ArticlePDF Available

Mental Health and Stress among Call Center Employee

Authors:

Abstract

The present research attempted to examine mental Health and Adjustment of Undergraduates from different Universities i.e. Jamia Millia Islamia , Jawaharlal Nehru University and Delhi University. Sample comprised 30 each male and female from three different universitiesThe participants were administered Bell Adjustment and Mental Health inventory for the purpose of this study. Results indicated that all the uinergraduates differed significantly on both mental as well as on adjustment scores. Male and female didn't differ on both the measures irrespective of their institutional affiliation.
215
Mental Health and Stress among Call Center Employees
Sushma Suri and Saba Rizvi
Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi
The present study aimed to find out the stress and mental health among call
center employees. For this purpose a total of 100 employees were selected
from two different call centers i.e. Domestic (N=50) and International (N=50).
The sample included both male and female employees in equal number. Two
scales namely Life Stress Scale and Mental Health Inventory were administered
to all the subjects. Obtained scores were analyzed with help ANOVA and t-
test. Results revealed that significant difference in stress and mental health
observed with respect to both genders from domestic call center. Male employees
from both the call centers differed significantly on stress scores.
Keywords:Call Center, Stress, Mental Health
The Call Center community often defines
itself as an industry, with numerous national
and international call centers. But there has
some dispute amongst researchers as to
whether it is appropriate to refer such thing
as the “call center industry”. Bain and Taylor
(1999) argue that it is more appropriate to
use the term “sector” as call centers are
found across a wide range of industries and
may be similar primarily in terms of their core
technologies. Belt, Richardson and Webster
(2000) agreed that call centers are not an
“industry” as the term generally defined, but
rather represent certain ways of delivering
various services using the telephone and
computer technologies across traditional
industry boundaries.
National call center represents a unique
management challenge. Forecasting calls,
calculating staffing requirements, organizing
sensible schedule, managing the
environment in real-time, and, in general,
getting the right people in the right places at
the right times. The international researchers
have found between technologies used, work
practices and key issues including
monitoring, control, training and labor
demographics for workers in countries as
diverse as Germany, Japan, Australia,
Greece, US, UK and the Netherlands.
The basic reasons by which employees
getting stress in their routine life is non-stop
mobile calling, duty to make interaction with
customer and complete the target within
the time, threat of intensity; make the
employees stressful and depressed. Dollard,
Dormann, Boyd, and Wine field (2003)
assessed two unique stressors associated
with the human service work i.e. emotional
dissonance, the need to hide negative
emotions and client related social stressors.
The latter may involved disproportionate
customer expectations and verbally
aggressive customers. These stressors
affect all human service workers, even though
they may vary in the extent to which their work
involves lasting relationships with customers.
They argued that social support and training
designed to develop “role separation” are
crucial resources needed to help human
© Journal of the Indian Academy of Applied Psychology,
July 2008, Vol. 34, No.2, 215-220.
216
service workers cope with the unique
stressors of their jobs. Following are the key
stressors in call centers:
Nature of job: The primary source of
stress reported is inherent to the nature of
the job spending all day on the phone dealing
with people one another, day after day, is
difficult. Many studies report agents as
wanting to ‘just get off the phones’ .Belt and
colleagues (2000) note “agents in all three
sectors financial services, IT and third-party
services spoke of the phenomenon of
“burnout”, caused by the pressure of working
exclusively ‘on the phones’. In the same study,
the author’s mention that the issue of
‘burnout’ was also recognized by some
managers. Knights and McCabe (2003) take
a different approach to stress in the
workplace. They note that although much
organizational analysis and most of the call
center literature tends to conceptualize stress
as an individual problem, it is actually located
within “a framework that emphasizes the
interrelationships between structural relations
of power and the subjective interpretations
and actions of employees”.
Quality/quantity conflict: Call centers
are rooted in contradictory tensions and
structural paradoxes, and confront a number
of trades-offs on that basis. There set a
context for attitudes towards the organization
and can impose conflicting role requirements
on agents. A core example is that of the
pressure for quantity versus the aspiration
for quality, the guiding logic of which is the
conundrum of trying to get closer to the
customer while routinising, centralizing,
reducing costs and prescribing standards.
