ArticlePDF Available

A Study on Oral Tradition as a Communication tool

Authors:
David Wilson at Karunya University
David Wilson
Download full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation
Content uploaded by David Wilson
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by David Wilson on Jun 24, 2017
Content may be subject to copyright.
IJRESS Volume 5, Issue 7 (July, 2015) (ISSN 2249-7382)
International Journal of Research in Economics and Social Sciences (IMPACT FACTOR – 5.545)
International Journal of Research in Economics & Social Sciences
Email id: editorijrim@gmail.com, http://www.euroasiapub.org
118
A Study on Oral Tradition as a Communication tool
David Wilson D
Dept. of English,
Karunya University, Coimbatore
Abstract-
How many mothers can sing a lullaby? How many Fathers do tell bedtime stories to their wards
today? The ability of man to speak and communicate distinguishes him from other beings. Human
activity to communicate through speech and his intelligence, the cognitive ability to be aware of his
surroundings and visualize them in his mind are the two pivotal factors in human society’s
progression. In it, Oral Tradition is an aspect of human society’s evolution. Oral tradition has
become a domain of great interest to scholars of different disciplines of knowledge today. It has a
huge scope for the discipline of communication too. In the absence of script, it is a complex process
of passing on information of a people’s culture, custom and behaviour from one generation to the
next by word of mouth through stories. This article presents an appraisal of oral tradition as a
means of communication. It also discusses whether oral traditions can be taken as valid historical
sources.
Key Words – Oral Tradition, Communication Tool, Information, Historiography, Folk
Traditions, Story Telling.
I. Introduction-Defining the Oral Tradition
Many people have tried to define the term in their own ways. Vansina [10] has defined oral
traditions as “documents of the present” also inheriting “a message from the past.” For Turner [9], it
is one of the branches of literary studies which reaches back far enough in time to invite a
consideration of that crucial period in human prehistory when biological evolution overlapped with
cultural evolution (p. 68). The oral traditions encompass all verbal testimonies that are reported
statements concerning the past [10]. According to Henige [5], oral tradition, as a genre, should have
been transmitted over several generations and to some extent be the common property of a group
of people (p. 232). As Rosenberg observes, it “is the transmission of cultural items from one
member to another, or others. Those items are heard, stored in memory, and, when appropriate,
recalled at the moment of subsequent transmission” [7].
Two types of testimonies have been commonly discussed –direct and indirect. Bauer and
Bernheim use the term ‘direct testimony’ for eyewitness account, and ‘indirect statement’ for a
reported one. Bernheim puts oral tradition in the category of direct testimonies on the grounds that
both are communicated orally. It is, however, better to classify oral traditions and eyewitness
IJRESS Volume 5, Issue 7 (July, 2015) (ISSN 2249-7382)
International Journal of Research in Economics and Social Sciences (IMPACT FACTOR – 5.545)
International Journal of Research in Economics & Social Sciences
Email id: editorijrim@gmail.com, http://www.euroasiapub.org
119
accounts separately, because each has special characteristics. Anyone can narrate and transmit the
events, which they have seen, or heard from their ancestor. However,
the definition of ‘oral tradition’ by Bauer and Berhneim does not accept that ‘oral tradition’ which
comes from an eyewitness.
II. Oral Tradition versus Written Tradition
There are different point of views in the ‘East’ and the ‘West’ regarding the interrelationship
between oral and written tradition. In Vedic Hindu tradition, it is believed that both oral and
written form of word existed since creation, though the emphasis is primarily on oral one [1]. Here,
literacy was not considered a sine qua non of wisdom, and it is said that even the great grammarian
Panini was not a literate [6]. But, in the context of the West, it is widely assumed that only
‘developed’ societies or countries have their own advanced ‘written culture’ which is a sign of
modernity and progress.
