ArticlePublisher preview available

Posttraumatic Growth and Perceived Health: The Role of Posttraumatic Stress Symptoms

Authors:
To read the full-text of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors.

Abstract

The contested discourse regarding the nature of posttraumatic growth (PTG) includes 2 main competitive claims. The first argues that PTG reflects authentic positive transformation while the second posits that PTG reflects illusory defenses that could be maladaptive in the long run. The present study assesses these competing claims by investigating secondary PTG in relation to the somatic domain. Specifically, this study investigates: (a) the association between PTG, and perceived health (PH), as measured by 3 indices of somatic complaints, self-rated health (SRH) and a number of health problems; (b) the association between PTG, posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) and PH over time; and (c) the mediating role of PTSS between PTG and PH, among wives of former prisoners of war (ex-POWs) and wives of control veterans. Assessments were conducted 30 (T1) and 38 (T2) years after the Yom Kippur War. Results showed that wives of ex-POWs endorsed higher PTSS, higher PTG and poorer PH, compared to control wives. Higher PTG was associated with higher PTSS and poorer PH. PTG at T1 predicted an increase in PTSS between T1 and T2, which in turn was correlated with poorer PH. PTSS at T2 as well as changes in PTSS from T1 to T2 mediated the association between T1 PTG and T2 PH measures. The present findings imply that PTG might have negative implications on PH through the amplification of PTSS, among secondary trauma victims. It seems that although spouses of trauma victims describe benefits resulting from vicarious trauma exposures, their body indicates differently. (PsycINFO Database Record
Posttraumatic Growth and Perceived Health: The
Role of Posttraumatic Stress Symptoms
Yael Lahav, Zahava Solomon, and Yafit Levin
Tel-Aviv University and I-CORE Research Center for Mass Trauma, Tel Aviv, Israel
The contested discourse regarding the nature of posttraumatic growth (PTG) includes 2 main
competitive claims. The first argues that PTG reflects authentic positive transformation while the
second posits that PTG reflects illusory defenses that could be maladaptive in the long run.
The present study assesses these competing claims by investigating secondary PTG in relation
to the somatic domain. Specifically, this study investigates: (a) the association between PTG, and
perceived health (PH), as measured by 3 indices of somatic complaints, self-rated health (SRH)
and a number of health problems; (b) the association between PTG, posttraumatic stress
symptoms (PTSS) and PH over time; and (c) the mediating role of PTSS between PTG and PH,
among wives of former prisoners of war (ex-POWs) and wives of control veterans. Assessments
were conducted 30 (T1) and 38 (T2) years after the Yom Kippur War. Results showed that wives
of ex-POWs endorsed higher PTSS, higher PTG and poorer PH, compared to control wives.
Higher PTG was associated with higher PTSS and poorer PH. PTG at T1 predicted an increase
in PTSS between T1 and T2, which in turn was correlated with poorer PH. PTSS at T2 as well
as changes in PTSS from T1 to T2 mediated the association between T1 PTG and T2 PH
measures. The present findings imply that PTG might have negative implications on PH through
the amplification of PTSS, among secondary trauma victims. It seems that although spouses of
trauma victims describe benefits resulting from vicarious trauma exposures, their body indicates
differently.
Although there is an abundance of evidence for the exis-
tence of posttraumatic growth (PTG; Tedeschi & Cal-
houn, 2004), its nature as well as long term implications
remain very partially understood. The present study works within
this dearth to shed light on the nature of PTG and its long-term
associations. To this end the associations between PTG, perceived
health (PH) and posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) are exam-
ined among wives of former prisoners of war (ex-POWs) and
wives of comparable combatants who were not held captive.
Moreover, the mediating role of PTSS within the PTG-PH rela-
tionship was likewise investigated.
Posttraumatic Growth
War captivity is among the most extreme traumatic events in
existence, typically following active combat which may be
devastating and traumatic in its own right. Prisoners of war are
often subjected to harsh physical and psychological abuse,
torture, severe deprivation of basic needs (i.e., food, water,
sleep), as well as repeated humiliation and degradation at the
hands of their captors (e.g., Herman, 1992). As a result, ex-
POWs are at high risk for physical and psychiatric disorders,
most notably posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD; e.g., Dikel,
Engdahl, & Eberly, 2005).
The implications of war captivity are not limited to primary
trauma survivors (i.e., ex-POWs), and may be transmitted to
significant others, a phenomenon known as secondary traumatiza-
tion (e.g., Figley, 1986). Moreover, it has recently been incorpo-
rated within the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental
Disorders, fifth edition (DSM-V; American Psychiatric Associa-
tion, 2013) that learning about a close family member’s traumatic
event constitutes a firsthand trauma. Wives of ex-POWs whose
husbands’ lives were at-risk while they were held captive, are
clearly answer to this criterion and are hence at-risk themselves.
