ArticlePublisher preview available

The Role of Anxiety Sensitivity in the Pathogenesis of Panic: Prospective Evaluation of Spontaneous Panic Attacks During Acute Stress

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

Expectancy theory posits that anxiety sensitivity may serve as a premorbid risk factor for the development of anxiety pathology (S. Reiss, 1991). The principal aim of the present study was to determine whether anxiety sensitivity acts as a specific vulnerability factor in the pathogenesis of anxiety pathology. A large, nonclinical sample of young adults (N = 1,401) was prospectively followed over a 5-week highly stressful period of time (i.e., military basic training). Anxiety sensitivity was found to predict the development of spontaneous panic attacks after controlling for a history of panic attacks and trait anxiety. Approximately 20% of those scoring in the upper decile on the Anxiety Sensitivity Index (R. A. Peterson & S. Reiss, 1987) experienced a panic attack during the 5-week follow-up period compared with only 6% for the remainder of the sample. Anxiety sensitivity also predicted anxiety symptomatology, functional impairment created by anxiety, and disability. These data provide strong evidence for anxiety sensitivity as a risk factor in the development of panic attacks and other anxiety symptoms.
Journal
of
Abnormal Psychology
1997,
Vol. 106,
No. 3.
355-364
In
the
public domain
The
Role
of
Anxiety Sensitivity
in the
Pathogenesis
of
Panic:
Prospective Evaluation
of
Spontaneous Panic Attacks
During Acute Stress
Norman
B.
Schmidt
and
Darin
R.
Lerew
Uniformed
Services University
of the
Health
Sciences
Robert
J.
Jackson
United States
Air
Force Academy
Expectancy theory posits that anxiety sensitivity
may
serve
as a
premorbid risk factor
for the
development
of
anxiety pathology
(S.
Reiss,
1991).
The
principal
aim of the
present study
was to
determine whether anxiety sensitivity acts
as a
specific vulnerability factor
in the
pathogenesis
of
anxiety
pathology.
A
large, nonclinical sample
of
young adults
(N =
1,401)
was
prospectively
followed
over
a
5-week highly stressful period
of
time (i.e., military basic
training).
Anxiety sensitiv-
ity
was
found
to
predict
the
development
of
spontaneous panic attacks
after
controlling
for a
history
of
panic attacks
and
trait anxiety. Approximately
20% of
those scoring
in the
upper decile
on the
Anxiety
Sensitivity Index
(R. A.
Peterson
& S.
Reiss,
1987)
experienced
a
panic attack during
the
5-week
follow-up period compared
with
only
6% for the
remainder
of the
sample. Anxiety sensitivity
also
predicted anxiety symptomatology, functional impairment created
by
anxiety,
and
disability.
These data provide strong evidence
for
anxiety sensitivity
as a
risk factor
in the
development
of
panic
attacks
and
other anxiety symptoms.
Panic attacks
are
discrete
and
intense
periods
of
autonomic
arousal accompanied
by
fear.
Spontaneous panic,
as
opposed
to
situationally bound
or
situationally
disposed
panic,
is
unex-
pected
and not
readily associated with
a
triggering stimulus.
Panic attacks,
in
particular spontaneous panic,
are the
central
and
defining
feature
of
panic disorder,
but
panic
attacks
are not
limited
to
those experiencing panic disorder
or
agoraphobia.
Panic
is
common
to all the
anxiety disorders (Barlow
et
al.,
1985),
hence
its
separation
from
panic disorder
in the
fourth
edition
of the
Diagnostic
and
Statistical Manual
of
Mental
Dis-
orders
(DSM-IV;
American Psychiatric Association,
1994).
In
Norman
B.
Schmidt
and
Darin
R.
Lerew, Department
of
Medical
and
Clinical Psychology, Uniformed Services University
of the
Health
Sciences;
Robert
J.
Jackson, Department
of
Behavioral Sciences
and
Leadership, United States
Air
Force Academy.
This research
was
supported
by
Uniformed Services University
of the
Health
Sciences Grant RO72CF. Portions
of
this article were presented
at the
104th
Annual Convention
of the
American Psychological Associa-
tion, Toronto, Ontario, Canada,
August
1996,
and at the
30th Annual
Conference
of the
Association
for
Advancement
of
Behavior Therapy,
New
\brk,
New
"Vbrk,
November
1996.