Certeaus argues that writing as a technical instrument became divested of its Christian
determinants and was re-employed as a function of new strategies of reproduction and
capitalization [2]. According to Certeau, ‘Written tradition’ symbolized the concept of modernity
and the ‘oral’ tradition became a symbol of backward societies of nation [8]. In this background,
written tradition has ride on top of the orality, and a visual architecture of language has been
superimposed upon restless acoustic flow of sound [4]. However, we cannot say that oral tradition
does not exist. As Turner [9] argues, the oral tradition continues in our own culture in at least two
realms: liturgy and theater (p. 86). When oral and written forms of expressions are taken in the
context of communication, the significance of oral tradition becomes even apparent.
III. Oral Tradition and History
Every literate or illiterate person has a certain kind of ‘oral’ practice. For illiterate ones, oral
communication becomes crucial and even most of the people who are literate do not write. Thus, it
is a primary means of communication and a practice of daily life. People can remember and
transmit many oral traditions, which they have or which they listened from their ancestors,
irrespective of whether they have ‘written’ practice or not. Apart from regular practices of
conversation, people have their legends, myths, folktales, memories, folksong, sayings and
IJRESS Volume 5, Issue 7 (July, 2015) (ISSN 2249-7382)
International Journal of Research in Economics and Social Sciences (IMPACT FACTOR – 5.545)
International Journal of Research in Economics & Social Sciences
Email id: editorijrim@gmail.com, http://www.euroasiapub.org
120
proverbs. However, there is no possibility of precise transmission of those oral practices from one
generation to another.
Among the various kinds of historical sources, oral traditions occupy a special place. They
are constantly used not only as the most important sources for the history of peoples without
writing, but also as the foundation of many written sources too, especially those of classical
antiquity and of the early Middle Ages. Oral traditions are historical sources of a social nature that
derives from the fact that they are unwritten, they can transmit, and preservation depends on the
powers of memory of successive generations of human being. The oral tradition forms the main
available source for a reconstruction of the past, who have no written culture practice and even
among peoples who have writing, many historical sources, including the most ancient ones, are
based on oral traditions.
Oral materials could be of potential value to historians, whether proverbs, poetry/songs,
lengthy historicized texts, or epics. Vansina urged historians to regard these materials in much the
same way as they had traditionally regarded written documents— as capable of being exploited for
both direct and indirect historical information. In fact, most of the historians and ethnographers are
taking oral tradition as sources of history. India can be taken as a case for this point.
India became independent in 1947 and people still remember and compare the situation
before and after independence. Some people are eyewitness of the whole transition period and thus
have their stories. Those kinds of stories, rhyme, songs, and proverbs can help to study the
perception of people and it can help to narrate cultural, political, social histories of the particular
society or the nation. If we compare the written text before independent and after independent, it
will give different kind of historical knowledge. Same way, we can compare the oral (linguistic)
change among people. Apart from this, we can compare the perception of different generation,
which may help to analyse the historical, cultural or social transition of the society.
IV. Beyond Historiography
The oral tradition is not only the sources of histories but itself a history of language, culture,
society and tradition. It tells us what people speak, how they behave, how they speak or what they
think and speak. It tells different people can explain the certain events differently. Yes, if the
different versions of a story or event exist, the question of ‘reliability’ would be raised. But, if we
analyze some concept like “different social groups use different varieties of language”, “language
IJRESS Volume 5, Issue 7 (July, 2015) (ISSN 2249-7382)
International Journal of Research in Economics and Social Sciences (IMPACT FACTOR – 5.545)
International Journal of Research in Economics & Social Sciences
Email id: editorijrim@gmail.com, http://www.euroasiapub.org
121
reflect the society or culture in which it is used”, “language shapes the society in which it is used”
[3] etc, we can see possibilities different versions in accordance with time, space or language.
It may be in the poetic form or it may be in rhyme, story, proverbs or other forms.