Kaczynski and colleagues (2000) suggest
that this dilemma is particularly difficult for
front-line workers because they may be likely
“to identify with embodied individual
customers, for interactions with specific
customers may be an important arena for
meaning and satisfaction within work”. They
suggested that goal of balancing customer
orientation with efficiency; it leads to prefer
workers to identify with a generic category.
Intensity: The third central stressor in
call center work is its intensity. As Bain (2001)
argues “ far from being either in terminal
decline or on the wane, Taylorism-in
conjunction with a range of either control
mechanisms is not only alive, well and deeply
embedded in the call center labor process,
but its malevolent influence appears to be
spreading to previously uncharted territory”.
Targets: There is a fourth feature of
some call center work that may engender
stress: performance targets. There are
various types of targets, which may vary
between inbound and outbound centers.
Inbound centers typically have targets for call
duration, ‘wrap time’, and daily call volume.
Outbound centers often have ‘completion;
targets, which are closely monitor and upon
which pay may be partially based. Taylor and
Bain (1999) argued that particularly in the
financial services industry in the UK, targets
are a significant source of stress for workers
as more and more is placed upon meeting
them in an increasingly competitive business
environment. In centers that claim not to
prioritize targets, researches have found that
staff often feels significant pressure. Targets
simply intensify the stress produced by the
quantity/qualify debate, or, as one agent is
quoted as saying, “They’re usually more into
numbers than anything”. Lankshear ei.al.
(2001 ) describe a series of conversations
with managers in their call center site here
management consistently conceptualized
their performance reports (for example, one
commented that it’s ‘human nature’ for
productivity to drop before and after a
holiday), and used their stats as an excuse
to praise good performance and coach those
who consistently had difficulty meeting
targets.
Mental Health: There has been many
attempts to describe mental health in ideal
terms which have generally led to list of
Mental Health and Stress
217
qualities which characterize the mature,
healthy, fully functioning, self actualization.
The study of the characteristics that make
up mental health has been called positive
psychology. This is evident that positive
thinking is important in promoting health.
Older men and women who expressed a
positive outlook towards life were less likely
to suffer heart attacks than those who
expressed a negative Ostir et. al; (2001). The
effects of positive thinking can even extent
life. Analysis of brief autobiographies written
more than 60 years ago by Catholic nuns
when they were in the 20s suggests that
those with a positive outlook live longer than
nuns who wrote about their lives in more
neutral terms (Danner, Snowdon & Frieson,
2001). However it is concluded that positive
attitude may be merely a result of good
health. For a number of years, mental health
professionals believed that seeking reality as
accurately possible was the best path to
health. Researches found that happy people
often have falsely high opinion of themselves,
given self service explanation for events and
have exaggerated beliefs about their ability
to control the world around them (Taylor,
1998; Taylor & Brown, 1994). Developing
positive self illusion has also been shown to
have dramatic effects on performance. Sports
Psychologist Loher (1989) pieced together
videotaped segment of 17yrs old Michael
Chang’s most outstanding tennis points in the
past year. Chang periodically watched the
videotape and always saw himself winning,
never saw himself make mistakes, and
always saw himself in a positive mood. Several
months later, Change became the youngest
male to win the French Open Tennis
Championship. Study on placebo effects
depicted that it’s a powerful part of healing
and should be used more Brown (1998).
Placebo effects are not just inactive ‘sugar
pills’ but affect patients attitudes towards their
own health outcomes. Seeking help, getting
a diagnosis, beginning treatment and looking
forward to resuming towards a healthful life
are all part of a positive attitude towards one’s
own health. Although the placebo itself may
be inactive, the positive attitude triggered by
the placebo and other interventions may be
life saving. On the basis of the interview
conducted on call center employees it was
observed that the culture of the centers are
totally westernized having good social
network of well behaved people, employees
are highly payable. Indian youths chooses
call center just to get good money. But for
many employed in the call center sector, “the
daily experience is of retentive, intensive and
stressful work, based upon Taylorist
principles, which frequently results in
employee “burnout”. Brown ((1999) more
vividly, characterizes the work as “repetitive
brain strain”. Call centers are established by
organizations to “create an environment in
which work can be standardized to create
relatively uniform and repetitious activities so
as to achieve economics of scale and
consistent quality of customer service”.
