction (2017) 15:13421359
DOI 10.1007/s11469-016-9668-0
*Abby L. Goldstein
abbyl.goldstein@utoronto.ca
1
Department of Applied Psychology and Human Development, Ontario Institute for Studies in
Education, University of Toronto, 252 Bloor Street West, 9-174, Toronto, ON M5S 1V6, Canada
2
Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, ON, Canada
3
Departments of Psychiatry, Psychology and Neuroscience, Faculty of Medicine and Faculty of
Science, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada
4
Department of Psychology, York University, Toronto, ON, Canada
5
Department of Psychology, Western University, London, ON, Canada
Content courtesy of Springer Nature, terms of use apply. Rights reserved.
... Second, as coders were employed to objectively measure the session evaluation variable, the session satisfaction reported directly by the clients could not be considered. Although self-reported data provide valuable insights into client perspectives, they can be susceptible to biases, such as social desirability and recall errors (Del Boca & Noll, 2000;Goldstein et al., 2017). Therefore, incorporating external observers or supervisors for a more comprehensive understanding and improving external validation, as suggested by Colli et al. (2015), could offer a perspective different from relying solely on self-reported measurements. ...
Article
Full-text available
The main objective of this study was to examine the role of psychological symptoms in the relationship between technological issues and session evaluation within the context of metaverse counseling. Evaluating the effectiveness of sessions within virtual counseling environments and understanding how psychological factors influence clients’ sensitivity to technological issues during these sessions seemed important. Dataset comprising 148 sessions with 25 South Korean clients and 6 counselors was used for analysis. The findings indicated that technological issues negatively influenced each session's evaluation (between session levels), but these issues did not significantly affect the overall session evaluation among clients (between‐client levels). Interestingly, clients with more severe psychological symptoms tended to be less satisfied with each counseling session when faced with more technological difficulties than clients who faced fewer psychological symptoms. The theoretical and practical implications of this study were further discussed, along with suggestions for future research.
... This study adopts quantitative method to identify the dimensions of tourism experience in gaming destination and explore its relations with cultural distances. When surveying gambling behavior, social desirability bias emerges as a significant factor that impacts the quality of the data (Goldstein et al., 2017). Online reviews, as a type of unstructured UGC, have the advantage of reducing the impacts of researchers' intrusion (Wong & Wu, 2013). ...
Article
This study focuses on the cultural distances between gaming tourists and service providers based on Hofstede's culture model and aims to identify the correlation between cultural distances and various experience components. Online reviews of casino resorts in Macau are collected from TripAdvisor. Seven key experience categories in casino resorts and their correlations with cultural distances of six national cultural dimensions are revealed by combining the topic modeling method and correlation analysis. The significance of correlations is found to vary with distinct types of experience categories, which provides new insight into the convergence-divergence debate of culture in tourism studies.
... To examine the relation between sport fandom and the intention to engage in online sports betting, the interaction effect of the perception of gambling needs to be tested. Due to individual social desirability, negative perceptions of gambling might be associated with online sports betting intention (Goldstein et al., 2017). Future studies should suggest a strategy to control excessive gambling behavior by controlling social desirability. ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose To extend research into sport consumer behaviors related to online sports betting, this study is designed to identify and examine the relationship between online sports betting motivations and online sports betting intentions. By applying a push-pull framework from online sport consumption and gambling studies, nine motivations to engage in online sports betting were identified. These motivations were hypothesized to motivate online sports betting intentions. Design/methodology/approach A quota sampling technique based on the sports bettor demographics available in the American Gaming Association (AGA, 2019) and the Pew Research Center (2022) obtained a total of 550 completed surveys that met the inclusion and exclusion criteria. For data analyses, confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) and structural equation modeling (SEM) were used to examine the measurement model and the hypothesized model, respectively. Findings The results revealed that four motivations (i.e. monetary gain, excitement, convenience and negative technology-readiness) were related to online sports betting intention, while five motivations (i.e. sport fandom, positive technology-readiness, impulsivity, socialization and promotion) were not. Originality/value The results provide foundational theoretical knowledge of what motivates sports fans to participate in online sports betting. Furthermore, the findings assist practitioners in their allocation of resources by enhancing their understanding of online sports betting motivations.