Sometime there may be different ‘character’, ‘place’ or ‘time’ in accordance with the socio cultural
value and tradition. The possibilities of distortion of the events prevailed anywhere which should
be examined. Nevertheless, oral tradition speaks the ‘story’ of not only the past but also of
contemporary social, cultural and linguistic structure of the society. Moreover, it is also a history of
language, culture and society.
V. Oral Traditions of India
Men must have been definitely communicating amongst themselves before invention of
script. Even after invention of script, which must have been the preserve of the privileged few,
record of events, epics, traditions, stories of valour, songs, etc. must have been passed on from
generation to generation through oral tradition. In India even after the advent of script, Vedas were
to be learnt only from a Guru through oral rendition and never through reading. One reason could
be the need for chaste pronunciation and correct intonation. Another reason could be the selfish
desire to keep it the preserve of a few.
On another plane, till the advent of gadgets like phonogram, record-player, tape recorder,
etc. music was preserved entirely in the minds of a few and passed on to the disciples through word
of mouth. Not only the lyrics, but the entire style was preserved and carried forward by the Gurus
and Sishyas through oral tradition. It is mind boggling to realise that there were and are well-
versed veda pandits who could chant thousands and thousands of lines from memory even while
learning new lessons and practicing what was learnt already. Likewise, the repertoire of an eminent
singer, who can elaborate a raga, brings everything from out of his memory improvising the style
and duration for that particular occasion, particular mood, particular audience, is also something to
marvel.
Likewise historical events, mythological stories, etc. are sung by illiterates all learnt by rote.
There were songs for every occasion and every chore to lessen the burden of the task or for mere
merriment. All these are passed on through oral tradition. The tradition of making children commit
to memory is a continuation of this process. If we are to preserve the vast heritage of our culture,
IJRESS Volume 5, Issue 7 (July, 2015) (ISSN 2249-7382)
International Journal of Research in Economics and Social Sciences (IMPACT FACTOR – 5.545)
International Journal of Research in Economics & Social Sciences
Email id: editorijrim@gmail.com, http://www.euroasiapub.org
122
epics, sagas, language, history, we should nurture our tradition of imparting knowledge by rote.
Mere publication or recording alone will simply not be adequate.
VI. The Folk Oral Traditions of India
The folk oral traditions of India go back into timeless antiquity. The heroes and heroines of the
bygone eras are kept alive through songs and dances of simple rustic people. The nomadic tribes
that wandered far into distant valleys in search of pastures and waterholes to tend their herds
burst out into poignant soulful songs pining for their beloveds and yearning for the smells, sounds
and feel of their motherland. Nehru, in his Discovery of India talks about how tribes that had drifted
apart long ago, recognized each other through their songs, after centuries of separation.
The two major epics that shaped the Indian sensibility, the Ramayana and Mahabharata,
were preserved and spread as oral epics. The Suthas narrated and sang the glory of its heroes and
heroines in divine fervour. Even to this day the tradition of devote groups of listeners gathering
around a Sutha to listen to the ancient stories, rather than read the epic poems themselves, is still
alive.
VII. Indian Story Telling
Though poetry is easier to remember than prose, the oral tradition in Indian literature was
not confined to poetic literature. Indian story telling has been moulded to suit oral form right from
the very beginning of narrative fiction in India. India owes a lot of its rich tradition of storytelling to
its tribal people. The tradition of storytelling evokes pictures of weary travellers, at the end of a
long day’s hard journey, gathering around a fire lit on the sands of a river bank un der the starry
night, listening with rapt attention and amusement to the stories of wonder and awe of distant
lands inhabited by exotic people, narrated by an elder, in magical soothing voice with theatrical and
lyrical interludes. With each re-telling, the stories gathered additional narrative, becoming more
circuitous to enhance the drama of the live recitation.