Method
Sample:
The sample of the present study consists
of 100 employees working in two different call
centers i.e. domestic (N=50) and
International (N= 50). The sample included
both male and female employees in equal
number.
Tools:
Mental health inventory: It was
developed by Jadish and Shrivastava (1983)
consists 55 items having six dimensions:
positive self-evaluation, realistic perception,
and integration of personality, autonomy,
group-oriented attitudes, and environmental
mastery. Reliability of the test is found at 0.75
level.
Life stress scale: It was developed by
Aggarwal and Naidu(1986) and consists of
30 items describing undesirable experiences
and events likely to occur in the lives of
people. The reliability of the scale was 0.88.
Sushma Suri and Saba Rizvi
218
Procedure
In the present study equal numbers of
call center employees were selected from
domestic call center (Airtel Bharti) and
international call centers (IBM) situated in New
Delhi and NCR. These employees were
contacted and proper rapport was
established. Appropriate instructions were
given to facilitate the completion of the
questionnaires.
Results and Interpretation
The Obtained scores of this 2x2 factorial
study were analyzed with the help of ANOVA
and t-test to see the significance of difference
among various groups. ANOVA revealed the
main effect of call center employees on stress
scores was significant, F(1)=8.55; p<.004. the
main effect of gender was highly significant
F(1)=8.01; p<.005. The interaction of call
center and gender also showed high
significant values as F(2)=10.1; p=<.002.
However, the results indicated that
employees working in two different call
centers differed significantly . As regards to
gender male and female differed with each
other on stress scores.
ANOVA showing the main effect of call
center employees on mental health scores
was NS, F(1)=.263. The main effect of gender
indicated significant difference F(1)= 9.06;
p<.003. the interaction of call center and
gender was non significant F(1)=1.15. On the
basis of above results it was found that
employees from two different call centers
namely domestic and international did not
differ significantly on mental health scores.
Table 1: Mean, SD and t-ratio of employees
from Domestic and International on stress
and mental health scores (male=50 and
female =50)
Call Center Stress Mean SD t-value
Male 1 137.4 14.4
2 118.2 12.2 5.33**
Female 1 136.3 21.2
2 137.1 13.2 0.16
Male 1 137.4 14.4
Female 1 136.3 21.2 1.34
Male 2 137.1 13.3
Female 2 118.2 12.1 5.26**
Mental Health
Male 1 147.3 6.91
2 118.2 6.89 1.7
Female 1 143.3 11.6
2 142.1 13.9 0.69
Male 1 143.3 13.09
Female 1 142.1 13.9 0.69
Male 2 150.6 6.39
Female 2 142.1 13.9 2.81*
Mental Health and Stress
Table 2: Mean, SD and t-ratio of employees from Domestic and International on
different dimensions of mental health scores (male=50 and female =50).
Call Center Mental Health Mean SD t-value
1 Positive self evaluation 27.6 4.14 1.01
2 28.5 3.81 .86
1 Realistic perception 19.7 2.43 1.12
2 20.1 2.22 1.97
1 Integration of Personality 16.5 1.71 3.04
2162 .76
**p <0.01 * p<0.05 International = 1 Domestic= 2
Results obtained by t-test, showed that
male employees from domestic and
international call center differed significantly
with one another on stress scores as the
(t=5.33, p=<.01). Interview conducted
personally on employees revealed that
international call center employees have more
work stress as compare to domestic one. This
is due to heavy work load, no limited time for
social interaction and completion of work
219
within a given period of time. The work culture
is more strict and systematic as compared to
domestic one. Our study is in accordance with
the previous study by Norman et al. (2004)
who conducted a cross-sectional baseline
survey, which was part of a prospective
cohort study. Fifty-seven call center workers
were compared with a reference group of
1,459 professional computer users from other
occupations. A questionnaire covered
physical and psychosocial working conditions
and symptoms during the last month.
Structured observations in accordance with
an ergonomic checklist were used to assess
workstation design during the subject’s
ordinary work. The call center group had
worked for a shorter time in their present
tasks and spent longer continuous time in
front of the computer than the reference
group. There were deficiencies in workspace,
keyboard- and input device placement. The
subjects reported poor support from their
immediate supervisor, low control and limited
opportunities to influence their work. A higher
proportion of the call center group reported
musculo skeletal symptoms.
