Content uploaded by Bhoj R Singh
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Bhoj R Singh on Jun 03, 2016
Content may be subject to copyright.
1
Lies of Dr. Gaya Prasad and Party: Part 2
Corruption in FMD vaccine and FMD CP in India: Lies & lies by Dr. Gaya Prasad (presently
VC at SVBPUA&T, Meerut, earlier ADG Animal health at ICAR, Act. Director of IVRI,
Izatnagar, Prof. and Head Department of Biotechnology at Haryana Agric. University,
Hissar) and party. The Deceivers
As you know that Dr. Gaya Prasad was the chairman of the committee that countered the report
submitted by CCS NIAH, Baghpat
(https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267705649_Testing_of_FMD_Vaccine_intended_to_be_used_un
der_FMD-CP_of_Govt_of_India_at_CCS_NIAH_Baghpat_UP_India) on substandard quality of the FMD
vaccine used for FMD CP all over India at expense of Central Government.
In this series we will talk about the collusion of the committee with the suppliers of substandard FMD
vaccine and compilation of lies in the report submitted by the committee
(file:///C:/Users/JD%20CADRAD1%202013/Downloads/GoI%20Expert%20Committee%20report%202015
%20(1).pdf) to bluff the department, to cheat the farmers and the Nation, and to benefit the companies,
and punish the honesty and honest scientist. Now you need to decide who is unscrupulous.
Today we will take on just two of the many lies of the Dr. Gaya Prasad Committee
1. The committee barks on page 3 at point 8: --Dr. BR Singh/ CCS NIAH did not have the approval
from the competent authority in DADF, GOI to undertake stability and sterility testing and doing
research on FMD vaccine.
2. At page 4 point 13 the committee wrote -----There was every chance of contamination from the
environment. The sterility test results were simply mentioned as yes/ no ------.
1. Now friends for Point 1 at page 3 at no. 8 above, please read the DADF Annual reports of three
earlier years before my posting (May to November 2014) and of the year of my posting:
A. Column 1 of page 38 of DADF Annual Report 2011-12
(http://dadf.gov.in/sites/default/files/Annual%20Report%20English%202011-
12%20%20%2011_0.pdf):
The Institute has started functioning and is carrying out the following activities.
The virology laboratory has been made functional with facilities for testing of quality assurance of FMD
vaccine by way of testing of serum samples by LPB-ELISA and sterility of vaccines.
B. Again see at column 1 of page 39 of DADF Annual Report 2013-14
(http://dadf.gov.in/sites/default/files/FINAL%20ANIMAL%20AR%202013-
14%20FOR%20WEB%20%20%204_0.pdf)
3.19.2 The National Institute of Animal Health (NIAH) has been established at Baghpat, Uttar Pradesh
to undertake the testing of vaccines and biologicals for their quality. The Institute has started
functioning and is carrying out the following activities: • The virology laboratory is functional with
facilities for testing of quality assurance of FMD vaccine by way of testing of serum samples by LPB-
ELISA and sterility of vaccines. Institute has tested the FMD vaccine for sterility, safety and potency
C. Please see column 2 of page 39 of DADF Annual Report of year 2014-2015
(http://dadf.gov.in/sites/default/files/Animal%20Husbandry%20English%202014-15%20%201_0.pdf.
3.6.2.1 The Chaudhary Charan Singh National Institute of Animal Health (CCSNIAH) has been
established at Baghpat, Uttar Pradesh to undertake the testing of vaccines and biologicals for their
quality. The Institute has started functioning and is carrying out the following activities: a) The virology
laboratory is functional with facilities for testing of quality assurance of FMD vaccine by way of
testing of serum samples by LPB-ELISA and sterility of vaccines. b) The bacteriology laboratory is
also functional to carry out the quality control testing of BQ, HS and Enterotoxaemia (ET) vaccines. c)
The Poultry vaccine-testing laboratory has been established with standardization of tests for the New
Castle Disease vaccine (Live) and Infectious Bursal Disease (IBD) vaccine.
Dear Friends, please now look at the website of CCS NIAH, Baghpat welcome page
(http://ccsniah.gov.in/):
It reads “----------------CCS NIAH has a committed group of scientists which endeavors to provide best
services to the stakeholders for quality control testing of veterinary biologicals, following testing
protocols as per Indian Pharmacopoeia 2014 and Drugs & Cosmetic Act 1945.---------------------- ”.
