Design and management of reconfigurable assembly lines in the automotive industry

ArticleinCIRP Annals - Manufacturing Technology 65(1) · June 2016with 118 Reads
Cite this publication
Abstract
Automotive suppliers are facing the challenge of continuously adapting their production targets to variable demand requirements due to the frequent introduction of new model variants, materials and assembly technologies. In this context, the profitable management of the product, process and system co-evolution is of paramount importance for the company competitiveness. In this paper, a methodology for the design and reconfiguration management of modular assembly systems is proposed. It addresses the selection of the technological modules, their integration in the assembly cell, and the reconfiguration policies to handle volume and lot size variability. The results are demonstrated in a real automotive case study.

Do you want to read the rest of this article?

Request full-text
Request Full-text Paper PDF
  • Article
    The recent challenges for assembly-based manufacturing are primarily governed by dynamic market with mass customisation requirements. In this context, modular products are gaining attentions after success in automobile, electronics and many other sectors. Another contemporary research on reconfigurable assembly system (RAS) is a manifestation of reconfigurable manufacturing system (RMS) philosophy in mixed-model assembly operations to handle flexibility issues in functionality and capacity. In this paper, an integration model for these two state-of-the-art design and assembly philosophies are presented. A tri-objective formulation and module selection plans are developed for modular products in an RAS environment. Non-dominated Pareto optimal solutions considering assembly cycle time, balance delay and smoothness indices as three objectives are found to select optimal product modules during assembly process. The assumptions and features of this model are complying with a typical manufacturer from auto or electronics industries having some parts outsourced to original equipment manufacturers (OEMs). An industrial case study dealing with assembly of automobile engines is included as a base model to illustrate the application and scope of the research.
  • Article
    In this paper, a tri-objective optimization problem related to sequencing in multi-model reconfigurable assembly systems (RAS) is addressed. RASs are also designed around product families similar to the more generic reconfigurable manufacturing systems (RMSs). A multi-model assembly line needs reconfiguration after assembling each batch of the products from the family. Further, the changeover of assembly line from one product type to another is also of varying degree of complexity and reconfiguration cost. Two novel indices for commonality and reconfiguration complexity are proposed here to incorporate this feature of RAS. Optimizing the reconfiguration time/cost is taken as the first objective while fulfilling the product due dates and the work load balance among the assembly stations as the second and third objective functions, respectively. This optimization problem is solved using a Multi-objective Self-Organizing Migrating Algorithm (MOSOMA) metaheuristic to find the non-dominated Pareto optimal solutions representing optimum sequencing of products in the family. An approach for identifying the best solution from the multiple Pareto optimal solutions using aggregate fitness is also proposed. A numerical illustration along with computational procedure is presented on a hypothetical RAS model.
  • Conference Paper
    Todays fluctuated market context is mainly characterized by high product variety, variable volumes and short product life. Thus, assembly system design should be in such a way that it can face this variable issues within a short period of time at a low cost. In the context of global competition, it requires that products are with a short life-cycle and a high degree of customization. Therefore, the assembly system design should be able to adapt to the varying market demands. For this varying demand, there should be an alternative to the conventional assembly system. The Reconfigurable Assembly systems (RAS) are those type of assembly systems which can rapidly change their capacity as quantities that are assembled and functionality (product type, within a product family) in order to adapt the fluctuating and uncertainty in market demand. In the present scenario, some of the relevant research issues from design and operation in the area of RAS are identified in this paper. These research issues are identification of product family for RAS, design of modular products, design of optimum configuration for RAS, optimum design for assembly, identifying and quantifying design requirements, use of proper simulation tool for RAS, identification of quality problems, etc. Challenges and scopes in each area of these issues are identified.
  • Thesis
    Full-text available
    This thesis sets out to explore issues of designing reconfigurable manufacturing systems, which is a complex and multi-disciplinary engineering task. In addition, the aspired objectives and required features of support tools for automated design of such production systems are described. Based on this problem definition, a novel, interactive software tool is presented that enables production system designers to efficiently and effectively generate an understanding of alternative production system configurations. The approach was evaluated to show its theoretical implications as well as the usefulness and practical applicability as perceived by industrial system designers. The evaluation results indicate that the tool can be a means to design production system configurations efficiently and effectively. For more detailed information, please see inside.