Results revealed that male and female
from international call center didn’t show any
significant difference, this is due to the fact
that the nature of work is similar for both male
and female employees in international call
centers. As regards to stress scores of
women employees from two call centers didn’t
show any significant difference as their mean
scores are 136.3 and 137.7 respectively
whereas male and female from domestic call
center differed significantly (t= 5.26,
p=<0.01). Responses collected on the basis
of interview indicated that in domestic call
centers field work is mostly done by the male
employees which indicate less anxiety and
stress among female employees hence a
significant difference observed. Regarding
mental health employees from domestic call
center didn’t show any significant difference
with their international counterparts
irrespective of their sex. Male and female
subjects from domestic call center differed
significantly with each other. Responses
collected on the basis of interview indicated
that working condition and deadline is same
for both male and female employees in
international call center. On different
dimensions of mental health like positive self
evaluation, realistic perception, integration of
personality, measures of autonomy,
environmental mastery employees from
international call centers didn’t differ
significantly with their domestic counterparts.
They differed significantly on group oriented
attitude. Obtained data revealed that
employees from different call centers have
the same criteria to measure the self. They
are aware towards themselves and real world
and conscious about their autonomy.
Regarding group oriented attitude
international employees are having
individualistic approach as compared to
domestic one who believed in teamwork and
have positive towards group oriented attitude.
The overall results of the present study
suggest the need for stress management
programs for reducing the stress and
developing positive thinking among young
employees working in call centers.
References
Aggarwal B.B., & Naidu, D. (1986). A life stress
scale for university students, cited
From Nandita Goswami 1999, A Study of
Life Stress and Coping Style Among
University Youth (male & female),
Unpublished M. Sc. Dissertation,
University of Rajasthan.
Bain, P. (2001) Taylorisim, target and the quality-
quantity dichotomy in Call Centers, Paper
Presented to the 19th International Labor
Process Conference, Royal Holloway
College, University of London, 26-28, March.
Bain, P. & Taylor, P (2000). Entrapped by the
Electronic Panopticon? Worker
Resistance in the Call Centers, New
Technology, Work and Employment, 15, 2-
18.
Sushma Suri and Saba Rizvi
220
Belt, V. Richardson, R. & Webster, J. (2000).
Women’s work in the information
economy: the case of telephone call
centers, Information, Communication &
Society, 3, 366-385.
Brown, W. A., (1998) The Placebo Effect,
Scientific American Magazine, 9 278:1, 90-
95.
Brown, P. (1999). The Silent Screen Behind
the Tele Smile, The Age : Business.
Danner, D.D., Snowdon, D.A., & Friesen W. V (
2001). Positive emotion in early life and
longevity, findings from nun study, Journal
of Personality And Social Psychology, 80,
804–813.
Dollard, M. F., Dormann, C., Boyd, C. M., &
Winefield, H. R. (2003). Unique aspects of
stress in human service work, Australian
Psychologist, 38, 84 –91.
Jagdish,. A & Srivastva, A. K., (1995). Mental
Health Inventory, Manovaigyanik Prikashan
Sansthan. Varanasi,
Korczynski, M. K., Shires, S. & Frankel M, T.,
(2000). Service work in consumer capitalism
customers, control and contradiction, Work
Employment And Society, 14, 66-68.
Knights, D. & Mccabe, D. (2003). Governing
Through Teamwork: Reconstituting
Subjectivity In A Call Center. Journal Of
Management Studies,40, 1587-1611. Received: January 21, 2008
Revision received: April 22, 2008
Accepted: May 7, 2008
Lankshear, G., Cook, P., Mason, D., Coates, S.,
Button, G. (2001) Notes and Issues: “Call
centre employee’s responses to electronic
monitoring: some research findings”, Work,
Employment and Society,15, 595-605.
Lohehr, J (1989). Personal Communication
United States Tennis Association
Training Camp, Saddlerbook,
Norman, K. Nilsson, T. & Hagberg, M, (2004)
Working conditions and health among
female and male employees at a call center
in Sweden, American Journal of
Industrial Medicine, 46, 55-62.
