ArticlePDF Available

Better knowledge need not affect behavior: A randomized evaluation of the demand for lottery tickets in rural Thailand

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

Many households in developing countries spend substantial amounts on lottery tickets but have only poor knowledge about the properties of the game and hold upwardly biased beliefs on the prospects of winning. To test whether more accurate knowledge reduces lottery participation, households in rural Thailand were informed, in a randomized intervention, on the actual probability distribution of the Thai Government Lottery. This indeed led to a better knowledge about the Thai Government Lottery in the treatment group. However, the improved knowledge did not (substantially) affect the willingness to pay for lottery tickets.
Content may be subject to copyright.
∗ ‡
=
a
b
c
c
c
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
e
e
e
e
a
>1<1b
c d e
23 50 = 27
p
ψ
ψ
ψ50.99p0.99p < ψ <
1.01pψ=1.01p
ψ p
(1 )p < ψ < (1 + )p
= 0.01 = 0.05 = 0.2
=.01
R2
N
p0.99 < ψ < p 1.01
=
R2
N
0.84 0.92
u(c)=(cα)1α α 1
α6= 0 π p
y w
pu(y+π) + (1 p)u(y) = u(y+w)
w=y·h(1 p+p(1 + π/y)α)11i.
α= 1 w=
w α
y= 30,000 p= 7 ×106
π= 106
w= 7 w= 2.041 w= 0.2014 α= 1 α= 0.5
α=1p= 106
α w = 1 w= 0.291 w= 0.029
7 : 1 w
p p y
a
b
c
c
c
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
a
>1<1b
c
d
ψ ψ
ψ50.95p0.95p < ψ <
1.05pψ=1.05p ψ 50.80p0.80p < ψ <
1.20pψ=1.20p
=.2
R2
N
p0.99 < ψ < p 1.01
=
R2
N
=
a
b
c
c
c
d
d
d
d
d
d
d
R2
N
p0.99 < ψ < p 1.01
=
p0.99 < ψ < p 1.01
:
0.02 .04 .06 .08
050 100 050 100
Control Group Treatment Group
Density
Lottery Ticket Reservation Price
Graphs by Lottery Treatment Variable
... In addition, the income gap and education gap are speculated as potential moderators of these relationships. The effects of scientific knowledge and risk perception on behavioral decision making are emphasized by previous literature [15][16][17]. An individual's chance of making mistakes can be influenced by incomplete knowledge when solving problems, because they may choose incorrect strategies [18]. ...
... In some cases, the evidence with respect to knowledge and consequent behaviors is ambiguous and mixed. For example, improved knowledge does not have positive effects on the misuse of fertilizers [21] and willingness to buy lottery tickets [16]. Therefore, the effect of scientific knowledge on the preference for defensive consumption goods may remain uncertain. ...
... This implies that the scientific knowledge effect of environmental hazards cannot improve farmers' defensive awareness and preferences in rural areas. Information activities, training programs, and educational interventions can improve understanding and knowledge, but do not necessarily affect behavior [16]. If there are cognition illusions and optimistic bias about the actual environment, people will not prefer defensive labels despite their knowledge of environmental risks [52]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Little is known about the preference for defensive consumption goods and their defensive attributes under environmental risks in developing countries. The paper takes the water purifier as an example of defensive consumption goods against heavy metal pollution risk from drinking water. Using a survey data in China, the discrete choice experiment method is employed to investigate rural farmers’ preferences for a water purifier. The scientific knowledge and risk perception effects are used to determine farmers’ preferences for the defensive attribute on a water purifier. Using a mixed logit model, rural farmers are found to prefer a water purifier with low price, free installation, a longer warranty period, and a heavy metal filter (i.e. the defensive attribute). Farmers’ neighborhood norm perception dominates the defensive preference while scientific knowledge do not work significantly. More specifically, the more the neighborhood norm perception is recognized, the more likely farmers are to improve their own preferences for the defensive attribute. Affected by the neighborhood norm perception, rural farmers’ preferences for the defensive attribute are found to be increased significantly as average income gaps narrow. The future defensive health policies should be devoted to improving environmental risk awareness and utilizing informal social networks in areas with high environmental risks.
