Article

Resolving the Korean Conflict through a Combination of Human Rights and Human Security

Authors:
Bo-hyuk Suh
Bo-hyuk Suh
Daniel Clausen
Daniel Clausen
Daniel Clausen
  • This person is not on ResearchGate, or hasn't claimed this research yet.
Download citation
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Why has the division-armistice system lasted over 70 years in the Korean Peninsula? It could be said that the system has been sustained by the existence of forces that still remain to support the division of the peninsula by reproducing distrust and a sense of animosity. For instance, the continuing confrontations and conflicts over human rights between the two Koreas are remnants of the Cold War. Exploiting peace and security issues for political gains by the two division powers also demonstrates the continuation of the division-armistice system. How can the protracted conflict under this system be overcome? This study analyzes the characteristics of the protracted conflict in the Korean Peninsula and explores alternatives from a macro-critical perspective. The author attempts to answer this research question by paying attention to the synergistic effects of human rights and security. The politicization of human rights and continuing militarism are manifestations of the negative synergistic effects of the norms under the division-armistice system. Including security in human rights and embracing human rights in peace are essential for transforming these negative synergistic effects into positive effects toward developing a sustainable peace. Human security and the right to peace are proposed here as alternatives for creating positive synergistic effects. In resolving the Korean conflict, it is becoming increasingly important to make efforts in improving inter-Korean relations, promoting peaceful and democratic transition in North Korea, and increasing civilian control of the military in all countries concerned.

No full-text available

Request Full-text Paper PDF

To read the full-text of this research,
you can request a copy directly from the authors.

... Suh Bo-hyuk (2016) argues that we should pay more attention to human security and the right to peace to overcome militarism and politicization of the human rights issues on the Korean Peninsula. Choi Dae Seok and Park Young Ja (2011) lament that our research on North Korean defectors has failed to produce highquality works despite growth in volumes. ...
View
The influence of human security challenges on the effectiveness of regionalism: The Case of ASEAN+3
Thesis
Full-text available
  • Aug 2019
The aim of this research is to address the gap of the non-state-centric approach of human security to the notion of regionalism that has been dominated by the state-centric definition of security so far. Thereby the object of reference is not the state but the individual itself. This thesis assists in broadening the knowledge of regionalism but also puts high emphasis on the concept of human security and the affiliated challenges such as ethnic cleansing, human rights violation, genocide, migration influx and territorial disputes in the region of ASEAN+3. Although the RIO has been acknowledged and recognised as one of the successful examples of regionalism, the controversy about its consensus, its decision-making mechanism, and its non- interference mentality undermines its economic success by exposing millions of individuals to a variety of threats. Nevertheless, this would not have been considered ASEAN’s issue if the RIO did not commit itself for maintaining peace and regional stability in its charter, official statements and treaty. Furthermore, this thesis does not marginalise the RIO’s economic success nor its economic effectiveness but it rather asks how effective regionalism is with regards to traditional and non-traditional threats under the same umbrella term of human security challenges. ASEAN+3 cannot uphold its principles and values expressed in its official documents. At the same time, the organisation cannot replicate the same effectiveness and success that it has in its economic policies in the area of human security. As the pillar of all types of security, human security is under-implemented, under-promoted and under-represented in the case of East and Southeast Asia that adumbrates its economic achievements.
View
View
View
Human Security: Concepts and Implications
Article
  • Jan 2006
This book, now available in paperback, traces the key evolutions in the development of the concept of human security, the various definitions and critiques, how it relates to other concepts, and what it implies for polities, politics, and policy. Human security is an important subject for the whole world, in particular Asia, as it deals with interactions among fields of social change, such as development, conflict resolution, human rights, and humanitarian assistance. In a globalizing world, in which threats become trans-national and states lose power, security can no longer be studied in a one-dimensional fashion. Written by authors who are experts in this field and with case studies from different regions (Afghanistan, Central Asia and South Asia) presented throughout, this book - now available in paperback - contributes to this new multidimensional conception of security, analyzes its strengths and weaknesses, and focuses on its implications for analysis and action. © 2007 Shahrbanou Tadjbakhsh and Anuradha M. Chenoy. All rights reserved.
