ArticlePDF Available

Inclusive Growth through Branchless Banking: A Review of Agent Banking and its Impact

Authors:
  • Eastern Bank Limited
  • Bangladesh Bank

Abstract

Branchless banking, the use of alternative delivery channels such as mobile banking and agent banking, is becoming increasingly popular among commercial banks in many developing countries. Branchless banking is believed to increase the use of financial services among financially excluded adults and is therefore becoming an increasingly popular phenomenon in many developing countries. Several countries adopted the concept of agent banking and getting huge success in the area of financial inclusion e.g. Kenya, Colombia, Brazil, Pakistan, Peru and so on. Post-Independence, the main concerns for Bangladesh has been its economic growth, poverty as well as food safety. We have achieved satisfactory growth over the last one decade. However one challenge is growth needs to be inclusive that is equally distributed among all sections of the society. Financial inclusion plays a critical role in achieving inclusive growth of a country. The study is therefore attempt to assess the contribution of branchless banking in inclusive growth in different countries. Further this paper sets out to try exploring the opportunities with branchless banking as a way to overcome barriers to financial access in Bangladesh. This would help to find out new opportunities for inclusive growth of Bangladesh.
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
86
Inclusive Growth through Branchless Banking: A Review of
Agent Banking and its Impact
Rezwan Mahmood
Independent Researcher & Banking Professional, Eastern Bank Limited, Bangladesh
Sandip Sarker
Management Trainee Officer, The Premier Bank Limited, Bangladesh & Independent Researcher
Abstract
Branchless banking, the use of alternative delivery channels such as mobile banking and agent banking, is
becoming increasingly popular among commercial banks in many developing countries. Branchless banking is
believed to increase the use of financial services among financially excluded adults and is therefore becoming an
increasingly popular phenomenon in many developing countries. Several countries adopted the concept of agent
banking and getting huge success in the area of financial inclusion e.g. Kenya, Colombia, Brazil, Pakistan, Peru
and so on. Post-Independence, the main concerns for Bangladesh has been its economic growth, poverty as well
as food safety. We have achieved satisfactory growth over the last one decade. However one challenge is growth
needs to be inclusive that is equally distributed among all sections of the society. Financial inclusion plays a
critical role in achieving inclusive growth of a country. The study is therefore attempt to assess the contribution of
branchless banking in inclusive growth in different countries. Further this paper sets out to try exploring the
opportunities with branchless banking as a way to overcome barriers to financial access in Bangladesh. This would
help to find out new opportunities for inclusive growth of Bangladesh.
Keywords: Agent banking, Bangladesh, Inclusive growth, Financial inclusion, Banks.
JEL Classification: G20, G21.
1. Introduction:
The use of formal financial services such as credit, savings, insurance and remittances is commonly referred to as
financial inclusion. An extensive body of research suggests that access to fundamental financial services is crucial.
It enables people to save for the future, invest in profitable business opportunities and to protect themselves against
unpredictable shocks (DemirgüçKunt, et al., 2008). After Independence, Bangladesh has come a long way in
ensuring inclusive growth. But there is no room for complacency, when it comes to the state of financial inclusion
in our country even after 42 years of Independence. The formal banking sector in the country has tried so many
things to expand their outreach and bring the marginalized people in the society under its umbrella. But still more
than 62 percent people lack access to the formal financial service. To bring this large number of people under the
coverage of the formal financial sector we need to think about devising some new mechanisms. Agent banking
can be one such mechanism. By using alternative delivery channels, such as mobile banking and agent banking,
the idea is to go beyond branches and increase the accessibility of financial services. Branchless banking is
believed to increase the use of financial services among financially excluded adults and is therefore becoming an
increasingly popular phenomenon in many developing countries. Agent banking is comparatively a new idea that
can help the formal banking sector reach out to the marginalized people of the society through their agents, who
will provide several banking services to the people locally. Understandably, agents will be appointed in such areas
where it will not be feasible for a bank to open a full-fledged branch. Agents will provide banking services to the
people on behalf of a bank and the nearest branch of the bank will provide necessary logistic support. Definitely
the agents will be guided by profit motive in addition to the clearly-defined roles and responsibilities for them.
The challenges for banks will be to devise a business model that will generate adequate revenue to compensate all
parties in the value chain as well as shape up the agent network and tackle the operational challenges to selecting,
training and managing agents. In short, agent outlets will be mirror bank branches. To make the business case
work, banks may offer the operators guaranteed monthly payments at a certain rate of commission per transaction
on top of it and may also provide armored car services. Agent banking has worked wonders in several developing
countries in different parts of the world like Brazil, Columbia, Peru, Malaysia, Kenya etc. Agent banking has been
a revolutionary inclusion in the financial system of Brazil as the agents there deal with almost everything like bills
and pension payments, cash deposits, withdrawals and money transfer. The list is not limited to these only, because
the number of services provided by the agent bankers is increasing with the passage of time. Even in the early
2,000s about a quarter of Brazil lacked access to formal financial services which has been mitigated to a great
extent after introduction of this mechanism. As reported by the Banco Central do Brasil, the central bank of Brazil,
since the introduction of agent banking, 12 million current accounts were opened across the agency banking
network within only three years and the total amount of transactions reached 2.6 billion reflecting the necessity of
such a service. Columbia and Peru also turned to the mechanism. Although in Columbia the bank branches covered
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
87
73 percent of the municipality, the agent banking helped raise the coverage to nearly 100 percent. In 2009, the
total numbers of transactions in Peru and Columbia were 67 million and 29 million respectively which were quite
big compared to the size of their respective economy. Agent banking in all three countries has been most successful
in easing payments made by different households such as utility bills, taxes etc. As data suggest, such payments
account for more than 70 percent of the total transactions in remote areas. Among other countries, Malaysia
implemented agent banking under the guidelines of the Bank Negara Malaysia, their central bank, in early 2012.