The
opinions
or
assertions
con-
tained
herein
are the
private ones
of the
authors
and are not to be
construed
as
official
or
reflecting
the
views
of the
Department
of De-
fense,
the
United States
Air
Force Academy,
or the
Uniformed Services
University
of the
Health Sciences.
We
express
our
appreciation
to
David
S.
Krantz
for
helpful
comments
on
a
draft
of the
manuscript
and to
Annette
Waddelow
and
Carla
Pulliam
for
assistance with data collection.
We
also thank Donald
F.
Klein
for
his
helpful
comments.
Correspondence concerning this article should
be
addressed
to
Nor-
man
B.
Schmidt, Uniformed
Services
University
of the
Health Sciences,
Department
of
Medical
and
Clinical Psychology,
4301
Jones Bridge
Road,
Bethesda,
Maryland 20814-4799. Electronic mail
may be
sent
via
Internet
to
schmidt@usuhsb.usuhs.mil.
fact,
surveys
of
nonclinical samples suggest that
a
substantial
number
of
adults experience spontaneous panic attacks
(Norton,
Dorward,
&
Cox, 1986; Norton, Harrison, Hauch,
&
Rhodes,
1985).
One
study
of
over
2,000
college students indicated
a
lifetime
prevalence
of
approximately
12% for
spontaneous panic
(Telch,
Lucas,
&
Nelson,
1989).
'
'Fear
of
fear''
has
played
an
important role
in the
conceptual-
ization
of and
research
on
both panic attacks
and
panic disorder.
Goldstein
and
Chambless
(1978)
suggested that panic
disorder
patients learn
to
fear symptoms
of
anxiety through interoceptive
classical conditioning
of
internal physical sensations. Internal
bodily cues
become
a
conditioned stimulus
for the
conditioned
response
of
anxiety
and
panic. According
to
Goldstein
and
Chambless,
fear
of
fear
develops
as a
consequence
of
having
panic
attacks. Fear
of
fear
has
also been
described
within cogni-
tive
theories
of
panic
(Beck
&
Emery, 1985; Clark,
1986),
which
suggest that panic attacks arise
from
the
catastrophic
misinterpretation
of
benign bodily perturbations. Misinterpreta-
tion
of
bodily cues leads
to a
vicious cycle
in
which
faulty
interpretation
leads
to
more anxiety
as a
fearful
response
to
arousal increases
the
very symptoms that constitute
the
focus
of
apprehension. This process
may
ultimately spiral into
full-
blown
panic
as
fear
feeds upon itself
(see
McNally,
1990).
The
construct
of
anxiety sensitivity
is
closely linked
with
fear
of
fear (Reiss
&
McNally,
1985).
Anxiety sensitivity refers
to
the
extent
to
which
an
individual believes that autonomic arousal
can
have
harmful
consequences.
For
example, individuals with
high
anxiety sensitivity
may
believe that shortness
of
breath
signals
suffocation
or
that heart palpitations indicate
a
heart
attack, whereas those with
low
anxiety sensitivity experience
these sensations
as
unpleasant
but
nonthreatening.
Consistent
with
cognitive theories
of
anxiety,
the
anxiety sen-
sitivity
conceptualization
posits
that cognitive
misappraisal
is
critical
for the
generation
of
anxiety. However, anxiety sensitiv-
355
THIS ARTICLE HAS BEEN CORRECTED. SEE LAST PAGE.
... The current results directly contrast the notion that the higher prevalence of mental health challenges in RCMP officers is related to inherent psychological vulnerabilities or insufficiencies that can be screened out as part of recruitment (Horswill and Carleton, 2021) to mitigate the high prevalence of mental health disorders among serving RCMP (Carleton et al., 2018). Consistent with the extant literature, the higher prevalence of positive screening for mental health challenges among serving RCMP (i.e., 50.2%) relative to the general population (i.e., 10.1%; Government of Canada, 2012; Carleton et al., 2018) may be associated with frequent PPTE exposures (Galatzer-Levy et al., 2011;Kilpatrick et al., 2013;Carleton et al., 2019) and other occupational stressors (Pozzulo et al., 2017;Carleton et al., 2020;Ricciardelli et al., 2020b) or the interaction of individual vulnerabilities with occupational stressors (Schmidt et al., 1997). Cadets who have relatively higher scores compared to other cadets may still be at risk of experiencing mental health challenges due to interactions between innate susceptibility and environmental susceptibility (i.e., exposure to PPTE). ...