Ostir, G.V., Markides, K.S., Peek, K., & Goodwin
J.S., (2001). The association between
emotional well being and the incidence of
stroke in older adult, Psychosomatic
Medicine, 63, 210-215.
Taylor, P., and Bain, P. (1999) An assembly line
in the head: work and employee relationship
in the call center, Industrial Relation Journal.
30 (2), 101-117.
Taylor, S.E., (1998) Positive illusion , in H.S.
Friedman (ed), Encyclopedia of Mental
Health , San Diago, Academic Preess.
Taylor, S.E., & Brown , J. D., (1994), Positive
illusion and well being revisited: separating
fast from fiction, Psychological Bulletin 116,
21-27.
Sushma Suri, PhD, Lecturer, Department of Psychology, Jamia Millia Islamia,
New Delhi-110025 .Suri_sushma6@yahoo.co.in
Saba Rizvi, Completed her Masters in Applied Psychology. Presently doing
B. Ed (special education).
Mental Health and Stress
... Though a large number of studies have been carried out on call center employees, only a few studies (Banu & Gomathi, 2014;Machado et al., 2013;P. Singh & Pandey, 2005;Subbarayalu, 2013;Suri & Rizvi, 2008;Vaid, 2009), have dealt explicitly with the health problems of the women employees. ...
... High levels of stress is one of the negative aspects of call center employment which acts as a catalyst for inducing physical and psychological health problems among the employees. Some studies have brought out the high levels of occupational stress among call center employees (Annamalai & Nandagopal, 2013;Johnson et al., 2005;Latha & Panchanatham, 2011;Nadeem, 2009;Shahnawaz, 2006;Subbarayalu, 2013;Suri & Rizvi, 2008). The psychological health problems reported by the women employees were sleep disturbance, depression, anxiety, and stress (Banu & Gomathi, 2014;Hossain et al., 2016;Subbarayalu, 2013). ...
Article
Full-text available
Indian women are fast moving from conventional jobs to night-shift jobs in transnational call centers. Women working at night is a relatively new phenomenon and stands apart from the usual Indian lifestyle. Night work and the dual burden of work and family have adverse implications on women employees’ physical and psychological health. The paper highlights the occupational health hazards of women employees of international call centers through a systematic review of 38 articles published between 2000 and 2018. Data and evidence from studies on women employees of international call centers in India reveal that odd working hours against the biological clock make women employees suffer from several health problems. Women were more prone to health problems as compared to their counterparts. The responsibility of balancing work and family leads to high levels of stress. Despite the attractive salary package, most women employees suffer health hazards and psychological disorders.
... While employment within the business process outsourcing (BPO) sector has meant that young adults are reaching their career milestones and financial goals much before [2], surveys show that Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) employees face steady challenges at work that can be chronically stressful. centers in India are both domestic and international, but the prominence arises in transnational call centers wherein the clients are from developed countries like USA, UK, and elsewhere [3]. Due to the difference in time zones between India and such countries, most work is performed during night hours corresponding to a time suitable to their international customers. ...
Research
Full-text available
Introduction: Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) industry has been rapidly expanding in India over the last 10 years. While em
... Amongst the service activities that are expected to give high mental workload are such as operators, telemarketers, office workers and those who are in the transportation sector (e.g., road, railway track and airway). These services can cause mental fatigue and consequently increase the risk of accidents [6][7][8][9][10]. ...
