ArticlePDF Available

A Neogene salt body as the primary source of the salinity in Lake Kinneret

Authors:
Arch. F{ydrobiol. Spec. Issues Advanc. Limnoi. 55, p. 59-85, February 2000
Limnoiogy and Lake Management 2000+
A SJeogeffie saEt body as the primary s@ue'ce Gf saHFmnty
an Lakc KEmmcret
Akiva Flexer, AnnatYellin-Dror, Joel Kronfeld, Eliyahu Rosenthal,
Zvi Ben-Avraham, Philippe Pascal Artsztein and Lea Davidson
with 6 figures
Abstract: A mineraiogicai study of sporadic samples from the thick salt sequence found within wildcat
Zemah-!, revealed the presence of evaporite minerals beyond the level of halite precipitation. The pres-
ence of post halite minerals extending up to, and including, bischofite cannot be excluded. The finding of
the more soluble K and Mg salts shows evidence of an advanced degree of seawater evaporation that
acted, presumably cyclically, on seawater that intruded during Miocene-Pliocene times into the Rift
Valley. The wildcat Zemah-l borehole is located immediateiy south of Lake Kinneret. The region is
dissected by regional faults that extend longirudinally across the lake. These faults may act as conduits
for groundwater that flushes the salt body at various levels as it rises to the surface. The presence of such
an extensive, mineralogically differentiated salt body (similar to other such structures in the Rift) may
explain the high Cl, Br and Mg contents and the deficiency of Na in groundwater and spnngs emereing
along the eastern shore of the lake and in the nearby Rift extension. The Zemah-l salt body as weil as
similar structures in the Rift, may be the sources of the brines discharging along the eastern, southern and
southwestem shores of the lake and pcssibiy may be diffusing upwards throu-eh the sediments alon-q the
entire lake floor.
lntroduetEosi
Lake Kinneret (Fig. 1) is the major water reservoir of Israel. The preservation of its water
quality is of national importance. The source of saiinity of Lake Kinneret has been a topic of
investigation for decades. As yet, no consensus of opinion has been reached regarding either
the sources of salt nor the processes of salinization. These are basic elements that need to be
detennined before practical methods can be applied to decrease the sait inputs. All investiga-
tors agree that within the catchment area there must be internal sources of salinity. The upper
Jordan River, which contributes 2/3 of the recharge to the lake, brings in only 1l-20 mg l-i Cl
whereas the chloride content of lake water is in the 220-390 mg l-t Cl range (Snron & Mgno
Au"fh.ors' addresses: Akiva Flexer, Annat Yellin-Dror, Joel Kronfeld, Eliyahu Rosenthal, Zvi Ben-
Avraham, Philippe Pascal Artsztein and Lea Davidson, Faculty of Exact Sciences, Department of Geo-
physics and Planetary Sciences, Tel-Aviv University, Tel Aviv 69978,Israel.
007r -1 128/00/0055-069 $ 4.25
A. Flexer et al.
'\d!1
iirr;::rJi.i
:':itt!.:1jr*
n4i::'i .i
;;li;r:i$
!n$8;;Q.
:*:.ii*:la$
r. ;,.:. L.:
-* . .'. -l
: 1:.i
.:t!.::::lillir
:!i:*$
,:i:::tii--..ia.r:
aa!1!rrli:n
:' r":,: I
..".",i-":r
i;ir:Li$i
i:,;lr.iir;i,ii
,,r:*i;,-ir-
j:;iii,ii:ilt
iil:'{,$i
:!$ili.!.$
Fi'*uecr'.€.8i{ *arn'es
Iniene,J Sait ilerno*-q
iS-*i=;itrc- * i
r ' ..1^
lLlU IJt-r L*v
Fiig" 3.. Location map showing Lake Kinneret and the salt bodies along the R'ift Valley'
1987, GopgEN 1991). Additional recharge comes from rainfall on ihe surrounding hitrls. Along
the shoreline and subrner_eed are many -saiine springs which are considered to be major con-
tributors of sait to the lake (snaoN & MERo !g87, slltrs et al. 1989). In 1964, a salt water
carrier was built which diverts the saline water, from the Tiberias, Fuliya, and rabgha springs
(Fig. 2), to the iower Jordan River. Recently, Srn-I-Bn (1994) demonstrated that there is a net
chloride flux through lake bottom sediments to the watel body of the lake' she proposed that a
hypersalinebrineunderliestheSedimentsandpercolatesthroughthem,
The presenr study was carried out to invesiigate the feasibility that a solid salt body (or
bodies) that was discovered in the area can gen-*erate the brines which are the main salinitv*
inputs to the lake. previous srudies discountld the possibility of a solid body of salt as the
contributor of salinity because sait was regarded aS synonymous with halite' Moreover' neither
the Na/Cl nor the CVBr ratlos, found in iater emerging from the saline springs' conform to
+a j,i
i'
J.
i
-I
A Neogene sait bodv V7
32050'
2E 0 anl
,tr8
?50
?E ran'
32'50'
245
240
Fig" 2" i-ocation map of the Zem*'l borehoie and the saline sprin,ss alon-e the slioreline of l-ake Kinneret.
tirat expected from the dissoiution of halite. Accordingly, MeRcADo & Meno (1984), pointed
oui that the cieficiency of Na. SOu and the enrichment of Ca, N{g and Br reiative to a sea water
precursor, cannot be explained by dissolution of a salt body composed of haiite. Nlencus &
SI-aceR (1985), without carrying out any systemati.c minerai identification, reported that the
drilied section in the Zemah-l borehoie containeci soiely halite and anhycirite.
The present study investigated the mineraiogy of pari of the evaporite section encountereC
in the Zeman-l borehole. Our preliminary' findings presented here reveal the occurrence of
minerals of the more soluble salts of potassium and magnesium in addition to halite. This
evidence suggests that the presence of a solid body (or numerous bodies) of evaporites in the
catchment area may be the primary source of a hypersaline brine that contributes soiutes to
groundwater emerging in the saiine springs and percolating through the bottom sediments.
GeoicgteaE as^dd gc@pF?yeEeaE baekEround
i-ake Kinneret (Sea of Galiiee) is one of two lakes (the other being the Dead Sea ro the south)
that fill morphotectonic depressions alon-e the Dead Sea-Jordan R.ift Valley (Figs. 1, 3). Lake
72 A. Flexer et al'
G)
$
$
T
3
.J
t- ! & *\.*}' + 4 |
sJ4Jre41+
! -..R!
Kinries"et
gL4+J
!&+z:
4;4J49
4LJ&J
+iLlg
+3
4+4+4
lF-r + + 4 !
-
+ -l lst+Til;d votcanics
+ | l?ti .',:'iI]
I
: +t
-
(-
$
o
a
NVolcanics
Carbonates
Fault
0 5 10km
| ----------.t-----
: _j
.:.. :
.':: L
iI
,:l
_,11
,,.::. j
::-.
i.t i
i'!
i3
'. fl
'.1
"i;ii '
.jii
t:t
j'] l
::il
:il
'.;':
F,ig. 3. The structural and surface geology of the Lake Kinneret area (Ivlodified after BEN Avn'q'HAM et al'
1996). A. F. -Alm"g;;i;;,1' r"-- lo'-dun fault' S'A' - Sheikh Aii faull
Kinneret is located at the northern portion of the Kinneret-Bet shean basin (BEN A'RAHAI* et
a'. 1996). The lake i, zo tm 1ong, 12 km at its widest, ancl has a maximum depth of 46 m' The
A Neogene salt body Ta
lake surface is situated at approximately -210 m MSL. This low elevation makes it a re_eional
drainage base of rainfail recharge failing in the surrounding hills and transported through the
stepwise downfaulted blocks (Fig. a) to beneath the lake floor.
The Dead Sea- Jordan Vailey Rift is a piate boundary of the transform type which connects
the Red Sea, where sea floor spreading occurs, with the Zagtos zone of continental collision.
This rift is one of the most prominent tectonic features in the Middle East. The movement
along the transform has caused a ieft-lateral relative displacement of 105 km since the time of
its formation (GanruxKEL et al. i98 l,). Several fault systems occur in this area, the main ones
being the N-S transform system (Fig" 3) forming a longitudinal graben containing the buried
salt body of Zemah. The main eastern border fault of the lake has a general N-S strike (Fig. 3).
The western side of Lake Kinneret and its southern extension to the Bet Shean Valley is distin-
guished by a series of tilted blocks separated by transversal faults (SalrzivteN 1964). Seismic
studies show that the lake area is tectonically active. The average heat flow measured in the
Lake Kinneret is quite high (75 mW m-2, BEN.\vnernu et ai" 1986).
Sarrznaex (1954) and MicHBLSoN et al. (1987) investigated the compiex geology of the
areas surrounding the lake. Previous studies of the sub-bottom structure and stratigraphy of
Lake Kinneret included seismic refraction and reflection measurements (Beu AvnaHeM et a1.,
1981, 1986), magnetic measurements (FolrutAN & Yuvel- 1916, BEN AvneHAM et al. 1980,
GNzeuRc & BsN AvReHnvr 1986, EppsLBAuM & BsN AvRasalt 7991), heat flow measure-
ments (tsEN AvneHAM et al. 1978) and gravity measurements (BEI.I AvnaHeiv et al. 1996).