... Army recruits undergoing basic Anxiety sensitivity = ASI-3 Total score; Fear of negative evaluation = BFNE-S; Resilience = BRS; Anger = DAR-5; Illness and injury sensitivity = ISI-R total score; Intolerance of uncertainty = IUS-12 Total score; Pain anxiety sensitivity = PASS-20 total score. training who had significantly lower AS scores compared to the general population, but relatively higher scores compared to fellow recruits, were more likely than other recruits to experience panic attacks during basic training (Schmidt et al., 1997). The subsequent RCMP Study data collections will allow for testing of the posited causal and interactive relationships between dispositional risk and resilience variables, diverse stressors, coping activities which may also serve as risk or resilience factors, and mental health. ...
Article
Despite the higher prevalence of mental health disorders among serving Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) relative to the general population, RCMP cadets begin training with lower putative risk and greater perceived resilience than young adults in the general population. The current study was designed to assess the effectiveness of the Cadet Training Program—the paramilitary training RCMP recruits complete to become serving RCMP—in strengthening RCMP cadets’ mental health by examining putative risk and resilience factors among post-training/pre-deployment cadets. Post-training/pre-deployment cadets (n = 492; 70.5% men) completed self-report measures of several putative risk variables (i.e., anxiety sensitivity, fear of negative evaluation, illness and injury sensitivity, intolerance of uncertainty, pain anxiety, and state anger) and perceived resilience. Cadets’ post-training/pre-deployment scores were compared to their pre-training scores (see Khoury et al. in Front Psychol 14:1048573, 2023) on the same measures, and to scores from Canadian, American, Australian, and European young adult control samples. Participants had significantly lower scores on all putative risk variables with the exception of state anger, and significantly higher scores on perceived resilience, at post-training/pre-deployment compared to pre-training. Participants also had significantly lower scores on all putative risk variables, and significantly higher scores on perceived resilience, compared to scores from young adult control samples. These uncontrolled pilot findings suggest the Cadet Training Program may be beneficial for RCMP cadets’ mental health and provide further evidence that the nature of policing, rather than individual differences in risk and resilience, likely explains serving RCMP’s relatively higher prevalence of mental health disorders.
... Low distress tolerance combined with a high frequency of major life events significantly increases the strength of this relationship. These results are consistent with and extend previous findings that specific stress levels interact with stress tolerance to predict subsequent panic onset [28,29]. Furthermore, the presence of a moderate association with depression has particular clinical relevance in HIV due to evidence of its propensity to predict accelerated disease progression [30] and death [31]. ...
Article
Full-text available
A crucial factor in the success of treatment for patients with Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV) is adherence to antiretroviral (ARV) therapy among People Living with HIV/AIDS (PLWHA). Adherence issues remain a persisting problem with multifaceted causes. There are many studies on variables related to ARV therapy adherence, but no study has been found on spiritual well-being and distress tolerance in ARV therapy adherence. This study aims to determine the relationship between distress tolerance and spiritual well-being on adherence to ARV therapy in PLWHA. This research used a quantitative approach with a cross-sectional design. The sample collection process followed a consecutive sampling technique, with data gathered from 129 participants at the South Lampung Regional General Hospital located in Indonesia. Data collection was conducted using three questionnaires administered by the interviewer, which assessed distress tolerance using the Miller–Smith Rating Scale For Stress Tolerance (MSRS-ST), evaluated spiritual Well-Being using the Spiritual Well-Being Scale (SWBS), and gauged ARV therapy adherence using the Medication Adherence Rating Scale (MARS). Data analysis using a simple logistic regression with a 95% confidence interval (CI) showed a significant relationship between distress tolerance (p-value 0.002) and spiritual well-being (p-value 0.036) towards ARV therapy adherence in PLWHA. The results of multiple logistic regression yielded distress tolerance as the most dominant and influential variable in this research. Distress tolerance and spiritual well-being impact adherence to ARV therapy in PLWHA. Suggestions for healthcare services should consider these factors to decrease the risk of non-adherence to therapy and inadvertently heighten mortality risk.