View
View
View
View
PEACE AS A NORTH KOREAN HUMAN RIGHT
Article
  • Feb 2014
  • CRIT ASIAN STUD
This essay analyzes the “human rights” framework that evolved, paradoxically, as a way to address human rights and human security needs in the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (North Korea) by withholding humanitarian assistance from that country. This framework turns on the premise that the North Korean “regime” is the source of the society's ills, that it is unwilling to implement radical reforms needed to restore its economy for fear that they would undermine its rule, and that it maintains its grip upon society by means of propaganda and repression. Regime collapse, some argue, will thus lead to a better life for the North Korean people. Informed by this view, in combination with “intelligence” sources that predict the imminent collapse of the “regime,” U.S. policy has been loath to provide any assistance, including food aid, that might prolong the life of the state. By viewing North Korean society today in the context of its historical experience before and since the decline of its economy starting in the early 1990s, this essay challenges assumptions that underlie the “human rights” argument for regime collapse. It explores alternative reasons for the society's unexpected survival and argues that analysis of North Korean society in abstraction from the state of war in which it is situated, fails to offer realistic options for addressing the human security of the North Korean people.
View
Korea's Globalization
Article
  • Feb 2001
1. Korea and globalization (Segyehwa): a framework for analysis Samuel S. Kim 2. Globalization and strategic choice in South Korea: economic reform and labor Barry K. Gills and Dongsook S. Gills 3. Globalization and workers in South Korea Yong Cheol Kim and Chung-in Moon 4. Segyehwa reform of the South Korean developmental state C. S. Eliot Kang 5. Globalization of the South Korean Chaebol Eun Mee Kim 6. Overcome by globalization? The rise of women's policy in South Korea Seungsook Moon 7. Strangers in the midst of globalization: migrant workers and Korean Nationalism Katherine H. S. Moon 8. South Korean Foreign relations faces the globalization challenges Chae-jin Lee 9. Segyehwa, the Republic of Korea, and the United Nations B. C. Koh 10. The security domain of South Korea's globalization Victor Cha 11. Korea's globalization drive: promise versus performance Samuel S. Kim.
View
View
Hysteria of Division
  • Jan 2012
  • Seukryule Hong
Hong, Seukryule. 2012. Hysteria of Division. Paju: Changbi.
Inventing Human Rights: A History
  • Jan 2008
  • Lynn Hunt
Hunt, Lynn. 2008. Inventing Human Rights: A History. New York: W. W. Norton & Company.
Promoting Peace and Human Rights in the Korean Peninsula
  • Jan 2007
  • Kyung - Park
Park, Kyung-seo. 2007. Promoting Peace and Human Rights in the Korean Peninsula. Seoul: Ewha Womans University Press.
Creating Korean Insecurity: The US Role
  • Jan 2007
  • 21-42
  • Bruce Cumings
Cumings, Bruce. 2007. "Creating Korean Insecurity: The US Role." In Hazel Smith ed., Reconstituting Korean Security: A Policy Primer, Tokyo: United Nations University Press, 21-42.
Human Security in Global Governance: Implications for the East Asian Region Focusing on South Korea
  • Jan 2011
  • 5-31
  • Pedro B Bernaldez
Bernaldez, Pedro B. 2011. "Human Security in Global Governance: Implications for the East Asian Region Focusing on South Korea." OUGHTOPIA 26 (2), 5-31.
The Division System in Crisis: Essays on Contemporary Korea
  • Jan 2011
  • Nak-Chung Paik
Paik, Nak-chung. 2011. The Division System in Crisis: Essays on Contemporary Korea. Los Angeles: University of California Press.
What is Militarism In Asbjrn Eide and Marek Thee eds., Problems of Contemporary Militarism
  • Jan 1980
  • 127-139
  • Ernie Regehr
Regehr, Ernie. 1980. " What is Militarism. " In Asbjrn Eide and Marek Thee eds., Problems of Contemporary Militarism. New York: St Martin's Press, 127-139.