These studies clearly indicate that, like the surface geology, the sub-bottom structure of the
lake is also quite complex and is being affected by active faulting. The sedimentation rate in
Lake Kinneret is quite high; various estimates range from2toT mrn/year (Sriu-eR 1974).
This causes smoothenin,e of the floor and, as a result, the morphology of the floor does not
reflect the subbottom structure. (Bex AvRRnavt et a1. 1990).
Thc Zemafx=tr saflt body
The wiiCca tZemah-1 borehoie was drilled immediaiely to the south of Lake Kinaeret (Fig. 2),
This is anan'ow se-gmentof theJorrlan- DeadSeaRJftValleyborieredby nonnalfauits andfclds.
Two extensive faults that transect the sedimentary cclumn of the lake from the north to the south
are situated on either side cf the well (Fi-e. 4). A 2.8 km thick unit of evapoites, magniatic,
carbonates andmaris was encountered betweenl344-4X42maeptb. Evaporites constitute 3570,
or fii1iy 980 m of the unit (Mencus & SLAGpn 1985). Much further to the south within the R.ift
Valiey occur ihe hypersaline brines of the Dead Sea and the adjacent Mount S'dom salt body.
Henass (pers. comrn., 1998) has noted 27 layers of post-halite evaporite mineralizatlonin the
S'dom salt plug. Oil exploration on the Lisan Peninsula in the Kingdom of Jordan encountered,
beneath the Upper Pieistocene marls, halite as well as beds of sylvite and carnalite. The salt body
found beneath the Lisan Peninsula is believed to be correlative to the Mount S'dom deposit
(Bevonn lg74).Though the chronological controls are weak, the upper portion of these salt
bodies have been tentatively placed as being from Late Miocene to Pliocene (BeNnps.l9"7 4,ZeK
1974). This would make them approximately coeval with the Zemah-l evaporites (Miocene-
Pliocene age) (Sner-iv 1991). Within Lake Kinneret proper, seismic profiling has not as yet
identified salt diapirs. However, gravity data from the northern and western portions of the lake,
indicate several negative anomalies that could be interpreted as salt bodies (L. Eernenuu,
personal comm., 1998). If these are indeed diapirs, then horizontal beds of salt may be also
I
V4 A. Flexer et al.
Kiss:er€t Ei*-{3ev R=n'wt-i-hgstst
lti
ttt
?+*
Its'*kzen
-ffi& I
385,/2S +
Iel-fr(€ta{
I
I
I
B-€-
?.ffiiP+z
B NryEl€ Csver Brsati
Distence {km}
Fig. 4. NW- SE geological cross -section tirough Lake Kinneret and the Zemah-1 borehole.
present in the sediment succession of the iake. Important concentraiions of gypsum deposited
along the mar-qins of the Miocene lake were found atMenahamia andWadi Issachar (ScuurlieN
1959, Silailv 1991). Though Mencus & Slacnn (i985) described the evaporite in wiidcat
Ze1;1ah-I as being soieiy halite anrl anhydrite, Raae (i998) noted the possibiiity that in weil
post-haiite ininerals were also deposited Zemah-!. Tlierefore mineral icent'rficaiicn of a se-
quence of approximateiy 400 m section in the evapoiite section was cariied out to check, ii
indeec, ihe evaporite bcciy is iimited mineraiogicaiiy to halite and anhydrite.
ftilethods and resulHts
The cuttings frorn the wiidcat Zemah-l borehole have not been systeniaticaily anaiyzedprevi-
ously for their chemicai and mineralogicai compositions. Therefore neutron, bulk ciensity and
acoustic logs obtained from the Zemah-1 drilling were cross-plotted to identify the iithology
and mineralogy (Scrn-EIN & Spwer i986, Yei.i-IN-DRoR 1984).
A common practice in log interpretation is to cross-plot various iog readings in order to
deterrnine formation lithology and compute porosity accurateiy. Cross plots of sonic versus
density logs are wicieiy used in the interpretation of shaiy sands. For carbonates, the density
versus neutron cross-plot is commonly empioyed. These piots and the caiculations based on
them are extremeiy useful, but when the lithoiogy is a complex mixture of minerals, interpre-
tation of data often becomes ambiguous.
The "litho-porosity" cross-plot was introduced for interpretation in formations of compiex
iithoiogy (Bunre et al. 1963). It presents simultaneously data from a1i three standard porosity
A Neogene salt body
eYE7,!i:i3=)L*=
=:lg+iEi:=E;i\?=
:lr';ag€EEU;rli
;d,'€f : FE:*;E:: =:
EE=Ee:;*=s$E?E:
:€g;*IEiES:€€EE
r&;odUEgE-?.==i==2
a
x
o
C
c
o
!
Z
-J
Z
IJ
fl E fr q E q I 6 R 3 sd
-rFoEec:a hi
crsiE4tq€o
-q-'nqccq
'j;'j;.irioir.i.; q
6
z
X
o
.=
c
o
I
J
0)
z
Z
U
lN
li
1*
IL:
l=
l.
i"
t
la
I
I
lo
f@
I
l*
lF-
'5
o'6 "d"
o!tr
orr'r-u6 Alrsuap ritng b
q1
r
c
6
N
6
N
r
a
o
q:
c
o
n
o
o
o
F
.=
,6
C
c
L
,9
:
UJ ;\
E-QNA€
o--Fqo
ll/ras 7t aujt] ltsuerl lluos lF
crlu-rO Allsuap 4.te b
a
A. Flexer et al.
tools, the sidewall neutron porosity 1og, the formation density compensateci iog and the
borehole compensated sonic lo-e. Frorn the reading of these 1ogs, two porosity inciependeni
parameters, "M" and "N", are derived - M from the sonic and density logs, and I"[ from the
neuffon and density logs. in the piot of M versus N, a unique point regardless of porosity
represents each pure rock mineral. For a formation of complex lithology, the position of 1og
data-points on the M-N plot reiative to the pure mineral points is of great assisrance in identi-
flring various minerals in the formation.
The sonic, neutron and density 1og data, from the depth interval -1345 m (top of sait body)
io -1731 m (base of upper salt body layer), from the Zemah-l borehole, was digitized. Cross-
plots of sonic versus density, density versus neutron, sonic versus neutron and M versus N
were produced (Fig. 5). The salt evaporite mineraiogy was thus detennined by the use of the
cross-plots. The three companion plots were used for verifying the interpretation of the litho-
porosity plot.
Xn the 2100 m of section studied, two different lithological point-groups were clearly recog-
nized on the cross plots (Fi-e. 5): (i) a magmatic group, and (2) a halite and post-halite salr
group. Within this group there appear to be various evaporite minerals made up of the sulfate
and chioride salts containing K and Mg, not all of which have yet been identified exactly. No
anhydrite was detected in this sequence.
Figs. 5 a,b,c, show that the iithology is well described by the three cross-piots. However the
final rnineralogic identification is determined by the iitho-porosity plot (Fig. 5d) which shows
that this 400 m section contains appreciable amounts of halite anC post-haiite evaporite miner-
als. A trend of points to the right and upwards on the M versus N cross ptrot is indicative of the
salt zone. The continuation of this trend upward indicates the existence of a variety of salt
minerals that may well include carnalite or even bischofite. It should be recalled that the se-
quence of evaporite minerais deposited from seawater found in the classic Zechsiein section
from Gerrnany (citeC in Kaeus<oPF i967) is roughiy as follows: carbonares, suifates (gypsuin
anhydrite), halite and afterwards kieserite, pol,vhalite, cal-nalite, syivite and bischofite. A lovr
Fia/Cl ratic and an enrichment in bromine distinguishes the post-halite. depositionai sequence .
The present research should stili be ccnsidered preiiminary. nevertheiess, it shouli be ein-
phasized that ourin-e terminal evaporation, the pcrtion of post-haiite minelals can becorne a
si-enificant fraction of the evaporite succession.
