Technical ReportPDF Available

Policy Learning in Europe: Social Policy and Labour Market Reforms in 11 Countries

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This report compares policy learning processes in 11 European countries. Based on the country reports that were produced by the national teams of the INSPIRES project, this paper develops an argument that connects problem pressure and politicization to learning in different labor market innovations. In short, we argue that learning efforts are most likely to impact on policy change if there is a certain problem pressure that clearly necessitates political action. On the other hand, if problem pressure is very low, or so high that governments need to react immediately, chances are low that learning impacts on policy change. The second part of our argument contends that learning impacts on policy change especially if a problem is not very politicized, i.e. there are no main conflicts concerning a reform, because then, solutions are wound up in the search for a compromise. Our results confirm our first hypothesis regarding the connection between problem pressure and policy learning. Governments learn indeed up to a certain degree of problem pressure. However, once political action becomes really urgent, i.e. in anti-crisis policies, there is no time and room for learning. On the other hand, learning occurred independently from the politicization of problem. In fact, in countries that have a consensual political system, learning occurred before the decision on a reform, whereas in majoritarian systems, learning happened after the adoption of a policy during the process of implementation.
No caption available
… 
Content may be subject to copyright.
!"
"
"
Innovative Social Policies for Inclusive and
Resilient Labour Markets in Europe"
" "
!
!
!
"#$%!
&'()*+!(,-./)/0!)/!12.'3,4!5'*)-(!3'()*+!-/6!
(-7'2.!8-.9,:!.,;'.8<!)/!==!*'2/:.),<!
"
!
>?,!.,<,-.*?!(,-6)/0!:'!:?,<,!.,<2(:<!?-<!.,*,)@,6!;2/6)/0!;.'8!:?,!12.'3,-/!A'882/):+B<!
5,@,/:?!C.-8,D'.9!&.'0.-88,!2/6,.!0.-/:!-0.,,8,/:!E'$!%FG=F=!H&.'I,*:!JE5&JK15L!!
!
!
!
"
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
INSPIRES!!
Working!paper!series!2013!no.!1!
ISSN!221591605!
#"
"
!
!
Project!title:!
JE5&JK15!
Funding!scheme:!
C&M!!
Project!acronym:!
JE5&JK15!
Project!ID:!
%FG=F=!
!
Consortium!coordinator:!
1.-<82<!N/)@,.<):+!K'::,.6-8!
Start!date!project:!
G=OGFOFG=%!
Project!duration:!
PF!Q'/:?<!
!
Deliverable!number:!
!
#$%!
Work!package!
number:!
#!
Due!date!of!
deliverable:!
%=O=FOFG=#!
Actual!delivery!date:!
!
=GO=FOFG=#!
!
Lead!beneficiary!for!this!deliverable:!
J"R1S&T!U-2<-//,!
Document!version:!
V,.<)'/!F!
!
Authors:!
&?)()33!>.,)/!
W)2()-/'!X'/'()!
",()-!&)<'/)!
Keywords:!
&'()*+!(,-./)/0T!<'*)-(!3'()*+T!(-7'.!8-.9,:!3'()*+!
!
!
Dissemination!Level!
PU!
&27()*!
XX!
PP!
K,<:.)*:,6!:'!':?,.!3.'0.-8!3-.:)*)3-/:<!!
!
RE!
K,<:.)*:,6!:'!-!0.'23!<3,*);),6!:'!:?,!*'/<'.:)28!
!
CO!
A'/;)6,/:)-(T!'/(+!;'.!8,87,.<!';!:?,!*'/<'.:)28!
!
"
""
$"
"
Policy'learning'in'Europe:'Social'policy'
and$labour$market$reforms$in$11$
countries"
%&'('))"*+,'-."/'0('1-2"32-2('."4,('1"%'52-'"
University!of!Lausanne!
*&'5" +,)2+6" 728)1+,5" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" '-" !!" ;0+2),1-" 720-6+',5<" =),7'>'71((9." ?," 1+,"
72--,76'-:" )+2@(,8" )+,550+,5" 1-A" 6&," )2('6'7'516'2-" 2>" 1" :'B,-" )+2@(,8" 62" )2('79"
(,1+-'-:" 1-A" )2('79" 7&1-:,5" '-" A'>>,+,-6" ;0+2),1-" 720-6+',5" 1-A" A'>>,+,-6" 7(056,+5" 2>"
527'1("1-A"(1@20+"81+C,6")2('7',5<"*&'5"+,)2+6"'5"1"59-6&,5'5"2>"!!"720-6+9"560A',5."?&'7&"
?,+,"72-A076,A"'-"6&,"720+5,"2>"6&,"DE=%DF;="+,5,1+7&" )+2G,76."?&'7&"'5">0-A,A"0-A,+"
6&,";0+2),1-"H288'55'2-I5" J6&"K+18,?2+C" %+2:+18<"*&," )+2G,76"728)1+,5"+,>2+85"2>"
(1@20+"81+C,6"1-A"527'1(")2('7',5"'-"6&,">2((2?'-:"720-6+',5L"3,(:'08."/,+81-9."/+,,7,."
M0-:1+9."D61(9."E,6&,+(1-A5."=(2B,-'1."=)1'-."=?,A,-."=?'6N,+(1-A"1-A"6&,"OP<""
D-" 6&'5" +,)2+6." ?," 1+," :2'-:" 62" >2705" 2-" )2('79" (,1+-'-:<" K2+" ,17&" 2>" 6&," 8,-6'2-,A"
720-6+',5."1"-16'2-1("6,18"2>",Q),+65"A+1>6,A"1"720-6+9"+,)2+6."?&'7&",Q18'-,5"1"-08@,+"
2>"5,(,76,A" '--2B16'2-5" '-" A'>>,+,-6" 1+,15" 2>" 527'1(" 1-A" (1@20+" 81+C,6" )2('7',5" 1-A" 6&,"
+2(," 6&16" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" )(19,A" 6&,+,'-<" *&," 5,(,76'2-" 2>" '--2B16'2-5" '5" @15,A" 2-" 6&,"
,>>2+65"2>")+'2+"?2+C'-:")17C1:,5."'-"?&'7&"6&,"518,",Q),+65",Q18'-,A"2B,+1(("6+,-A5"'-"
527'1(" 1-A" (1@20+" 81+C,6" )2('7',5" '-" 6&," 8,-6'2-,A" 720-6+',5" A0+'-:" 6&," ),+'2A" >+28"
#RRR" S" #R!$" 1-A" :+20),A" 6&,8" '-62" 5'Q" 7(056,+5." -18,(9" 9206&" 0-,8)(298,-6." 2(A,+"
?2+C,+5" 1-A" ,Q6,-5'2-" 2>" ?2+C'-:" ('>,." A'51@(,A" ),+52-5." :2B,+-1-7,." 176'B16'2-" 1-A"
>(,Q'@'('69"1-A">(,Q'70+'69<"315,A"2-"6&'5"2B,+B',?"2>"(1@20+"81+C,6"+,>2+85."6&,"-16'2-1("
,Q),+6" 6,185" 5,(,76,A" '--2B16'2-5" 1-A" 1-1(95,A" 6&,'+" 2+':'-." '8)(,8,-616'2-" 1-A" 6&,"
+2(," 2>" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" 6&,+,'-<" *&'5" +,)2+6." 59-6&,5'N,5" 6&,">'-A'-:5" 2>" 6&," -16'2-1("
,Q),+6" +,)2+65" 1-A" 166,8)65" 1" @15'7" 1-1(95'5" 2>" 6&," A9-18'75" 6&16" '8),A," 2+" >1B20+"
)2('79"(,1+-'-:"@,'-:"'8)2+61-6">2+"+,>2+85<"
T"
"
D-"2+A,+"62"A2"6&'5." ?,"1+,":2'-:")+27,,A"15">2((2?5<"D-"6&,"-,Q6"5,76'2-."?,"?'(("A,>'-,"
)2('79"(,1+-'-:"1-A"A'57055"'65"+,(16'2-"62")2('79"7&1-:,<"*&,-."?,"1+,":2'-:"62"'-6+2A07,"
62">0+6&,+",(,8,-65"6&16"-,,A"62"@,"61C,-"'-62"72-5'A,+16'2-"62"0-A,+561-A"6&,"'8)176"2>"
)2('79"(,1+-'-:"2-"+,>2+85<"*&,5,"1+,",72-28'7"1-A")2('6'71(")+2@(,85")+,550+,5."15"?,(("
15" 6&," )2('6'7'N16'2-" 2>" 1" )+2@(,8<" U>6,+" 6&16." ?," ?'((" )+,5,-6" 6&," +,50(65" 2>" 6&,"
728)1+'52-"@,6?,,-"6&,"!!"720-6+9"+,)2+65"1-A"1-1(95,"72-56,((16'2-5."'-"?&'7&")2('79"
(,1+-'-:")(19,A"1-"'8)2+61-6"+2(,">2+")2('79"7&1-:,"1-A"?&,-"-26<"H2-7(05'2-5">2((2?<"
V,1+-'-:"1-A"7&1-:,"
*&,"81'-"'-6,+,56"2>" 6&'5"+,)2+6"'5"'-")2('79"(,1+-'-:"1-A" 6&,"72-A'6'2-5"0-A,+"?&'7&"'6"
&15"1-" '8)176" 2-")2('79"7&1-:,<" %2('79" (,1+-'-:"&15"@,,-" 1-" '8)2+61-6" ,(,8,-6"2>" 6&,"
1-1(95'5"2>")0@('7" )2('7',5" >2+" 1" (2-:" 6'8,<" D-" &'5" )+,5,-616'2-" 2>" 6&," >18205" 1AB27179"
721('6'2-"72-7,)6."%10("=1@16',+"+,>,+5" 62" (,1+-'-:" 15" )1+6" 2>" WX6&," @+21A,+" )+27,55" 2>"
)2('79" 7&1-:,5" @9" 1-1(95'-:" 6&," 81--,+" '-" ?&'7&" ,('6,5" >+28" A'>>,+,-6" 1AB27179"
721('6'2-5":+1A01((9" 1(6,+" 6&,'+" @,(',>" 5956,85" 2B,+"6'8,.")1+6'1((9" 15" 1" +,50(6" 2>" >2+81("
)2('79"1-1(95'5"1-A" 6+'1(" 1-A" ,++2+" (,1+-'-:Y" Z=1@16',+" ![\\L" !$R]<" U(+,1A9" @,>2+,." @06"
,5),7'1((9"1>6,+."(,1+-'-:"&15"@,,-"50@G,76"62"1"B156"-08@,+"2>"1-1(95,5"1-A"@,,-"50@G,76"
62" A'>>,+,-6" 56+1-A5" 2>" +,5,1+7&." ?&'7&" ?," &1B," +,B',?,A" >2+" 6&," )+2G,76" '-" 1-26&,+"
+,)2+6"Z*+,'-"#R!^]<"
V,1+-'-:"'5"8256(9"15527'16,A"?'6&")2('79"7&1-:,<"K2+",Q18)(,."'-"&'5"5,8'-1("1+6'7(,"2-"
)2('79" )1+1A':85." %,6,+" M1((" )06" >2+?1+A" 6&+,," >2+85" 2>" )2('79" 7&1-:,L" K'+56" 2+A,+"
7&1-:,5."?&'7&",-61'("6&,"1A1)616'2-"2>",Q'56'-:"'-56+08,-65."5,72-A"2+A,+"7&1-:,5"6&16"
,-61'(" 6&," 1A1)616'2-" 2>" -,?" )2('79" '-56+08,-65" 1-A" 6&'+A" 2+A,+" 7&1-:,5." ?&'7&"
728)+'5," 2>" 1" 7&1-:," '-" 6&," &',+1+7&9" 2>" )2('79" '-56+08,-65<" *&,+,@9." 6&'+A" 2+A,+"
7&1-:,5"1+,"5'8'(1+"62"7&1-:,5"2>"6&,")2('79")1+1A':8"Z%<"U<"M1(("![[$L"#J\]."?&'7&"'5"6&,"
@15'7" >+18,?2+C" 2>" 'A,15" 1-A" 561-A1+A5" 1772+A'-:" 62" ?&'7&" 1" 527'1(" )+2@(,8" '5"
'-6,+)+,6,A"1-A" 6&,")2('79" 81A,"Z%<"U<" M1(("![[$L" #J[]<"_2+,"+,7,-6" 1))('716'2-"2>" 6&,"
>+18,?2+C" &1B," A'56'-:0'5&,A" 1" >20+6&" 2+A,+" 7&1-:,." ?&'7&" 52(,(9" >2705,5" 2-" 6&," 6&,"
1A1)616'2-"2>"2B,+1+7&'-:" 'A,15." ?&,+,15" 7&1-:,5" '-" 6&," &',+1+7&9" 2>" '-56+08,-65" 1+,"
72-5'A,+,A" 15" 6&'+A" 2+A,+" 7&1-:,5<" *&," A'>>,+,-7," @,6?,,-" 1" 6&'+A" 2+A,+" 7&1-:,"
1772+A'-:"62"M1((."1-A"1"6&'+A"2+A,+"7&1-:,"1772+A'-:"62"K1(C-,+"'5"6&16"6&,"(166,+"+,:1+A5"
6&'+A" 2+A,+" 7&1-:," 15" 6&," 7&1-:," 2>" &',+1+7&9" '-" )2('79" '-56+08,-65." '<,<" 6&," 6,7&-'71("
15),765" 2>" )2('7',5." @06" -26" -,7,551+'(9" 6&," @+21A,+" 'A,15" 6&16" :0'A,5" 1" 5,6" 2>" )2('79"
^"
"
'-56+08,-65<"D>"6&,"@+21A,+"'A,15"7&1-:,." 6&'5"?20(A"@,">20+6&"2+A,+"7&1-:,."1772+A'-:"
62" K1(C-,+<" /,+A1" K1(C-,+" ,Q,8)('>',5" 6&," A'>>,+,-7,5" 5&," A,>'-,5" @,6?,,-" 6&'+A" 1-A"
>20+6&"2+A,+"7&1-:,"?'6&"+,:1+A"62";O"1-6'`7+'5'5")2('7',5"ZK1(C-,+."#R!^]<"H2-6+1+'?'5,."
'-" &'5" 1-1(95'5" 2>" 817+2,72-28'7" )2('79" +,>2+8." %,6,+" M1((" '-6,+)+,65" 1" 7&1-:,"'-"6&,"
&',+1+7&9"'-")2('79"'-56+08,-65"15"1")1+1A':816'7"7&1-:,<""
D-"6&'5" +,)2+6." ?," 6+9" 62" A'5527'16," (,1+-'-:" >+28")2('79"7&1-:,<" D>" )2('79" 7&1-:,5." 6&'5"
A2,5"-26"8,1-"6&16"6&,+,"&15"@,,-"(,1+-'-:"'-"6&,"5,-5,"6&16"'--2B16'B,"'A,15"2-"&2?"62"
52(B,"1")+2@(,8")(19,A"1-"'8)2+61-6"+2(,">2+">2+80(16'-:"6&,"72-6,-65"2>")2('79"7&1-:,<"
D6"720(A" 1(52" @," 6&," 715," 6&16" 1762+5"2-(9"1A1)6,A" 1" )2('79" 1772+A'-:" 62" 6&,'+" ,(,762+1("
'-6,+,565."2+"6&16"6&,+,"6&,9"(,1+-")2('6'71((9"2-(9."-18,(9"62"1A1)6"6&,'+"56+16,:',5"62"5619"
'-")2?,+"16"6&,"7256"2>"-26"52(B'-:"6&,"17601(")+2@(,8<"
K2+"6&,")0+)25,"2>"6&'5"+,)2+6."?,"-,,A"62"7(1+'>9"?&16"?,"8,1-"?'6&"(,1+-'-:<"U(6&20:&"
6&,"('6,+160+,"2-")2('79"(,1+-'-:"'5"B156."6&,+,"'5"1-"'8)2+61-6"A'56'-76'2-"6&16"-,,A5"62"@,"
81A," ?'6&" +,:1+A" 62" (,1+-'-:<" a-" 6&," 2-," &1-A." 6&,+," '5" 2+:1-'N16'2-1(" 1-A" )2('6'71("
(,1+-'-:<"*&,5,"72-7,)65"+,>,+"62"6&,"0)A16,"2>"@,(',>5"2>" '-A'B'A01("2+"72((,76'B,"1762+5"
@15,A"2-"-,?"'A,15"2+"1"7,+61'-")+2@(,8")+,550+,."@06"?'6&"6&,'+"2?-")2?,+"'-6,+,565"'-"
8'-A<"D-"26&,+"?2+A5."(,1+-'-:"8,1-5"6&,"1A1)616'2-"2>"6&,"56+16,:9"62"+,81'-"'-")2?,+"
2+" 62" +,61'-" )2('6'71(" '->(0,-7,." 1(52" C-2?-" 15" b)2?,+'-:Y" ZM,7(2" ![JT]<" D-" 6&'5" 715,."
)2('7981C,+5" ?20(A" (,1+-" 1@2B," 1((" )2('6'71((9<" K2+" ,Q18)(,." '>" 1" )+2@(,8" 1)),1+5."
A,7'5'2-"81C,+5"?20(A"7&1-:,"6&,'+"@,(',>5"'-"1"?19"6&16"1((2?5"6&,8"62"5619"'-")2?,+<"
U-9"52(06'2-"62"6&,")+2@(,8"6&,9")+2)25,"?20(A"1@2B,"1((":01+1-6,,"6&,8"62"81'-61'-"
6&,'+" )2('6'71(" '->(0,-7,"Z325?,((" #RR[]<" a-" 6&," 26&,+" &1-A." 6&," )2('79" (,1+-'-:"
),+5),76'B," 15508,5" 6&16" )2('7981C,+5" 1+," 1@(," 62" (,1+-." 1-A" 1A1)6" 6&,'+" @,(',>5"
1772+A'-:"62"1")+2@(,8"6&16"-,,A5"62"@,"52(B,A."+16&,+"6&1-"?'6&"+,5),76"62"6&,'+"?1-6"62"
5619"'-")2?,+"Z3,--,66"1-A"M2?(,66"![[#c"41B'6,+"#R!^c"/'(1+A'",6"1(<"#RR[c"_19"![[#]<"
D-"26&,+"?2+A5." )2('7981C,+5")+'2+'6'N," )+2@(,8"52(B'-:" 2B,+")2?,+'-:"ZM2))," #R!!]<"
*&'5"?19"2>"(,1+-'-:"71-"2770+"'-"1"-08@,+"2>"?195L"
!< K'+56(9.",B'A,-7,">2+" -,?")2('7',5" 71-"@," :,-,+16,A">+28"+,5,1+7&"6&16"&15" @,,-"
0-A,+61C,-"1@+21A"2+"A28,56'71((9<"=07&"+,5,1+7&"71-">2+",Q18)(,"61C,"6&,">2+8"
2>" )'(26" )+2:+185." ,Q),+'8,-65" 2+" 5'8)(," 5616'56'71(" 5'80(16'2-5" Z_1+6'-" 1-A"
=1-A,+52-"![[[]<"
d"
"
#< =,72-A(9." (,1+-'-:" 71-" 61C," 6&," >2+8" 2>" 0)A16'-:" @,(',>5" @15,A" 2-" )2('79"
,Q),+',-7,"'-"26&,+"720-6+',5"2+"16"&28,<"K2+",Q18)(,")2('7',5"'-"6&,"518,">',(A"
6&16"?,+,"'8)(,8,-6,A"1@+21A"2+",Q),+',-7,5"2>"5'8'(1+"'-56+08,-65"'-"A'>>,+,-6"
)2('7',5" A28,56'71((9" Z/'(1+A'" #R!R]<" a6&,+" 6&1-" 72-A076'-:" +,5,1+7&" @,>2+,"
)066'-:"1")2('79"'-62")(17,."6&'5"?19"2>"(,1+-'-:"'5"2>6,-"@15,A"2-"6+'1("1-A",++2+"
)+'-7')(,." ?&'7&" 71-" S" 16" 6'8,5" S" &1B," 5':-'>'71-6" 527'1(" 1-A" ,72-28'7"
72-5,e0,-7,5"ZH<"_<"M1(("#R!!]<"
$< *&'+A(9." (,1+-'-:" 71-" 2770+" 15" 1" 72-5,e0,-7," 2>" 6&," '->(0,-7," 2>" '-6,+-16'2-1("
1762+5." 507&" 15" 6&," ;O<" D-" 6&," ;0+2),1-" 715,." 6&,+," 1+," 1" -08@,+" 2>" @'-A'-:"
:0'A,('-,5."@06"1(52" )+27,55,5"1'8'-:"62">256,+")2('79" (,1+-'-:"182-:56"8,8@,+"
5616,5." 507&" 15" 6&," a),-" _,6&2A" 2>" H22+A'-16'2-"Za_H]"Zf,'6('-" ,6" 1(<" #RR^]<"
M2?,B,+." A0," 62" )255'@(," >'-1-7'1(" +,60+-5" 6&16" 8':&6" @," 16617&,A" 62" 6&,"
728)('1-7," ?'6&" 6&,5," )+27,A0+,5." '6" '5"A'>>'70(6"62" G0A:," 6&," ('-," @,6?,,-"
B2(0-61+9"(,1+-'-:"1-A"6&,"728)('1-7,"?'6&"+0(,5<"
D-"6&'5"+,)2+6."?,"?1-6"62"0-A,+561-A"0-A,+"?&'7&"72-A'6'2-5")2('79"7&1-:,"2770+5"A0,"
62")2('79"(,1+-'-:."1-A"0-A,+"?&'7&"72-A'6'2-5."'6"&1)),-5"15"1"72-5,e0,-7,"2>")2('6'71("
(,1+-'-:." 2+" >2+" )2('6'71(" +,152-5" 2-(9." 507&" 15" 598@2('7" )2('7981C'-:<" *&,+,>2+,." ?,"
72-6+156")2('6'71("(,1+-'-:"?'6&")2('79"(,1+-'-:">2+"1-1(96'71(")0+)25,5<"*&,"6,+8"W)2('79"
(,1+-'-:Y" +,>,+5" 62" C-2?(,A:,." ?&,+,15" W)2('6'71(" (,1+-'-:Y" 17720-65" >2+" (,1+-'-:" 6&16"
72-7,+-5")2('6'71(" '-6,+,565<" H2-6+156'-:" 6&,5," 6?2" 72-7,)65" '-" 6&'5" ?19" '5" 1-"'A,1(`
69)'71("1))+217&."'-"6&,"g,@,+'1-"5,-5,"2>"6&,"6,+8"Zg,@,+"![\R]."1-A"'-"6&,"+,1('69"2>"
)2('6'71(" )+27,55,5." 6&,+," '5" 1(?195" 1" 8'Q60+," 2>" 6&,5," 6?2" >2+85" 2>" (,1+-'-:<"
E,B,+6&,(,55."?,"1+:0,"6&16"2))25'-:"6&,5,"6?2"69),5"2>"(,1+-'-:"'5"'8)2+61-6."@,7105,"
'6"),+8'65"62"A'5,-61-:(,"6&,"+,(16'2-5&')"2>")+2@(,8`52(B'-:"1-A")2('6'75"?'6&"+,:1+A"62"
6&,"'8)176" 2>"(,1+-'-:" 2-")2('79"7&1-:,<" =28,"82+," +,7,-6" 72-6+'@06'2-5"62" 6&,")2('79"
(,1+-'-:" ('6,+160+,"&1B," ?1+-,A" 62" -26" 0-A,+,56'816," 6&," )2('6'7'N16'2-" 2>" )2('79"
(,1+-'-:." -261@(9" @,7105," 171A,8'75" 6,-A" 62" 2B,+,56'816," 6&," '8)176" 2>" +,5,1+7&" 1-A"
-,?" 'A,15" 728)1+,A" 62" )2('6'71(" '-6,+,565<" Z325?,((" #RR[c" H&18)'2-" #R!$c" 41B'6,+"
#R!^L"T[[]<"*&'5"'5"1(("6&,"82+,")(105'@(,.":'B,-"6&16"72-A076'-:")2('79"+,(16,A"+,5,1+7&."
507&"15")'(26")+2G,765"2+",Q),+'8,-65">2+"(1@20+"81+C,6"+,>2+85."-,,A5"+,520+7,5."6'8,"
1-A" 561@(," 72-6,Q601(" 72-A'6'2-5<" h,6." 6&," )2('6'71(" @05'-,55" '-" 82A,+-" A,827+17',5" '5"
>156"82B'-:."1-A"?'-A2?5"2>"2))2+60-'69"2),-"1-A"7(25,"e0'7C(9<"*&,+,>2+,."'6"'5"-26"1(("
0-A,+5622A" 6&16" +,5,1+7&" +,50(65" 1+," 1B1'(1@(," ?&,-" -,,A,A" 1-A" 6&16" 6&," )2('6'71("
J"
"
1:,-A1"71-" @,")(1--,A" 1772+A'-:"62" 1"(,1+-'-:" )+27,55<"*&,+,>2+,."6&,",-B'+2-8,-6" 2>"
,B,+9A19" )2('6'75" A2,5" -26" -,7,551+'(9" )+2B'A," 6&,5," 72-A'6'2-5L" D6" '5" )255'@(," 6&16"
)2('7',5"7&1-:,"?'6&206"(,1+-'-:"6&16"'5"@15,A"2-"50@561-6'B,",B'A,-7,")(19'-:"1"+2(,<"D-"
2+A,+" 0-A,+561-A" 6&," '8)176" 2>" (,1+-'-:" 2-" )2('79" 7&1-:,." '6" '5" '8)2+61-6" 62" C,,)" '-"
8'-A" 6&16" 6&,+," 1+," A'>>,+,-7,5" @,6?,,-" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" 1-A" 7&1-:,<" g&,+,15" '6" '5"
A'>>'70(6"62"'81:'-,")2('79"(,1+-'-:"?'6&206"1-9"7&1-:,."7&1-:,5"'-")0@('7")2('7',5"71-"
728,"1(2-:"?'6&206" )2('79"(,1+-'-:<" D-">176.")2('79"(,1+-'-:"'5" -,'6&,+"1" 50>>'7',-6"-2+"1"
-,7,551+9"72-A'6'2-">2+")2('79"7&1-:,<""
D-"6&,">2((2?'-:."?,"1+,":2'-:"62"A'57055"72-A'6'2-5"6&16"8':&6"'8)176"2-"?&,6&,+")2('79"
(,1+-'-:" 1>>,765" )2('79" 7&1-:,." 2+" '>" +16&,+" )2('6'71(" >1762+5." 507&" 15" )2('6'71(" (,1+-'-:"
'8)1765"2-" 6&," 7&1-:," 2>" 1")2('79<"/'B,-" 6&16" 6&'5" +,)2+6" >2705,5"2-"1" -08@,+" 2>" B,+9"
A'>>,+,-6" +,>2+85" '-" A'>>,+,-6" )2('6'71(" 1-A" '-56'606'2-1(" 72-6,Q65." ?," 1+:0," 6&16" 6?2"
@+21A(9"72-7,'B,A">1762+5"1+,"'8)2+61-6L")+2@(,8")+,550+,"1-A"6&,"2B,+1((")2('6'7'N16'2-"
2>"1")+2@(,8<""
%+2@(,8")+,550+,"1-A")2('6'7'516'2-"
U(6&20:&" 6&," )2('6'71(" 57',-7," ('6,+160+," &15" ,8)&15'N,A" 6&," '8)2+61-7," 2>" 6&,"
72--,76'2-" @,6?,,-" (,1+-'-:" 1-A" 7&1-:,." )2('7',5" 71-" 7&1-:," A0," 62" &':&" )+2@(,8"
)+,550+,"?'6&206" 1-"17601("(,1+-'-:" &1)),-'-:" Z3,--,66"1-A" M2?(,66" ![[#c"H&18)'2-"
#R!$]."507&"15"'-"6'8,5"2>"7+'5'5"?&,-")2('6'7'1-5"-,,A"62">'-A"e0'7C"52(06'2-5"62"0+:,-6"
)+2@(,85" Z3+10-" #R!$]<" U-26&,+" )+2@(,8" +,:1+A'-:" 6&," '8)176" 2>" (,1+-'-:" '5" 6&,"
)2('6'7'516'2-" 2>" '550,5<" *&'5" 71-" ,'6&,+" (,1A" 62" )2('79" 7&1-:," ?'6&206" 1" &':&" )+2@(,8"
)+,550+,"@,'-:")+,5,-6.">2+",Q18)(,"?&,-")2('6'7'1-5"?1-6"62"A,82-56+16,"6&16"6&,9"WA2"
528,6&'-:Y<" 42'-:" -26&'-:" ?20(A" @," 6&,"?2+56" 2)6'2-" )255'@(,." @,7105," 6&'5" ?20(A"
5':-1(" 6&16" 1" )2('6'7'1-"'5"'-71)1@(,"'-" +,176'-:" 62" 1" 7+'5'5"Z32-2('" #R!#]<" a-" 6&," 26&,+"
&1-A."6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"'--2B16'B,"'A,15"'-62"-,?")2('7',5"8':&6"@,"'8),A,A"A0,"62"
,(,762+1("'-6,+,565."5),7'1("'-6,+,56")2('6'75"2+"5'8)(,"'-56'606'2-1("'-,+6'1<"
%+2@(,8")+,550+,"
%+2@(,85" 1+," 1-" '8)2+61-6" ,(,8,-6" 62" 6+'::,+" 1-9" (,1+-'-:" )+27,55." @,7105," 6&,9"
56'80(16," '-6,+,565" '-" 62)'75<" K+28" )2('79`81C,+5I" )2'-6" 2>" B',?." 1-" '550," -,,A5" 62" @,"
)+2@(,816'7"'-"2+A,+"62"@,"2>"72882-"'-6,+,56"1-A"A,81-A"+,:0(16'B,"2+"+,A'56+'@06'B,"
176'2-<" *&,+,>2+,." 1" 7,+61'-" 527'2`,72-28'7" )+2@(,8" )+,550+," 5&20(A" @," )+,5,-6." '-"
\"
"
2+A,+"62"56'80(16,"1"(,1+-'-:")+27,55"+,:1+A'-:"1"7,+61'-")2('79."507&"15"527'1(")2('79"2+"
,A0716'2-1(" )2('79" >2+" ,Q18)(," Z%<" U<" M1((" ![[$]<" F,:1+A'-:" (1@20+" 81+C,6" 1-A" 527'1("
)2('7',5"'-"6&,";O."1"-08@,+"2>")+2@(,8")+,550+,5"1)),1+,A"6&16"5&20(A"6+'::,+"(,1+-'-:"
)+27,55,5<"K'+56(9."6&,"A,82:+1)&'7"A,B,(2)8,-6"&15"1-"'8)176"2-"6&,")+2@(,8")+,550+,"
2-" ),-5'2-" 5956,85<" U:'-:" )2)0(16'2-5." (2?,+" @'+6&" +16,5" 1-A" (2-:,+" ('>," ,Q),761-79"
&1B,"-,7,55'616,A"62"+,>2+8"),-5'2-" 5956,85."'<,<"@9"+,A07'-:"6&,")255'@'('6',5">2+",1+(9"
+,6'+,8,-6"1-A" 62" '-7+,15," 6&," +,6'+,8,-6" 1:," '-" :,-,+1(<" =,72-A(9." '-" 528," 720-6+',5"
0-,8)(298,-6"+16,5" 1+," &':&,+" 6&1-" '-" 26&,+5.",5),7'1((9"9206&" 0-,8)(298,-6" B1+',5"
:+,16(9"@,6?,,-" 6&," ;0+2),1-" ,72-28',5<"*&'+A(9.",72-28'7" 1-A" >'571(" A9-18'75"&1B,"
)06" )+,550+," 2-" )2('7981C,+5<" ='-7," 6&," ![[R5." 81-9" a;H4" 720-6+',5" ?'6&" 8160+,"
?,(>1+,"5616,5"&1B,",-6,+,A"1"),+'2A"2>"@0A:,6"72-52('A16'2-."?&'7&")065")+,550+,"2-"
:2B,+-8,-6" >'-1-7,5" 62" >0+6&,+" 1A1)6"527'1(" )2('7',5"Zg1:57&1(" 1-A" g,-N,(@0+:,+"
#RR\]<"*&," ,72-28'7"1-A">'-1-7'1(" 7+'5'5" 1>6,+"#RR\" &15" 1::+1B16,A"6&'5" )+2@(,8" ,B,-"
82+,"1-A"'-7+,15,A">'571(")+,550+,5"2-"6&,"?,(>1+,"5616,<"
*&,-." ;0+2),1-" 720-6+',5" >17," 1" -08@,+" 2>" )2('6'71(" )+,550+,5" 6&16" )255'@(9" 1>>,76"
(,1+-'-:" 1-A" )2('79" 7&1-:,<" E261@(9." 6&,+," '5" 6&," 72882-" >'571(" )2('79." -261@(9" 6&,"
_1156+'7&6" 6+,16',5." ?&'7&" 7+,16,A"A,@6" 1-A" A,>'7'6" ('8'65" >2+" ;O" 8,8@,+5<" 40+'-:"6&,"
>'-1-7'1("1-A",72-28'7"7+'5'5."6&,5,"+,:0(16'2-5"&1B,"@,,-"6':&6,-,A"1:1'-."'-"6&,"(':&6"2>"
6&," 2-:2'-:" 7+'5'5" 2>" 6&," ;0+2),1-" ,72-289<" E261@(9." 6&,5," +,:0(16'2-5" )06" 528,"
)+,550+,5"2-" (1@20+" 81+C,6" 1-A" 527'1(" )2('7',5." @,7105," 6&,9" A'8'-'5&" 6&," (,B,+1:," 2>"
527'1(")2('7',5" ,B,-"82+,." )1+6'70(1+(9" ?&,-"'6" 728,5"62"5),-A'-:<" g&,+,15"@,>2+," 6&,"
7+'5'5" 81-9" 5616,5." -261@(9" K+1-7," 1-A" /,+81-9." '8)(,8,-6,A" 6&," >'571(" +0(,5" 2>" 6&,"
_1156+'7&6" 6+,16',5" -26" 56+'76" ,-20:&." 6&'5" &15" @,728," 82+," A'>>'70(6" -2?<" _2+,"
'8)2+61-6(9."6&," 7+,16'2-" 2>" 6&," ;0+2" 1-A" 6&," 6+1-5>,+" 2>" 82-,61+9" 52B,+,':-69" 62" 6&,"
;0+2),1-" H,-6+1(" 31-C" @9" ![" ;O`8,8@,+5" &1B,"61C,-" 1?19" 6&," )255'@'('69" 62"
1062-28205(9" 1AG056" 62" ,72-28'7" )+2@(,8" )+,550+,5" 05'-:" '-56+08,-65" 2>" 82-,61+9"
)2('79<"H2-5,e0,-6(9.":2B,+-8,-65"2>";0+2`5616,5"-,,A"62"1AG056"'-6,+-1((9"Z15"2))25,A"
62" ,Q6,+-1(." 82-,61+9" 1AG0568,-6]" 62" ,72-28'7" 1-A" >'571(" )+2@(,8" )+,550+," Zg1(6,+"
>2+6&728'-:]."?&'7&" '8)1765" 2-" 6&," 71)17'69" 62" (,1+-"15"?,(("15" 6&," 2)6'2-5" >2+")2('79"
7&1-:,"6&16"1+,"1B1'(1@(,<"
M2?,B,+."6&,+," 1+,"1(52" 52>6,+"'-7,-6'B,5" 62")2('79" (,1+-'-:" '-"6&," ;O."-18,(9"6&+20:&"
6&," '-56+08,-65" 6&16" 1+," @15,A" 2-" 6&," a_H" Za),-" _,6&2A" 2>" H22+A'-16'2-]<" *&'5"
["
"
'-56+08,-65" ,-61'(5" 80601(" +,B',?" 2>" )2('7',5" '-" 6&," 8,8@,+" 5616,5" 1-A" 1'85" 16"
56'80(16'-:" 80601(" (,1+-'-:" @,6?,,-" ;O" 8,8@,+5" @9" ),,+`+,B',?5." @,-7&81+C5" 1-A"
26&,+"'-A'7162+5"6&16"1((2?"62"728)1+,"6&,"720-6+',5I"52(06'2-5"62",8)(298,-6"1-A"26&,+"
527'1(")+2@(,85<"*&,":21("2>"6&'5"'-56+08,-6"'5"-26"62"722+A'-16,")2('7',5"'-"6&,"5,-5,"62"
+,17&" 1:+,,8,-65" 1-A" 72882-" 7288'68,-65." @06" '6" 1'85" 16" )2('79" 1AG0568,-6" @9"
(,1+-'-:">+28"26&,+"720-6+',5"+16&,+"6&1-",->2+7,1@(,"1:+,,8,-65"62"2-,"1-26&,+"2+"6&,"
;0+2),1-")+'-7')(,"Zf,'6('-" ,6" 1(<"#RR^]<" K'-1-7'1(" '-7,-6'B,5" 16"6&," ;O" (,B,(" 728,"'-62"
)(19" +16&,+" '-A'+,76(9." >2+" ,Q18)(," 6&+20:&" )+2G,765" 6&16" 1+," >0-A,A" @9" 6&," ;0+2),1-"
=27'1("K0-A"Z;=K]<"
*&,"+,(16'2-5&')"@,6?,,-" )+2@(,8")+,550+," 1-A"(,1+-'-:." ?,"1+:0,.":2,5" '-"6?2" ?195<"
a-"6&,"2-,"&1-A."1"7,+61'-")+2@(,8")+,550+,"-,,A5"62"@,")+,5,-6"'-"2+A,+">2+"(,1+-'-:"62"
61C,")(17,<"D>",B,+96&'-:"?2+C5" ?,((."?&9"5&20(A"6&,+," @,"1"5,1+7&">2+"@,66,+"52(06'2-5."
