ChapterPDF Available

Investigating Consumer Message Processing of Fear and Challenge Based Advertising: A Conceptual Framework.

Authors:
Svetlana de Vos at Australian Institute of Business
Svetlana de Vos
Roberta Carolyn Crouch at Flinders University
Roberta Carolyn Crouch
Pascale Genevieve Quester at Swinburne University of Technology
Pascale Genevieve Quester
Jasmina Ilicic at Monash University (Australia)
Jasmina Ilicic
Download full-text PDFDownload full-text PDF
Read full-text
Download citation

Abstract

The proposed conceptual framework further advance our theoretical understanding of consumer cognitive, emotional and behavioral processes associated with fear/challenge message appeals in a social marketing context. We integrate disparate areas of knowledge from the fields of psychology and personality research and examine moderating effects of individual differences such as experiential avoidance, distress tolerance, and identity styles on information processing and behavior when exposed to a combined fear/challenge appeal. The proposed theoretical framework combines an information processing construct with a revised protection motivation model, to more explicitly reveal how cognitive processing affects persuasion of fear/challenge appeals. The conceptual framework also tests the mediating effects of response efficacy and self-accountability on depth of information processing and attitude change. Understanding the intricate details of information processing should enable social marketers to tailor messages to specific psychological profiles of customers in order to alter their behavior.
LookingForward,LookingbackDrawingonthepasttoShapeTheFutureOfMarketing_Book_Chapt
er.pdf
Content uploaded by Svetlana de Vos
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Svetlana de Vos on Jan 10, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
5a55b6fdaca272bb6962ae
83.pdf
Content uploaded by Svetlana de Vos
Author content
All content in this area was uploaded by Svetlana de Vos on Jan 10, 2018
Content may be subject to copyright.
ResearchGate has not been able to resolve any citations for this publication.
View
The Role of Appraisal and Emotion in Coping and Adaptation
Chapter
Full-text available
  • Jan 2011
There is a puzzling bifurcation in the scientific literatures concerned with psychological stress, coping, and emotion. Robust, but largely separate, literatures have developed to focus on appraisal, stress, coping, and adaptation, on the one hand, and on appraisal and emotion, on the other. Although the topics touched upon in these literatures are highly overlapping, the two literatures appear to have developed largely independently, and cross-references between them are rare. In our own work, we have contributed to the literatures on both emotion and psychological stress and coping. However, we have long subscribed to the type of unified theoretical framework that Lazarus envisioned, and we believe that such a framework provides a much more powerful perspective for studying issues of adaptation than the two seemingly separate literatures that currently exist. In the present chapter we make the case for adopting a unified theoretical framework concerned with appraisal, emotion, coping, and adaptation. After providing an overview of psychological stress and coping theory, we consider the appraisal theory approach to studying emotion. We discuss some of the basic theoretical assumptions underlying this approach, and then describe a set of specific appraisal models of emotion that we have helped develop and test. In doing so, we illustrate how the development of these emotion models has been heavily dependent upon stress and coping theory. We then consider how current stress and coping theory might be informed by the advances we have described within emotion theory, and conclude by briefly considering some of the key benefits we believe a unified theoretical perspective has to offer the study both of emotion and of coping and adaptation.
View
Persuasion and the structure of affect. Dual systems and discrete emotions as complementary models
Article
Full-text available
  • Jan 2001
Participants viewed eight PSAs, providing data on their cognitive and emotional rc spouses to each, as well as judgments of the perceived effectiveness of the messages. They also responded to Carver and White's (1994) BIS/BAS scales designed to measure individual differences in the behavioral inhibition and behavioral activation systems. Consistent with dual-systems theories of affect, the BIS scales predicted arousal Of negative emotions, while BAS was associated with the elicitation of positive emotions. However, when predicting perceived message effectiveness, the positive affects showed variation in the sign and magnitude of the coefficients, as did the negative affects. This latter finding supports a discrete-emotions perspective. Knowledge that the two affect structures are appropriate to different conceptual domains (i.e., elicitation vs. effect) should enable researchers to formulate more precise questions regarding the role of affect in persuasion.
View
Emotions: A Cognitivephenomenological Analysis
Chapter
  • Dec 1980
We have attempted four main tasks in this chapter. First, a systematic overview is given of the cognitive–phenomenological theory of emotions put forth by Lazarus and his colleagues. The concepts of cognitive appraisal, coping, and several key principles in the theory, including transaction and flux, are reviewed. Second, we offer a working definition of emotion which also serves to summarize the main tenets of the theoretical point of view. Third, we draw upon this point of view to deal with a number of phylogenetic issues concerning the nature of emotion in humans and infra-humans. Finally, we attempt to redress the traditional imbalance of thought in which positively toned emotions have been neglected in favor of the negative. We systematically examine some of the conceptual issues that have made it difficult to integrate positively toned emotions into emotion theory. In this discussion, emphasis is placed on the functions of physiological changes in positively toned emotions and on the ways that positively toned emotions affect coping. Throughout, our view has been that the neglect of positively toned emotions in emotion theory has obscured their importance in human adaptation and in psychological growth and change.
View
Mixing emotions: The use of humor in fear advertising
Article
  • Mar 2012
  • J Consum Behav