Hsthento proposed s^nodcls fon hnlnc fonrnatlon
The results of the mineralogical analysis of the Zeman-l sait beds are very pertinent to undei-
standing the chernistry and origin of the thermal springs and have bearing on the salinization
process of the iake as a whole. The water chemistry of the thermal springs has been extensiveiy
studied in the past and many theories have been put forth as to the origin of the brine. Most
models that have been proposed to explain the salinization of the lake water assumed mixing
of a primary brine with fresh water. GoloscsulDT et aL. (1967) found that the Rift brines are
of the Ca-chloride type and are characterized by Na-deficiency. They discerned two hydroche-
mical subgroups: groundwater with Mg/Ca > 1 found along the eastern and southern shores cf
the lake and groundwater with Mg/Ca < 1 characterizing sources along its western and north-
western shores. Mezon & Mgno (1969 a, b) suggested that the saline end member was essen-
tia11y seawater that intruded into the Rift Valley and evaporated there. According to these au-
thors, the hydrochemical characteristics of groundwater along the entire Rift Valley from the
A Neogene salt body ZV
Kinneret to the Dead Sea, are of sufficient constancy to warrant the existence of a single sea-
water-derived saline en<i mernber. SteRwsrY (197 4) also proposed thai the source of the 111ft
brines was from liquicis derived from Miocene sea water intrusions, that have further evapo-
rated beyond the halite stage. This was recently,supported by boron isotopic data (VexcosH et
al. 1994). After their partial evaporation, the residual Mg-rich brines interacted with the car-
bonates of the Judea Group exposed along the margins of the Rift, thus acquiring a Ca-chlonde
composition"
Gvnrzveu and co-workers (1997) presented a hydrological model of the Kinneret basin
that takes into consideration the thermal regime and the fauits surroundin-e the basin. In its essen-
tial form, the model shows that freshwater recharged by rainfall on the mountain ranges sur-
rounding the lake flows through aquifers that drain to the lake. The flow of the fresh water com-
ponent is controlled by the hydraulic head, which is determined by the topographic differences
(approx. 650 m) between the mountain recharge area and the lake. The initially cool recharge
water flowing towards the lake through deep-seated aquiferous strata is heated. In the vicinity of
the lake, groundwater driven both by its hydraulic head as well as by thermai convection rises
along fauits. mixes with proposed brines and emerges as brackish or saline springs.
Based on chemical and isotopic observations, BERGELSoN et aL. (1999) proposed that the
salt source is an ancient, intensively evaporated brine (21 ta 33 foid sea water) which perco-
lated throu,eh the valley forrnations from a lake thai formed in the Rift Valley foilowing
seawater intrusion during the Late Miocene.
The new suggcstcd rnodcl and ats negEenaE rmpEaeateons
Any hydrochemical models intended to explain the formation and distribution of brackish and
saline waters arounC and in Lake Kinneret have to consider tne following points:
a. The sftarp differentiation between the Mg-chloride saline waters along the eastern and
southem shores and the Ca-chloride waters along the wesiem anci northwestern marEins of
ihe lake.
b. Both waters are Na-deficieni, with NarCl <A.7, and are consiiierabiy enriched in Bi (Ci,lBr
weight ratios as low as 70).
c. High-resolution sei,smic profiles indicate ihat the lake bottoin and ileai'by areas aro dorni-
nated by major fault- and graben-structuies that extend across the la,ke from Degania, to-
wards and near to the location of wiidcat Zemah-L.
d. The mineralogicai data demonstrates that within theZemah-1 salt bodv there occur layers
containing K-Mg-salts, which are of the post-halite evaporite group.
In view of these constraints, we propose a new modei for the formation of a brine causing,
in the first place, salinization of groundwater along the eastern, southern and southwestern
shores of Lake Kinneret. This model involves dissolution of sulfates, of halite and of K-Mg
rich and Na poor, post halite evaporites from the studied section of Zemah-1. The creation of a
Ca-chloride brine with Mg/C a> l, the result of the previously suggested dissolution process,
was tested and confirmed by experimental modeling using NETPATH code (Pr-utvrueR et al.
1994).This was also confirmed by applying the SNORM code (BoorNE & JoNEs 1986, JoNes
& Boonrie 1937) which showed that saline groundwater along the eastern, southern and south-
western shores of the iake evolved as the result of dissolution of sulfates, halite, bishofite,
carnalite and polyhalite.
5
.:g
78 A. Flexer ei al.
Along the western shores of the lake such groundwaters were encountered as far northward
as 1 km south of the Roman spring of Tiberias. It is further suggested that dissolution of the
salts is by fresh groundwater flowing into the Rift and reaching the buried salt body of Zemah
(and other such bodies, which are known tb exislin the Rift). The model of GvrnrzueN et al.
(L997) allows for the descent of the recharge water to depth, great enough to encounter the salt
bodies such as encountered in the Zemah-I borehole. Leaching of the sait and the subsequent
dilution of the newly formed brine with fresh water can occur during ascent. This convection
model can be used to explain the different salinities and temperatures observed in the springs
emerging around the lake. Rising convection cells under the lake as a whoie would also be in
agreement with the findings of increasing chlorinify in the sediment pore water with increas-
ing depth of the sediment (Sm-i-rn 1994).
Leaching by the recharge water of soluble, late precipitated Mg-salts would obviously cre-
ate a Mg-rich brine such as has been encountered aiong the eastern shores of Lake Kinneret.
The chemical composition is uniike that of the known Rift brine (GolnscHMIDT et al. 1967)
which is characterized by Mg/Ca < 0.6 and low CllBr ratios. However, if the lithoiogy of the
rock-sequence characterizing the Rift fiii surrounding the Zemah salt piug is considered, and if
plausible waterlrock reactions are envisaged, then the hydrochemical link between the Mg-
rich brines (generated by dissolution of Zemah salts) and the Mg/Ca < 0.6 Rift brines, may be
established. The lithological section surrounding the plug inciudes hundreds of meters of clay-
rich clastics and thick sequences of gabbro. The clays could easily act as exchange reactors
removing Na from the brine and enriching it in additional Mg (originating from the volcanic
rock-masses)" The Ca-rich brines encountered along the western littoral of the iake could be
the result of massive Mg-removal by dolomitization (see aiso BgncelsoN et al. 1999) of the
surrounding carbonate sr.rata. All these assumptions were tested by experimental modeling by
appiyin,e the NETFATH code (Pt-ulturn et a1. 1994). Numerous runs confirmed that Ca-chio-
ride brines emerging along the western littoral of the iake could eventually cievelop from the
eastern, Mg-rich brines, as the resuit of the previously suggested hydrochemicai processes.
Leachin-e of haiite would yield hi-eh CllBr ratios, whiie very 1ow CVBr ratio vaiues are
chaiacteristic of the brines in Lake Kinneret. Hence, the high bromide concentrations found
ubiquitously in the Kinneret basin, have to be expiained in order tc validate the whole rnodel.
Ocean water has a C1/Br ratio of approxrmately 286. The Jordan River water inputs have iower
raiios, approximateiy 252. The Cl/Br ratio for the Lake Kinneret water deciined from i20-i40
before the Salt Water Carrier diverted the salty springs, to a present vaiue of approximateiy
100-110. The most saiine springs alon_e the western littoral of the lake have Cl,{Br ratios of
about 70-80. Lower ratio values were observed in water seeping into bottom sed"iments. Otirer
springs (Fuliya, tsarbootim and Tabgha) exhibit ratios that fall in the ran-ee from 100-i60 (a11
Br data frorn SIILLER & NISSENBALIM 1996). Therefore, mixing of seawater with fresh water
cannot yield the CVBI that is observed.
High concentrations of Br in the Rift (generating low Cl/Br ratio vaiues) couid be attributed
to severai sources. According to MnzoR & Mnno (1969 a, b) and SrRRiNsrv (1974), Br was
enriched during the progressive stages of salt precipitation from a seawater bocly. This sea
penetrated during the Miocene into the Rift and is purported to have become the precursor of
the Ca-chioride Rift and Dead Sea brines (SreixHonN 1983). These brines which are the re-
sidual fluids after the massive precipitation of halite, will thus be enriched in tsr (tsneITICH &
F{nRuaxN 1963, R.ees 1998), as the distribution coeffrcient between halite and soiution is iess
than 1 (Ztx 1974). According to SrurR & NISSENBAUM (1996). the pore water from sedi-
A Necgene sali body Zg
ment cores taken from boreholes drilled into the bottom of the 1ake, are characterized by low
CllBr ratics. These ratios decrease down the sediment cores. The lowest ratios encountered are
approximately 55, which are significantly lower than values noted in the Tibeias Springs
(70-80)"
There are, however, other processes that can be invoked to explain the high Br-content of
the brines. It is also possibie that Br enrichment can come from the degradation of organic
matter (Ntssexreul,t & Mencenirz I99I) as weil as leaching of Br from basic igneous and
volcanic rocks and metamorphics (Leurnvo & LeltpEN 1987, NuRwrr et ai. 19SS). Thus, the
gabbro and the basalt, which are widely distributed in the subsurface as well as throughout the
whoie area aiong the margins of the rift, may also supply considerable amounts of Br (Raen
1998). F{ence, the dissolution of salt minerais, beyond the stage of initiai halite deposition, can
produce the highly concentrated Mg-Ci brines found along'the western margin of the lake as
well as the ubiquitously iow Cl/Br ratios. The high Br concentration may be additionaliy en-
hanced by gaining Br from the volcanic rocks and/or by degradation of organic matter. Inde-
pendent support fcr the proposed hydrological model is presented in a recent geo-electrical
anaiysis (Golouex et al. 1997) carried out to locate saline water in the bottom sediments of
Lake Kinneret. The salinity models, deveioped to explain the resistivity profiles, show that in
the southern part of the lake there are brine halos with the salinity increasing inwards towards
the direction of the Zemah solid salt body.