Article
Full-text available
Service sector is a job that is considered exposed to high mental demand. There is lack of technique to measure issues related to the mental workload and mental fatigue levels among workers. Moreover, no studies have yet developed a model to predict mental fatigue especially for service sector workers. It is necessary to investigate mental workload and mental fatigue in real time working activities. The main purpose of this study was to identify the trends and relationship between mental workload and mental fatigue level among service sector workers. Ten participants with a mean age of 35.00±8.62 (SD) years took part in the study. Two experiments in Without Rest (WoR) and With Rest (WR) segments involving data entry and arithmetic tasks were conducted. Physiological measures using Electroencephalogram (EEG), Electrooculogram (EOG) and heart rate (HR) were assessed while participants were performing the tasks. The result shows that EEG alpha signal was significantly higher at the end of WR compared to WoR segment (p<0.05). Comparison between WoR and WR segments for each task show that HR of WR tasks were significantly lower in all tasks (p<0.05). This study developed seven mental workload and mental fatigue conceptual models with strong variables correlations (r>0.05) to evaluate the variability of both parts of two types of activities, namely, data entry and arithmetic tasks. The findings highlighted that validated parameters and methods for mental fatigue and mental workload measures are brain signals and heart rate monitoring, and task performance measure. Significant findings of the study could be as a reference for organizations to plan and manage resources by optimizing mental workload condition and minimizing mental fatigue occurrence
... While employment within the business process outsourcing (BPO) sector has meant that young adults are reaching their career milestones and financial goals much before [2], surveys show that Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) employees face steady challenges at work that can be chronically stressful. centers in India are both domestic and international, but the prominence arises in transnational call centers wherein the clients are from developed countries like USA, UK, and elsewhere [3]. Due to the difference in time zones between India and such countries, most work is performed during night hours corresponding to a time suitable to their international customers. ...
... The evolving ways of life (20%), demand for luxury, high paid salary for the employees with less qualification (40%) are the main reasons for the young graduates to choose the business 535 process outsourcing jobs (chavan and Potdar, 2011) this study was conducted in India by chavan is in consensus with the present study. however, another study stated that a good work environment is the major criteria for choosing BPO jobs by the youth (Insha, rodrigues and chavan, 2018) (Suri and rizvi, 2008). This could be due to the fact that surveys are conducted in different geographic locations which lead to the differences to the present study. ...
... In a study secondary school male teachers showed significant positive correlation with stress and adjustment while secondary school female teachers show significant negative relationship in their stress and adjustment (Singh, 2003), a significant difference in stress and mental health has been found with respect to both the genders in domestic call centers. Female employees of the call centers face more stress and problems as compared to men (Suri, 2008). ...
Article
Full-text available
Since time immemorial women in Indian society have been existing quintessentially. Working women have set exemplary and consummate models for many others to move in life. Their inborn knack and abilities are the attributes a society look for. However, in much other respect, these women are the one who suffer tremendously in various aspects. Their myriad contribution has always been neglected which resulted in the distortion of their milieu. Withdrawal of legal rights, illiteracy, maltreatment and gender biases are few instances to ponder. Their perpetual and sustained atrocity has made working women to undergo many psychological issues harming their overall well-being. The present study aims to explore the difference in psycho-social problems of working women in relation to their type of family, age, and locale. We verified the formulated hypotheses using data collected from 100 female teachers comprising of 6 schools including the government and private based in Bathinda (Punjab). Data analysis was done through t-test to find out the level of significance in relation to the type of school, type of family, age and locality. Results reveal no significant difference in the psycho-social problems of women teachers working in government and private schools with respect to their demographics. The implications of the results are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
This quasi-experimental study examines the effectiveness of a psychoeducational group intervention program consisting of psychoeducation sessions and group exercises based on psychodrama warm-up activities resulting from the needs of public sector call center agents in the workplace. Forty municipality call center employees from two municipalities (intervention and control groups) completed pre- and post-test measures before and after the intervention program. A follow-up session for the intervention group took place one month after the completion of the intervention sessions. The intervention group showed significant pre-to-post-test short-term effects such as reduced depersonalization, increased mental well-being, psychological resilience, personal accomplishment, group atmosphere, and group cohesion. On the other hand, no significant difference was noted in the control group from pre- to post-test, except for the decrease in the group atmosphere scores. Group atmosphere and group cohesion scores remained significantly increased after one-month follow-up measures compared to the pre-test in the intervention group.
Article
Full-text available
Esta pesquisa teve como objetivo quantificar o nível de estresse ocupacional percebido pelos atendentes de telemarketing de um contact center, localizado no Rio Grande do Norte. Uma vez que as empresas desse ramo são, historicamente, conhecidas pelas dificuldades em suas relações trabalhistas, torna-se uma necessidade estudar o que os profissionais dessa área sentem em relação aos problemas que ocorrem em sua vida profissional. Trata-se de um estudo de caso que, para a coleta de dados, foi utilizado o questionário, com aplicação da Escala de Estresse Percebido (Perceived Stress Scale – PSS) para medir o nível de estresse no indivíduo. Com base nos resultados da pesquisa, constatou-se que a maioria dos atendentes sofre do estresse ocupacional em nível moderado ou alto, evidenciando que o ambiente de trabalho do contact center pesquisado é formado por agentes estressores que predispõem os funcionários a doenças ocupacionais como o estresse.