Article
Full-text available
Interoceptive exposure (IE) involves the use of exercises, activities, or tasks to intentionally induce (or exacerbate) physical symptoms in the body, to challenge misconceptions about the harmful nature of the physical symptoms that maintain fear and problematic avoidance. IE was originally developed for the cognitive behavioral treatment and prevention of panic disorder. Bodily sensations and concern about physical symptoms are common features in many conditions, not limited to panic disorder. For this reason, IE could be theoretically relevant to cognitive behavioral intervention for many psychological, behavioral, and medical conditions. Yet, IE remains relatively underrecognized and underused as an intervention. Exposure involves feeling discomfort before experiencing relief; thus, it is often perceived as an aversive, unsafe, and illogical intervention because of the seemingly paradoxical approach. We conducted a systematic literature search for a scoping review with the aim of locating published studies on IE to understand how it has been studied beyond panic disorder. Studies focused solely on panic disorder were excluded. We were able to identify and extract data from 132 studies (published between 1992 and 2022), though this published literature is difficult to find. The use of IE has been widely investigated in conditions beyond panic disorder, although evidence for its efficacy is difficult to isolate from other forms of exposure and cognitive behavioral features. There is the strongest evidence for the efficacy of IE as a part of multicomponent cognitive behavioral treatments for posttraumatic stress disorder, health anxiety, irritable bowel syndrome, and to aid in benzodiazepine discontinuation. Interventions that were primarily or exclusively IE-based did not consistently or directly influence claustrophobia fear, separation anxiety, suicidality, insomnia symptoms, cigarette or drug abstinence, or pain-related fear. No serious adverse events were reported in any study. Studies of IE require larger sample sizes, detailed descriptions and rationale of IE exercises, higher IE dosing, extended follow-up assessment, and documentation of safety.
Article
Full-text available
Objectives Digital interventions are increasingly in demand to address mental health concerns, with significant potential to reach populations that disproportionately face barriers to accessing mental health care. Challenges with user engagement, however, persist. The goal of this study was to develop user personas to inform the development of a digital mental health intervention (DMHI) for a perinatal population. Materials and Methods We used participatory User-Centered Design (UCD) methods to generate and validate personas (ie, representative profiles of potential users). We applied this methodology to a case example of an Anxiety Sensitivity Intervention. Phases included (1) Characteristic identification, (2) Persona generation, (3) Persona consolidation, (4) Persona validation, and (5) Persona refinement. Advisory Council members with lived expertise of perinatal mental health conditions generated 6 personas. We used cluster analysis and qualitative analysis to consolidate personas. We used participant interviews with perinatal individuals experiencing depression or anxiety and economic marginalization (n = 12) to qualitatively validate and refine these personas. Results We identified 4 user personas with potentially unique design needs that we characterized as being “Resilient,” “Lonely,” “Overwhelmed,” and “Aware.” Discussion Personas generated through this process had distinct characteristics and design implications including the need to prioritize (1) content personalization, (2) additional content describing support options and resources (eg, doulas, midwives), (3) careful consideration of the type of information provided by users, and (4) transparent options for information and data sharing. Conclusion DMHIs will need to be adapted for relevance for a perinatal population. The personas we developed are suggestive of the need for design considerations specific to distinct potential user groups within this population.