2
The website speaks (http://ccsniah.gov.in/About.html): “Chaudhary Charan Singh National Institute of
Animal Health (CCS NIAH), Baghpat was established by the Department of Animal Husbandry, Dairying
and Fisheries, Ministry of Agriculture & Farmers Welfare, Government of India, under the sub scheme
“Establishment of National Veterinary Biological Products Quality Control Center”, under the Central
Sector Scheme ‘’Directorate of Animal Health’’ as a national facility for quality assessment of veterinary
vaccines and diagnostics to be used in India.”
At http://ccsniah.gov.in/History.html it speaks about:
“----------------.The foundation stone for the laboratory was laid on the 2nd March 2003 by the then
Hon’ble Union Minister for Agriculture, Shri Ajit Singh.--------------------- The project was inaugurated
by the Hon’ble Union Minister for Agriculture, Cooperation and consumer Affairs on the 1st september,
2010.”
The Institute having Mission (http://ccsniah.gov.in/Mission.html)
Achieve excellence in quality control and assurance of standard, efficient and safe veterinary biologicals
in India.
Harmonize the quality of veterinary vaccines and diagnostics in India as per global standards.
And the mandates http://ccsniah.gov.in/Mandate.html are defined as:
• To act as a nodal institute to recommend licensing of veterinary vaccines in the country.
• To make available facilities for quality control of veterinary vaccines and diagnostics.
To make available standards for veterinary biologicals and diagnostics
2. Dear friends, for Point 2 at page 4 no. 13, please look the at following:
The facilities at CCSNIAH, Baghpat (http://ccsniah.gov.in/Facilities.html;
http://ccsniah.gov.in/LaboratoryBlock.html).
The campus of CCS National Institute of Animal Health has two blocks namely Administrative and
Laboratory Block. Laboratory block consists of BSL-2 and BSL-3 and is connected to the animal house for
large and small animal provided with containment ABSL-2+ facility. The Laboratory block is supported with
HVAC, LTDP, ETP, incinerator, fire-fighting and alarm systems and an Electric substation. Other
supporting facilities are library, conference hall and internet through Wi-Fi.
The laboratory block has been divided into office area and laboratory area which is further split into BSL-
2 & BSL-3 areas. The laboratories have been designed so as to comply with the safety requirement to allow
management of potentially hazardous substances as well as evacuation of the staff with minimum risk, if the
need arises. The containment facility of lab has well equipped HVAC, installed to maintain appropriate
negative pressure, temperature required to meet the specific requirement of the activities being carried out.
The HVAC system has dedicated units for BSL-2, BSL-3, small and large animal house and also has
incorporated building management system for monitoring and control of temperature & humidity.
BSL-2 LAB
The BSL-2 area has clearly demarcated preparatory & containment facility. The preparatory area has
segregated rooms meant specifically for washing & sterilization, holding and performing works on virus and
bacteria not requiring contained environment. There is also separate cold room for storing of vaccines and
serum samples etc. The containment facility of the BSL-2 area is well designed & equipped facility meant
suitably for agents involving moderate potential hazard to personnel, animals & environment with minimum
economic loss to animal industries. The BSL-2 labs are provided with BSCs, PPE as primary barrier with
secondary barrier being provided by walls, doors & well equipped AHUs which ensure negative pressure of -
15 Pas to -50 Pas for bio-safety. For sterility testing of vaccines there is an entirely separate facility with
dedicated AHU. Also there is decontamination room at the end of the BSL-2 containment area intended for
decontamination of the infected material.
BSL-3 LAB
Like BSL-2, BSL-3 also has designed preparatory & containment facility. The preparatory area has
washing & sterilization area, egg preparatory room, virology lab, media preparatory lab. The containment
facility of BSL-3 lab is suitable for handling high risk pathogens which are highly infectious and harmful for
animals & human health but safeguard the environment as well as lab personnel. The containment area has
facility to conduct quality control testing of bacterial vaccine (aerobic & anaerobic), viral vaccine (large &
small) and poultry vaccine of risk group-III organisms. In BSL-3, provision of dedicated rooms for
conducting sterility & cell culture work is also there. The area of BSL-3 has a provision for 100% exhaust
for total environmental protection by the way of filter in the exhaust with BIBO provision. The additional
3
feature of the BSL-3 containment is CIF and decontamination within the area. All the preparation of
challenge organism required for potency testing of vaccine falling in the category are handled in the BSL-3
labs.