The Structure and Change of Division Order: The Dynamics of the Interface Relationship between Hostility and Dependence, 1945-1995
  • Jan 1997
  • 41-79
  • Myung - Park
Park, Myung-rim. 1997. "The Structure and Change of Division Order: The Dynamics of the Interface Relationship between Hostility and Dependence, 1945-1995." National Strategy 3(1), 41-79.
Progress Report of the Human Rights Council Advisory Committee on the Right of Peoples to Peace
  • Apr 2011
  • Un Human
  • Rights Council
UN Human Rights Council. 2011. " Progress Report of the Human Rights Council Advisory Committee on the Right of Peoples to Peace. " A/HRC/17/39. March 28.
Statement by H.E. Yun Byung-se, Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Korea
  • Mar 2014
  • Byung-Se Yun
Yun, Byung-se. 2014. "Statement by H.E. Yun Byung-se, Minister of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Korea." 25th Session of the UN Human Rights Council. March 5.
Newly Written Understanding of Current North Korea
  • Jan 2000
  • Jong-Seok Lee
Lee, Jong-seok. 2000. Newly Written Understanding of Current North Korea. Seoul: Yuksabipyungsa.
SIPRI Yearbook 2014: Armaments, Disarmament and International Security
  • Jan 2014
  • Sam Perlo-Freeman
  • Carina Solmirano
Perlo-Freeman, Sam and Carina Solmirano. 2014. SIPRI Yearbook 2014: Armaments, Disarmament and International Security. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Understanding Rights to Peace: Concept, History, Analysis, and Application
  • Jan 2014
  • Kyoung-Joo Lee
Lee, Kyoung-Joo. 2014. Understanding Rights to Peace: Concept, History, Analysis, and Application. Seoul: Sapyoung Academy.
Democracy, Human Rights and Peace in Korea:Psychological, Political and Cultural Perspectives
  • Jan 2001
  • Henriette Aasen
  • Sinding
Aasen, Henriette Sinding, Uichol Kim and GeirHelgesen eds. 2001. Democracy, Human Rights and Peace in Korea:Psychological, Political and Cultural Perspectives. Seoul: KyoyookKwahaksa.
The Armistice in the Korean Peninsula and Korea-US-Japan Trilateral Military Alliance Paper presented at the 3rd International Workshop for Peace and Disarmament in the Asia-Pacific Region
  • Dec 2012
  • Taeho Lee
Lee, Taeho. 2012. " The Armistice in the Korean Peninsula and Korea-US-Japan Trilateral Military Alliance. " Paper presented at the 3rd International Workshop for Peace and Disarmament in the Asia-Pacific Region (November 27).
Peacelessness in the Korean Peninsula and Division Violence Paper Presented at the Workshop of 'Division Violence' Organized by the Institute for Peace and Unification Studies
  • Sep 2014
  • Philo Kim
Kim, Philo. 2014. " Peacelessness in the Korean Peninsula and Division Violence. " Paper Presented at the Workshop of 'Division Violence' Organized by the Institute for Peace and Unification Studies (IPUS) of Seoul National University (August 20).
The Human Right to Peace. Ottawa: Saint Paul University. International Congress on the Human Right to Peace
  • Jan 2003
  • Douglas Roche
Roche, Douglas. 2003. The Human Right to Peace. Ottawa: Saint Paul University. International Congress on the Human Right to Peace. 2010. "Santiago Declaration on the Human Rights to Peace." December 9.
Declaration and Programme of Action on a Culture of Peace
  • Oct 1999
  • Un General Assembly
UN General Assembly. 1999. "Declaration and Programme of Action on a Culture of Peace." A/53/243 (October 6). Accessed at http://www.unesco.org/ cpp/uk/declarations/2000.htm (December 1, 2015)
A History of Militarism (Revised Edition)
  • Jan 1959
  • Alfred Vagts
Vagts, Alfred. 1959. A History of Militarism (Revised Edition). New York: Meridian Books.