Preprint
Full-text available
Objective: Despite the higher prevalence of mental health disorders among serving Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) relative to the general population, RCMP cadets begin training with lower putative risk and greater perceived resilience than young adults in the general population. The current study was designed to assess the effectiveness of the Cadet Training Program-the paramilitary training RCMP recruits complete to become serving RCMP-in strengthening RCMP cadets' mental health by examining putative risk and resilience factors among post-training/pre-deployment cadets. Method: Post-training/pre-deployment cadets (n=492; 70.5% men) completed self-report measures of several putative risk variables (i.e., anxiety sensitivity, fear of negative evaluation, pain anxiety, illness and injury sensitivity, intolerance of uncertainty, and state anger) and perceived resilience. Cadets' post-training/pre-deployment scores were compared to their pre-training scores (see Khoury et al., 2023) on the same measures, and to scores from Canadian, American, Australian, and European young adult control samples. Results: Participants had significantly lower scores on all putative risk variables with the exception of state anger, and significantly higher scores on perceived resilience, at post-training/pre-deployment compared to pre-training. Participants also had significantly lower scores on all putative risk variables, and significantly higher scores on perceived resilience, compared to scores from young adult control samples. Conclusion: These uncontrolled pilot findings suggest the Cadet Training Program may be beneficial for RCMP cadets' mental health and provide further evidence that the nature of policing, rather than individual differences in risk and resilience, likely explain serving RCMP's relatively higher prevalence of mental health disorders.
Article
To meaningfully use the Anxiety Sensitivity Index-3 (ASI-3) with athletes, measurement invariance must be established. Thus, we sought to determine appropriate factor structures for the ASI-3 in an athlete sample, assess measurement invariance between an athlete sample and a less active sample, and compare ASI-3 scores between these groups. Two university student samples were recruited: an athlete sample ( n = 216) and a less active control sample ( n = 321). Results supported bifactor and hierarchical factor structures for the ASI-3 overall and in the athlete sample. Measurement invariance of these factor structures was established. ASI-3 score comparisons indicated that the athlete sample had significantly lower levels of global anxiety sensitivity, and lower physical and social concerns. Results support the use of the ASI-3 to address mental health concerns in athletes and permit meaningful comparisons between athletes and nonathletes using the ASI-3 and its subscales.
Chapter
Same as 2017 chapter not sure why here again
Article
The principal objective of this study is to investigate the impact of perceived stress on traffic and road safety. Therefore, we designed a study that allows the generation and collection of stress-relevant data. Drivers often experience stress due to their perception of lack of control during the driving process. This can lead to an increased likelihood of traffic accidents, driver errors, and traffic violations. To explore this phenomenon, we used the Stress Perceived Questionnaire (PSQ) to evaluate perceived stress levels during driving simulations and the EPQR questionnaire to determine the personality of the driver. With the presented study, participants can categorised based on their emotional stability and personality traits. Wearable devices were utilised to monitor each participant's instantaneous heart rate (HR) due to their non-intrusive and portable nature. The findings of this study deliver an overview of the link between stress and traffic and road safety. These findings can be utilised for future research and implementing strategies to reduce road accidents and promote traffic safety.
Article
Full-text available
This investigation sought to expand existing knowledge of anxiety sensitivity in a sample of high school students (N = 2,365) assessed over 4 years. The stability of anxiety sensitivity levels across assessment periods was examined, and cluster analyses were used to identify different developmental pathways in levels of anxiety sensitivity. Groups of adolescents with stable low, stable high, and escalating anxiety sensitivity levels were identified. Adolescents with stable high or escalating anxiety sensitivity were significantly more likely to report experiencing a panic attack than individuals with stable low anxiety sensitivity. Results also indicated that Asian and Hispanic adolescents tended to report higher anxiety sensitivity but that their anxiety sensitivity was less strongly associated with panic than that of Caucasian adolescents.
Article
Full-text available
This article presents data on the prevalence and symptomatology of panic attacks and panic disorder (PD) in a large nonclinical sample (n = 2,375) of college students. Results showed that approximately 12% of the sample had experienced at least one unexpected panic attack and that 2.36% met DSM-III-R criteria for panic disorder. Although there were no sex differences in overall panic attack prevalence, men reported significantly more panic-related worry than women, and women reported a higher panic frequency than men. Compared to subjects who met DSM-III-R criteria for PD, infrequent panickers presented with fewer panic symptoms, fewer panic episodes, less panic-related worry, lower anxiety sensitivity, and less panic-related avoidance. Moreover, compared with PD subjects, the infrequent panickers were much less likely to report fears of dying, going insane, and derealization during a panic attack. The findings provide preliminary support for the role of anxious apprehension as a psychological vulnerability factor in the pathogenesis of panic disorder.