Dise usslon
It is entirely plausibie that within the area extending between the Dead Sea in the south and the
surroundings of Lake Kinneret in the north, the Late Miocene sea that intruded the Rift Va11ey,
treft behind it mineralogically differentiated evaporite deposits. The presence of VIg and Br-
rich brines are of potential economic interest, both for the extraction of chemicals and for
balneotheraphy. From a hydrologicai perspective, these brines are of considerabie significance
in that they affect the quality of the Rift Val1ey water sources" SranilisKy \1914) already
proposed that the bines found in the subsurface of the Rift, represent a resiciual product of
evaporated Pliocene seawater, which precipitate<i halite duing the course of its evolution. The
Ca-chloride composition of these brines was attained by doiornitization. This part of the model
appears to be geochemicaiiy plausible. However, StaRtNSKY (1914) su,egesteci that these
brines migrated from their source of origin westwards, up to 100 km from the margins of the
Rift. .Aiong their migration paths, these brines were supposedly diiuted chemically b,v fresh
water. F{owever, the very high hydraulic pressures (hundreds of atmospheres) characterizing
the Ca-chloride brines in the deep boreholes around Lake Kinneret (Devora 2A., Jordan 1 and
Rosh Pina 1; RoseNTsai- 19BB), ciearly indicate the deep confi.nement of these brines. This
evidence wouid contradict the model of SreRINsKy (1914) for brine formation. His model
implied that, in the Rift, the residual evaporated seawater, percoiated into adjacent permeable
formations and accumulated there. No explanations were given for the process of confinement
of these fluids. I4oreover, since the Pliocene, no geological processes have occured., which
could have generated such deep confinement (Rosnxrriar 1988, 1989, ILANr et a1. 1988).
At the time of Sranntsrv'S publication (1974), the existence of the Zemah salt plug was
unkncwn. This relativeiy new evidence simplifies the regional salinization model as it points
to 1ocal brine-forming processes making iong distance migration unnecessary (RosrxrHAL
1988). Moreover, it could possibly offer a different view on the issue of confinement. The new
J
:l
n
,{i
4
'dl
u
I
i:!
rl
,3
;j
:li
fi
;.la
:i.t
8CI A. Flexer et al,
modei impries occurrence of Mg-rich residual fluids in the vicinity of the sait piug. Fresh
water recharged by rainfall on the surrounding areas and driven by high hydrauiic heads,
slowly percolates through rhe ciastic fi1l of the Rift reaching the saiine fluids, diluting them
and piston-pushing them into preferentially penneable strata or along the existing fault sys-
tems. The piston action courd be enhanced both by diapir flow and/or by the ongoing block
movements in the Rift, which would squeeze the liquids and push them into permeable strata'
The existence of intensively evaporated marine brine, beyond the onset of halite precipi-
tation, as suggested by BrncELSoN et ai. (1999), is plausible' However' the downward per-
colation of such concentrated residual liquors percolating through hundreds of meters of
undisturbed, impermeable, previously deposited sequences (some of them containing thick
formations of evaporites) is, geoiogically infeasiblt' 9n the other hand' the 637C1 and 63aS
data of BERGELS.N et ar. (1999) are consistent with the extreme evaporative stages of our
model.
Theproposedgeochemicalmodelcanbeverifiedifitcanalsoexplaintheconcomitant
isotopic changes to both 2H and rsO, that occur during each step in the evolving water/brine'
The model presented here would initially have the descending groundwater dissolve the salt
from the diapir,and then rise. The most saline and hottest spring (the Tiberias Roman Spring;
Ger et al. i969) should be the isotopicaliy, closest surface expression of this process. Ideally,
in the next step, the isotopic composition of other saiine springs or saline groundwater should
be estabiished by mixing of the lepresentative Roman Spring water or the primary brine with
locai fresher water (Lake Kinneret watef or loca1 ground water)' Thus' all of the relevant re-
gional waters strouri falr aiong isotopic mixing rines if the solid sait body can be considered as
a primary saiinity source. The isotopic compoiition of the freshwater end members-precipita-
tion,localgroundwatersandLakeKinneretareknown'asarethevaluesofthemoresaline
springs and groundwater (Ger et aI. L969, Br,nCBr-SON 1999), which wouid constitute the
intermediate group or evolved mixtures. A't first glance' defining the isotopic influence of the
solid sait *uy upplu, problematic. Dissoiution of sa1t, again oniy as a first consideration' may
bethoughttochangethesaiinitybutnottheisotopiccomposi.tionofthedissolving
groundwater. This, hJwru"r, would hold true only if the diapir were composed of halite' The
entireprecedingchemicaiargumentwasmadetoestabiishthepresenceofthemostsolubie
sulfate and chloride mineral saits of K and Mg' These salts began to precipitate when the
original sea water had been reduced by evaporation to gnlV t '54Vo af its original voiume (Ma-
soN 1964). What characterizes these .uupotut" minerals is that most of them do contain rem-
nants of the water from which they prr.ipitut.d. This evaporative signature shouid be pre-
served in the water of hydration that.ryrtuigr.t with the common evaporate minerals' such as
epsomite iNngSOnZH,O;, h""uhydrite (MgSOo6HrO)' kieserite (MgSO4'H'O)' bischofite
(MgClr6Hro) andcarnaiite 6UgCL 6HrO)' t1',11G highly saline evaporative environments'
the isotopic signature should U" ,rniqo"i The 6,rsO values should be enriched' though only
moderateiy positive. Values not unlft those of the Dead Sea (6 ']Ou-o*, =+4'5Voo) may be
expected; but, the 62H values, which started out being enriched in the evaporating brine' un-
dergo a reversal in the later stages and can end up becoming quite depleted, especially com-
pared to the 6rso vaiues. The isotopic reversals are caused by a decreased activity of the water
due to the high solute content. This leads to reducing the humidity contrast between the bound-
arylayerandtheatmosphere(e.g.Sornn&GAT1g15),Additionalisotopicfractionationbe-
tween the saline solution and the water of hydration can accentuate the separation between r8O
and 2l{ that is preserved in the water of hyiration' For example, the equiiibrium fracti'onation
A Neogene sait body Bf
factor (u) between brine and the water of hydration of gypsum has been determined (Sonen
I9l5) both for deuterium (cro=0.980) and for ttO (s o_,r= 1.004). Water of ,,anomalous" iso-
topic composition, but very similar to that of the expected values have indeed been encoun-
tered in the RiftValley, at the Mount S'doin diapir. Moreover, these brines are in direct contact
with the sait body, which has been recognized (as reported above) to contain evaporative min-
erals beyond the stage of initiation of halite precipitation. The brine from the deep S'dom-1
well exhibits 6"O,,-o*f+4.4%o and 6tH1,*o*f -28%o, while the Maayan Hareach seepage ex-
hibits 6t8o1.*o*1=+2.I%o and E'H1.*o *t= -29%o (data from GAT et al. 1969, unfortunately the
salinities of the brines were not reported). These values are obviousiy not pure water of hydra-
tion; but probabiy represent difrerent degrees of dilution with meteoric water.
A plot of these samples, along with ail of the relevant water types in the area. on a 62H
versus 6180 diagram (Fig. 6) enables the mixing relationships to become apparent. In this
diagram (modified from Get et al. 1969) the brine from Mount S'dom is extrapolated to repre-
sent the expected isotopic values derived from the leaching of the Zemah-l salt body. This is
oniy an approximation, because although the isotopic values of precipitation in the l{egev also
lie along the Eastern Mediterranean Water Line (62H =8 618O+22%o) the precipitation is less
depleted compared to that of the Hills of Galiiee. By drawing a iine that connects the S'dom-1
water to the fresh eastern Galilean aquifer, the isotopic relationship of the prirnary brine can be
Locol meteoric
woter line
Ic stern
oquifer Rom cn
spring,^@-
s-A
-t?
Lo ke K in nerei
Jordon
River M oayc nHarecch
-.--j- 1
I
n
l
S'dom-i
ern
fer
rt
^r
ui
We
oq -4-20
8l8c (%")
Fig. 6. l8O-Deuterium relationships of the saline and fresh water sources in the Lake Kinneret area. The
isotopic values for Lake Kinneret represent an average year, not of drought nor especially rainy. The
S'dom-i brine is taken to represent an approximation of the isotopic values to be expected from the
dissolution of the Zemah- I salt body by ground water.
A mixing line connecting the S'dom-1 values to the local Meteoric line (Eastern Galilean aquifer) is
denoied by an arrow and the number 1. This line defines the primary brine. An arrow and the number 2
Cencte a second mixing line connectin-e Lake Kinneret to the point of intersection with primary brines.
The saline \i/ater sources fail along this line. Other symbols are: small open circles for sweet water
springs; large open circles for aquifers; triangles for the mineral springs of ihe Fulya area; filled circles
for the Tiberias mineral springs; fllled squares for the minerai springi along eastlrn shore region and
stars for the springs around the Mt. S'dom area.
-o
^\
O
(i.)
40
20
U
-lu
-40
-ou 4
-A
-8
----r
A. Flexer et al.
established. This line is an isotopic mixing line connecting two end members. trt also repre-
sents a mixing of salinity between these same two end rnembers, the rain and the Zemah-1 salt.