  • Article
    The production systems of today are required to meet changing market conditions. To date, most conventional flexible systems depend on human flexibility. However, the demand for flexible automation systems is increasing owing to rising labor costs and quality requirements, even in emerging countries. To implement automation systems in the unpredictable market, cost reduction is essential to reduce the investment risk. However, there is no systematic design method for reducing the cost of automation systems. In this study, we propose a new design method wherein the waiting time of material handling equipment is reduced by allocating multiple operations to the equipment.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    This paper presents a comprehensive review and evaluation of heuristics and meta-heuristics for the two-sided assembly line balancing problem. Though a few reviews have been presented, some latest methods are not included and there is no comparison of the meta-heuristics in terms of their performances. Furthermore, since various kinds of encoding schemes, decoding procedures and objective functions have been applied, the results cannot be generalized and the published comparison might be unfair. This paper contributes to knowledge by comparing the published methods, ranging from well-known simulated annealing to recent published iterated local search, and evaluating the six encoding schemes, 30 decoding procedures and five objective functions on the performances of the meta-heuristics meanwhile. The experimental design approach is applied to obtain valid and convincing results by testing algorithms under four termination criteria. Computational results demonstrate that the proper selection of encoding scheme, decoding procedure and objective function improves the performance of the algorithms by a significant margin. Another unique contribution of this paper is that 15 new best solutions are obtained for the large-sized type-II two-sided assembly line balancing problem during the re-implementation and evaluation of the meta-heuristics tested.
  • Conference Paper
    Full-text available
    In reconfigurable manufacturing systems (RMS), the evaluation of configurations is usually based exclusively on technical performance indicators for an efficient and effective manufacturing. Ergonomics and human factors related aspects are rarely considered in the evaluation of reconfiguration opportunities, which leads to less realistic and pragmatic reconfiguration decisions. This article suggests both technical and ergonomics indicators to achieve a more realistic evaluation of reconfiguration decisions. A case study is introduced, and a TOPSIS based method is used to achieve multi-criteria evaluation and selection of an alternative configuration when reconfiguring an RMS. We particularly compare reconfiguration decisions with and without ergonomics indicators, and therefore establish the worthiness of considering both aspects simultaneously.
  • Article
    Managing changes and disturbances resulted by fluctuating order streams and diverse product portfolios requires efficient capacity management decisions and production planning strategies. High volume products can be produced cost efficiently on dedicated assembly lines, while the assembly of low runners is more efficient on reconfigurable lines. In the paper a hierarchical planning decision workflow is introduced to assign the products to dedicated and reconfigurable lines, and to optimize the system configuration and the production plan of the reconfigurable system in an integrated way. The proposed solution is demonstrated through the results of an industrial case study.
  • Global Automotive Supplier Study-­‐‑ Record profits versus increasing volatility Assembly System Design and Operations for Product Variety
    • Roland Berger
    • Strategy Consultant Hu
    • Sj Ko
    • J Weyand
    • L Elmaraghy
    • Ha Lien
    • Tk Koren
    • Y Bley
    • H Chryssolouris
    • G Nasr
    • N Shpitalni
    Roland Berger Strategy Consultant (2014) Global Automotive Supplier Study-­‐‑ Record profits versus increasing volatility. [5] Hu SJ, Ko J, Weyand L, ElMaraghy HA, Lien TK, Koren Y, Bley H, Chryssolouris G, Nasr N, Shpitalni M (2011) Assembly System Design and Operations for Product Variety. CIRP Annals–Manufacturing Technology 60(2):715-­‐‑ 735.
  • Book
    Manufacturing Flexibility is usually seen as the main answer for surviving in present markets characterized by short lead times, tight product tolerances, pressure on costs, frequent changes of demand and continuous evolution of products. However, the competitiveness of a firm can be negatively affected by capital intensive investments in system flexibility. Indeed production contexts characterized by mid to high demand volume of well identified families of products in continuous evolution normally do not require the highest level of flexibility. Designing manufacturing systems that optimally satisfy the production requirements represents a very complex problem, since aspects ranging from manufacturing strategy to process planning, and from scenario analysis to performance evaluation must be considered over the system lifecycle. The book addresses these interdependencies proposing an integrated approach to flexible production system design. Since traditional system architectures are not always the most efficient solution to face new production contexts a new manufacturing system architecture named Focused Flexibility Manufacturing Systems – FFMSs is also introduced. Indeed the explicit design of flexibility can lead to hybrid systems, i.e. automated integrated systems consisting of general purpose and dedicated machines. This is a key issue of FFMSs which are designed to achieve an optimal balance between flexibility and productivity at system level.