Indeed, research has indicated that wives of ex-POWs endorse
more PTSS and more severe psychological distress than wives of
comparable combat veterans (e.g., Greene, Lahav, Bronstein, &
Solomon, 2014).
Having an intimate relationship with an ex-POW, however, may
also lead to positive gains or transformations, characterized as
PTG (e.g., Tedeschi & Calhoun, 1996). According to Tedeschi and
Calhoun (2004) PTG is exhibited in three domains: elevated pos-
itive self-perception, improved interpersonal relationships, and a
more optimistic world view. Research has documented PTG
among survivors of various traumatic events including disasters,
This article was published Online First February 11, 2016.
Yael Lahav, Zahava Solomon, and Yafit Levin, Bob Shapell School of
Social Work, Tel-Aviv University, and I-CORE Research Center for Mass
Trauma, Tel Aviv, Israel.
Correspondence concerning this article should be addressed to Yael
Lahav, I-CORE Research Center for Mass Trauma, P.O.B. 39040, Tel
Aviv, 69978 Israel. E-mail: lahav.yael62@gmail.com
This document is copyrighted by the American Psychological Association or one of its allied publishers.
This article is intended solely for the personal use of the individual user and is not to be disseminated broadly.
American Journal of Orthopsychiatry © 2016 American Orthopsychiatric Association
2016, Vol. 86, No. 6, 693–703 http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/ort0000155
693
... However, others questioned the validity of PTG as a scientific construct, as well as its retrospective assessment methodology and capacity to evaluate real psychological change (Boals & Schuler, 2023). Furthermore, PTG's positive 'illusory' cognitive bias has been criticised to function as an active coping strategy for self-enhancement when responding to the impacts of trauma (e.g., Lahav, Levin, & Solomon, 2016), and even violation of post-event recovery expectations, or expectations and cultural scripts (Jayawickreme & Blackie, 2014). ...
... It is also important to note the controversies surrounding the concept of PTG. Thus, PTG may act as a positive "illusory" cognitive bias in which GSE may facilitate it as an active coping strategy for self-enhancement when responding to the impacts of trauma (e.g., Lahav, Levin, & Solomon, 2016). ...
Article
Posttraumatic growth (PTG) is a possible common reaction to exposure to potentially traumatic events (PTEs) during military service. However, knowledge about correlates of PTG among female combat veterans is sparse. This study examines associations between combat exposure, posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS), general self‐efficacy (GSE), and PTG among Israeli female veterans. This is a cross‐sectional studyA volunteer sample of female Israeli combat veterans ( n = 616) and non‐combat veterans ( n = 484) responded to self‐report questionnaires. Combat veterans reported higher levels of combat exposure, PTSS, GSE, and PTG, as compared to non‐combat veterans. Among combat veterans, combat exposure and GSE were associated with greater PTG. Importantly, PTSS and GSE mediated the link between combat exposure and PTG. The study's findings are among the first to report about possible psychological growth outcomes among Israeli combat veterans. Clinicians treating female veterans coping with combat trauma should be aware of the heterogeneity of reactions to military service challenges and the importance of enhancing veterans' GSE to facilitate PTG.
... For instance, the disturbing and unwanted memories of the trauma repeatedly intrude the victim's consciousness, which can lead to strong physical reactions such as palpitations and difficulty breathing, as well as negative feelings such as agitation and anxiety. These physical and emotional reactions are stressful to the body and can increase the physiological work of the autonomic nervous system (Lahav et al., 2016), leading to an escalation of somatic problems, making victims feel unwell. ...
... The illness could also cause them to reconsider what is truly important to them and reorder priorities in life. The current finding also mirrors previous evidence of a positive association between posttraumatic growth and somatic complaints (Lahav et al., 2016) or psychiatric distress Calhoun and Tedeschi, 2006). ...
Article
Background This study investigated the association between posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), psychiatric co-morbidity and posttraumatic growth (PTG) among Chinese adolescents using network analysis. Methods 867 Chinese adolescents (male = 424, female = 443) were recruited from three secondary schools. They completed the Posttraumatic Stress Disorder Checklist for DSM-5, the Posttraumatic Growth Inventory, and the General Health Questionnaire-28. Results Domains of each construct mainly clustered within their respective communities with several bridging edges identified. The prominent roles of bridging nodes and edges (positive and negative) were highlighted. Key bridging nodes were negative alterations in cognitions and mood for PTSD, anxiety and insomnia for psychiatric co-morbidity and appreciation of life for PTG. Limitations The cross-sectional nature of the present study may preclude the identification of real causal relationships between nodes. Conclusions Following a trauma, adolescents displayed posttraumatic stress along with general psychological disorder symptoms. These distress reactions could affect the way they appreciated life and their motivation to seek future life possibilities. Findings from the current study may provide some clue for the facilitation of posttraumatic growth among clinical patients.