Thus, not only will dissolution of these evaporative minerals change the chemicai compcsition
of the water but they will aiso impart to it a highly evaporative signature. In Fig. 5 this line (i)
falls beneath the point of the Tiberias Roman Spring. However, if a second line (2) is drawn
from Lake Kinneret to intersect the primary brine (1), a second mixing line is established, both
isotopically and of salinity. This iine passes through the Tiberias Roman Spring sample. This
means that after the brine has been created by the leaching of the evaporite bcdy by
groundwater, it mixes with the water of Lake Kinneret as it moves upwards. This causes an
isotopic shift and a dilution of the brine. If the second mixing line (2) is drawn, the saline water
sources (from Gnt et a1. 1969) also fall along or close to ihis line. Indeed, ail of the saiinity and
isotopic compositions of the water sources of the Kinneret basin can be explained by the mix-
ing of meteoric water, Lake Kinneret water and the primary brine. Using the present model,
both the chemical distribution of the springs is explained as well as the distribution of the
stable isotopes in the water sources.
e ene Husions
The new evidence presented in this paper implies that salinization processes invoiving both
groundwater and lake water, are caused by two different brines. The saline Vlg-rich
groundwater emerging along the eastern, southern and southwestern shores of the lake were
formed by fresh water percolating into the Rift, leaching the salt piug and rising as the water
becomes heated. Along the western and southwestern shores of the lake thennomineral waters
emerge which could be dilution products of a deep-seated Ca-chioride brine. By ccnsidering
possible water/rock interaction processes, it is not excluded that the "westerit" Ca-chiorioe
brine could have geochemically evolved from the "eastefit" M-e-rich brine.
The new evidence indicates the existence of two brines differing in their chemical cctiipcsi-
tion and controlleii by dlfierent hydrauiic mechanisrns. F{ence, the manageinent of giounowar"er
and lake water salinities needs tc consider differeni methods and rneasures for the speciflc
hydrogeolo-eicai regimes of the twc, possibly -eeochemicaily interconnected, brines.
The data presented here would also suppcrt the hypothesis that difiusion of briaes across
the sediment-water interface tarkes place over the entire lake bottoin and is the major source cf
chloide input today (Srnt-nn 1994, SrrlLER & NisssNe,\uM 1995).
The Zemah satrt deposits may offer the key to understanding the salinizaiion processes af-
fecting the whole Nationai Reservoir. This identification of the salt body as being the possibie
primary brine source suggests a method for preserving the water quality of the 1ake. If the
leaching of this salt by inflowing fresh recharge water can be diminished, the resultant brine
formation will be reduced. Therefore, it is suggested to control the amount of deep draina_ee of
fresh recharge water from the surrounding areas, to prevent its reaching and leaching of the
salt body and the subsequent upward movement of the newly formed brine.
ffiefcrecrces
BEN AvRAHAvt, 2., HaNEL, R. & VnLncnR, F{. (1978): Heat flow through the Dead Sea rift. - Marine
Geol.28: 253-269.
I
f
A Neogene salt body Bg
BeN Avneruu, 2., SHoHAM,.Y., KLED.I, E., MICIfiLSON, H. & SERRUYA, C. (1980): Magnetic suwey of
Lake Kinneret - Central Jordan Valley, Israel. - Marine Geophys. Res. 4: 257-276.
BEN AvRAH ANI,Z., GINzsunc, A. & Yuvat, Z. (198I): Seismic reflection and refraction investigation of
Lake Kinneret - Central Jordan Valley, Isiael. -Tectonophysics 80: 165-181.
BsN AvnaruM, 2., SHALIV, G. & Nun, A. (1986): Acoustic reflectivity and shallow sedimentary struc-
ture in the Sea of Galilee - Jordan Valley, Marine Geol. 70: 175-189.
Bpn Avnarnv, 2., TEN-BRINK, tL, BELL, R. & RszwtKov, M. (1996): Gravity fie1d over the Sea of
Galilee: evidence for a composite basin along a transform fault. -J. Geophys. Res. 10tr: 533-5M-
BEN AvRAHAM,Z., ANnr, G., GouN, A. & Bncnq,Z.B. (1990):The bathymetry of Lake Kinneret and
its structural significance. - Israel J. Earth Sciences 39: 71-84.
BnNorR, F. (1974): The Geology of Jordan. - Contributions to the Regional Geology of the Earth, Vol-
ume 7, Gebriider Borntraeger, Berlin.
BERGELSoN, G., NATrv, R. & BEIN, A. (1999): Salinization and dilution history of ground water dj.s-
charging into the Sea of Galiiee, the Dead SeaTransform, Israei. -Applied Geochemistry 14: 91-118.
BoorNe, M.W. Jr. & Joms, B.F. (1986):A quantitative chemical-mineralogical characterization of natu-
ral waters. - U.S. Geological Suwey, Water Resources Investigations, Rep. 86-4086.
BRArrcH, O. & HennMAI{t{, A.G. (1963): Zur Geochemie des Broms in salinaren Sedimenten, Teil 1:
Experimentelle Bestimmung der Br-Verteilung in verschiedenen nati.irlichen Salzsystemen. -
Geochim. et Cosmochim. Acta 27:36L-39I.
BSRKE, J.A., CeMpeELL, R.L. & Scuumr, A.W. (1963): The Litho-Porosity cross plot. -Tenth Annual
Symposium of the Society of Professional Analysts: 271-301.
EpppleauM, L. & BBtt AvnetrANt, Z. (1997): Detail interpretation of magnetic anomalies in Lake
Kinneret. -Israel Geoiogical Society Annual Meeting (abstracts), Kfar Giladi, Israel, p. 17.
FoLrNreN,Y. & Yuval, Z. (1976):Aeromagnetic map of Israel, 1:250000. -Israel lnstitute for Petroleum
Research and Geophysics, Holon.
GAT, J.R., MAZoR, E. & Tzun,Y. (1969): The stable isotope composition of mineral waters in the Jordan
Rift Valley, Israel. - J. of Hydrology 7: 334-352.
G,qgnNrcr-,Z.,ZIK,I. & FnsuNp, R. (1981): Active faulting in the Dead SeaRift. -In: FRpuND, R. &
GanrLrr'rKEI-, Z. (eds): The Jordan-Dead Sea Rift. Tectonophysics 80: 1-26.
GNzeuRc, A. & BeN AvRAHAM, Z. (1985): Sffucture of the Sea of Gaiilee graben, Israel, from magnetic
measurements. - Tectonophysics 126: 152-164.
G9LDMAN, M., YzERSKT, VI., HuRwnz, S. & GvRTZMAN, H. (1997): Locating the salt water in the
bottom sediments of Lake Kinneret by geo-electrical methods. - Israel Water Commission Rep. 907/
154196 (in Hebrew).
Golosmr,mr, M.J., ARAD, A. & Nggv, D. (1967): The mechanism of the saline springs in the Lake
Tiberias depression. - Geol. Survey of Israel Bulletin 45, 19 pp.
GcplEN, M. (1991): The salinity of Lake Kinneret. -In: GopHsN, M. & ORrnNssRc, Z. (eds): Salinity of
Lake Kinneret: reality, objectives and connections to soil and soil managenent. - Lake Kinneret
Authority, Zemach, Jordan Valley lsI33z,Israel, 18-26 (in Hebrew).
Gvnrzuerq, H., GARVEN, G. & GvnrnnaN, G. (1997):Thermal anomalies associated with forced and
free ground-water convection in the Dead Sea Rift Valley. - Geol. Soc. of America Buil. 109: 1167-
tr16.
irei'u. S., RosgNrriei-, E., KRoNFELD, J. & FLBxER, A. (1988): Epigenetic doiomitization and iron
mineralization along fauits and their possible relation to the paleohydrology of Israel. - Applied
Geochemistry 3: 487 -498.
J+hES, B.F. & BoDNlE, M.W. (1987): Nomative sait characterization of natural water. - In: FnIrz P. &
Fts*tPE, S.K. (eds): Saline water and gases in crystalline rocks. Geological Association of Canada"
Special Paper 33: 5-18.
Kr.cusropr, - (1967): Introduction to Geochemistry" - McGraw-!{ill Book Company, New York,
721 pp.
_I
84 A. Flexer et al.
Lauenuo, P.W. & LAMpEN, P.H. (1987): Brackish and saline ground waters in Finland. - In: FRrrz, P. &
FRApE, S.K. (eds): Saline water and gases in crystalline rocks. Geological Association of Canada
Special Paper, 33: 103-109.
MARCUS, E. & Sracnn, J. (i985): The sedimentary-magmatic sequence of the Zemah-l weil (Jordan-
Dead Sea Rift,Israel) and its emplacement in iime and space. - Israel J. of Earth Sciences 34: 1-10.
MASON, B. (1964): Principles of Geochemistry, second ed. - John Wiley & Sons, New York.
MAZoR, E. & MEno, F. (1969a): Geochemical tracing of mineral and fresh water sources in the Lake
Tiberias basin, Israel. - J. Hydrol. 7:276-317.
- - (1969b): The origin of the Tiberias-Noit water association in the Lake Tiberias Basin, Israei. - J.
Hydrol. 7:318-333.