... This study reported house-edge was better understood by gamblers than return to player and had a stronger association with perceived chances of winning. Two further RCT's examined education on the odds of gambling (Broussard & Wulfert, 2019;Zenker, Wagener, & Vollmer, 2018). Broussard and Wulfert (2019) reported that education on the odds of winning was associated with reduced gambling over a 2week period. ...
... Broussard and Wulfert (2019) reported that education on the odds of winning was associated with reduced gambling over a 2week period. Zenker et al. (2018) reported that there was no impact from education on odds on lottery purchases at 3-month follow-up evaluation. ...
Technical Report
Full-text available
This review builds on the 2018 NSW gap analysis by reviewing recent Australian and, where relevant, international gambling research to identify areas in which evidence and/or knowledge is minimal or lacking. The findings of the current review will inform the Responsible Gambling Fund’s prioritisation of research projects for their 2020-2021 research plan. The methodology included a rapid literature review of 198 peer-reviewed articles and 17 grey literature reports published between 1 October 2018 and 23 April 2020. Key findings (i) The research on emerging technologies is limited, although there are consistent findings that gaming and gambling are increasingly converging, and of an association between in-game purchases and gambling problems (ii) There is sufficient evidence of the associations between advertising and gambling behaviours to support gambling advertising being a priority for policy and regulation (iii) The evidence base on the effects of prevention and harm reduction intervention is dominated by evaluations of individual-level initiatives, with a paucity of research on supply reduction interventions (iv) There was disagreement in the literature on the definition, conceptualisation and measurement of harm. Further gambling harm measurement tools are needed to support the design and measurement of prevention, harm minimisation and treatment research. (v) Vulnerable groups were consistently found to have lower gambling participation but higher rates of gambling problems.Vulnerable groups were identified as young people, people from culturally and linguistically diverse communities, Aboriginal people, at-risk professions, and groups susceptible to family violence and other co-morbidities.
... As such, lottery managers should reduce the advertisements of winning and develop debiasing strategies to reduce positive illusions. The evidence-based debiasing strategies can be considered are educational videos (Wohl et al., 2013), instruction concerning odds (Zenker et al., 2018), graphic warning messages (Munoz et al., 2013), and Anti-gambling advertising (Lemarié & Chebat, 2015). Regarding the effects of winning exposure on positive illusions were stronger for lottery gamblers with low SES and low levels of the highest amount ever won, the second recommendation is to reduce winning exposure in poverty communities and regions and pay more attention to gamblers who always lose money. ...
Article
Full-text available
Positive illusions and winning exposure are key factors leading to problem lottery gambling, but few studies have examined the relationships between them. 402 Chinese lottery gamblers was conducted with the Winning Exposure Questionnaire, the Positive illusion Questionnaire, the Winning Experience Questionnaire, and the Social and Economic Status Questionnaire to investigate the relationship between winning exposure and positive illusions as well as the moderating role of winning experience and socioeconomic status. The results showed that winning exposure can significantly and positively predict the positive illusions (optimism bias, better than average bias, and illusion of control) of lottery gamblers. The highest winning amount and subjective socioeconomic status significantly moderated the relationship between winning exposure and optimism bias. That was to say, for lottery gamblers with smaller maximum winning amount and lower subjective socioeconomic status, the association between winning exposure and optimism bias was stronger. Furthermore, the moderating effect of highest winning amount in the relationship between winning exposure and better than average bias, and the moderating effects of occupational status and subjective socioeconomic status in the relationship between winning exposure and illusion of control were marginally significant.
Article
Full-text available
The expansion of illicit lottery activities has caused significant harm to both agricultural production and the livelihood of rural residents. An analysis of the factors that influence rural residents' participation in underground lotteries can provide crucial insight for regulating the lottery industry's development. This study examines the present state of rural residents' participation in underground lotteries, investigates the factors that impact their participation using the Double-Hurdle model, and further employs the ISM model to evaluate the correlations and hierarchical structure among the factors, using field survey data collected from 603 rural residents in S Province, China. The findings reveal that 53.07% of the respondents have participated in underground lotteries. Risk preference, information acquisition, social networks, age, education, family burden, percentage of agricultural labor, agricultural business scale, and household income significantly affect whether residents purchase lotteries (WPL). All factors, except the percentage of agricultural labor and agricultural business scale, also significantly impact underground lottery spending (LS). Among the significant influencing factors, rural residents' risk preference is the direct surface factor, whereas agricultural business scale, household income, information acquisition, and social networks are the middle indirect factors, and residents' age, education, family burden, and percentage of agricultural labor are the deep-rooted factors. It is recommended to regulate the lottery industry's development can be achieved by enhancing entertainment and cultural activities, expanding economic opportunities, enhancing rural education, increasing law awareness, and improving the public welfare lottery business model. The conclusions offer a valuable reference point for the standardized development of the lottery industry and the promotion of social stability in rural areas.