... Although self-reported gambling in general yield adequate reliability, helpline data may also include a lesser response bias than data from population surveys as callers with gambling problems are likely to have overcome feelings of embarrassment, stigma and shame that may increase the likelihood of desirable responding. 23,24 Helplines have a wide reach particularly in Europe and their client base reflects the population groups that have been identified at risk for gambling harms in population studies (particularly males, young individuals, and seniors). 22 Helpline data have been previously used to study trends in overall gambling harms within societies 25,26 or the main product categories causing harms at specific time points. ...
Article
Full-text available
Background Gambling products differ in terms of their harm potential. Products are also constantly developing and changing. However, little research has addressed changes and trends in the types of gambling that are associated with harms. The current study explores trends in the gambling product categories identified as harmful in longitudinal helpline data from three Nordic countries. Methods We use data collected by national helplines in Denmark (StopSpillet), Finland (Peluuri) and Sweden (Stödlinjen) in their daily operations (N = 46 646). The data consist of information collected on gamblers and concerned significant others who have contacted these helplines between January 2019 and December 2022. We analyse which gambling products are mentioned as harmful by clients. The analysis uses linear regression with the interaction term (country) times time regressed over the outcome variable (proportion per month). Results The results show that an increased share of contacts concern online gambling. Online casino products have become the most harmful category across contexts. The share of reported harms from online betting and new emerging online forms is also increasing. The share of land-based products as a reported source of harms has decreased across 2019–22. Conclusions The results suggest that online gamlbing environments, and particularly online casino products, are associated with increasing harms to help-seekers. The harmfulness of different gambling products may not be stable, but change over time. Further harm prevention efforts are needed to address the online gambling field, including emerging formats.
... A number of studies find negative correlations between social desirability bias and PG measures, but not gambling behaviour generally (e.g. gambling frequency, expenditure) (Goldstein et al., 2017;Kuentzel et al., 2008;Schell et al., 2021). While this evidence is correlational, it suggests that social desirability bias may lead to an underestimation of PG in surveys, but perhaps not gambling behaviour among the wider population. ...
Technical Report
Full-text available
Gambling is a large and growing industry. With that growth, there has also been growing concern about the potential harms that can arise from problem gambling. In late 2022, new legislation was introduced in Ireland to provide for more stringent regulation of the gambling industry and to establish an independent regulator, the Gambling Regulatory Authority of Ireland (GRAI). This review summarises and evaluates evidence from international research that is relevant to a number of policy questions. In doing so, it also identifies where evidence is deficient or lacking, to highlight some important and fruitful avenues for future research.
... While the use of retrospective questionnaires is widespread in psychology, it is nevertheless susceptible to involuntary distortions of memory (self-deceptive enhancement) and impression management (Goldstein et al., 2017). An in situ observational study is theoretically possible, though such close observation would be looked upon with suspicion and would pose ethical problems, particularly in terms of monitoring alcohol consumption. ...
Article
Full-text available
While comorbidity of problematic alcohol and gambling use is well established, much less is known about the way in which alcohol consumption while gambling interacts with problem-gambling severity and other individual differences. We hypothesised three factors that would interact with alcohol consumption while gambling on electronic gaming machines (EGMs) to influence four behavioural gambling measures: preferred number of lines bet, average duration of play, average spend per session and preferred electronic gaming machine denomination. The latter is a measure of gambler’s preference for the monetary denomination in which EGM bets are placed (e.g. 1 cent, 2 cents, 5 cents, 10 cents, 20 cents, $1), with higher denomination EGMs being higher risk since bets can be placed in larger amounts and money can be lost more rapidly. The three hypothesised interacting factors were problem-gambling severity, presence/absence of alcohol use disorder and biological gender. A total of 1557 male and female participants completed a questionnaire, measuring their problem-gambling status, problem alcohol status, consumption of alcohol at the gambling venue, preferred EGM denomination, preferred number of lines bet, average duration of play and average spend per session. We found the anticipated gender-differential spending effect with males spending more than females, but we also found a surprising reverse differential spending effect for problem gamblers such that females spent more than males. We also found that alcohol consumption while gambling was generally associated with a preference for higher denomination machines and that those players without alcohol problems who drank at the venue preferred to bet on more lines, suggesting a double-max strategy amongst gamblers who drank at the venue. Finally, for non-problem and low-risk gamblers, concurrent alcohol consumption was related to preference for higher denomination EGMs in female players, but not for male players. These findings are discussed in the context of the physiological and psychological effects of alcohol.