... Repairing relational and self-regulation capacity increases psychological resources by balancing repair and enhancement, leading to growth-oriented dynamics such as growth mindset (Brunzell et al., 2015). Elements such as emotional expression (Linley et al., 2011), self-compassion (Wong & Yeung, 2017), and perceived health (Lahav et al., 2016) influence the impact of trauma symptom development and growth after adversity. ...
Thesis
Full-text available
What helps a client embrace change? Growth mindset and positive mental health aid psychotherapeutic change. Positive mental health facets aiding change include wellbeing, emotional regulation, distress tolerance, interpersonal effectiveness, self-control, self-awareness, and spirituality. The literature review examined the formulation, principles, critique, and function of growth mindset construct within contexts of success, talent, neuroscience, trauma, impairment, and each positive mental health facet. The review indicated growth mindset impacts change. The objective involved testing for evidence of associated relationship between growth mindset and positive mental constructs using Pearson's correlation coefficient. Utilization occurred of eight self-rating measures, one each for wellbeing, emotional regulation, distress tolerance, interpersonal effectiveness, self-control, self-awareness, and spirituality. Growth mindset measures received individual comparison with nine positive mental health measures. The null hypothesis was r ≤ .03. There were nine alternative hypotheses, one per positive mental health measure. The sample size was 148, obtained by internet survey distribution. The result was failure to reject the null hypotheses for all nine alternative hypotheses allowing for the following conclusions: no evidence of associated relationships; growth mindset and positive mental health constructs are meaningful and useful; belief alone does not lead to change effort. Recommended research includes qualitative case studies, quasi-experiment comparisons, development of enhanced measurements, or longitudinal observation. Keywords: growth mindset, fixed mindset, positive mental health, psychotherapeutic change, change beliefs
... In this vein, as our study not only included funeral directors but also cemeteries and morgues employees, these results may directly inform practical guidelines in fostering such interventions among the funeral and mortuary professional categories. Moreover, programs based on the awareness on job risks and characteristics are also functional from a positive perspective in order to prevent the depletion of resources with negative consequences on individual balance and health [79]. ...
Article
Full-text available
The funeral and mortuary sector, including funeral homes, cemeteries and crematoria, is a largely neglected sector in regard to the study of occupational factors that can affect the quality of working life. The present study aimed at overcoming this gap by investigating job demands and resources that may affect burnout levels. Data were collected through a self-report questionnaire involving funeral industry employees (N = 229) from cemetery, morgues, crematoria and funeral agencies in a Northern Italian region. The survey was cross-sectional and non-randomized. Results reveal that among job demands, stigma consciousness, supervisor incivility and work-to-family negative spillover significantly affect levels of burnout, whereas meaningfulness of work and family-to-work positive spillover may represent relevant resources to counter the onset of burnout. The results of this study contribute to new insights into the psychosocial working conditions that affect occupational wellbeing among the funeral industry sector by also giving insight into how to promote resources to prevent burnout.
... Specifically, these individuals might suffer from elevated levels of intrusion, avoidance, and hyperarousal peritraumatic stress symptoms. Previous findings which have indicated associations between PTG and various negative outcomes (Dekel et al., 2015;Lahav et al., 2016bLahav et al., , 2017aLiu et al., 2017a;Shakespeare-Finch and De Dassel, 2009) provide some support for this explanation. ...
Article
Trauma survivors who suffer from posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptoms may be particularly vulnerable when facing the COVID-19 pandemic. Yet trauma exposure may also lead to salutogenic outcomes, known as posttraumatic growth (PTG). Nevertheless, the implications of PTG attributed to prior trauma, for trauma survivors’ adjustment when facing additional stressors, are unclear. Addressing this gap, 528 Israeli trauma survivors were assessed for PTG and PTSD symptoms attributed to prior trauma, as well as peritraumatic stress symptoms related to the pandemic, as part of an online survey. Analyses revealed that being younger, female, quarantined, negatively self-rating one’s health status, and suffering from PTSD symptoms were associated with elevated peritraumatic stress symptoms. Furthermore, PTG attributed to prior trauma made a significant contribution in explaining elevated intrusion, avoidance, and hyperarousal symptoms. The present results point to the need for clinicians to take into account reports of PTG attributed to prior trauma when treating trauma survivors during the current pandemic.