By the end of 2012 there were 4,120 agents deployed and they plan to increase it up to 5,000 agents by 2014. The
rate of financial inclusion in the sub-district of Mukims in Malaysia was less than 50 percent before the
introduction of agent banking, but now this rate has increased up to 75 percent. Agent banking was first
implemented in Kenya in 2010, when 32 percent of their total population lacked access to financial services. Since
the launch of agent banking, 10,000 agents have been licensed to supplement the services towards this section of
people left out. The impact was somewhat readily observed. Within 2011 the total transactions in terms of value
rose to US$ 24 million and the financial exclusion was reduced significantly. In Bangladesh, the outreach of
microfinance institutions (MFIs) is vast with more than 650 licensed MFIs operating in different regions with a
client base of up to 40 million. Most of the big organizations like BRAC, Grameen Bank and ASA have their
outreach in almost all over the country while the BRAC, in particular, has been able to launch its services in the
global arena as well. Having targeted the poverty-stricken segment of people, they have done a great job in
providing small-scale financial services to these marginalized people and making them included in the financial
system. But the services provided by the MFIs have their limitations as well. They charge a high rate of interest
and the procedure of collecting overdue payments is cumbersome. The regulatory framework of MFIs still needs
to pass the test of time. The MFIs also have limitations in respect to providing a wide range of financial services
to customers which a scheduled bank can provide. The study has attempted to identify the role of agent banking
in inclusive growth. The findings can serve as an important policy implication for developing countries that are
searching ways for inclusive growth.
2. Methodology:
The study is based on secondary data. Different journals have been used to find out the impact and activities of
agent banking in different countries. Their success stories as well as business models have been complied. At the
same time data from Bangladesh bank website has been used to compile the activities of agent banking by
commercial banks in Bangladesh. Based on the data some possible recommendations have been given which could
improve the agent banking activities in Bangladesh.
3. Agent Banking Model:
Agent banking, also known as correspondent banking, is a model for delivering financial services to locations for
which bank branches would be uneconomical. It is a delivery channel that holds high potential for closing the
delivery gap. Agent banking is a branchless banking model that allows financial institutions to use third party retail
agents and leverage on ICT to provide financial services outside the traditional brick and mortar bank premises. It
is opening up new windows of opportunity for financial institutions to reach out to more people, especially in
remote, rural areas, while bringing down costs of operation (Mas, 2008; Mas & Siedek, 2008). Banking agents can
be post offices, shops, pharmacies, microfinance institutions, retail outlets, supermarkets, petrol stations and
internet/communication centers. Agent banking presents various benefits for the banks, for the customers, for the
agents and for the country in which it is practiced. First and foremost, agent banking allows financial institutions
to establish physical presence in rural areas, remote areas or low population density where the cost of opening a
branch may not make business sense. Secondly, it allows customers to access financial services in a more familiar
way than in a branch as the unbanked are not familiar with the procedures of a traditional bank branch. Thirdly, it
increases the sales from customers seeking banking services while increasing the income source for the agents
through the commissions or fees they get from banks. Last but not least, agent banking contributes to a more
efficient and inclusive financial system by extending financial services to a wider population (Mas & Siediek,
2008).
4. Financial Inclusion in South Asia: Positioning Bangladesh
According to the Global Findex Survey 2015 (World Bank 2015), 46.4% of total adults have bank accounts at
formal financial institutions which were 33% in 2011. The number is higher in Sub-Saharan and Middle East
region. In the region, 42 percent of adults with an account made no deposits or withdrawals in the past year,
compared to 15 percent of adults with an account globally. It is also estimated that 625 million of the world’s
unbanked people live in south Asia. In addition to this, there are huge opportunities to expand financial inclusion
among women. In 2011, 24% of women have an account at formal financial institution compared to 37% in 2014.
The gender gap in developing economies remains unchanged from 2011 at 9% points. In South Asia shifting
payments from cash into accounts could significantly increase financial inclusion. Overall financial inclusion is
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
88
improving among the region’s poor but this is not enough. The gap between the adults living in the poorest 40%
of the household and adults living in the richest 60% of the household is 14% points. In developing economies
overall, the income gap in account penetration was 20% points in 2011. However, what matters most is whether
people use their accounts and how they are using those accounts. Among the account holders in South Asia, 42%
use their account to save or to make or receive payments. In Bangladesh, 22% of the account holders use their
account to save and only 1% of the account holders pay school fees through an account. Still 32% of the adults
pay school fees in cash.
Graph 1: Financial Inclusion Scenario in South Asia
Source: Global Financial Inclusion Database 2015
Graph 1 shows the financial inclusion scenario in south Asia. It shows that Bangladesh done well in terms
of mobile accounts. Among the countries in south Asia Sri Lanka and India has made significant progress. In Sri
Lanka nearly 82% of total adults have accounts at formal financial institution compared to 31% in Bangladesh.
Bangladesh has done well in terms of adults who borrowed from formal financial institutions. At the same time,
the progress of Bangladesh in terms of use of Internet to make payments is also satisfactory.