0-(,55" '6" '5" >2+" )2('6'71(" +,152-5i" M2?,B,+." (,1+-'-:" 61C,5" 6'8,." ,5),7'1((9" '>" '6" '5"
72-5'A,+,A" 15" (,1+-'-:" '-" 1-" 171A,8'7" 5,-5,<" *2" 7+,16," 50@561-6'B," ,B'A,-7," 2-"
1(6,+-16'B," 52(06'2-5" -,,A5" )16',-7,." +,520+7,5" 1-A" 528,&2?" 561@(," 72-A'6'2-5<"
M2?,B,+."6&,",72-28'7"1-A"6&,")2('6'71(",-B'+2-8,-65"8':&6"7&1-:,"e0'7C(9" 1-A"6&,+,"
720(A" @," -2" 82+," 6'8," >2+" (,1+-'-:<" K2+" ,Q18)(,." '-" 6'8,5" 2>" )2('6'71(" 1-A" ,72-28'7"
7+'5,5." 52(06'2-5" -,,A" 62" @," >20-A." @06" 2>6,-" 6&,+," '5" -2" 6'8," 62" (,1+-" @15,A" 2-"
50@561-6'B,",B'A,-7,<"D-"6&,5,"715,5.")2('79"7&1-:,"2770+5"'-"6&,"5,-5,"2>"6+'1("1-A",++2+"
1-A" A,7'5'2-" 81C,+5" 6,-A" 62" +,(9" 2-" 72:-'6'B," 5&2+67065." 507&" 15" @':" 720-6+',5" 2+"
'A,2(2:'71((9" 5'8'(1+" :2B,+-8,-65<" H2-5,e0,-6(9." 622" &':&" )+2@(,8" )+,550+," 5&20(A"
+,A07,"6&,",>>,76"2>")2('79"(,1+-'-:"2-">2+80(16'-:" '-56'606'2-5."16" (,156"'-" '65"171A,8'7"
5,-5," 1-A" (,1+-'-:" @,728,5" 1" 6+'1(" 1-A" ,++2+" :18," '-" +,1('69." ?'6&" )26,-6'1((9" >1+`
+,17&'-:",72-28'7"1-A"527'1("72-5,e0,-7,5<"
%2('6'7'516'2-"
*&," )2('6'7'516'2-" 2>" )+2@(,85" 1-A" 52(06'2-5" '5" 6&," 5,72-A" ,(,8,-6" 6&16" ?," -,,A" 62"
72-5'A,+" '-" 2+A,+" 62" 0-A,+561-A" 6&," '8)176" 2>" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" 2-" 7&1-:,<" a6&,+" 6&1-"
2+':'-16'-:" '-" ,B'A,-7,`@15,A" 'A,15" >2+" @,66,+" 52(06'2-5." )2('7981C,+5" 8':&6" 1A1)6"
)2('7',5."81'-(9"?'6&"6&,'+")2('6'71("'-6,+,565"'-"8'-A<"*&'5"A2,5"-26"8,1-"6&16"6&,+,"'5"-2"
,B'A,-7,`@15,A"(,1+-'-:."@06" '6" 8':&6" @," 6&," 715," 6&16" 507&" '->2+816'2-" '5" ':-2+,A." 2+"
05,A" 62" )+'81+'(9" 516'5>9" )2('6'71(" '-6,+,565" +16&,+" 6&1-" 62" 52(B,"1" )+2@(,8"Z325?,(("
#RR[c" /2(A56,'-" 1-A" P,2&1-," ![[$]<" *&,+,@9." '6" '5" '8)2+61-6" 62" C,,)" '-" 8'-A" 6&16"
!R"
"
)2('7981C,+5" 50::,56" 1-A" '8)(,8,-6" -,?" )2('7',5." 7(1'8'-:" 6&16" 6&,9" 1+," W-,?Y" 1-A"
W@,66,+Y"?'6&206"6&'5"@,'-:"50@561-6'1((9")+2B,-"@9"'-A,),-A,-6",B'A,-7,<"a>6,-."6&'5"'5"
-26")255'@(,"2+"-26">,15'@(,."A0,"62" 72-56+1'-65"2>"6'8,"1-A"+,520+7,5<"M2?,B,+.",B,-"'>"
6&,+,"'5"528,"50@561-6'B,",B'A,-7,"1B1'(1@(,">2+"@,66,+"52(06'2-5."2+"720(A"@,")+2A07,A"
?'6&" +,152-1@(," 6'8," 1-A" +,520+7,5." +,>2+85" 8':&6" @," '8)(,8,-6,A" 1-9?19" ?'6&206"
(,1+-'-:" S" 2+" '--2B16'B," 'A,15" 8':&6" @," 05,A" A'>>,+,-6(9" 6&1-" '-6,-A,A." 2+" 2-(9"
'8)(,8,-6,A")1+6'1((9">2+")2('6'71("+,152-5<"D6"'5"'8)2+61-6"62"72-5'A,+"6&'5")2('6'7'N16'2-"
2>")+2@(,85"'-"2+A,+"62"0-A,+561-A")2('79"7&1-:,<"Z41B'6,+"#R!^."T[[]"
M2?,B,+." &2?" 8':&6" 6&," )2('6'7'516'2-" 2>" )+2@(,85" '8)176" 2-" )2('79" 7&1-:,i"
%2('6'7'516'2-"8,1-5"6&16"1" )+2@(,8"'5"50@G,76"62" )2('6'71("72-6,5616'2-."8256(9"@,6?,,-"
561C,&2(A,+5."507&" 15"'-6,+,56" :+20)5.")2('6'71(" )1+6',5"2+"6&," @0+,107+179<"F16&,+" 6&1-"
7&1-:'-:" 1" )2('79" 1772+A'-:" 62" 6&," 'A,1" 6&16" )+2B'A,5" 6&," W@,56Y" 2+" W8256" )+28'5'-:Y"
52(06'2-" 62" 52(B," 1" :'B,-" )+2@(,8." A,7'5'2-`81C,+5" 5,,C" 62" >'-A" 1" 52(06'2-" 6&16" @,56"
5,+B,5"6&,'+",(,762+1(" '-6,+,565<"D-"715," 2>"527'1(")2('7',5."6&'5"71-"@,"62"-26"706"@,-,>'65"
A0,"62")2('6'71("+,152-5"1-A"62"81'-61'-"&':&"@,-,>'65."15"'6"&1)),-5"'-"6&,"715,"2>"&,1(6&"
71+,")2('7',5"ZM17C,+"#RRT]<"a-"6&,"26&,+"&1-A.")2('6'7'N16'2-"8':&6"1(52",-61'("598@2('7"
176'2-." >2+" ,Q18)(," @9" '8)(,8,-6'-:" +,>2+85" 6&16" 1+," -26" -,7,551+9." 2+" @9" 1B2'A'-:"
0-)2)0(1+"52(06'2-5" A0," 62" )2('6'71("+,152-5<" D-" 507&" 1" 715,." )+2@(,8" 52(B'-:" 2+',-6,A"
(,1+-'-:." @15,A" 2-" +,5,1+7&." 8':&6" :,6" 1" +1?" A,1(." A0," 62" )2('6'71(" 1-A" 'A,2(2:'71("
'-6,+,565<" D-" 26&,+" ?2+A5." )2('7981C,+5" 1A1)6" 52(06'2-5" '-" 1" ?19" 6&16" '6" A2,5" -26"
,-A1-:,+"6&,'+")2('6'71("'-6,+,565"Z%',+52-"![[T]<"K2+",Q18)(,."(,>6")1+6',5"?20(A"6,-A"62"
>1B20+"+,A'56+'@06'B,")2('7',5."@,7105,"6&,9"1+,"72-B'-7,A"6&16"6&'5"'5"6&,"@,56"'A,1.",B,-"
'>" 6&,+," '5" ,B'A,-7," 50::,56'-:" 1" @,66,+" 52(06'2-<" a>" 720+5,." 507&" 1" 56+16,:9" '5" 7(25,(9"
'-6,+6?'-,A"?'6&")1+69I5",(,762+1("'-6,+,565"ZU+8'-:,2-"#R!#]<" a-"6&," 26&,+"&1-A."'6" '5"
1(52")255'@(,"6&16")2('7981C,+5"7&25,"0-)2)0(1+"8,150+,5."@,7105,"6&,9"?1-6"62"52(B,"1"
7,+61'-")+2@(,8."1-A"71+," (,55"1@206" ,(,762+1("72-5,e0,-7,5."507&"15" '6"&1)),-,A" ?'6&"
6&," +,>2+8" 2>" 0-,8)(298,-6" 1-A" 527'1(" 155'561-7," Z72((2e0'1((9" C-2?-" 15" M1+6N" Dj"
+,>2+8]"'-"/,+81-9"ZK(,7C,-56,'-"#RR\]<"
D-" 6&'5" 72-6,Q6." '-56'606'2-5" 1+," '8)2+61-6." @,7105," '-" 528," 720-6+',5." 6&," )2('6'71("
5956,8"+,e0'+,5">'-A'-:"1"72-5,-505"182-:56" A'>>,+,-6"1762+5."'<,<" '-6,+,56":+20)5"-,,A"
@,'-:"&,1+A" >2+81((9." 6&,+," 1+," 6?2" )1+('18,-61+9" 7&18@,+5" 2+" 6&,+," '5" 1" B,+9" 176'B,"
72-56'606'2-1("720+6<"D-"6&'5"715,."?,"?20(A",Q),76"6&16"(,1+-'-:"61C,"1"5,72-A1+9"+2(,"'-"
!!"
"
6&,">2+80(16'2-"2>"A,7'5'2-5."@,7105,"6&,+,"1+,"81-9"'-6,+,565"6&16"-,,A"62"@,"61C,-"'-62"
17720-6<" M2?,B,+." 6&'5" A2,5" -26" -,7,551+'(9" -,,A" 62" &1)),-<" *&,+," 8':&6" @," (,1+-'-:"
@15,A" )2('79" 7&1-:,." A,5)'6," 81-9" '-56'606'2-1(" B,62" )2'-65<" D-" 507&" 1" 715,"2-(9" 6&,"
('C,('&22A" '-7+,15,5" 72-5'A,+1@(9" 6&16" 1" )+2@(,8" ?'((" @," )2('6'7'5,A<" M2?,B,+." 6&,"
('6,+160+," 2-" '-56'606'2-1(" 7&1-:," '-" 527'1(" )2('7',5" &15" 5&2?-" 6&16" :2B,+-8,-65" (,1+-"
1@2B," 1((" )2('6'71((9." @,7105," 6&,9" 6+9" 62" 1A2)6" )2('7',5" '-" 1"?19" 6&16" )+26,765" 6&,'+"
,(,762+1("'-6,+,565"ZM17C,+"#RR^c"%',+52-"![[T]<"
F,:1+A'-:" 527'1(" 1-A" (1@20+" 81+C,6" )2('7',5." 6&,+," 1+," 6&+,," ?195" '-" ?&'7&")2('7',5"
8':&6"@,")2('6'7'N,AL"
!< *&,">'+56"2-,"'5"6&,")1+6'51-"1+,-1<"V,>6"1-A"+':&6")1+6',5"20:&6"62"&1B,"A'>>,+,-6"
2)'-'2-5" 2-" +,>2+8'-:" 527'1(" )2('7',5." ?&'7&" 8':&6" '8)176" 2-" 6&," '->(0,-7," 2>"
,B'A,-7," 1-A" (,1+-'-:" 2-" )2('79" 52(06'2-5<" a-" 6&," 26&,+" &1-A." )1+6',5" 8':&6" '-"
:,-,+1("1:+,,"2-"1"52(06'2-."'<,<"(,>6" 1-A"+':&6")1+6',5"50))2+6"6&,"'-7+,15,"2>"6&,"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"Z=7&8'A6"![[d]<"
#< =,72-A(9." '-6,+,56" :+20)5." ,5),7'1((9" 527'1(" )1+6-,+5" 1+," '8)2+61-6<" /,-,+1((9"
5),1C'-:." 0-'2-5" 5&20(A" 50))2+6" 82+," :,-,+205" 527'1(" )2('7',5" ?&,+,15"
,8)(29,+5" 20:&6" 62" @," '-" >1B20+" 2>" (,55" +,:0(16,A" (1@20+" 81+C,65<" *&'5"
15508)6'2-5"1+," :,-,+1((9"C-2?-."&2?,B,+." 6&,9"8':&6"72-A'6'2-" 6&," '8)176"2>"
(,1+-'-:" 2-" )2('79" 7&1-:,." @,7105," 6&,5," 1762+5" &1B," 6&," '-6,+,56" 62" '->(0,-7,"
52(06'2-5"'-" 6&,'+" )+2),+" '-6,+,56<" g&16" '5" 82+,."6&,"720-6+9" +,)2+65" 5&2?" 6&16"
6&,"8,-6'2-,A"1762+5"&1B," 6&,'+"2?-" +,5,1+7&"7,-6+,5" '-"81-9" 2>"6&," 720-6+',5"
0-A,+" 2@5,+B16'2-" '-" 6&'5" +,)2+6" 1-A" 8':&6" 6&,+,>2+," 7288'55'2-" 6&,'+" 2?-"
+,5,1+7&"1-A",B'A,-7,"6&16"50))2+65"6&,'+")2'-6"2>"B',?<"a-"6&,"26&,+"&1-A."6&,9"
8':&6"1(52"(,1+-"1-A"7&1-:,"6&,'+"2)'-'2-"2-"7,+61'-")2('79"15),765<";B'A,-6(9."6&,"
1A1)616'2-" 2>" ,Q'56'-:" @,(',>5" 2-" )2('7',5" '5" 82+," ('C,(9" 72-7,+-'-:" 5,72-A1+9"
15),765" 6&1-" 17601(" )2('79" @,(',>5." ?&'7&" >1B20+5" 581((." @06" -2" @':" 7&1-:,5" 2>"
)2('7',5"Z=1@16',+"1-A"k,-C'-5`=8'6&"![[[L"!T^]<"
$< *&'+A(9.")2('6'71("'-56'606'2-5"71-"5&1),")2('79"(,1+-'-:<"=),7'>'71((9"6&,"A'>>,+,-7,"
@,6?,,-" 6&," 72-5,-501(" 2+" 81G2+'61+'1-" '-56'606'2-5" 8':&6" &1B," 1-" '8)176" 2-"
&2?"(,1+-'-:"&1)),-5"ZM,8,+'G7C"1-A"j'55,+"#RR$L"##]<"*&,+,@9."?,"1+,"1+:0'-:"
6&16" '-" 72-5,-501(" )2('6'71(" 5956,85." (,1+-'-:" 5&20(A" 2770+" @,>2+," 1" +,>2+8" '5"
'8)(,8,-6,A"?&,+,15"'-"81G2+'61+'1-"'-56'606'2-5"'6"'5"6&,"26&,+"?19"1+20-A<"*&,"
!#"
"
+,152-">2+"6&'5"'5" 6&16"72-5,-501(")2('6'71(" 5956,85."(,1+-'-:"2770+5" 62:,6&,+."'<,<"
6&+20:&"527'1(")1765<"*&,-."81-9"2>" 6&," 81'-" 1762+5" '-" 6&," )2('6'71(" 5956,8." '<,<"
)1+6',5." '-6,+,56" :+20)5" 1-A" 8'-'56+',5" @+'-:" 1(2-:" 6&,'+" 2?-" C-2?(,A:," >+28"
6&,'+"2?-"(,1+-'-:"622(5"1-A")+27,55,5<!"H2-5,e0,-6(9."(,1+-'-:"2770+5"15" 1")1+6"
2>"6&,"72-5,-505`@0'(A'-:")+27,55<"*&,+,@9."1762+5"-,,A"62"@,"72-B'-7'-:."?&'7&"
'5"?&9"6&,9"8':&6"-,,A"62")+,5,-6"?,(("+,5,1+7&,A"1+:08,-65.")255'@(9"2-,5"6&16"
1+," :+20-A,A" 2-" )2('79"+,(16,A" +,5,1+7&<" H2-6+1+'?'5,." 72-5,-501(" '-56'606'2-5"
720(A"A'(06," 1" )+,>2+8,A" 52(06'2-"6&+20:&",Q7,55'B," )2('6'7'516'2-" 2>" 1" )+2@(,8"
1-A"72-5,-505">2+816'2-<"D-"6&'5"715,."1"52(06'2-"8':&6"@,")2('6'71((9">,15'@(,."@06"
-26"B,+9",>>,76'B,."2+",B,-"A,6+'8,-61(.">+28"1")+2@(,8`52(B'-:"1))+217&<"a-"6&,"
26&,+" &1-A." '-" 81G2+'61+'1-" )2('6'71(" 5956,85" :2B,+-8,-6" 71-" A,7'A," 1(2-,<"
*&,+,>2+,." (,1+-'-:" 8':&6" 2770+" 1>6,+" 6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-" 2>" 1" +,>2+8." 8256(9"
A0+'-:"6&,",B1(016'2-")+27,55<""
*2" 508" 0)." '-" 6&'5" 5,76'2-" ?," A'57055,A" )255'@(," ,(,8,-65" 6&16" 8':&6" 56'80(16," 1-A"
'8),A,"6&," '8)176"2>" )2('79"(,1+-'-:" 2-")2('79"7&1-:,5<" g,"&1B," 1+:0,A"6&16" )+2@(,8"
)+,550+,.",'6&,+"2>"527'2`,72-28'7"2+")2('6'71("2+':'-."8':&6"'8)176"2-"?&,6&,+"(,1+-'-:"
61C,5")(17,"1-A"&2?"'6"'->(0,-7,5")2('79"7&1-:,<"%1+6'70(1+(9."?,")06">2+?1+A"6&,")2'-65"
6&16"6&,+," -,,A5" 62"@," 528," )+2@(,8")+,550+," '-" 2+A,+"62"56'80(16," (,1+-'-:." @06"6&16"
622"&':&")+2@(,8")+,550+," '8),A,5" 6&," '8)176" 2>" (,1+-'-:" 2-" 6&," 7&1-:,5" 2>" )2('7',5."
@,7105,"6&,-" 6&,+," '5" -2" 6'8," 62" '8)(,8,-6"6&,"W@,56Y" 52(06'2-" >2+" 6&," 72882-" :22A<"
g&16"'5"82+,."?,"&,(A"6&16")1+69"A'>>,+,-7,5"1-A"'-6,+,56":+20)5."15"?,(("15"72-5,-501("
'-56'606'2-5"'8)176"2-"&2?"2>"(,1+-'-:"1>>,765")2('79"7&1-:,<"
F,50(65L"V,1+-'-:"1-A")2('79"7&1-:,"
D-"6&,">2((2?'-:"5,76'2-."?,"1+,":2'-:"62"1-1(95,"6&,"'8)176"2>")2('79"(,1+-'-:.")+2@(,8"
)+,550+,5" 1-A"'550," )2('6'7'516'2-" 2-" (1@20+" 81+C,6" 1-A" 527'1(" )2('79" +,>2+85" '-" !!"
;0+2),1-"720-6+',5<"U5"8,-6'2-,A" @,>2+,."6&,",8)'+'71("@15'5">2+"6&,5,"+,)2+65" 1+,"6&,"
720-6+9" +,)2+65" 2-" (1@20+" 81+C,6" 1-A" 527'1(" )2('79" '--2B16'2-5" 6&16" -16'2-1(" ,Q),+6"
6,185" 72-A076,A<" ;17&" 6,18" ?15" )+2B'A,A" ?'6&" 1" 6,8)(16," 6&16" 72-61'-,A" :0'A,('-,5"
+,:1+A'-:" 6&," '->2+816'2-" 6&16" -,,A,A" 62" @," 72((,76,A" >2+" 6&," +,)2+65<" ;17&" 2>" 6&,"
720-6+9"6,185"1-1(95,A"(,1+-'-:"'-"6&+,,"'--2B16'2-5">+28"A'>>,+,-6"7(056,+5"6&16"?,+,"
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
!"g,"A'57055"6&,"(,1+-'-:"622(5"1-A")+27,55,5"2>",17&"720-6+9"'-"4^<T<"
!$"
"
5,(,76,A">+28"1"(1+:,"2B,+B',?"2>"+,>2+85<"
D-" 6&," >2((2?'-:." ?," 1+," :2'-:" 62" A'57055" 6&," 728)1+16'B," +,50(65" '-" 6&+,," 5,76'2-5<"
K'+56(9." ?," 1+," :2'-:" 62" ,B1(016," &2?" )+2@(,8" )+,550+," '-A07,A" (,1+-'-:" 1-A" :'B,"
,Q18)(,5" >+28" 6&," 715," 560A',5" 6&16" 5&2?" 0-A,+" ?&'7&" 72-A'6'2-5" )+2@(,8" )+,550+,"
5)1+C,A" (,1+-'-:" )+27,55,5" @9" )2('6'7'1-5" 1-A" :2B,+-8,-65<" D-" 6&," 5,72-A" )1+6" 2>" 6&,"
>'+56"50@5,76'2-." ?,"1+,":2'-:" 62"206('-,"0-A,+" ?&'7&"7'+708561-7,5")+2@(,8" )+,550+,"
(,1A5"62" )2('79"7&1-:,." @06"?'6&206"'-B2(B'-:" (,1+-'-:")+27,55,5<" D-"6&," 5,72-A")1+6"2>"
6&'5" +,)2+6." ?," 1+," :2'-:" 62" ,Q)(1'-" &2?" (,1+-'-:" )(195" 1" +2(," '-" 1:,-A1" 5,66'-:" 1-A"
A,7'5'2-`81C'-:"2>"(1@20+"81+C,6"1-A"527'1(")2('7',5<"D-"6&,"6&'+A"5,76'2-."?,"1+,":2'-:"
62"206('-,"&2?"6&,")2('6'7'516'2-"2>")+2@(,85"'8),A,5"6&16"(,1+-'-:",>>,765"'->(0,-7,"2-"
52(06'2-5"1-A"&2?")2('6'71("1:,-A1I5" '8)176,A" )2('79" 7&1-:," +16&,+" 6&1-" (,1+-'-:" 1-A"
)+2@(,8" 52(B'-:<" U" 5956,816'7" 2B,+B',?" 2>" 1((" '--2B16'2-5" 1-A" 6&," (,1+-'-:" 6&16" ?15"
16617&,A"62"6&,8"71-"@,">20-A"'-"6&,"1--,Q"2>"6&'5"+,)2+6<"
%+2@(,8")+,550+,"1-A"(,1+-'-:"
*&,"+,(16'2-"@,6?,,-")2('79"(,1+-'-:"1-A")+2@(,8")+,550+,"71-"61C,"6?2">2+85<"K'+56(9."
)+2@(,8" )+,550+," 71-" ':-'6," )2('79" (,1+-'-:." @,7105," 6&,+," -,,A5" 62" @," 528," 52+6" 2>"
0-52(B,A"'550,"6&16" '5"+,(,B1-6" >2+")2('7981C,+5" 1-A"6&16" -,,A5"1AA+,55'-:" '-"2+A,+"62"
'8)+2B," 6&," 72882-" :22A<" =,72-A(9." )+2@(,8" )+,550+," 71-" 1(52" @," )+2@(,816'7" >2+"
)2('79"(,1+-'-:.",5),7'1((9"?&,-"'6"'5"B,+9"&':&.">2+",Q18)(,"?&,-"6&,",72-28'7"5'6016'2-"
-,7,55'616,5" '88,A'16," +,176'2-" @9" )2('7981C,+5" 1-A" 6&,+," '5" -2" 6'8," 62" 5,,C" 1-A"
,B1(016,"6&,"@,56"52(06'2-"@,>2+,"'8)(,8,-6'-:"1"81G2+"+,>2+8<"
%+2@(,8")+,550+,"71-"@,"72-A07'B,"62"(,1+-'-:"
*&," >'+56" +,50(6" 6&16" ?," 71-" +,6+',B," >+28" 6&," 728)1+16'B," 1-1(95'5" 2>" 6&," 720-6+9"
+,)2+65"2>"?2+C")17C1:,">'B,"'5"6&16"6&,+,"'5"1"72--,76'2-"@,6?,,-")+2@(,8")+,550+,"1-A"
(,1+-'-:." '-" 6&," 5,-5," 6&16" 7&1-:,5" '-" 6&," 527'2`,72-28'7" 2+" )2('6'71(" ,-B'+2-8,-6"
6+'::,+,A" (,1+-'-:" )+27,55,5" 2>" )2('7981C,+5" 1-A" 561C,&2(A,+5" 6&16" 5,1+7&,A" >2+" -,?"