Article
Purpose: This study aimed to elucidate the experiences and growth trajectories of mothers who have infants with esophageal atresia, which would contribute to our understanding of their unique nursing care requirements and support the development of personalized nursing care strategies and interventions for these critically ill infants. Design and methods: This study used a qualitative descriptive approach including face to face interviews with semi-structured questions. The interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed verbatim. Results: Eight mothers were interviewed between November 2021 to January 2022. The mothers described two categories of care experiences: "grief" and "post-traumatic growth". Subcategories included "beginning of chaos", "facing reality", "forced mother-infant separation", "deprived life", "deepened self-knowledge", "enhanced perception of social support", and "shift in life priorities". Conclusions: The findings of this study indicated mother of infants with esophageal atresia experienced grief, and also reported growth. A better understanding of mothers' experience and positive changes may facilitate peditric nursing practice and promote mothers to attain good psychological adaptation to enable them to take good care of their children. Application to practice: Pediatric nurses' insight into the experience of mothers caring for infants with esophageal atresia could facilitate increased physical intimacy and optimized interaction time to understand the unique personality of these infants. Collaborating with mothers could enhance nurses' comprehension of their perspectives, concerns, and needs, and could guide intervention strategies.
Article
Full-text available
Childhood abuse puts individuals at risk for psychopathology and psychiatric symptoms such as posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and anxiety symptoms. At the same time, research has indicated that some survivors report positive transformations in the aftermath of their trauma, known as posttraumatic growth (PTG). Yet the essence of PTG reports is questionable, and some scholars claim that it may reflect maladaptive illusory qualities. Furthermore, according to a recent theoretical model, PTG might be dissociation-based and related to survivors' bonds with their perpetrators. This study aimed to explore these claims by assessing PTG, dissociation, and identification with the aggressor (IWA), as well as PTSD and anxiety symptoms. An online survey was conducted among 597 adult childhood abuse survivors. Study variables were assessed via self-report measures. Analyses indicated positive associations between PTG, dissociation, and IWA. Three distinct profiles were found, reflecting high, medium, and low scores on PTG, dissociation, and IWA. Profile type explained PTSD and anxiety symptoms above and beyond gender, age, and abuse severity. These findings suggest that whereas some childhood abuse survivors might experience a positive transformation subsequent to their trauma, others' PTG reports might reflect dissociative mechanisms and pathological attachments to their perpetrators , and thus might be maladaptive. ARTICLE HISTORY
Article
Objective: Relying on anthropomorphism research, Illness Personification Theory (ILL-PERF) posits that individuals living with a chronic illness ascribe human-like characteristics to their illness. Herein we examine the personification of chronic pain using a new measure: the Ben-Gurion University Illness Personification Scale (BGU-IPS). Method: Three samples of chronic pain patients (Sample 1 and 2 are distinct samples sharing similar characteristics, collected in the context of a cross-sectional design, Ns = 259, 263; Sample 3: a 2-waves longitudinal, N =163) completed the 12-item BGU-IPS, and measures of pain and related factors. Results: An orthogonal, two-factor structure was revealed for the BGU-IPS pertaining to negative vs. positive personifications. Negative personification was associated with pain intensity and illness-related distress (e.g., depression and low adjustment to pain). Positive personification was correlated with hope, pain-related sense of control, and low depression. However, positive personification also augmented the associations between negative personification and several risk factors. Conclusions: Pain personification, particularly as assessed via the BGU-IPS, plays a major role in (mal)adaptation to chronic pain.
Article
Full-text available
This study investigated the trajectories in posttraumatic growth (PTG) among adolescents who survived from the Yancheng tornado in China, and explored the effects of posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) on these trajectories. Participants (n = 246) finished 4 assessments at 6, 9, 12, and 18 months after the tornado. Growth mixture model and logistic regression were used to examine the heterogeneous trajectories and the role of PTSS for differentiating trajectories respectively. Two latent PTG trajectories were observed: group with decreasing PTG and group with fluctuant PTG, which might stem from the illusory component and the factual component of PTG respectively based on the two-component model; and adolescents with more PTSS had higher probabilities generating decreasing PTG, that is, illusory PTG. This study suggested differentiating PTG trajectories and related influencing factors to improve the post-disaster psychological interventions in a longitudinal perspective.