The power of the spoken language to ignite the listener’s imagination and transport him to the
world of ideas, dreams, myths and fables, is truly amazing. As a professor of Mass communication
remarked that in the saying of the word, something is also done, and cannot be undone. Indian
literature is full of tales in which a word was misused, uttered capriciously or wrongly, with
IJRESS Volume 5, Issue 7 (July, 2015) (ISSN 2249-7382)
International Journal of Research in Economics and Social Sciences (IMPACT FACTOR – 5.545)
International Journal of Research in Economics & Social Sciences
Email id: editorijrim@gmail.com, http://www.euroasiapub.org
123
mischievous or even disastrous consequences. And, in some ways the power of words can be seen
as magic; but this is not mere magic.
VIII. Validity and Reliability
Ethnologists who have attempted to study the past of people ‘without writing’ have faced
some problems and they believe or think that oral tradition are never reliable or it may contain a
certain amount of truth. They also believe that it is impossible to assess the amount of truth
contained in oral tradition so it should be thoroughly examined [10]. Definitely, oral tradition
should be examined from the parameter of validity and reliability but the same is true with ‘written
text’. F. Graebner argues that the reliability of oral traditions cannot be probed unless there is some
measure of agreement between various independent accounts and unless the facts conveyed
correspond with those postulated by cultural historical studies [10].
In brief, the question of validity and reliability is to be welcomed unless it is put with a bias
to discredit the oral tradition. Any provision and instrumentation regarding its validity and
reliability will, in fact, increase the scope of examining the oral tradition in order to explore it as
more authentic source of information.
IX. Conclusion
Every study of the ‘oral traditions’ is a part of the historical study which belongs to society.
Every ‘oral’ or ‘written’ tradition has some information about the past events, even if they are
fiction. We collect and preserve all ‘written documents’ because we think it is ‘real’ and ‘reliable’ but
we do not want to collect the ‘oral narration’. My argument is that it is not a matter of technology,
time consumption or expenses but of our conviction always emphasis that the ‘written documents’
have certain ‘truth’ than any kind of ‘oral tradition’.
Scholars think that every ‘oral content’ might be distortion by people or the right story of
the past might be blurred in the transmitting process. However, in my opinion, distorted or blurred
oral traditions also have ‘historical’, ‘cultural’, ‘social’ and ‘linguistic’ content and it is a part of
history. As P.C. Lloyd argues, all traditions contain some truth and the historian may be able to see
in what directions distortion is most likely to have taken place and to asses better their value as
historical evidence [10]. Oral tradition may have some confusion and contradictions, partly because
IJRESS Volume 5, Issue 7 (July, 2015) (ISSN 2249-7382)
International Journal of Research in Economics and Social Sciences (IMPACT FACTOR – 5.545)
International Journal of Research in Economics & Social Sciences
Email id: editorijrim@gmail.com, http://www.euroasiapub.org
124
of lapses of memory, partly because of possible motives for distortion. However, this kind of
problem also seems in ‘written content’.
As Kaviratna [6] says, "the written word can give only an idea of the fact, but the word is not the fact
itself." Whether ‘oral sources’ is reliable or not for particular events can be examined but it speaks
the ‘contemporary social, linguistic and cultural history, therefore, we have to record and analyze it.
I would like to quote Rosenberg, Oral traditions are both more specific and less ambiguous
communication, because the speaker reinforces his or her specificity of meaning with gesture,
expression, intonation, and so on, and various self-correcting mechanisms of which fixed print is
incapable [7]. Certainly, it is not the matter of advocating illiteracy, but giving oral tradition its due
importance.
References
[1] Adhikary, N. M. “Hindu awadharanama sanchar prakriya”, M.A. thesis, Purvanchal
University, Nepal, 2003.
[2] Ahearne, J. Michel De Certeau: Interpretation and its other. Stanford
University Press, 1995.
[3] Burke, P. The art of conservation. New York: Cornell University Press.1993.
[4] Havelock, E. A. The alphabetic mind: A gift of Greece to the modern world.