5. Agent Banking in Different Countries:
Many countries i.e. Colombia, Brazil, Peru, Kenya, India have already adopted agent banking as a way of financial
inclusion. Brazil has the largest agent network in the world with more than 140,000 agents, of which 47,000 are
authorized to handle deposits and open accounts (CGAP, Feb. 2010). Most agents include post offices, grocery
stores and other retail outlets. Brazil follows bank-based agent banking model but recently nonbank-based agent
banking has just started to emerge (EFInA, 2011). In Brazil, banks operate 71,000 deposit-handling agents in every
municipality of the country (Jayo, 2010). According to CGAP research from 2007 (Siedek), at least 75 percent of
Brazilians use branchless banking agents, compared to 43 percent who have a bank account. Brazilian agents
handle 2.4 billion transactions per year. In 2008, agents transacted 75% of the volume (agents made 1.6 billion
transactions) and 70% of the value (agents transacted a total of US$105 billion) of total bill payments in Brazil
(CGAP & FGV, 2010). Rural agents transact more deposits and withdrawals as a percentage of total transactions
(38%) than their urban counterparts (8%) (CGAP & FGV, 2010). Although permitted to offer several types of
services, less than 30% of agents actually handle bank accounts. Most specialize in receiving bill payments, which
account for approximately 75% of all agent transactions (47% of which are utility bill payments). Withdrawals
and deposits account for 12.6% and are nearly equally divided into savings and current accounts (including
simplified accounts). Only 0.16% of transactions are account opening and 7.3% are government transfers (CGAP,
Jan. 2010).
Colombia follows only bank-based agent banking and nonbank-based agents are not allowed under the
current regulations (EFInA, 2011). According to the Financial Inclusion Report 2013 by Banca de las
Oportunidades (BDO), 62% of total population had access to formal financial services in Colombia as at August
2011. Around 78 million transactions were made through agents from June 2007 to July 2011 which total values
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
India Bangladesh Sri Lanka Bhutan Nepal Pakistan Afghanistan
Adults who Borrowed from a Formal Financial Institution (% age 15+)
Adults with an Account at a Formal Financial Institution(% age 15+)
Mobile Account (% age 15+)
Used a debit card to make payments (% age 15+)
Used the Internet to pay bills or make purchases (% age 15+)
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
89
were approximately 15 billion pesos. Total number of agents in Colombia increased more than twice in 2011 and
it became 13,296 in the end of July whereas the number was 6,104 in January. Among them 78% agents were
operating in urban areas and rest 22% in rural areas. In Colombia, from August 2010 to July 2011, collections (of
utility bill payments) have made up the majority of transactions (around 1.8 million in July 2011), followed by
mandatory payments, such as loan repayments and official government payments, such as tax (over 800,000 in
July 2011). There have usually been more withdrawals made than deposits, but the numbers of these two
transaction types are consistently close. The numbers of credit applications, money transfers and opening of
savings accounts are negligible. In terms of the value of transactions, deposits and withdrawals constitute the two
highest transaction types (both were around US$180,000 in July 2011), followed by mandatory payments and
collections. Money transfers had the lowest value (consistently averaging around US$20,000 per month).
Peru follows bank-based agent banking model. As on December 2010, the total numbers of agents were
9,204 of which mainly are grocery stores, pharmacies, retail outlets etc. In Peru, agents carry out approximately
45 million transactions per year. In 2010, less than 50% of the total financial system transactions were conducted
through traditional bank branches and ATMs; and POS terminals accounted for 36% of total transactions (SBS &
CGAP, 2010).
Kenya follows mainly the nonbank-based agent banking model which are specially lunched by Mobile
Network Operators (MNO). M-PESA was the first such model which also famous worldwide. This service was
launched in 2007 and by April 2011 had more than 14 million users and 27,988 agent outlets (Safaricom, 2011).
In Kenya, MNOs’ combined total transactions through mobile payments amounted to Ksh 2.45 billion (US$24
million) per day (CBK, 2011). There are also bank-based agents operate in Kenya i.e. grocery stores, hotels,
supermarkets, pharmacies and telecommunications companies. In 2010, total numbers of bank based agents were
around 6,000 (CBK, 2011).
India follows both bank-based and nonbank-based agent banking model. Despite several attempts by the
Reserve Bank of India to amend the regulations to try to encourage greater commitment by banks, agent banking
has had limited impact to date on financial inclusion in India. In March 2011, there were 58,351 agents in India
of which 94% were in rural areas. An average of 8.4 deposits and 3.1 withdrawals were carried out by individual
FINO (a technology firm and one of the first pioneers of agent banking in India) agents each day in 2010. So, with
10,000 agents nationwide, approximately 84,000 deposits and 31,000 withdrawals are carried out per day. The
average deposit size was Rs. 175 (US$3.50) and the average withdrawal size was Rs. 368 (US$7.39) per agent.
So, approximately Rs 15 million (US$301,000) worth of deposits and Rs. 11 million (US$221,000) of withdrawals
are being processed each day (CGAP, Apr. 2010).
6. Agent Banking Success Factors:
A variety of factors have facilitated the development of agent banking in different countries. In Brazil, the Central
Bank has introduced and refined regulations regularly over last decade which have been supportive of agent
banking. Secondly, agents used as Conditional Cash Transfers (CCT) payment channel; so volume of transactions
were high and eventually made acting as an agent more profitable and therefore more appealing. Finally, banks
have been keen to use agents as a means of cost cutting and to increase their client base through geographic
expansion (CGAP, Jan. 10).
A combination of factors has contributed to the success of the agent banking model in Colombia. The
dedication of a specific public institution, the Banca de las Oportunidades, which lobbies the Financial
Superintendence of Colombia (SFC) for regulatory changes and subsidizes the creation of agents in
unserved/unbanked areas, has had a dramatic impact on financial inclusion. Secondly, agents have now acquired
experience in agent banking and this has led to increased confidence in agents and use of their services. Finally,
Colombia has flexible agent banking regulations which (i) allow any type of legal entity to act as an agent and
deliver financial services on its own premises; and (ii) allow agents to deliver a wide variety of financial services,
including account opening (EFInA, 2011).
