Due to its ability to reversibly crosslink proteins, cysteine has a unique role as an amino acid in nature. For controlled, asymmetric formation of disulfides from two thiols, one thiol needs to be activated. While few activating groups for cysteine have been proposed, they are usually not stable against amines making them unsuitable for solid phase peptide synthesis or amine initiated polymerization of α-amino acid-N-carboxy-anhydrides (NCAs). In this report we describe a series of new thiol activated cysteines, as well as their NCAs and explore the link between electron deficiency of the leaving group and control over NCA polymerization.