... Likewise, prevalence surveys rely on subjective self-reports, and are prone to error [7], such as selective non-response, or selection bias [6,8], and socially desirable responding [9]. Even the largest surveys have been shown to rely on the responses of a small number of the overall populace [6]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Introduction: Gambling is increasingly recognised as an important public health issue. Problem gambling is associated with highly negative impacts on physical, psychological and social well-being, not only for those who gamble but also for those around them. There has been a rapid expansion of internet gambling and attributes such as continuous play and instant rewards, and enhanced privacy may lead to a greater likelihood of gambling-related harms. In this randomised controlled feasibility study, we are testing (1) the acceptability and feasibility of three online responsible gambling interventions targeting people with low-to-moderate risk of online problem gambling and (2) the feasibility of a future full-scale randomised controlled trial (RCT) to test their effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. Methods and analysis: Four-arm randomised controlled feasibility study with qualitative substudy. One-hundred and forty UK residents with low-to-moderate risk of online gambling recruited via gambling operators and social media will be randomised (1:1:1:1) to either (1) goal setting, (2) descriptive norms messages (challenge perceptions of peer behaviours), (3) injunctive norms messages (challenge perceptions of peer attitudes) and (4) control (delayed intervention). Interventions will be delivered over 6 weeks and individually tailored. Outcomes, administered online, will be measured at baseline, 7 weeks, and 3 and 6 months post randomisation (including gambling risk behaviours and cognitions, anxiety and depression, quality of life, health use and productivity). Analyses will be descriptive, focusing on feasibility and acceptability of the interventions and study procedures. Telephone/online interviews, with a subsample of approximately 30 participants, will elicit experiences of participating in the study. Prespecified progression criteria will guide decisions around whether to progress to a definitive RCT. Ethics and dissemination: Ethical approval obtained from Bournemouth University Research Ethics Committee (reference number 33247). Participants will be given a participant information sheet plus a 'Key Facts' summary and will provide informed online consent. Findings will be published in peer-reviewed journals and presented at conferences and public engagement events. Trial registration number: ISRCTN37874344.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose of Review The purpose of this review was to identify possible sources of bias in the study of gambling among older adults. These sources of bias included social desirability bias including issues of increased stigmatization of gambling behaviors in older adults, recall bias including deficits in the recall of negative experiences, and selection bias including increased reliance on survey methods that are more likely to exclude older adults. Recent Findings Due to the paucity of research directly examining sources of bias in the study of older adult gambling, this review took recent developments in the field of gambling research and compared them across known issues in researching older adults taken from other fields. Those sources of bias that have the most support in the literature were discussed. Summary The trend of increased focus on the experiences of older adults in gambling research is likely to continue given the aging of the Global North and potential vulnerabilities to harm associated with old age. The field must make a more effort to directly assess unique sources of bias in this area in order to ensure that future findings are reflective of the wide range of experiences that is captured within the category of “older adult.”
Chapter
Full-text available
In psychological assessment, we aim for the most accurate description of some cognitive or behavioral attribute. In assessment involving self-reports, this objective is invariably haunted by the possibility of misrepresentation. Certainly we would be sceptical of self-reports of intelligence, perhaps because of its universal desirability. Among the few qualities typically rated as even more desirable than intelligence is having a good personality. Thus it seems dangerous to ignore the possibility that at least some respondents systematically misrepresent their own personality.
Article
Full-text available
We assessed the impact of two distinct forms of socially desirable responding—self‐deceptive enhancement and impression management—on sexuality self‐reports (n = 504) under anonymous testing conditions. Results revealed significant positive relationships between self‐deceptive enhancement and sexual adjustment variables for both sexes. Impression management was significantly negatively related to a number of intrapersonal (e.g., unrestricted sexual fantasies, sexual drive) and interpersonal (e.g., sexual experience, virginity status) sexual behaviors for females, and to unrestricted sexual attitudes and fantasies for males. We calculated correlations were first calculated between self‐deceptive enhancement, impression management, and personality and conservatism scores. Self‐deceptive enhancement and impression management were significantly associated with personality for males and females, and with conservatism for females only. When personality and conservatism variance were partialed out, associations between self‐deceptive enhancement and sexuality variables were eliminated, but associations between impression management and sexuality measures remained significant. These findings highlight the importance of a two‐factor approach to assessing socially desirable responding, and provide modest support for the view that response bias may intrude in self‐report sex data, even under anonymous testing conditions.