52(06'2-5" 62" )+2@(,85." 61C'-:" '-62" 17720-6" ,B'A,-7," 6&16" '5" >2+" ,Q18)(," @15,A" 2-"
5616'56'71("1-1(95'5.")'(26")+2G,765"2+"'-A,),-A,-6",Q),+6'5,<"
*&'5"72--,76'2-"@,6?,,-")+2@(,8")+,550+,"1-A"(,1+-'-:"71-"@,">20-A")1+6'70(1+(9"?'6&"
+,:1+A" 62" 6&," +,>2+8" 2>" ),-5'2-" 5956,85" '-" ;0+2),1-" 720-6+',5<" K2+" ,Q18)(,." '-"
!T"
"
/,+81-9."'-6,+,56":+20)5.")2('6'71(")1+6',5"1-A" 8,8@,+5"2>"6&," 1A8'-'56+16'2-"+,1('N,A"
1(+,1A9"'-"6&,"![[R5"6&16"6&,"/,+81-"W70(60+,"2>",1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6Y"-,,A5"62"@,"+,>2+8,A"
'-"2+A,+"62" C,,)" 6&," ),-5'2-" 5956,8" 50561'-1@(,<" H2-5,e0,-6(9." 1" 5,1+7&" >2+" 52(06'2-5"
@,:1-."?&'7&"?15">2((2?,A"@9"1"-08@,+"2>"1A1)616'2-5"2>"6&,"),-5'2-"5956,8<"='8'(1+(9"
52"'-"6&," E,6&,+(1-A5"1-A" '-"3,(:'08<"4067&":2B,+-8,-65"@,:1-" 62"0-A,+561-A" A0+'-:"
6&,"![[R5."6&16"6&,"720-6+9l5"),-5'2-"5956,8"-,,A5"62"@,"7&1-:,A."&2?,B,+"'6"622C"0-6'("
#RR\">2+"6&,":2B,+-8,-65"62" 561+6" 1" +,>2+8" )+27,55." @,7105," 6&," 7+'5'5" 2),-,A" 1" -,?"
?'-A2?"2>"2))2+60-'69"ZU1" ,6"1(<"#R!^]<" 3,(:'08"'5"1-26&,+" ,Q18)(,."?&,+,"'-7+,15'-:"
)+2@(,8" )+,550+,." '<,<" 1:'-:" )2)0(16'2-." 6+'::,+,A" 1" (,1+-'-:" )+27,55<" D-6,+,56'-:(9"
&2?,B,+."6&,";O")(19,A"1"+,(16'B,(9"'8)2+61-6"+2(,"'-"6&,"3,(:'1-"715,."-261@(9"6&+20:&"
'65";0+2),"#R#R"56+16,:9."?&'7&"5,6"1"61+:,6",8)(298,-6"+16,">2+"6&,",(A,+(9<"K2((2?'-:"
6&,"50::,56'2-5"@9" 6&,";O" 7288'55'2-."6&,"4'"F0)2":2B,+-8,-6" 7+,16,A"1" 7288'55'2-"
>2+"),-5'2-"+,>2+8"6&16"520:&6"62">'-A"52(06'2-5"2-"&2?"62"'8)+2B,"6&,",8)(291@'('69"2>"
),-5'2-,+5<"
U"5,72-A",Q18)(,"?&,+,")+2@(,8")+,550+,"6+'::,+,A"(,1+-'-:")+27,55,5"1+,"'-"6&,"1+,1"
2>" 8'-'808" ?1:,5." '-" /,+81-9." @06" 1(52" '-" 6&," OP<" D-" /,+81-9." 6&," 72B,+1:," 2>"
5077,55>0((9" 7(25,A" 72((,76'B," @1+:1'-'-:" 1:+,,8,-65" +,A07,A" :+1A01((9" 5'-7," 6&," 8'A`
![[R5" 1-A" 6&,+," ?15" 1" 72-5'A,+1@(,"A'>>,+,-7," '-"?1:,5" 72B,+1:,5" @,6?,,-" ;156" 1-A"
g,56"/,+81-9<" U5"1" 72-5,e0,-7,." 0-'2-5"1-A" 1(52" 6&,"527'1(" A,827+16'7")1+69")06" 6&,"
8166,+" 2-" 6&," )2('6'71(" 1:,-A1<" M2?,B,+." @,>2+," 6&," +,>2+8" 720(A" @," '8)(,8,-6,A." 1"
(,1+-'-:")+27,55" 622C" )(17,."15"?," ?'((" ,Q)(1'-" '-" 6&,">2((2?'-:"5,76'2-<" F,:1+A'-:" 6&,"
OP."6&,"'550,"2>"1"-16'2-1("8'-'808"?1:,",-6,+,A"6&,"-16'2-1(")2('6'71("1:,-A1" A0+'-:"
6&,"![\R5."A0," 62" 6&," +'5'-:" '-5,70+'6',5" 2-" 6&," (1@20+" 81+C,6" >2((2?'-:" ('@,+1('516'2-"
+,>2+85" 15" ?,((" 15" '-7+,15'-:" :(2@1('516'2-" 1-A" '65" '8)176" 2-" 6&," A28,56'7" (1@20+"
81+C,6<"h,6."1>6,+"6&," )+2@(,8"&1A"@,,-")06" 2-"6&,")2('6'71("1:,-A1."(,1+-'-:"2770++,A<"
;5),7'1((9."6&,+,"?,+,"1"-08@,+"2>",B1(016'2-5"1(52"@15,A"2-"6&,",Q),+',-7,"'-"6&,"O<=<."
@,>2+,"6&,"V1@20+")1+69")06"6&,")+2@(,8"2-"'65")2('6'71("1:,-A1<"
U"6&'+A" ,Q18)(,">2+" )+2@(,8" )+,550+,"6+'::,+'-:" )2('79"(,1+-'-:"'5" 9206&",8)(298,-6."
?&'7&"@,718,"2@B'205" 560A9'-:" '--2B16'2-5" '-" 6&+,," 720-6+',5." -261@(9" D61(9." =?,A,-."
1-A"=?'6N,+(1-A<"3,:'--'-:"?'6&"6&,"(166,+."6&,"=?'55",72-289"?,-6"6&+20:&"1"5&2+61:,"
2>" 6+1'-'-:" )(17,5" >2+" 920-:" )0)'(5" '-" 6&," ![[R5." ?&'7&" 6+'::,+,A" 1" (,1+-'-:" 1-A" 6&,"
155,558,-6"2>" -,?" 2)6'2-5" >2+" 6+1'-'-:" 0-,8)(29,A" 9206&<" D-" =?,A,-." 6&," -08@,+" 2>"
!^"
"
0-,8)(29,A"9206&"'-7+,15,A" 72-5'A,+1@(9">2((2?'-:" 6&,"#RRR5<"*&'5")+2@(,8")+,550+,"
7105,A" 528," (,1+-'-:" ,>>,765." >2+" ,Q18)(," 6&," 5,1+7&" >2+" -,?" 'A,15" 1@+21A<" D-" 6&16"
72-6,Q6.")2('7981C,+5"622C"'-5)'+16'2-">+28"1@+21A."-261@(9"6&,"'A,1"+,:1+A'-:"6&,"G2@"
:01+1-6,,">2+"9206&")+2:+18." ?&'7&"1'8,A"16"6+1'-'-:"920-:"0-,8)(29,A"1-A"62")(17,"
6&,8" '-" G2@5" ?15" '-5)'+,A" @9" 5'8'(1+" ,Q),+',-7,5" '-" 4,-81+C" 1-A" 6&," OP<" U-26&,+"
,Q18)(,">2+"(,1+-'-:")+27,55,5"6&16">2((2?,A"9206&"0-,8)(298,-6"71-"@,">20-A"'-"D61(9<"
D-" 6&'5" 715,." 6&," 81'-" )+2@(,8" ?15" 1" (17C" 2>" 6+1-5>,+" 2>" 920-:" 1A0(65" >+28"
1))+,-6'7,5&')5" 62" 6&," (1@20+" 81+C,6." ?&'7&" (,1A" 62" 1" -08@,+" 2>" 1A1)616'2-5" 2>" 6&,"
1))+,-6'7,5&')")+2:+18">2+"920-:"1A0(65."-261@(9"'-"#RR$."#R!!"1-A"#R!$<"*&,"'A,15">2+"
6&," #RR$" +,>2+8" ?,+," 61C,-" >+28" 6&," K+,-7&" 82A,(" 2>" 6,+6'1+9" &':&,+" ,A0716'2-."
?&,+,15"A0+'-:"6&," 7+'5'5.")2('7981C,+5"60+-,A" 62"/,+81-9"'-"2+A,+"62" :16&,+"'A,15"62"
+,>2+8"6&,"D61('1-"5956,8"2>"1))+,-6'7,5&')5<"
*&,-" 6&,+," '5" 1" 5,72-A" >2+8" 2>" )+2@(,8" )+,550+,." ?&'7&" &15" @,,-" 72-A07'B," 62"
:2B,+-8,-6"(,1+-'-:." '-"6&," 5,-5,"6&16"&,(),A" 62")06" 7,+61'-")+2@(,85"2-" 6&,"-16'2-1("
)2('6'71("1:,-A15<"E261@(9."6&'5"?15"6&,"'8)176"2>"52>6")2('6'71(")+,550+,"728'-:"206"2>";O"
:2B,+-1-7,."-261@(9"6&,")1+6'7')16'2-"'-"a_H5<"K2+",Q18)(,"6&,"3,(:'1-"),-5'2-"+,>2+8."
15" ?,((" 15" 6&," 9206&" ,8)(298,-6" )(1-" ?15" '-7,-6'B'N,A" -26" 2-(9" @9" 6&," )+2@(,8"
)+,550+,5." @06" 1(52" ;O" :0'A,('-,5<" ='8'(1+(9" '-" =)1'-." 6&," ;O" )06" 528," '550,5" 2-" 6&,"
1:,-A1."'<,<"6&,"176'B,"'-5,+6'2-")+2:+18."?&'7&"?15" A,>'-,A">2((2?'-:";O":0'A,('-,5"'-"
#RRR"1-A" 6&,-">0((9" ,561@('5&,A"'-"#RRd<" *&,"518," 2770++,A"?'6&" +,:1+A"62" 6&,"D61('1-"
+,>2+8"2>")0@('7",8)(298,-6"5,+B'7,5<"
*22"&':&")+2@(,8")+,550+,"'8),A,5"(,1+-'-:",>>2+65"
M2?,B,+." )+2@(,8" )+,550+," A2,5" -26" -,7,551+'(9" (,1A" 62" )2('79" (,1+-'-:." @06" 71-" 1(52"
&1B,"6&,"72-6+1+9",>>,76."-18,(9"62"'8),A,"(,1+-'-:"@9")2('79"81C,+5<"E261@(9."6&'5"'5"6&,"
715," ?&,-" )+2@(,85" 1+," B,+9" )+,55'-:." >2+" ,Q18)(," 0-,8)(298,-6" +'5,5" B,+9" >156." 2+"
A,@65"'-"527'1(" '-50+1-7,5"1+,"622" &':&"1-A" '88,A'16,"176'2-"'5" -,7,551+9<"D-"6&'5"715,."
)2('7981C,+5"?1-6"62"'8)(,8,-6"52(06'2-5"e0'7C(9"1-A"6&,+,"'5"1"6,-A,-79"62"(,55"'8)176"
2>" (,1+-'-:<" *&," '-6,-6'2-" 2>" e0'7C" +,176'2-5" 1+," >'+56" 2>" 1((" 62" 52(B," 6&," )+2@(,8." @06"
)2('79"81C,+5"?1-6"1(52"62")+,5,-6"6&,85,(B,5"15"@,'-:"176'B,"'-"6'8,5"2>"7+'5'5<"D-"6&,5,"
5'6016'2-5."6&,+,"'5"('66(,"6'8,">2+"(,1+-'-:<"H2-5,e0,-6(9."6&,"A22+"'5"2),-">2+")2('6'71((9"
+16&,+."2+",B,-"W)1-'7"A+'B,-Y"6&1-")+2@(,8`2+',-6,A"52(06'2-5<"
!d"
"
*&'5"+,(16'2-5&')"@,6?,,-")+2@(,8")+,550+,"1-A"6&,"1@5,-7,"2>"(,1+-'-:"'5"2-,"6&16"?,"
71-" 2@5,+B," A0+'-:" 6&," :(2@1(" >'-1-7'1(" 1-A" ,72-28'7" 7+'5'5" 15" ?,((" 15" '65" 1>6,+816&5<"
_256"-261@(9"'-"6&16"5,-5,"1+," 6&,",Q18)(,5">2+"(1@20+"81+C,6"+,>2+85"'-"/+,,7,<"M':&"
)+2@(,8")+,550+," '5"2@B'205" '-"6&,"/+,,C" 715,."-261@(9" ,Q6+,8,(9"&':&"0-,8)(298,-6"
+16,5." 0-50561'-1@(," A,@6" 1-A" '-50>>'7',-6" 527'1(" @,-,>'65<" g&16" '5" 82+,." 6&,+," '5"
72-5'A,+1@(,")2('6'71(")+,550+,">+28"6&,";0+2),1-"H,-6+1("31-C."6&,";O"H288'55'2-"1-A"
6&," D_K" 62" 1A1)6" (1@20+" 81+C,6" 1-A" 527'1(" )2('7',5" '-" 2+A,+" 62" 8,,6" >'571(" 1'85<" *&'5"
72-6,Q6" &15" (,A" 62" -08@,+" 2>" >1+" +,17&'-:" +,>2+85<" E261@(9." 6&,5," 1AG0568,-65" ?,+,"
6,8)2+1(",8)(298,-6">2+")0@('7"@,-,>'6."?&'7&")+2B'A,A"G2@"5,,C,+5"?'6&" 1"6,8)2+1+9"
G2@"6&16" 1((2?,A"6&,8">2+" ,Q18)(,"62"7(,1-" 56+,,65<"U"5,72-A" +,>2+8",-61'(5"1" B207&,+"
57&,8,"62">'-1-7,"6,8)2+1+9"6+1'-'-:"2>"0-,8)(29,A"'-")+'B16,"728)1-',5"6&16"?15"5,6"
0)"'-"#R!!<"*&,"6&'+A"+,>2+8"?15"1-"'-7+,15,"2>" 6&,">0(("+,6'+,8,-6"1:,."?&'7&",-6,+,A"
'-62">2+7," '-" #R!^<"D-" 1((" 2>"6&,5,"+,>2+85." (,1+-'-:" A'A"-26" 5,,8" 62")(19"1-" '8)2+61-6"
+2(,." 1(6&20:&" 6&," 72-6,-65" 2>" 6&,5," +,>2+85" &1A" @,,-" )06" 2-" 6&," 1:,-A1" 2>" /+,,C"
)2('7981C,+5"1"(2-:"6'8,"1:2.",'6&,+"@9"+,7288,-A16'2-5">+28"6&,";O"2+"6&,"a;H4<"g,"
720(A"1+:0,"6&16"G056"@,7105,"6&,5,"+,>2+85"?,+,"'8)(,8,-6,A"A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5.")2('79"
(,1+-'-:" '5" )+,5,-6<" M2?,B,+." +16&,+" 6&1-" (,1+-'-:" >+28" 72-B'-7'-:" ,B'A,-7,."
)2('7981C,+5"728)(',A"?'6&"6&,"b50::,56'2-5b"2>",Q6,+-1("1762+5."5'-7,"'6":01+1-6,,A"6&,"
72-6'-016'2-"2>">0-A5"1-A"(21-5"62"@,")1'A<"M2?,B,+."6&,5,")2('7',5"?,+,"-26"50@G,76"62"
6+'1(5"2+"26&,+",B'A,-7,`@0'(A'-:"'-"/+,,7,"'65,(>"@,>2+,"6&,9"?,+,")06"'-62"(,:'5(16'2-<"D-"
26&,+"?2+A5."81-9"2>"6&,"7+'5'5")2('7',5"718,"'-62",>>,76"15"1"72-5,e0,-7,"2>"728)('1-7,."
+16&,+" 6&1-" B2(0-61+9" (,1+-'-:." 15" '6" &1A" @,,-" 1))(',A"'-" 6&," a_H<" *&," )2('7',5"
'8)(,8,-6,A"'-"/+,,7," ?,+,"-26" 6&,"+,50(6" 2>"1"A'(':,-6"(,1+-'-:")+27,55."@06">2((2?,A"
6&,"82A,(":'B,-"@9"6&," D_K."1-A" 6&,";O." ?'6&206"6,56'-:" ?&,6&,+"6&,9" ?20(A"9',(A" 6&,"
A,5'+,A" +,50(65." '-" 6&," /+,,C" 72-6,Q6<" K2+" 6&," /+,,C" :2B,+-8,-65." 6&," 7&2'7," ?15" 62"
>2((2?",Q6,+-1((9"50::,56,A")2('7',5."2+"62"+'5C"@,'-:",Q7(0A,A">+28"6&,"715&`>(2?"2>"6&,"
;0+2N2-,."?'6&"A,6+'8,-61(",72-28'7"1-A"527'1("72-5,e0,-7,5<"
=)1'-" '5" 1-26&,+" ,Q18)(," 2>" (1@20+" 81+C,6" +,>2+85" '-" 6'8,5" 2>" 6':&6" 7+'5'5" )+,550+,5<"
E261@(9."6&," 6,8)2+1+9" 155'561-7," 57&,8," 62" 50))2+6"+,'-5,+6'2-"'-" 6&," G2@" 81+C,6" 15"
?,((" 15" 6&," 56+16,:9" 62" ,-720+1:," ,-6+,)+,-,0+5&')" 1-A" 5,(>`,8)(298,-6" >2+" 920-:"
0-,8)(29,A"'5",Q18)(,5"2>"7&1-:,"?'6&206"(,1+-'-:<"326&"8,150+,5" 718,"'-62">2+7,"'-"
6&," 72-6,Q6" 2>" ,Q6+,8,(9" &':&" 0-,8)(298,-6." ,5),7'1((9" 9206&" 0-,8)(298,-6" A0+'-:"
6&,"7+'5'5<"%1+6'70(1+(9" 6&,"6,8)2+1+9"155'561-7,"57&,8,"Z'-" 6&,"%F;%UFU" )+2:+188,]"
!J"
"
'5"1-"'-6,+,56'-:"'((056+16'2-"2>")2('79"7&1-:,"?'6&206"(,1+-'-:."@,7105,"A,7'5'2-"81C,+5"
A,7'A,A"62" '8)(,8,-6"'6" A,5)'6,"6&,">176" 6&16"1" )+,B'205"5'8'(1+")+2:+188," &1A"&1A" 1"
(2?"'8)176<"=0@5,e0,-6",B1(016'2-5"2>"6&,")+2:+18"5&2?,A"6&16"'6"&1A"1"?,1C"'8)176"2-"
+,'-5,+6'-:" +,7')',-65" '-62" 6&," (1@20+" 81+C,6<" *&," 56+16,:9" 62" ,-720+1:,"
,-6+,)+,-,0+5&')" 1-A" 5,(>`,8)(298,-6" >2((2?,A" ;O`56+16,:',5" 2-" 9206&" ,8)(298,-6<"
M0-:1+9"5&2?5"5'8'(1+"A9-18'75"A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5."?&,-"6&,":2B,+-8,-6"'8)(,8,-6,A"1"
)16&?19"62" ?2+C"57&,8,"Z#RR[]" 1-A"1" -,?" (1@20+"72A," Z#R!!]<" 326&"+,>2+85" A'A"-26"
2+':'-16," '-" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" ,>>2+65." @06" 2-(9" 6&," )+,550+," 2>" 6&," 7+'5'5" 2-" 6&," -16'2-1("
,72-289<" %2('79" (,1+-'-:" '-" 6&," 5,-5," 6&16" ,Q),+'8,-65" ?,+," 72-A076,A" 2+" 6&,"
,Q),+',-7,"2>"26&,+"720-6+',5"?15" )+2>20-A(9",B1(016,A"A'A"-26"720-6">2+"6&,"1A2)6'2-"
2>"6&," +,>2+8<"K2+" ,Q18)(,"+,:1+A'-:" 6&,"(1@20+" 72A,."?&'7&" ?,1C,-,A"6&,"M0-:1+'1-"
O-'2-5",B,-">0+6&,+."2-(9"(,:1("e0,56'2-5"?,+,"'8)2+61-6">2+"6&,":2B,+-8,-6<"
*&," +,)2+65" 5&2?" 1(52" '-561-7,5" 2>" (,1+-'-:" 1>6,+" +,>2+85" &1A" @,,-" '8)(,8,-6,A<" D-"
6&,5," 715,5." :2B,+-8,-65" 'A,-6'>',A" 1" )+2@(,8" )+,550+,." '8)(,8,-6,A" 1" 52(06'2-" 1-A"
,B1(016,A"1-A"1A1)6,A"6&,")2('7',5"1>6,+"6&16<"*&'5"2770++,A">2+",Q18)(,"'-"=?'6N,+(1-A<"
*&,"720-6+9I5" ,72-289" ?,-6" 6&+20:&"1"+,7,55'2-" A0+'-:" 6&," ,1+(9"![[R5." ?&'7&" 718,"
1(2-:"?'6&"1"+,A076'2-"2>"1B1'(1@(,")(17,5">2+"1))+,-6'7,5&')5">2+"920-:"),2)(,<"D-"#RR#."
6&," -16'2-1(" )1+('18,-6" 1A2)6,A" 1" +,B'5'2-" 2>" 6&," ,Q'56'-:" j2716'2-1(" ;A0716'2-" 1-A"
*+1'-'-:"(1?."?&'7&",-61'(,A"182-:56"26&,+5"1"7,-6+1('516'2-"2>"6&,",Q'56'-:"+,:0(16'2-5"
+,:1+A'-:"B2716'2-1("6+1'-'-:<"*&,"52(06'2-" >2+"6&,"(1?"?15" @15,A"2-"50::,56'2-5"81A,"
@9",Q),+6"7288'55'2-5."&2?,B,+"6&,+,"?,+,"-2")'(26")+2G,765",67<"V,1+-'-:">+28",Q),+65"
2770++,A"1>6,+"6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"6&,"(1?."'-"6&,"720+5,"2>"1-",B1(016'2-"'-"#RRJ<"*&,"
+,)2+6" 2-" (1@20+" 81+C,6" +,>2+85" '-" =?,A,-" 2@5,+B,A" 1" 5'8'(1+" A9-18'7." -261@(9"
+,:1+A'-:"6&,"1A1)616'2-"2>"176'B'69"728),-516'2-"1-A"6&,"+,>2+8"2>"9206&",8)(298,-6"
(,:'5(16'2-<"D-"#RRJ."6&,":2B,+-8,-6"+,>2+8,A",(':'@'('69">2+"176'B'69"728),-516'2-">+28"
![`$R"9,1+5."@06",(':'@'('69"72-A'6'2-5"@,718,"56+'76,+<"E261@(9."6&,"@,-,>'65"?,+,"+,(16,A"
62"528,")1'A"?2+C"1-A"155,558,-6"72-A'6'2-5"@,718,"6':&6,+<"V,1+-'-:"2770++,A"A0+'-:"
6&,")+27,55"2>" )2('79" '8)(,8,-616'2-<" K2+" ,Q18)(,." '-" #RR\." 6+'1(5" ?'6&" )+'B16," 1762+5"
?,+," '-6+2A07,A" 1-A" '-" #R!!." 1-" ,B1(016'2-" A,82-56+16,A" 6&16" 1(6&20:&" 1))('716'2-"
+16,5" &1A" A20@(,A." )(17,8,-6" +16,5" +,81'-,A" (2?<" U" 5'8'(1+" 56+0760+," 2770++,A" ?'6&"
+,:1+A"62"6&,"G2@":01+1-6,,")+2:+18">2+"6&,"9206&."?&'7&"?15"7+,16,A"'-"#RRd."A0,"62"1"
&':&"+16,"2>"0-,8)(29,A"9206&<"*&,"'A,15">2+"6&,")+2:+18"2+':'-16,A"'-"26&,+"720-6+',5."
>2+",Q18)(," '-" 4,-81+C"1-A" 6&," OP<"M2?,B,+."6+'1(5" ?,+," -26"81A,." @06" 6&,")+2:+18"
!\"
"
?15",B1(016,A"1>6,+"'8)(,8,-616'2-<"
However,!the! reports!reveal! a!number! of! instances,! in! which!the! crisis!impacted! not!only!
negatively! on! learning! efforts! of! governments<" *&," >'+56" ,Q18)(," '5" D61(9." -261@(9" 6&,"
+,>2+8"2>"6&,"D61('1-"1))+,-6'7,5&')"5956,8." ?&,+,"(,1+-'-:"2770++,A" A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5."
1(6&20:&" '-" 1" B,+9" '-72-5'56,-6" ?19<" D-" #RR$." 6&," D61('1-" :2B,+-8,-6" &1A" A,7'A,A" 62"
1A1)6"'65"5956,8" 1772+A'-:"62" 6&,"K+,-7&" 82A,("2>" 6,+6'1+9"&':&,+",A0716'2-<"M2?,B,+."
6&'5" 7&1-:,A" '-" 6&," 720+5," 2>" 6&," 7+'5'5." ?&,-" 6&," W,Q),+6" :2B,+-8,-6Y" 0-A,+" _2-6'"
'8)(,8,-6,A" 1" A01(" 1))+,-6'7,5&')" )+2:+18" 1((2?'-:" >2+" 920-:" D61('1-5" 62" 1))(9" 62"
1))+,-6'7,5&')5"'-"/,+81-9<"U6"6&,"518,"6'8,."6&,":2B,+-8,-6"0-A,+622C"1">176">'-A'-:"
8'55'2-" 62" /,+81-9<" M2?,B,+." 6&,5," ,>>2+65" ?,+," -26" 72-6'-0,A" 0-A,+" 6&," F,-N'"
:2B,+-8,-6<"*&,"E,6&,+(1-A5"1+," 1"5,72-A",Q18)(,"?&,+,"6&,"7+'5'5"&1A" 1-"'8)2+61-6"
'8)176" 2-" )2('79" 7&1-:," 1-A" 6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-" 2>" (,1+-'-:" 6&,+,'-." -18,(9" 6&,"
1A1)616'2-"2>"6&,"+,6'+,8,-6" 1:,<"='-7,"6&,"![[R5."6&,";O"1-A" 6&,"a;H4"&1A"50::,56,A"
6&16" 6&," 4067&" :2B,+-8,-65" -,,A" 62" '-7+,15," 6&," +,6'+,8,-6" 1:,." @06" ,(,76,A" 2>>'7'1(5"
&1A"-26"A1+,A"62"A2"52."A0,"62")2('6'71("2@5617(,5<"U>6,+"#RR\."1"-,?"7288'55'2-"Z31CC,+"
H288'55'2-]" 0-A,+('-,A" 1:1'-" 6&," -,7,55'69" >2+" 6&," :2B,+-8,-6" 62" 1A1)6." 1-A" 6&,"
72-6,Q6" 2>" ,72-28'7" '-5,70+'69" 1-A" &':&,+" :2B,+-8,-6" A,@6" 7&1-:,A" )0@('7" 2)'-'2-<"
;B,-601((9."'-"#R!^."+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"720(A"@,"'-7+,15,A">+28"d^"62"dJ"9,1+5<"
*2" 508" 0)." 20+" 1-1(95'5" 5&2?5" 6&16" )+2@(,8" )+,550+," 71-" (,1A" 62" (,1+-'-:." @06" 1(52"
'8),A,"(,1+-'-:")+27,55,5.",5),7'1((9"?&,-"6&,"72-6,Q6"-,7,55'616,5"'88,A'16,"176'2-<"
D-"2+A,+"62"56'80(16,"(,1+-'-:")+27,55,5"@,>2+,"1-"17601("+,>2+8"'5"81A,."6&,+,"-,,A5"62"
@,"528,"C'-A"2>")+2@(,8")+,550+,."'-"2+A,+">2+"1")+2@(,8"62"+'5,"2-62"6&,"1:,-A1"1-A"62"
6+'::,+")2('6'71("176'2-<"*&'5"71-"@,"527'2`,72-28'7"2+")2('6'71(")+,550+,5."?'6&"6&,"(166,+"
728'-:" >2+" ,Q18)(," >+28" 6&," ;O" 1-A" 1" 720-6+9I5" )1+6'7')16'2-" '-" a_H5<" a-" 6&," 26&,+"
&1-A." '>" )+2@(,8" )+,550+," '5" &':&." :2B,+-8,-65" -,,A" 62" +,176" e0'7C(9" 1-A" 6&,+," '5" -2"
6'8,">2+"(,1+-'-:<"*&'5"A9-18'7"@,718,",5),7'1((9"2@B'205"A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5"1-A"6&,"1-6'`
7+'5'5")2('7',5"'-"=206&,+-";0+2),<"a-"6&,"26&,+"&1-A."6&,"7+'5'5"1(52"7+,16,A"?'-A2?5"2>"
2))2+60-'69"62" '8)(,8,-6" (,1+-'-:`@15,A" 52(06'2-5." ?&'7&" 720(A" -26"@,")06" '-62" )(17,"
@,>2+,."A0,"62"0->1B20+1@(,")2('6'71("7'+708561-7,5<"
K2+85"2>"(,1+-'-:"
U5"?," A'57055,A" '6" '-" 6&," )+,B'205" 5,76'2-." (,1+-'-:" '5")1+6"2>" 6&," +,>2+8" )+27,55,5" '-"
!["
"
;0+2),1-"(1@20+"81+C,6"1-A"527'1(")2('7',5."&2?,B,+"'65"'8)176"2-"6&,"7&1-:,"2>")2('7',5"
A,),-A5"2-")+2@(,8")+,550+,"15"?,(("15"2-"6&,")2('6'7'N16'2-"2>"1"7,+61'-")+2@(,8<"=2">1+."
?,"&1B,"1-1(95,A"&2?"1-A"?&9")+2@(,8")+,550+,"?15")25'6'B,"1-A"-,:16'B,">2+")2('79"
(,1+-'-:<" D-" 6&'5" 5,76'2-." ?," 1+," :2'-:" 62" 206('-," A'>>,+,-6" >2+85" 2>" (,1+-'-:" 6&16" ?,"
>20-A"'-"6&,"720-6+9"+,)2+6."@,>2+,"60+-'-:"62")2('6'71("2@5617(,5"1:1'-56"(,1+-'-:"'-"6&,"
-,Q6"5,76'2-<"
*&,+," ?,+," B1+'205" >2+85" 2>" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" 6&16" )(19,A" 1" +2(," >2+" 1:,-A1" 5,66'-:."
>2+80(16'2-"2>"52(06'2-5."A,7'5'2-"81C'-:"15"?,(("15"'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"+,>2+85<"D-"6&,"
>2((2?'-:." ?," 1+," :2'-:" 62" ('56" 1" -08@,+" 2>" ?195" '-" ?&'7&" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" 2770++,A."