Oral Tradition, 1(1), 1986,134-150. Retrieved from http://journal.oraltradition.org/
[5] Henige, D. Oral, but oral what? The nomenclatures of orality and their
implications. Oral Tradition, 3(1-2), 1988, 229-38. Retrieved from
http://journal.oraltradition.org/
[6] Kaviratna, H. Unbroken chain of oral tradition.1971, Retrieved August 17, 2012
fromhttp://www.theosophynw. org/theosnw/world/general/ge-kavi.htm
[7] Rosenberg, B. A. The complexity of oral tradition. OralTradition, 2(1),1987, 73-90.
Retrieved from http://journal.oraltradition.org/
[8] Skaria, A. Hybrid histories: Forest, frontiers and wildness in western India.
Delhi: Oxford University Press.1999.
[9] Turner, F. Performed being: Word art as a human inheritance. Oral Tradition,
1(1), 1986, 66-109. Retrieved from http://journal.oraltradition.org/
[10] Vansina, J. Oral tradition a study in historical methodology. Trans. H. M.
Wright. Penguin Books.1965.
... They are direct and indirect testimonies of life incidents. For the eyewitness, it is a direct account, an 'indirect statement' for a reported one (Wilson, 2015). It is possible to coin and employ words as names of locations or individuals. ...
... Accordingly, Certeau (1995) maintains that while written tradition is a symbol of the concept of modernity oral tradition is symbolic of the backward societies of nations. Following this conceptual background, Wilson (2015) observes that written tradition rides on top of the orality, and a visual architecture of language superimposed upon an acoustic restless flow of sound. ...
Creation, Preservation and Documentation of Oral Tradition in Ancient Yorùbá and Hebraic Cultures
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2024
Oral tradition in both ancient Yoruba and Hebraic cultures has remained challenging in contemporary times. This study therefore comparatively examines the creation, preservation, and documentation of oral tradition in ancient Yoruba and Hebraic cultures with the view to evaluating its transition and historical trajectory. Historical narrative and documentary/archival research methods as well as Key Informant Interview (KII) employed in this study. Data was generated and subjected to content analysis. In Yoruba cosmology, oral traditions created were more concretized in the minds of people through cultural activities demonstrated in the form of moonlight stories, folktales, festivals, and so on that portrayed the community norms, beliefs, practices, and morals. These cultural practices become immortalized through repeated performances over a period and these cultures are being celebrated even to date. On the other hand, the Hebraic people believe that the oral tradition was a creation of God for man and that these traditions passed down orally in successive patterns from one generation to another prior to their documentation. Regarding, the preservation and documentation of oral tradition in ancient Yoruba, it is believed that it is passed from mouth to mouth and through stories from one lineage to another. However, for the Hebraic people, the oral traditions preserved before their documentation as observed in the Hebrew Scriptures as well as seen in the written “Torah” (the first five books of the Old Testament). Consequently, the Hebraic oral traditions preserved through memorization, documented first in the Mishnah and some other ancient documents. Preserved in stories that illustrated the model of a sage who was in the order of Moses and was called the “rabbi”. The influence of globalization, misinterpretation and migration on Yoruba oral traditions remains challenging. This is not an exemption even with the Hebraic oral traditions though written.
View
... In the absence of script, it is a complex process of passing on information of a people's culture, custom and behavior from one generation to the next by word of mouth through stories. Vansina in Wilson (2015) defined oral traditions as "documents of the present" also inheriting "a message from the past." Oral traditions have been transmitted over several generations and to some extent become the common property of a group of people (Henige in Wilson 2015). ...
... Vansina in Wilson (2015) defined oral traditions as "documents of the present" also inheriting "a message from the past." Oral traditions have been transmitted over several generations and to some extent become the common property of a group of people (Henige in Wilson 2015). ...