Fear is used to advertise many products, services, and causes such as antismoking, sunscreen usage, and safe driving. Past research indicates that high levels of fear tension arousal can prompt defensive responses in the audience, which, in turn, can reduce the persuasive effect of the ad. We show in two studies that humor can reduce these defensive responses and hence increase the persuasiveness of fear advertising. Specifically, we show that increasing the level of fear tension arousal decreases persuasion when humor is absent but increases persuasion when humor is present. Further, this interaction of humor and fear tension arousal is mediated by defensive responses related to message elaboration and vulnerability to threat. Our results suggest that the effectiveness of fear advertising can be increased by adding an element of humor to the ad. Copyright
View
Patterns of Coping Associated With Identity Processing Styles
Article
  • Oct 2011
  • Identity
The purpose of this study was to examine patterns of relationships between identity processing styles and a range of beneficial and problematic coping strategies. Participants completed self-report measures of identity styles (informational, normative, and diffuse-avoidant), identity commitment, and 15 different coping strategies. The diffuse-avoidant style was positively associated with denial, disengagement, and substance use, and it was also positively related to humor. The normative and informational styles were positively correlated with active coping, planning, restraint, seeking social support, and turning to religion; however, the informational style was more highly correlated with all of these coping strategies except turning to religion. The informational style was the only identity style that was positively related to acceptance and positive reinterpretation and growth.
View
The Effects of Risk Disclosure and Ad Involvement on Consumers in DTCA Advertising
Article
  • May 2007
  • J Consum Market
Purpose – The importance of consumer involvement is well recognized in marketing theory, but has been absent from past inquiries in consumers' processing of DTC advertisements. The authors believe it is necessary to account for varying levels of involvement between consumers in order to better appreciate their responses to DTC advertisement claims. The present study aims to shed additional insight into the relationship between consumer involvement and the processing of risk information in DTC advertising. Design/methodology/approach – The study was a between‐subject factorial design and consisted of 156 students from a North American university. It used an instructional manipulation designed to compare how low and highly involved consumers perceive DTC drug advertisements and more specifically the benefit and risk information contained in such advertisements. Findings – Findings indicate that consumers' perception and processing of DTC advertisements resembles consumers' reaction to fear appeals. Furthermore, consistent with previous studies, consumers react negatively to DTC advertisements containing a high content of risk information. Findings indicate that greater differences in consumer processing of risk information is observed when the sample is categorized as high versus low involved, rather than sufferer versus non‐sufferer, and that this consumer characteristic is important enough to include when examining consumer reactions to DTC advertisements. Originality/value – The relationship between amount of risk information and consumer responses has not been empirically examined while controlling for the potential role of involvement. This study is a first step in addressing this gap.
View
When scary messages backfire: Influence of dispositional cognitive avoidance on the effectiveness of threat communications
Article
  • Feb 2010
We examined whether individual differences in cognitive avoidance influence the effectiveness of threat communications in changing attitudes and intentions regarding health-promoting behaviors. Two-hundred ninety-seven participants completed a measure of dispositional cognitive avoidance and read either a high or a low threat communication. We found that after a high threat message, low cognitive avoiders reported more favorable attitudes toward and intentions to adopt the action recommendation than high cognitive avoiders. The recommended response was appraised more positively by high cognitive avoiders after the low threat message than after the high threat message. Exactly the opposite pattern of results was found for low cognitive avoiders. In sum, individual differences in cognitive avoidance are an important moderator of the effectiveness of threat communications.
View
Anxiety, coping strategies, and the processing of threatening information: Investigations with cognitive-experimental paradigms
Article
  • May 2011
  • PERS INDIV DIFFER
This review treats individual differences in anxiety and coping from several perspectives. It starts with the argument that structural considerations (often linked to trait concepts) and processing considerations (often linked to situational demands and actual behavior) are not fundamentally in opposition, but that global and uncontextualized trait concepts (e.g., trait anxiety) require revision to incorporate cognitive–affective units such as appraisals, goals, or self-regulatory competencies (cf. Mischel, 2004). The article then presents a personality-oriented coping theory (the model of coping modes; MCM; Hock & Krohne, 2004; Krohne, 1993, 2003) which attempts to incorporate these units. The MCM distinguishes vigilant (uncertainty-oriented) and cognitively avoidant (arousal-oriented) coping processes and views them as dispositional preferences related to personality. Empirical evidence (based on cognitive-experimental designs in the fields of attentional orientation and the interpretation and retrieval of ambiguous and aversive information) is reviewed and supports central assumptions of the theory.
View
There are Threats and (Maybe) Fear-Caused Arousal: Theory and Confusions of Appeals to Fear and Fear Arousal Itself
Article
  • Oct 1997
Most research in the area generally known as “fear appeals” has examined the persuasive effects and effectiveness of different types of threat-based communications on various groups of consumer subjects, often failing to distinguish between the threats, the literal communication stimuli, and the actual fear arousal response that different types of threats might engender. Building on a noteworthy exception to that pattern of past work, which provided a basis for a model of fear arousal, the authors further clarify the distinction between threats and psychological responses to the threats. They test an expanded model based on that distinction that provides further understanding of consumer fear arousal responses to advertising stimuli.
View