?'6&206"1-9"2+A,+"2>"'8)2+61-7,<"
!< Statistical!information:"*&,">'+56" 1-A" 8256" 72882-"?19" 2>" )2('79" (,1+-'-:"'5" @9"
8,1-5"2>"5616'56'71("'->2+816'2-"1-A"82A,(('-:"2>",Q),76,A">060+,"A,B,(2)8,-65"
2>" ,72-28'7" 1-A" A,82:+1)&'7" >':0+,5<" D-" 81-9" 2>" 6&," 720-6+9" +,)2+65" 6&16" ?,"
+,7,'B,A." 6&," ,Q),+65" +,)2+6" 6&16" (,1+-'-:" 2770++,A" @9" 8,1-5" 2>" 5616'56'75." >2+"
,Q18)(,"'->2+816'2-"1@206"(1@20+"81+C,6"A,B,(2)8,-6."A,82:+1)&'7",B2(06'2-"
1-A"A161"2-")0@('7">'-1-7,5<"315,A"2-"6&,5,"'->2+816'2-.":2B,+-8,-65"1-A"26&,+"
1762+5" 05," 5'8)(," 5616'56'71(" 1-1(95,5" 15" ?,((" 15" 82+," 728)('716,A" ,72-28,6+'7"
82A,(('-:" '-" 2+A,+" 62" )+,A'76" >060+," A,B,(2)8,-65" 1-A" 1A1)6" ,Q'56'-:" )2('79"
'-56+08,-65"1772+A'-:(9<"U")+28'-,-6",Q18)(,">2+"6&'5"69),"2>"(,1+-'-:"2770++,A"
'-"6&,">',(A"2>"),-5'2-")2('79"1-A"6&,"1A1)616'2-"2>"6&,"+,6'+,8,-6"1:,<"
#< Expert!consultation:"*&'5"'5"1"B,+9"@+21A" 716,:2+9"2>"(,1+-'-:." ?&'7&"'-7(0A,5"1(("
C'-A5"2>",Q),+6"'-B2(B,8,-6"'-"6&,")+27,55"2>"+,>2+8'-:"527'1("1-A"(1@20+"81+C,6"
)2('7',5<" E2?1A195." 72-50(6'-:" ,Q),+65" &15" @,728," 1" 561-A1+A" )+27,A0+," '-"
)0@('7")2('79<"M2?,B,+."6&,+,"'5"1"B,+9"?'A,"B1+',69"2>"?&2"71-"@,"1-",Q),+6."1-A"
82+," '8)2+61-6(9" 561C,&2(A,+5" ?'6&" )2('6'71(" '-6,+,565" -28'-16," 6&,'+" 2?-"
,Q),+65<" H2-5,e0,-6(9." '6" '5" '8)2+61-6" 62" e0,56'2-" 6&," @17C:+20-A" 2>" ,Q),+6"
+,)2+65"6&16"1+,"@,'-:"05,A"@9"B1+'205"1762+5."A0,"62")255'@(,")2('6'71("1>>'('16'2-5<"
E261@(9." ,Q),+6'5," 7288'55'2-,A" @9" )2('6'71(" )1+6',5." 6+1A," 0-'2-5." ,8)(29,+"
2+:1-'516'2-5"1-A"26&,+"'-6,+,56":+20)5."15"?,(("15"6&,":2B,+-8,-6"'65,(>")(19"1-"
'8)2+61-6"+2(," >2+" +,>2+85."@06" '6" '5"-,7,551+9" 62" 57+06'-'N,"6&,8" >2+" 1")255'@(,"
)2('6'71("@'15<";Q),+6"+,)2+65"6&16"?,+,")06">2+?1+A"@9"82+,"'-A,),-A,-6"1762+5."
507&"15")1+('18,-61+9" +,5,1+7&"5,+B'7,5"2+" '-A,),-A,-6",Q),+65" 1+,"('C,(9"62" @,"
#R"
"
82+,"2@G,76'B,"6&1-"+,5,1+7&"6&16"&15"@,,-",Q)('7'6(9"7288'55'2-,A"@9"1")2('6'71("
561C,&2(A,+<"
$< Expert!commissions:";Q),+6"7288'55'2-5" 1+," 1"50@:+20)" 2>" ,Q),+6"'-B2(B,8,-6."
?&'7&" )(19,A" 1-" '8)2+61-6" +2(,." -261@(9" >2+" 6&," +,>2+8" 2>" ),-5'2-" 5956,85" '-"
H2-6'-,-61(" ;0+2),1-" ?,(>1+," 5616,5<" a>6,-." >2+8,+" )2('6'7'1-5" 2+" ?,((`C-2?-"
,Q),+65" 61C," 6&," (,1A" 2>" 6&," 7288'55'2-<" _,8@,+5" 2>" 6&," 7288'55'2-5" 1+,"
+,)+,5,-616'B,5"2>"6&,"8256"'8)2+61-6")2('6'71(")1+6',5"15"?,(("15"'-6,+,56":+20)5<"
*&," :21(" 2>" 5,66'-:" 0)" 6&,5," 7288'55'2-5" '5" 62" 71-1('N," 72->('765" 1-A" ,-50+," 1"
728@'-16'2-" 2>" ,Q),+6'5," 1-A" )2('6'71(" -,:26'16'2-" +,:1+A'-:" '8)2+61-6" 1-A"
)2('6'7'N,A" '550,5." 507&" 15" ),-5'2-" +,>2+85<" ='-7," 6&," 7288'55'2-5" 728@'-,"
>176'2-1(",Q),+6'5," 1-A")2('6'71(" '-6,+,565.")2('7981C,+5" &2),"6&16" 6&,9"728,"0)"
?'6&" 50::,56'2-5" 6&16" 1+," 50'61@(," >2+" 1" 728)+28'5,<" ;Q18)(,5" >2+" 6&,5,"
7288'55'2-5"1+," 6&," =m55806&" H288'55'2-" 1-A" 6&," Fm+0)" H288'55'2-">2+"6&,"
+,>2+8"2>"6&,"/,+81-"),-5'2-"5956,8<";Q18)(,5">+28"26&,+";0+2),1-"720-6+',5"
1+,"6&," 31CC,+"1-A" 6&,"4,j+',5" H288'55'2-5" '-"6&," E,6&,+(1-A5."15" ?,((" 15"6&,"
3,(:'08"),-5'2-"+,>2+8"7288'55'2-<"
T< Pilots:"%'(265"1+,"1-26&,+"?19"2>"&2?"(,1+-'-:"71-"2770+"'-"6&,"+,>2+8")+27,55<"D-"
6&'5"715,."'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"1"+,>2+8"'5"'8)2+61-6">2+"17601("A,7'5'2-"81C'-:<"D-"
'65"'A,1(">2+8.")2('79"81C,+5"5,6"0)"1"-08@,+"2>")'(265"6&16"6,56"1")(1--,A"+,>2+8"
@,>2+,"'6"'5"@,'-:"'8)(,8,-6,A"-16'2-?'A,<"*&,5,"C'-A"2>"(,1+-'-:"'-56+08,-6"'5"
>2705,A"2-"1))('716'2-."6&,")+2@(,8"'5"6&16"'6"-,,A5"6'8,"0-6'(")'(265"&1B,"@,,-"5,6"
0)"1-A"1+,",B1(016,A<"M2?,B,+."'-"6&,",B,+9A19"@05'-,55"2>")2('7981C'-:."6'8,"'5"
571+7,"1-A"6&,+,>2+," )2('7981C,+5" A2" -26" ?1'6" >2+" 6&," >0((" ,B1(016'2-" 2>" 1" )'(26"
0-6'("6&,9"A,7'A,"1@206" 1"(1?." 2+"'8)(,8,-6" '6"A,5)'6," 1")'(26" )+2:+18"6&16" ?15"
-26"5077,55>0(<" *&," 720-6+9" +,)2+65"2-" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" +,)2+6"6&16":2B,+-8,-65"
5,6"0)")'(265"'-"2+A,+"62":1'-"C-2?(,A:,"2-"6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"1")2('79"+16&,+"
6&1-" 62" A,7'A,">2+" 2+" 1:1'-56" 1" +,>2+8<" K2+" ,Q18)(,." +,:1+A'-:" 6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-" 2>" 176'B'69" 728),-516'2-5" >2+" A'51@(,A" 9206&." 6&," =?,A'5&"
:2B,+-8,-6"72-A076,A"1"-08@,+"2>")'(26")+2:+185<"='8'(1+(9."'-"6&,"E,6&,+(1-A5."
,Q),+'8,-65")+2B'A,A"528," '-5':&65"2-" 6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-" 2>"6&," )1+6'7')16'2-"
(1?." ?&'7&" '-6,:+16,A" 527'1(" 155'561-7,." 6&," 5&,(6,+,A" ,8)(298,-6" 176" >2+"
A'51@(,A"?2+C,+5"1-A"6&,"@,-,>'65">2+"0-,8)(29,A"?&2"@,718," A'51@(,A"@,>2+,"
6&,9"&1A"60+-,A"!\<"D-"=?'6N,+(1-A."6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"6&,"^6&"+,B'5'2-"2>"6&,"
#!"
"
'-B1('A'69" '-50+1-7," '8)+2B,A" 6&," )255'@'('69" >2+" )+'B16," )+2B'A,+5" 62" A,81-A"
>'-1-7'-:" >2+" )'(26" )+2G,765." ?&'7&" ?,+," 1>6,+?1+A5" ,B1(016,A" @9" 6&," >,A,+1("
:2B,+-8,-6<"
^< Learning! from! own! experience:" V,1+-'-:" >+28" 2?-" ,Q),+',-7," 8,1-5" 6&16"
:2B,+-8,-65"(,1+-">+28"5077,55>0("2+"0-5077,55>0(")2('7',5"'-"6&,'+"2?-"720-6+9<"
*&'5"69)," 2>"(,1+-'-:" '5" A'>>,+,-6">+28" )'(265." @,7105,"6&,+," 1+," -2"6,56" 6+'1(5"2+"
,Q),+'8,-65."@06")2('7',5"?,+,"1A1)6,A"5'-7,"6&,9"A'A"-26">0(>'("6&,'+")0+)25,"2+"
?,+," 622" ,Q),-5'B,<" O501((9." 6&'5" C'-A" 2>" (,1+-'-:" ,-61'(5" 6&," 1A1)616'2-" 2>" 1"
)2('79"1>6,+"1-",B1(016'2-")+2G,76<"K2+",Q18)(,."6&,"T6&"1-A"6&,"^6&"+,B'5'2-"2>"6&,"
=?'55" '-B1('A'69" '-50+1-7," ,-61'(" 6&'5" C'-A" 2>" (,1+-'-:<" =07&" (,1+-'-:" '5" B,+9"
72882-" 1-A" A'>>,+,-6" >+28" (,1+-'-:" @9" 6+'1(5" 2+" ,Q),+'8,-65" 6&16" ?,+,"
72-A076,A" @,>2+," A,7'A'-:" 2+" '8)(,8,-6'-:" 1" )2('79." 15" 0)A16'-:" 2>" 'A,15"
2770++,A" 1>6,+" 1" )2('79" &1A" @,,-" >0((9" '8)(,8,-6,A<" U" 5),7'1(" 715," 2>" (,1+-'-:"
>+28"2?-",Q),+',-7,"'5"(1?"2-"1-"2B,+1(("8'-'808"?1:,."'-"/,+81-9<"3,>2+,"6&,"
2B,+1(("8'-'808"?1:,."?&'7&"?15"A,7'A,A"'-"#R!^.">20-A"6&,"50))2+6"2>"6&,"6?2"
81'-" )1+6',5" 1-A" 6&," 0-'2-5." ,Q'56'-:" 8'-'808" ?1:,5" '-" 528," 5,762+5" ?,+,"
,B1(016,A<" a-7," '6" ?15" 50>>'7',-6(9" +,5,1+7&,A" 6&16" 8'-'808" ?1:,5" A'A" -26"
+,A07,"6&,"-08@,+"2>"G2@5"1B1'(1@(,."6&,"72-5,+B16'B,"H&+'56'1-"4,827+16'7"%1+69"
1:+,,A"62"6&,"+,>2+8<#"
d< Learning!from!other!countries:"U-26&,+">2+8"2>"(,1+-'-:">2705,5"2-",Q),+',-7,5"2>"
26&,+"720-6+',5<"*&'5" ?19"2>"(,1+-'-:"'5"7(25,(9" 72--,76,A"62"6&," )+,B'205")2'-6<"
*&," 81'-" A'>>,+,-7," @,6?,,-" 6&," 6?2" '5" &2?,B,+" 6&16" -,?" 'A,15" 1+," ,Q)('7'6(9"
61C,-" >+28" 26&,+" 720-6+',5<" D-" ;O`:2B,+-1-7,." 6&'5" 69)," 2>" (,1+-'-:"&15" @,,-"
'-56'606'2-1('N,A" ?'6&" 6&," ,561@('5&8,-6" 2>" 6&," a_H." ?&'7&" 1'85" 16" >17'('616'-:"
(,1+-'-:"182-:56";O"8,8@,+"5616,5<"D-"6&,"+,)2+65"2-")2('79"(,1+-'-:."?&'7&"?,"
)+2A07,A"'-"6&," DE=%DF;=`)+2G,76."6&,+," ?,+,"528," '-561-7,5"2>" (,1+-'-:"'-" 6&,"
5,-5," 6&16" 'A,15" ?,+," 61C,-" >+28" 26&,+" 720-6+',5." &2?,B,+." ?'6&206" ,Q)('7'6(9"
+,>,+,-7'-:"62" 6&," a_H<" =28," 2>"6&," ,Q18)(,5" 8,-6'2-,A" '-" 6&,"6,Q6"?,+," 6&16"
/+,,7,." D61(9" 1-A" =)1'-" 6+',A" 62" (,1+-" >+28" /,+81-9" '-" 6&," >',(A" 2>" 9206&"
0-,8)(298,-6"A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5<"D-"=?,A,-."'A,15">2+"6&,"G2@":01+1-6,,")+2:+18"
>2+"6&,"9206&"718,">+28"5'8'(1+" )+2:+185." '-" 4,-81+C" 1-A" 6&," OP<" *&," 4067&"
)1+6'7')16'2-"(1?"?15"'-5)'+,A"@9",Q),+',-7,5"'-"3,(:'08"1-A"/,+81-9"1-A"'A,15"
""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
#"U-26&,+"+,152-"?15"6&16"26&,+"5,762+'1("8'-'808"?1:,")+2G,765">1'(,A<"
##"
"
2-" 6&," A,7,-6+1('N16'2-" 2>" ?,(>1+," 5,+B'7,5" 718," >+28" =?,A,-<" *&," /,+81-"
8'-'808" ?1:," (1?" ?15" &,1B'(9" '->(0,-7,A" @9" 6&," 3+'6'5&" (,:'5(16'2-" S"
)2('7981C,+5"1-A",Q),+65"0-A,+622C"5,B,+1(">176">'-A'-:"8'55'2-5"62"6&,"OP<"*&,"
=?'55" :2B,+-8,-6" 622C" 'A,15" >+28" 1-" U056+1('1-" 1-A" H1-1A'1-" )+2G,76" 2-" 6&,"
+,'-6,:+16'2-" 2>" &1-A'71)),A" '-A'B'A01(5" '-" 6&," (1@20+" 81+C,6" 1-A" 6&," +,)2+65"
8,-6'2-" 5,B,+1(" '-561-7,5" 2>" O<=<" ,Q),+',-7,5" '-5)'+'-:" +,>2+8" '-" ;0+2),1-"
720-6+',5<"
J< Learning! from! subnational! governments:"V,1+-'-:" 2770++,A" -26" 2-(9" @,6?,,-"
:2B,+-8,-65."@06"1(52"@,6?,,-"50@-16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-65<"%1+6'70(1+(9."6&,+,"1+,"
6?2" ,Q18)(," >2+" 6&'5<" K'+56(9." '-" =?'6N,+(1-A." (,1+-'-:" @,6?,,-" 71-62-1("
:2B,+-8,-65" '5" 1-" '8)2+61-6" >,160+," 2>" 6&," '-B1('A'69" '-50+1-7,." @,7105," 6&,"
71-62-1(" '-B1('A'69" '-50+1-7," 2>>'7,5" 1+," +,5)2-5'@(,">2+" 6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-"
)+27,55<"D8)(,8,-616'2-")+176'7,5"B1+9"@,6?,,-"71-62-5."1-A"6&,"-16'2-1("2>>'7,"
>2+" 527'1(" '-50+1-7,5" 6+',5" 62" >17'('616," 1-" ,Q7&1-:," 2>" )+176'7,5" @,6?,,-" 6&,"
B1+'205"71-62-1("2>>'7,5."'-"2+A,+"62"'8)+2B,"2B,+1(("),+>2+81-7,"2>"6&,"'-B1('A'69"
'-50+1-7,<"*&,+," &15"@,,-" 1"5'8'(1+" A9-18'7"+,:1+A'-:" 6&,"'-6+2A076'2-"2>"715,"
81-1:,8,-6"'-"B2716'2-1("6+1'-'-:<"D-" 3,(:'08." 6&," +,>2+85" 2>" 6&," -16'2-1(" G2@"
82-'62+'-:"57&,8,5"?,+,"@15,A"2-",Q),+',-7,5"'-"6&,"K(,8'5&"+,:'2-<"
\< Learning! from! international! actors:";B,-601((9." 6&," +,)2+65" A'57055,A" (,1+-'-:"
>+28" '-6,+-16'2-1(" 1762+5<" a-" 6&," 2-," &1-A." -2-`@'-A'-:" ;O" :0'A,('-,5" 1-A"
56+16,:',5")(19,A"'8)2+61-6"+2(,5"'-"6&'5"+,:1+A.">2+",Q18)(,"'-"3,(:'08."@06"1(52"
'-" =)1'-<" h,6." +,:1+A'-:" 6&," '->(0,-7," 2>" 6&," ;O." '6" '5" 1(?195" '8)2+61-6" 62"
A'56'-:0'5&" 6&," '->(0,-7," 2>" 'A,15" >+28" >'-1-7'1(" '-7,-6'B,5<" H20-6+',5" 8':&6"
7&1-:," )2('7',5" 1772+A'-:" 62" ;0+2),1-" :0'A,('-,5" '-" 2+A,+" 62" &1B," @,66,+"
72-A'6'2-5" >2+" +,7,'B'-:" >'-1-7'1(" 50))2+6." +16&,+" 6&1-" 1A1)6'-:" 6&,'+" 2?-"
)2('7',5<" U-26&,+" '8)2+61-6" ,(,8,-6" '5" 6&," a;H4<" D65" +,)2+65" 1+," 8,-6'2-,A" 15"
'8)2+61-6"520+7,5">2+"-16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-65" ?&,-"'6" 728,5"62" 6&,",B1(016'2-" 2>"
6&,'+" )2('7',5" 1-A" '-56+08,-65<" M2?,B,+." 6&," 17601(" '->(0,-7," 2>" 6&," 720-6+9`
5),7'>'7"+,7288,-A16'2-5"2-")2('79"206)065"1+,"-26"1(?195"7(,1+<"
*2"72-7(0A,."6&,+,"'5"1"B1+',69"2>"?195"'-"&2?":2B,+-8,-65"(,1+-<"*&,5,",-61'("(,1+-'-:"
>+28"26&,+5"1-A"2?-",Q),+',-7,5"15"?,(("15">+28"'-6,+-16'2-1("1762+5"1-A"2+:1-'516'2-5<"
H2-7,+-'-:"6&,"8,6&2A"2>"(,1+-'-:."5616'56'71("'->2+816'2-"'5"B,+9" '8)2+61-6."15"?,(("15"
,Q),+6")1+6'7')16'2-"1-A"7288'55'2-5."1(6&20:&"6&,"(166,+"6?2"1+,"82+,"B0(-,+1@(," 62"
#$"
"
)2('6'71(" '->(0,-7,<" ;Q),+'8,-65" 1-A" )'(265" 1+," '8)2+61-6." @06" ,5),7'1((9" >2+" 6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-" 2>" )2('7',5<" a>6,-6'8,5." :2B,+-8,-65" A,7'A," 1@206" 1" )2('79." 1-A"
7288'55'2-",Q),+'8,-65"1-A")'(265"1>6,+?1+A5<"D>"6&," ,Q),+'8,-6" '5" 72-A076,A" @,>2+,"
1-A">1'(5."'6"8':&6"&1)),-"6&16"1")2('79"'5"@,'-:"7&1-:,A"1-9?195<" *'8,"5,,85"62"@,"2>"
7+07'1("'8)2+61-7,">2+"(,1+-'-:<"g,"2-(9"5,,"1"56+2-:"'8)176"2>"(,1+-'-:"S"0-A,+5622A"15"
6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"-,?"'A,15"6&16"1+,"7,+61'-(9")+2B,-"62"?2+C"S"'>"6&,+,"'5",-20:&"
6'8," 62" 72-A076" +,5,1+7&<" a>6,-." 6&'5" '5" &2?,B,+" -26" 6&," 715," 15" A,7'5'2-" 81C,+5" 1+,"
0-1@(,"1-An2+"0-?'(('-:" 62"?1'6">2+" 1"52(06'2-"62"@,"+')," 1772+A'-:"62"6&," 561-A1+A5"2>"
57',-6'>'7",B'A,-7,." 5'-7," ?'-A2?5" 2>" 2))2+60-'69" >2+" A,7'5'2-`81C'-:" 2),-" 1-A" 7(25,<"
*&,+,>2+,."(,1+-'-:" 5,,85" 62" )(19" 1-"'8)2+61-6"+2(," '-" 6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-" )&15," 2>"1"
)2('79<"
%2('6'7'516'2-"1-A"(,1+-'-:"
a0+"+,50(65"&1B,"5&2?-"6&16"(,1+-'-:")+27,55,5"&1B,"@,,-"1")1+6"2>"(1@20+"81+C,6"1-A"
527'1(" )2('7',5" 1A1)616'2-" '-" ;0+2),<" g&,6&,+" 6&,5," (,1+-'-:" )+27,55,5" &1B," (,A" 62"
)2('79"7&1-:,"S"2+"?,+,"'-7(0A,A"6&,+,'-"S"A,),-A5"2-"6&,")+2@(,8")+,550+,"'-"1"7,+61'-"
)2('79">',(A<" U" 5,72-A" ,(,8,-6" 6&16" '5" '8)2+61-6">2+"?&,6&,+" (,1+-'-:"&15" 1-" ,>>,76" 2-"
)2('79" 7&1-:," '5" 6&," )2('6'7'516'2-" 2>" 1" )+2@(,8." -18,(9" ?&,6&,+" 1" +,>2+8" )+2)251("
-,,A5"62" )155" )2('6'71("A,1A(27C5<" D-" 6&,5,"715,5."52(06'2-5" 6&16" &1B,"@,,-" >20-A" 62"@,"
05,>0(" @9" '-A,),-A,-6" ,Q),+65" 8':&6" @," 7&1-:,A" 72-5'A,+1@(9." '-" 2+A,+" 62" )155" 1"
)+27,55"2>"72-5,-505">'-A'-:<" U-26&,+">2+8" 2>")2('6'7'N16'2-",-61'(5" )2('6'71("(,1+-'-:"S"
1762+5" 05," '--2B16'B," 'A,15" )+'81+'(9" 62" '8)+2B," 6&,'+" )2('6'71(" 56+16,:9<" F16&,+" 6&1-"
2-(9">2705'-:"2-")2('79"7&1-:,.")1+6',5"1-A"'-6,+,56":+20)5"5,,C"62">'-A"?195"62"+,>2+8"
)2('7',5"1-A" 62" 5619" '-")2?,+" 16" 6&," 518,"6'8,c"'-" 715," 2>" A20@6."6&,9"?20(A" &2?,B,+"
)+'2+'6'N,"6&,'+" 2?-" '-6,+,565"Z325?,((" #RR[c" %',+52-" ![[T]<" a-"6&,"26&,+" &1-A." 6&,+,"
8':&6"@," 1" (26" 2>"598@2('7"176'2-." -18,(9" 6&16" 0--,7,551+9"2+" ,B,-" A181:'-:" )2('7',5"
1+,")06"'-62")(17,">2+")2('6'71("+,152-5."'<,<"62"5,,C",(,762+1("50))2+6<"
*&," 8,-6'2-,A" A9-18'75" &1B," '->(0,-7,A" +,>2+85" '-" 6&," 720-6+',5" 6&16" ?," 2@5,+B,A<"
K2+",Q18)(,"'-"/,+81-9."6&,")+2G,76"2>"'8)(,8,-6'-:"1"-16'2-?'A,"8'-'808"?1:,"622C"
1" (2-:" 6'8," @,>2+," '6" @,718," 1" (1?." -261@(9" A0," 62" 6&," 72-5,-501(" ,(,8,-65" '-" 6&,"
-16'2-1(" )2('6'71(" 5956,8." 507&" 15" 6&," 72--,76'2-" @,6?,,-" )1+6',5" 1-A" 2+:1-'N,A"
'-6,+,565." 1-A" )1+('18,-61+9" @'718,+1('58<" U(6&20:&" ,B'A,-7," ?15" 1B1'(1@(," >+28"
1@+21A" ZOP]" 1-A" A28,56'71((9" 72-6,-A'-:" 6&16" 1" 8'-'808" ?1:," ?15" B,+9" 0-('C,(9" 62"
&1B,"-,:16'B,",>>,765"2-"6&,"G2@"81+C,6."'6"622C"1"(2-:"6'8,"0-6'("6&,"+,>2+8"?15">'-1((9"
#T"
"
'8)(,8,-6,A<"*&,"1A1)616'2-"2>",1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6" 1:,"'5"1" 5'8'(1+",Q18)(,<"D-" 6&'5"715,."
6&,+," ?,+,"1" -08@,+" 2>" :+1A01(" +,>2+85." '-" /,+81-9." ?&'7&" 5(2?(9" 1AG056,A" 6&,"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,">+28"6&,"(16,"![[R5"0-6'("#R!$<"*&,">176"6&16"6&,"/,+81-"+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"
720(A"-26" @," 50561'-,A" ?15" 1(+,1A9" C-2?-" @,>2+," ![[^<" M2?,B,+." A0," 62" )2('6'71("
+,152-5":2B,+-8,-65"A,7'A,A"-26"62"1A1)6"+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"'88,A'16,(9"1-A"1@+0)6(9<"
D-"3,(:'08"1-A"6&,"E,6&,+(1-A5."+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"1-A"),-5'2-"+,>2+85"&1B,">17,A"5'8'(1+"
7&1((,-:,5<"D-"3,(:'08." 6&,"W/,-,+16'2-" %176Y"Z#RR^]." ?&'7&"?15"1"81G2+"+,>2+8" 2>"6&,"
),-5'2-" 5956,8." 15" '6" 7+,16,A" @,-,>'65" >2+" (1@20+" 81+C,6" +,`,-6+9." '5" )2('6'71((9" 56'(("
72-6,56,A<" ='8'(1+(9." 6&," 10:8,-616'2-" 2>" 6&," ),-5'2-" 1:," '-" #R!#" ?15" -26" >+,," >+28"
)2('6'71("72->('76c"&2?,B,+."@17C,A"@9"6&,"1+:08,-6"2>"6&,"),-5'2-"+,>2+8"7288'55'2-."
6&," +':&6`?'-:" :2B,+-8,-6" )05&,A" 6&," +,>2+8" 6&+20:&" )1+('18,-6" ?'6&206" 1" (26" 2>"
72-50(616'2-<"g&16"'5"82+,."'-"6&,"3,(:'08"715,.";O"7288'55'2-"+,)2+65"5,,8,A"62"&1B,"
'8)176,A" 6&," +,>2+8" 72-5'A,+1@(9<" D-" 6&," E,6&,+(1-A5." '-7+,15'-:" 6&," +,6'+,8,-6" 1:,"
?15"2-"6&,")2('6'71("1:,-A1"5'-7,"6&,"(16,"![[R5."@06"1"+,>2+8"728)+28'5,"720(A"2-(9"@,"
>20-A"'-"#R!$"1-A"#R!^<"O-6'("6&,-.")1+6',5"6&16")06"1-"10:8,-616'2-"2>"6&,"+,6'+,8,-6"
1:,"2-"6&,")2('6'71("1:,-A1"&1A"50>>,+,A"A,B15616'-:"(255,5"'-")2)0(1+'69"1-A"6&,"'550,"
&1A"@,728,"('C," 1"+,A"+1:">2+"1" @0(("62"6&,",(,762+16,<"*&'5" 6'8,"2>")2('6'7'516'2-",-A,A"
A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5<"
*&," +,>2+8" )+2G,765" 2>" 6&," =?'55" '-B1('A'69" '-50+1-7," 1+," 1-26&,+" ,Q18)(," >2+" &2?"
)2('6'7'516'2-"2>"1")+2@(,8"'8),A,A")2('79"(,1+-'-:<"D-"![[[."1"+,>2+8">1'(,A"'-"1")2)0(1+"
B26,." ?&'7&" &1A" ,-61'(,A" 528," 8,150+,5" 62" A,1(" ,1+(9" 2-" ?'6&" 6&," &':&" A,@65" '-" 6&,"
'-B1('A'69"'-50+1-7,<"D-"2+A,+" 62" 1A1)6." 6&+,," 26&,+" +,>2+85" >2((2?,A<" K'+56(9." 1"+,>2+8"
6&16"6':&6,-,A"72-6+2(5">2+"6&," 71-62-1("'-50+1-7,"2>>'7,5"1-A"1'8,A"16"7+,16'-:"0-'>',A"
561-A1+A5."'-"#RRT<"=,72-A(9."'-"#RR\."6&,"'-B1('A'69"'-50+1-7,"7&1-:,A"?&,-")+,B,-6'B,"
1-A" ,1+(9" A,6,76'2-" '-56+08,-65" @,718," 6&," )+'81+9" '-56+08,-6" 2>" '-6,+B,-6'2-." 1-A"
A,7'5'2-5">2+"),-5'2-5"622C"2-(9"1"5,72-A1+9"+2(,<"*&'+A(9."'-"#R!#."@0A:,6"72-52('A16'2-"
'-"6&," '-B1('A'69"'-50+1-7," ?15" )06">2+?1+A<" *&,">176"6&16" 1">'+56"+,>2+8" 166,8)6">1'(,A"
(,A" 62" 82+," )+2>20-A" 8,150+,5" '-7(0A'-:" 1" 56+2-:" >2705" 2-" +,`'-6,:+16'2-" 1-A"
)+,B,-6'2-",>>2+65<"
*&,5," ,Q18)(,5" 5&2?" ?&16" ?," 1(+,1A9" C-2?" 1@206" 6&," +,(16'2-5&')" @,6?,,-"
)2('6'7'516'2-" 1-A" '-56'606'2-1(" 7&1-:,." -18,(9" 6&16" &':&(9" )2('6'7'5,A" )2('7',5" 1+,"
#^"
"
0-('C,(9"62" 7&1-:,." @,7105," 561C,&2(A,+5" A,>,-A"6&,'+"'-6,+,565" 1-A" +,60+-5<" M2?,B,+."