In Peru, agents are the cheapest means of accessing financial services. Banks neither charge customers to
use agents nor allow agents to charge customers, thus positioning agent banking as the lowest cost channel.
Kenya’s regulators at the Central Bank of Kenya (CBK) have been much praised for their open and flexible
approach to regulating agent banking specially for nonbank-based agents. The role of the donors and the World
Bank in facilitating the development of agent banking in Kenya should not be underestimated. Alliance for
Financial Inclusion (AFI) also supported the CBK through its Knowledge Transfer Program (EFInA, 2011).
There are several key drivers supporting the development of agent banking in India. First, the government
appears to be committed to increasing access to finance and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) recognizes the
potential and risks posed by branchless banking models. The RBI has regularly tried to encourage the growth of
the agent banking model by relaxing its regulations and in 2005, it substantially relaxed its AML/CFT requirements
for banks specifically the identification and proof-of-residence requirements for small-value accounts which
created a favorable situation for branchless banking. Second, there is a winning combination of a large,
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
90
sophisticated banking sector; a dynamic and competitive mobile phone industry; and plenty of cutting-edge
technology providers (CGAP, Jan. 2010).
7. Agent Banking Scenario In Bangladesh
More than 62% of the population still lacks access to the formal financial service. Agent banking can be one
mechanism to bring this large number of people under the coverage of the formal financial sector. Agent banking
is comparatively a new idea that can help the formal banking sector reach out to the marginalized people through
their agents, who will provide several banking services to the people locally. Bangladesh Bank, the Central Bank
of Bangladesh, has issued licenses to four private commercial banks for running agent banking operations among
which Bank Asia and Dutch-Bangla Bank already started recruiting agents at the grassroots level from January 19,
2014 to offer banking services through them. Another two banks i.e. South Bangla Agriculture and Commerce
Bank and NRB Commercial Bank are going to launch the service soon. Bank Asia, as the pioneer, successfully
introduced Agent Banking in 6 (six) Upazila under Munshiganj District as a pilot Project. This success has given
the confidence to expand the project all over Bangladesh. Bank Asia had already appointed 55 agents in 38
Upazilas under 20 districts while Dutch-Bangla recruited 35 sub-agents under 19 districts.
Bank Asia, the pioneer in agent banking in Bangladesh, has made a unique Agent Banking model with
technology based banking concept ensuring appropriate security with real-time banking for customers. Besides,
following steps are taken for smooth handling of Agent Banking:
Bank Asia Agent Booths are distinctly branded with Bank Asia logo & Agent’s name, a like to a small
bank branch.
Bank Asia branches and Regional office will monitor agent operating in the area for smooth functioning
besides monitoring by Agent Banking department.
Bank Asia agent are fully equipped with I.T devices like POS ,card reader, Image capturing Web Cam,
biometric identification system and mobile connectivity through internet banking.
All Agent Banking Customers are logged through their Biometric authorization.
Customer transactions are integrated to the Core Banking System and real time transaction and customer
gets instant transaction confirmation through SMS and system generated printed receipt.
Bank Asia Agent booths are branded through Bank's logo clearly, which identifies the Bank and agents
identity to the customer. Bank’s contact number and call center number also given for emergency
customer help.
For cash transaction, Agent have to maintain an account in Agent Banking system, which is fetched for
cash deposit and withdrawal transaction by customers and system automatically debit or credit agent
account and customer account simultaneously . Agent has to maintain sufficient balance to accommodate
customer transaction value. The Agent account balance is determined on the volume of transaction and
Agent account have to maintain sufficient balance and Cash in hand balance for uninterrupted transaction
of customers.
The bank has also taken some Customer Protection Policy as given below:
Only Bank's approved Products and Services will be offered to the customers of Agent Banking;
Agent booths are branded with Bank Asia Agent Banking Logo for identification with Contact address
and Telephone number of Bank Asia at each Agent Booth;
Notification in Bangla is placed at Visible Manner for awareness of customer about Agent Banking
transaction and Bank Charges;
Agent banking customers Deposit will be under cover of Bank Deposit Insurance scheme under Insurance
Act-2000.
For smooth operation of Agent Banking function a separate Department in the name and style "Agent Banking
Department" has been created by Dutch-Bangla Bank. The Department will serve wide range of customers
throughout the country by providing banking and financial services with the help of mobile telecommunication
devices/ computer system/ using biometric technology. Especially for clients in remote locations, Agent Banking
Department will help them deposit and withdraw funds and other admissible services at banking agents, i.e., retail
outlets that turn Deposit to electronic funds and vice versa. With the help of the agent banking service customer
can enjoy the convenience of banking service at any place of the country. An Agent must provide, as a minimum,
cash deposit and cash withdrawal services. The agent's activities could be within normal course of banking
business of the DBBL but conducted at places other than bank premises ATM booths. Agent must provide services
in the designated business premises.
The following services will be covered under Agent Banking in Bangladesh as per Bangladesh Bank’s guidelines:
Collection of small value cash deposits and cash withdrawals (ceiling should be determined by the
management of the Bank from time to time in line with the guideline of central bank);
Inward foreign remittance disbursement;
Facilitating small value loan disbursement and recovery of loans and installments;
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
91
Facilitating utility bill payment;
Cash payment under social safety net programmed of the Government;
Facilitating fund transfer (ceiling should be as per limit given by Bangladesh Bank from time to time);
Balance and Statement inquiry;
Collection and processing of forms/documents in relation to account opening, loan application, credit and
debit card application from public;
Post sanction monitoring of loans and advances and follow up of loan recovery;
Receiving of clearing cheque;
Other functions like collection of insurance premium including microinsurance etc;
ATM Withdrawal;
Merchant Payment;
Fund transfer [Person to Person (P2P), Person to Business (P2B), Business to Person (B2P), Person to
Government (P2G), Government to Person (G2P), Business to Government (B2G), Government to
Business (G2B)]
As per Central Bank’s guidelines, agents are not allowed to provide the following services on behalf of the banks:
Giving final approval of opening of bank accounts and issuance of bank cards/ cheques;
Dealing with loan/ financial appraisal;
Encashment of cheques; and
Dealing in Foreign currency.