Msncaoo, A. & Meno, F. (1984): The salty inflows to the Kinneret. - Tahal, Water Planning for Israel
(Ltd.), Report 01/84148,l44pp. (in Hebrew).
MtcneLsoN, A., FLEXER, A. & ERBz , Z. (1987): Comparison of the eastern and western sides of the Sea
of Galilee and its implication on the tectonic nature of the Jordan Valley. - Tectonophysics 141: i 51-
r68.
NEEV, D" & ElaEny, K.O. (1967): The Dead Sea: depositional processes and environment of evaporites.
- Geological Survey of Israel, Bull. 4L, I47 pp.
NrssBNsaulvr, A. & MaRceRtrz, M. (1991): Bromine-rich groundwater in the Hula Valley, Israel. -
Naturwissenschaften 7 8: 217 -2L8.
Nurur, P.A., KurcoNEN, I.T. & Laurnvo, P.W. (1988): Geochemistry and origin of saline
groundwaters in the Fennoscandian Shield. -Applied Geochemistry 3: 185-203"
PlulrtrrpR, N.L., PnrsrEMoN, E"C. & PARKHURST, D.L. (1994):An interactive code (NETPAIH) for
modeling Net geochemical reactions along a flow PATH, version 2-0. - U.S. Geological Survey,
Water Resources Investigations Report, 94-4169, Reston, Virginia.
RAAB, M. (1998):The origin of the evaporites in the Jordan-Dead SeaValley in view of the evolution of
brines and evaporites during seawater evaporation. - Geological Suwey of Israel Report GSV1/98,
Jerusalem, Israel, 138 pp.
RoseNrHal, E. (1988): Ca-chloride brines at common outlets of the Bet Shean-Harod multiple aquifer
system, Israel. - J. Hydrol. 97: 89-106.
(1,997): Thermomineral waters of Ca-chloride composition: review of di_agnostics and of brine evolu-
tion. - Environmental Geol. 32:245-250.
SALTZMAN, U. (1964): The geology of the Tabgha-Huqoq-Migdai area. - Report, Tahal, Water Planning
for Israel Ltd., Tel-Aviv,55 pp. (in Hebrew, English summary).
Scnuur,raN, N. (1959): The Geology of the Central Jordan Valley. - Ph.D. thesis, The llebrew University,
Jerusalem, 103 pp. (in Hebrew, Engiish abstract.)-
Scm-Ew, N. & Sptvar, D. (1986):A log-interpretated mineralogical composition for solution mining of
underground caverns in Mount S'dom. - Israel J. of Earth Sciences 35: 136-i48.
Scuogr-lrR, H. (1956): Geochemie des eaux souterraines. Application aux eaux de gisements de petrole.
- Soc. Ed. "Technip", Paris, 213 pp.
Srnuv, G. (1991): Stages in the tectonic and voicanic history of the Neogene basin in the lower Galilee
and the valleys. - Israei Geoi. Survey Current Research, 1-94.
SrMoN, A. & Meno, F. (1987): The influence of lake level on the salinity concentrations in Lake Kinneret
waters. -In: GAL, Y. & SHtLo, E. (eds): The levels of Lake Kinneret in relation to water problems, 41-
53 (in Hebrew)"
SN.{[H, S.V., SpRnuyA, S., GemvaN, Y. & BswreN, T. (1989): Internal sources and sinks of water, P, N,
Ca, and Cl in lake Kinneret, Israel. - Limnol. and Oceanogr.34 1202'1213.
Soren, Z" (.I975): Isotopic Composition of Hydration Water of Gypsum. - Ph.D. thesis, The Weizmann
Institute of Science, Rehovot, 108 pp. (in Hebrew, with English abstract).
Sorpn, Z. &.GAT, J.R. (i975): The isotope composition of evaporating brines: Effect of the isotopic
activity ratio in saline solutions. - Earth and Planetary Science Letters 26:179-186.
A Neogene salt body gs
STARINSKY, A. (I974): Relationship between Ca-chloride brines and sedimentary rocks in Israel. - ph.D.
thesis, The Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel, 176 pp. (in Hebrew English abstract).
SrenruonN,I. (1983): In-situ salt precipitation at the Dead Sea. - Limnol. and Oceanogr.2S:580-593.
StrLtER, M. G97$: Rates of transport and sedimentation in Lake Kinneret. - Ph.D. thesis, Weizmann
Institute of Science, Rehovot, 240 pp. (in Hebreri, English summary).
- 0994): The chloride content in pore water of Lake Kinneret sediments. - Israel J. of Earth Sciences
43: l'79-185.
STILLER, M. & NisseNBAIr4, A. ( 1996): CllBr ratio in pore water from Lake Kinneret (Sea of Galilee). -
Israel J. ofEarth Sciences 45: i53-160"
VENGOSH, A., StaruNsKY, A., KoLoDIvy, Y. & Cnwes, A.R. (1994): Boron isotope geochemistry of
thermal springs from the northern RiftValley. Israel. - J. Hydrology 162l' 155-169.
YBI-lnq-DRoR, A. (1984): The relationship between the Talme-Yafe and Judea Groups-Interpretation
from geophysical logs. - M.Sc. thesis, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, 116 pp. (in Hebrew, English
abstract).
ZtK,I. (1974): Sedimentology and bromine geochemistry of marine and continental evaporites in the
Dead Sea area. - ln: Coocax, A.H. (ed): Fourth Symposium on Salt. Houston, Texas. Northern Ohio
Geological Society 13: 349-361.
... During the last four decades, the geochemistry and evolution of the DSR brines and of the saline springs in LK surroundings have been studied extensively (Goldschmidt et al., 1967;Mazor and Mero, 1969;Starinsky, 1974;Bergelson et al., 1999;Flexer et al., 2000;Klein-BenDavid et al., 2004 and references therein). According to Starinsky (1974) the evolution of the DSR brines occurred by on surface evaporation of sea water well within the halite deposition domain, leading to molar Na/Cl b 0.86 and Br/Cl N 1.5 × 10 − 3 . ...
... Brine B represents a much more advanced stage of evaporation (occasional outflow cutoff and rapid concentration buildup) and is within the bischofite stability field. Klein-BenDavid et al. (2004) concluded that the Ca-chloridic brines of the DSR represent mixtures in various proportions of brines A and B. Flexer et al. (2000) recently proposed an alternative model for formation of brines in the northern part of the DSR. It relates the formation of brine to dissolution of sulfates, halite and K-Mg rich evaporites, such as detected in the sequence of Zemach1 borehole. ...
... It relates the formation of brine to dissolution of sulfates, halite and K-Mg rich evaporites, such as detected in the sequence of Zemach1 borehole. Flexer et al. (2000) suggest that such a model may explain the chemical composition of DSR brine occurrences, especially those on the eastern and southern shores of LK which do not fit well the existing models of brine evolution in the DSR. ...
... In addition to the Jordan River, a few other nahals drain the central Golan Heights, and saline springs discharge into the lake mainly along the western edge of the lake (Kolodny et al., 1999;Flexer et al., 2000;Fruchter et al., 2017;Lev et al., 2019). Streams that originate in Upper and East Galilee (Fig. 1b), such as Nahal Amud and Nahal Tzalmon, are dry or nearly dry by the time they reach Ginosar valley (Israel Hydrological Survey database, Israel Water Authority, Jerusalem) because their water has been appropriated for irrigation. ...
Article
Full-text available
Detrital sediments of the Sea of Galilee are predominantly pedogenic products of settled dust and local bedrocks transported from Upper Galilee and the Golan Heights. Using the mineralogy, chemistry, and Nd and Sr isotope ratios of the core LK12-22 collected offshore of the Ginosar valley and of contemporaneous soils from the Nahal Tzalmon and Nahal Amud catchments, we reconstructed Late Holocene regional hydroclimate. The core samples span ɛ Nd isotope values of −6 to −2 and ⁸⁷ Sr/ ⁸⁶ Sr ratios of 0.7075 to 0.7077 between the isotope fields of the Terra rossa soils and basaltic soils. Sediments from the drier Iron Age and Arabic and Ottoman periods are closer in Nd-Sr isotope ratios of the basaltic soils, while those of the wetter Middle to Late Bronze and Roman–Byzantine periods are closer to the Terra rossa soils, reflecting enhanced mobilization of sediments from the Tzalmon catchment where Terra rossa–type soils accumulated. This result corroborates other regional data that indicate semiarid to temperate conditions in the south Levant during most of the Late Holocene. Wetter conditions over the Galilee Mountains and the Ginosar valley catchment during the Roman period could have promoted the flourishing farming-fishing society that heralded the rise of Christianity.
... The study of Ca-chloride brines suggested that they could be of several origins, such as Archaic brines (Starinsky 1974;Rosenthal 1988;Vengosh and Rosenthal 1994;Guttman 1997Guttman , 2000) or ablation of evaporites ( Flexer et al., 2000;Möller et al., 2007). ...