Article
The impacts of call center work have been the subject of several studies, but currently, there is paucity of research about lesbian women in the Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) industry. Call center work poses several physical and social health concerns and the worker’s lesbian identity poses yet another challenge in navigating this work environment. This descriptive study used a qualitative approach. Ten (10) lesbian call center workers gave their narratives through semi-structured in-depth interviews in more than a year of doing fieldwork in Eastwood, Quezon City, Philippines. Working in call centers has multiple detrimental effects to health. The participants of the study experienced physical health issues that include voice problems, sleeping problems, unhealthy eating habits, and unhealthy vices such as smoking. Call center work has also affected their social health due to the inflexible and highly variable shifting work schedule, and lesbian call center agents were subject to subtle forms of discrimination in the office. There is a need to look into the effects of call center work on lesbians, as they are inevitably subject to physical and social health impacts, and these impacts are compounded by different forms of discrimination in the workplace.
Article
Full-text available
Handwritten autobiographies from 180 Catholic nuns, composed when participants were a mean age of 22 years, were scored for emotional content and related to survival during ages 75 to 95. A strong inverse association was found between positive emotional content in these writings and risk of mortality in late life (p < .001). As the quartile ranking of positive emotion in early life increased, there was a stepwise decrease in risk of mortality resulting in a 2.5-fold difference between the lowest and highest quartiles. Positive emotional content in early-life autobiographies was strongly associated with longevity 6 decades later. Underlying mechanisms of balanced emotional states are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
Two unique stressors associated with human service work are emotional dissonance, particularly the need to hide negative emotions (emotion work), and client/customer-related social stressors. The latter may involve disproportionate or ambiguous client/customer expectations and/or verbally aggressive customers. These stressors affect all human service workers, even though they may vary in the extent to which their work involves lasting relationships with clients/customers, and in the amount of training they have received to deal with client/customer-related social stressors. For example, health professionals typically develop long-lasting relationships with their clients whereas call centre workers may have only a single brief interaction. In accordance with contemporary theories of work stress (conservation of resources, effort-reward imbalance, demand-control-support), we argue that social support and training designed to develop “role separation” are crucial resources needed to help human service workers cope with the unique stressors of their jobs.
Article
Full-text available
This paper is concerned with the work experiences and career opportunities of women employed in technology-intensive offices known as telephone 'call centres'. Call centres have grown rapidly across Europe in recent years, creating a significant number of new jobs and receiving considerable attention within the media, business and academic communities. However, despite the fact that the majority of call centre jobs have been taken by women, researchers have so far paid little attention to their position in this new 'industry'. The article addresses this research gap. In particular, it is concerned with the question of whether call centre work is offering women new opportunities for skill development and career progression, or whether a more familiar trend is taking place in which women are being drawn into a highly routinized, 'de-skilled' and de-valued area of work. The paper also uses the specific example of call centre work in order to reflect on broader issues about the changing nature of women's work and employment in the so-called 'information economy'.
Article
Full-text available
This article presents a thoroughgoing critique of Fernie and Metcalf’s perspective, that the call centre is characterised by the operation of an ‘electronic panopticon’ in which supervisory power has been ‘rendered perfect’. Drawing on evidence from a telecommunications call centre the authors analyse the significance of emerging forms of employee resistance.
Article
Full-text available
To date, academic studies of the call centre ‘sector’ remain limited in scope. Here the authors attempt to remedy that omission by analysing the recent and spectacular growth of call centres in the UK, drawing on a wide variety of sources, including two extensive surveys of developments in Scotland during 1997.