Article
Full-text available
The Economics Nobel 2019 for Abhijit Banerjee, Esther Duflo and Michael Kremer for their experimental approach to alleviating global poverty has been received by economists with a wide array of reactions. This article introduces the experimental revolution in development economics and the work of Banerjee, Duflo and Kremer and then discusses a number of critiques that have been raised about it: methodological concerns relating to the internal and external validity of experiments in economics; a supposed focus of RCTs on the microlevel and a distraction of development economics away from structural issues; the scope of experimental research for poverty reduction; and normative concerns arising when experiments are used in development economics.
Article
Full-text available
Purpose of Review This review seeks to increase awareness of the broad range of interventions for problem gambling that focus on mitigating biased beliefs and behaviors. A secondary goal of this review is to stimulate thinking surrounding the use of so-called debiasing strategies within the areas of responsible gambling, prevention, and treatment of gambling problems. This is accomplished by classifying gambling interventions according to a taxonomy of debiasing strategies which is used more broadly within the field of decision science. Recent Findings Many interventions use cognitive and process-driven (known as technological) debiasing strategies. Furthermore, advances in technology to include digital games and online programs have the power to increase both the efficacy and appeal of such approaches. Unfortunately, far fewer interventions have taken advantage of affective and motivational debiasing strategies. Summary There are potential insights to be had and new directions to be explored by incorporating debiasing strategies and decision science into investigations of problem gambling interventions. Possibilities include identifying and examining understudied areas, combining debiasing strategies with existing treatments for problem gambling, developing multimodal debiasing interventions, and focusing explicitly on process-driven approaches.
Article
Full-text available
Sexual health problems cause negative externalities from contagious diseases and public expenditure burdens from teenage pregnancies. In a randomized evaluation, we find that an online sexual-health education course in Colombia leads to significant impacts on knowledge and attitudes and, for those already sexually active, fewer STIs. To go beyond self-reported measures, we provide condom vouchers six months after the course, and find a 9 percentage point increase in redemption. We find no evidence of spillovers to untreated classrooms, but we do observe a social reinforcement effect: the impact intensifies when a larger fraction of a student’s friends is also treated.Institutional subscribers to the NBER working paper series, and residents of developing countries may download this paper without additional charge at www.nber.org.
Article
Full-text available
We evaluate the impact of a health information intervention implemented through mobile phones, using a clustered randomized control trial augmented by qualitative interviews. The intervention aimed to improve sexual health knowledge and shift individuals towards safer sexual behavior by providing reliable information about sexual health. The novel technology designed by Google and Grameen Technology Center provided automated searches of an advice database on topics requested by users via SMS. It was offered by MTN Uganda at no cost to users. Quantitative survey results allow us to reject the hypothesis that improving access to information would increase knowledge and shift behavior to less risky sexual activities. In fact, we find that the service led to an increase in promiscuity, and no shift in perception of norms. Qualitative focus groups discussions support the findings of the quantitative survey results. We conclude by discussing a potential mechanism explaining the counterintuitive findings.
Article
Full-text available
This study examines the cognitive and social psychological factors underlying UK National Lottery play. A total of 384 respondents were asked about their own lottery playing behaviours, their knowledge of lottery odds and their beliefs about the role of skill, chance, luck and optimism in lottery play. Using hypothetical scenarios, respondents were also asked to rate the likelihood of winning the lottery jackpot (matching all six numbers) with number combinations reflecting different levels of apparent randomness, previous matches, near misses and prize size manipulations. Frequency of lottery play was found to be positively correlated with age, income, Instants scratchcard play, gambling on horse/greyhound racing, the football pools, and binge as well as with beliefs about skill, luck and optimism. Frequency of lottery play was negatively correlated with general education and estimate of relative win likelihoods based on the perceived randomness of number combinations. Planned contrasts revealed that compared to individual (non-syndicate) players, syndicate lottery players played more regularly and gambled more on the football pools. Results are discussed in the light of current cognitive theories surrounding the misperception of probability and their relation to lottery play and in the need for future models to recognise the social factors inherent in syndicate-based lottery participation.