Article
Full-text available
Although self-reports of panic attacks are common among student populations, it is not clear that their panic experiences are actually comparable to those of patients with clinical anxiety disorders. An empirical approach was taken to this problem by using a cluster analysis procedure to identify subjects within two samples of university students who reported panic attack symptom profiles that resembled those of patients with panic disorder. Such empirically defined "clinical" panic attacks were reported by 7.0% and 8.1% of the two samples. This predominantly female group accounted for most of the increased psychopathology that has been reported in previous studies of nonclinical panic.
Article
Panic disorder is frequently complicated by high rates of co-occurring nonpsychiatric medical conditions. The present study examined the relationship between medical morbidity, perceived physical health, and treatment outcome in panic disorder. Patients meeting the American Psychiatric Association's Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of mental disorders (1994) criteria for panic disorder (N = 71) completed 12 sessions of cognitive-behavioral treatment and were assessed at posttreatment and 6-month follow-up. Medical comorbidity and perceived health were both found to be related to end-state functioning. Medical comorbidity did not uniquely predict outcome beyond its shared variance with perceived health. At posttreatment, 71% of patients who perceived their physical health as good met recovery criteria compared with only 35% of those who perceived their health as poor. At follow-up, 67% of those who perceived their physical health as good met composite recovery criteria compared with only 33% of those with perceived poor health. These findings offer preliminary support for the impact of physical health, both actual and perceived, on treatment outcome of patients with panic disorder.
Article
Assessed 108 20–67 yr old patients complaining of anxiety using a structured interview and categorized them into the DSM-III anxiety-disorder and major-depression categories. The incidence and nature of panic was examined in a detailed fashion in Ss in 2 separate interviews and included a search for any difference as a function of whether panic was predictable or cued (e.g., panic when encountering a phobic object or situation) or unpredictable. At least 83% of Ss in each diagnostic category admitted to having had a panic attack. Frequency of DSM-III panic attacks distinguished among categories, but few differences emerged among diagnostic categories on severity of the 12 DSM-III symptoms associated with panic. Symptom severity was also similar for Ss reporting either predictable or unpredictable panic. However, Ss with unpredictable panic reported a significantly greater number of the 12 symptoms than did those with predictable panic. These data point to differences between these 2 types of panic and underline the importance of discovering the nature of these differences. (38 ref)
Article
We tested the hypothesis that the Anxiety Sensitivity Index (ASI) measures a unitary personality variable. College students (N = 840) were administered the ASI along with a questionnaire assessing panic and anxiety symptomatology. The ASI demonstrated adequate internal reliability (α = .82) and showed modest discrimination on two of three anxiety disorder indices (i.e., anxiety medication usage and panic history). Results of a principal components analysis with varimax rotation revealed a four-factor solution which explained 53.5% of the total variance. Our findings seriously challenge previous claims that the ASI measures a single factor. Rather, our data suggest that the ASI measures several loosely-related cognitive appraisal domains concerned with the anticipated negative consequences of anxiety. The four factors that emerged from our analysis were (a) concern about physical sensations, (b) concern about mental/cognitive incapacitation, (c) concern about loss of control, and (d) concern about heart/lung failure. It is concluded that the ASI is a convenient and reliable instrument for assessing perceived physical consequences of anxiety but that the instrument is lacking in its coverage of anxiety consequences related to social concerns. Implications of the findings for treatment are discussed.
Article
The purpose of the present study was to determine whether the fear of anxiety and fear of sadness can be reduced to other, well-established classes of fear. A second goal was to examine the relationships between these fears and the avoidance of stimuli that evoke these emotions. The Fear Survey Schedule-III, modified to include items assessing the fear of anxiety and the fear of sadness, was administered to 330 nonclinical subjects. Measures of agoraphobic avoidance and of avoidance of saddening stimuli were also completed. The results of a factor analysis of the fear scale revealed that the fear of anxiety and the fear of sadness loaded on separate factors, and were not subsumed within other, well-established classes of fear. The results of causal modelling supported the hypothesis that fear of anxiety contributes to agoraphobic fear, and that both fears promote agoraphobic avoidance. Support was also found for a causal model in which fear of sadness engenders a fear of the cues to sadness, and that both fears promote the avoidance of sadness-evoking stimuli.