View
... It involves the collection of information from generation to generation through spoken communication (VijayaKumari, 2018). Wilson (2015) identifies oral traditions as vital for understanding cultural history and the foundation for written sources but warns about the erroneous transmission of these oral practices from generation to generation. Hence, teachers must validate the reliability and authenticity of these sources. ...
Historyahe: K-12 Elementary Teachers’ Personal Accounts of Teaching Philippine and Local History
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2024
Recent curriculum revisions in the Philippine educational system have resulted in various changes in the social studies curriculum, but insufficient studies have been conducted on this topic. The paper explored the experiences of K-12 elementary teachers in teaching Philippine and local history through a phenomenological research design involving five participants from two schools in Marabut, Samar. The results revealed that participants' rewarding experiences included promoting historical appreciation and localizing historical education. Conversely, the challenges included inadequate learning materials, lack of teachers' knowledge, scarcity of local historians, students' poor historical understanding, lack of training, and curriculum changes. Despite these challenges, the participants utilized a variety of solutions and effective teaching methods. Thus, the researchers recommended integrating historical education at all educational levels, providing adequate training and resources, and establishing local studies centers to enhance the appreciation of the country's rich history.
View
Navigating the Digital Age Challenges and Strategies for the Future of Print Journalism
Conference Paper
Full-text available
  • Feb 2024
The advent of the digital age has reshaped the landscape of journalism, posing significant challenges for print media. With audiences increasingly turning to digital platforms for news consumption, traditional print publications face declining readership and revenue, necessitating innovative strategiesfor adaptation and survival.Aim: This paper aims to explore the challenges confronting print journalism in the digital age and propose effective strategies to ensure its sustainability and relevance in the evolving media landscape. Methodology: This study employs a qualitative approach, drawing on a comprehensive review of existing literature, industry reports, and case studies to identify key challenges faced by print journalism in the digital age. Strategies for addressing these challenges are synthesized through analysis and interpretation of data. Additionally, expert interviews with journalists, media executives, and industry professionals provide insights and perspectives to inform the development of effective strategies for the future of print journalism. Results: The analysis reveals a range of challenges confronting print journalism, including audience shift to digital platforms, declining revenue streams, and increased competition. Effective strategies identified include digital investment, revenue diversification, content adaptation, and technological integration, essential for ensuring the sustainability and relevance of print journalism
View
Revalorisation and Reconstructing Indigenous Language Instructional Policy towards Oral Tradition at the Basic Education Level in Cameroon
Article
  • Jan 2025
Language instructional policy in Cameroon/Africa has always marginalised indigenous instructional approach, bringing the imported methods to the centre. No wonder why instructional policy in Cameroon has over the years evolved from the structural classical method through the objective-based and, currently, the competency-based approach, which are predominantly foreign. Such policy devalues the local pedagogy as instruction is not contextualised towards local realities leaving the impression that African culture has nothing good to display regarding pedagogy, which is not valid; given that oral traditional strategy existed before Western colonisation. Therefore, valorisation and reconstruction of local instructional approach is needed, which this study provides at the basic education level in Cameroon by checking teachers' and learners’ perspicacity towards using the oral tradition during language instruction and its utilisation by instructors at the Basic Education level in Cameroon with focus on some Primary Schools in Bamenda. Exploiting a mixed method approach, data was collected from a randomly selected sample population of 210 pupils and 32 teachers from the target population using interviews, questionnaires and observation. Underpinning the study within the frameworks of Social Learning and Sociocultural theories findings were made such as; teachers/ learners express positive/encouraging perspicacity about implementing oral traditional methods in teaching indigenous languages at the target level despite their limited utilisation of the said method by instructors, which is not backed by policy. Following the findings, the integration of oral traditional strategies into language instruction and the adjustment of policy to accommodate Indigenous pedagogy at the basic education level are recommended.