  • Article
    This paper reviews the state-of-the-art methodologies for automating design with intelligent human–machine integration from the perspectives of ontology and epistemology. The human–machine integrated automating design paradigm is reviewed systematically based on a proposed prototype of human–machine integrated design, from the aspects of ontology-based knowledge management with local-to-global ontology transitions, and epistemology-based upward-spiral cognitive process of coupled design ideation. Particularly, imaginal thinking frame is proposed as the foundation of intelligent human–machine interaction that puts human and machine on an equal platform. Further, this paper presents implementations and applications of the automating design paradigm and concludes with the identification of future trend.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Remote Laser Welding (RLW) has received increased attention in the recent years due to its benefits in terms of processing speed, lower investment, cost per stitch, and process flexibility. However, its potential in automotive assembly remains under exploited, mainly due to challenges involving system, process and fixture design, and part variation challenges. In this paper, an integrated rapid deployment framework for RLW process is proposed to improve ‘right-first-time’ implementation of RLW in assembly systems. It enables closed-loop optimization of system layout, task assignment, fixture layout, process parameters, robot path planning and programming as an interlinked iterative approach. The results are demonstrated in an automotive door assembly pilot study.
  • Article
    This research introduces new systematic methods dealing with a complete end-to-end design process of the production system. This paper helps product developer and systems engineer to (1) differentiate between product function and added function that are used only for the purpose of manufacturing and assembly process, (2) how these function related to the design parameters in both physical domains for the product design and the production system. Graph network (NW), change propagation index (CPI) and hybrid design structure matrix (HDSM) were introduced to: (1) establish connectivity between subsystems (modules) before mapping design changes, (2) measure the degree of change to the state of the system due to change propagated through the entire system, (3) estimate how much embedded flexibility is needed for these elements (design variables) to accommodate future changes. A practical example of an actual production system was presented. The hybrid design structure matrix (HDSM) is used to transmit the knowledge gained and detailing the design of the production system. (c) 2013 CIRP.
  • A Decomposition Method to Support the Configuration/Reconfiguration of Production Systems Automating design with intelligent human–machine integration
    • M Colledani
    • T Tolio
    • Yh Yin
    • Ayc Nee
    • Sk Ong
    • Jy Zhu
    • Ph Gu
    • Lj Chen
    Colledani M, Tolio T (2005) A Decomposition Method to Support the Configuration/Reconfiguration of Production Systems. CIRP Annals– Manufacturing Technology 54(1):441-­‐‑ 444. [11] Yin YH, Nee AYC, Ong SK, Zhu JY, Gu PH, Chen LJ (2015) Automating design with intelligent human–machine integration. CIRP Annals–Manufacturing Technology 64(2):655-­‐‑ 677.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Performance evaluation models are used by companies to design, adapt, manage and control their production systems. In the literature, most of the effort has been dedicated to the development of efficient methodologies to estimate the first moment performance measures of production systems, such as the expected production rate, the buffer levels and the mean completion time. However, there is industrial evidence that the higher moments of the production output may drastically impact on the capability of managing the system operations, causing the observed system performance to be highly different from what expected. This paper presents a methodology to analyze the cumulated output and the lot completion time moments of Markovian reward models. Both the discrete and the continuous time cases are considered. The technique is applied to unreliable manufacturing systems characterized by general Markovian structures. Numerical results show how the theory developed in this paper can be applied to analyse the dependency of the output variability and the service level on the system parameters. Moreover, they highlight previously uninvestigated features of the system behavior that are useful while operating the system in practical settings.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    A great challenge facing industry today is managing variety throughout the entire products life cycle. Drivers of products variety, its benefits, pre-requisites and associated complexity and cost are presented. Enhancing consumers’ value through variety and approaches for achieving it efficiently including modularity, commonality and differentiation are discussed. Variant-oriented manufacturing systems paradigms, as enablers of product variety, and the effective co-development of variants and their manufacturing systems to ensure economic sustainability are reviewed. Industrial applications and guidelines to achieve economy of scope with advantages of economy of scale are discussed. Perspectives and insights on future research in this field are offered.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    In the paper, a simulation-based technique is focused on that defines the boundaries and components of a reconfigurable assembly system according to historical order-streams. Fluctuating production volumes and “end-of-life-cycle” products require frequent revisions of the production structure applied, in order to gain production space and to level between capacity and throughput of the system. The proposed method separates the low- and high volume products and product families dynamically, by assigning to them the appropriate reconfigurable or dedicated production lines, respectively. A comprehensive industrial case-study and a new indica-tor on system's operational behavior are presented as well.