8. Policy Initiatives by Bangladesh Bank:
Bangladesh Bank, the central bank of Bangladesh, had issued a circular on December 9, 2013 approving agent
banking in the rural areas where banks have no branches. Bangladesh Bank has issued ‘Guidelines on Agent
Banking for the Banks’ as per authority conferred to it by Article 7A (e) of Bangladesh Bank Order, 1972, Section
45 of Bank Company Act, 1991 and Section 4 of Bangladesh Payment and Settlement Systems Regulations, 2009.
The guidelines were issued for promoting agent banking as a complimentary channel for financial inclusion and
supervising agent banking of banks. According to Section 7(1) and 7(2) of Guidelines on Agent Banking,
scheduled banks in Bangladesh are required to obtain prior approval from Bangladesh Bank for undertaking agent
banking business. In another circular on January 6 this year, the central banks endorsed agent banking also in the
urban areas not covered by traditional banking system.
9. Concluding Remarks
From the above discussion it is evident that agent banking can serve as an important tool of inclusive growth of a
country. In Bangladesh, the opportunities are also high. Therefore, some possible actions can be taken to create
significant impact on inclusive growth through agent banking in Bangladesh. It can be done through favorable
agent banking policies on which Bangladesh bank is working. Evidence shows that the success of agent banking
in different countries depended on their favorable and flexible policies regarding agent banking and continuous
efforts by the Central Banks of those countries. Wholehearted contributions from commercial banks are a must.
So, Bangladesh Bank needs to focus on that issue to encourage commercial banks to come forward enthusiastically.
Additionally, both agents and customers need to be motivated to make the agent banking concept successful. Using
agents should be cost effective for banks, less costly for customers, and profitable for agents. Incentives can be
given to the customers who are using agent for their transactions so that they can be motivated more to use such
alternative financial channel. At the same time, different seminars as well as conferences on agent banking like
school banking can be organized on a regular basis to promote its usefulness. Even government can engage
different NGOs to develop and create financial literacy and knowledge among the customers regarding agent
banking. Finally holistic effort by the government, Bangladesh bank, commercial banks, MFIs as well as mobile
companies can create awareness among people in using agent for different financial services.
Agent banking can ensure the access of the marginalized people to several financial services, especially
in remote areas. It can work wonders in financial inclusion and enhancing financial activity in remote areas. It can
also prove financially viable for the formal banking sector. If the vibrant banking sector puts relentless efforts by
following the proper guidance of the central bank, agent banking can prove an effective tool for enhancing financial
inclusion and materializing the dream of a poverty-free Bangladesh. In Bangladesh, there are huge opportunities
of financial inclusion through agent banking. Bangladesh bank has already taken some initiatives to promote agent
banking and achieve inclusive growth. Since agent banking activities has started in 2013, there is little data on that.
In future, further research can be carried out with large set of data to measure the impact of agent banking in
inclusive growth in Bangladesh.
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
92
References
Banca de las Oportunidades (BDO). Financial Inclusion Report 2013. From:
http://www.bancadelasoportunidades.gov.co/documentos/Reporte%20Inclusion%20Financiera/3er_rep
orte/reporte_ver_ingles/reporte_web_ingles.pdf
Central Bank of Kenya. (2011) Remarks by Prof. Njuguna Ndung'u, Governor, Central Bank of Kenya, at the
launch of the draft electronic retail transfers and draft electronic money issuers Regulations.
CGAP (April, 2010). Building viable agent networks in India. From:
http://www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/connect/73590c8049585f409f8abf19583b6d16/Tool+10.8.+CGAP+Anal
ysis+-+FINO+and++EKO+Channel+Management.pdf?MOD=AJPERES
CGAP (February 2010). Nationwide impact of agents in Brazil. From: http://www.cgap.org/blog/nationwide-
impact-agents-brazil
CGAP (January, 2010). Update on Regulation of Branchless Banking in Brazil. From:
http://www.cgap.org/publications/regulation-branchless-banking-brazil
CGAP (January, 2010). Update on Regulation of Branchless Banking in India. From:
https://www.cgap.org/sites/default/files/CGAP-Regulation-of-Branchless-Banking-in-India-Jan-
2010.pdf
CGAP and FGV (2010). Branchless Banking Agents in Brazil: Building Viable Networks. From:
http://technology.cgap.org/2010/02/25/nationwideimpact-of-agents-in-brazil/
DemirgüçKunt, Aslı, Thorsten Beck, and Patrick Honohan. (2008). Finance for All? Policies and Pitfalls in
Expanding Access. World Bank, Washington, DC.
EFInA (October, 2011). Evaluation of Agent Banking Models in Different Countries. From:
http://www.efina.org.ng/assets/Documents/EFInAAgent-banking-study-report-26-Oct-
2011.pdf?phpMyAdmin=%2CWvBxPNpx0z2BcKe8h2UcHJI%2CXb.
International Monetary fund (2014). Financial Access Survey (FAS). [FAS_Dataset]. From:
http://fas.imf.org/Default.aspx
Jayo, M. (2010). Network integration modelsin the Brazilian banking correspondents channel: A qualitative
taxonomy. Report prepared for CGAP on April 2010.