Peacelessness and Maldevelopment: A New Theme for Peace Research in Developing Nations Paper presented at the International Peace Research Association
  • Jul 1967
  • Sugata Dasgupta
Dasgupta, Sugata. 1967. " Peacelessness and Maldevelopment: A New Theme for Peace Research in Developing Nations. " Paper presented at the International Peace Research Association (June 17-19).
We Have Thousands of Rightful Reasons to Maintain the Nuclear Deterrence
  • Nov 2010
  • Korea Central
  • News Agency
Korea Central News Agency. 2010. " We Have Thousands of Rightful Reasons to Maintain the Nuclear Deterrence. " (October 23).
Korea's National Interests and Security Conditions in the Age of Globalization
  • Jan 2011
  • 207-231
  • Ihn-Hwi Park
Park, Ihn-hwi. 2011. "Korea's National Interests and Security Conditions in the Age of Globalization." The Korean Journal of International Studies 9(2), 207-231.
The Right to Peace, Human Rights from the Grassroots Up: Focused on 'Right to Peace' Discourses by Korean Social Movements
  • Jan 2011
  • ECON SOC
  • 167-210
  • Jae-Sung Lim
Lim, Jae-sung. 2011. "The Right to Peace, Human Rights from the Grassroots Up: Focused on 'Right to Peace' Discourses by Korean Social Movements." Economy and Society 91, 167-210.
UNESCO's Work on Education for Peace and Non-Violence
  • Dec 2008
  • Unesco
UNESCO. 2008. "UNESCO's Work on Education for Peace and Non-Violence." ED-2008/WS/38. Paris. Accessed at http://unesdoc.unesco.org/ images/0016/001607/160787e.pdf (December 1, 2015)
The Sorrows of Empire: Militarism, Secrecy, and the End of the Republic
  • Jan 2004
  • Chalmers Johnson
Johnson, Chalmers. 2004. The Sorrows of Empire: Militarism, Secrecy, and the End of the Republic. New York: Metropolitan Books.
Militarism in My Heart: Militarization of Women's Consciousness and Culture in South Korea
  • Jan 2000
  • Insook Kwon
Kwon, Insook. 2000."Militarism in My Heart: Militarization of Women's Consciousness and Culture in South Korea." Ph.D. Dissertation, Clark University.
Sociology of the Boundary between North and South Korea
  • Jan 2012
  • Myoung-Kyu Park
Park, Myoung-kyu. 2012. Sociology of the Boundary between North and South Korea. Paju: Changbi.
Report on the March Plenary Session of the Central Committee of the Korea Workers' Party
  • Apr 2013
  • Rodong Sinmun
Rodong Sinmun. 2013a. "Report on the March Plenary Session of the Central Committee of the Korea Workers' Party." (April 2).
Peacelessness and Maldevelopment: A New Theme for Peace Research in Developing Nations
  • Jun 1967
  • Sugata Dasgupta
Dasgupta, Sugata. 1967. "Peacelessness and Maldevelopment: A New Theme for Peace Research in Developing Nations." Paper presented at the International Peace Research Association (June 17-19).
Paper Presented at the Workshop of 'Division Violence' Organized by the Institute for Peace and Unification Studies (IPUS) of Seoul National University
  • Aug 2014
  • Philo Kim
Kim, Philo. 2014. "Peacelessness in the Korean Peninsula and Division Violence." Paper Presented at the Workshop of 'Division Violence' Organized by the Institute for Peace and Unification Studies (IPUS) of Seoul National University (August 20).
Paper presented at the 3rd International Workshop for Peace and Disarmament in the Asia-Pacific Region
  • Nov 2012
  • Taeho Lee
Lee, Taeho. 2012. "The Armistice in the Korean Peninsula and Korea-US-Japan Trilateral Military Alliance." Paper presented at the 3rd International Workshop for Peace and Disarmament in the Asia-Pacific Region (November 27).
Young Hoon Song, Yong Seok Chang, and Eun-meeJeong
  • Jan 2013
  • Myoung-Kyu Park
  • Philo Kim
Park, Myoung-kyu, Philo Kim, Young Hoon Song, Yong Seok Chang, and Eun-meeJeong. 2013. 2013 Research on Unification Awareness. Seoul: IPUS, Seoul National University.