Article
Full-text available
A theory of inhibition and psychosomatic disease suggests that the failure to confide traumatic events is stressful and associated with long-term health problems. We investigated the short-term autonomic correlates of disclosing personal and traumatic experiences among two samples of healthy undergraduates. In Experiment 1, subjects talked into a tape recorder about extremely stressful events that had occurred in their lives, as well as what they planned to do following the experiment. Skin conductance, blood pressure, and heart rate were continuously measured. Based on judges' ratings of subjects' depth of disclosure, subjects were classified as high or low disclosers. Talking about traumatic events was associated with decreased behavioral inhibition, as measured by lower skin conductance levels among high disclosers. Disclosing traumatic material was also associated with increased cardiovascular activity. In Experiment 2, subjects both talked aloud and thought about a traumatic event and about plans for the day. Half of the subjects were alone in an experimental cubicle and talked into a tape recorder; the remaining subjects talked to a silent “confessor” who sat behind a curtain. Among high disclosers, both talking and thinking about traumatic events produced lower skin conductance levels than did thinking or talking about plans for the day. The presence of a confessor inhibited subjects' talking. Implications for understanding the nature of confession and the development of an inhibitory model for psychosomatic processes are discussed.
Article
Full-text available
Secondary traumatization describes the phenomenon whereby those in proximity to trauma survivors develop psychological symptoms similar to those experienced by the direct survivor. The current study examined secondary trauma (ST) and generalized distress symptoms (general psychiatric symptomatology, functional disability, and self-rated health) in wives of former prisoners of war (ex-POWs). The study compared wives of Israeli ex-POWs from the 1973 Yom Kippur War with wives of a matched control group of non-POW Yom Kippur War combat veterans (CVs). The wives also were divided into groups based on their husbands' current posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) status and PTSD trajectory (i.e., chronic, delayed), and their outcomes were compared with resilient CVs. We found that wives of ex-POWs with PTSD reported higher ST and generalized distress than wives of ex-POWs and non-POW CVs without PTSD. Wives of ex-POWs with chronic PTSD reported the highest levels of functional disability. We also found that the relationships between husbands' prior captivity, and wives' ST and general psychiatric symptomatology were fully mediated by the husbands' PTSD symptoms. These findings indicate that it is exposure to a partner with PTSD that leads to overall ST and other distress symptoms, and not simply to a trauma survivor. Furthermore, the more severe their husbands' PTSD, the more wives are at risk for ST and general psychiatric symptomatology. Wives of partners with PTSD should therefore be considered high-risk groups for ST and distress that may require targeted interventions. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2014 APA, all rights reserved).
Article
Full-text available
Objective: The current study aimed to investigate (a) "secondary" posttraumatic growth (PTG) in wives of former prisoners of war (ex-POWs) and its association to husbands' captivity, husbands' posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), and husbands' PTSD trajectories; and (b) the bidirectional relationships over time between wives' posttraumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) and PTG. Method: The study compared 116 wives of Israeli ex-POWs from the 1973 Yom Kippur War with 56 wives of a matched control group of non-POW combat veterans. Wives were divided into groups according to husbands' captivity status, husbands' PTSD status, and husbands' PTSD trajectories; and ANOVAs and MANOVAs were conducted to assess group differences in PTSS and PTG, both cross-sectionally and longitudinally. Autoregressive cross-lag modeling was also used to assess bidirectional relationships between wives' PTSS and PTG over time. Results: Wives of ex-POWs with PTSD reported significantly higher PTG compared with wives of ex-POWs without PTSD and wives of controls. While PTG and PTSS remained stable over time, importantly, the Time 1 (T1) level of PTG predicted avoidance symptoms at Time 2 (T2); the higher the wives' PTG at T1, the higher their avoidance symptoms at T2, but not vice versa. Conclusions: These findings support the notion that "secondary PTG" exists. They also strengthen the theory that growth and distress can co-occur. Finally, the finding that PTG predicted subsequent avoidance symptoms suggests that PTG does not prevent the future development of distress.
Article
This article describes the concept of posttraumatic growth, its conceptual foundations, and supporting empirical evidence. Posttraumatic growth is the experience of positive change that occurs as a result of the struggle with highly challenging life crises. It is manifested in a variety of ways, including an increased appreciation for life in general, more meaningful interpersonal relationships, an increased sense of personal strength, changed priorities, and a richer existential and spiritual life. Although the term is new, the idea that great good can come from great suffering is ancient. We propose a model for understanding the process of posttraumatic growth in which individual characteristics, support and disclosure, and more centrally, significant cognitive processing involving cognitive structures threatened or nullified by the traumatic events, play an important role. It is also suggested that posttraumatic growth mutually interacts with life wisdom and the development of the life narrative, and that it is an on-going process, not a static outcome.