Dear friends just see the outlay of expenses incurred on maintenance of the
facilities at CCS NIAH in 2012-13, 2013-14 and also now days. (These are not
exact figures but almost true):
Operational expenses at CCS NIAH Baghpat
Operational expenses: ~ ₹2 crore per year, From 2013 onward
HVAC (Heating, Ventilation and Air Conditioning) Plant maintenance: ~ ₹33 lakh/year (Hepa
filters were changed only in early 2014 for Rs. 30 L)
LTDP (Liquid Thermal Decontamination Plant) maintenance ~ ₹4.5 Lakh/ year
ETP (Effluent Treatment Plant) maintenance: ~ ₹9 lakh/year
Incinerator maintenance: ~ ₹3.5 Lakh/ year
Civil structure maintenance: ~ ₹15 lakh/ year
Fire fighting and Fire alarm system maintenance: ~ ₹5 lakhs/ year
Electrical substation maintenance: ~ ₹15 Lakh/ year
Electricity charges: ~ ₹80 Lakh per year.
Now dear all, you should decide, how many and how big lies Dr. Gaya Prasad (self acclaimed
honest personality) and party wrote:
Is it not forgery/ frauds, putting wrong information to the people?
Is it not mal-intention to benefit the producers of substandard vaccine?
Is it not cheating with the nation and poor farmers (consumer of FMD vaccine)?
Is it not an anti-National act of Dr. Gaya Prasad Committee?
Does Dr. Gaya Prasad not know what is the definition of mandates and Mission of an
Institute?
Do there is the need of permission for the Director of the Institute from anybody to
accomplish the mission of an Institute and fulfil its mandates?
Does Dr. Gaya Prasad not understand BSL-3 norms?
Does Dr. Gaya Prasad not know that about 2 Crore rupees is the annual maintenance
cost of the laboratory facility of CCS NIAH?
Does Dr. Gaya Prasad not understand the meaning of putting something on record (work
record at CCS NIAH) as Annual report of a Government of India department (DADF)?
Does the information about work done at CCS NIAH get entered in DADF Annual
reports (2011-2015) without the knowledge of DADF? Or the Committee members
could not see and read?
No, friends, nothing was wrong, everything was in order at CCS NIAH and was in knowledge
of the Government of India, what we were doing at CCS NIAAH, but collusion of the
Committee and some officials at DADF and ICAR was force behind false reporting by Dr.
Gaya Prasad and Party.
There are other documents like letter from officers from DADF for testing the vaccine,
communications about the ongoing testing with me but they are not of much relevance here.
Those may be documents for the Honourable Court to decide the identity of people involved
in this scam and bluffing the country and farmers of the country under FMD-CP.
Dear Friends you yourself have to think what should be done with such people.
4
FMD -
Part 2
CCSNIAH
(https://www.researchgate.net/publication/267705649_Testing_of_FMD_Vaccine_intended_to_be_used_under_F
MD-CP_of_Govt_of_India_at_CCS_NIAH_Baghpat_UP_India) FMD :
. CCSNIAH ,
(file:///C:/Users/JD%20CADRAD1%202013/Downloads/GoI%20Expert%20Committee%20report%202015%2
0(1).pdf). .
.
1. 3 8 ----- (
, ) FMD .
2. 4 13 CCS NIAH,
.
.
1 ,
2011 2015 :
2011-12 38 (DADF)
(http://dadf.gov.in/sites/default/files/Annual%20Report%20English%202011-12%20%20%2011_0.pdf)
CCS NIAH, ELISA and sterilty FMD
.
2013-14 39 (DADF)
(http://dadf.gov.in/sites/default/files/FINAL%20ANIMAL%20AR%202013-
14%20FOR%20WEB%20%20%204_0.pdf) CCSNIAH FMD ,
.
2014-15 39 (DADF)
(http://dadf.gov.in/sites/default/files/Animal%20Husbandry%20English%202014-15%20%201_0.pdf)
CCSNIAH FMD ELISA .
CCSNIAH
(http://ccsniah.gov.in/):
CCS NIAH,
. 1 2010 .
.
2 CCSNIAH (http://ccsniah.gov.in/): CCS
NIAH BSL-2, BSL-3 HAVC, LTDP, ETP, ,
.
.
5
, - :
?
FMD ?
?
?
?
BSL-2 BSL-3 -
?
CCS NIAH
8 .
, CCS NIAH FMD
, . IVRI
FMD .
, .
, ,
.
, ,
.
, .
. ,
,
,
,
. , , ,
.