Article
Full-text available
This article focuses on teamworking as a form of governmentality whereby management seeks to govern by distance. This involves mobilizing the support and commitment of employees to teamworking and organizational goals by appealing to their autonomy, unity, sociability and desire for a more enriched work experience. It is the struggle over subjectivity that is of concern here, for teamworking can be seen as a technology that aims to transform individuals into subjects that secure their sense of meaning and significance through working as a team. We will explore through a case study of a call centre in a large building society how a discourse of teamworking has begun to impinge upon individuals so as to shape not only how they behave but also how they think, derive meaning and understand the world. In turn, we consider some of the tensions and inconsistencies of teamworking in relation to the secrecy of pay differentials, and the return to productivity pressures after a period of relaxation and trust. Ultimately the article examines how individuals respond to, agonize over, resist and baulk against the imposition of 'team lives' when this rubs up against what they understand to be their 'private lives'. This will involve considering gender tensions that have so far been largely neglected in relation to call centres and teamworking. Teamworking, we will argue, reflects a will to govern rather than a mechanism of government. Copyright 2003 Blackwell Publishing Ltd..
Article
Full-text available
S. E. Taylor and J. D. Brown (see record 1992-16903-001 ) published an article that challenged the notion that accurate perceptions of self and the world are essential for mental health. The authors argued instead that people's perceptions in these domains are positively biased and that these positive illusions promote psychological well-being. In the current article, the authors review their theoretical model, correct certain misconceptions in its empirical application, and address the criticisms made by C. R. Colvin and J. Block (see record 1994-41047-001 ).
Article
Full-text available
Individuals with high levels of depressive symptoms have an increased risk of many illnesses, including stroke. Measures of depressive symptoms include questions about the presence of negative affect, such as sadness, as well as the absence of positive affect, such as happiness and optimism. We assessed whether positive or negative affect, or both, predicted risk of stroke. Data were from a 6-year prospective cohort study of a population-based sample of 2478 older whites and blacks from five counties in North Carolina who reported no history of stroke at the baseline interview. Baseline, in-person interviews were conducted to gather information on sociodemographic, psychosocial, and health-related characteristics of subjects. Thereafter interviews were conducted annually for 6 years. Increasing scores on the modified version of the Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (CES-D) were significantly associated with stroke incidence for the overall sample (relative risk [RR] = 1.04 for each one-point increase, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 1.01-1.09) over the 6-year follow-up period after adjusting for sociodemographic characteristics, blood pressure, body mass index, smoking status, and selected chronic diseases. Positive affect score demonstrated a strong inverse association with stroke incidence (RR = 0.74, 95% CI = 0.62-0.88). Increasing scores on the modified CES-D are related to an increased risk of stroke, whereas high levels of positive affect seem to protect against stroke in older adults.
Article
There is an important literature suggesting that the consumer has become a key focus of identity and figure of authority in contemporary society. Within this literature, however, there is little consideration of the role that the identification with the customer could play in management control within production, nor of the ensuing potential contradictions. This paper examines these issues in front line call centre work. Control in this setting is theorised as being informed by dual logics of customer-orientation and bureaucratisation. The paper shows the important use of norms of customer identification in control. It also highlights two levels of contradictions in the use of these norms. First there is the contradiction between continuing bureaucratic control and the attempts to develop normative control. Second, there are contradictions within the development of customer-related normative control. Specifically, the definition of the customer as the focus for normative commitment is a contested terrain, with systematic and significant differences existing here between call centre workers and management.
Article
There is a growing literature on employment in call centres, much of which suggests that they are characterised by high levels of work intensification and surveillance. Recently, a debate has emerged about the nature of surveillance in such workplaces and the level and character of employee resistance (Bain and Taylor 2000; Fernie and Metcalf 1998; Mulholland 1999) with some, such as Bain and Taylor, claiming that the argument is characterised by a paucity of empirical evidence. Against this background, this paper reports on the results of an observational study of call centre work. In what follows we describe the ways in which managers, supervisors and call centre operatives oriented to the monitoring and surveillance capabilities of call centre technology, to the complex social context in which it was embedded and to a range of negotiated definitions of the nature and purposes of the centre's operations. We make no claims here that the call centre reported on is typical of all such centres. Nor do we seek directly to enter the debate about whether call centre surveillance is panoptic in character or about the extent and character of resistance. Nevertheless, it will become apparent that our findings do have relevance for these debates.