  • Article
    The configuration phase of a production system is characterized by the need of evaluating a large number of system alternatives. In this phase, a fast and reliable performance evaluation tool able to analyze and explain the behaviour of the system is necessary. The paper proposes an approximate analytical method based on decomposition techniques for modelling and evaluating the performance of production systems involving split and merge of production flows, multiple products, buffers with finite capacity and manufacturing/assembly/disassembly operations. The paper also reports the application of the method to the performance evaluation and reconfiguration of a real system producing white goods.
  • Article
    Full-text available
    Manufacturing enterprises are changing the way they behave in the market to face the increasing complexity of the economic, socio-political and technological dynamics. Manufacturing products, processes and production systems result in being challenged by evolving external drivers, including the introduction of new regulations, new materials, technologies, services and communications, the pressure on costs and sustainability. The co-evolution paradigm synthesises the recent scientific and technical approaches proposed by academic and industrial communities dealing with methodologies and tools to support the coordinated evolution (co-evolution) of products, processes and production systems. This paper aims at reviewing and systemising the research carried out in the field of manufacturing co-evolution with a particular focus on production systems. An introductory investigation of various industrial perspectives on the problem of co-evolution is presented, followed by the description of the co-evolution model and the methodology adopted for framing the existing scientific contributions in the proposed model. Then, the core part of the work is presented, consisting in a systemised analysis of the current methodologies dealing with co-evolving product, process and system and a description of problems that remain unsolved, thus motivating future research strategies and roadmaps.
  • Article
    From the Publisher:This book presents a unified theory of Generalized Stochastic Petri Nets (GSPNs) together with a set of illustrative examples from different application fields. The continuing success of GSPNs and the increasing interest in using them as a modelling paradigm for the quantitative analysis of distributed systems suggested the preparation of this volume with the intent of providing newcomers to the field with a useful tool for their first approach. Readers will find a clear and informal explanation of the concepts followed by formal definitions when necessary or helpful. The largest section of the book however is devoted to showing how this methodology can be applied in a range of domains.
  • Article
    In this work, a method of deriving assembly line design alternatives and evaluating them against multiple user-defined criteria has been presented. The design problem has been formulated in a way that it can be transformed from a decision-making problem into a search problem. A systematic way of generating the solution space of the search problem, based on the real-life design project requirements, has been described in detail. An intelligent search algorithm that uses the three control factors to guide the search was introduced and applied to efficiently derive high-quality line designs. Investment cost, availability, equipment reutilisation, annual production volume and flexibility metrics have been used for evaluating the alternative designs. The method was implemented in a software tool, which can automatically generate discrete event simulation models for the calculation of several performance metrics. The results of the application, in an automotive case, indicate that the tool is appropriate for supporting decision making during the stage of rough planning, although several functionalities can be used during more advanced stages such as the detailed planning concept.
  • Standard representations for information entities common to manufacturing simulation could help reduce the costs associated with simulation model construction and data exchange between simulation and other manufacturing applications. This would make simulation technology more affordable and accessible to a wide range of potential industrial users. The Core Manufacturing Simulation Data (CMSD) specification was created to foster the more widespread use of manufacturing simulation technology through the reduction of data interoperability issues. CMSD is a standardized, computer-interpretable representation that allows for the efficient exchange of manufacturing shop-floor-related data in a manner that it can be used to create and execute manufacturing simulations. CMSD was standardized under the auspices of the international Simulation Interoperability Standards Organization (SISO). It defines an information model that describes the characteristics of and relationships between the core manufacturing entities that define shop floor operations. This enables greater integration and data exchange possibilities for manufacturing simulations and other manufacturing applications. This paper presents an overview of CMSD, its motivation, structure, and content. Case studies using CMSD to integrate real world manufacturing applications are also presented.