Technical ReportPDF Available

Att integrera jämställdhet i länstransportplanering Slutredovisning av forskningsprojektet Implementering av metod för jämställdhetskonsekvensbedömning (JKB) i svensk transportinfrastrukturplanering

Authors:

Abstract and Figures

This report summarises the research project, Implementation of a Method for Gender Equality Impact Assessment in Swedish Transport Planning that began in 2013. The aim of the project was to develop and test the model for Gender Equality Impact Assessment as proposed in the report Gender Equality in Traffic Planning. Principally the focus was on the Swedish national gender equality objectives of economic equality and the equal distribution of unpaid housework and provision of care. The project also aimed to identify the need for development of knowledge (of gender equality) and to develop an undergraduate training course for professionals in transportation planning. The departure of the project was taken in the objectives of gender equality in transport and the national gender equality objectives. Especially, the focus was on the gender equality objectives of economic equality and the equal distribution of unpaid housework and provision of care because these goals were proved particularly difficult to tweak in transport planning. Previous research shows that the objectives of economic equality and equal distribution of unpaid housework and provision of care, can be best addressed in the early stages of planning and that these goals are very important on a comprehensive stage in the planning process. For example, how places of work, education and livelihood are tied together with places for accommodation and other activities in people’s everyday lives. This means, for example, investments in regional commuter routes and that transportation will be integrated into regional development goals and the work to strengthen citizens’ access to new labour market regions (functional regional expansion). The research project was organised into five work packages, where researchers and planners collaborated. Initially the researchers analysed how gender came into account in the last two regional transport plans, and in focus groups and workshops with planners discussed their viewpoints on gender equality in the regional transportation planning. The result of the analysis of the collaboration with the transport planners showed that they generally lack access to professionalised knowledge and skills to independently start development projects on gender equality. Examples of difficulties regarding the testing and further development of the JKB-model, focused in part on lack of competence on how to transform data on gender equality into operational skills. The main barrier to actively work with gender mainstreaming, according to the planners, is the lack of clear guidelines and directives for the regional transport plans.
Content may be subject to copyright.
A preview of the PDF is not available
... Sweden is known to score highly on gender indexes, such as the EU Gender Equality Index [24], and has gender mainstreaming as a policy strategy for realizing gender equality [25]. In the Swedish transport sector, there is already a recognition of the importance of paying attention to gender aspects [26][27][28], even though it is not necessarily realized [29]. In Swedish transport policy, social concerns are included in the overall target [30,31], with more specific attention to gender reflected in the functional target that seeks to create accessibility through the design, function and use of the transport system; this should provide everyone with basic access to good quality transportation in everyday life, specifically, "the transport system should respond equally to women's and men's transport needs." ...
Article
Full-text available
There are large discrepancies in the transport sector along gender lines in travel patterns and means of transportation used, but also in attitudes and norms among citizens, planners and decision-makers, with women generally more positive towards measures involving the lowering CO2 emissions. At the same time, the number of women involved in transport-related decisions is low. This is a problem for gender equality but possibly also for sustainability. A careful review of previous studies indicated a lack of analyses on the subject based on quantitative data at the local level. We investigated a possible link between women’s presence in local policymaking and more sustainable transport policies, and whether it is possible to capture such an effect. The main contribution of this paper is a methodological approach in which, besides generating unique data on representation in municipalities (confirming men’s dominance, specifically in transport policymaking), possibilities for quantitatively measuring gender and the level of sustainability in transport planning are discussed and tested. Challenges in collecting relevant data and analyzing possible covariances in the data set are discussed and presented as well as suggestions for further investigations into the possible link between gender and sustainable transport performance.
Article
Full-text available
Gender mainstreaming has been hampered by the governance guides of New Public Management (NPM). Public Value Management is an alternative approach that can be interpreted as a concept for management accounting that meets the challenges that NPM was never able to handle. This paper discusses the case of gender mainstreaming in the Swedish transport sector. IMPACT The authors suggest that the governance of public value will contribute to highlighting important qualitative aspects necessary for the successful implementation of gender mainstreaming. The success of work with the strategy of gender equality is dependent on which management accounting system that is in use. A good example is to use gender-awareness as an input and to go beyond short-term assessment of output into long-term valuation of outcomes. To avoid ending up with irrelevant output measures, gender-aware planning and assessment of qualitative processes and outcomes is required.
Chapter
Transport and mobility are integrated with everyday activities in people’s lives. Transport research and planning has been characterized by utilitarian, rationalistic and quantitative epistemologies. Also, for a long time transport planning research has been gender coded as masculine. In this collection we show the importance of combining methodologies and that ‘numbers’ is useful when addressing issues of power and gender equality but also that qualitative and critical epistemologies bring important and necessary knowledge to the transport planning research field. This collection is a contribution to the research field of transport planning, representing a plurality of epistemologies—but with one important common denominator: transport planning as inheritably political practice and that transport planning research has to acknowledge the diversity of social positions when planning for equity and accessibility.
Article
Full-text available
This article presents the concept of "intersectionality" and argues for its usefulness for feminist research. The concept is used in recent international feminist debates in order to theorize how gender and other sociocultural power differentials such as ethnicity, race, sexual preference, age and nationality interact in the construction of subjectivity and material conditions of subjects. The first part of the article introduces the concept, a couple of key reference texts and political contexts. It is argued that thinking in terms of intersections between gender and other markers of sociocultural power differences is a much more integrated part of feminist thinking than a first glance at the actual use of the concept "intersectionality" reveils. The argument is based on references to feminist theoretical and political debates around the relationship between gender and class, gender and sexual preference, gender, race and ethnicity, gender and age - and discussions, started in the 1970s and early 1980s. Other related feminist theoretizations, transversalism (Yuval-Davis), nomadism (Braidotti), inappropriate/d otherness (Haraway), are also interpellated in order to sustain the argument that thinking in terms of intersections is an integrated dimension of much feminist thought. The second part of the article mobilizes key arguments for the usefulness of intersectionality as a theoretical and political tool in feminism and refers, moreover, to possible problems. Six principles are articulated on which feminist intersectionality analysis, according to the author, should be based. The main argument in favour of feminist intersectionality analysis is that this approach makes it possible to speakabout differencesand diversity in political collectives, as for exemple, women's movements, and to take into account different positionalities, without creating a slippery slope towards a discursive situation, where gendered power differentials can be "legitimately" ignored in favour of an exclusive focus on other diversity markers.
Article
Hvorfor har integrationen af køn i svensk transportpolitik fulgt en konservativ kurs og ikke en mere progressiv vej? Det skyldes blandt andet en uafklaret forståelse af køn som analytisk kategori.
Article
Time is a significant dimension of the everyday journey. The temporal aspects of a journey are both quantitative and qualitative. The perception of time has been related to different time order systems in various societies and to differences within the spheres of production and reproduction. In this paper the differences between men and women in attitudes towards different time aspects of transport are analysed and discussed, with the empirical results based on a survey from Oslo 1993. A random sample of 1,053 persons, 18 years or older, was interviewed about everyday activities, travel and attitudes related to transport. The analyses show that there are diversities between groups of men and women in the perception of time and time use associated with the means of transport. On average, women have a more positive attitude towards public transport than men, and women also are more willing to accept longer travel times if one has to use public transport instead of the car. It is argued that the dominant time order related to production, the temporal practice in everyday life and the experienced time could explain some of these differences. In relation to these aspects of social time, men's and women's position and perception are different.