Thesis
Full-text available
This research investigates the water natural resource and its future development along the Central Jordan Valley region. The hydrogeological modeling of the Central Jordan Valley is correlated to the Dead Sea Rift Valley geological history background. The geological reconstruction of major events in the basin history enables identifying the tectonic and sedimentary processes, which defined the regional hydrogeological system. Thus, events such as compression and decompression, resulting folding and faulting during the uplift of the eastern and western borders of the Dead Sea basin, seawater invasions and fast subsidence of the basin floor, and the sedimentary events that followed, can be pinpointed correctly in time and space. The characterization of the hydrogeological system was performed using a combination of multidisciplinary methods of geosciences including: classic field geology, geochemical and geophysical field methods and climatological analysis of precipitation systems. The results were processed through a combination of models, yielding an integration of different types of datasets. The Dead Sea Rift is a geologically unique region, where powerful tectonic processes had created a deep (about 400 m.b.s.l.) and narrow valley. High mountainous ridges border the valley's eastern and western margins (up to about 1000 m.a.s.l. in the east). An active transform fault crosses its center, shifting the eastern geological plate about 105 km northwards relative to the western plate. Naturally, this complexity is induced on the hydrogeological and hydrochemical system. The western aquiferous strata are of Cretaceous (mainly upper) age and younger, up to recent alluvial complex. The eastern strata are of the Jurassic age and younger ending at the same alluvial complex. Nevertheless, the regional aquifer on both sides is Karstic Cretaceous limestone and dolomite. The clastic aquifer complex mentioned was sedimented since the last sea transgression (Pliocene). It contains a thick sequence of salt-rich sediments and evaporative layers, which are draining groundwater from the adjacent aquifers, while increasing the groundwater TDS as it replenishes the aquiferous complex. Since no reliable sub-surface data of the Central Rift is in existence, a profound geophysical research, based on seismic profiles interpretation was carried out. An analysis of the results from this section of the work led to several important implications:  Several newfound faulting systems were discovered in the sub-surface of the Rift, the most intriguing is of the Fari’a graben. The graben was found to be continuous to the east cutting through a buried north-south extending anticlinal structure; in addition, the northern margin of the graben shows indications for strike slip movement. The aquiferous water divide line is found north to the Fari’a, at the Argaman region. Hence, south of it groundwater is draining via several intermediate basins to the Dead Sea basin, and north of it to the Bet She’an and Kinnarot basins.  While the eastern Rift margins descend to the valley along a narrow faulting zone, with clastic alluvial sediments laid against it, in the west, the approach to the valley is by a set of step blocks that extend eastward in the sub-surface. The outcome of this setting is that fresh groundwater cropping can be feasible also within the Rift, as the Cretaceous aquiferous strata are not as deep as previously suspected.  The sub-surface topography indicates that an intermediate hydrological basins set is located along the study area. An evaporative lens, several hundreds meters thick with a maximum length of about 10 km and width of about 4 km, was found in one of these basins. The atmospheric study leads to the conclusion that several atmospheric and geological factors define the chemical and isotopic parameters of rainwater. The synoptic setting of every rain event defines an individual chemical signature for each such event. Nevertheless, the chemical “fingerprint” of rainwater is preserved only during the rain stage itself. As the runoff stage begins, this “fingerprint” is altered due to salts dissolution out of soils and soil crusts. By combining the methods of rainwater analysis, evaluation of geochemical-properties, and identification of air masses from various sources and trajectories, the following conclusions could be drawn:  Relatively low-salinity rainwater found to be of the CaCO3 type, which is associated with continental and local air-mass sources. High-salinity rainwater was mainly of NaCl type, which is associated with marine air-masses. However, their 87Sr/86Sr ratios point out that their marine origin fraction is lower than 20%, indicating that the Ca2+ and Sr2+ are mostly of continental origins.  Calcium and carbon input to the low salinity group is mainly due to dissolution of dust containing significant amounts of carbonate rocks weathering products. CaCO3 rainwater is more common in the arid regions. Furthermore, some of the rains, which originated from marine air-mass trajectories, manifest enrichment by Ca-carbonate due to input of local dust during dust storms. In these few cases, high salinities with co-dominance of CaCO3 and NaCl rainwater were obtained.  D vs. 18O relationship reveals that three geochemical systems define rainwater chemical properties. NaCl type rainwater correlates with the geochemical system of the Eastern Mediterranean Meteoric Water Line, which consisted mainly of marine western trajectories. CaCO3 type rainwater derived as expected mainly out of continental trajectories in which the southwestern trajectories subjected to the Global Mean meteoric Water Line chemical system and the eastern and local trajectories are subjected to Local Meteoric Water Line system.  Since most of the study area is covered with sediments of the impermeable Lisan formation, and since evaporation potential is higher than the amount of precipitations even during the winter, runoff recharge to the Jordan Valley aquifer complex is negligible. Nevertheless, a unique increase in TDS and of carbonate alkalinity in runoff, and probably also in runin, was observed. The outcome of this process is that negligible freshwater recharge transforms into a significant salts contributor. This mechanism is attributed to soluble salts contribution out of arid soils, soil crusts, and a small amount of agricultural residues, and in several locations, evaporative bodies such as the one found in the subsurface of the Mallaha area.  D vs. 18O ratio remains unchanged along the meteoric evaporation line of the rain, which generated the flood event in the runoff stage. The chemical characteristics of the runoff are unique for every drainage basin. The alkalinity of runoff is higher than expected from the dissolution of calcite or aragonite. This could indicate that in many cases, beside dissolution of halite, a great portion of the increase in TDS and in carbonate, alkalinity is due to dissolution of soluble Na-carbonate salts, which accumulates in soil crusts and in the unsaturated zone of arid zones.  The natural reservoir of Wadi Mallaha marsh was probably created in a structural low that formed due to halokinetic processes and the dissolution of evaporative body, which was found in the seismic study. It is replenished during the rainy season, and is completely evaporated at the beginning of the hot season. Moreover, overflow of the upper water layer of the marsh to the Jordan River during (the rare) rainy winters, makes this system even more complex. The subsurface occurrence of the evaporative complex might also be manifested by the geochemical characteristics of the water in the marsh, and its morphologic setting.  The water of Wadi Yitav (which drains to the Wadi Mallaha marsh) preserves the geochemical signature of local rainwater, probably as this hydrogeochemical system is relatively young and isolated magnifying the impact of this ongoing process of cyclic enrichment of desert soil with salts out of rainwater.  Two wadis in the northern part of the study area (Milha and Bezeq) had the highest TDS, pH and 13C values, in addition to the lowest 14C activities. Although evaporative bodies were not yet encountered in this specific area, the geochemical scenario of wadis Milha and Bezeq might imply the existence and contribution of such elements in the northern part of the study area. The final research stage was interpolation of the results into integrated models. The first model applied was a salts reconstruction model, which was the basis for water groups reconstruction for a PhreeqC model. Whereas the results of the hydrochemical modeling were cross-correlated with the spatial subsurface structure as deciphered during the geophysical study. The integrated view over this complex system stress certain characteristics, which could have implications over the regional water management policy: • The runoff TDS increase in comparison to rain is up to second order of magnitude in certain cases. This process is probably due to dissolution of salts from soil crusts. The same trend might be intensified as runin recharges the shallow aquifers after it had dissolved additional salts in the unsaturated zone. Groundwater recharge by water with TDS values with up to several thousands milligram per liter might be an important source for groundwater deterioration. • The groundwater in the region can be classified into six groups, which characterize the chemical parameters of each water group. Nine saline end members, in addition to water-rock interactions were classified as major sources of salts to the groundwater of the region. • The geophysical modeling revealed two saddle-like structures in the regions of Uj’a and Argaman, which occurred as aquiferous layers at shallow depths beneath the young sedimentary cover. Facilitation of these aquifers for exploitation is more than feasible, otherwise, as indicated by the geochemical modeling, the fresh groundwater of the Cretaceous (Naaran) and Eocene (Argaman) aquifers will turn saline as they flow eastwards and replenish the Neogene and Quaternary aquifers.
... They are divided into Lower Basalt (Early Middle Miocene), Intermediate Basalt (Late Miocene), Cover Basalt (Early Pleistocene), Yarmouk Basalts (Middle Pleistocene), Post-Cover and Ruman Basalts (Late Pleistocene), and Raqqad Basalts (Late Pleistocene) (Heimann, 1990;Shaliv, 1991). The majority of the surface outcrops of basalts surrounding the lake are of Pliocene and Pleistocene age (Heimann et al., 1996;Flexer et al., 2000). ...
Chapter
For the estimation of water contamination, the resistivity method application is traditionally assumed as the most effective one. Many resistivity studies were suggested for the localization of water horizons and their mapping. For example, it is well known that sources of self-potential (SP) signals may be produced by electro-kinetic, electro-chemical, and thermoelectric effects. Sometimes the most intriguing use of SP at the groundwater-surface water interface is to characterize the variability in redox conditions. SP measurements have been used to extend the spatial coverage of redox measurements obtained from monitoring wells associated with a contaminant plume at the Entressen landfill in France. Advanced magnetic analysis (with an application of the procedures especially developed for complex physical-geological environments), paleomagnetic mapping, K-Ar dating, and structural reconstructions are suggested for mapping water basins in complex physical-geological environments. The application of such an integration is described in detail in the example of the Sea of Galilee, Israel. An aquifer (saturated zone) is an underground layer of water-bearing permeable rock. A typical hydrological system on land is composed of a vadose (or unsaturated) zone (region of aeration between the surface and the water table), an unconfined aquifer between the water table and the first confining bed or aquitard), and confining aquitards separate the aquifers. Hydrogeology basics and sedimentary rocks' main characteristics are discussed concerning thermal waters, including the principal features of confined aquifers. Besides this, some specific elements of recharge and discharge zones and water flow through aquifers are described.