View
Chapter 15. Multilingualism, linguistic diversity, and English in India: Effects on underprivileged children’s linguistic and cognitive development
Chapter
  • Nov 2024
This volume comprises studies and keynote addresses presented at the 16th Generative Approaches to Second Language Acquisition Conference hosted by The Norwegian University of Science and Technology, NTNU, in Trondheim in 2022. The selection of cutting-edge studies presented covers a wide array of topics within generative linguistics, including the acquisition of grammatical features, challenges of functional morphology, the impact of the native language on subsequently acquired languages, and interfaces between linguistic domains. Other chapters address how non-native language processing differs from native processing, while the volume also highlights internal and external factors affecting bi- and multilingual development and points to important avenues for further generative research on second language acquisition.
View
Integrating ATI Culture into English Language Teaching
Article
  • Jul 2022
This qualitative study examined the Ati narratives to preserve their culture and language. Using a validated questionnaire, the researcher interviewed Ati elders and tribal leaders in semi-structured and open-ended questions. The narratives of the Ati culture reveal a variety of themes, including danger and valor, life and survival, feasts and celebrations, faith and devotion, and resilience and heroism. The Ati, as indigenous peoples, were superstitious regarding indigenous healing, burial, and courtship. Their lives are fraught with danger, but they face it with bravery. Their existence is precarious, as they are constantly on the lookout for food. They demonstrate resilience in the face of arduous tasks such as charcoal production and exotic food hunting, disaster preparation, and interpersonal relations with the non-ethnic group. They are proud of their race because they have role models who influence their faith in God and their ancient elders' bravery during the war. They are overjoyed at the prospect of their race being the first to settle in the new land. Their close family ties contribute to their adaptability. Putting Ati-narratives into English language classes will help keep the rich culture and language of the Ati people alive.
View
Pervasive State Control On Temples: An Administrative Furore?
Article
Full-text available
  • Dec 2023
It all started with the eviction proceedings of a practicing advocate who was a tenant on the premises of the temple owned by the royal family of Travancore. The action of the executive officer who tried to oust the practicing advocate from the land on which he was a tenant was challenged. The predisposition of the tenant was that the executive officer himself lacked the authority to exercise powers by holding his office. In addition to that, the person vide whom he was appointed under hand and seal lacked the authority to do so since his authority in office was questioned. This spiked the fire of the famous Padmanabhaswamy Temple dispute which not only underscores pervasive state control but also speaks volumes of the pseudo-secularism in the exercise of administrative privileges present in the country. The action of a religious community to agree to the state control over its religious institutions on the condition prevailing that, the state shall hold the authority to take care of funds and management of transactions but not the religious activities of the Institution is a drowning Armada sure to sink. This is because the community is oblivious to the fact that investment in secularism starts with transactions undertaken and monetary power conferred. That the religious institution be governed by a secular body in addition to which the latter be vested with the power to make appointments of significant position holders to the religious institution goes against the very spirit of the provisions of the constitution. The right of a religious community to administer its religious institution which is not secular, perhaps essentially religious is an Essential Religious Practice or at least significant for carrying out its Essential Religious Practices. The Padmanabhaswamy Temple Verdict of the Apex Court, by taking into consideration the intricacies of the Covenant and interpretation of its clauses has accurately differentiated between the right of the state to supervise and the unwritten privilege enjoyed by it to control and administer. This paper focuses on:•Evolution of essential religious practice and its applicability to the Padmanabhaswamy Temple issue;•In-depth analysis of the Padmanabhaswamy Temple vis-a-vis the Kerala High Court judgment;•Shedding light on inspiring factors of the verdict: The Shirur Math Judgment and Chidambaram Temple Verdict that propelled as clarion calls for self-governance of religious institutions;•Highlighting how rampant and essential the judgment is for the community in the light of the Hindu Religious Endowment Board Act, 1951 and the reignited hope in the Judiciary along with constitutional provisions reinstated by it.