Mas, I, (2008). Realizing the Potential of Branchless Banking: Challenges ahead.
Mas, I. & Siediek, H. (2008). Banking through Networks of Retail Agents. CGAP Focus Note No. 47, Washington,
D.C.
Safaricom (2011). M-PESA Customer and Agent Numbers. From: http://www.safaricom.co.ke/personal/m-
pesa/m-pesa-agents
SBS & CGAP (February, 2010) Financial Inclusion and Consumer Protection in Peru: The branchless banking
business. From: http://www.cgap.org/publications/financial-inclusion-and-consumer-protection-peru
Siedek, H. (2007). Banking Agents - Market Reach. From: http://www.cgap.org/gm/document-
1.9.2115/agents_marketreach.pdf.
Websites
Banca de las Oportunidades: http://www.bancadelasoportunidades.gov.co/ (accessed on 07 August 2015).
Banco Central do Brasil: http://www.bcb.gov.br/?ENGLISH (accessed on 07 August 2015).
Bangladesh Bank: https://www.bb.org.bd/ (accessed on 22 July 2015).
Bank Asia Ltd: http://www.bankasia-bd.com/agentbanking/ (accessed on 22 July 2015).
Central Bank of Kenya: https://www.centralbank.go.ke/ (accessed on 12 August 2015).
Central Reserve Bank of Peru: http://www.bcrp.gob.pe/home.html (accessed on 12 August 2015).
CGAP: http://www.cgap.org/p/site/c/tech/ (accessed on 01 August 2015).
Dutch Bangla Bank Ltd: http://www.dutchbanglabank.com/electronic-banking/agent-banking.html (accessed on
22 July 2015).
M-PESA: http://www.safaricom.co.ke (accessed on 21 August 2015).
Reserve Bank of India: https://www.rbi.org.in/ (accessed on 15 August 2015).
Authors Profile:
Rezwan Mahmood is an Independent Researcher and a Banking Professional of Eastern Bank
Limited, Bangladesh. He received BBA and MBA degree from Khulna University, Bangladesh
and PGD in Human Resources Management from Bangladesh Institute of Management under
the Ministry of Industries, Bangladesh. He has several publications in international journals.
His areas of interest include Marketing, Management and Human Resources Management
especially in the service industry. He also conducted several researches in the field of Social
Science & Development Economics.
Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development www.iiste.org
ISSN 2222-1700 (Paper) ISSN 2222-2855 (Online)
Vol.6, No.23, 2015
93
Sandip Sarker is currently serving as Management Trainee Officer at The Premier Bank
Limited, Bangladesh. He has completed his BBA & MBA from Khulna University. He has
several publications in the area of business & development economics. Further he also attended
several conferences in home & abroad where he presented his research works. His area of
interest includes Development Economics.
... According to Bangladesh Bank (2013) providing banking services on a limited scale to the deprived class of people of the society through agents appointed by valid agreement instead of a teller/cashier is called agent banking. It is like an outlet that provides services like deposit collection and withdrawal facility, funds transfer facility, collections of bills, etc on behalf of a bank (Mahmood & Sarker, 2015). That's the reason it is called agent banking. ...
... Some of the early studies have been done by (Dermish, Kneiding, Leishman, & Mas, 2011;Mahmood & Sarker, 2015;Mangani, Heatubun, & Tambunan, 2021) conducted some of the first research in Latin America after the agency banking system was established. According to their research, branchless banking reduces service delivery costs; platforms are mostly used to make client payments, rather than saving or credit; and a lower number of people have started utilizing branchless financial banking services than expected. ...
Article
Full-text available
In recent times, commercial agent banking services have got considerable attention from academia and the banking industry for accelerating financial inclusion in emerging economies. However, it's incomprehensible to accelerate the economic progression through financial inclusion while ignoring a huge segment of the nonbank people from unprivileged areas. A very few studies have been conducted on the association between agent banking services and financial inclusion in emerging economies such as Bangladesh. The present Business Management and Strategy ISSN 2157-6068 2021, Vol. 12, No. 2 207 study aims to investigate the impact of agent banking services provided by commercial banks on financial inclusion. To begin with the investigation, this study was based on agency theory considering the purposive sampling technique. This quantitative study was conducted on 19 commercial banks which are currently providing agent banking services in Bangladesh. An econometric model was proposed whereas the dependent construct has one specific dimension named as financial inclusion proxy by several accounts as a percentage of the adult population, in contrast, the independent construct had three dimensions named as-deposited amount, credited amount, and inward remittance of agent bank. In addition to that, this econometric model was based on secondary data whereas data analysis was conducted by considering panel data statistical method using GRETL (2019) software. This statistical analysis revealed that currently both the deposited amount and credited amount do have a significant impact on financial inclusion. It has also been inferred that using agent banking for in-warding remittance and new accounts open by clients have a positive significant relationship with financial inclusion. It is argued that agent banking services by comprising unbanked people in financial inclusion will ultimately prompt the opportunity for proper mobilization of resources and funds while maintaining safety and security. Further, it is also claimed that this study would assist to illustrate the present performance of agent banking services in financial inclusion from a multidimensional perspective which will contribute to providing some more innovative and sustainable products and services towards the unbanked people. Finally, this study recommends that commercial banks through agent banking should include a maximum number of nonbank populations into the financial inclusion by ensuring sustainable agent banking services which will accelerate the emerging economics Sustainable Development Goal (SDGs) performance.