?'6&" +,:1+A" 62" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" 6&,5," >'-A'-:5" '8)(9" 6&16" 720-6+',5" ?'6&" 82+," B,62"
)(19,+5" 1-A" '-56'606'2-1(" B,62" 56+0760+,5" 6,-A" 62" 5(2?" A2?-" 6&," (,1+-'-:" )+27,55" 1-A"
)2('6'7'5,")+2@(,85<"*&'5"'5")1+6'70(1+(9"2@B'205"+,:1+A'-:"6&,"+,>2+8"2>"6&," +,6'+,8,-6"
1:,"'-"6&,"E,6&,+(1-A5<"D-"6&'5"715,."'6"?15"7(,1+"6&16"1"7&1-:,"?15"-,7,551+9."@06"A0,"62"
,(,762+1("'-6,+,565.")2('7981C,+5"1B2'A,A"+,>2+85"0-6'("6&,"7+'5'5")+2B'A,A"1"?'-A2?"2>"
2))2+60-'69<" M2?,B,+." '-" =?'6N,+(1-A" 1-A" /,+81-9." 6&," +,>2+8" 2>" 6&," '-6+2A076'2-" 2>"
6&," 8'-'808" ?1:," 1-A" 6&," '-B1('A'69" '-50+1-7," +,>2+85" 1+," 2),-" 62" A'>>,+,-6"
'-6,+)+,616'2-5<" K'+56(9." '-" /,+81-9." 6&,+," ?15" -2" 81G2+'69" >2+" )2('79" 7&1-:," 0-6'("
,B'A,-7," ?15" 1@52(06,(9" 72-B'-7'-:" 6&16" 1" -16'2-1(" 8'-'808" ?1:," ?20(A" -26" &1B,"
-,:16'B," ,>>,765" 2-" 6&," ,72-289" S" 1-A" 26&,+" 2)6'2-5" >2+" 5,762+" ?'A," 8'-'808" ?1:,"
1:+,,8,-65"?,+,"-26")255'@(,<"D-"=?'6N,+(1-A."6&,">1'(0+,"2>"1"+,>2+8"'-"![[["6+'::,+,A"1"
-08@,+"2>")+2>20-A"+,>2+85."-261@(9"61C'-:"'-62"17720-6")+,B,-6'B,"1-A"+,`'-6,:+16'B,"
8,150+,5"@,>2+,"7066'-:"6&,"@0A:,6"2>"6&,"'-B1('A'69"'-50+1-7,<"H(,1+(9."@26&"715,5",-61'("
,B'A,-7,">2+")2('6'71("(,1+-'-:."@,7105,")2('7981C,+5"520:&6">2+"56+16,:',5"62"1A1)6"1-A"
5619"'-"72-6+2(<"M2?,B,+."6&,"A,81-A5">2+"72-5,-505"5(2?,A"6&,")2('6'71(")+27,55"A2?-"
1-A"7+,16,A"1(52"6'8,"62")+2)25,"1(6,+-16'B,"52(06'2-"1-A",B'A,-7,"6&16"720(A"(16,+"2-"@,"
05,A"2-"6&,"+,>2+8")+27,55<"
*&," 720-6,+>17601(" 62" 6&'5" '-6,+)+,616'2-" '5" 6&16" '-" 720-6+',5" ?'6&" (,55" B,62" )2'-65."
+,>2+85"71-"@,")155,A">156,+<" *&'5" '8)(',5" >2+" (,1+-'-:" 6&16" 1" (,55" )2('6'7'5,A" )+2@(,8"
5&20(A" (,1A" 62" @,66,+" (,1+-'-:" ,>>,765." @,7105," +,>2+85" 1+," -26" @,'-:" 5(2?,A" A2?-<"
M2?,B,+." 2-" 6&," 26&,+" &1-A." A0," 62" 6&," (17C" 2>" 720-6,+`81G2+'61+'1-" ,(,8,-65."
:2B,+-8,-65"71-"+16&,+")05&"6&,'+"2?-")+2G,765"6&+20:&."?&'7&"8':&6"2),-"6&,"A22+">2+"
52(06'2-5"6&16" 1+," '-" 6&," '-6,+,56" 2>" )2('6'71(" )1+6',5" +16&,+" 6&1-" 6&," 72882-" :22A<"
;Q18)(,5">2+"6&,5,">'-A'-:5"1+,"6&,"=?,A'5&")+2:+18"6&16",-61'(,A" 1"G2@":01+1-6,," >2+"
920-:"0-,8)(29,A." ?&'7&"?15" @15,A"2-" +,5,1+7&"72-A076,A" @9"2+:1-'N16'2-5"6&16" 1+,"
7(25,"62"6&,":2B,+-'-:" +':&6`?'-:")1+69<"='8'(1+(9."6&,"+,>2+8"2>"6&," 3+'6'5&")16&?19"62"
?2+C")+2:+18."?&'7&"&15"@,,-"52(A"@9"6&,">'+56"H18,+2-":2B,+-8,-6"15"@,'-:"W1(("-,?.Y"
@06"'-">176"'6"+,5,8@(,A"7(25,(9"62"6&,")+,B'205")+2:+18<"306"6&,"+16&,+"@+21A"81G2+'69"
1((2?,A"6&,":2B,+-8,-6"62")+,5,-6"1"52(06'2-"6&16"'6"720(A"7(1'8"62"@,"1((`-,?"1-A"81C,"
598@2('7"+,>2+85<"
*?2" 26&,+" ,Q18)(,5" 1+," 6&," /+,,C" 1-6'`7+'5'5" )2('7',5" 1-A" 6&," M0-:1+'1-" )16&?19" 62"
#d"
"
?2+C"57&,8,."1(6&20:&"6&,9"2+':'-16,"'-",-6'+,(9"A'>>,+,-6")2('6'71("826'B,5<"_1-9"2>"6&,"
+,>2+85" '-" /+,,7," 1+," 826'B16,A" @9" ,Q6,+-1(" )+,550+,." @06" 1(52" @9" 6&," :21(" 62" 1661'-"
,(,762+1("50))2+6<"K2+",Q18)(,"6&,"6,8)2+1("?2+C")+2:+18"6&16"?15"7+,16,A"'-"#R!!"@9"
6&," %1)1-A+,20" :2B,+-8,-6" 1:1'-56" 6&," 2))25'6'2-" 2>" 6&," 72-5,+B16'B," )1+69<" *&,"
)+2:+18" &'+,A" +,7')',-65" >2+" >'B," 62" 5,B,-" 82-6&5" >2+" )0@('7" ?2+C<" *&," 'A,1" >2+" 6&,"
)+2:+18"2+':'-16,A"'-" /+,,7,"1-A"?15">'-1-7,A"@9" 6&,";0+2),1-"=27'1("K0-A<"V16,+" 2-"
=9+'N1"5077,55>0((9" )2('6'7'5,A" 6&'5")+2@(,8<"U" 5,72-A" ,Q18)(,"'5"6&," )16&?19" 62"?2+C"
)+2:+18"6&16"6&,"M0-:1+'1-":2B,+-8,-6")06"'-62")(17,."15"2>"#RR[<"*&,")+2:+18"1((2?5"
:2B,+-8,-6" 62" )06" 0-,8)(29,A" ?&2" 71-" ?2+C" '-62" 1" :,-,+1(" ?2+C" 57&,8,." ?&'7&" '5"
-,,A5`@15,A"1-A">2+7,5"+,7')',-65"62" 722),+16,"'>"6&,9"?1-6"62"C,,)"6&,'+"@,-,>'65."1-A"
>2+7,5"6&,8"62"A2")0@('7"?2+C<"*&,"+,>2+8")155,A")1+('18,-6"A,5)'6,"6&,">176"6&16"6&,+,"
?15" 18)(," ,B'A,-7," 6&16" 6&,5," )+2:+185" &1B," -2" ,>>,76" 2-" +,:0(1+" (1@20+" 81+C,6"
+,'-6,:+16'2-."15"6&,9":,-,+16,A",(,762+1("50))2+6<"
*2"508"0)."6&'5"5,76'2-"&15"5&2?-"6&16"6&,")2('6'7'516'2-"2>")+2@(,85"'8),A,5"6&,",>>,76"
2>"(,1+-'-:"2-")2('79"7&1-:,.">2+",Q18)(,"@,7105,":2B,+-8,-65"&1B,",(,762+1("'-6,+,565<"
U"5,72-A"+,152-"6&16"71-"+,A07,"6&,"'8)176"2>"(,1+-'-:"'-"6&,"+,>2+8")+27,55"'5"6&,"-,,A"
62"@0'(A"1"@+21A"72-5,-505<"M2?,B,+."6&,"+,50(65"5&2?"1(52"6&16"72-5,-501("'-56'606'2-5"
7+,16," 1" >1B20+1@(," ,-B'+2-8,-6" >2+" (,1+-'-:." @,7105," 6&,9" 5(2?" A2?-" 6&," A,7'5'2-"
81C'-:")+27,55"1-A" 7+,16,"6'8," >2+"+,5,1+7&"2-"52(06'2-5"@,>2+," 1"+,>2+8" '5"@,'-:" )06"
'-62" (,:'5(16'2-<" a6&,+?'5,." :2B,+-8,-65" 6,-A" 62" e0'7C(9" +,5)2-A" 62" )+2@(,85" 1-A"
(,1+-'-:" >2((2?5" 1>6,+" 6&16" A0+'-:" 6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-" )+27,55<" D-" 26&,+" ?2+A5."
)2('6'7'N16'2-"8':&6"@,")25'6'B,."15"'6"7+,16,5"6&,"6'8,">2+"(,1+-'-:<"
H2-7(05'2-"
D-" 6&'5" +,)2+6." ?," 728)1+,A" 6&," >'-A'-:5" 2>" !!" 720-6+9" +,)2+65" 6&16" 1-1(95,A"6&,"
1A1)616'2-"2>"(1@20+" 81+C,6"1-A"527'1(" )2('79"+,>2+85"1-A"6&,"+2(,"2>"(,1+-'-:"6&,+,'-<"
g,"561+6,A"20+"1-1(95'5."?'6&"6?2"81'-"&9)26&,5,5."-18,(9"6&16"6&,"'8)176"2>"(,1+-'-:"
A,),-A5"2-")+2@(,8")+,550+,5"1-A"6&,")2('6'7'516'2-"2>"1":'B,-")+2@(,8<"%1+6'70(1+(9."?,"
&2(A"6&16"B,+9"&':&"2+"B,+9"(2?")+2@(,8")+,550+,"15"?,(("15"1"72-5'A,+1@(,")2('6'7'516'2-"
2>" 1" )+2@(,8" &1B," -,:16'B," ,>>,765" 2-" )2('79" (,1+-'-:<" a0+" ,8)'+'71(" +,50(65" )1+6(9"
72->'+8" 20+" &9)26&,5,5." @06" )+2B'A," 1(52" 528," '-6,+,56'-:" +,50(65" 6&16" A2" -26" 8167&"
?'6&"20+"6&,2+,6'71(",Q),7616'2-5<"
#J"
"
!< U5" ,Q),76,A." )+2@(,8" )+,550+," &15" )25'6'B," 1-A" -,:16'B," ,>>,765" 2-" )2('79"
(,1+-'-:<"D-"2+A,+" 62"6+'::,+"1"(,1+-'-:")+27,55" 6&16"8':&6")26,-6'1((9"'8)176"2-"
+,>2+85." 528," C'-A" 2>" )+2@(,8" )+,550+," S" ,72-28'71(." A,82:+1)&'71(." 2+"
)2('6'71(" S" -,,A5" 62" @," )+,5,-6<" h,6." '>" 6&," )+2@(,8" )+,550+," @,728,5" 622" &':&."
)2('79" 81C,+5" 6,-A" 62" >1B20+" >156" 52(06'2-5." ?&'7&" +,A07,"6&," 71)17'69" 1-A"
)255'@'('69">2+"1"(,1+-'-:`@15,A"+,50(6."16"(,156")+'2+"62"6&,"A,7'5'2-"1@206"1":'B,-"
)2('79<" *&,5," C'-A5" 2>" A9-18'75" &1B," @,728," 1))1+,-6" A0+'-:" 6&," 7+'5'5."
,5),7'1((9" '-" =206&,+-" ;0+2),1-" 720-6+',5." ?&,-" :2B,+-8,-65" '8)(,8,-6,A"
>0-A18,-61(" +,>2+85" B,+9" e0'7C(9." ?'6&206" 155,55'-:" 6&,'+" )26,-6'1(" '8)176"
@,>2+,&1-A<" *&," +,152-5" >2+" 6&'5" 1+," 2@B'205(9" 6&," '88,-5," ,72-28'7" 1-A"
)2('6'71(")+,550+,." ?&'7&" &1B,"&2?,B,+" '8),A,A" 2-"(,1+-'-:<"h,6." 6&," 7+'5'5"&15"
1(52" )25'6'B," ,>>,765" +,:1+A'-:" 6&," 72--,76'2-" @,6?,,-" (,1+-'-:" 1-A" )2('79"
)+,550+,." @,7105," 6&," 7+'5'5" 72-6,Q6" 7+,16,A" ?'-A2?5" 2>" 2))2+60-'69" >2+" )2('79"
7&1-:,<"
#< *&,"+,)2+65"+,B,1(,A"A'>>,+,-6">2+85"2>"(,1+-'-:."?&'7&"71-"@,"A'B'A,A"'-62"6&+,,"
69),5"2>"(,1+-'-:L"
1< K'+56(9." 6&,+," '5" imposed! learning" 2+" 728)('1-7,<" *&'5" ,-61'(5" 6&16"
720-6+',5" 7&1-:," )2('79"15" 1" 72-5,e0,-7," 2>" ,Q6,+-1(" )2('6'71(" )+,550+,"
+16&,+" 6&1-" 6&," 1A1)616'2-" 2>" )+,>,+,-7,5" 1-A" @,(',>5" A0," 62" >17601("
C-2?(,A:,"1-A"+,5,1+7&"'-)06<"
@< =,72-A(9." 6&,+," '5" observational! learning<" *&'5" ,-61'(5" )2('79" (,1+-'-:"
@15,A"2-"6&,"2@5,+B16'2-"1-A",Q),+',-7,5"2>"26&,+"720-6+',5."50@-16'2-1("
:2B,+-8,-65" @06" 1(52" >+28" '-6,+-16'2-1(" 1762+5<" *&," A'>>,+,-7,5" 62"
'8)25,A" (,1+-'-:" '5" 6&16" 6&,+," '5" -2" )2?,+" '-B2(B,A." '-" 6&," 5,-5," 6&16"
)2('79" 7&1-:,5" 2770+" 15" 1" 72-5,e0,-7,5" 2>" 2@5,+B16'2-" 2>" 26&,+5" +16&,+"
6&1-"@9"6&,"'8)25'6'2-"2>"-,?"'A,15<"
7< Intentional! learning"'5"6&,"6&'+A">2+8" 2>" (,1+-'-:" 6&16" 71-" @," +,6+',B,A"
>+28" 6&'5" +,5,1+7&<" E261@(9." '6" 728)+'5,5" 2>" (,1+-'-:" >+28" 5616'56'71("
'->2+816'2-.",Q),+65."@06"1(52")'(265"1-A",72-28,6+'7"82A,(5<"*&,"'8)176"
2>"(,1+-'-:"'-" 6&,")2('79")+27,55" A'>>,+5<";Q),+65"1+,"2>6,-"&,1+A"@,>2+,"1"
(1?" '5" 17601((9" A,7'A,A" ?&,+,15" )'(265" 1-A" ,Q),+'8,-65" 1+," @,'-:"
72-50(6,A")+'2+"62"6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"1")2('79<"
$< *&,"6&'+A">'-A'-:"'5"6&16"6&,")2('6'7'516'2-"2>")+2@(,85"&15"1-"'8)2+61-6",>>,76"2-"
#\"
"
?&,6&,+"(,1+-'-:"'8)1765"2-")2('79"7&1-:,"2+"-26<"g,">20-A",B'A,-7,."1772+A'-:"
62"?&'7&" '-" 720-6+',5" ?'6&" 81-9" 720-6,+`81G2+'61+'1-" '-56'606'2-5" 6&," 5),,A" 2>"
7&1-:,"?15"5(2?<" M2?,B,+." 6&'5" ?15" -26" -,7,551+'(9" -,:16'B," >2+" 6&," '8)176" 2>"
(,1+-'-:."@,7105,"1"(2-:")2('6'71(")+27,55"7+,16,5"6'8,">2+"(,1+-'-:"62"&1)),-"1-A"
62"'->(0,-7,"2-"6&,">2+80(16'2-"2>"52(06'2-5<"a-"6&,"26&,+"&1-A."'-"720-6+',5"?'6&"
(,55"'-56'606'2-1("B,62" )2'-65."+,>2+85" )155">156,+." @06"(,1+-'-:" 2770+5"2-(9" 1>6,+"
A,7'5'2-"81C'-:"S"A0+'-:"6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-")+27,55<"
"
""
#["
"
U--,Q"
*&," >2((2?'-:" 61@(," )+,5,-65" 6&," 715," 560A',5" 2>" 720-6+',5" 1-A" '--2B16'2-5" 6&16" ?,+,"
72-A076,A"'-"6&,"720+5,"2>"6&,"720-6+9"+,)2+65"6&16"1+,")1+6"2>"g%^<"K2+",17&"720-6+9."D"
18" )+,5,-6'-:" 6&," '--2B16'2-5" 6&16" ?," 1-1(9N,A" 15" ?,((" 15" 528," >'-A'-:5" 6&16" 1+,"
72882-" 62" 1((" 2>" 6&," 1-1(9N,A" '--2B16'2-5" +,:1+A'-:" )2('79" (,1+-'-:." '>" 6&," 106&2+5"
0-A,+('-,A"6&'5<"
Table!1:!Overview!of!policy!learning!in!selected!labor!market!and!social!policy!innovations!
Country!
Policy!fields!and!
instruments!
Feedback:
mechanism!&!origin!
of!solution!
Problem!pressure!&!
Salience!
Politicization!
(Interest!groups,!
parties)!
BE!
InnBE1:'D-7+,15'-:"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,">2+"
6&,",(A,+(9"1-A"C,,)"
1"(1+:,+"5&1+,"2>"
6&,8",8)(29,AL"
/,-,+16'2-")176"'-"
#RR^"?15"6&,"81'-"
+,>2+8."?&'7&"
,-61'(,A"(16,+"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,."+,`
,-6+9"'-7,-6'B,5."
728),-516'2-">2+"
,8)(29,+5."),-5'2-"
@2-05">2+"6&25,"
72-6'-0'-:"62"?2+C"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"!R]<"*&,"
+,B'5'2-"2>"6&,"+,>2+8"
'-"#R!#"+,>2+8,A"6&,"
),-5'2-"1:,",B,-"
>0+6&,+"Zdd"@9"#R#^"
1-A"dJ"@9"#R$R]")(05"
56+'76,+"+,:0(16'2-5"
>2+",1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"!$]<"
;O">,,A@17CL"H20-6+9"
5),7'>'7"
+,7288,-A16'2-5"
A,81-A,A"1-"
'-7+,15,"2>"6&,"
,8)(298,-6"+16,"2>"
6&,",(A,+(9<"g&16"'5"
82+,."6&,";O"=6+16,:9"
#R#R"5,6"1"61+:,6">2+"
,8)(298,-6"+16,"2>"
6&,",(A,+(9<"*&,5,"
'-7,-6'B,5"&1A"1-"
'8)176"2-"3;<"4'"
F0)2":2B,+-8,-6"
'-561((,A"1"
H288'55'2-">2+"
%,-5'2-"F,>2+8"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"!!]<"
428,56'7"(,1+-'-:"
6&+20:&"6&,"),-5'2-"
+,>2+8"7288'55'2-"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"$^]<"
M':&(9"51(',-6"'550,."
5'-7,"A'56+'@06'B,"
,(,8,-65"1+,"
'-B2(B,Aii"
%+,550+,"@9"6&,";<"
H288'55'2-"A0,"62"
+,)2+65c">,A,+1("
:2B,+-8,-6"1-A"
721('6'2-")1+6',5"1+,"
1(52"'8)2+61-6"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"!#]c"
)2('6'7'N,A."@06"6&,"
:2B,+-8,-6"
5077,,A,A"62")05&"'6"
6&+20:&"'-"#R!Tc"
/,-,+16'2-")176"'5"
56'(("B,+9"72-6,56,A"
)2('6'71((9"Z=6+09B,-"
1-A"%2((,6"#R!^L"#d]<"
"
H2-5,+B16'B,5"
A,81-A,A"@0A:,61+9"
A'57')('-,"Z=6+09B,-"
1-A"%2((,6"#R!^L"$d]<"
%2('6'71("(,1+-'-:L"
H,-6+,`+':&6"
:2B,+-8,-6")05&,A"
6&,"+,>2+8"6&+20:&"
Z#R!T]"?'6&206"
@+21A"72-50(616'2-"'-"
2+A,+"62"1B2'A"622"
$R"
"
807&")2('6'7'N16'2-"2>"
6&,"8166,+"Z=6+09B,-"
1-A"%2((,6"#R!^L"$d]<"
InnBE2:'E,?"G2@"
82-'62+'-:"57&,8,"'-"
#RRTL"V'-C5"6&,"
+,7,')6"2>"
0-,8)(298,-6"
@,-,>'65"62"176'B,"
,>>2+65"62">'-A"1"G2@<"
E2-`728)('1-7,"'5"
51-76'2-,Ac"#R!#"6&,"
57&,8,"?15",Q6,-A,A"
62"920-:,+"1-A"2(A,+"
0-,8)(29,Ac"#R!T"
6&,"_'7&,("
:2B,+-8,-6"&15"
)(1--,A"62",Q6,-A"
6&,5,")+176'7,5"62"
61+:,6":+20)5"2>"
72((,76'B,"(192>>5"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"!R]<"
K(,8'5&"+,:'2-"05,A"
'65"-,?(9":1'-,A"
1062-289"62"
,561@('5&"6&'5"
'-56+08,-6<"*&,"
A,7'5'2-"?15"@15,A"
2-")+2G,76'2-5"2>"6&,"
K(,8'5&",8)(298,-6"
5,+B'7,"Z=6+09B,-"1-A"
%2((,6"#R!^L"!d]c"
M2?,B,+"176'B16'-:"
6&,"^Ro"A'A"-26"?2+C"
52"?,(("Z=6+09B,-"1-A"
%2((,6"#R!^L"!J]<"
V,1+-'-:"6&+20:&"6&,"
,Q),+',-7,"2>"6&,"
K(,8'5&"+,:'2-"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"$J]<"
"
"
InnBE3:'h206&"
;8)(298,-6"%(1-L"
/21("?15"62"'-7+,15,"
,8)(298,-6"2>"
920-:c",561@('5&,A"@9"
1"A,7+,,"'-"#RR[">2+"
6&,",-6'+,"K(,8'5&"
+,:'2-"Z=6+09B,-"1-A"
%2((,6"#R!^L"#R]<"
*&,"'A,1",8,+:,A"
>+28"6&,";O"![[\"
;8)(298,-6"
/0'A,('-,5"Z=6+09B,-"
1-A"%2((,6"#R!^L"![]<"
U5"2>"#RR^"1"-08@,+"
2>",Q),+'8,-65"?,+,"
72-A076,A."2+:1-'N,A"
@9"6&,":2B,+-8,-6"
1-A"E/a5"62"'-7+,15,"
,8)(298,-6c"
5077,55>0((9"
,B1(016,A"1-A"6&,-"
@,718,"1"(1?"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"![`#R."$[]<"
"
E26")2('6'7'N,Ac"
+,7,'B,5"50))2+6"
>+28"1((")2('6'71("
)1+6',5"Z=6+09B,-"1-A"
%2((,6"#R!^L"#d]<"
Common:"
;O"+,7288,-A16'2-5"
"
H&1-:,"2>"
$!"
"
1-A"a;H4"+,)2+65"1+,"
'8)2+61-6">2+"1(("
)2('79"81C,+5"
Z=6+09B,-"1-A"%2((,6"
#R!^L"#J]<"
F,:'2-5"5,,8"62"
(,1+-">+28"1-26&,+<"
*&,"K(,8'5&"%;="
Z%0@('7";8)(298,-6"
=,+B'7,]"&15"
5077,55>0((9"
728)(,6,A"528,"
)+2G,765"1-A"6&,"
g1((2-'1-"
:2B,+-8,-6"'5"
(,1+-'-:"Z=6+09B,-"
1-A"%2((,6"#R!^L"#J`
#\]<"F,7,-6"
A,B2(06'2-"
:2B,+-8,-6"2-(9"'-"
#R!T"Z=6+09B,-"1-A"
%2((,6"#R!^L"#^]<"
CH!
InnCH1:'E,?"
81-1:,8,-6`@9`
2@G,76'B,5"1-A"
72-6+2("5956,8"2>"
71-62-1("A'51@'('69"
2>>'7,5<"*&'5"+,>2+8"
)155,A"6&,"-16'2-1("
)1+('18,-6"'-"#RRT<"D6"
+,>2+85"6&,"2B,+5':&6"
2>"6&,">,A,+1("
:2B,+-8,-6"2B,+"6&,"
71-62-1("2>>'7,5<"
g&16"'5"82+,."'6"
7+,16,A"+,:'2-1("
8,A'71("5,+B'7,5"62"
561-A1+A'N,"6&,"
,B1(016'2-"2>"@,-,>'6"
7(1'85"'-"6&,"
'-B1('A'69"'-50+1-7,"
Z32-2('",6"1(<"#R!^L"^`
d]<"
*&,">,A,+1("
:2B,+-8,-6"
)+2)25,A"6&'5"
52(06'2-."-18,(9"62"
6':&6,-"72-6+2("2>"
71-62-1(")+176'7,5"@9"
&1B'-:"82+,"
A'57+,6'2-"+,:1+A'-:"
6&,"71-62-1("2>>'7,5"
1-A"@9",561@('5&'-:"
5616,"8,A'71("
728),6,-7,5"'-"6&,"
+,:'2-1("8,A'71("
5,+B'7,5<"U-26&,+"
2)6'2-"?20(A"&1B,"
@,,-"62"+1'5,"61Q,5."
@06"507&"1"+,>2+8"
)+2)251(">1'(,A"'-"1"
)2)0(1+"+,>,+,-A08."
'-"![[["Z32-2('",6"1(<"
#R!^L"J`!R]<"
*&,"+,>2+8"
+,5)2-A,A"62"6&,"
)+2@(,8"2>"622"&':&"
A,@65"'-"6&,"'-B1('A'69"
'-50+1-7,<"*&,5,"1+,"
8256(9"A,@65"?'6&"6&,"
-16'2-1("),-5'2-"
'-50+1-7,"Z32-2('",6"
1(<"#R!^L"\]<"*&,"
)+2@(,8"'5"6&16"6&,"
71-62-1("2>>'7,5"1+,"
'-"7&1+:,"2>"A,7'A'-:"
2-"@,-,>'6"7(1'85."@06"
6&,9"+,)2+6"62"6&,"
71-62-1(":2B,+-8,-6"
1-A"-26"6&,">,A,+1("
:2B,+-8,-6<"g&16"'5"
82+,."6&,"71-62-1("
2>>'7,5"(17C"8,A'71("
728),6,-7,5"1-A"
A,),-A"2-"6&,"
H1-62-5"B5<">,A,+1("
:2B,+-8,-6<"
a+':'-1((9."6&,"
-16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-6"
&1A")+2)25,A"6&16"
6&,"+,:'2-1("8,A'71("
5,+B'7,5"1+,"0-A,+"'65"
50),+B'5'2-<"*&,"
71-62-5"(2@@',A"
5077,55>0((9"1:1'-56"
6&'5"56+16,:9"'-"6&,"
-16'2-1(")1+('18,-6."
?&'7&",B,-601((9"
72->'-,A"6&,"5,6`0)"2>"
6&,"+,:'2-1("8,A'71("
5,+B'7,5<"='8'(1+(9."
6&,")1+('18,-6"
:+1-6,A"6&,">,A,+1("
2>>'7,"2>"527'1("
'-50+1-7,5"(,55"
A'57+,6'2-"B'5`p`B'5"
$#"
"
155,558,-6"2>"
,Q6,+-1("A2762+5"2+"
6&,"/%"2>"6&,"@,-,>'6"
7(1'81-6"Z32-2('",6"
1(<"#R!^L"d]<"
6&,"71-62-1("2>>'7,5"
6&1-")+2)25,A"@9"6&,"
-16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-6"
Z32-2('",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$!`$#]<"
InnCH2:'E,?"5,6"2>"
,1+(9"'-6,+B,-6'2-"
'-56+08,-65">2+"-,?"
A'51@'('69"@,-,>'6"
7(1'81-65<"
=),7'>'71((9."6&,"
+,>2+8"7+,16,A"-,?"
'-56+08,-65"62"
)+,B,-6"'-A'B'A01(5"
?'6&"A'51@'('6',5">+28"
@,728'-:"A,),-A,-6"
2-"),-5'2-5",1+(9"2-<"
*&'5"+,>2+8",-61'(,A"
1"7&1-:,"'-"6&,"2+A,+"
2>"6&,"'-56+08,-65"
05,A"'-"6&,"'-B1('A'69"
'-50+1-7,"@9")066'-:"
)+,B,-6'2-"@,>2+,"
),-5'2-5"Z32-2('",6"
1(<"#R!^L"!#`!T]<"
*&,"52(06'2-"?15"
50::,56,A"@9"6&,"
-16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-6<"
;B,-601((9."6&,"(1?"
81A,"'6",15',+">2+"
)+'B16,"2+:1-'N16'2-5"
62")+2)25,")'(265">2+"
8,150+,5"1'8'-:"16"
)+,B,-6'-:"
'-A'B'A01(5">+28"
:,66'-:"622"e0'7C(9"
),-5'2-5"1-A"'-56,1A"
6+9'-:"62"+,'-5,+6"
6&,8"'-62"6&,"(1@2+"
81+C,6"Z32-2('",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!T`!^]<"
;55,-6'1((9."6&,"
8,150+,"6+',A"62"
+,5)2-A"62"1"5'8'(1+"
)+2@(,8"6&1-"6&,"
)+,B'205"'--2B16'2-L"
+,A07'-:"6&,"A,@6"2>"
6&,"'-B1('A'69"
'-50+1-7,"Z32-2('",6"
1(<"#R!^L"d]<"
*&'5"'--2B16'2-"?15"
&':&(9")2('6'7'N,A"1-A"
'5")1+6"2>"1"
728)+28'5,<"a-,`
5'A,A"52(06'2-5"62"
+,A07,"A,@6"'-"6&,"
'-B1('A'69"'-50+1-7,"
,'6&,+"@9"61Q"+1'5,5"2+"
7065"'-"@,-,>'65"&1A"
-2"81G2+'69<"
H2-5,e0,-6(9."
)2('6'71(")1+6',5"
56+0::(,A"62">'-A"1"
728)+28'5,"6&16"
1((2?,A"62"+,A07,"
72565"1-A"16"6&,"518,"
6'8,",-50+,A"5'8)(,"
7065"'-"@,-,>'65">2+"
@,-,>'7'1+',5"Z32-2('"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"$#`$$]<"
InnCH3:'*&'5"
'--2B16'2-"'5"1"-,?"
(1?"6&16"+,>2+85"
B2716'2-1("6+1'-'-:"'-"
=?'6N,+(1-A"
Zj2716'2-1("1-A"
%+2>,55'2-1("*+1'-'-:"
1-A";A0716'2-"U76."
#RR#]<"*&,"(1?"
+,:+20),A"1(("
6+1'-'-:")+2:+185"
0-A,+"6&,"2B,+5':&6"
2>"6&,">,A,+1("
:2B,+-8,-6<"g&16"'5"
82+,."'6"7+,16,A"1"
%1+('18,-6"&1A"
1(+,1A9"A,81-A,A"62"
+,>2+8"6&,",Q'56'-:"
,A0716'2-1("6+1'-'-:"
5956,8."@06"'6"?15"
2-(9"'-"#RRT"6&16"6&,"
K,A,+1("H20-7'("
)+2)25,A"1"-,?"(1?"
>2+"72-50(616'2-<"*&,"
A+1>6"&1A"@,,-"5,6"0)"
@9"1-",Q),+6"
7288'55'2-"Z32-2('"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"!\]<"
%25'6'B,",B1(016'2-"2>"
6&,"715,"81-1:,8,-6"
%+2@(,8"?15"6&16"6&,"
2(A"5956,8"A'A"-26"
+,5)2-A"1-982+,"62"
6&,"A,81-A5"62"6&,"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"
81+C,6"Z32-2('",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!J`!\]<"_1-9"
920-:56,+5"720(A"-26"
>'-A")(17,5">2+"1-"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"
1-982+,"Z32-2('",6"
1(<"#R!^L"TJ]<"
``"
$$"
"
0-'>',A"0)),+`
5,72-A1+9"5956,8"2>"
,A0716'2-."?&'7&"&1A"
-26"@,,-"6&,"715,"
@,>2+,."@,7105,"
71-62-5"&1A"81-9"
>+1:8,-6,A"52(06'2-5"
Z32-2('",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!\]<"
'-"#RRJ"Z32-2('",6"1(<"
#R!^L"T\`T[]<"
Common:''
"
"
"
GER!