View
The Functions of Language Analysis on Oral Tradition Tangis in Karonese
Article
Full-text available
  • Mar 2023
This research deals with the analysis of language functions on oral tradition's Tangis in Karonese. The aim of this research is to: (a) describe how language functions are realized on oral tradition's Tangis in Karonese and (b) explain the reason why language functions are used on oral tradition's Tangis in Karonese. This research was conducted by using the descriptive qualitative method. The data of this research is taken from the utterances spoken by the pilgrims when did the Tangis. There are five language functions found in Tangis from the six language functions proposed by Roman Jakobson. They were referential 54,1%, conative 32,4%, emotive 8,1%, phatic 2,7 %, and poetic 2,7%. Besides the language functions found, there are also the reasons the language functions are used on oral tradition's Tangis in Karonese. They were thoughts, feelings, needs, and observation.
View
Oral Traditions and Folk Art: A Case of Phad Paintings with Emphasis on ‘Pabuji Ki Phad’, and Commercialisation of Crafts
Article
Full-text available
  • Jun 2023
The term, ‘Oral traditions', applies to both the process of its transmission and its outcome, derived from the oral messages being passed down to the generations (Vansina, 1985). The practice of narrating epics and stories, therefore, is an example of oral traditions. One such epic is that of Pabuji, which is painted on a scroll called 'Phad’ and is transmitted through folk art and orality in the regions of Bhilwara and Shahpura in Rajasthan. Oral traditions were probably incorporated into folk art and performances to overcome language barriers and ease the process of transmission (Mode & Chandra,1985). Therefore, studying the relationship between oral traditions and folk art seems to be of value. Keeping this in mind, the paper will attempt to introduce the epic of Pabuji and the process of its transmission.
View
View
View
View
The Complexity of Oral Tradition
Article
  • Jan 1987
In challenging a remark I had once made while presenting a paper at a professional meeting, a member of the audience said that he could demonstrate that there was no oral tradition in sixteenth-century Spain. To me this meant that the speaker had proof that people living on the Iberian Peninsula at that time never spoke to one another. Obviously, to him, "oral tradition" meant something else entirely. The very concept, the comprehension of such a mode of life, is alien to literates; and despite the writing done on the subject in recent decades by Walter Ong, Albert Lord, Ruth Finnegan, Claude Lévi-Strauss, and Jack Goody (to name only a few), "Oral Tradition" is not a concept widely understood by professional educators, let alone agreed upon. This essay will outline some of the major research and thinking done on this subject to date, to provide a context for uni-disciplinary work now done. It will not announce a truth; it will describe what the author has in mind when speaking of this mode. Although many Romantics were, for their own reasons, enthralled with the idea of savage nobility and its lifeworld, a world in which the complicating (and corrupting) products of technology had not yet been imposed, that simple (oral) society has not been easy to identify. In his The Singer of Tales (1960:137), Albert Lord laments the rise of literacy in the Yugoslavia where he and Milman Parry did so much of their fi eldwork with the remark that printing had introduced the notion of the "fi xed" text and that there were now very few singers "who have not been infected by this disease." Their performances are reproductions rather than creations, Lord continues, and "this means death to oral tradition . . ." (ibid.). Anthropologists and folklorists would not agree, since much of their research on the subject indicates that rarely is a
View
View
View
View
Hindu awadharanama sanchar prakriya
  • Jan 2003
  • N M Adhikary
Adhikary, N. M. "Hindu awadharanama sanchar prakriya", M.A. thesis, Purvanchal University, Nepal, 2003.
Interpretation and its other
  • Jan 1995
  • J Ahearne
  • Michel De Certeau
Ahearne, J. Michel De Certeau: Interpretation and its other. Stanford University Press, 1995.
The art of conservation The alphabetic mind: A gift of Greece to the modern world
  • Jan 1993
  • P Burke
  • E A Havelock
Burke, P. The art of conservation. New York: Cornell University Press.1993. [4] Havelock, E. A. The alphabetic mind: A gift of Greece to the modern world.