... Agent banking may be one of the most effective mechanisms to include this big population in the formal financial system. (Mahmood & Sarker, 2015) Serving Bangladesh's unbanked population has been ranked as one of Bangladesh Bank's top priority for promoting financial inclusion in Bangladesh. Agent banking is an important one of the many steps Bangladesh Bank has done and policies it has set up to encourage financial inclusion. ...
Article
Full-text available
Agent banking is working as the strongest medium of financial inclusion in Bangladesh now a days. The unbanked population of the rural areas are getting the opportunity of having financial transactions through agent at their convenient place and people and banks. The aim of this paper is to bring in light the updated scenario of agent banking operation in Bangladesh for the last five years from September 2018 to September 2022. The paper focused the year wise financial inclusion rate and growth of the rural, unbanked, and lowly community of Bangladesh through the point of view from agent banking. The study used the agent banking consolidated report from published secondary data from the Bangladesh Bank's financial inclusion wing to perform the five years comparative analysis. The study used total population sampling obtained from purposive sampling technique and the analysis is done on growth rate calculation and five years trend by MS Excel. The analysis is a summary of all the thirty-one scheduled commercial banks data who are currently practicing agent banking services according to the guideline of Bangladesh bank. Introduction: Bringing a wide range of people from a huge population under financial services is a big challenge. This challenge is further magnified when financial services concepts are not readily available to all. Moreover, factors such as corruption and mismanagement create reluctance among the public to participate in the financial service sectors. (Rising Risks in Bangladesh's Banking Sector, n.d.) Bringing the unbanked population into the official financial system is known as financial inclusion. (Khanam, 2022) Financial inclusion in Bangladesh has been a multi-decade effort to reach those that had previously had little access to structured finance. Since starting with microcredit, this journey has expanded to include all facets of financial inclusion, including access, usage, and quality. (Peer-Learning Series: Fintech and Financial Inclusion and the Case of Bangladesh, n.d.) Bangladesh has successfully deepened financial inclusion, as evidenced by statistics from Scheduled Bank that show the percentage of urban-based branches risen from 42.6% to 51.5% from the years 2010 to 2019 while the percentage of rural-based branches decreased from 57.4% to 48.5% due to reasons such as modifying the definition of urban area and private banks' partial treatment of rural areas. As a result, opening of rural branches should be taken into consideration. But the positive side is, the percentage of branches
... Agent banking was then introduced as a model that could help deliver financial services to places where having bank branches would not be economically feasible. Mahmood and Sarker (2015) define agent banking as a delivery channel that possesses great potential for minimizing the delivery gap, allowing for branchless banking so that third-party retail agents can close in on ICT to provide financial services outside the traditional brick and mortar premises. Examples of these in South Africa are CapFin and M-PESA, which are largely used in the African context. ...
... Increased customer base and geographical spread of agent banking activities ensures financial deepening (Waithanji, 2012). Agent banking ensures enhanced financial activities in the remote parts of the country and greater access of the marginalized people and thus can contribute to financial inclusion (Mahmood and Sarker, 2015). ...
... In the current covid-19 condition, branchless banking will help the community remain served by financial services (Shahabi et al., 2021). Inclusive financial services with agents are the main thing in promoting economic growth in a country (Mahmood & Sarker, 2015). Branchless banking can have a positive impact on MSMEs in developing their business (Sarika, 2015). ...
Article
Full-text available
Purpose – This study aims to examine the effect of branchless banking on the level of profitability in Islamic banks. Methodology – This study uses two Islamic banks that have implemented branchless banking (BRI Syariah and BTPN Syariah) and two Islamic banks that have not implemented this policy (BNI Syariah and Bukopin Syariah). This study uses regression analysis techniques with panel data. The model used in this study is the fixed effect model. Findings – This study shows that the branchless banking policy has a positive impact on profitability. This result implies that the implementation of branchless banking can improve the performance of Islamic banks in Indonesia. So, it is hoped that other Islamic banks can implement this branchless banking policy to overcome the limitations of their network. In addition, branchless banking can expand customer reach to areas that have not been served well by Islamic banks. Originality – Research on branchless banking in Islamic banks in Indonesia is still limited. There are only few studies comparing banks that have implemented branchless banking with banks that have not implemented this policy. Therefore, this research will contribute to a study that discusses branchless banking in Islamic banks in Indonesia, especially its impact on performance.
... Inclusive banking services using agents can be an important service in promoting economic growth in a country (Mahmood and Sarker, 2015). Therefore, banks should be able to have a long-term relationship between the organizers of smart conductors and agents. ...
Article
Full-text available
Laku Pandai’s program is one of the policies that implemented by the financial service authority (OJK) to expand the banking service to the people. One of the Islamic banks that had implemented the program is Bank of BRI Sharia. This research is going to examine the effectiveness of Laku Pandai’s program to deposit funds in Bank of BRI Sharia. This study using regression with the dummy variable. The result shows that there is a difference between pre and post-Laku Pandai’s program in Bank of BRI Sharia. This result implies that the Laku Pandai’s implementation had an impact on increasing deposit funds in Bank of BRI Sharia. So, it is recommended to add more Islamic banks that implemented the Laku Pandai’s program
Article
Full-text available
Serving the unbanked people of Bangladesh has been considered as one of the top priorities by Bangladesh Bank for fostering financial inclusion in Bangladesh. As a result, Bangladesh Bank has taken several measures and structured some policies for promoting financial inclusion and agent banking is significant among those.. This paperattempts to highlight and assesscurrent practices of agent banking and critically examine therole of commercial banks in promoting financial inclusion through agent bankingin Bangladesh.The growth rate of agent banking in terms of numbers of banks, agents, outlets and amounts of deposits, credits and remittance is outstanding in Bangladesh. In this paper it has been found that, in the third quarter of 2018, the average growth rate is more than 15%.Some variables like total number banks offering agent banking service, total amount and number of loan disbursed, bankwise contribution, total number of customers and agents, total amount of deposit collected have been investigated to reflect the magnitude of agent banking in Bangladesh. The empirical results indicate that, contribution of agent banking in serving unbanked people, disbursement of loan and collection of deposit is increasing in every quarter and DBBL has the highest contribution in terms of total agents, customers and transaction compared to other banks offering agent banking services. Finally, some opportunities and challenges of agent banking in Bangladesh have been discussed in this research paper.