InnGER1:'=616062+9"
_'-'808"g1:,"
Z#R!^]c"M'562+9"2>"
5,762+"?'A,"
8'-'808"?1:,5"'-"
/,+81-9."?&'7&"1(52"
1))(',A"62">2+,':-"
?2+C,+5"Z%256'-:"2>"
g2+C,+5"U76.">'+56"
1))('716'2-"'-"![[d]<"
U>6,+"#RRJ."26&,+"
5,762+5">2((2?,A"1-A"
?,+,"'-7(0A,A"0-A,+"
6&,"U76"Zk1-5,-"1-A"
P-06&"#R!^L"!#]<"
O-'2-5"561+6,A"62")06"
6&,")+2:+18"2-"6&,"
-16'2-1(")2('6'71("
1:,-A1"'-"#RR#c"6&,"
)+2)251("?15"
50))2+6,A"@9"
'-A,),-A,-6"
+,5,1+7&"'-56'606,5."
'<,<"6&,"/,+81-"
D-56'606,">2+"
;72-28'7"F,5,1+7&"
2+"6&,"D-56'606,">2+"
;8)(298,-6"
F,5,1+7&]"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"T\]<"
"
%+2@(,8"?15"6&,"
A,7('-,"2>"72((,76'B,"
1:+,,8,-65"'-"81-9"
5,762+5"1-A"1-"
'-7+,15'-:"?1:,"
A'5)1+'69"@,6?,,-"
;156"1-A"g,56"
/,+81-9"Zk1-5,-"1-A"
P-06&"#R!^L"[`!R]<"
"
*&,"1))('716'2-"2>"6&,"
8'-'808"?1:,"'-"
81-9"5,762+5"5,+B,A"
15"1"e015'`
"
a))25'6'2-"2>"6&,"
+,>2+8"718,"
,5),7'1((9">+28"6&,"
,8)(29,+I5"
2+:1-'N16'2-5."@06"
1(52"6&,"0-'2-5"?,+,"
-26"'88,A'16,(9"'-"
>1B2+"2>"6&'5"'A,15."
@,7105,"6&,9"?,+,"
1>+1'A"62"(25,"
@1+:1'-'-:"1062-289"
Zk1-5,-"1-A"P-06&"
#R!^L"\."!!`!#."![]<"
"
;5),7'1((9."@05'-,55"
2))25'6'2-"?15"
56+2-:<"*&,'+"
2))25'6'2-"?15"
5077,55>0("1>6,+"6&,"
,(,76'2-"2>"#RR^<"
M2?,B,+."'-"#R!$."1(("
6&,"26&,+")1+6',5."
,Q7,)6">2+"6&,"
@05'-,55"?'-:"2>"6&,"
H4O"?,+,"72-B'-7,A"
6&16"1":,-,+1("
8'-'808"?1:,"?15"
-,7,551+9"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"!#."
![]<"
$T"
"
,Q),+'8,-6<"
"
D-"#RR[."6&,",Q'56'-:"
5,762+'1("8'-'808"
?1:,5"?,+,"
,B1(016,A"'-",':&6"
5,762+5"1-A"-2"
-,:16'B,",>>,76"720(A"
@,">20-A">2+"
,8)(298,-6"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"!#]<"
"
U)1+6">+28"6&16"6&,+,"
?,+,"5,B,+1(">176"
>'-A'-:"8'55'2-5"62"
6&,"OP"@9"
)1+('18,-61+'1-5"
>+28"@26&"@':")1+6',5"
1-A"6+1A,"0-'2-"
+,)+,5,-616'B,5"62"
(,1+-"1@206"6&,",>>,76"
2>"6&,"8'-'808"?1:,"
Zk1-5,-"1-A"P-06&"
#R!^L"!\.T[]<"
"
K1B2+1@(,",72-28'7"
5'6016'2-"'-"#R!^"
81C,5"'6",15',+"62"
'-6+2A07,"1"8'-'808"
?1:,"Zk1-5,-"1-A"
P-06&"#R!^L"T[]<"
"
h,6."6&,"A,7'5'B,"
,B,-6">2+"'-6+2A07'-:"
6&,"8'-'808"?1:,"
?15"6&,">1'(0+,"62"
+,17&"1"72((,76'B,"
1:+,,8,-6">2+"6&,"
&25)'61('69"1-A"+,61'("
5,762+c"6&,-"6&,"H4O"
A,7'A,A"62"1:+,,"62"
6&,"?1:,"Zk1-5,-"1-A"
P-06&"#R!^L"#R]<"
InnGER2:'F,A076'2-"
2>",1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6"
1:,c"6&'5"'--2B16'2-"
72B,+5"1"-08@,+"2>"
+,>2+85">+28"6&,"
,1+(9"![[R5"0-6'("
#RR[."?&,-"-16'2-1("
:2B,+-8,-65"'-"
/,+81-9"
_256"'8)2+61-6">2+"
6&'5"+,>2+8"?,+,"7256"
)+,550+,."?&'7&"?,+,"
,B,-"1::+1B16,A"@9"
6&,"_1156+'7&6"6+,169"
1-A"6&,"A,>'7'6"
7,'('-:5c"?&16"'5"
82+,."6&,"?,1C"
,72-28'7"5'6016'2-"
"
O501((9."6&,"57',-6'>'7"
('6,+160+,"+,:1+A5"6&,"
+,>2+8"2>"![[#"15"6&,"
+,50(6"2>"1"72-5,-505"
-26"2-(9"2>"6&,"
72-5,+B16'B,")1+69."
@06"1(52"6&,"6+1A,"
0-'2-5"1-A"6&,"=27'1("
4,827+16'7"%1+69"'-"
$^"
"
72-6'-0205(9"
'-7+,15,A"+,6'+,8,-6"
1:,"Zk1-5,-"1-A"
P-06&"#R!^L"$R]c"
*&,5,"'--2B16'2-5"
2770++,AL"=61:,"!L"
![[#.",-6,+'-:"'-62"
>2+7,"#RR!."@06"?15"
1AB1-7,A"'-"![[JL"
/+1A01("'-7+,15,"2>"
+,5),76'B,"+,6'+,8,-6"
1:,5">2+")1+6'70(1+"
:+20)5"=61:,"#L"
U77,(,+16'2-"2>"6&,"
)+27,55"2>")&15'-:`
206"6&,"2)6'2-5">2+"
,1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6"
Z![[d]."F1'5'-:"
0)),+`6&+,5&2(A">2+"
6&,",1+(9"),-5'2-">2+"
5,B,+,(9"A'51@(,A"
Z![[[]."F1'5'-:"
6&+,5&2(A">2+"6&,"
,1+(9"),-5'2-">2+"
0-,8)(29,A"q"
U@2('6'2-"2>",1+(9"
+,6'+,8,-6">2+")1+6"
6'8,"0-,8)(29,A"
Z#RRT]c"=61-A1+A"
+,6'+,8,-6"?'6&"dJ"
Z#RRJ]c"E,?",1+(9"
+,6'+,8,-6"57&,8,"
>2+"6&25,"
72-6+'@06'-:"T^"9,1+5"
1-A"82+,"
Z#RRJn#R!$]"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"$!]"
1-A"/,+81-9"
+,0-'>'716'2-")06"
1AA'6'2-1(")+,550+,"
2-"6&,"/,+81-"
),-5'2-"5956,8"
Z/;F`F,)."$T`$\."$d]<"
"
F2(,"2>"7288'55'2-5"
'-7+,15,A"1-A"6&25,"
2>"527'1(")1+6-,+5"
A,7+,15,A"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"$J]<"
"
H+,16'2-"2>"1"-,?"
,1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6"
57&,8,"'-"#RR^"?15"
B,+9"7(25,"62"6&,"
50::,56'2-5"2>"6&,"
'-A,),-A,-6"M,+N2:`
H288'55'2-"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"$[]<"
"
V,1+-'-:"'-"6&'5"
+,>2+8"2770++,A"'-"
6&+,,"?195L"
"
1]<";Q),+6"-,6?2+C"
Z),-5'2-",Q),+65"
>+28"527'1(")1+6-,+5."
8'-'56+',5"1-A"
)2('6'71(")1+6',5]."
?&'7&"'->2+81((9"
)+,)1+,A"6&,"+,>2+85"
'-"![[#"q"![[["
@15,A"2-"6&,"
5616'56'71("
'->2+816'2-"`r"
A,)2('6'7'N,A"1-A"A,`
)1+('18,-61+'N,A"
)2('6'71(")+27,55<"
6&,"-16'2-1("
)1+('18,-6<"H4O"1-A"
,8)(29,+5"&1A"
1(+,1A9"@,,-"'-">1B2+"
2>"82+,"('@,+1('N16'2-"
A0+'-:"6&,"![\R5"
Zk1-5,-"1-A"P-06&"
#R!^L"$T]<"=27'1("
A,827+165"1-A"
0-'2-5"?,+,"2))25,A"
15"6&,9"?,+,"1>+1'A"2>"
+1'5'-:"
0-,8)(298,-6"+16,5."
@06"6&,")+2G,76'2-5"2>"
1-"1:,'-:")2)0(16'2-"
1-A"6&,"7256"6&,+,2>"
>2+"6&,"+,6'+,8,-6"
5956,8"Zk1-5,-"1-A"
P-06&"#R!^L"$^]"
"
D-7+,15'-:"
)2('6'7'N16'2-"2>"6&,"
),-5'2-")2('6'75"1>6,+"
![[[."?&,-"6&,"H4O"
15"?,(("15"6&,"=%4"
@26&"7+,16,A"6&,'+"
2?-",Q),+6"
7288'55'2-5"62"
)+2)25,"50::,56'2-5"
>2+"&2?"62"561@'('N,"
6&,"5956,8"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"$\]<"
"
4,5)'6,5"
)2('6'7'N16'2-"528,"
50::,56'2-5"2>"6&,"
'-A,),-A,-6"Fm+0)`
7288'55'2-")155,A"
)1+('18,-6"'-"#RRT."
@06"6&,"561-A1+A"
$d"
"
U>6,+"6&,"
)2('6'7'N16'2-"2>"6&,"
+,>2+8")+27,55."
,Q),+6"7288'55'2-"
+,)(17,A"6&,"'->2+81("
-,6?2+Cc"81-9"2>"
6&,'+"50::,56'2-5"
?,+,"'8)(,8,-6,A"`r"
,(,762+1("50'7'A,">2+"
6&,"=27'1("4,827+165"
Zk1-5,-"1-A"P-06&"
#R!^L"TR`T!]<"
"
E2"A'+,76";O"
'->(0,-7,."@06"
_1156+'7&6"'5"
'8)2+61-6<"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"?15"
-26"+1'5,A."@,7105,"'6"
?15"A,,8,A"622"
A1-:,+205")2('6'71((9<"
"
*&,"'-6,+,56"2>"6&,"
=27'1("4,827+165">2+"
6&,"+,-,?1("2>"6&,"
,1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"
@,728,5"1(52"
1))1+,-6"'-"6&,"
(10-7&'-:"2>"528,"
)+2G,765"62">'-A"
2)6'2-5">2+"+,`
'-6+2A07'-:",1+(9"
+,6'+,8,-6<"
;B,-601((9."-2-,"2>"
6&,5,"2)6'2-5"720(A"
@,"+,61'-,A"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"$T]<"
"
aB,+1(("@+21A"
72-5,-505"6&16"6&,"
+,>2+8"'5"-,7,551+9c"
6&,"'-7+,8,-61("
7&1-:,5">+28"![[#`
#RRJ"2770++,A"'-"1"
?19"6&16"-2"5,B,+,"
7065"-,,A,A"62"@,"
81A,<";B,-"?&,-"6&,"
'550,"@,718,"82+,"
)2('6'7'N,A."6&,+,"?15"
-2"2B,+1(("+0)60+,"2>"
6&,")2('6'71("
72-5,-505"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"^R]<"
InnGER3:'
%,+5),76'B,"^RI)(05"`"
1"-16'2-1(")+2:+18"
>2+"2(A,+"G2@5,,C,+5L"
*&,"/,+81-"W70(60+,"
2>",1+(9"+,6'+,8,-6Y"
&1A"'-7,-6'B'N,A"
81-9",(A,+(9"
"
%+2:+18"?15"
(10-7&,A"@9"6&,"
K,A,+1("_'-'56+9">2+"
;8)(298,-6"1-A"
$J"
"
V10-7&,A"@9"6&,"
K,A,+1("_'-'56+9"2>"
;8)(298,-6"1-A"
=27'1("U>>1'+5"'-"
8'A#RR^."5'Q"82-6&"
1>6,+"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
M1+6N"Dj<"*&,"
)+2:+18")&15,A"206"
'-"#R!^L"k2@`7,-6,+5"
720(A"1))(9">2+"
>0-A'-:"62":,6"
50))2+6"G2@5,,C,+5"
^R)(05c"/,+81-"
82-,9"2-(9"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"T$]<"
G2@5,,C,+5"62"05,"
0-,8)(298,-6"
@,-,>'65"62"7+,16,"
)16&?195"'-62"
+,6'+,8,-6<"M1+6N"Dj"
81A,"6&'5"56+16,:9"
72-5'A,+1@(9"82+,"
728)('716,A<"
*&,+,>2+,."6&'5"
)+2:+18"?15"5,6`0)"
Zk1-5,-"1-A"P-06&"
#R!^L"TT]<"
"
%25'6'B,",B1(016'2-"2>"
6&,")+2:+18"'-"6,+85"
2>"+,`'-6,:+16'2-"2>"
+,7')',-65"'-"6&,"
(1@2+"81+C,6."@06"-26"
81-9"2>"6&,8"
81-1:,A"62"81C,"1"
('B'-:"A0,"62"(2?"
51(1+',5<"
"
/2B,+-8,-6"
A2708,-65"+,>,++,A"
62"6&,"=627C&2(8"
61+:,65"Z#RR!L"^Rs"
,8)(298,-6"+16,"2>"
,(A,+(9"@9"#R!R]."@06"
6&,+,"?15"-2",Q)('7'6"
(,1+-'-:"1-A"6+1-5>,+"
2>"'A,15"('C,"6&,"
3+'6'5&"E,?"4,1("^Ro"
Z#RRR"62"#RR[]"2+"6&,"
K'--'5&"E16'2-1("
%+2:+18"2-"U:,'-:"
g2+C,+5"Zk1-5,-"1-A"
P-06&"#R!^L"Td]<"
"
*&,"5077,55>0("
=27'1("U>>1'+5"?'6&206"
1AA'-:">0+6&,+"
(,:'5(16'2-"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"T$]<"
$\"
"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
^Ro"(,1A"62"
50@5,e0,-6")+2:+185"
'-"/,+81-9"Zk1-5,-"
1-A"P-06&"#R!^L"Td`
TJ]<"
Common:"
"
"
"
GRE!
InnGR1:''
*,8)2+1("
,8)(298,-6">2+"
)0@('7"@,-,>'6"#R!!L"
K'B,"62"5,B,-"82-6&5"
6,8)2+1+9"
,8)(298,-6">2+"
)0@('7"@,-,>'6"Z'<,<"
7(,1-'-:"2>"
80-'7')1('6',5]c"
1+20-A"^RR;0+2"
?1:,")(05"527'1("
'-50+1-7,"
72-6+'@06'2-5"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!R]<"
M1A"1(+,1A9"@,,-"
1))(',A"A0+'-:"6&,"
![[R5"'-"+,:'2-5"?'6&"
B,+9"&':&"
0-,8)(298,-6."@06"
>2+"1"),+'2A">2+"!#`#T"
82-6&5"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"$[]<"
DA,1"2+':'-16,A"
A28,56'71((9"@9"6&,"
/+,,C":2B,+-8,-6"
1-A"?15">'-1-7,A"@9"
6&,";=K"Z;0+2),1-"
=27'1(">0-A]"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!R]<"
%+2@(,8"'-"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-."
+,7')',-65">,(6"('C,"
@,-,>'7'1+',5"+16&,+"
6&1-",8)(29,,5"`r"
@15'71((9"-2"2-,"
720(A">'-A"1"
),+81-,-6"G2@"1>6,+"
6&,")+2:+18"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!!`!#]<"
K2((2?'-:"528,"2>"
6&,"a_H5."6&,5,"528,"
6,8)2+1+9"?2+C5"
)+2:+185"&1A"@,,-"
7+,16,A"'-"6&,">2+8"2>"
'-6,+-5&')5"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"#d`#\]<"
U>6,+"6&,"2-5,6"2>"6&,"
7+'5'5."6&,"'550,"?15"
A'57055,A"?'6&"/+,,C"
,Q),+65"?&2"?2+C,A"
2-"6&'5"'550,"1@+21Ac"
=9+'N1"622C"'6"0)"'-"
"
%2('6'7'N,A")2('79"
)+27,55<"a))25'6'2-"
)1+6',5"?,+,"1:1'-56"
6&,"8,150+,"1-A"
A,81-A,A"82+,."62"
,561@('5&"82+,"
50561'-1@(,"8,150+,5"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!R]<"
"
%0@('7"?2+C"
)2('6'7'N,A"'550,"@9"
=9+'N1<"
$["
"
#R!^"Z%1)1A2)20(20"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"TR]<"
InnGR2:'j207&,+"
=7&,8,"62">'-1-7,"
6,8)2+1+9"6+1'-'-:"2>"
0-,8)(29,A"'-"
)+'B16,"728)1-',5."
7+,16,A"#R!!<"*&,"
B207&,+">'-1-7,A"
6+1'-'-:"1-A"
,8)(298,-6"2>"6&,"
+,7')',-6"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!#`!$]<"
*&,"a;H4"&1A"
50::,56,A"507&"1"
)+2:+18"1(+,1A9"
,1+(',+"2-"Z#RR^]."@06"
6&,"'-6+2A076'2-"'-"
/+,,7,">1'(,A<"a-(9"'-"
#R!!."?&,-"6&,"7+'5'5"
)+,550+,"&1A"
10:8,-6,A"
72-5'A,+1@(9."6&,"
)+2:+18"?15"
'8)(,8,-6,A<"K0-A5"
718,">+28"6&,";=K"
Z;0+2),1-"=27'1("
K0-A]"#R!!"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!#]<"
*&,5,"B207&,+5"&1A"
@,,-")1+6"2>"6&,"
+,7288,-A16'2-5"2>"
6&,";O."-18,(9"6&,"
;;="#R!!"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!$`!T]<"
"
40+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5."
0-,8)(298,-6"
182-:56"/+,,C"9206&"
&1A"+,17&,A"82+,"
6&1-"dR"),+7,-6."2-(9"
6&,-"6&,":2B,+-8,-6"
+,176,A"#R!!"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!$`!T]<"
_,150+,5"?,+,"@15,A"
2-"6&,"5,70+,A";O`
>0-A5"Z%1)1A2)20(20"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"!T]<"
"
*&,"7288'66,,"
Z=7',-6'>'7"H288'66,,"
2>"6&,"E16'2-1("
H20-7'("2>"
U5527'16'2-"2>"
j2716'2-1("*+1'-'-:"
62";8)(298,-6]"6&16"
)+2)25,A"6&,"+,>2+8"
62"6&,"_'-'56+9"2>"
,8)(298,-6"?15"
A'B'A,A<"=28,"
8,8@,+5"2))25,A"
6&,"50::,56'2-5."
1+:0'-:"6&16"'6"?20(A"
)06"622"807&"2>"1"
>2705"2-"'-A'B'A01("
+,5)2-5'@'('69"1-A"
?,1C,-"6&,"5616,I5"
A06',5"62"71+,">2+"6&,"
0-,8)(29,A"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"T!]<"
TR"
"
%+2@(,8L"%+2:+18"
A'A"-26"1((2?">2+"
81-9"920-:"),2)(,"
62"+,,-6,+"6&,"(1@2+"
81+C,6">2+"1"(2-:,+"
6'8,"),+'2Ac"8256"
A+2)),A"206"1>6,+"6&,"
)+2:+18"&1A">'-'5&,A"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!^]<"
DA,15"?,+,"
6+1-5>,++,A">+28"6&,"
,Q),+',-7,"'-"26&,+"
720-6+',5."@06"-26"
1A1)6,A"62"6&,"/+,,C"
(1@2+"81+C,6"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"#!]<"
"
4'57055,A"6&,">'+56"
6'8,"A0+'-:"6&,"
7+'5'5c"'A,1"718,">+28"
1":09"?&2"?,+,"1"
>2+8,+"2>>'7,+"'-"
3+055,(5"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"T!]<"
"
*&,"6&,-"%152C"
:2B,+-8,-6"1A2)6,A"
6&,")+2:+18"
>2((2?'-:"6&,"
+,7288,-A16'2-5"2>"
6&,"g2+(A"31-C"1-A"
6&,"D_K"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"T#]<"
InnGR3:'=6+'76,+"
+0(,5">2+"2@61'-'-:"1"
>0(("),-5'2-"5'-7,"
;Q6,+-1(")+,550+,"
"
K+'56"166,8)65"62"
M':&(9"51(',-6"'550,"
A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5."2>"
720+5,"
/+,,C"),-5'2-"
+,>2+85"&1A"@,,-"
)256)2-,A"5'-7,"6&,"
T!"
"
#R!^<"E261@(9."6&,"
2B,+1(("(,B,("2>"
),-5'2-5"?'(("@,"
71(70(16,A"1772+A'-:"
62"6&,"508"2>"1(("
9,1+5."-26"2-(9"6&,"
@,56">'B,"9,1+5"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!J]<"
+,>2+8"6&,"/+,,C"
),-5'2-"5956,8"&1A"
@,,-"81A,"'-"![[J"
@9"1">2+8,+"D_K"
7&1'+81-"?&2"
)+,A'76,A"6&,"
72((1)5,"2>"6&,"/+,,C"
),-5'2-"5956,8"@9"
#RR^c"D-"6&,"518,"
B,'-."OP"17601+',5"
+,7288,-A,A"62"
5':-'>'71-6(9."+,>2+8"
6&,"),-5'2-"5956,8"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"$J]<"
"
F,>2+8"+,60+-,A"62"
6&,"61@(,"0-A,+"6&,"
)+,550+,"2>"6&,"
*+2'C1"
8'A`![[R5<"D6"&1A"
@,,-"B,+9"7(,1+"6&16"
6&,"A,81-A">2+"
>'-1-7'-:"?20(A"
,Q)(2+,."@06"1"
72-5,-505"2-"1"+,1("
+,>2+8"720(A"-26"@,"
>20-A"Z%1)1A2)20(20"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"!J]<"
O-'2-5"1-A"26&,+"
1762+5"7&1((,-:,"
+,>2+85"'-"720+6."
2>6,-"5077,55>0((9."
@,7105,"6&,9"?,+,"
,Q7(0A,A">+28"6&,"
)1+('18,-61+9"
A,7'5'2-`81C'-:"
)+27,55"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"#!]<"
%152C"1-A"6&,"(1@2+"
0-'2-5"2))25,A"6&,"
+,>2+8"'-"6&,"(16,"
![[R5.")+,5,-6'-:"
26&,+"71(70(16'2-5"
1-A",B'A,-7,"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"$J]<"
Common:"
*+2'C1"1-A"6&,"
8,82+1-A085"1>>,76"
1:,-A1`5,66'-:"2>"
'550,5"
Z%1)1A2)20(20",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!J]<"
"
V17C"2>"72-50(616'2-"
@,>2+,"+,>2+85"
1(+,1A9")+'2+"62"6&,"
7+'5'5c",B,-"(,55"
+,:1+A'-:"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
6&,"6+2'C1"A,81-A,A"
1-6'`7+'5'5")2('7',5c"
2>6,-"Z%1)1A2)20(20"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"#!]<"
HU!
InnHU1:'K'+56"
)+2:+18"7+,16,A"'-"
*&,+,"?15"2-,")+'2+"
)+2:+18."?&'7&"6&,"
"
D-'6'16,A"@9"6&,"
-16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-6"
T#"
"
#RR^."26&,+5"
>2((2?,A"#RRJ"1-A"
#R!#.",Q6,-A'-:"6&,"
@,-,>'65"62"26&,+"
B0(-,+1@(,":+20)5<"
*&,"=*UF*"71+A5"
Z=*UF*."=*UF*"%VO=."
=*UF*";t*FU."
=*UF*"3aEO="1-A"
=*UF*"F;/DaE]"1+,"
,55,-6'1((9"1"?1:,"
50@5'A9."?&'7&":+1-65"
61Q"+,(',>5">2+"?1:,5"
0)"62"1"7,+61'-",Q6,-6"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#!`##]<"
g2+(A"31-C"&1A"
>0-A,A"'-"6&,"![[R5"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#d]<"
"
D-"6&,"#RRJ."
,8)(298,-6"+16,"2>"
6&,")2)0(16'2-"
2B,+1(("1-A",5),7'1((9"
6&,"920-:"?15"
)1+6'70(1+(9"(2?"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#d."TT]<""
"
U5"2>"#RR\."6&,")0@('7"
,8)(298,-6"+16,"
,Q)(2A,A"%+2:+18"
?15">0-A,A"@9"6&,";O"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
T[]<"
*&,")+2:+185"
?2+C,A"?,(("1-A"6&,"
61+:,65"720(A"@,"
2B,+17&',B,A"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#T]<"
"
%+2:+18"?15">0-A,A"
@9"6&,";O."6&,+,>2+,"
6&,"'A,15"?,+,"
'8)(,8,-6,A"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#d]<"
*&,"106&2+5",56'816,"
6&16"?'6&206"6&,"
)+2:+18."
0-,8)(298,-6"'-"
M0-:1+9"?20(A"@,"
72-5'A,+1@(9"82+,"
&':&"
ZMO`F,)."#d]<"
T$"
"
InnHU2:'*&,"
)16&?19"62"?2+C"
57&,8,c"561+6,A"'-"
k1-01+9"#RR[c"6&25,"
?&2"71-"?2+C"
182-:56"6&,"
0-,8)(29,A"1+,")06"
'-62"1":,-,+1("?2+C"
57&,8,"1-A"-,,A"62"
A2")0@('7"?2+Cc"
-,,A5`@15,A"1-A"
+,7')',-65"-,,A"62"
722),+16,"ZV,-:9,(",6"
1(<"#R!^L"d\]<"
"
U(':-8,-6"?'6&"
0-,8)(298,-6"
155'561-7,"'-"#R!!"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
JR]<"
"
K'-,`60-'-:"2>"
57&,8,5"'-"#R!$"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
JR]<"
='8'(1+")+2:+185"
?,+,"1(+,1A9"+0-"
@,>2+,"5'-7,"6&,"(16,"
![\R5"1-A"&1A"@,,-"
+,`05,A"A0+'-:"6&,"
![[R5<"M2?,B,+."'6"
?15"2-(9"A0+'-:"6&,"
7+'5'5"2>"#RR[."6&16"
6&,"-08@,+"2>"
+,7')',-65"'-"6&,"
)+2:+18",Q7,,A,A"
6+,8,-A205(9"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
d[]<"
"
;B'A,-7,"'5"@,'-:"
':-2+,A"ZV,-:9,(",6"
1(<"#R!^L"J#]<"
"
D-")+'-7')(,."
:2B,+-8,-65"
50))2+6,A"6&,"'550,."
@06"6&,"@0+,107+179"
+,5'56,A"6&,5,"
)+2:+185.",5),7'1((9"
6&,"7+,16'2-"2>"6&,"
)16&?19"62"?2+C"
57&,8,"ZV,-:9,(",6"
1(<"#R!^L"JR]<"
"
%+2:+185"1+,"@,'-:"
'8)(,8,-6,A"A,5)'6,"
,B'A,-7,"6&16"6&,5,"
)+2:+185"A2"-26"
9',(A":22A"+,50(65"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
J#]."&2?,B,+"6&,9"
1+,"05,>0("62"166+176"
,(,762+1("50))2+6<"
InnHU3:'E,?"V1@2+"
H2A,"#R!!c"*&,"
+,>2+8",-61'(5"1"
5':-'>'71-6"
>(,Q'@'('516'2-"2>"6&,"
(1@2+"81+C,6c""
"
*&,"-,?"+,>2+8")06"
72-5'A,+1@(,"'8),605"
2-">+,,"+,:0(16'2-5"
@,6?,,-"0-'2-5"1-A"
,8)(29,+5."?&'7&"
?20(A"?,1C,-"6&,"
0-'2-5",B,-">0+6&,+"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
E26"@15,A"2-"1-9"
,Q),+'8,-65"2+"26&,+"
166,8)65."@06"6&,"
)+2:+18"?15"G056"
'8)(,8,-6,A"15"507&."
1>6,+"72-50(6'-:"(,:1("
e0,56'2-5"ZV,-:9,(",6"
1(<"#R!^L"JT]<"
"
U")+'2+"+,>2+8"'-"
#RRT"6&16"?15"
)+2)25,A"@9"6&,"
('@,+1(`(,>6"
:2B,+-8,-6">1'(,A"
A0,"62"6&,"+,5'561-7,"
2>"6&,"O-'2-5"
ZV,-:9,(",6"1(<"#R!^L"
J$]<"
"
*&,"a+@1-"
:2B,+-8,-6"&1A"
,Q7(0A,A"6&,"0-'2-5"
>+28"72-50(616'2-"
1-A"6&,9"2-(9"?,+,"
TT"
"
JT]<"
&,1+A"1>6,+"6&,";O"
1-A"6&,"DVa"&1A")06"
)+,550+,"2-"6&,"
M0-:1+'1-"
:2B,+-8,-6"ZV,-:9,("
,6"1(<"#R!^L"JT]<"
Common:"
"
"
"
IT!
InnIT1:'
U))+,-6'7,5&')">2+"
920-:"?2+C,+5c"6&+,,"
1A1)616'2-5L"#RR$."
#R!!."#R!$"Z=,+:'",6"
1(<"#R!^L"^!]<"
"
U>6,+"6&,"2-5,6"2>"6&,"
7+'5'5."9206&"
0-,8)(298,-6"
'-7+,15,A"56,1A'(9c"
72-52('A16'2-"176"2>"
#R!!"A'A"1(52"1>>,76"
6&,"9206&"1))+,-6'7,"
5956,8"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"^!`^^]<"g&16"'5"
82+,."6&,"#R!!"
+,>2+8"5&20(A"
'8)+2B,"6&,"-,6?2+C"
2>"527'1(")1+6-,+5"1-A"
+,:'2-5"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!T]<""
"
#R!$"+,>2+8"0-A,+"
V,661"1-A"6&,"#R!T"
A,7+,,"0-A,+"F,-N'"
>2705,A"2-"
5'8)('>9'-:"72-6+1765"
>2+"1))+,-6'7,5."61Q"
+,(',>5">2+",8)(29,+5"
1-A"+,A07,A"6+1'-'-:"
2+:1-'N16'2-5<"*&,5,"
+,>2+85"?'6&A+,?"
_1'-")+2@(,8"2>"6&,"
>'+56"+,>2+85"'-"6&,"
![[R5"?15"6&,"
0-,8)(298,-6"+16,"
182-:56"920-:"
),2)(,"1-A"1"(17C"2>"
6+1-5'6'2-"62"6&,"
(1@2+"81+C,6<"g&16"'5"
82+,."15"2>"6&,",1+(9"
#RRR5."6&,"D61('1-"
:2B,+-8,-6"?1-6,A"
62"+,176"62"6&,"61+:,65"
5,6"@9"6&,"V'5@2-"
Z#RRR]"1-A"
=627C&2(8"Z#RR!]"