Article
Full-text available
High quality gambling participation and prevalence studies are important to monitor and manage risks associated with an ever changing gambling environment. Such studies are expensive and choices must be made to balance precision and cost constraints. Common approaches include not screening infrequent gamblers and/or gamblers with low gambling expenditure, on the assumption that these gamblers are unlikely to be problem gamblers. Some studies combine moderate risk and problem gamblers to obtain robust groups for analysis. The resultant methodological variations compromise comparability and interpretation of changes over time and across jurisdictions. The Victorian Gambling Study 2008-2012 (VGS) and the Swedish Longitudinal Gambling Study 2008-2014 (Swelogs) are large jurisdiction-wide surveys with sample sizes of 15,000 and 8,165 respectively. Both studies screened all past-year gamblers. This paper reports on the modelling of some common methodological variants. Understanding the impact of these different variations enables better design of future studies and facilitates comparisons between existing prevalence studies within and across jurisdictions.
Article
Full-text available
Stigma has been identified as a major barrier to help-seeking, treatment and recovery from gambling problems. However, little research has attempted to examine in any depth the causes, characteristics and consequences of stigma in relation to people experiencing gambling problems. The effects of stigma on people experiencing gambling problems, although not directly examined, are apparent through low rates of problem disclosure and treatment-seeking. In this paper, we aim to inform research into stigma associated with problem gambling by highlighting gaps in existing research and by providing direction for future research. The contribution of this paper is that for the first time stigma and problem gambling are drawn together and reviewed using broad constructs and literature from a range of seminal and new sources to present a synthesis of new and important information on stigma. In regards to problem gambling, the dimensions of stigma, except for origin, have yet to be investigated as well as the processes of stigma creation, the characteristics of public and felt stigma and coping strategies used to manage stigma. The practical implications of this review are summarised in a framework provided to inform future research into stigma related to problem gambling.
Chapter
The set of techniques known collectively as real-time data capture (RTDC) is becoming increasingly important in medical research. Based on the collection of data in people's typical environments, RTDC is primarily used with self-reported data, such as medical symptoms and psychological states. Now, its guiding principles and supporting technologies also provide a framework for scientists to monitor physiological information such as heart rate, blood pressure, and skin conductance. This volume gives the most complete view yet of the state of RTDC science and its potential for use across the health and behavioural sciences.
Article
The Experience Sampling Method (ESM) introduces in-situ sampling of human behaviour, and provides researchers and behavioural therapists with ecologically valid and timely assessments of a person's psychological state. This, in turn, opens up new opportunities for understanding behaviour at a scale and granularity that was not possible just a few years ago. The practical applications are many, such as the delivery of personalised and agile behaviour interventions. Mobile computing devices represent a revolutionary platform for improving ESM. They are an inseparable part of our daily lives, context-aware, and can interact with people at suitable moments. Furthermore, these devices are equipped with sensors, and can thus take part of the reporting burden off the participant, and collect data automatically. The goal of this survey is to discuss recent advancements in using mobile technologies for ESM (mESM), and present our vision of the future of mobile experience sampling.
Article
The current study examined the relationship between gambling motives and gambling in various social contexts using both retrospective and real-time assessment of gambling social context. Ninety-five young adults (79 males, 16 females; aged 19–24 years) who reported gambling at least 4 times in the past month participated. Scores on the Gambling Motives Questionnaire (GMQ; Stewart & Zack, 2008) were used as a measure of gambling motives (Enhancement, Social, Coping). Data on the social context of gambling (alone, with family, with friends, with strangers) were derived retrospectively from the Gambling Timeline Follow-Back (G-TLFB; Weinstock, Whelan, & Meyers, 2004) as well as in real time using experience sampling (ES) methods (Conner Christensen, Feldman Barrett, Bliss-Moreau, Lebo, & Kaschub, 2003). For both the G-TLFB and ES data, we conducted a series of multivariate regression analyses with the block of gambling motives predicting gambling behaviour in each social context. Across the two assessment methods, coping gambling motives positively predicted gambling alone, whereas social gambling motives negatively predicted gambling alone and positively predicted gambling with friends. These findings suggest that individuals who gamble for particular motives are more likely to do so in specific social contexts.