Article
Full-text available
Most academic and development policy discussions about microentrepreneurs focus on credit constraints and assume that subject to those constraints, the entrepreneurs manage their business optimally. Yet the self-employed poor rarely have any formal training in business skills. A growing number of microfinance organizations are attempting to build the human capital of microentrepreneurs in order to improve the livelihood of their clients and help further their mission of poverty alleviation. Using a randomized control trial, we measure the marginal impact of adding business training to a Peruvian group lending program for female microentrepreneurs. Treatment groups received thirty- to sixty-minute entrepreneurship training sessions during their normal weekly or monthly banking meeting over a period of one to two years. Control groups remained as they were before, meeting at the same frequency but solely for making loan and savings payments. We find little or no evidence of changes in key outcomes such as business revenue, profits, or employment. We nevertheless observed business knowledge improvements and increased client retention rates for the microfinance institution. (c)© 2011 The President and Fellows of Harvard College and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Chapter
Until today there have been few databases that satisfy the theoretical requirements for studying vulnerability to poverty as indicated in Chapter 2. Among existing datasets the Ethiopian Rural Household Survey used, for example, by Dercon et al. (2002; 2005) is prominent and provides a panel dataset well suited to vulnerability analysis. The first wave of data collection was carried out in 1989 in six farming villages in central and southern Ethiopia, with a focus on the crisis and recovery in the 1980s. An expansion of the survey to 15 villages across the country in early 1994 yielded a sample of 1477 households. Additional rounds of the survey were carried out in late 1994, 1995, 1997, 1999, and 2004. In the 1995 wave, a general shock module was implemented, which was further improved in later rounds (Dercon et al., 2005).
Article
This paper critically reviews the existing literature on the effectiveness of gambling prevention programmes for youth. Two categories of preventive strategies, all universal and most school-based, are presented: gambling-specific prevention programmes and gambling and related skills workshops. The age of the participants across the different studies varied from 9 to 20 years. Results show that programmes in both categories are generally effective in reducing misconceptions and increasing knowledge about gambling. However, a lack of long-term follow-ups and of behavioural measures makes it difficult to draw any clear conclusions about the effectiveness of such programmes. Recommendations are presented to improve the development and evaluation of future prevention programmes for youth gambling.
Article
There has been a long history of patron participation in parimutuel horse race wagering and attendance, which are major recreational products in consumer budgets. In this paper, the demand for parimutuel horse race wagering and attendance has been specified and estimated for both Thoroughbred and Standardbred racetracks in a multistate market area. The data are annual over the period 1960--1987. It is found that demand is price elastic in every case. Racing quality, personal income, the number of racing days, competition from a state lottery, and from professional sports (baseball, basketball, football) are all significant determinants of these demands. Both attendance and wagering are found to increase with an increase in racing quality. However, it seems that the new patrons, attracted by quality racing, tend to wager less than those who attend regularly. The presence of a state lottery is found to have resulted in a substantial loss in attendance as well as in wagering at each of the racetracks. This, in turn, has resulted in a loss in both attendance and wagering-related revenue to racetracks, horsemen at those racetracks, and state governments. Professional sports are estimated to have a negative impact on attendance and wagering demands. For example, an additional 10 days of competition from professional sports in 1987 would have resulted in a 4% decrease in both attendance and wagering. Both attendance and wagering can be increased by lowering the takeout rate from present levels or by offering more quality races.
Article
After a discussion of the evolution and criticisms of state run lotteries, this article examines the ethics of lottery advertising. A discussion of the appeals used by lottery advertisers is followed by evidence concerning the impact of expected value information on lottery purchase intentions. Findings point toward less emphasis on the lottery as a solution to financial and job problems and more emphasis on information about the actual value of a lottery bet. Using accepted standards from the marketing literature, lottery advertising is found to be deceptive.