61+:,65"1-A"6+',A"62"
(,1+-">+28"26&,+"
720-6+',5"ZV,-:9,(",6"
1(<"#R!^L"^!`^#]<"
"
#RR$"+,>2+8"
>2((2?,A"6&,"K+,-7&"
82A,("2>"6,+6'1+9"
&':&,+",A0716'2-"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"?15"
72)',A"."1-A"
,B1(016'2-5"?,+,"
81A,"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"^#]<"
"
D-"6&,"7+'5'5."6&,"
D61('1-":2B,+-8,-6"
60+-,A"62"/,+81-9"
"
U))+,-6'7,5&')"&15"1"
@1A"+,)0616'2-"'-"
D61(9."72-6+1+9"62"
U056+'1"1-A"/,+81-9"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"^!`
^^]<"
"
#R!!"+,>2+8"2>"6&,"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"
2770++,A"'-"6&,"
72-6,Q6"2>"1056,+'69."
?&'7&"'-6,++0)6,A"
,1+(',+"+,>2+85"
Z#RR$]"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"![]<"
"
40+'-:"6&,"_2-6'"
:2B,+-8,-6."6&,"
+,50(65"2>"6&,">176"
>'-A'-:"8'55'2-"62"
/,+81-9"5&20(A"@,"
'8)(,8,-6,A."@06"6&,"
)+27,55"?15"562)),A"
1>6,+"6&,"7&1-:,5"
>+28"6&,"_2-6'"62"6&,"
V,661"1-A"6&,-"6&,"
F,-N'":2B,+-8,-6<"
;5),7'1((9"6&,"(166,+"
7&1-:,",-A,A"6&,"
+,>2+8")+27,55"Z=,+:'"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"^$`^T]<"
T^"
"
>+28"6&,"72-7,)6"2>"
6&,"1))+,-6'7,5&')"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!^]<"
1-A"@,:1-"62"
)+2826,"-16'2-1("
1))+,-6'7,5&')"
72-6+1765"0-A,+"6&,"
_2-6'`/2B,+-8,-6<"
/,+81-"A01("82A,("
?15"+,:1+A,A"15"
5077,55>0("Z=,+:'",6"
1(<"#R!^L"^#]<"D-"#R!#."
A01("1))+,-6'7,5&')"
)+2:+18"?'6&"
/,+81-9."?&'7&"
1((2?,A"D61('1-"
920-:56,+5"62">'-A"
1))+,-6'7,5&')5"'-"
/,+81-9"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"^$]<"
K0+6&,+82+,">176`
>'-A'-:5"8'55'2-5"62"
/,+81-9."?&'7&"
>20-A"6&16"D61(9"
(17C,A",5),7'1((9"1"
-16'2-1("7,+6'>'716'2-"
5956,8"1-A"1"
722+A'-16'2-"2>"6&,"
+,:'2-5"1-A"
80-'7')1('6',5"Z=,+:'"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"^$]<"
InnIT2:'F,>2+8"2>"
0-,8)(298,-6"
@,-,>'65c"D-"6&,"9,1+5"
#RRR`#R!#"6&,"
@,-,>'65">2+"
0-,8)(29,A"?,+,"
,Q6,-A,A"
72-6'-0205(9."'-"D61(9<"
H2-5,e0,-6(9."6&,"
81'-">2705"2>"V_%5"
?15"2-")155'B,"
,(,8,-65"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
U>6,+"#R!!."6&,"
,Q6,+-1(")+,550+,"2-"
D61(9"'-7+,15,A"
72-5'A,+1@(9."5'-7,"
6&,"*+2'C1"A,81-A,A"
72-52('A16'2-")2('7',5"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"$T`
$^]<"
"
D-"#RR[."?&,-"6&,"
>'+56"+,:'2-1("
:2B,+-8,-65"?1-6,A"
"
H22+A'-16'2-"2>"
80-'7')1('6',5"1-A"
+,:'2-5"'5"(17C'-:."
?&'7&"?15"1")+2@(,8"
'-"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
26&,+5I"@,56")+176'7,5"
1-A",>>,76'B,(9"
&18),+,A"(,1+-'-:"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"
^d]<"
"
Td"
"
#R!^L"$$`$T]<"
"
U>6,+"6&,"#RR[."6&,"
@,-,>'65"?,+,"
'-7+,15,A."@06"528,"
,(,8,-65"2>"
72-A'6'2-1('69"1-A"
UV_%5"?,+,"1AA,A."
'-"6&,"@,:'--'-:"6&'5"
?15"&2?,B,+"8256(9"
,Q),+'8,-61((9"Z=,+:'"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"$T]<"
"
K2+",Q18)(,"6&,"
#R!#"+,>2+8"
,Q6,-A,A",(':'@'('69"62"
82+,":+20)5."@06"
,(':'@'('69"72-6+2("
@,718,"807&"6':&6,+"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"$^]"
62"05,";=K"82-,9."6&,"
)2('7',5"&1A"62"5&'>6"
62?1+A5"82+,"
UV_%5<"='-7,"6&,"
A,81-A">2+">'-1-7'-:"
'-7+,15,A"'-"#R!#."
6&,"-16'2-1("
:2B,+-8,-6"
A,81-A,A"
-,:26'16'2-5"?'6&"6&,"
;=K"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$d]<"
"
O501((9."
)2('7981C'-:"'-"D61(9"
A+'B,-"@9")+2@(,8"
)+,550+,"+16&,+"6&1-"
)2('79"(,1+-'-:<"
4'>>,+,-6"'-"#RR[."
5'-7,"6&,+,"?15"1"
-,,A">2+"7+,16'B,"
52(06'2-5."15"6&,"
+,)2+6"1+:0,5c"='-7,"
UV_%5"?,+,"
-,7,551+9"62":,6"6&,"
;=K"82-,9."+,:'2-1("
2>>'7,5"?,+,"1((2?,A"
62"W,Q),+'8,-6Y"`r"
@06"-26"81-9"A'A"'-"
6&,",-A"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"^^`^d]<"
"
V,1+-'-:">+28"6&,"
M1+6N`+,>2+8"'-"
/,+81-9"62"1A1)6"6&,"
5,72-A")'((1+"2>"
0-,8)(298,-6"
)+26,76'2-"Z=,+:'",6"
1(<"#R!^L"^d]<"
V,1+-'-:">+28"
/,+81-9"2770++,A"62"
528,",Q6,-6."@06"6&,"
527'1(")1+6-,+5"
B,62,A"6&,"
82A'>'716'2-"2>"5&2+6`
6,+8"?2+C"1-A"1"
+,>2+8"2>"527'1("
155'561-7,"57&,8,5"
?,+,"-26")06"'-62"6&,"
+,>2+8")17C1:,<"
InnIT3:'F,>2+8"2>"
;=K"82-,9"561+6,A"
"
"
TJ"
"
6&,")0@('7"
,8)(298,-6"
5,+B'7,5c"D-"D61(9."
)(17,8,-6"5,+B'7,5"
&1A"@,,-"'-")0@('7"
&1-A5"1-A"?15"
:+1A01((9")+'B16'N,A"
A0+'-:"6&,"![[R5<"
*&,"+,152-5">2+"6&'5"
?,+,")1+6(9";O"+0(,5"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#d]<"_1'-"%+2@(,8L"
(17C"2>"722+A'-16'2-"
@,6?,,-"+,:'2-1("1-A"
80-'7')1("1:,-7',5<"
a-(9"'-"#R!^."6&,"
-16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-6"
7+,16,A"1"E16'2-1("
U:,-79">2+"U76'B,"
V1@2+"_1+C,6"%2('7',5"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#J]<"*+1'-'-:"'5"
0501((9"'-"6&,"&1-A5"
2>"6&,"+,:'2-5"1-A"
>'-1-7,A"@9";=K"
82-,9"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"$R]<"
6&,"'8)(,8,-616'2-"
2>"UV_%5"'-"D61(9"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"
^\]<";0+2),1-'N16'2-"
ZUV_%5]"1-A"05,"2>"
;0+2),1-"82-,9">2+"
D61('1-")2('7',5"Z7256`
5&'>6'-:]"Z=,+:'",6"1(<"
#R!^L"^\]<"
"
a;H4"&15"7+'6'7'N,A"
6&16"D61('1-"%;="1+,"'(("
,e0')),A">2+"
5956,816'7"6+1'-'-:c"
'-"/,+81-9")0@('7"
1:,-7',5"1+,"807&"
@,66,+"561>>,A"6&1-"'-"
D61(9">2+",Q18)(,"
Z=,+:'",6"1(<"#R!^L"
^\]<"
Common:"
"
"
"
NL!
InnNL1:'%1+6'7')16'2-"
(1?"#R!$c"D-6,:+16'2-"
2>"6&+,,",Q'56'-:"
(1?5L"527'1("
155'561-7,."5&,(6,+,A"
,8)(298,-6"176">2+"
A'51@(,A"?2+C,+5."
@,-,>'65">2+"
0-,8)(29,A"?&2"
&1B,"@,718,"
A'51@(,A"@,>2+,"6&,9"
60+-,A"!\<"*&,"-,?"
F,5,1+7&"+,)2+65"
&1B,")(19,A"1-"
'8)2+61-6"+2(,"'-"
)066'-:"6&,"'550,"2-"
6&,"1:,-A1."'<,<"6&,"
A,j+',5"+,)2+6"
Z#RR\]"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"[]<"
"
#RR[`#R!#L"
E16'2-?'A,"
,Q),+'8,-65"ZU1",6"1(<"
"
D-"6&,"A,7'5'2-`
81C'-:")+27,55."
)1+6',5"1-A"
561C,&2(A,+5"?,+,"
A'B'A,AL"H&+'56'1-"
A,827+165"1-A"
('@,+1(5"15"?,(("15"6&,"
80-'7')1('6',5"
50))2+6,A"6&,"
A,j+',5"+,)2+6<"*&,"
527'1(`A,827+165"1-A"
6&,"0-'2-5"2))25,A"
T\"
"
(1?"6'+,5"62")+2B'A,"
5,+B'7,5"62"6&,5,"
),2)(,"1-A"
+,'-6,:+16,"6&,8"'-"
6&,"(1@2+"81+C,6"1-A"
50))2+6",8)(29,+5"
>'-1-7'1((9"'-"&'+'-:"
6&,5,"),2)(,<"g&16"'5"
82+,."80-'7')1('6',5"
?'(("@,"'-"7&1+:,"2>"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"S"
1-A"1(52">'-1-7'-:"2>"
6&,5,"8,150+,5"`r"
1B,-0,">2+"7256`
5&'>6'-:"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"J]<"
#R!^L"!R]<"
"
V,1+-'-:")(19,A"1-"
'8)2+61-6"+2(,"'-"6&'5"
+,>2+8"'-"6&,"
>2((2?'-:"?195<"
M2?,B,+."6&,"8256"
'8)2+61-6"e0,56'2-5"
?,+,"@0A:,61+9"
'550,5<"!<"*&,"
)+2)251("?15"@15,A"
2-"5616'56'71("
'->2+816'2-."?&'7&"
?15"'8)2+61-6"ZU1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"$d]<"#<"
U71A,8'7"+,5,1+7&"
+,)2+65")(19,A"1-"
'8)2+61-6"+2(,">2+"
1:,-A1"5,66'-:"ZU1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"$J]<"$<"
;Q),+'8,-65"?,+,"
A2-,<"M2?,B,+."6&,'+"
)2('79"'8)176"?15"
+16&,+"82A,56."5'-7,"
+,7288,-A16'2-5"
?,+,"-26"B,+9"
5),7'>'7<"M2?,B,+."6&,"
,Q),+'8,-65"&1A"
528,"'8)176"1-A"
)+2B'A,A"05,>0("
,B'A,-7,5">2+"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
6&,"8,150+,5"ZU1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"$\]<"T<"
%2('79",Q),+65"?,+,"
&,1+A"'-"6&,"
>2+801(16'2-")+27,55."
@06"6&,'+"'->2+816'2-"
?15"-26"72-5'A,+,A"
'8)2+61-6<"^<"
6&,")(1-5.",5),7'1((9"
@,7105,"6&,9"A'A"-26"
6+056"6&,"71)17'6',5"2>"
6&,"7'6',5"62"
'8)(,8,-6"6&,"
)+2:+18"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!R]<"
"
*&,")256`,Q),+'8,-6"
A,7'5'2-`81C'-:"
)+27,55"?15"&,1B'(9"
'->(0,-7,A"@9"6&,"1-6'"
7+'5'5")2('7',5<"E,?."
=27'1("4,827+16'7"
:2B,+-8,-6."?&'7&"
,B,-601((9"1:+,,A"
?'6&"6&,")+2)251("
1(6&20:&"6&,")1+69"
&1A"2))25,A"'6"@,>2+,"
6&,"7+'5'5<"*&,"
80-'7')1('6',5"?,+,"
C'7C,A"206"2>"6&,"
)+27,55."1(6&20:&"
6&,9"&1A")1+6'7')16,A"
@,>2+,<"D-"6&,",-A."
6&,+,"?15"1"
728)+28'5,"@,6?,,-"
6&,"6?2"@'::,56"
)1+6',5"-,7,551+9."
5'-7,"6&,"=27'1("
4,827+165"&1A"-2"
81G2+'69"'-"6&,"
=,-16,<"H256`
72-61'-8,-6")(19,A"1"
82+,"'8)2+61-6"+2(,"
6&1-"e01('69"2>"
5,+B'7,5"A0,"62"6&,"
7+'5'5"72-6,Q6<"ZU1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"!!]<"
T["
"
D-6,+-16'2-1("
(,1+-'-:"?15"-26"52"
'8)2+61-6.",5),7'1((9"
6&,";O"7&1--,(5"A'A"
-26")(19"1"+2(,"
72-6+1+9"62"O="
,Q),+',-7,5<"
/,+81-9"1-A"
3,(:'08"?,+,"
8,-6'2-,A"15"520+7,5"
2>"'-5)'+16'2-."1-A"
=71-A'-1B'1-"
720-6+',5"15"
,Q18)(,5">2+"
A,7,-6+1('N16'2-"ZU1"
,6"1(<"#R!^L"$J`$[]<"
"
InnNL2:'D-7+,15,"2>"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,">+28"
d^"62"dJc"6&,"+,>2+8"
)155,A"'-"#R!^"ZU1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"!J]<"
%+,550+,"@9"6&,";O"
1-A"6&,"a;H4"62"
+,>2+8">156,+"15"?,(("
15"6&,"31CC,+"
H288'55'2-"6&16"
0-A,+('-,A"1:1'-"'-"
#RR\"6&16"6&,"
A,82:+1)&'7"
)+,550+,"2-"6&,"
),-5'2-"5956,8"
?20(A"'-7+,15,",B,-"
>0+6&,+<"
"
*&,"#RR\"7+'5'5"1-A"
6&,"-,7,55'69"62"
72-52('A16,"6&,"
)0@('7"@0A:,6"2),-,A"
6&,"?'-A2?"2>"
2))2+60-'69"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"$[`TR]<"
%,-5'2-"+,>2+85"'-"
6&,"E,6&,+(1-A5"'5"1"
&':&(9"51(',-6"'550,"
1-A")0@('7"2)'-'2-"
>',+7,(9"2))25,A"
7&1-:'-:"6&,",Q'56'-:"
5956,8"6&16":+1-6,A"
,B,+9"7'6'N,-"16"(,156"
JRs"2>"6&,"8'-'808"
?1:,"15"2>"d^<"D-"6&,"
![[T."6&,"H&+'56'1-"
A,827+165"5,B,+,(9"
(256"'-",(,76'2-5"?&,-"
1--20-7'-:"62"+1'5,"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"1-A"'-"
#RRd."6&,"527'1("
A,827+165"50>>,+,A"
5':-'>'71-6(9"'-"6&,"
)2((5"1>6,+"@+'-:'-:"
6&,"'550,"62"6&,"
1:,-A1"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"$[`TR]<"
#RR\"7+'5'5"?15"1"
?'-A2?"2>"
2))2+60-'69"1-A"
)0@('7"+,5'561-7,"
1:1'-56"'-7+,15'-:"
6&,"+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"
+,A07,A"1-A"?1+-'-:"
@9"57',-6'56"?,+,"
&,1+A<"*&,"
72-5,+B16'B,"
:2B,+-8,-6">1'(,A"62"
+,17&"1"72-5,-505"
?'6&"6&,"527'1("
)1+6-,+5<"a-(9"6&,"
F066,"D"1-A"F066,"
:2B,+-8,-65"
5077,,A,A"62"@+'-:"1"
@'(("62"6&,")1+('18,-6"
'-"#R!$."?&'7&"
)155,A"1-A"'-7+,15,A"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"62"dJ"
15"2>"#R#^<"D-"#R!^"
1-26&,+"+,>2+8"?15"
^R"
"
1AA,A."?&'7&"('-C,A"
6&,"+,6'+,8,-6"1:,"62"
1B,+1:,"('>,"
,Q),761-79"1-A"
'-7+,15,A"
,-6'6(,8,-6"1:,"
>156,+"ZU1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!J]<""
"
H2-5,-505"@,6?,,-"
6&,")1+6',5"6&16"1"
+,>2+8"'5"-,7,551+9c"
)+2@(,8"?15")0@('7"
2))25'6'2-"1-A"
2))25'6'2-"@9"6+1A,"
0-'2-5]<"
InnNL3:'g2+C"1-A"
=,70+'69"U76."#R!TL"
*&,"176"7&1-:,5"6&,"
A'58'551("2>"?2+C,+5"
1-A"6&,"72-A'6'2-5"2>"
>(,Q"?2+Cc"'6"
@+21A,-5"6&,"177,55"
62"a(A,+"
O-,8)(298,-6"
D-728,"=7&,8,"U76."
@06"-1++2?5"6&,"
177,55"62"6&,"a(A,+"
1-A"%1+6'1((9"
4'51@(,A"g2+C,+5"
O-,8)(298,-6"
D-728,"=7&,8,"U76"
ZU1",6"1(<"#R!^L"#R]<"
V'66(,"(,1+-'-:"'-"6&'5"
'--2B16'2-L"F16&,+"
)2?,+'-:"6&1-"
)0NN('-:."@,7105,"6&,"
)+2G,76"?15"50@G,76"62"
72-5'A,+1@(,"
-,:26'16'2-5"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"TR]<"
"
D->2+81("-,6?2+C5"
?,+,"B,+9"'8)2+61-6<"
=7',-6'>'7",Q),+65"
?,+,"72-50(6,A"2-(9"
'->2+81((9<"40,"62"6&,"
5&2+6"6'8,"),+'2A">2+"
6&,")+2G,76."6&,+,"?15"
-2"6'8,">2+",Q6,-5'B,"
)'(26")+2G,765"ZU1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"T!]<"
"
O5,"2>"528,"
5616'56'71("A161c"6&,"
31CC,+"7288'55'2-"
?15"8,-6'2-,A"15"
"
*&,"+,>2+8"'5"6&,"
+,50(6"2>"6&,")2('6'71("
-,:26'16'2-5"@,6?,,-"
)2('6'71(")1+6',5"1-A"
6&,"527'1(")1+6-,+5"
ZU1",6"1(<"#R!^L"#!`
##]</,-,+1((9."6&,+,"
?15"1"72-5,-505"
+,:1+A'-:"8256"2>"6&,"
72-6,-65<"a-(9"6&,"
,8)(29,+5")+,>,++,A"
1"(,55"728)(,Q"
A'58'551("(1?"ZU1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"#$]<"
"
*&,"8,150+,",-61'(,A"
5':-'>'71-6"@0A:,6"
7065"Z!<#"3'((]."@06"6&,"
72-6,Q6"2>"6&,"7+'5'5"
(,:'6'8'N,A"6&,5,"
8,150+,5"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"#$]<"
^!"
"
@,'-:"'8)2+61-6"
5,B,+1("6'8,5<"*&,"
+2(,"2>"6&,";O."?15"
+16&,+"8'-2+<"*&,"
_'5527"A161@15,"?15"
05,A"62"728)1+,"6&,"
4067&"0-,8)(298,-6"
@,-,>'65"62"6&25,"2>"
26&,+";0+2),1-"
720-6+',5"1-A"62">'-A"
206"6&16"6&,"4067&"
5956,8"?15"+16&,+"
:,-,+205"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"T!]<"
Common:"
aB,+1((."6&,"106&2+5"
1+:0,"6&16"6&,+,"'5"
('66(,")2('79"(,1+-'-:."
8256(9"52"'-"6&,"
+,>2+8"2>"6&,"
+,6'+,8,-6"1:,."
?&,+,"6&,+,"?15"1"
(1+:,"72-5,-505"
182-:56"
561C,&2(A,+5"1-A"
)1+6',5"15"?,(("15"
72-B'-7'-:",B'A,-7,<"
_2+,":,-,+1((9."
)2('6'7'1-5"6,-A"62"
177,)6"6&,"'-5':&65"2>"
57',-6'>'7",B'A,-7,"
ZU1",6"1(<"#R!^L"T#]<"
"
*+'1("1-A",++2+"15"
?,(("15"5616'56'71("
'->2+816'2-"1+,"82+,"
'8)2+61-6"6&1-"
728)(,Q"
,Q),+'8,-65."5'-7,"
6&,+,"'5"(,55"7256"
16617&,A"62"6&,"
"
%2('6'71("-,:26'16'2-5"
1+,"'8)2+61-6c"?&16"
'5"82+,."
)2('7981C,+5"2>6,-"
?1'6">2+"6&,"+':&6"
828,-6"62"
'8)(,8,-6"1-"'A,1"
ZU1",6"1(<"#R!^L"T#]."
?&,-"'6">'65"6&,'+"
),+52-1("1:,-A1<"
^#"
"
>2+8,+"ZU1",6"1(<"
#R!^L"T$]<"
SLO!
InnSLO1:'%,-5'2-"
+,>2+85"'-"#R!R"1-A"
#R!$<"*&,":21("?15"62"
+,A07,")0@('7"
,8)(298,-6"1-A":,6"
15"81-9"),2)(,"15"
)255'@(,"2>>"6&,"
)0@('7"5,762+"
Zk25')2B'u"1-A"v08'"
#R!^L"d]<"
``"
``"
``"
InnSLO2:'V1@2+"
_1+C,6"F,:0(16'2-"
U76c"-2"7(,1+"
'->2+816'2-"1B1'(1@(,"
+,:1+A'-:"6'8'-:"1-A"
5,e0,-7,5"Zk25')2B'u"
1-A"v08'"#R!^L"[`
!!]<"
``"
``"
``"
InnSLO3:'U76"62"
)+,B,-6"0-A,7(1+,A"
?2+Cc"6&,+,"?,+,"
5,B,+1("+,>2+85."
#R!R."#R!!."#R!$"1-A"
#R!T<"*&,"+,>2+8"'-"
#R!T",Q,8)6,A"528,"
>2+85"2>"?2+C">+28"
A,7(1+16'2-."@06"6&,"
+,)2+6"'5"-26"B,+9"
5),7'>'7"1@206"'6"
Zk25')2B'u"1-A"v08'"
#R!^L"!$]<"
``"
``"
``"
Common:'U76'B,"
"
"
U))1+,-6(9"1(("6&,"
+,>2+85"?,+,"1"
+,176'2-"62"6&,"
A,81-A5"@9"6&,";O"
1-A"6&,"15527'16,A"
A,81-A5">2+">'571("
722+A'-16'2-c"+,)2+6"
^$"
"
5,,85"62"@,"7+'6'71("
1@206"6&'5."@06"A2,5"
-26",Q)(1'-"1-9"
>0+6&,+"Zk25')2B'u"
1-A"v08'"#R!^L"!\]<"
SP!
InnSP1:'U76'B,"
D-5,+6'2-"D-728,c"
H+,16,A"15"2>"#RRR"
@15,A"2-"6,8)2+1("
A,7+,,5c">0(("
,561@('5&8,-6"'-"
#RRd"Z_1+6w-,N`
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!#]<"
K2((2?,A"6&,"
50::,56'2-"2>"6&,";O."
-261@(9"6&,";0+2),1-"
H288'55'2-<"U6"6&,"
6'8,"Z#RRR`#RRd]."
6&,":21("2>"6&,")2('79"
?15"62"'-7(0A,"
B0(-,+1@(,":+20)5"'-"
6&,"(1@2+"81+C,6c"
&2?,B,+."6&'5"
7&1-:,A"A0+'-:"6&,"
7+'5'5<"*&,-"6&,"
'-56+08,-6"@,718,"1"
622("62"'-7(0A,"
,B,+9@2A9."A0+'-:"
6&,"7+'5'5`"
+,5),76'B,(9"6&,"
-08@,+5"2>"
1))('716'2-5"`r"#R!#"
F,>2+8."*':&6,-'-:"2>"
72-A'6'2-5"Z_1+6w-,N`
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!$]"
"
E26"B,+9")2('6'7'N,Ac"
-2")1+69"A'>>,+,-7,5"
+,:1+A'-:"6&,"+,>2+8"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"!$]<"h,6."
6&,+,"?15"2))25'6'2-"
2>"@05'-,55"
2+:1-'N16'2-5"62"6&,"
+,>2+8"Z_1+6w-,N`
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!^]<"
InnSP2:'*,8)2+1+9"
155'561-7,"57&,8,">2+"
0-,8)(298,-6"62"
50))2+6"+,'-5,+6'2-"
'-"6&,"G2@"81+C,6<"
=,+B'7,5"72-61'-,A"
'-728,">2+"6&25,"?&2"
&1B,"-2"82+,"7(1'85"
2-"+,:0(1+"
0-,8)(298,-6"
@,-,>'65"Z7+,16,A"
#R!!]"Z_1+6w-,N`
*&,"+,152-5">2+"6&,"
+,>2+8"?,+,"1@2B,"
1(("6&,",72-28'7"1-A"
527'1(")+,550+,5"2>"
6&,"7+'5'5"Z_1+6w-,N`
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!J]<";B1(016'2-"1-A"
1A1)616'2-"2>"6&,"
)+2:+18"'-"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"!#]<"
h,6.")+'2+"62"
M':&"0-,8)(298,-6"
'5"1"51(',-6"'550,."
)+,5081@(9."'-"=)1'-<"
;55,-6'1((9."@26&"
)1+6',5"50))2+6,A"6&,"
8,150+,<"*&,"
527'1('56":2B,+-8,-6"
7+,16,A"6&20:&"6&,"
)2('79"1-A"6&,"F1G29"
:2B,+-8,-6"A'A"-26"
1@2('5&"'6"'-"#R!#."9,6"
6&,+,"?,+,"528,"
A'57055'2-5"?'6&"6&,"
0-'2-5"1@206"6&,"
)+2:+18"Z_1+6w-,N`
^T"
"
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!d]c"F,>2+8"'-"#R!#."
1A1)616'2-"1>6,+"6&,"
,B1(016'2-"Z_1+6w-,N`
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!J`!\]<"
'-6+2A07'-:"6&,"
'-56+08,-6."1")'(26"
&1A">1'(,A"1-A"6&,"
)2('79"?15"7+,16,A"
1772+A'-:"62"C-2?-"
)+176'7,5"+16&,+"6&1-"
5077,55>0("
,Q),+'8,-616'2-"Z-2"
(,1+-'-:]."15"528,"2>"
6&,"'-6,+B',?"
)1+6-,+5"+,)2+6,A<"
;B1(016'2-5"2>"6&,"
)2('79"5&2?,A"6&16"
2-(9"!\s"2>"
+,7')',-65">20-A"G2@5"
>2+"82+,"6&1-"6?2"
82-6&5"1>6,+"
>'-'5&'-:"6&,")+2:+18"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"T[`^R]<"
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!J]<"*&,"72-5,+B16'B,"
:2B,+-8,-6"1A1)6,A"
6&,")+2:+18"
1772+A'-:"62"6&,"
561-A1+A5"2>"6&,"
)+'2+":2B,+-8,-6"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"!J`!\]<"
InnSP3:'=6+16,:9"2>"
,-720+1:'-:"
;-6+,)+,-,0+5&')"
1-A"5,(>`,8)(298,-6"
Z#R!$`#R!d]c":21("
,-720+1:,"
,8)(298,-6"1-A"5,(>`
,-6+,)+,-,0+5&')"2>"
920-:"),2)(,<"*1Q`
+,(',>">2+"920-:"
0-,8)(29,Ac"81C'-:"
5,(>`,8)(298,-6"
728)16'@(,"?'6&"
0-,8)(298,-6"
@,-,>'65"Z_1+6w-,N`
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#R]<"
_1'-")+2@(,8"
)+,550+,L"(1+:,"
-08@,+"2>"
0-,8)(29,A"920-:"
),2)(,c"(1+:,"'-7+,15,"
A0+'-:"6&,"7+'5'5"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"#!]<"DA,15"
728,">+28"6&,";O"
56+16,:',5"Z_1+6w-,N`
_2('-1",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#!]c"=6+2-:";O"
'->(0,-7,."'<,<"6&,"
>2((2?'-:"
'-56+08,-65L"*&,"
=6+16,:9"#R#R.";O"
h206&"=6+16,:9"#R!R`
#R!\.";0+2),1-"
h206&"/01+1-6,,"
D-'6'16'B,"1-A"6&,"
j,+9"51(',-6"'550,"
%2('79"?15"
>2+80(16,A"1-A"
)155,A"@9"6&,"
72-5,+B16'B,")1+69c"
-2"5':-'>'71-6"
2))25'6'2-"@9"26&,+"
)1+6',5"`r"-,,A5"62"@,"
5,,-"1>6,+"1")255'@(,"
7&1-:,"'-"
:2B,+-8,-6"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"##]<"
^^"
"
K(1:5&')"'-'6'16'B,"
h206&"2-"6&,"_2B,"
1-A"a))2+60-'6',5">2+"
h206&"D-'6'16'B,"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"T$]c"%2('79"
@15,A"2-"e01-6'616'B,"
,B1(016'2-5"@9"
-16'2-1("1-A"
;0+2),1-"5616'56'75c"
7'B'("5,+B1-65"
728)(1'-"6&16"6&,'+"
,Q),+',-7,"'5"-26"
61C,-"'-62"
72-5'A,+16'2-"1-A"
/,+81-9"5&20(A"@,"
61C,-"15"1"82A,(<"U6"
6&,"518,"6'8,"6&,"
+,)2+6"5195"6&16"
'-6,+B',?")1+6-,+5"
0-A,+('-,A"6&16"
(,1+-'-:">+28"26&,+5"
'5"A'>>'70(6."A0,"62"
0-'e0,"-16'2-1("
7&1+176,+'56'75"
Z_1+6w-,N`_2('-1",6"
1(<"#R!^L"TT]<"
Common:"
"
"
"
SWE!
InnSWE1:'H28)(,6,"
+,>2+8"2>"6&,"
=?,A'5&"5,72-A1+9"
,A0716'2-"5956,8."
'-7(0A'-:"-,?"
70++'70(08."