Article
Full-text available
This paper constructs a study on recognizing the determinants of capital structure by using panel dataset of 38 manufacturing companies in Bangladesh over the year from 2013 to 2018. This study also constructs a comparative test between Pecking order theory and Trade-off theory. Fixed Effects Models are used, as multiple linear regression model, in this study to determine the impacts of nine independent variables on debt financing and its components. As determinants; financial distress(-), size(+), growth(+), non-debt tax shield(-)and tax rate(+)influence on debt financing; efficiency(+), liquidity(+), non-debt tax shield(-), financial distress(-), size(+), tax rate(+)and tangibility(+)influence on long-term debt ratio; tangibility(-), liquidity(-), growth(+)and non-debt tax shield(- )influence on short-term debt ratio. The study finds the dominant influence of trade-off theory, which indicates while companies take the capital structure decisions, they trade-off between the tax benefits from debt financing and the bankruptcy costs for debt financing.
Article
Technology can enable banks and their customers to interact remotely in a trusted way through existing local retail outlets. Customers can be issued bank cards with appropriate personal identification number (PIN)-based or biometric security features, and the local store - the “banking agent” - can be equipped with a point-of-sale (POS) device controlled by and connected to the bank using a phone line or wireless or satellite technology. Infrastructure requirements can be further reduced by using mobile phones both to hold “virtual cards” for customers and as a POS device at the store.
Article
In this paper we further develop a broad vision for financial inclusion sketched out in Mas (2008), where payments can be easily made through an electronic network. What makes visioning such a payments utility possible is the technology we have today, which can be used to bridge distances, close information gaps, contain settlement risks, and generally reduce transaction costs. We are confident that today’s technology can do the job. Now the challenge is to develop attractive services that engage customers and workable business models that enable decentralized, largely private, institutions to build this payments utility.
Network integration modelsin the Brazilian banking correspondents channel: A qualitative taxonomy
  • M Jayo
Jayo, M. (2010). Network integration modelsin the Brazilian banking correspondents channel: A qualitative taxonomy. Report prepared for CGAP on April 2010.
Evaluation of Agent Banking Models in Different Countries
  • Efina
EFInA (October, 2011). Evaluation of Agent Banking Models in Different Countries. From: http://www.efina.org.ng/assets/Documents/EFInAAgent-banking-study-report-26-Oct-2011.pdf?phpMyAdmin=%2CWvBxPNpx0z2BcKe8h2UcHJI%2CXb. International Monetary fund (2014). Financial Access Survey (FAS). [FAS_Dataset]. From: http://fas.imf.org/Default.aspx
From: http://www.safaricom.co.ke/personal/m- pesa/m-pesa-agents SBS & CGAP) Financial Inclusion and Consumer Protection in Peru: The branchless banking business. From: http://www.cgap.org/publications/financial-inclusion-and-consumer-protection-peru Siedek Banking Agents -Market Reach
  • M-Pesa Safaricom
  • Agent Customer
  • Numbers
Safaricom (2011). M-PESA Customer and Agent Numbers. From: http://www.safaricom.co.ke/personal/m- pesa/m-pesa-agents SBS & CGAP (February, 2010) Financial Inclusion and Consumer Protection in Peru: The branchless banking business. From: http://www.cgap.org/publications/financial-inclusion-and-consumer-protection-peru Siedek, H. (2007). Banking Agents -Market Reach. From: http://www.cgap.org/gm/document- 1.9.2115/agents_marketreach.pdf.
Central Bank of Kenya, at the launch of the draft electronic retail transfers and draft electronic money issuers Regulations
Central Bank of Kenya. (2011) Remarks by Prof. Njuguna Ndung'u, Governor, Central Bank of Kenya, at the launch of the draft electronic retail transfers and draft electronic money issuers Regulations. CGAP (April, 2010). Building viable agent networks in India. From: http://www.ifc.org/wps/wcm/connect/73590c8049585f409f8abf19583b6d16/Tool+10.8.+CGAP+Anal ysis+-+FINO+and++EKO+Channel+Management.pdf?MOD=AJPERES CGAP (February 2010). Nationwide impact of agents in Brazil. From: http://www.cgap.org/blog/nationwideimpact-agents-brazil CGAP (January, 2010). Update on Regulation of Branchless Banking in Brazil. From: http://www.cgap.org/publications/regulation-branchless-banking-brazil CGAP (January, 2010). Update on Regulation of Branchless Banking in India. From: https://www.cgap.org/sites/default/files/CGAP-Regulation-of-Branchless-Banking-in-India-Jan-2010.pdf CGAP and FGV (2010). Branchless Banking Agents in Brazil: Building Viable Networks. From: http://technology.cgap.org/2010/02/25/nationwideimpact-of-agents-in-brazil/
Banking through Networks of Retail Agents
  • I Mas
  • H Siediek
Mas, I. & Siediek, H. (2008). Banking through Networks of Retail Agents. CGAP Focus Note No. 47, Washington, D.C.
M-PESA Customer and Agent Numbers
  • Safaricom
Safaricom (2011). M-PESA Customer and Agent Numbers. From: http://www.safaricom.co.ke/personal/mpesa/m-pesa-agents