... There must therefore be other inflows. There are only two possibilities for those inflows: FLEXER et al., 2000;INBAR et al., 2010; diapirs in the Lisan peninsula). It must therefore be assumed that the mineralization in the J4 Aquifer of the Bekaa is substantially high. ...
Technical Report
Full-text available
The groundwater catchment of Jeita Spring was analyzed in detail, using more than a dozen tracer tests, more than a thousand stable isotope samples and other means. The contributions from different sources and the flow paths could be detected. This was the first comprehensive analysis of a groundwater catchment of a spring in Lebanon. Hope that more will follow in order to permit a better management of water resources in this beautiful country !
Conference Paper
Full-text available
Skrzypek G., Sachanbiński M., Jędrysek M.O., 2003, Oxygen stable isotope geochemistry of chrysoprase from Wiry and Szklary mines (SE Poland). Book of extended synopses. International Symposium on Isotope Hydrology and Integrated Water Resources Management, International Atomic Energy Agency, Vienna, Austria, IAEA-CN-104/P-181, 358-359.
Article
Groundwater-surface water interactions as result of in- and effluent conditions along a stream may have a strong impact on the quantity and quality of the river water. These interactions are controlled by river morphology and by transient hydraulic gradients between river and surrounding groundwater. Here we document the existence of spatiotemporal variations in groundwater-surface water interactions in the bed of the Lower Jordan River through pore water analysis of shallow sediment cores using major ions (Na⁺, Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺, Cl⁻, Br⁻, SO4²⁻) and stable isotopes (δ¹⁸O, δ²H). Our results demonstrate that temporal variations are neither spatially uniform nor steady. Upwelling of groundwater is seasonally dependent and forced by a winter pulse of groundwater recharge and by estival low river discharge.
Article
The Jordan Valley and the area of the Dead Sea are a closed drainage base for numerous aquifers and water bodies of diverse ages and of different chemical and isotopic compositions. The elucidation of the relationships between these water bodies, of interaquifer flow and of salinization processes is a necessary step for the rational management of these waters and of primary importance for the further development of water resources in an area with an ever increasing population and expanding agriculture.
Article
Full-text available
Iron mineralization occurs in carbonate rocks of the Cretaceous Judea Group in northern Sinai and the Negev. This mineralization, along with strong enrichment of trace metals, fills fissures and veins. The mineralization is not directly emplaced into the Judea Group limestones but rather within epigenetic dolomites or ankerites which postdate the country rocks. The epigenetic phenomena are narrowly restricted to regional tectonic lineaments. The association of mineralization phenomena with tectonic zones of high permeability suggests that fluid transfer between two distinctly different geochemical environments was the main mineral emplacing agent. Epigenetic dolomitization initially resulted from upflow of old Mg-rich brines along the fault face. During later stages, the residual CaCl2 brines flowing through the underlying Paleozoic-Mesozoic clastic rocks accumulated Fe and trace metals by leaching of volcanic intrusions. The introduction, via faulting, of these pressurized, acidic, low Eh, metal-bearing brines into the overlying aerated and alkaline carbonate surroundings led to precipitation of Fe which in turn scavenged the trace metals. The Mg-rich brines developed during the Cambrian-Lower Cretaceous mostly continental time-interval. The episodic expulsion of pressurized dolomitizing and metal-bearing brines was related to various stages of tectonic and igneous activity occuring during the Early Miocene-Pleistocene.
Article
A thick mass of evaporites, shale and conglomerate of the Dead Sea Group, of Plio-Pleistocene to Recent age, forms the sedimentary fill, up to 8-10 km thick, of the Dead Sea trough in the Jordan Rift Valley. The history of this evaporite basin, origin of salts, basin morphology, depth of brine and conditions of influx-evaporation-reflux system, is examined, by comparing sedimentological and bromine data and existing data from marine evaporites. Cyclic sedimentation in the Dead Sea Group, of thick rocksalt units alternating with thinner shale units is considered to have been deposited mainly in shallow water with occasional exposure and dessication. In later stages the basin was cut off from the sea with playa, lagoonal, sabkha and fluviatile conditions prevailing. Rare occasional influxes of the sea occurred. Seasonal and cyclic sedimentation proceeds through the carbonate and sulfate phases, continuing in the deeper areas to the halite phase and rarely reaching conditions of dessication. The bromine content in the rocksalt, 40-600 ppm, is within the range of salt of marine origin. The general trend of bromine concentration is a progressive increase up the sequence. Bromine profiles are semi-regular with occasional high peaks indicating dessication episodes, verified by characteristic sedimentary structures.
Article
A Miocene-Pliocene section, penetrated in the Zemah 1 borehole in the Jordan-Dead Sea Rift, comprises evaporites, marls, limestones, basalt flows and intrusive gabbros. The section is divided into five lithostratigraphic units, some of which are partly or completely unknown inside or outside the Jordan-Dead Sea Rift. A structural interpretation for each of these units has enabled a reconstruction of the geological history of the area since Miocene times. An anticlinal structure, detected on seismic profiles, is inferred to be associated with bending or stepping to the right of an irregular sinistral strike-slip fault, which is part of the Jordan-Dead Sea Rift. This fault can be related to the known post-Miocene phase of sinistral wrench faulting along the Jordan-Dead Sea Rift. Besides strike-slip movement, normal faulting has been active in several phases since the Miocene. A pseudotachylyte found in one of the gabbro intrusions may indicate movements along the Jordan-Dead Sea Rift. These movements are at least younger than 3.8 Ma.
Article
New observations are reported on the geochemistry of deep saline inland groundwaters, suggesting that the character of these old groundwaters was affected mainly by long-lasting water-rock interactions.-from Authors
Article
Mapping the floor of the Sea of Galilee (Lake Kinneret) with a shallow seismic system of 3.5 kHz resulted in interesting data that were not obtained previously with standard single-channel seismic systems. Over most of the lake acoustic penetration is not possible, probably because of the high gas content in the top sedimentary sequence. However, in a few areas, excellent penetration of about 20 m was achieved. One area is a terrace in the southern part of the lake, south of a small bathymetric escarpment at depths of 13-21 m along Israel latitudinal Grid 238. It is unclear whether the existence of gas in the sediment or other parameters are responsible for the marked difference in acoustic penetration on both sides of the scarp. Another area with acoustic penetration is in the vicinity of hot and salty submarine springs. Although there is no difference in the composition of the upper sedimentary layers between these areas and neighbouring areas, there is a marked difference in the acoustic penetration. The contact between areas with acoustic penetration to areas without acoustic penetration is very sharp. The craters of the submarine springs are usually located on the borders of the areas with acoustic penetration or even at some distance away from them. It is possible that the activity of the hot and salty submarine springs controls the acoustic penetration. However, determination of the exact mechanism for the existence of the zones of acoustic penetration must await further studies of the sediments, especially for measurements of various parameters that control the seismic response of the rock. Another discovery made with the shallow seismic profiles is the existence of some bathymetric irregularities on the floor of the Sea of Galilee. In view of the high sedimentation rate in the lake, which tends to smooth the floor, a bathymetric irregularity such as a linear bathymetric step could be a surface expression of an active fault.
Article
The mechanism governing salinization of ground water discharging into the Sea of Galilee in Israel has been the subject of debate for several decades. Because the lake provides 25% of the water consumed annually in Israel, correct identification of the salt sources is essential for the establishment of suitable water-management strategies for the lake and the ground water in the surrounding aquifers. Existing salinization models were evaluated in light of available and newly acquired data including general chemistry, and O, H, C and Cl isotopes. Based on the chemical and isotopic observations, the proposed salt source is an ancient, intensively evaporated brine (21- to 33-fold seawater) which percolated through the valley formations from a lake which had formed in the Rift Valley following seawater intrusion during the late Miocene. Low Na:Cl and high Br:Cl values support the extensive evaporation, whereas high Ca:Cl and low Mg:Cl values indicate the impact of dolomitization of the carbonate host rock on the residual solution. Based on radiocarbon and other isotope data, the dilution of the original brine occurred in two stages: the first took place ∼30 000 a ago by slightly evaporated fresh-to-brackish lake water to form the Sea of Galilee Brine. The second dilution phase is associated with the current hydrological regime as the Sea of Galilee Brine migrates upward along the Rift faults and mixes with the actively circulating fresh ground water to form the saline springs. The spatially variable chemical and isotopic features of the saline springs suggest not only differential dilution by fresh meteoric water, but also differential percolation timing of the original brine into the tectonically disconnected blocks, registering different evaporation stages in the original brine. Consequently, various operations to reduce the brine contribution to the lake may be differentially effective in the various areas.