,A0716'2-":21(5"1-A"
:+1A'-:"571(,5<"a-,"
)+28'-,-6"1-A"
'8)2+61-6",(,8,-6"
?15"6&,"'A,1"62"
56+,-:6&,-"6&,"
*&,"8,A'1")+,5,-6,A"
6&,",Q),+',-7,5"'-"
26&,+"720-6+',5.">2+"
,Q18)(,"'-"
=?'6N,+(1-A"1-A"
/,+81-9."15"?,(("15"
4,-81+C<"*&,"
52(06'2-"6&,9"
50::,56,A",-61'(,A"
@,66,+"722+A'-16'2-"
@,6?,,-",8)(29,+5"
1-A"6&,"5616,"62"&1B,"
"
*&,"+':&6"?'-:")1+69"
&1A"81A,"6&,"'550,"
)1+6"2>"'65",(,762+1("
718)1':-"'-"#RRd"
ZgMhii]"1-A"5,6"0)"1"
7288'66,,"62"
)+2)25,"1"-,?"
56+0760+,">2+"
5,72-A1+9",A0716'2-"
'-"#RRJc"6&,")2('6'71("
)+27,55"728)+'5,A"2>"
1-"'-7(05'2-"2>"61+:,6"
^d"
"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"
)+2:+18"1-A"7+,16,"
6':&6,+"72--,76'2-5"
@,6?,,-">'+85"1-A"
6&,"57&22("5956,8c"
6&,"@'((")155,A"
)1+('18,-6"'-"#RR\"
1-A"6&,"+,>2+8"?15"
'-6+2A07,A"'-"#R!!"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"#d`
#J]<"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"
)+2:+185"6&16"
72++,5)2-A"?'6&"6&,"
A,81-A5"2>"6&,"(1@2+"
81+C,6"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"T\`
T[]<"
"
U))+,-6'7,5&')5"
)+2:+185"?,+,"
'-6+2A07,A"15"6+'1(5"
'-"#RR\<"*&,+,"&1A"
@,,-"166,8)65"@,>2+,"
62"56+,-:6&,-"
,A0716'2-"2-"6&,"
)+'B16,"81+C,6."@06"
6&,+,")+2@(,85."507&"
15"6&,">'-1-7'1("
728),-516'2-">2+"
,8)(29,+5">2+"
,Q18)(,"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"T[`
^R]<"
:+20)5"'-")2('79"
>2+80(16'2-"Z6+1A,"
2+:1-'N16'2-5."527'1("
)1+6-,+5."57&22("
0-'2-5"1-A"560A,-6"
2+:1-'N16'2-5]"15"
?,(("15"1")0@('7"
&,1+'-:"2>"6&,"
(,:'5(16'B,"A+1>6<"*&,"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"
)+2:+18"?15"8256"
A,@16,A.",5),7'1((9"
6&,"A,(,:16'2-"2>"
6+1'-'-:"728),6,-7,5"
62">'+85<"*&,"
@0+,107+179"2))25,A"
6&,5,"+,>2+85."@06"
6&,":2B,+-8,-6"
'-5'56,A"1-A"6&,"
1))+,-6'7,5&')"?15"
5,6"0)"Z=g;`F,)."#J`
#\]<"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"#J`
#\]<"
"
U")+2@(,8"+,:1+A'-:"
)2('79"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
6&,5,")+2:+18"?15"
6&16"6&,+,"?15"2-(9"1"
581(("-08@,+"2>"
560A,-65"?&2"?,+,"
+,1((9"'-6,+,56,A"'-"
6&,5,")+2:+185"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"$R]<"
InnSWE2:'U76'B'69"
728),-516'2-">2+"
A'51@(,A"9206&c"715&"
@,-,>'65c"'-6+2A07,A"
P,9")+2@(,85"
)+,550+,">2+"6&,"#RRJ"
+,>2+8L"'-7+,15'-:"
1))('716'2-5">2+"6&,"
"
*&,"(,>6":2B,+-8,-6"
'-6+2A07,A"6&,"#RR$"
)+2:+18c"'-"#RRJ"6&,"
+':&6`?'-:"
^J"
"
#RR$c"6&,"+,>2+8"
5&'>6,A"6&,",(':'@'('69"
>+28"![`$R"9,1+5c"
+,B'5,A"'-"#RRJc"
72-A'6'2-1('69L"6&,"
@,-,>'65"?,+,"+,(16,A"
62"528,")1'A"?2+C"
1-A"155,558,-6"
72-A'6'2-5"@,718,"
56+'76,+"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"$$`
$T]<"
@,-,>'6."@06"-2"
'-7+,15,"'-")(17,8,-6"
2-"6&,"(1@2+"81+C,6"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"$\]<"
"
U5"2>"#RR\."
82-'62+'-:"?15"
,561@('5&,A">2+"6&,"
)+2:+18"1"-08@,+"2>"
+,)2+65"?,+,"
)0@('5&,A<"D-"#R!!."
1-",B1(016'2-"5&2?,A"
6&16"5'-7,"![[^."
1))('716'2-"A20@(,A."
@06"6&,")(17,8,-6"
62?1+A5"+,:0(1+"
,8)(298,-6"
+,81'-,A"15"(2?"15"
,B,+"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"^!]<"
"
U5"2>"#RR\."6+'1(5"
?'6&")+'B16,"1762+5"62"
155,55"6&,'+"
)(17,8,-6"+16,5"
728)1+,A"62")0@('7"
1762+5."&2?,B,+"
)+'B16,")+2B'A,+5"A'A"
-26"728,"0)"?'6&"
@,66,+"+,50(65"Z_'-15"
1-A"U-A,+552-"#R!^L"
^!`^#]<"
"
U-26&,+")'(26"
155,55,A"@,66,+"
'-56+08,-65">2+"
+,60+-'-:"62"?2+C"
1-A"'8)+2B'-:"?2+C"
71)1@'('69<"U>6,+"
:2B,+-8,-6"
+,>2+8,A"6&,"
)+2:+18"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"$T]<"
"
*&,"#RRJ"+,>2+8"?15"
50@G,76"62"1")0@('7"
72-50(616'2-."15"1-9"
(,:'5(16'B,"+,>2+8"
)+2)251(<"aB,+1((."6&,"
+,>2+8"+,7,'B,A"1"(26"
2>"50))2+6."15"'6"
1'8,A"16"176'B16'-:"
A'51@(,A"9206&"@,66,+"
>2+"6&,"(1@2+"81+C,6c"
6&,"2-(9"72->('76"
)2'-6"?15"+,:1+A'-:"
6&,"+2(,"2>"6&,")0@('7"
1:,-79"Z=DU]"'-"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"
)+27,55"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"$^]<"
"
4'>>,+,-7,5"@,6?,,-"
80-'7')1('6',5"'-"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"A0,"
62"A'>>,+,-6">'-1-7'1("
72-56+1'-65"Z_'-15"
1-A"U-A,+552-"#R!^L"
$J]<"
^\"
"
155,558,-6."6&,"
)+2:+18"@,718,"1"
-16'2-1(")2('79"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"^#]<"
"
g&16"'5"82+,."6&,"=DU"
05,A"528,"8,6&2A5"
6&16"?,+,"A,B,(2),A"
1@+21A."'<,<"'-"6&,"O<=<"
62"'8)+2B,"6&,"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
U76'B'69"
728),-516'2-<"
_0-'7')1('6',5"1-A"
+,:'2-5"71-"1))(9">2+"
6&,5,">0-A5"62"
'8)+2B,"6&,'+"
'8)(,8,-616'2-"2>"
6&,5,")2('7',5"Z_'-15"
1-A"U-A,+552-"#R!^L"
^!`^#]<"
InnSWE3:'k2@"
:01+1-6,,">2+"9206&c"
%(17,8,-6"1-A"
6+1'-'-:")+2:+18">2+"
9206&c"#RRdc"_1'-"
-2B,(69L"81-A162+9"
)1+6'7')16'2-"62"C,,)"
+,80-,+16'2-c"
'8)(,8,-6,A"@9"6&,"
-16'2-1("1:,-79"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"$[]<"
_1'-")+2@(,8"?15"
+'5'-:"9206&"
0-,8)(298,-6"#RR!`
#RRd"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"$[]<"
"
DA,15"718,">+28"
5'8'(1+",Q),+',-7,5"
'-"4,-81+C"1-A"/3"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"TR]<"
"
;B1(016'2-5"2>"6&,"
)+2:+18"5&2?"6&16"
6&,")+2:+185"1+,"'-"
)+176'7,"-2+">0(("6'8,"
)+2:+185"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"T#]<"
"
E16'2-1(":2B,+-8,-6"
+':&6"?'-:"
:2B,+-8,-6")155,A"
6&,"+,>2+8."@06"6&,"
'550,"&1A"@,,-"2-"6&,"
1:,-A1"@,>2+,<"D-"6&,"
72-50(616'2-")+27,55."
6&,"8256"72-6,56,A"
)2'-6"?,+,"6&,"
51-76'2-5"
)1+6'7')1-65">17,A"'-"
715,"6&,9"A'A"-26"
728)(9"?'6&"6&,"
)+2:+18I5"2@(':16'2-"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"TR]<"
;5),7'1((9"6&,"O-'2-5"
>',+7,(9"2))25,A"6&'5"
^["
"
"
4,B,(2)8,-6"2>"6&,"
)+2:+18"@15,A"2-"
+,5,1+7&"@9"6&,"+':&6`
?'-:")1+69I5"
+,5,1+7&,+5<"306"6&,"
8,82+1-A08">2+"6&,"
+,>2+8"+,>,+5"62"1"
:2B,+-8,-6"+,)2+6"
6&16"206('-,5"5,B,+1("
>1762+5"62"'8)+2B,"
9206&",8)(298,-6"
Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"^$]<"
)2'-6Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"
#R!^]"Z_'-15"1-A"
U-A,+552-"#R!^L"TR`
T!]<"
Common:"
"
"
"
UK!
InnUK1:"
;8)(298,-6"1-A"
50))2+6"1((2?1-7,"
Z;=U]c"1'85"16"
A'51@(,A"2+"),2)(,"
?'6&"(2-:`6,+8"&,1(6&"
72-A'6'2-5c"
D-6+2A07,A"'-"6&,"
g,(>1+,"1-A"F,>2+8"
U76"'-"#RRJ"Z_7;-&'(("
,6"1(<"#R!^L"!^]<"
*20:&,+"51-76'2-5"'-"
#R!#"Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"
#R!^L"!^]<"
h,1+(9",B1(016'2-5"
Z-,:16'B,]c")+2:+18"
-26"+,:1+A,A"15"B,+9"
,>>'7',-6"1-A"&1B'-:"1"
&':&")(17,8,-6"+16,"
728)1+,A"62"26&,+"
)+2:+185"Z-2"
?2-A,+":'B,-"6&16"
>2705,A"2-"
&1-A'71)),A]"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
!d`!J]<"#RRJ"
7&1-:,A"6&,"
A,>'-'6'2-"2>"
A'51@'('69"Z_7;-&'(("
,6"1(<"#R!^L"dJ]<"
E,:16'B,"+,)2+65"
1@206"),+>2+81-7,."
@06"-2"1A1)616'2-"2>"
6&,")+2:+18"#RRJ"
7&1-:,A"6&,"
A,>'-'6'2-"2>"
A'51@'('69"Z_7;-&'(("
,6"1(<"#R!^L"d\]<"
%+2@(,8")+,550+,L"
(2?"),+>2+81-7,c"
51(',-7,i""
D-6,+,56":+20)5"1-A"
+,)+,5,-616'B,5"&1A"
(2@@',A">2+"6&,"#RRJ"
7&1-:,"2>"6&,"
A,>'-'6'2-"2>"
A'51@'('69"Z_7;-&'(("
,6"1(<"#R!^L"dJ]<"
InnUK2:"*&,"?2+C"
F,)2+65"5&2?"6&16"
=1(',-7,L"OP"
H2-5,+B16'B,5">1B2+"
dR"
"
)+2:+18c"+,)(17,A"
%16&?195"62"g2+C"'-"
#R!!."@06"'5"
,55,-6'1((9"6&,"518,."
@,7105,"'6"+,5)2-A,A"
62"6&,"K+,0A`F,)2+6"
2>"#RRJ."?&'7&"
,B1(016,A"6&,"2(A"
)+2:+18."@06"6&,"
:2B,+-8,-6"7(1'8,A"
'6"62"@,"1(("-,?"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
#J]<"#R!!"'-7+,15,"2>"
51-76'2-5"Z_7;-&'(("
,6"1(<"#R!^L"$$]<"
51-76'2-5"&1B,"
)25'6'B,",>>,765"2-"
51B'-:."@06"-,:16'B,"
,>>,765"2-"G2@`>'-A'-:<"
g2+C")+2:+18"
),+>2+8,A")22+(9"'-"
6&,"@,:'--'-:c"561+6,+"
?'6&206")'(26"
-16'2-?'A,"Z_7;-&'(("
,6"1(<"#R!^L"$$]<"
"
,(,762+16,"50))2+6'B,"
2>"&':&,+"51-76'2-5"
62?1+A5"
0-,8)(298,-6"
@,-,>'6"+,7,'B,+5"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$#]<"
&':&,+"51-76'2-5."
&2?,B,+."6&,"62)'7"
&1A"-26"@,,-")1+6"2>"
6&,"E,?"V1@2+"
%+2:+18")+'2+"62"
#R!R"Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"
#R!^L"$$]<"
InnUK3:"E16'2-1("
_'-'808"g1:,c"
'-6+2A07,A"![[\"@9"
V1@2+"1>6,+")+28'5,A"
'-"6&,",(,76'2-c"
,-6,+,A"6&,")2('6'71("
1:,-A1"A0+'-:"6&,"
![\R5c"@26&"81'-"
)1+6',5"?,+,"2))25,A"
62"'6"'-"6&,"![\R5"1-A"
,1+(9"![[R5"15"6&,9"
?,+,"1>+1'A"2>"
-,:16'B,",>>,765"2-"
6&,",72-289"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$#`$$]<"
K+,,N,"2>"8'-'808"
?1:,">2+"6&,"920-:."
'-"#R!#"Z_7;-&'((",6"
1(<"#R!^L"$#]<"
![[#`![[J."6&,"
),+7,)6'2-"2>"
8'-'808"?1:,"
7&1-:,A."A0,"62"
)25'6'B,",B1(016'2-5"
2>"6&,"U8,+'71-"
8'-'808"?1:,"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$T]<"E2"OP",B'A,-7,"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$^]<"V16,+",B1(016'2-5"
2>"6&,"OP")+2:+18"
A'A"-26">'-A"1-9"
-,:16'B,",>>,76"2>"6&,"
(1?"2-",8)(298,-6"
)+176'7,5"Z_7;-&'((",6"
1(<"#R!^L"$d]<"E2"
)25'6'B,",>>,76"
,Q),76,A"72-7,+-'-:"
6&,">+,,N,">2+"920-:"
),2)(,"5&20(A"&1B,"
2-"6&,'+",8)(298,-6"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$[]"
=1(',-6c"(1@2+"?2-"
6&,",(,76'2-"?'6&"6&'5"
62)'7"'-"![[Jc"?&,-"
'6")+28'5,A"62"
'-6+2A07,"1"
7288'55'2-"62"A,1("
?'6&"6&,"'550,"+16&,+"
6&1-")+28'5'-:"1-"
17601("+16,+"2>"
8'-'808"?1:,"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
$T]<"
H2-5,+B16'B,"
:2B,+-8,-6"
50))2+6,A">+,,N,">2+"
9206&"_g."'-"#R!#<"
E26"7(,1+"2-"?&'7&"
,B'A,-7,"Z_7;-&'((",6"
1(<"#R!^L"$\]<"
%2('6'7'N,A"'-"![[J."
72-5,+B16'B,"
:2B,+-8,-6"A'A"-26"
50))2+6"6&,"'A,1."
1(6&20:&"@05'-,55"
A'A"52<"*&'5"?15"2-,"
2>"6&,"+,152-5"?&9"
(1@2+"(256"6&,",(,76'2-"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
JT]<"
!
Common'elements'
H,-6+1(":2B,+-8,-6"
"
%0@('7"2)'-'2-"'5"
d!"
"
15"'-'6'162+c"
'-A,),-A,-6"6&'-C"
61-C5")(19"1"+2(,"'-"
A,)(29'-:")2('79"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
TR]c"V%H"
ZH288'55'2-">2+"
_'-'808"g1:,]"'5"1-"
'8)2+61-6",(,8,-6"2>"
)2('79"(,1+-'-:"
Z_7;-&'((",6"1(<"#R!^L"
J^]<"
1:1'-56"6&,"
5':-'>'71-6"5),-A'-:"
>2+"0-,8)(298,-6"
'-50+1-7,",67<"
D-A'B'A01("'5"
+,5)2-5'@(,">2+"
>'-A'-:"1"G2@<"
H2-5,e0,-6(9."6&,+,"
1(("6&+,,"81'-")1+6',5"
&1B,"6,-A,A"62"
50))2+6"82+,"
+,56+'76'B,"
0-,8)(298,-6"
)2('7',5"Z_7;-&'((",6"
1(<"#R!^L"T\]<"
"
"
""
d#"
"
3'@('2:+1)&9"
U1."%10("B1-"A,+.",6"1(<"Z#R!^]."lD-`A,)6&"1-1(95'5"2>" %2('79"D--2B16'2-5<"H20-6+9"F,)2+6"
E,6&,+(1-A5l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5nE16'2-1(s#R+,)2+6s#RE,6&,+(1-A5s#R>'-1(s#RRJR[#R
!^s#\#s#[<)A>L";0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
U+8'-:,2-."P(105"Z#R!#]."l*&,"%2('6'75"2>"K'571("F,5)2-5,5"62"6&,"H+'5'5"2>"#RR\S#RR[l."
Governance,"#^"ZT]."^T$`d^<"
3,--,66." H2('-" k<" 1-A" M2?(,66." _'7&1,(" Z![[#]." l*&," V,552-5" 2>" V,1+-'-:L" F,72-7'('-:"
*&,2+',5"2>"%2('79"V,1+-'-:"1-A"%2('79"H&1-:,l."Policy!Sciences,"#^"Z$]."#J^`[T<"
32-2('." /'0('1-2." %'52-'." 4,('1." 1-A" *+,'-." %&'('))" Z#R!^]." lV1@20+" 81+C,6" '--2B16'2-5"
1-A" )2('79" (,1+-'-:L" F,)2+6" =?'6N,+(1-Al." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5n=?'6N,+(1-AxK'-1(s#RF,)2+6xg%Tx^x![xR\x!^s#\!s#[<
)A>L";0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
325?,((."H&+'56'-1"Z#RR[]."The!Political!Uses!of!Expert!Knowledge:!Immigration!Policy!and!
Social!Research"ZH18@+'A:,L"H18@+'A:,"O-'B,+5'69"%+,55]<"
3+10-." 3,-G18'-" Z#R!$]." l%+,)1+,A-,55." H+'5'5" _1-1:,8,-6" 1-A" %2('79" H&1-:,L" *&,"
;0+2"U+,1"16"6&,"H+'6'71("k0-760+,"2>"#RR\S#R!$l."The!British!Journal!of!Politics!&!
International!Relations,"!J"Z$]."T![`T!<"
H&18)'2-." H9+',((," Z#R!$]." la+:1-'516'2-1(" F,>2+85" '-" U76'B," g,(>1+," =616,5L" U"
H28)1+16'B," U-1(95'5" 2>" 6&," *0+-" 62" l='-:(," /16,?195l" '-" g,56,+-" ;0+2),l."
ZO-'B,+5'69"2>"V1051--,]<"
41B'6,+." K1(C" Z#R!^]." l*&," %2('6'71(" O5," 2>" P-2?(,A:," '-" 6&," %2('79" %+27,55l." Policy!
Sciences,"T\."T[!`^R^<"
K(,7C,-56,'-." *'82" Z#RR\]." lF,56+0760+'-:" g,(>1+," >2+" 6&," O-,8)(29,AL" *&," M1+6N"
V,:'5(16'2-"'-"/,+81-9l."Journal!of!European!Social!Policy,"!\"Z#]."!JJ`\\<"
/'(1+A'."K1@+'N'2"Z#R!R]."lg&2"(,1+-5">+28"?&16"'-"%2('79"4'>>05'2-"%+27,55,5il."American!
Journal!of!Political!Science,"^T"Z$]."d^R`dd<"
/'(1+A'." K1@+'N'2." Km:('56,+." P16&1+'-1." 1-A" V09,6." =6y)&1-," Z#RR[]." lV,1+-'-:" K+28"
a6&,+5L" *&," 4'>>05'2-" 2>" M25)'61(" K'-1-7'-:" F,>2+85" '-" a;H4" H20-6+',5l."
Comparative!Political!Studies,"T#"ZT]."^T[`J$<"
/2(A56,'-."k0A'6&"1-A"P,2&1-,."F2@,+6"a"Z![[$]."lDA,15"1-A"K2+,':-"%2('79L"U-"1-1(96'71("
K+18,?2+Cl." Ideas! and! Foreign! Policy.! Beliefs,! Institutions,! and! Political! Change"
ZD6&171"1-A"V2-A2-L"H2+-,(("O-'B,+5'69"%+,55]."$`$R<"
M17C,+." k172@" =<" Z#RRT]." lF,B',?" U+6'7(,L" 4'581-6('-:" 6&," M,1(6&" H1+," =616,i" %2('6'71("
D-56'606'2-5." %0@('7" %2('7',5" 1-A" 6&," H28)1+16'B," %2('6'75" 2>" M,1(6&" F,>2+8l."
British!Journal!of!Political!Science,"$T"ZRT]."d[$`J#T<"
```" Z#RR^]." l%2('79" 4+'>6L" *&," M'AA,-" %2('6'75" 2>" O=" g,(>1+," =616," F,6+,-7&8,-6l."
Institutional! Change! in! Advanced! Political! Economies"ZE,?" h2+CL" aQ>2+A"
O-'B,+5'69"%+,55]."TR`\#<"
M1((." H<" _'7&1,(" Z#R!!]." l%2('79" (,1+-'-:" 1-A" )2('79" >1'(0+," '-" 50561'-1@(," 620+'58"
:2B,+-1-7,L" >+28" >'+56`1-A" 5,72-A`2+A,+" 62" 6&'+A`2+A,+" 7&1-:,il." Journal! of!
Sustainable!Tourism,"!["ZT`^]."dT[`J!<"
M1((." %,6,+" U<" Z![[$]." l%2('79" %1+1A':85." =27'1(" V,1+-'-:." 1-A" 6&," =616,<" *&," H15," 2>"
;72-28'7"%2('7981C'-:"'-"3+'61'-l."Comparative!Politics,"$"Z#^]."#J^`[d<"
M,7(2."M0:&" Z![JT]." Modern!Social! Policy!in! Britain!and! Sweden:!From! Relief!to! Income!
Maintenance"ZE,?"M1B,-L"h1(,"O-'B,+5'69"%+,55]<"
M,8,+'G7C."U-62-"1-A"j'55,+."k,((,"Z#RR$]."l%2('79"V,1+-'-:"'-";0+2),1-"g,(>1+,"=616,5l."
Z&66)Lnn,07,-6,+<?'57<,A0na_Hn%1),+5n&,8,+'G7Cj'55,+#<)A>L"O-'B,+5'6',5" 2>"
V,9A,-"1-A"U856,+A18]<"
d$"
"
M2)),."F2@,+6"Z#R!!]."The!Governance!of!Problems:!Puzzling,!Powering!and!Participation"
Z3+'562(L"%2('79"%+,55]<"
k1-5,-." U-A+,15" 1-A" P-06&." _166&'15" Z#R!^]." lV1@20+" 81+C,6" '--2B16'2-5" 1-A" )2('79"
(,1+-'-:<" E16'2-1(" +,)2+6" `" /,+81-9l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5nE16'2-1(s#RF,)2+6s#R/,+81-9xR$R[s#\!s#[<)A>L"
;0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
k25')2B'u." 418'+" 1-A" v08'." D+,-1" Z#R!^]." lH20-6+9" F,)2+6" =(2B,-'1l."
Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5ng%Txg%^x=(2B,-'1xE16'2-1(F,)2+6xK'-1(s#\!s#[<)A>L"
;0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
V,-:9,(." /9z+:9." *{6&." V'((1." 1-A" /z-7N." 32+@|(1" Z#R!^]." lg2+C" %17C1:," T" `" D-" A,)6&"
1-1(95'5" 2>" 6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-" 1-A" A,B,(2)8,-6" 2>" )2('79" '--2B16'2-5<" g2+C"
%17C1:,"^"`"%+27,55,5"2>")2('79"(,1+-'-:"'-"M0-:1+9<"H20-6+9"+,)2+6"`"M0-:1+9l."
Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5nDE=%DF;=xg%Txg%^xM0-:1+9x>'-1(s#\!s#[<)A>L"
;0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
_1+6'-." =6,B," 1-A" =1-A,+52-." D1-" Z![[[]." l;B1(016'-:" )0@('7" )2('79" ,Q),+'8,-65"
8,150+'-:" 206728,5." 82-'62+'-:" )+27,55,5" 2+" 81-1:'-:" )'(265il." Evaluation,"^"
Z$]."#T^`^\<"
_1+6w-,N`_2('-1."=1-A+1."%1Bw1."%10(1"=1@16,+."1-A"K,++,+."k2+A'"/1+7y5"Z#R!^]."l=)1-'5&"
+,)2+6" 2-" 6&," A,B,(2)8,-6." '8)(,8,-616'2-" 1-A" ),+>2+81-7," 2>" 5,(,76,A"
'--2B16'2-5." 1-A" )2('79" (,1+-'-:." 1A2)6'2-" 1-A" )2('79" (,1+-'-:" '->+156+0760+,5l."
Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5ng%T`
g%^xs#R=)1-'5&s#R+,)2+6s#R2-s#R6&,s#RA,B,(2)8,-6.s#R'8)(,8,-616'
2-s#R1-As#R),+>2+81-7,s#R2>s#R5,(,76,As#R'--2B16'2-5.s#R1-As#R)2(
'79s#R(,1+-'-:s#\!s#[<)A>L";0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
_19."%,6,+"k<"Z![[#]."l%2('79"V,1+-'-:"1-A"K1'(0+,l."Journal!of!Public!Policy,"!#"ZRT]."$$!`
^T<"
_7;-&'((.";('51@,6&."*19(2+`/22@9."%,6,+."1-A"a662."UA,('-,"Z#R!^]."lD-"A,)6&"1-1(95'5"2>"
6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-" 1-A" A,B,(2)8,-6" 2>" )2('79" '--2B16'2-5." 1-A" %+27,55,5" 2>"
)2('79" (,1+-'-:" '-" 6&," O-'6,A" P'-:A28l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5nKDEUVxF;%aF*x?)T^xOPs#R)A>s#\!s#[<)A>L"
;0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
_'-15." F,-16," 1-A" U-A,+552-." V'51" Z#R!^]." l=?,A'5&" +,)2+6" 2-" 6&," A,B,(2)8,-6."
'8)(,8,-616'2-" 1-A" ),+>2+81-7," 2>" 5,(,76,A" '--2B16'2-5c" 1-A" )+27,55,5" 2>"
)2('79" (,1+-'-:l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5n=?,A,-s#Rg%T`
^s#RKDEUVs#Rj;F=DaEs#Rs#\?'6&206s#R7288,-65s#[s#\!s#[<)A>L"
;0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
%1)1A2)20(20." 4,5)'-1." 4'820(15." H2-561-6'-,." 1-A" P20+17&1-'5." E'C25" Z#R!^]."
l/F;;H;<" %1+6" a-,L" D-`A,)6&" 1-1(95'5" 6&," '8)(,8,-616'2-" 1-A" A,B,(2)8,-6" 2>"
)2'(79"'--2B16'2-5"Z4T<!]<"%1+6"*?2L"%2('79"(,1+-'-:"1A2)6'2-"1-A")2('79"(,1+-'-:"
'->+156+0760+,5" Z4^<#]l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5n/+,,7,s#R?)Ts#R1-As#R?)^s#R>'-1(s#\!s#[<)A>L"
;0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
%',+52-."%10("Z![[T]."Dismantling!the!Welfare!State:!Reagan,!Thatcher,!and!the!Politics!of!
Retrenchment!in!Britain!and!the!United!States"ZH18@+'A:,L"H18@+'A:," O-'B,+5'69"
%+,55]<"
=1@16',+."%10(" U<" Z![\\]." lU-" UAB27179" H21('6'2-" K+18,?2+C" 2>" %2('79" H&1-:," 1-A" 6&,"
F2(,"2>"%2('79`2+',-6,A"V,1+-'-:"6&,+,'-l."Policy!Sciences,"#!"Z#`$]."!#[`d\<"
dT"
"
=1@16',+."%10("U<"1-A"k,-C'-5`=8'6&."M1-C"Z![[[]." l*&,"UAB27179"H21('6'2-" K+18,?2+CL"
U-"U55,558,-6l."'-"%10("=1@16',+"Z,A<]."Theories!of!the!Policy!Process"Z320(A,+."HaL"
g,56B',?"%+,55]."!!J`dd<"
=7&8'A6." _1->+,A" /<" Z![[d]." lg&,-" %1+6',5" _166,+L" U" F,B',?" 2>" 6&," %255'@'('6',5" 1-A"
V'8'65" 2>" %1+6'51-" D->(0,-7," 2-" %0@('7" %2('79l." European! Journal! of! Political!
Research,"$R"Z#]."!^^`\$<"
=,+:'."j'662+'2."/'1--,(('."E'72(1."1-A"H,>1(2."F0::,+2"Z#R!^]."lD-`A,)6&"1-1(95'5"2>"%2('79"
D--2B16'2-5<" H20-6+9" F,)2+6" >2+" D61(9" 4T<!" 1-A" 4^<!l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5n4Tx!`^x!`D*xR!R[!^s#\!s#[<)A>L";0+2),1-"
H288'55'2-]<"
=6+09B,-." V0A2" 1-A" %2((,6." D:-17," Z#R!^]." lD8)(,8,-616'2-" 2>" %2('79" D--2B16'2-5"
%+27,55,5" 2>" %2('79" V,1+-'-:" '-" 3,(:'08l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5nDE=%DF;=s#R3,(:'1-s#R+,)2+6s#Rg%s#RTs#R1-As#
R^x;ExUTZ#]<)A>L";0+2),1-"H288'55'2-]<"
*+,'-."%&'('))"Z#R!^]."l4^<!."V'6,+160+,"+,)2+6L"U"+,B',?"2>")2('79"(,1+-'-:""'-">'B,"56+1-A5"
2>" )2('6'71(" 57',-7," +,5,1+7&" ZDE=%DF;=" %+2G,76]l." Z&66)Lnn???<'-5)'+,5`
+,5,1+7&<,0n05,+>'(,5n4^x!s#RF,B',?s#R;5519s#\!s#[<)A>L";O`
H288'55'2-]<"
g1:57&1(." O?," 1-A" g,-N,(@0+:,+." /,2+:" Z#RR\]." lF21A5" 62" =077,55L" 30A:,6"
H2-52('A16'2-5"'-"a;H4"H20-6+',5l."Journal!of!Public!Policy,"#\"ZR$]."$R[`$[<"
g1(6,+." =6,>1-'," Z>2+6&728'-:]." lH+'5'5" %2('6'75" '-" ;0+2),L" g&9" U056,+'69" '5" ;15',+" 62"
D8)(,8,-6"'-"=28,"H20-6+',5"6&1-"'-"a6&,+5l."Comparative!Political!Studies<"
g,@,+." _1Q" Z![\R]." Wirtschaft! und! Gesellschaft:! Grundriss! der! verstehenden! Soziologie"
Z*m@'-:,-L"_2&+"=',@,7C]<"
f,'6('-."k2-16&1-."%27&,6."%&'(')),."1-A"_1:-0552-."